piston less pump for rocket
TRANSCRIPT
INTRODUCTION:
NASA have developed a Low cost rocket fuel pump which has
Comparable performance to turbopump at 80-90% lower cost. Perhaps
the most difficult barrier to entry in the liquid rocket business is the
turbo pump. A turbo pump design requires a large engineering effort
and is expensive to mfg. and test. Starting a turbo pump fed rocket
engine is a complex process, requiring a careful of many valves and
subsystems.In fact ,Beal aerospace tried to avoid the issue entirely by
building a huge pressure feed booster. Their booster never flew, but the
engineering behind it was sound and ,if they had a low cost pump at
their disposal ,they might be competing against Boeing. This pump
saves up to 90% of the mass of the tanks as compared to a pressure fed
system. This pump has really proved to be a boon for rockets . By this pump
the rocket does not have to carry heavy load and can travel with very high
speed.
NECESSECITY:
The turbo pumps used in rocket are very heavy,containing many
rotating parts by which there are more frictional losses which more
consumption of fuel there by decreasing the efficiency of the engine .Also,
the maintainanace of such pump is, very important factor since the rocket
has to remain stable in the space, is difficult and require complex methods
for it. If this pump gets any fault then its repairance requires long time and
also it is avery hectic task.So, there must be such a device which
overcomes all the drawbacks of the turbopump as above. The
pistonless pump is the solution for the problems faced by using
turbopumps. They have only a drawback that they supply fuel with less
pressure as compared to turbopumps.
DESCRIPTION
The pistonless pump is similar to a pressure fed system, but instead of
having the a main tank at high pressure (typically 300-500 psi) the proposed
pump system has a low pressure tank (5 -50 psi) which delivers propellant at
low pressure into a pump chamber, where it is then pressurized to high
pressure and delivered to the engine. A diagram of the pump operation is
shown in Figure 1. Two pumping chambers are used in each pump, each one
being alternately refilled and pressurized. The pump starts with both
chambers filled (Step 0, not shown). One chamber is pressurized, and fluid is
delivered to the rocket engine from that chamber(Step 1). Once the level gets
low in one chamber, (Step 1a) the other chamber is pressurized; and flow is
thereby established from both sides during a short transient period(Step 2)
until full flow is established from the other chamber. Then the nearly empty
chamber is vented and refilled. (Step 3) Finally the cycle repeats. This
results in steady flow and pressure. The pump is powered by pressurized gas
which acts directly on the fluid. Initial tests showed pressure spikes as the
pump transitioned from one chamber to the other, but these have since been
eliminated by adjusting the valve timing. For more details on the pump and a
discussion of the second-generation design see reference 1 or 8. This pump
is more robust than a piston pump in that it has no high pressure sliding
seals, and it is much less expensive and time consuming to design than a
turbopump and a system which uses the pump has far lower dry mass and
unusable residuals than turbopumps do.
THE DUAL PISTONLESS PUMP:
NASA has designed,built and tested a simple, light weight pump
(dual pistomless pump) for use in liquid propelled rocket where a
reliable pump with minimal moving parts is needed. This pump has the
potential to reduce the cost and increase the reliability of rocket fuel pumps
by a factor of 20 to 100.
WORKING:
Rocket engines requires a tremendous amount of fuel high
at high pressure .Often th pump costs more than the thrust
chamber.One way to supply fuel is to use the expensive
turbopump mentioned above,another way is to pressurize fuel
tank. Pressurizing a large fuel tank requires a heavy , expensive
tank. However suppose instead of pressurizing entire tank, the
main tank is drained into a small pump chamber which is then
pressurized. To achieve steady flow, the pump system consists of
two pump chambers such that each one supplies fuel for ½ of
each cycle. The pump is powered by pressurized gas which acts
directly on fluid. For each half of the pump system, a chamber is
filled from the main tank under low pressure and at a high flow
rate, then the chamber is pressurized, and then the fluid is
delivered to the engine at a moderate flow rate under high
pressure. The chamber is then vented and cycle repeats. The
system is designed so that the inlet flow rate is higher than the
outlet flow rate.This allows time for one chamber to be vented ,
refilled and pressurized while the other is being emptied.A bread
board pump has been tested and it works great .A high version
has been designed and built and is pumping at 20 gpm and 550psi.
WORKING CYCLE
PISTONLESS PUMP FIGURE:
As shown in the above diagram , two cylinders are there ,
filled with the fuel from the main tank. This main tank is emptied
in these two cylinders, these cylinders are pressurized by the high
pressure tank,as shown.The high pressure tank pressurizes one
cylinder of high pressure,as shown,as soon as the cylinder is
emptied , it is vented, again it gets filled up from the main tank.The
same cycle reapeats for the second cylinder.the cycle is such that,
fuel is supplied by the cylinder one by one.ie. each cylinder
supplies fuel for each half cycle.As one cylinder supplies the fuel
other has enough time to refill.
APPLICATIONS:
DEEP SPACE PROPULSION :
NASA has a need for high power propulsion to land and
spacecraft on the moons of Jupitor and beyond.this pump would
allow these missions to go forward due to lower weight of the fuel
tanks. For example, to land on Europa with a hydrazine
monopropellant rocket , pump fed design would save 80% of the
tank weight compared to a pump fed design.Further weight
savings could be achieved by heating the pressurant gas more,
because the pressurant would not be in contact with the propellant
for more than a few seconds . In addition ,the chamber could be
increased , saving engine weight and improving performance.
2. X PRIZE VEHICLE FUEL PUMP APPLICATION:
For X-prize competitors, a the fuel pump will reduce the cost
and increase the safety and reliability of their amateur manned
vehicles.Sitting on top of tons of rocket fuel is dangerous
enough,siiting on top if tons of rocket fuel at high pressure is
even more so. Many of the competitors plan to use Hydrogen
Peroxide(HTP) and jet fuel to power their rockets.When the
pump is used to pump HTP, it can decompose some of the fuel in
a gas generator to run the pump. This saves a considerable
amount of weight pressurant and main tankage.
In addition , the factor on the low pressure tanks will be similar to the
cost of the high pressure tanks alone.
PERFORMANCE VALIDATION:
A calculation of the weight of this type of pump shows that the
power to weight ratio would be dominated by the pressure chamber
and that it would be of the order of 8-12 hp per lb., for a 5 second
cycle using a composite chamber. This performance is similar to
state of the art gas-generator turbopump technology. (The F1
turbopump on the Saturn V put out 20 hp/lb) This pump could be
run until dry, so it would achieve better residual propellant
scavenging than a turbopump. This system would require a supply
of gaseous or liquid Helium which would be heated by a heat
exchanger mounted on the combustion chamber before it was used
to pressurize the fuel, as in the Ariane rocket.. The volume of gas required
would be equivalent to a standard pressure fed design, with a small
additional amount to account for ullage in the pump chambers. The rocket
engine itself could be a primarily ablative design, as in the NASA Fastrac,
scorpious rocket or in recent rocket engine tests.
INSTALLATION FIGURE:
A proof of concept model of the pump has been constructed out of
clear plastic and tested at low pressure. The results of the test are shown
below.The pressure and flow are quite steady. The pump system is run with
a Labview based computer program. There are two floats which are used to
monitor the level in each pump chamber and each chamber uses a two
solenoid valves, one to pressurize source and on to vent the chamber. The
installation figure of the pistonless pump is shown in the above figure. The
high pressure cylinder used for pressurizing fuel,is installed at the bottom of
the rocket,shown in green colour in the figure.And above this cylinder
further assembly is mounted as shown in the first diegram. Thus the figure
shows that the installation is very easy as compared to that of the turbo
pump.
WORKING MODEL OF ROCKET FUEL PUMP:
The pump shown is equipped with electronic level sensors and air
cylinder actuated ball valves. The pump works as predicted and it will be
easy to reconfigure it to pump LOX and jet fuel.this type of pump will make
rocket propulsion systems much more reliable and less expensive than that
of the turbo jet pump.
FLOW AND PRESSURE DATA FOR ROCKET FUEL PUMP:
The above graph shows the variation of the flow of fuel through
both of the cylinders .It shows that as one cylinder gets emptied the
other one gets filled up and fuel is supplied by each cylinder to
the engine for each half cycle. As one cylinder gets emptied the
other one gets filled up , thus giving an uninterrupted fuel supply
to the engine. Also, the time required for the refill of the fuel in
the cynlinder is sufficient to supply fuel for next half cycle.
A video of the pump in action is also available.The is steady as
well and as the design is improved, the flow and pressure will be
steadier. This pump is similar to one mentioned in 1960 in
Exploring the Solar System by Felix Godwin p-21 p-22 and to one
patented by Sobey,(3,213,804) Jim Blackmon and Eric Lanning
(6,314,978) A second generation version (patent pending) that is
lower in weight (12 hp/lb) has been designed and built and is now
being tested. The first prototype is designed to work with our Atlas
Vernier. It provides 20 GPM at 600+ psi and it is made of stainless
steel and Teflon to be compatible with all common rocket
fuels(LOX,RP-1, H2O2, hydrazine etc). Check this page soon for
test results. We plan to build a couple of flight ready versions of
this pump to pump LOX and kerosene and fly it on one of our
Atlas vernier powered rockets This rocket will be able to acheive an
altitude of over 100 miles
ADVANTAGES:
Safety:
• Negligible chance of catastrophic failure because typical failure
modes are benign.
• Leaks from the main tank involve lower pressures, coarser
atomization, and lower explosion hazards than from high pressure
propellants
• Easy to start up and shut down, similar to pressure fed systems. No
spool up time required.
• Thrust can be modulated quickly, to steer, rendezvous, or reduce
start/stop transient loads
• The pump can be run dry with no adverse effects. The pump can even
purge the lines leading to the engine.
• Minimal pogo effect as tank pressure is decoupled from engine
pressure.
• The pump is failure tolerant. A small leak in one of the check valves
will only increase the pressurant consumption of the pump, it will not
cause a pump failure. Software can be designed to keep a pump with
redundant valves and sensors operational, despite failed sensors or
valves.
• Unlike other pumps, no problems with seals, cavitation, whirl or
bearings.
Reliability:
• Check valves, level sensors and pneumatic valves can be made
redundant if necessary. The check valves in particular can be made
very reliable, while the pressurant supply and vent valves are small
enough to allow redundancy. All these components are currently
available as space qualified COTS components.
• The gas and liquid valves are only required to operate for about 100-
1000 cycles, so the valves would not be subject to significant wear.
• No sliding parts, no lubrication, may be started after being stored for a
long time.
• Not susceptible to contamination. Our prototype has been sitting in a
rusty steel tank for a year and it still works fine.
• The pump can be started after being stored for an extended period
with high reliability because it can use valves which have already
been flight qualified.
• The pump can also be vented to a low pressure so as to reduce loads
on propellant valves with seals subject to creep or degradation for
long duration space flights.
• Overall vehicle reliability in emergencies should improve, because
pump chambers allow limited propellant storage near the engines, that
can be used even if upstream feedlines are damaged.
Performance:
• It can be installed in the propellant tank to minimize vehicle size. Will
not reduce volume of propellant tanks because pump chambers hold
displaced propellant.
• Allow for design flexibility, arbitrarily shaped tanks can be located to
control CG
• For application in a weightless environment, the pump can be
designed to have at least one chamber full at engine cutoff, thereby
allowing for zero G restart with the propellant in the pump chamber
providing the ullage thrust. This means that the propellant settling
maneuvers and propellant control devices in the main tank are not
required.
• The pump also allows for efficient motor throttling with a response
time on the order of the pump cycle time, that is 2-5 seconds, with
much faster thrust ramp-up with a full chamber (<0.1 second if
desired), and tail-off, if it is acceptable to waste a modest amount of
pressurant). The pump works well at flow rates from zero to full flow,
so it can be used to provide pressurized propellant for attitude control
• If the pump is combined with an injector which can be partially shut
down, very deep throttling can be achieved.
• The pump vent gas can provide roll control or be diffused and/or
vented to both sides of the vehicle to minimize inadvertent application
of thrust. The fraction of the pump gas vented at high pressure is more
than enough to pressurize the main tank, for tank pressures less than
roughly 1/3 of pump discharge pressure).
DISADVANTAGES:
The pistonless pumps has disadvantages along
with such fine advantages.
1.They cannot pump to higher pressure than drive gas (area ratio is 1:1)
2.They cannot use either a staged combustion or expander cycle.
3.A gas generator cycle is also difficult to integrate with the pistonless
pump.
4.The generated gas must be chemically compatible with both the
propellants.
5.This gas generator lowers the Ignition start period of the engine.
CONCLUSION:
The most significance of property of Pistonless pump that makes
them different from that of turbo pump ,is the absence of piston.
This is the most unique technique.In this ,no. of rotating
parts is very less as compared to that of turbopump. Also, it’s installation is
very easy.and moreover, it is light weight than turbo pump.So, it has less
losses and improves,rather increases efficiency of engine.Also, it is much
economical than turbopump.
The only drawback of pistonless pump is that, that it cannot
supply high pressure fuel and also,it cannot have stage combustion or
expander cycle,further, it has no vibrations.
BIBLOGRAPHY:
1}Theory Of Rocket propulsion (By R.H.Boden)
2}Book Of Rocket Propulsion (By zechosloviky)
3}Mechanics Of Thermodynamics Of propulsion
(By Philip Hill,Call Peterson)
4}http :// www . kahuna . sdsu . edu
5}www . flowmetrics . com
6}www.xcor.com
INDEX
SR NO. TOPICS PAGE NO.
1} INTRODUCTION 1
2} NECESSITY 2
3} DUAL PISTONLESS PUMP 2
4} WORKING OF THE PUMP 3
5} DIAGRAM OF PISTONLESS PUMP 4
6} ADVANTAGES 6
7} APPLICATIONS 7-8
8} PERFORMANCE VALIDATION 9
9} ISTALLATION IN ROCKET 10-11
10} WORKING MODELOF THE PUMP 12-13
11} GRAPH OF FLOW RATE VS. TIME 14-15
12} DISADVANTAGES 16
13} COCLUSION 17
14} BIBLOGRAPHY 18
ABSTRACT:
Pistonless pump for rocket has been proved to be the most
economical than piston pump or turbopump.
In pistonless pumps, piston is absent. It has very much less
rotating parts than that of piston pumps or turbo pumps. So, it has less
friction losses and there by it helps to improve the efficiency of the engine
considerably.They can be easily installed in the rocket than
turbopumps.Also,it reduces the weight of rocket.
This article discusses the working , advantages of pistonless
pump over turbopump.
Pistonless pumps are 80-90% economical than that of
piston pump or turbo pumps.Nasa has manufactured such kind of pump and
tested it actually,and they found it works conveneiently.