one45 curriculum management system training for medical ... · an overview of the system. the...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Project Analysis
One45 Curriculum Management System Training
for Undergraduate Medical Education Administrators
OI&LSYvette Montoya ‐ 543 ‐ Dr. Kevin Brady
![Page 2: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Introduction
In response to a need for one centralized system which would allow Undergraduate Medical
Education to house all their curricular data, One 45 a new web based curricular management system
was purchase in the fall of 2014. One 45 helps access and track curriculum for the first 2 years of
medical school. Administrators within the Curriculum Support Center use the system to manage
academic schedules, add content material, manage student and small group lists and
assign/manage/report instructor and student evaluations. This system has allowed the department to
combine several different databases and tools into one robust system. Although this system has
streamlined many processes, the Curriculum Support Administrators have taken on the challenge of
learning a complex system with little to no training.
Learner Analysis
The following analysis looks at the learner’s characteristics, prerequisites, cultural and
geographic characteristics and motivation. The primary audience of learners are medical school
administrators working in a higher education setting. A secondary audience is administrative assistants
who work in the Curriculum Support Center.
General Characteristics
Ethnicity. The Curriculum Support Center (CSC) consists of a culturally diverse group of mostly
hispanic and white decent. According to UNM Office of Institutional Analytics the Health
Sciences Center is made up of 35.3% Hispanics and 52.7% White staff (2012).
Gender. According to UNM Office of Institutional Analytics regular full time staff consists of
79.3% female and 20.7% male (2012). This is a sufficient difference from main campus which
has 66.3% female and 33.7% male. CSC office has a majority of females, 6 females and 2 males.
Age. CSC staff members are between the ages of 30 and 60 years of age.
Education. All learners have their high school diploma with about half having their bachelor’s
degree. English is their primary language.
Cultural and Geographic Characteristics. Geographically learners reside in Albuquerque, New
Mexico.
Prerequisite Skills and Knowledge
![Page 3: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
The level of experience that most administrators have with the One45 curricular management
system is novice but there are some specific prerequisite skills that they must have to participate. The
learner will need to have knowledge of:
UNM Medical School Curriculum Phase 1 through 4
Awareness of components of each Curricular Phase
Blocks associated with specific curricular phase and student class year
Basic Computer Skills
Motivation
The main motivation will be natural consequences. Learning the new system will have an
immediate impact on the learner’s ability to do their job. They will have the opportunity to apply newly
acquired skills and immediately put them to use. (Keller Psychology of Learning for instruction, Driscoll).
Verbal persuasion will also contribute to the learner’s motivation as I am looking to incorporate mentors
as part of the training having staff members who have been successful in learning the program to tutor
new users. Having standardized goals so learners have expectancies to compare their performance to as
well as having them set their only personal goals.
Task Analysis
Task analysis describe the physical tasks and cognitive plans necessary for a learner to
accomplish a goal. Using printed guides and/or workflows in One45 to go through step by step
instruction for certain tasks;
Become familiar with One45 system and how it is used in curriculum management
Navigate through curricular management system
Perform tasks in One45 with the guidance of an instructor and user guides
Analyze performance and share best practices and tips with other learners
Content Analysis
Content for this training will focus on familiarizing learners will the One45 system, helping them
maneuver through academic schedules and related content and guiding them through step by step
instruction of how to complete work related tasks. The training will be instructor lead and began with
![Page 4: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be
based on internet resources, interviews with Oner45 users, and a systematic pilot testing. The training
will consist of lecture, demonstrations, small group discussions and one on one help. Depending on the
skill level of the learner those who may be more familiar with the system may aid the instructor in
helping others.
Knowledge: Lecture/Demonstration
1) Review Objectives of Training
2) Overview of UNM School of Medicine Phase I Curricular Map
a) Review academic schedule of first and second year medical students
i) Identify each block and its duration
b) Review different types of student activities and how they are categorized
i) Foundations of Clinical Practice
ii) Tutorials
iii) Clinical Skills
iv) Continuity Clinic
v) Medical Ethics & Professionalism
vi) Culture, Identity, Diversity
vii) Pim Electives
3) Overview of One 45 system
a) General facts about the system and what it is used for
b) Goals of Curriculum Support Center using the system
4) Role of Administrators in One45
a) Overview of types of tasks Administrators will be performing in the system
i) Enter /review/edit academic schedules
ii) Add sections
iii) Add sessions
iv) Confirm dates, times and materials
v) Create student groups
vi) Add faculty to course
vii) Create/send evaluation packages to students and faculty
viii) Monitoring incomplete evaluations
![Page 5: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
ix) Creating evaluation report
5) Navigating through the One45 system
a) How to log into One45
b) Explore components of One45 system
i) Access Phase I academic schedule
(1) Management Tool
(a) Curricular Year
(b) Course/Block
(c) Sessions and Sections
(2) Tools
(a) People
(b) Evaluations
(c) Handouts/Links
(3) Student Groups
(a) Group Families
(b) Groups in
(c) People in group
(d) Pick leaners
(4) Rolodexes
(a) Students
(b) Faculty
Skills: Manipulation, Articulation
6) With the guidance of your instructor and peers demonstrate tasks with the use of job performance
aids
a) Add/edit sessions in academic schedules
b) Add sections to sessions
c) Add student groups to sessions and/or sections
d) Assign learners to student group
e) Assign facilitators to sessions and/or sections
f) Create student and instructor evaluation forms
g) Assign/manage/report instructor evaluation forms
![Page 6: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
h) Assign/manage/report student evaluation forms
i) Assign/mange/report weekly assignments
Attitude: Small group discussion
7) Once learners have performed tasks they will discuss their experience
a) What went well
b) What do learners still have questions on or need help with
c) Any tips or best practices from instructor or peers
Context Analysis
Organization
Support: The director of the CSC is in support of the development of an One45 training to fill the
operational needs of the office. The administrators have agreed to participate and I have designated one
in particular to be a subject matter expert (SME). Time has been designated for interviews with the SME
as well as the CSC director and learners. I will also be observing those using the system.
Constraints
Time: The development of the training is happen while the system is already in use. The new curricular
year will began in July 2014 but the preparation has already begun.
Participation: When teaching several people in a small group setting it can be difficult to provide
personalized instruction. It can also be challenging to accommodate different learning styles. Some
learners may have difficulty keeping up with the pace of instruction while others may disengage if pace
is to slow.
Resources: Project is considered part of normal operations so there is no designated budget. There is
only one instructional designer.
![Page 7: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Technological
Conference rooms are available for use. Rooms have internet connection, desktop computer, over‐head
projector and white boards. Each of the learners will need access to lab top or desktop. Laptops are
available to be checked out from the Educational Technologies Services department which CSC is a sister
office with or personal laptop can be brought. All materials related to course will be on shared O: Drive
which all learners have access to. One45 is a web based system that is accessible to everyone taking the
training and there is no extra cost involved.
Physical
Training will be instructor led in an office setting or conference room where groups can be lead through
a step by step instructions, sharing materials and skills through presentations, demonstrations and
discussions.
Instructor will be on hand to direct learners by referencing user guides, demonstrating tasks and
answering questions. Learners will be able to share ideas and team problem solve.
Goal Analysis
Organizational:
Curriculum Support Center Administrators will use a systematic approach to completing tasks in
One45 system.
Curriculum Support Center Staff will have formal training in the One45 system
Training will help employees understand the functions of the One45 system within the CSC.
Maximize efficiency in the use of the One45 system while minimizing errors.
Standardize practices for One45 users throughout the CSC.
Instructional:
Create instructional materials to be used in training sessions and as reference guides when
completing tasks in One45.
Design instructor‐ led course focusing on the use of performance aids and small group
interaction.
![Page 8: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Design Document OLIT : 543 Yvette Montoya
Instructional Need Audience Course Length Delivery Method
One 45 a new web based curricular management system was recently purchase to helps access and track curriculum within the first 2 years of medical school. Administrators in the Curriculum Support Center use the system to manage academic schedules, add content material, assign/manage student groups, assign instructors to sessions, and assign/manage/report instructor and student evaluations. This system has allowed the department to combine several different databases and tools into one robust system. Although this system has streamlined many processes, the Administrators in the Curriculum Support Center need training to learn this complex system.
UNM School of Medicine Undergraduate Medical Education Administrators Modified
Approximately 4 hours
Instructor‐ Led
![Page 9: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Design Document OLIT : 543 Yvette Montoya
Course Goals Course Prequisites Indicate how the One45 system works and identify what
the benefits of using the system for curriculum
management
Acquire knowledge of how to successfully navigate
through the One45 system
Identify tasks and how to complete them
Develop skills by following sequential and logical
approaches to entering and managing information within
the system
The learner will need to have knowledge of:
Familiarity of UNM Medical School Curriculum Phase 1
through 4
Awareness of components of each Curricular Phase
Blocks associated with specific curricular phase and student
class year
Basic Computer Skills
Design Specifications Terminal Objective Enabling Objectives Domain Instructional
Strategies Instructional Activities
As a result of training the learner will identify major components of Phase I curriculum and interpret how the One 45 system will benefit administrators in managing the curriculum.
Summarize Phase I Curricular Map Recognize and recall structure of academic schedules for students in the first 2 years of medical schools Categorize different
Cognitive/ Affective
Lecture/ Discussion
Give an overview of UME Curriculum using an online diagram that lays out the structure of Phase I curriculum and illustrates major components Reference the diagram to distinguish key elements of student schedules Using a student academic schedules as a reference the instructor will describe
![Page 10: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Design Document OLIT : 543 Yvette Montoya
types of student activities within the curriculum Explain general information about the One45 system and how it is used for curriculum management List and discuss benefits of using the system Identify tasks that administrators will perform in the system
different types of student activities and how they are categorized Discussion and questioning from learners Provide information on One45 by giving an overview of system and reference general facts from the systems website Present benefits of using a curriculum management system and specify logic behind why Undergraduate Medical Education has implemented the system Give short description of each task
As a result of training the learner will effectively navigate in the One45 Curriculum information management system.
Review how to access and log into system Characterize major components of the One45 system Perform a search within for a specific session in an academic schedule Locate tools used to add
Cognitive Lecture/ Demonstration
Instructor will log into system and ask students to do the same Demonstrate how to access different academic schedules and class groups Indicate were to locate essential elements within the system such as sessions, sections, management tool and rolodexes
![Page 11: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Design Document OLIT : 543 Yvette Montoya
and modify content
As a result of the training learners follow sequential and logical approaches to enter and manage information in the One45 system
Add/edit sessions and sections into an academic schedule Add student groups to sessions/ sections Assign learners to student group Assign instructor to sessions Create student and instructor evaluation forms Assign/manage instructor evaluation packages Assign/manage student evaluation packages Assign/mange/report weekly assignments
Cognitive/ Psychomoter
Demonstration/Practice
Brief overview of instruction and expectations of learners Provide learners with user guides for completing each task Demonstrate onscreen how to complete each task by using the step by step guide
![Page 12: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Design Document OLIT : 543 Yvette Montoya
Distinguish various reporting options in the one45 system and know how to export raw data Run a report and export data to monitor sent evaluations
As a result of the training learner will identify ways to complete tasks using best practices and problem solve within the system
Give examples of how they were able to complete tasks smoothly Apply structured approaches and techniques to solving challenges encountered when using the system Propose alternative ways to solve issues faced within the system while performing tasks. Identify ways to increase productivity over time
Cognitive, Affective
Labs/Studios Ask learner to apply knowledge acquired by performing each tasks on their own with guidance from instructor and peers Provide immediate feedback to learners regarding their own performance Have learner analyze processes and have discussions on experience
![Page 13: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Evaluation Plan Yvette Montoya
OI&LS 543
Background
Based on the need for administrators in the UNM School of Medicine, Curriculum
Support Center (CSC), to gain critical skills required to navigate and manage
information within the “One45” web-based curricular management system, a formal
training has been proposed.
Purpose
The purpose of the “One45” evaluation report is to gather important information,
identify effective instructional strategies and determine if revisions are needed, in order
to make the training more effective. According to Don Clark, “Evaluation is the
systematic determination of merit, worth, and significance of a learning or training
process by comparing criteria against a set of standards.
Formative Evaluation
Morrison, Ross, and Kemp (2004) identify eight elements to every plan that are
modified for each evaluation. These elements direct the testing for all instructional
mediums, such as e-learning, classroom, and printed material. In my formative
evaluation I have followed these steps.
![Page 14: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Purpose:
“A formative evaluation (sometimes referred to as internal) is a method
for judging the worth of a program while the program activities are forming (in
progress). This part of the evaluation focuses on the process (Clark). This
formative evaluation will analyze the learning materials and review the process
of how the material is being delivered. This will help to determine if changes to
need be made in order to enhance the effectiveness of the course.
Audience:
Interim results will be shared with director of the Curriculum Support office, the
target recipients of the evaluation will be the Instructional Designer, Subject Matter
Expert (SME), and CSC staff.
Issues:
Are materials appropriate for learners’ skill level?
Was course material ie. user guides clear and easy to follow?
Are user guide steps sequenced appropriately?
Was the content accurate, up to date and comprehensible?
Did the training improve the learner’s awareness and attitude towards the One45
system?
Did the learners demonstrate ability to master the objectives based on
information provided in instruction?
Does any further information required to ensure the learners successfully
complete training?
![Page 15: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Resources:
Materials (User guides and design document)
Access to CSC office in order to conduct interviews with Subject Matter Expert
SME expert will be asked to fill out a questionnaire to assess, course materials,
user guides and instructional strategies
CSC director will be asked to fill out a questionnaire regarding long term goals of
training
In one-to-one interview Instructional Designer will discuss purpose, structure and
format of course with SME
Test Group, consists of 3 leaners who attend a pilot class
During test training information will be gathered by trainer on observation form
Before and after pilot class learners will be asked to fill out surveys that will
evaluate the instructional strategy, review course content and material and
assess if objectives have been met.
Data collection instruments (office observation form, interview questions,
surveys, self-evaluation forms)
Small classroom with projector, computer and 3 laptops with internet access
![Page 16: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Evidence
The data collected during the evaluation process will include
Qualitative feedback based on the instructional designer’s observations and
results from Subject Matter Expert questionnaire
Quantitative findings from learner survey gathered before and after pilot class.
Data-gathering Techniques:
Evaluator Target Instruments
Instructional Designer
Learner group
Gather information on
instructional methods and
course materials based on
question and answer
sessions and student
feedback collected by
periodically answering
specific questions given
throughout the training
Observation form
SME
CSC director
Analysis on course format
One to one interview
Questionnaires
![Page 17: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
and content, course
materials and instructional
strategies
Learner Group Obtain information on
learner satisfaction with
the One45 training and
materials provided to them
for further use.
Pre and Post Surveys
Analysis
The data will be collected and organized into a comprehensive evaluation report,
which will give an overview of the qualitative findings and outcome from the observation
from, one-to-one interview, questionnaire as well as the quantitative results from the
learner surveys. The data will summarized on a spreadsheet in order to analyze the
findings and address if the objectives for the training were met. Recommendations with
be based on the finding and address the any issues.
Reporting
A final formative evaluation report will be provided to the CSC director and
Subject Matter Expert and a presentation will be give an overview of the findings and
recommendations.
![Page 18: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Summative Evaluation
According to Don Clark, “A summative evaluation (sometimes referred to as
external) is a method of judging the worth of a program at the end of the
program activities (summation). The focus is on the outcome.” This summative
evaluation will occur after the implementation of the training and examine components
of instruction, learner’s attitudes and learner’s ability to perform tasks given the skills
acquired during the course.
Objectives
Based on Kirkpatrick’s Four Levels of Evaluation the four objectives for this
evaluation plan are as follows;
1. Reaction: Gather data about learners attitudes and feedback related to
instruction
2. Learning: Assess if learners are able to perform certain tasks referencing user
guides
3. Behavior: Determine if after training, learners use guides and find them
beneficial to complete daily tasks assigned in One45
4. Results: Determine if training has improved overall attitudes towards using the
system and helped streamline processes and increase productive
![Page 19: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Evidence:
The following information is needed in order to gather data and analysis the
effectiveness and impact of the One45 training:
Post learner opinion survey completed at end of training in order to measure
learners overall satisfaction with training.
Instructor’s observation checklist, students will be asked to complete a task that
will test a specific set of skills to assess performance
A post self-assessment will be sent to learners, preferably via email once
learners have had the opportunity to complete tasks in authentic situation
Evaluation Design
The evaluation design will reference the methodology used to assess the
overall effectiveness of the training as well as give the designer an indication of the
learner’s attitudes and abilities after the completion on the training. Success will be
based on data gathered from; post learning survey, which will capture learner’s attitudes
and feeling towards the instruction; observation checklist, which will allow the instructor
to observe learners skill set; and learner’s self-assessment which will provide insight on
if learning objectives were met and whether the training had successful organizational
outcomes. The evaluation will be implemented through written and email
communications. Learners will submit their data to instructor and via online tool, such as
survey monkey. Data will then be complied and analyzed. The finding will be reported to
Curriculum Support Center director and administration.
![Page 20: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Objective Process Measures Data Tool
Gather data about learners
attitudes and feedback
related to instruction
Learners perception of
effectiveness of training
Post Survey
Assess if learners are able
to perform certain tasks
referencing user guides
Knowledge/skills gained Observation Checklist
Determine if learners
reference user guides after
training and find the guides
a useful resource
Worksite implications Post Self-Assessment
Determine if training has
improved overall attitudes
towards using the system
and helped streamline
processes and increase
productive
Impact on organization Post Self-Assessment
![Page 21: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Data Collection
Both quantitative and qualitative data will be collected for the summative
evaluation. The data will provide effectiveness of instruction based on learner’s
attitudes, skill level and worksite competence.
Post Survey
Qualitative data on student opinions, attitudes, and confidence towards working
in the system will be gathered at end of training. This will help provide feedback on
student engagement with the material as well as skill level, comprehension and any
misconceptions.
Instructor Observation Checklist
Quantitative data will be collected by the instructor, using the checklist to assess
learner’s mastery skills and competence. Learners will be asked to complete a task
given user guide as a reference. This will give them the opportunity to test the
knowledge they’ve acquired. Instructor will base finding on rating scale provided in
checklist.
Post self-assessment
Both quantitative and qualitative data will be collect in the post self-assessment
survey. An online survey will be sent within one week of training, learners will be asked
to reflect on their learning experience. They will rate their ability to understand concepts
or techniques used in training, how they addressed any challenges faced and if they felt
![Page 22: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
a sense of completion to the learning process. Data will be collected and added to
database to analysis.
Analysis
Smith and Ragan (1999) recommend analyzing data in a fashion that will be easy for
the decision makers "to see how the instructional program affected the problem
presented in the needs assessment" (p. 360). Descriptive statistics (e.g. means, range,
frequency) or inferential statistics (differences between two instructional programs or
from pretest to posttest within the same program) may be required. After reviewing
objectives, qualitative information will be categorized by strengths, weaknesses, overall
experiences, recommendations, and outcome indicators. Quantitative data will be
studied by creating a mean or average for questions based on the ratings.
Reporting
The data will be provided to the CSC director and instructional designer, as an
indication of the learner’s attitudes and abilities after the completion on the training and
if intended outcomes have been fulfilled. The findings will be used to address any
issues and instructional designer will make changes based on feedback from CSC
director and data before instruction is implemented again.
![Page 23: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Confirmative Evaluation
“Historically, formative and summative evaluations formed the foundation for
judging a program in improving performance before, during and immediately after
program implementation. Confirmative evaluation expands traditional evaluation to
measure long term and expanded performance improvement. Additionally, it assists an
organization's change process by identifying areas where additional effort is necessary
and by confirming institutionalization of desired changes” (Dessinger & Mosley, 2004;
Mohrman & Cummings, 1983). This confirmative evaluation will collect, examine and
interpret data which focuses on long term outcomes of the One45 training and
determine if the training continues to improvement performance within the department.
Purpose
The purpose of the confirmative evaluation is to measure the long term
effectiveness of training and confirm the learner’s continuous performance abilities as
well as to help determine if any further improvements are needed.
Key Questions
The confirmative evaluation will assess the following questions;
Do learners feel the new processes and tools provided to them in the training
have enhanced their abilities to complete tasks in the One45 system?
Do the learners feel the instructional materials provided during the training are
still relevant when completing tasks within the system?
After training are learners continuously able to perform tasks correctly and
efficiently?
![Page 24: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Has learners understanding of the One45 system changed their attitudes and
values since the training?
Evidence
The following data must be complied in order to address key questions;
Qualitative data based on interviews with learners and small focus groups
Qualitative data based on Self-Performance Assessments
Evaluation Plan
The evaluation plan will assess the outcome of the training and makes a judgement
to determine the continued worth to the department. The overall impact will be based on
a learner-oriented approach and measured using the following methods
Conduct quarterly interviews with learners, supervisor and students who use the
system. Determine if learner’s skills and attitudes have improved since
implementation of training
Learners will take a self- performance assessment based on their performance
and views towards the One45 system
Data collection
There will be 2 methods for collecting the data;
Quantitative data via interviews with learner, supervisor, and students
Qualitative data obtained by the use of a rating scale to determine means and
standards which indicate learner’s success, views and understanding of the
system
![Page 25: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Analysis
Qualitative data will be compiled and analyzed based on the feedback provided
from interviews and small group discussions with the learners. Response will focus on
learner’s accomplishments, behavior and attitudes towards the system in order to
determine the effectiveness of the training program and if any further changes are
required.
Qualitative data will be collect and analyzed through a self-performance assessment
which will have the leaners rate their experiences in order to measure individual and
departmental performance improvement and the overall results of the training.
Reporting
Results collected and analyzed for this confirmative evaluation will identify the
successful aspects of the training related to individual and department performance as
well as understanding and attitudes towards the system and identify any needed
enhancements in the training program. The evaluation will be used as a continuous
improvement tool and will be administered periodically based on the need of the
department. Finding from the evaluation will be shared with department director,
managers and instructional designer.
![Page 26: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Resources
Smith, P. and Ragan, T. (1999). Instructional design (2nd ed.). New York: John Wiley &
Sons, Inc.
![Page 27: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Evaluation Samples Yvette Montoya OI&LS 543
Formative Evaluation - One on One Interview with SME
What outcomes should come from this training?
Are the objectives clear and do they match the desired outcomes?
Is the training presented in a logical sequence?
Is there a sufficient amount of time given for the instruction?
Are the materials provided appropriate for the skill level of learners?
Are the user guides clear, easy to follow and could used as a reference after the
training?
Does the online instruction enhance the learning experience?
Is there additional information that should be provided during the training?
Do you feel the training helps improve overall attitudes towards using the system?
![Page 28: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Summative Evaluation- Post Survey
Please take a moment to answer the following questions. Your comments are an important contribution as we design learning experiences to meet your professional needs.
What will you do differently in your practice as a result of this training?
What do you feel were the strengths of this training?
What do you feel you had difficulty with?
Are there any areas of this training that you feel could be improved?
What additional training-development education do you require?
![Page 29: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Confirmative Evaluation- Self- Performance Assessment
1. Please rate the following statements using a 1 through 5 scale where:
1 = Disagree Strongly 5 = Agree Strongly
____ What value does the one45 system have on enhancing your workflow process?
____ Have new processes and tools provided in the training improved your abilities to
complete tasks in the One45 system?
____ What is your comfort level with using the One45 system after the training?
____ Do your feel the instructional materials provided during the training are still
relevant when completing tasks within the system?
____ How much has your overall knowledge of the one45 system increased?
![Page 30: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Management Plan Yvette Montoya OI&LS 543
Environment
The environment includes the physical space and technology required to hold an effective
course. This training has the support of the Curriculum Support Center director and the University will
act as an institutional resource. Trainings will take place in classrooms and/or conference rooms on
campus. They will need to be reserved beforehand and have access to technical equipment such as a
projector and screen as well as access to the internet and tables with enough space for laptops. Laptops
for the learners can be checked out from the Educational Technology Services department. Another
option would be to reserve a computer lab if available in which learners will use desktops.
Resources
Personnel is a critical resource during the planning and implementation of the training. Having
sufficient staffing to provide essential support is imperative to the long term success of the training.
Once implemented we will have employee subject matter experts to add with the promotion,
preparation and delivery of training based on a rotation schedule. The instructional designer, CSC
director and managers will also have continuous roles in the evaluation process. Below is a responsibly
assignment matrix to designate responsible parties for key duties throughout the Instructional Design
process.
![Page 31: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Staffing
Tasks Individuals
Instructional Designer Subject Matter Expert CSC Director
Project Approval X
Analysis X X
Goals and Objectives X X X
Instructional Strategies X X
Evaluation Plan X X
Content development X X
Training preparation X X
Formative evaluation X X X
Training promotion and launch X X
Training delivery X
Summative evaluation X X X
Confirmative evaluation X X X
Revisions X X X
Budget
Budget needs such as technologies, staffing, equipment and physical space for this project will be
covered by the institution so costs will be keep to a minimal.
Cost Categories Cost
Time
Instructional Designer All business will take place during regular
Subject Matter Expert/Instructor hours and will not accrue additional costs
CSC Director
Materials
Training Handouts (Facilitator Guides, learner user guides, evaluations)
$150
Data analysis and reporting documents $100
Total $250
![Page 32: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Schedule
Time Topic Title
8:00am – 8:20am Welcome o Ice Breaker (10 minutes) o Review Objectives and goals of Training (5 minutes) o Review Agenda (5 minutes)
8:20am‐ 9:00am
Overview of UNM School of Medicine Phase I Curricular Map
o Review academic schedule of first and second year medical students (20 minutes)
o Identify each block and its timeline (10 minutes) o Review different types of student activities and how they
are categorized (10 minutes)
Foundations of Clinical Practice
PBL Tutorials
Clinical Skills
Continuity Clinic
Medical Ethics & Professionalism
Culture, Identity, Diversity
Pim Electives
9:00am‐ 9:20am Overview of One 45 system o General facts about the system and how it is used to manage and
track medical school curriculum (10 minutes) o Ways in which it One45 will benefit the Curriculum Support Center
(10 minutes)
9:20am‐ 10:00am (Each sections should take approx. 5 minutes)
Role of Administrators in One45 o Overview of types of tasks Administrators will be
performing in the system
Enter /review/edit academic schedules
Add sections
Add sessions
Confirm dates, times and materials
Create student groups
Add faculty to course
Create/send evaluation packages to students and faculty
Monitoring incomplete evaluations
Creating evaluation report
![Page 33: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
10:00am‐ 10:55am Navigating through the One45 system o How to log into One45 o Explore components of One45 system o Access Phase I academic schedule (30 minutes)
Management Tool
Curricular Year
Course/Block
Sessions and Sections
Tools
People (10 minutes)
Evaluations
Handouts/Links
Student Groups (10 minutes)
Group Families
People in group
Pick leaners Rolodexes (5 minutes)
Students
Faculty
10:55am‐ 12:10pm (each task should take between 7 minutes)
With the guidance of your instructor and peers demonstrate tasks with the use of job performance aids
o Add/edit sessions in academic schedules o Add sections to sessions o Add student groups to sessions and/or sections o Assign learners to student group o Assign facilitators to sessions and/or sections o Create student and instructor evaluation forms o Assign/manage/report instructor evaluation forms o Assign/manage/report student evaluation forms o Assign/mange/report weekly assignments
12:10pm‐ 12:30pm Small group discussion ‐ Once learners have performed tasks they will discuss their experience
o What went well o What do learners still have questions on or need help with o Any tips or best practices from instructor or peers o Fill out evaluations
![Page 34: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
The following chart is a timeline for milestones in the project
Milestones January March April May June August
Analysis
Planning meeting with CSC director and SME to identify needs and desired outcomes
x
Conduct analysis, establish goals x
Follow up meeting with SME and CSC director for approvals
x
Design & Development
Write objectives x
Determine instructional needs x
Course design x
Create instructional materials x
Establish and approve evaluation plan x
Implementation
Create Prototype x
Conduct Pilot x
Formative evaluation x
Make needed revisions x
Full implementation x
Summative evaluation x
Confirmative evaluation x
Deliverables
Analysis/Design
Analysis Plan
Design Plan
Management Plan
Evaluation Plan
Development/Implementation/Evaluation
Facilitator guide
Learner guide
Sample learner user guides
o Monitoring uncompleted evaluations
o Assigning students to groups
o Assigning faculty to groups
Sample Evaluation instruments
o Formative‐ Questionnaire
o Summative –Instructor observation checklist
o Confirmative‐ Learner self‐assessment
![Page 35: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
One45 Administrator Manual Yvette Montoya
OI&LS 543
Agenda
Time Topic Title 8:00am – 8:20am Welcome
o Ice Breaker o Review Objectives and goals of training o Review agenda
8:20am- 9:00am
Overview of UNM School of Medicine Phase I Curricular Map o Review academic schedule of first and second year medical
students o Identify each block and timeline o Review different types of student activities and how they are
categorized
9:00am- 9:20am Overview of One 45 system o General facts about the system and how it is used to manage and
track medical school curriculum o Ways in which it One45 will benefit the Curriculum Support Center
9:20am- 10:00am (Each sections should take approx. 5 minutes)
Role of Administrators in One45 o Overview of types of tasks Administrators will be performing in the
system
10:00am- 10:55am Navigating through the One45 system o How to log into One45 o Explore components of One45 system o Access Phase I academic schedule
10:55am- 12:10pm
With the guidance of your instructor and peers demonstrate tasks with the use of job performance aids
12:10pm- 12:30pm Small group discussion - Once learners have performed tasks they will discuss their experience
![Page 36: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
![Page 37: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
![Page 38: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
One45 Fact Sheet
One45 software system is an online curricular management, scheduling and evaluation
tool.
Core Benefits
Improve workflow efficiency
Enhance communications between several entities
Centralized student and faulty information
Centralized schedules
Track teaching efforts of your faculty
Track curriculum inventory for reporting purposes
How will you use the system?
Create & manage schedules
Manage users
Schedule faculty and learners
Set up evaluation workflow
Sent and track evaluations
Generate and produce evaluation reports
![Page 39: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
One45 User Guides
To view your schedule:
1. Click the Schedules tab. Click on Management Tool. Your curriculum schedule opens in a
new window.
Your schedule is organized into portfolios that appear as folders. Each portfolio relates to a year in
the program.
Within each portfolio the courses that the students are taking for the academic year are listed. To
see the courses within a portfolio, click on the small arrow next to the porfolio. Your courses appear
as boxes beneath the portfolio.
Courses in one45 are broken down into session and sections. The sessions are used for multiple components of a course (i.e. lectures and labs). To view the sessions within a course, click on the arrow next to the course. Each session appears as a flower. These sessions can be broken down further into sections. Each section refers to a specific event which you can schedule the time, date and room number. You are able to view the sections by clicking on the arrow next to the session.
![Page 40: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
To Assign Students in One45
1. Click on Schedules
![Page 41: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
2. Click Management Tool
![Page 42: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
3. Click ➤ Arrow on appropriate Year and Block
![Page 43: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
4. Click on pencil and sort by date
5. Find date of activity you want to enter faculty to. Click arrow to find group.
6. Click pencil on group. Select tools.
![Page 44: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
7. Select People
8. Click Learner. Click Add
![Page 45: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
9. In Families, click on appropriate year. Then groups will populate, click on appropriate group list. Next students will then populate in far right box.
10. Click on “Add learners as:” tab at bottom on screen and change to student or appropriate assignment.
![Page 46: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
11. Click on the learners name (to add multiple learners hold “Control” button and click on multiple students). Name will populate in Individuals box (to remove a student from this list double click on the student name). Click Save when group is complete.
![Page 47: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
To Assign Faculty in One45
1. Click on Schedules
![Page 48: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
2. Click Management Tool
![Page 49: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
3. Click ➤ Arrow on appropriate Year and Block
![Page 50: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
4. Click on pencil and sort by date
5. Find date of activity you want to enter faculty to. Click arrow to find sessions.
6. Click pencil on group. Select tools.
![Page 51: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
7. Select People
8. Click Facilitators. Click Add
![Page 52: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
9. Click in search box and type facilitator last name, click search button
![Page 53: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
10. Double click on faculty name (name will appear in box below). Go to Add facilitator drop down and change to appropriate title and save.
11. To add another faculty click the add button
![Page 54: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Monitoring uncompleted evaluations
1.) Click on “Sendouts” Tab 2.) Click on “Custom Search” under “Evaluation Tracking”
![Page 55: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
3.) Click on last “all or Form” drop down list under “find forms with the following criteria”
4.) Select appropriate form 5.) Choose appropriate time period (From, To) Under “date options”
then click “Export to excel” button at bottom of screen
![Page 56: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
6.) Click downloaded Excel spreadsheet.
![Page 57: One45 Curriculum Management System Training for Medical ... · an overview of the system. The materials created for this course, by the instructional designer will be based on internet](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022062606/5fe0de679068001c546e33cd/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
7.) Delete unneeded columns, keep Moment name (for tutor evaluations only), Evaluator Name, Target Name, Status
8.) Highlight Status column then add filter 9.) Click the drop down arrow on status column and sort by A-Z. Those
with Outstanding or Saved, not completed will need to be contacted.