new york bus sales - hrm 464 (consulting project)
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
1/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
0
Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs
Hug`c Tbsourfbs Focsumtecn [roabft*Vudgettbj to1
Mecjs`y G`stroneov`cce, Hug`c Tbsourfbs G`c`nbr
Vudgettbj dy
Bref` BefhbCefl Lozeom
Gb`nh`c Lbrren`c
Gefh`bm GurphyLbrry Gorres
Fhrestecb GecebreT`cje Vtrugpimbr
Zhb Vfhoom oi DusecbssVt`tb Rcevbrsety oi Cbw Uorl `t Oswbno
Oswbno, Cbw Uorl 06049
G`y 06, 4;02
Zhb `uthors `rb ucjbrnr`ju`tbs `t thb Vt`tb Rcevbrsety oi Cbw Uorl `t Oswbno. Zhes Hug`c Tbsourfbs Focsumtecn[roabft w`s focjuftbj ec iumiemmgbct oi thb Vfhoom oi Dusecbss Vbceor Vbgec`r ec Hug`c Tbsourfb G`c`nbgbct.
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
2/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
4
Bxbfutevb Vugg`ry
Irog Ibdru`ry 46, 4;02 to G`y 06, 4;02, VRCU Oswbno stujbcts rbvebwbj Cbw Uorl
Dus V`mbs Hug`c Tbsourfb pr`ftefbs weth spbfe`m bgph`ses nevbc to thb jbnrbb th`t pr`ftefbs `rb
`mencbj weth orn`cez`teoc`m no`ms. ^hemb gost pr`ftefbs `rb biibftevb, thrbb `rb`s oi egprovbgbct
wbrb ejbcteiebj1 jbvbmopgbct oi `c ocmecb `ppmef`teoc systbg, `c bvomvbj bgpmoybb wbmmcbss
pronr`g, `cj thb opteoc oi `c opt-out :;0(l) bcrommgbct systbg. Egpmbgbct`teoc sunnbsteocs `rb
oiibrbj.
Ovbrvebw
Zhb purposb oi thes proabft es ior VRCU Oswbno stujbcts to ejbcteiy egprovbgbcts ec
Hug`c Tbsourfb profbssbs weth ` suffbssium fogp`cy dy fogdececn bvbrythecn wb h`vb mb`rcbj
ovbr thb iour yb`rs ec thb Hug`c Tbsourfb G`c`nbgbct pronr`g `cj puttecn thosb topefs to usb
ec ` fogp`cy focsumtecn proabft. Dy gbbtecn weth thb Hug`c Tbsourfb jbp`rtgbct oi ` fogp`cy
`cj oiibrecn sunnbsteocs oc how to egprovb Hug`c Tbsourfb pr`ftefbs, VRCU Oswbno stujbcts
`rb b`rcecn v`mu`dmb bxpbrebcfb ec thb romb oi ` focsumt`ct ior Hug`c Tbsourfb jbp`rtgbcts. Ec
rbturc, thb fogp`cy es rbfbevecn ejb`s ior egprovbgbct ec thber Hug`c Tbsourfb profbssbs.
Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs es `c orn`cez`teoc ioucjbj ec 05>2 `cj hb`jqu`rtbrbj `t >>92
M`lbport To`j, Fhettbc`cno, Cbw Uorl 06;6>. Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs `mso h`s two othbr mof`teocs
mof`tbj ec Tofhbstbr `cj T`vbc`, Cbw Uorl. Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs sbmms Dmub Derj sfhoom dusbs to
sfhoom jestrefts mof`tbj ec Cbw Uorl Vt`tb. Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs `mso oiibrs ` iumm-sbrvefb rbp`er
`cj p`rts jbp`rtgbct ior thb Dmub Derj dusbs th`t thby sbmm whefh es `v`em`dmb yb`r-roucj. Zhb
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
3/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
6
fogp`cy herbs sfhoom dus jrevbrs ec orjbr to tr`csport thbsb dusbs d`fl `cj iorth whbthbr et es ior
jestredutecn thb somj dusbs to thb duybrs or whbthbr et es to tr`csport thb dusbs d`fl `cj iorth ior
rbp`ers `cj/or p`rts. Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs furrbctmy h`s 04; bgpmoybbs, 8; oi whefh `rb iumm-tegb.
Cot ocmy jobs CU Dus V`mbs h`vb typef`m oiiefb poseteocs sufh `s `ffouctecn, hug`c rbsourfbs,
`cj g`c`nbgbct, dut et mso oiibrs poseteocs ec thb p`ectecn, sbrvefecn, cj p`rts jbp`rtgbcts. Cbw
Uorl Dus V`mbs es ` i`gemy-owcbj fogp`cy th`t es iofusbj oc cot ocmy fustogbr s`tesi`fteoc dut
bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc dy oiibrecn ` m`rnb dbcbiets pronr`g. Zhb fogp`cy es `mso s`ibty-iofusbj
ior doth bgpmoybbs `cj fustogbrs. Bgpmoybbs `cj vesetors `rb rbquerbj to wb`r s`ibty vbsts `cj
nm`ssbs whbc ec fbrt`ec p`rts oi thb i`femety. V`ibty es so egport`ct to Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs th`t
thby bvbc h`vb ` V`ibty Foorjec`tor poseteoc. Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs sbmms `cj sbrvefbs Dmub Derj
sfhoom dusbs to sfhoom jestrefts, so es focfbrcbj weth s`ibty oi ets fustogbrs `cj thb fhemjrbc who
rejb thbsb dusbs bvbry j`y to sfhoom. Ec orjbr to lbbp thbg s`ib, Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs h`s streft
st`cj`rjs ec pm`fb ec rbn`rjs to thb dusbs. Zhb no`ms oi Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs fbctbr `roucj
bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc, fustogbr s`tesi`fteoc (qu`mety oi projuft), `cj s`ibty ior doth bgpmoybbs
`cj fustogbrs.
Eciorg`teoc w`s fommbftbj dy two sbp`r`tb vesets to Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs hb`jqu`rtbrs, dy
ectbrvebwecn thb Hug`c Tbsourfbs G`c`nbr, `cj dy rbvebwecn thb g`tbre`ms th`t w`s nevbc to us
dy thb Hug`c Tbsourfbs G`c`nbr.
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
4/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
:
Hug`c Tbsourfb [r`ftefbs
Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs h`s `c bxtrbgbmy strocn dbcbiets p`fl`nb th`t es oiibrbj to thber
bgpmoybbs. Ec i`ft, >2% oi dbcbiets es p`ej dy Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs whemb ocmy 42% oi dbcbiets es
p`ej dy bgpmoybbs. Zhb fogp`cy `mso oiibrs ` strocn tueteoc rbegdursbgbct pm`c. Cbw Uorl Dus
V`mbs h`s strocn s`ibty pronr`g weth toom rbegdursbgbct pm`c cj s`ibty ecfbctevb ior oiibrecn
cbw ejb`s. Zhb fogp`cy `mso oiibrs ecfbctevbs ior s`mbs. Zhb fogp`cy oiibrs fogp`cy vbhefmbs,
n`s f`rjs, B-Q p`ssbs `cj fbmm phocbs to sfhoom dus jrevbrs so thby `rb prbp`rbj ior jrevecn thb
sfhoom dusbs ior mocn jest`cfbs. Bgpmoybb rbfonceteoc es `mso vbry egport`ct to thb fogp`cy, so
thby oiibr fm`g d`lbs, irbb Zh`clsnevecn turlbys, `cj irbb prezbs. M`stmy, thb fogp`cy oiibrs `c
`nnrbssevb fogpbcs`teoc strufturb whefh es bethbr `dovb g`rlbt or `t g`rlbt w`nbs. Cbw Uorl
Dus V`mbs h`s ` vbry strocn Hug`c Tbsourfb jbp`rtgbct whosb pr`ftefbs `rb `mencbj weth
fogp`cy no`ms. Zh`t es, bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc, fustogbr s`tesi`fteoc (qu`mety oi projuft) `cj
s`ibty ior doth bgpmoybbs cj fustogbrs. Ocmy thrbb rb`s ior egprovbgbct wbrb ejbcteiebj. Zhbsb
`rb`s `rb `jjrbssbj dbmow.
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
5/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
2
Egprovbgbct @rb` 0
Ocb orn`cez`teoc`m no`m thes HT pr`ftefb f`c db dbttbr `mencbj weth es bgpmoybb
s`tesi`fteoc. Furrbctmy, ec orjbr to `ppmy to Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs, `c `ppmef`ct gust sbcj thber
rbsugb throunh bg`em to thb Hug`c Tbsourfb G`c`nbr. Zhbc thb Hug`c Tbsourfb G`c`nbr wemm
bg`em thb `ppmef`ct d`fl `c `ppmef`teoc to thb fogp`cy (`cj ` jrevbrs `ppmef`teoc rbquerbj dy thb
Jbp`rtgbct oi Zr`csport`teoc ei `ppmef`dmb), whefh thb `ppmef`ct woumj thbc rbturc d`fl to thb
Hug`c Tbsourfb G`c`nbr. ^b dbmebvb th`t thbrb es `c bxtr` stbp to thes profbss th`t f`c g`lb thb
`ppmef`teoc profbss to thb fogp`cy to db too mbcnthy. Zhes cot ocmy f`c mosb `ppmef`cts `mocn thb
w`y, dut foumj possedmy bcj up jbfrb`secn bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc ei herbj weth thb mocn
`ppmef`teoc/herecn profbss. b dbmebvb th`t thes profbss foumj db egprovbj dy c ocmecb ppmef`teoc
systbg. [mb`sb rbibr to @ppbcjex (0) ec orjbr to sbb ` vesu`m rbprbsbct`teoc oi our v`mub fh`ec. @s
you f`c sbb dy thb v`mub fh`ec, egpmbgbctecn `c ocmecb `ppmef`teoc systbg cot ocmy rb`fhbs `c
orn`cez`teoc`m no`m dy ecfrb`secn bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc dut et `mso bcjs up futtecn fosts ior thb
orn`cez`teoc `cj s`vbs tegb ior thb Hug`c Tbsourfb jbp`rtgbct. Et jobs thes dy frb`tecn ` queflbr
`ppmef`teoc profbss whefh ec turc ecfrb`sbs bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc dbf`usb oi thb quefl `ppmef`teoc
profbss. Dbf`usb wb `rb futtecn `c bcterb stbp out oi thb `ppmef`teoc/herecn profbss, et `mso bcjs up
gecegezecn `ppmef`teoc fosts.
Bciorfecn `c ocmecb `ppmef`teoc profbss wemm `mmow b`sb `cj focvbcebcfb, strufturb, `cj
sbfurety ior thb `ppmef`ct. F`cjej`tbs `ppmyecn ior ` aod ocmecb wemm cot cbbj to worry `dout iemmecn
ec brror-irbb h`rj fopy iorgs `cj spbcjecn gocby oc post`nb to rbturc thbg. Zhbrb's `mso thb
dbcbiet oi lcowecn `c ppmef`teoc h`s dbbc s`ibmy rbfbevbj dy rbfruetbr dy rbfbept oi focierg`teoc
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
6/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
9
`t thb bcj oi thb `ppmef`teoc profbss. @c ocmecb `ppmef`teoc profbss `mmows `c bgpmoybr to provejb
` gorb strufturbj iorg`t ior ppmef`cts. @s opposbj to ecvetecn rbsugbs cj fovbr mbttbrs or essuecn
pro iorg `ppmef`teoc iorgs, ocmecb `ppmef`teoc systbgs `mmow rbfruetbrs to `sl t`rnbtbj qubsteocs
`cj rbqubst bvejbcfb spbfeief to thb romb. Zhes g`lbs et fmb`r to potbcte`m f`cjej`tbs wh`t es
bxpbftbj oi thbg `cj how thby shoumj fogpmbtb thb `ppmef`teoc profbss.
Zhb g`ec `jv`ct`nb oi egpmbgbctecn `c ocmecb `ppmef`teoc systbg es th`t et es fost
biibftevb. Iemmecn ` poseteoc throunh cbwsp`pbr fm`sseiebjs, hb`jhuctbrs or ectbrc`m pbrsoccbm
jbp`rtgbcts f`c db tegb-focsugecn `cj fostmy< ocmecb `ppmef`teocs f`c rbjufb thb fost oi herecn
focsejbr`dmy. G`cy ocmecb aod fm`sseiebj setbs `rb irbb or fh`rnb geceg`m ibbs ior bgpmoybrs, or
you f`c frb`tb `c `ppmef`teoc iorg throunh your owc wbdsetb. ^b jej rbsb`rfh oc jeiibrbct
`ppmef`ct tr`flecn wbdsetbs `cj Qoho es ` top r`tbj ocmecb `ppmef`teoc systbg weth fhb`p prefbs.
Tbibr to @ppbcjex (4) showecn thb `pproxeg`tb prefbs.
Ocmecb `ppmef`teocs `rb `mso `v`em`dmb wormjwejb. Cbwsp`pbrs `cj fogp`cy
`ccoucfbgbcts tbcj to rb`fh ocmy mof`m g`rlbts. Rsecn `c ocmecb `ppmef`teoc systbg you foumj
rb`fh progesecn f`cjej`tbs who g`y db wemmecn to rbmof`tb to Vyr`fusb ior thb renht aod `cj thby
foumj db gorb qu`meiebj ior thb poseteoc. Opbcecns f`c b`semy db `jvbrtesbj `cj sprb`j oc thb
Ectbrcbt throunh aod-postecn setbs, fogp`cy wbdsetbs, dmons `cj sofe`m cbtworls.
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
7/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
>
Egprovbgbct @rb` 4
Ocb orn`cez`teoc`m no`m thes HT pr`ftefb f`c db dbttbr `mencbj weth es ecfrb`sbj bgpmoybb
s`tesi`fteoc. Furrbctmy, thb wbmmcbss pronr`g `t Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs ecfmujbs ` rbjufbj prefb oi
gbgdbrshep to thb UGF@. Zhes es jocb throunh thb fogp`cy p`yecn p`rt oi thb gbgdbrshep prefb,
thb UGF@ provejecn ` jesfouct oi thb gbgdbrshep prefb, `cj thb bgpmoybb p`yecn thb rbst oi thb
gbgdbrshep prefb (ei jbserbj). Zhb fogp`cy `mso egpmbgbctbj ` sbp`r`tb wbmmcbss pronr`g dy
ecst`mmecn ` vbcjecn g`fhecb th`t w`s orenec`mmy jbsencbj to ocmy oiibr hb`mthy mucfh/sc`fl
opteocs. ^b dbmebvb th`t thbsb two wbmmcbss pronr`gs th`t thb fogp`cy oiibrs f`c db egprovbj.
[mb`sb rbibr to @ppbcjex (6) ec orjbr to sbb ` vesu`m rbprbsbct`teoc oi our v`mub fh`ec. @s you f`c
sbb dy thb v`mub fh`ec, egpmbgbctecn `c egprovbj bgpmoybb wbmmcbss pronr`g cot ocmy rb`fhbs
`c orn`cez`teoc`m no`m dy ecfrb`secn bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc dut et `mso bcjs up futtecn fosts ior thb
orn`cez`teoc. Dy oiibrecn ` irbb nyg gbgdbrshep or hb`mthebr mucfh `cj/or sc`fl opteocs,
bgpmoybbs wemm bcj up dbecn gorb `ttbctevb `cj h`vecn henhbr gor`mb whefh hbmps worl nbt jocb
i`stbr `cj gorb `ffur`tbmy. Zhes bcjs up ecfrb`secn bgpmoybb hb`mth, moy`mty `cj foggetgbct
dbf`usb et shows th`t CU Dus V`mbs es jbjef`tbj to ecfrb`secn thb hb`mth oi thber bgpmoybbs. Ec
tbrgs oi fost, h`vecn hb`mthebr bgpmoybbs `mso gecegezbs hb`mth ecsur`cfb fosts.
CU Dus V`mbs h`s ` vbry wbmm-roucjbj dbcbiets pronr`g th`t thby oiibr thber bgpmoybbs.
Zhber dbcbiets ecfmujb gbjef`m, jbct`m, meib `cj vomuct`ry tbrg ecsur`cfb, imbxedmb spbcjecn
`ffoucts, short tbrg jes`demety, `cj ` :;0(l) pm`c. Ior gost fogp`cebs hb`mth ecsur`cfb fosts t`lb
up to 2;% oi thber proiets `cj rbfbctmy fosts h`vb dbbc fmegdecn. Z`x ecfbctevbs `rb oiibrbj to
bgpmoybrs who egpmbgbct worlpm`fb wbmmcbss pronr`gs. Zhes es to bcfour`nb fogp`cebs to
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
8/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
8
gotev`tb bgpmoybbs to p`rtefep`tb `cj mb`j hb`mthebr mevbs. Ocb stujy ioucj th`t `t mb`st ocb-iourth
oi ecfurrbj dy worlecn `jumts `rb `ttredutbj to fh`cnb`dmb hb`mth resls, sufh `s tod`ffo usb, jebt,
`cj m`fl oi bxbrfesb (Zemmg`c).
^b dbmebvb egpmbgbctecn ` wbmmcbss pronr`g ior `mm bgpmoybbs woumj db bxtrbgbmy
v`mu`dmb to your fogp`cy. Zhb wbmmcbss ecfbctevbs th`t `rb `mrb`jy ec pm`fb `rb ` nooj pm`fb to
st`rt, ior bx`gpmb thb jesfouct ior ` nyg gbgdbrshep `t thb UGF@ shoumj jbiecetbmy rbg`ec. Dy
frb`tecn ` gorb fohbsevb wbmmcbss pronr`g bgpmoybbs woumj ibbm gorb gotev`tbj to p`rtefep`tb.
Vbttecn gocthmy no`ms frb`tbs `c ecfbctevb ior bgpmoybbs to `ftu`mmy `ttbcj thbg nyg `cj `mso
`mmows you to db `dmb to qu`cteiy thb us`nb oi thb pronr`g.
Et w`s drounht to our `ttbcteoc th`t ` mot oi thb gbfh`cefs `cj dus jrevbrs suiibr irog d`fl
prodmbgs `cj othbr physef`m p`ecs irog bethbr jrevecn `mm j`y or dbecn ec jeiiefumt poseteocs mm j`y
sbrvefecn dusbs. Zhes foumj hecjbr thber pbriorg`cfb `cj bvbc thber `dsbctbbesg. @fforjecn to
^ormj Bfocogef Iorug st`testefs fogp`cebs th`t h`vb egpmbgbctbj `c biibftevb wbmmcbss
ecfbctevb pronr`g h`vb bxpbrebcfb ` rbturc oc ecvbstgbct oi >22% ec projuftevety. Zhb resb ec
projuftevety es jub to g`cy i`ftors ecfmujecn mowbrecn `dsbctbbesg `cj egprovecn oc-thb-aod
utemez`teoc (^bmshhocs).
Tbw`rjecn bgpmoybbs g`lecn nooj jbfeseocs ec `mm `rb`s oi thber mevbs sufh `s hb`mthy
worl bcverocgbct, b`tecn h`dets, strbss g`c`nbgbct, `cj iec`cfb g`c`nbgbct frb`tbs cot aust `c
ecfbctevb to db `ftevb dut `mso `c ecfbctevb to mevb ` hb`mthy meib `mm `roucj. @s you f`c sbb ec
@ppbcjex (:), thb 4;04 @im`f ^orl Iorfbs Tbport, bgpmoybbs th`t `rb oiibrbj wbmmcbss pronr`gs
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
9/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
5
fogp`rbj to thosb th`t `rb cot `rb gorb melbmy to h`vb henhbr aod s`tesi`fteoc, ibbm h`ppebr weth thb
bgpmoybr, `cj db gorb s`tesiebj weth thber ovbr`mm dbcbiets (Zemmg`c).
Zhb dennbst rb`soc ior egpmbgbctecn ocb oi thbsb pronr`gs es dbf`usb et h`s thb potbcte`m
to mowbr hb`mth f`rb fosts dy `dout $>;; pbr bgpmoybb pbr yb`r. @ fogprbhbcsevb `c`myses oi :4
pudmeshbj stujebs oi worl setb hb`mth progoteoc pronr`gs showbj th`t fogp`cebs th`t
egpmbgbctbj `c biibftevb wbmmcbss pronr`g rb`mezbj senceief`ct fost rbjufteocs `cj iec`cfe`m
n`ecs, ecfmujecn 48% rbjufteoc ec sefl j`ys, 49% rbjufteoc ec hb`mth fosts, 6;% rbjufteoc ec
worlbrs fogpbcs`teoc `cj jes`demety g`c`nbgbct fm`egs, `cj $2.56 to $0 s`vecns-to-fost r`teo
(Zemmg`c).
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
10/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
0;
Egprovbgbct @rb` 6
Ocb orn`cez`teoc`m no`m thes HT pr`ftefb f`c db dbttbr `mencbj weth es ecfrb`sbj bgpmoybb
s`tesi`fteoc. Furrbctmy, Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs oiibrs `c opt-ec opteoc ior :;0(l) bcrommgbct. ^b
dbmebvb th`t `c opt-out/`utog`tef bcrommgbct systbg ior :;0(l) woumj db ` dbttbr opteoc ior thb
fogp`cy. [mb`sb rbibr to @ppbcjex (2) ec orjbr to sbb ` vesu`m rbprbsbct`teoc oi our v`mub fh`ec.
@s you f`c sbb dy thb v`mub fh`ec, egpmbgbctecn `c egprovbj opt-out/`utog`tef bcrommgbct
systbg ior :;0(l) cot ocmy rb`fhbs `c orn`cez`teoc`m no`m dy ecfrb`secn bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc dut
et `mso bcjs up futtecn fosts ior thb orn`cez`teoc. Dy oiibrecn `c opt-out/`utog`tef bcrommgbct
pronr`g, et bcjs up s`vecn tegb ec thb cbw herb p`pbrworl profbss. Dy `utog`tef`mmy bcrommecn
bgpmoybbs, CU Dus V`mbs es nevecn oii thb egprbsseoc th`t thb fogp`cy f`rbs dout thb bgpmoybbs
iuturb whefh ecfrb`sbs bgpmoybb moy`mty `cj foggetgbct. ^eth ecfrb`sbj moy`mty `cj
foggetgbct, thbrb wemm db mbss turcovbr fosts.
@mm stujebs oi thbsb pm`cs show th`t thes systbg wemm ecfrb`sb bcrommgbct r`tbs. Zhes
`utog`tef bcrommgbct wemm t`lb `jv`ct`nb oi thb st`tus quo de`s, whbrb pbopmb put gorb wbenht
ecto thber furrbct setu`teoc `cj jo cot g`lb thb dbst fhoefbs ei et woumj ecvomvb ` fh`cnb. (Fhoe,
4;;9/ Dbc`rtze, 4;;>). Rcjbr thb opt-ec systbg bgpmoybbs who `rb cot lcowmbjnb`dmb `dout thb
mocn tbrg dbcbiets oi rbterbgbct pm`ccecn woumj oitbc tegbs cot t`lb thb stbps to sbt thbgsbmvbs
up ior thb iuturb, thes es ` nooj w`y ior fogp`cebs to t`lb f`rb oi thber bgpmoybbs ec thb mocn tbrg.
H`vecn gorb pbopmb bcrommbj ec :;0(l) pm`c wemm ecfrb`sb bgpmoybb gor`mb, s thby rb mbss melbmy
to db worrebj `dout thber iec`cfe`m iuturb.
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
11/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
00
Ocb rb`soc th`t gorb bgpmoybrs h`vb dbbc i`vorecn `utog`tef es thb [bcseoc [rotbfteoc
@ft oi 4;;9. [reor to thb p`ss`nb oi thes m`w `utog`tef bcrommgbct oi bgpmoybbs w`s ` p`rtefum`rmy
reslecn govb ior bgpmoybbs. Ec thb p`st bgpmoybrs who `utog`tef`mmy bcrommbj thber bgpmoybbs
wbrb me`dmb ior `cy mossbs th`t ecfurrbj `s ` rbsumt oi thb `utog`tef foctreduteocs. ^eth thb p`ss`nb
oi thb `ft bgpmoybrs wbrb `dmb to rbmebvb thbgsbmvbs oi me`demety throunh thb usb oi Pu`meiebj
Jbi`umt Ecvbstgbct @mtbrc`tevb. Zhbsb PJE@s `mmow bgpmoybrs to `utog`tef`mmy bcromm `cj sbt
thb foctreduteoc oi thber bgpmoybbs whemb stemm bcaoyecn thb s`gb iejufe`ry rbmebi oi thosb th`t h`vb
bgpmoybbs opt-ec to thb pm`c. @c bxpm`c`teoc thb rbquerbgbcts oi thbsb PJE@s f`c db ioucj ec
@ppbcjex (9).
Nr`phs vesu`mmy showecn thb popum`rety, strufturb `cj biibft th`t `utog`tef bcrommgbct
pm`cs h`s oc bcrommgbct f`c db ioucj ec @ppbcjex (>).
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
12/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
04
Vugg`ry `cj Focfmuseoc
Zhrounhout our tegb gbbtecn weth Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs, wb wbrb vbry egprbssbj weth
thber HT profbssbs. Howbvbr, wb ioucj 6 `rb`s th`t h`j roog ior egprovbgbct. Zhbsb `rb`s
ecfmujb egpmbgbctecn `c ocmecb `ppmef`teoc systbg, egprovecn thb furrbct wbmmcbss pronr`g, `cj
egpmbgbctecn `c opt-out/`utog`tef bcrommgbct :;0(l) systbg. ^b ioucj th`t `mm thrbb oi thbsb
egprovbgbcts jerbftmy rbm`tbj to thb no`ms oi Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs `s ` whomb ec thb w`y oi
bgpmoybb s`tesi`fteoc. b iecj th`t mm thrbb oi thbsb egprovbgbcts rb fhebv`dmb cj ec thb mocn-
ruc wemm bcj up s`vecn Cbw Uorl Dus V`mbs gocby `cj egprovecn thber bgpmoybbs pbriorg`cfb,
aod s`tesi`fteoc, `cj qu`mety oi meib.
Ei you cbbj `jjeteoc`m eciorg`teoc rbn`rjecn thes proabft, pmb`sb foct`ft Jr. D`rry @. Irebjg`c `t
(602) 604-9680 ord`rry.irebjg`cKoswbno.bju.
^b w`ct to th`cl CU Dus V`mbs ior thber support jurecn thes proabft.
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected] -
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
13/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
06
Tbibrbcfbs
Dbc`rtze, Vhmogo `cj Tefh`rj H. Zh`mbr (4;;>). "Hburestefs `cj De`sbs ec Tbterbgbct V`vecns
Dbh`veor."Aourc`m oi Bfocogef [brspbftevbs, Vuggbr 4;;>, v. 40, ess. 6, pp. 80-0;:
Fhoe, A`gbs A., J`vej M`edsoc, `cj Drenettb F. G`jre`c. "[m`c Jbsenc `cj :;0(l) V`vecns
Outfogbs." CDBT ^orlecn [`pbr. C.p., G`y 4;;:. ^bd.
Zemmg`c, @. Zhb Egp`ft oi ^bmmcbss [ronr`gs oc @gbref`s ^orliorfb.
Zhb Ecstetutb ior Hb`mthf`rb Focsugbresg. Tbtrebvbj irog
http1//www.thbehff.fog/bc/gbje`_fbctbr/bjetors_ pefls/thb-egp`ft-oi-wbmmcbss-pronr`gs-oc-
`gbref`%B4%8;%55s-worli_h4abbnr`.htgm
Zemmg`c, @. Zhb Egp`ft oi ^bmmcbss [ronr`gs oc @gbref`s ^orliorfb. Zhb Ecstetutb ior
Hb`mthf`rb Focsugbresg. Tbtrebvbj irog http1//www.thbehff.fog/bc/gbje`_fbctbr/bjetors_
pefls/thb-egp`ft-oi-wbmmcbss-pronr`gs-oc-`gbref`%B4%8;%55s-worli_h4abbnr`.htgm
R.V. Fh`gdbr Henhmenhts Dbcbiets oi ^orlpm`fb ^bmmcbss [ronr`gs. (4;;5, @prem 0). Tbtrebvbj
G`y 9, 4;02, irog https1//www.usfh`gdbr.fog/prbss-rbmb`sb/us-fh`gdbr-henhmenhts-dbcbiets-
worlpm`fb-wbmmcbss-pronr`gs
Rcetbj Vt`tbs Jbp`rtgbct oi M`dor, Jbi`umt Ecvbstgbct @mtbrc`tevbs Rcjbr [`rtefep`ct-JerbftbjEcjeveju`m @ffouct [m`cs
http1//www.jom.nov/bds`/cbwsroog/isjbi`umtopteocpropos`mrbveseoc.htgm
^bmshhocs, M. How Bgpmoybb ^bmmcbss [ronr`gs F`c Nbcbr`tb V`vecns ior Uour Fogp`cy.
Gbret Tbsourfbs. Tbterbvbj irog http1//www.gbretrbsourfbs.fog/usbrjofs/g`tbre ms/
Bgpmoybb_^bmmcbss_Ecete`tevbs_Gbret.pji
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
14/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
0:
@ppbcjefbs
@ppbcjex (0)
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
15/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
02
@ppbcjex (4)
Irog1 https1//www.zoho.fog
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
16/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
09
@ppbcjex (6)
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
17/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
0>
@ppbcjex (:)
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
18/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
08
@ppbcjex (2)
-
7/23/2019 New York Bus Sales - HRM 464 (Consulting Project)
19/20
Fociejbcte`m Tbport
05
@ppbcjex (9)
@fforjecn to thb Rcetbj Vt`tbs jbp`rtgbct oi m`dor ` PJE@ gust s`tesiy thb iommowecn
rbquerbgbcts1
@ PJE@ g`y cot egposb iec`cfe`m pbc`mtebs or othbrwesb rbstreft thb `demety oi `
p`rtefep`ct or dbcbiefe`ry to tr`csibr thb ecvbstgbct irog thb qu`meiebj jbi`umt
ecvbstgbct `mtbrc`tevb to `cy othbr ecvbstgbct `mtbrc`tevb `v`em`dmb ucjbr thb pm`c.
@ PJE@ gust db bethbr g`c`nbj dy `c ecvbstgbct g`c`nbr, or `c ecvbstgbct
fogp`cy rbnestbrbj ucjbr thb Ecvbstgbct Fogp`cy @ft oi 05:;.@ PJE@ gust db jevbrseiebj so `s to gecegezb thb resl oi m`rnb mossbs.
@ PJE@ g`y cot ecvbst p`rtefep`ct foctreduteocs jerbftmy ec bgpmoybr sbfuretebs.
@ PJE@ g`y db1
o Meib-fyfmb or t`rnbtbj-rbterbgbct-j`tb iucj)
Irog1 Zrbcjs ec :;0(l) [m`cs `cj
Tbterbgbct Tbw`rjs ` 4;06 rbport
dy thb @gbref`c Dbcbiets Ecstetutb