pipeline construction in pursuit of the zero accident project

102
Pipeline Construction In pursuit of the “zero accident” project project Mainline pipeline construction is an industry that requires specialized solutions to the effective implementation of a Health and Safety Management System. If a Risk Management Plan is to be effective, it is essential that it be simple, streamlined, and reinforced with pipeline & right of way specific solutions that incorporate historic lessons way-specific solutions that incorporate historic lessons learned and address the unique nature of the workforce and the fast paced work methodology. http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Upload: peter-kinsey

Post on 20-Jan-2015

6.886 views

Category:

Business


10 download

DESCRIPTION

Pipeline Construction - In Pursuit of the Zero Accident Project

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Pipeline Construction In pursuit of the “zero accident”

projectproject

Mainline pipeline construction is an industry that requires specialized solutions to the effective implementation of a

Health and Safety Management System. If a Risk y g yManagement Plan is to be effective, it is essential that it be simple, streamlined, and reinforced with pipeline & right of

way specific solutions that incorporate historic lessonsway-specific solutions that incorporate historic lessons learned and address the unique nature of the workforce

and the fast paced work methodology.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 2: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Rearranging tons of earth; securing working equipment while performing heavy lifts on extreme slopes; moving

and working heavy equipment on unstable ground; blasting ROW and then rock ditch; diverting rivers; lifting and moving tons of materiel over every type of terrain a d o g to s o ate e o e e e y type o te a

imaginable, are daunting tasks.

Pulling it off without accidents and losses is aPulling it off without accidents and losses is a formidable challenge

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 3: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Much of the equipment used on a pipeline ROW during mainline construction is unique to the Pipeline industry q p y

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 4: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Each piece of equipment has it’s own characteristics, history of accidents and inherent

hazards

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 5: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Pipeliners are faced with extreme slopes and rugged terrain

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 6: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Imagine arriving on the ROW for the first time, amid the fast paced and seemingly chaotic activity, of equipment and

people afoot, all in constant motion.people afoot, all in constant motion. How do you identify an unsafe act, practice or condition, if

you are unfamiliar with the equipment, it’s limitations and the work methodology? t e o et odo ogy

Where will the Caught Between, Struck by, Struck Against…injuries occur next? It can be a little overwhelming. Your first concern will probably be locating a

safe place from which to observe the action and where you won’t be in the way.Ind str specific ha ard recognition training is essentialIndustry specific hazard recognition training is essential.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 7: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

The degree of success or failure of your HSSEThe degree of success or failure of your HSSE Management System (MS) is measured by the number

of incidents and accidents occurring on your project.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 8: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

The work is hazardous strenuoushazardous, strenuous, and very fast-paced. It

is undertaken at remote worksites, withremote worksites, with limited access making it difficult to monitor to

control

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 9: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

All pipeline projects attract a percentage of itinerant professionals who are accustomed to being well paid for p g p

their knowledge and skills…

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 10: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

…who have their own culture, are uniquely independent, and fiercely reluctant to changing long established work y g g g

habits

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 11: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

The workforce and supervisors may speak different languages and be from different ethnic and religiouslanguages and be from different ethnic and religious

backgrounds, intelligent, but largely uneducated, often illiterate and intimidated by paper work.

http://www pipe-line-safety comhttp://www.pipe line safety.com

Page 12: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Many of the workers are new to and unfamiliar with the equipment and work processes and require

ongoing specialized training. As the ROW enters new areas under changing labor organization or political

influence, the previously trained and nowinfluence, the previously trained and now competent workforce, will have to be let go and a new group will replace them, requiring repeated re-training

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 13: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

• Working very long hours, seven days a week, frequently well into the hours of darkness is afrequently well into the hours of darkness is a

universal practice within the industry. The risks from all these hazards are compounded, as time

progresses, by an increasing fatigue factor. • Each morning and often several times a day, renewed risk assessments must be made. This

requires experienced and competent supervisorssupervisors.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 14: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Inexperienced workers are exposed to a constantly changing menu of life threatening hazards as thechanging menu of life threatening hazards as the

work progresses along the pipeline corridor and the worksite ground conditions underfoot continuously

change…

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 15: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

… bedrock, shot rock, boulders, sand, swamp, permafrost, extreme slopes side-slopeextreme slopes, side slope…

…all present differing and unique hazards during the operation of heavy equipment, the use of side booms and cranes for lifting operations and the handling of materielcranes for lifting operations, and the handling of materiel

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 16: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

…and what about the complexity of managing a fleet of vehicles logging approximately 800,000 miles a month in gg g pp y ,arguably the most rugged, extreme off-road and hazardous conditions on this planet, where, at the wheel drivers are assigned whose driving experience iswheel, drivers are assigned whose driving experience is limited to driving on horizontal asphalt in an urban environment

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 17: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Despite all these seemingly insurmountable hurdles, an accident free project is achievable. It

h b d b fhas been done before. There are specific and systemic controls that have

been implemented on previous pipelinebeen implemented on previous pipeline construction projects that have proven

significantly effective at reducing losses, injuries and accidentsand accidents

The following slides outline a few suggestionsThe following slides outline a few suggestions based on those past and proven solutions.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 18: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

If "Safety First" is your motto, then molding attitudes and setting an example are your priorities. The first and most important step which cannot be over-emphasized is to

t bli h li f i ti b t thestablish open lines of communication between the workers and management, to encourage the worker's

suggestions, and demonstrate that you are receptive to, and show respect for their suggestions To achieve thisand show respect for their suggestions. To achieve this

you have to gain the worker's respect and trust. Considering the often large cultural gap separating the rank

and file worker with the manager, this is a complex and g , pdelicate task and probably the single most important

aspect of your HSSE Management System.Once your workers start talking to you, you are on your way

t d ti d ti i th b f id t dto a dramatic reduction in the numbers of accidents and incidents. Molding the attitudes of an entire workforce is

achievable. Your yard-stick for measuring success is how frequently your workers willingly and on their ownhow frequently your workers willingly and on their own

initiative speak out, without fear of reprisal, about hazards they have identified. As you start to get

feedback from the seeds you planted, it can be exciting y p , gand very rewarding.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 19: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Establishing open lines of communication between the workers and management will

reduce lossesreduce lossesEmpowering the workers to speak out and take action when they see

something that might cause an accident requires:g g q1. A Client delivered, specialized HSSE behavioral training workshop for

Client inspection staff and incoming Contractor upper management and site supervisors. Management participation is critical.

2 A high profile project system of rewards aimed at the individual worker2. A high profile project system of rewards, aimed at the individual worker and contractor supervisors based on the identification of specific and overlooked hazards, which if not identified could have caused an accident. It should include a) daily spot awards: caps, t-shirts, coffee cups etc. b) weekly meetings where certificates and more significant gifts areweekly meetings where certificates and more significant gifts are awarded, and c) monthly award ceremonies where special recognition of a worker’s participation is recognized by prizes of significant monetary value.

3 U il l f f l3. Unilateral enforcement of zero tolerance.

Only with the worker’s cooperation, participation and constant vigilance on the ROW can a zero accident project be a realityROW can a zero accident project be a reality.

Page 20: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Empowering WorkersParticipation by Contractor foremen/site supervisors is

essential

Th k ill f d id if h d if h f i l f h iThe workers will not step forward to identify hazards, if they fear reprisals from their foreman.

If the Contractor Project upper management buys in, the foremen will too. Financial i ti k ll t ti t th C t tincentives work well to motivate the Contractor.

Rewards aimed at an individual’s participation can be very effective. Awarding hats and mementos to the individual works better than recognizing a group and giving out TVs & VCR M t lk Si ifi t fi i l d f id tif i l k d d iVCRs. Money talks. Significant financial awards for identifying overlooked and serious hazards send a clear message to the worker of management’s commitment to Safety.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 21: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Money, careers and employment are frequently on the line during the course pipeline projects.

The first time you as a manager allow HSSE to take second place to schedule, the news will spread through the workforce like a wild fire Everyone is watching andthe workforce like a wild fire. Everyone is watching and

talking.

This is how the momentum of a carefully implemented HSSE MS can become undermined. Disillusioned

workers don’t participate. Safety really is an attitude. p p y yOn most projects this is a common failure

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 22: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Money TalksyContractors actions are based on self interest – profiting financially from compliance with HSSE requirements is a strong and effective motivational force.a strong and effective motivational force.– Baseline mandatory HSSE requirements must be

incorporated into the contract. Withh ldi t f h f– Withholding a percentage of cash from progresspayments, based on results of periodic HSSEEvaluations and a Performance Monitoring System

– Penalties for non completion of contract on time onlyincreases the schedule driven nature of a project andincreases the likelihood of accidents when nearingcompletion.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 23: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Identifying and prohibiting poor practices establishing clearIdentifying and prohibiting poor practices, establishing clear standards & expectations with the Contractor will reduce

losses

Pipe line construction, as an industry, goes back sixty years or more. The equipment and the methodology

have not changed significantlyhave not changed significantly.

The same accidents reoccur on one pipeline project after another The root causes of those accidents are knownanother. The root causes of those accidents are known.

Focusing on the root causes of past loss-events at the start of a project and establishing standards to eliminate thoseof a project and establishing standards to eliminate those causes will prevent re-occurrences of those loss events

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 24: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Lack of supervision is often the root cause of accidentsDue to the multitude of isolated worksites along the hundreds of

miles of right of way corridor, supervision is frequently only intermittent at many locations.

Buried gas

pipeline

A clean-up dozer is unsupervised for 45 minutes at the start of a shift. TheA clean up dozer is unsupervised for 45 minutes at the start of a shift. The project has no clear procedure for dealing with buried utilities crossing the

ROW and enforcement of standards is slack.

The blade snags a gas pipeline which leads to

this ►

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 25: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standards for controlling power line hazardsIf the hazards of power lines are not strongly emphasizedIf the hazards of power lines are not strongly emphasized,

procedures established and strictly enforced, accidents will occur.

A supervisor was not informed about a low power line crossing the ROW up ahead. The power line project procedure lacksthe ROW up ahead. The power line project procedure lacks

adequate controls and is loosely enforced. It does not require a pre-job survey of access roads to identify power line hazards,

nor other controls which are necessary to manage this extremenor other controls which are necessary to manage this extreme hazard. The supervisor sends an excavator out to the shoofly

for loading out…

Page 26: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

The operator had not been trained what to do to t li f ll i t t ith li Hstay alive following contact with a power line. He

attempted to get off his tractor and was subsequently electrocutedsubsequently electrocuted

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 27: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

SIDE BOOMS

O t d Sid bOperator and Side boom mechanic competency Assurance

Why is it necessary?

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 28: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Establishing clear controls and standards with the Contractor at the start of a project will prevent re-

occurrences of these accidents.

These two accidents were completely avoidable If the Client hadThese two accidents were completely avoidable. If the Client had established standards and enforced them, these accidents would not

have occurred.It is very surprising how quickly a side boom can lose stabilityIt is very surprising how quickly a side boom can lose stability

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 29: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

On constantly changing worksite ground conditions: bedrock, shot rock, boulders, sand, extreme slopes, side-, , , , p ,slope… side booms perform 95% of all critical lifts on a

pipeline construction project. The safe operation of a side boom in these conditions requires skilled and specializedboom in these conditions requires skilled and specialized tradesmen: Operators and mechanics, who possess a set

of skills and experience very different from a crane operator d d b kh h iand dozer or backhoe mechanics.

Moving heavy suspended loads, and working on unstable g y p gground, exposes the operator and his ground support crew to a constantly changing menu of life threatening hazards. Exposure to the changing weather and long shifts sevenExposure to the changing weather, and long shifts, seven days a week, often well into the hours of darkness, further compounds these hazards by the addition of fatigue and

di ll h i d ditiradically changing ground conditions

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 30: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor PracticeCrowning booms at Tie-in

Impossible for operator to gauge strain on load line. Load line failure is sudden an lethal

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 31: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Is this unsafe?Poor preparation of ROW

Didn’t prepare ROW to get boomsDidn t prepare ROW to get booms close enough for the lift – relying on

excavator buckets to restrain counterweights to increase lifting

No Construction Road, no swamp mats

power beyond Caterpillar specifications

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 32: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Good PracticeU f tUse of swamp mats

Note: poor practices are not identified in

this slide

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 33: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor Practice Excavator buckets are used to increase the side boom’s lifting power beyond

Caterpillar specifications Often the reason is that the Contractor has notCaterpillar specifications. Often the reason is that the Contractor has not mobilized enough side booms to perform the work safely, or the foreman is inexperienced. It is a bad habit and dangerous practice that is very common

and almost universally accepted in the industryand almost universally accepted in the industry.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 34: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Restraining counterweights subjects a lifting operation to the potential of sudden and catastrophic failure

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 35: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor Practice

Load line two

blockedblocked

Boom lineBoom line tight

This operator was carrying his load high and close to the Boom

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 36: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor craft trainingLack of operator knowledge of Cross Steering,

a light rain shower and a clay ROW

How can a side boom flip upside down, crush and kill the operator when descending such a slight grade ?

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 37: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor Practice – Boom line under load should never touch the bull horns

Boom Line Breaks on

contact with bullload should never touch the bull horns contact with bull horns

Sudden failure of boom. Boom drops onto workers at

tie in.http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 38: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Get to know the Side Boom Tractor95% of all lifts are performed with the side boom

A very high percentage of ROW hazards are associated with it use.

Newer Hydraulic “High Track” Side Boom Tractor

Older conventional 500 series Side BoomTrack Side Boom Tractor series Side Boom

Tractorhttp://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 39: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

The older conventional series side boom tractors are recognized by their rear drive sprocket and g y p

“oval track” profile

Loss of Engine on a steep slope = Loss of Control

These tractors are equipped with a manually applied, mechanical

Oval track

profiley

braking system supplemented by a hydraulic booster. It is common practice in the pipeline industry for side booms

operators to have their brake bands backed-off, beyond Caterpillar specifications.

On a steep slope, in the event of an engine failure, if the operator does not apply the brake before the engine stops or immediately

afterwards, before the tractor gains momentum, the tractor’s manual brakes will not stop the tractor from taking off uncontrolled down the

slope It will not stop until it comes to level ground or hits otherslope. It will not stop until it comes to level ground or hits other equipment or vehicles in it’s path.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 40: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Hydraulic Series side boom tractors are recognized by their rear drive sprocket and ecog ed by t e ea d e sp oc et a d

“high track” profile

Th lifti f th tLoss of engine on a steep

The lifting power of the more recent high track hydraulic side booms, is

transferred from the engine to the cable drum by way of a hydraulic pump,

slope = breaks engage in “fail safe” manner

y y y p p,hydraulic motor and a couple of valves. The newer high track hydraulic group

are reliable though not as maneuverable as the first and do notmaneuverable as the first and do not

require the same level of skill to operate.

Advantages

High

•Require less operator training.•Almost eliminates the possibility of draw works failure (catastrophic dropping of load)High

Trackdropping of load)•Track brakes lock on engine failure

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 41: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Boom line brake

Steering Clutches

Page 42: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standard “Double Dogging” Side Boom TractorsDouble Dogging Side Boom Tractors

parked with booms up should be “double dogged” which ensures that the boom or

load will not fall unintentionallyload will not fall unintentionally

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 43: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

StandardOn steep slopes ensure operators stay on p p p y

their tractors

If the operator bumps the levers, getting out of his seat, the load will release unless the levers are set in the locked out position. In winter, bulky clothing can

catch the controls on the operator’s left side and put the tractor in gear. The operator then inadvertently steps onto the moving track The track catches andoperator then inadvertently steps onto the moving track. The track catches and

sweeps his foot sideways, he stumbles and his body is either sucked under the cross bar (gear in forward) or (gear in reverse) he falls to the rear, and his tractor

runs over him - this usually ends in a fatality.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 44: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standard: Equipment maintenance

Preferred PracticeCross spooling damages

wire rope & invites i t f ilequipment failure

Poor practice

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 45: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standard: Equipment maintenanceIf you see a boom laid down for maintenance

There are two wedge socket terminals on the

If you see a boom laid down for maintenance check the wedge sockets

There are two wedge socket terminals on the side boom’s lifting rigging. Check the wedges in both the boom and load line wedge sockets

The boom line raises and lowers the boom. A point of Side boom load line blocks with

similar wedge socket terminal endfailure can be at the wedge socket terminal on the top

boom block

similar wedge socket terminal end

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 46: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Maintenance Standards should never be taken for granted. Contractor management competence & integrity should

not be assumed It should be verifiedThe cable that failed was steel cored & ¾ inch. Two months

ft i t ll ti it d

not be assumed. It should be verified.

V-shape ddl f after installation it passed an

inspection. Four months after that it failed. The cable parted just inside the terminal wedge

saddle of home made

wedge caused

failure here just inside the terminal wedge socket. Only extraordinary luck

prevented a fatality in this incidentincident

Wedge sockets and wedges on Caterpillar side boom

tractors are machined parts and critical in the lifting

rigging.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 47: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Contractor maintenance assurance and assurance of competency of mechanical staff is a very important.

Auditing Contractor equipment before mobilization in countryAuditing Contractor equipment before mobilization in-country will reduce accidents and incidents on your project.

Caterpillar

Home made wedge

identified in wedge side boom

load line wedge socket

Short cuts in Contractor maintenance should be anticipated. Side booms should be closely looked at prior to and after mobilizationshould be closely looked at prior to and after mobilization.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 48: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standards on Steep Slopes

Secure equipment on Side booms should use hard bar harnesses noslopes with proper

harnesseshard bar harnesses, no

attachment to belly hooks

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 49: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standard - Equipment MobilizationMobilization of equipment for operation on steep slopes with “StreetMobilization of equipment for operation on steep slopes with Street

Pads” designed for operation on horizontal asphalt should be prohibited

“Street Pads” –three grouser

bars

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 50: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standard for equipment tracks

Three Grouser “street pads” full of mud

Single grouser pads i t fpads – full of mud appropriate for

boulder-strewn steep slopeshttp://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 51: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standard - Pipe Support Serious debilitating injuries and fatalities from poorly

supported pipe joints & sections are common.

This type of pipe support is unacceptable

It is necessary to establish and strictly enforce a uniform standard in building skid cradles, crotches and slides

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 52: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

The skids must be a hard wood of minimumThe skids must be a hard wood of minimum specific dimensions

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 53: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor Practice

Avoid this type of construction construction

This… …becomes this

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 54: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

The pipe sections expand/lengthen in the sun during the day and contract/shrink in the cool of the night, causing significant longitudinal movement on their skid supportssignificant longitudinal movement on their skid supports. Skid supports have to be built and spaced correctly to

accommodate that movement.

Improved but not optimum Practice Skid

Good Practice: Skid Crib. Sand bags are not the best choice ofCrotch best choice of

chockhttp://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 55: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Good Practicecoaching may be necessary g y y

Note that the weight of the

pipe section onpipe section on the top skid in

the “V”…

…locks the dl t thcradle together

minimizing casual theft of wood by locals y

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 56: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Mainline sections should be crotched every 4 – 6 joints and more frequently at loose ends. Serious debilitating

accidents on pipe gang caused by pipe movement due toaccidents on pipe gang caused by pipe movement due to collapsing skid supports, coming off the lose end of a

section are not uncommon

Note: A disgruntled local with a pocket knife can in a few minutes undermine the stability of this pipe section causing

a serious hazarda serious hazardhttp://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 57: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Careful planning of the length of sections and incorporation of loose ends is also important…p

There are the consequences for poor practices

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 58: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standards at Crossings Procedures and controls are necessary at Road

d R il C i id id dand Railway Crossings to avoid accidents and protect the asphalt road surface

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 59: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standards at CrossingsStandards at CrossingsLack of Adequate Controls at Railroad Crossing

can Damage Rails which will Derail a Traing

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 60: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Rails must be protected. Specific t d d t t t il t bstandards to protect rails must be

established

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 61: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standards at CrossingsExcavating (daylighting) pressurized pipelines

Strict adherence to aStrict adherence to a detailed procedure is

required for excavating f i tiliti iforeign utilities crossing

our ROW.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 62: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standards for Excavations Preparation of excavations for worker entry arePreparation of excavations for worker entry are

critical

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 63: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Standard for fencing off open excavationsStandard for fencing off open excavations

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 64: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Bell Hole StandardE th t th ld h t i t dit h idEnsure that the welders have an escape area cut into ditch side wall and floor of trench, in the event of lateral or vertical pipe

movement.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 65: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Bell Hole StandardBell Hole Standard

Good side wall cut back however

slope is pinadequate for

safe worker entry

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 66: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Bell Hole StandardBell Hole Standard

If the pipe moves laterally, suddenly and violently two

Mainline ditch wall cut back for safety of workers

workers will be crushed

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 67: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Bell Hole StandardBell Hole Standard

Good side wall cutwall cut back but

ditch slope iis

inadequate

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 68: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Hoisting StandardsPoor Practice

This poor practice is very difficult to monitor and control along a pipeline corridor It results in many accidents Lifting with excavator buckets iscorridor. It results in many accidents. Lifting with excavator buckets is acceptable using buckets with certified and approved factory eyes and

hooks. Control can be achieved by requiring the Contractor to identify each bucket with clear markings - weld on identification tags or numbers andbucket with clear markings weld on identification tags or numbers, and

carry on each machine the bucket’s certification. The contractor site supervisor must ensure this documentation, including the lifting chart for

excavator is in the cab of each excavator, for cross reference/verification by , yClient inspection staff.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 69: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Good PracticeFactory and weld-on eyes and hooksy y

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 70: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor PracticePotential Crush Injury – Front end set in tractorPotential Crush Injury Front end set in tractor

Hooking up a Choker Belt requires positioning of workers on both sides of a pipe joint, and one worker in

the Danger Zone between two joints.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 71: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Workers must at all times avoid placing themselves between two joints.

Crush injuries of workers between two joints are not uncommon in this industry. Potential Causes & what to look out for:

Earl morning frost and the operator does not arm his break bands to• Early morning frost and the operator does not warm his break bands to remove frost/ice. The boom falls outward

• If the operator doesn't latch his boom, as he picks up the load line the boom comes out. If the operator reacts to seeing his boom swing out, by latching the boom brake, the load line will jerk the closest pipe joint toward the adjacent joint crushing any worker in between.

• Poor boom maintenance has already been identified with respect to this set in tractor

• Operator accustomed to live draw works is put on a 583 R with• Operator accustomed to live draw works is put on a 583 R with hydraulic draw works (which has no manual brake). If he has not set the safety latches and he bumps the free-fall lever, a suspended sag will drop and flop over against the adjacent pipe jointdrop and flop over against the adjacent pipe joint.

• Failure of boom line - loss of boom head pin, home made wedges etc.

Page 72: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor PracticePoor Practice

Why should workers not ride on skid sloops?

Note side slope on ROW

y p

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 73: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

What is wrong with this picture?at s o g t t s p ctu e

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 74: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

What is wrong with these pictures?What is wrong with these pictures?

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 75: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

What are these men anticipating? What is the poor practice that created this hazard?

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 76: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

When lowering-in a pipe string under a utility crossing or flume pipe, in a deep & unsafe excavation, how do youflume pipe, in a deep & unsafe excavation, how do you attach a sling to the leading side boom’s load line hook,

without having to sending a worker into the unsafe ditch?

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 77: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor PracticeAvoiding this situation requires changing habits, planning and incorporating an alternate strategy in the method statement

for creek crossings.Hazard:

The solution to poor planning invariably is to take a chance and put a worker atand put a worker at risk. Sometimes you get away with it and sometimes you don’t Workers in

unsafe

A worker just climbed

under the

unsafe sloughing excavation

Placing workers in unsafe, sloughing ditch must be avoided. No workers should be allowed to cross the ditch on the elevated flume pipe, nor climb under the

fl i t f d th h th lli i h li Th th d t t t h ld

under the pipe here

flume pipe to feed through the pulling winch line. The method statement should include mitigation measures to avoid such hazardous practices

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 78: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Common accident on the bending crew. On each ll f th b di hipull of the bending machine

Safety steel toe

saves foot

Worker inadvertently places toes

under tongueunder tongue

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 79: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

You see an operator checking his fuel tankI thi f ?Is this safe?

Common hip crush injury. Operator’s hip touches counterweight lever Counterweights creep up increasingcounterweight lever. Counterweights creep up increasing pressure on the lever which speeds up the counterweight

withdrawal. Operator is crushed between the tank or ROPS d t i htand counterweight.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 80: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

You are a lower-in inspector observing the Contractor lower in a section over the crestContractor lower in a section over the crest

of and down a steep slope

A very serious accident is about to happen. Can you see what is wrong?y g

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 81: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

What Went Wrong?

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 82: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Lack of operator skill, poor engineering and gaps in the steep slope method statement

caused this accident

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 83: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

It takes only a moment of inattention to roll a side boom. Side boom operator competency boo S de boo ope ato co pete cyassurance is important on every project

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 84: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

What Went Wrong?What Went Wrong?

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 85: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

With schedule driven pressures of a lump sum contract, it is easy to lose control and get squeezed into a corner where the cost of

backing up and starting again is perceived as too expensive and/orbacking up and starting again is perceived as too expensive and/or hazardous, and where taking a shortcut is too tempting for both

Contractor and Client construction delivery managersHazards: The solution

1. Placing workers under and on the ditch side of

Hazards:to poor

planning invariably is

to take asuspended sections

2. Using excavator

to take a chance and put a worker

at risk. buckets on counterweights to increase load capability of side

Sometimes you get

away with it andcapability of side

boom

The method statement should include

and sometimes you don’t

Worker cleaning mud off pipe and fixing holidays

in coatingThe method statement should include mitigation measures to prohibit and avoid

such hazardous practices

in coating

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 86: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Potential Accident

Avoiding a crush injury against the headache rack is about sequence of h k l t l i f th lki d k i ti ti i f lifthook placement, clearing of the walking deck, communication, timing of lift and coordinated movement of tractor and truck. If side boom lifts the pipe

joint prematurely, it can rock forward into the headache rack, crushing anyone in it's path.y p

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 87: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

After Equipment has been mobilized and is in-country it may be too late and too y y

expensive to make changes

Fleet of personnel carriers has been mobilized

Hazard Identified : Personnel i hi h t d d

This accident was identified and anticipated. There was not a long wait

to see the resultingcarriers high centered, and unsuitable for steep slopes

and unstable in rough terrain

to see the resulting accident

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 88: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Poor practices and substandard Contractor equipment maintenance lead to seriousequipment maintenance lead to serious

accidents

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 89: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Equipment StandardsFull height headache racks are recommendedFull height headache racks are recommended on stringing trucks to protect the driver from

sudden deceleration

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 90: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Equipment StandardsHoe Rock Hammers require heavy wire mesh screensHoe Rock Hammers require heavy wire mesh screens

fitted, facing forward and outside of the operator’s glass window. This screen is essential to protect the operator

f i b k j tilfrom airborne rock projectiles.

Operators struck and injured by rock projectiles is not uncommonOperators struck and injured by rock projectiles is not uncommon

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 91: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Good PracticeGood Practice

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 92: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Equipment Standards Test heads should have a pre-fabricated grating/platform p g g p

incorporated into their construction for workers to stand on when performing their work: hammering wrenches on flange

bolts rigging squeeze iron and compressor hoses and duringbolts, rigging squeeze iron and compressor hoses, and during blow downs. In winter, de-watering intensifies the hazards with

ice build up and slippery conditions. T t H d ith f b i t d f i h tl fTest Heads with pre-fabricated frames are inherently safer.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 93: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Pipe Storage StandardPipe joints stockpiled in parallel configuration onPipe joints stockpiled in parallel configuration on side hills , creates a potential mid-section crush injury hazard to any workers caught between

th j i tthese joints

At every start joint, road ROW side hill slope

section setup and temporary pipe stockpile even a slight

needs to be corrected during

Grading Operations even a slight

side hill creates a serious risk…http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 94: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Power line support structure ProtectionSteel footings of towers supporting high voltage powerSteel footings of towers supporting high voltage power lines immediately adjacent to traveled routes of project

vehicles should be protected with berms or concrete b ibarriers.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 95: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Power line hazard managementGuard Posts and rope/buntingp g

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 96: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

End Prep ShavingsShavings are often left overnight orShavings are often left overnight or longer, on the ground or in sacks along the ROW. Often the bigger

h i d d th

Poor Practice

shavings are recovered and the smaller pieces left on the ground

and blown by the wind into yadjacent property. This presents a hazard to workers, the public and

livestock Cuts from metallivestock. Cuts from metal shavings are frequently debilitating

injuries.

Use of a drop cloth and immediate removal from the ROW is

recommendedrecommended

Improved Practice http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 97: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Management of Induced VoltagePipe joints and pipe sections which run parallel to, cross p j p p p

under or lie with 500 meters of an electric power transmission line are subject to an electrostatic and

electromagnetic field Alternating current is induced intoelectromagnetic field. Alternating current is induced into strung pipe and welded pipe sections, which may result in a

potentially lethal hazardous condition.

Procedures and specialized, trained and qualified labor are required to mitigate this hazard

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 98: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Good PracticeGood Practice

Good ditch slope, ladder, mats to support p ppbooms, compressed gas bottles lifted in cage, laborer unhooking factory swaged wire rope

sling to lift concreted section for tie insling to lift concreted section for tie in.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 99: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Good PracticeOn Stringing the use of the Vaculift mitigatesOn Stringing, the use of the Vaculift mitigates many of the risks associated with the use of slings. All workers standing clear of danger g g g

zones.

Regular Scheduled maintenance is required and critical to the safe use of this equipment. There is a maximum altitude at which this equipment can safely be

dused.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 100: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Good Practice – Hazard Warning SignsGood Practice Hazard Warning Signs

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 101: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

Good PracticeGood Practice

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com

Page 102: Pipeline Construction   In Pursuit Of The Zero Accident Project

It can be done safely.It can be done safely.

http://www.pipe-line-safety.com