opening pandora’s box - university of pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “pandora's box...

69
OPENING PANDORA’S BOX Identifying risk of neurodevelopmental impairment in preterm infants Jessie van Dyk Neonatologist, St Joseph’s Health Centre University of Toronto

Upload: others

Post on 01-Apr-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

OPENING PANDORA’S BOX

Identifying risk of neurodevelopmental impairment in preterm infants

Jessie van Dyk Neonatologist, St Joseph’s Health Centre University of Toronto

Page 2: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Conflictofinterest

Nothingtodeclare…

Page 3: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

“Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the bottom of Pandora's box. Something wonderful.

Hope.”

Lisa Marie Rice,

Breaking Danger

Page 4: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

OUTLINE•  Whyarethesebabiesatrisk?•  Whydoweneedtoidentifythoseatrisk?

•  Dowehavetoolsavailabletous?•  Arewedoingagoodjobatpresent?

Page 5: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Background

Page 6: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

TheBurdenofPrematurity–WHOstatistics

•  ±15millionbabiesborn<37completedweeksGA/yr•  Thisnumberisrising•  Pretermbirthcomplicationsareleadingcauseofdeathamongchildren<5yearsofage~1milliondeathsin2015

•  75%ofthesedeathscouldbepreventedwithcurrent,cost-effectiveinterventions

•  Across184countries,therateofpretermbirthrangesfrom5%to18%ofbabiesborn

•  InCanada:onlyroughly8%oflivebirthsperyear,butmajorcosttoCanadianHealthcaresystem~CAD587.1millionperyearin2014

Page 7: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Thepreterminfant•  Magnitudeappreciatedbygrossinspectionofbrain:

-13wks:fetalcortexsmooth,nosulciorgyri

-26wks:developmentofcentral&lateralsulcus,rudimentaryinsula

-Gyralandsulcalformationincompleteevenat34wks

Page 8: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Etiology

Dysmaturation•  Graymatterarchitecturedistorted•  Whitematterconnectivityaltered•  Cerebellumunder-developed•  SensorysystemdisorganizationSecondarycorticaldysplasiaVolpeJJ.Braininjuryinpreterminfants:acomplexamalgamofdestructiveanddevelopmentaldisturbances.JLancet2009;8:110-124.AlywardGP.NeurodevelopmentalOutcomesofInfantsBornPrematurely.JDevBehavPediatr2005;26:427-440.

Page 9: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

PrematureBirth•  Majorityofpretermsfreeofmajormorbidity•  Greatersurvivalatdiminishinggestationalages

•  Majormorbidityrelativelystableat6-25%–  Cerebralpalsy–  Visionimpairment–  Hearingimpairment–  Cognitiveimpairment

•  50-70%mayhave‘minormorbidities’thataffectschoolperformance

Page 10: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

‘MinorMorbidities’•  Include:

– Motordelays– Executivedysfunction– Attentiondeficitdisorder– Languagedelays– Learningdisabilities&IQ– Auditorydys-synchrony– Corticalvisualimpairment– Visualmotordifficulties– Behaviorproblems*– Socialemotionaldysregulation*

Page 11: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

‘Pretermphenotype’?

•  “PrematuritySyndrome”firstreportedbyDrillienin1939

Page 12: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

BehavioralphenotypeDescribesaconstellationofbehavioral,cognitive,motor,andsocialstrengths&difficultiesobservedinapopulationwithacommonbiologicaldisorderPrematuresurvivorshaveaphenotypeCommonbiologicaldisorder=alterationsinbraindevelopmentHodappRM,FidlerDJ.SpecialEducationandGenetics:Connectionsforthe21stCentury.TheJSpecEduc1999;33:130-137.BackSA,MillerSP.BrainInjuryinPrematureNeonates:APrimaryCerebralDysmaturationDisorder?AnnNeurol2014:75;469-86.ChurchPT,LutherM,AsztalosE.Theperfectstorm:minormorbiditiesinthepretermsurvivor.CurrPediatrRev,2012;8:142-151

Page 13: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

BehaviorProblems

•  MultiplestudieshavelookedatbehavioraloutcomeofprematurityVohrB,MsallME,SeminPerinatol1997;21:202-220MarlowN,HennessyEM,BracewellMA,WolkeD.Pediatrics2007;120:793-803.HilleETM,denOudenAL,SaigalSetal.J.Lancet2001;357:1641-1643.

•  Overall,documentedincreased:–  ADHD– Withdrawnsocially–  Anxiety–  Depression–  Dysregulation

Page 14: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

AttentionDeficitHyperactivityDisorder(ADHD)

•  2.5-4timesgreaterriskinpreterms•  Inattentionmostfrequentlycited•  Nostudieslookingatstimulantsandpreterminfants

•  Inconsistentdataonwhetherpersistsintoadulthood

Page 15: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

ExecutiveFunction

•  Mentalprocessesthatdevelopto:–  enableself-regulation–  problemsolving–  goaldirectedactions

•  Internalconductor

Page 16: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

ExecutiveDysfunction•  VictorianInfantCollaborativeStudyGroup

–  AndersonPJ,DoyleLWetal.Pediatrics2004;114:50-57

•  ELBW’s2-3xmorelikelytohaveexecutivedysfunction-↓GAà↑difficulty

•  Globaldysfunction,notonesetpattern

•  Difficultywith:-Startingnewactivities-Organizinginformation-Planningasequenceofactivities-Transitioningfromonetasktoother

Page 17: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

SocialEmotional

Socialemotionaldysregulation

•  Increasinglyreported

•  Childrenare…emotionallylabilehavedifficultywith

transitionslowfrustrationtolerancepoorpersistencetotask

Internalizingconditions•  Lessrisktakingdueto:

–  Underlyinganxiety–  Greaterparentalmonitoring–  Diminishedpeerrelationships

•  Morelikelytoliveathomeasyoungadults

HackM,FlanneryDJ,SchluchterM,CartarL,BorawskiE,KleinN.NEJM2002;346:149-157.

Page 18: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

AcademicOutcome

•  Lesslikelytoattend4yearcollege,lowerscoresonstandardizedassessmentsofeducationalachievement

•  Unemploymentsame–  Jobincomehoweverinverselyrelatedtogestationalage

•  HackM.JDevBehavPediatr2009;30:460-470.•  HackM,FlanneryDJ,SchluchterM,CartarL,BorawskiE,KleinN.NEJM2002;346:149-157.

Page 19: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

AutismSpectrumDisorder–DSMV

Deficitsinsocialcommunicationandsocialinteraction•  Socialemotionalreciprocity•  Nonverbalcommunication•  Difficultymaking,sustaining,orunderstandingrelationships

Restrictedrepetitivepatternsofbehavior•  Stereotypedmovementpatterns•  Inflexibleadherencetoroutines•  Fixatedinterestswithabnormalintensityandfocus

Page 20: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

AutismSpectrumDisorder&theprem

•  ManystudiesevaluatingriskfactorsforASD•  Fewstudiesevaluatingprevalenceofautismamidst

prematuresurvivors

•  Signsmaypresentinearlyinfancy,caninclude:-abnormalsocialinteractions-atypicalcommunication-restrictedinterests/play-splinterskillsmaydevelop-sensoryhypo/hypersensitivity

Page 21: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

•  103enrolledinfants– MRIattermCAobtained

•  Birthweight<1500g

•  Followupdata:– ModifiedChecklistforAutisminToddlers(M-CHAT)

–  VinelandAdaptiveBehaviorScale(VABS)–  ChildBehaviorChecklist(CBCL)

Page 22: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

PositiveScreeningforAutisminEx-PretermInfantsLimperopoulos,Pediatrics2008

•  26%positiveonM-CHAT•  70%ofthosepositivefoundtofail2criticalitems•  Abnormalscorescorrelatedhighlywith:-InternalizingbehavioralproblemsonCBCL-SocializationandcommunicationdeficitsontheVinelandScales.•  Factorssignificantlyassociatedwithabnormalscreen:-LowerbirthweightorGA-Malegender-Chorioamnionitis-Acuteintrapartumhemorrhage-Illnessseverityonadmission-AbnormalMRI

Page 23: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

PositiveScreeningonM-CHATinELGAN’sKubanetal,J.Pediatrics,2009

•  21%screenedpositiveonM-CHAT

•  16%positivewithoutmotor,vision,orhearingimpairment

•  10%positivewithoutco-existingimpairment*

Page 24: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

CerebellarHemorrhage(CH)&ASD

Limperopoulos,Pediatrics2007

•  Retrospective,casecontrolled(isolatedCH,lessthan32wk)controlsmatchedforGA,gender,yearofbirth

•  MRItoconfirmdiagnosis•  60infantseligible,51survivedtostudy•  CHvscontrols:positiveASDscreener37%vs0%,internalizingbehavioralproblems34%vs9%

Page 25: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Latepreterminfant

Page 26: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Latepreterminfant•  Brainweightat34weeksonly65%oftermbrain

•  Gyral&sulcalformationincomplete

•  Corticalvolumeincreases50%between34-40weeks

•  25%ofcerebellardevelopmentafter34weeksGA

•  Synaptogenesis&dendriticarborizationincomplete

Page 27: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Specificlong-termissues

Medical

Cognition

Motordeficits

Behaviour

Page 28: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Earlyoutcomedata

•  124LPTvs33terminfants•  AlbertaInfantMotorscale(AIMS)at6mo&GriffithsMental

DevelopmentScales(GMDS)at12mochronologicalage•  LPTperformedsignificantlyloweronallsubscalesofGMDS•  Similarscoreswhencorrectedforprematurity

Page 29: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

•  LPTinfantsvstermcontrols•  BayleyScalesofInfantDevelopmentShortForm-ResearchEdition(BSF-R)at24monthschronologicalage

•  LPThadhigheroddsofmental(OR1.52)orphysical(OR1.56)developmentaldelay

Page 30: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

24monthoutcomes

Comparedtoterminfants,increasedoddsofhaving:

•  Moreseverementaldelay(52%)•  Mildermentaldevelopmentaldelay(43%)•  Severepsychomotordevelopmentaldelay(43%)

•  Milderpsychomotordevelopmentaldelay(58%)

Page 31: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Comparedtoterminfants:•  Riskfordevelopmentaldelayordisability36%higher•  Riskforsuspensioninkindergarten19%higher•  Riskfordisabilityinpre-kindergarten(3-4years)•  Riskforexceptionalstudenteducation

10-13%higher•  Riskforretentioninkindergarten

Page 32: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

At6years•  Latepretermvstermcontrolsmatched•  InadjustedmodelsLPTbirthassociatedwithincreasedriskof-FullscaleIQ<85(aOR2.35,95%CI1.20-4.61)-PerformanceIQ<85(aOR2.04,95%CI1.09-3.82)àLPTbirthassociatedwithlowerIQat6years,independentof

maternalIQ,residentialsettingandsociodemographics

•  TalgeNMetal.Late-Pretermbirthanditsassociationwithcognitiveandsocioemotionaloutcomesat6yearsofage.Pediatrics

2010;126:1124-1131

Page 33: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Threefoldincreasedriskfordevelopingcerebralpalsy in LPT infants compared with terminfants (RR 3.1, 95% confidence interval2.3-4.2)

Page 34: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

ChildrenbornLPT>3timesaslikelyasterminfantstobediagnosedwithcerebralpalsy(hazardratio

3.39,95%CI2.54-4.52)

Page 35: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Other•  Executivefunctiondeficitsespeciallyrelatedtocomplex

memorytasks(Baronetal,2012)•  Higherlevelsofinternalizingandattentionproblems(Van

Baaretal,2009;Talgeetal,2010)•  At3,5&8yrs20%ofLPTscoredinclinicallysignificant

rangeonCBCLvsexpected10%(Grayetal,2004)•  AmongLPT’s,thoseadmittedtoNICUhadhigherscoreson

CBCLat3yrs,especiallyforaggressivebehaviorandexternalizingproblems(Boylanetal,2014)

Page 36: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Social

•  Slightlyhigherrisktoreceivesocialsecuritybenefitsearlyadulthood(RR1.15,95%CI1.12-1.17)(Teuneetal,2011)

•  HelsinkiBirthCohortStudy:comparedwiththosebornatterm,LPTinfantsweremorelikelyto…

-bemanualworkers-haveabasicoruppersecondaryleveleducation-belongtothelowestthirdbasedonincome-bedownwardlymobileintheircareer-haveloweroccupationsthantheirfathers(Heinonenatal,

2013)

•  Lesslikelytocompletehighschool(RR0.96),lesslikelytocompleteuniversity(OR0.87)(Teuneetal,2011)

Page 37: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Whytrytodeterminerisk?

Page 38: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Earlyintervention

•  Optimaltiming<12-15monthsCA•  Maximalplasticityimmediatelyaftercompletionofneuralmigrationàdendriticoutgrowth&synapticformationmostactive

•  Mixedevidence•  Improvefunction

Page 39: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Earlyintervention•  Improvedsocialandcognitiveabilities•  Improvedschoolcompletion•  Improvedworkforceproductivity•  Reducedcrimerates•  Reducedteenagepregnancy

•  ‘Theearlierinlifetheseinterventionswereintroduced,thehighertheeconomicandsocialreturns’(Heckman,‘Schools,SkillsandSynapses’2010)

Page 40: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Earlyintervention

•  ReviewofEIprogramsforinfantsathigh-riskofdevelopmentaldelay:improvedmotorandcognitivedevelopmentwithspecificdevelopmentalprograms(Blauw-Hospersetal2007)

•  Cochranereview:improvedcognitiveoutcomesininfancy,whichwassustainedatpreschoolage,notsustainedatschoolage-heterogeneitybetweenstudieswassignificant(Spittleetal2015)

Page 41: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Sohowdowedeciderisk?

Page 42: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Clinicalfactors?•  Illnessseverity?•  Knownclinicalpredictors:-Preterm:BPD,ROP,braininjury,infection,NEC-Latepreterm:firstbaby,poorfeeding•  Notaperfecttool–Schmidtetalcautioned‘limitedclinicalusefulnessoftheindividualriskestimates’–  53%ofcohortwhodevelopedBPDàfavorable18monthoutcome

–  26%ofinfantswithoutBPDàdied/developedneurosensoryimpairment

Page 43: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

NeuroimagingSignificantpredictivevalueinspecificpopulations:egtermHIEPretermpopulation:•  Onlycertainmarkers(egwhitematterinjury)predictiveof

laterneurodevelopmentoutcome(mostcommonlyCP)•  Dependentonspecialisttrainingandexpertise•  Interpretfindingsinconjunctionwithotherclinical

information•  MajorityoffindingsonMRINOTsuccessfullylinkedto

long-termimpairment•  Upto15%ofchildrenwithCP:‘normal’MRI•  Greatstressforparentsofpreterminfants(‘severely

traumatizing’,Pearce2012)

Page 44: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Screeningtools

Page 45: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

•  Noperfecttoolexists•  GeneralMovements(GMs),MRI,headultrasound,MovementAssessmentofInfants(MAI),neurologicalexam

•  NormalGMassessment:-veryhighnegativepredictivevalueof95-100%-negativelikelihoodratioof0•  AbnormalGMs:Pooledsensitivity98%,specificity91%,diagnosticoddsratio(DOR)453(95%CI18-11495)forpredictingcerebralpalsy(CP)at2yearsofage

Page 46: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

PredictivevalueofneurodevelopmentalassessmentsusedtopredictCPinyoungchildren

Test Number of studies reviewed (n)

Number of participants (n)

Range of cerebral palsy prevalence (%)

Sensitivity [% (95% CI)] or range

Specificity [% (95% CI)] or range

Neurological assessment

4 1190 6.3-52.4 88 (55, 97) 87 (57, 97)

Cranial ultrasound (CUS)

10 2827 5.0-59.0 74 (63, 83) 92 (81, 96)

Brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)

3 702 11.5-22.8 86-100% 89-97%

Assessments of general movements (GM)

6 1358 6.3-52.4 98 (74, 100) 91 (83, 93)

Page 47: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

GeneralMovements

•  ‘Seriesofgrossmovementsofvariablespeedandamplitudewhichinvolveallpartsofbody’

Prechtl&Nolte,1984•  Presentfrom9-10weekspost-menstrualage(PMA)

•  Ataround4monthscorrectedageareslowlyreplacedbymoregoal-directedmovements

Page 48: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Developmentalprogressionandage-specificcharacteristicsofgeneralmovements

Postmenstrualage(weeks)28303234363840424446485052545658

PretermGMsExtremelyvariablemovementsthatincludefrequentpelvictiltsandtrunkmovements(±28weeksto36-38weeksPMA)

WrithingGMsMovementsarenowmoreforcefulandslower,withlesspelvisandtrunkinvolvement(36-38weeksto46-52weeksPMA)

FidgetyGMsAcontinuousflowofsmall,elegantmovementsnowoccurringconstantly,irregularlyalloverthebody,withhead,trunkandlimbsparticipatingequally.Thesemaybesuperimposedonlarger,fastermovements(46-52weeksto54-58weeksPMA)

Page 49: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

AssessmentofQualityofGeneralMovements

classificationcharacteristics

•  Complexity-spatialvariationofmovements

•  Variability-temporalvariationofmovements

•  Fluency-smoothqualityofmovement

‘VariationisfundamentalfeatureoffunctionofhealthyearlyCNS…stereotypyhall-markofearlybraindysfunction…’Touwen1993,Hadders-Algra2000

Page 50: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

ScoringQualityofgeneralmovementonoverall

impressionIstherecomplexity?Istherevariability?

Isitfluent?

Dichotomousclassification:

NormalGMs

Richincomplexity,variability(&fluency)

AbnormalGMs

Lackingincomplexity,variability(&fluency)

Page 51: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

AvailableevidenceReliabilityoftheAQGMSpittleetal,2008

Characteristic Cohen’skappa(κ) Interpretation(accordingtoLandis&Koch)

Inter-raterreliability 1.00 Perfectagreementbetweenraters

Intra-raterreliability 0.84–0.92 Near-perfectagreement

Goodreliabilityevenwithminimaltraining

Page 52: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

•  Preterminfantsborn<30weeksGA•  GMsassessedduringwrithing&fidgetyphases•  ‘Normal’vs.‘abnormal’•  Motor,language&cognitivefunction•  Strongestassociation:GMqualityat3mocorrectedageàCPat2&4yrs

•  Associationwithcognitiveoutcomeslessrobustbutpromising…deservesfurtherresearch

•  Benefitofserialassessments?

Page 53: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Otherassociations

•  Minorneurologicaldeficits•  Autismspectrumdisorder?

Page 54: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

OURSTUDYAt6weeksCAAt3monthsCAAt18-24monthsCA(±6weeks)(±6weeks)(±12weeks)(WrithingGMphase)(FidgetyGMphase)

NormalAQGM

NormalAQGM

AbnormalAQGM

AbnormalAQGM

NormalAQGM

AbnormalAQGM

Outcomesassessed:

• BSID-III• Comprehensiveneurological

examinationwithdiagnosisofCP

• Presenceofvisualorhearingimpairment

Page 55: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

NEURODEVELOPMENTALOUTCOMECATEGORIZATION

Diagnosticcriteria Normalormildimpairment

Moderateimpairment Severeimpairment

Cognitive BSID-IIIcognitivecompositescore>85

BSID-IIIcognitivecompositescore70-85

BSID-IIIcognitivecompositescore<70

Motor BSID-IIImotorcompositescore>85orNodiagnosisofCP

BSID-IIImotorcompositescore70-85orDiagnosisofCPwithGMFCSlevel1-2

BSID-IIImotorcompositescore<70orDiagnosisofCPwithGMFCSlevel3-5

Language BSID-IIIlanguagecompositescore>85

BSID-IIIlanguagecompositescore70-85

BSID-IIIlanguagecompositescore<70

Vision Mildvisualimpairment(visualacuitybetterthan20/200inbotheyes)

Bilateralblindness(visualacuity<20/200instrongesteye)

Bilateralblindnessthatcannotbecorrected

Hearing Mildhearingloss(notrequiringamplification/injustoneear)

Bilateralhearingloss(requiringamplification)

Severetoprofoundhearingimpairment(nofunctionalhearingwithamplification)

Page 56: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Table12:UnadjustedandadjustedoddsratioforassociationofAQGMtrajectories,maternalandneonatalcharacteristics,short-termneonatalmorbiditiesandNDI

UnadjustedOR(95%CI)

AdjustedOR(95%CI)

TrajectoryA-AvsN-NA-AvsN-AA-AvsA-NA-NvsN-NA-NvsN-AN-AvsN-N

2.5(1.2,5.3)2.4(1.1,5.4)2.2(1.1,4.4)1.1(0.5,2.8)1.1(0.4,2.8)1.0(0.4,2.8)

1.7(0.8,3.6)2.0(0.9,4.6)2.5(1.2,5.1)0.7(0.2,1.7)0.8(0.3,2.2)0.8(0.3,2.4)

MaternalcharacteristicsMaternalageatdelivery(years)Maternaleducation(post-secondary)Homelanguage(notEnglish)Parentalcircumstance(singleparenthousehold)

1.0(0.95,1.0)0.5(0.2,1.1)1.1(0.6,2.0)1.8(0.8,3.9)

NeonatalcharacteristicsGender(male)Gestationalage(weeks)Birthweight(grams)Modeofdelivery(Caesariansection)Multiplebirth

2.1(1.3,3.3)0.8(0.7,0.9)0.9(0.8,0.9)1.0(0.6,1.6)1.2(0.7,2.0)

2.3(1.4,4.0)

0.9(0.8,1.0)

Short-termneonatalmorbiditiesPresenceofBPD±receivedpostnatalsteroidsPresenceofintraventricularhemorrhagePresenceofretinopathyofprematurityPresenceofnecrotizingenterocolitisPresenceofPDArequiringligation

3.8(2.2,6.8)2.2(1.1,4.3)1.8(0.2,14.8)1.2(0.4,3.5)5.8(2.3,15.0)

2.5(1.3,4.8)1.5(0.7,3.0)

3.8(1.4,10.5)

Page 57: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Table14:AssociationbetweenAQGMscoreat6weeks(writhingphase)and3months(fidgetyphase)andmotorimpairment

UnadjustedOR

(95%CI)

AdjustedORfor6weeksCA(95%CI)

AdjustedORfor3monthsCA(95%CI)

AQGMscoreAvsNat6weeksCAAvsNat3monthsCA

2.1(0.9,4.6)2.9(1.3,6.3)

1.8(0.7,4.5)

3.4(1.4,7.9)

MaternalcharacteristicsMaternalageatdelivery(years)Maternaleducation(post-secondary)Homelanguage(notEnglish)Parentalcircumstance(singleparenthousehold)

1.0(0.9,1.0)0.6(0.2,1.6)1.7(0.8,3.4)1.7(0.7,4.1)

NeonatalcharacteristicsGender(male)Gestationalage(weeks)Birthweight(grams)Modeofdelivery(Caesariansection)Multiplebirth

2.0(1.0,3.7)0.8(0.7,0.9)0.9(0.8,1.0)0.5(0.3,1.0)0.8(0.4,1.5)

1.8(0.9,3.7)

1.0(0.9,1.2)

2.1(1.0,4.3)

1.0(0.9,1.2)

Short-termneonatalmorbiditiesPresenceofBPD±receivedpostnatalsteroidsPresenceofintraventricularhemorrhagePresenceofretinopathyofprematurityPresenceofnecrotizingenterocolitisPresenceofPDArequiringligation

3.1(1.6,5.9)8.9(4.2,18.8)7.1(0.9,58.7)0.3(0.04,2.4)4.4(1.7,11.2)

2.3(1.0,5.2)7.8(3.6,17.1)

3.7(1.3,10.6)

3.6(1.2,10.5)8.3(3.7,18.5)

3.6(1.2,10.5)

Page 58: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

HammersmithInfantNeurologicalExamination(HINE)

•  RecommendedinInternationalClinicalPracticeEarlyDiagnosisofCerebralPalsyGuidelines,particularlyinsituationswherethemostpredictivetools(GeneralMovementsandMRI)notabletobeused

•  Infants2-24monthsofage•  AHINEscore<57at3months96%predictiveofcerebral

palsy(sensitivity96%;specificity87%)•  >5monthsage(corrected)ithas90%predictive

accuracyfordetectingtheriskofcerebralpalsy

Page 59: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

So…dowehaveaclearanswerthen?

•  Notreally…•  Inthiscase:lessisn’tmore•  Combineclinicaldata+imaging+reliablescreeningtoolsappropriateforthechosenpopulation

•  Futureresearch:clinicalpredictionrulesforspecificneonatalpopulations?

Page 60: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the
Page 61: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Parentalmentalhealth

Page 62: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the
Page 63: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Schoolreadiness

Page 64: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the
Page 65: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

KnowledgeofEducatorsEducators(n=138)lessknowledgeableaboutoutcomesofprematurity•  75%awareand/orknowledgeableaboutADHD/ADD•  62.5%awareand/orknowledgeableaboutlearningdisabilities•  60.6%awareand/orknowledgeableaboutASD•  24.8%awareand/orknowledgeableaboutdevelopmental

outcomesofprematurityFactorsthatenhancededucators’knowledge•  Havingexperiencewithachildbornpreterm•  Havingachildwithanindividualizededucationplan•  AdditionaleducatorqualificationsChurchPT,CavanaghA,LeeSK,ShahV.AcademicChallengesforthePretermInfant:Educators’Knowledge,Attitudes,andPerceptionsofIdentifiedBarriers.Prelimdata.

Page 66: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the
Page 67: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

SowhatamIsupposedtotakeawayfromthis?

•  Haveastructuredapproachtofollowingprematureinfants

•  Usealltoolsavailabletoyou–MRI/US,GMA,astructuredneurologicalexam(HINE)

•  Ifconcerned(youORparents)àREFERforintervention

•  Educateparentsonrisksandexpectations,empowerthemtoadvocate

•  Educateteacherswheneverpossible!•  Don’tforgettoassessparentalwellness

Page 68: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Resources•  EdinburghPostnatalDepressionScalehttp://med.stanford.edu/content/dam/sm/ppc/documents/DBP/EDPS_text_added.pdf

•  ProvincialCouncilforMaternalandChildHealth(PCMCH)http://www.pcmch.on.ca/ontario-neonatal-follow-program/

•  SunnybrookHealthSciencesCentreNeonatalFollow-upClinicwebsite–parentandproviderresourceshttp://followup.sunnybrook.ca/

•  Neoknowledgehttp://www.neoknowledge.org/

Page 69: OPENING PANDORA’S BOX - University of Pretoria 2019... · 2019. 3. 21. · “Pandora's box had been opened and monsters had come out. But there had been something hidden at the

Thankyou!

[email protected]