national zero waste council i plastics advisory panel ... · the national zero waste council, an...
TRANSCRIPT
NATIONAL ZERO WASTE COUNCIL I PLASTICS ADVISORY PANEL
Regulatory Approaches for Priority Plastic WastesAMENDED, DECEMBER 6, 2019
About the National Zero Waste Council
The National Zero Waste Council, an initiative of Metro Vancouver, is a leadership initiative bringing together governments, businesses and non-government organizations to advance waste prevention in Canada and the transition to a circular economy.
For more information, please visit www.nzwc.ca.
I.Objectives
1|P a g e
I. OBJECTIVESPlasticsserveusefulpurposesandcanbepartofmoreefficientpackagingandproducts,savingenergy,preventingothertypesofwastes,andprotectinghumanhealth.Thatsaid,someusesof(ormismanagementof)plasticcanbeproblematic,andcouldbeaddressedthroughtheapplicationofthe5Rshierarchy–thatis,focusingonmaterialsandproductredesignforsourcereductionandreuse,thenimprovedcollectionandrecycling,andfinallydisposalinaresponsiblemanner.Theobjectivesofthisdocumentareto:
• Identifyaselectionof‘priority’plasticwastes• Suggestspecificregulatorymeasurestoprevent,andbettermanage,thoseplasticwastes
ThisdocumenthasbeencompiledandreviewedbytheNationalZeroWasteCouncil’sPlasticsAdvisoryPanel;aPanelco-chairedbyrepresentativesofMetroVancouverandtheCommunautémétropolitainedeMontréalwhoaremembersoftheCouncil.InformingthisanalysisistheworkoftheCircularEconomyLeadershipCoalition(ofwhichtheCouncilisafoundingmember),theCCMEPlasticsStrategyandtheG7OceansPlasticsCharteraswellasrelevantresearch,analysisandactionsbylocalgovernmentsacrossCanada.Duetotimeconstraints,notallmembersofthePlasticsAdvisoryPanelwereabletoreviewtherecommendationsinfulldetail.Therefore,whilethePanelwasingeneralagreementwiththeoverallrecommendationsmade,itshouldbenotedthattheopinionsexpressedinthisdocumentarenotnecessarilythoseofallthePanelmembersortheirrespectiveorganizations.
II.GuidingPrinciplesandSelectionCriteria
2|P a g e
II. GUIDINGPRINCIPLES&SELECTIONCRITERIA
Theguidingprinciplesandcriteriausedtoselectpriorityplastics,andthesuggestedregulatorymeasures,include:
• SOURCEREDUCTION/PREVENTION:the5Rshierarchyandthepreferredorderofreduction,reuse,recycling,recoveryandresidualmanagement.Historically,mostregulatorymeasureshaveprovideddriversforincreasedrecyclingwhilereuseorsourcereductionhavebeenoverlooked.Inimplementingtheregulatorymeasuresrecommendedinthisdocument,regulatorsshouldincluderequirementsforwastepreventionbyreducingplasticuseatthesource.InordertomeetthetargetsoftheG7OceanPlasticsCharter,mandatoryandincrementallyincreasedrecycledplasticcontentwouldneedtobeimposedonallplasticsmarketedinCanada;
• MUNICIPALIMPACT:theimpactoftheplasticitemsonmunicipaloperations,particularlymunicipallitterandillegaldumping,oronmunicipalwastewatertreatment;
• ENVIRONMENTALIMPACT:impactonthereceivingenvironments,particularlyasacontributortooceanplasticsandimpactonmarinelife;
• ALTERNATIVES:thepracticalavailabilityofalternativestotheplasticmaterialusedintheitem,oralternativestotheitemitself;and
• BENEFITS:economic,environmentalorsocialbenefitsoftheplasticitem.
Otherconsiderationsarelistedbelow.
• OnesizedoesnotfitallNosingleregulatorymethodisuniversallyapplicable.Measuresmayinclude:
o Outrightprohibitionoftheuse/saleofaproductormaterial.o ‘Traditional’ExtendedProducerResponsibility(EPR)makingthe
manufacturer/brandownerofaproductfinanciallyandlegallyresponsibletocollectanddispose/recycletheirproductafteritsuse.Adeposit/refundsystemmaybeused,andtheEPRprogrammayincluderequirementstodrivewastepreventionthroughproductredesign,asopposedtosimplyincreasedrecycling.
o Otherproductstewardshipmodelsinwhichgovernmentstakeonaportionofthefundingand/oroperationofcollectionanddisposal/recyclingofaproductafteruse.
o Taxationorotherincentivesforproductcollection&recycling,orwasteprevention.
o Voluntaryindustryprogramsforwasteprevention/wasterecycling,withpossiblebackdropregulations,ifvoluntaryeffortsareunsuccessfulinagiventimeframe.
II.GuidingPrinciplesandSelectionCriteria
3|P a g e
• UnintendedconsequencesmustbeconsideredForexample,replacingaplasticitemwithanalternativematerialmayhaveanevengreaternegativeenvironmentalimpactsoveritslifecycle.
Therecanalsobeunintendedsocio-economicimpactswhichmaynecessitatesomeexemptionswhenimplementingbansandotherregulations.Forinstance,therearepeopleforwhomstrawsarenecessarynotoptionalandforwhomstrawsofalternativematerialsarenotideal.
• Biodegradable/compostableplasticsarenotacompletesolutiono Certificationstandardsforbiodegradable/compostableplasticsare
currentlysetoutonlyasasingle-level‘pass-fail’system.Thosecertifications(e.g.thoseestablishedbyAmericanSocietyforTestingandMaterialsandbytheBiodegradableProductsInstitute)allowsaplastictobecalledbiodegradable/compostableifitbreaksdowntoaspecifieddegree,overaminimumperiodoftime,whenexposedtoacertainminimumtemperatureandotherphysicalconditions.However,thatrequiredperiodoftimeisusuallylongerthanthenormalresidencetimeofmostcommercialcompostinganddigestionfacilities,andtheminimumrequiredtemperaturesarefarbelowthatofsay,amarineenvironment.
Theresultisthatmany‘certifiedbiodegradable’plasticswillnotsufficientlybiodegradeinexistingcommercialcompostingordigestionfacilities,letaloneinthenaturalenvironmentoflandoroceans.Someadvocateregulationstorequireorganicsprocessingfacilitiestomodifytheirdesignandoperationstoaccommodatethelongerprocessingrequirementsofsomebiodegradableplastics.However,itwouldbemorerealistictoexpectnewproductstobedesignedtofitthecapabilitiesofexistinginfrastructure.Thiscouldbedonethroughrequirementsbyseniorgovernments.
o Thewidespreaduseofbiodegradableplasticscouldhavetheunintendedconsequenceofincreasinglitteringandmarineplastics,ifthepublicmistakenlythinkssuchmaterialswillalwaysbiodegradeinthenaturalenvironment.
• Compromisesmaybenecessary
o Insomecases,areductionofplasticwastemaybepreferable,evenifitresultsinotherenvironmentalimpacts.Forexample,itmaybepreferableandmorepracticaltooffsetGHGs,thantotrytocompensateforoceanplasticspollution.
o Someregulatorymeasuresmayneedpartialinterimfundingfromgovernmentsinorderfortimelyimplementation.
II.GuidingPrinciplesandSelectionCriteria
4|P a g e
• RegulatorymeasuresneedsupportingprogramsSupportingprogramsforregulatorymeasuresincludebutarenotlimitedto:o Institutionalizingsourcereduction/wastepreventionthrough:
• Publicandprivatesectorprocurementpolicies,• Legislatedtargetsforsourcereduction/wasteprevention• Coordinated,harmonizedregulationsincludingEPR(including
requirementsforsourcereduction),andrestrictionsontheuseofunnecessarysingle-useitems.ManyCanadianmunicipalitiesincludingVictoria,Vancouver,MontrealandTorontohavebegunimplementingrestrictionsontheuse,distributionandsaleofcertainsingle-useitems.However,suchrestrictionsareproblematicforretailersandindustriesoperatingacrossmanydifferentlocationswithdifferentrequirements.Whereverpossible,theseshouldbecoordinatedorharmonizedataProvincialorevenFederallevel
o Institutionalizingrecyclingthrough:• Legislatedminimumrecycledcontentrequirementsinindividual
itemsorwithinanindustryoverall(notethatminimumrecycledcontentshouldalsobeconsideredinimplementingEPRprograms),
• Legislatedrequirementsforlabelling/disclosingofrecycledcontento Suitableenforcementtodrivecomplianceo Community-basedsocialmarketingandothermethodstoencourage
voluntarybehaviourchangeo Publiceducationprogramstoincreaseawarenesso Guidelinesby/forlocalgovernmentstoban,restrict,ormanagea
particularplastic
III.PriorityPlasticTypes
5|P a g e
III.PRIORITYPLASTICTYPES(inalphabeticalorder)
Alloftheplasticsinthissectionarepriorities.Rankingthembasedontonnageandothercriteriaisnotfeasiblegiventhetimeavailabletocompletethisdocument,andbecausecredibletonnagedataonmanyoftheseitemsissimplynotavailable.Asaresult,theplasticshavebeenlistedinalphabeticalorder,andnorankingisimplied:
Bags(singleuse)
• Recommendedmethodsofmanagement:a. Controlledusage(e.g.bans/restrictionsonuse)[Localgovernments]b. Economicincentives(e.g.mandatoryfeesatpointofsale)[Localgovernments]c. Increasedlitteringfines[Localgovernments]d. Expansionof/inclusioninexisting/newEPRforpackaging,preferablywithadeposit-
refundrequirement[Seniorgovernments]• Plasticbagsareeasilywindblown,frequentlylittered,andreadilymistakenforfoodby
manymarineanimals.Alternativestosingle-useplasticbagsarewidely-knownandpractical,althoughdependingonthematerialused,asufficientlyhighnumberofreusesmustbemadeinordertooffsetimpactsofproduction.PlasticbagsarecurrentlysomewhatcoveredbyexistingpackagingEPRprograms.Althoughlogisticallymoredifficulttoadminister,adeposit-refundsystemcouldensurehigherrecoveryratesandlesslittering.Specificcollectionordropoffpointsareusedsomewhatsuccessfullyinsomeprovincesalready.Similarly,studies(AustralianStateofVictoria,StateEnvironmentandClimateChangeMinister)haveshownthatchargingasufficientfeeforsuchsingle-useitemsismoreeffectivethanofferingadiscountforbringingareusablealternative.Increasedrequirementsforminimumrecyclablecontentshouldbeconsideredwhereverpossible.Acountry-wideban(asperFrance)couldbeconsidered.
Balloons
• Recommendedmethodsofmanagement:a. Consumereducation/guidesonalternativestoballoons[Localgovernments]b. Controlledusage(e.g.bans/restrictionsonuse)[Localgovernments]c. Increasedlitteringfines[Localgovernments]d. EPRthroughdepositsonhelium-filledballoons[Seniorgovernments]
• Althoughnotalargecontributortomarineplasticsormunicipallitterintermsofweight,balloonshaveanotableanddisproportionateimpactontheenvironment.Releasedballoonshavethepotentialtotravellongdistances,particularlyhelium-filledballoons.TheyhavebeencitedbyorganizationssuchasOceanConservancyandtheMarineConservation
III.PriorityPlasticTypes
6|P a g e
Societyasoneofthedeadliestoceanplasticitemsastheyaremistakenforfoodbymarineanimalssuchasseaturtles,dolphins,andbirds.Whileitmaybechallengingtoplacedepositsonsuchalow-valueitem,theyshouldstillbeconsidered,astraditionalEPRmakesitunlikelythatlow-valueitemslikeballoonswouldbereturnedforrecycling,anddepositshaveworkedwellonotherlow-valueitemssuchasbeveragecontainers.
BottlesandCaps
• Recommendedmethodsofmanagement:a. Sourcereductionthroughthepromotionofreusablebottlesandtheconsumptionof
tapwater[Localgovernments]b. Expansionof/inclusioninexisting/newEPRforpackaging[Seniorgovernments]
• WherebeveragecontainerEPRprogramsexist,recoveryratesarehigh-particularlyinthoselocaleswithdepositrefundsystems.Depositsystemshaveaproventrackrecordofveryhighrecoveryratesoverthelast5decades.PlasticcapsaresomewhatcoveredbythoseEPRprograms,thoughconsistentEPRrequirementsacrossCanada,andeducationtoencouragetheinclusionofcapsintherecyclingofbottlesisneeded.Recyclersandmanufacturersshouldalsoworktoencouragethatplasticcapsandbottlesaremadeofthesameplastic,wheneverpossible.WerecommendnationalharmonizationofEPRforbeveragecontainersandcaps.Increasedrequirementsforminimumrecyclablecontentshouldbeconsideredwhereverpossible.
Cigarettefilters
• Recommendedmethodofmanagement:Anationalprohibitionontheuseofcelluloseacetate(oranynon-biodegradablematerial)asafilterforcigarettemanufacturing.Thisprohibitionwouldnecessitatesourcereductionofplasticwastethroughthesubstitutionofalternativebiodegradablenon-plasticfiltersand/orinnovationinthephysicaldesignofcigarettes.[Seniorgovernments].
AnalternativeapproachwouldbeforanationallyharmonizedEPRprogrammakingthemanufacturerslegallyandfinanciallyresponsiblefortheassociatedcostsofcollectingcigarettefilterslitteredonlandandintheoceans.Whilethiswouldnotnecessarilyeliminateplasticcigarettefiltersentirely,itcouldprovideanincentiveforredesignofcigarettes.Itcouldpossiblyalsoincluderesponsibilityforenvironmentalimpactsrelatedtothedisposaloftheassociatedtobaccocomponentslitteredintheenvironment.
• Mostcigarettefiltersaremadefromcelluloseacetatewhichisnotbiodegradable.Worldwide,anestimated4.5trillioncigarettebuttsarelitteredeachyear,makingthemthesinglemostlittereditem.Similarly,OceanConservancylistscigarettebuttsasthesingle
III.PriorityPlasticTypes
7|P a g e
mostcommoniteminbeachlitterenteringoceans.AccordingtotheWHO,StanfordUniversityandSanDiegoStateUniversity,cigarettefiltersdonotserveanyactualfunctioninmakingcigarettessafer,andareessentiallyamarketingtool.TraditionalEPRisnotagoodoption,aseffectivecollectionof,andaccountingforcigarettebuttswouldbelogisticallyimpractical.Previousattemptsbythecigaretteindustrytopromoteportableashtraysandeducatethepublicagainstlitteringbuttswereverylimitedinscopeandalmostcompletelyineffective.
ClothingandOtherTextiles(madewithsyntheticfibers)• Recommendedmethodofmanagement:ModifiedEPRmakingsyntheticfiberclothing
manufacturerscontributetothecostofplasticmicrofibermitigation,and/orresearchtowardnewtechnologies[Seniorgovernments].
• Itisnowwell-knownthatthelaunderingofclothingmadeofsyntheticfiberssuchaspolyester,acrylic,andnylonresultsinthereleaseofhugenumbersofplasticmicrofibers.Muchofthiscanbecapturedatsewagetreatmentplants,buttheuncapturedmicrofibersarestillplentifulandarenowdetectedinourmunicipaldrinkingwatersaroundtheworld.Whilethescienceregardingtheimpactofplasticmicrofibersonhumansisnotyetcertain,plasticsareknowntopreferentiallyabsorbcertaintoxinsandmayreleasetheminthebody.Itisnotrealistictothinkthatsyntheticclothingfiberscouldbebannedorreplacedatthistime.Similarly,atraditionalEPRprogram(whereindustrycollectsandrecycles/disposesoftheproductafteritbecomesawaste)wouldnotaddressthereleaseofmicrofiberswhichoccursmostlyduringtheuseoftextilesratherthanafterthetextilesbecomeawaste.However,EPRprogramscouldtakeanotherformwheretextilemanufacturersmakeamandatorycontributiontoafundthatwould
a. upgrademunicipalsewagetreatmenttofurtherreducethereleaseofmicrofibersb. incentivizehomeownerstoinstallfiltersformicrofibersonwashingmachines(until
suchtimeasthesefiltersaremadeastandardfeatureonnewwashingmachines)c. gotowardsresearchintonewandemergingmethodstoredesign/treat/recover
syntheticfibers
FishingGear(especiallynets)
• Recommendedmethodofmanagement:IndustryEPRdeliveredinconjunctionwithgovernment[Seniorgovernments]
• Thoughnotamunicipallitterissueinanyway,fishingnetsareincludedinthisdocumentgivenitsveryhighrankingasaproblematicoceanplastic.AccordingtosomestudiessuchasthosebyWorldAnimalProtection,abandonedfishingnetscomprisealmosthalfoftheweightofoceanplastics,andorganizationssuchasOceanConservancylistabandonedfishingnetsasthedeadliestofallplasticitemsinthemarineenvironment.Internationalprohibitionsagainstabandonmentoffishinggearhasexistedsince1973,butislargelyunenforceableandineffective.
III.PriorityPlasticTypes
8|P a g e
Giventheurgentneedtoaddressabandonednets,andthelackofenforcedregulation,ourrecommendationistoregulatethefishinggearmanufacturersunderaproductstewardshipprogramimmediately.However,whiletraditionalEPRisusuallyfundedentirelybythemanufacturersandbrandownersoftheproduct,thehighcost,lowturnover,andthesmallnumberofmanufacturersoffishingnetswilllikelyrequireadifferentmodelinordertoallowforquickimplementation.Inthiscase,itwilllikelyrequirepartialfundingfromthefederalgovernment,andstrictenforcementofminimumrecoveryrates.Discussionsbetweenthefederalgovernmentandthefishingindustryshouldbeinitiatedimmediately.Incentivessuchasdepositsor‘bounties’onfishingnetsshouldbeconsidered,recognizingthattheamountofasuitablyincentivizingdepositmayneedtobehighbecauseoftherelativelylargeinitialpurchasecost.
FoamCushions(especiallymattressesandfurniture)
• Recommendedmethodofmanagement:EPRformattressesandfurniture[Seniorgovernments]
• Thecushioningmaterialsusedinmattressandupholsteredfurniturearemostlycomposedofpolyurethanefoamrubbermaterials.Theseitemsarenotcommonlylitteredonbeachesorfoundinthemarineenvironment.However,illegaldumpingofmattressesandfurnitureisaverycostlyproblemformunicipalgovernments.IntheMetroVancouverareaalone,therearetensofthousandsofillegaldumpingincidentseachyear,withclean-upcostsrepresentingseveralmilliondollars.Similarly,inQuebec,followingJuly1st“OfficialMovingDay”(whenthevastmajorityofleasesarerenewed),significantresourcesneedtobedeployedbymunicipalitiestocollectmattressesandfurniture.MattressandbulkyfurniturearewellsuitedfortraditionalEPR,whichisbeingconsideredinanumberofprovinces.
FoodwareforTakeout
Containers(RigidandFoamPlastic)Cupsandlids(singleuseplastic)Straws(single-use,plastic)Utensils(singleuseplastic)
• Recommendedmethodsofmanagement:
i. Controlledusage(e.g.bans/restrictionsonuse)[Localgovernments]ii. Supportforreusablealternativeswherepractical[Localgovernments]iii. Economicincentives(e.g.mandatoryfeesatpointofsale)[Localgovernments]iv. Increasedlitteringfines[Localgovernments]v. InclusionunderEPR,preferablyharmonizednationwide[Seniorgovernments]
• Apopularbeliefisthatconventionalplastics,especiallyfoodware,canbewidelyreplacedwithcertifiedbiodegradableplastics,butthisisnotyetacompletesolution.Asdiscussedinthe‘considerations’sectionoftheGuidingPrinciplesandSelectionCriteria,notall‘certifiedbiodegradable’plasticscanbesufficientlybiodegradedinexistingcommercialcomposting
III.PriorityPlasticTypes
9|P a g e
ordigestionfacilities,letaloneinthenaturalenvironment(i.e.onlandorinoceans).Seniorgovernmentscouldregulatethatthetimeframeandphysicalconditionsunderwhicha‘certified’plasticmustbiodegradeshouldbe(a)comparabletothosefoundinthenaturalenvironment,or(b)comparabletothosefoundintypicalexistingcommercialcomposting/digestionfacilities.
• Containers(singleuserigidandfoamplastic):Bothrigidplasticandexpandedpolystyrenetakeoutcontainersarefoundasbeachlitter,andaspartofmunicipallitter.Althoughtheyarenotassignificantacontributorasotherplastics(e.g.cigarettebutts,fishingnets,bottles,orbags),theyarestillinthetop10ofbeachlitteredplasticitems.Foamplasticsinparticularhavealowdensityandtendencytobreakaparteasilyintosmallfragments,whichmakethemproblematicaswindblownplasticsintheenvironment.Recognizingtherangeofdifferentmeasuresbeingusedbydifferentlocales,werecommendsupportingprojectsthatswitchfromsingleuseitemstoreusablecontainers,nationalharmonizationofbans,fee/incentives,and/orEPRforplastictake-outcontainers.Wherepossible,andnotinconflictwithotherregulationsorperformancestandards,requirementsforlocalproductionandminimumrecycledcontent(whetherthroughconventionalplasticsrecycling,orthroughemergingrecyclingtechnologiessuchasdepolymerization)mayalsobeconsidered.
• CupsandLids:Plasticandplastic-coatedcupsandlidsareanothercategorythatisnotnecessarilythelargestcontributortolitter,butstillinthetoptenofbeachlittereditems.TheyarealreadysomewhatcoveredbyEPRprogramsinthoseprovincesinwhichEPRforpackaginghasbeenimplemented,andcouldbereadilyaddedtoprogramswherecoveragedoesnotalreadyexist.Forlocalesrelyingoneconomicincentives,behavioraleconomicsstudieshaveshownthatchargingafeeforsuchsingle-useitemsismoreeffectivethanofferingadiscountforbringingareusablealternative.Voluntaryreductionofsingle-usecupsandlidsisalreadyoccurringinsomelocales.Recognizingtherangeofdifferentmeasuresbeingusedbydifferentlocales,werecommendsupportingprojectssuchascupshareprogramsthatswitchfromsingleusetoreusablecups,nationalharmonizationofbans,fee/incentives,and/orEPRforplasticcupsandlids.Increasedrequirementsforminimumrecyclablecontentshouldbeconsideredwhereverpossible.
• Straws:Asahigh-profilesingle-useitem,theplasticstrawhasreceivedmuchattention,thoughotherplasticitemsarearguablymoreconcerningintermsofweight,numberofoccurrences,anddirectimpactonmarinelife.Nonetheless,theimpactoftheplasticstrawissignificant,alternativesarereasonablypractical,andtheycanbecoveredunderexistingandfutureEPRprograms.Thereisanecdotalevidencethatseveralbusinesses(e.g.,restaurants)havealreadyvoluntarilymovedtosupplystrawsonlyuponrequestfromthecustomer.Bestpracticestoreducetheuseofstrawscouldbeformalizedwithinavoluntaryagreementwithindustrytoavoidtheuseofstraws.Thatsaid,manycommunitiesarealsousingprohibitions,and/oreconomicincentivestoreduceplasticstrawuse.Similarly,behavioraleconomicsstudieshaveshownthatchargingafeeforsuchsingle-useitemsismoreeffectivethanofferingadiscountforbringingareusablealternative.Recognizingtherangeofdifferentmeasuresbeingusedbydifferentlocales,werecommendsupportingprojectsthatswitchfromsingleusestrawstoreusablestrawsorotheralternatives,nationalharmonizationofbans,fee/incentives,and/orEPRforplasticstraws.
• Utensils(singleuseplastic):Intermsofweight,plasticutensilsarenotalargecontributortobeachlitter/oceanplastics,andnotaparticularlylargecomponentofmunicipallitter.
III.PriorityPlasticTypes
10|P a g e
However,accordingtoOceanConservancy,thesmallparticlesthatresultfromthemicro-fracturingoftheseitemsisparticularlyharmfultomarineanimalsthatmistakethemforfood.Thesamemethodsofmanagingotherfood-relatedsingle-useplasticscouldapplytoutensils.Forlocalesrelyingoneconomicincentives,behavioraleconomicsstudieshaveshownthatchargingafeeforsuchsingle-useitemsismoreeffectivethanofferingadiscountforbringingareusablealternative.Asisthecasewithstraws,voluntaryreductionofplasticutensilsisalsooccurringinsomelocales.Recognizingtherangeofdifferentmeasuresbeingusedbydifferentlocales,werecommendsupportingprojectsthatswitchfromsingleusetoreusableutensilsorotheralternatives,andnationalharmonizationofbans,fee/incentives,and/orEPRforplasticutensils.Increasedrequirementsforminimumrecyclablecontentshouldbeconsideredwhereverpossible.
FoodWrappers(singleuse,flexible/filmplastic)
• Recommendedmethodsofmanagement:a. Voluntarilyorthroughgovernmentdirective,thepackagingindustryshould
formalizeanewefforttowardsreducingpackagingatthesource(e.g.anewprogramsimilartothatoftheformerNationalPackagingProtocolledbytheCCMEinthe1990s).[Seniorgovernments]
b. Expansionof/inclusioninexisting/newEPRforpackaging[Seniorgovernments]• Byweight,foodwrappers(e.g.candywrappers)arearelativelysmallcontributorto
municipallitter,althoughsomeshorelinecleanupevents(e.g.InternationalCoastalCleanupDay2017)foundfoodwrapperstobethesecondmostprevalentitemofbeachlitter(aftercigarettebutts).FoodwrappersarealreadysomewhatcoveredbyEPRprogramsinthoseprovincesinwhichEPRforpackaginghasbeenimplemented,andcouldbereadilyaddedtoprogramswherecoveragedoesnotalreadyexist.
Tires
• Recommendedmethodofmanagement:Mandatoryrequirementforresearchanddevelopmentbythetiremanufacturingindustryandotherstakeholders(e.g.CanadianAssociationofTireRecyclingAgencies),complementedbypubliceducationtoimprovepublicawareness[Seniorgovernments]
• Thishasbeenincludedinthisdocument,asmicroparticlesfromtiresareasignificantcontributortooceanplastics,buttheyhavenotbeencategorizedasapriorityperse,asnoimmediateapparentsolutionscanberecommendedyet,regulatoryorotherwise.Automotivetiresincludeamixtureofnaturalandsyntheticrubbers.Intheirnormaluse,thewearandtearofbeingdrivenovertheirlifetimecausesupto20%oftheoriginalweightoftirestobelostasmicroscopicrubberdust(mostlyunder100nanometersinsize),depositedontoroads,parkinglots,driveways,etc.Many,ifnotmostofthosemicroscopicparticlescanentersurfacewatersystemsorotherwatercoursesandeventuallyreachlakesandoceanswithoutgoingthroughmunicipalsewagetreatment.
III.PriorityPlasticTypes
11|P a g e
Likemicrobeadsfrompersonalcareproducts,theparticlesfromtiresarealreadymicroplasticswhentheyreachtheocean–noperiodoffracturingfromUV,saltwater,orwaveactionisneeded.TheIUCNin2017estimatedthat28%ofthemicroplasticsinouroceanscomefromcartires.Withabout20milliontiresreplacedeachyearinCanadathisrepresentstensofthousandsoftonnesofrubbermicroparticles.Inmanyprovinces,tiresarealreadycollectedandrecycledunderregulatedEPRprograms.However,justasisthecasewithtextiles,thisoccursafterthetiresareworn,andthemicroparticleshavealreadybeenreleased.Butunliketextiles,therearenopotentialin-situfilters,ortreatmentplantsthatcouldinterceptallstormwater.Furthermore,thereisnorealisticcommerciallydevelopedalternativetotheautomotivetire,andnobiodegradablerubbermaterialthatcouldberealisticallysubstituted.Becauseofthesereasons,aregulationoradditionalEPRrequirementfortireswouldnotappeartobeviable.Werecommendthatdirectedresearchisneeded–intomechanicalalternativestothetireitself(suchaslonger-lastingnon-pneumaticdesigns),alternativestothesyntheticrubbermaterialsused(suchasnaturalGuayuleorTaraxacumrubbers),newmethodstocaptureofrubbermicroparticlesfromsurface/stormwater,increasingadhesionofwornrubberparticlestoroads,etc.
Wetwipes(singleuse)
• Recommendedmethodsofmanagement:a. Controlledusagethroughbans/restrictionsonuseofplasticsinmanufacturing[Senior
governments]b. Controlledusagethroughrestrictionsonsales[Localand/orSeniorgovernments]c. Economicincentives(e.g.mandatoryfeesatpointofsale)[Localgovernments]
Concurrentwiththis,exploreupstreamapproachessuchasfederally-mandatedrequirementsforimplementationbyprovincesandmunicipalities[Seniorgovernments]
d. InclusioninExtendedProducerResponsibilityprograms[Seniorgovernments]e. Prohibitionfrombeinglabelledoradvertisedas“flushable”[Seniorgovernments]
• Wetwipesareagroupofsingle-useitemsgenerallyusedforcleaningpurposes.Somewipessuchasthoseusedforautomotivedetailingandhouseholdcleaningarepredominantlydisposedingarbage.Wetwipesusedforcleaningtoiletsandbathroomsaswellasforpersonalhygienepurposes(baby/adult)aremostoftenflusheddowntoilets.
• Whileaminorityofwetwipesaremadefromnaturalfibres,mostarecomposedofpolyester,polyethyleneorotherplasticmaterials.
• Wetwipesflusheddowntoiletsaccumulateinsewersystemsandareamajorcauseofblockagesandclogging,amountingtoanestimated$250MperyearindirectcleanupandmaintenancecostsformunicipalwastewatersystemsinCanada.Thisdoesnotincludeanyindirectcosts(e.g.floodingdamage,microplasticsinreceivingwaters)ofdisposal.
• AnInternationalWaterServicesFlushabilityGroup(IWSFG)hasdevelopedcriteriafor‘flushable’products.Onlyproductsthatmeettheirproposedcriteriawouldbedeemedto
III.PriorityPlasticTypes
12|P a g e
becompatiblewithmunicipalsewersystemsandwouldbeallowedtousetheterm“flushable”.AstudybyRyersonUniversity(March2019)testedatleast64differentwetwipeproductssoldinCanada,anddemonstratedthatnoneofthem,whetherusingnaturalorsyntheticmaterials,currentlymeetthecriteria.
• ControlledusagethroughbansontheuseofplasticsinmanufacturingofwetwipeswouldrequireactionbytheSenior(likelyFederal)government.Therearewetwipeproductsavailableforsalethatuseonlynaturalmaterials.Restrictionsonsalescouldbedoneatthelocallevel(inthesamewaythatsaleofcosmeticpesticidesisbannedbysomemunicipalities),butaharmonizedrestrictionattheProvincial,orpreferablyFederallevelwouldbemuchmoreeffectiveandefficient.
• EPRforwetwipescouldbeimplementedprovincially,butwouldbemoreeffectiveandefficientattheFederallevel.EPRmakesthemanufacturersresponsibleforrecoveringtheirwasteproductsforrecyclingand/ordisposal.Becauserecoveryofflushedwipesisimpractical,inpracticethemanufacturersofwetwipescouldbe(a)madefinanciallyresponsibleforannualcompensationtomunicipalwastewatersystemsfortheirincrementalmaintenancecosts,and(b)requiredtoconductsubstantialpubliceducationtoredirectwipesfromtoiletstothegarbage.Manufacturersmighttherebybesignificantlymotivatedtoproposeproductredesignasanalternative.
• Therecommendationtoprohibitplasticwetwipesfrombeinglabelled“flushable”isanalogoustoCalifornia’splasticslabelinglawthatprohibitsthesaleofanyplasticproductorpackagingwitha"biodegradable"orotherunprovenclaimimplyingthattheitemwillbreakdown,fragmentordecomposeinalandfillorotherenvironment.
IV.OtherPlasticTypes
13|P a g e
IV.OTHERPLASTICTYPES
Thefollowingplasticsarenotlargecontributorstooceanplastics,ortoproblemswithmunicipallitter,orsewagetreatment.Nonetheless,theyarelistedhereforconsideration:AgriculturalPlastics
• Recommendedmethodofmanagement:TraditionalEPRthroughneworexistingprograms[Seniorgovernments]
• Agriculturalplastics(suchasbalertwine,grainbags,balewrap,silageplasticandfeedbags)contributeverylittletotheproblemofoceanplasticsortourbanlitter/illegaldumping,althoughimpactsinruralcommunitiesareofgreaterconcernduetoissuessuchasopenburningonfarms.Agriculturalplasticsdocontributetolandfillplasticwastes,andhavebeenidentifiedasaLevel1EPRpriorityinQuebecandarethetargetofsomevoluntaryprogramsandpilots(e.g.Alberta,Saskatchewan,NovaScotia,etc.)
VinylSidingfromConstructionandDemolition
• Recommendedmethodofmanagement:TraditionalEPR[Seniorgovernments]• SignificanttonnagesofplasticscanbefoundinConstructionandDemolition(C&D)wastes
goingtolandfills.However,C&Dplasticswasteisnotasignificantissueforoceanplastics,norisitalargeissueformunicipallitter(illegaldumpingofdemolitionmaterialsfromsmallcontractorsisamunicipallitterissue,butsuchincidentsgenerallydonotincludelargeamountsofplastics).SignificantlogisticalchallengesforrecoveryofmostC&Dplasticswouldneedtobeworkedout.ThepredominantplasticswillbePVCintheformofvinylsidingandPVC,PEandPPinplasticplumbing.Otherminorcontributorsincludewindowanddoorframes,blindsandshutters,filmplasticsfrompackagingofbuildingmaterials,etc.C&DmaterialshavebeenontheCCMEplanforEPR,butnogenerally-acceptedmodelshavebeendevelopedtodate.Fromalogisticalstandpoint,andfocusingonthetwolargestcontributorstoplastics,whicharesidingandpiping,onlysidinglendsitselftoapotentialEPRsolution.Sidingiseasilyaccessibleontheexteriorofbuildinganddoesnotrequirehighlevelsofphysicaldeconstructionorexcavation.Piping,ontheotherhand,existsinsideofcabinetsandwalls,orisburiedonthebuildingproperty,soremovalforrecyclingisconsiderablymoreonerous,andmoreworkwouldneedtobedonetodeveloparealisticregulatorymethodofmanagement.Somelocaleshaveuseddepositsondemolitionswhichare
IV.OtherPlasticTypes
14|P a g e
refundedinwholeorinpartaftermaterialshavebeenrecoveredforrecycling,butthesearedonebyindividualmunicipalitiesthroughtheirlocalbuildingpermittingsystems,andtendtofocusonmoreeasilyrecoveredmaterials.
Miscellaneous
Asdescribedattheoutset,priorityplasticswereselectedbasedoncriteriathatincludednegativeimpactonmunicipaloperations(particularlylitterandsewagetreatment)andontheenvironment(particularlyoceans).Thereareanumberofotherplasticitemsnotdiscussedinthisdocumentdueinparttotimeconstraints,butalsobecausetheyhavenosignificantimpactonmunicipaloperationsoroceanenvironments(pertheselectioncriteria).Theseincludebutarenotlimitedtoplastictoys,plasticsfromelectronics,plasticmaterialsinautomobiles,andinchildcarseats.Astheregulatorymeasuresrecommendedforthehigherpriorityplasticsareimplemented,someoftheseotherplasticsshouldalsobeaffected.Forexample,
o EPRforelectronicsnaturallycapturesplasticsfrome-wasteandelectronictoys.o Minimumrequirementsforindustrysourcereductionandrecycledcontentshould
affectmanyoftheseplasticitemsNonetheless,astimeandresourcespermit,theseotherplasticitemsshouldbeaddressedastheydorepresentopportunitiesforsolidwastediversionfromdisposal.
V.Acknowledgement
15|P a g e
V.ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
WegiveoursincerethankstothemembersofthePlasticsAdvisoryPanel.ThePanelmembersare:MajaVodanovic,CommunautéMétropolitainedeMontréal(Co-Chair)AndrewMarr,MetroVancouver(Co-Chair)(inalphabeticalorder)CharlotteUeta,CityofTorontoChristinaSeidel,RecyclingCouncilofAlberta/SonnerveraInternationalCorp.EtienneAngers,Recyc-QuebecJasonGale,CascadesMattGemmel,FederationofCanadianMunicipalitiesMichelAllaire,CommunautéMétropolitainedeMontréalMikhaelMetauro,CascadesMonicaKosmak,CityofVancouverSophieLanglois-Blouin,RecycQuebecWiththesupportoftheNationalZeroWasteCouncilsecretariatandMetroVancouver:AndrewDoiAnnRowanHeatherSchoemakerJoanneGauci