national security advisors v. cia

7/31/2019 National Security Advisors v. CIA

1/38

SKGPC@ _PJPC_ @G_PRGOP OFSRP

IFR PMC @G_PRGOP FI OFLSEBGJ

KJPGFKJL _COSRGPW OFSK_CLFR_ :2>> _fpm Ofrpmfsc Rfj`, _gpc :20

Jrlgkhpfk, YJ 222>0,

jk`

AJPMRWK _JOA ::: @jyg` Pcrrjoc

Omjrlfppcsygllc, YJ 227>?,

jk`

DCIIRCW _PCGK

0308 Hrjkp Rfj`, KX Xjsmgkhpfk, @O 2>>:9,

jk` Ogygl Jopgfk Kf+ :4:2%oy%VVVVV

EJRA TJG@

:23> Ofkkcopgop Jyckc, KX, _gpc 2>> Xjsmgkhpfk, @O 2>>?9,

jk`

JLL _GEGLJRLW _GPSJPC@ ^JRPGC_,

^ljgkpgiis,

y+

OCKPRJL GKPCLLGHCKOC JHCKOW

Xjsmgkhpfk, @O 2>3>3,

@cick`jkp+

^ljgkpgiis Kjpgfkjl _corgpw Ofksclfrs, Ajpmrwk _joa, Dciircw _pcgk, jk` Ejra Tjg`, jk`

xmcrc j~~rf~rgjpc jll fpmcr sgegljrlw sgpjpc` gk`gyg`jls, brgkh pmgs jopgfk jhjgksp @cick`jkp

Ockprjl Gkpcllghckoc Jhckow ~rsjkp pf pmc Ircc`fe fi Gkifrejpgfk Jop, 3 S+_+O+ 332, cp scz+,

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc : fi ?=


2/38

2

js jeck`c`-IFGJ', pmc J`egkgsprjpgyc ^rfoc`rc Jop, 3 S+_+O+ 8>:, cp scz+ -J^J', pmc

Gk`c~ck`ckp Fiigocs J~~rf~rgjpgfks Jop, ?: S+_+O+ 78>: -GFJJ', pmc Ejk`jes Jop, 2=

S+_+O+ :?9:, pmc Ic`crjl @coljrjpfrw D`heckp Jop, 2= S+_+O+ 22>:, jk` pmc Jll Xrgps Jop,

2= S+_+O+ :93:+

DSRG_@GOPGFK

:+ Pmgs Ofrp mjs bfpm sbdcop ejppcr drgs`gopgfk fycr pmgs jopgfk jk` ~crsfkjldrgs`gopgfk fycr @cick`jkp ~rsjkp pf 3 S+_+O+ 332-j'-0'-B' jk` 2= S+_+O+ :??:+

YCKSC

2+ Yckc gs j~~rf~rgjpc k`cr 3 S+_+O+ 332-j'-0'-B', 8>? jk` 2= S+_+O+ :?7:+^JRPGC_

?+ ^ljgkpgii Kjpgfkjl _corgpw Ofksclfrs -K_O' gs j kfk%~rfigp frhjkgtjpgfk k`crpmc ljxs fi pmc Ofeefkxcjlpm fi Ygrhgkgj jk` mjs pmc jbglgpw pf `gsscegkjpc gkifrejpgfk fk j

xg`c sojlc+

0+ ^ljgkpgii Ajpmrwk _joa -_joa' gs j S+_+ ogpgtck jk` gs j rcsg`ckp fi pmcOfeefkxcjlpm fi Ygrhgkgj+

3+ _joa gs j ^m+@+ sp`ckp jp pmc Skgycrsgpw fi Ygrhgkgj xfragkh fk mcr `gsscrpjpgfkfk ~flwhrj~m bgjs+ Pmc @grcopfr fi Hrj`jpc _p`gcs ifr pmc @c~jrpeckp fi ^flgpgos mjs

jpmfrgtc` mcr pf iglc IFGJ rczcsps js j rc~rcsckpjpgyc fi pmjp gkspgppgfk+ _mc gs pmcrcifrc

ofksg`crc` j rc~rcsckpjpgyc fi jk c`ojpgfkjl fr kfkofeecrogjl sogckpgigo gkspgppgfk xmfsc

~r~fsc gs somfljrlw fr sogckpgigo rcscjrom xgpmgk pmc ecjkgkh fi 3 S+_+O+ 332-j'-0'-J'+

9+ ^ljgkpgii Dciircw _pcgk -_pcgk' gs j S+_+ ogpgtck jk` gs j rcsg`ckp fi pmc @gsprgop fiOflebgj jk` gs j rc~rcsckpjpgyc fi pmc kcxs ec`gj xgpmgk pmc ecjkgkh fi 3 S+_+O+

332-j'-0'-J'+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc 2 fi ?=


3/38

?

8+ ^ljgkpgii Ejra Tjg` -Tjg`' gs j S+_+ ogpgtck jk` gs j rcsg`ckp fi pmc spjpc fiEjrwljk`+

=+ _gegljrlw sgpjpc` gk`gyg`jls gkol`c jkwfkc xmf, xgpmgk fkc wcjr fi pmc iglgkh fipmgs Ofe~ljgkp, sbegppc` pf pmc `cick`jkp Ockprjl Gkpcllghckoc Jhckow -OGJ' j rczcsp ifr

Ejk`jpfrw @coljssgigojpgfk Rcygcx sccagkh oljssgigojpgfk rcygcx fi rcofr`s k`cr pmc ofkprfl

jk` jpmfrgpw fi OGJ jk` xmfsc rczcsp OGJ rcisc` pf ~rfocss bw xjw fi rclgjkoc ~fk jk

kljxillw%~rfelhjpc` rczgrceckp pmjp pmc gk`gyg`jl ofeegp ~irfkp pf ~jw j~~lgojblc iccs+

7+ @cick`jkp OGJ gs jk jhckow xgpmgk pmc ecjkgkh fi 3 S+_+O+ 332-c', jk` gs gk~fsscssgfk jk`&fr ofkprfl fi pmc rcofr`s rczcspc` bw ^ljgkpgiis, jk` jll sgegljrlw sgpjpc`

gk`gyg`jls, xmgom jrc pmc sbdcop fi pmgs jopgfk+

OLJ__ JOPGFK JLLCHJPGFK_

:>+ Ofkps : jk` 2 fi pmgs jopgfk jrc brfhmp bw K_O, _pcgk, jk` Tjg` -ofllcopgyclwE@R ^ljgkpgiis' fk pmcgr fxk bcmjli jk` fk bcmjli fi pmc oljss fi jll fpmcrs sgegljrlw sgpjpc`

k`cr pmc ~rfygsgfks fi Ic`+ R+ Ogy+ ^+ 2?-j' jk` -b'+

::+ Pmc oljss sf rc~rcsckpc` bw E@R ^ljgkpgiis gk pmgs jopgfk, jk` fi xmgom pmcw jrcecebcrs, ofksgsps fi jkwfkc xmf sbegppc` pf OGJ sgkoc 2? _c~pcebcr 2>:: j rczcsp ifr

Ejk`jpfrw @coljssgigojpgfk Rcygcx sccagkh oljssgigojpgfk rcygcx fi rcofr`s k`cr pmc ofkprfl

jk` jpmfrgpw fi OGJ jk` xmfsc rczcsp OGJ rcisc` pf ~rfocss bw xjw fi rclgjkoc ~fk jk

kljxillw%~rfelhjpc` rczgrceckp pmjp pmc gk`gyg`jl ofeegp ~irfkp pf ~jw j~~lgojblc iccs+

:2+ Pmc c}jop kebcr fi ecebcrs fi pmc oljss, js mcrcgkjbfyc g`ckpgigc` jk``csorgbc`, gs kfp akfxk, bp gp gs rcjsfkjblc pf bclgcyc pmc oljss gs sf kecrfs pmjp dfgk`cr fi

gk`gyg`jl ecebcrs gs ge~rjopgojl+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc ? fi ?=


4/38

0

:?+ Pmc rclgci sfhmp gs ofeefk pf pmc ckpgrc oljss, jk` pmcrc jrc ofeefk zcspgfksfi ljx jk` ijop pmjp rcljpc pf jk` jiicop pmc rghmps fi cjom ecebcr fi pmc oljss+ Pmcsc ofeefk

zcspgfks gkol`c jk` gkyflyc xmcpmcr OGJ ijglc` pf ~rf~crlw ~rfelhjpc gps kcx rchljpgfk

jpmfrgtgkh gp pf rcisc pf ~rfocss E@R rczcsps xgpmfp jk ~irfkp ofeegpeckp pf ~jw jll

j~~lgojblc iccs, js xcll js xmcpmcr pmjp kcx ~flgow gpscli gs kljxil+ Ocrpjgk `cickscs rjgsc` bw

OGJ xfl` j~~lw czjllw pf jll ecebcrs fi pmc oljss+

:0+ Pmc oljges fi E@R ^ljgkpgiis jhjgksp OGJ jrc pw~gojl fi pmc oljges fi pmc oljss gkpmjp pmc oljges fi jll ecebcrs fi pmc oljss `c~ck` fk j smfxgkh fi pmc jops fi OGJ js hgygkh rgsc

pf rghmps pf pmc rclgci sfhmp mcrcgk+ Pmcrc gs kf ofkilgop js bcpxcck E@R ^ljgkpgiis jk` fpmcr

ecebcrs fi pmc oljss xgpm rcs~cop pf pmgs jopgfk, fr xgpm rcs~cop pf pmc oljges ifr rclgci ofkpjgkc`

mcrcgk+

:3+ E@R ^ljgkpgiis jrc rc~rcsckpjpgyc ~jrpgcs ifr pmc oljss jk` jrc jblc pf jk` xgllijgrlw jk` j`czjpclw ~rfpcop pmc gkpcrcsps fi pmc oljss+ Pmc jppfrkcws ifr E@R ^ljgkpgiis jrc

c}~crgckoc` jk` oj~jblc gk lgpghjpgkh pmc oljges jp gssc jk` mjyc soocssillw rc~rcsckpc`

oljgejkps gk fpmcr E@R ejppcrs fi pmgs kjprc+ Jppfrkcws Acl EoOljkjmjk fi K_O jk` Brj`lcw

^+ Efss fi Ejra _+ Tjg`, ^+O+, xmf mjyc j ofebgkc` kgkc wcjrs xfrpm fi c}~crgckoc mjk`lgkh

E@R rczcsps, xgll jopgyclw ofk`op jk` bc ~rgejrglw rcs~fksgblc ifr pmc ofk`op fi pmc jopgfk

fk bcmjli fi pmc ~ljgkpgii oljss+

:9+ Pmgs jopgfk gs ~rf~crlw ejgkpjgkc` js j oljss jopgfk gk pmjp pmc ~rfscopgfk fisc~jrjpc jopgfks bw gk`gyg`jl ecebcrs fi pmc oljss xfl` orcjpc j rgsa fi j`d`gojpgfks xgpm

rcs~cop pf gk`gyg`jl ecebcrs fi pmc oljss xmgom xfl` js j ~rjopgojl ejppcr bc `gs~fsgpgyc fi

pmc gkpcrcsps fi fpmcrs kfp ~jrpw pf pmc j`d`gojpgfks, fr xfl` sbspjkpgjllw ge~jgr fr ge~c`c

pmcgr jbglgpw pf ~rfpcop pmcgr gkpcrcsps+



5/38

3

:8+ Pmgs jopgfk gs ~rf~crlw ejgkpjgkc` js j oljss jopgfk gkjseom js pmc zcspgfks filjx jk` ijop ofeefk pf pmc ecebcrs fi pmc oljss ~rc`fegkjpc fycr jkw zcspgfks jiicopgkh fklw

gk`gyg`jl ecebcrs, jk` j oljss jopgfk gs s~crgfr pf fpmcr jyjgljblc ecpmf`s ifr pmc ijgr jk`

ciigogckp j`d`gojpgfk fi pmc ofkprfycrsw+

IGR_P OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O&_PCGK&TJG@ J^J IJGLSRC PF ^RF^CRLW ^RFESLHJPC

RCHSLJPGFK_'

:=+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

:7+ Fk :9 Dkc :778 OGJ ~blgsmc` jk Gkpcrge Rlc gk pmc Ic`crjl Rchgspcrxmgom, gk~crpgkckp ~jrp, scp ifrpm pmc rlcs hfycrkgkh gps IFGJ jk` Ejk`jpfrw @coljssgigojpgfk Rcygcx

-E@R' ~rfhrjes+ _cc 92 Ic`+ Rch+ ?2073 -Dkc :9, :778'+ Pmcsc rchljpgfks xcrc

sbsczckplw ckpcrc` gkpf pmc Of`c fi Ic`crjl Rchljpgfks js ?2 O+I+R+ ^jrps :7>> jk` :7>=+

Pmcsc rcejgk pmc hfycrkgkh rchljpgfks ifr OGJs IFGJ jk` E@R ~rfhrjes+

2>+ ?2 O+I+R+ :7>>+:? `csorgbcs OGJs icc sproprc ifr IFGJ rczcsps, gkol`gkhpmc rczgrceckps4 j' pmjp fklw ofeecrogjl rczcspcrs jrc pf bc omjrhc` rcygcx iccs1 b' pmjp

rc~rcsckpjpgycs fi pmc kcxs ec`gj jk` rc~rcsckpjpgycs fi c`ojpgfkjl gkspgppgfks jrc kfp pf bc

omjrhc` scjrom iccs1 o' pmjp jll fpmcr kfk%ofeecrogjl rczcspcrs jrc ckpgplc` pf pxf ircc mfrs fi

scjrom pgec jk` :>> ~jhcs fi `~lgojpgfks ircc fi omjrhc1 jk` `' pmjp icc xjgycrs jrc pf bc

jxjr`c` xmck rclcjsc fi pmc gkifrejpgfk rczcspc` xfl` bc gk pmc ~blgo gkpcrcsp+

2:+ ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:? spjpcs4 QE@RU QrUczcsps ej`c `grcoplw pf pmgs Jhckow xgllbc lgjblc ifr ofsps gk pmc sjec jefkp jk` k`cr pmc sjec ofk`gpgfks js s~cogigc` gk ?2 OIR ~jrp

:7>>+



6/38

9

22+ S~fk gkifrejpgfk jk` bclgci, ~rgfr pf 2? _c~pcebcr 2>::, OGJ rjrclw gi cycromjrhc` iccs pf ~rfocss E@R rczcsps+ Fi pmc elpg~lc irczckp E@R rczcspcrs srycwc` bw

^ljgkpgiis, kfkc rcojllc` cycr bcgkh omjrhc` bw OGJ ifr E@R rczcsps+

2?+ Fk 2? _c~pcebcr 2>:: OGJ ~blgsmc` gk pmc Ic`crjl Rchgspcrj ~r~frpc` IgkjlRlc jppce~pgkh pf ef`giw ?2 O+I+R+ ^jrp :7>=+ 89 Ic`+ Rch+ 37>?2 -_c~p+ 2?, 2>::'+ OGJ `g`

kfp sbdcop pmgs rlc pf ~blgo kfpgoc jk` ofeeckp ~rgfr pf ~rfelhjpgkh gp js j Igkjl Rlc+ G`+ jp

37>?? -Pmgs rlc gs bcgkh gssc` js j igkjl rlc xgpmfp ~rgfr kfpgoc fi ~rf~fsc` rlcejagkh js

jllfxc` bw pmc J`egkgsprjpgyc ^rfoc`rc Jop ifr rlcs fi jhckow ~rfoc`rc jk` gkpcr~rcpjpgfk+'

20+ 89 Ic`+ Rch+ 37>?2 ~r~frpc` pf rc~ljoc pmc icc ljkhjhc fi ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:?,xmgom spjpc` pmjp E@R rczcsps xfl` bc hfycrkc` bw IFGJ icc rchljpgfks, xgpm pmc kcxlw

j``c` ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:0, xmgom, gkpcr jlgj, cspjblgsmc` j kcx icc sproprc rj`gojllw `giicrckp

pmjk pmc IFGJ icc sproprc jk` ejk`jpc` pmjp OGJ xfl` fklw ~rfocss jk E@R rczcsp gi pmc

rczcspcr jhrcc` pf ~jw jll scjrom, rcygcx, jk` `~lgojpgfk iccs+ Bcojsc OGJ gssc` pmgs js j

Igkjl Rlc, gp xjs geec`gjpclw ckpcrc` gkpf pmc Of`c fi Ic`crjl Rchljpgfks ~fk ~blgojpgfk gk

pmc Ic`crjl Rchgspcr+

23+ _mfrplw jipcr ~blgsmgkh pmgs kcx rlc, OGJ bchjk rcs~fk`gkh pf E@R rczcspsxgpm `cejk`s pmjp rczcspcrs ofeegp pf ~jw jll scjrom, rcygcx, jk` `~lgojpgfk iccs jp pmc kcx

icc somc`lc `csorgbc` gk ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:0+

29+ Fk 8 @cocebcr 2>:: K_O sbegppc` E@R Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>082 pfOGJ+ K_Os rczcsp lcppcr ej`c kf eckpgfk fi iccs, rclwgkh js gp `g` fk OGJs lfkh ~rjopgoc fi

kfp omjrhgkh E@R iccs+

28+ Fk :0 @cocebcr 2>:: OGJ rcs~fk`c` pf Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>082 xgpm pmcifllfxgkh `cejk`4



7/38

8

Xc ojk scjrom ifr jk` rcygcx pmc ejpcrgjl wf rczcspc`, bp esp j`ygsc

wf pmjp C}copgyc Fr`cr :?239 jpmfrgtcs jhckogcs pf ofllcop iccs ifr rcofr`s

scrygocs+ Pmcrcifrc, wf xgll bc rcs~fksgblc ifr pmc ill `grcop ofsps ifr scjromgkh,

rcygcxgkh, jk` `~lgojpgkh rcs~fksgyc rcofr`s+

J``gpgfkjl rcygcx iccs, mfxcycr, xgll `c~ck` ~fk pmc kebcr fi

`foeckps xc igk` jk` of~wgkh iccs xgll `c~ck` ~fk pmc kebcr fi rclcjsjblc

`foeckps+ Rc~rf`opgfk ofsps jrc igipw ockps ~cr ~jhc+ Gk j``gpgfk, pmcrc gs j

egkgee icc fi $:3 ifr rc~rf`opgfk ofsps+ Ifr wfr gkifrejpgfk, xc jrc

ckolfsgkh j of~w fi fr icc somc`lc+

_cjrom iccs jrc jsscssjblc cyck gi xc igk` kf rcofr`s, fr, gi xc igk` jkw,

xc `cpcregkc pmjp xc ojkkfp rclcjsc pmce+ Ofksczckplw, xc xgll omjrhc wf

cyck gi fr scjrom rcslps jrc kchjpgyc fr gi xc ojkkfp rclcjsc jkw gkifrejpgfk+

Joofr`gkhlw, xc xgll kcc` wfr ofeegpeckp pf ~jw j~~lgojblc iccs bcifrc xc ojk

~rfocc`+ Xc xgll mfl` wfr rczcsp gk jbcwjkoc ifr 03 `jws irfe pmc `jpc fi pmgs

lcppcr ~ck`gkh wfr rcs~fksc+

2=+ Fk :9 @cocebcr 2>:: K_O sbegppc` E@R Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>3:= pfOGJ+ Rclwgkh fk pmc ijop pmjp OGJ mj` kfp ~rf~crlw ~rfelhjpc` pmc kcx ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:0

pmrfhm kfpgoc jk` ofeeckp, K_Os rczcsp lcppcr spjpc`4

Bcojsc pmc Ockprjl Gkpcllghckoc Jhckow jsscsscs iccs ifr E@R rczcsps gk pmc

sjec ejkkcr gk xmgom gp jsscsscs iccs ifr IFGJ rczcsps, xc mcrcbw spjpc ifr pmc

rcofr` pmjp xc mjyc kf ofeecrogjl gkpcrcsp gk pmgs rcofr`, pmjp xc jrc j kfk%~rfigp

frhjkgtjpgfk frhjkgtc` k`cr _copgfk 3>:-o'-?' fi pmc pj} of`c, jk` pmjp xc xgll

~fsp pmgs rcofr` fk fr xcbsgpc ifr ~blgo joocss ircc fi omjrhc+ Xc pmcrcifrc



8/38

=

zjlgiw js jk jll fpmcr rczcspcr js `cigkc` gk ?2 O+I+R+ :7>>+:?-g'-?'+ Js

som, xc `f kfp jhrcc pf ~jw jkw iccs, js pmgs `foeckp ojk bc cjsglw lfojpc` jk`

gs kf efrc pmjk igyc ~jhcs lfkh+

27+ Fk 22 @cocebcr 2>:: OGJ rcs~fk`c` pf Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>3:=, spjpgkh,Ifr wfr gkifrejpgfk pmc Ockprjl Gkpcllghckoc Jhckow `fcs kfp jsscss iccs ifr ejk`jpfrw

`coljssgigojpgfk rcygcx rczcsps gk pmc sjec ejkkcr gk xmgom gp jsscsscs iccs ifr Ircc`fe fi

Gkifrejpgfk Jop rczcsps ifr pmcrc jrc kf icc ojpchfrgcs gk ~rfocssgkh E@Rs1 pmcrcifrc, xc

ojkkfp ~ljoc wf gk pmc jll fpmcr ojpchfrw js rczcspc`+ OGJ pmck rc~cjpc` pmc ljkhjhc sc`

gk gps rcs~fksc pf Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>082+

?>+ Fk 0 Djkjrw 2>:2 Tjg` sbegppc` E@R Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>380 pf OGJ+Tjg`s rczcsp lcppcr spjpc`4

Bcojsc pmc Ockprjl Gkpcllghckoc Jhckow jsscsscs iccs ifr E@R rczcsps gk pmc

sjec ejkkcr gk xmgom gp jsscsscs iccs ifr IFGJ rczcsps, G mcrcbw spjpc ifr pmc

rcofr` pmjp Er+ Tjg` mjs kf ofeecrogjl gkpcrcsp gk pmcsc rcofr`s+ Mc pmcrcifrc

zjlgigcs js jk jll fpmcr rczcspcr js `cigkc` gk ?2 O+I+R+ :7>>+:?-g'-?'+ Js

som, mc `fcs kfp jhrcc pf ~jw jkw iccs, js pmcsc `foeckps ojk bc cjsglw lfojpc`

jk` jrc lcss pmjk :>> ~jhcs lfkh+

?:+ Tjg`s rczcsp lcppcr jlsf spjpc`4Joofr`gkh pf ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:?, QE@RU Rczcsps ej`c `grcoplw pf pmgs

Jhckow xgll bc lgjblc ifr ofsps gk pmc sjec jefkp jk` k`cr pmc sjec ofk`gpgfks

js s~cogigc` gk ?2 OIR ~jrp :7>>+ G je jxjrc pmjp pmc OGJ mjs rcockplw

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc = fi ?=


9/38

7

jppce~pc` pf rc~ljoc pmgs rchljpgfk xgpm ?2 O+I+R+ :7>Q=U+:0:

?2+ Fk :2 Djkjrw 2>:2 OGJ rcs~fk`c` pf Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>380, sgkh pmcc}jop sjec ljkhjhc sc` gk gps rcs~fksc pf Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>3:=+

-scc 89 Ic`+ Rch+

37>?2 -_c~p+ 2?, 2>::'', bp sgkoc pmjp rchljpgfk xjs kfp ~rfelhjpc` pmrfhm

~rf~cr kfpgoc jk` ofeeckp rlcejagkh, pmc hfycrkgkh rchljpgfk rcejgks pmc

frghgkjl ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:?+

??+ Fk 7 Djkjrw 2>:2 _pcgk sbegppc` Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>9?= pf OGJ+_pcgks rczcsp lcppcr spjpc`4

G je j dfrkjlgsp xgpm j lfkh mgspfrw fi kjpgfkjl scorgpw gkycspghjpgyc rc~frpgkh+ G

ljkomc` OZs Mfecljk` _corgpw `jglw gk 2>>2 jk` scryc` js kjpgfkjl scorgpw

c`gpfr+ G je j irczckp ofkprgbpfr pf kjpgfkjl ejhjtgkcs jk` F~%c` ~jhcs fycr

pmc wcjrs, jk` scryc` js `c~pw ifrcghk c`gpfr ifr S^G `rgkh pmc :7=>s+ G mjyc

j~~cjrc` fk ygrpjllw cycrw S+_+ jk` ifrcghk pclcygsgfk jk` rj`gf kcpxfra js j

ofeeckpjpfr fk kjpgfkjl scorgpw gsscs, jk` ew _~wPjla blfh gs fkc fi pmc efsp

rcofhkgtc` kjpgfkjl scorgpw kcxs blfhs gk c}gspckoc+ Js som, G c}~cop pmjp G xgll

kfp bc omjrhc` jkw scjrom fr rcygcx iccs, gk joofr`jkoc xgpm pmc OGJs

rchljpgfks+ G je xgllgkh pf ofeegp pf ~jw jll `~lgojpgfk iccs jp pmc rjpc fi :>

ockps&~jhc jipcr pmc igrsp :>> ~jhcs, xmgom jrc pf bc ~rfyg`c` ircc fi omjrhc, gk

joofr`jkoc xgpm pmc OGJs rchljpgfks+

:Tjg`s rczcsp lcppcr egspjacklw rcicrrc` pf pmc kcx rchljpgfk js ?2 O+I+R+ :7>>+:0, bp pmc

ofkpc}p xjs olcjr+



10/38

:>

?0+ Fk 2> Djkjrw 2>:2 OGJ rcs~fk`c` pf Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>9?=, sgkh pmcc}jop sjec ljkhjhc sc` gk gps rcs~fksc pf Rczcsp Kf+ CFE%2>:2%>>082+ OGJs lcppcr ej`c

kf eckpgfk fi _pcgks rczcsp ifr ~ljoceckp gkpf pmc kcxs ec`gj icc ojpchfrw+

?3+ Fpmcr irczckp E@R rczcspcrs kfp ~jrpw pf pmgs ljxsgp mjyc ofkigrec` sgegljrprcjpeckp bw OGJ+ Pmc Kjpgfkjl _corgpw Jromgyc mjs ofkigrec` pmjp sgkoc 9 @cocebcr 2>::, gps

igrsp rcofr`c` gkspjkoc fi pmgs rcs~fksc, gp mjs rcocgyc` g`ckpgojl lcppcrs irfe OGJ gk rcs~fksc pf

kgkc E@R rczcsps iglc` sgkoc :> Kfycebcr 2>::+

?9+ S~fk gkifrejpgfk jk` bclgci, OGJ kfx `cejk`s pmjp cjom jk` cycrw E@Rrczcspcr ofeegp pf ~jwgkh jll scjrom, rcygcx, jk` `~lgojpgfk iccs sgkh pmc kcx icc somc`lc

bcifrc gp xgll jooc~p jk E@R rczcsp+

?8+ OGJs frghgkjl rchljpgfk ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:? cspjblgsmc` pmjp E@R rczcspcrsxfl` bc omjrhc` iccs joofr`gkh pf OGJs IFGJ icc hg`clgkcs+ OGJ ygfljpc` pmc J^J bw

~blgsmgkh j Igkjl Rlc sbspjkpgjllw jlpcrgkh pmgs rchljpgfk xgpmfp igrsp gssgkh j ^rf~fsc` Rlc

sbdcop pf kfpgoc jk` ofeeckp+ 89 Ic`+ Rch+ 37>?2 `fcs kfp eccp pmc kjrrfx rczgrceckps ifr

jk gkpcr~rcpjpgyc rlc pmjp gs c}ce~p irfe pmc kfpgoc jk` ofeeckp rczgrceckp+

?=+ ^ljgkpgiis jrc pmcrcifrc ckpgplc` pf rclgci gk pmc ifre fi j `coljrjpfrw fr`cr pmjp OGJgs gk ygfljpgfk fi gps spjppfrw rcs~fksgbglgpgcs k`cr pmc J^J jk` pmjp pmc ~r~frpc` Igkjl Rlc

~blgsmc` jp 89 Ic`+ Rch+ 37>?2 gs kll jk` yfg`+ ^ljgkpgiis jrc jlsf ckpgplc` pf rclgci gk pmc ifre

fi jk gkdkopgfk ofe~cllgkh OGJ pf ~rfocss jll E@R rczcsps sbegppc` sgkoc 2? _c~pcebcr

2>:: joofr`gkh pf pmc rczgrceckps fi pmc frghgkjl ?2 O+I+R+ :7>=+:? jk` ~rfmgbgpgkh OGJ irfe

`cygjpgkh irfe pmgs rchljpgfk kpgl gp mjs ~rf~crlw ~rfelhjpc` j kcx rchljpgfk joofr`gkh pf pmc

~rfoc`rcs cspjblgsmc` gk pmc J^J+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc :> fi ?=


11/38

::

_COFK@ OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O&_PCGK&TJG@ J^J&EJK@JES_&GFJJ YGFLJPGFK FI GFJJ'

?7+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

0>+ C}copgyc Fr`cr :?329 gs sglckp fk pmc gssc fi xmcpmcr jhckogcs ojk omjrhc iccspf E@R rczcspcrs+

0:+ Pmc GFJJ jpmfrgtcs jhckogcs pf ofllcop iccs ifr scrygocs joofr`gkh pf cspjblgsmc`hg`clgkcs+ Jhckogcs ejw kfp ofllcop iccs irfe gk`gyg`jl ~jrpgcs ifr scrygocs xmgom bckcigp pmc

~blgo hckcrjllw+ _ccKjpgfkjl Ojblc Pclcygsgfk Jssk+, Gko+ y+ Skgpc` _pjpcs, 0:3 S+_+ ??9, ?02

-:780'+

02+ @coljssgigojpgfk jk` rclcjsc fi hfycrkeckp rcofr`s xmgom kf lfkhcr eccp pmcrczgrceckps fi C+F+ :?329 bckcigps pmc ~blgo hckcrjllw+ _cc C+F+ :?329 -Fr `ceforjpgo

~rgkog~lcs rczgrc pmjp pmc Jecrgojk ~cf~lc bc gkifrec` fi pmc jopgygpgcs fi pmcgr Hfycrkeckp+

Jlsf, fr Kjpgfk(s ~rfhrcss `c~ck`s fk pmc ircc ilfx fi gkifrejpgfk bfpm xgpmgk pmc Hfycrkeckp

jk` pf pmc Jecrgojk ~cf~lc+' OGJs jppce~p pf omjrhc iccs ifr pmgs ~blgo scrygoc gs gk `grcop

ygfljpgfk fi pmc GFJJ js gkpcr~rcpc` bw pmc S+_+ _~rcec Ofrp+

0?+ Pmc ~rfmgbgpgfk jhjgksp omjrhgkh iccs ifr scrygocs pmjp bckcigp pmc ~blgo hckcrjllwgs kfk%`gsorcpgfkjrw+ OGJs ~rf~fsc` ~flgow fi omjrhgkh iccs pf ~rfocss E@R rczcsps gs gk

ygfljpgfk fi pmc GFJJ+ _om j ~flgow gs jrbgprjrw, oj~rgogfs, jk jbsc fi `gsorcpgfk, fr fpmcrxgsc

ofkprjrw pf ljx+

00+ OGJ gs ygfljpgkh gps olcjrlw ejk`jpc` egkgspcrgjl `pw k`cr j~~lgojblc ojsc ljx,pmcrcbw mjregkh ^ljgkpgiis bw omjrhgkh iccs ifr E@R rczcsps+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc :: fi ?=


12/38

:2

03+ Pmc Ofrp ejw `rjx gps jpmfrgpw pf rcec`w pmgs ~flgow cgpmcr irfe pmc J^J fr pmcGFJJ+

09+ ^ljgkpgiis jrc bcgkh ejpcrgjllw mjrec` bw pmgs ~rjopgoc bcojsc pmcgr lchgpgejpcE@R rczcsps jrc bcgkh `ckgc` bcojsc pmcw xgll kfp ofeegp pf ~jwgkh gllchjl iccs pf ~rfocss pmc

rczcsps+

08+ ^ljgkpgiis spjk` pf ofkpgkc pf bc mjrec` bw pmgs fkhfgkh ~flgow gk pmc iprc, jspmcw rchljrlw iglc E@R rczcsps xgpm OGJ jk` xgll ofkpgkc pf `f sf gk pmc iprc+

0=+ ^ljgkpgiis mjyc j `grcop gkpcrcsp gk cksrgkh pmjp jhckogcs ~rfocss E@R rczcsps gkjoofr`jkoc xgpm ic`crjl ljx+

07+ ^ljgkpgiis jrc pmcrcifrc ckpgplc` pf rclgci gk pmc ifre fi cgpmcr4 -j' j `coljrjpfrwfr`cr pmjp OGJ gs gk ygfljpgfk fi gps spjppfrw rcs~fksgbglgpgcs k`cr pmc GFJJ jk` jk gkdkopgfk

~rfmgbgpgkh OGJ irfe omjrhgkh iccs ifr E@R rczcsps1 fr -b' j xrgp fi ejk`jes fr`crgkh OGJ

pf ofe~lw xgpm pmc j~~lgojblc ojsc ljx hfycrkgkh pmc GFJJ jk` joofr`gkhlw ~rfocss E@R

rczcsps ircc fi omjrhc+

PMGR@ OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>:2%>>0?2'

3>+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

3:+ Fk :2 @cocebcr 2>:: K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr jll OGJrcofr`s `foeckpgkh pmc `cogsgfkejagkh ~rfocss bcmgk` pmc `cogsgfk pf ifrhf kfpgoc jk`

ofeeckp rlcejagkh ifr QpmrccU rlcs Q~blgsmc` gk pmc Ic`crjl Rchgspcrxgpmfp kfpgoc jk`

ofeeckpU, gkol`gkh, bp kfp lgegpc` pf, jll lchjl jkjlwscs fi pmc j~~lgojbglgpw fr gkj~~lgojbglgpw fi

3 S+_+O+ 33?-b'-?'-J'+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc :2 fi ?=


13/38

:?

32+ Fk 2? @cocebcr 2>:: OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>:2%>>0?2+ Gk pmgs lcppcr, OGJ spjpc`, Xc xgll scjrom ifr rcofr`s c}gspgkh

pmrfhm pmc `jpc fi pmgs jooc~pjkoc lcppcr+

3?+ Fk 27 @cocebcr 2>:: K_O sckp j lcppcr ofkpjgkgkh pmc ifllfxgkh pf OGJ4G mjyc rcocgyc` wfr 2? @cocebcr 2>:: lcppcr rchjr`gkh pmc jbfyc

gk`gojpc` IFGJ rczcsp+ Wfr lcppcr spjpcs, Xc xgll scjrom ifr rcofr`s c}gspgkh

pmrfhm pmc `jpc fi pmgs jooc~pjkoc lcppcr+ Mfxcycr, pmgs gs kfp jooc~pjblc+ Pmc

rczcsp lcppcr s~cogigojllw spjpc` gk bfl` gpjlgos jp pmc pf~ fi pmc lcppcr4 Pmgs

rczcsp gs kfp pf bc lgegpc` pf rcofr`s orcjpc` ~rgfr pf pmc `jpc fi wfr

joakfxlc`hceckp lcppcr+ Gp ljpcr spjpc`, gk pmc bf`w fi pmc lcppcr4

Igkjllw, ~lcjsc ofksg`cr pmgs lcppcr jk jiigrejpgyc rcdcopgfk fi jkw lgegpjpgfk

fi wfr scjrom pf rcofr`s orcjpc` ~rgfr pf pmc `jpc fi pmgs rczcsp+ Pf pmc

ofkprjrw, xc spg~ljpc pmjp pmgs scjrom smfl` bc rcsprgopc` pf rcofr`s

orcjpc` ~rgfr pf pmc `jpc fi pmc OGJs ofeeckoceckp fi pmc scjrom ifr

rcofr`s -js f~~fsc` pf pmc `jpc pmjp rcocg~p fi pmc rczcsp xjs

joakfxlc`hc` bw pmc OGJ'+

^lcjsc ofkigre pmjp wf xgll scjrom ifr rcofr`s c}gspgkh pmrfhm pmc `jpc

pmjp wf ofeeckoc wfr scjrom ifr rcofr`s, jk` pmjp wfr ~rcygfs spjpceckp xjs

jk j`egkgsprjpgyc crrfr jk` kfp j rcisjl pf jbg`c bw pmc pcres fi fr rczcsp+

30+ Fk 2 Icbrjrw 2>:2 OGJ gkifrec` K_O, gk pmc ofkpc}p fi jkfpmcr IFGJ rczcspkfp gkol`c` gk pmgs ojsc, Xgpm rchjr` pf wfr jiigrejpgyc rcdcopgfk fi jkw lgegpjpgfks ~crpjgkgkh

pf fr scjrom opfii `jpc wf jrc jsagkh pmjp xc c}~jk` fr scjromcs pf pmc `jpc pmc scjrom

ofeeckocs+ Xc mjyc ofksg`crc` wfr fbdcopgfk, bp esp j`ygsc wf pmjp pmgs gs fr orrckp

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc :? fi ?=


14/38

:0

~rjopgoc+ Bjsc` ~fk pmgs spjpceckp, ~fk gkifrejpgfk jk` bclgci gp xfl` bc ipglc pf

j`egkgsprjpgyclw j~~cjl pmc ge~fsgpgfk fi j `jpc%fi%jooc~pjkoc%lcppcr op%fii+

33+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bwOGJ, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

39+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+ K_O mjs j irpmcr lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf

pmc sc fi j rcjsfkjblc op%fii `jpc bw OGJ, jk` j bljkacp `jpc%fi%jooc~pjkoc%lcppcr op%fii `fcs

kfp sjpgsiw pmjp rghmp+

IFSRPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>:2%>>9?2'

38+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

3=+ Fk :7 Djkjrw 2>:2 K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr jll rcs~fksclcppcrs sckp pf E@R rczcspcrs ifr rczcsps kebcrc` CFE%2>:2%>>?>> jk` mghmcr+

37+ Fk 7 Icbrjrw 2>:2 OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>:2%>>9?2+ Gk pmgs lcppcr, OGJ spjpc`, Xc xgll scjrom ifr rcofr`s c}gspgkh


9>+ Fk 2: Icbrjrw 2>:2 K_O xrfpc pf OGJ pf oljrgiw pmc sof~c fi pmgs rczcsp,spjpgkh, ^lcjsc j`` pmc ifllfxgkh scofk`jrw `cigkgpgfk pf Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:2%>>9?24 Gi jk

E@R rczcsp xgpm j kebcr xgpmgk pmgs rjkhc gs j rcicrrjl irfe jkfpmcr hfycrkeckp jhckow,

gkgpgjl rcs~fksc lcppcr gs `cigkc` js pmc igrsp ~gcoc fi ofrrcs~fk`ckoc -gkol`gkh cejgl' sckp pf

pmc rcicrrgkh jhckow gk rcs~fksc pf pmc rcicrrjl, rchjr`lcss fi gps ofkpckp+



15/38

:3

9:+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bwOGJ, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` jègkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

92+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+ K_O mjs j irpmcr lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf



IGIPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ RCZSGRGKH OFEEGPECKP IFR JLL ICC_'

9?+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

90+ Fk 9 _c~pcebcr 2>:: K_O sbegppc` IFGJ Rczcsp Kfs+ I%2>::%>2:9> jk` I%2>::%>2:92 pf OGJ+ Fk :0 _c~pcebcr 2>:: K_O sbegppc` IFGJ Rczcsp Kfs+ I%2>::%>2209,

I%2>::%>220=, jk` I%2>::%>2293 pf OGJ+

93+ Fk 27 _c~pcebcr 2>:: OGJ rcs~fk`c` pf pmcsc igyc rczcsps, spjpgkh gk cjomlcppcr4

Xc `cpcregkc` pmjp wfr rczcsp ijlls gkpf pmc jll fpmcr icc ojpchfrw, xmgom ejw

rczgrc wf pf ~jw omjrhcs pf ofycr pmc ofsp fi scjromgkh ifr jk` rc~rfògkh

rcs~fksgyc rcofr`s -gi jkw' bcwfk` pmc igrsp :>> ~jhcs fi rc~rfòpgfk jk` pmc igrsp

pxf mfrs fi scjrom pgec, xmgom jrc ircc+ Of~gcs jrc pck ockps ~cr ~jhc+ _gkoc

wf spjpc ifr pmc rcofr` wfr kxgllgkhkcss pf ~jw jkw iccs, xc xgll kcc` wfr

ofeegpeckp pf ~jw jll j~~lgojblc iccs bcifrc xc ojk ~rfocc` xgpm fr scjromcs+

Xc xgll mfl` wfr rczcsp gk jbcwjkoc ifr 03 `jws irfe pmc `jpc fi pmgs lcppcr

~ck`gkh wfr rcs~fksc+



16/38

:9

99+ Fk 0 Fopfbcr 2>:: K_O xrfpc pf OGJ rczcspgkh oljrgigojpgfk, jsagkh4Igrsp Qwfr lcppcrU sjws -rghmplw' pmjp xc jrc ckpgplc` pf pxf mfrs fi scjrom pgec

jk` :>> ~jhcs fi rc~rfòpgfk ircc fi omjrhc+ Pmgs gs gk joofr`jkoc xgpm IFGJ,

sf xc mjyc kf fbdcopgfk pf gp+ Mfxcycr, gp pmck sjws pmjp wf xgll kfp ~rfocc`

xgpm wfr scjrom kpgl xc ~rfegsc pf ~jw jll j~~lgojblc iccs+ ^lcjsc ofkigre pmjp

wf ecjk pmjp wf xgll ofkòp pmc igrsp pxf mfrs fi scjrom rchjr`lcss fi fr

~rfegsc pf ~jw, sgkoc xc jrc ckpgplc` pf pmjp bw ljx, jk` pmjp wf xgll kfpofkòp

jkwirpmcrscjromcs jbsckp j ~rfegsc pf ~jw+ Bp pmjp wf xgll kfpbc mfl`gkh fr

rczcsps gk jbcwjkoc bcifrc wf ofkòp pmjp igrsp pxf mfrs fi scjrom, sgkoc xc

jrc ckpgplc` pf pxf ircc mfrs fi scjrom pgec ~cr rczcsp cyck gi xc kcycr jksxcr

wf+

98+ Fk 8 Fopfbcr 2>:: OGJ rc~lgc` pf K_O, spjpgkh4Ifr wfr gkifrejpgfk, gp gs kfp ~fssgblc pf lgegp fr scjromcs ifr rcofr`s fk j

~jrpgoljr pf~go pf ~rcogsclw pxf mfrs+ Bcojsc sfec fi pmc scjromcs jrc

jpfejpc`, xmcrcjs fpmcrs jrc kfp, pmc pfpjl scjrom ciifrp ojkkfp bc lgegpc` gk jk

jrbgprjrw xjw, som js pmc ej}gee jefkp pmjp ojk bc ~crifrec` js wf

rczcspc`+ Pmcrc jrc kf ~rfygsgfks gk pmc icc ojpchfrgcs ifr pxf mfrs ircc scjrom

~cr sc+ J rczcsp gk pmc jll fpmcr ojpchfrw gs sbdcop pf jll fi pmc ~rfygsgfks

ofkpjgkc` gk pmgs icc ojpchfrw+ Pmgs ecjks pmjp wf esp jhrcc pf ~jw scjrom ofsps

bcwfk` pmc igrsp pxf mfrs fi scjrom pgec, jk` of~wgkh ofsps bcwfk` pmc igrsp :>>

~jhcs fi jkw rclcjsjblc `foeckps xgpm j omcoa `rjxk fk j S+_+ bjka fr

sbsg`gjrw gk S+_+ `flljrs+ Fpmcrxgsc, wfr rczcsp xfl` kfp eccp pmc ofk`gpgfks



17/38

:8

fi pmgs ojpchfrw js `cigkc` bw ljx+ Xc ojk pjac kf irpmcr jopgfk fk wfr rczcsp

klcss xc rcocgyc wfr icc ofeegpeckp js `csorgbc` jbfyc+

9=+ OGJ jlsf gssc` pmgs rcs~fksc pf pxckpw%sg} fpmcr IFGJ rczcsps iglc` bw K_O fk:0 _c~pcebcr 2>::, bp ljpcr xjgyc` jll iccs ifr pmfsc rczcsps js jk jop fi jègkgsprjpgyc

`gsorcpgfk jipcr K_O j~~cjlc` OGJs `ckgjls fi gps icc xjgycr rczcsps+

97+ S~fk gkifrejpgfk jk` bclgci, OGJs rcisjl pf ~rfyg`c pxf ircc mfrs fi scjrompgec pf jll fpmcr rczcspcrs xmf rcisc pf ~jw jkw iccs rc~rcsckps jk fkhfgkh ~flgow, ~rjopgoc,

fr _pjk`jr` F~crjpgkh ^rfoc`rc -_F^'+ OGJs sbsczckp `cogsgfk pf xjgyc jll iccs ifr

pxckpw%sg} fi pmcsc rczcsps js jk jop fi jègkgsprjpgyc `gsorcpgfk `g` kfp ofkspgppc j rcycrsjl fi

gps ~fsgpgfk fk pmc gssc fi K_Os ckpgplceckp pf pxf ircc mfrs fi scjrom pgec+

8>+ J ~flgow, ~rjopgoc, fr _F^ fi rcisgkh pf ~rfyg`c pxf ircc mfrs fi scjrom pgec pfjll fpmcr rczcspcrs gs gk ygfljpgfk fi IFGJ+ _om j ~rjopgoc ofkspgppcs fprjhcfs ofkòp ifr

~r~fscs fi pmc brfj` czgpjblc ~fxcrs ~rfyg`c` bw IFGJ pf pmc Ofrp+ _om j ~flgow gs

jrbgprjrw, oj~rgogfs, jk jbsc fi `gsorcpgfk, fr fpmcrxgsc ofkprjrw pf ljx+

8:+ Js j irczckp IFGJ rczcspcr pf OGJ, K_O spjk`s pf ofkpgkc pf bc mjrec` bwpmgs fkhfgkh ~rjopgoc gk pmc iprc+

82+ K_O gs pmcrcifrc ckpgplc` pf rclgci gk pmc ifre fi j `coljrjpfrw fr`cr pmjp OGJ gs gkygfljpgfk fi gps spjppfrw rcs~fksgbglgpgcs k`cr IFGJ jk` jk gkdkopgfk ofe~cllgkh OGJ ~rsjkp

pf pmjp spjppc pf ~rfyg`c jll fpmcr rczcspcrs xgpm pxf ircc mfrs fi scjrom pgec rchjr`lcss fi

xmcpmcr fr kfp pmcw ofeegp pf ~jwgkh jkw iccs+



18/38

:=

_G]PM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OMJRHGKH _CJROM ICC_ IFR JSPFEJPC@ _CJROMC_'

8?+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

80+ OGJs 8 Fopfbcr 2>:: lcppcr pf K_O jrhcs, gk ~crpgkckp ~jrp, pmjp pmc rcjsfk pmjpscjromcs ojkkfp bc lgegpc` pf j scp jefkp fi pgec gs bcojsc sfec fi pmc scjromcs jrc jpfejpc`+

83+ Pmc ijop pmjp sfec fi pmc scjromcs jrc jpfejpc` mjs kf bcjrgkh fk pmc lckhpm fipmc scjrom ifr icc ~r~fscs klcss OGJ ofkps pmc pgec pmjp j ofe~pcr pjacs pf ~crifre jk

jpfejpc` scjrom xgpm kf mejk ~jrpgog~jpgfk js ~jrp fi pmc scjrom pgec+

89+ S~fk gkifrejpgfk jk` bclgci, OGJs rcicrckoc pf jpfejpc` scjromcs gk`gojpcs jkfkhfgkh ~flgow, ~rjopgoc, fr _F^+

88+ J ~flgow, ~rjopgoc, fr _F^ fi ofkpgkh ifr icc ~r~fscs pmc pgec s~ckp bw jofe~pcr ~crifregkh jk jpfejpc` scjrom xgpm kf mejk ~jrpgog~jpgfk gs gk ygfljpgfk fi IFGJ+

_om j ~rjopgoc ofkspgppcs fprjhcfs ofk`op ifr ~r~fscs fi pmc brfj` czgpjblc ~fxcrs

~rfyg`c` bw IFGJ pf pmc Ofrp+ _om j ~flgow gs jrbgprjrw, oj~rgogfs, jk jbsc fi `gsorcpgfk, fr

fpmcrxgsc ofkprjrw pf ljx+

8=+ K_O spjk`s pf ofkpgkc pf bc mjrec` bw pmgs fkhfgkh ~flgow gk pmc iprc, js gprchljrlw iglcs IFGJ rczcsps xgpm OGJ jk` xgll ofkpgkc pf `f sf gk pmc iprc+

87+ K_O gs pmcrcifrc ckpgplc` pf rclgci gk pmc ifre fi j `coljrjpfrw fr`cr pmjp OGJ gs gkygfljpgfk fi gps spjppfrw rcs~fksgbglgpgcs k`cr IFGJ jk` jk gkdkopgfk ofe~cllgkh OGJ ~rsjkp

pf pmjp spjppc pf fklw ofkp pgec ifr icc ~r~fscs s~ckp bw mejks ofk`opgkh scjromcs+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc := fi ?=


19/38

:7

_CYCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>:>%>>>89'

=>+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

=:+ Fk = Fopfbcr 2>>7 K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr jll `coljrjpgfks jk`jiig`jygps iglc` bw pmc @grcopfr fi Ockprjl Gkpcllghckoc fr mgs `csghkcc gk elpg~lc ic`crjl ofrp

ojscs+

=2+ Fk :8 @cocebcr 2>>7 OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>>>89+

=?+ Fk 3 Kfycebcr 2>:> OGJ rclcjsc` cghmp `foeckps pf K_O jk` xgpmmcl` jkkakfxk kebcr fi `foeckps ogpgkh C}ce~pgfks -b'-:' jk` -b'-?'+

=0+ Fk :: Kfycebcr 2>:> K_O j~~cjlc` pmc j`czjow fi OGJs scjrom jk` jllxgpmmfl`gkhs+ OGJ joakfxlc`hc` pmgs j~~cjl fk 9 @cocebcr 2>:>+

=3+ Fk 28 Dkc 2>:: OGJ jiigrec` jll fi gps gkgpgjl xgpmmfl`gkhs+ Pmgs lcppcr ej`c kfeckpgfk fi K_Os j~~cjl fi pmc j`czjow fi OGJs scjrom+

=9+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

CGHMPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>:2%>>30='

=8+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

==+ Fk 0 Djkjrw 2>:2 K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr elpg~lc c}mgbgpsirfe pmc ojscBfckgkh y+ OGJ, Kf+ >8%0?> -@+@+O+'+



20/38

2>

=7+ Fk := Djkjrw 2>:2 OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>:2%>>30=+

7>+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bwOGJ, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

7:+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

KGKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-TJG@ IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL SKAKFXK KF+ :'


7?+ Fk 0 Djkjrw 2>:2 Tjg` sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr krc`jopc` of~gcsfi brgcis mc mj` xrgppck gk pxf _pcrlgkh y+ Pckcpofrp ojscs, Kf+ >:%=>8? -_+@+K+W+' jk` Kf+ >?%

?27 -C+@+ Yj+' -ofllcopgyclw _pcrlgkh ojscs'+

70+ OGJ mjs kfp ~rfyg`c` Tjg` xgpm jk joakfxlc`hceckp fi pmgs rczcsp+73+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bw

OGJ, Tjg` mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

79+ Tjg` mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk mc sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

PCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-TJG@ IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL SKAKFXK KF+ 2'


Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc 2> fi ?=


21/38

2:

7=+ Fk 0 Djkjrw 2>:2 Tjg` sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr rcofr`s ~crpjgkgkhpf pmc oljssgigojpgfk fi gkifrejpgfk gk pmc brgcis mc xrfpc gk pmc _pcrlgkh ojscs+

77+ OGJ mjs kfp ~rfyg`c` Tjg` xgpm jk joakfxlc`hceckp fi pmgs rczcsp+:>>+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bw

OGJ, Tjg` mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

:>:+ Tjg` mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk mc sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

CLCYCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>:2%>>303'

:>2+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

:>?+ Fk 0 Djkjrw 2>:2 K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr jll rcofr`s`foeckpgkh jkw lfss fi rcofr`s irfe pmc `cspropgfk fi pmc OGJ fiigoc gk 8 Xfrl` Prj`c Ockpcr

fk :: _c~pcebcr 2>>:+

:>0+ Fk := Djkjrw 2>:2 OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>:2%>>303+ Gk pmgs lcppcr OGJ rcisc` pf ofkigre fr `ckw pmc c}gspckoc fr

kfkc}gspckoc fi jkw rcs~fksgyc rcofr`s, ogpgkh C}ce~pgfks -b'-:' jk` -b'-?'+

:>3+ Fk 22 Djkjrw 2>:2 K_O j~~cjlc` pmgs `cpcregkjpgfk+ OGJ joakfxlc`hc` pmgsj~~cjl fk 2 Icbrjrw 2>:2+

:>9+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bwOGJ, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

:>8+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc 2: fi ?=


22/38

22

PXCLIPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL SKAKFXK KF+ ?'

:>=+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

:>7+ Fk 2? Djkjrw 2>:2 K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr rcofr`s ~crpjgkgkhpf pmc oljssgigojpgfk fi pmc c}gspckoc fr kfkc}gspckoc fi rcofr`s rcs~fksgyc pf Rczcsp Kf+ I%

2>:2%>>303+

::>+ OGJ mjs kfp ~rfyg`c` K_O xgpm jk joakfxlc`hceckp fi pmgs rczcsp+:::+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bw

OGJ, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

::2+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

PMGRPCCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL SKAKFXK KF+ 0'

::?+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

::0+ Fk :7 @cocebcr 2>:: K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr rcofr`s~crpjgkgkh pf pmc oljssgigojpgfk fi pmc c}gspckoc fr kfkc}gspckoc fi IFGJ rczcsps sbegppc` bw

_ofpp Mf`cs pf fpmcr hfycrkeckp jhckogcs jk` rcicrrc` pf OGJ+

::3+ OGJ mjs kfp ~rfyg`c` K_O xgpm jk joakfxlc`hceckp fi pmgs rczcsp+::9+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bw




23/38

2?

::8+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

IFSRPCCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-_JOA IFGJ CLCOPRFKGO RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>:2%>>0?:'

::=+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

::7+ Fk :2 @cocebcr 2>:: _joa sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr pmc Ijll :79:_p`gcs gk Gkpcllghckoc Lcppcr pf pmc C`gpfr ckpgplc` Rcscryjpgfks fk pmc ^flwhrj~m+ _joa

s~cogigojllw rczcspc` pmjp pmc rcofr` bc ~rfyg`c` gk clcoprfkgo ifrejp+

:2>+ Fk 2: @cocebcr 2>:: OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>:2%>>0?:+ Gk pmgs lcppcr OGJ spjpc` pmjp pmgs rcofr` mj` bcck ~rcygfslw rclcjsc`

jk` ckolfsc` jk krc`jopc` ~j~cr of~w+

:2:+ Fk 27 @cocebcr 2>:: _joa j~~cjlc` OGJs rcisjl pf ~rfyg`c mcr pmc clcoprfkgorcofr` smc rczcspc`+

:22+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bwOGJ, _joa mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

:2?+ _joa mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmgs rcofr` gk pmc clcoprfkgo ifrejpsmc rczcspc`, jk` pmcrc gs kf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

IGIPCCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-JLL IFGJ RCIS_GKH PF ^RFYG@C CLCOPRFKGO RCOFR@_'

:20+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc 2? fi ?=


24/38

20

:23+ ^ljgkpgiis mjyc kcycr rcocgyc` clcoprfkgo rcofr`s irfe OGJ gk rcs~fksc pf IFGJrczcsps+ Fpmcr irczckp IFGJ rczcspcrs, gkol`gkh pmc Kjpgfkjl _corgpw Jromgyc, _pcyck

Jipcrhff`, jk` Egomjcl Rjykgptaw, xmf bcpxcck pmce mjyc iglc` pmfsjk`s fi IFGJ rczcsps

xgpm OGJ, mjyc ofkigrec` pmjp pmcw mjyc kcycr rcocgyc` clcoprfkgo rcofr`s irfe OGJ gk rcs~fksc

pf IFGJ rczcsps+

:29+ OGJ jègps pmjp gp mjs j bljkacp ~flgow fi ofksg`crgkh cycrw rcofr` kfp rcj`glwrc~rfògblc gk clcoprfkgo ifrejp xgpm pmc c}oc~pgfk fi j sclcop icx ojpchfrgcs fi irczckplw

rczcspc` rcofr`s+ OGJ `cick`s pmgs ~flgow xgpm pmc jrheckp pmjp gps IFGJ ~rfocssgkh sfipxjrc

gs fklw lfojpc` fk gps oljssgigc` ofe~pcr swspce, jk` pmjp jipcr ~rfocssgkh rcofr`s ifr rclcjsc

sgkh pmjp sfipxjrc gp gs k`lw br`cksfec pf pmck rcefyc pmc rcofr`s irfe pmc oljssgigc`

swspce jk` brk pmce pf `ghgpjl ec`gj+ _cc hckcrjllw OGJs iglgkhs gk Ojsc Kfs+ ::%00?, ::%000+

:28+ J ~flgow, ~rjopgoc, fr _F^ fi rcisgkh pf ~rfyg`c jkw rclcjsjblc rcofr`s gkclcoprfkgo ifrejp -xgpm pmc c}oc~pgfk fi j sclcop icx ~rc`cigkc` ojpchfrgcs' gs gk ygfljpgfk fi

IFGJ+ _om j ~rjopgoc ofkspgppcs fprjhcfs ofkòp ifr ~r~fscs fi pmc brfj` czgpjblc

~fxcrs ~rfyg`c` bw IFGJ pf pmc Ofrp+ _om j ~flgow gs jrbgprjrw, oj~rgogfs, jk jbsc fi

`gsorcpgfk, fr fpmcrxgsc ofkprjrw pf ljx+

:2=+ ^ljgkpgiis spjk` pf ofkpgkc pf bc mjrec` bw pmgs fkhfgkh ~flgow gk pmc iprc, jspmcw rchljrlw iglc IFGJ rczcsps xgpm OGJ jk` xgll ofkpgkc pf `f sf gk pmc iprc+

:27+ ^ljgkpgiis jrc pmcrcifrc ckpgplc` pf rclgci gk pmc ifre fi j `coljrjpfrw fr`cr pmjp OGJgs gk ygfljpgfk fi gps spjppfrw rcs~fksgbglgpgcs k`cr IFGJ jk` jk gkdkopgfk ofe~cllgkh OGJ pf

pglgtc j efrc rcjsfkjblc IFGJ ~rfocssgkh swspce pmjp gs gk ofe~lgjkoc xgpm pmc clcoprfkgo

rcofr`s ~rfygsgfk fi IFGJ+



25/38

23

_G]PCCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>::%>:987'

:?>+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

:?:+ Fk 2> Dkc 2>:: K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr rcofr`s ~crpjgkgkh pfpmc scjrom pffls jk` gk`gocs jyjgljblc pf pmc ofe~fkckps gk pmc @grcopfr fi pmc Ockprjl

Gkpcllghckoc Jhckow Jrcj -@OGJ Jrcj' ifr ofk`opgkh scjromcs fi pmcgr rcs~copgyc rcofr`s gk

rcs~fksc pf IFGJ rczcsps+

:?2+ Fk ?> Dkc 2>:: OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>:987+ Gk pmgs lcppcr, OGJ spjpc`, Xc xgll scjrom ifr rcofr`s c}gspgkh


:??+ Fk 2= @cocebcr 2>:: K_O sckp j lcppcr ofkpjgkgkh pmc ifllfxgkh pf OGJ4G je xrgpgkh pf oljrgiw pmjp, xgpm rcs~cop pf Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>:987, jkw

`foeckp xmgom ofkpjgks rcs~fksgyc gkifrejpgfk gs pf bc ~rfocssc` js

rcs~fksgyc pf pmgs rczcsp gk gps ckpgrcpw+ Gk fpmcr xfr`s, wf jrc kfpjllfxc` pf

rc`jop gkifrejpgfk irfe rcs~fksgyc `foeckps js kfk%rcs~fksgyc+ Gi pmcrc xjs

jkw `fbp bcifrc js pf pmc gkpck`c` sof~c fi pmgs rczcsp, pmcrc smfl` bc kfkc

kfx1 Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>:987 gs ifr jkw jk` jll rcofr`s gk pmcgr ckpgrcpw xmgom

ofkpjgk gkifrejpgfk `csorgbc` gk pmc gkgpgjl rczcsp lcppcr+

Irpmcrefrc, js sg} efkpms mjyc ~jssc` xgpmfp j rcs~fksc irfe wf sgkoc

wfr igrsp joakfxlc`hceckp lcppcr, xc ifrejllw fbdcop pf pmc sc fi ?> Dkc 2>::

js j op%fii `jpc ifr wfr scjrom+ Gk lghmp fi pmgs, xc c}~cop pmjp wf xgll sc pmc

`jpc pmjp wf ofeeckoc-`' pmc scjrom js j efrc j~~rf~rgjpc op%fii `jpc+



26/38

29

:?0+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bwOGJ, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

:?3+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+ K_O mjs j irpmcr lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf



_CYCKPCCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL SKAKFXK KF+ 3'

:?9+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

:?8+ Gk rcs~fksc pf K_Os Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>>9=2, OGJ rclcjsc` pxf rc`jopc``foeckps, EFRG Kfs+ O>3993397 jk` O>399338>+ J sghkgigojkp jefkp fi gkifrejpgfk xjs

rc`jopc` irfe pmcsc pxf `foeckps js kfk%rcs~fksgyc pf pmjp rczcsp+

:?=+ Fk 2= @cocebcr 2>:: K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr pmc ~frpgfks fi@foeckps O>3993397 jk` O>399338> xgpmmcl` irfe Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>>9=2 js kfk%

rcs~fksgyc+

:?7+ OGJ mjs kfp ~rfyg`c` K_O xgpm jk joakfxlc`hceckp fi pmgs rczcsp+:0>+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bw


:0:+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+



27/38

28

CGHMPCCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>::%>:98='


:0?+ Fk 2> Dkc 2>:: K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr of~gcs fi pmc igycefsp rcockp ecefrjk`j fr ~flgow spjpceckps orcjpc` bw pmc OGJ Gkifrejpgfk jk` Ejkjhceckp

_crygocs -GE_' fiigoc ifr `gsprgbpgfk xgpmgk GE_+

:00+ Fk ?> Dkc 2>:: OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>:98=+ Gk pmgs lcppcr, OGJ spjpc`, Xc xgll scjrom ifr rcofr`s c}gspgkh


:03+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bwOGJ, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+

:09+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+ K_O mjs j irpmcr lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf



KGKCPCCKPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>::%>2:37'


:0=+ Fk ?: Jhsp 2>:: OGJ rcs~fk`c` pf K_Os IFGJ Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>:>:>xgpm j lcppcr xmgom spjpc`, gk ~crpgkckp ~jrp, Irpmcr, pmc rcygcx fi som rcofr`s xfl` ge~fsc jk



28/38

2=

c}ocssgyc jk` krcjsfkjblc br`ck fk pmc Jhckow, jk` ~rsjkp pf rclcyjkp ~rcoc`ckp, xc esp

`colgkc pf ~rfocss som rczcsps+

:07+ Fk 9 _c~pcebcr 2>:: K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr rcofr`s~crpjgkgkh pf pmc rclcyjkp ~rcoc`ckp pf xmgom pmgs lcppcr rcicrrc`+ Pmgs rczcsp jlsf s~cogigc`

pmjp gi pmgs ljkhjhc xjs `rjxk irfe j rc~fsgpfrw fi pce~ljpc ljkhjhc, pmc ckpgrc rc~fsgpfrw fi

pce~ljpc ljkhjhc xjs pf bc ofksg`crc` rcs~fksgyc pf pmc rczcsp, jk` kfkc fi gp xjs pf bc

ofksg`crc` kfk%rcs~fksgyc+

:3>+ Fk 27 _c~pcebcr 2>:: OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>2:37+

:3:+ Fk 2: Fopfbcr 2>:: OGJ rclcjsc` fkc `foeckp ofe~rgsc` sflclw fi pmc~jrjhrj~m xmgom mj` bcck sc` gk pmc rcs~fksc lcppcr pf Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>:>:>+ OGJ

xgpmmcl` jk kakfxk kebcr fi fpmcr rcofr`s gk pmcgr ckpgrcpw ogpgkh C}ce~pgfks -b'-?' jk`

-b'-3'+ OGJ `g` kfp lgsp pmc rcofr`s xgpmmcl` gk pmcgr ckpgrcpw, kfr `g` gp c}~ljgk xmw gp mj` kfp

gkol`c` pmc rcejgk`cr fi pmc rc~fsgpfrw fi pmgs pce~ljpc ljkhjhc+

:32+ Fk 27 @cocebcr 2>:: K_O sckp j lcppcr ofkpjgkgkh pmc ifllfxgkh pf OGJ,ifllfxgkh jk j~~rf~rgjpc sprgkh fi ojsc ljx ogpjpgfks4

Wfr lcppcr ~rfyg`c` kf gkifrejpgfk rchjr`gkh pmc kjprc fi pmc rcofr`s bcgkh

xgpmmcl` gk pmcgr ckpgrcpw+ Xmglc gp gs czjllw xcll%cspjblgsmc` pmjp jk jhckow fcs

kfp mjyc pf ~rfyg`c pmc lcycl fi `cpjgl fi j Yjhmk gk`c} jp pmc j`egkgsprjpgyc

spjhc, gp esp ~rfyg`c sfecpmgkh xmgom g`ckpgigcs pmc rcofr`s bcgkh xgpmmcl` jk`

`csorgbcs pmc rcjsfks ifr pmcgr xgpmmfl`gkh gk hckcrjl pcres+ Ifr ~r~fscs fi

C}ce~pgfk -b'-3', pmjp xfl` ckpjgl g`ckpgiwgkh xmgom ~rgyglchcs -c+h+, `clgbcrjpgyc

~rfocss, jppfrkcw%olgckp, jppfrkcw xfra ~rf`op' jrc bcgkh oljgec`+ Pmcrcifrc,

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc 2= fi ?=


29/38

27

~lcjsc ~rfyg`c s xgpm som j lgsp gk j ~rfe~p ijsmgfk sf pmjp xc ejw rcjom jk

gkpcllghckp `cogsgfk rchjr`gkh fr j~~cjl sprjpchw, gkol`gkh xmcpmcr fr kfp pf

j~~cjl pmc j`czjow fi wfr scjrom+ Skpgl xc fbpjgk som j lgsp, xc `f kfp

ofksg`cr wfr rcs~fksc pf ofkspgppc j ~rf~cr igkjl `cpcregkjpgfk rcs~fksc jk`

rcdcop wfr j~~cjl `cj`lgkc+

:3?+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bw OGJxmgom eccps pmc rczgrceckps fi_mcreof Gk`sprgcs y+ _corcpjrw fi pmc S+_+ Jgr Ifroc, 032 I+

_~~+ ?>9 -K+@+ P}+ :78=', jk` gps ~rfhckw, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc

rcec`gcs+

:30+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

PXCKPGCPM OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ OFK_PRSOPGYC RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>:2%>>300'


:39+ Fk 0 Djkjrw 2>:2 K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr jll pce~ljpcljkhjhc sc` bw OGJ IFGJ jkjlwsps pf ofe~fsc rcs~fksc lcppcrs pf IFGJ rczcspcrs+

:38+ Fk 2> Djkjrw 2>:2 OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>:2%>>300+ OGJ spjpc` pmjp gp xjs ~rfocssgkh j rczcsp ifr pmc sjec rcofr`s

irfe jkfpmcr rczcspcr, jlpmfhm gp `g` kfp spjpc xmjp op%fii `jpc gp sc` ifr pmc ~rcygfs rczcsp+

:3=+ Js pxckpw xfragkh `jws mjyc clj~sc` xgpmfp j sbspjkpgyc `cpcregkjpgfk bwOGJ, K_O mjs c}mjspc` jll rczgrc` j`egkgsprjpgyc rcec`gcs+



30/38

?>

:37+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+ K_O mjs j irpmcr lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf

pmc sc fi j rcjsfkjblc op%fii `jpc bw OGJ, jk` pmcrc gs kf lchjl bjsgs ifr OGJ pf sge~lw

~rfyg`c rcofr`s xmgom mjyc bcck ~rfocssc` ifr j ~rcygfs rczcspcr sgkh j op%fii `jpc xmgom

~rc`jpcs K_Os rczcsp+

PXCKPW%IGR_P OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-_JOA IFGJ RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>::%>2:3='

:9>+ ^ljgkpgiis rc~cjp jk` rcjllchc pmc jllchjpgfks ofkpjgkc` gk jll ~jrjhrj~ms scp ifrpmjbfyc+

:9:+ Fk 9 _c~pcebcr 2>:: _joa sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr pmgrpw%pxfs~cogigc` `foeckps orrckplw ~blgsmc` gk pmc OGJ Rcofr`s _cjrom Pffl -ORC_P', jk

clcoprfkgo `jpjbjsc mfsc` jp pmc Kjpgfkjl Jromgycs jk` Rcofr`s J`egkgsprjpgfk bp ejgkpjgkc`

bw OGJ+ Pmgs rczcsp lcppcr spjpc`, QRUcofr`s xmgom jrc orrckplw ~blgsmc` gk ORC_P gk

rc`jopc` ifre smfl` bc rcygcxc` ifr ill rclcjsc k`cr IFGJ+ _joa rczcspc` j ~blgo gkpcrcsp

icc xjgycr jk` clcoprfkgo rcofr`s+

:92+ Fk :? _c~pcebcr 2>:: OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>::%>2:3=+ OGJ rclcjsc` ~j~cr of~gcs fi pmc rc`jopc` ycrsgfks fi pmc pmgrpw%pxf

`foeckps xmgom xcrc ~blgsmc` gk ORC_P+ Gk pmgs lcppcr OGJ jlsf `ckgc` _joas rczcsp ifr j

~blgo gkpcrcsp icc xjgycr jk` jsscssc` j `~lgojpgfk icc fi $:?, spjpgkh pmjp pmcrc ofl` bc kf

~blgo gkpcrcsp gk rclcjsgkh rcofr`s xmgom xcrc jlrcj`w ~blgsmc` gk ORC_P+

:9?+ Fk 29 _c~pcebcr 2>:: _joa j~~cjlc` jll rc`jopgfks gk pmc pmgrpw%pxf `foeckps,gk`gojpgkh pmjp smc mj` rczcspc` pmjp jll rc`jopc` rcofr`s bc ~rfocssc` illw ifr rclcjsc k`cr

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc ?> fi ?=


31/38

?:

IFGJ+ _joa jlsf j~~cjlc` OGJs icc xjgycr ckgjl, bp ~jg` $:? js jk jop fi hff` ijgpm xgpm pmc

c}~copjpgfk pmjp gp xfl` bc rcprkc` gi mcr j~~cjl xjs hrjkpc`+

:90+ Fk := Fopfbcr 2>:: OGJ rcs~fk`c` pf _joas j~~cjl, spjpgkh, gk ~crpgkckp ~jrp4Gp xjs kfp olcjr pmjp wf xcrc rczcspgkh j rc%rcygcx fi pmcsc `foeckps

xmck wfr rczcsp olcjrlw -jk` bfl`lw' rczcspc` pmc jbfyc sbdcop+ Mfxcycr, xc

ojk f~ck j kcx rczcsp pf j``rcss pmgs rc%rcygcx gi wf xgsm+

^lcjsc bc j`ygsc` pmjp wf xcrc kfp hgyck j~~cjl rghmps gk pmc cjrlgcr

rcs~fksc, jk`, js som, xc ojkkfp jooc~p wfr j~~cjl+ Pmjp rczcsp xjs j scjrom

gk fr ~rcygfslw rclcjsc` `jpjbjsc ofkpjgkgkh rcofr`s jlrcj`w rclcjsc` gk

ofkkcopgfk xgpm j `giicrckp ~rfhrje+

:93+ _joa mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk smc sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+ _~cogigojllw, pmcrc gs kf lchjl bjsgs ifr OGJ pf

sge~lw ~rfyg`c rcofr`s xmgom mj` bcck ~rcygfslw ~rfocssc` xmck _joa c}~lgogplw s~cogigc` gk

mcr gkgpgjl rczcsp lcppcr pmjp jll rcofr`s orrckplw ~blgsmc` gk rc`jopc` ifre xcrc pf bc rc%

~rfocssc` ifr rclcjsc k`cr IFGJ+

:99+ _gegljrlw, js OGJs `ckgjl fi _joas rczcsp ifr j ~blgo gkpcrcsp icc xjgycr xjs~rc`gojpc` fk jk gkofrrcop jsse~pgfk pmjp smc mj` rczcspc` pmc pmgrpw%pxf rcofr`s js pmcw xcrc

~blgsmc` gk ORC_P, _joa mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf rcocgyc j ~blgo gkpcrcsp icc xjgycr,

jk` pmcrc gs kf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+

PXCKPW%_COFK@ OJS_C FI JOPGFK

-K_O IFGJ RCOFR@_ @CKGJL I%2>:2%>>>=>'


Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc ?: fi ?=


32/38

?2

:9=+ Fk 0 Ejw 2>:> K_O sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr, gkpcr jlgj, QpUmc :3IFGJ rczcsps rcocgyc` bw pmc Ockprjl Gkpcllghckoc Jhckow -OGJ' `rgkh Igsojl Wcjr 2>>= pmjp

xcrc oljssgigc` js ill `ckgjls bcojsc pmc Rcofr`s QxcrcU kfp Rcjsfkjblw @csorgbc` gk

_copgfk Y, Omjrp B-:' fk ^jhc = fi pmc 2>>= Jkkjl Rc~frp, jyjgljblc jp

mpp~4&&xxx+ifgj+ogj+hfy&p}p&jkkjlVrc~frpV2>>=+~`i+

:97+ Bw pclc~mfkc fk 3 Ejw 2>:>, OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk`jssghkc` gp Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::9+

:8>+ Bw pclc~mfkc fk 8 Jhsp 2>:>, K_O jk` OGJ jhrcc` pf ofebgkc pmgs rczcspxgpm Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::8 jk` clgegkjpc Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::9+ Bw lcppcr jpc` :8

Kfycebcr 2>:>, OGJ ecefrgjlgtc` pmc pcres fi pmc 8 Jhsp 2>:> pclc~mfkc ojll+

:8:+ Fk 2= Icbrjrw 2>:: K_O iglc` sgp gk pmc ojscKjpgfkjl _corgpw Ofksclfrs y+OGJ, Kf+ ::%000+ Ofkp :8 fi pmjp ofe~ljgkp ofksgspc` fi j ofkspropgyc `ckgjl IFGJ ofkp ifr

pmc ecrhc` Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::8+

:82+ Fk ?: Jhsp 2>:: OGJ ~rfyg`c` K_O xgpm rcofr`s rcs~fksgyc pf pmc ecrhc`Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::8+ OGJs rcs~fksc `g` kfp gk`gojpc xmgom rcofr`s xcrc rcs~fksgyc pf

Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::9 jk` xmgom xcrc rcs~fksgyc pf pmc frghgkjl, kfk%ecrhc` I%2>:>%

>:::8+

:8?+ Bcojsc gp gs kfp ~fssgblc pf `gsocrk irfe pmc rcofr`s pmcesclycs xmgom rcofr`sjrc rcs~fksgyc pf xmgom rczcsp, K_O jsac` OGJ scycrjl pgecs pf g`ckpgiw pmc igipcck rcofr`s

xmgom xcrc rcs~fksgyc pf Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::9+ OGJ rcisc` pf ~rfyg`c jkw oljrgigojpgfk,

ogpgkh pmc ijop pmjp pmc rczcsps mj` bcck ofebgkc` xgpm K_Os ofksckp+

:80+ Fk :2 Fopfbcr 2>:: K_O pmcrcifrc sbegppc` pf OGJ j IFGJ rczcsp ifr pmc igrsp~jhc fi pmc gkgpgjl rcs~fksc lcppcr ifr cjom fi pmc igipcck IFGJ rczcsps g`ckpgigc` gk Rczcsp Kf+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc ?2 fi ?=
http://www.foia.cia.gov/txt/annual_report_2008.pdfhttp://www.foia.cia.gov/txt/annual_report_2008.pdfhttp://www.foia.cia.gov/txt/annual_report_2008.pdf


33/38

??

I%2>:>%>:::9+ K_O irpmcr spjpc`, QGUi wf ~rcicr pf dsp ~rfyg`c s xgpm j lgsp fi pmc igipcck

rczcsps sf rcicrckoc` gk pmc 2>>= Jkkjl Rc~frp, xc xgll jooc~p pmjp gk lgc fi pmc Qrczcspc`U

rcofr`s+

:83+ Fk ?: Fopfbcr 2>:: OGJ joakfxlc`hc` rcocg~p fi pmgs rczcsp jk` jssghkc` gpRczcsp Kf+ I%2>:2%>>>=>+ OGJ rcisc` pf ~rfocss pmc rczcsp, spjpgkh pmjp gp xjs j `~lgojpc fi

fkc fi pmc lgkc gpces fi pmc ecrhc` Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::8+

:89+ Fk 0 Kfycebcr 2>:: K_O xrfpc pmc ifllfxgkh pf OGJ4Xc mjyc rcocgyc` wfr lcppcr `jpc` ?: Fopfbcr 2>:: rchjr`gkh pmc jbfyc

gk`gojpc` rczcsp+ Xc jrc jxjrc pmjp pmgs rczcsp gs j `~lgojpc fi ~jrp fi Rczcsp

/I%2>:>%>:::81 xc gk ijop sjg` sf gk pmc rczcsp lcppcr+ Xc jlsf c}~ljgkc` zgpc

olcjrlw pmjp pmc gkifrejpgfk xc jrc sccagkh gs `foeckpjpgfk jllfxgkh s pf

`cpcregkc xmgom fi pmc rcofr`s pmjp wf rclcjsc` fk ?: Jhsp 2>:: xcrc

rcs~fksgyc pf Gpce ? fi pmjp rczcsp+ Pf zfpc4

Pf jssgsp gk wfr scjrom, pmcsc rcofr`s xcrc jlrcj`w g`ckpgigc` jk` rclcjsc`

gk rcs~fksc pf Rczcsp Kfs+ I%2>:>%>:::9 jk` I%2>:>%>:::8+ Mfxcycr,

wf ofebgkc` pmfsc pxf rczcsps gkpf fkc -I%2>:>%>:::8', jk` xmck wf

rclcjsc` pmc rcofr`s wf `g` kfp s~cogiw xmgom rcofr`s xcrc rcs~fksgyc pf

I%2>:>%>:::9 jk` xmgom xcrc rcs~fksgyc pf I%2>:>%>:::8+ Wf

sbsczckplw rcisc` pf ~rfyg`c jkw oljrgigojpgfk fk pmjp kfpc,

kcocssgpjpgkh pmc iglgkh fi pmgs IFGJ rczcsp+ Mfxcycr, gi wf ~rcicr pf

dsp ~rfyg`c s xgpm j lgsp fi pmc igipcck rczcsps sf rcicrckoc` gk pmc 2>>=

Jkkjl Rc~frp, xc xgll jooc~p pmjp gk lgc fi pmc jbfyc rcofr`s+

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc ?? fi ?=


34/38

?0

Xc pmcrcifrc j~~cjl wfr `cogsgfk pf kfp ~rfyg`c s xgpm pmc rcs~fksgyc

rcofr`s xc rczcspc`+ Js wf ojk scc, pmc rcs~fksgyc rcofr`s pjack js j xmflc gk

pmc ofkpc}p fi pmgs rczcsp ~rfyg`c s xgpm gkifrejpgfk pmjp xc xcrc kfp jblc pf

`cpcregkc irfe wfr ?: Jhsp 2>:: rclcjsc+ Bcojsc pmc OGJ rcisc` -pmrfhm

gps jppfrkcw' pf ~rfyg`c pmgs gkifrejpgfk pf s xmck xc jsac` `rgkh pmc ofrsc fi

pmc lgpghjpgfk fycr Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::8, jk` bcojsc pmc OGJ xfl` rcdcop j

rczcsp gk xmgom xc jsac` Xmgom rczcsps xcrc rcicrckoc` gk _copgfk Y, Omjrp

B-:' fi pmc 2>>= Jkkjl Rc~frp js ill `ckgjls bcojsc pmc QrUcofr`s xcrc kfp

rcjsfkjblw `csorgbc`6 fk pmc hrfk`s pmjp IFGJ `fcs kfp rczgrc jhckogcs pf

jksxcr zcspgfks, xc mjyc kf jlpcrkjpgyc bp pf rc%rczcsp pmcsc igipcck ~jhcs bw

pmcesclycs xgpm kf fpmcr `foeckps sf pmjp xc ojk `cpcregkc pmc jksxcr ifr

frsclycs+

:88+ Fk 2> Djkjrw 2>:2 OGJ rcisc` pf jooc~p K_Os j~~cjl, spjpgkh4 Wfr gkgpgjlrczcsp xjs kfp ~rfocssc`, pmcrcifrc, pmcrc jrc kf j`egkgsprjpgyc j~~cjl rghmps jk` xc ojkkfp

jooc~p wfr j~~cjl+ Wf jrc ckofrjhc`, mfxcycr, pf rcigkc pmc sof~c fi wfr rczcsp jk` sbegp

gp jkcx jp jkw pgec+ K_O sbsczckplw sckp j ij} pf OGJ rczcspgkh pf s~cja xgpm _sjk

Ygsosf, OGJs IFGJ ^blgo Lgjgsfk, rchjr`gkh pmgs rczcsp jk` jlsf lcip pxf yfgoc ejgl

ecssjhcs ifr mcr+ K_O jlsf rczcspc` pmjp pmc Fiigoc fi Hfycrkeckp Gkifrejpgfk _crygocs

-FHG_' jsa Es+ Ygsosf pf rcprk gps ojlls, xmgom pmc FHG_ rc~rcsckpjpgyc gk`gojpc` smc xfl`+

Kcgpmcr Es+ Ygsosf kfr jkwfkc clsc irfe OGJ mjs ofkpjopc` K_O jbfp pmgs rczcsp+

:8=+ K_O mjs j lchjl rghmp k`cr IFGJ pf fbpjgk pmc gkifrejpgfk gp sccas, jk` pmcrc gskf lchjl bjsgs ifr pmc `ckgjl bw OGJ fi sjg` rghmp+ _~cogigojllw, pmcrc gs kf lchjl bjsgs ifr OGJ pf

rcisc pf ~rfocss j rczcsp bcojsc pmc rcofr`s xcrc jlrcj`w ~rfyg`c` pf K_O, xmck pmc kcx



35/38

?3

rczcsp s~cogigc` pmjp K_O xjs rczcspgkh rcofr`s xmgom xfl` g`ckpgiw xmgom fi pmc mk`rc`s fi

rcofr`s rcs~fksgyc pf Rczcsp Kf+ I%2>:>%>:::8 xcrc pmc igipcck rczcsps s~cogigojllw eckpgfkc`

gk pmc 2>>= Jkkjl Rc~frp+

^RJWCR IFR RCLGCI

XMCRCIFRC, ^ljgkpgiis Kjpgfkjl _corgpw Ofksclfrs, Ajpmrwk _joa, Dciircw _pcgk, jk`

Ejra Tjg`, jk` xmcrc j~~rf~rgjpc jll fpmcr sgegljrlw sgpjpc` gk`gyg`jls, ~rjw pmjp pmgs Ofrp4

-:' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp pmc Ockprjl Gkpcllghckoc Jhckows jppce~p pf ~rfelhjpc jkcx E@R rchljpgfk xgpmfp kfpgoc jk` ofeeckp gs j ygfljpgfk fi ic`crjl ljx, jk` pmjp pmgs

ygfljpgfk xjs gkpckpgfkjl jk`&fr xgllil1

-2' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp pmc rchljpfrw ef`gigojpgfks jppce~pc` gk 89 Ic`+ Rch+37>?2 jrc kll jk` yfg`1

-?' Fr`cr OGJ, gk pmc ifre fi gkdkopgyc rclgci, pf ~rfocss jll E@R rczcsps rcocgyc`sgkoc 2? _c~pcebcr 2>:: joofr`gkhlw1

-0' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp j ~flgow fi omjrhgkh iccs pf E@R rczcspcrs gs j ygfljpgfk fipmc GFJJ, jk` pmjp pmgs ygfljpgfk xjs gkpckpgfkjl jk`&fr xgllil1

-3' Fr`cr OGJ pf ~blgolw jkkfkoc, gkol`gkh fk gps xcbsgpc, pmjp gp mjs `gsofkpgkc`ckifroceckp fi gps ~flgow fi rczgrgkh jk ~irfkp ofeegpeckp irfe E@R rczcspcrs pf ~jw

j~~lgojblc iccs1

-9' ^rfmgbgp OGJ, gk pmc ifre fi gkdkopgyc rclgci, irfe ~rfelhjpgkh kcx rchljpgfksjpmfrgtgkh gp pf omjrhc E@R rczcspcrs ifr pmc ~rfocssgkh fi pmcgr rczcsps1

-8' Fr`cr OGJ pf ofkpjop cycrw E@R rczcspcr xmf gs ~jrp fi pmc oljss jk` fiicr pmcf~~frpkgpw pf rcgkspjpc pmcgr rcs~copgyc rczcsps jk` pmck ~rfocss joofr`gkhlw1



36/38

?9

-=' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp OGJ ygfljpc` IFGJ bw rcisgkh pf ~rfyg`c pxf ircc mfrs fiscjrom pgec pf jll fpmcr rczcspcrs xmf rcisc` pf ~jw iccs, jk` pmjp pmgs ygfljpgfk xjs

gkpckpgfkjl jk`&fr xgllil1

-7' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp jkw OGJ rchljpgfks, hg`clgkcs, fr ~flgow spjpceckps pmjpjpmfrgtc pmc rcisjl pf ~rfyg`c pxf ircc mfrs fi scjrom pgec jll fpmcr rczcspcrs xmf rcisc

pf ~jw jkw iccs ofkspgppc jk krcjsfkjblc gkpcr~rcpjpgfk fi pmc spjppfrw fblghjpgfks ge~fsc` bw

IFGJ1

-:>' Fr`cr OGJ, gk pmc ifre fi gkdkopgyc rclgci, pf ~rfyg`c pxf ircc mfrs fi scjrompgec pf jll fpmcr rczcspcrs xmf rcisc pf ~jw jkw iccs jk` pf jeck` gps rchljpgfks, hg`clgkcs,

jk` ~flgow spjpceckps joofr`gkhlw1

-::' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp OGJ ygfljpc` IFGJ bw ofkpgkh pgec s~ckp bw ofe~pcrs~crifregkh jpfejpc` scjromcs ifr icc ~r~fscs, jk` pmjp pmgs ygfljpgfk xjs gkpckpgfkjl jk`&fr

xgllil1

-:2' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp jkw OGJ rchljpgfks, hg`clgkcs, fr ~flgow spjpceckps pmjpjpmfrgtc ofkpgkh pgec s~ckp bw ofe~pcrs ~crifregkh jpfejpc` scjromcs ifr icc ~r~fscs

ofkspgppc jk krcjsfkjblc gkpcr~rcpjpgfk fi pmc spjppfrw fblghjpgfks ge~fsc` bw IFGJ1

-:?' Fr`cr OGJ, gk pmc ifre fi gkdkopgyc rclgci, kfp pf ofkp pgec s~ckp bw ofe~pcrs~crifregkh jpfejpc` scjromcs ifr icc ~r~fscs jk` pf jeck` gps rchljpgfks, hg`clgkcs, jk`

~flgow spjpceckps joofr`gkhlw1

-:0' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp OGJ ygfljpc` IFGJ bw rcisgkh pf ~rfyg`c jkw rclcjsjblcrcofr`s gk clcoprfkgo ifrejp -xgpm pmc c}oc~pgfk fi j sclcop icx ~rc`cigkc` ojpchfrgcs', jk` pmjp

pmgs ygfljpgfk xjs gkpckpgfkjl jk`&fr xgllil1



37/38

?8

-:3' @coljrc jk` igk` pmjp jkw OGJ rchljpgfks, hg`clgkcs, fr ~flgow spjpceckps pmjpjpmfrgtc rcisgkh pf ~rfyg`c jkw rclcjsjblc rcofr`s gk clcoprfkgo ifrejp -xgpm pmc c}oc~pgfk fi j

sclcop icx ~rc`cigkc` ojpchfrgcs' ofkspgppc jk krcjsfkjblc gkpcr~rcpjpgfk fi pmc spjppfrw

fblghjpgfks ge~fsc` bw IFGJ1

-:9' Fr`cr OGJ, gk pmc ifre fi gkdkopgyc rclgci, pf pglgtc j efrc rcjsfkjblc IFGJ~rfocssgkh swspce pmjp gs gk ofe~lgjkoc xgpm pmc clcoprfkgo rcofr`s ~rfygsgfk fi IFGJ jk` pf

jeck` gps rchljpgfks, hg`clgkcs, jk` ~flgow spjpceckps joofr`gkhlw1

-:8' Fr`cr OGJ pf `gsolfsc pmc rczcspc` rcofr`s gk pmcgr ckpgrcpw jk` ejac of~gcs~rfe~plw jyjgljblc pf ^ljgkpgiis gk clcoprfkgo ifrejp xmck sf rczcspc`1

-:=' Fr`cr ~rclgegkjrw jk` ~crejkckp gkdkopgyc jk`&fr `coljrjpfrw rclgci js ejw bcj~~rf~rgjpc1

-:7' Jxjr` rcjsfkjblc ofsps jk` jppfrkcws iccs js ~rfyg`c` gk 3 S+_+O+ 332-j'-0'-C', 2= S+_+O+ 20:2-`', fr jkw fpmcr j~~lgojblc ljx1

-2>' C}~c`gpc pmgs jopgfk gk cycrw xjw ~rsjkp pf 2= S+_+O+ :938-j'1 jk`-2:' Hrjkp som fpmcr rclgci js pmc Ofrp ejw `cce dsp jk` ~rf~cr+



38/38

@jpc4 Icbrjrw 22, 2>:2

Rcs~copillw sbegppc`,

Acllw B+ EoOljkjmjk, Csz+@O Bjr /7=08>0

Kjpgfkjl _corgpw Ofksclfrs:2>> _fpm Ofrpmfsc Rfj`_gpc :20

Jrlgkhpfk, YJ 222>0?>:%82=%37>=20>%9=:%2:=7 ij}

AclNKjpgfkjl_corgpwLjx+frh

Brj`lcw ^+ Efss, Csz+

@O Bjr /7837>3Ljx Fiigoc fi Ejra _+ Tjg`, ^+O+:23> Ofkkcopgop Jyckc, KX

_gpc 2>>Xjsmgkhpfk, @O 2>>?92>2%030%2=>7

2>2%??>%39:> ij}Brj`NEjraTjg`+ofe

Ofkscl ifr ^ljgkpgiis

Ojsc :4:2%oy%>>2=0%BJM @foeckp : Iglc` >2&22&:2 ^jhc ?= fi ?=
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]

national security advisors v. cia

Documents