internal control and accounting …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/isys.pdfii...

27
INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS Qualifications and Credit Framework Level 4 Diploma in Accounting

Upload: phungdien

Post on 07-Mar-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

Qualifications and Credit Framework

Level 4 Diploma in Accounting

Page 2: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

ii

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.

Published by Kaplan Publishing UK Unit 2, The Business Centre Molly Millars Lane Wokingham Berkshire RG41 2QZ

ISBN 978-1-78415-401-1

The text in this material and any others made available by any Kaplan Group company does not amount to advice on a particular matter and should not be taken as such. No reliance should be placed on the content as the basis for any investment or other decision or in connection with any advice given to third parties. Please consult your appropriate professional adviser as necessary. Kaplan Publishing Limited and all other Kaplan group companies expressly disclaim all liability to any person in respect of any losses or other claims, whether direct, indirect, incidental, and consequential or otherwise arising in relation to the use of such materials.

© Kaplan Financial Limited, 2015

Printed and bound in Great Britain.

We are grateful to the Association of Accounting Technicians for permission to reproduce past assessment materials and example tasks based on the new syllabus. The solutions to past answers and similar activities in the style of the new syllabus have been prepared by Kaplan Publishing.

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of Kaplan Publishing.

Page 3: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

iii

iii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

CONTENTS Introduction v

Unit guide vii

The assessment xv

Study skills xvii

STUDY TEXT AND WORKBOOK

Chapter Study text

Key techniques activities

Question Answer

1 Report writing 1

2 The purposes and uses of accounting statements

53

3 The organisation − Activities 1 – 3

89281 291

4 The organisation’s environment − Activities 4 – 5

87282 296

5 Fraud in an accounting system − Activity 6

115283 299

6 Internal review − Activity 7

145284 299

7 Information systems – Activity 8

189286 302

8 Improving the system – Activities 9 – 11

221286 303

Page 4: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

iv

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Page

Specimen case study 313

Specimen case study: Guidance notes 325

Specimen case study: Solution with mapping document

337

Index I.1

Page 5: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

v

v INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

INTRODUCTION

HOW TO USE THESE MATERIALS

These Kaplan Publishing learning materials have been carefully designed to make your learning experience as easy as possible and to give you the best chance of success in your AAT assessments.

They contain a number of features to help you in the study process.

The sections on the Unit Guide, the Assessment and Study Skills should be read before you commence your studies.

They are designed to familiarise you with the nature and content of the assessment and to give you tips on how best to approach your studies.

STUDY TEXT

This study text has been specially prepared for the revised AAT qualification introduced in September 2013.

It is written in a practical and interactive style:

• key terms and concepts are clearly defined

• all topics are illustrated with practical examples with clearly workedsolutions

• frequent practice activities throughout the chapters ensure thatwhat you have learnt is regularly reinforced.

Page 6: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

vi

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

ICONS

The study chapters include the following icons throughout.

They are designed to assist you in your studies by identifying key definitions and the points at which you can test yourself on the knowledge gained.

Definition

These sections explain important areas of Knowledge which must be understood and reproduced in an assessment.

Example

The illustrative examples can be used to help develop an understanding of topics before attempting the activity exercises.

Activity

These are exercises which give the opportunity to assess your understanding of all the assessment areas.

Quality and accuracy are of the utmost importance to us so if you spot an error in any of our products, please send an email to [email protected] with full details, or follow the link to the feedback form in MyKaplan.

Our Quality Co-ordinator will work with our technical team to verify the error and take action to ensure it is corrected in future editions.

Page 7: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

vii

vii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

UNIT GUIDE

Purpose of the unit

The AAT has stated that the general purpose of the unit is to ensure that learners know and understand the role of accounting in an organisation and why internal controls should be in place. They should be able to recognise systemic weaknesses where errors or fraud may occur. Learners should be able to evaluate an accounting system, or part of a system (either based on a real situation or a scenario) paying attention to any ethical considerations and identifying where actual or possible breaches in professional ethics may exist.

Learners must then be able to make recommendations for improvement. Learners may draw upon their knowledge and experience gained in completing other units within this qualification.

Another purpose of this unit is to ensure that learners are able to communicate clearly, both orally and in writing, at level 4 standards (degree standard) and in a manner appropriate to the workplace. This will form part of the assessment.

Learning objectives

On completion of this unit the learner will be able to:

• Understand the principles of internal control.

• Make recommendations on how to implement or improve a system.

• Evaluate the accounting systems within an organisation.

• Evaluate the organisation from the perspective of its ethical stance and in terms of sustainability.

• Explain where improvements could be made.

Page 8: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

viii

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Learning Outcomes and Assessment Criteria

The unit consists of six learning outcomes, which are further broken down into Assessment Criteria. These are set out in the following table with Learning Outcomes in bold type and Assessment criteria listed underneath each Learning Outcome. Reference is also made to the relevant chapter within the text.

Performance Criteria

To perform this unit effectively you will need to know and understand the following:

Chapter 1 Understand the role of accounting within the

organisation

1.1 Describe the purpose, structure and organisation of the accounting function and its relationship with other functions within the organisation

2, 3

1.2 Explain the various business purposes for which the following financial information is required – statement of profit or loss, statement of cash flow and statement of financial position

2

1.3 Give an overview of the organisation’s business and its critical external relationships with stakeholders

2, 4

1.4 Explain how the accounting systems are affected by the organisational structure, systems, procedures and business transactions

2, 3

1.5 Explain the effect on users of changes to accounting systems caused by external regulations and organisational policies and procedures

2, 4

2 Understand the importance and use of internal controls

2.1 Identify the external regulations that affect accounting practice

2

2.2 Describe the causes of and common types of fraud and the impact of this on the organisation

5

Page 9: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

ix

ix INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Chapter 2.3 Explain methods that can be used to detect fraud

within an accounting system 5

2.4 Explain the types of controls that can be put in place to ensure compliance with statutory or organisational requirements

5, 7

2.5 Explain how an internal control system can support the accounting function

6, 7

3 Evaluate the accounting system and identify areas for improvement

3.1 Identify an organisation’s accounting system, including hardware and software packages

6, 8

3.2 Review record keeping systems to confirm whether they meet organisational requirement

8

3.3 Identify weaknesses in and the potential for improvements to the accounting system and consider their impact on the operation of the organisation

6, 8

3.4 Identify potential areas of fraud arising from lack of control within the accounting system and evaluate the risk

8

3.5 Review methods of operating for cost effectiveness, reliability and speed

8

4 Conduct an ethical evaluation of the accounting system

4.1 Evaluate the accounting system against ethical principles

6

4.2 Identify actual or possible breaches of professional ethics

6

5 Conduct a sustainability evaluation of the accounting system

5.1 Evaluate the accounting system against sustainability principles

6

5.2 Identify where improvements could be made to improve sustainability

6

Page 10: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

x

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Chapter 6 Make recommendations to improve the

accounting system

6.1 Make recommendations for changes to the accounting system, including ethical and sustainability considerations with a clear rationale and an explanation of any assumptions made

8

6.2 Identify the effects that any changes would have on the users of the system

8

6.3 Enable individuals to understand how to use the accounting system by use of training, manuals, written information or help menus

6, 8

6.4 Identify the implications of recommended changes in terms of time, financial costs, benefits and operating procedures

8

Page 11: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xi

xi INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Delivery guidance

The AAT have provided delivery guidance giving further details of the way in which the unit will be assessed. The role of accounting within the organisation Students should be able to give an overview of the organisation they are reviewing which may be a real work place or the case study scenario. They should also be able to balance the needs between various stakeholders and be able to identify the key external relationships held. This may include shareholders, banks, suppliers and the Government amongst others. The student needs to appreciate that the stakeholders will change depending on the nature of organisation under review.

Inter-departmental relationships should be identified and the overall structure, purpose and organisation of the accounting function should be clearly defined. Students need to be clear on the financial statements.

Students should be able to determine what type of system the organisation requires depending on the size and nature of the business. They should be able to identify what the system should be capable of doing in terms of the types of reports produced, the transactions and processing needed and the requirement of an audit trail, for example. The benefits of different systems, accounting software and type of hardware available should be examined and explained.

Evaluate the accounting system and identify areas for improvement The accounting system should be reviewed to see whether the system requirements, identified above, matches the current accounting system of the organisation. The strengths and weaknesses of the system should then be analysed (including the current working practices) to see whether the organisation is operating at optimum levels. This should include efficiencies in terms of time, financial costs, benefits and operating procedures.

An accounting system may cover all accounting functions including, but not restricted to, sales, purchases and nominal ledgers, credit control, banking, payroll, petty cash, budgeting and management reporting. All of these may be evaluated in a small organisation with a simple structure, or just one or two areas may be evaluated in a larger, more complex, organisation.

Students are also required to have a good understanding of the regulations surrounding the preparation of the accounts and its accounting practices. These would include the laws which are relevant due to the status of the organisation and accounting standards.

Page 12: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xii

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

The importance and use of internal control systems Fraud is an issue for any business and students should be aware of the common types which may occur in a business. They should consider the implications the fraud (financial, reputation and operationally) will have on the organisation. The methods used to detect the fraud should be identified and the procedures in place to prevent it happening initially. The student needs to consider other internal control mechanisms necessary to meet organisational and/or statutory requirements.

When reviewing the internal control system the student should evaluate the particular areas which leave the business open to fraudulent activity, or errors. The potential for fraud should be highlighted and the level of risk graded in terms of impact and probability. The risk can be graded as 1 (minimal) to 5 (high) or simply as low, medium and high.

Potential fraud equates to potential loss. The types of loss can be monetary, inventory or time based. There are many examples, developed later in this text, but could include ghost employees (payroll), over-ordering of stock for personal use (inventory), fictitious trade payable being set up (accounts payable) to name but a few.

Conduct an ethical evaluation of the accounting systems Using their knowledge of the five fundamental principles of professional ethics, students should evaluate the accounting system for any actual or possible breaches. The company’s corporate code of ethics should also be evaluated against the principles which are confidentiality, integrity, professional behaviour, objectivity and professional competence.

Conduct a sustainability evaluation of the accounting system A sustainability review should be undertaken by the student with a view to making possible improvements. The impact of the organisation on the environment, the economy or society in general should be considered. Examples of this could be to reduce the carbon footprint, reduce the use of natural resources (paper, electricity, petrol etc) or improving corporate social responsibility.

All weaknesses identified within the accounting system (whether by means of error, fraud, breach of ethics or a sustainability issue) should be expanded to consider their impact on the organisation with the important factors being in terms of time, money or reputation.

Page 13: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xiii

xiii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Make recommendations to improve the accounting system For every weakness identified in the accounting system there must be at least one clear and sensible recommendation, which should include improving the areas of ethics and sustainability within the organisation. If the student has identified a number of ways in which a weakness can be remedied they should state all the possibilities and then conclude which is the preferred solution. The recommendation must be fully justified.

All recommendations should be fully quantified in terms of the cost of the proposal and the associated savings. The total benefits should exceed, or outweigh, the costs involved. Where qualitative benefits may sometimes prove difficult to state in monetary terms, for example, an increase in motivation due to the sharing of responsibilities, the costs of implementing a recommendation should always be quantified. If the student is unsure as to the exact amount then estimates and assumptions are encouraged rather than ignoring them.

Everything has a cost and the student should appreciate that time is both a cost (if incurred) and a benefit (if saved). When calculating the cost of writing new procedure notes, for example, the time to write the report is considered plus on-costs (assume 15% – this covers employers’ national insurance contributions and other staff benefits). Furthermore if an employee is to be sent on a training course, in addition to the training cost itself, the time of the employee must be factored in (lost opportunity cost) plus the on-costs.

Staff will be affected by change and therefore the student must be able to anticipate what effect the recommendations will have on them. They must be aware of how the systems in place may need to change with regards to training and the updating of necessary skills and knowledge. Any training which is to be provided, external or internal courses, would need to be costed out and the use of manuals, help menus and written documentation, such as procedure notes, should be included. All recommendations must consider the need for staff training.

Page 14: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xiv

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Page 15: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xv

xv INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

THE ASSESSMENT

The format of the assessment

The assessment will take the form of a formal report It will be written by the learner and assessed locally by the training provider.

The 4,000-word report can be based on the workplace or an AAT on-line case study. The report must cover all the assessment criteria for all six learning outcomes.

The report should be:

• Written in the third person.

• Spelling and grammar should be of a suitable level for a business report.

• Word processed. The review of the organisation and its accounting system should specifically cover:

• Record keeping systems – this is where the student will identify the purpose of the financial reports and then consider how those reports meet the organisation’s needs.

• Internal systems of control – the student will look to see how the accounting system and the internal control mechanisms support each other and whether any key controls are missing.

• Fraud – learners should be able to identify both the causes and the common types of fraud as well as the methods used specifically to detect fraud. Some areas of a business are more prone than others and the student should carefully examine the potential in these areas.

• Working methods/practices – here the operations of the organisation are examined in terms of reliability, cost effectiveness and speed. The computer systems in place and the hardware used should also be evaluated at this point.

• Training – the way the organisation supports its staff and the way that training is used, or could be used.

Page 16: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xvi

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

• Professional ethics – the student is looking for any actual, or possible, breaches against the AAT code of ethics (refer to PEAF/PETH unit for more information)

• Sustainability – the students should first look to see whether the organisation has a sustainability policy in place and whether it is taking responsibility for its own actions. They should also look to make improvements against the principles of sustainability.

The assessment material will normally be delivered online and assessed locally. The local assessor (training provider) will be required to ensure that all assessment criteria are covered. Learners will be required to demonstrate competence across all of the assessment criteria for this learning and assessment area.

Learners have a maximum time allowance to complete the unit of six months.

Page 17: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xvii

xviiINTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

STUDY SKILLS

Preparing to study

Devise a study plan Determine which times of the week you will study.

Split these times into sessions of at least one hour for study of new material. Any shorter periods could be used for revision or practice.

Put the times you plan to study onto a study plan for the weeks from now until the assessment and set yourself targets for each period of study. n your sessions make sure you cover the whole course, activities and the associated questions in the workbook at the back of the manual.

If you are studying more than one unit at a time, try to vary your subjects as this can help to keep you interested and see subjects as part of wider knowledge.

When working through your course, compare your progress with your plan and, if necessary, re-plan your work (perhaps including extra sessions) or, if you are ahead, do some extra revision / practice questions.

Effective studying

Active reading You are not expected to learn the text by rote, rather, you must understand what you are reading and be able to use it to pass the assessment and develop good practice.

A good technique is to use SQ3Rs – Survey, Question, Read, Recall, Review:

1 Survey the chapter Look at the headings and read the introduction, knowledge, skills and content, so as to get an overview of what the chapter deals with.

2 Question Whilst undertaking the survey ask yourself the questions you hope the chapter will answer for you.

Page 18: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xviii

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Read Read through the chapter thoroughly working through the activities and, at the end, making sure that you can meet the learning objectives highlighted on the first page.

3 Recall At the end of each section and at the end of the chapter, try to recall the main ideas of the section / chapter without referring to the text. This is best done after a short break of a couple of minutes, after the reading stage.

4 Review Check that your recall notes are correct.

You may also find it helpful to re-read the chapter to try and see the topic(s) it deals with as a whole.

Note taking Taking notes is a useful way of learning, but do not simply copy out the text.

The notes must:

• be in your own words

• be concise

• cover the key points

• well organised

• be modified as you study further chapters in this text or in related ones.

Trying to summarise a chapter without referring to the text can be a useful way of determining which areas you know and which you don’t.

Three ways of taking notes 1 Summarise the key points of a chapter 2 Make linear notes

A list of headings, subdivided with sub-headings listing the key points.

If you use linear notes, you can use different colours to highlight key points and keep topic areas together.

Use plenty of space to make your notes easy to use.

Page 19: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xix

xix INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

3 Try a diagrammatic form The most common of which is a mind map.

To make a mind map, put the main heading in the centre of the paper and put a circle around it.

Draw lines radiating from this to the main sub-headings which again have circles around them.

Continue the process from the sub-headings to sub-sub-headings.

Highlighting and underlining You may find it useful to underline or highlight key points in your study text – but do be selective.

You may also wish to make notes in the margins.

Further reading

In addition to this text, you should also read the ‘Student section’ of the ‘Accounting Technician’ magazine every month to keep abreast of any guidance from the examiners.

Page 20: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

xx

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Page 21: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

1

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

Introduction Internal Control and Accounting Systems (ISYS) – is assessed by means of a project plus assessor questioning and employer testimony. The project takes the form of a report to management that analyses the internal controls and management accounting system. The report should identify how both might be enhanced to improve their effectiveness.

It is therefore essential that you know precisely how to arrange such a report and present it to management. This is a valuable skill to have, as no doubt you will be writing many more reports throughout your career.

CONTENTS

1 Assessment

2 How to produce the project

3 Reports – effective business communication

4 Structure of the report

5 Writing the report

6 Writing a report – example

7 Checklist of tasks

Report writing

Page 22: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

2

Report writing: Chapter 1

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

1 Assessment

1.1 Introduction It is easy to think that the final level of your AAT qualifications consists only of computer based tests. However, there is a project to be undertaken which is equally important to any of the other assessments you do and you must therefore give this as much attention as your studying and revision for any of the other units.

This guide has been designed for any student as an aid to writing and presenting your report and completing this unit successfully. It is not meant to be followed slavishly or to be prescriptive but as a rough outline and guide to what the AAT is looking for in a proving competence in this unit.

1.2 Nature of the project The project takes the form of a report to management that analyses the internal control and management of accounting systems. It should identify how both might be enhanced to improve their effectiveness. In producing this report students will need to prove competence in the co-ordination of work activities and the identification and grading of fraud in that system. Students must be able to identify weaknesses and make recommendations for improvement. All changes made must be monitored and reviewed for their effectiveness.

The total length of the project (excluding appendices) should be approximately 4000 words. An appropriate manager should attest to the originality, authenticity and quality of the project report. The project should be based on an actual accounting function, or part-function, within the student’s workplace in the present or recent past.

There are three ways of approaching the project depending on your own circumstances.

1 You actually manage an accounting function – therefore you can use your own real work experiences to prove your ability to meet the competencies of the accounting standards.

2 You work in the accounting environment – therefore you will have to observe, talk to managers and staff and critically analyse their performance to make recommendations that prove that you understand and could meet the required level of competence if given the opportunity.

Page 23: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

3 KAPLAN PUBLISHING

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

3 You may be able to identify ideas from other accounting systems experience in a voluntary organisation, club or charity.

Alternatively, you will have to use the AAT case study. This is a case study that should enable you to observe a scenario and critically analyse it and make recommendations that prove that you understand and could meet the required level of competence if given the opportunity. Whichever approach you use, the assessment is the same:

• 4,000 word report

• assessor interview/questioning

• employer testimony.

1.3 Skill building The use of a formal written report to assess this unit is to ensure that you have gained a wider range of skills than those assessed by examination. These include:

• Planning skills – you will need to plan all aspects of the recommendations that you make, plan for any contingencies and plan for the consequences of any changes made.

• Analytical skills – the report is analytical in nature, not descriptive. You will need to be able to analyse a current situation in a clear non-judgemental manner.

• Research skills – the report and recommendations will need to be researched and evidence of that included in the appendices. Research tools used need to be listed in the methodology.

• Report writing skills – a skill you will need to use in your career.

• Communication skills – a necessary skill which often proves lacking at interview.

• Time management skills – management skills needed to ensure that all aspects of the report are completed on schedule.

1.4 The Approved Assessment Centre’s (AAC) role The AAC should undertake the following steps.

• Make an initial assessment of the project idea.

• Use one-to-one sessions to advise and support the student.

• Encourage workplace mentors to participate (testimony, etc.)

• Ensure the project is the student’s original work.

• Use formative assessments and action plans to guide the student.

Page 24: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

4

Report writing: Chapter 1

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

• Undertake summative assessment against performance criteria.

• Sign off each performance criterion.

• Conduct a final assessment interview with documented questioning.

1.5 Your role As an AAT student it is your responsibility to choose a topic or theme for your project that will generate high quality evidence. You will need this to prove to your assessor and verifier that you are competent against the standards.

To do this you will need to think about which of your activities are relevant and how you can use these to build a report, which will demonstrate your competence. It is important that you regard not just the writing of the report but the presentation of the final product as being an opportunity for you to develop.

It is your duty to reference the report against the accounting standards and performance criteria. This is to ensure that you have covered every aspect and to easily guide the assessor and verifier through your report.

Remember, that with the aid of your assessor, it is your responsibility to:

• meet with the assessor at agreed times

• identify your theme for the project

• draft the report

• map to the standards

• present the final report

• keep your assessor informed about your progress – stick to target dates and deadlines.

You should ensure that the project’s format is such that it: • covers all assessment criteria • covers the objectives set out in the Terms of Reference of the

project, is well laid out, easy to read and includes an executive summary

• uses report form style with appropriate language • shows clear progression from one idea to the next • cross-refers the main text to any appendices • uses diagrams and flowcharts appropriately • starts each section on a fresh page.

Page 25: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

5 KAPLAN PUBLISHING

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

You should ensure that the project’s content is such that:

• issues and objectives are clearly identified

• the current situation is clearly analysed

• recommendations are subjected to cost-benefit analysis

• key data is included and superfluous detail is omitted

• the methodology is fully described

• a strategic approach is taken

• the project focuses on company needs, not personal feelings.

1.6 Workplace mentor It is essential that you receive support and guidance from your employer as well as your assessor throughout every stage of your project. It is, after all, your employer who will stand to benefit from this free consultancy work that you are doing. They will also have a greater understanding about your chosen topic than your assessor can have.

It is therefore strongly recommended that you arrange for someone to be a workplace mentor. Your mentor does not have to be your manager but should be someone who can help you through your project, providing both technical and motivational support. You should ensure that your mentor is involved in your work from the outset and understands the standards and timescales you are working to. They may be able to offer guidance on suitable ideas for the project by identifying current problems either in your workplace or that of clients. They may also help with the planning of work and ‘opening doors’ to introduce you to key staff. It may be helpful to find someone who has recently written a report themselves, perhaps as part of their own studies.

Page 26: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

6

Report writing: Chapter 1

KAPLAN PUBLISHING

2 How to produce the project

2.1 Introduction This introduction contains detailed and practical guidance on how to produce your project and should be read very carefully before you start.

The steps involved in producing the project can be summarised practically as follows.

1 Initial planning • Think of a suitable topic.

• Address the performance criteria.

• Check suitability with your manager at work. Perform initial research. Submit a project plan to your assessor.

2 Consider plan • Your assessor considers the project plan and assesses whether you can begin writing the report.

3 Research • Set up a research file.

• Make notes from this text, producing answers to guidance checklists at the end of each chapter.

• Speak to people in work who have the knowledge and experience you need to successfully deal with the criteria.

4 Write up, using Chapter 1 of this text

• The project should be approximately 4,000 words excluding Appendices.

• Report writing and presentation skills will be important.

5 Assessment process

• Your assessor will assess your report and provide feedback on how well you have done.

Each of these steps is covered in detail below.

Page 27: INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING …kaplan-publishing.kaplan.co.uk/.../study-texts/ISYS.pdfii INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS KAPLAN PUBLISHING British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication

7 KAPLAN PUBLISHING

INTERNAL CONTROL AND ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS

2.2 Initial planning An interesting topic Choosing the topic is a very important part of the project. Get this right and you are halfway there – get it wrong and you can waste many hours trying to write a report on something where you have very little evidence. The final decision is yours in negotiation with your assessor. There are various ways to choose your topic.

• Identify a weakness in a system in your own area of work.

• Ask your college for a list of topics that have led to successful projects.

• Think about your department and ask ‘what would I do differently to make the process or system better?’ Are there areas that you think could be improved?

• Ask your line manager and other colleagues for ideas about something which could be improved at work.

• Look at a similar report at work. Although the project has to be your own original work, you will be able to get an idea of how your final report will look, the writing style and what each section contains.

• Analyse the various work functions e.g. payroll, purchase ledger, capital expenditure, reconciliation, petty cash, control systems etc. – are they well managed? Is there a weakness in the chain that could be improved? Are there any gaps?

• Determine whether the company is actually, or possibly, breaching any of the fundamental ethical principles – confidentiality; professional competence and due care; integrity; objectivity; professional behaviour.

• Perform an evaluation of sustainability with the accounting system identifying any areas which you feel could be improved. As sustainability is still a voluntary choice for business there should be plenty of scope here.

Before looking at possible topics, it is important to remember that the best project for you will be the one that interests you and which is relevant to your workplace. A selection of possible topics is listed below:

• Relationship between the treasury department and the accounts department, including appraisal of internal procedures.

• Issues arising from a change of ownership of a business and the effect upon staff roles.

• Problems arising from complex sales pricing and invoicing and their effects upon staff efficiency.