on coal mines verdeo targets methane both post and pre-mining

22
2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. CMM Offset Generating Project Case Studies Presentation to the CAR Workshop November 9, 2010 Morgantown, WV Santosh Lakhan & Jeff Liebert Verdeo Group 1

Upload: others

Post on 04-Feb-2022

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

CMM Offset Generating Project Case StudiesPresentation  to  the  CAR  WorkshopNovember  9,  2010Morgantown,  WV

Santosh  Lakhan  &  Jeff  LiebertVerdeo Group

1

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

Verdeo Update: Projects Under Development

Longwall Coal Mine Gob gas destruction

feasibility assessment

Abandoned Longwall Coal MineCarbon monetization of gob gas

pipeline injection

Longwall Coal MineGob gas destruction

Longwall Coal MineGob gas and VAM feasibility

assessment

Longwall Trona MineGob gas destruction and

utilization

Longwall Coal MineVAM oxidation

Longwall Trona MineGob gas destruction and

utilization

Verdeo Offices

Oil/Gas ProductionFugitive methane

capture

Oil/Gas ProductionFugitive methane

captureOil/Gas Production

Fugitive methanecapture

The leading portfolio of methane projects in North America with environmental attributes

Mexican LandfillsLFG gathering and destruction

projects

Gas ProductionLeak Detection and Repair

Coal Mining CompanyCMM/CBM to power generation

Coal Mining CompanyPortfolio feasibility

assessment, gob gas field test

2

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

Longwall being  mined

Future  longwalls

Gob  Vent  Boreholes

Ventilation    &

Bleeder  Fans Pre-­‐mine  Degas  Wells

VAM

Gob  Gas

Pre-­‐mine  

Degas

Mined  Out  Area

Sources  of  Mine  Methane  Emissions

3

On coal mines Verdeo targets methane, both post and pre-mining

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 4

Varying methane concentrations result in only a select set of project types being applicable to each source

Applicable  Project  Types

RTO/RCO  Oxidation

Incineration

Power  Generation  using  Lean  Gas  Engines

Pipeline  Injection

Ventilation  Air Gob  Vent  Boreholes Pre-­‐mining  Degas

Source  of  methane

Higher  methane  concentrations  make  this  an  

inefficient    and  costly  mechanism  for  abatement

Methane  concentrations  are  too  low  to  be  ignited  and  

combusted  in  an  incinerator

While  technically  feasible  “waste”  of  potentially  high  

quality  gas  stream  

Methane  concentrations  are  too  low  to  power  lean  gas  

engines

Methane  concentrations  are  too  low  for  pipeline  quality

Higher  methane  concentrations  make  this  an  

inefficient    and  costly  mechanism  for  abatement

0.3– 1.9%  CH4(stable  in  flow  

&  concentration)40  – 80%  CH

4(fluctuates  

depending  on  mining)70  – 90%  CH

4(relatively  stable  

in  flow  and  concentration)

*  Longevity  of  gob  wells  and  infrastructure  costs  (including  piping  to  well)  could  make  this  economically  unviable

*

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 5

Verdeo has worked or is currently developing projects in each of these project types

Gob  or  GoafGo

b  well

Extraction  Pump

Caved  in  

sections

Oxidizers Flare

Pre-­‐mine  De

gas    well

Incineration

Pipeline

Pipeline  Injection

Mine

Vent  Shaft

Fan

Ventilation  Air  Methane  Oxidation

Gas  Conditioning

Pre-­‐mine  De

gas    well

Lean  Gas  Engine  

Power  Generation

Containerized  Lean  Gas  Engine

• Generating  units  are  containerized  increasing  portability  

• Modularity  allows  for  plant  to  be  scaled  up  and  down  depending  on  gas  availability

• Engines  can  cope  with  fluctuating  gas  compositions

• Plants  are  large  to  capture  economies  of  scale  and  are  typically  located  closer  to  gas  pipelines  

• Requires  significant  gas  gathering  and  collection  infrastructure  

• Incinerator  can  be  integrated  with  existing  extraction  pumps

• Both  extraction  pumps  &  incinerators  are  portable  &  can  follow  mining  activity  &  can  also  be  used  on  a  peaking  basis

• Incinerators  are  designed  to  cope  with  fluctuations  in  methane  concentrations

• Regenerative  Thermal  Oxidizer  (RTO)  plants    are  relatively  large  comprising  multiple  modular  RTO  units

• Plant  must  be  located  more  than  100  feet  from  vent  or  bleeder  shaft  evasé  

• Plant  can  be  relocated  if  needed• RTO  can  be  designed  for  an  operational  range  as  low  as  0.2%  CH4

Plant  Characteristics

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 6

Varying methane concentrations result in only a select set of project types being applicable to each source

Applicable  Project  Types

RTO  Oxidation

Incineration

Power  Generation  using  Lean  Gas  Engines

Pipeline  Injection

Ventilation  Air Gob  Vent  Boreholes Pre-­‐mining  Degas

Source  of  methane

Higher  methane  concentrations  make  this  an  

inefficient    and  costly  mechanism  for  abatement

Higher  methane  concentrations  make  this  an  

inefficient    and  costly  mechanism  for  abatement

0.3  – 1.9%  CH4(stable  in  flow  

&  concentration)40  – 80%  CH

4(fluctuates  

depending  on  mining)70  – 90%  CH

4(relatively  stable  

in  flow  and  concentration)

*  Longevity  of  gob  wells  and  infrastructure  costs  (including  piping  to  well)  could  make  this  economically  unviable

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 7

When fully operational the McElroy VAM project will generate approximately 380,000 offsets annually

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 8

Design  and  Development Construction  and  Commissioning Ongoing  Operations

• Financing• System  integration• Coal  mining  and  CMM  experience

• Project  finance  and  management

• Air  permitting

• Engineering  and  design  capabilities

• RTO  experience

• Mining  experience• Engineering  support• Permitting  and  environmental  support

• Project  management• System  integration• Carbon  services• Investment  management• CMM  and  VAM  expertise

• Technology  solution  fabrication

• Plant  construction• Testing  and  commissioning  

• Site  location• VAM  resource• General  safety  and  engineering  support

• Offset  generation• Offset  monetization• Investment  management• Project  and  Performance  management

• Plant  operation• Maintenance• Ongoing  technical  services

• VAM  resource• General  safety  and  engineering  support

McElroy project roles and responsibilities

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 9

Varying methane concentrations result in only a select set of project types being applicable to each source

Applicable  Project  Types

RTO  Oxidation

Incineration

Power  Generation  using  Lean  Gas  Engines

Pipeline  Injection

Ventilation  Air Gob  Vent  Boreholes Pre-­‐mining  Degas

Source  of  methane

Methane  concentrations  are  too  low  to  power  lean  gas  

engines

0.3– 1.9%  CH4(stable  in  flow  

&  concentration)40  – 80%  CH

4(fluctuates  

depending  on  mining)70  – 90%  CH

4(relatively  stable  

in  flow  and  concentration)

*  Longevity  of  gob  wells  and  infrastructure  costs  (including  piping  to  well)  could  make  this  economically  unviable

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 10

The development of the CMM power project is being undertaken in three distinct sequential phases

Feasibility  AssessmentPlant  Design,  Permitting  and  

Interconnect  Study

Construction  and  

Commissioning  

• Understand  mine  power  requirements  and  profile

• Assess  gas  availability,  quality  and  volumes

• Determine  potential  technology  solutions  and  applicability  

• Estimate  plant  size  and  design  based  on  gas  availability,  electricity  demand  and  technology  options

• Analyze  the  financial  case  for  the  power  plant  and  determine  success  criteria

• Develop  project  structure  and  financing  options

• Finalize  plant  design  and  operational  characteristics

• Determine  plant  emissions  profile  and  initiate  permitting  applications

• Undertake  grid  interconnect  study  to  understand  implications  of  introducing  power  to  the  grid

• Determine  stand-­‐by  power  requirements

• Negotiate  off-­‐take  or  tolling  agreements

• Construct  and  commission  plant  according  to  finalized  design  specifications

• Ongoing  operation  and  maintenance  of  the  plant  to  meet  availability  and  efficiency  targets

• Expansion  of  the  plant  depending  on  the  mine  electricity  needs  and  modularity  of  the  technology  solution

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

Understanding the sources and sinks of energy was critical in conceptualizing the power plant

11

Gas  Supply  Potential Mine  Power  Demand  ProfileGenerating  Plant  Capabilities

Daily  power  demand  profile ILLUSTRATIVE

ILLUSTRATIVE

Gas  Composition  Analysis

Gas  Production  Volume  Analysis ILLUSTRATIVE

ILLUSTRATIVE

• Analysis  of  mine  methane  in-­‐situ  reserves

• Determine  drainage  potential  and  CMM  &  CBM    delineations  based  on  mining  plan  and  projections

• Build  a  gas  supply  profile  with  projections  on  volume  and  composition  of  supply

• Assess  drilling  and  infrastructure  requirements  for  gas  supply  e.g.  compressions,  gas  treatment,  piping

Pre-­‐technology  selection

• Define  plant  generating  characteristics  based  on  gas  supply  and  power  demand  analysis

Post-­‐technology  selection

• Determine  plant  production  characterizes  and  determine  the  potential  for  excess  power  sales  to  the  grid  or  the  need  for  supplemental  grid  power  and  backup/contingency  provision

• Assess  the  need  and  implications  of  grid  interconnect

• Identify  power  sources  and  sinks  at  mine  facilities

• Build  a  mine  power  demand  profile  based  on  historic  use  and  projections

• Assess  possibility  for  shaping  demand  profile  to  better  suit  power  generating  plant  capabilities  or  to  avoid  peak  costs  

Equipment  and  Process  Load  Curves ILLUSTRATIVE

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

Gas  Analysis

12

Electricity  Demand  Analysis

Plant  Size  Assessment

Plant sizing was based on a detailed analysis of gas supply and mine electricity demand

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 13

Plant  Description  and  Details: Key  Metrics  and  Considerations:

• Project  description:

Generation:  20  MWeLocation:  PennsylvaniaFuel  Source:  Fugitive  Coal  Mine  Methane

• Key  Stakeholders  &  Parties:

Mining  Company  :  Leading  Appalachian  &  Powder  River  Basin,  publicly  traded,  coal  mining  company      Engine  suppliers:  GE  Jenbacher (5  X  4MW)

• Project  Economics  &  Metrics:

Number  of  lean  gas  engines:  5Electrical  efficiency:  39.1%Plant  availability:  93%Projected  grid  prices:  $65/MWh

• Key  issues  and  risks:

Plant  availability  and  power  output  are  dependant  on  the  quality  and  quantity  of  methane  supplyProject  economic  viability  depends  heavily  on  strong  power  demand  &  pricing  Depending  on  the  size  of  the  plant  the  GHG  emissions  from  the  plant  could  exceed  25,000  tCO2e    which  could  cause  permitting  issues

The project is poised to enter the design and permitting stage of development

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 14

Varying methane concentrations result in only a select set of project types being applicable to each source

Applicable  Project  Types

RTO  Oxidation

Incineration

Power  Generation  using  Lean  Gas  Engines

Pipeline  Injection

Ventilation  Air Gob  Vent  Boreholes Pre-­‐mining  Degas

Source  of  methane

Methane  concentrations  are  too  low  for  pipeline  quality

0.3– 1.9%  CH4(stable  in  flow  

&  concentration)40  – 80%  CH

4(fluctuates  

depending  on  mining)70  – 90%  CH

4(relatively  stable  

in  flow  and  concentration)

*  Longevity  of  gob  wells  and  infrastructure  costs  (including  piping  to  well)  could  make  this  economically  unviable

*

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

Alpha’s Coal Gas Recovery Project was recently validated as a GHG offset project

15

Equitable  

Pipeline

Coal  Gas  Recovery  

Processing  Plant

Testing  

Program

Commercial  

Expansion

Commercial  

Expansion

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

0

1 1

2

3

6

8

9

5

4 4

2

1

0

1 1

0

2

1

2

1

0

2 2

1

2

0 0

1

0 0 0 0

DD  Wells VV  Wells Gob  Wells

Alpha’s drilling program expanded their R&D test program achieving commercial scale

16

Testing  Phase Commercial  

Expansion

08/31/2004 08/31/2005 08/31/2006 08/31/2007 08/31/2008 08/31/2009 08/31/2010 08/31/2011 08/31/2012 08/31/2013 08/31/2014

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

Project will generate 2.7 – 3.1 million offsets over the life of the project

17

2.1 2.31.7

2.33.1

2.1 1.8 1.4 1.2 1.1 1.0 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.5 0.5

1.12.9

3.85.1 5.6 5.8

5.14.5

4.0 3.7

0.2 2.6

3.8

4.9

5.03.9 2.8

1.7

0.9

0.5

0.1

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019

3.3

6.7

9.2

10.1 10.1

9.4

8.4

6.9

4.7

5.8

4.6

Total  offsets  produced:  2.7  – 3.1  MMtCO2e

4.2

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 18

Varying methane concentrations result in only a select set of project types being applicable to each source

Applicable  Project  Types

RTO  Oxidation

Incineration

Power  Generation  using  Lean  Gas  Engines

Pipeline  Injection

Ventilation  Air Gob  Vent  Boreholes Pre-­‐mining  Degas

Source  of  methane

Methane  concentrations  are  too  low  to  be  ignited  and  

combusted  in  an  incinerator

While  technically  feasible  “waste”  of  potentially  high  

quality  gas  stream  

0.3– 1.9%  CH4(stable  in  flow  

&  concentration)40  – 80%  CH

4(fluctuates  

depending  on  mining)70  – 90%  CH

4(relatively  stable  

in  flow  and  concentration)

*  Longevity  of  gob  wells  and  infrastructure  costs  (including  piping  to  well)  could  make  this  economically  unviable

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 19

First operating gob gas incineration installation on an active underground mine in the US

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 20

Introducing the MDU™ - World’s first off-grid, mobile integrated gob gas incineration and measurement system

MDU™(Methane  Destruction  Unit)

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value. 21

Operational  Configuration

Transportation  Configuration

Configured for rapid deployment and easy mobility

2010 CAR Workshop – Morgantown, WV Unlocking Carbon Value.

For fully financed, turn-key methane abatement or beneficial use projects please contact:

22

1600 K Street, NW, Suite 700, Washington, DC 20006 / www.verdeogroup.com

Denver Washington, DC Austin

Santosh LakhanDirector

Phone: [email protected]

Ben AppleDirector

Phone: [email protected]

Jeff LiebertManaging Director

Phone: [email protected]