perfor m ance measure m ent and co m parison of h y brid ... m oza , a ssistant profe ssor-me...

4
) M R E J I ( t n e m e g a n a M d n A h c r a e s e R g n i r e e n i g n E f o l a n r u o J l a n o i t a n r e t n I 9 4 3 2 : N S S I - e m u l o V , 8 5 0 2 - e u s s I , 2 0 - 5 1 0 2 l i r p A , 4 0 0 5 1 m o c . m r e j i . w w w t c a r t s b A h c r a e s e r s u o d n e m e r t , t n e c e r t A s i k r o w d e i r r a c o t g n i r e e n i g n e e l i b o m o t u a f o d l e i f e h t n i t u o d n a n o i t e l p e d l e u f l a n o i t n e v n o c f o m e l b o r p e h t t c a r e t n u o c l u f m r a h o p . s n o i s s i m e t n a t u l l n e e b s a h s e l c i h e v c i r t c e l E t n a t u l l o p d e c u d e r d n a t s o c g n i n n u r w o l r o f d e v o r p l e u f l a n o i t n e v n o c y b d e r e w o p e l c i h e v d e r a p m o c n o i s s i m e . l e s e i d d n a e n i l o s a g e k i l , r e v e w o H t o n e r a s e l c i h e v c i r t c e l e d n a e l c i h e v f o e g n a r w o l f o e s u a c e b r a l u p o p e r i u q e r g n o l e r e h W . e m i t g n i g r a h c , s a e l c i h e v d e r e w o p e n i g n e C I r e h g i h d n a e m i t g n i l l i f e r r e l l a m s , e g n a r r e g n o l s e d i v o r p . d e e p s g n i s i u r c t a y c n e i c i f f e d a o l t r a p g n i r u d , r e v e w o H l u f m r a h r e h g i h , e n i g n E C I d e s a b e n i l o s a G f o n o i t a r e p o o o p d n a n o i s s i m e t n a t u l l o p . d e v r e s b o s i y m o n o c e l e u f r A r e l e e h w o w t d i r b y h s i p a t o t d e p o l e v e d f o e g a t n a v d a e h t d e e p s g n i s i u r c t a y c n e i c i f f e r e h g i h d n a e g n a r g n o l C I f o e n i g n E w o l t a n o i t a r e p o t n e i c i f f e & s n o i s s i m e r e w o l d n a d e e p s . r e w o p c i r t c e l e f o d i r b y h e h T S E y t o o c S S V T o w t e h w h t i w y t i c a r a d o d a V n i d e t s e t s i r e l e s n o i t i d n o c g n i v i r d g n i s i u r c t a g n i v i r d d n a g n i v i r d y t i c d e t s e g n o c e v l o v n i 1 s w o h s t l u s e r e h T . d e e p s 1 4 . 1 l e u f n i t n e m e v o r p m i % d e s a b e n i l o s a g l a n o i t n e v n o c o t d e r a p m o c n o i t p m u s n o c . r e l e e h w o w t s m r e T x e d n I c i r t c e l E i h e v C I , r e w o p d i r b y H , l e u F , e l c e n i g n E . I I N O I T C U D O R T N f o s m e l b o r p e r e v e s g n i c a f y l t n e r r u c s i d l r o w e l i b o m o t u A n o i s s i m e n e h t g n e r t s y l r a l u g e r d n a s l e u f l i s s o f f o n o i t e l p e d . s m r o n e v i t a n r e t l a f o d l e i f e h t n i d e i r r a c n e e b s a h h c r a e s e R n i a r t r e w o p e t a n r e t l a d n a s l e u f y g r e n e e l b a w e n e r , y g o l o n h c e t . y g o l o n h c e t d i r b y h d n a n i t n e m e v o r p m i n w o h s s a h l e u f o i B e r u t c u r t s a r f n i d n a y t i l i b a l i a v a r e v e w o h n r e c n o c s i h t . e g r a l e t i u q s i t n e m e r i u q e r e k i l s e c r u o s y g r e n e e l b a w e n e R n e m p o l e v e d y g o l o n h c e t t u b l a i t n e t o p d o o g e v a h y g r e n e r a l o s t . s s e r g o r p r e d n u l l i t s s i n w o h s s a h e l c i h e v d e r e w o p c i r t c e l E e c n a t p e c c a y l b a k r a m e r n a n i n o i t a r t e n e p e l b a r e d i s n o c s a h d n a s a h l e u f l a n o i t n e v n o c y b d e l e u f e n i g n E C I . t e k r a m e l i b o m o t u a d n a t e k r a m e l i b o m o t u a n i e c n a t r o p m i r i e h t d e v o r p y a d o t l l i t s f o y t i r o j a m , r e v e w o H . e n i g n E C I y b d e r e w o p e r a s e l c i h e v e h t d n a l e u f f o n o i t e l p e d f o s m e l b o r p g n i c a f e r a s e n i g n e C I , r e h t r u F . s m r o n s n o i s s i m e n e h t g n e r t s g n i v i r d y t i c e h t g n i r u d g n i l d i r e g n o l , p o t s d n a t r a t s t n e u q e r f , d e e p s w o l f o s n o i t i d n o c r o w e n i g n e C I f o n o i t a r e p o m e l b o r p e h t n e s ] 1 [ . , t s a r t n o c n I e l b a k r a m e r s w o h s e l c i h e v c i r t c e l e e k i l s e g a t n a v d a w o l s n o i s s i m e g n i r e d i s n o c ( s n o i s s i m e t n a t u l l o p s s e l , t s o c g n i n n u r t n e l i s d n a ) y t i c i r t c e l e f o n o i t c u d o r p o t e u d n o i t c u d o r p i n o S a r d n i v a R , t n e d u t S G P - t n e m t r a p e D g n i r e e n i g n E l a c i n a h c e M , l u r a P e t u t i t s n I a r a d o d a V , y g o l o n h c e T d n a g n i r e e n i g n e f o , a i d n I a z O m a y t i N , r o s s e f o r P t n a t s i s s A - , t n e m t r a p e D g n i r e e n i g n E l a c i n a h c e M l u r a P e t u t i t s n I n e f o g n i r e e n i g a i d n I , a r a d o d a V , y g o l o n h c e T d n a m i t g n i g r a h c r e g n o l , e g n a r w o l , r e v e w o H . n o i t a r e p o d n a e . d e t i m i l e l c i h e v c i r t c e l e f o e c n a t p e c c a e d a m s a h t s o c r e h g i h t a n o i t a r e p o t n e i c i f f e e k i l e n i g n E C I f o s e g a t n a v d a e h t p a t o T d n a e m i t g n i l e u f e r e l b i g i l g e n & e g n a r g n o l , d e e p s g n i s i u r c e k i l c i r t c e l E y t i c t a n o i t a r e p o t n e i c i f f e & t s o c g n i n n u r w o l v i r d d i r b y H . d e p o l e v e d s i e l c i h e v d i r b y h a , s n o i t i d n o c g n i r o f y g r e n e g n i r e v i l e d , s e c r u o s r e w o p e r o m r o o w t s a h e l c i h e v e h t n u r o t , s n o i t a n i b m o c n i r o y l e l o s r e h t i e n o i s l u p o r p e l c i h e v ] 3 [ s n o i t i d n o c g n i v i r d y t i c d n a d e e p s w o l g n i r u D . l i w n o i s l u p o r p e h t r o f r e w o p c i r t c e l e y b d e d i v o r p e b l y g r e n e ] 4 [ e n i g n E C I e h t n o i t i d n o c d e e p s g n i s i u r c g n i r u D . . n o i s l u p o r p r o f r e w o p s e d i v o r p . I I D F O T N E M P O L E V E H D I R B Y T O W W R E L E E H . A e l c i h e V t n e s e r P l e d o m S E y t o o c S S V T s i e s o p r u p s i h t r o f d e t c e l e s e l c i h e v e h T . s a e r a s n o i t a c i f i c e p s r o j a M e l b a T n i n e v i g I. I e l b a T r e l e e h W o w T f o n o i t a c i f i c e p S : e k a M S V T l e d o M S E y t o o c S e n i g n E 4- r e d n i l y c e l g n i S , e k o r t s t n e m e c a l p s i D c c 0 6 r e w o P . x a M M P R 0 0 5 6 @ P H B 5 e u q r o T . x a M M P R 0 0 0 4 @ m N 8 . 5 t h g i e W g k 5 7 . B s t n e n o p m o c r o j a m d n a n o i t a c i f i d o M e v l a n i g i r O s i e n i g n E C I e h T . e l c i h e v e v i r d l e e h w r a e r s i e l c i h d i r b y h e l c i h e v e h t e k a m o T . y l n o l e e h w r a e r e h t g n i r e w o p , a W 0 5 2 r o t o m C D s s e L h s u r B , , I . g i f n i n w o h s e h t n i d e t t i f s i . l e e h w t n o r f f o b u h C D L B e h t e c a l p o t d e v o m e r s i e k a r b t n o r F . r o t o m i r o t o m C D L B e h T . r o t o m s u o n o r h c n y s p o o l d e s o l c a s 0 3 e v a s n a c t I - r o t o m l a m r o n a y b d e m u s n o c r e w o p f o % 0 5 0 8 f o e g n a r y c n e i c i f f e d n a - t a e u q r o t h g i h e d i v o r p n a c t I . % 0 9 . d e e p s w o l r o t o m e h t o t e g a t l o v t n a t s n o c e d i v o r p o T b u h l e e h w t n o r f n i d e t t i f r o t o m C D L B : I . g i F n o c y r a s s e c e n e c u d o r p o t t n e r r u c e h t y r a v o t d e d e e n s i r e l l o r t c i f i c e p s e h t o t d e n g i s e d e r a s c i n o r t c e l e r e w o p e h T . e u q r o t f o t n o r f e h t t a d e t a c a o l s i t I . r o t o m c i r t c e l e e h t f o c i t s i r e t c a r a h c d i r b y H f o n o s i r a p m o C d n a t n e m e r u s a e M e c n a m r o f r e P r e l e e h W o w T a z O m a y t i N , i n o S i v a R

Upload: buianh

Post on 20-Mar-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Perfor m ance Measure m ent and Co m parison of H y brid ... m Oza , A ssistant Profe ssor-Me chanica l En gin ee rin g De partm e nt, Paru l I nstitut e of engin ee rin g and Te chn

)MREJI( tnemeganaM dnA hcraeseR gnireenignE fo lanruoJ lanoitanretnI 9432 : NSSI - emuloV ,8502 - eussI ,20 - 5102 lirpA ,40

051 moc.mreji.www

tcartsbA — hcraeser suodnemert ,tnecer tA si krow

deirrac ot gnireenigne elibomotua fo dleif eht ni tuo dna noitelped leuf lanoitnevnoc fo melborp eht tcaretnuoc

lufmrah op .snoissime tnatull neeb sah selcihev cirtcelE tnatullop decuder dna tsoc gninnur wol rof devorp leuf lanoitnevnoc yb derewop elcihev derapmoc noissime

.leseid dna enilosag ekil ,revewoH ton era selcihev cirtcele dna elcihev fo egnar wol fo esuaceb ralupop eriuqer gnol

erehW .emit gnigrahc ,sa elcihev derewop enigne CI rehgih dna emit gnillifer rellams ,egnar regnol sedivorp

.deeps gnisiurc ta ycneiciffe daol trap gnirud ,revewoH lufmrah rehgih ,enignE CI desab enilosaG fo noitarepo

oop dna noissime tnatullop .devresbo si ymonoce leuf r A releehw owt dirbyh si pat ot depoleved fo egatnavda eht

deeps gnisiurc ta ycneiciffe rehgih dna egnar gnol CI fo enignE wol ta noitarepo tneiciffe & snoissime rewol dna

deeps .rewop cirtcele fo dirbyh ehT SE ytoocS SVT owtehw htiw ytic aradodaV ni detset si rele snoitidnoc gnivird

gnisiurc ta gnivird dna gnivird ytic detsegnoc evlovni1 swohs tluser ehT .deeps 14.1 leuf ni tnemevorpmi %

desab enilosag lanoitnevnoc ot derapmoc noitpmusnoc .releehw owt

smreT xednI — cirtcelE ihev CI ,rewop dirbyH ,leuF ,elc

enignE

.I I NOITCUDORTN fo smelborp ereves gnicaf yltnerruc si dlrow elibomotuA noissime nehtgnerts ylraluger dna sleuf lissof fo noitelped

.smron evitanretla fo dleif eht ni deirrac neeb sah hcraeseRniart rewop etanretla dna sleuf ygrene elbawener ,ygolonhcet

.ygolonhcet dirbyh dna ni tnemevorpmi nwohs sah leuf oiB erutcurtsarfni dna ytilibaliava revewoh nrecnoc siht

.egral etiuq si tnemeriuqer ekil secruos ygrene elbaweneRnempoleved ygolonhcet tub laitnetop doog evah ygrene ralos t

.ssergorp rednu llits si nwohs sah elcihev derewop cirtcelE ecnatpecca ylbakramer na ni noitartenep elbaredisnoc sah dna

sah leuf lanoitnevnoc yb deleuf enignE CI .tekram elibomotua dna tekram elibomotua ni ecnatropmi rieht devorp yadot llits

fo ytirojam ,revewoH .enignE CI yb derewop era selcihev eht dna leuf fo noitelped fo smelborp gnicaf era senigne CI

,rehtruF .smron snoissime nehtgnerts gnivird ytic eht gnirud gnildi regnol ,pots dna trats tneuqerf ,deeps wol fo snoitidnoc

row enigne CI fo noitarepo melborp eht nes ]1[ . ,tsartnoc nI elbakramer swohs elcihev cirtcele ekil segatnavda wol

snoissime gniredisnoc( snoissime tnatullop ssel ,tsoc gninnur tnelis dna )yticirtcele fo noitcudorp ot eud noitcudorp

inoS ardnivaR , tnedutS GP - tnemtrapeD gnireenignE lacinahceM , luraP

etutitsnI aradodaV ,ygolonhceT dna gnireenigne fo , aidnI azO maytiN , rosseforP tnatsissA - ,tnemtrapeD gnireenignE lacinahceM

luraP etutitsnI ne fo gnireenig aidnI ,aradodaV ,ygolonhceT dna

mit gnigrahc regnol ,egnar wol ,revewoH .noitarepo dna e .detimil elcihev cirtcele fo ecnatpecca edam sah tsoc rehgih

ta noitarepo tneiciffe ekil enignE CI fo segatnavda eht pat oT dna emit gnileufer elbigilgen & egnar gnol ,deeps gnisiurc

ekil cirtcelE ytic ta noitarepo tneiciffe & tsoc gninnur wolvird dirbyH .depoleved si elcihev dirbyh a ,snoitidnoc gni

rof ygrene gnireviled ,secruos rewop erom ro owt sah elcihev eht nur ot ,snoitanibmoc ni ro ylelos rehtie noisluporp

elcihev ]3[ snoitidnoc gnivird ytic dna deeps wol gniruD .liw noisluporp eht rof rewop cirtcele yb dedivorp eb l

ygrene ]4[ enignE CI eht noitidnoc deeps gnisiurc gniruD . .noisluporp rof rewop sedivorp

.II D FO TNEMPOLEVE H DIRBY T OW W RELEEH

.A elciheV tneserP ledom SE ytoocS SVT si esoprup siht rof detceles elcihev ehT .

sa era snoitacificeps rojaM elbaT ni nevig I.

I elbaT releehW owT fo noitacificepS : ekaM SVT

ledoM SE ytoocS enignE 4- rednilyc elgniS ,ekorts

tnemecalpsiD cc 06 rewoP .xaM MPR 0056@PHB 5 euqroT .xaM MPR 0004@mN 8.5

thgieW gk 57

.B stnenopmoc rojam dna noitacifidoM ev lanigirO si enignE CI ehT .elcihev evird leehw raer si elcih

dirbyh elcihev eht ekam oT .ylno leehw raer eht gnirewop , a W 052 rotom CD sseL hsurB , ,I.gif ni nwohs eht ni dettif si

.leehw tnorf fo buh CDLB eht ecalp ot devomer si ekarb tnorF.rotom i rotom CDLB ehT .rotom suonorhcnys pool desolc a s

03 evas nac tI - rotom lamron a yb demusnoc rewop fo %0508 fo egnar ycneiciffe dna - ta euqrot hgih edivorp nac tI .%09

.deeps wol rotom eht ot egatlov tnatsnoc edivorp oT

buh leehw tnorf ni dettif rotom CDLB :I .giF

noc yrassecen ecudorp ot tnerruc eht yrav ot dedeen si rellort

cificeps eht ot dengised era scinortcele rewop ehT .euqrot fo tnorf eht ta detacaol si tI .rotom cirtcele eht fo citsiretcarahc

dirbyH fo nosirapmoC dna tnemerusaeM ecnamrofrePreleehW owT azO maytiN ,inoS ivaR

Page 2: Perfor m ance Measure m ent and Co m parison of H y brid ... m Oza , A ssistant Profe ssor-Me chanica l En gin ee rin g De partm e nt, Paru l I nstitut e of engin ee rin g and Te chn

releehW owT dirbyH fo nosirapmoC dna tnemerusaeM ecnamrofreP

151 moc.mreji.www

.I giF ni nwohs sa elcihev eht V 21 ,seirettab dica dael ruoF dna 02 ot lellarap ni detcennoc era ,hcae seiticapac hA

rotom CDLB ot V 84 ta tnerruc yrassecen edivorp nwohs eraII giF ni . .gk 38.21 si derusaem kcap yrettab eht fo thgieW

lellaraP ni detcennoc kcap yrettaB II giF

A yrettaB I giF ni nwohs ,regrahc II desu si , eht egrahc ot CD ot ni tnerruc CA ylppus citsemod gnitrevnoc yb yrettab

.tnerruc tinu cirtcele fo noitpmusnoc eht sdrocer osla regrahCsyalpsid dna .emas rednu decalp si tniop gnigrahc yrettaB A

.ekohc raen taes eht ellortnoc si rotom cirtcele eht fo deepS drevel rotarelecca yb )V .gif( yb gnireets fo edis tfel no decalp

A .rellortnoc hguorht tnerruc gnitsujda revoegnahc hctiws gif()IV CI ot cirtcele morf ylppus rewop eht egnahc ot dedivorp si

Q ehT .asrev eciv ro enignE TB zratS - Xe0001Q atad SPGohs reggol VI gif ni nw sihT .pal rof atad eht drocer ot desu si

gnivom ,dellevart ecnatsiD ,noitarud emiT sdrocer ecived deeps egareva dna deeps mumixaM ,emit deppots ,emit 01 .e.i zH01 ta enod saw gnidrocer atad ehT .pal eht gnirud

.dnoces 1 ni noitacol semit

F III :gi – regrahC yrettaB

VI :giF – reggol atad SPG

V :giF – edom cirtcelE rof rotareleccA

IV :giF – hctiwS revoegnahC cirtcelE

t swohs II elbaT iceps rojam eh sa elcihev deifidom fo noitacif

.woleb

elciheV deifidoM fo noitacificepS II elbaT ekaM VT S

ledoM SE ytoocS tnemecalpsiD cc 06

rewoP .xaM)edoM enilosaG( MPR 0056@PHB 5

rewoP .xaM)edoM cirtcelE( W 052

euqroT .xaM )edoM enilosaG( MPR 0004@mN 8.5

euqroT .xaM )edoM cirtcelE( 6.3 mN

yrettaB hA02/V 84 doireP gnigrahC 6- sruoH 8

deepS .xaM ( )edoM cirtcelE hpmk 82 ot 42

thgieW 64.78 gk

.III P ECNAMROFRE M DNA TNEMERUSAE C NOSIRAPMO si noitpmusnoc leuf elcihev fo ecnamrofrep eht erusaem oT si tset eht rof detceles etuor ehT .esac eht htob ni deredisnoc

orc kinerhS yb dewollof tniop rahlaM morf derats ,sdaor ss ,daor ssorc navadnurV ,etaginaP ,ivdnaM ,razab aidnaD ssorc kinerhs ,razab aidnaD ,ivdnaM ,etaginaP ,etatse radraS

tniop rahlaM dna daor tarajuG ,aradodaV ni si etuor latot ehT . 7.3 etaginaP ot razab aidnaD morf hcterts ehT .gnol mk 8.71

rpmoc mk si elcihev erehw aera ytic ciffart yvaeh fo sesi esned ot eud gnildi yvaeh dna pots dna trats tneuqerf deriuqer

gnilangis dna ciffart hcterts tser eht roF . mk 2.5 fo sesirpmoc ta nur ot elcihev swolla hcihw sdaor ediw dna ciffart thgil fo

ta deeps gnisiurc & og dna pots ssel dna emit eht fo tsom edom enilosag ylno ni nur elcihev eht pal tsrif tA .emit gnildi era atad rehto dna noitpmusnoc leuF .pal eht tuohguorht

.III elbaT ni nwohs dna dedrocer pal dnoces nI elcihev eht si 2.5 hguorht edom enilosaG ni nur ciffart thgil fo hcterts mk

aera ytic fo hcterts mk 7.3 eht hguorht edom cirtcele ni dna deriuqer stinU ,noitpmusnoc leuF .ciffart esned htiw egrahc ot

.III elbaT ni nwohs dna dedrocer era atad rehto dna yrettab eht TB zratSQ ehT ,pal eht htob nI - Xe0001Q si reggol atad SPG

eht wohs ot tenretni eht ot detcennoc dna atad eht gnidrocer no pal .pam elgooG zratSQ htiw atad derutpac ehT

TB - si reggol atad SPG Xe0001Q

elbaT III rojam rof noitcelloC ataD : nosirapmoc elciheV

( enilosaG ) elciheV

( dirbyH ) eepS xaM d )hpmk( 31.35 2.63

deepS .gvA )hpmk( .02 27 .02 94 emiT eldI )nim( 11 21

emiT gnivoM )nim( 25 35 emiT latoT )nim( 36 56

ecnatsiD paL )mk( 8.71 8.71 noitpmusnoC enilosaG )mg( 785 248

noitpmusnoC tinU cirtcelE ------------- 38.0 g(enilosag ot cirtcelE )m 272

25 0

Page 3: Perfor m ance Measure m ent and Co m parison of H y brid ... m Oza , A ssistant Profe ssor-Me chanica l En gin ee rin g De partm e nt, Paru l I nstitut e of engin ee rin g and Te chn

)MREJI( tnemeganaM dnA hcraeseR gnireenignE fo lanruoJ lanoitanretnI 9432 : NSSI - emuloV ,8502 - eussI ,20 - 5102 lirpA ,40

251 moc.mreji.www

giF TB zratSQ yb dedrocer ataD :IIV - edoM enilosaG ni reggol atad SPG Xe0001Q

TB zratSQ yb dedrocer ataD :IIV giF - edoM enilosaG ni reggol atad SPG Xe0001Q

Page 4: Perfor m ance Measure m ent and Co m parison of H y brid ... m Oza , A ssistant Profe ssor-Me chanica l En gin ee rin g De partm e nt, Paru l I nstitut e of engin ee rin g and Te chn

releehW owT dirbyH fo nosirapmoC dna tnemerusaeM ecnamrofreP

351 moc.mreji.www

C NOISULCNO III elbaT eht morF , si deniatta deeps mumixam taht nees si ti

ni esaercni si emas eht rof esuac ehT .elcihev dirbyh ni ssel ot eud elcihev dirbyh fo thgiew rehgih ,dnuor dnoces ni ciffart

egareva ehT .stnenopmoc rehto dna yrettab enilosag fo deepssi selcihev dirbyh dna .evitarapmoc eldi rennam ralimis nI

nivom ,emit dna emit g enilosag ni ralimis yrev era emit latottsrif tA .edom dirbyh dna , f ni sgnivas suodnemert leu si

%32.94 devresbo ni edom dirbyh enilosag ot derapmocedom ( eht ylppus ygrene cirtcele gniredisnoc ,revewoH .038.0 tinU( - )S/J 0063* emiT( - )S 692=0001/ :Jk6 gniredisnoC

52.0 ycneiciffe ygrene emoH ot laoC : ygrenE ecneh ylppuS = eht gk/Jk00044 sa enilosag fo VC gniredisnoC .Jk 46811

tnelaviuqe ygrene cirtcele mg 272 eb ot semoc leuf fo tnuoma noitpmusnoc leuf latot dna 25 ot semoc edom dirbyh ni .mg 0

,suhT noitpmusnoc leuf ssel % 14.11 swohs elcihev dirbyH rof devas si leuf fo mg 76 sA .elcihev enilosag ot derapmoc .decuder osla si noissime noitullop fo tnuoma emas eht pal eht

OC stime tnalp rewop ,rehtruF 2 OC naht lufmrah ssel si hcihwCH dna ]2[ .

R CNEREFE SE ]1[ gnuihC ,NEHC .P ecarG ,NIL .T mailliW ,UH .Y ymA - ,GNAHC neW

gnehC dna - raluciheV dna snoissimE fo scitsiretcarahC“ ,US ieW fo sgnideecorP ”senaL suB evisulcxE s’iepiaT ni sesuB fo snoitarepO

.loV, 3102 ,seidutS noitatropsnarT rof yteicoS aisA nretsaE eht 9 ]2[ lciheV dirbyH fo esU ehT“ samaL .Q .W dnA ,ohlavraC eD .R .A .C se

OC gnicudeR roF lasoporP A sA 2 ot noitubirtnoC stI dna snoissimE ,8 .loV ,etabuaT fo ytisrevinU ”snoissimE saG esuohneerG gnicudeR

70 .p .9002 enuJ ,10 oN - 11 ]3[ snaH - iK dnaloR ,thcahcS negrüJ nahpetS dna relkniW znarF regrebhcr

owT rof rednetxE egnaR” tdimhcS .P - 5102 ”snoitacilppA releehW ]4[ laeR fo tcapmI“ nainamarbuS .P.K dna inamaseN .S.K - gnivirD dlroW

,5002 rebmeceD ”snoissimE raluciheV nO scitsiretcarahCICU - STI - PW - 50 -5

]5[ ,elbmaK .H ayirphgnaS amrahS .K.G dna wehtaM .V moTlaer fo tnempoleveD“ - ,”enuP fo yduts esaC :elcyc gnivird dlrow

liviC fo tnemtrapeD ,enuP ,tropsnarT daoR fo etutitsnI lartneC ,iabmuM ,iawoP ,yabmoB ygolonhceT fo etutitsnI naidnI ,gnireenignE

.aidnI ,670 004 arthsarahaM ]6[ ejnaS sraC roF nrettaP elcyC gnivirD“ ramuK ardnivaR dnA ahniS ve

aisA nretsaE ehT fO sgnideecorP ,”aidnI fO ytiC deziS muideM nI3102 ,9.loV ,seidutS noitatropsnarT roF yteicoS

]7[ 0041 fO ydutS ytilibisaeF dna sisylanA latnemirepxE” etpuG rihduSC enignE leseiD CC yB elciheV cirtcelE dirbyH otnI detrevnoC ra

secnavdA no ecnerefnoC lanoitanretnI ht4 ,srotoM buH CDLB gnisUygrenE ,3102 hcraeseR ygrenE ni 771 ) 4102 ( 45 aidecorP – 481

]8[ tsoC” nospmiS werdnA dna lekraM ynoT - gulP fo sisylanA tifeneB - nIheV cirtcelE dirbyH AJ/LERN” ygolonhceT elci - 045 - ,96904

AVEW - 6002 - 350

inoS ivaR p si eH .gnireenigne elibomotua dna enignE CI fo tneduts GP si fo rebmem tneduts a si eH .elcihev dirbyH fo dleif eht ni hcraeser gniusrup

.aidnI EAS azO maytiN rruC .rosseforp tnatsissA na si ni DhP gniusrup si eh yltne

ni EM sih deusrup sah eH .gnireenignE elibomotuA fo dleif ehtlacinahceM - gnireenignE tnemnrevoG morf gnireenignE elibomotuA

EB deusrup sah eH .juhB ,egelloc - fo etutitsnI amriN morf lacinahcemrp dna dehsilbup sah eH .ygolonhceT ni srepap 71 naht erom detnese

eH .secnerefnoC lanoitaN dna slanruoj lanoitaN ni ,slanruoJ lanoitanretnI krow hcraeser tuo deirrac sah eH .siseht noitatressid EM 01 desivrepus sah

i eh tneserp tA .gnikarb evitareneger dna dna sleuf etanretlA fo aera eht ni a s .EAS fo rebmem dna ETSI fo rebmem efil