nbp integrated webcast power point 042512 - wefnet.org april 25, 2012/nbp integrated webcast...

23
4/23/2012 1 National Biosolids Partnership Webcast “Thermal Hydrolysis Comes to America: DC Water’s Blue Plains Digestion Project” April 25, 2012 2 Sam Hadeed Biosolids Program Manager Water Environment Federation National Biosolids Partnership Alexandria, VA WEF Residuals & Biosolids Committee Staff Liaison [email protected] WELCOMING REMARKS Starting in January 2010, NBP began offering a series of ”no charge” quarterly webcasts devoted to general biosolids management and technical topics of interest to water quality and biosolids professionals: Carbon Footprint Implications from Biosolids Management Practices Advances in Solids Reduction Processes Combined Heat and Power Generation Opportunities at Wastewater Treatment Facilities Charting the Future of Biosolids Management: Forum - Findings on Trends and Drivers Implementing the New SSI MACT Standards – Issues and Challenges Ahead Terminal Island Renewable Energy – LA’s Biosolids Slurry and Brine Injection Project Renewable Green Energy from Biosolids – POTW Case Studies to Achieve Net Energy Production When Opportunity Knocks, How Can Municipalities and POTWs Partner with the Biofuels Industry 2.0 Professional Development Hours for this webcast http://www.wef.net/nbp/ NBP’s Commitment to Excellence in Biosolids Management 4 NBP - WEF Resources for Biosolids Management www.biosolids.org – NBP Web Page and E-Newsletter www.wef.org - Biosolids Channel of Access Water Knowledge WEFTEC 2012 September 29-October 3, 2012 New Orleans, Louisiana http://www.weftec.org

Upload: dothu

Post on 30-Jan-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

1

National Biosolids PartnershipWebcast

“Thermal Hydrolysis Comes to America: DC Water’s Blue Plains Digestion

Project”

April 25, 2012

2

Sam Hadeed

Biosolids Program Manager Water Environment FederationNational Biosolids PartnershipAlexandria, VA

WEF Residuals & Biosolids Committee Staff Liaison

[email protected]

WELCOMING REMARKS

Starting in January 2010, NBP began offering a series of ”no charge” quarterly webcasts devoted to general biosolids management and technical topics of interest to water quality and biosolids professionals:• Carbon Footprint Implications from Biosolids Management Practices• Advances in Solids Reduction Processes• Combined Heat and Power Generation Opportunities at Wastewater Treatment

Facilities• Charting the Future of Biosolids Management: Forum - Findings on Trends and

Drivers• Implementing the New SSI MACT Standards – Issues and Challenges Ahead• Terminal Island Renewable Energy – LA’s Biosolids Slurry and Brine Injection

Project• Renewable Green Energy from Biosolids – POTW Case Studies to Achieve Net

Energy Production• When Opportunity Knocks, How Can Municipalities and POTWs Partner with

the Biofuels Industry

2.0 Professional Development Hours for this webcast

http://www.wef.net/nbp/

NBP’s Commitment to Excellence in Biosolids Management

4

NBP - WEF Resources for Biosolids Management

www.biosolids.org – NBP Web Page and E-Newsletter

www.wef.org - Biosolids Channel of Access Water Knowledge

WEFTEC 2012 September 29-October 3, 2012New Orleans, Louisiana http://www.weftec.org

Page 2: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

2

Alexandria, VA Sanitation Authority King County, WA Div. WW TreatmentCity of Santa Rosa, CA Public Utilities Louisville & Jefferson Co. KY Metro Sewer DistrictCity of Wyoming, MI Clean Water Plant Madison, WI Metropolitan Sewerage DistrictCentral Davis County, UT Sewer District Metro Denver, CO WW Reclamation District Columbus, GA Water Works Metro Water Reclamation Dist. of Greater Chicago, ILDC Water Orange County, CA Sanitation DistrictNew England Organic Hawk Ridge Composting Facility Orange County, FL UtilitiesWater Environment Services of Clackamas County, OR Resource Management Inc., NH East Bay Municipal Utility District - Oakland, CA Kent County, DE Regional WTFButler County, OH DES Encina Wastewater Authority – Carlsbad, CACity of Albany, OR Wastewater Treatment Plant City of Raleigh, NC Public Utilities DepartmentCity of Chattanooga, TN DPW City of Mankato, MNCity of Fort Worth, TX Water Dept City of Los Angeles, CA Dept of Public WorksCity of Grand Rapids, MI City of Lawrence, KS Dept. of UtilitiesGreater Moncton Sewerage Commission, Canada Lewiston-Auburn, ME WPA Camden County, NJ Municipal Utility District City of Richmond, VA Public Utilities Dept.Renewable Water Resources – Greenville, SC Knoxville Utilities Board, TN

NBP EMS Certified Agencies (34)

A key component of the NBP program is the EMS and third-party audit program. The following agencies/organizations have achieved the prestigious NBP EMS certification.

Thermal Hydrolysis Comes to America: DC Water’s Blue Plains Digestion Project

Learning Objectives

• This webinar will focus on the benefits of thermal hydrolysis from multiple perspectives including:• An owner that has selected the technology, • A company that provides thermal hydrolysis engineered systems, and • Design firms responsible for designing and constructing the first system in North America.

• Other owners and engineers considering thermal hydrolysis would gain an understanding of the issues of:• Cost• Digester and equipment requirements (digester size, pre and post dewatering, heating and

cooling requirements), • Biogas production potential, • Biosolids characteristics, • Odor control, and • Solids reduction.

Today’s Webcast

7

Walt Bailey

Director, Department of Wastewater TreatmentDC Water – Blue PlainsWashington, DC

“How DC Water Decided to Choose Thermal Hydrolysis (Cost Minimization,

Product Quality, Green Energy”

[email protected]

TODAY’S SPEAKERS

8

Keith Panter

International Biosolids Consultant, Managing DirectorCambi - Ebcor LtdCheshire, United Kingdom

“What is Thermal Hydrolysis and Where is it Used?”

[email protected]

TODAY’S SPEAKERS

Page 3: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

3

9

Perry Schafer

Vice-President Brown & CaldwellRancho Cordova, CA

“Procurement Challenges and Innovations”

[email protected]

TODAY’S SPEAKERS

10

Peter Loomis

Senior Project Manager CDM SmithFalls Church, VA

“Design & Construction Considerations”

[email protected]

TODAY’S SPEAKERS

11

Dave Parry

Wastewater and Energy Market Leader, Senior Vice PresidentCDM SmithBellevue, WA

“Design & Construction Considerations”

[email protected]

TODAY’S SPEAKERS

Walter Bailey, PE, BCEE, WEF Fellow Assistant General Manager-Blue Plains

DC Water and Sewer AuthorityApril 25, 2012

Page 4: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

4

Review of Blue Plains AWTP and Service Area Development of Anaerobic Digestion Program R&D Work for the Biosolids Program Due Diligence on Thermal Hydrolysis Recommended Program to use TH/Digestion

Operated by DC Water 391mgd (ADWF capacity) ~160 acre site Largest Advanced

WWTP in the world

14

2.2 million pop served (4 million “Population Equivalent”)

Includes all of the District of Columbia and portions of Virginia and Maryland suburbs

A portion of the service area has combined sewers Source: DCWater.com

Page 5: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

5

Large-scale Class B lime stabilization–product largely used in land application

About 65 truck-loads per day (1200 wet tons/day)

Staff has greatly minimized product odors over the years

EMS certification of DC Water Biosolids Program in 2004

17

NPDES Permit ~4.2 mg/l TN (Mass-based Limits)

P-removalNPDES limit < 0.18 mg/l

18

New Filtrate Treatment Process

$84 million

BP Tunnel Dewatering Pump Station & Enhanced Clarification Facility

$300 million

Upgrade & expansion of the Nit/ Denit system

Upgrade of the Secondary High Rate System

$26 million

New Biosolids Management Program

$460 million Dual Purpose Sed Basins Upgrade

$18 million-

Enhanced Nutrient RemovalFacilities

$340 million

1999 BMP recommended implementing new Class B anaerobic digestion to greatly reduce quantities

Continue land application as long as viable with Class B Biosolids

2000 – old (1938) digesters shut down-safety concerns, inadequate capacity, and odorous product with centrifuge dewatering

All biosolids since that time have been Class B lime-stabilized

Page 6: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

6

Developed plans for large egg-shaped digestion project by 2006-45 MG of tankage

Research showed that with centrifuge dewatering, odor regrowth would be a problem, and also pathogen indictor regrowth/resuscitation

Costs escalated, and with limited competition, the project became too costly.

Research starting 2002 under Dr. Sudhir Murthy’s direction at DC Water-WERF/other funding

Tested many digestion and dewatering process options at lab-scale

Work by VA Tech (Novak/team) Bucknell Univ. (Higgins/team) and others

Tracked development and performance of all pertinent processes including Thermal Hydrolysis (TH)

Tested over 50 process options at lab-scale (Wilson/Novak) Feedstock for all tests was Blue Plains solids

(primary and WAS) Included Thermal Hydrolysis + MAD

(evolution of work at Stanford Univ. and elsewhere)

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

TA

D 5

5°C

10-

day

TA

D 5

5°C

7.5

-da

y

MA

D 1

5-da

y

TA

D 5

8°C

15-

day

TA

D 5

8°C

15-

day

TA

D 5

5°C

10-

day

TA

D 5

5°C

5-d

ay

MA

D 1

0-da

y

TA

D 5

5°C

15-

day

TA

D 5

1°C

15-

day

TA

D-A

ER

7.5

/3-d

ay

TA

D 5

5°C

7.5

-day

MA

D 2

0-da

y

MA

D 2

0-da

y

MA

D-A

ER

15

/3-d

ay

TA

D 5

5°C

15-

day

TP

AD

55°

C 7

.5/7

.5-d

ay

TA

D 5

3°C

15-

day

AG

AD

2/1

8-d

ay

MA

D-A

ER

7.5

/3-d

ay

TA

D 5

5°C

20-

day

TA

D 5

3°C

15-

day

MA

D 1

5-da

y

TA

D 4

9°C

15-

day

TH

-MA

D 1

5-da

y

MA

D 1

5-da

y

TA

D-A

ER

55°

C 1

0/6-

day

TP

AD

55°

C 1

0/1

0-d

ay

TA

D-A

ER

55°

C 1

5/3-

day

MA

D 2

0-da

y

MA

D 2

5-da

y

TP

AD

55°

C 1

0/1

0-d

ay

MA

D-A

ER

20

/6-d

ay

TP

AD

55°

C 5

/10-

day

TP

AD

55°

C 7

.5/7

.5-d

ay

TA

D-A

ER

55°

C 1

5/9-

day

MA

D-A

ER

15

/9-d

ay

TH

-MA

D-A

ER

15

/6-d

ay

Vo

lati

le S

olid

s R

edu

ctio

n

23

TH + MAD was Eventually Selected

Extensive odor regrowth testing on digestion and dewatering processes.

Additional work on pathogen indicator densities following centrifuge dewatering confirmed regrowth/resuscitation potential for most digestion processes

Major work on dewatering combined with each digestion process tested

Page 7: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

7

DC Water recognized the need for biosolids product improvement and diversification over time

12 Alternatives developed/evaluated:◦ Various anaerobic digestion processes◦ Digestion pretreatment

including TH ◦ Thermal drying options◦ Many options used existing

lime stabilization capacity to handle peak/abnormal events

Employed expert panel as part of the evaluations

Evaluation included site visits at TH/digestion plants in the UK

Capital and annual O&M cost comparisons Energy use and renewable power production-key issues Space/footprint issues were critical for feasibility GHG emission calcs/comparisons Comparison for various risks,

O &M factors, plus sensitivity analyses Ability to produce low-odor product

and minimize indicator regrowth (only TH/digestion could prevent indicator regrowth)

Visits and evaluations by DC Water to TH facilities (ten plants) over the past decade

TH projects have progressed successfully to large size/capacity from 1995 to 2010

DC Water has conducted research and field testing at TH/digestion plants to confirm performance and suitability at Blue Plains

Anglian Water’s Cotton Valley Plant, UK

Anaerobic Digestion remains the cornerstone of BMP Least reactor volume and small footprint TH by Cambi proven at large-scale and can be

implemented in USA Produces well-dewatered and high quality product Class A product (diversification) needed long-term

for sustainable program Produces best energy

scenario and GHG reduction Board of Directors of

DC Water approved recommendation in 2008

Page 8: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

8

WERF Award for Excellence in Innovation given at WEFTEC 2011 in Los Angeles

For extensive use of WERF-funded research to attain a new level of biosolids product stability

Awarded to DC Water in collaboration with Brown and Caldwell and Bucknell University

Walter Bailey, PE, BCEE, WEF Fellow Assistant General Manager-Blue Plains

DC Water and Sewer Authority

Thank you!!!

[email protected]

Keith Panter, Ebcor Ltd.

Key Papers:◦ Haug et al 1978 – shows moderate heat treatment

increases digestion rate and improves dewatering◦ Li and Noike 1992 – demonstrates optimum time

and temperature for WAS hydrolysis and benefits Cambi invention 1992 addresses issues of

previous heat treatments ( e.g. Zimpro) and uses the system as a pre-treatment for anaerobic digestion

First plant in Norway 1995 - operating for 17 years now

Page 9: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

9

CAMBI PLANT LOCATIONS

EUROPE

Norway

Poland

Denmark

UK

Ireland

GermanyBelgium

Finland

Plus Niigate, Japan Brisbane, Australia Santiago, Chile Washington DC

Projects developing in China and the Americas

0

100,000

200,000

300,000

400,000

500,000

600,000

700,000

800,000

900,000

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

/3

cumulative 37 projects

cumulative capacitytds/year

27 million population equivalent

Optimum temperature about 160º C, 320º F to avoid side-stream issue – pressure cooking not caramelization

Batch process with steam injection (150 psi) -to avoid heat exchangers’ scaling and corrosion

Treats cake and has internal recycle of steam – to reduce energy consumption

Steam pressure drop disintegration – reduces particle size and viscosity for subsequent digestion

Coupling with anaerobic digestion – high solids digestion to make a biosolids for recycling/disposal and improve energy balance. High gas yields at short retention.

PROCESS FLOW – THERMAL HYDROLYSIS PRE-TREATMENT BEFORE ANAEROBIC DIGESTION – “CONTINUOUS/BATCH”

FLASH TANKdisintegration

REACTOR(s) – UP TO 6Batch pressure cooking

PULPERPre-heat tank

Raw sludge cake ~17% DS

homogenised/hygienised sludge

hydrolysedsludge

steam 150 psi

hydrolysed sludge to digestion8-12% DSDilution and cooling needed

Recycled steam forenergy recovery

Process gases (to digester)

Page 10: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

10

Typical Cambi plant for 60 mgd

pulper reactors

Flash tank

Raw cake silo

cooler

Mezzanine with valves

viking

Batch heat sterilization Meets all known safety standards worldwide, USEPA

alternate 1 time/temp Class A batch – no reactivation Destruction of Extra Cellular Polymer – ECP

Sludge becomes compressible for dewatering (10% DS% gain) and less viscous (10% hydrolysed =~ 5% conventional)

Hydrolysis of insoluble COD 30-50% solubilisation enables very rapid digestion, 10

days HRT, 60% VSR Steam disintegration of particulate matter

Increases digestion rate and reduces viscosity further

5. Dewatered biosolids cakeat 30-35%DS

2. Cambi hydrolyzed sludgeat 12-13% DS (pre-dilution)

3. Mix of digested sludge (3/4) and hydrolyzed sludge (1/4)to digester. 7-8% DS

1. Dewatered15-18% DS (before THP) 4. Digested

sludge6% DS

Control parameters ”Cambi” digester Conventional digester

Retention time 10-15 days 20 days

DS% feed 9 – 12% 4 – 6%

Digester Volume < ½ of conventional 1

VS load >5-7 kg/m3/day380-550 lbs/1000 cuft

2-3 kg/m3/day150-250 lbs/1000 cuft

pH 7.5 – 8.0 6.8 --7.5

Temperature 38-42ºC, 100 -108ºF 35-37ºC, 95 -98ºF

VFA / Total alkalinity 0.1- 0.5 0.1- 0.5

Ammonium 2000-3000 mg/l 600-1500 mg/l

Gas quality 62-68% CH4, H2S low 60-65% CH4, H2S high

Foaming bacteria None Nocardia, Microthrix

Page 11: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

11

Operating costs ($10-40/tds) for THP –its all about steam and polymer costs

•Focus on low cost pre-dewatering – aim for 5-6 lbs/tds•Integrate engine waste heat (exhaust gas) with steam production – Cambi system is 20-50% more efficient per tds than other systems due to energy recycle -DC is ~self sufficient in steam due to turbine waste heat•Operates automatically 24/7 with day shift supervision and maintenance in most systems

THP uses 1/3rd of biogas if no cogen

Compact new build digestion e.g. Dublin, DC “Turbo” digestion to create capacity – often

with regional sludge centre e.g. Manchester –and majority of UK plants

100% WAS e.g. Welsh and Danish plants (aerobic digestion conversion?)

WAS only mixed with primary (Class B) for digestion feed at 7% DS e.g. Santiago, Chile (instead of acid phase – dewatering upside)

Moving away from incineration and thermal drying to class A, high solids cake, cogen for

lower costs and GHG footprint

Naestved (DK, 2000) – 8 mgdextended aeration sludge

KAPUSCISKA WWTP, BYDGOSZCZ, POLAND 25 mgd

• 2004: 20,000 tpa cake at 20-23% DS

• 2006: 10,000 tpa Cambi cake 30-33% DS

Page 12: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

12

Keith Panter, Ebcor Ltd.Thank you!!

[email protected]

Perry Schafer, PE, BCEE, Brown and CaldwellDC Water Biosolids Management Team

April 25, 2012

Program development to Preliminary Design level by the Biosolids Program Manager

Thermal hydrolysis/digestion – challenges and innovations

Procurement issues for TH/digestion at Blue Plains

48

Existing Solids Processing Area - Class B Lime Stabilization

New Biosolids Program Site (7 acres)

Page 13: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

13

System and PeakingLime StabilizationAverage AnnualPeak MonthPeak Week and Greater

TH-DigestionAverage AnnualPeak MonthPeak Week and Greater

2012-Existing

340400-450400-450*

000

2015-New System

BackupBackup

Up to 350

380450500

* Higher production peaks are stored within existing processes. Dewatering

Lime

Store &Loadout

Class B

DAFTs

Mix

R

R

Screening and Pre-Dewatering

FinalDewatering

RecycleProcessing

R

LoadoutCambi™ THP

Steam Biogas

Biogas Treatment and CHP

Emissions

MesophilicAnaerobicDigestion

Class A

Power

R

R

GravityThickeners

Blend Tank

50

Cake product will be ~30 % solids, stable, screened, Class A

The Plan: Continued land application-

initial focus Develop and maximize

marketable products starting in 2015

Further processing likely, including blending materials with Class A cake

Under Chris Peot’s leadership at DC Water

51

TH/digested cake land application at Aberdeen, Scotland

VS loading at 0.4+ lb VS/ft3/day

Only 15 MG of Digesters, Rather than 40+MG required for typical MAD

At $5/gal = $125+ million savings and much less space required

0

1

2

3

4

DC Water Digesters

Typical Sludge Digestion

Ft3 biogas/day

Ft3 of tankage

Feeding ~10% Solids

Page 14: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

14

Taller tanks for capacity, mixing, and saves space

Optional concrete construction methods for price competition

DC Water tanks are 3.8 MG each(~95ft Ø by 70+ ft SWD)

Continuous Normal Surface Overflow

Backup and Emergency Overflows

Continuous Bottom Withdrawal

Tank Headspace

Typical Draft Tube MixingSystem

5 per Tank

MotorGas Takeoff

Four CambiTHPTrains

Typically 80 - 90° C Thermally Hydrolyzed Solids

Cooling HEXs Digesters

= Control Valve with Flow Meter

Higher pressure

portion of feed loop

Documented events of rapid liquid level rise (gas holdup)

Highly-loaded, tall digesters with thick solids increase the risk

Control measures include continuous feed, controlled DTM mixing, extra freeboard, huge overflow capacity, and overflow storage

Overpressure damaged fixed cover digester

Cake drops directly into cake bins

Pre-dewatered cake pumped minimum distance to THP trains

Final Dewatering (BFP) cake-single belt conveyor to loadout

15 to 18%Solids

Pre-Dewatering Centrifuges

PC Pump to Cambi THP

Cake Bin

Page 15: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

15

Detailed business case evaluation of BFPs vs. centrifuges

Both technologies achieve ~30% solids

BFPs use less energy Net present value of options was

similar - space requirements also similar

No regrowth with either, but odor regrowth potential with centrifuge

BFP pilot testing in U.K. on Cambi/digested feed – to determine parameters for design

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Cak

e S

olid

s (%

)

Belt Filter PressDewatering

CentrifugeDewatering

1 2 3 43 5 6 3 3 7 8

THP Site

Centrifuge Dewatering

Belt Filter Press

Dewatering

THP Site

Ca

ke S

olid

s (%

)

Power toBlue Plains AWTP

Maximize power production and meet steam needs of Cambi THP

12 bar (175 psi) steam

73 % overall power/heat efficiency

Low-NOx emissions from Solar Mercury 50 gas turbine

Flexible operation to meet peak steam needs

3 Turbine/HRSG system is being installed: ~13 MW total power, ~10 MW net power

HRSG

Duct Burner

Steam to Cambi THP

Gas Turbine(Solar Mercury 50)

Generator

CombustionAir

DigesterGas Compressor

Gas

Supplemental Natural Gas

Exhaust Gas

Single point responsibility for design and construction

Schedule advantages Ability to share risks

appropriately Earlier price determination Tunnel project decision was

already made-DB TH projects typically procured

overseas via DB

DB

A decade of TH evaluation, site visits and R&D work, resulted in sole-source decision in 2009

Determined that Cambi’s THP was the only TH system proven at the scale required for Blue Plains

DC Water then contracted with Cambi to define the interfaces for Blue Plains

Cambi THP – 4 Train System for DC Water

Page 16: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

16

61

MesophilicDigestion

Workshops to assess risks Market surveys of potential DB contractors Discussions with TH owners in UK/Europe Examined experience of other large vendor systems within

major project procurement

62

Conclusion: DC Water/Program Management developed Term Sheet for Cambi THP (scope/price/key terms established). Term Sheet expanded to Cambi subcontract by winning DB Team

Screening and Pre-Dewatering

Cambi THP

Main Process Train

Prescriptive RFP to insure facilities will “fit” and provide high-quality equipment/system

For critical equipment, specific vendors were named

Over 30 Performance Guarantees/Acceptance Tests were defined: capacity, performance, permit-related

Limited Technical Alternatives were allowed within the proposal process

6 SOQs received, then short-listed to 3 for proposals with price/technical evaluation. Successful DB procurement process

Main Process Train

MesophilicDigestion

Screening and Pre-Dewatering

Cambi THP

64

Dewatering

Lime

Store &Loadout

Class B

Mix

R

R

Screening and Pre-Dewatering

FinalDewatering

RecycleProcessing

R

LoadoutCambi™ THP

Steam Biogas

Biogas Treatment and CHP

Emissions

MesophilicAnaerobicDigestion

Class A

Power

R

R

GravityThickeners

Site Preparation

DBO DBB

DBB

DB

Blend Tank

DAFTs

Page 17: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

17

66

Perry Schafer, PE, BCEE, Brown and CaldwellDC Water Biosolids Management Team

[email protected]

April 25, 2012

Peter Loomis, PEDave Parry, PE, PhD, BCEE

CDM Smith

April 25, 2011

Page 18: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

18

Program Approach Project Approach Project Team Design

Requirements Design Issues &

Resolutions Summary

Solids Screening Building

Odor Control Towers Thermal

Hydrolysis Process (Cambi)

DigestersPreDewatering Building

Enclosed Flares

Combined Heat and Power Facilities (Not in MPT Project)

Digester Building

Existing Buildings

ThermalHydrolysis Cooling HEX

Tuning HEXDilutionWater

Pre-DewateringScreening

Pre-Dewatering

Building

DigestersThermal Hydrolysis

(Cambi) Process

Page 19: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

19

B&CArcadis

PC/CDM Smith Joint Venture,

Cambi

DC Water

OVERALL PROJECT MANAGER

DESIGN PROJECT MANAGERPERMIT MANAGERCONSTRUCTION PROJECT

DIRECTORCOMMISSIONING MANAGER

Design/build RFP/Contract with

design concepts DC Water design and

construction standards apply

Prescriptive Firm fixed price Cambi and Emerson as

required suppliers

Throughput of 450 dtpd firm capacity

Expandable to 675 dtpd Feed sludge is mix of

TPS & TWAS and highly variable

Class A biosolids produced

33 Process Guarantees in the Contract

Page 20: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

20

Digester building located underground

Concurrent installation of piles for all structures

Allows early mobilization of mechanical installers

Saves time and increases DC Water savings

Solids Blending Tanks Sludge Screening Pre-Dewatering Dewatered Sludge Storage and Pumping Thermal Hydrolysis (Cambi) Biosolids Cooling Digestion Digested Biosolids Transfer & Holding

Sludge Conditioning for THP

Sludge Viscosity post-THP

Biosolids Cooling Rapid Rise Event

Contingencies Gas Production Condensate Control

Screening required to 5 mm◦ Reduces wear on THP

components◦ Reduces risk of pressure vessel

failure◦ Increased life of pump stators

Dewatering to 15% to 18% DS (>16.5% avg)◦ Design basis for Cambi

throughput is 16.5% DS◦ Optimize processing time

Page 21: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

21

Preliminary work done by Dr. Matt Higgins

Thermal hydrolysis greatly reduces apparent viscosity

Digestion after THP further reduces apparent viscosity

Rheology similar to sludges at 1.7 to 1.9x concentrations

0.0010

0.010

0.10

1.0

10

0.1 1 10 100

2.0% MAD2.9% MAD3.6% MAD3.9% MAD3.9% Cambi-MAD5.5% Cambi-MAD6.1% Cambi-MAD

App

aren

t Vis

cosi

ty (P

a-s)

Shear Rate (1/s)

Max inlet T = 112.7°F Cooling water max inlet T = 81°F Discharge T = 100°F Velocity = 6.5 fps Viscosity = 20 cP to 35 cP

Hydrolyzed biosolids exit THP at up to 194°

Cooling sources◦ Dilution water◦ Solids blending◦ Tube-in-tube heat exchangers

Contract Requirement is 9.6 MMBtu/Hr per digester

Tuning HEX also at 1.3 MMBtu/hr per digester

Page 22: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

22

Freeboard in each digester Overflow wetwell (shared

between each pair of digesters)

Total storage is 400,000 gallons each digester

Additional standpipe storage allows overflow rate of 24,000 gpm

Mixers are bi-directional Considering standby power

for 2 mixers per digester

Hydrolyzed sludge biodegrades at a higher rate

Expect 55% VS removal (40% typical for MAD)

No gas storage other than headspace

Digester gas pressure 50% higher than typical (18” w.c.vs. 12” w.c.)

Significant H2S not expected due to high ferric dosing in liquids train

Condensate collection for each digester◦ Higher gas production◦ No gas storage◦ Reduces risk of plugging

Sideline condensate collection◦ Lower headloss◦ Minimizes plugging from foam

Project D/B team and approach

Benefits of 3D/4D Construction sequence Design details◦ Dewatering, screening◦ Cooling◦ Rapid rise◦ Biogas management◦ Condensate control

Page 23: NBP Integrated Webcast Power Point 042512 - wefnet.org April 25, 2012/NBP Integrated Webcast Pow… · Perry Schafer Vice-President Brown & Caldwell Rancho Cordova, CA “Procurement

4/23/2012

23

Peter Loomis, [email protected] Parry, PE, PhD, BCEE

[email protected]

CDM SmithThank you!!!

“Thermal Hydrolysis Comes to America: DC Water’s Blue Plains Digestion Project”

Q & A Session