natural gas market information. scope of presentation natural gas information –market monitoring...
TRANSCRIPT
Scope of Presentation
• Natural gas information– market monitoring
– support for market transactions
• Information models– architecture
Wel
lhea
d P
rodu
ctio
n
Gas ProcessingPlant
Pipeline
UndergroundStorage
LocalDistrib.Company
Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Elect. Util.
Imports
Generalized SchematicSales of Natural Gas in U.S.
Third Party (Marketer, Broker)
Consumers
Wel
lhea
d P
rodu
ctio
n Gas ProcessingPlant
Pipeline
UndergroundStorage
LocalDistrib.Company
Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Elect. Util.
Imports
Generalized Schematic Physical Flow ofNatural Gas in U.S.
Consumers
ParticipantsParticipants Miles of PipeMiles of Pipe Regulatory Regime in 2000Regulatory Regime in 2000
ProducersProducers 8,000 Independents8,000 Independents ---- Phased price deregulationPhased price deregulation24 Majors24 Majors Begun in 1979, completed in 1989Begun in 1979, completed in 1989
PipelinesPipelines 160160 285,000285,000 Federal Energy RegulatoryFederal Energy RegulatoryCommission (FERC)Commission (FERC)
Natural Gas MarketersNatural Gas Marketers 260260 ---- UnregulatedUnregulated
Local Gas UtilitiesLocal Gas Utilities 1,2001,200 833,000833,000 State Utility CommissionsState Utility Commissions
End UsersEnd Users Residential 53 millionResidential 53 million ---- UnregulatedUnregulatedCommercial 4.5 millionCommercial 4.5 millionIndustrial 40 thousandIndustrial 40 thousand
Electric Utilities 500Electric Utilities 500 ---- Interstate - FERCInterstate - FERCIntrastate - State CommissionsIntrastate - State Commissions
The U. S. Natural Gas Industry At A Glance
Sources of Information
• Delivery– LDC / pipeline tariffs
– Pipeline internet sites
– Third party internet sites
• Commodity– Spot Market Center Systems
– Futures Markets (NYMEX / KCBOT)
– Third party (after-the-fact) published prices
– EIA (used to monitor historical activity)
MarketersMarketersBrokersBrokersTradersTraders
OPERATORSOPERATORS
ProducersProducersPipelinePipelineStorageStorageLDCsLDCs
Diverse Users with ...
Trade Press and MediaTrade Press and Media
FINANCIALFINANCIAL
Risk ManagersRisk ManagersInvestorsInvestors
CONSUMERSCONSUMERS
Information Information AggregatorsAggregators
Market Market PlayersPlayers
GovernmentGovernment
CONSUMERSCONSUMERSPricePriceTerms and Quality of ServiceTerms and Quality of ServiceAlternative Fuel PricesAlternative Fuel PricesLong-term AvailabilityLong-term Availability
Spot pricesSpot pricesFutures pricesFutures pricesSupply/demandSupply/demandforecastsforecastsMarket analysisMarket analysis
MARKETERSMARKETERSSpot pricesSpot pricesFutures pricesFutures pricesStorage Storage changeschangesSupply Supply DemandDemandWeatherWeather
ReservesReservesFlow RatesFlow RatesNominationsNominationsReceipts/DeliveriesReceipts/DeliveriesWeatherWeatherPricesPrices
...Diverse Information Needs
Information Information AggregatorsAggregators
Market Market PlayersPlayers
GovernmentGovernment Trade Press and MediaTrade Press and Media
OPERATORSOPERATORS FINANCIALFINANCIAL
Regulators Role Is Changing
Company Centric Industry CentricFederal regulation of pipelines (by FERC)
focuses on the structure and operation of energy markets.– Effect of competition– Impact of policies– Monitoring and oversight of markets
Overarching Goal of Federal Energy Regulators in the U.S.
• Maximize consumer and economic benefits
• Minimize the need for future regulatory intervention
Market Monitoring
Tracking performance indicators of a well-functioning market
• Efficiency
• Transparency
• Transactional liquidity
• Ease of market entry and exit
• Competition
Information Needed to Support Rate Making Activities
CompanySpecific
IndustryAggregate
Current and historical data on costs,cost components, prices,throughput, services
Types of customers and theirparticular service needs and usagepatterns
Estimates and future costs andchange in components, demand,customer make-up
Access to Information - Important in a Competitive Market
Relevant information is needed by:
• Consumers - to make informed decisions on energy purchases.
• Regulators - to monitor transactions and to prevent exercise of market power.
What is “Relevant” Information?
Information on …• Available services - e.g. capacity (capacity,
available capacity, system outages)
• Market structure including affiliate relationships
• Transactional Information
• Imbalance and overrun information
The Information Revolution...The Information Revolution...How far We’ve comeHow far We’ve come
Transparent wholesale natural gas pricesTransparent wholesale natural gas pricesWeekly storage ‘estimates’Weekly storage ‘estimates’Futures market informationFutures market informationElectronic access to capacity informationElectronic access to capacity informationElectronic gas trading systemsElectronic gas trading systems
• • • • •
Information that was not available priorInformation that was not available prior to the industry restructuringto the industry restructuring
In the Future Information Needs May Include
• Transparent retail natural gas and electricity prices
• Real time information systems • Information on exchanges of gas (maybe
even daily storage estimates) • Gas/electric convergence (and developing
Btu markets) may lead to additional information needs
Information Systems to Support Market Transactions
• Electronic bulletin boards
• Electronic trading systems
• Value added networks (VANs)
Non-EIA Information Systems For Consumers
Online CommercialInformation Services
FERCBulletin Board
Commercial EDI Interchange Services
IndividualP ipeline EBB
Electronic GasTrading Systems
User
Internet Energy CompanyHome Page
Link
- Nominations - Buying/Selling Gas- Capacity Availability
- Network Services- Access to P ipeline EBBs
- Regulatory Filings, Tariffs, etc.- EDI Converted Data
- NYMEX Quotes- Dow J ones - Weather- etc.
- Capacity Availability- Nominations- Gas Trading- Information Services
- EDI Converted to Common F ormat
First Tier Services Second Tier Services
- NYMEX Quotes- Dow J ones - Weather- etc.
- F ile Download
- Gas Management- C onfirmations- Billing
- P roduct Imformation- P ublic Announcements
- Service Offerings
- F ile Download
- F ile Download
The Case for Standardized Business Practices
Gas Industry Standards Board• Pro-active approach - reps from many
segments of the industry participate
• Facilitates business transactions with multiple pipelines and suppliers.
Information Technology Architecture (As Implemented by the FERC)
Built on the concept of 3 layered infrastructures connected by the
security infrastructure:
• Information infrastructure
• Communication infrastructure
• Processing infrastructure
Information InfrastructureWell-defined data and data relationships are
essential to a secure and interoperable information infrastructure
• The information itself is what is most important • Characterizes the type of information (who needs it and how it is
generated, accessed and maintained.• Defines data, models, data relationships, facilitates storage and
retrieval, and describes the constraints/limitations on the use of the data
• This knowledge is then used to develop a tech. strategy for efficiently managing the data
• Value through use of common data format and exchange standards
Communications Infrastructure
• Objectives:• connectivity - ability to interface with current and
anticipated processing equipment
• interoperability - permit hardware from competing vendors to communicate. Open system design that allows independence and flexibility
• scalability - configured to support required range of users and traffic requirements
Communications Infrastructure
• Consists of the communication equipment, software and networks that link computers and peripherals within the organization. Provides:– protocols for information movement– mechanisms for detecting network faults– mechanisms for linking with other networks
Processing Infrastructure
• Provides the computer systems and software necessary for:– computing, comparing, selecting, evaluating
– moving, displaying information
– managing user interfaces
– managing system processes and controlling system usage
Security Infrastructure
• Consists of the requirements, policies and practices to secure information sharing:– safeguard resources and supervise resource
sharing– ensure resource availability to authorized users– detects and reports intrusion attempts by
unauthorized users
Design Considerations• Flexible - should accommodate future needs
• A standard architecture reduces the complexity of the computing environments promoting consistency among applications and data and reduce redundant products
• Central to the definition of architecture is the identification and use of standards.
• Develop the user's ability to transparently interact and exchange information with other systems and users.
• Communication services and associated standards are a fundamental part of establishing interoperability.
Goals Re: Information: FERC Model
• Flexible
• Practical
• Efficient (more efficient operations)
• Reduce costs/customer burden
• Provide efficient, cost-effective access to the information that is needed by regulated entities and the general public -- when they need it -- and in a format that is useful to them.
• IN ADDITION - security of the data, data network and interchange may be a major concern.
Primary Technical Considerations
• Primary focus include the concepts of flexibility, enhancement, security, cost/benefit and standards.
• Provide vendor-neutral, cross-platform method of transporting and validating critical data
E-filing Information
• Becoming more prevalent in the gas industry.
• Should ensure that any gains or improvements made (e.g. e-filing) are not hindered by non-electronic processing i.e., all manual processes immediately following the electronic filing process.
Transition Strategy - Options:1. System leap - where organizations standardize on a system
for several years then "leap" forward to new systems every 3-5 years (total system replacement every x years)
2. Incremental change paradigm - when organizations continuously adopt incremental upgrades – Advantages include: minimal training costs, min. problems with
staffing and communication, budget requirements are spread-out over several years
3. Rolling replacement - e.x. change occurs at a constant rate - e.g. a third of the change happens each year.
Key Data Area of Interest
• Supply activities: production, storage, imports• Supply infrastructure:
– transmission and storage capacity– drilling, producing wells
• Consumption by sector• Prices:
– cash and futures markets– wellhead to downstream
Why is Good Information Important?
• Information is needed for policy making and for assessing the gas industry’s performance.
• Public policy now relies on competition to ensure adequate supplies, low costs, and reasonable prices to consumers.
• Private investors need accurate and reliable information for investment decisions.
Measurement of Volumetric Information about the Domestic Natural Gas Industry
• Production volume• Underground storage• Consumption by residential, commercial or
industrial customers• Consumption by regulated electric utilities• Consumption by other electric generators• Transportation of natural gas
Monthly Measurement of Natural Gas Data
Industry Segment
Domestic natural gasproduction
Underground NaturalGas Storage
Consumption and pricesfor residential,commercial, industrial,and NUGS sectors
Consumption and pricesto regulated elecricutilities
Data System
EIA-895
EIA-191
EIA-857
EIA-759 and FERC-423 (run by anotheroffice in EIA)
Respondents
Offices of States (AndU.S. Department ofInterior) where naturalgas is produced
Operators of all knownunderground natural gasstorage fields
Sample of approximately400 companies deliveringto those sectors
Regulated utilities withlarge electric generationplants
Monthly Data Measurement Points and Systems: Physical Flows of Natural Gas from Wellhead to Burnertip
NaturalGasProducedatWellhead
GasProcessingPlant
Pipeline
UndergroundStorage
OtherPipeline(s)
LocalDistributionCompany
Residential
Commercial
Industrial
NUGS
Utility
ImportsandExports
Form EIA-857
FormEIA-191
FormEIA-895
FormEIA-759
Important Issues for Data Quality
(Accuracy and Adequacy)
• How do we assure that we are asking the right questions of the right parties?– Assessing the changing information needs – Issues of frame development and frame
maintenance• If a sample, its design and assuring
representativeness and precision
– Issues of Forms design
Major Steps and Processes in a Survey
• Initial Steps– Determine requirements for information– Design and test instrument– Obtain approval for instrument– Develop and implement processing system– Field instrument
Major Steps and Processes in a Survey - Cont.
• Fielding the instrument (some of the details)– Determine the potential respondents
• Building and maintaining the frame
– Select the respondents• Total enumeration or sample?
• If latter, design and select the sample
– Distribute the instruments
Major Steps and Processes In a Survey - Cont.
• For each survey cycle– Receive, track, and enter data from
respondents– Edit responses
• Follow up with respondents for edit failures
– Deal with non-response– Prepare and evaluate aggregate estimates– Prepare dataset feeds for distribution media
Dealing with Data Problems
• Nonresponse• Imputation• Nondisclosure of confidential information
• Noncoverage due to design considerations• “Truth in statistics” statements• Recognize limitations and develop
alternative procedures to fill the gaps in data requirements
Natural Gas Information Products Accessibility
• Products are distributed through the EIA web site.
• The EIA web site provides quick release of products.
• Some reports are also printed, although EIA is phasing out most printing.
• Databases are available through the EIA web site and on the EIA CD
Information needshave increased
Why is EIA doing Strategic Information Planning?
No coverage of key areas - marketers
Declining coveragein some existing data
series (prices)
Reassess Data/Reassess Data/Information ProgramInformation Program
EIA’s goal: - minimize respondent burden - optimize processes/resources
- maximize customer satisfaction
NEXT GENERATION * NATURAL GAS (NG)2
A project to design and implement a new, comprehensive information program for natural gas to meet
customer requirements in the
post-2000 time frame.
Natural Gas Data Systems Development
With changes in the regulatory and financial environment, EIA’s natural gas systems are
increasingly unable to successfully measure the industry
•Separation of equity from custody flows•Rise of Actors outside the scope of current systems•Development of new phenomena such as market hubs
Next Generation * Natural Gas
Project Overview
Data Requirements
Information CollectionRedesign
Cognitive andPilot Testing
Implementation
IndustryConceptual
Design
Focus GroupReport
• Purpose: Obtain opinions, information and insights on
what data EIA should collect in the future
• Format:– structured– administered by an independent firm– discussions are confidential
• Results: will be used to guide EIA in designing the
natural gas data program to meet the information needs of
the industry
Focus GroupsFocus Groups