nrc/dominion improved technical specifications project m ... · minion • • nrc/dominion...
TRANSCRIPT
• •minion
NRC/Dominion
Improved
Technical Specifications
Project M'eeting
May 12, 2009
Agenda
• Meeting Purpose
• Demonstration/Beta Testing of information transfer
• Review Current Schedule
• Set Window for Submittal Date
• Discuss License Renewal communications/timing
• Current issues
• Discuss NRC Project Planning
• Open Discussion/Questions Doml ion
2
1
Purpose
• Demonstrate the software to be used to document and resolve NRC questions and comments pertaining to the KPS ITS submittal.
• Discuss current KPS status and schedule for submitting KPS ITS to the NRC.
• Obtain NRC input regarding their anticipated schedule for review.
• Discuss the current issues that may affect the ITS submittal.
3
Electronic Information Exchange
• Orientation - Process overview
- Changes to the process
• Beta test criteria - Key attributes of the system
- Software changes
Domi •
4
2
Current Kewaunee Schedule
• Discuss the "for information only" copies of the ITS metrics.
Notes: - These metrics are a "snapshot" of ITS performance
- The 2009 outage is September/October
- Most Core team members will fully participate in the outage.
Dominion 5
LAR Submittal, Date
• The licensee proposes an ITS LAR submittal window of August 17 to 31,2009.
• Current performance indicates a high potential to achieve the earlier date.
• Dominion will periodically update the NRC PM of progress.
• Submittal content will be consistent with past submittals
D-inioa 6
3
Discuss License Renewal communications/timing
• The current plan for completion of license renewal is November 2010.
• Dominion prefers that ITS be included in the renewal.
inion 7
Current issues
• Potential Beyond Scope Items - TSTF- 493, Clarify Application of Setpo,int Methodology
for LSSS Functions
- TSTF - 411, Surveillance Test Interval Extensions for Components of the Reactor Protection System (WCAP15376-P) Rev. 1
- TSTF-500, Rev. 1, DC Electrical Rewrite
o-lnion 8
4
Current issues
• Issues: - Control room XlQ issue
- Main Steam Safety valves
- Inverters and battery charger specifications
9
Kewaunee Conversion TSTF Adoption
• TSTFs Adopting - TSTF 411, Frequency allowances for ESFAS and RPS - TSTF 343, Containment Structural Integrity (3.0 to 3.1 Issue) - TSTF 400, Clarify SR on Bypass of DG Automatic Trips (3.0 to 3.1 Issue) - TSTF 439, Elimination of Second Completion Time (3.0 to 3.1 Issue) - TSTF 470, Correct Titles & References to PAM Instrument Bases (3.0 to 3.1
Issue) - TSTF 471, Eliminate use of tenn CORE ALTERATIONS - TSTF 479, Changes to Reflect Revision to 10CFR50.55a (3.0 to 3.1 Issue) - TSTF 482, Correct LCO 3.0.6 Bases (3.0 to 3.1 Issue) - TSTF 485, Correct Example 1.4-1 (3.0 to 3.1 Issue) - TSTF 493, Clarify Application of Setpoint Methodology for LSSS Functions - TSFT 497, Limit Inservice Testing Program SR 3.0.2 Application to
Frequencies of 2 Years or Less - TSTF 513, Revise Operability Requirements and Actions for RCS Leakage
Instrumentation(06/2009) - TSTF-500, Rev. 1, DC Electrical Rewrite (07/2009)
DominioB 10
5
Kewaunee Conversion TSTF Adoption (cont.)
• CUIPS Adopting - TSTF 374, Diesel Fuel Oil
- TSTF 359, Increased Flexibility in Mode Restraints
- TSTF 421, RCP Flywheel Inspection (lSI Plan Adopted)
- TSTF 412, One Steam Supply to TO AFW Pump
- TSTF 475, Control Rod Notch Testing Frequency and SRM Insert Control Rod Action
- TSTF 490, Deletion of E-Bar
- TSTF 491, Removal of MSIV & MFRV Isolation Times
- TSTF 511, Elimination of Work Hour Restriction Dominion
11
Discuss NRC Project Planning
• NRC review project milestones/dates - Acceptance review
- Section 1.0 - Section 2.0
- Sections 3.1 to 3.9
- Section 4.0
- Section 5.0
- SER
Dontinion
12
6
Open Discussion/Questions
DoaIh'ion 13
7
.oI,:lUaI level 2 • I'IS Conversion ~. C'JI11lIett> - 23. 29'10 ~)ry: Deeigl.i Lbelliling Basis
Tlrgel Projected Actual Completion Comp.lelion COIJllNtion ~. TOll1
IAir.5IOnH Stll10atl DI. Dalll Date \'Ie iah I Ccmpr.. ComplelG p,dect IoQd<oH 61'.'2007 f1,12C07 1'.11.'2(')7 O.'o:A I(O~. O.1O~··
PFRB PMDMalicn: MNlino r. IC.'2007 9f27f?OO7 9o'2712CI)] 0.10'10 I(O~. 0.10~'
Dw'ebo PR.' Dwebo& "tut PO 7f1(\'2007 "t!.·2(07 lM1J2OlIf O~ lCO~. 025~
Pr~IA"fV... SchedJe 1':),31,'2007 3lW2C(6 111112001 0.10'10 1(O'!'. 0.10" Phue 1: ITSC.JfT.,'I...ion LAR ~tll AtWWTllH1 W,'2OCe 1;1112008 1.'11[2(')8 0.e0'4 I(O~. 0.500/
Phue 1: O~...bp'Aw'J'i. ~oJeocl P\ln :rlC.'20al 4,11.2008 112ll.'2oo. 0.e0'4 l(O~. 0.50" Phiite 1: ~ PlOiKl 3:4.'2O(e ""'''2OC6 '1112001 O.2Cl'lt. 100·~ 020~
Phite 2: 06'o'il1co' ~ Pika18 ,1.r,.'2OCe 7ftl20C/lJ 18.1'.O'lC. .ee~. 1424~'
Phaae 2: Rwlaw 14 Paka»s 5' 12.'20Ce 7f'lJ2(o();l 8.00"4 79~. 4.74~·
Phaae 2: A""""... 1~ P......... !lo':;Y)'2OCe 7{2:12COO '.00"4 .~. L38'!'
O~ 111m Cbtln ,12.'20(09 71292COO 2.00"4 58". 1.1~ LARValdllicn ~22l2009 71292(o();l 1.00"4 O~. OiJO'lf:
Slttnit 10 NRC 7/22.'20Co9 7.'31/:2(Q) 0.05"4 o~. O!JC/'lI,
Phaae 3: RAJ AlKMon a'J.'2009 E.'1i201,) 15.00"4 0"' OIlC/'ll,
Pilate 3 : LAR .. SER Awoval 612.'2010 6'221"') 0.15"4 0·'.. O.'lC/'ll,
Deriebo and Attmie IlroliNrenlillicn Ran ""5;'2009 5'1 '12COO 0.05"4 O~. OiJC/'lI,
Phile .& : Rwiw and D_bo PrtOilduroHl 5116'2009 1127:'2010 3S.1'.O'lC. O~. OJ)C/'lI,
Phile.& : Rwiw and D_bD PlI:XIrantl 5'16'2009 7[27:'2010 10,00"4 O~. O!JC/'lI,
,PlBle.&: Rwiw l Deriotbp Tlairiro ".'2.'2009 1:292010 2.00"4 O~. 0.0
Phite'&: ImllemtrtTrainilli (5 LORP O;cles) 211,'2010 6/3(12010 5.00"4 O~. 0.0 Phaae.&: Readi1eM Aaeemenl 7:112010 a'g2010 1,C()04 O~. (1,0)
Phi.. .&: LAR ImPemenlillion· SER .. - 18C.:I a'3:~01') 9/3(12010 1.00"4 0·'., OD Phile.&: Potl hrdElllEl'llalion Aawnw 1C~1.'2010 1Q'3Cf20fll 0.e0'4 0"' .).oC/'ll,
lP!dectC~Ul 1IJ1,'201 0 12131:2010 0.e0'4 0·'.. O!lO'lE I·)O..C(~.
1OooJ~ ~--,.
90% +--~.
80'% +-----'. 70% +--__ 60% -t---__
50%+--~
40%+--30'¥o +---20% ;-__...L... -::::II--'...=- ---; 10% +-----------:-:::;;:orIl.......~~=-------------__l
0% -h......._I.-A-t*--t--"""*~~+__+-I___+___+-+--+-_I___I_____lr___+__f_-+___+-+__1
:\ :\
fiy....{C ~...(t ~\
'" 1--Project Status - Milestone I
ITS Development Individual Package Status
100
90
80
70
CI> 60-CI> Q.E 50 0 u ';;fl. 40
30
20
10
0 PKG 1 PKG PKG PKG PKG
1a 1b 2a 2b PKG PKG PKG PKG 2c 3a 3b 3c
Individual Package #
I_ Draft .Review DAPprova'l
PKG PKG 4 PKG 5 PKG 6 PKG 3d INTG
ITS Development Draft Status
i100 --------------------~7)(--li
90 I X ............... I
80 I ~4C )(' I
70 I ,
60 -11__---'
50 I // I
Q)
~ 40 I, X7 r - l--------------/~~~--------------------l,c. E o u 30 I /AI' I ~ Cl
1720 I • I
10 I 7' I
o *' .. [ iI iii ,
Apr-DB May-DB Jun-OB Jul-OB Aug-DB Sep-OB Oct-DB Nov-DB Dec-DB Jan-09 Feb-09 Mar-09 Apr-09 May-09 Jun-09
-+-Draft Draft Ideal
ITS Development Review Status
~I ~ I
70+1--
001 v e
80+!---
L~=---------~~>£-j,fL-T--60 !
100 I ~
.l!! CD Q. 401 ;/' I E o ()
~ o
7 e
/'
7 .....
30 r---------------------=/7'7£L=-------------jL------------I ---
20 I
10 I ~-==
0* • ... .........- , May-08 Jul-08 Sep-08 Nov-DB Jan-09 Mar-09 May-09 Jul-09
I """"'*- Review Ideal -.-- Review I
•
•
•
(]l 0 ctn ::> ....., ...
CO... ~
UJ - a CO >0
(]l~ 0Q. >. ro0 2
<C... c::: Q)
E 0
(]l 0 -0
(ij >i5. 0~ « .... a.Q) a. «C
UJ +I-(]l 0 ~ <II 2
(]l o
,......--+----+---+----+---t----4----+---t"----4----, ~ o o o o o a o aLL o 0) co <0 C') C\l ....
ITS Development Open Item Status III Total I 180-,-,----
• Closed ~------,-----------,
o
40 +1-----------------------------------------:-"1
20
120
140 Ie. "'
160 I _ 11;;'l
et°O .! c8.80 I
o o =l:t: 60 1
PKG 1 PKG PKG PKG PKG PKG PKG PKG PKG PKG PKG 4 PKG 5 PKG 6 Total 1a 1b 2a 2b 2c 3a 3b 3c 3d
Open Item by ITS Package #
CJ)
E Q) -''U
Q) cu CJ)
(5.2I-U
+ +
eQV~ ~ eQ ~
Vc 0 f/) ~
L: E eQ ~ CI)
Vc 0 ...., ~- ~ ~ c: Va vCI) C%;C. L0 eQ <2 "'C
Vc V ~CI)
~ ~f/) Q)0 Va v ..- ~ eu 0 'L C f/) eQ ~
> Vc V
- - ~ co ~ ~...., va V0
~I~ <%Va ve ~ <~ Va v ~
~ ~ Va 0 eoL 6'Q ~
Vc 0 ~
0 0 0 0 0 a a a 0 0 ~ c;,~ Va 0co <D ~ N 0 co <D ~ N eo~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~G0
--------
t
~
. '. ~
'~J' ..' ,r~,-s Acturu Target
Level 2 • Setpoint Calculation Program Reportlrg Dati}: 518/2009 0/0 Compl..te = 31.05% '1'0 Compl..te = 20.97% Category: CalCtJ/;Jlions
Target Projected Actual ActlYlty Complotion CoJl'1)letlon Completion % % % Total
Milestones Start Date DRt8 Dato Date Welaht ComDlete Comokite 11"2Qo'~ 11'20'2000PFRB Preoar.ltion'" Meetina
:?l'2i:;:{l()Q 2iQ'2000Project KIckoff Startup 09V9Iop SChQdule :?l'2imoo 2112'2009 C10819 Hioh lLoN Pressurizo)/' Pressure 2'I&'moQ W30'2009 C10619 low Reac10r Coolant Flow ~3a20002!16i~CII006 Coot. Pressure - istti ~,St Lrv'ContScravl ~30'20002!16i Cll t 16 H1-21lo-2 SG NA lVl 4l2Q1moQ 9i3CY2000 C10654 LoN St line PrQSsurQ (Sll 2'1 &'::oo1l W3a2000 CN - soo- 02 - 60PDT :'OTDT "·I..::roll Qo'30'2009
S'4i3JOO W3CY2000CI0082 Hlch Pressurizer Level f{llCXXXXX Poww ~e + polO W3CY2009
&'3(\0' Ql31i200QElectrical setlXlint Calc, Placerolder it a-'3QiEleclrical SetDOlnt Calc. Placeholder f2 9/3112000 Qlt7l W3CY2000Tech R""ort
5O.59i72.49 10127/2009lali 11)'27,1Project Closeout 10'31l2009
!()OI¥. t .0fJr. 2.rolC. I()OI¥. 2.00r.. I.~
I()OI¥.2.~ 2.0fJr. 41'221'2000 O,~ !OO¥. 9.001'0
612!:l.OOQ 9.009(, 7tW. 6.6B'¥. Si6l3J09 9.009(, 990/. 6.9.w.. 7ilf3JOO 9.<m'0 110/0 1.0orY..
0.009(, 00/., 0.000/0 Bi2a'3J09 9.009(, 60/0 0.521'0
0.009(, 01'. 0.001'. O,~ O'¥. 0.000/0 6.C()qi 00/., 0.001'0 6.00'lI 0.001'0 S.C()qi
O'¥. I»~ 0.001'0
5.~ O'¥. 0.001'0 O'¥. 0.001'.I.~
100.<m'o Project NOtes 1. NM l.F.Nel2: li31/08 (Additionru it€4l1s-TrJnsition Plan, CR's & Project Closure.
~ ,. ,. " ,t."n
t
100% 90% 80% 70% 600;.0 50% 40% 30% 20%
10% 0%
,
~......'" &
~ .--~
.......--:-- --
I!
\ l\
11 1 ~
/'"
---- •
#~##~~####~~~###~###~ti-l,. .r!t~ ~'.P.#"e ~~ .:::~ ~"e 4? rj,"e ~? ~'{6J 4 ,.~~6' ;;;,'P ,~"D ~"D ,..:t ~ f>{t "i'P (\~6''re II,:' '."" """,~ ',"" . ..... \( (. . "\' '.~ ~~ \"1 cy ., .! ~ '!'l.,. . 'Ii' ".t ~ ';>( ';>( ':Y '::t "0' '\' 'Q' ~\ cy ....~ ~
1--- Project Status - Milestone I