outline

19.04.2023 1www.helsinki.fi/yliopisto

EXCELLENCE FOR SOCIETYINTERNATIONAL EVALUATION OF RESEARCH AND DOCTORAL TRAINING AT THE

UNIVERSITY OF HELSINKI2005-2010

Vice-Rector Johanna Björkroth7 May 2012

219.04.2023Osasto / Henkilön nimi / Esityksen nimi

Outline

• Role of Steering group

• Risk taking endeavour

• Evaluation aspects

• Success of RCs in evaluation

• Rewards

Steering group (2010-2012) and its role

Vice-Rector Johanna Björkroth (pj)

Professor Marja Airaksinen (vpj)

Chief information specialist Maria Forsman

Professor Arto Mustajoki

Univ. lecturer Kirsi Pyhältö

Director, Academic Affairs Ossi Tuomi

Doctoral candidate Jussi Vauhkonen

Some critical questions discussed

• Participation categories

• Researcher Community – in evaluation – in future

• Voluntary participation

• Performance profiles related to success and rewarding

• Usefulness of data and reports

• Bibliometrics

• Societal impact

Evaluation aspects in Panels’ feedback

• Scientific quality • Scientific significance• Societal impact• Processes of leadership and management• Collaboration• Innovativeness• Future significance

•

Material given to the Panels

• E-forms

• List of publications (TUHAT)

• List of other scientific activities (TUHAT)

• CWTS/Leiden bibliometric analyses • RCs

• Entire University

• HULib bibliometric analyses for the RCs

• Doctoral Survey

• Background information• Statistics about the UH and the Finnish HE

www.helsinki.fi/yliopisto 19.04.2023 7

Participating Researcher Communities(page161)

Cat 1 Cutting Edge

2 Near Cutt. E.

3 Except

4 Innov. opening

5 Soc. impact

Total RCs

Total Persons

Bio 13 3 5 4 2 27 1345

Med 12 4 0 5 2 23 1170

Nat 11 3 0 6 2 22 1084

Hum 10 6 6 4 2 28 1085

Soc 11 8 5 6 6 36 1173

RCs 57 24 16 25 14 136

Pers 3045 1047 507 714 544 5857


Mean of scores (1-5) 3.96

• Natural Sciences 4.16

• Biological, Agr. and Vet. Scs 4.02

• Humanities 4.02

• Medicine, Biomed and Health Scs 4.00

• Social Scs 3.72

• (Page 168)

Quality and focus of research



• Humanities 4.30

• Medicine, biomed and Health Scs 4.09

• Natural Scs 4.02


• Social Scs 3.86

• (Page 168)

Doctoral training



• Humanities 4.18

• Medicine, biomed and Health. Scs 4.17

• Biological, Agr. and Vet Scs 4.02

• Social Scs 3.94


• (Page 168)

Societal impact



• Medicine, biomed and Health Scs 4.22


• Social Scs 4.08

• Humanities 4.07


(Page 168)

Collaboration

1219.04.2023

He

lDe

vB

io

Ce

llMo

lBio

l

Co

E-M

iFo

Sa

PL

US

VM

PS

Ev

oD

ev

o

EG

RU

Co

E M

RG

Co

E_

VIR

RE

S

PH

YT

OP

AT

H

ME

MB

RE

C

MIC

RO

MU

SG

EN

VIT

RI

ViiG

en

PE

AT

LA

ND

ER

S

SB

&B

Ve

tSc

i

BIO

SY

ST

Fo

od

Nu

tri

SU

VA

LU

E

EN

IGM

A

SS

A

INB

IOS

PH

AB

IO

FR

ES

H

LE

GM

ILK

AR

C

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

Panel of Biological, Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences (RCs 27)

Quality of research Doctoral training Societal impact Cooperation Category fitness

Distributions of numeric evaluation – Panel:Biological, Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences(page 67)

1319.04.2023

Co

mp

Dis

Ge

n

CS

B

Ind

iViD

rug

Ne

uro

ion

tro

ph

CA

NB

IO

Ne

uro

n

P-M

olm

ed

Pro

Lip

ids

PU

RE

InfB

io

PD

BD

Sk

in a

nd

alle

rgy

MN

RP

DE

CO

DE

/DE

CO

DA

De

Po

Na

De

nta

l

NE

UR

OM

ED

Le

ga

l Pro

t

Wo

me

n's

He

alth

Ca

rdio

Me

d

PA

RT

ICL

E

MS

Gro

up

ID-T

M

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

Panel of Medicine, Biomedicine and Health Sciences


Distributions of numeric evaluation – Panel: Medicine, Biomedicine and Health Sciences(page84)

1419.04.2023

AL

KO

AT

M

AN

DY

BA

YE

S

INV

LIC

Pa

Co

GIM

ME

C

LT

CC

NO

DE

S

AS

P

MA

TE

NA

HU

BI

EC

O

MA

C

Co

E C

MS

HL

G

BN

CT

MI

HY

RL

Me

dC

he

mB

io

SO

FT

SY

S

CA

RB

ON

14

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

Panel of Natural Sciences


Distributions of numeric evaluation – Panel:Natural Sciences (page 105)

1519.04.2023

BA

UL

T

VA

RIE

NG

AM

NE

LD

HF

TA

RE

LS

OC

PP

MP

CS

TT

FC

CM

VG

RE

LD

IAL

CE

CH

Inte

rac

tion

Mu

sS

ig

SH

C

Tra

ST

RC

SP

Ge

nd

er

Stu

die

s

Co

Co

La

C

LF

P

AR

CH

-HU

HIS

T

ILL

C

LM

PS

LM

S

CIT

A

GL

W

AH

CI

AR

T

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

Panel of Humanities


Distributions of numeric evaluation – Panel:Humanities (page125)

1619.04.2023

CP

HS

DE

PS

Y

PE

WE

EC

I

CN

C

CR

AD

LE

EA

T

Ed

Psy

chH

E

Po

sPu

s

TS

EM

FC

RE

ES

AG

EC

ON

La

w

PP

H

SO

CE

-DG

I

EN

FIF

O

So

cio

po

lis

DY

NA

SO

BIC

GE

NU

RC

MS

ER

HE

LP

S

KU

FE

No

rdS

oc

SB

II

SC

A

ST

S

CE

A

ME

TE

OR

I

TR

AN

SR

UR

BA

N

Sig

Me

ME

CO

L

ST

RU

TS

I

Cu

lCa

p

KU

MU

DE

VE

RE

LE

So

cSta

ts

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

Panel of Social Sciences


Distributions of numeric evaluation – Panel:Social Sciences (page146)


Total 10.47 million euro – division based on the performance of research and doctoral training

• Rewards will be addressed according to the numerical scores of RCs in participation categories

• The highest 30 percent in each category will be rewarded

• Score level of success is unique in each category

• Amount of reward will be determined according to the number of PIs in successful RCs

• The success criteria is determined by the first four evaluation questions

Monetary rewards for the years 2013 - 2016


Category 1: Cutting edge (page 345)

Category 1: Cutting edge Field of Sc RC Responsible person Euro Bio, Agr, Vet. Scs HelDevBio Thesleff, Irma 330000

CellMolBiol Lappalainen, Pekka 210000

CoE-MiFoSaPLUS Palva, Airi 390000

VMPS Palva, Tapio 360000

Humanities VARIENG Nevalainen, Terttu 150000

AMNE Kajava, Mika 360000

LDHFTA Janhunen, Juha 450000

Med., Biomed., Health Scs CompDisGen Kaprio, Jaakko 510000

CSB Aaltonen, Lauri 120000

IndiViDrug Backman, Janne 180000

CANBIO Alitalo, Kari 540000

Neuron Rauvala, Heikki 360000

Natural Scs ALKO Ukkonen, Esko 510000

ATM Kulmala, Markku 420000

Social Scs CPHS Martikainen, Pekka 270000

DEPSY Räikkönen, Katri 120000

PEWE Keltikangas-Järvinen, Liisa 210000

ECI Koskenniemi, Martti 150000


Category 2: Close to Cutting Edge (page 346)

Category 2: Close to Cutting edge Bio, Agr, Vet. Scs MEMBREC Gahmberg, Carl 210000

Humanities CECH Lauha, Aila 90000

CMVG Anttonen, Pertti 90000

Medic, Biomed, health Scs PDBD Tuominen, Raimo 150000

Natural Scs GIMMEC Pellikka, Petri 210000

NODES Kangasharju, Jussi 180000

Social Scs EAT Kultti, Klaus 180000

TSEM Lanne, Markku 120000


Category 3: Exceptional(page 346)

Category 3: Exceptional Bio, Agr, Vet. Scs EvoDevo Jernvall, Jukka 150000

PEATLANDERS Vasander, Harri 270000

Humanities BAULT Koskenniemi, Kimmo 390000 CoCoLaC Havu, Eva 420000 ARCH-HU Lavento, Mika 120000


Category 4: Innovative opening (page 347)

Category 4: Innovative opening Bio, Agr, Vet. Scs MUSGEN Järvelä, Irma 60000

ViiGen Helariutta, Yrjö 210000 Humanities RELDIAL Ruokanen, Miikka 120000 SHC Heinämaa, Sara 180000 RCSP Heikkilä, Markku 240000 Medic, Biomed, health Scs Neuroiontroph Saarma, Mart 210000 ProLipids Ikonen, Elina 120000 Social Scs EdPsychHE Lindblom-Ylänne, Sari 300000


Category 5: Societal impact (page 347)

Category 5: Societal impact

Humanities RELSOC Saarinen, Risto 240000 TraST Vehmas-Lehto, Inkeri 270000 Medic, Biomed, health Scs P-Molmed Kallioniemi, Olli 210000 Natural Scs BAYES Kuikka, Sakari 90000


• MORE – Helsinki

• Has been noted by other universities

• Produced a valuable set of data

• Initiated discussion about collaboration

• Produced first time bibliometric raports

Conclusion

Thank you

All reports are available in electronic form:

http://www.helsinki.fi/julkaisut/halvin_julkaisut.shtml

University-level paperback report can be ordered:

https://elomake.helsinki.fi/lomakkeet/35495/lomake.html

outline

Documents

health scs4

social scs4

natural scs4

vet scs4

social scs3

natural scs3

natural sciences page

health sciencespage84