pee lab 3 (specific gravity)
TRANSCRIPT
ABUBAKAR TAFAWA BALEWA UNIVERSITY,
PMB 0248, BAUCHI
SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING AND ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY
PETROLEUM ENGINEERING PROGRAMME
PETROLEUM ENGINEERING LABORATORY REPORT
FIRST SEMESTER, 2011/2012 SESSION
EXPERIMENT 3: SPECIFIC GRAVITY OF SOIL PARTICLES
NAME: ISAAC CHUKWUDI VICTOR CHIMEZIE
REG. No.: 09/21700/U/2
LEVEL: 300
COURSE CODE: PEE 315
SUPERVISOR: SULEIMAN A. MOHAMMED
ABSTRACT
Specific gravity of the soil grains is an important property and is used to determine the voids
ratio, porosity, and degree of saturation if density and water content are known.
Density, as applied to any kind of homogeneous monophasic material of mass M and
volume V, is expressed as the ratio of M to V. Under specified conditions, this definition
leads to unique values that represent a well-defined property of the material. For
heterogeneous and multiphasic materials, however, such as porous media, application of
this definition can lead to different results, depending on the exact way the mass and
volume of the system are defined.
The soil particle density of a soil sample is calculated on the basis of the measurement of
two quantities: (1) Ms, the mass of the solid phase of the sample (dried mass) and (2) Vs, the
volume of the solid phase. Assuming that water is the only volatile in a soil sample, the mass
(Ms) can be obtained by drying the sample (usually at 110 ± 5C) until it reaches a constant
weight, Ws. This method may not be valid for organic soils or soils with asphalt.
The experiment conducted was carried out to determine the specific gravity of soil samples
using density bottle method.
The experiment was carried out hitch-free in the PEE Lab as all apparatus were adequately
provided and we were able to know the technical know-how on the determination of
specific gravity of soil sample.
Three (3) samples were provided i.e. Granite, Gypsum and Sandstone having Specific
Gravities of 2.5, 2.476 and 2.609 respectively. Thereafter the average was taken, which was
gotten to be 2.528.
It was therefore noted that Sandstone has the highest specific gravity followed by Granite
and Gypsum.
2 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
INTRODUCTION
At the end of this experiment, the student should have at least known the following:
1. Determination of Specific Gravity of various samples.
2. The knowledge on how to use the Density Bottle.
3. The use of specific gravity to carry out rock analysis on pore spaces.
3 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Soil is a typical heterogeneous multiphasic porous system which, in its general form,
contains three natural phases: (1) the solid phase or the soil matrix (formed by mineral
particles and solid organic materials); (2) the liquid phase, which is often represented by
water and which could more properly be called the soil solution; and (3) the gaseous phase,
which contains air and other gases. In this three-phase soil system, the concept of average
density can be used to define the following densities: (1) density of solids or soil particle
density, s; (2) bulk or dry density, b; and (3) total or wet density.
The masses and volumes associated with the three soil phases must be defined before the
definitions of the different densities that characterize the soil system can be formalized.
Thus, consider a representative elementary volume (REV) of soil that satisfies the following
criteria:
1. A sufficiently large volume of soil containing a large number of pores, such that the
concept of mean global properties is applicable, and
2. A sufficiently small volume of soil so that the variation of any parameter of the soil from
one part of the domain to another can be approximated by continuous functions.
The soil particle density, or the density of solids, represents the density of the soil (i.e.,
mineral) particles collectively and is expressed as the ratio of the solid phase mass to the
volume of the solid phase of the soil.
Relative density, or specific gravity, is the ratio of the density (mass of a unit volume) of a
substance to the density of a given reference material. Specific gravity usually means
relative density with respect to water. The term "relative density" is often preferred in
modern scientific usage.
If a substance's relative density is less than one then it is less dense than the reference; if
greater than 1 then it is denser than the reference. If the relative density is exactly 1 then
the densities are equal; that is, equal volumes of the two substances have the same mass. If
the reference material is water then a substance with a relative density (or specific gravity)
less than 1 will float in water. For example, an ice cube, with a relative density of about 0.91,
will float. A substance with a relative density greater than 1 will sink.
4 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
For the Specific Gravity of Soil Sample using Density Bottle is expressed as:
GS=w2−w1
(w¿¿ 4−w1)−(w¿¿3−w2)×Density of H 20¿¿
Where:
GS - Specific Gravity
W1 - Weight of Empty Density Bottle with Stopper
W2 - Weight of Soil Sample, Empty Density Bottle and Stopper
W3 - Weight of Empty Density Bottle, Soil Sample, Stopper and Distilled Water
W4 - Weight of Full Density Bottle, Soil Sample, Stopper and Water
In most mineral soils, the soil particle density has a short range of 2.6-2.7 g/cm3. This density
is close to that of quartz, which is usually the predominant constituent of sandy soils. A
typical value of 2.65 g/cm3 has been suggested to characterize the soil particle density of a
general mineral soil. Aluminosilicate clay minerals have particle density variations in the
same range. The presence of iron oxides and other heavy minerals increases the value of the
soil particle density. The presence of solid organic materials in the soil decreases the value.
Specific gravity values for a soil are not normally used strictly for classification purposes, but
are used in the calculation and interpretation of other test results. The specific gravity tests
specified in the British Standard (BS 1377:part 2:1990, clause 8) are relatively simple and are
based upon determination of the dry weight of a sample of the soil, and the weight of the
same sample plus water in a container of known volume. The volume of the container is
obtained by weighing the container empty, and full of water. The main problems in
conducting the test are of accurate weighing, and complete removal of the air from the soil
after the addition of water.
The method still used by most test houses to determine the particle density of fine-grained
soil utilizes a 50m1 density bottle (BS 1377:part 2:1990 clause 8.3). Unfortunately there is no
simple means of knowing when all the air has been removed from the bottle and hence the
soil must be de-aired under vacuum. The use of de-aired water will help but it is still
necessary to leave the sample in the density bottle under vacuum for several hours. The
major difficulty with this test is the provision of a satisfactory vacuum and measuring the
length of time required to remove the air completely. These factors can clearly lead to
errors in specific gravity determinations. Krawczyk (1969) found that the difficulties of de-
airing the soil could be overcome by shaking the sample instead of placing it under vacuum.
5 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
The advantages of shaking are that the shaking action is easily standardized and the removal
of air is more rapid than by the application of a vacuum. Krawczyk proposed that the test
should be carried out in a 1 litre gas jar to make the same test suitable for fine-, medium-
and coarse-grained soils and the shaking action provided by an end-over-end shaker. This
alternative method has been included in the British Standard (BS 1377:part 2:1990, clause
8.2) and should be treated as the preferred method, since in providing a more reliable
technique of de-airing the soil it yields more repeatable results.
The results of particle density tests are used in the interpretation of sedimentation test
results, to check the results of laboratory compaction tests (BS 1377:1975, clauses 4.1.4,
2.1), and to find the voids ratios of samples during consolidation tests. Incorrect particle
density values affect the position of the voids ratio vs. logarithm of pressure plot for an
oedometer consolidation test but they do not affect the values of the coefficients of
consolidation (Cv) or compressibility (Mv). A change in particle density leads to a different
particle size distribution from the sedimentation test, but the difference is not large and is
probably considerably less than the effects of natural soil variability or the assumptions
involved in the test.
The major problem arising from an incorrect particle density determination is that of the
credibility of compaction tests carried out on the same soil. A low particle density value will
push the zero air voids line on a dry density/moisture content plot down and to the left, and
may show compaction test results to be apparently impossible (and therefore inaccurate) as
they cross over the zero air voids line.
Its value helps to some extent in identification and classification of solids. It gives an idea
about the stability of soil as a construction material; higher value of specific gravity gives
more strength for roads and foundation. It is used in comparing the soil particle size by
means of hydrometer analysis. It is also used in estimation of critical hydraulic gradient in
soil when sand boiling condition is being studied and in zero air void calculation in the
compaction theory of solids.
Its value ranges as follows:
1. Coarse grained soils: 2.6 to 2.7
2. Fine grained soil: 2.7 to 2.8
3. Organic soil: 2.3 to 2.5
6 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
PROCEDURE
1. The density bottle was weight completely with a stopper after it was being dried
completely to obtain (W1).
2. 5g of soil passing the 2mm BS sieve was riffled from a large sample, oven dry sample at
105 – 110OC and was cooled in a desiccator and placed in the density – bottle. The soil,
bottle and stopper were weighed together to obtain W2.
3. Water was added to the bottle to cover the soil and was gently subjected to a vacuum
in the desiccator for one hour to avoid rigorous boiling until air was no more seen.
4. The bottle was vibrated and the process was then repeated until air was no longer
released.
5. Thereafter, more de-aired distilled water was added to fill the bottle.
6. The stopper was then fitted and the whole left at a constant temperature of 20OC for 1
hour.
7. The density bottle (empty), stopper, soil sand and distilled water was thereafter
weighed to get W3.
8. The bottle was thoroughly cleaned and filled with water. It was then allowed to stand
for 1 hour. There was no apparent decrease in water volume hence there was no need
for the bottle to be topped – up and allowed to stand for a further period of time.
7 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
INSTRUMENTATION
1. Density Bottle
2. Stopper
3. Water (Distilled)
4. Desiccator
5. Thermometer
6. Weighing Balance
SAMPLES USED
1. Granite
2. Gypsum
3. Sandstone
8 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
9 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
SAMPLES USED
Granite (g) Gypsum (g) Sandstone (g)
Weight (g) Mass (g) 5.0 5.0 5.0
W1 – Empty Bottle + Stopper - 19.0 19.0 19.0
W2 – Sample + Empty Bottle + Stopper - 24.0 24.2 25.0
W3 – Sample + Water + Bottle + Stopper - 46.7 46.8 47.4
W4 – Sample + Water + Full Bottle + Stopper - 43.7 43.7 43.7
Specific Gravity 2.5 2.467 2.609
Average Specific Gravity 2.528 2.528 2.528
DISCUSSION
The experiment was conducted successfully without any problems as all necessary
help provided.
As earlier mentioned, the specific gravity of the samples was calculated and
Sandstone was observed to have the highest specific gravity of 2.609 followed by Granite,
which had a Specific Gravity of 2.5 and lastly Gypsum, having 2.467. The average specific
gravity was calculated to be 2.528.
10 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
RECOMMENDATION
The density bottle is the main apparatus, which was being used during the
experiment is used in determining the specific gravity or relative density of substances.
The experiment was carried out successfully in the PEE Laboratory without any
interference but I strongly recommend that de-aired distilled water be used instead of
ordinary water so as to prevent minor alterations in results.
11 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
CONCLUSION
The experiment was conducted successfully in the laboratory and hence the aim of
the experiment was achieved. It was discovered that the specific gravity of different soil
samples vary. From the ones provided: Granite, Gypsum and Sandstone, it was observed
that Gypsum had the lowest specific gravity followed by Granite while Sandstone had the
highest specific gravity holding a value of 2.609.
APPENDIX
12 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
Calculation for the Specific Gravity
GS=w2−w1
(w¿¿ 4−w1)−(w¿¿3−w2)×Density of H 20¿¿
GS - Specific Gravity
W1 - Weight of Empty Density Bottle with Stopper
W2 - Weight of Soil Sample, Empty Density Bottle and Stopper
W3 - Weight of Empty Density Bottle, Soil Sample, Stopper and Distilled Water
W4 - Weight of Full Density Bottle, Soil Sample, Stopper and Water
Density of Water = 1.0g/cm3
For Granite:
W1 = 19.0g W2 = 24.0g W3 = 46.7g W4 = 43.7g
GS= 24−19(43.7−19 )−(46.7−24)
GS=52
GS=2.5
For Gypsum:
W1 = 19.0g W2 = 24.2g W3 = 46.8g W4 = 43.7g
GS= 24.2−19(43.7−19 )−(46.8−24.2)
GS=5.22.1
GS=2.476
For Sandstone:
W1 = 19.0g W2 = 25.0g W3 = 47.4g W4 = 43.7g
GS= 25−19(43.7−19 )−(47.4−25)
GS= 62 .3
GS=2.609
13 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Engineer Manual (1970), Laboratory Soil Testing. Engineering and Design. EM 1110-2-1906
Fox R. W. McDonald, A. T. (2003), Introduction to Fluid Mechanics. 4th Edition. Wiley. USA
Jackie Chee (2007), Pet E 327 Lab Report #1, Alberta, Canada
UNESCO-NIGERIA Technical & Vocational Education, Hydrogeology Practical Manual
Laboratory Manual, Determination of Specific Gravity using Density Bottle Method
www.articlebase.com
www.civilengineering.com/papers/soil_sample/relative_density/wk12239820.htm
www.wikipedia.com/en/density_bottle.htm
www.wikipedia.com/en/relative_density.htm
www.wikipedia.com/en/soil_density.htm
14 | S p e c i f i c G r a v i t y o f S o i l P a r t i c l e s 0 9 / 2 1 7 0 0 / U / 2