planning for coexistence linking situation assessment to ... · monica t. engel, jerry j. vaske,...
TRANSCRIPT
Silvio MarchiniWildCRU-Oxford University
LEMaC-ESALQ-USPChester Zoo
IUCN
Conceitos daCoexistência Humano-Fauna
http://costaricawildlife.org/portfolio-items/kabek-conservation/
HUMAN-WILDLIFE CONFLICT
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
19
97
19
98
19
99
20
00
20
01
20
02
20
03
20
04
20
05
20
06
20
07
20
08
20
09
20
10
20
11
20
12
20
13
20
14
20
15
20
16
20
17
20
18
Nu
mb
ero
fR
esu
lts
Google Scholar
"Human-Wildlife Conflict" "Human-Wildlife Coexistence"
Human-Wildlife Conflicta complex phenomenon
I. DAMAGE
II. KILLING
III. CLASH OF OPINIONS
I. PREDATION/COMPETITION/HERBIVORYEcology and economics > Technical solutions
II. KILLING
III. CLASH OF OPINIONS
Human-Wildlife Conflicta complex phenomenon
I. PREDATION/COMPETITION/HERBIVORYEcology and economics > Technical solutions
II. HUMAN BEHAVIOURBehavioural sciences > Behaviour change
III. CLASH OF OPINIONS
Human-Wildlife Conflicta complex phenomenon
I. PREDATION/COMPETITION/HERBIVORYEcology and economics > Techical solutions
II. HUMAN BEHAVIOURBehavioural sciences > Behaviour change
III. SOCIAL CONFLICTSocial/political sciences> Negotiation
Human-Wildlife Conflicta complex phenomenon
Definition of HWC
“Struggles involving conservation and other human interests that emerge when the behaviour and needs of wildlife are at odds with human goals or ideals, leading to negative impacts on people and/or wildlife”.
IUCN Task Force on HWC, 2019
Conflict-to-coexistence continuum
Wildlife
Sta
keh
old
ers (+)
(+)
(-)
(-)
Convivência
ex. Praga, animal-problema
ex. Caça,comércio ilegal,sobreexploração
‘ConflitoHumano-
Fauna’
Human-Wildlife Relationships
Co-ocorrência
COEXISTÊNCIA
Nuisance
Human-wildlife relationship
Wildlife
Hu
ma
ns
(+)
(+)
(-)
(-)
ConvivênciaPoaching
Illegal tradeOverharvest
Human-wildlife conflict
The proper goal
Human Wildlife
CONSERVATION
The proper goal
Human WildlifeHuman Wildlife
CONSERVATION CO-EXISTENCE
The proper goal
Human Wildlife Human Wildlife
CONSERVATION CO-EXISTENCE
Human Wildlife Human Wildlife
CONSERVATION CO-EXISTENCE
The proper goal
Human Wildlife Human Wildlife
CONSERVATION CO-EXISTENCE
The proper goal
PEOPLEWildlife
Situation Assessment:Human Dimension
Interpersonal/intergroup factorsSocial normsTrustEngagementCommunication
Intrapersonal factorsKnowledgeAttitudeFeelingToleranceValues
Wildlife
Individual Group/community
Levels of assessment
Interpersonal/intergroup factorsSocial normsTrustEngagementCommunication
Intrapersonal factorsKnowledgeAttitudeFeelingToleranceValues
Wildlife
Individual
Societal factorsGovernance PoliciesMarketCulture
Systemic/macro
Group/community
Levels of assessment
Conservation Letters, 2013
Monica T. Engel, Jerry J. Vaske, Alistair J. Bath & Silvio Marchini (2016): Predicting Acceptability of Jaguars and Pumas in the Atlantic Forest, Brazil, Human Dimensions of Wildlife, DOI:
10.1080/10871209.2016.1183731
Predicting Acceptability of Jaguars and Pumas in the
Atlantic Forest, Brazil
HOW TO CHANGE BEHAVIOUR
IF PEOPLE… THEN
Do not know enough to understand the
problem
Provide information
HOW TO CHANGE BEHAVIOUR
IF PEOPLE… THEN
Do not know enough to understand the
problem
Provide information
Know about the problem, BUT
do not care about it
Change incentive,
feelings, social norms
(eg persuasive
communication, social
marketing)
http://connect.xcelenergy.com/minnesota/conservation-by-peer-pressure/
Social norms approachto behaviour change
• the pleasure we take in doing the right thing (or avoiding the shame of doing the wrong thing) is often a more effective incentive than money.
• “to encourage civic action by appealing to both material interests and moral sentiments, framed so that the two work synergistically rather than at cross-purposes.”
2016
Theory of Change
Theory of Change (ToC) x Logical Framework
http://www.tools4dev.org/resources/theory-of-change-vs-logical-framework-whats-the-difference-in-practice/
Results chain
Reduce damageSave the species
EffectivenessEfficacyEfficiency
Monitoring & Evaluation
www.evalcommunity.com
Cu
sco
San
Die
go
Kual
a Lu
mp
ur
Co
qu
imb
o
Padrões de diversidade biológica e coexistência humano-fauna: componentes que sustentam os serviços
ecossistêmicos
1. Caracterizar as assembléias de mamíferos
2. Analisar padrões de diversidade das assembléias
de mamíferos
3. Verificar a ocorrência de estruturação populacional e fluxo gênico e inferir sobre a
conectividade funcional
4. Descrever a dieta de mamíferos carnívoros, o uso
dos recursos e habitat
5. Desenvolver e implementar um modelo para avaliação da percepção social dos serviços ecossistêmicos;
6. Desenvolver e implementar modelos para minimizar o conflito entre produtores rurais e mamíferos predadores
7. Fazer recomendações para políticas públicas que minizemos conflitos e ameaças e maximizem a conservação da biodiversidade e a coexistência humano-fauna
Armadilhamento fotográfico
Protocolo TEAM
Estações amostrais
Grid de 60 km2
1 Km de espaçamento
Estações de seca e chuvaPNG
PETAR
PECB
LA
PESM-NITA
PESM-NSV
Corredor sudeste MA
Bacia Hidrográfica do Paraíba do Sul
PESM – Núcleo Itariru
PESM – Núcleo Santa Virgínia
Estação Ecológica de Bananal
APA São Francisco Xavier
Mb Rio das Flores (Valença e Barra do Piraí)
Mb Coléginho; Olho d´água e Valão Grande
(Cambuci e Italva)
Sub-baciaRios
Pomba e
Muriaé
Mb Ouro e Varre-Sai (Porciúncula e
Varre-Sai)
Desenho de estudo
DIMENSÕES HUMANAS
PESM-NITA (23)
PETAR (40)
PESM-NSV-VG (24)
PECB (60)
Modelo Conceitual
InteraçõesHumano-
Fauna
Coexistência Human-Fauna
Fatoresbiofísicos
SERVIÇOS ECOSS.
Fatoresbiofísicos
DESSERVIÇOS ECOSS.
Com PSA x Sem PSA
Fatoresbiofísicos
Fatores biofísicos
Ecosystem Disservices
Participatory design
of “good practices”
protocol.
Envolvendo stakeholders na escolha das soluções
Envolvendo stakeholders na escolha das soluções
Envolvendo stakeholders na escolha das soluções
adaptações
RESILIÊNCIA
Alexandra ZimmermannCarolina BolañosClaudia Martins
Daniel RochaDavid MacdonaldEmiliano Ramalho
Esteban Brenes-MoraIara Ramos
Jenny A. GlikmanKatia Ferraz
Leticia PradoMariana Catapani
Mariana Landis
Nuno NegrõesPedro Correia
Ricardo BoulhosaRoberta PaolinoRogerio de PaulaRonaldo MoratoSantiago ZuluagaSolange Vargas
Thais GuimaraesThiago ReginatoWezddy del Toro
Yara BarrosYuri Ribeiro
Saiba mais