perspectives on community and economic development in a global economy
TRANSCRIPT
Perspectives on Community and Economic Development in a Global
Economy
Affordable Housing and Community Development Law ConferenceOctober 9, 2009Newport, RI
Director, Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and EthnicityWilliams Chair in Civil Rights & Civil Liberties, Moritz College of Law
john a. powell
Changes, Challenges and Opportunities Facing our Society
• Our world today is more complex and interconnected–Global labor market–Global financial market–Global credit market–Global climate change
2
Globalization
• Where does your stuff come from?
• Under what conditions?
• Different communities are situated differently with regards to institutions
• Institutions mediate opportunity
• Structural Inequality– Example: a Bird in a cage.
Examining one wire cannot explain why a bird cannot fly. But multiple wires, arranged in specific ways, reinforce each other and trap the bird.
Communities have different resources, and these result in differential
outcomes…• Example: Universal healthcare?
– One community has no health insurance, but a hospital down the street.
– Another community has no health insurance and no hospital.
Structural Racialization
6Adapted from the Aspen Roundtable on Community Change. “Structural Racism and Community Building.” June 2004
System Interactions
Source: Barbara Reskin. http://faculty.uwashington.edu/reskin/7
Dual Delivery SystemsCredit, Housing, Education, Labor
8
The Global to Local connection:Dual Credit Delivery System
• A powerful example• The link between Race,
Neighborhood location, and (in)accessibility to prime or sustainable loans
9
From Redlining to
Reverse Redlining
A Geography of Credit…
“Race or Risk” ?
Source: United for a Fair Economy
…what about fair credit
Effects of a Dual Credit Delivery System
• Credit-starved communities from decades of red-lining
• Loss of wealth
• Lost Tax Revenue• Higher Demand
for Services
• Entrenched marginalization in housing and credit markets
• Other Implications?• Higher- Education
loans?• Business
Development?
Predatory Loans Foreclosure
Further Neighborhood Destabilization
Further disinvestment by Prime
Financial Institutions
Global financial systems operate outside the scope of US regulations and they are increasingly complex…
13
The Post Depression FHA Era: The Three Party Mortgage Market
Pre Depression: The Two Party Housing Market
Homebuyer
Party 1
Seller (and/or)
Lending Institution Party 2
Homebuyer
Party 1
LendingInstitution
Party 2
Government Sponsored Institution
purchases, insures or underwrites loan Pa
rty 3
Based on research by Chris Peterson, University of Utah Law School
…From Two Party Transactions to Mortgage Securitization at a Global Scale
14Created by Chris Peterson, University of Utah Law School
Today: The web of actors and institutions involved in the
sub prime lending and mortgage securitization
market
Reassess our Assumptions
Are unfettered markets good?Is government action inherently bad?Who wins and who loses?
Source: United for a Fair Economy
More than ‘thinking globally’ and ‘acting locally’
• Our global economy requires affirmative, deliberate collective action, across multiple domains, and at a regional level
• How can we affirmatively incorporate our marginalized communities into the mainstream economy?
Opportunity Structures
• We all live in opportunity structures called neighborhoods, nations
• Even where we have universal goals, we have different paths.
• Different strokes for different folks
A New Paradigm: “Globalizing” Community and Economic Development
• Traditional model is highly localized and irrelevant for our global economy
• Fragmented and incremental strategies ignore the complexity of multiple systems of disadvantage (cumulative causation)
Remember the bird cage?
Two types of StrategiesExample:
Dual Credit SystemsTransactional
Locate solutions within the individual or community
Financial literacy programsPayday lending restrictions
Transformational
Fix the System, get rid of the DUAL system
Link to broader Housing and Credit MarketsBut it’s a systemic deficiency;
communities are still vulnerableEmpowers communities
against future risks
A New Paradigm contd.
• A Systems Approach: the “snowball effect”
• Personalized remedies: every community has its own arrangement of institutions that produce disparate outcomes
• Continuous monitoring of the system– Changing factors in a system can alter conditions ‘on the
ground’ quickly– Example: Declining housing markets decrease private market
development and decrease effectiveness of Inclusionary Zoning policies
Potential Alternatives
• Federal– Fannie and Freddie to “affirmatively further fair housing”?– Role for financial institutions that received federal bailout
funds?– HUD initiatives: Sustainable Communities
• Local? Regional!– What about foreclosures in non-segregated
neighborhoods for affordable housing?– What about strategic reuse of abandoned properties in
distressed neighborhoods?
Different communities will have different structural needs
Appendix
22
How can practitioners embrace an opportunity-
based model of development?
Communities of Opportunity
– Everyone should have fair access to the critical opportunity structures needed to succeed in life
– Affirmatively connecting people to opportunity creates positive, transformative change in communities
– More than just de-concentration! Narrowly focused strategies: mobility-based OR in-place
– Transformational strategies include BOTH
23
An Opportunity- Based Model of Community and Economic Development
• A systems approach– Understanding relationships that suppress access to opportunity– Identifying critical leverage points to produce pathways to
opportunity
• Involving collaboration and engagement in multiple domains– Education; housing; finance etc.
• Opening up pathways to opportunity through engagement on critical intervention points– People, Places and Linkages
24
Expanded Geography of Action
• Collective and deliberate action • Horizontal collaborations: regional
collaborations, public/private/nonprofit partnerships
• Vertical collaborations: local, state, and federal policy reforms
Focus explicitly on racial and social justice
• Evaluations. Do proposed projects:– Perpetuate residential
segregation? – Exacerbate jobs-mismatch? – Perpetuate environmental
injustice? • Without addressing the social,
racial and interregional inequities facing the region, our future is compromised
27
High OpportunityLow Opportunity
Connecting Multiple Domains: e.g. Housing and Schools:
How can we reverse this pattern?
28
LIHTC and Segregated Schools• Currently, LIHTC development is conflicting with efforts to
desegregate schools.• Nearly ¾’s of African American and Hispanic LIHTC residents are
located in segregated schools.
Figure 8: Percentage of LIHTC Population within Proximity to Segregated Schools:
Population in household by household race:
> 90% White
50 to 100% Students of Color
American Indian 16.8% 18.7%
Asian 6.9% 71.3%
Black 6.0% 69.6%
Hispanic 8.4% 74.3%
Other Race 33.5% 23.2%
White 32.5% 17.0%
Housing
ChildcareEmployment
Education
Health
Transportation
Effective Participation
Housing is an opportunity anchor and key leverage point
29
Example: Opportunity- Based Housing
• Rethink fair housing…• Not just integration but integration into opportunity• Inclusive fair housing means access to good schools,
jobs, doctors, child care, transportation, parks, and the civic fabric
30
Example: Opportunity Mapping
• Opportunity is spatially distributed throughout our metropolitan regions (varying by community)
• Opportunity mapping is a tool to help guide policy and advocacy, providing a quantitative assessment of where opportunities are and where they are deficient– Guiding responses
• Understanding what resources need to be developed in communities
• Understanding how to connect marginalized residents to areas of opportunity throughout the region
31
Charles
Loudoun
Fauquier
Fairfax
Montgomery
Prince George's
Anne Arundel
Calvert
Howard
Prince William
StaffordCulpeper
Jefferson
Frederick
St. Mary's
Clarke
District of Columbia
BaltimoreBaltimore City
Arlington
Alexandria
Manassas
Fairfax City
Falls Church
Manassas Park
Prepared by: The Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race & Ethnicity, March 1, 2007Source: U.S. Census Bureau and Opportunity Analysis by Kirwan Institute
Legend
Water Features
County Areas
Neighborhood
Opportunity Ranking
Very Low Opportunity
Low Opportunity
Moderate Opportunity
High Opportunity
Very High Opportunity
Neighborhood Opportunity AnalysisWashington DC-Baltimore Region
32
Putting it All Together: Neighborhood Revitalization
33
– A systems response• Where are your key
leverage points?• What are the critical
intervention points?
– Equity focused• Creating a
community for all
– Emphasis on strategic collaboration
Neighborhood
Revitalization
Housing Stock
Public Investme
nt
Geography (Local;
Regional)
Larger Market Forces
Neighborhood
Leadership
Institutional
Partners
Anchor Institutio
ns
For more information, see our report “Pathways to Opportunity: Partnership and Collaboration for Revitalizing the Rosemont-Walbrook Neighborhood” available at www.kirwaninstitute.org
Questions or Comments: www.kirwaninstitute.org34