pas-e platelet additive solution haemovigilance report ... · pas-e platelet additive solution...

21
PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank Tolksdorf, Ignacio Alvarez Dr. Frank Tolksdorf, Senior Medical Manager Macopharma International GmbH, Langen, Germany [email protected] Manchester, 11 July 2018 1

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jun-2020

17 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE

Chryslain Sumian, Frank Tolksdorf, Ignacio Alvarez

Dr. Frank Tolksdorf, Senior Medical ManagerMacopharma International GmbH, Langen, Germany

[email protected]

Manchester, 11 July 2018

1

Page 2: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

• Employee of Macopharma, Langen, Germany

• Macopharma is manufacturer of platelet additive solutions SSP (PAS-B) and SSP+ (PAS-E)

Disclosure

2

Page 3: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

„Haemovigilance“

It´s all about Vigilance

„Materiovigilance/Medical Device Vigilance“

„Pharmacovigilance“

„Biovigilance“

3

Page 4: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

Legal basis: New Medical Device Regulation (MDR)

2022:IVDR

Regulation (EU)

2017/746

AIMD: Active Implantable Medical DevicesIVD: In Vitro Diagnostic DirectiveMDD: Medical Device DirectiveMDR: Medical Device Regulation

2020

2020:

MDR Regulation

(EU) 2017/745

AIMD

90/385/EEC

MDD

93/42/EEC

IVD

98/79/EC

4

NEW

Page 5: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

New

NameCitrate Phosphate Acetate Magnesium Potassium Gluconate Glucose

Alternative

Names

Previous ISBT

128 Name

PAS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS Not named

PAS-A X X X PAS (1) Not named

PAS-B X XPAS-II, PAS-2

SSP, T-SolPAS-II

PAS-C X X XPAS III, PAS-

3, IntersolPAS-III

PAS-D X X X X X Composol PS PASIII-MgK

PAS-E X X X X XPAS IIIM,

SSP+, T-PAS+Not named

PAS-F X X X XPlasmaLyte

A, IsoplateNot named

PAS-G X X X X X X Not named

Terminology of Platelet Additive Solutions

Rice B. ISBT 128 Standard: standard terminology for blood, cellular therapy, and tissue product descriptions, version 6.23. 2016; https://www.iccbba.org/tech-library/international-nomenclature/platelet-additive-solution-pas-3

1. Generation

2. Generation

Platelet Additive Solution (PAS)

5

Page 6: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

PAS are buffered electrolyte solutions, designed for partial replacement of plasma in platelet

concentrates to improve:

Safety:

• Reduced risk of plasma-related adverse transfusion reactions

• Enabling ABO-incompatible transfusions

• Reduced risk of using mismatching plasma for resuspension

• Enabling pathogen reduction treatment

Quality:

• Standardisation of platelet products

• Improved storage stability, extended storage time

Stock management/logistics:

• Versatile configurations (volume, connectivity, operational flexibility)

• Improved availability of platelet products (weekends, vacation periods)

• Reduced discard-rate/number of outdated products

• Additional plasma savings6

Platelet Additive Solution (PAS)

Page 7: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

7

Research & Development

CE & Approval Commercialisation

Classification& Regulatory

pathway

RiskManagement

Clinical Investigation/ Applications

CE submission

Clinical EvaluationClinical

Investigation/ Evaluation

Post-Market Surveillance

Planning ProductDesign Changes/

Extensions

Pre-/postAudit

Technical File/Design Dossier

Lifecyclemonitoring

Applicationsfor Product/ CE renewal

QM-based interlinked activities

Page 8: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

Post-Market Surveillance

(PMS)

Clinical Evaluation

Report (CER)

Risk Management (RM)

Systematic process to collect and analyse experience gained from usage of medical devices in the market, if necessary:• Update benefit/risk assessment • Update design/IFU/labelling • Update clinical evaluation• Identification of needs for preventive,

corrective or field safety corrective action• Improve the usability, performance and safety

Analysis of clinical data (clinical investigation, clinical experience and/or clinical literature review):• Demonstrate conformity with the essential requirements• Demonstrate/confirm clinical safety & performance,

risk/benefit assessment (support labelling claims)

Continuous iterative process throughout the entire lifecycle of a device, requiring regular systematic updating:• Risk Analysis, estimation, evaluation,

assessment, control, residual risk • Impact analysis of any change (design,

production, condition of use, …etc)

QM-based interlinked activities

8

Page 9: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

Risk Management Scope

• Market introduction of PAS in 2000

• >10 Million units of Macopharma PAS have been supplied to 55 countries

• PAS is CE class III MD, covering 15 references

• Compliance with current standards for RM

Regular review of Risk Management process related to Design, Production and Usability of PAS:

• Individual/Global residual risk assessment

• Risk reduction and control measures are in place

• Residual risk is considered acceptable

• Risk/Benefit assessment outcome: Clinical benefits outweigh residual risks

R&D

Process/ProductValidation

Industrialization

Distribution, Warehouse

Processing

Application/ Administration

Disposal

Pro

du

ctLi

fe C

ycle

9

Page 10: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

• >7 Mio units of PAS included in HV programmesof 15 countries

• 89 Haemovigilance- and related reports reviewed

• State-of-the-art reviews (Databases, Journals, Registries, Presentations/Abstracts, Customer Surveys, etc.)

• Pre- and post-market clinical studies

Haemovigilance Scope

10

Page 11: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

SHOT Report 2016

11

Recommendation• Platelets suspended in platelet additive solution (PAS) are associated with a reduction in allergic response (BSH Estcourt et al. 2017). Hospitals should consider preferential use of readily available pooled platelets suspended in PAS in patients with a history of allergic reactions. This should include paediatric patients where apheresis platelets are usually the platelet component of choice. If reactions continue, despite antihistamine cover, then platelets resuspended in 100% PAS can be supplied

Page 12: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

SHOT Report

12

Reactions related to thenumber of issues fromUK Blood Services

Implementation pooledplatelets in PAS-ESHOT Report 2016

Page 13: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

13

Rate of allergic reactions 2014 to 2016

SHOT Report

SHOT Report 2016

Page 14: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

NZ Blood

14

Annual numberof bloodcomponentstransfused

Annual Report 2016, NZ Blood

Page 15: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

Reported events 2009-2014 by type of platelet component transfused (imputability score ≥3):

0.640.59

0.85

0.27

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

Plasma PAS

Rat

e a

s%

of

un

its

tran

sf

Adverse events

APC BC

0.36

0.19

0.38

0.15

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

Plasma PAS

Rat

e a

s%

of

un

its

tran

sf

Allergic events

APC BC

15

NZ Blood

p = 0.001

Adapted from Annual Report 2014, NZ Blood

APC: Apheresis plateletsBC: Pooled buffy coat platelets

Page 16: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

16

Swissmedic HV Report

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Platelet units

issued

27,600 29,600 29,900 33,068 34,265 34,750 35,328 36,439 38,374

Adverse

reactions

1/178 No data No data No data ~ 1/350 ~ 1/380 ~ 1/350 ~ 1/350 ~1/350

Allergic

reactions

~ 1/300 ~ 1/670 ~ 1/500 1/568 ~ 1/500 ~ 1/500 ~ 1/500 ~ 1/650 ~1/500

Annual TR reporting rates 2008-2016 related to the number of PCs issued:

Implementation ofuniversal PI

Adapted from Swissmedic HV Reports 2008-2016

Implementation of PAS(-E)

Page 17: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

17

Transfusion reactions 2008-2011

PC

2011-2015

PI-PC

Units transfused 93,600 167,200

Risk = 1 reaction per x PC Reports Risk Reports Risk

All high-imputability reports 344 ~ 1/ 270 448 ~ 1/ 375 P<0.001

High-imputability reports,

Grade 3 & 4

33 ~1/ 2800 19 ~ 1/ 8800 P<0.001

Reported transfusion reactions involving conventional and pathogen-inactivated PC:

Swissmedic HV Report

PC: platelet concentrate

PI-PC: pathogen-inactivated platelet concentrate

Adapted from Swissmedic HV Reports 2008-2015

Page 18: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

THERAFLEX UV-Platelets

Principle:

• UVC light only, NO photoactive agent needed• DNA/RNA directly absorbs UVC light

Process:

• Platelets suspended in SSP+ (PAS-E)• Agitation + UVC treatment (<1min)• Fast processing and release

Clinical Studies

18

Page 19: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

Type of Study Objective(s) Design, Type of control n Study population Ref.

Observational post-

market study

Recovery & CCI of platelets in SSP+

compared with platelets in plasma

Plasma platelets 3940 Txn patients Tardivel et al. ISBT

2012

Recovery and

Survival

post-transfusion recovery and life-span of

platelets in SSP+

Open label;

fresh platelets

12 healthy subjects Cardigan et al.

2008

Recovery and

Survival

post-transfusion recovery and life-span of

platelets in SSP+ treated with UVC-PRT

Open label; Non-treated

fresh platelets

12 healthy subjects Bashir et al.

Transfusion. 2012

Recovery and

Survival

post-transfusion recovery and life-span of

platelets in SSP+ treated with UVC-PRT

Open label; Non-treated

stored platelets

37 healthy subjects Blajchman et al.

2010

Phase I

Safety & Tolerance

safety and tolerance of platelets in SSP+

treated with UVC-PRT;

Open label; Non-

controlled

11 healthy subjects Thiele et al. Vox

sanguinis. 2015

Phase III „CAPTURE“

Efficacy

Efficacy (CCI) and safety of SSP+ platelets

treated with UVC-PRT

RCT, Non-treated

platelets

150 patients ongoing

• Neither adverse reactions, nor antibody formation were observed

• Outlook: Post-Market surveillance studies are planned to evaluatethe safety of THERAFLEX UVC-treated platelets suspended in SSP+

Clinical Studies

19

Page 20: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

• Use of platelets suspended in platelet additive solution (PAS) is associated with a reduction in allergic response

• No (s)AE/AR related to PAS-E/SSP+ have been reported in routine use, regardlessof supply volume or extend of use

• No (s)AE/AR related to PAS-E/SSP+ have been reported in clinical studies

• Risk/Benefit ratio has been considered/remains up-to-date and acceptable forboth users and patients

• National HV reports are a valuable source for safety information for transfusion services and manufacturers

Conclusions

20

Page 21: PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT ... · PAS-E PLATELET ADDITIVE SOLUTION HAEMOVIGILANCE REPORT, RESIDUAL RISK AND RISK/BENEFIT UPDATE Chryslain Sumian, Frank

Thanks for your attention!