pmoptimization relationship venn diagram (2)

Upload: doug-henry

Post on 09-Apr-2018

225 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    1/75

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Strategies forStrategies for

    Obtaining GreaterObtaining Greater

    Reliability Thru EfficiencyReliability Thru Efficiency1

    Unlocking Maintenance CapacityUnlocking Maintenance Capacity

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    2/75

    LAI Reliability Systems Background

    33 Years serving Maintenance & Reliability Inventors of:

    3-Dimensional PMOptimization

    Reliability Fusion Software

    Work Management Simulation

    OME Overall Maintenance Effectiveness

    Reliability University

    Corporate HeadquartersChicago / Antioch, IL

    Nashville OfficeNashville / Franklin, TN

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. Page 2

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    3/75

    Maintenance Efficiency;Impact on the Big Picture

    Page 32009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    4/75

    Lean Six Sigma

    DMAIC Improvement Process Road Map

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. Page 4

    Review Project Charter Validate Problem

    Statementand Goals

    Validate Voice of theCustomerand Voice of theBusiness

    Validate FinancialBenefits

    Validate High-LevelValue Stream Mapand Scope

    Create CommunicationPlan

    Select and LaunchTeam

    Develop Project

    Schedule Complete Define Gate

    Identify PotentialRoot Causes

    Reduce List ofPotential RootCauses

    Confirm RootCause to OutputRelationship

    Estimate Impact ofRoot Causes onKey Outputs

    Prioritize RootCauses

    Complete AnalyzeGate

    Develop PotentialSolutions

    Evaluate, Select, andOptimize Best Solutions

    Develop To-Be ValueStream Map(s)

    Develop and ImplementPilot Solution

    Confirm Attainment ofProject Goals

    Develop Full ScaleImplementation Plan

    Complete Improve Gate

    Implement MistakeProofing

    Develop SOPs,Training Plan andProcess Controls

    Implement Solutionand Ongoing ProcessMeasurements

    Identify ProjectReplicationOpportunities

    Complete ControlGate

    Transition Project toProcess Owner Project Charter

    Voice of theCustomer and KanoAnalysis

    SIPOC Map Project Valuation /

    ROIC Analysis Tools RACI and Quad

    Charts Stakeholder

    Analysis Communication

    Plan Effective MeetingTools

    Inquiry andAdvocacy Skills

    Time Lines,

    Value Stream Mapping Value of Speed (Process

    Cycle Efficiency / LittlesLaw)

    Operational Definitions Data Collection Plan Statistical Sampling Measurement System

    Analysis (MSA) Gage R&R Kappa Studies Control Charts Histograms Normality Test Process Capability

    Analysis

    Process Constraint IDand Takt TimeAnalysis

    Cause and Effect

    AnalysisFMEAHypothesis Tests/Conf.Intervals

    Simple and MultipleRegression

    ANOVAComponents ofVariation

    Conquering Productand ProcessComplexity

    Queuing Theory

    Work ManagementSimulation

    Planning & Scheduling PMOptimizationTotal Productive

    Maintenance Design of Experiments

    (DOE) Solution Selection

    Matrix Planning Optimization

    PdM / CBM OME Overall

    Maintenance

    Mistake-Proofing/Zero Defects

    Standard OperatingProcedures (SOPs)

    Process Control Plans Visual Process ControlTools

    Statistical ProcessControls (SPC)

    Solution Replication Project Transition

    ModelTeam Feedback

    Session

    Value Stream Map forDeeper Understandingand Focus

    Identify Key Input,Process and OutputMetrics

    Develop OperationalDefinitions

    Develop Data CollectionPlan

    Validate MeasurementSystem

    Collect Baseline Data Determine Process

    Capability Complete Measure Gate

    Tools

    Activities

    Kaizen, 5S, NVA Analysis,Generic Pull Systems,

    Four Step Rapid Setup Method

    Kaizen, 5S, NVA Analysis,Generic Pull Systems,

    Four Step Rapid Setup Method

    Identify and Implement Quick ImprovementsIdentify and Implement Quick Improvements

    ImproveImproveAnalyzeAnalyze ControlControlMeasureMeasureDefineDefine

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    5/75

    The Focus of LAI Reliability Systems

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems,Inc. 5

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    6/75

    The LEAN Reliability StrategyThe LEAN Reliability Strategy

    2008 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    The perfect balance of Effectiveness &Efficiency

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    7/75

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    8/75

    Reality Today

    Maintenance primary focus on Reliability(Effectiveness) Downtime avoidance

    Unscheduled & Scheduled

    Occurrence & Duration Impact is felt, Craft pride and workmanship

    Massive opportunity for Efficiency gains

    Drives Maintenance to become an Event

    Maintenance productivity averages 25-30%As a process we have much more in commonwith production than we may think

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. Page 8

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    9/75

    The Solution

    The solution is the opposite of most approaches

    1.1.Open Flow of the MaintenanceOpen Flow of the Maintenance

    ProcessProcess

    2.2.With additional capacity, do theWith additional capacity, do theright workright work

    The challenges of Efficiency improvement

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. Page 9

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    10/75

    Efficiency Solutions

    Capacity Challenges Maintenance resources, Productivity levels Reactive maintenance levels, Downtime levels

    10

    OME Overall Maintenance Effectiveness

    Planning & Scheduling

    Value Stream Mapping in a MaintenanceFunctionPMOptimization Initial Optimization

    Lean and Constraint Management applied toMaintenance

    Maintenance Efficiency Processes

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    11/75

    Constraint in Maintenance?

    Where in this process is the constraint?

    112009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    20 18 17 10 12 16

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    12/75

    Constraint in Maintenance?

    What is the visible evidence of the constraint?

    122009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    20 18 17 10 12 16

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    13/75

    Work Management Process

    WorkWork

    IdentificationIdentification

    WorkWork

    PlanningPlanningWorkWork

    SchedulingScheduling

    WorkWork

    ExecutionExecutionWorkWork

    Follow-UpFollow-UpWorkWork

    AnalysisAnalysis

    Emergency

    CI Loop Maintenance Reliability Loop

    AssuresMaintenance

    Efficiency

    AssuresMaintenanceEffectiveness

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 13

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    14/75

    Work ID Planning SchedExecutio

    nFollow

    upAnalysis

    Constraint in Maintenance?

    Where is the constraint in Maintenance?

    142009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    20 18 17 10 12 16

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    15/75

    Work ID Planning SchedExecutio

    nFollow

    upAnalysis

    Constraint in Maintenance?

    Where is the constraint in Maintenance?

    152009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    20 18 17 10 12 16

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    16/75

    Constraint in Maintenance?

    What is the evidence of the Maintenanceconstraint?

    162009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Work ID PlanningScheduli

    ngFollow

    upAnalysis

    Execution

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    17/75

    Constraint in Maintenance?

    How do we protect the constraint? Place a buffer (B) in front to protect against

    supply variables

    Pre-inspect the buffer to ensure 100% quality

    enters

    172009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Work ID Planning SchedExecutio

    nFollow

    upAnalysis

    B

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    18/75

    2. Set-ups

    1. Breakdowns

    4. Idling &Minor Stops

    3. Reduced Rate

    6. Scrap / rework

    5. Start up Loss

    LostTime

    LostSpeed

    LostUnits

    CurrentCapacity

    (OEE)

    Theoretical

    Max

    Schedu

    ledRu

    nTim

    Availability

    Performance

    Quality

    Overall Equipment Effectiveness

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 18

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    19/75

    4. Idling &Minor Stops

    3. Reduced Rate LostSpeed

    2. Set-ups

    1. Breakdowns

    6. Scrap / rework

    5. Start up Loss

    LostTime

    LostUnits

    CurrentCapacity

    (OEE)

    Theoretical

    Max

    Overall Equipment Effectiveness

    Schedu

    ledRu

    nTim

    Availability

    Quality

    MarketMarket

    DemanDeman

    dd

    Performance

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 19

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    20/75

    3 Types of Backlog Market Demand

    PM Preventive MaintenancePdM Predictive MaintenanceTPM Operator Care

    CM Corrective MaintenancePRJ Projects

    Carryover Work

    RM Reactive MaintenanceEM Emergencies

    Scope Creep

    PMOptimization

    Planning &Scheduling

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 20

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    21/75

    Value Stream Mapping for MaintenanceHIGH LEVEL MAPPING

    Getting Started

    Review / Develop a Project Charter Validate Problem Statement and Goals

    Capture Voice of the Customer

    Define/Validate Financial Benefits

    Create Communication Plan

    Select Project Team

    Develop Project Schedule

    Develop a High Level Value Stream Map

    Create a SIPOC Chart

    Map the Current State with a Top Down Flow Chart

    Determine Product/Process Family to Value Stream Map

    212009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    22/75

    Lean Maintenance Overview

    2007: 151,000 Work Orders

    $50MM

    48 Days Avg Work Order Completion Time

    Project Goals: 75% Reduction in WO Completion Time

    48 Days Avg to 12 Days

    75% Reduction in Work in Process

    26,000 Work Orders to 6,500 (and keep going)

    75% Reduction in Emergency Work Orders

    l S i f i

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    23/75

    SupplierCustomer

    3-1000 (Pre-Prioritize)

    PM Schedule

    PhoneRadioEmailWeb

    Equipment (i.e., lift,cranePartsToolsContractors

    OfficesMaintenanceEngineeringSecurityDP OPSAPI OPSUtilitiesEHSQACASExternalMaintenance

    Initiate Prioritize Plan Scheduling Execute Analyze Document / Close

    1

    2-5

    P-GEMS

    Initiate

    .4Lead time Days

    188Inventory W/O

    5 Mins 15 Mins

    Days10.8

    8 min

    Days14.2

    10.3 Mins

    Days10.9

    3.3 Hrs

    Days16.3

    2 Mins

    Days4.1

    2 Mins

    Days2.2

    Prioritize Plan Scheduling Execute Analyze Document / Close

    5.5Overhead Staff

    10.8Lead time Days

    836Inventory W/O

    5Overhead Staff

    14.2Lead time Days

    6671Inventory W/O

    11Overhead Staff

    10.9Lead time Days

    5820Inventory W/O

    12Overhead Staff

    16.3Lead time Days

    8689Inventory W/O

    172Overhead Craft.

    4.1Lead time Days

    2209Inventory W/O

    11Overhead Staff

    2.2Lead time Days

    1191Inventory W/O

    6Overhead Staff

    9.8Million

    Cost ofcontractors

    $

    48Lead time Days

    25,604Inventory W/O

    298Overhead Staff

    172Craftsman Craft

    9.8MillionContractor $

    Total

    Note:Staffing headcountdoes not include:Stores staff

    Call center mgrValidation techsRMTsUtilitiesOperations

    5Process time Mins 15Process time Mins 8Process time Mins 10.3Process time Mins 3.3Process time Hrs 2Process time Mins4Process time Hrs

    2Process time Mins

    Days.4

    Value Stream Mapping for MaintenanceHIGH LEVEL MAPPING

    V l S M i f M i

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    24/75

    Value Stream Mapping for MaintenanceMAINTENANCE WORK TYPE PROCESS MAPPING

    Value Stream Mapping (Sub Process) for

    Preventive / Corrective / Reactive Maintenance Data Collection & Defining Measures

    Identify Key Input, Process and Output Metrics

    Develop Data Collection Plan

    Collect Baseline Data

    Determine Process Capability

    Draw the Process Flow Map Adding The Material Flow Layer Adding The Information Flow Layer

    Adding The Data Collection Layer Adding The Process and Lead Time data Layer

    242009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Work Order: 232954 Description: Office Furniture Move Muda 63%

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    25/75

    Work Order: 232954 Description: Office Furniture Move 63%Date: 10/22/03 Team: Kirby's Facilities Team Value

    Added37%

    Labor Minutes / Step

    Step Description Trade Qty Good Inrrptn Notes

    1 Travel to the job Millwright 1 10

    2 Find requestor 1 5 W/O wasn't clear

    3 Scope job - Part A 1 5

    4 Gather tools 1 5 Didn't know what to bring

    5 Move 5 drawer file cabinet Millwright 1 106 (cabinet full - find Mitch) 1 20 Mitch wasn't prepared for me

    7 Get Mitch some boxes to unload file cabinet Millwright 1 15 Boxes weren't where theyshould be

    8 Need desk dolly - find it 1 10 Bob had the dolly

    9 Move desk to column 2Y22 Millwright 2 5

    10 Looks like someone already delivered a different desk - findcustomer

    1 5 There was a desk there already

    11 Yep - Return non-required desk to dock for shipment Millwright 1 15

    12 Travel from dock back to Finance Department 1 10

    13 Scope job - Part B 1 5

    14 Microfilm reader needs to be moved from this desk - findadditional Millwright 1 10 Desk had heavy stuff on it

    15 Move microfilm machine Millwright 2 11

    16 Move furniture within Finance Millwright 2 10

    17 Move Mitch's cabinet to dock Millwright 1 10

    18 Move bookshelf Millwright 1 15

    19 Doesn't fit opening - find customer to relocate bookshelf 1 10 Should have measured it

    20 Install bookshelf Millwright 1 5

    21 Close job Millwright 1 2

    Minutes 82 137Tools / Parts / Resources Total Time 219

    1 Desk Dolly

    1 Refrigerator Dolly

    4 Boxes

    2 Office layout diagram

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    26/75

    Travel to the job

    Find requestor

    Scope job - Part A

    Gather tools

    Move 5 drawer file cabinet

    (cabinet full - find Mitch)

    Get Mitch some boxes to unload file cabinet

    Need desk dolly - find it

    Move desk to column 2Y22

    Looks like someone already delivered a differentdesk - find customer

    Yep - Return non-required desk to dock forshipment

    Travel from dock back to Finance Department

    Scope job - Part B

    Microfilm reader needs to be moved from this desk- find additional Millwright

    Move microfilm machine

    Move furniture within Finance

    Move Mitch's cabinet to dock

    Move bookshelf

    Doesn't fit opening - find customer to relocatebookshelf

    Install bookshelf

    Close job

    2008 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Corrective Maintenance Analysis

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    27/75

    2. Undoc. Work

    1. Not on Jobs

    4. Idling &Minor Stops

    3. Actual vs. Plan

    6. Callbacks &rework

    5. Start up Loss

    LostTime

    LostTime

    LostTime

    CurrentCapacity

    (OME)

    Theoretical

    MaxThroughput

    ElevationEffectiveness

    CostReductionEfficiency

    Overall Maintenance Effectiveness

    Schedu

    ledW

    orkT

    Utilization

    PlanningCompliance

    Quality

    MaintenanMaintenan

    ce Backlogce Backlog

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 27

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    28/75

    Maintenance & Reliability Model

    OperatorUpkeep

    PM

    PdM

    ID Planning Scheduling

    ExecutionFollow UpAnalysis

    CMMS / History

    Visual Workplace5S Control

    SpecifyValue

    IDValue

    Stream

    Pull Perfect

    Control Point / Constraint Management

    Flow

    Discretionary Focus

    FMEA / RCFA / RCM

    TPMTPM Work ManagementWork Management

    QuickChange Over

    SMED

    OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness) OME (OverallMaintenance Effectiveness)

    2008 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. All Rights Reserved

    Spare PartsMaterialsManagement

    OEE / OMEOptimizatio

    n

    Equipment Criticality Ranking (ECR) Equipment DatabaseMaintenance &Reliability

    Performance Metrics

    Effectiveness 3-D PMOptimization3-D PMOptimization Efficiency

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 28

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    29/75

    Defining Preventive Maintenance

    Definition:Regularly scheduled work performedat prescribed intervals, intended to proactivelyAvoid, Delay, orDetectthe onset of failure,ensuring that equipment continues to function asrequired by the user...

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 29

    PMOptimization

    Addresses

    Condition-based

    Monitoring(CbM)

    PreventiveMaintenance

    (PM)

    PredictiveMaintenance

    (PdM)

    ScheduledContract

    Maintenance(PM)

    OperatorUpkeep(TPM)

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    30/75

    Few Choices to Consider

    Desired OutcomeDesired Outcome

    Develop the correct PM

    Correct task

    Frequency

    Optimum resourcesEase of implementation

    On all equipment

    Unites all activities

    Analyzes collected data

    Adapts and grows

    Leveragability

    Fills the CMMS gaps

    Craft

    Feedback

    PM Scrubbing

    RCM/FMEA

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    31/75

    3-Dimensional PMOptimization Impact

    Maintenance PM LaborScheduled PM DowntimePM Parts Cost

    40%35%60%

    It is the right task, performed by the rightskill, at the right interval & at minimal cost.

    PM Coverage 50%

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 31

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    32/75

    High percentage of labor hours in PM

    Why PMOptimization?

    Most controllable unit of work we have

    Need capacity to get ahead of the curve

    Efficiency perspective:

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 32

    PMs

    Too many good components beingreplacedToo much scheduled downtimePM data located in many differentsystems

    Limited CMMS functionality

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    33/75

    PMs

    Why PMOptimization?

    Elevated reactive maintenance levels

    Beyond compliance, are they working?

    Effectiveness perspective:

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 33

    Too many failures still occurring

    Too much unscheduled downtimePMs not developed using consistentprocessPMs not identifying work early enough

    Planning & Scheduling processesstarved

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    34/75

    PMO and RCM Partnership

    Equipment Criticality

    Leverage Zone

    Resource

    sRequi r

    ed

    (L

    abor&Ma

    terial)

    RCM / FMEA

    3-Dimensional PMOptimization3-Dimensional PMOptimization

    RCM / PMOptimizationRCM / PMOptimization

    PartnershipPartnership

    Craft Feedback / Data Scrubbing 2008 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    EquipmentQ

    uantity

    Low High

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 34

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    35/75

    3-Dimensional PMOptimization

    352009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    The right task performed by the right skillat the right time at minimal cost

    1. Initial Optimization

    Ongoing efficiencyoptimization throughanalysis of PM task results tracked at afailure mode level

    2. PM Task Pass/Fail Analysis

    Ongoing effectiveness optimization throughanalysis of equipment reliability from otherequipment performance tracking systemsbeyond the PM System

    3. Equipment Reliability Analysis

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    36/75

    Essential Elements of a World-Class PM

    A World-Class PM will answer these basic questions:

    362009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    What are we trying toprotect?

    Against what?

    What are we going toabout it?

    How are we going to doit?

    Required functionality of theequipment

    Failure modes at a component level

    Prevent or detect the onset of failureor its cause through a PM Activity

    Who, how often, how long, operationalstatus, conditions, resources,instructions

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    37/75

    PMOptimization Processes

    372009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    1. Prepare for PMO

    2. Define Equipment Reliability Requirements

    3. Review Existing PM

    4. Screen Tasks for Removal

    5. Optimize Remaining Value-added Tasks

    6. Fill Gaps in PM

    7. Review OEM Recommendations

    8. Optimize PM Work Order

    9. Implement Change

    10. Leverage Improvement

    Optimization Steps

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    38/75

    Remove unnecessary non value-added steps 6 Task removaltechniques

    5S for Your PMs

    Organize remaining PM activities to where they belong Reliabilityrequirements identifiedOptimize remaining PM tasks 9 Task & WO techniquesManage ongoing efforts using a consistent process ProcessassuranceSustain continued optimization Task Pass/Fail &

    Reliability Analysis

    PMO Equivalence5S Step How its done

    Sort

    Straighten

    Shine

    Standardize

    Sustain

    15 Optimization Techniques

    Remove

    Existing PMs

    Failures

    Optimized PM Coverage

    Optimize Add

    Open FailureModes

    Consider

    Adjust

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    39/75

    4. Screen Tasks for Removal

    A. Confirm Applicability of Tasks

    B. Determine if Failure can be Foreseen/Prevented

    C. Remove Redundant PM Tasks

    D. Review Value vs. Cost of PM Task

    E. Reduce Scope of PMs on Non-critical EquipmentF. Redesign Equipment to Eliminate need for PM

    Task

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 39

    5 Optimize Remaining Value-Added Tasks

    http://www.istockphoto.com/icons.phphttp://www.istockphoto.com/icons.php
  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    40/75

    5. Optimize Remaining Value-Added TasksB. Apply Task Optimization Techniques

    Efficiency-Based Task Optimization Techniques

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 40

    1. Determine if Task can be Promoted Is there a better task?

    2. Determine Appropriate Skill Set

    Can others perform this

    task?

    3. Determine Required Equipment Status Running or down?

    4. Determine if Job Plan is RequiredWhat is required to performtask?

    5. Determine if Modifications can Reduce

    Task Time How can I make task easier?

    Optimization Techniques Addressing the issue

    6. Reduce Frequency of the PM Task Why this often?

    3 Review Existing PM

    http://www.istockphoto.com/icons.phphttp://www.istockphoto.com/icons.php
  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    41/75

    3. Review Existing PMD. Determine Task Type

    PM Tasks Classification

    PMs can be grouped into one of 4 Task Types

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 41

    Type 1 Activity-Based Performance of physical activity

    1L Lubrication

    1C Cleaning

    1A Adjustment

    1R Replacement

    Type 2SubjectiveInspection Perceived condition

    Type 3ObjectiveInspection

    Factual condition

    Type 4ConditionMonitoring

    Measured and trended condition

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    42/75

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 42

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    43/75

    42%

    82%

    42%

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 43

    O i i i & i i k

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    44/75

    PMOptimization & Business Risk

    Page 442009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    S i bili C i PM L i

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    45/75

    Sustainability; Creating PM Longevity

    Where do we go from here? On-going process of

    continuous Optimization

    PM Task Pass/Fail Analysis Equipment Reliability

    Analysis

    SSort

    SStraighten

    SShine

    SStandardize

    SSustain

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. Page 45

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    46/75

    PMOptimization Relationships

    Asset Selection

    Equipment Needs Development

    Current PM to Needs Analysis

    Task Removal Techniques (6)

    Task Optimization Techniques (6)

    CMMS History to PM Analysis

    Open Failure Modes Review

    OEM Review

    Work Order Optimization

    Leveraging Results

    PMOptimization Core

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    47/75

    TPMTPM

    PMOptimization Relationships

    TPM Daily Upkeep

    TPM Site Profile

    Operator Task Development

    TPM Visual Reference Development

    TPM Daily / Weekly Schedule

    Standardized Work

    Paperless Work Completion

    Work Request Contributor

    TPM Daily Upkeep Training

    Kaizen Events

    MOE Process

    Work Management feedback, prioritization,coding, backlog mgt., TPM Metrics

    TPM Team Engagement

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    48/75

    TPMTPM

    VisualVisual

    WorkplaceWorkplace

    PMOptimization Relationships

    Visual Workplace

    Equipment, Function, ComponentImaging

    Icon-Based TPM Tasking

    TPM Daily/Weekly Kits

    Gauge Marking

    Task Imaging

    Maintainability / Accessibility

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    49/75

    TPMTPM

    VisualVisual

    WorkplacWorkplac

    ee

    StandardiStandardi

    zed Workzed Work

    PMOptimization Relationships

    Standardized Work

    PMO Master Library - Equipment

    Naming, Tasking, Frequencies,Failure Modes

    Multi Site Best Practice Sharing

    Standardized Training System

    PMO Master Library - Components

    Standardized Forms & Tools

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    50/75

    TPMTPM

    VisualVisual

    WorkplacWorkplac

    ee

    StandardiStandardi

    zed Workzed Work

    LubricatiLubricati

    onon

    ProgramProgram

    PMOptimization Relationships

    Lubrication Program

    Lubrication Tasks Identified

    Quantities (volume)

    Frequencies (occurrence)

    Color Coding

    Lubricant Consolidation

    Lubrication Storage

    Lubrication Training

    Lubricant Assignment

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    51/75

    TPMTPM

    VisualVisualWorkplacWorkplac

    ee

    StandardiStandardi

    zed Workzed Work

    PMOptimization Relationships

    Reliability Readings

    Objective Reliability Data Collection

    Reporting / Graphing

    Trend able Data from TPM Activities

    Auto Work Order Generating

    LubricatioLubricatio

    nnProgramProgram

    ReliabiliReliabili

    tytyReadingReading

    ss

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    i i i l i hi

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    52/75

    TPMTPM

    VisualVisualWorkplacWorkplac

    ee

    StandardiStandardi

    zed Workzed Work

    ReliabilityReliabilityReadingsReadings

    LubricatioLubricatio

    nnProgramProgram

    PdMPdM

    PrograProgra

    mm

    PMOptimization Relationships

    PdM Program

    PdM Tasks Identified

    PdM Technologies Assigned /Deployed

    PdM Routes by Technology

    PdM Hardware

    PdM Data Management

    PdM Training

    Partnering w/ PdM Technologies

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    PMO i i i R l i hi

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    53/75

    TPMTPM

    VisualVisualWorkplacWorkplac

    ee

    StandardiStandardi

    zed Workzed Work

    ReliabilityReliability

    ReadingsReadings

    LubricatioLubricatio

    nnProgramProgram

    PdMPdM

    ProgramProgram

    PMOptimization Relationships

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Solutions for Maintenance, Operations, & Facilities

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    54/75

    TPM Operator CareTPM Operator Care

    A Natural Outcome of PMOptimization

    ator Care / TPM a natural outcome of PMOptimization

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    55/75

    ator Care / TPM a natural outcome of PMOptimization

    et your site profile for ideal OC task characteristics

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    56/75

    et your site profile for ideal OC task characteristicsTasks meeting criteria set alarm in PMOptimizer and are moved to TPMTasks can be manually advanced to TPM Module

    TPM / OC Task Management

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    57/75

    TPM / OC Task ManagementSet production / task schedulingCustomize and load TPM / OC Images at a task level

    M / OC Image Creator

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    58/75

    M / OC Image Creatorverlay drag and drop graphics, text, and symbols calling out task locationpdated images are saved and used in TPM visual references and reports

    PM Manager

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    59/75

    PM ManagerManager represents or works with typical TPM Story Boards for task statusQuick View look into task status by area or line

    PM Manager

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    60/75

    PM ManagerManager represents or works with typical TPM Story Boards for task statusQuick View look into task status by area or line

    M PerformerO t T k I t f TPM d 5S ti iti d i i l t l

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    61/75

    asy Operator Task Interface: TPM and 5S activities managed in a single toolefault icons based on task typerovides all information needed: Image, Task, Instructions, Measurements Lube

    Clean tooling slidesand inspect forabnormalities

    TPM PerformerAll i d d t t fi ti

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    62/75

    All required data at your fingertipsLaunch work requests paperless interfaceFailure modes launch task log or work order generation

    Clean tooling slidesand inspect for

    abnormalities

    Tooling slidesshowingSigns of wear

    Generated workorder

    TPM Operator Daily Checklist

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    63/75

    TPM Operator Daily Checklist

    63

    Hydraulic Unit> Motor> Visually inspect motor conditionA. Ok / B. Dirty / C. Hot / D. Noisy

    04

    546702

    Inspection Details

    1.Locate motor on rear of unit

    2.Visually inspect motor air path

    3.Is air path or exterior built up w/

    debris?

    4.If dirty, hot or noisy, notify

    maintenance

    OperationsNorth American

    OperationsNorth American

    1.00 Minute

    Lube:

    No lubricants required

    Tools:

    Flow template gauge (1)

    located: Cabinet b24

    Parts:No parts required

    Safety:

    No safety or PPE required to

    perform inspection

    Task Duration:

    2.00 Minutes

    Comments / Notes:

    &

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    64/75

    Page 64

    PM Optimization Process

    2006 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Maintenance & ReliabilityMaintenance & Reliability

    Operator

    Upkeep

    PM

    PdM

    ID Planning Scheduling

    ExecutionFollow UpAnalysis

    CMMS / History

    Visual Workplace5S Control

    Specify

    Value

    ID

    Value

    Stream

    Pull Perfect

    Control Point / Constraint Management

    Flow

    Discretionary Focus

    FMEA / RCFA / RCM

    TPMTPM Work ManagementWork Management

    Quick

    Change Over

    SMED

    OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness) OME(Overall Maintenance Effectiveness)

    2008 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. All Rights Reserved

    Spare PartsMaterials

    Management

    OEE / OME

    Optimization

    Equipment Criticality Ranking (ECR) Equipment DatabaseMaintenance & Reliability

    Performance Metrics

    Effectiveness 3-D PMOptimization3-D PMOptimization Efficiency

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    65/75

    Oils Grease OtherCategories

    - Hydraulic

    H1 Hyd AW 32

    + Gear Oil

    + Spindle Oil

    + Air Line Oil

    + Way Oil

    Name

    ISO 32 Nevastane AW 32 Keystone

    Edit ISO Product Manufacturer Details

    Hyd AW 46 ISO 46 DTE 25 Mobil Oil

    Hyd AW 68 ISO 68 DTE 26 Mobil Oil

    MSDS

    Product

    Keystone

    Supplier

    Tri-State

    Tri-State

    H1 Hyd AW 32

    Details

    H1 rated food grade light lubricating & anti-wear

    hydraulic oil

    Usage

    Hydraulic systems & general purpose applications

    where a light lubricating oil is required to penetrate

    or minimize attraction of dust

    Close

    Blended Learning Environment

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    66/75

    Blended Learning Environment

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc. 66

    LIVE OVERVIEW SESSIONSEvery course includes monthly LIVE OVERVIEWSESSIONS. Learn all aspect of the course; Interactwith our Subject Matter Expert, ask questions, evenactivate your camera. Great for managers.

    Click to learn more

    ON-DEMAND HOW-TO TRAINING

    You will learn HOW TO in these on-demand videolessons all around your schedule. Work with youron-screen instructor, perform exercises, downloadmaterials. Its everything you need.

    Click to learn more

    LIVE COACHING & SUPPORT

    Each course includes monthly coaching tomaximize your training experience and ensuresuccessful application of the tools. Personalcoaching both remote and on-site are available.

    Click to learn more

    Its a Complete TrainingSystem

    The perfect blend of Efficiency &Effectiveness. Utilizing the latest, advancedtechnologies this powerful combination ofLive and On-Demand training engages theuser, builds relationships and when coupledwith products and services ofFlexibleDeployment, ensures site-owned changemanagement.

    FLEXIBLE ON-SITE DEPLOYMENT

    LIVE OVERVIEW SESSIONS

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    67/75

    LIVE OVERVIEW SESSIONS

    LIVE, remote awareness sessions

    Ideal for site leadership

    Concierge scheduling

    Multiple site participation HQ Video feed of your instructor

    Phone bridge or VOIP connections

    Live interactivity

    Polling, quizzes, file transfer

    Post Q/A Session

    Activate your webcam

    Recorded for review

    672009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    lick to preview

    ON-DEMAND HOW-TO TRAINING

    http://reliabilityu.acrobat.com/p35869859/http://reliabilityu.acrobat.com/p35869859/
  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    68/75

    ON DEMAND HOW TO TRAINING

    On-Demand available 7/24

    Professionally produced

    Incorporates e-learning best practices

    Chapter-based learning

    SCORM / AICC Certified

    Cutting edge user engagement

    On-screen Virtual Instructor

    Materials / file transfer

    Quizzes and testing Full system reporting

    Hosted or installed in your LMS

    682009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Click to preview session

    lick to preview

    LIVE COACHING & SUPPORT

    http://reliabilityu.articulate-online.com/8207466541http://reliabilityu.articulate-online.com/8207466541
  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    69/75

    LIVE COACHING & SUPPORT

    Scheduled live remote coaching

    Questions portal Full client participation

    Support materials

    Concierge scheduling

    Multiple site participation

    HQ Video feed of your instructor Phone bridge or VOIP connections

    Activate you camera and voice line

    Options

    Private sessions

    On-site coaching available

    692009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    On-Line CoachingOn-Line Coaching

    Corporate Branding

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    70/75

    Co po a e a d g

    Page 702009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    PMOptimization Blended Learning Approach

    http://www.istockphoto.com/icons.phphttp://www.istockphoto.com/icons.php
  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    71/75

    Client Core Team

    LAI / Site Team

    ReliabilityU (LAI)

    LAI

    PMOptimization Blended Learning Approach

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Site preparation meeting & kit (Remote)

    PMOptimization Boot Camp

    On-Demand PMO tactical training

    Live remote coaching

    LAIReliability Fusion live training sessions

    Phased ImplementationPhased Implementation Involved PartiesInvolved Parties

    LAI / Core TeamLive PMO Awareness Session (Remote) day

    1 hour

    4 days

    As needed

    Core Team/ Site Team /LAI

    Site support process and open issuesmeeting

    day

    Core Team / LAISustainability Audits

    RWP Blended Learning Approach

    http://www.istockphoto.com/icons.phphttp://www.istockphoto.com/icons.php
  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    72/75

    Core Team

    Core Team / LAI

    Core Team

    Core Team/ LAI / SiteTeam

    LAI / Site Team

    ReliabilityU (LAI)

    LAI

    Core Team

    RWP Blended Learning Approach

    2009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Site Kick-off session

    RWP Simulation w site

    Site assessment

    Site strategy customization

    On-Site systems implementation

    On-Demand RWP tactical training

    Live remote coaching

    Value-Stream maintenance mapping

    Core Team/ LAISustainability Audits

    Phased ImplementationPhased Implementation Involved PartiesInvolved Parties

    Core TeamRisk Assessment 3 days

    3 days

    3 days

    3 weeks

    As needed

    On-Demand RWP Training

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    73/75

    g

    Training of choice (gain or maintain site participation)

    Comprehensive systems training

    Fully accessible 24/7

    Chapter-based learning

    SCORM / AICC Certified

    SMRP CMRP Accredited

    Sustainability tool

    Speed of delivery

    Increased site penetration

    Increased MRG capacity

    Marketing tool (latest technology)

    732009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Microsoft Office

    Excel 97-2003 Worksheet

    Concerns / Challenges

    http://reliabilityu.articulate-online.com/p/8207453304/player.htmlhttp://reliabilityu.articulate-online.com/p/8207453304/player.html
  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    74/75

    g

    Maintain or exceed current RWP effectiveness

    Increase site demand for MRG direction/tools Current limiting factors

    High perceived cost

    Large internal site commitment (T&M)

    10 month duration to obtain benefits

    Deployment method perceived as inflexible

    Sites are deploying internally

    Page 742009 LAI Reliability Systems, Inc.

    Additional RWP Deployment Features

  • 8/8/2019 Pmoptimization Relationship Venn Diagram (2)

    75/75

    p y

    Live awareness sessions monthly

    Support implementation: Site-based project management (project insight)

    Standardized base deployment plan

    Milestones, deliverables

    Tracking, reporting from the center (web-based)

    Monthly remote coaching sessions

    Optional / need based on site coaching

    MRG support

    Community of best-practice sharing