photdm implementation feedback | jesus salgado | esac | 18 october 2011 | ivoa interop @ pune 2011 |...

17
PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus Salgado ESAVO 18/10/2011

Upload: cameron-miller

Post on 17-Jan-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1

Photometry DM implementation feedback

Jesus Salgado

ESAVO

18/10/2011

Page 2: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 2

Introduction

– Required component of the IVOA SED effort– Effort focused in adding what it was missing from current known specifications

(Spectrum DM & Characterization)

– DM authors covers main IVOA groups involved on photometry:P. Osuna, D. Baines (ESAVO)C. Rodrigo (SVO)M. Louys, M. Allen, S.Derriere (Strasbourg/CDS)E. Hatziminaoglou (ESO)J. McDowell (VAO)

– Authors are technicians and scientists – Draft was reviewed by EuroVO Science Advisory Committee so we get good

inputs and ideas from scientific point of view

Page 3: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 3

FILTERFILTER PROFILE PROFILE SERVICESERVICE

(SVO)(SVO)

Give me list of registered FiltersGive me list of registered Filters(possible constrained by wavelength range)(possible constrained by wavelength range)

Response, VOTableResponse, VOTable

Give Details for a certain filter listGive Details for a certain filter list

Response, VOTable Response, VOTable Including link to Transmission curveIncluding link to Transmission curve

Show filters so user can selectShow filters so user can select

Use filterUse filterDetails to create synthetic photometry points using real/model Details to create synthetic photometry points using real/model

spectra as inputspectra as input

FILTERFILTERPROFILEPROFILESERVICESERVICE

PROTOCOLPROTOCOL

Initial first use case: Synthetic PhotometryInitial first use case: Synthetic Photometry

Page 4: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 4

FILTERFILTER PROFILE PROFILE SERVICESERVICE

(SVO)(SVO)

PHOTOMETRYPHOTOMETRYDATADATA

SERVICESERVICE(SVO)(SVO) PHOTOMETRYPHOTOMETRY

DATADATASERVICESERVICE(CDS?)(CDS?) PHOTOMETRYPHOTOMETRY

DATADATASERVICESERVICE(others?)(others?)

SSAP like querySSAP like query

To be definedTo be defined(Photometry details attached(Photometry details attached

or by filter ID)or by filter ID)

FILTERFILTERPROFILEPROFILESERVICESERVICE

PROTOCOLPROTOCOL

Initial second use case: Photometry in catalogs

Page 5: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 5

FILTERFILTER PROFILE PROFILE SERVICESERVICE

(SVO)(SVO)

PHOTOMETRYPHOTOMETRYDATADATA

SERVICESERVICE(CDS)(CDS)

Cone Search like queryCone Search like query

VOTable + GroupsVOTable + Groups

FILTERFILTERPROFILEPROFILESERVICESERVICE

PROTOCOLPROTOCOL

Final second use case: Photometry in catalogs

Page 6: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 6

Vizier implementation

– IVOA note was produced to describe how to include photometry characterization in groups in a catalog VOTable response

– This can be used for Cone Search and TAP services

– Relevant utypes of the Photometry DM WD are used so applications can handle the photometric information

– More than 200 catalogs are being adapted in Vizier to include this information (acknowledge to F. Ochsenbein and S. Derriere) (ASU syntax for queries)

– Some of them have been already included in VOSpec as a proof of concept

UGC2826_2MASS_phot.xml

UGC2826_NVSS_phot.xml

– Cone Search services have been updated to latest PhotDM

– These services could be registered using the photometry capability (Nice to have)

Page 7: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 7

Vizier implementation (II)

– Example for 2MASS

– http://cdsarc.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/test/votable/-P?-source=2246&-c=3C273&-c.rs=5

– New added feature recently added:

– http://cdsarc.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/test/votable/-P?-c=3C273&-c.rs=5

– Catalog selection (-source= parameter) can be removed, All photometric information for all vizier catalogues, provided you give a center target. Example for 5 arcsec search around 3C273

Page 8: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 8

Filter Profile Service

Description

– Provides a way to retrieve information about filters

http://svo.cab.inta-csic.es/theory/fps3/

– More than 1700 filters.

– Web interface

– description

– graphs

– properties

– zero points

VO service

– Retrieving information about a filter knowing its ID

http://svo.cab.inta-csic.es/theory/fps3/fps.php?ID=2MASS/2MASS.H

– Retrieving information about a filter and its calibration knowing PhotCalIDhttp://svo.cab.inta-csic.es/theory/fps3/fps.php?PhotCalID=2MASS/2MASS.H/AB

– Searching for filters: SSAP-like service

Page 9: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 9

Filter Profile Service (II)

Page 10: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 10

Filter Profile Service (III)

Page 11: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 11

Filter Profile Service (IV)

Page 12: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 12

VOSpec implementation

– Access to SSAP like services including photometric data

– Access to Cone Search services including photometry capability

– Access to Filter Profile Service to get Filter descriptions

– Module to use transmission curve to generate synthetic photometry

Page 13: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 13

Pending improvements in VOSpec

– Integrate version with the recent services updates. No major problem is expected as neither FPS nor Cone Searches have reported problems during the update to latest DM version (Required)

– Explore new vizier service features (A real nice to have)

– Discover cone search (TAP?) services from the registry by using the photometry capability (Capability not defined and changes expected in registry) (Nice to have)

– Develop specific registry navigation of cone search services (Nice to have)

– Explore Filter Profile Service interface with a dedicated panel (This can be done already although it would be better to have a Filter Profile Service protocol defined)

– As soon as we have a stable Spectrum 1.2, adapt SSAP/Spectrum parser to consume photometric information (Future feature)

Page 14: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 14

Photometry DM 1.0

Page 15: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 15

Photometry DM 1.0 (II)

– New version 1.0 (13/10/2011) under author list discussion

– This version includes two types of changes:

– “Introduction” and “Astronomical Photometry” sections updated

– Some minor changes in the model itself (only some utypes and description updates in line with other IVOA data models)

– Pending: Find possible optical-biased terms in the text. Preliminary analysis shows that this does not produce implementation problems

– Integrate the different updated implementations

– Distribution to the working group and external reviewers (extra effort is required)

– If no major problems are found in the model, start RFC process

Page 16: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 16

Other specifications pending issues

– Describe the photometry capability so cone search or TAP services can be properly registered and discovered (not necessary for PhotDM although useful)

– Describe Filter Profile Service as a separate note (work to be done in coordination with DAL group)

– Follow-up of Spectrum 1.2 evolution (that will include PhotDM utypes)

Page 17: PhotDM implementation feedback | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 18 October 2011 | IVOA interop @ Pune 2011 | Pag. 1 Photometry DM implementation feedback Jesus

IPDA PDAP | Jesus Salgado | ESAC | 13 September 2011 | IPDA meeting Pasadena 2011 | Pag. 17

THANK YOU

Jesus Salgado

PhotDM: implementation [email protected]