ofsted forum oct_15_2014

21
Philip Moriarty School of Physics & Astronomy University of Nottingham [email protected] @Moriarty2112 www.nottingham.ac.uk/physics/research/nano Lies, damned lies, and Ofsted’s pseudostatistics

Upload: philip-moriarty

Post on 02-Jul-2015

266 views

Category:

Education


2 download

DESCRIPTION

Lies, Damned Lies, and Ofsted's Pseudostatistics. Slides from a presentation given at a joint National Union of Teachers (NUT) - University and College Union (UCU) forum on October 15 2014. Speaking alongside Kevin Courtney (NUT, @cyclingkev) and Nadia Whittome. See also http://physicsfocus.org/lies-damned-lies-ofsteds-pseudostatistics/

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

Philip MoriartySchool of Physics & Astronomy

University of Nottingham

[email protected]@Moriarty2112

www.nottingham.ac.uk/physics/research/nano

Lies, damned lies, and Ofsted’s pseudostatistics

Page 2: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

The day job: Research

Condensed matter physicist Single atom/molecule

imaging and manipulation

Page 3: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

Condensed matter physicist Single atom/molecule

imaging and manipulation

The day job: Research

Page 4: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

The day job: Teaching

Measurements without uncertainties/error bars “not even wrong”

Page 5: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

Not everything that counts…

http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/26/everything-counts-einstein/

Page 6: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

Beyond the ivory tower…

Page 7: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014
Page 8: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014
Page 9: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

http://icingonthecakeblog.weebly.com/blog

Page 10: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014
Page 11: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014
Page 12: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

WTF?!

Page 13: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014
Page 14: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

Measuring success?

Page 15: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

…and universities are no better.

Page 16: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

The normal distributionThe normal distribution

Page 17: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

But marks aren’t necessarily But marks aren’t necessarily normally distributed…normally distributed…

Consider

0, 50, 100

49, 50, 51

Page 18: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

……and neither are many other and neither are many other things in lifethings in life

Page 19: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014

The central limit theoremThe central limit theorem

Page 20: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014
Page 21: Ofsted forum oct_15_2014