pam northern chapter...

31
21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 1 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994 2 1 2 3 4 Reasons for energy saving UBBL Clause 38A Fire safety of Insulation material Fire compartment CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Upload: others

Post on 03-Dec-2019

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

1

PAM Northern Chapter Seminar17 June 2017

1CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

2

1

2

3

4

Reasons for energy saving

UBBL Clause 38A

Fire safety of Insulation

material

Fire compartment

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 2: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

2

3

1REASON for ENERGY SAVING

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

4

We spend up to 90% of our time indoorsLiving, working, learning and playing

PERCENTAGE OF TOTAL HOURS OF THE DAY

WOMENMEN

64%

2%

16%

3%

1%6% 8%

71%1%

11%

4%

1%

5%7%

Home

Weekend house

Working place or school

Other people's home

Restaurant, café or pub,

Travelling

Other unspecifieslocation

Source: 2004 European commission , Eurostat survey , How Europeans spend their time in everyday life of women and men*-aged 20-74

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Source : st.gobain

Page 3: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

3

Thermal ComfortSource : www.laeven.net

5

UBBL

Source : malaymailonline

Source buildingonpurpose.org

Cost Saving

Reduce Carbon Footprint

Source : climate generation

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

6

2UBBL CLAUSE

38 A

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 4: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

4

7

� UBBL Clause 38A 1.New or renovated non-residential buildings with air-conditioned space exceeding 4,000 m2S shall be :

� a. designed to meet the requirements of MS 1525 with regards to Overall Thermal transfer Value (OTTV) and Roof Thermal Transfer value (RTTV)

� b. provided with an energy Management system

UBBL CLAUSE 38A

� UBBL Clause 38A 2The roof for all buildings (residential and non residential) shall not have a thermal transmittance (U Value) greater than :

� a. 0.4 W/m2K for light weight roof ( under 50 kg/m2)

� b. 0.6 W/m2K for heavy weight roof ( over 50 kg/m2)

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

8

MS 1525 : RTTV

� Roof Thermal Transfer Value (RTTV)The design parameter that indicates the solar thermal load transmitted through the roof where the roof is provided with skylight.

5.5.1 Maximum thermal transmittance U Value of roof

Roof Weight Group Maximum U Value W/m2KLight (< 50 kg/m2) 0.40Heavy (> 50 kg/m2) 0.60

5.5.3 If the roof area is shaded from direct solar radiation by ventilated external shading device e.g. double ventilated roof, the roof U value may be increased by 50%.

5.5.4 If reflective treatments are used on external roof surface where solar reflectivity is ≥ 0.7 and the treated surface is free from algae growth, the U value may be increased by 50%.

5.6.2 For roof with skylights, the maximum recommended RTTV is 25 W/m2 in addition to the requirement of 5.5.1

Only applies for air-conditioned building

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 5: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

5

9

MS 1525 : RTTV

� Roof Thermal Transfer Value (RTTV)The design parameter that indicates the solar thermal load transmitted through the roof where the roof is provided with skylight.

5.5.1 Maximum thermal transmittance U Value of roof

Roof Weight Group Maximum U Value W/m2KLight (< 50 kg/m2) 0.40Heavy (> 50 kg/m2) 0.60

5.5.3 If the roof area is shaded from direct solar radiation by ventilated external shading device e.g. double ventilated roof, the roof U value may be increased by 50%.

5.5.4 If reflective treatments are used on external roof surface where solar reflectivity is ≥ 0.7 and the treated surface is free from algae growth, the U value may be increased by 50%.

5.6.2 For roof with skylights, the maximum recommended RTTV is 25 W/m2 in addition to the requirement of 5.5.1

Only applies for air-conditioned building

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

10

HEAT LOSS or HEAT GAIN

� HEAT LOSS� Cold Climate� Highlands

Source : smart home vision

� HEAT GAIN� Tropical / Hot Climate� Lowlands

Source : smart home vision

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 6: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

6

11

RTTV & U VALUE

� Roof Assembly/Build-up� Type of materials of roof assembly/build up� Thickness� Air Space� Water absorption of materials� Fire safety of materials

CRITERIA

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

12

ROOF ASSEMBLY / BUILD-UP

ROOFBUILD-UP

Surface deck material : type & thickness

Bottom deck material : type & thickness

Inner Core

Insulation material : type & thickness

Air space (if applicable)

Foil material (if any) : type & thickness

Vapour control layer (if any) : type & thickness

Other materials (if any) : type & thickness

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 7: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

7

13

� Thermal Conductivity, K value λThermal conductivity is the amount of energy (heat flow) that passes a material with thickness of 1 m, size of 1 m2 and temperature difference on both sides of the material of 10Cλ K value measured in W/mK

� Thermal Transmittance, U valueThermal transmittance is the rate of transfer of heat (in watt) through 1 m2 of material or structure divided by the difference in temperature across the material or structureU value = 1 / R – measured in W/m2K

� Thermal Resistance, R valueThermal resistance is the measurement of temperature difference, at steady state, between 2 defined surfaces of a material or structure through a unit area, in which the material resist heat flow.R value = t / λ (t / K) - measured in m2K/W where t is thickness

THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY (K value)THERMAL RESISTANCE (R value)THERMAL TRANSMITTANCE (U value)

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

14

� Thermal Conductivity (K value), W/mKK value (λ)Lower the better

� Thermal Transmittance (U value), W/m2KU value = 1 ÷ Thermal Resistance (1 / R value)Lower the better

� Thermal Resistance (R value), m2K/WR value = thickness ÷ thermal conductivity (t / K value)Higher the better

THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY (K value)THERMAL RESISTANCE (R value)THERMAL TRANSMITTANCE (U value)

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 8: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

8

15

� Change in product > change in R value & U Value

PIR Foam 50 mm, K value is 0.022 W/mKR value = 0.05 ÷ 0.022 = 2.273 m2K/WU Value = 1 ÷ 2.273 = 0.44 W/m2K Mineral wool 50 mm, K value is 0.034 W/mK

R value = 0.05 ÷ 0.034 = 1.470 m2K/WU Value = 1 ÷ 1.470 = 0.68 W/m2K

� Compression changes the thicknessChange in thickness > change in R value & U Value

Mineral wool K value is 0.034 W/mK for 50 mm (0.05 m)R value = 0.05 ÷ 0.034 = 1.47 m2K/WU Value = 1 ÷ 1.47 = 0.68 W/m2K Compression > Thickness 50 mm > 20 mm

R value = 0.02 ÷ 0.034 = 0.588 m2K/WU Value = 1 ÷ 0.588 = 1.70 W/m2K

THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY (K value)THERMAL RESISTANCE (R value)THERMAL TRANSMITTANCE (U value)

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

16

� Moisture or leakage caused insulation materials to be saturated with water> Change in thermal conductivity> Change in R value & U Value

Leakage – water K value is 0.60 W/mK

R value = 0.05 ÷ 0.60 = 0.083 m2K/WU Value = 1 ÷ 0.083 = 12.05 W/m2K

Mineral wool K value is 0.036 W/mKThickness 50 mm (0.05 m)R value = 0.05 ÷ 0.034 = 1.47 m2K/WU Value = 1 ÷ 1.47 = 0.68 W/m2K

THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY (K value)THERMAL RESISTANCE (R value)THERMAL TRANSMITTANCE (U value)

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 9: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

9

17

EFFECT of WATER ABSORPTION

Degeneration of roof framing

High water absorption insulation material

• Corrode the steel framing

– rust can breed tetanus & inhalation of rust particles can cause

lung injury.

• Cause timber frame to decay

– promote growth of fungi and mold.

Growth of fungi and mould

• High water absorption insulation material would promote growth of fungi and mold

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

18

5. Thermal Resistance5.2 Surface Resistance

1. Surface resistances apply to surfaces in contact with air.

2. Surfaces in contact with another material has no surface resistance

Surface Resistance Direction of Heat Flow

m2K/W Upwards Horizontal Downwards

RSE 0.04 0.04 0.04

RSI 0.10 0.10 0.17

ISO 6946

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 10: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

10

19

5. Thermal Resistance

5.3 Thermal Resistance of Air Layers

Values apply to air layer which :

• Bounded by 2 faces that are effectively parallel and perpendicular to the direction of heat flow and that have

emissivity not less than 0.8.

• Has thickness (in the direction of heat flow) of less than 0.1 times of each one of the other 2 dimensions and not

greater than 0.3 m

• Has no air interchange with the internal environment.

Thickness of air layerThermal Resistance m2K/W

Direction of Heat Flow

mm Upwards Horizontal Downwards

0

5

7

10

15

25

50

100

300

0.00

0.11

0.13

0.15

0.16

0.16

0.16

0.16

0.16

0.00

0.11

0.13

0.15

0.17

0.18

0.18

0.18

0.18

0.00

0.11

0.13

0.15

0.17

0.19

0.21

0.22

0.23

ISO 6946

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

20

5. Thermal Resistance5.4 Thermal Resistance of Unheated Spaces

Roof spaces – for a roof structure consisting of a flat, uninsulated ceiling and pitch roof, the roof space

may be regarded as if it were a thermally homogeneous layer with a thermal resistance as given in the

following table.

Characteristic of RoofRU

m2K/W

Tiled roof with no felt, boards or similar 0.06

Sheeted roof or tiled roof with felt or boards or similar under the

tiles0.2

As above but with aluminium cladding or other low emissivity

surface at underside of roof0.3

Roof lined with boards and felt 0.3

NOTE : The values in this table include thermal resistance of ventilated space and of the

(pitched) rood construction. They exclude the external surface resistance RSE.

ISO 6946

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 11: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

11

21

BRE 443

3.10. Reflective Foil Products

3.10.1 Bubble sheet with aluminium foil facingThe thermal resistance (R value) of bubble sheet with foil facings consists of the resistance of the bubble sheet

and the resistance of air spaces on either one side of it or both sides where the resistance of air space(s) takes

account of the emissivity of the surfaces.

3.10.2 Multi-foil insulationMulti-foil insulation comprises products that consists of several layers of foil separated by other materials.

They are intended for applications with an air space on either side and the overall thermal performance includes

the effect of low emissivity surfaces facing these air spaces

4.8. Airspace Resistance

4.8.2 Unventilated airspaces, low emissivity surface

Low emissivity surface (e.g. aluminium foil) has no effect on the U value if not adjacent to an air space in the

construction.

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

22

BRE 443

For tiled faced products, with the foil adjacent to an unventilated airspace of

width at least 25 mm, the thermal resistance of the airspace may be taken as :

Low emissivity surface, heat flow horizontal (wall) 0.44 m2K/W

Low emissivity surface, heat flow upwards (roof) 0.34 m2K/W

Low emissivity surface, heat flow downwards (floor) 0.50 m2K/W

4.8. Airspace Resistance

4.8.2 Unventilated airspaces, low emissivity surface

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 12: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

12

23

Unhindered air space

Aluminium foil Reflective facing down

HEAT

Unhindered air space

Aluminium foil

Reflective facing UP

HEAT

Minimise Heat Gain

Increase Heat Gain

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

24

Unhindered space

Aluminium foileffective

Aluminium foilNOT effective

Metal Roof

Aluminium foilNOT effective

ROCKWOOL Insulation

Metal Roof

BRE 443 4.8.2 Unventilated airspaces, low emissivity surface

Low emissivity surface (e.g. aluminium foil) has no effect on the U value if not adjacent to an air space in the construction.

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 13: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

13

25

Aluminium foil

50 mm air space

50 mm air space

HEAT

Thermocouple

Aluminium foil

HEAT

Thermocouple

A test report indicated that configuration/build up of

50 mm air gap + aluminium foil + 50 mm air gap

would achieve a R value of 2.294 m2K/W.

Different build up would NOT achieve this R value.

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

26

Aluminium foil

Metal Roof

100 mm air spaceAluminium foil

Metal Roof

50 mm air space

50 mm air space

A test report build up to achieve a

R value of 2.294 m2K/W.

Different build up would NOT achieve

R value of 2.294 m2K/W

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 14: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

14

27

Bubble foil

HEAT

Thermocouple

Bubble foil

40 mm air space

50 mm air space

HEAT

Thermocouple

50 mm air space

Bubble foil

A test report indicated that configuration/build up of 40 mm air gap +

bubble foil + 50 mm air gap + bubble foil + 50 mm air gap would

achieve a R value of 3.659 m2K/W.

Different build up would NOT achieve this R value.

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

28

Bubble foil

Metal Roof

Bubble foil

Metal Roof

BRE 443

3.10.2 Multi-foil insulationMulti-foil insulation comprises products that consists of several layers of foil separated by other

materials.

They are intended for applications with an air space on either side and the overall thermal performance

includes the effect of low emissivity surfaces facing these air spaces

A test report build up to achieve a

R value of 3.659 m2K/W.

Different build up would NOT achieve

R value of 3.659 m2K/W

Bubble foil

Metal Roof

Bubble foil

40 mm air space

50 mm air space

50 mm air space

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 15: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

15

29

THERMAL BRIDGING

Thermal Bridging is an area of an object or structure which has a significantly higher heat transfer than the surrounding materials resulting in an overall reduction in thermal insulation of the object or structure.

DISCONTINUE / GAPS

PENETRATION

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

30

DECOUPLED ASSEMBLY TO MINIMISE THERMAL BRIDGING

Thermal Bridging has an effect of up to 20% of the R value and U value of metal deck roofing

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 16: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

16

31

CALCULATION OF ROOF U VALUE

ROOFBUILD-UP

Surface Deck

Bottom Deck

Inner Core

RSE External Surface Resistance

RSI Internal Surface Resistance

R6 value of insulation material

R4 value of air space (if applicable)

R1 value of surface deck material

R7 value of bottom deck material

R2 value of foil material (if applicable)

R3 value of vapour control layer (if applicable)

R5 value of other material (if applicable)

1UTOTAL =

RSE + R1 + R2 + R3 + RQ + RSI

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

32

UBBL Clause 38A 2 - 0.60 W/m2K

RC FLAT ROOF – THERMAL PERFORMANCE U VALUE

NOT

INSULATEDINSULATED

K valueW/mK

R valuem2K/W

R valuem2K/W

External Surface Resistance RSE 0.040 0.040

Screed 25 mm 1.15 0.022 0.022

Weather proofing layer 0.23 0.022 0.022

PIR Foam 30 mm 0.022 1.364

Vapour control layer (bitumen) 5 mm 0.23 0.022 0.022

Reinforced Concrete 1% steel 150 mm 2.3 0.065 0.065

Internal Surface Resistance RSI 0.170 0.170

TOTAL 0.341 1.705

U value W/m2K 2.93 0.59

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 17: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

17

33

RC FLAT ROOF – THERMAL PERFORMANCE U VALUE

NOT

INSULATEDINSULATED

K valueW/mK

R valuem2K/W

R valuem2K/W

External Surface Resistance RSE 0.040 0.040

Screed 25 mm 1.15 0.022 0.022

Fibre Cement board 9.0 mm 0.30 0.030

ROCKWOOL 160 kg/m3 50 mm 0.034 1.470

Vapour control layer (bitumen) 0.23 0.022 0.022

Reinforced Concrete 1% steel 150 mm 2.3 0.065 0.065

Internal Surface Resistance RSI 0.170 0.170

TOTAL 0.319 1.789

U value W/m2K 3.13 0.55

UBBL Clause 38A 2 - 0.60 W/m2K

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

34

RC FLAT ROOF – THERMAL PERFORMANCE U VALUE

NOT

INSULATEDINSULATED

K valueW/mK

R valuem2K/W

R valuem2K/W

External Surface Resistance RSE 0.040 0.040

Screed 25 mm 1.15 0.022 0.022

PIR Foam 30 mm 0.022 1.364

Vapour control layer (bitumen) 5 mm 0.23 0.022 0.022

Reinforced Concrete 1% steel 125 mm 2.3 0.054 0.054

Lysaght Bondek 1.0 mm 45 0.000 0.000

Internal Surface Resistance RSI 0.170 0.170

TOTAL 0.308 1.672

U value W/m2K 3.25 0.60

UBBL Clause 38A 2 - 0.60 W/m2K

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 18: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

18

35

FLAT ROOF – THERMAL PERFORMANCE U VALUE

NOT

INSULATEDINSULATED

K valueW/mK

R valuem2K/W

R valuem2K/W

External Surface Resistance RSE 0.040 0.040

TPO Membrane 1.52 mm 0.029 0.052

Fibre Cement board 9.0 mm 0.30 0.03

ROCKWOOL 160 kg/m3 100 mm 0.034 2.941

Bluescope Lysaght 0.52 m TCT 45 0.000 0.000

Internal Surface Resistance RSI 0.170 0.170

TOTAL 0.210 3.151

U value W/m2K 4.76 0.32

UBBL Clause 38A 2 - 0.40 W/m2K

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

36

RC FLAT ROOF – THERMAL PERFORMANCE U VALUE

NOT

INSULATEDINSULATED

K valueW/mK

R valuem2K/W

R valuem2K/W

External Surface Resistance RSE 0.040 0.040

Screed 25 mm 1.15 0.022 0.022

Weather Proofing Layer 0.23 0.022 0.022

Reinforced Concrete 1% steel 150 mm 2.3 0.065 0.065

ROCKWOOL 60kg/m3 50 mm 0.034 1.471

Internal Surface Resistance RSI 0.170 0.170

TOTAL 0.319 1.790

U value W/m2K 3.13 0.56

UBBL Clause 38A 2 - 0.60 W/m2K

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 19: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

19

NOT

INSULATEDINSULATED

THERMAL

BRIDGE

K valueW/mK

R valuem2K/W

R valuem2K/W

External Surface Resistance RSE 0.04 0.04

Lysaght Standing Seam 0.8 mm TCT 45.3 0.00 0.00

ROCKWOOL 40kg/m3 75 mm

Rafter 1200 mm centres0.036 n.a 2.083

Internal Surface Resistance RSI 0.17 0.17

TOTAL 0.210 2.293 2.02

U value W/m2K 4.76 0.44 0.50

37

SINGLE SKIN METAL DECK - THERMAL PERFORMANCE U VALUE

UBBL Clause 38A 2 - 0.40 W/m2K

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

NOT

INSULATEDINSULATED

K valueW/mK

R valuem2K/W

R valuem2K/W

External Surface Resistance RSE 0.04 0.04

Lysaght Standing Seam 0.6 mm TCT 45.3 0.00 0.00

ROCKWOOL 40kg/m3 100 mm

Rafter 1200 mm centres0.036 n.a 2.778

Internal Surface Resistance RSI 0.17 0.17

TOTAL 0.210 2.99

U value W/m2K 4.76 0.33

38

SINGLE SKIN METAL DECK - THERMAL PERFORMANCE U VALUE

THERMAL

BRIDGE

R valuem2K/W

2.62

0.38

UBBL Clause 38A 2 - 0.40 W/m2K

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 20: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

20

39

3FIRE SAFETY OF INSULATION MATEIALS

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

40

Insipient/Ignition – combustion begins

Growth – flaming combustion of an item, spread of fire

Flashover – condition in compartment changes to combustion/ignition of all exposed surface

Fully developed – all items/materials in compartment are alighted, maximum heat release

Decay – gradual decrease of fire due to decrease in fuel

Source : FirePoint Joseph M Ellington

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 21: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

21

41

Test Standards

BS 476Fire test on building materials and structures

Part 4Non-combustibility test for materials preheated to 750OC

In UBBL – often mentioned about non-combustible materials

For homogeneous materials

E.g. fibre cement board, PU/PIR foam, glasswool, stonewool

REACTION TO FIRE

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

42

Test Standards

BS 476

Fire test on building materials and structures

Part 6

Method of test for fire propagation for products

Part 7

Method of test to determine the classification of surface spread of flame.

Current Situation - Class “O”

For non-homogeneous materials

E.g. plasterboard, aluminium foil, bubble foil

Can be easily achieved

E.g. add in metal layer, fire retardant coating, etc

REACTION TO FIRE

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 22: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

22

43

REACTION TO FIRETest standards

EN 13501 Part 1Fire classification of construction products and building elements.

Classification using test data from reaction to fire tests.

EN ISO 1182Non-combustibility test preheated to 750OC

EN ISO 1716Determination of the burning behaviour using a radiant heat source (gross heat of combustion –

calorific value)

EN ISO 11925 part 2Ignitability of building products subjected to direct impingement of flame

Part 2 single flame source test edge flame attack 30s exposure no flame spread >150 mm

vertically from point of application of test flame within 60s from time of application

EN 13823Building products excluding floorings exposed to the thermal attack by a single burning item.

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

44

TEST STANDARDS

Difference betweenBS 476 Part 4 v EN 13501 Part 1

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 23: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

23

45

EN 13501-1 Classification & Calorific Potential (Fuel Load)

TYPECalorific potential

kJ/kg

En 13501-1

Classification

Petrol 42,000 F

Aluminium/Bubble Foil (LDPE backing) 40,3001 E-F

Expanded Polystyrene (EPS) 40,1802 E-F

Extruded Polystyrene (XPS) 40,1802 E-F

Polyisocyanurate (PIR) Foam 24,0001 C-D

Polyurethane (PU) Foam 23,0402 D-E

Glasswool <1,000 A1-A2

ROCKWOOL <1,000 A1

1 2005 study – US Department of Transportation & Federal Aviation Administration2 2014 study – Heat Flux Effect of common thermal insulation materials

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

46

Asphyxiant Gases

Make you suffocate

Causes incapacitation

Carbon Monoxide

Carbon Dioxide

Hydrogen Cyanide

Irritant Gases

Irritate eyes, nose and throat

Hydrogen Chloride

Nitrogen Oxides

Formalydehyde

Phenol, etc

Why Should we be concern about smoke?Type of Gases

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 24: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

24

47

FIRE TOXICITY

2011 study – Centre For Fire and Hazard Science : University of Central Lanchasire

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

48

75% of all fire deaths are caused by smoke inhalationSource: Hall, Jr. John R. NFPA Fire Analysis & Research, Quincy, MA. “Burns, Toxic Gases,

and other Hazards”.

Approximately 57% of people killed in fires are not in the room of the

fire’s originSource: NFPA Fire Protection Handbook, 18th Ed. Table 1-1P. Pg. 1-15.

Visibility - 47% of survivors caught in a fire could not see more than 3.5mSource: NFPA Fire Protection Handbook, 18th Ed. Table 8-1P. Pg. 8-17

Smoke travels 36m-146m per minute under fire conditionsSource: Estimate based upon ceiling jet velocity calculations for typical ceiling heights and

heat release rates.

Why Should we be concern about smoke?

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 25: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

25

49

4FIRE COMPARTMENT

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

50

PART DESCRIPTION

VII BY LAWS 133 – 224 : Fire Requirement

VIII By Laws 225 – 253 A : Fire Detection, Fire Alarm and Fire Extinguishment

UBBL PART VII - VIII

BY LAWS DESCRIPTION

133 Interpretation

134 Designation of purpose Group

136 Provision of compartment walls & compartment floors

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 26: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

26

51

UBBL PART VII - FIRE REQUIREMENT

FIFTH SCHEDULE designation of purpose group & dimension of buildings & compartments By laws 134 & 136

PURPOSE GROUP BUILDING HEIGHT FLOOR AREA m2 CUBIC CAPACITY m3

Part I – Buildings other than single storey buildings

I Small Residential N/A N/A N/A

II Institutional Any height 2,000 No limit

III Other residential Not exceeding 28 m 3,000 8,500

Exceeding 28 m 2,000 5,500

IV Office N/A N/A N/A

V SHOP Any height 2,000 7,000

VI FACTORY Not exceeding 28 m No limit 28,000

Exceeding 28 m 2,000 5,500

VII Place of Assembly N/A N/A N/A

VIII Storage & General Not exceeding 28 m No limit 21,000

Exceeding 28 m 1,000 No limit

Part II – Single storey buildings

II Institutional Any height 3,000 No limit

III Other residential Any height 3,000 No limit

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

52

NINTH SCHEDULE minimum periods of fire resistance for elements of structure By laws 142(3), 147, 158(1), 162, 213, 216(2)

PURPOSE GROUP BUILDING HEIGHT FLOOR AREA m2 CUBIC CAPACITY m3 GRD/UPPER STOREY BASEMENT

Part I – Buildings other than single storey buildings

I Small Residential N/A N/A N/A up to 1 hr up to 1-½ hr

II Institutional Any height 2,000 No limit up to 1-½ hrs up to 2 hrs

III Other residential Not exceeding 28 m 3,000 8,500 1 hr 1-½ hrs

Exceeding 28 m 2,000 5,500 1-½ hrs 2 hrs

IV Office N/A N/A N/A up to 2 hrs up to 4 hrs

V SHOP Any height 2,000 7,000 up to 2 hrs up to 4 hrs

VI FACTORY Not exceeding 28 m No limit 28,000 up to 1 hr up to 4 hrs

Exceeding 28 m 2,000 5,500 up to 2 hrs up to 4 hrs

VII Place of Assembly N/A N/A N/A up to 4 hrs up to 4 hrs

VIII Storage & General Not exceeding 28 m No limit 21,000 up to 4 hrs * up to 4 hrs

Exceeding 28 m 1,000 No limit up to 4 hrs * up to 4 hrs

Part II – Single storey buildings

II Institutional Any height 3,000 No limit ½ hr

III Other residential Any height 3,000 No limit ½ hr

UBBL PART VII - FIRE REQUIREMENT

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 27: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

27

53

BY LAWS DESCRIPTION

86Party wall (deleted in updated UBBL)

(1)200 mm total thickness of solid masonry or in situ concrete

(3) Party walls to be at least 230 mm above surface of roof or at right angles to such upper surface

136 Provision of compartment walls & compartment floors

137Compartmentation by heightFloors in building exceeding 30 m in height to be constructed as compartment floor

138 Other walls & floors to be constructed as compartment wall or compartment floor

139 Separation of fire risk areas

141 Separating walls

142External walls(1) If any external wall that is carried across the end of separating wall, such external wall & separating wall

shall be bonded together or the junction of such walls shall be FIRE-STOPPED.

147 Construction of separating walls

UBBL PART VII - FIRE REQUIREMENT

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

54

BY LAWS DESCRIPTION

148

Special requirements as to compartment walls & compartment floors(1) Where there is opening : usage of fire doors and fire damper

(2) Where compartment wall or compartment floor forms a junction with any structure (compartment wall,

external wall, separating wall or protected shaft), such structures shall be bonded together at the junction

or the junction shall be FIRE-STOPPED.

149Horizontal and vertical barriers at the external walls.750 mm beyond the exterior wall in the plane of the floor or by vertical panels not less than 900 mm in height

150 Protected shaft

157 Protected shaft consisting of staircase

161 Fire-stopping

162 Fire doors in compartment walls and separating walls

163 Fire doors including frames to comply to MS 1073

252 AAtriums in buildings(d) Fully protected by automatic sprinkler system.

(f) & (g) Smoke control of smoke exhaust system.

UBBL PART VII - FIRE REQUIREMENT

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 28: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

28

55

COMPARTMENT WALL & COMPARTMENT FLOOR

By Laws136 – Provision of compartment walls and compartment floors based on Fifth Schedule.137 – Compartmentation by height (30 m).138 - Other walls and floors to be constructed as compartment walls or compartment floors.148 – Special requirements as to compartment walls and compartment floors

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

56

SEPARATING WALL & COMPARTMENT WALL

SEPARATING WALL

SEPARATING WALL

SEPARATING WALLSeparation of units/buildings.By Laws139 – Separation of fire risk

FRP determined by AHJ based on fire hazard.

141 – Separating wall.147 – Construction of

separating walls

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 29: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

29

57

SEPARATING WALL & COMPARTMENT WALL

SEPARATING WALL

SEPARATING WALL

FIRE COMPARTMENT

FIRE COMPARTMENT

FIRE COMPARTMENT

SEPARATING WALLSeparation of units/buildings.By Laws139 – Separation of fire risk

FRP determined by AHJ based on fire hazard.

141 – Separating wall.147 – Construction of

separating walls

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

58

PARTY WALL / SEPARATING WALL

225 mm

Roof

Party wall / Separating wall

225 mm

Roof

Party wall / Separating wall

By Laws86 (3) – Party wall 230 mm (deleted).141 (3) – Separating wall 225 mm

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 30: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

30

59

EXTERNAL WALL

750 mm

750 mm

900 mm

900 mm

900 mm

Fire Stop

Fire Stop

By Laws142 & 148 – Fire stop149 – Horizontal and vertical barriers at the external walls.

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

60

FIRE RESISTANCE / FIRE RATED SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION

SUBMISSIONBomba CertificateFire Resistance System Certificate : Indicating 60, 120 or 240 minutes

(for Integrity and/or Insulation)NOT Class “O” CertificateEach Bomba Certificate & Fire test report is for 1 system, 1 type of application

COMPLETIONBorang Bomba C1, C2 & C3Only for Fire resistance / Fire Rated Systemtogether with a valid Bomba Fire Resistance System Certificate

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994

Page 31: PAM Northern Chapter Seminararchitecturemalaysia.com/Files/Pool/98_170622_0914411441_pam_nc_cpd... · 21/06/2017 1 PAM Northern Chapter Seminar 17 June 2017 CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik

21/06/2017

31

61

DESCRIPTION ROCKWOOL Glasswool

FIRE SAFETY

EN 13501 Part 1

Melting Point

Class A1

> 1,000OC

Class A1-A2

±650OC

EN 1609 WATER ABSORPTION RATE

a. High water absorption affects thermal resistance.

b. High water absorption would cause frame degenaration &

health effect

c. High water absorption can would promote growth of

fungi/mould

0.12 kg/m3 Excessive

SAGGING

Lower density will be easier to sag. Min 40 kg/m3

16 kg/m3

(for roofing)

32 kg/m3

THICKNESS

Thickness affect thermal resistance performance

Lesser

compression

Higher

compression

LOWER FREQUENCY INSULATION BETTER lesser

SUMMARY

CONFIDENTIAL Lee Ho Aik [email protected] or [email protected] 012 3224557 or 016 2061994