phe research 2014/15 annual review · phe research 2014/15: annual review 6 funding phe records...
TRANSCRIPT
PHE Research 2014/15 Annual review
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
2
About Public Health England
Public Health England exists to protect and improve the nation's health and wellbeing, and
reduce health inequalities. It does this through world-class science, knowledge and
intelligence, advocacy, partnerships and the delivery of specialist public health services.
PHE is an operationally autonomous executive agency of the Department of Health.
Public Health England
Wellington House
133-155 Waterloo Road
London SE1 8UG
Tel: 020 7654 8000
www.gov.uk/phe
Twitter: @PHE_uk
Facebook: www.facebook.com/PublicHealthEngland
For queries relating to this document, please contact: [email protected]
© Crown copyright 2015
You may re-use this information (excluding logos) free of charge in any format or
medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence v3.0. To view this licence,
visit OGL or email [email protected]. Where we have identified any third
party copyright information you will need to obtain permission from the copyright holders
concerned.
Published: December 2015
PHE publications gateway number: 2015537
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
3
Contents
About Public Health England 2
Foreword 4
Executive summary 5
Research in PHE 5
Strategy 5
Funding 6
Significant research initiatives 7
Global and international research 8
Building research capacity and capability 8
Publications 11
Research governance 17
Staff recognition for research achievements
(notified to PHE’s Research Support Office) 19
Appendix 1: Funding awards involving PHE that were secured during 2014/15 21
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
4
Foreword
Public Health England (PHE) is the expert national public health agency that fulfils the
statutory duty of the Secretary of State for Health to protect health and address
inequalities, and executes his power to promote the health and wellbeing of the nation.
PHE has operational autonomy. Our freedoms are set out in the Framework Agreement
with our parent department, the Department of Health. The agreement makes clear that
PHE must speak to the evidence and its professional judgement. The overwhelming
majority of our staff are scientists, researchers and public health professionals.
PHE has four core functions:
protecting the public’s health from infectious diseases and other hazards to health
improving the public’s health and wellbeing and reducing health inequalities
improving population health through sustainable health and care services
building the capability and capacity of the public health system
We deliver these through advocacy, partnerships, world-class science, knowledge and
intelligence, and the delivery of specialist public health services.
Across the full range of its functions, PHE requires access to high-quality evidence
much of which derives from research. PHE is well placed to undertake the research
necessary to generate some of that evidence and it accesses the remainder through the
robust findings of researchers globally. Whether undertaking research itself, or
accessing findings, PHE works closely with researchers based in universities or other
research institutions.
The current report focusses on a year of major change in the organisation of PHE’s
research and related activities. Changes are most evident in the closer, mutually-
dependent working with the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) health
protection research units (HPRUs) and in revised relationships with UK-based health
research funding organisations.
Reassuringly, change was accompanied by sustained excellence – papers published in
the most respected, peer-reviewed scientific literature, substantial external income
achieved from diverse national and international sources, and high-quality research
training experienced at doctoral level and beyond.
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
5
Executive summary
PHE research achievements:
more than £22 million in external research income
669 peer-reviewed publications
significant contributions to the evidence base for public health policy and practice
Research in PHE
PHE does not commission research. Our mandate from government, agreed with the
Department of Health, refers to ‘undertaking and contributing to research and
development in areas relevant to our functions’. PHE resources and expertise are
augmented by engagement with academic researchers as well as national and
international health services and industry.
Building for the future, PHE must both sustain its productivity, excellence and leadership
around current research strengths while also developing research on other major
challenges to health, non-communicable diseases. That process has begun and its
achievement will be a hallmark of PHE’s research review reports in future years.
Workshops have been held to prompt engagement of researchers internally and
externally and research funders with the principal evidence gaps for public health.
Workshop reports are published on our website. See
https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/public-health-england/about/research
Strategy
Our strategy ‘Doing, supporting and using public health research – the PHE strategy for
research, translation and innovation’ was completed and published in August 2015. The
achievement of measures of success set out for that strategy will be the framework of
future annual research reviews. See https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/doing-
supporting-and-using-public-health-research-phe-strategy
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
6
Funding
PHE records show that £22.1m of external funding was secured for research and
related activities during financial year 2014/15. Funding sources are shown in Table 1.
The impact of the shift in the principal source of funding – from direct grant to
competitive, peer reviewed awards – is evident. The organisation must now benefit from
the relevance, focus and quality of its research endeavour, resources, and researcher
experience, by engaging more frequently in open competitions. Successful attraction of
funding awards is the goal. However, the value of high-quality feedback from
international peers engaged by the external funding bodies is also recognised as a
significant driver of research quality.
A selection of funding awards that contributed to the sums below demonstrates that
many collaborating partners – in academia, health and care services, industry and not-
for-profit organisations – facilitate the diversity of PHE research (Appendix 1).
Table 1: Sources of external research funding to PHE
Funding source 2013/2014 (£m) 2014/2015 (£m)
Direct funding from the Department of Health to
support research (legacy from the Health
Protection Agency)
9.5 --
Department of Health, including NIHR (via open
competition)
1.6 6.2
Funding from other government departments (via
open competition)
3.3 2.3
UK higher education institutions 0.3 0.4
UK businesses 1.6 1.0
Not-for-profit organisations 1.8 2.9
European Commission programmes 3.1 3.3
Other international funding (including non-UK
government)
8.5 5.9
Total 29.7 22.0
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
7
Significant research initiatives
By the end of March 2015 the 13 NIHR HPRUs had completed their first full year of
operation, albeit one that included set-up activities such as staff recruitment.
Achievements noted in the report, eg high-quality publications, were delivered by those
units. In future years, the PHE annual research review will highlight in detail the
advances in public health knowledge made by the NIHR HPRUs.
The global response to the outbreak of Ebola virus disease that began in West Africa in
2014 was informed by the work of a number of the NIHR HPRUs. In addition, PHE staff
in a number of units were themselves deployed as part of the response.
A significant dimension of health research in NIHR HPRUs is the involvement and
engagement of patients and people (PPI/PPE). All units have PPI/PPE strategies and
dedicated staff support to ensure its implementation.
Details of the achievement and current work of the NIHR HPRUs are on their websites,
accessible through the links in Table 2.
Table 2: The National Institute for Health Research health protection research units
NIHR HPRU Website
Blood-borne and sexually transmitted infections http://bbsti.hpru.nihr.ac.uk
Gastrointestinal infections www.hprugi.nihr.ac.uk/
Chemical and radiation threats and hazards www.ncl.ac.uk/hpru/
Health impact of environmental hazards http://hieh.hpru.nihr.ac.uk/
Environmental change and health www.hpru-ech.nihr.ac.uk/
Development of modelling methodology www1.imperial.ac.uk/hprumodelling/
Emergency preparation and response http://epr.hpru.nihr.ac.uk/
Emerging and zoonotic infections www.hpruezi.nihr.ac.uk/
Respiratory infections www1.imperial.ac.uk/hprurespiratoryinfections/
Immunisation
Evaluation of interventions www.bristol.ac.uk/social-community-
medicine/centres/nihr-hpru/
Healthcare-associated infections and
antimicrobial resistance
www.herc.ox.ac.uk/research/dce-research-at-
herc/studies-15/health-protection-research-unit-in-
healthcare-associated-infections-and-
antimicrobial-resistance
www1.imperial.ac.uk/hpruantimicrobialresistance/
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
8
Global and international research
Global health is a significant area of PHE activity and much is underpinned by excellent
research particularly in infectious disease and emergency responsiveness. The
organisation’s ability to respond alongside global partners to the ebola outbreak in 2014
would have been diminished significantly without its ongoing research.
While much of our other research is relevant to public health internationally, our ability
to conduct research with international partners in significant research consortia is
demonstrated by our continuing success in attracting funding via a range of European
Commission research and development programmes.
Building research capacity and capability
PHE runs two, small, internal funding schemes: the PhD studentship scheme and the
Pump Priming Fund.
The purpose of the PhD studentship scheme is to recruit talented new researchers to
the organisation, while also developing PHE staff in the co-supervisor role. As PHE is
not a degree awarding institution, projects are undertaken in collaboration with
academic partners and the doctoral student registers with one of those.
In addition to support from the academic partner, PHE takes seriously, and dedicates
resource to, ensuring an excellent research training environment and experience for
each PhD student. The PhD projects listed in Table 3 were awarded funding through
internal competition in 2014/15 and students were selected through open (external)
competition.
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
9
Table 3: New PhD studentships awarded by PHE in 2014/15
Project title University partner
Public health implications of association between influenza
virus and pneumonia-causing bacteria: secondary bacterial
infection and severity of influenza
Cambridge University
Characterising the gamma delta T cell response to cancer
and infectious disease: two sides to the same story?
St Georges, University of
London
Group processes in community responses to flooding:
Implications for resilience and wellbeing
Sussex University
Potential toxicity of inhaled nicotine in e-cigarette refills St Georges, University of
London
Antibody correlates of protection for Ebola virus infection:
Effects of mutations within the virus on cell entry and
immune escape
Liverpool University
New materials to act as fortuitous dosemeter for emergency
dosimetry
Durham University
The purpose of the PHE Pump Priming Fund is to stimulate new areas of research or
provide support for relatively small projects that are likely to lead to more substantial
proposals for external funding. Applications from relatively inexperienced researchers
are also encouraged. The maximum award per project is £10,000. The projects detailed
in Table 4 were selected for funding through internal competition in 2014/15. The
success of each project in achieving goals set out in the initial proposals is tracked and
will be reported.
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
10
Table 4: Pump Priming projects funded by PHE in 2014/15
Project title Awardees
Development of methodologies for the quantification of
cerium dioxide and silver nanoparticles in biological
samples
Tim Marczylo, Rachel Smith,
James Warren
Sensor systems for rapid detection of bacterial growth Mark Sutton, Robert Watson
Magnetic bead immunocapture enrichment of clinical
specimens for virus discovery using host’s IgM antibody
response
Arinder Kohli, Samreen Ijaz,
Richard Tedder
Surveillance of treatment failures in primary care delivery
of the National Chlamydia Screening Programme
Kevin Dunbar, Gillian Smith,
Rachel Pitt
“Antibacterial” hand soaps: do the risks associated with
long-term daily use outweigh any associated benefit?
Ginny Moore, Mark Sutton
New entrant LTBI screening pilot for high risk populations
in Kirklees and Bradford
Ebere Okereke, Clare
Humphreys
Development of methodologies for the quantification of
substances of concern for human health in fetal blood
spots
Karen Exley, Tim Marczylo,
Ovnair Sepai
Use of transgenic cell lines to predict susceptibility of
mouse strains to viral infections
Victoria Graham
Bacterial metagenomics; Application of next generation
sequencing (NGS) technology for the direct detection
and analysis of bacterial species from highly complex
bacterial communities
Dunstan Rajendram, Kartyk
Moganeradj, Kevin Herbert
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
11
Publications
PHE staff achieved publication of 669 individual peer-reviewed articles during the
calendar year 2014. This number was assessed through reports from authors and
systematic literature searching. This number excludes reports produced by PHE as part
of its advice and guidance functions. We note 215 other publications, including
published conference abstracts, book chapters, editorials and letters. A full list of
publications is available.
The total number of publications is lower than that reported for 2013. In part this is
accounted for by more systematic exclusion of duplicate records such as electronic and
print publication of the same paper. The systematic approach used this year will be
continued in future to enable more accurate inter-year comparison.
Each of the 669 articles included at least one PHE author and together appeared under
more than 200 different journal titles, reflecting the broad scope of PHE’s remit. The
journals in which PHE authors published the most frequently were:
Epidemiology & Infection – 37
PLoS ONE – 37
Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy – 32
Eurosurveillance – 29
Vaccine – 23
In line with the policies of many research funders, PHE supports and encourages
publication in open access titles.
Publication highlights
A full list of all publications involving PHE published during 2014/15 accompanies this
report.
A selection of key papers is presented below together with a brief description of its
importance for public health.
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
12
Table 5: PHE publication highlights from 2014/15
Publication Why is this important?
Amos GC et al. (2014) Functional
metagenomic analysis reveals rivers are
a reservoir for diverse antibiotic
resistance genes. Vet Microbiol. Jul
16;171(3-4):441-7.
doi: 10.1016/j.vetmic.2014.02.017
Amos GC et al. (2014) Waste water
effluent contributes to the dissemination
of CTX-M-15 in the natural environment.
J Antimicrob Chemother. Jul;69(7):1785-
91.
doi: 10.1093/jac/dku079
This is the first study to demonstrate that CTX-M-
producing bacteria, derived from faecal carriers in
the general population, pass through the UK’s
high quality sewage treatment plants. CTX-M is
the world’s and the UK’s most significant cause
of multiple resistance in Gram negative bacteria
such as E. coli. We recovered significant
numbers of viable CTX-M producing E. coli and
the gene from a small river – a recreational water
course, also used by farm animals for drinking –
into which the treatment works discharged. The
river is a previously unrecognised source of
colonisation of multiple-resistant bacteria relevant
to humans.
Buttigieg KR et al (2014). A Novel
Vaccine against Crimean-Congo
Haemorrhagic Fever Protects 100% of
Animals against Lethal Challenge in a
Mouse Model PLoS ONE 01/2014;
9(3):e91516.
doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0091516
This paper highlights the first ever effective
vaccine candidate against CCHF virus.
Dowall SD et al (2014). Effective Binding
of a Phosphatidylserine-Targeting
Antibody to Ebola Virus Infected Cells
and Purified Virions J. Immunol.
Research ID 347903
doi: 10.1155/2015/347903
This publication highlights PHE research
capability on Ebola before the 2014/15 outbreak
in West Africa.
Elderfield RA et al (2014). Accumulation
of human-adapting mutations during
circulation of A(H1N1)pdm09 influenza
virus in humans in the United Kingdom. J
Virol. Nov 15;88(22):13269-83.
doi: 10.1128/JVI.01636-14.
This dissection of the mutations associated with
adaptation of pandemic influenza A H1N1 since
2009 and investigation of viral fitness using in
vitro model systems adds to understanding of
how novel influenza viruses adapt to humans
from animal hosts.
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
13
Eylert, MF et al (2014). Falling bladder
cancer incidence from 1990 to 2009 is not
producing universal mortality
improvements. J. Clin. Urol. 7 (2) 90-98.
doi: 10.1177/2051415813492724
Reductions in bladder cancer incidence and
mortality in England coincide with a decrease in
high-risk occupations and public health measures
to reduce smoking. Some risk factors in modern
living may as yet be unidentified. It remains
paramount to ensure equity of access and
treatment regardless of gender, age, region and
social deprivation to further improve mortality.
The journal identified that this article was one
shared the most online.
Hayward AC et al (2014). Comparative
community burden and severity of
seasonal and pandemic influenza: results
of the Flu Watch cohort study. Lancet
Respir Med. March 16.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S2213-
2600(14)70034-7.
Publication of the FLUWATCH community cohort
study covering a period of five years from 2007 to
2012 summarised the application of modern
epidemiological and virological methodologies to
influenza illness in the community, yielding
detailed information about symptomatic and
asymptomatic infections in different seasons. The
study provided major insights about differences
and similarities of health seeking behaviour
during pandemic periods compared with
seasonal epidemic periods. This will be a
landmark study for many years to come.
Manning G et al (2014). Quantifying
murine bone marrow and blood radiation
dose response following (18)F-FDG PET
with DNA damage biomarkers. Mutat
Res. 770:29-36.
doi: 10.1016/j.mrfmmm.2014.09.002.
This study showed that leucocyte gene
expression and micronuclei in reticulocytes were
highly sensitive biomarkers for reliable estimation
of the poorly-understood low doses of radiation
delivered in vivo to murine blood and bone
marrow from whole-body fluorine 18 ((18)F)-
fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission
tomography (PET).
Marriott AC et al (2014) Low dose
influenza virus challenge in the ferret
leads to increased virus shedding and
greater sensitivity to oseltamivir. PLOS
ONE 9(4): e94090.
doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0094090
This paper is significant in demonstrating an
improved model for influenza infection, which can
aid development of antivirals and vaccines as
well as reducing the number of animals required
for such development.
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
14
Meijer A et al (2014). Global update on
the susceptibility of human influenza
viruses to neuraminidase inhibitors, 2012-
13. Antiviral Res. 17. pii: S0166-
3542(14)00200-9.
doi: 10.1016/j.antiviral.2014.07.001.
Perez-Sautu U, et al (2014). Y155H
amino acid substitution in influenza
A(H1N1)pdm09 viruses does not confer a
phenotype of reduced susceptibility to
neuraminidase inhibitors. Euro Surveill.
10;19(27). pii: 20849.
These papers report the early detection of
unusual viruses and resistance to antiviral
treatments by PHE Respiratory Virus Unit,
through enhanced surveillance and mechanistic
studies of unusual variants.
Newman EN et al (2014) Seroconversion
for Infectious Pathogens among UK
Military Personnel Deployed to
Afghanistan, 2008-2011. Emerg Infect
Dis. 20(12):2015-22.
doi:
10.3201/eid2012.131830.PMID:25418685
This publication highlights the utility of the
longstanding and fruitful PHE collaboration with
the Ministry of Defence.
Nicholson KG et al (2014). Randomised
controlled trial and health economic
evaluation of the impact of diagnostic
testing for influenza, respiratory syncytial
virus and Streptococcus pneumoniae
infection on the management of acute
admissions in the elderly and high-risk
18- to 64-year olds. Health Technol
Assess. May;18(36):1-274, vii-viii. doi:
10.3310/hta18360.
Evaluation of cost-effectiveness of rapid
laboratory diagnosis for respiratory illness
requiring NHS secondary care over several
winter seasons, funded through NIHR Health
Technology Assessment, produced some
surprising findings. These have been used to
inform NICE guidelines (2014) on community
acquired pneumonia (CAP).
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
15
Parker M et al (2014). Identifying the
Science and Technology Dimensions of
Emerging Public Policy Issues through
Horizon Scanning. PLOS One.
doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0096480
Resulting from a seminar at the Centre for
Science and Policy (Cambridge, March 2013) this
paper identifies 30 emerging issues considered
to be top priorities for policy makers, including in
health and healthcare. A possible measure of
subjective wellbeing combined with life
expectancy is discussed. It could be used as a
‘common currency’ across government and
sectors to compare the impact of apparently
disparate policies and inform decisions about
resource allocation and prioritisation.
Pebody RG, et al (2014). Uptake and
impact of a new live attenuated influenza
vaccine programme in England: early
results of a pilot in primary school age
children, 2013-14 influenza season. Euro
Surveill. 5;19(22). pii: 20823.
This report of early analysis of the effectiveness
of live attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV) in
children is likely to be of interest to an
international audience as the new vaccine
programme is introduced into the UK.
Pernot E, et al (2014). Usefulness of
saliva samples for biomarker studies in
radiation research. Cancer Epidemiol
Biomarkers Prev. 23(12):2673-80.
doi:10.1158/1055-9965.EPI-14-0588.
Saliva samples could be an ideal non-invasive
alternative to blood, particularly in children and
for large molecular epidemiology studies. This
can facilitate the management of emergency
situations and detection and surveillance of
diseases. Saliva can be used to study effects of
limited magnitude from low doses of infra-red
radiation as many samples are required for
statistical significance.
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
16
Thomas HL et al (2014). Enhanced
MERS coronavirus surveillance of
travellers from the Middle East to
England. Emerg Infect Dis. 20(9):1562-4.
doi: 10.3201/eid2009.140817
Abroug F et al (2014). World Health
Organization Global Outbreak Alert and
Response Network Middle East
Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus
International Investigation Team. Family
cluster of Middle East respiratory
syndrome coronavirus infections, Tunisia
2013. Emerg Infect Dis. 20(9):1527-30.
doi: 10.3201/eid2009.140378.
These papers report the PHE Respiratory Virus
Unit contribution to development of knowledge on
MERS Corona virus through surveillance and
outbreak investigations.
Tonge, DP, et al (2014). Amplicon –
Based Metagenomic Analysis of Mixed
Fungal Samples Using Proton Release
Amplicon Sequencing PLOSOne
9(4)e93849
doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0093849
A high-throughput sequencing method to
determine fungal speciation is described. Fungal
spores contribute significantly to disease,
particularly respiratory disease, in the UK and are
closely associated with activities such as
composting and weather events like flooding.
Current methods for speciation are culture based
and may only identify about 17% of the ca.
12,000 species named for the UK, itself only a
fraction of those in the environment. This method
is faster, with broader scope for fungal
identification and, with refinement, can become
quantitative. This is an important advance in
understanding the contribution of fungi to public
health.
Vardoulakis S, et al (2014). Comparative
assessment of the effects of climate
change on heat- and cold-related
mortality in the United Kingdom and
Australia. Environ Health Perspect.
122(12):1285-92
doi: 10.1289/ehp.1307524
This paper highlights the influence that climate
change is likely to have on deaths. While climate
change could have a beneficial effect in reducing
cold weather deaths there will be an increase in
hot weather deaths. The best methods to reduce
the effect of extreme temperatures on mortality
need to be considered.
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
17
Research governance
PHE research governance staff support the ethical review and regulatory processes for
all research applications that involve human subjects, their tissues and/or data.
Twenty four research studies received PHE sponsorship approval and received a
‘sponsorship in principle’ letter between 1 April 2014 and 31 March 2015. Study titles
are listed in Table 6 below. To date they are either open or in the final stages of set up.
No clinical trials or DNA analysis studies were set up under PHE sponsorship during
2014/15. The largest increase in studies during the year relative to previous years was
in motivational messaging.
Table 6: Research studies sponsored by PHE
Study name and subject area Study type
Behavioural science
Improving outcomes from NHS Health Checks Southwark Motivational messages
Analysis of suboptimal dosing in methadone maintenance
treatment
Questionnaires and focus
groups
Effectiveness of appearance versus health-framed alcohol
awareness Interventions
Internet research
Assessing the effect of different reminder text messages
on uptake of NHS Health Checks in Southwark
Motivational messages
The impact of content on GP screens on NHS Health
Check uptake
Motivational messages
Contacting GPs to reduce unnecessary prescriptions of
antibiotics
Motivational messages
A cluster RCT using body image scans in NCMP results
letters
Motivational messages
Blood-borne infection
Assessing the feasibility of blood-borne virus testing
inemergency departments
Tissue analysis
Emergency response
Study of decontamination efficacy following the 'Ladder
Pipe' decontamination procedure with and without
detergent
Evaluation
Study of the effect of delay on decontamination
effectiveness and outcomes, following the 'Ladder Pipe'
decontamination procedure
Evaluation
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
18
Environmental hazards
Biological dosimetry and radiation response Tissue analysis
Evaluation of heavy metals and chemicals in dried
newborn blood spots
Tissue analysis
Gastrointestinal infection
Autochthonous hepatitis E – pathogenesis of infection Tissue analysis
Immunology and vaccination
Immunisation in orthodox Jewish communities Questionnaire and focus
groups
Pneumo carriage, PIN study Tissue analysis
Mental health
Haringey Mental Wellbeing Survey 2014 Questionnaire study
Microbiology
“Antibacterial” hand soaps: do the risks associated with
long-term daily use outweigh any associated benefit?
Evaluation
Respiratory infection
Improving the detection of active TB in A&E departments Tissue analysis
Sexual health
Evaluation of a rapid diagnostic platform for the molecular
detection of Chlamydia trachomatis
Evaluation
Establishment of a national syphilis serum bank Tissue analysis
Are patients experiencing undetected chlamydia treatment
failure?
Tissue analysis
Repeat diagnosis of syphilis in attendees of GUM clinics Data analysis
UK HIV stigma index 2014 Questionnaire study
Investigation of measured antibody response to chlamydia
trachomatis infection in women with known clinical
histories using residual serum samples collected from
genitourinary medicine (GUM) clinic attendees
Tissue analysis
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
19
Staff recognition for research achievements (notified to PHE’s Research
Support Office)
Research undertaken by PHE staff may lead to a direct impact on public health
programmes or interventions. This is exceptionally important for the effective delivery of
PHE’s remit. But research can also contribute significantly to the careers and personal
professional satisfaction of those involved. External recognition of research
achievements contribute further to personal fulfilment and we are very pleased to profile
in Table 7 a small snapshot of the many indicators of esteem gained by colleagues.
Table 7: Recognition of PHE staff for their research gained 2014/15
Personal highlights of PHE staff 2014/15
Tim Gant:
gave the Health and Environmental Sciences Institute CITE plenary lecture at
EUROTOX
gave the Philip Chambers memorial lecture at the meeting of the Irish Society of
Toxicology
gave the Royal College of Pathologists Joachim Kohn memorial lecture
renewed as Honorary Professor of Health and Medical Science at the University of
Surrey (three-year renewal)
renewed as Honorary Senior Research Fellow at Imperial College (two-year renewal)
Clare Heaviside:
awarded an Honorary Senior Lectureship at London School of Hygiene & Tropical
Medicine
renewed as an Honorary Senior Research Fellow at the University of Birmingham
Lisa Jameson: awarded PhD from University of Liverpool
Stacey Leech: awarded PhD from London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Helen Maguire: appointed as Honorary Clinical Reader at the Department of Infection
and Population Health, University College, London, 2014
Paul Shrimpton: awarded the European Federation Of Medical Physics Medal in
recognition of an individual's outstanding and internationally acknowledged contribution
to the advancement of medical physics
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
20
Hannah Tanner: awarded Robert Gaddie medal poster prize at the West Midlands
Association of Clinical Biochemistry for a poster entitled “16s PCR and Sequencing:
Development and Validation of a New Assay”
Katy-Anne Thompson: awarded funding for PhD project (Does tap design impact microbial
colonisation/biofilm formation) from Hospital Infection Society, in collaboration with
University of Southampton
Sotiris Vardoulakis: awarded an Honorary Associate Professorship at the
University of Exeter
Neil Woodford:
included in Thomson Reuters’ highly cited researchers list: http://highlycited.com/
seconded part-time to the Prime Minister’s Review on antimicrobial resistance,
chaired by Jim O’Neill
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
21
Appendix 1: Funding awards involving PHE that were secured
during 2014/15
Award title Awarding body Award to
PHE
Lead organisation Collaborating
organisations
Investigating and defining reduced
susceptibility to antiseptics among
Staphylococcus aureus isolates
Hospital Infection Society £9,500 PHE University of Birmingham
MMP-1 Caseating mouse model as
a model of natural transmission
Bill and Melinda Gates
Foundation
£229,400 University of
Southampton
PHE
Prime-boost vaccine combinations
in guinea pigs
Norwegian Government
(NORAD) through
Tuberculosis Vaccine
Institute
£161,124 Tuberculosis Vaccine
Initiative
PHE
Evaluation of rotavirus vaccination
impact on local health system
Pharmaceutical company £20,400 University of
Liverpool
PHE
Development of advanced
Bayesian techniques for application
to the calculation of internal doses
and their uncertainties
United States Department
of Energy
£182,239 Pacific Northwest
National Laboratory
PHE
In vivo microevolution of Neisseria
meningitidis during progression
from harmless commensal to
invasive pathogen
Meningitis UK/Trust £148,387 University of Oxford PHE, Wellcome Trust
Sanger Institute
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
22
Development and validation of
Legionella PCR for water sampling
Health & Safety Executive £61,707 PHE HSE
Sexual risk reduction National Institute for Health
Research
£6,124 UCL School of Life
and Medical
Sciences
PHE
Vaccine evaluation in mice Global Health and
Vaccination Research
(GLOBVAC)
£262,501 Norwegian University
of Life Sciences
PHE
Macrophage growth inhibition
assay project
Bill and Melinda Gates
Foundation (via Aeras)
£43,200 University of Oxford PHE
Evaluation of the Check Points
assay for detecting carbapenemase
genes in multi-drug resistant Gram-
negative bacteria
Check Points £9,100 PHE None
MIRACLe: Molecular indicators of
radiation exposure from circulating
lymphocytes
European Commission
programmes
£32,400 PHE CEA (Commissariat a
l’Energie Atomique et aux
Energies Alternatives)
France
Sampling and decontamination of
inhabited areas using automated
robots
Home Office £49,023 PHE None
Activity of β-lactamase inhibitor
combinations
Pharmaceutical company £30,128 PHE None
Defining reservoirs of ESBL-
producing E. coli and the threat
posed to personal animal and
public health in the UK
National Institute for Health
Research
£594,987 PHE Cardiff University, Animal
& Plant Health Agency,
University of East Anglia,
Scottish Water, Glasgow
Royal Infirmary
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
23
Does ELF-EMF exposure affect
DSB repair following exposure to
100 mGy
The EMF Biological
Research Trust
£26,092 University of Sussex PHE
Shaping EUROpean policies to
promote HEALTH equity (EURO-
HEALTHY)
European Commission
programmes
£197,038 PHE University of Coimbra
and 12 other consortium
partners
Strategic Clinical network
(Maternity) North East and North
Cumbria – data collaboration
NHS Northern Clinical
Network
£30,000 PHE NHS Northern Clinical
Network
North East Invasive Pneumococcal
Disease Research Project
Pharmaceutical company £250,000 PHE University of Leeds
National Drug Treatment Monitoring
System (NDTMS) in prisons
National Offender
Management Service
£169,612 PHE None
Comparing effectiveness of
interventions in the elderly
European Commission
programmes
£432,907 Epiconcept, France PHE and 22 other
consortium partners
Evaluation of eravacycline vs.
carbapenemase-producing
enterobacteriaceae and non
fermenters
Pharmaceutical company £29,574 PHE None
EURO-CARES: A plan for
European curation of returned
extraterrestrial samples
European Commission
programmes
£62,502 Natural History
Museum
PHE and 7 other
consortium partners
BIOMIT National Institutes of
Health
£19,400 CREAL (Centre de
Recerca en
Epidemiologia
Ambiental) Spain
University Hospital
Hradec Kralova, Czech
Republic; PHE
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
24
TBVI co-ordinated bid European Commission
programmes
£1,097,837 Tuberculosis Vaccine
Initiative (TBVI)
PHE and 9 other
consortium partners
Testing the efficacy of chemical
showers with a novel BSL4 suit
Defence Science
Technology Laboratory
(Dstl)
£21,276 PHE None
Interventions against TB: Eliciting
the mucosal response to TB
European Commission
programmes
£623,253 St George's,
University of London
PHE and 8 other
consortium partners
Tropical infectious disease:
expanding and accelerating product
development
Medical Research Council £24,000 Liverpool School of
Tropical Medicine
(LSTM)
PHE, Oxford University
Feasibility study and tests to
determine sterilisation limits for
sample return planetary protection
measures
European Space Agency £689,861 Open University PHE
Assessing the reliability of internal
dose coefficients using uncertainty
analysis
Environment Agency £50,000 PHE None
Improving the anti-Fim3 response
to 5-component acellular pertussis
vaccines
Pharmaceutical company £105,000 PHE None
Innate immune responses as
therapeutic targets
MoD Centre for Defence
Enterprise
£9,726 University of
Strathclyde
PHE
Detection and characterisation of
inflammatory agents associated
with bioaerosols
Natural Environment
Research Council
£84,342 Cranfield University PHE, Open University,
University of West of
England, University of
Plymouth, Environment
Agency
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
25
Immunogenicity study of
staphylococcal vaccine in NHPs
Pharmaceutical company £125,207 Pharmaceutical
company
PHE
Evaluation of test for detection of
carbapenemase activity
Pharmaceutical company £8,912 PHE None
CONCERT European Commission
Joint Programme in
Radiation Protection
£371,042 Federal Office for
Radiation Protection,
Germany
PHE and 5 other
consortium partners
Gates foundation investment to
establish natural transmission
model
Bill and Melinda Gates
foundation
£90,701 PHE None
In vitro Ebola studies – Mapping
targets for therapy
MoD Centre for Defence
Enterprise
£10,629 University of
Liverpool
PHE
Humanised antibodies against
Ebola virus
Wellcome Trust £43,000 Pharmaceutical
company
PHE, University of
Westminster
CLOGIGAT European Commission
programmes
£84,400 PHE Norwegian University of
Life Sciences (UMB),
Norwegian Institute of
Public Health (NIPH)
Haringey Mental Wellbeing Survey Haringey Council £6,300 PHE None
A review of national nuclear
emergency recovery capabilities
Department for Food,
Environment and Rural
Affairs
£191,717 PHE None
European Virus Archive (EVA)
project
European Commission
programmes
£216,073 Aix-Marseille
University, France
PHE and 16 other
consortium partners
Development of a screening
capability for alphamers
Pharmaceutical company £29,656 PHE None
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
26
National Awareness and Early
Diagnosis Initiative (NAEDI) cancer
networks supporting primary care/
Cancer Research UK facilitators
evaluation
University of Durham £15,680 University of Durham PHE National Cancer
Intelligence Network
Activity of protein synthesis
inhibitors against multiresistant
bacteria
Pharmaceutical company £19,147 PHE None
Modern approaches for developing
diagnostics for Ebola virus
European Commission
programmes
£243,742 Public Health Agency
of Sweden
PHE
Ebola virus disease – correlates of
protection, determinants of
outcome, and clinical management
European Commission
programmes
£177,147 Bernhard Nocht
Institute
PHE
Clinical trial of Favipiravir for activity
against Ebola
European Commission
programmes
£12,289 Lyon P4 PHE, Institut Pasteur,
Universiteit Utrecht,
Bernhard-Nocht-Institute
for Tropical Medicine
Training on PCR assays for
arbovirus detection
Dstl £127,000 PHE Institute of Virology, Baku
A point of care antimicrobial
resistance test for Neisseria
gonorrhoeae and Mycoplasma
genitalium infection
National Institute for Health
Research
£85,153 St George’s,
University of London
PHE, University of East
Anglia, Atlas Genetics
Exploring the enhancer effect of a
new Serine-β-Lactamase inhibitor,
mechanisms of resistance
Enterobacteriaceae
Pharmaceutical company £43,327 PHE None
Rapid detection of volatile organic
compounds
Dstl £81,612 PHE None
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
27
Evaluation London HIV Prevention
Programme
Schools For Public Health
Research
£112,000 UCL PHE
MOFINA (mobile filovirus nucleic
acid test)
European Commission
programmes
£92,036 Pharmaceutical
company
PHE
Collaboration on ovine polyclonals Pharmaceutical company £890,682 PHE Pharmaceutical company
Resistance surveillance programme
on bacteraemia and lower
respiratory tract infection
British Society for
Antimicrobial
Chemotherapy
£254,200 PHE NHS
Development of
fluoroindoloquinolones as broad
spectrum bactericidal agents
against multi-drug resistant bacteria
Medical Research Council £12,000 Kings College
London
PHE
Using chemical modification of a
novel antimicrobial drug scaffold to
reduce efflux from multidrug
resistant Gram-negative ESKAPE
pathogens (studentship)
Biotechnology and
Biological Sciences
Research Council
0 Kings College
London
PHE
New approaches for antibiotic
development (studentship)
Kings Health Partnerships 0 Kings College
London
PHE
Health protection research unit in
healthcare acquired infections
National Institute for Health
Research
£53,400 University of Oxford PHE, Animal & Plant
Health Agency
Health protection research unit in
healthcare acquired infections
National Institute for Health
Research
£84,700 Imperial College
London
PHE, Wellcome Sanger
Institute, NWL Academic
Health Science Network,
Cambridge Veterinary
School
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
28
Health protection research unit in
blood-borne and sexually
transmitted infections
National Institute for Health
Research
£369,700 University College
London
PHE, London School of
Hygiene and Tropical
Medicine
Health protection research unit in
gastrointestinal infections
National Institute for Health
Research
£106,000 University of
Liverpool
PHE, University of East
Anglia, University of
Oxford, Institute of Food
Research
Health protection research unit in
chemical and radiation threats and
hazards
National Institute for Health
Research
£165,400 Newcastle University PHE
Health protection research unit in
health impact of environmental
hazards
National Institute for Health
Research
£236,600 Kings College
London
PHE, Imperial College
London
Health protection research unit in
environmental change and health
National Institute for Health
Research
£173,600 London School of
Hygiene and Tropical
Medicine
PHE, Exeter University,
University College
London
Health protection research unit in
development of modelling
methodology
National Institute for Health
Research
£227,000 Imperial College
London
PHE
Health protection research unit in
emergency preparation and
response
National Institute for Health
Research
£205,500 Kings College
London
PHE, Newcastle
University, University of
East Anglia
Health protection research unit in
emerging infections and biological
threats
National Institute for Health
Research
£108,800 University of
Liverpool
PHE, Liverpool School of
Tropical Medicine
PHE Research 2014/15: Annual review
29
Health protection research unit in
respiratory infections
National Institute for Health
Research
£156,700 Imperial College
London
PHE, Imperial College
NHS Trust, Birmingham
University
Health protection research unit in
immunisation
National Institute for Health
Research
£122,000 London School of
Hygiene and Tropical
Medicine
PHE
Health protection research unit in
evaluation of interventions
National Institute for Health
Research
£120,000 University of Bristol PHE, University College
London, Cambridge MRC
Biostatistics Unit,
University of the West of
England