opinions, opinions
DESCRIPTION
This is a presentation given to the faculty of the School of Arts and Letters at the College of St. Scholastica on newspaper coverage of the opening of the Building for Women in DuluthTRANSCRIPT
Opinions, Opinions!:
The Opening of the Building for Women on the Editorial Pages
Overview of the Presentation
Explanation of research process Contextualization of larger project Theoretical presuppositions Methodological Considerations Analysis and Conclusions
Have Project Will Travel
Postmodern Assumptions Mumby describes postmodern research
as contingent and contextual Subjectivity of researcher shapes
projects and processes Inductive Approach
Existing Relationship to BFW Later, artifacts to theory
The Overall Data Pool
Excluded Materials Interviews with
Welsh and Rocco Donor lists Grant narratives Letters to donors Articles in small,
local publications
Included Materials News Stories
included in DNT Opinion Pieces in
DNT Advertisements in
DNT
The Heterosexual Matrix
In Gender Trouble, Butler defines the heterosexual matrix as “that grid of cultural intelligibility through which bodies, genders, and desires are naturalized” premised upon “a stable sex expressed through stable gender [. . .] that is oppositionally and hierarchically defined through the practice of heterosexuality” (151)
. . . Across the disciplines
Scholars in various disciplines theorize the heterosexual matrix Sociology of sport Art Education International Women’s Studies Leadership Studies Disability Studies
Foci in Comm Studies
Performance Blood donation Pride festivals Coming Out Bildungsroman Political activism
Heteronormativity Will & Grace bad girls Next Best Thing Media coverage of
Brandon Teena’s murder
The Analytical Goal
In Bodies that Matter, Butler contents that the goal of using the heterosexual matrix analytically is to question the law of binaries which maintain “sexes” as different and opposite (11).
Generative Criticism
Inductive Interesting or puzzling artifact or case Artifact or case leads to theory
Clustering Key Words
World Views Key words in context describe a world
view
Manifest Content
Bishop Schweitz’s resignation from United Way Board
United Way and Neutrality on Abortion Programs versus Agencies Building for Women and Abortion
Potential Key Words
Abortion Pedophilia Mothering as work Women and
children in poverty Fetus infantalized Women
infantalized
Adoption Lesbianism Secrecy Arrogance Hierarchy Their women Intrinsic value of
women
“Their Women”
Texts written by or quoting pro-life women
These women often tokenized in discourse
12 artifacts written by pro-life women
Women Infantilizing Fetuses
Julie Woodley, “It was essential for women to dispose of an unwanted ‘fetus’—our ‘creed’ never allowed us to call it a child” (13 Feb. p. 14A)
Julie Frost, “They [the United Way] need to reconsider this because killing unborn children is truly a shame of the human race” (27 Dec., p. 5A)
Jan Pilon: First to Speak
"The three organizations are the YWCA and the Program for Aid to Victims of Sexual Assault, both United Way agencies, plus Women's Health Center, Duluth's only abortion clinic."
"A friend of mine, one who has generously supported many good causes, was approached for a gift by one of the partners. She was not told of the coalition and was shocked to learn later that her money would benefit (directly or indirectly) a clinic that performs more than 1000 abortions each year."
Conclusions
Many authors infantilize fetus by calling them “babies” or “children.”
Many writers infantilize women by assuming they make uninformed choices.
Many pro-choice authors claim men have only a supporting roles in pregnancy decisions.
Conclusions Continued
Pro-Life authors compare Bishop Schweitz regularly to Martin Luther King, Jr.
Many writers employ quasi ad hominen arguments Women as selfish Catholic priests as pedophiles
Secrecy
All writers define secrecy and neutrality in terms of personal interest
If a writer knew about the BFW it was not a secret; if they didn’t, it was a secret.
Neutrality
Pro-Life Authors: “How many of us, do we suppose, seek
shelter behind that safe and conventient word” (Elaine Strand, 25 Jan., 5A)
Pro-Choice Authors: “By trying to remain neutral United Way is
accused of being pro-choice” JoAnne Axtell, 14 Jan., 5A)