particle sensors comparison 2019 - system plus€¦ · ©2019 by system plus consulting | particle...

36
©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE +33 2 40 18 09 16 [email protected] www.systemplus.fr HPMA115S0-XXX SDS011 PMS 7003 SPS30 GP2Y1010AU0F PPD42NJ Particle Sensors C omparison 2019 Report by Benjamin Pussat September 2019 – version 1

Upload: others

Post on 02-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1

PPD71

22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin44200 NANTES - FRANCE +33 2 40 18 09 16 [email protected] www.systemplus.fr

HPMA115S0-XXX SDS011 PMS 7003 SPS30

GP2Y1010AU0F PPD42NJ

Particle Sensors Comparison 2019Report by Benjamin PussatSeptember 2019 – version 1

Page 2: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 2

Table of Contents

Overview / Introduction 4

o Executive Summary

o Particle Sensor Market

o Overview

Specifications Comparison 9

o Main Features

o Block Diagrams

o Dimensions

Physical Comparison 28

o Teardown / Part Collection

o Electronic Boards

o Comparison Table : Chipset & other parts

Cost Comparison 64

o BoM Cost

o Added-Value Cost

o Manufacturing Cost

Company Services 82

o Company Services

o Contact

o Legal

Page 3: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 3

Overview / Introduction• Executive summary• Particle Sensor Market• Overview

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Executive Summary

System Plus Consulting has analyzed, compared and reviewed seven different particle sensors from six manufacturers :

o HPMA115S0-XXX from Honeywell

o SDS011 from Nova Fitness

o PMS 7003 from Plantower

o SPS30 from Sensirion

o GP2Y1010AU0F from Sharp

o PPD42NJ from Shinyei Technology

o PPD71 from Shinyei Technology

These particle sensors use light-scattering principle in order to detect particles and measure their concentration in the air.

This report compares the different sensors features, structure, chipset, optical parts, and then estimates a bill of materialscost, added-value cost and manufacturing cost.

Plus, are available all the teardown photos, components identifications, PCBs characteristics, several IC die photos.

Page 4: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 4

Overview / Introduction• Executive summary• Particle Sensor Market• Overview

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Particle Sensor Market

© Yole Développement

Page 5: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 5

Overview / Introduction• Executive summary• Particle Sensor Market• Overview

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Particle Sensor Market

© Yole Développement

Page 6: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 6

Overview / Introduction• Executive summary• Particle Sensor Market• Overview

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Overview

HPMA115S0-XXX

Main characteristics:• Laser-based light scattering particle

sensing• PM2.5, PM10 output • Concentration range: 0 to 1,000 µg/m3• Max accuracy: +- 15µg/m3• Response time: < 6 s• Lifetime up to 10 years• Ope. temperature: -20°C to +50°C• Dimensions (LxWxH): 43x36x23.7mm

Applications: • HVAC (commercial & residential)• Indoor/handled air quality monitors• Air purifiers (commercial & residential)• Automotive cabin air purifiers• Market introduction : N/A

Datasheet

SDS011

Main characteristics:• Laser-based light scattering particle

sensing• PM2.5 & PM10 output • Concentration range: 0 to 999.9 µg/m3• Max accuracy: +- 10µg/m3• Response time: <10s• Lifetime up to 8,000 working hours• Ope. temperature: -10°C to +50°C• Dimensions (LxWxH): 71x70x23mm

Applications: • HVAC (commercial & residential)• Indoor/handled air quality monitors• Air purifiers (commercial & residential)

• Market introduction : 2015 (estimation)

Datasheet

PMS 7003

Main characteristics:• Laser-based light scattering particle

sensing• PM1.0, PM2.5 & PM10 output

Concentration range: 0 to 1,000 µg/m3• Max accuracy: +- 10µg/m3• Response time: <10 s• Lifetime > 3 years• Ope. temperature: -10°C to +60°C• Dimensions (LxWxH): 48x37x12mm

Applications: • HVAC (commercial & residential)• Indoor/handled air quality monitors• Air purifiers (commercial & residential)

• Market introduction : 2016

Datasheet

SPS30

Main characteristics:• Laser-based light scattering particle • sensing• PM1.0, PM2.5, PM4.0, PM10 output

Concentration range: 0 to 1,000 µg/m3• Max accuracy: +-10µg/m3• Response time: N/A• Lifetime > 8 years• Ope. temperature: -10°C to +70°C• Dimensions (LxWxH): 41x41x12mm

Applications: • HVAC (commercial & residential)• Indoor/handled air quality monitors• Air purifiers (commercial & residential)

• Market introduction : 2018

Datasheet

N/A : Non-available

Page 7: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 7

SPECIFICATIONSCOMPARISON

Page 8: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 8

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison• Main features• Block Diagrams• Dimensions

Physical comparison

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Block Diagram – Honeywell HPMA115S0

Display Module

PCB Antenna

Laser Diode(on PCB)

BiconvexLens

Air inlet

Air outlet

Photodiode(on PCB)

NPNOpAmp

+ Filtering

Laser DiodePhotodiode

Light trap

MOSFET

PW

M f

eed

bac

k

TX

PCB

MCU(Algorithm)

RX

1 8

Power Conversion(LDO Regulator)

Connector

Fan

Particle

Air flow

Emitted light

Scattered light

Page 9: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 9

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison• Main features• Block Diagrams• Dimensions

Physical comparison

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Dimensions (Sensirion SPS30)

Page 10: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 10

P H Y S I C A LCOMPARISON

Page 11: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 11

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison• Teardown / Part Collection• Electronic Boards• Comparison Table

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Teardown – Plantower PMS 7003

Page 12: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 12

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison• Teardown / Part Collection• Electronic Boards• Comparison Table

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Part Collection – Shinyei PPD71

Top Cover(ABS*, 7.1g)

Main Board(Top side)

Page 13: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 13

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison• Teardown / Part Collection• Electronic Boards• Comparison Table

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Electronic Board – Plantower PMS 7003 – IC Opening

XXXXXXXXX Logo +

Die part number

Page 14: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 14

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison• Teardown / Part Collection• Electronic Boards• Comparison Table

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Electronic Board – Sensirion SPS30

Page 15: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 15

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison• Teardown / Part Collection• Electronic Boards• Comparison Table

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Electronic Board – Sensirion SPS30

SunonMF20060V2-1C010-G99

Fan 5V 0.32W 20x20x6mm Wired

Manufacturer Website

Mnfr Not IdentifiedP/N Not IdentifiedLaser Diode Module

15.5x6mm, Aperture 3mm

PCB Manufacturer : Introlines IndustrialPCB Manufacturing Country : Hong KongPCB Characteristics : IT-402M

Electronic Board Assembly/Test Date Code Electronic Board Part Number

PCB Manufacturing Date Code

Flame Rating

Page 16: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 16

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison• Teardown / Part Collection• Electronic Boards• Comparison Table

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Comparison table – Chipset N/A : Non-available

Product part : MCU Operational Amplifier Voltage Regulator Photodiode

SharpGP2Y1010AU0F

N/A Brand : SharpPart number : S126Description : ASIC TSSOP16

N/A Brand : SharpPart number : PD413PI2E00FDescription : IR Photodiode 960nm 150mW 90° Radial TH

ShinyeiPPD42NJ

N/A Brand : JRCPart number : NJM2902MDescription : IC OpAmp Quad 500kHz SO14

N/A Brand : Mnfr not identifiedPart number : P/N not identifiedDescription : IR Photodiode Side View with 3mm Diameter lens TH

ShinyeiPPD71

Brand : STMicroelectronicsPart number : STM8S003F3P6TRDescription : IC MCU 8-Bit 16MHz 8KB Flash TSSOP20

Brand : Hamamatsu (estimated)Part number : P/N not identifiedDescription : ASIC Photodiode + amplifier + I²C interface SOP12

Brand : Torex SemiconductorPart number : XC6223A331MR-GDescription : IC LDO Voltage Regulator 3.3V 300mA SOT23-5

Brand : Hamamatsu (estimated)Part number : P/N not identifiedDescription : ASIC Photodiode + amplifier + I²C interface SOP12

Page 17: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 17

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison• Teardown / Part Collection• Electronic Boards• Comparison Table

Cost comparison

About System Plus

Comparison table – Other parts N/A : Non-available

Page 18: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 18

C O S TCOMPARISON

Page 19: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 19

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

BoM Cost – Overview

The material cost corresponds to the purchasing price of the components (either electronic or not), as well asthe mechanical parts, composing the electronic system.

The price search of each reference is realized on the basis of catalogues and web sites of electroniccomponents distributors and manufacturers. It is often necessary to ask for specific quotations for sometargeted references.

Prices found during our researches among distributors and manufacturers are associated to quantities whichmay vary from a few units to several thousands or millions of pieces.

It is therefore mandatory to have reliable simulation rules that can be used for this type of extrapolation. Thesimulation rules used in this study come from previous analyses that have been conducted by System PlusConsulting and take into account parameters such as quantities, different types of distributors andmanufacturers, average profit margin on several types of products. These simulation rules have beenintegrated in the SYScost+ software to conduct the calculations.

When specific prices are given in EUR and USD, the conversion rate used is: 1 USD = 0.89 EUR.

The report details BOM cost for 1,000,000 units.

On the two next slides there is an example of the detailed BoM of a system and its material cost breakdown.

Page 20: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 20

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

BoM Cost – Honeywell HPMA115S0 – Example

Page 21: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 21

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

BoM Cost – Comparison table – Chipset N/A : Non-available

Product : MCU Operational Amplifier Voltage Regulator Photodiode

SharpGP2Y1010AU0F

N/A Brand : SharpPart number : S126Description : ASIC TSSOP16

$0.41/unit (1,000,000 units)

N/A Brand : SharpPart number : PD413PI2E00FDescription : IR Photodiode 960nm 150mW 90° Radial TH

$0.179/unit (1,000,000 units)

ShinyeiPPD42NJ

N/A Brand : JRCPart number : NJM2902MDescription : IC OpAmp Quad 500kHz SO14

$0.209/unit (1,000,000 units)

N/A Brand : Mnfr not identifiedPart number : P/N not identifiedDescription : Photodiode Side View with 3mm Diameter lens TH

$0.178/unit (1,000,000 units)

ShinyeiPPD71

Brand : STMicroelectronicsPart number : STM8S003F3P6TRDescription : IC MCU 8-Bit 16MHz 8KB Flash TSSOP20

$0.205/unit (1,000,000 units)

Brand : Hamamatsu (estimated)Part number : P/N not identifiedDescription : ASIC Photodiode + amplifier + I²C interface SOP12

$0.743/unit (1,000,000 units)

Brand : Torex SemiconductorPart number : XC6223A331MR-GDescription : IC LDO Voltage Regulator 3.3V 300mA SOT23-5

$0.099/unit (1,000,000 units)

Brand : Hamamatsu (estimated)Part number : P/N not identifiedDescription : ASIC Photodiode + amplifier + I²C interface SOP12

-

Page 22: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 22

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

Product : Electronics Cost PCBs Cost Others Cost Total BoM Cost

Honeywell HPMA115S0

$0.88 $0.45 $6.57(Lens/Laser Diode/Fan...) $7.90

Nova Fitness SDS011

$1.08 $0.39 $7.06(Lens/Laser Diode/Fan...) $8.53

PlantowerPMS 7003

$0.77 0.31 $6.77(Lens/Laser Diode/Fan...) $7.85

SensirionSPS30

$1.00 $0.33 $6.55(Lens/Laser Diode/Fan...) $7.88

Sharp GP2Y1010AU0F

$0.74 $0.12 $1.06$1.92

ShinyeiPPD42NJ

$0.85 $0.19 $0.97$2.01

Shinyei PPD71

$1.13 $0.21 $1.13$2.47

BoM Cost – Comparison table – Whole System N/A : Non-available

Page 23: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 23

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

$6.57 $7.06

$6.77

$6.55

$1.06

$0.97

$1.13

$0.88

$1.08

$0.77$1.00

$0.74

$0.85$1.13

$0.45

$0.39

$0.31 $0.33

$0.12$0.19 $0.21

BoM Cost Breakdown

BoM Cost – BreakdownOther parts BoM Cost

Electronics BoM Cost

PCB Cost

Page 24: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 24

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

Added-Value Cost – Overview

Assembly

- The added-value cost of a product is the total cost of the operations for assembling and testing this product.

As shown below, it depends of several parameters as energy used, machine cost depreciation, labor cost, consumables, among many others.

- On the two next slides there is an example of the detailed hypotheses made for added-value cost calculation.

Consumables

Energy

Labor

Factory Deprec.

Machine Deprec.

MaterialsAssembled

Product

Maintenance

Rework/WasteYield

Added-value CostBoM Cost Manufacturing Cost+ =

Page 25: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 25

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

Added-Value Cost – Honeywell HPMA115S0 – Electronic Board (Example) Step n° Step name Step Code Inline step? Side Auto/Manual Step Time (s) Equipment number Equip. Price (USD) Remark

1 Material preparation MP No - M 30s / reference 1 5,000

2 Storage buffer SB No - - 5s / board 1 20,000

3 Stencil printing SP Yes 2 A 20s / panel 1 200,000

4 Solder paste inspection SPI Yes 2 A 0.003s / pin 1 250,000

5 Chipshooter CS Yes 2 A 0.1-0.2s/comp. 1 900,000

6 Pick and place SMT P&P Yes 2 A 0.1-7.2s/comp. 1 450,000

7 Automated optical inspection AOI Yes 2 A 5s / panel 1 250,000

8 Reflow RF Yes 2 A 24s / panel 1 90,000

9 Automated optical inspection AOI Yes 2 A 5s / panel 1 250,000

10 Storage buffer SB No - - 5s / board - - Same machine as step n°2

11 Stencil printing SP Yes 1 A 20s / panel - - Same machine as step n°3

12 Solder paste inspection SPI Yes 1 A 0.003s / pin - - Same machine as step n°4

13 Chipshooter CS Yes 1 A 0.1-0.2s/comp. - - Same machine as step n°5

14 Pick and place SMT P&P Yes 1 A 0.1-7.2s/comp. - - Same machine as step n°6

15 Automated optical inspection AOI Yes 1 A 5s / panel - - Same machine as step n°7

16 Reflow RF Yes 1 A 24s / panel - - Same machine as step n°8

17 Automated optical inspection AOI Yes 1 A 5s / panel - - Same machine as step n°9

18 Storage buffer SB No - - 5s / board 1 20,000

19 In-situ test ICT No 1+2 A 7s / board 1 300,000

20 Functional test FCT No 1+2 A 3s / board 1 200,000

21 Storage buffer SB No - - 5s / board 1 20,000

22 Depaneling DP No 1+2 A 5s / board 1 40,000

23 Manual Assembly + Screwing MA No 1 M 15s / board 6 5,000 Laser Module

24 Manual Soldering MS No 1+2 M 45s / board 6 5,000 Laser Module/Shielding/Fan/Connector

25 Visual Inspection VI No 1+2 M 10s / board 6 5,000

26 Storage buffer SB No - - 5s / board 1 20,000

27 Board conditioning BC No - M 5s / board 1 3,000

Panel size : 78 Boards Total equipment price : $3,400,000

Page 26: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 26

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

Added-Value Cost – Comparison table

Product : Electronic Board A-V Laser Diode Board A-V System A-V Total Added-Value Cost

Honeywell HPMA115S0

$0.52(Laser Diode+Lens+Spring assembly on this board)

$0.04(Laser diode on PCB

assembly only)

$0.21$0.77

Nova Fitness SDS011

$0.61 $0.19(Laser Diode+Lens+Spring

assembly included)

$0.18$0.98

PlantowerPMS 7003

$0.48 $0.14(Laser Diode+Lens+Spring

assembly included)

$0.18$0.79

SensirionSPS30

$0.28 $0.16(Laser Diode+Lens+Spring

assembly only)

$0.26$0.70

Sharp GP2Y1010AU0F

$0.25 N/A $0.10$0.35

ShinyeiPPD42NJ

$0.19 N/A $0.08$0.27

Shinyei PPD71

$0.30 N/A $0.21$0.51

N/A : Non-available

Page 27: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 27

Overview / Introduction

Specifications comparison

Physical comparison

Cost comparison• BoM cost• Added-value cost• Manufacturing cost

About System Plus

Manufacturing Cost – Sensirion SPS30 – Example

For each system, a manufacturing cost can be calculated on the assembly/sub-assembly level. The Sensirion SPS30 Particle Sensor is composed of 3 main parts :

- A laser module which costs $4.97 ($4.81 of material & $0.16 of added-value).

- An electronic board which costs $1.74 ($1.46 of material & $0.28 of added-value).

- All the other parts which costs $1.87 ($1.61 of material & $0.27 of added-value).

The $8.58 Total Manufacturing Cost includes the all the Assembly Costs & the BoM Costs.

Article

QtyADDED VALUE

Manufacturing

Duration (s)

Particle Matter Sensor 1 0.26$ 120 1.61$ 1.86$

Electronic Board 1 0.28$ 53 1.46$ 1.74$

Laser Diode Module 1 0.16$ 80 4.81$ 4.97$

0.70$ 253 7.88$ 8.58$

SP19446 - Sensirion SPS30 Particulate Matter

SensorASSEMBLY COST

MATERIAL COST

MANUFACTURING

COSTwithout scrap

& supplying costs

TOTAL

ASSEMBLY

COST

MATERIAL

COST%

3.0% 18.7% 21.7%

3.3% 17.1% 20.3%

1.9% 56.1% 58.0%

8% 92% 100%

Electronic Board

SP19446 - Sensirion SPS30 Particulate Matter

Sensor

Particle Matter Sensor

TOTAL

Laser Diode Module

Page 28: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 28

Overview / Introduction

Company Profile & Supply Chain

Physical Analysis

Manufacturing Process Flow

Cost Analysis

Selling Price Analysis

Feedbacks

Linked report

About System Plus

Linked Report

Gas and Particle Sensors 2018

Air quality is breathing life into the sensor market!

Market and Technology Report by Yole Développement

Bundle offer possible with the Particle Sensor Comparison 2019, contact us for more information at [email protected].

Page 29: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

Due to increasing air quality levelrequirements, air and gas particulatematter sensing has become an ever-growing market, particularly insemiconductor, indoor depollution andautomotive applications.

Only a few well-known companies sharethis market, which is worth more than$100 million today. Many products havealready been released in differentapplications, for different particle sizes.

However, these particle sensors mustrespect dimensional constraints to beintegrated into other systems. They mustoperate for years without maintenanceand have a reasonable selling price toreach as many areas as possible.

In this comparative report, System PlusConsulting analyzes seven particle sensorsfrom the top main manufacturers:Honeywell’s HPMA115S0-XXX, NovaFitness’ SDS011, Plantower’s PMS 7003,Sensirion’s SPS30, Sharp’sGP2Y1010AU0F, and Shiyei Technology’sPPD42NJ and PPD71.

In this analysis technical choices made bymanufacturers are highlighted, at theprinted circuit boards, electronic

components and hardware levels. Blockdiagrams help readers to understand thecomponent functions and the mechanicaldesign. Different tables compare thecommon chipsets and main partsidentified, their respective costs. Then,combined with manufacturinghypotheses, a manufacturing price isestimated for each system.

For further details on gas and particlesensors market and technology, consultYole Développement’s linked report.

COMPLETE TEARDOWN WITH

• Main features

• Block diagrams

• Teardown

• Printed circuit board characteristics and component identification

• Chipset comparison tables

• Added value comparison table

• Manufacturing cost comparison table

From detection to measurement, discover manufacturers’ technical choices anddevice manufacturing costs.

REVERSE COSTING® – STRUCTURE, PROCESS & COST REPORT

Title: ParticleSensor Comparison

Pages: 85

Date: September 2019

Format: PDF & Excel file

Price: EUR 6,490

Particle Sensor Comparison 2019

IC – LED – RF – MEMS – IMAGING – PACKAGING – SYSTEM – POWER - DISPLAY

Page 30: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Overview/Introduction

• Executive Summary

• Particle Sensor Market

• Overview

Specification Comparison

• Main Features

• Block Diagrams

• Dimensions

Physical Comparison

• Teardown/Part Collection

• Electronic Boards

• Comparison Table : Chipset and Other Parts

Cost Comparison

• BoM Cost

• Added-Value Cost

• Manufacturing Cost

AUTHOR

PARTICLE SENSOR COMPARISON 2019

Benjamin Pussat has joined System Plus Consulting as a cost technician in 2017, He is incharge of reverse costing with a focus on boards and systems. He previously workds forSercel, Sagem S&D and SEIA where he was in charge of board testing and then hardwareand software development.He holds a Bacherlor's degree in electronics for the University of Nantes (Nantes, FR).

LINKED REPORT

Gas and Particle Sensors 2018 – Air quality is breathing lifeinto the sensor market!

Market and Technology Report by Yole Développement

Bundle offer possible with the Particle Sensor Comparison 2019, contact us for more information at [email protected].

BoM Cost – Comparison Table - Chipset

Page 31: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

COSTING TOOLS

REVERSE COSTING® – STRUCTURE, PROCESS & COST REPORT

Process-BasedCosting Tools

ParametricCosting Tools

IC Price+

MEMS CoSim+

MEMS Price+

Power CoSim+

Power Price+

LED CoSim+

3D PackageCoSim+

DisplayPrice+

PCBPrice+

SYSCost+

SYSCost+It provides all component costs estimationincluding PCB, housing and connectors, and asimulation of the assembly cost and test process atthe board and system level.

IC Price+The tool performs the necessary cost simulation ofany Integrated Circuit: ASICs, microcontrollers,memories, DSP, smartpower…

PCB Price+It calculates the real price impacts of change tolayer count, copper thickness, change ofmanufacturing country, or the increasing of rawmaterial costs, such as gold or copper.

Our analysis is performed with our costing tools SYSCost +, IC Price+ and PCB Price+.

System Plus Consulting offers powerful costing tools to evaluate the production cost and selling price from

single chip to complex structures.

WHAT IS A REVERSE COSTING®?

Reverse Costing® is the process of disassembling a device (or asystem) in order to identify its technology and calculate itsmanufacturing cost, using in-house models and tools.

CONTACTS

ABOUT SYSTEM PLUS CONSULTING

System Plus Consulting is specialized

in the cost analysis of electronics

from semiconductor devices to

electronic systems.

A complete range of services and

costing tools to provide in-depth

production cost studies and to

estimate the objective selling price of

a product is available.

Our services:

• STRUCTURE & PROCESS

ANALYSES

• TEARDOWNS

• CUSTOM ANALYSES

• COSTING SERVICES

• COSTING TOOLS

• TRAININGS

www.systemplus.fr

[email protected]

Headquarters22, bd Benoni GoullinNantes Biotech44200 NantesFrance+33 2 40 18 09 [email protected]

Europe Sales OfficeLizzie LEVENEZFrankfurt am MainGermany+49 151 23 54 41 [email protected]

America Sales OfficeSteven LAFERRIEREWestern USA & Canada+1 [email protected]

Chris YOUMANEastern USA & Canada+1 919-607-9839 [email protected]

Asia Sales OfficeTakashi ONOZAWAJapan & Rest of Asia+81 80 4371 [email protected]

Mavis WANGGreater China+886 979 336 [email protected]

Peter OKKorea+82 10 4089 [email protected]

Page 32: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

ORDER FORMPlease process my order for “Particle Sensor Comparison 2019” Reverse Costing® – Structure, Process & Cost Report Ref: SP19446

Full Structure, Process & Cost Report : EUR 6,490* Bundle offer possible with the Gas and Particle Sensors 2018

Market and Technology report by Yole Développement, contact us. Annual Subscription offers possible from 3 reports, including this

report as the first of the year. Contact us for more information.

SHIP TO

Name (Mr/Ms/Dr/Pr): .............................................................

Job Title: …….............................................................................

Company: ….............................................................................

Address: …….............................................................................

City: ………………………………… State: ..........................................

Postcode/Zip: ..........................................................................

Country: ……............................................................................

VAT ID Number for EU members: ..........................................

Tel: ……………….........................................................................

Email: .....................................................................................

Date: ......................................................................................

Signature: ..............................................................................

BILLING CONTACT

First Name : ............................................................................

Last Name: …….......................................................................

Email: …..................................................................................

Phone: ……..............................................................................

PAYMENT

By credit card:

Number: |__|__|__|__| |__|__|__|__| |__|__|__|__|

|__|__|__|__|

Expiration date: |__|__|/|__|__|

Card Verification Value: |__|__|__|

By bank transfer:HSBC - CAE- Le Terminal -2 rue du Charron - 44800 St Herblain FranceBIC code: CCFRFRPP• In EUR

Bank code : 30056 - Branch code : 00955 - Account : 09550003234 IBAN: FR76 3005 6009 5509 5500 0323 439

• In USDBank code : 30056 - Branch code : 00955 - Account : 09550003247 IBAN: FR76 3005 6009 5509 5500 0324 797

REVERSE COSTING® – STRUCTURE, PROCESS & COST REPORTPARTICLE SENSOR COMPARISON 2019

Each year System Plus Consultingreleases a comprehensive collectionof new reverse engineering andcosting analyses in various domains.You can choose to buy over 12months a set of 3, 4, 5, 7, 10 or 15Reverse Costing® reports.

Up to 47% discount!

More than 60 reports released eachyear on the following topics(considered for 2018):• MEMS & Sensors: Accelerometer

– Environment - Fingerprint - Gas - Gyroscope - IMU/Combo -Microphone - Optics - Oscillator -Pressure

• Power: GaN - IGBT - MOSFET - Si Diode - SiC

• Imaging: Camera - Spectrometer• LED and Laser: UV LED – VCSEL -

White/blue LED• Packaging: 3D Packaging -

Embedded - SIP - WLP• Integrated Circuits: IPD –

Memories – PMIC - SoC• RF: FEM - Duplexer• Systems: Automotive - Consumer

- Energy - Telecom

ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTIONS

Return order by: FAX: +33 2 53 55 10 59MAIL: SYSTEM PLUS CONSULTING

22, bd Benoni GoullinNantes Biotech44200 Nantes – France

EMAIL: [email protected]

*For price in dollars please use the day’s exchange rate *All reports are delivered electronically in pdf format*For French customer, add 20 % for VAT*Our prices are subject to change. Please check our new releases and price changes on www.systemplus.fr. The present document is valid 6 months after its publishing date: September2019

Page 33: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

1.INTRODUCTIONThe present terms and conditions apply to the offers, sales and deliveries of services managed by System PlusConsulting except in the case of a particular written agreement.Buyer must note that placing an order means an agreement without any restriction with these terms and conditions.

2.PRICESPrices of the purchased services are those which are in force on the date the order is placed. Prices are in Euros andworked out without taxes. Consequently, the taxes and possible added costs agreed when the order is placed will becharged on these initial prices.System Plus Consulting may change its prices whenever the company thinks it necessary. However, the companycommits itself in invoicing at the prices in force on the date the order is placed.

3.REBATES and DISCOUNTSThe quoted prices already include the rebates and discounts that System Plus Consulting could have granted accordingto the number of orders placed by the Buyer, or other specific conditions. No discount is granted in case of earlypayment.

4.TERMS OF PAYMENTSystem Plus Consulting delivered services are to be paid within 30 days end of month by bank transfer except in thecase of a particular written agreement.If the payment does not reach System Plus Consulting on the deadline, the Buyer has to pay System Plus Consulting apenalty for late payment the amount of which is three times the legal interest rate. The legal interest rate is thecurrent one on the delivery date. This penalty is worked out on the unpaid invoice amount, starting from the invoicedeadline. This penalty is sent without previous notice.When payment terms are over 30 days end of month, the Buyer has to pay a deposit which amount is 10% of the

total invoice amount when placing his order.

5. OWNERSHIPSystem Plus Consulting remains sole owner of the delivered services until total payment of the invoice.

6.DELIVERIESThe delivery schedule on the purchase order is given for information only and cannot be strictly guaranteed.Consequently any reasonable delay in the delivery of services will not allow the buyer to claim for damages or tocancel the order.

7.ENTRUSTED GOODS SHIPMENTThe transport costs and risks are fully born by the Buyer. Should the customer wish to ensure the goods against lost ordamage on the base of their real value, he must imperatively point it out to System Plus Consulting when theshipment takes place. Without any specific requirement, insurance terms for the return of goods will be the carriercurrent ones (reimbursement based on good weight instead of the real value).

8.FORCE MAJEURESystem Plus Consulting responsibility will not be involved in non execution or late delivery of one of its dutiesdescribed in the current terms and conditions if these are the result of a force majeure case. Therefore, the forcemajeure includes all external event unpredictable and irresistible as defined by the article 1148 of the French CodeCivil?

9.CONFIDENTIALITYAs a rule, all information handed by customers to system Plus Consulting are considered as strictly confidential.A non-disclosure agreement can be signed on demand.

10.RESPONSABILITY LIMITATIONThe Buyer is responsible for the use and interpretations he makes of the reports delivered by System Plus Consulting.Consequently, System Plus Consulting responsibility can in no case be called into question for any direct or indirectdamage, financial or otherwise, that may result from the use of the results of our analysis or results obtained usingone of our costing tools.

11.APPLICABLE LAWAny dispute that may arise about the interpretation or execution of the current terms and conditions shall be resolvedapplying the French law.It the dispute cannot be settled out-of-court, the competent Court will be the Tribunal de Commerce de Nantes.

TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SALES

Page 34: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 29

COMPANYSERVICES

Page 35: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 30

Overview / Introduction

Teardown Analysis

Cost Analysis

Selling Price Analysis

Feedbacks

About System Pluso Company serviceso Contacto Legal

Business Models Fields of Expertise

Custom Analyses(>130 analyses per year)

Reports(>40 reports per year)

Costing Tools

Trainings

Page 36: Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 - System Plus€¦ · ©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 1 PPD71 22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin 44200 NANTES - FRANCE

©2019 by System Plus Consulting | Particle Sensors Comparison 2019 31

Overview / Introduction

Teardown Analysis

Cost Analysis

Selling Price Analysis

Feedbacks

About System Pluso Company serviceso Contacto Legal

Contact

Europe Sales OfficeLizzie LEVENEZFrankfurt am MainGERMANY+49 151 23 54 41 [email protected]

www.systemplus.fr

Asia Sales OfficeTakashi [email protected]

Mavis WANGGREATER [email protected]

NANTESHeadquarter

FRANKFURT/MAINEurope Sales Office

LYONYOLE HQ

TOKYOYOLE KK

GREATER CHINAYOLE

PHOENIXYOLE Inc.

America Sales OfficeSteve LAFERRIEREEastern [email protected]

Troy BLANCHETTEWestern [email protected]

KOREAYOLE

Headquarters22 Boulevard Benoni Goullin44200 NantesFRANCE+33 2 40 18 09 [email protected]