policy coordination in systems of innovation: a structural-functional analysis of regional industry...
TRANSCRIPT
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 1/35
f
\k|dw co# 7<;;/<>
\ojnf~ foowmnck}noc nc v~v}d`v oh
nccoxk}noc2 K v}wtf}twkj-htcf}nockj
kckj~vnv oh wdanockj ncmtv}w~ vt||ow} nc
Vqdmdc
@kactv Cnjvvoc )@kactv#cnjvvocLfnwfjd#jt#vd.
FNWFJD* Jtcm Tcnxdwvn}~* Vqdmdc
Bdwedw @oom~vvoc ) bdwedw#`oom~vvocLfnwfjd#jt#vd.
FNWFJD* Jtcm Tcnxdwvn}~* Vqdmdc
]inv nv k |wd-|wnc} xdwvnoc oh k |k|dw }ik} ikv gddc vtg`n}}dm how|tgjnfk}noc }o k botwckj
]inv xdwvnoc2 Vd|}d`gdw 7<;;
Fdc}wd how Nccoxk}noc* Wdvdkwfi kcm Fo`|d}dcfd nc }id Jdkwcnca Dfoco`~ )FNWFJD.
Jtcm Tcnxdwvn}~
\#O# Goy ;;1* Vøjxdak}kc ;8* V-77; << Jtcm* VQDMDC
i}}|2//qqq#fnwfjd#jt#vd/|tgjnfk}nocv
NVVC ;84=-6;=>
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 2/35
Q\ 7<;;/<>\ojnf~ foowmnck}noc nc v~v}d`v oh nccoxk}noc2 K v}wtf}twkj-htcf}nockj kckj~vnv ohwdanockj ncmtv}w~ vt||ow} nc Vqdmdc@kactv Cnjvvoc kcm Bdwedw @oom~vvoc
KGV]WKF] ]id hwk`dqowe oh wdanockj nccoxk}noc v~v}d`v inaijnai}v }id v~v}d`nf ck}twd oh dfoco`nf
mdxdjo|`dc} kcm }id n`|ow}kcfd oh foowmnck}noc oh |ojnf~ kf}nxn}ndv# Vtfi foowmnck}noc
|wdvt||ovdv kc tcmdwv}kcmnca oh }id tcmdwj~nca |wogjd`v kcm ioq }id~ fkc gd kmmwdvvdm#
Adcdwnf |wogjd`v nc nccoxk}noc v~v}d`v wdhdw }o nvvtdv oh jkfe oh wdvotwfdv* cdak}nxd jofe-nc*
kcm v}wtf}twkj ow htcf}nockj hwka`dc}k}noc# Nc v|n}d oh }inv* }idwd kwd hdq aoom dyk`|jdv oh
v~v}d`k}nf kckj~vdv oh nccoxk}noc v~v}d`v }ik} }ked nc}o kffotc} go}i v}wtf}twkj kcm
htcf}nockj |wo|dw}ndv oh }id v~v}d`# ]inv |k|dw kmmwdvvdv }inv nvvtd g~ ohhdwnca k hwk`dqowe
how kckj~rnca nccoxk}noc v~v}d` |wogjd`v* htcf}nocv* kf}nxn}ndv* kcm kf}owv kcm* gkvdm oc
}inv* ohhdwv ncvnai}v qn}i wdakwm }o }id wojd oh wdanockj kf}owv kv foowmnck}owv oh nccoxk}nocv~v}d` kf}nxn}ndv#
Ed~qowmv2
Wdanockj nccoxk}noc v~v}d`v* nccoxk}noc |ojnf~* v~v}d`nf |wogjd`v
Mnvfjkn`dw2 Kjj }id o|ncnocv dy|wdvvdm nc }inv |k|dw kwd }id wdv|ocvngnjn}~ oh }id ncmnxnmtkj
kt}iow ow kt}iowv kcm mo co} cdfdvvkwnj~ wd|wdvdc} }id xndqv oh o}idw FNWFJD wdvdkwfidwv#
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 3/35
;¬
¬
\ojnf~¬foowmnck}noc¬nc¬v~v}d`v¬oh ¬nccoxk}noc2¬¬¬
K¬v}wtf}twkjhtcf}nockj¬kckj~vnv¬oh ¬wdanockj¬ncmtv}w~¬vt||ow} ¬nc¬
Vqdmdc¬
¬
¬
@kactv¬Cnjvvoc¬kcm¬Bdwedw¬@oom~vvoc¬
¬
FNWFJD¬)Fdc}wd¬how¬Nccoxk}noc*¬Wdvdkwfi¬kcm¬Fo`|d}dcfd¬nc¬}id¬Jdkwcnca¬Dfoco`~.¬
Jtcm¬Tcnxdwvn}~*¬Vqdmdc¬
@kactv#CnjvvocLfnwfjd#jt#vd5¬Bdwedw#@oom~vvocLfnwfjd#jt#vd¬
¬\k|dw ¬ |wd|kwdm ¬ how ¬}id¬8}i¬Nc}dwck}nockj ¬Vd`nckw ¬oc¬Wdanockj ¬Nccoxk}noc¬\ojnfndv*¬FNWFJD*¬Jtcm ¬
Tcnxdwvn}~*¬Vqdmdc*¬;6;=¬Of}ogdw ¬ 7<;;¬
¬
MWKH] ¬XDWVNOC 2¬\jdkvd¬mo¬co} ¬fn}d¬ow ¬fnwftjk}d¬qn}iot} ¬ |dw`nvvnoc¬ hwo`¬}id¬kt}iowv¬
¬
¬
Kgv}wkf} ¬
]id¬ hwk`dqowe¬ oh¬ wdanockj¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v¬ inaijnai}v¬ }id¬ v~v}d nf¬ ck}twd¬ oh¬ dfoco nf¬
mdxdjo|`dc}¬ kcm¬ }id¬ n`|ow}kcfd¬ oh¬ foowmnck}noc¬ oh¬ |ojnf~¬ kf}nxn}ndv#¬ Vtfi¬ foowmnck}noc¬
|wdvt||ovdv¬ kc¬tcmdwv}kcmnca¬ oh¬ }id¬ tcmdwj~nca¬ |wogjd`v¬ kcm¬ ioq¬ }id~¬ fkc¬ gd¬kmmwdvvdm#¬
Adcdwnf¬|wogjd`v¬nc¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬wdhdw¬}o¬nvvtdv¬oh¬jkfe¬oh¬wdvotwfdv*¬cdak}nxd¬jofe“nc*¬
kcm¬ v}wtf}twkj¬ ow¬ htcf}nockj¬ hwka`dc}k}noc#¬ Nc¬ v|n}d¬ oh¬ }inv*¬ }idwd¬ kwd¬ hdq¬ aoom¬ dyk`|jdv¬ oh¬
v~v}d`k}nf¬kckj~vdv¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬}ik}¬}ked¬nc}o¬kffotc}¬go}i¬v}wtf}twkj¬kcm¬htcf}nockj¬
|wo|dw}ndv¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬]inv¬|k|dw¬kmmwdvvdv¬}inv¬nvvtd¬g~¬ohhdwnca¬k¬hwk`dqowe¬how¬kckj~rnca¬
nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬|wogjd`v*¬htcf}nocv*¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬kcm¬kf}owv¬kcm*¬gkvdm¬oc¬}inv*¬ohhdwv¬ncvnai}v¬
qn}i¬wdakwm¬}o¬}id¬wojd¬oh¬wdanockj¬kf}owv¬kv¬foowmnck}owv¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬kf}nxn}ndv#¬
¬
¬
¬
¬
¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 4/35
7¬
¬
;# Nc}womtf}noc¬
Qidc¬n}¬fo`dv¬}o¬wdanockj¬|ojnfndv¬how¬v}n`tjk}nca¬nccoxk}noc¬kcm¬nccoxk}noc“gkvdm¬awoq}i*¬}id¬
nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬)NV.¬|dwv|df}nxd¬ikv*¬oxdw¬}id¬jkv}¬mdfkmdv*¬dxojxdm¬nc}o¬k¬|o|tjkw¬hwk`dqowe¬
how¬wdvdkwfidwv¬kcm¬|ojnf~¬`kedwv#¬K¬wdkvoc¬how¬n}v¬|o|tjkwn}~¬nv¬}ik}¬n}¬kfecoqjdmadv¬}id¬hkf}¬
}ik}¬ nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬ viotjm¬ gd¬ v~v}d nf¬ nc¬ }id¬ vdcvd¬ }ik}¬ }idwd¬ nv¬ k¬ cddm¬ how¬ foowmnck}noc¬
gd}qddc¬ k¬ mnxdwvn}~¬ oh¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ nc¬ owmdw¬ }o¬ kmmwdvv¬ wdjdxkc}¬|wogjd`v¬ nc¬ kc¬ dhhdf}nxd¬ qk~#¬]idvd¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬|dwhow`dm¬g~¬mnhhdwdc}¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬nv¬}itv¬co}¬k¬
}kve¬ocj~¬how¬|tgjnf¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬gt}¬ncxojxd¬kf}owv¬hwo`¬}id¬qiojd¬v~v}d`2¬hnw`v¬)}id¬|womtf}noc¬
v}wtf}twd.5¬ tcnxdwvn}ndv*¬ wdvdkwfi¬ ncv}n}t}dv*¬ dmtfk}nockj¬ kcm¬ }wkncnca¬ owakcnrk}nocv¬ )}id¬
ecoqjdmad¬nchwkv}wtf}twd.5¬kcm¬|tgjnf¬kcm¬|wnxk}d¬cd}qowenca¬kcm¬|ojnf~¬kf}owv¬)}id¬vt||ow}¬
v}wtf}twd.#¬Foowmnck}noc¬nv¬wd{tnwdm¬go}i¬gd}qddc¬kf}owv¬kcm¬kf}nxn}ndv#¬
Nc¬kmmn}noc¬}o¬gdnca¬v~v}d`nf*¬dhhdf}nxd¬wdanockj¬|ojnf~¬oh}dc¬cddmv¬}o¬gd¬}knjowdm¬}o¬}id¬v|dfnhnf¬
md`kcmv¬ oh¬ }id¬ ncmtv}wnkj¬ kcm¬ wdanockj¬ foc}dy}#¬ Nc¬ v|n}d¬ oh¬ }id¬ |wkf}nfdv¬ oh¬ `kc~¬ wdanockj¬
ncn}nk}nxdv*¬d#a#¬}o¬fwdk}d¬wd|jnfk¬Vnjnfoc¬Xkjjd~v*¬}idwd¬nv¬co¬ocd“vnrd“hn}v“kjj¬|ojnf~¬how¬|wo`o}nca¬
nccoxk}noc¬nc¬wdanocv¬)Cktqdjkdwv¬kcm¬Qnc}bdv¬7<<7.#¬]id¬v|dfnhnf¬|wdfocmn}nocv¬kcm¬cddmv¬oh¬
}id¬ wdanoc¬ kcm¬ ncmtv}w~¬ `tv}¬ gd¬ focvnmdwdm¬ qidc¬ mdvnacnca¬ kcm¬ dydft}nca¬ |ojnf~#¬ Mnhhdwdc}¬ncmtv}wndv¬ )d#a#¬ inai/joq¬ }dfi5¬ `kcthkf}twnca/vdwxnfdv5¬ jofkj/ajogkj¬ d}f#.¬ kwd¬ hkfdm¬ qn}i¬
mnhhdwdc}¬ fikjjdcadv¬ kcm¬ |wogjd v#¬ Htw}idw`owd*¬ }idwd¬ kwd¬ kjvo¬ focvnmdwkgjd¬ mnhhdwdcfdv¬
gd}qddc¬wdanoc¬}~|dv¬)d#a#¬|dwn|idwkj¬wdanocv5¬jkaanca¬wdanocv5¬twgkc¬wdanocv5¬fjtv}dwdm¬wdanocv5¬
hwka`dc}dm¬ wdanocv¬ d}f#.#¬ ]idwdhowd*¬ mdvnacnca¬ wdanockj¬ |ojnf~¬ wd{tnwdv¬ kfecoqjdmanca¬ }id¬
v|dfnhnfn}ndv¬oh¬}id¬wdanoc¬kcm¬n}v¬dfoco`nf¬v}wtf}twd#¬¬
Qinjd¬ncfwdkvncaj~¬|o|tjkw*¬}id¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬k||wokfi¬ikv¬kjvo¬k}}wkf}dm¬fwn}nfnv`¬how¬co}¬
|woxnmnca¬ vthhnfndc}j~¬|wkf}nfkj¬atnmdjncdv¬how¬|ojnf~¬`kedwv¬)d#a#¬Dm{tnv}¬7<;;5¬Dm{tnv}¬7<<45¬
Ejdnc¬Qooj}itnv¬d}¬kj#¬7<<4.#¬]inv¬|k|dw¬kmmwdvvdv¬}id¬nvvtd¬oh¬ioq¬nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬fkc¬gd¬
‚ftv}o`nrdm‐¬ nc¬}dw`v¬oh¬ }id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬|dwhow`dm#¬ Kf}nxn}ndv¬ viotjm¬gd¬mdvnacdm¬ gkvdm¬oc¬ }id¬
htcf}nocv¬}id~¬kwd¬}o¬|dwhow`#¬]id¬htcf}nocv*¬nc¬}twc*¬kmmwdvv¬v|dfnhnf¬tcmdwj~nca¬ |wogjd`v¬nc¬}id¬
wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d #¬]id¬|k|dw¬|wo|ovdv¬k¬ hwk`dqowe¬how¬kckj~rnca¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d ¬
|wogjd`v*¬ htcf}nocv*¬ kcm¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm*¬ gkvdm¬oc¬}inv*¬ohhdw¬ ncvnai}v¬wdakwmnca¬}id¬ wojd¬oh¬ }id¬
kf}owv¬kcm¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬)d#a#¬|ojnf~.¬kv¬foowmnck}owv¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬kf}nxn}ndv#¬Nc¬monca¬}inv*¬
qd¬ fo`gncd¬ htcf}nockj¬ kcm¬ v}wtf}twkj¬ kckj~vdv¬ oh¬ }id¬ v~v}d ¬ nc¬ jncd¬ qn}i¬ }id¬ ncfwdkvnca¬
d`|ikvnv¬oc¬}id¬htcf}nockj¬|k}}dwcv¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`¬wk}idw¬}ikc¬vojdj~¬oc¬n}v¬v}wtf}twkj¬|wo|dw}ndv¬
)Ideedw}¬d}¬kj#¬7<<15¬Boicvoc¬kcm¬Bkfogvvoc¬7<<<5¬Jnt¬kcm¬Qin}d¬7<<;.#¬
]id¬|k|dw¬mdkjv¬qn}i¬wdanockj ¬|ojnf~¬wk}idw¬}ikc¬ck}nockj¬ow¬vdf}owkj#¬]idwd¬nv¬k¬}wdcm¬nc¬Vqdmdc¬
kcm¬o}idw¬Dtwo|dkc¬fotc}wndv¬}ik}¬}id¬|oqdw¬kcm¬`kcmk}d¬}o¬nchjtdcfd¬kwd¬ncfwdkvncaj~¬gdnca¬
vinh}dm¬ hwo ¬ ck}nockj¬ }o¬ wdanockj¬ jdxdj¬ )Gowwëv¬ kcm¬ ]vkamnv¬ 7<<9.#¬ ]inv¬ nv¬ co}¬ vtw|wnvnca¬
focvnmdwnca¬}id¬awdk}dw¬kt}oco`~¬oh¬wdanockj¬kf}owv¬}o¬mdvnac¬v|dfnkjnrdm¬|ojnf~¬kn`dm¬k}¬}id¬
wdanockj¬v~v}d`#¬Kjvo*¬}id¬|ovvngnjn}~¬}o¬nchjtdcfd¬kcm¬qowe¬mnwdf}j~¬qn}i¬}id¬NV¬kf}owv¬nv¬awdk}dw¬
nc¬}id¬wdanockj¬foc}dy}¬kv¬fo`|kwdm¬}o¬ck}nockj¬ow¬DT¬jdxdj¬qidwd¬nchjtdcfd¬nv¬`owd¬ncmnwdf}*¬
}iwotai¬ how`tjk}noc¬ oh¬ ck}nocqnmd¬ow¬ dxdc¬ nc}dwck}nockj¬ wdatjk}nocv¬ kcm¬ vt||ow}¬ |woawk`v#¬
Nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬}id¬wdanockj¬jdxdj¬nv¬n`|ow}kc}¬kjvo¬how¬kco}idw¬wdkvoc#¬Kv¬Govfi`k¬)7<<>¬|#4.¬
wdfoacnrdv*¬qidc¬ecoqjdmad¬v|njjv¬oxdw¬gd}qddc¬owakcnrk}nocv*¬n}¬}dcmv¬co}¬}o¬}wkxdj¬oxdw¬joca¬
adoawk|infkj¬ mnv}kcfdv#¬ Anxdc¬ }id¬ fdc}wkj¬ wojd¬ oh¬ ecoqjdmad¬ mdxdjo|`dc}¬ kcm¬ mnhhtvnoc¬ how¬
nccoxk}noc*¬k¬wdanockj¬|dwv|df}nxd¬nv¬}itv¬|wdhdwwdm#¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 5/35
6¬
¬
]id¬|k|dw¬gdancv¬qn}i¬k¬gwndh¬nc}womtf}noc¬}o¬wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬)WNV.¬kcm¬wdanockj¬
nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬)WN\.#¬]inv¬nv¬ hojjoqdm¬g~¬ k¬|wdvdc}k}noc¬oh¬ }id¬kckj~}nfkj¬hwk`dqowe#¬Kh}dw¬
}ik}*¬ }id¬ d`|nwnfkj¬ v}tm~¬ ‖¬ hoftvnca¬ oc¬ }iwdd¬ vdf}ow¬ v|dfnhnf¬ WNV¬ vt||ow}¬ |woawk`v¬ nc¬ Veäcd*¬ }id¬
vot}idwc`ov}¬|woxncfd¬oh ¬Vqdmdc¬ ‖¬nv¬|wdvdc}dm#¬Jkv}j~*¬|ojnf~¬wdfo``dcmk}nocv¬kcm¬focfjtvnocv¬
kwd¬|wdvdc}dm#¬
¬
7# Nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬kcm¬NV¬|ojnf~¬
]id¬focfd|}¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬ikv¬gddc¬mdhncdm¬oc¬k¬ct`gdw¬oh¬mnhhdwdc}¬jdxdjv¬)Fkwjvvoc¬d}¬
kj#¬7<<7.*¬}iotai¬}idvd¬mdhncn}nocv¬fkc¬`ov}¬oh}dc¬gd¬}wkfdm¬gkfe¬}o¬vd`nckj¬foc}wngt}nocv¬g~¬
Hwdd`kc¬ kcm¬ Jtcmxkjj¬ )vdd¬ Jtcmxkjj¬7<<1¬ how¬ k¬ inv}ownfkj¬ oxdwxndq.#¬ Ocd¬ dkwj~¬mdhncn}noc¬ nv¬
Hwdd`kc„v2¬ ‚…v~v}d`v¬ oh¬ nccoxk}noc¬ kwd¬ cd}qowev¬ oh¬ ncv}n}t}nocv*¬ |tgjnf¬ ow¬ |wnxk}d*¬ qiovd¬
kf}nxn}ndv¬ kcm¬ nc}dwkf}nocv¬ ncn}nk}d*¬ n`|ow}*¬ `omnh~*¬ kcm¬ mnhhtvd¬ cdq¬ }dficojoandv‐¬ )Hwdd`kc¬
;>91.#¬Jtcmxkjj¬);>>7.¬htw}idw¬mnv}ncatnvidv¬gd}qddc¬k¬gwokm¬kcm¬k¬ckwwoq¬xndq¬oc¬nccoxk}noc¬
v~v}d`v#¬]id¬ckwwoq¬mdhncn}noc¬ncfjtmdv¬‚###owakcnvk}nocv¬kcm¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬ncxojxdm¬nc¬vdkwfinca¬
kcm¬dy|jownca‐¬vtfi¬kv¬W(M¬md|kw}`dc}v¬kcm¬tcnxdwvn}ndv#¬]id¬gwokm¬mdhncn}noc*¬qinfi¬qd¬kmo|}¬
nc¬}inv¬|k|dw*¬ncfjtmdv¬‚###kjj¬|kw}v¬kcm¬kv|df}v¬oh¬}id¬dfoco`nf¬v}wtf}twd¬kcm¬}id¬ncv}n}t}nockj¬
vd}“t|¬khhdf}nca¬jdkwcnca¬kv¬qdjj¬kv¬vdkwfinca¬kcm¬dy|jownca‐¬)|#;7.#¬
Hwo`¬}idvd¬mdhncn}nocv¬n}¬viotjm¬gd¬fjdkw¬}ik}¬kc¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬viotjm¬co}¬gd¬vddc¬kv¬kc¬
kf}ow¬ow¬kc¬owakcnvk}nockj¬dc}n}~5¬ co}¬ dxdc¬cdfdvvkwnj~¬kv¬k¬ awot|¬oh¬kf}owv¬ }ik}¬ focvfnotvj~¬
qowe¬ }oqkwmv¬ k¬ fo``oc¬ aokj#¬ Wk}idw*¬ }id¬ wdanockj¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v¬ )WNV.¬ k||wokfi¬
focv}n}t}dv¬ kc¬ kckj~}nfkj¬ hwk`dqowe¬ }ik}¬ inaijnai}v¬ }id¬ v~v}d nf¬ ck}twd¬ oh¬ nccoxk}noc¬ kcm¬
nccoxk}noc¬ |ojnf~¬ )]øm}jnca¬ kcm¬ ]wn||j¬ 7<<4.#¬ ]id¬ kf}owv¬ nc¬ kc¬ NV¬ fkc¬ gd¬mnxnmdm¬ nc}o¬ }iwdd¬
v}~jnrdm¬ fk}daowndv2¬ );.¬ }id¬ |womtf}noc¬ v}wtf}twd*¬ n#d#¬ fo`|kcndv¬ )tvdm¬ kv¬ k¬ fojjdf}nxd¬ }dw ¬
ncfjtmnca¬go}i¬|womtfnca¬kcm¬coc“|womtfnca¬fo`|kcndv.5¬)7.¬}id¬ecoqjdmad¬nchwkv}wtf}twd*¬n#d#¬
tcnxdwvn}ndv*¬ wdvdkwfi¬ ncv}n}t}dv¬ kcm¬ }wkncnca¬ owakcnvk}nocv5¬ kcm¬ )6.¬ }id¬ vt||ow} ¬ v}wtf}twd*¬
xkwnotv¬owakcnvk}nocv*¬oh}dc¬|tgjnfj~¬htcmdm*¬}kvedm¬qn}i¬vt||ow}nca¬}id¬dfoco`~#¬]idvd¬kf}owv¬
kwd¬ncxojxdm¬nc¬k¬fo`|jdy¬qdg¬oh¬how`kj¬kcm¬nchow`kj¬ cd}qowev*¬go}i¬qn}inc¬kcm¬gd}qddc¬}id¬
vtgawot|v#¬]idvd¬cd}qowe¬wdjk}nocvin|v¬cddm¬co}¬cdfdvvkwnj~¬gd¬how`kjnrdm#¬Wk}idw¬}id¬kf}owv¬
viotjm¬gd¬fo`|k}ngjd¬qn}i¬dkfi¬o}idw*¬}idwdg~¬focv}n}t}nca¬k¬`t}tkjj~¬wdnchowfnca¬v~v}d #¬]id¬
ncv}n}t}nockj ¬focmn}nocv*¬ go}i¬ how kj¬ )jdakj¬d}f#.¬kcm¬ nchow`kj¬)cow`v*¬xkjtdv¬ d}f.*¬|woxnmd¬ }id¬
‚wtjdv¬oh¬}id¬ak`d‐¬how¬}id¬qk~¬nc¬qinfi¬nc}dwkf}noc¬kcm¬cd}qowe¬how`k}noc¬}ked¬|jkfd¬)Cow}i¬
;>><.#¬
Gwokmj~¬ mdhncdm*¬ nccoxk}noc¬ |ojnf~¬ mdkjv¬ qn}i¬ |wo`o}nca¬ }id¬ mdxdjo|`dc}*¬ mnhhtvnoc*¬ kcm¬
dhhnfndc}¬tvd¬oh¬cdq¬|womtf}v¬)d#a#¬aoomv¬kcm¬vdwxnfdv.¬kcm¬|wofdvvdv¬kcm¬kv¬vtfi¬hojjoq¬ocd¬oh¬
}qo¬adcdwnf¬k||wokfidv2¬k¬jknvvdr“hknwd¬ow¬k¬v~v}d`nf¬k||wokfi¬)Jtcmxkjj¬kcm¬Gowwëv¬7<<4.#¬]id¬
v~v}d`nf¬k||wokfi¬mnvftvvdm¬nc¬}inv¬|k|dw¬ownanck}dv¬nc¬}id¬foc}dc}noc¬}ik}¬`ov}¬|ojnf~¬hndjmv¬cddm¬}o¬gd¬focvnmdwdm¬nc¬}dw`v¬oh¬}id¬dy}dc}¬}o¬qinfi¬}id~¬foc}wngt}d¬}o¬nccoxk}noc¬)ngnm.#¬N}¬nv¬
}itv¬co}¬|ovvngjd¬}o¬htjj~¬tcmdwv}kcm¬nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬qn}iot}¬kjvo¬focvnmdwnca¬n}v¬qowencav¬nc¬
wdjk}noc¬}o¬o}idw¬|ojnfndv¬jned¬}ky¬|ojnf~*¬dmtfk}noc¬|ojnf~*¬hnckcfnkj¬|ojnf~¬d}f#¬Hojjoqnca¬vtfi¬kc¬
k||wokfi*¬}id¬foowmnck}nca¬jncekadv¬gd}qddc¬|kw}v¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`¬gdfo`dv¬fdc}wkj#¬]id¬v~v}d`nf¬
k||wokfi¬ikv¬tcmdw¬ }id¬ }dw`ncojoa~¬oh¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v¬ akncdm¬ `tfi¬ fwdmdcfd¬ nc¬|ojnf~¬
fnwfjdv¬ nc¬Dtwo|d¬ k}¬mnhhdwdc}¬ jdxdjv¬ oh¬k||jnfk}noc2¬ DT*¬ ck}nockj*¬ wdanockj*¬ kcm¬ oc¬vdf}owkj¬ow¬
}dficojoanfkj¬ jdxdjv#¬ Nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d ¬ |ojnf~¬ mnhhdwv¬ hwo`¬ adcdwkj¬ dfoco nf¬ |ojnf~¬ kv¬ n}¬ nv¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 6/35
=¬
¬
v|dfnhnfkjj~¬kgot}¬nccoxk}noc¬kcm¬n}¬}kedv¬k¬ v~v}d`¬|dwv|df}nxd¬wk}idw¬}ikc¬kc¬ kf}ow“fdc}wnf¬ow¬
jknvvdr“hknwd¬|dwv|df}nxd¬)Dm{tnv}¬ ;>>15¬ Jtcmxkjj¬kcm¬Gowwëv¬ 7<<4.#¬Xndqnca¬ nccoxk}noc¬kv¬ k¬
|wofdvv¬}kenca¬|jkfd¬nc¬k¬v~v}d`¬oh¬kf}owv¬wk}idw¬}ikc¬qn}inc¬k¬v|dfnhnf¬owakcnrk}noc¬)k¬hnw`¬ow¬k¬
tcnxdwvn}~.¬ ow¬ k¬ fjkvv¬ oh¬ kf}owv¬ )hnw`v.¬ vnacnhnfkc}j~¬ nchjtdcfdv¬ }id¬ qk~¬ nc¬ qinfi¬ nccoxk}noc¬
|ojnf~¬viotjm¬gd¬mdvnacdm¬}o¬gd¬dhhdf}nxd#¬¬
Nc¬kc¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬foc}dy}¬’|ojnf~„¬nv¬}itv¬}o¬gd¬tcmdwv}oom¬nc¬k¬gwokm¬vdcvd*¬}o¬ncfjtmd¬kf}owv¬ wd|wdvdc}nca¬ }id¬ vt||ow}¬ v}wtf}twd¬ hwo`¬ go}i¬ |tgjnf¬ kcm¬ |wnxk}d¬ vdf}owv¬ )Gowwëv¬ kcm¬
]vkamnv¬7<<9.#¬Htw}idw`owd*¬|ojnf~¬nv¬}o¬gd¬vddc¬kv¬v~v}d`nf¬nc¬}id¬vdcvd¬}ik}¬n}¬ncxojxdv¬}id¬
kf}nxn}ndv¬oh¬k¬`tj}n}tmd¬oh¬kf}owv¬kcm¬}idnw¬bonc}¬dhhow}v#¬]ik}¬nv*¬qinjd¬|ojnf~¬`kedwv¬wd|wdvdc}¬k¬
fdw}knc¬fjkvv¬ oh¬kf}owv*¬|tgjnf¬ kcm¬|wnxk}d*¬}ik}¬ ikv¬}id¬wojd¬oh¬ v~v}d`¬hkfnjn}k}owv¬ )|kw}¬ oh¬ }id¬
vt||ow}¬ v}wtf}twd.*¬ |ojnf~¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ ncxojxd¬ kf}owv¬ hwo ¬ kjj¬ |kw}v¬ oh¬ }id¬ WNV¬ )|womtf}noc¬
v}wtf}twd*¬ ecoqjdmad¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd*¬ kcm¬ vt||ow}¬ v}wtf}twd.#¬ ]~|nfkjj~¬ |ojnf~¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ kwd¬
foowmnck}dm¬g~¬|ojnf~¬`kedwv¬)}id¬vt||ow}¬v}wtf}twd.*¬gt}¬qn}iot}¬kf}nxd¬|kw}nfn|k}noc¬)go}i¬nc¬
mdvnac¬ kcm¬ dydft}noc.¬ hwo ¬ kjj¬ WNV¬ kf}owv¬ )wd|wdvdc}nca¬ }id¬ ecoqjdmad¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd*¬
|womtf}noc¬v}wtf}twd*¬kcm¬vt||ow}¬v}wtf}twd.¬}id¬dhhdf}v¬oh¬}iovd¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬qnjj¬gd¬v}wnf}j~¬
jn`n}dm#¬¬
Hojjoqnca¬}inv¬ncvnai}*¬n}¬nv¬fjdkw¬}ik}¬}id¬v~v}d`nf¬k||wokfi¬ncidwdc}¬}o¬NV¬}idow~¬modv¬co}¬nchdw¬
}ik}¬ }id¬ v~v}d ¬ fkc¬ gd¬ focvfnotvj~¬ mdvnacdm¬ ow¬ |jkccdm#¬ Vn njkwj~¬ }o¬ nccoxk}noc¬ |wofdvvdv*¬
qinfi¬kffowmnca¬}o¬\kxn}}¬)7<<4.¬kcm¬o}idwv¬kwd¬inaij~¬foc}ncadc}*¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬dxojxd¬nc¬
k¬ jkwadj~¬ tc|jkccdm¬ `kccdw#¬ ]idwdhowd*¬ fdc}wkjnrdm¬ foc}woj¬ oxdw¬ }id¬ v~v}d ¬ nv¬ fjkn dm¬
n`|ovvngjd#¬ Kv¬ kwatdm¬ g~¬ Dm{tnv}¬ )7<<4¬ |#;>;.¬ ‚nccoxk}noc¬ |ojnf~¬ fkc¬ ocj~¬ nchjtdcfd¬ }id¬
v|oc}kcdotv¬mdxdjo|`dc}¬oh¬ VNv¬ }o¬ k¬ jn n}dm¬ dy}dc}#‐#¬ Cocd}idjdvv*¬ }idwd¬ nv¬ vfo|d¬ how¬ |ojnf~¬
nchjtdcfnca¬}id¬mdxdjo|`dc}¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v*¬gt}¬}idwd¬nv¬co¬ocd¬vnrd¬hn}v¬kjj¬k||wokfi¬}o¬
mdvnacnca¬vtfi¬|ojnf~#¬Qn}iot}¬kckj~rnca¬}id¬v|dfnhnfn}ndv¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`*¬}id¬wdanockj¬vd}}nca*¬kcm¬
}id¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬ncv}n}t}nocv*¬kcm¬kf}owv¬|wdvdc}¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`*¬|ojnf~¬qnjj¬`ov}¬jnedj~¬gd¬ncdhhdf}nxd¬
)Jtcmxkjj¬kcm¬Gowwëv¬7<<45¬]øm}jnca¬kcm¬]wn||j¬7<<4.#¬¬
¬
6# Kckj~}nf¬hwk`dqowe ¬
]id¬kckj~}nfkj¬hwk`dqowe¬|wdvdc}dm¬nc¬}inv¬vdf}noc¬nv¬gkvdm¬oc¬}id¬fo`gncdm¬joanfv¬oh¬htcf}nockj¬
kcm¬v}wtf}twkj¬kckj~vnv¬oh¬v~v}d`v¬oh¬ nccoxk}noc#¬]id¬fo`gnck}noc¬oh¬ v}wtf}twd¬)kf}ow“hoftvdm.¬
kcm¬htcf}noc¬)v~v}d`“hoftvdm.¬nv¬adcdwkjj~¬vddc¬kv¬k¬`kbow¬v}wdca}i¬oh¬}id¬NV¬k||wokfi¬)Dm{tnv}¬
;>>1.#¬ Vtfi¬k||wokfidv¬ikxd¬ioqdxdw¬gddc¬jkwadj~¬kgvdc}¬ nc¬ }id¬ jn}dwk}twd¬kv¬ `ov}¬vfiojkwv¬
hoftv¬ oc¬ }id¬ wojdv¬ oh¬ v|dfnhnf¬ kf}owv¬ ow¬ |ojnfndv¬ oc¬ }id¬ v~v}d`¬ )Jnt¬ kcm¬ Qin}d¬ 7<<;.#¬ ]id¬
htcf}nockj¬mn`dcvnoc¬|nxo}v¬oc¬}id¬}wncn}~¬oh¬|wogjd`v*¬htcf}nocv*¬kcm¬kf}nxn}ndv#¬]id¬vd{tdcfd¬nc¬
qinfi¬ }idvd¬ kwd¬ }o¬ gd¬ kmmwdvvdm¬ nv¬ }o¬ v}kw}¬ qn}i¬ kckj~vnv¬ oh¬ }id¬ |wogjd`v¬ }ik}¬ dynv}¬ nc¬ }id¬
wdanockj¬v~v}d`5¬nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬oh¬}id¬htcf}nocv¬}ik}¬cddm¬}o¬gd¬hnjjdm¬g~¬|ojnf~¬)g~¬kjj¬}iwdd¬}~|d¬oh¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`.¬nc¬owmdw¬}o¬`n}nak}d¬}idvd¬|wogjd`v5¬kcm¬jkv}j~¬nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬oh¬kf}nxn}ndv¬
}ik}¬fkc¬gd¬mdvnacdm¬kcm¬n`|jd`dc}dm¬g~¬}id¬kf}owv¬}o¬|dwhow`¬}idvd¬htcf}nocv#¬]id¬v}wtf}twkj¬
fo`|ocdc}¬oh¬}id¬kckj~vnv¬hoftvdv¬oc¬}id¬kf}owv¬}ik}¬fkww~¬ot}¬}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬qn}inc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬
Hnatwd¬;¬|woxnmdv¬k¬vfid`k}nf¬oxdwxndq¬oh¬}id¬joanf¬oh¬otw¬kckj~}nfkj¬hwk`dqowe#¬¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 7/35
4¬
¬
¬
Hnatwd¬;2¬Vfid`d¬oh ¬}id¬v}wtf}twkj¬kcm¬htcf}nockj¬mn`dcvnocv¬oh ¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v#¬¬
¬
6#; \wogjd`v¬¬
Tcmdwv}kcmnca¬}id¬tcmdwj~nca¬|wogjd`v¬kcm¬fikjjdcadv¬}o¬gd¬kmmwdvvdm¬nv¬}id¬v}kw}nca¬|onc}¬how¬
nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d ¬ |ojnf~#¬ ]iwdd¬ adcdwnf¬ |wogjd`v¬ }ik}¬ `k~¬ ik`|dw¬ nccoxk}noc¬ kf}nxn}~¬ nc¬
wdanockj¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v¬ ikxd¬ gddc¬ |wo|ovdm¬ nc¬ }id¬ jn}dwk}twd2¬ jkfe¬ oh¬
wdvotwfdv/owakcnvk}nockj¬ }inccdvv*¬ hwka`dc}k}noc*¬ kcm¬ cdak}nxd¬ jofe¬ nc¬ )Nvkevdc¬ 7<<;5¬
Cktqdjkdwv¬kcm¬Qnc}bdv¬7<<75¬ ]øm}jnca¬kcm¬]wn||j¬7<<4.#¬]idvd¬ |wogjd`v¬fkc¬gd¬ wdjk}dm¬ }o¬
go}i¬}id¬v}wtf}twkj¬kcm¬htcf}nockj¬mn`dcvnocv¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v#¬
Hnw`v„¬nccoxk}nxd¬fk|kfn}~¬md|dcmv¬co}¬ocj~¬oc¬ioq¬qdjj¬}id~¬t}njnrd¬nc}dwckj¬wdvotwfdv*¬gt}¬kjvo¬
oc¬ }idnw¬ kgvow|}nxd¬ fk|kfn}~¬ nc¬|wofdvvdv¬ oh¬ o|dc¬ nccoxk}noc¬ )Fidvgwotai¬7<<65¬ Foidc¬ kcm¬
Jdxnc}ikj¬ ;>><.#¬ ]itv¬ }id¬ kxknjkgnjn}~¬ oh¬ wdjdxkc}¬ wdvotwfdv¬ qn}inc¬ }id¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d *¬
fot|jdm¬qn}i¬kf}owv„¬kgvow|}nxd¬fk|kfn}~*¬nv¬fdc}wkj¬how¬}id¬htcf}nockjn}~¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Jkfe¬oh¬
wdvotwfdv¬`k~¬gd¬oh¬vdxdwkj¬}~|dv¬md|dcmnca¬oc¬}id¬v|dfnhnfn}ndv¬oh¬}id¬wdanoc¬kcm¬ncmtv}w~#¬Nc¬
vo`d¬ fkvdv¬ jkfe¬ oh¬ hnckcfnkj¬ wdvotwfdv¬ )d#a#¬ xdc}twd¬ fk|n}kj¬ ow¬ vddm¬ `ocd~.¬ nv¬ fdc}wkj¬ qinjd¬
it`kc¬ fk|n}kj¬ nv¬ k¬`owd¬ vnacnhnfkc}¬|wogjd`¬nc¬o}idwv#¬Jkfenca¬W(M¬ow¬ ecoqjdmad¬wdvotwfdv¬
)d#a#¬ vfndc}nhnf¬ ecoqjdmad*¬ ow¬ `owd¬ k||jndm¬ venjjv¬ kcm¬ fk|kgnjn}ndv¬ d#a#¬ nc¬ `kwed}nca¬ ow¬
nc}dwck}nockjnrk}noc.¬`k~¬gd¬fdc}wkj¬nc¬vo`d¬foc}dy}v#¬Jkfe¬oh¬wdvotwfdv¬nv¬oh}dc¬fowwdjk}dm¬qn}i¬
}id¬nvvtd¬oh¬owakcnrk}nockj¬mdcvn}~/}inccdvv¬qn}inc¬}id¬WNV#¬Qidwd¬}idwd¬nv¬k¬jkfe¬oh¬wdvotwfdv¬
}inv¬ nv¬ oh}dc¬ gdfktvd¬ }idwd¬ nv¬ k¬ jkfe¬ oh¬ jofkj¬ kf}owv¬ }ik}¬ vt||j~¬ }idvd¬ wdvotwfdv¬ )mnwdf}j~¬ ow¬
}iwotai¬dy}wk“wdanockj¬jncekadv.#¬Nc¬owakcnrk}nockjj~¬}inc¬wdanocv*¬|ojnf~¬`dkvtwdv¬viotjm¬v}kw}¬
hwo`¬kc¬ tcmdwv}kcmnca¬oh¬qinfi¬v|dfnhnf¬ wdvotwfdv¬ kcm¬kf}owv¬ kwd¬ jkfenca#¬Kckj~rnca¬}id¬WNV¬
fo`|ocdc}v¬ ‖¬ |womtf}noc¬ v}wtf}twd*¬ ecoqjdmad¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd*¬ kcm¬ vt||ow}¬ v}wtf}twd¬ ‖¬ nv¬ k¬
cdfdvvkw~¬ hnwv}¬ v}d|¬ }oqkwmv¬ vtfi¬ kc¬ tcmdwv}kcmnca#¬ ]id¬ `knc¬ fikjjdcad¬ how¬ }id¬ nccoxk}noc¬
vt||ow}¬ ncn}nk}nxd¬ nv¬ }idc¬ }o¬ k}}wkf}¬ ow¬ hkfnjn}k}d¬ }id¬ fwdk}noc¬ oh¬ ed~¬ wdvotwfdv¬ dn}idw¬ g~¬
nchjtdcfnca¬ wdanockj¬ vt||j~¬ ow¬ g~¬ v}n tjk}nca¬ wdanockj¬ kf}owv¬ }o¬ `dd}¬ }idvd¬ cddmv¬ }iwotai¬
jncekadv¬}o¬dy}wk“WNV¬foc}kf}v¬)Nvkevdc¬7<<;.#¬¬
Vn`njkwj~*¬nc¬ hwka dc}dm¬wdanocv*¬kjj¬wdjdxkc}¬kf}owv¬kcm¬wdvotwfdv¬`k~¬gd¬|wdvdc}¬gt}¬qn}iot}¬
how`nca¬k¬qowenca¬v~v}d`#¬How¬|ojnf~¬}o¬gd¬vtffdvvhtj¬n}¬`tv}¬gd¬focvnv}dc}¬qn}i¬}id¬ncft`gdc}¬
kf}owv„¬aokjv¬kcm¬xkjtdv*¬kcm¬qn}i¬}id¬wdvotwfdv¬kxknjkgjd¬qn}inc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Hwka`dc}k}noc¬`k~¬}itv¬ ownanck}d¬ nc¬ k¬ jkfe¬ oh¬ hn}¬ gd}qddc¬ |ojnf~¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ kcm¬ kf}owv„¬ v}wk}dandv#¬ Vtfi¬ k¬ xndq¬
fowwdv|ocmv¬ qn}i¬ `kckadwnkj¬ }idowndv¬ }ik}¬ vioq¬ }ik}¬ hnw`v¬ }ik}¬ kjnac¬ }idnw¬ v}wk}dandv¬ kcm¬
kf}nxn}ndv¬qn}i¬}id¬v|dfnhnf¬ wd{tnwd`dc}v¬oh¬ }idnw¬dcxnwoc`dc}kj¬foc}dy}¬|dwhow`¬vnacnhnfkc}j~¬
gd}}dw¬}ikc¬}iovd¬}ik}¬mo¬co}¬)fh#¬'v}wk}danf¬hn}'¬d#a#¬Jtekv¬d}¬kj#¬7<<;5¬Xdcek}wk`kc¬kcm¬\wdvfo}}¬
;>><.#¬Htw}idw`owd*¬|wogjd`v¬oh¬hwka`dc}k}noc¬`k~¬kjvo¬gd¬ wdjk}dm¬}o¬ }id¬jdxdj¬oh¬ nc}dwkf}noc¬
qn}inc¬ }id¬v~v}d`¬kcm¬}id¬ ncft`gdc}v„¬ecoqjdmad¬kgot}¬ }id¬v~v}d`#¬Jn`n}dm¬ nc}dwkf}noc¬kcm¬
dyfikcad¬`k~¬gd¬mtd¬}o¬k¬jkfe¬oh¬}wtv}¬gd}qddc¬}id¬kf}owv¬)Nvkevdc¬7<<;.#¬Kj}dwck}nxdj~¬n}¬`k~¬
Fkww~¬ot}¬¬
Kmmwdvv¬¬\dwhow`¬¬
Kf}nxn}ndv¬ \wogjd`v
Kf}owv¬
Htcf}nocv Htcf}nockj ¬mn`dcvnoc¬
V}wtf}twkj ¬mn`dcvnocNchjtdcfd¬}id¬
gdikxnotw¬oh ¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 8/35
8¬
¬
gd¬k¬wdvtj}¬oh¬}id¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬WNV¬vn`|j~¬gdnca¬tchk`njnkw¬qn}i¬dkfi¬o}idw¬kcm¬}idwdhowd¬co}¬
wdfoacnrnca¬|o}dc}nkj¬v~cdwandv#¬¬
]idvd¬}qo¬}~|dv¬oh¬hwka`dc}k}noc¬|wogjd`v¬kwd¬idwd¬mnvftvvdm¬nc¬}dw`v¬oh¬ncv}n}t}nockj¬xdwvtv¬
htcf}nockj¬`nv`k}fi#¬ ]id~¬go}i¬ wdjk}d¬ }o¬ }id¬ |wogjd`¬ oh¬ hwka`dc}k}noc¬ gt}¬ }id¬ `dkvtwdv¬ }o¬
oxdwfo`d¬ }id ¬ qotjm¬ mnhhdw#¬ Htcf}nockj ¬`nv`k}fi¬ nv¬ qidc¬ }id¬ htcf}nocv¬ vt||ow}dm¬ g~¬ }id¬
vt||ow}¬v}wtf}twd¬oh¬ }id¬WNV¬mo¬co}¬wdvtj}¬ nc¬`t}tkjj~¬wdnchowfnca¬v~cdwandv¬how¬}id¬WNV¬kf}owv#¬]inv¬nv¬oh}dc¬kc¬dhhdf}¬oh¬jkfenca¬foowmnck}noc¬gd}qddc¬}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬nc¬}id¬WNV¬)]øm}jnca¬kcm¬
]wn||j¬7<<4.#¬Kc¬dyk`|jd¬nv¬qidc¬ecoqjdmad¬dyfikcad¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kn`nca¬}o¬hkfnjn}k}d¬ecoqjdmad¬
mdxdjo|`dc}¬kcm¬mnhhtvnoc¬nc¬}id¬WNV¬nv¬|dwhow`nca¬|oowj~¬gdfktvd¬oh¬jkfe¬oh¬v~cdwandv¬gd}qddc¬
kfkmd`nk¬ kcm¬ |wnxk}d¬ fo`|kcndv#¬ Ncv}n}t}nockj ¬ `nv`k}fi¬ wdhdwv¬ }o¬ vn}tk}nocv¬ qidc¬ }id¬
ncv}n}t}nockj¬hwk`dqowe¬modv¬co}¬hn}¬kjj¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬WNV¬ow¬qidc¬}idwd¬nv¬k¬jkfe¬oh¬}wtv}¬gd}qddc¬
}id¬ kf}owv#¬ Ncv}n}t}nocv¬ ‖¬ }id¬ wtjdv¬ oh¬ }id¬ ak`d/fomdv¬ oh¬ focmtf}*¬ wot}ncdv¬ kcm¬ how`kj¬
wdatjk}nocv¬kcm¬jkqv¬‖¬hnjj¬k¬fdc}wkj¬wojd¬nc¬hkfnjn}k}nca¬}wtv}¬fwdk}noc¬kcm¬wdmtfnca¬tcfdw}knc}~¬
)]øm}jnca¬kcm¬Ekth`kcc¬;>>>.#¬Ncv}n}t}nockj¬`nv`k}fi¬`k~¬gd¬`kcnhdv}dm¬kv¬k¬jkfe¬oh¬fojjdf}nxd¬
xnvnoc¬kcm¬kf}noc¬k`ocav}¬}id¬kf}owv#¬¬
]id¬ }inwm¬ adcdwnf¬ |wogjd`¬ ikv¬ }o¬ mo¬ qn}i¬ |ovn}nxd¬ hddmgkfe*¬ |k}i¬ md|dcmdcf~*¬ kcm¬ jofe“nc¬dhhdf}v¬ )Kw}itw¬ ;>>=.#¬ ]inv¬ nv¬ kc¬ ncidwdc}¬ |wogjd`¬ oh¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d v¬ qn}i¬ k¬ vikwdm¬
ncv}n}t}nockj¬ vd}}nca#¬ Vikwnca¬ kc¬ ncv}n}t}nockj¬ vd}}nca¬ ‖¬ d#a#¬ jkqv*¬ wtjdv*¬ kcm¬ fo``oc¬ ikgn}v*¬
wot}ncdv*¬ cow`v*¬ ftj}twd*¬ kcm¬ dv}kgjnvidm¬ |wkf}nfdv¬ ‖¬ `k~¬ jdkm¬ }o¬ ncdw}nk¬ kcm¬ jofe“nc¬ nc}o¬
dv}kgjnvidm¬qk~v¬}o¬mo¬gtvncdvv*¬k||wokfi¬`kwed}v*¬|womtfd¬|womtf}v¬kcm¬t}njnrd¬}dficojoandv¬
)Ckwtjk¬ 7<<7.#¬ ]id¬ v}wdca}i¬ oh¬ nc}dwckj¬ kcm¬ dy}dwckj¬ ncdw}nkj¬ howfdv¬ oc¬ owakcnvk}nocv¬ kcm¬
v~v}d v¬kwd¬focvnmdwkgjd¬)Ikcckc¬kcm¬Hwdd`kc¬;>9=.#¬]idwd¬ nv¬ }itv¬k¬ wnve¬}ik}*¬qinjd¬}idwd¬
`k~¬ gd¬ k¬ htcf}nocnca¬ WNV¬ nc¬ |jkfd*¬ }id¬ v~v}d ¬ `k~¬ gd¬ }oo¬ fjovdm¬ kcm¬ wnanm¬ wdvtj}nca¬ nc¬
ncv}n}t}nockj*¬vofnkj¬kcm¬foacn}nxd¬ jofe“nc¬)Govfi`k¬7<<4.#¬]id¬wnve¬oh¬cdak}nxd¬jofe“nc¬ nv¬`ov}¬
|wdxkjdc}¬nc¬ojm¬ncmtv}wnkj¬wdanocv¬mo`nck}dm¬g~¬}wkmn}nockj¬ncmtv}wndv¬)Nvkevdc¬7<<;5¬]øm}jnca¬
kcm¬]wn||j¬7<<4.¬kcm¬}dficojoandv¬)Cdawo¬d}¬kj#¬7<<1.#¬K¬ed~¬nvvtd¬how¬}id¬WNV¬nv¬}o¬hkfnjn}k}d¬}id¬
t|awkmnca¬kcm¬wdcdqkj¬oh¬}id¬ecoqjdmad¬gkvd¬kcm¬qk~v¬}o¬mo¬gtvncdvv¬qinjd¬k}¬}id¬vk`d¬}n`d¬|woxnmnca¬v}kgnjn}~#¬Nc¬dvvdcfd¬}o¬kfindxd¬k¬gkjkcfd¬gd}qddc¬v}kgnjn}~*¬o|dccdvv*¬kcm¬hjdyngnjn}~¬nc¬
}id¬ ncv}n}t}nockj¬ v}wtf}twd¬ )Govfi`k¬7<<4.¬ kcm¬ nc¬}id¬ `omdv¬ oh¬gtvncdvv¬ kcm¬ k||wokfidv¬ }o¬
}dficojoa~¬)Kw}itw¬;>9>.#¬]inv¬nv¬vo`d}n`dv¬|wogjd`k}nf¬gdfktvd¬}id¬ncmtv}w~¬`k~¬dy|dwndcfd¬
awoq}i¬nc¬}id¬viow}¬kcm¬`dmnt`¬}dw`¬gt}¬`k~¬dcfotc}dw¬|wogjd v¬nc¬}id¬joca¬wtc¬gdfktvd¬oh¬
jofe“nc#¬Akncnca¬ kffd|}kcfd¬ kcm¬ jdan}n`kf~¬ how¬ ncxdv} dc}v¬ nc¬t|awkmnca¬}id¬ ecoqjdmad¬gkvd¬
kcm¬gtvncdvv¬|wkf}nfdv¬`k~¬}idc¬gd¬mnhhnftj}#¬¬
Kv¬njjtv}wk}dm¬ nc¬]kgjd¬ ;¬ }idvd¬adcdwnf¬|wogjd`v¬fkc¬gd¬dy|wdvvdm¬kjoca¬go}i¬htcf}nockj¬kcm¬
v}wtf}twkj¬ mn`dcvnocv¬ oh¬ }id¬ v~v}d #¬ Jkfe¬ oh¬ wdvotwfdv¬ ikv¬ |kw}j~¬ }o¬mo¬qn}i¬ owakcnvk}nockj¬
}inccdvv¬ )v}wtf}twkj¬ mn dcvnoc.¬ kcm¬ }id¬ fojjdf}nxd¬ |dwhow`kcfd¬oh¬ }idvd¬ kf}owv¬ )htcf}nockj.#¬
Vn`njkwj~*¬ hwka`dc}k}noc¬|wogjd`v¬fkc¬gd¬ dy|jkncdm¬ nc¬ }dw`v¬ oh¬ v}wtf}twkj¬ hkf}owv¬ )qidc¬}id¬
ncv}n}t}nockj¬ hwk`dqowe¬ mo¬co}¬ vt||ow}¬ }wtv}¬fwdk}noc¬jdkmnca¬ }o¬ joq¬ jdxdj¬oh¬ nc}dwkf}noc.¬ ow¬
htcf}nockj¬hkf}owv¬)v}wk}danf¬`nvhn}.#¬Jkv}j~*¬cdak}nxd¬jofe“nc¬dhhdf}v¬`k~¬gd¬fktvdm¬g~¬v}wtf}twkj¬
ncdw}nk¬)n#d#¬}id¬v}wtf}twkj¬kcm¬ncv}n}t}nockj¬fo`|ovn}noc¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`.¬ow¬htcf}nockj¬ncdw}nk¬)n#d#¬
}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm¬wot}ncdv¬qn}inc¬}id¬v~v}d`.#¬
¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 9/35
1¬
¬
]kgjd¬;2¬Adcdwnf¬|wogjd`v¬nc¬v~v}d`v¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬¬
\wogjd`v¬kcm¬Fikjjdcadv¬ Htcf}nockj¬mn`dcvnoc V}wtf}twkj mn`dcvnoc¬Jkfe¬oh ¬wdvotwfdv¬ Qdke¬|dwhow`kcfd
]id¬htcf}nockj¬mn`dcvnoc¬oh ¬}id¬|wogjd ¬
oh ¬jkfe¬oh ¬wdvotwfdv¬nv¬qidc¬}idwd¬kwd¬
wdjdxkc}¬ncv}n}t}nocv
¬how
¬vt||j~nca
¬}id
¬
cddmdm¬wdvotwfdv¬gt}¬qidc¬}idvd¬kf}owv¬mo¬co}¬htcf}noc¬}o¬}id¬gdv}¬nc}dwdv}¬oh ¬}id¬
v~v}d`#¬]inv¬`k~¬gd¬nc¬}dw`v¬oh ¬{tkjn}~¬ow¬{tkc}n}~#¬N}¬`k~¬gd¬}id¬fkvd¬}ik}¬}id¬
dynv}nca¬owakcnvk}nocv¬mo¬co}¬hoftv¬oc¬}id¬
ot}|t}¬`ov}¬cddmdm¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d ¬ow¬qidc¬}id¬{tkjn}~¬oh ¬}id¬wdvotwfdv¬|womtfdm¬nv¬ncvthhnfndc}#¬
Owakcnvk}nockj¬}inccdvv¬Ocd¬how`¬oh ¬jkfe¬oh ¬wdvotwfdv¬ownanck}dv¬hwo`¬owakcnvk}nockj¬}inccdvv*¬n#d#¬}ik}¬
}idwd¬kwd
¬k¬ncvthhnfndc}
¬ct`gdw
¬oh
¬
kf}owv/owakcnvk}nocv¬}ik}¬fkc¬vt||j~¬
wdvotwfdv¬cddmdm¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Ocd¬
dyk`|jd¬`k~¬gd¬k¬jkfe¬oh ¬dmtfk}nockj¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬how¬}id¬vt||j~¬oh ¬venjjdm¬
jkgotw#¬
Hwka`dc}k}noc¬ Htcf}nockj¬`nv`k}fi
Qidc¬}id¬htcf}nocv¬vt||ow}dm¬g~¬}id¬
vt||ow}¬v}wtf}twd¬oh ¬}id¬WNV¬mo¬co}¬wdvtj}¬nc¬`t}tkjj~¬wdnchowfnca¬kf}noc¬)v~cdwandv.¬
how¬}id
¬v~v}d
¬kv
¬k¬qiojd#
¬Vtfi
¬v}wk}danf
¬`nvhn}¬`k~¬gd¬kc¬dhhdf}¬oh ¬jkfenca¬
foowmnck}noc¬gd}qddc¬}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬nc¬
}id¬WNV¬ow¬k¬jkfenca¬tcmdwv}kcmnca¬oh ¬|ojnf~¬`kedw¬how¬}id¬v}wtf}twd¬kcm¬
m~ck`nf¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬¬
V}wtf}twkj/ncv}n}t}nockj¬¬`nv`k}fi¬Qidc¬}id¬ncv}n}t}nockj¬hwk`dqowe¬mo¬co}¬hn}¬}id¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬WNV¬wdvtj}nca¬nc¬k¬jkfe¬
oh ¬}wtv}¬gd}qddc¬kf}owv#¬Kjvo¬qidc¬}idwd¬
}id¬kf}owv
¬nc
¬}id
¬v~v}d
¬nv
¬tchk`njnkw
¬qn}i¬dkfi¬o}idw¬qinfi¬kjvo¬jdkmv¬}o¬
jn`n}dm¬nc}dwkf}noc#¬¬
Jofe¬nc¬¬ Htcf}nockj¬ncdw}nk¬Jofe“nc¬nc¬}dw`v¬oh ¬}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm¬
htcf}nocv¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬]inv¬nv¬kc¬
ncidwdc}¬|wogjd ¬oh ¬v~v}d`v¬qn}i¬k¬
vikwdm¬ncv}n}t}nockj¬vd}}nca¬vncfd¬}ik}¬oh}dc¬dc}knjv¬fwdk}noc¬oh ¬fo``oc¬ikgn}v*¬cow`v*¬dv}kgjnvidm¬|wkf}nfdv¬d}f#¬]itv*¬}id¬kgnjn}~¬}o¬fikcad¬kcm¬kmk|}¬}id¬
kf}nxn}ndv¬|dwhow`dm¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d ¬`k~¬
gd¬fnwft`vfwngdm#¬
V}wtf}twkj¬ncdw}nk¬]inv¬ikv¬}o¬mo¬qn}i¬jofe“nc¬dhhdf}v¬ownanck}nca¬nc¬}id¬dynv}nca¬v}wtf}twkj¬fo`|ovn}noc¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Dynv}nca¬
kf}owv¬kcm¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬kwd¬vtgbdf}¬}o¬
v}wtf}twkj¬ncdw}nk#¬
¬
Jkv}j~*¬n}¬viotjm¬gd¬co}dm¬}ik}¬}idvd¬|wogjd`v¬kwd¬g~¬co¬`dkcv¬`t}tkjj~¬dyfjtvnxd#¬K¬wdanoc¬qn}i¬
kc¬ dv}kgjnvidm¬ fjtv}dw¬ `k~¬ dy|dwndcfd¬ |wogjd`v¬ qn}i¬ hwka`dc}k}noc*¬ jofe“nc*¬ kcm¬ dxdc¬
owakcnrk}nockj¬ }inccdvv#¬ How¬ dyk`|jd*¬ k¬ wdanoc¬ qn}i¬ k¬ v}woca¬ ncmtv}wnkj¬ fjtv}dw¬ `k~¬ jkfe¬
n`|ow}kc}¬kf}owv¬)d#a#¬`k~¬ikxd¬k¬v}woca¬|womtf}noc¬v}wtf}twd¬kcm¬vt||ow}¬v}wtf}twd¬gt}¬jkfe¬kc¬
kmxkcfdm¬ ecoqjdmad¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd.#¬ Kv¬ k¬ wdvtj}¬ oh¬ }inv¬ }id¬ vk d¬ wdanoc¬ `k~¬ dy|dwndcfd¬
focvnmdwkgjd¬ jofe“nc¬ nc¬ dv}kgjnvidm¬ }dficojoandv¬ kv¬ }id¬ ecoqjdmad¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd¬ cddmdm¬ how¬
}dficojoanfkj¬wdcdqkj¬nv¬ jkfenca#¬]inv¬`k~¬kjvo¬gd¬fot|jdm¬qn}i¬kc¬djd`dc}¬oh¬hwka`dc}k}noc¬nh¬}id¬fjtv}dw¬nv¬mnxnmdm¬nc}o¬vtg“awot|v¬oh¬kf}owv¬}ik}¬gdjoca¬}o¬}id¬vk`d¬ncmtv}w~¬ow¬vdf}ow¬gt}¬
gd}qddc¬qinfi¬nc}dwkf}noc¬kcm¬dyfikcad¬nv¬jn`n}dm¬how¬v}wtf}twkj¬kcm/ow¬inv}ownfkj¬wdkvocv#¬¬
¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 10/35
9¬
¬
6#7 Htcf}nocv¬V|dfnh~nca¬}id¬tcmdwj~nca¬|wogjd`v¬}o¬gd¬kmmwdvvdm¬kcm¬ioq¬}id~¬wdjk}d¬}o¬}id¬ htcf}nockj¬kcm¬
v}wtf}twkj¬mn`dcvnocv¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`¬nv¬cdfdvvkw~¬nc¬owmdw¬}o¬tcmdwv}kcm¬qinfi¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬}o¬
gd¬|dwhow`dm¬g~¬|ojnf~#¬\wnow¬ }o¬mdvnacnca¬ }id¬v|dfnhnf¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ioqdxdw*¬}idwd¬ nv¬k¬ cddm¬}o¬
dy|jnfk}d¬}id¬htcf}nocv¬}ik}¬}idvd¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬}o¬hnjj# ¬Nc¬}id¬jn}dwk}twd¬oc¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬kc¬
dxojxnca¬ |kwkmna`*¬ |kw}nftjkwj~¬ qn}inc¬ }id¬ }dficojoanfkj¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v¬ )]NV.¬ vfiooj¬ oh¬}iotai}*¬nv¬{tdv}nocnca¬}id¬xkjtd¬oh¬htw}idw¬kckj~vdv¬oh¬}id¬v}wtf}twd¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬)Jnt¬
kcm¬Qin}d¬7<<;.#¬N}¬nv¬kwatdm¬}ik}¬}id¬hoftv¬cddmv¬}o¬gd¬oc¬ed~¬htcf}nocv¬)|wofdvvdv.¬}ik}¬`ked¬
}id¬v~v}d`¬|dwhow`nca¬qdjj¬)Ideedw}¬d}¬kj#¬7<<1.#¬K}¬}id¬`ov}¬adcdwkj¬jdxdj¬}id¬`knc¬htcf}noc¬oh¬
kc¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬nv¬}o¬|twvtd¬}id¬fwdk}noc¬oh¬nccoxk}nocv¬)Dm{tnv}¬7<<4.#¬Ioqdxdw*¬}o¬gd¬
tvdhtj¬ htw}idw¬ v|dfnhnfk}noc¬ oh¬ }id¬ vtg¬ htcf}nocv¬ vt||ow}nca¬ }id¬ `knc¬ htcf}noc¬oh¬ nccoxk}noc¬
v~v}d`v¬ nv¬ wd{tnwdm#¬ Boicvoc¬ kcm¬ Bkfogvvoc¬ )7<<<¬ |#;<>.¬ mdxdjo|dm¬ }id¬ focfd|}¬ oh¬ ’v~v}d`¬
htcf}nocv„¬kcm¬mdhncdm¬n}¬kv¬‚k¬foc}wngt}noc¬oh¬k¬vncajd¬fo`|ocdc}¬ow¬k¬vd}¬oh¬fo`|ocdc}v¬}o¬k¬
v~v}d „v¬ |dwhow`kcfd‐#¬ ]id~¬ kwatd¬ }ik}¬ kc¬ NV¬ fkc¬ hwtn}htjj~¬ gd¬ kckj~vdm¬ nc¬ }dw`v¬ oh¬ n}v¬
’htcf}nockj¬ |k}}dwc„*¬ n#d#¬ ioq¬ }idvd¬ htcf}nocv¬ ikxd¬ gddc¬ vdwxdm¬ )vdd¬ kjvo¬ Ideedw}¬ kcm¬ Cdawo¬
7<<>5¬ Cdawo¬ d}¬ kj#¬ 7<<1.#¬ Qn}inc¬ }id¬ jn}dwk}twd¬ hoftvnca¬oc¬ }id¬ htcf}nockj¬ kckj~vnv¬ oh¬ NVv*¬ k¬
ct`gdw¬oh¬ htcf}nocv¬ikv¬gddc¬nmdc}nhndm¬)vdd¬Fikw`nckmd¬kcm¬Dm{tnv}¬7<<8¬kcm5¬@kwekwm¬kcm¬]wthhdw¬7<<9¬how¬oxdwxndqv.#¬
Nc¬}inv¬|k|dw¬qd¬gtnjm¬oc¬}id¬ncxdc}owndv¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬htcf}nocv¬g~¬Gdweade¬d}¬kj#¬kcm¬
Ideedw}¬d}¬kj#¬)Gdwade¬d}¬kj#¬7<<9k5¬Gdwade¬d}¬kj#¬7<<9g5¬Ideedw}¬kcm¬Cdawo¬7<<>5¬Ideedw}¬d}¬kj#¬
7<<1.#¬]idvd¬kt}iowv¬nmdc}nh~¬k¬ct`gdw¬oh¬htcf}nocv¬}o¬gd¬|dwhow`dm¬g~¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`2¬
Ecoqjdmad¬ mdxdjo|`dc}¬ kcm¬ mnhhtvnoc*¬ Dc}wd|wdcdtwnkj¬ dy|dwn dc}k}noc*¬ Nchjtdcfd¬ oc¬ }id¬
mnwdf}noc¬oh¬vdkwfi*¬@kwed}¬how`k}noc*¬Jdan}n`k}noc*¬Wdvotwfd¬`ognjnrk}noc*¬kcm¬Mdxdjo|`dc}¬oh¬
|ovn}nxd¬ dy}dwckjn}ndv/v~cdwandv#¬ Qinjd¬ }idvd¬ qdwd¬ ownanckjj~¬ mdxdjo|dm¬ how¬ }dficojoanfkj¬
nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v*¬}id~¬kjvo¬|onc}¬}o¬ed~¬htcf}nocv¬oh¬ vdf}owkj¬vtgvd}v¬oh¬wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬
v~v}d`v#¬]kgjd¬7¬mdvfwngdv¬}id¬ed~¬htcf}nocv¬oh¬WNV¬kv¬kmo|}dm¬nc¬}inv¬|k|dw#¬¬
¬
]kgjd¬72¬Htcf}nocv¬oh¬}dficojoanfkj¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬)kmk|}dm¬gkvdm¬oc¬Gdwade¬d}¬kj#¬7<<9g5¬Ideedw}¬d}¬kj#¬7<<1.¬
Nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬
htcf}nocv¬¬Mdvfwn|}noc¬oh ¬htcf}noc¬ Dyk`|jdv¬oh ¬ed~¬ot}|t} ¬oh ¬
htcf}noc¬
Ecoqjdmad¬mdxdjo|`dc} ¬kcm¬
mnhhtvnoc¬
Fwdk}noc¬oh¬ecoqjdmad¬kcm¬hkfnjn}k}noc¬oh¬nchow`k}noc¬kcm¬ecoqjdmad¬dyfikcad#¬¬¬
Vfndc}nhnf*¬}dficojoanfkj*¬kcm¬`kwed}¬ecoqjdmad#¬Gtnj}¬kcm¬mnvvd`nck}dm¬}iwotai¬W(M*¬
jdkwcnca¬hwo`¬cdq¬k||jnfk}nocv*¬n`n}k}noc¬d}f#¬¬
Dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|¬ Fwdk}noc¬oh¬cdq¬gtvncdvvdv¬
¬Ncmnwdf}j~2¬dy|dwn`dc}nca¬qn}i¬cdq¬|womtf}v*¬
nmdc}nh~nca¬kcm¬}dv}nca¬cdq¬`kwed}v¬kcm¬o||ow}tcn}ndv¬d}f#¬¬
Gtvncdvv¬fwdk}noc¬
V~v}d`¬nchwkv}wtf}twd¬fwdk}noc¬
]id¬mdxdjo|`dc}¬kcm¬`knc}dckcfd¬oh¬}id¬nchwkv}wtf}twd¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`¬
\i~vnfkj¬nchwkv}wtf}twd*¬d#a#¬|womtf}noc¬|jkc}v*¬dmtfk}nockj¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬d}f#¬¬Coc“|i~vnfkj¬nchwkv}wtf}twd¬*¬d#a#¬dmtfk}nockj¬ncv}n}t}dv#¬
Wdvotwfd¬`ognjnrk}noc¬ K}}wkf}nca¬kcm¬gtnjmnca¬wdvotwfdv¬)it`kc*¬hnckcfnkj*¬fo`|jd`dc}kw~¬d}f#.¬wdjdxkc}¬}o¬}id¬WNV#¬¬¬
Jkgotw¬`kwed}v¬)venjjdm¬|do|jd.5¬hnckcfnkj¬fk|n}kj¬)d#a#¬xdc}twd¬fk|n}kj.5¬fo`|jd`dc}kw~¬kvvd}v¬)d#a#¬vt||ow}¬vdwxnfdv¬kcm¬
|womtf}v*¬nc|t}¬aoomv.¬¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 11/35
>¬
¬
Atnmkcfd¬oh ¬vdkwfi¬ Ncmtfd¬kf}owv¬}o¬dc}dw¬}id¬WNV*¬}o¬mnwdf}¬}idnw¬
vdkwfi¬kcm¬ncxdv}`dc}v¬}oqkwmv¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Kjvo¬}o¬mnwdf}¬}id¬k}}dc}noc¬oh¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`¬}oqkwmv¬v|dfnhnf¬|wogjd`v¬kcm¬awoq}i¬o||ow}tcn}ndv#¬
\wogjd`¬kcm¬o||ow}tcn}~¬
nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬kcm¬atnmd¬k}}dc}noc¬oh¬WNV¬kf}owv¬}o¬kmmwdvv¬}idvd¬
@kwed} ¬nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬
kcm¬how`k}noc¬
Nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬oh¬`kwed}v¬ow¬`kwed}¬cnfidv¬kv¬qdjj¬kv¬v}n`tjk}noc¬oh¬}id¬how`k}noc¬oh¬jofkj¬`kwed}v#¬¬
Gtvncdvv¬o||ow}tcn}ndv¬nmdc}nhndm¬kcm¬md`kcm¬v}n`tjk}dm/fwdk}dm¬
Jdan}n`k}noc¬ Fwdk}nca/gtnjmnca¬tcmdwv}kcmnca*¬vt||ow}¬kcm¬
jdan}n`kf~¬how¬}id¬WNV¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm¬kadcmkv¬)nc}dwckjj~¬kcm¬dy}dwckjj~.#¬
Nc}dwckjj~2¬Fwdk}nca¬foidwdcfd*¬
bonc}¬xnvnoc*¬vikwdm¬tcmdwv}kcmnca#¬Dy}dwckjj~2¬|wo`o}nca¬}id¬ncmtv}w~¬ow¬wdanockj¬kadcmk*¬jogg~nca¬d}f#¬
Hkfnjn}k}noc/fwdk}noc¬
oh ¬v~cdwandv¬¬V}n`tjk}d¬nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬kcm¬t}njnrk}noc¬oh¬
v~cdwandv¬qn}inc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Ncmnfk}dv¬}id¬m~ck`nfv¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`¬vncfd¬dy}dwckjn}ndv¬`kacnh~¬}id¬v}wdca}i¬oh¬}id¬o}idw¬htcf}nocv#¬
Fojjkgowk}noc¬kcm¬bonc}¬|wobdf}v¬
)d#a#¬bonc}¬|womtf}¬mdxdjo|`dc}*¬|wofdvvnca*¬W(M*¬jogg~nca*¬wdvotwfd¬mdxdjo|`dc}¬d}f#.¬¬
¬
]idvd¬htcf}nocv¬oh¬WNVv¬viotjm¬gd¬vddc¬kv¬qk~v¬}o¬kmmwdvv¬}id¬|wogjd v¬mnvftvvdm¬dkwjndw#¬Nc¬k¬
wdanoc¬ dy|dwndcfnca¬ cdak}nxd¬ jofe“nc¬ }dcmdcfndv¬ nc}o¬ dynv}nca¬ }dficojoandv¬ ecoqjdmad¬
mdxdjo|`dc}¬ kcm¬ mnhhtvnoc¬ kcm¬ dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|¬ wd|wdvdc}¬ htcf}nocv¬ }ik}¬ `k~¬ wdmtfd¬ vtfi¬
jofe“nc¬}dcmdcfndv#¬Vn`njkwj~*¬jofe“nc¬nc}o¬v|dfnhnf¬`kwed}v/vda`dc}v¬ow¬qk~v¬}o¬kmmwdvv¬`kwed}v¬
fkc¬ gd¬ kmmwdvvdm¬ g~¬ qk~¬ oh¬ `kwed}¬ nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬ kcm¬ how`k}noc¬ kcm/ow¬ dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|#¬
Qinjd¬ idj|htj*¬ v|dfnh~nca¬ }idvd¬ htcf}nocv¬ nv¬ ioqdxdw¬ co}¬ dcotai#¬ \ojnf~¬ kf}owv¬ cddm¬ kjvo¬ }o¬
mdxdjo|¬focfwd}d¬kf}nxn}ndv¬}o¬|dwhow`¬ow¬|wo`o}d¬}id`#¬¬
¬
6#6¬ Kf}nxn}ndv¬
Gkvdm¬oc¬kc¬tcmdwv}kcmnca¬oh¬ed~¬|wogjd`v¬kcm¬qinfi¬v~v}d`¬htcf}nocv¬}ik}¬kmmwdvv¬}idvd*¬n}¬nv¬
coq¬|ovvngjd¬}o¬nmdc}nh~¬v|dfnhnf¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬}ik}¬fkc¬|dwhow`¬ow¬|wo`o}d¬}idvd¬htcf}nocv#¬N}¬
nv¬qnmdj~¬kfecoqjdmadm¬}ik}¬vtffdvvhtj¬nccoxk}noc¬md|dcmv¬co}¬ocj~¬oc¬}id¬hnw`„v¬oqc¬v}wk}da~¬
gt}¬kjvo¬oc¬kf}nxn}ndv¬|dwhow`dm¬g~¬o}idw¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬)Foidc¬kcm¬Jdxnc}ikj¬
;>><5¬V|dcfdw¬7<<6.#¬]idvd¬kf}nxn}ndv¬fkc¬gd¬tcmdwv}oom¬kv¬‚|ojnf~¬}oojv‐¬k}¬}id¬`ov}¬focfwd}d¬
jdxdj#¬Qn}inc¬k¬anxdc¬WNV*¬k¬`tj}n}tmd¬oh¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬fkwwndm¬ot}¬oxdw¬xkw~nca¬}n`d¬iownrocv#¬
V|dfnhnfkjj~*¬`kc~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬vtfi¬kv¬kwwkcanca¬`dd}ncav*¬fotwvdv*¬jogg~nca¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬kcm¬vd}}nca¬
t|¬cdq¬ v~v}d ¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd¬ ncxojxd¬ k¬ jn n}dm¬ ct`gdw¬ oh¬ kf}owv¬ kcm¬ kwd¬ |dwhow dm¬ oxdw¬ k¬
jn n}dm¬ }n d#¬ K}¬ }id¬ vk d¬ }n d¬ }id¬ kn ¬ oh¬ }idvd¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ kwd¬ kjnacdm¬ qn}i¬ `owd¬ joca¬ }dw ¬
htcf}nocv¬ }ik}¬ ncfjtmd¬ `kc~¬ kf}owv¬ nc¬ }id¬ v~v}d #¬ Vn`|j~¬ |t}*¬ kc~¬ htcf}noc¬oh¬ }id¬ v~v}d ¬ nv¬
kfindxdm¬}iwotai¬}id¬|dwhow`kcfd¬oh¬k¬ct`gdw¬oh¬focfwd}d¬kf}nxn}ndv¬oxdw¬}n`d¬)kcm¬ocd¬kf}nxn}~¬
`k~¬foc}wngt}d¬}o¬}id¬|dwhow`kcfd¬oh¬vdxdwkj¬v~v}d`¬htcf}nocv.¬)@kwekwm¬kcm¬]wthhdw¬7<<9.#¬
How¬dyk`|jd*¬ncmtv}w~“kfkmd`nk¬vd`nckwv¬ow¬gwdkehkv}¬`dd}ncav¬`k~¬foc}wngt}d¬}o¬ecoqjdmad¬
mnhhtvnoc*¬ dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|*¬ kcm¬ fwdk}nca¬ v~cdwandv¬ qn}inc¬ }id¬ v~v}d #¬ ]id¬ htcf}noc¬ nc¬ }twc¬
viotjm¬kmmwdvv¬ocd¬ow¬`owd¬oh¬}id¬tcmdwj~nca¬|wogjd`v¬oh¬}id¬WNV#¬]id¬indwkwfi~¬oh¬kf}nxn}ndv“
htcf}nocv“|wogjd`v¬nv¬}itv¬k¬fdc}wkj¬kxdctd¬how¬foowmnck}noc¬kcm¬}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬fkc¬gd¬vddc¬kv¬
}id¬ joqdw“jdxdj¬ md}dw nckc}v¬ oh¬ }id¬ htcf}nockj¬ mn`dcvnoc¬ oh¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v¬ )fh#¬ Dm{tnv}¬
7<<4.#¬
Kc¬n`|ow}kc}¬kv|df}¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`nf¬k||wokfi¬}o¬nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬nv¬}ik}¬}idvd¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬co}¬
|dwhow`dm¬ dyfjtvnxdj~¬g~¬|ojnf~`kedwv#¬ NV¬ |ojnf~¬ nv¬ wk}idw¬ fkwwndm¬ ot}¬ fojjdf}nxdj~¬ g~¬kf}owv¬
hwo`¬ }id¬ ecoqjdmad¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd¬ )d#a#¬ wdvdkwfidwv¬ hwo`¬ jofkj¬ tcnxdwvn}ndv¬ |kw}nfn|k}nca¬ nc¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 12/35
;<¬
¬
ecoqjdmad¬mnhhtvnoc¬ow¬wdvotwfd¬`ognjnrk}noc¬kf}nxn}ndv.*¬}id¬|womtf}noc¬v}wtf}twd¬)d#a#¬v}kw}“t|¬
hnw`v¬foc}wngt}nca¬}o¬dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|¬ow¬`kwed}¬nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬kcm¬how`k}noc.*¬kcm¬}id¬vt||ow}¬
v}wtf}twd¬)d#a#¬|tgjnf¬gomndv¬}ik}¬owakcnvd¬nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬ncn}nk}nxdv¬}o¬hkfnjn}k}d¬v~cdwandv¬ow¬
jdan}n`k}noc.#¬¬Ikxnca¬vknm¬}inv*¬}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬}~|nfkjj~¬ncn}nk}dm¬kcm¬foowmnck}dm¬g~¬mnhhdwdc}¬
}~|dv¬ oh¬ |ojnf~¬ kf}owv¬ )|tgjnf¬ kf}owv*¬ ncmtv}w~¬ owakcnvk}nocv*¬ kcm¬ dxdc¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d ¬
cd}qowev¬d}f#.#¬ ]id¬ jn}dwk}twd¬oc¬gtvncdvv¬mdxdjo|`dc}¬ kcm¬ nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬ nv¬ oh}dc¬ xkatd¬
qidc¬n}¬fo`dv¬}o¬v|dfnh~nca¬}id¬|wdfnvd¬kf}nxn}ndv¬}ik}¬fkc¬gd¬tcmdw}kedc¬}o¬v}n`tjk}d¬fikcad¬nc¬
k¬|kw}nftjkw¬mnwdf}noc¬)Gowwëv¬kcm¬]vkamnv¬7<<9.#¬Ocd¬wdkvoc¬how¬}inv¬nv¬}ik}¬kf}nxn}ndv¬fkc¬gd¬oh¬
`kc~¬ }~|dv¬ kcm¬ mnhhdw¬ focvnmdwkgj~¬ gd}qddc¬ v~v}d`v#¬ Vncfd¬ |ojnf~¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ kwd¬ v|dfnhnf¬ nc¬
ck}twd*¬ }id~¬ kwd¬ oh}dc¬mdvnacdm¬}o¬kmmwdvv¬ }id¬ focfdwcv¬oh¬k¬ v|dfnhnf¬fjkvv¬oh¬kf}owv*¬ oh}dc¬k¬
v|dfnhnf¬vdf}ow¬ow¬ncmtv}w~#¬Htw}idw`owd*¬k¬vdf}owkj¬|dwv|df}nxd¬nv¬oh}dc¬cdfdvvkw~¬kv¬k¬gkvnv¬oc¬
qinfi¬}id¬v~v}d`v¬htcf}nocv¬kcm¬v|dfnhnf¬|wogjd`v¬fkc¬gd¬dxkjtk}dm#¬¬
NV¬ |ojnf~¬ }itv¬ }~|nfkjj~¬ ncxojxdv¬ k¬ `tj}n}tmd¬ oh¬ kf}ow“hoftvdm¬ kcm¬ v~v}d “hoftvdm¬ kf}nxn}ndv#¬
Kf}ow“hoftvdm¬ |ojnf~¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ ncfjtmd¬ vtgvnmndv¬ how¬ wdvdkwfi*¬ kjjofk}noc¬ oh¬ xdc}twd¬ fk|n}kj*¬
kmxnfd¬kcm¬venjjv¬mdxdjo|`dc}*¬ncftgk}ow¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm¬dmtfk}noc¬kcm¬}wkncnca#¬V~v}d`“hoftvdm¬
kf}nxn}ndv¬ ncfjtmd¬ vtgvnmndv¬ how¬ wdvdkwfi¬ fojjkgowk}noc*¬ vtgvnmndv¬ how¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd*¬ cd}qowe¬
fwdk}noc/`k}fi`kenca*¬ jogg~nca*¬ `kwed}nca/|wohnjnca¬ d}f#¬ Adcdwkjj~*¬ d`|ikvnv¬ nv¬ `owd¬ oc¬gdikxnotwkj¬kmmn}nockjn}~¬‖¬n#d#¬|dwvnv}dc}¬fikcadv¬nc¬}id¬gdikxnotw¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`¬kf}owv¬mtd¬}o¬
}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬|dwhow`dm¬)Gtnvvdwd}¬d}¬kj#¬;>>45¬Hkje¬7<<15¬Adowainot¬kcm¬Wodvvcdw¬7<<<.¬‖¬}ikc¬
oc¬ wdvotwfd¬ )wd.kjjofk}noc#¬ Gdikxnotwkj¬ kmmn}nockjn}~¬ hoftvdv¬ dy|jnfn}j~¬ oc¬ jdkwcnca¬ kcm¬
ecoqjdmad¬v|njjoxdwv¬}ik}¬wdvtj}*¬go}i¬mnwdf}j~¬kcm¬ncmnwdf}j~*¬hwo`¬nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬)Fjkw~vvd¬
d}¬kj#¬7<<>.#¬
¬
6#=¬ Kf}owv¬kcm ¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬
K}}dc}noc¬ coq¬ }twcv¬ }o¬ }id¬ v}wtf}twkj¬ mn`dcvnoc¬ oh¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v*¬ n#d#¬ }id¬ kf}owv¬ kcm¬
ncv}n}t}nocv¬ fo`|wnvnca¬ }id¬ v~v}d #¬ ]o¬ htw}idw¬ mdxdjo|¬ }id¬ v}wtf}twkj¬ mn dcvnoc¬ }itv¬ hkw¬mnvftvvdm¬nc¬}dw`v¬oh¬ecoqjdmad¬nchwkv}wtf}twd*¬vt||ow}¬v}wtf}twd*¬kcm¬|womtf}noc¬v}wtf}twd*¬k¬
htw}idw¬mnv}ncf}noc¬fkc¬ gd¬`kmd¬gkvdm¬oc¬}id¬ fdc}wkjn}~¬oh¬ }id¬ kf}owv¬ nc¬ }id¬ v~v}d #¬ Jnt¬ kcm¬
Qin}d¬ )7<<;.¬mnv}ncatnvi¬gd}qddc¬|wn`kw~¬kf}owv*¬vdfocmkw~¬kf}owv*¬kcm¬ncv}n}t}nocv#¬\wn`kw~ ¬
kf}owv¬kwd¬}iovd¬|dwhow`nca¬htcmk`dc}kj¬NV¬htcf}nocv;#¬Vdfocmkw~ ¬kf}owv¬kwd¬owakcnrk}nocv¬}ik}¬
khhdf}¬}id¬gdikxnotw¬oh¬ow¬nc}dwkf}noc¬gd}qddc¬|wn`kw~¬kf}owv¬)Jnt¬kcm¬Qin}d¬7<<;.#¬Vdfocmkw~¬
kf}owv¬ `k~¬ kf}¬ mnwdf}j~ *¬ d#a#¬ qidc¬ |tgjnf¬ gomndv¬ dv}kgjnvi¬ |ojnfndv¬ kcm¬ `ked¬ mdfnvnocv¬ kgot}¬
vtv}knckgnjn}~¬nc¬}id¬|tgjnf¬idkj}i¬fkwd¬v~v}d`¬n}¬khhdf}v¬}id¬qk~¬iov|n}kjv¬|twfikvd¬|womtf}v¬kcm¬
vdwxnfdv#¬Kj}dwck}nxdj~*¬vdfocmkw~¬kf}owv¬`k~¬kf}¬ ncmnwdf}j~ ¬}iwotai¬}id¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬}id~¬fwdk}d¬
kcm¬nchjtdcfd#¬G~¬how¬dyk`|jd¬ncv}n}t}nca¬fikcadv¬nc¬}id¬}ky¬v~v}d`*¬vdfocmkw~¬kf}owv¬ncmnwdf}j~¬
foc}wngt}d¬ }o¬ vd}}nca¬ t|¬ kc¬ ncv}n}t}nockj¬ v~v}d ¬ }ik}¬ wdqkwm¬ ow¬ mnvfotwkad¬ fdw}knc¬ }~|dv¬ oh¬
gdikxnotw#¬]id¬nc}dwwdjk}dmcdvv¬gd}qddc¬vdfocmkw~¬kf}owv¬kcm¬}id¬ncv}n}t}nockj¬vd}}nca¬oh¬}id¬NV¬
`k~¬}itv¬gd¬focvnmdwkgjd#¬¬
¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬¬
;¬Jnt¬kcm¬Qin}d¬)7<<;.¬tvd¬}id¬}dw`¬’htcmk`dc}kj ¬kf}nxn}ndv„¬oh ¬kc¬NV#¬]o¬kxonm¬fochtvnoc¬qn}i¬otw¬tvd¬oh ¬}id¬
focfd|}¬’kf}nxn}ndv„¬qd¬k||j~¬}id¬}dw`¬’htcf}nocv„¬idwd¬}o¬ncmnfk}d¬}id¬`owd¬adcdwnf¬ck}twd¬oh ¬Jnt¬kcm¬Qin}d„v¬’kf}nxn}ndv„#¬Jnt¬kcm¬Qin}d„v¬fjkvvnhnfk}noc¬mnhhdwv¬hwo`¬}ik}¬|wdvdc}dm¬dkwjndw¬kv¬}idnw¬htcmk`dc}kj¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬
wdvdkwfi*¬n`|jd`dc}k}noc*¬dcm¬tvd*¬jncekad*¬kcm¬dmtfk}noc#¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 13/35
;;¬
¬
Ncv}n}t}nocv¬wdhdw¬}o¬}id¬vd}v¬oh¬fo``oc¬cow`v*¬|wkf}nfdv*¬wtjdv¬ow¬jkqv¬}ik}¬atnmd¬kcm¬focv}wknc¬
}id¬ gdikxnotw¬ oh¬ }id¬ kf}owv¬ )Dm{tnv}¬ 7<<45¬ Jnt¬ kcm¬ Qin}d¬ 7<<;.#¬ Ncv}n}t}nocv¬ kwd¬ }itv¬
mnvd`gomndm¬owakcnrk}nocv¬}ik}¬kwd¬fwdk}dm*¬wdnhndm*¬kcm¬nchjtdcfdm¬g~¬}id¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬
Ow¬kv¬|t}¬g~¬Cow}i¬);>>7¬|#;<.*¬‚Nh¬ncv}n}t}nocv¬kwd¬}id¬wtjdv¬oh¬}id¬ak`d*¬owakcnrk}nocv¬kwd¬}id¬
|jk~dwv‐#¬ Ncv}n}t}nocv¬ fkc¬ gd¬ focfd|}tkjnrdm¬ nc¬ }dw`v¬ oh¬ how`kj¬ wtjdv¬ )d#a#¬ jdanvjk}nocv.¬ kcm¬
nchow`kj¬ focv}wknc}v¬ )d#a#¬ cow v¬ kcm¬ focxdc}nocv.¬ )Cow}i¬ ;>>7.#¬ Qnjjnk`voc¬ )7<<<.¬
n`|ow}kc}j~¬co}dv¬ }ik}¬ nchow kj¬ focv}wknc}v/ncv}n}t}nocv¬ )qik}¬id¬ }dw`v¬ Jdxdj¬;¬ ncv}n}t}nocv.¬
|nxo}¬oc¬|wofdvvdv¬oh¬d`gdmmdmcdvv¬kcm¬dcftj}twk}noc¬}ik}¬ikxd¬`kncj~¬v|oc}kcdotv¬ownancv¬
)Awkcoxd}}dw¬;>94.#¬]inv¬`kedv¬}id`¬wdjk}nxdj~¬jdvv¬khhdf}dm¬g~¬mdjngdwk}nxd¬fionfd¬kcm¬kf}nocv¬
}ikc¬ how`kj¬ ncv}n}t}nocv¬ )Jdxdj¬ 7¬ ncv}n}t}nocv.¬ gt}¬ kjvo¬ vtgbdf}¬ }o¬ kc¬ dxdc¬ inaidw¬ mdawdd¬ oh¬
ncdw}nk#¬Nc¬}id¬fkvd¬oh¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬kcm¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬}id¬how`kj¬mn`dcvnoc¬nv¬fjdkwj~¬
wdjdxkc}¬ nc¬ }dw`v¬ oh¬ ck}nockj¬ jdanvjk}noc¬ kcm¬ wdatjk}nocv¬ kv¬ qdjj¬ kv¬ ncmtv}w~¬ v}kcmkwmv*¬
mdhncn}nocv¬ kcm¬ atnmdjncdv¬ how¬ ioq¬ vdf}owv¬ kwd¬ mdhncdm¬ )how¬ dyk`|jd¬ }id¬ nchjtdc}nkj¬ D]K\¬
mdhncn}noc¬ oh¬ }id¬ fjdkc“}dfi¬ vdf}ow.#¬ Nchow`kj¬ ncv}n}t}nocv¬ kwd¬ ioqdxdw¬ d{tkjj~¬ n`|ow}kc}¬ how¬
tcmdwv}kcmnca¬}id¬qk~¬ NVv¬qowe¬kcm¬}id¬mdawdd¬}o¬qinfi¬ n}¬fkc¬gd¬ nchjtdcfdm¬g~¬|ojnf~¬kf}noc#¬ Nc¬
]kgjd¬6¬Jnt¬kcm¬Qin}d„v¬}~|ojoa~¬nv¬njjtv}wk}dm¬qn}i¬vo`d¬dyk`|jdv¬oh¬kf}ow¬}~|dv#¬¬
]kgjd¬62
¬Dyk`|jdv
¬oh
¬kf}owv
¬kcm
¬ncv}n}t}nocv
¬ncxojxdm
¬nc
¬kcm
¬nchjtdcfnca
¬wdanockj
¬nccoxk}noc
¬v~v}d`v#
¬
\wn`kw~¬kf}owv¬¬
Vdfocmkw~¬kf}owv Ncv}n}t}nocv
\dwhow`¬htcmk`dc}kj¬NV¬htcf}nocv¬¬¬
Khhdf}¬}id¬gdikxnotw¬oh ¬ow¬nc}dwkf}noc¬
gd}qddc¬|wn`kw~¬kf}owv¬]id¬vd}¬oh ¬wtjdv¬kcm¬|wkf}nfdv¬}ik}¬atnmd¬
kcm¬focv}wknc¬}id¬gdikxnotw¬oh ¬}id¬kf}owv¬
Kf}owv¬ Htcf}nocv¬ Kf}owv Wojd¬
Hnw`v¬¬¬
¬
¬
¬
¬
¬
Dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|*¬V~v}d`¬
nchwkv}wtf}twd¬
fwdk}noc¬
¬
¬
\tgjnf¬gomndv¬)d#a#¬Wdanockj¬kt}iown}~.¬¬
Nchjtdcfd¬}id¬
gdikxnotw¬oh ¬kcm¬¬
nc}dwkf}noc¬gd}qddc¬
|wn`kw~¬kf}owv¬¬
Jkqv¬kcm¬wdatjk}nocv¬¬¬
V}kcmkwmv¬kcm¬atnmdjncdv¬¬¬¬
Gtvncdvv¬|wkf}nfdv¬¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬
md|kw}`dc}v¬¬
¬
¬
Ecoqjdmad¬
mdxdjo|`dc}¬kcm¬
mnhhtvnoc¬
¬
Ck}nockj¬aoxdwc`dc}¬
¬
Nchjtdcfd¬v~v}d`¬
kcm¬}id¬kf}owv¬
¬
Cow`v¬kcm¬focxdf}nocv¬
\ojnf~¬kf}ow¬ Jdan}n`k}noc*¬Fwdk}noc¬oh ¬v~cdwandv¬¬
Ck}nockj¬kcm¬
wdanockj¬gomndv*¬CAOv¬kcm¬o}idw¬owakcnrk}nocv¬¬
Nchjtdcfd¬}id¬
v~v}d`¬kcm¬}id¬
kf}owv¬
¬
]id¬kmxkc}kad¬oh¬ k||j~nca¬}id¬|wn`kw~/vdfocmkw~¬kf}ow¬ fk}daowndv¬ nv¬ }ik}¬}id~¬njjtv}wk}d¬ }id¬
mnhhdwdc}¬ wojdv¬ }kedc¬ g~¬ NV¬ kf}owv¬ nc¬ mnhhdwdc}¬ vn}tk}nocv¬ kcm¬ nc¬ mnhhdwdc}¬ foc}dy}v#¬ ]id¬
|wn`kw~/vdfocmkw~¬mnv}ncf}noc¬nv¬co}¬k¬v}kgjd¬mnfio}o`~2¬n#d#¬kc¬kf}ow¬nv¬co}¬ncidwdc}j~¬|wn`kw~¬
ow¬ vdfocmkw~#¬ ]inv¬ gdfo`dv¬ k||kwdc}¬ qidc¬ wdjk}nca¬ }idvd¬ wojdv¬ }o¬ }id¬ htcf}nocv¬ mnvftvvdm¬
dkwjndw#¬Nc¬wdjk}noc¬}o¬ecoqjdmad¬mdxdjo|`dc}*¬k¬tcnxdwvn}~¬`k~¬gd¬k¬|wn`kw~¬kf}ow¬kv¬n}¬fkwwndv¬
ot}¬kf}nxn}ndv¬fdc}wkj¬}o¬}inv¬htcf}noc#¬Hnw`v¬kcm¬|ojnf~¬`kedwv¬nchjtdcfd¬}id¬gdikxnotw¬oh¬}id¬|wn kw~¬ kf}owv¬ kcm¬ }id¬ qk~¬ }id~¬ nc}dwkf}¬qn}i¬ o}idw¬kf}owv5¬ }id~¬ kwd¬ }itv¬ vdfocmkw~¬ kf}owv#¬
Qidc¬n}¬fo`dv¬}o¬}id¬fwdk}noc¬oh¬v~v}d`¬nchwkv}wtf}twd¬)d#a#¬nc¬}dw`v¬oh¬|jkc}v*¬fo``tcnfk}noc¬
kcm¬mnv}wngt}noc¬fikccdjv¬d}f#.¬tcnxdwvn}ndv¬`k~¬ikxd¬}id¬wojd¬kv¬vdfocmkw~¬kf}ow#¬Nc¬}iovd¬fkvdv¬
aoxdwc`dc}¬kcm¬hnw`v¬`ked¬ot}¬|wn`kw~¬kf}owv¬kv¬}id~¬kwd¬}id¬ocdv¬fkww~nca¬ot}¬}id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬
)gtnjmnca¬ cdq¬ |wofdvvnca¬ |jkc}v¬ ow¬ wokmv.#¬ ]id¬ jofk}noc¬ oh¬ kcm¬ }id¬ kf}nocv¬ }kedc¬ g~¬ jofkj¬
tcnxdwvn}ndv¬fkc¬ioqdxdw¬vnacnhnfkc}j~¬nchjtdcfd¬}id¬qk~¬nc¬qinfi¬}id¬kf}nxn}~¬nv¬fkwwndm¬ot}#¬¬
¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 14/35
;7¬
¬
=# Wdvdkwfi¬mdvnac¬kcm¬`d}iom¬
]id¬ d`|nwnfkj¬ v}tm~¬ nc¬ qinfi¬ }id¬ kckj~}nfkj¬ hwk`dqowe¬ ot}jncdm¬ kgoxd¬ qkv¬ mdxdjo|dm¬ kcm¬
k||jndm¬nv¬gkvdm¬oc¬}wnkcatjk}noc¬oh¬mnhhdwdc}¬`d}iomv¬kcm¬mk}k¬votwfdv#¬K¬`knc¬nc|t}¬ikv¬gddc¬
nc“md|}i¬ nc}dwxndqv¬ qn}i¬ xkwnotv¬ }~|dv¬ oh¬ v}kediojmdwv¬ nc¬ }id¬ v~v}d ¬ tcmdw¬ v}tm~#¬ Vtfi¬
v}kediojmdwv¬kwd¬hnw`v*¬tcnxdwvn}ndv¬kcm¬|tgjnf¬vdf}ow¬owakcnrk}nocv¬)n#d#¬ wd|wdvdc}nca¬kjj¬ }iwdd¬
|kw}v¬ oh¬ }id¬ v~v}d *¬ hnjjnca¬ }id¬ wojdv¬ oh¬ go}i¬ |wn kw~¬ kcm¬ vdfocmkw~¬ kf}owv.#¬ Nc¬ kmmn}noc¬ }o¬wdanockjj~“gkvdm¬ v}kediojmdwv*¬ nc}dwxndqv¬ qdwd¬ kjvo¬ focmtf}dm¬ qn}i¬ coc“wdanockj¬ kf}owv¬
foc}wngt}nca¬}o¬|woxnmnca¬hwk`dqowe¬focmn}nocv¬}o¬}id¬wdanockj¬v~v}d`#¬XNCCOXK*¬}id¬Vqdmnvi¬
Aoxdwc`dc}kj¬ Kadcf~¬ how¬ Nccoxk}noc¬ V~v}d`v*¬ nv¬ kc¬ dyk`|jd¬ oh¬ vtfi¬ kf}owv#¬ ]id¬ nc}dwxndqv¬
qdwd¬ mdvnacdm¬ kv¬ vd n“v}wtf}twdm¬ mnvftvvnocv¬ wdxojxnca¬ kwotcm¬ fdw}knc¬ }id`dv¬ qinfi¬ qdwd¬
nc}womtfdm¬ }iwotai¬ {tdv}nocv¬ kjjoqnca¬ how¬ o|dc¬ dcmdm¬ kcvqdwv¬ kcm¬ djkgowk}nocv#¬ 7;¬ vtfi¬
nc}dwxndqv¬qdwd¬focmtf}dm¬mtwnca¬}id¬fotwvd¬oh¬}id¬wdvdkwfi¬|wobdf}#¬¬
Nc¬ kmmn}noc¬ }o¬ }iovd¬ nc}dwxndqv*¬ }id¬ wdvdkwfidwv¬focmtf}dm¬ |kw}nfn|kc}¬ ogvdwxk}nocv¬ nc¬ hoftv¬
awot|¬`dd}ncav¬qn}i¬foowmnck}owv¬oh¬wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬vt||ow}¬ncn}nk}nxdv*¬go}i¬oc¬k¬wdanockj*¬
ck}nockj¬ kcm¬ nc}dwck}nockj¬ jdxdj#¬ ]idvd¬ `dd}ncav¬ akxd¬ }id¬ wdvdkwfidwv¬ kffdvv¬ }o¬ hnwv}“ikcm¬
nchow k}noc¬ oh¬ focfwd}d¬|wogjd`v¬ hkfnca¬ |ojnf~¬ foowmnck}noc¬ nc¬ wdkj¬}n`d#¬ ]dc¬vtfi¬`dd}ncav¬qdwd¬idjm¬mtwnca¬}id¬fotwvd¬oh¬}id¬wdvdkwfi¬|wobdf}#¬]id¬}inwm¬`knc¬votwfd¬oh¬mk}k¬nv¬gkvdm¬oc¬
wdxndqv¬ oh¬ |wdxnotv¬ v}tmndv*¬ |tgjnf¬ wd|ow}v¬ kcm¬ qdgvn}dv¬ foccdf}dm¬ }o¬ mnhhdwdc}¬ kf}owv¬ kcm¬
kf}nxn}ndv¬ncxojxdm¬nc¬ }id¬ wdanockj¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`¬oh¬ Veäcd*¬ ncfjtmnca¬fo`|kwk}nxd¬ v}tmndv¬
kcm¬moft`dc}v¬mdkjnca¬qn}i¬o}idw¬v~v}d`v¬oc¬k¬ck}nockj¬kcm¬nc}dwck}nockj¬jdxdj#¬
Gkvdm¬ oc¬ }idvd¬ }iwdd¬ votwfdv¬ oh¬ nchow k}noc*¬ }id¬ wdvdkwfidwv¬ fo`|njdm¬ k¬ mk}k¬ vd}¬ qn}i¬
nchow k}noc¬oc¬}id¬v}wtf}twd¬oh¬ }id¬Veäcd¬wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬)n#d#¬}id¬kf}owv¬kcm¬}idnw¬
wdjk}nocv.*¬}id¬`knc¬fikjjdcadv¬kcm¬go}}jdcdfev¬incmdwnca¬}id¬v~v}d`¬kv¬k¬qiojd¬}o¬|dwhow`¬qdjj¬
nc¬ mnhhdwdc}¬ wdv|df}v¬ )}id¬ tcmdwj~nca¬ |wogjd`v.*¬ }id¬`knc¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ fkwwndm¬ ot}¬ g~¬mnhhdwdc}¬
kf}owv¬ nc¬ mnhhdwdc}¬ |kw}v¬ oh¬ }id¬ v~v}d *¬ kcm¬ }id¬ fowd¬ htcf}nocv¬ }idvd¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ qdwd¬ vd}¬ }o¬
|dwhow`¬ow¬|wo`o}d#¬]iwotaiot}¬}inv¬mk}k¬|wofdvvnca*¬}id¬wdvdkwfidwv¬`kmd¬dhhow}v¬}o¬vd|kwk}d¬
wid}ownf¬ hwo`¬ kf}tkj¬ k||dkwkcfdv*¬ }idwdg~¬ fwn}nfkjj~¬ kvvdvvnca¬ }id¬ dhhdf}v¬ )htcf}nocv.¬ oh¬ }id¬
kf}nxn}ndv¬fkwwndm¬ot}¬nc¬mnhhdwdc}¬|kw}v¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d *¬kv¬qdjj¬kv¬}id¬fo`gncdm¬dhhdf}v¬)nc}dcmdm¬
kcm¬tcnc}dcmdm.¬oc¬}id¬v~v}d`¬jdxdj¬kv¬k¬qiojd#¬
]id¬hojjoqnca¬vdf}noc¬wd|ow}v¬oc¬}id¬`knc¬wdvtj}v¬hwo`¬}idvd¬ogvdwxk}nocv*¬hojjoqdm¬g~¬k¬vdf}noc¬
kckj~vnca¬ }id`¬ }iwotai¬ }id¬ jdcv¬ oh¬ }id¬ focfd|}tkj¬ hwk`dqowe#¬ Kv¬ nc}womtf}ow~¬ v}k}dm*¬ }id¬
wdxndq¬kcm¬kckj~vnv¬ikv¬ gddc¬ jn n}dm¬ }o¬foxdw¬ }iwdd¬v|dfnhnf¬|kw}v¬oh¬}id¬ wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬
v~v}d`*¬wd|wdvdc}nca¬}iwdd¬mnhhdwdc}¬vdf}owv2¬hoom*¬`ognjd¬fo``tcnfk}nocv¬kcm¬fjdkc“}dfi#¬]id¬
`knc¬wdkvocv¬how¬hoftvnca¬oc¬}idvd¬vdf}owv¬kcm¬}id¬|ojnf~¬ncn}nk}nxdv¬vt||ow}nca¬}id`¬kwd¬|kw}j~¬
}ik}¬}id~¬wd|wdvdc}¬fkvdv¬}o¬qinfi¬k¬jkwad¬vikwd¬oh¬wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬vt||ow}¬dhhow}v¬
ikxd¬gddc¬ kjjofk}dm¬}id¬ |kv}¬mdfkmd*¬kcm¬|kw}j~¬ }ik}¬}id~¬mnhhdw¬ vtgv}kc}nkjj~¬qn}i¬wdv|df}¬}o¬
ecoqjdmad¬gkvd*¬ncmtv}w~¬v}wtf}twd*¬kcm¬`kwed}¬owndc}k}noc#¬]id¬ hoom¬vdf}ow¬nv¬ }kwad}dm¬g~¬kc¬
dv}kgjnvidm¬ wdanockj¬ |ojnf~¬ ncn}nk}nxd¬ mwkqnca¬ oc¬ inv}ownfkj¬ v}wdca}iv¬ nc¬ }wkmn}nockj¬ hoom¬
|womtf}noc*¬ ftwwdc}j~¬ hkfnca¬ fikjjdcadv¬ how¬ wdcdqkj¬ }o¬ kxonm¬ gdnca¬ jofedm“nc¬ }o¬ ogvojd}d¬
}dficojoandv#¬ ]id¬ `ognjd¬ fo``tcnfk}nocv¬ fkvd¬ ikv¬ vo`d¬ vn njkwn}ndv¬ qn}i¬ wdv|df}¬ }o¬ }id¬
ncmtv}w~¬v}wtf}twd¬)k¬ct`gdw¬oh¬jkwad¬kcfiow¬hnw`v.*¬ioqdxdw¬nc¬}dw`v¬oh¬ecoqjdmad¬gkvd¬kcm¬
`kwed}¬owndc}k}noc¬ }idwd¬ kwd¬ gna¬ mnhhdwdcfdv#¬ ]idvd¬kf}owv¬ kwd¬ jkwadj~¬ vfndcfd“gkvdm¬ kcm¬ }id¬
`kwed}¬hoftv¬nv¬tj}n`k}dj~¬ajogkj#¬]id¬fjdkc“}dfi¬fkvd¬mnv|jk~v¬mnhhdwdcfdv¬go}i¬qn}i¬wdakwm¬}o¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 15/35
;6¬
¬
ncmtv}w~¬v}wtf}twd*¬ecoqjdmad¬gkvd¬kcm¬`kwed}¬owndc}k}noc#¬]inv¬nv¬htw}idw¬}otfidm¬t|oc¬nc¬}id¬
cdy}¬fik|}dw#¬
]idwd¬kwd¬ ioqdxdw¬ kjvo¬v}woca¬oxdwjk|v¬gd}qddc¬ }idvd¬ }iwdd¬fkvdv¬ vncfd¬nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v¬
kjqk~v¬ikxd¬k¬adcdwnf¬hoftv¬oc¬}id¬dc}nwd¬wdanockj¬dfoco`~¬kcm¬vncfd¬ocj~¬hdq¬kf}owv¬)d#a#¬vo`d¬
hnw`v¬ kcm¬ v|dfnkjnrdm¬ vt||ow}¬ owakcnrk}nocv.¬ ikxd¬ k¬ |twd¬ vdf}owkj¬ hoftv¬ )kv¬ o||ovdm¬ }o¬ d#a#¬
tcnxdwvn}ndv¬ kcm¬wdanockj¬aoxdwc`dc}v.#¬]o¬mdkj¬qn}i¬}inv*¬go}i¬}id¬v}wtf}twkj¬ kcm¬htcf}nockj¬kckj~vnv¬kjjoq¬how¬}id¬vk`d¬kf}owv¬hnjjnca¬mnhhdwdc}¬wojdv¬kcm¬foc}wngt}nca¬}o¬mnhhdwdc}¬htcf}nocv¬
nc¬mnhhdwdc}¬|kw}v¬oh¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Htw}idw`owd*¬ncvnai}v¬hwo`¬ogvdwxk}nocv¬oh¬o}idw¬vdf}owv¬nc¬}id¬
wdanockj¬dfoco`~¬kwd¬offkvnockjj~¬tvdm¬how¬fjkwnhnfk}noc¬kcm/ow¬htw}idw¬njjtv}wk}noc¬oh¬vo`d¬oh¬
}id¬fowd¬kwat`dc}v#¬
¬
4# ]id¬wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬nc¬Veäcd¬¬
Veäcd¬nv¬}id¬vot}idwc`ov}¬wdanoc¬oh¬Vqdmdc¬kcm¬ocd¬oh¬}id¬`ov}¬mdcvdj~¬|o|tjk}dm¬kwdkv¬nc¬}id¬
fotc}w~#¬Jofk}dm¬kfwovv¬ }id¬ Votcm¬hwo`¬}id¬ Fo|dcikadc¬ wdanoc¬ nc¬Mdc`kwe*¬ }id¬ `kbown}~¬oh¬
Veäcd„v¬;#7¬`njjnoc¬ncikgn}kc}v¬jnxd¬nc¬}id¬qdv}dwc¬|kw}¬oh¬}id¬wdanoc#¬]id¬}iwdd¬jkwadv}¬fn}ndv¬kwd¬@kj`ø¬)6<<#<<<¬ ncikgn}kc}v.*¬Idjvncagowa¬);6<#<<<.*¬Jtcm¬ );;<#<<<.*¬kjj¬jofk}dm¬oc¬ }id¬qdv}¬
fokv}#¬Qn}i¬k¬inv}ow~¬oh¬idkx~¬ncmtv}w~¬)vin|¬gtnjmnca*¬|tj|¬kcm¬|k|dw*¬focfwd}d¬kcm¬v}ocd.*¬hoom¬
|womtf}noc¬ kcm¬ |wofdvvnca*¬ vin||nca¬ kcm¬ }wkmd*¬ gt}¬ kjvo¬ vo`d¬ fid nfkj*¬ |jkv}nfv¬ kcm¬ }dy}njd¬
ncmtv}wndv*¬ }id¬wdanoc¬ikv¬dy|dwndcfdm¬ focvnmdwkgjd¬ ncmtv}wnkj¬}wkcvn}noc¬ nc¬ wdfdc}¬inv}ow~#¬Kv¬
vo`d¬vdf}owv¬ikxd¬kj`ov}¬mnvk||dkwdm¬)d#a#¬vin|¬gtnjmnca*¬}dy}njdv*¬|tj|¬kcm¬|k|dw.*¬cdq¬ocdv¬
ikxd¬d`dwadm#¬Hojjoqnca¬}id¬d`dwadcfd¬oh¬}id¬ecoqjdmad“gkvdm¬dfoco`~¬}id¬`knc¬tcnxdwvn}ndv¬
nc¬}id¬wdanoc¬)nc¬Jtcm¬kcm¬@kj`ø.¬ikxd¬|jk~dm¬n`|ow}kc}¬wojdv¬nc¬vik|nca¬}id¬ftwwdc}¬ncmtv}wnkj¬
jkcmvfk|d#¬Ncmtv}wndv¬jned¬|ikw`kfdt}nfkj*¬`dmnfkj¬}dficojoa~*¬kcm¬NF]¬dxojxdm¬nc¬}id¬vdfocm¬
ikjh¬oh¬}id¬7<}i¬fdc}tw~¬nc¬fjovd¬|woyn`n}~¬}o¬Jtcm¬Tcnxdwvn}~#¬Nc¬kmmn}noc¬}o¬}inv*¬Jtcm¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬
|jk~dm¬kc¬n`|ow}kc}¬wojd¬how¬t|awkmnca¬dv}kgjnvidm¬vdf}owv¬jned¬|kfekanca¬kcm¬hoom¬|wofdvvnca#¬
Oxdw¬}id¬jkv}¬mdfkmd*¬vdxdwkj¬cdq¬d`dwanca¬ncmtv}wndv¬kcm¬kwdkv¬oh¬dy|dw}nvd¬ikxd¬dxojxdm*¬co}¬jdkv}¬nc¬focbtcf}noc¬qn}i¬}id¬awoq}i¬oh¬@kj`ø¬Tcnxdwvn}~#¬]iotai¬v}njj¬wdjk}nxdj~¬v`kjj¬nc¬vnrd*¬
vdf}owv¬jned¬`oxnca¬`dmnk*¬fo`|t}dw¬ak`dv*¬fjdkc¬}dfi¬kcm¬vtv}knckgnjn}~¬kwd¬awoqnca#¬¬
]id¬ ncmtv}wnkj¬ v}wtf}twd¬ oh¬ Veäcd¬ nv¬ {tn}d¬ vn njkw¬ }o¬ }ik}¬ oh¬Vqdmdc¬ kv¬k¬ qiojd#¬ Nc¬ }dw`v¬oh¬
d`|jo~ddv¬|dw¬vdf}ow¬}idwd¬nv¬k¬<#>9¬fowwdjk}noc¬gd}qddc¬}id¬ncmtv}w~¬v}wtf}twd¬nc¬Veäcd¬kcm¬
Vqdmdc¬)7<<1.#¬;1¬vdf}owv¬kwd¬hotcm¬}o¬gd¬vnacnhnfkc}j~¬oxdwv|dfnkjnrdm¬nc¬}dw`v¬oh¬ct`gdw¬oh¬
d`|jo~ddv¬ nc¬ Veäcd¬ kv¬ k¬ qiojd#¬ Tcvtw|wnvncaj~¬ anxdc¬ n}v¬ inv}ownfkj¬ mo nckcfd¬ )Gowa¬ 7<<4.*¬
vdxdwkj¬oh¬ }idvd¬kwd¬qn}inc¬hoom¬|womtf}noc¬kcm¬|wofdvvnca#¬O}idwv¬kwd¬`kfincdw~¬|womtf}noc*¬
}wkcv|ow}k}noc*¬`dmnfkj¬d{tn|`dc}*¬kcm¬fojjdf}noc¬kcm¬}wdk}`dc}¬oh¬qkv}d¬)Idccnca¬d}¬kj#¬7<;<.#¬
Kv¬kjwdkm~¬ncmnfk}dm*¬ }id¬WNV¬nc¬ Veäcd¬ nv¬fikwkf}dwnrdm¬g~¬k¬ v}woca¬ecoqjdmad¬nchwkv}wtf}twd#¬
Jtcm¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬nv¬}id¬jkwadv}¬nc¬Vfkcmnckxnk¬qn}i¬=1#<<<¬v}tmdc}v¬kcm¬8#6<<¬d`|jo~ddv#¬@kj`ø¬Tcnxdwvn}~*¬btv}¬ 7<¬enjo`d}wdv¬ hwo`¬Jtcm*¬ikv¬ kc¬kmmn}nockj¬ 7=#<<<¬ v}tmdc}v¬kcm¬ ;#=<<¬ v}khh#¬
]oad}idw¬ qn}i¬ o}idw¬ kfkmd nf¬ dcxnwoc`dc}v¬ vtfi¬ kv¬ }id¬ Vqdmnvi¬ Kawnftj}twkj¬ Tcnxdwvn}~¬
ot}vnmd¬@kj`ø¬kcm¬Ewnv}nkcv}km¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬Fojjdad¬}id~¬`ked¬k¬v}woca¬ecoqjdmad¬kcm¬wdvdkwfi¬
dcxnwoc`dc}¬go}i¬nc¬ }dw`v¬oh¬ecoqjdmad¬|womtf}noc¬kcm¬mnvvd`nck}noc¬kcm¬}wkncnca¬oh¬ inaij~¬
venjjdm¬jkgotw#¬@kc~¬oh¬}id¬v}woca¬ncmtv}wnkj¬vdf}owv¬nc¬}id¬wdanoc¬kwd¬wd|wdvdc}dm¬g~¬`k}finca¬
ecoqjdmad¬ fdc}wdv¬ k}¬ }id¬ tcnxdwvn}ndv#¬ N}¬ nv¬ }id¬ wdanockj¬ kt}iown}~*¬ Wdanoc¬ Veäcd*¬ }ik}¬
foowmnck}dv¬)kcm¬fo“htcmv.¬`ov}¬vdfocmkw~¬kf}ow¬kf}nxn}ndv¬nc¬}id¬WNV#¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 16/35
;=¬
¬
4#;¬@ognjd¬fo``tcnfk}nocv*¬Fjdkc}dfi*¬kcm ¬Hoom ¬
]id¬wd`kncmdw¬oh ¬}inv¬|k|dw¬mdkjv¬qn}i¬}iwdd¬vdf}ow“v|dfnhnf¬wdanockj¬ nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬ ncn}nk}nxdv¬ nc¬
Veäcd#¬ ]idvd¬ kwd¬ Vtv}knckgjd¬ Gtvncdvv¬ Itg¬ }kwad}nca¬ fjdkc“}dfi*¬ @ognjd¬ Idnai}v¬ }kwad}nca¬ `ognjd¬
fo``tcnfk}nocv*¬ kcm¬ Veäcd¬ Hoom¬ Nccoxk}noc¬ Cd}qowe¬ }kwad}nca¬ }id¬ hoom¬ ncmtv}w~#¬ ]id¬ ncn}nk}nxdv¬
mnhhdw¬nc¬n`|ow}kc}¬wdv|df}v¬kcm¬fkc¬gd¬vddc¬kv¬}idd¬mnv}ncf}¬fkvdv¬oh ¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬|ojnf~#¬]id¬
hoom¬
fkvd¬
nv¬
k¬
}wkmn}nockj¬
ncmtv}w~¬
}~|nfkjj~¬
fikwkf}dwnvdm¬
kv¬
joq“}dfi
¬kcm
¬joq
¬xkjtd
¬kmmdm#
¬]id
¬
vdf}ow¬nv¬foidwdc}¬kcm¬dkv~¬}o¬mdhncd¬go}i¬qidc¬n}¬fo`dv¬}o¬fowd¬)hoom¬|womtf}noc¬kcm¬|wofdvvnca.¬
kcm¬ktynjnkw~¬vtg“vdf}owv#¬N}¬nv¬k¬jkwad¬vdf}ow¬qn}i¬k¬joca¬inv}ow~¬nc¬}id¬wdanoc¬kcm¬n}¬nv¬fikwkf}dwnvdm¬
g~¬qdjj¬dv}kgjnvidm¬hnw`v#¬]id¬owakcnrk}noc¬qinfi¬vdwxdv¬kv¬foowmnck}ow¬oh ¬}id¬WNV¬)VHNC.¬ikv¬gddc¬nc¬
|jkfd¬vncfd¬}id¬dkwj~¬;>><v#¬
]id¬ `ognjd¬ fo``tcnfk}nocv¬ fkvd¬ nv¬ vn`njkw¬ }o¬ }id¬ hoom¬ fkvd¬ ncvohkw¬ kv¬ n}¬ nv¬ kc¬ dv}kgjnvidm¬ kcm¬
foidwdc}¬ncmtv}w~¬qn}i¬|wo`ncdc}¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬wdanoc#¬Kv¬qn}i¬hoom*¬}id¬ncmtv}w~¬nv¬{tn}d¬jkwad¬go}i¬
nc¬Veäcd¬kcm¬ nc¬Vqdmdc¬kv¬k¬qiojd#¬Nc¬foc}wkv}¬}o¬hoom¬ioqdxdw*¬ n}¬ nv¬fikwkf}dwnvdm¬kv¬k¬inai“}dfi¬
kcm¬inai¬xkjtd¬kmmdm¬vdf}ow#¬Kco}idw¬mnhhdwdcfd¬ nv¬ }ik}¬qinjd¬ }id¬ hoom¬ ncmtv}w~¬fo`|wnvdv¬k¬ jkwad¬
ct`gdw¬oh ¬fo`|kcndv¬)go}i¬v`kjj¬kcm¬jkwad.*¬}id¬`ognjd¬fo``tcnfk}nocv¬ncmtv}w~¬nc¬Veäcd¬focvnv}v¬
oh ¬}iwdd
¬`tj}nck}nockj
¬fow|owk}nocv2
¬V]
¬Dwnfvvoc*
¬Voc~
¬Dwnfvvoc*
¬kcm
¬]djnk
¬Vocdwk#
¬]id
¬}qo
¬Dwnfvvoc
¬
fo`|kcndv¬kwd¬go}i¬ jofk}dm¬nc¬Jtcm¬kcm¬d`|jo~¬kgot}¬4<<<¬|do|jd#¬]id¬owakcnrk}noc¬foowmnck}nca¬
WNV¬vt||ow}¬ how¬}inv¬vdf}ow¬)@ognjd¬Idnai}v.¬ikv¬gddc¬ nc¬|jkfd¬vncfd¬`nm¬}o¬ jk}d¬ hnwv}¬mdfkmd¬oh ¬}id¬
7<<<v#¬
Jkv}j~*¬ }id¬ fjdkc“}dfi¬ vdf}ow¬ mnhhdwv¬ hwo`¬ }id¬ }qo¬ kgoxd¬ nc¬ n`|ow}kc}¬ qk~v#¬ Hnwv}j~*¬ n}¬ nv¬ k¬ ~otca¬
vdf}ow¬}ik}¬nv¬mnhhnftj}¬}o¬mdhncd¬qn}i¬kc~¬|wdfnvnoc#¬Fjdkc¬}dficojoa~¬nv¬oh}dc¬mdhncdm*¬gkvdm¬oc¬DT„v¬
Dcxnwoc`dc}kj¬ ]dficojoandv¬ Kf}noc¬ \jkc¬ )D]K\.¬ kv¬ ‚xkwnotv¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ }o¬ inaijnai}¬ dcxnwoc`dc}kj¬
}dficojoa~¬kcm¬dcxnwoc`dc}kj¬}dficojoa~¬nccoxk}nocv*¬kv¬qdjj¬kv¬}o¬|wo`o}d¬md`kcm¬kcm¬n`|woxd¬
`kwed}¬ focmn}nocv‐¬ )VQDC]DF¬ 7<<1.#¬ ]inv¬ njjtv}wk}dv¬ k¬ fdc}wkj¬ nvvtd¬ oh ¬ fjdkc“}dfi*¬ ck`dj~¬ }ik}¬ n}¬
ncfjtmdv¬kf}owv¬hwo`¬|o}dc}nkjj~¬kc~¬ncmtv}w~¬kcm¬vdf}ow¬oh ¬}id¬dfoco`~#¬Qinjd¬vo`d¬dyk`|jdv¬kwd¬
dkvnj~¬ nmdc}nhnkgjd*¬ how¬ dyk`|jd¬ hnw`v¬ ncxojxdm¬ nc¬ fojjdf}noc¬ kcm¬ }wdk}`dc}¬ oh ¬ qkv}d¬ ‖¬ ocd¬ oh ¬ hdq¬
vdf}owv¬ qn}i¬ vnacnhnfkc}¬ oxdwv|dfnkjnrk}noc¬ nc¬ Veäcd¬ ‖¬ n}¬ nv¬ mnhhnftj}¬ }o¬ nmdc}nh~¬ adcdwkj¬ fjkvvdv¬ oh ¬
gtvncdvvdv¬ow¬ ncmtv}wndv¬ }ik}¬ focv}n}t}d¬ }id¬fjdkc“}dfi¬ vdf}ow¬ )k¬ focfjtvnoc¬ mwkqc¬ g~¬ how¬ dyk`|jd¬
HOWK¬7<<>.#¬Nc¬}id¬Veäcd¬WNV*¬hnw`v¬|womtfnca¬ow¬‚n`|jd`dc}nca‐¬fjdkc“}dfi¬kwd¬hotcm¬qn}inc¬kwdkv¬
oh ¬ qk}dw¬ }wdk}`dc}*¬ dcdwa~¬ wdfoxdw~¬ hwo`¬ qkv}d*¬ dcdwa~¬ kcm¬ idk}nca¬ v~v}d`v¬ )gnodcdwa~*¬ gonjdwv¬
kcm¬mnv}wnf}¬idk}nca.*¬dcdwa~¬vkxnca¬focv}wtf}noc¬kcm¬vtv}knckgjd¬twgkc¬mdxdjo|`dc}#¬K|kw}¬hwo`¬}id¬
id}dwoadcdotv¬ ck}twd¬ oh ¬ }id¬ vdf}ow*¬ n}¬ nv¬ kjvo¬ {tn}d¬ ~otca¬ nc¬ }dw`v¬ oh ¬ NV¬ |ojnfndv¬ nc¬ Veäcd#¬ ]id¬ NV¬
foowmnck}noc¬ncn}nk}nxd¬)VGI.¬qkv¬how`dm¬nc¬}id¬`nm“jk}d¬7<<<v#¬¬
¬
8# Nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`
¬|ojnfndv
¬nc
¬Veäcd2
¬V}wtf}twkj
¬kcm
¬htcf}nockj
¬foowmnck}noc
¬
Nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~¬ncn}nk}nxdv¬ nc¬Veäcd*¬kv¬nc¬Vqdmdc¬kv¬k¬qiojd*¬kwd¬oh}dc¬gkvdm¬oc¬k¬fjtv}dw¬kcm/ow¬
nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬|dwv|df}nxd#¬]inv¬ nchdwv¬go}i¬k¬wdanockj¬kcm¬vdf}owkj¬|dwv|df}nxd¬kcm¬}inv¬`kedv¬
foowmnck}noc¬oh ¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬k¬fwtfnkj¬nvvtd#¬]id¬gdcdhn}¬oh ¬k¬foowmnck}dm¬k||wokfi¬nv¬}ik}¬n}¬kjjoqv¬
k¬mdawdd¬oh ¬v|dfnhnfn}~¬qidc¬mdvnacnca¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬vo¬}ik}¬}idvd¬kwd¬ftv}o`nrdm¬}o¬}id¬v|dfnhnf¬
cddmv¬ oh ¬ }id¬ vdf}ow¬ kcm¬ wdanoc#¬ Kv¬ fo`|kwdm¬ }o¬ `owd¬ adcdwkj¬ fwovv“vdf}owkj¬ kcm¬ fwovv“wdanockj¬
|ojnfndv¬n}¬modv¬ioqdxdw*¬kv¬kwatdm¬nc¬}id¬focfd|}tkj¬hwk`dqowe¬vdf}noc¬oh ¬}inv¬|k|dw*¬wd{tnwd¬`tfi¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 17/35
;4¬
¬
`owd¬ foowmnck}noc¬ gd}qddc¬ ncn}nk}nxdv*¬ kf}owv¬ kcm¬ kf}nxn}ndv#¬ ]id¬ mnvftvvnoc¬ gdjoq¬ kckj~rdv¬ }qo¬
fdc}wkj¬kv|df}v¬oh ¬|ojnf~¬foowmnck}noc2¬Foowmnck}noc¬gd}qddc¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬tcmdwj~nca¬ |wogjd`v*¬
kcm¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬ htcf}nocv¬oc¬}id¬ocd¬ikcm¬kcm¬foowmnck}noc¬gd}qddc¬mnhhdwdc}¬)}~|dv¬oh.¬NV¬
kf}owv¬oc¬}id¬o}idw#¬¬
Hnwv}j~*¬foowmnck}noc¬nv¬wd{tnwdm¬}o¬dcvtwd¬}ik}¬}id¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬|dwhow`dm¬kmmwdvv¬}id¬tcmdwj~nca¬
|wogjd`v¬oh
¬}id
¬vdf}ow
¬nc
¬}id
¬wdanoc#
¬Kv
¬kwatdm*
¬}id
¬adcdwkj
¬v~v}d`
¬htcf}nocv
¬nmdc}nhndm
¬nc
¬Fik|}dw
¬6¬
kwd¬kfindxdm¬g~¬}id¬|dwhow`kcfd¬oh ¬}kcangjd¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬g~¬ NV¬kf}owv#¬Vdxdwkj¬dyk`|jdv¬oh ¬}id¬
n`|ow}kcfd¬oh ¬foowmnck}noc¬gd}qddc¬tcmdwj~nca¬|wogjd`v*¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬kcm¬htcf}nocv¬fkc¬gd¬anxdc¬how¬
}id¬fkvdv#¬Kjj¬}iwdd¬fkvdv¬dy|dwndcfd¬|wogjd`v¬ wdjk}dm¬}o¬kgvdcfd¬oh ¬ed~¬wdvotwfdv¬ nc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬
Vtfi¬ wdvotwfdv¬ kwd¬ v|dfnhnf¬ venjjv¬ kcm¬ fo`|d}dcfndv¬ )d#a#¬ wdakwmnca¬ nc}dwck}nockj¬ `kwed}nca¬ kcm¬
dy|ow}v¬ nc¬}id¬fkvd¬oh ¬fjdkc“}dfi.¬kcm¬ jkfe¬oh ¬it`kc¬fk|n}kj¬)d#a#¬ jkfe¬oh ¬venjjdm¬ jkgotw¬ nc¬ hoom¬kcm¬¬
`ognjd¬ fo``tcnfk}nocv.#¬ V|dfnhnf¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ fkwwndm¬ ot}¬ g~¬ NV¬ kf}owv¬ hoftv¬ oc¬ kmmwdvvnca¬ }idvd¬
|wogjd`v#¬¬
]id¬|wogjd`¬oh ¬ jkfenca¬venjjv¬kcm¬fo`|d}dcfndv¬wdakwmnca¬dy|ow}v¬kcm¬ nc}dwck}nockjnrk}noc ¬k`ocav}¬
}id¬hnw`v¬nc¬}id¬fjdkc“}dfi¬vdf}ow¬nv¬kmmwdvvdm¬g~¬}id¬nc}dw`dmnkw~¬owakcnvk}noc¬Vtv}knckgjd¬Gtvncdvv¬
Itg¬)VGI.#
¬]inv
¬nv
¬mocd
¬g~
¬|woxnmnca
¬vdwxnfdv
¬kcm
¬kmxnfd
¬kf}nxn}ndv
¬wdakwmnca
¬gtvncdvv
¬mdxdjo|`dc}
¬nc
¬
}id¬fjdkc“}dfi¬vdf}ow¬kcm¬idj|¬qn}i¬k||wokfinca¬|o}dc}nkj¬dy|ow}¬`kwed}v*¬d#a#¬g~¬kwwkcanca¬xnvn}v¬}o¬
|o}dc}nkj¬`kwed}v#¬]idvd¬wk}idw¬v|dfnhnf¬vt||ow}¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬wdjk}dm¬}o¬NV¬htcf}nocv*¬how¬dyk`|jd¬}o¬
mnwdf}¬ }id¬ k}}dc}noc¬ oh ¬ kf}owv¬ nc¬ }id¬ v~v}d`¬ }oqkwmv¬ v|dfnhnf¬ `kwed}v*¬ |wogjd`v*¬ kcm¬ awoq}i¬
o||ow}tcn}ndv¬ )`kwed}¬ nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬ kcm¬ how`k}noc5¬ atnmkcfd¬ oh ¬ vdkwfi.#¬ Vtffdvvhtj¬ dydft}noc¬ oh ¬
vtfi¬kf}nxn}ndv¬md|dcmv¬oc¬}idwd¬gdnca¬kf}owv¬}ik}¬fkc¬fkww~¬ot}¬}idvd¬kf}nxn}ndv#¬Nc¬}id¬fkvd¬oh ¬fjdkc“
}dfi*¬jkfe¬oh ¬wdvotwfdv¬wdhdw¬|wn`kwnj~¬}o¬owakcnvk}nockj¬}inccdvv5¬n#d#¬}ik}¬}idwd¬kwd¬hdq¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬
v~v}d`¬}ik}¬|ovvdvv¬}id¬cddmdm¬fo`|d}dcfndv#¬]id¬NV¬ncn}nk}nxd¬)VGI.¬k}}d`|}v¬}o¬kmmwdvv¬}inv¬nc¬}qo¬
qk~v2¬ )n.¬ g~¬gtnjmnca¬t|¬ }idnw¬oqc¬fo`|d}dcfd¬kgot}¬dy|ow}¬ `kwed}v¬ }ik}¬fkc¬|woxnmd¬kmxnfd¬kcm¬
vt||ow}¬}o¬}idnw¬`d`gdwv*¬kcm¬ )nn.¬}o¬vdwxd¬kv¬k¬ jnce¬gd}qddc¬}id¬ hnw`v¬ nc¬}id¬ NV¬kcm¬dy}wk“v~v}d`¬
kf}owv¬vtfi
¬kv
¬}id
¬Vqdmnvi
¬]wkmd
¬Fotcfnj#
¬¬¬
Qidc¬n}¬fo`dv¬}o¬jkfe¬oh ¬it`kc¬wdvotwfdv*¬qinfi¬nv¬k¬|wogjd`¬how¬go}i¬}id¬`ognjd¬fo``tcnfk}nocv¬
vdf}ow¬kcm¬}id¬hoom¬vdf}ow¬nc¬Veäcd*¬}id¬|wogjd`¬nv¬htcf}nockj¬wk}idw¬}ikc¬v}wtf}twkj#¬]inv¬`dkcv¬}ik}¬
}id¬v~v}d`¬fo`|wnvdv¬kf}owv¬}ik}¬}wknc¬kcm¬dmtfk}d¬jkgotw¬qn}inc¬wdjdxkc}¬kwdkv*¬gt}¬}id~¬kwd¬tckgjd¬
}o¬|womtfd¬dcotai¬ot}|t}¬}o¬`dd}¬}id¬md`kcm¬oh ¬}id¬kf}owv¬ nc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬K¬ct`gdw¬oh ¬kf}nxn}ndv¬
kwd¬|dwhow`dm¬}o¬kmmwdvv¬}idvd¬|wogjd`v#¬Go}i¬nc¬hoom¬kcm¬`ognjd¬fo``tcnfk}nocv¬}id¬NV“ncn}nk}nxdv¬
)VHNC¬kcm¬@ognjd¬Idnai}v.¬fkww~¬ot}¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kn`nca¬k}¬k}}wkf}nca¬cdq¬ jkgotw¬}o¬}id¬vdf}ow#¬ Nc¬}id¬
fkvd¬oh ¬@ognjd¬Idnai}v¬}id¬hoftv¬nv¬oc¬dcfotwkanca¬~otca¬|do|jd¬}o¬ bonc¬}id¬}dficojoanfkj¬|woawk`v¬
k}¬ }id¬ tcnxdwvn}~¬ )`ognjnrk}noc¬ oh ¬ wdvotwfdv¬ |kw}j~¬ }iwotai¬ jdan}n`k}noc¬ kcm¬ vt||ow}nca¬ }id¬
mdxdjo|`dc}¬oh ¬ }id¬ v~v}d`v¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd¬ nc¬ }dw`v¬oh ¬dmtfk}nockj¬ ncv}n}t}nocv.#¬]inv¬ nv¬gkvnfkjj~¬k¬
qk~¬
}o¬
kmmwdvv¬
}id¬
|wogjd`¬
oh ¬
}id¬
vdf}ow¬
}ik}¬
~otca¬
|do|jd¬
}omk~¬
kwd¬
jdvv¬
k}}wkf}dm¬
g~¬
}dficojoanfkj¬tcnxdwvn}~¬|woawk`v¬}ikc¬ nc¬}id¬|kv}#¬Dxdc¬}iotai¬}id¬ jkwad¬`ognjd¬fo``tcnfk}nocv¬
fo`|kcndv¬ nc¬ }id¬ wdanoc¬vtfi¬kv¬Dwnfvvoc¬ )V]¬Dwnfvvoc¬kcm¬Voc~¬Dwnfvvoc.¬kcm¬]djnk¬Vocdwk¬ k}}wkf}¬
`kc~¬ oh ¬ }id¬ awkmtk}dv¬ hwo`¬ }id¬ tcnxdwvn}ndv¬ nc¬ }id¬ wdanoc*¬ }id¬ mwo|¬ nc¬ nc}dwdv}¬ nc¬ }dficojoanfkj¬
}wkncnca¬focv}n}t}dv¬k¬awoqnca¬|wogjd`¬how¬}id¬ncmtv}w~#¬]id¬ed~¬kf}owv¬nc¬}inv¬kwd¬}id¬`kbow¬`ognjd¬
fo``tcnfk}nocv¬hnw`v¬kcm¬}id¬Hkftj}~¬oh ¬dcancddwnca¬nc¬Jtcm#¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 18/35
;8¬
¬
Nc¬}id¬fkvd¬oh ¬}id¬hoom¬ ncmtv}w~¬}id¬vn}tk}noc¬ nv¬vjnai}j~¬mnhhdwdc}#¬]id¬ed~¬ nvvtd¬ how¬}id¬ NV¬ ncn}nk}nxd¬
)VHNC.¬ nv¬}o¬k}}wkf}¬v}tmdc}v¬oh ¬how¬dyk`|jd¬}dficojoa~¬kcm¬`kckad`dc}¬}o¬}id¬hoom¬vdf}ow¬wk}idw¬
}ikc¬k}}wkf}nca¬~otca¬|do|jd¬}o¬ bonc¬v|dfnhnf¬tcnxdwvn}~¬|woawk`v#¬]inv¬nv¬gdnca¬kmmwdvvdm¬g~¬vd}}nca¬
t|¬vfiojkwvin|v*¬|wo`o}nca¬}id¬ hoom¬ ncmtv}w~¬kv¬kc¬k}}wkf}nxd¬ ncmtv}w~¬}o¬dc}dw¬kcm¬ikxnca¬}wkncdd¬
|woawk`v¬ncxojxnca¬vo`d¬oh ¬}id¬jkwadv}¬hoom¬fo`|kcndv¬nc¬}id¬wdanoc¬)`ognjnrk}noc¬oh ¬wdvotwfdv¬kcm¬
jdan}n`k}noc.#¬]id¬hoom¬fo`|kcndv¬ nc¬}id¬wdanoc¬kwd¬}id¬ed~¬kf}owv¬how¬fkww~nca¬ot}¬}idvd¬kf}nxn}ndv¬
tcmdw¬}id¬foowmnck}noc¬oh ¬VHNC#¬K}}wkf}nca¬venjjdm¬ jkgotw¬}o¬}id¬ ncmtv}wndv¬ nv¬k¬qk~¬how¬go}i¬@ognjd¬
Idnai}v¬ kcm¬ VHNC¬ }o¬ dcvtwd¬ joca¬ }dw`¬ ecoqjdmad¬ fwdk}noc#¬ How¬ go}i¬ `ognjd¬ fo``tcnfk}nocv¬ kcm¬
hoom*¬ }id¬ |wogjd`¬ nv¬ htcf}nockj¬ wk}idw¬ }ikc¬v}wtf}twkj¬ vncfd¬ }id¬ wdjdxkc}¬kf}owv¬ kwd¬|wdvdc}¬ nc¬ }id¬
wdanoc¬gt}¬}id~¬kwd¬ftwwdc}j~¬tckgjd¬}o¬|womtfd¬k¬vthhnfndc}¬ct`gdw¬oh ¬v}tmdc}v/k}}wkf}¬v}tmdc}v¬}o¬
}idnw¬vdf}ow#¬¬¬
K¬ htw}idw¬ qk~¬ }o¬ mdkj¬ qn}i¬ }id¬ nvvtd¬ oh ¬ jkfe¬ oh ¬ it`kc¬ fk|n}kj¬ nc¬ }id¬ }qo¬ vdf}owv¬ nv¬ g~¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬
mdvnacdm¬}o¬hkfnjn}k}d¬dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|¬kcm¬fwdk}noc¬oh ¬cdq¬gtvncdvvdv#¬Nc¬`ognjd¬fo``tcnfk}nocv¬
}inv¬nv¬mocd¬g~¬vd}}nca¬t|¬ncftgk}ow¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm¬nc¬}id¬fkvd¬oh ¬hoom¬g~¬mnwdf}¬vt||ow}¬)coc“hnckcfnkj.¬
how¬ nccoxk}nocv¬ nc¬V@Dv¬)v}n`tjk}noc¬oh ¬dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|¬kcm¬atnmkcfd¬oh ¬vdkwfi.#¬]idvd¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬
}iotai¬
}id~¬
|kw}j~¬
kmmwdvv¬
}id¬
|wogjd`¬
oh ¬
jkfe¬
oh ¬
it`kc¬
wdvotwfdv*¬
kjvo¬
hnjj¬
o}idw¬
n`|ow}kc}¬
htcf}nocv¬ }ik}¬ kmmwdvv¬ |wogjd`v¬ oh ¬ hwka`dc}k}noc¬ kcm¬ jofe“nc¬ dhhdf}v¬ nc¬ }id¬ WNV#¬ Nc¬ go}i¬ `ognjd¬
fo``tcnfk}nocv¬ kcm¬ hoom*¬ }id¬ NV¬ foowmnck}owv¬ )@ognjd¬ Idnai}v¬ kcm¬ VHNC.¬ kwd¬ }id¬ |wn`kw~¬ kf}owv¬
|dwhow`nca¬}idvd¬htcf}nocv#¬Qn}i¬vt||ow}¬kcm¬ nchjtdcfd¬hwo`¬vdfocmkw~¬kf}owv*¬|wn`kwnj~¬k¬ct`gdw¬
oh ¬}id¬ed~¬fo`|kcndv¬nc¬}id¬wdv|df}nxd¬vdf}ow#¬¬
]idvd¬ dyk`|jdv¬ oh ¬ ioq¬ NV“kf}nxn}ndv¬ kwd¬ gkvdm¬ oc¬ kc¬ kckj~vnv¬ oh ¬ }id¬ tcmdwj~nca¬ |wogjd`v¬ oh ¬ }id¬
vdf}ow¬ )nc¬ }id¬ wdanoc¬kcm¬ nc¬adcdwkj.¬kcm¬ioq¬ }id¬kf}nxn}ndv¬|dwhow`¬ed~¬ NV“ htcf}nocv¬ njjtv}wk}d¬ }id¬
cddm¬ how¬ |ojnf~¬ foowmnck}noc#¬ N}¬ nv¬ kjvo¬ fjdkw¬ }ik}¬ }id¬ |wogjd`v¬ mnhhdw¬ g~¬ ncmtv}w~#¬ Nc¬ }id¬ fkvd¬ oh ¬
k}}wkf}nca¬ v}tmdc}v¬ }o¬ }dficojoanfkj¬ tcnxdwvn}~¬ |woawk`v¬ kcm¬ tcnxdwvn}~¬ awkmtk}dv¬ }o¬ }id¬ hoom¬
ncmtv}w~¬ }idvd¬ kwd¬ adcdwkj¬ |wogjd`v¬ how¬ }id¬ ncmtv}wndv¬ nc¬ Vqdmdc¬ kv¬ k¬ qiojd¬ )kcm¬ nc¬ `kc~¬ o}idw¬
vn`njkw¬dfoco`ndv.#
¬]id~
¬kwd
¬}itv
¬co}
¬v|dfnhnf
¬}o
¬}id
¬wdanoc#
¬O}idw
¬|wogjd`v*
¬vtfi
¬kv
¬mdxdjo|nca
¬}id
¬venjjv¬kcm¬fo`|d}dcfndv¬cdfdvvkw~¬ }o¬ nmdc}nh~¬cdq¬gtvncdvv¬o||ow}tcn}ndv¬ kcm¬cdq¬`kwed}v¬qn}inc¬
}id¬d`dwanca¬ hndjm¬oh ¬fjdkc“}dfi¬kwd¬`owd¬fjovdj~¬ jncedm¬}o¬}id¬ ncmtv}w~¬ nc¬}id¬v|dfnhnf¬wdanoc#¬]id¬
vk`d¬ nv¬ }wtd¬ how¬ adcdwk}nca¬ }id¬ cdfdvvkw~¬ venjjv¬ kcm¬ ecoqjdmad¬ }o¬ gd¬ kgjd¬ }o¬ k||wokfi¬ }idvd¬
`kwed}v#¬¬¬
K¬ vdfocm¬ |wogjd`¬ kwdk¬ nv¬ }ik}¬ oh ¬ hwka`dc}k}noc#¬ Hwka`dc}k}noc¬ ikv¬ }o¬ mo¬ qn}i¬ }id¬ nvvtdv¬ oh ¬
htcf}nockj¬kcm¬v}wtf}twkj¬`nv`k}fi*¬ n#d#¬qidc¬}id¬v~v}d`¬ htcf}nocv¬mo¬co}¬wdvtj}¬ nc¬v~cdwandv¬ )d#a#¬
gdfktvd¬ oh ¬ jkfe¬ oh ¬ foowmnck}noc.¬ kcm¬ qidc¬ }id¬ v}wtf}twkj¬ fo`|ovn}noc¬ kcm/ow¬ ncv}n}t}nockj¬
hwk`dqowe¬mo¬co}¬hn}¬}id¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬WNV#¬Nc¬}id¬fkvd¬oh ¬}id¬hoom¬vdf}ow*¬htcf}nockj¬`nv`k}fi¬qkv¬k¬
|wogjd`¬ kwdk¬ how¬ }id¬ hoom¬ vdf}ow¬ |wn`kwnj~¬ nc¬ }id¬ ;>><v#¬ ]id¬ WNV¬ fo`|wnvdm¬ k¬ v}woca¬ ecoqjdmad¬
nchwkv}wtf}twd¬
qn}inc¬
hoom¬
gt}¬
}idwd¬
qkv¬
jn`n}dm¬
nc}dwkf}noc¬
gd}qddc¬
ncmtv}w~¬
kcm¬
kfkmd`nk¬
)Ed`|ncve~¬ d}¬ kj#¬ 7<;;.#¬ Mwnxdc¬ g~¬ }id¬ DT“`d`gdwvin|¬ nc¬ ;>>4*¬ }id¬ VHNC¬ ncn}nk}nxd¬ mnm¬ ioqdxdw¬
mdxo}d¬ focvnmdwkgjd¬ dhhow}¬ }o¬ }inv¬ nvvtd¬ kcm¬ }omk~¬ hoom¬ nv¬ }id¬ fkvd¬ qn}i¬ `ov}¬ qdjj¬ mdxdjo|dm¬
foowmnck}noc¬gd}qddc¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm¬}id¬`ov}¬qnmdj~¬vikwdm¬xnvnoc¬oh ¬}id¬}iwdd¬fkvdv¬idwd¬mnvftvvdm#¬
Ikxnca¬ vknm¬ }inv*¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ kwd¬ v}njj¬ |dwhow`dm¬ }o¬ kmmwdvv¬ }id¬ |o}dc}nkj¬ ht}twd¬ |wogjd`¬ oh ¬
hwka`dc}k}noc#¬Findh ¬k`ocav}¬}idvd¬kwd¬}id¬foowmnck}noc¬oh ¬k¬jkwad¬ct`gdw¬oh ¬cd}qowev¬)fo`|wnvnca¬
F#D#O#v*¬wdvdkwfidwv*¬wd}knjdwv¬d}f#.¬}ik}¬mnwdf}j~¬kcm¬ncmnwdf}j~¬ohhvd}¬hwka`dc}k}noc¬}dcmdcfndv#¬¬¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 19/35
;1¬
¬
Cd}qowenca¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬fdc}wkj¬co}¬ocj~¬ nc¬hoom¬gt}¬ nc¬kjj¬}iwdd¬fkvdv¬kcm¬kv¬ nc¬}id¬fkvd¬oh ¬ hoom*¬
}idvd¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬ncv}wt`dc}kj¬how¬wdmtfnca¬}id¬)ftwwdc}¬ow¬|o}dc}nkj.¬|wogjd`¬oh ¬htcf}nockj¬kcm/ow¬
ncv}n}t}nockj¬`nv`k}fi¬kcm¬nmdc}nh~¬|o}dc}nkj¬v~cdwandv¬gd}qddc¬}id¬kf}owv#¬Nc¬fjdkc“}dfi¬}id¬nvvtd¬oh ¬
hwka`dc}k}noc¬ nv¬ |kw}nftjkwj~¬ dxnmdc}#¬ ]inv¬ ikv¬ |kw}j~¬ }o¬ mo¬ qn}i¬ }id¬ hkf}¬ }ik}¬ fjdkc“}dfi¬ nv¬ co}¬ kc¬
dv}kgjnvidm¬}wkmn}nockj¬ ncmtv}w~¬ow¬vdf}ow¬gt}¬ wk}idw¬k¬fo`|d}dcfd¬kwdk¬ )HOWK¬7<<>.#¬]itv*¬ nc¬ }id¬
fjdkc“}dfi¬WNV¬}id¬NV¬foowmnck}ow¬)VGI.¬nv¬}id¬fdc}wkj¬kf}ow¬}ik}¬qowe¬}o¬wdmtfd¬hwka`dc}k}noc*¬go}i¬
v}wtf}twkj¬kcm¬htcf}nockj5¬|wn`kwnj~¬}iwotai¬cd}qowenca¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm¬g~¬|dwhow`nca¬}id¬htcf}noc¬oh ¬
jdan}n`k}noc#¬¬
]id¬ }inwm¬adcdwkj¬ |wogjd`¬kwdk¬mnvftvvdm¬idwd¬ikv¬ }o¬mo¬qn}i¬cdak}nxd¬ jofe“nc#¬ ]inv¬ nv¬|kw}nftjkwj~¬
wdjdxkc}¬how¬}id¬fjdkc“}dfi¬kcm¬hoom¬vdf}owv#¬Nc¬}id¬fkvd¬oh ¬}id¬hoom¬ncmtv}w~¬}inv¬wdjk}d¬|wn`kwnj~¬}o¬
}id¬cddm¬how¬wdcdqkj¬kcm¬t|awkmnca¬oh ¬k¬}wkmn}nockjj~¬joq“}dfi¬ncmtv}w~#¬]inv¬ikv¬gddc¬k¬`kbow¬hoftv¬
kwdk¬oh ¬}id¬ NV¬foowmnck}ow¬ )VHNC.¬kcm¬ nv¬}itv¬vtgbdf}¬}o¬k¬ct`gdw¬oh ¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv#¬Qinjd¬ jofe“nc¬
dhhdf}v¬`k~¬gd¬oh ¬mnhhdwdc}¬}~|dv*¬}qo¬n`|ow}kc}¬kwdkv¬how¬}id¬hoom¬ncmtv}w~¬nv¬}dficojoanfkj¬jofe“nc¬
)}ik}¬ ncmtv}w~¬ kf}owv¬ gdfo`d¬ jofedm¬ nc}o¬ dv}kgjnvidm¬ qk~v¬ oh ¬ |womtfnca¬ kcm¬ monca¬ gtvncdvv.¬ kcm¬
`kwed}¬ jofe“nc¬ )nc}o¬k¬mo`nckc}¬xndq¬oc¬focvt`dwv*¬focvt`dw¬gdikxnotw*¬cddmv¬ kcm¬qkc}v*¬vkjdv¬
fikccdjv¬
d}f#.#¬
Nc¬
}id¬
fkvd¬
oh ¬
hoom*¬
jofe“
nc¬
}dcmdcfndv¬
kwd¬
kmmwdvvdm¬
g~¬
vt||ow}nca¬
wdvdkwfi¬
)d#a#¬
oc¬
hoom¬ }dficojoa~*¬ hoom¬ vfndcfd*¬ awddc¬ gno}dfi*¬ focvt`dw¬ kcm¬ wd}knj¬ v}tmndv¬ d}f#.¬ kcm¬ nc}dwkf}noc¬
gd}qddc¬ kfkmd`nk¬ kcm¬ ncmtv}w~¬ )ecoqjdmad¬ mdxdjo|`dc}¬ kcm¬ mnhhtvnoc.#¬ Kfkmd`nk¬ nv¬ vddc¬ kv¬ k¬
votwfd¬qidwd¬cdq¬k||wokfidv¬kcm¬}dficojoandv¬fkc¬gd¬nmdc}nhndm¬kcm¬g~¬dy}dcvnoc¬cdq¬gtvncdvvdv¬
kcm¬`kwed}v¬fwdk}dm¬)v}n`tjk}noc¬oh ¬dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|¬kcm¬`kwed}¬nmdc}nhnfk}noc.#¬Kco}idw¬kf}nxn}~¬}o¬
wdmtfd¬ }id¬ wnve¬ oh ¬ jofe“nc¬ nv¬ }iwotai¬ vo¬fkjjdm¬ howdvnai}¬atnjmv#¬ ]id¬ NV¬ foowmnck}ow¬ )VHNC.¬owakcnrdv¬
}id`k}nf¬`dd}ncav¬kcm¬vd`nckwv¬qidwd¬ncmtv}w~¬kcm¬kfkmd`nk¬`dd}¬kcm¬mnvftvv¬ht}twd¬kxdctdv¬how¬
mdxdjo|`dc}¬ kcm¬ |o}dc}nkj¬ ht}twd¬ |wobdf}v¬ )nc¬ kmmn}noc¬ }o¬ }id¬ kgoxd¬ kjvo¬ atnmkcfd¬ oh ¬ vdkwfi¬ kcm¬
fwdk}noc¬oh ¬v~cdwandv.#¬]id¬qiojd¬|onc}¬nv¬}o¬mnvftvv¬}id¬ht}twd¬mdxdjo|`dc}¬oh ¬}id¬ncmtv}w~#¬Jkv}j~*¬
nccoxk}noc¬kcm¬v}kw}“t|¬vt||ow}¬kf}nxn}ndv¬)coc“hnckcfnkj.¬ nv¬kc¬ ncmnwdf}¬qk~¬}o¬kmmwdvv¬}id¬|wogjd`¬
oh ¬jofe“nc¬)v}n`tjk}noc¬oh ¬dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|.#¬G~¬|woxnmnca¬idj|¬kcm¬atnmkcfd¬how¬cdq¬dc}wd|wdcdtwv¬
mdxdjo|nca¬nccoxk}nxd
¬nmdkv
¬kcm
¬focfd|}v*
¬}id
¬wnve
¬oh
¬gdfo`nca
¬dc}wdcfidm
¬nc
¬dynv}nca
¬mo`nckc}
¬
joanfv¬ nv¬ wdmtfdm#¬ ]idvd¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ ncxojxd¬ k¬ `tj}n}tmd¬ oh ¬ kf}owv#¬ Nc¬ }id¬ fkvd¬ oh ¬ hoom¬ nc¬ }id¬ Veäcd¬
v~v}d`¬Jtcm¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬ikv¬ikm¬}id¬`ov}¬|wo`ncdc}¬wojd¬}oad}idw¬qn}i¬}id¬NV¬foowmnck}ow¬)VHNC.#¬¬
How¬}id¬fkvd¬oh ¬fjdkc“}dfi*¬kf}nxn}ndv¬wdjk}dm¬}o¬gtnjmnca¬cd}qowev¬oh ¬fjdkc“}dfi¬kf}owv¬kcm¬ohhdwnca¬
gtvncdvv¬fwdk}noc¬kcm¬mdxdjo|`dc}¬kmxnfd¬vdwxnfdv¬ nv¬k¬qk~¬}o¬idj|¬owakcnrk}nocv¬hncm¬ecoqjdmad“
wdjk}dm¬ fo`|jd`dc}kwn}ndv¬ kcm¬ inaijnai}¬ }id¬ |o}dc}nkj¬ oh ¬ fjdkc“}dfi¬ kv¬ k¬ `dkcv¬ oh ¬ fwdk}nca¬ cdq¬
gtvncdvv¬ o||ow}tcn}ndv¬ )hkfnjn}k}noc¬ oh ¬ v~cdwandv¬ kcm¬ jdan}n`k}noc.#¬ N`|ow}kc}¬ nvvtdv¬ how¬ }id¬ NV¬
foowmnck}ow¬ )VGI.¬ nv¬ }o¬ vioq¬ qk~v¬ nc¬ qinfi¬ fjdkc“}dfi¬ fkc¬ gd¬ mwkqc¬ oc¬ }o¬ fwdk}d¬ cdq¬ gtvncdvv¬
mdkjv*¬|womtf}v¬kcm¬vdwxnfdv¬kjvo¬qn}inc¬dynv}nca¬ncmtv}wndv#¬]inv¬nv¬nc}dcmdm¬}o¬o|dc¬t|¬how¬k¬gwokmdw¬
xndq¬ oc¬ qik}¬ fjdkc“}dfi¬ `dkcv¬ kcm¬ njjtv}wk}d¬ ioq¬ wdanockj¬ hnw`v¬ `k~¬ gdcdhn}¬ hwo`¬ ncfow|owk}nca¬
fjdkc“}dfi
¬vojt}nocv
¬nc
¬}idnw
¬dynv}nca
¬|womtf}
¬kcm
¬vdwxnfd
¬ohhdwnca#
¬]inv
¬nv
¬}itv
¬`tfi
¬kgot}
¬wdmtfnca
¬
}id¬wnve¬oh ¬jofe“nc¬qn}inc¬o}idw¬ncmtv}wndv¬}iwotai¬}id¬kmo|}noc¬oh ¬fjdkc¬}dficojoandv#¬
]inv¬ kckj~vnv¬ fo`|wnvdv¬ go}i¬ htcf}nockj¬ kcm¬ v}wtf}twkj¬ djd`dc}v*¬ }iotai¬ }id¬ hoftv¬ nv¬ oc¬ htcf}noc¬
wk}idw¬ }ikc¬ v}wtf}twd#¬ How¬ dkfi¬ fkvd¬ )fjdkc“}dfi*¬ `ognjd¬ fo``tcnfk}nocv¬ kcm¬ hoom.*¬ k¬ htw}idw¬
kckj~vnv¬oh ¬}id¬v}wtf}twkj¬mn`dcvnoc¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`¬fkc¬kjvo¬gd¬focmtf}dm#¬]inv¬fkc¬hwtn}htjj~¬gd¬mocd¬
g~¬ }id¬ mnxnvnoc¬ nc}o¬ |wn`kw~¬ kcm¬ vdfocmkw~¬ kf}owv#¬ Nc¬ }id¬ }iwdd¬ fkvdv¬ idwd¬ mnvftvvdm*¬ }idwd¬ nv¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 20/35
;9¬
¬
focvnmdwkgjd¬ oxdwjk|¬ nc¬ }dw`v¬ oh ¬ kf}owv#¬ ]inv¬ nv¬ co}¬ vtw|wnvnca¬ kv¬ }id~¬ vikwd¬ }id¬ vk`d¬ wdanockj¬
foc}dy}¬kcm¬}itv¬}o¬k¬jkwad¬dy}dc}¬}id¬vk`d¬WNV#¬
Kv¬ikv¬gddc¬gwndhj~¬mocd¬kgoxd*¬ nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬oh ¬|wn`kw~¬kcm¬vdfocmkw~¬kf}owv¬nv¬hwtn}htjj~¬mocd¬g~¬
fkvd/vdf}ow¬kcm¬g~¬htcf}noc¬ow¬dxdc¬g~¬kf}nxn}~#¬]inv¬nv¬gdfktvd¬}id¬kf}owv¬kwd¬co}¬ncidwdc}j~¬|wn`kw~¬
ow¬vdfocmkw~¬gt}¬wk}idw¬}idnw¬wojdv¬kv¬foc}ncadc}¬oc¬}id¬kf}nxn}~¬ow¬htcf}noc¬|dwhow`dm#¬]inv¬`dkcv¬
}ik}¬
nc¬
}id¬
`ognjnvk}noc¬
oh ¬
wdvotwfdv¬
kcm¬
ecoqjdmad¬
fwdk}noc¬
kcm¬
mnhhtvnoc¬
htcf}nocv¬
nc¬
`ognjd¬
fo``tcnfk}nocv¬kcm¬hoom*¬k¬|wn`kw~¬kf}ow¬nv¬}id¬jofkj¬tcnxdwvn}ndv#¬]id~¬kwd¬ioqdxdw¬nchjtdcfdm¬g~¬
vdfocmkw~¬ kf}owv¬ nc¬ }id¬ |womtf}noc¬ v}wtf}twd¬ )d#a#¬ `kbow¬ fo`|kcndv¬ nc¬ }id¬ v~v}d`.¬ kcm¬ nc¬ }id¬
vt||ow}¬ v}wtf}twd¬ )d#a#¬ }id¬ NV¬ foowmnck}owv¬ @ognjd¬ Idnai}v¬ kcm¬ VHNC.#¬ Nc¬ o}idw¬ dyk`|jdv¬ }id¬ NV¬
foowmnck}owv¬ focv}n}t}d¬ |wn`kw~¬ kf}owv5¬ d#a#¬ how¬ `kwed}¬ how`k}noc¬ kcm¬ nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬ qn}inc¬ fjdkc“
}dfi¬qidwd¬VGI¬|dwhow`¬}inv¬kf}nxn}~¬}id`vdjxdv#¬Kco}idw¬dyk`|jd¬ nv¬ nc¬atnmkcfd¬oh ¬vdkwfi¬qn}inc¬
hoom¬ qidwd¬ VHNC¬ nv¬ k¬ |wn`kw~¬ kf}ow¬ qidc¬ owakcnvnca¬ howdvnai}¬ atnjmv#¬ Kf}owv¬ hwo`¬ }id¬ ecoqjdmad¬
nchwkv}wtf}twd¬ kcm¬ |womtf}noc¬ v}wtf}twd¬ kwd¬ ioqdxdw¬ kjvo¬ kf}nxd¬ nc¬ |dwhow`nca¬ }id¬ kf}nxn}~¬ kcm¬
viotjm¬}itv¬kjvo¬gd¬vddc¬kv¬|wn`kw~¬kf}owv#¬¬
Dxdc¬kh}dw¬vtfi¬k¬gwndh ¬kckj~vnv¬oh ¬}id¬kf}owv¬ nc¬}id¬v~v}d`¬ n}¬ nv¬dxnmdc}¬}ik}¬}idwd¬kwd¬focvnmdwkgjd¬
nc}dwmd|dcmdcfndv¬qn}inc
¬}id
¬v~v}d`#
¬]id
¬vdfocmkw~
¬kf}owv
¬`k~
¬nc
¬`kc~
¬fkvdv
¬gd
¬}id
¬vk`d
¬kv
¬}id
¬
|wn`kw~¬ kf}owv*¬ }iotai¬ }id~¬ iojm¬ mnhhdwdc}¬ wojdv¬ nc¬ mnhhdwdc}¬ v~v}d`¬ vd}}ncav¬ kcm¬ htcf}nocv#¬ ]id¬
vdfocmkw~¬kf}owv¬kwd¬}iovd¬khhdf}nca¬}id¬gdikxnotw¬oh ¬ow¬ nc}dwkf}noc¬gd}qddc¬|wn`kw~¬kf}owv#¬Hwo`¬
}id¬ |wdvdc}k}noc¬ idwd¬ n}¬ viotjm¬ gd¬ fjdkw¬ }ik}¬ foowmnck}noc¬ modv¬ co}¬ `dkc¬ aoxdwckcfd¬ ow¬
`kckad`dc}¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`¬g~¬how¬dyk`|jd¬|tgjnf¬gomndv¬kcm¬aoxdwc`dc}¬ncn}nk}nxdv#¬Wk}idw¬n}¬nchdwv¬
kc¬ tcmdwv}kcmnca¬ oh ¬ qinfi¬ kf}owv¬ kcm¬ mnvd`gomndm¬ ncv}n}t}nockj¬ kwwkcad`dc}v¬ kwd¬ |wdvdc}¬ nc¬ }id¬
v~v}d`¬kcm¬qik}¬}idnw¬|o}dc}nkj¬foc}wngt}nocv¬ }o¬kcm¬ nchjtdcfd¬oc¬mnhhdwdc}¬vdf}owv¬kcm¬ ncmtv}wndv¬
kwd#¬¬
]id¬fkvdv¬mnvftvvdm¬kgoxd¬njjtv}wk}d¬}id¬cddm¬how¬foowmnck}noc¬gd}qddc¬kf}owv*¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬htcf}nocv*¬
kcm¬}id¬tcmdwj~nca¬|wogjd`v#¬]id¬v}kw}nca¬|onc}¬ikv¬gddc¬}id¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬|dwhow`dm*¬}w~nca¬}o¬
jnce¬}id`¬}o¬}id¬ htcf}nocv¬}id~¬|dwhow`¬kcm¬}id¬tcmdwj~nca¬|wogjd`v¬}ik}¬kwd¬}o¬gd¬kmmwdvvdm¬g~¬
}id¬ htcf}nocv#¬]id¬kckj~vnv¬vdwxdv¬ }id¬|tw|ovd¬oh ¬ njjtv}wk}nca¬}id¬ nc}dwwdjk}dmcdvv¬oh ¬}id¬v}wtf}twkj¬
kcm¬htcf}nockj¬mn`dcvnocv¬oh ¬WNVv#¬K¬vn`njkw¬kckj~vnv¬fkc¬oh ¬fotwvd¬kjvo¬gd¬mocd¬dy¬kc}d¬g~¬v}kw}nca¬
hwo`¬ }id¬tcmdwj~nca¬|wogjd`v¬ nc¬k¬WNV¬ nc¬owmdw¬ }o¬ nmdc}nh~¬qinfi¬ htcf}nocv¬kwd¬cddmdm¬ }o¬kmmwdvv¬
}idvd¬|wogjd`v¬kcm¬qinfi¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kwd¬`ov}¬dhhdf}nxd¬how¬|dwhow`nca¬}idvd¬htcf}nocv#¬]inv¬fkc¬}idc¬
gd¬fot|jdm¬qn}i¬k¬v}wtf}twkj¬kckj~vnv¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`5¬n#d#¬qinfi¬kf}owv¬kwd¬|wdvdc}¬kcm¬co}¬|wdvdc}¬nc¬
}id¬v~v}d`v¬|womtf}noc¬v}wtf}twd*¬ecoqjdmad¬ nchwkv}wtf}twd¬kcm¬vt||ow}¬v}wtf}twd¬kcm¬qinfi¬wojdv¬
)|wn`kw~/vdfocmkw~.¬fkc¬}idvd¬kf}owv¬ikxd¬ nc¬}id¬|dwhow`kcfd¬oh ¬}id¬kf}nxn}ndv#¬Kcm¬ jkv}j~*¬qik}¬ nv¬
}id¬nchjtdcfd¬hwo`¬}id¬ncv}n}t}nockj¬vd}}nca¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`¬oc¬}id¬htcf}nocnca¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬¬
¬¬
1# Focfjtvnocv¬
]inv¬|k|dw¬kmmwdvvdv¬}id¬nvvtd¬oh ¬|ojnf~¬foowmnck}noc¬nc¬v~v}d`v¬oh ¬nccoxk}noc¬hwo`¬}qo¬mn`dcvnocv2¬
v}wtf}twd¬ kcm¬ htcf}noc#¬ V}wtf}twd¬ kcm¬ htcf}noc¬ nv*¬ kv¬ @kwekwm¬ kcm¬ ]wthhdw¬ )7<<9.¬ |onc}¬ ot}*¬ }qo¬
nc}dw}qncdm¬vnmdv¬oh ¬}id¬vk`d¬ogbdf}*¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬Nc¬}id¬vk`d¬qk~¬kv¬v}wtf}twkj¬hkf}owv¬nchjtdcfd¬}id¬
htcf}nocv¬ )qik}¬ }id¬ v~v}d`¬ modv¬ kcm¬ ioq¬ n}¬ qowev.¬ }id¬ htcf}nockj¬ mn`dcvnoc¬ kjvo¬ nchjtdcfdv¬ }id¬
mdxdjo|`dc}¬oh ¬}id¬v}wtf}twd¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`¬oxdw¬}n`d#¬Kckj~vdv¬oh ¬kc¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`„v¬v}wtf}twkj¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 21/35
;>¬
¬
kcm¬ htcf}nockj¬ fo`|ocdc}v¬ `tv}¬ }idwdhowd¬ gd¬ `tj}n“fktvkj¬ kcm¬|woxnmd¬ vfo|d¬ how¬ nc}dwmd|dcmdc}¬
wdjk}nocvin|v¬gd}qddc¬kf}owv*¬kf}nxn}ndv¬kcm¬htcf}nocv¬)Dm{tnv}¬7<<4.#¬]inv¬|k|dw¬}itv¬wdjk}dv¬}o¬}id¬
fwn}n{td¬ kakncv}¬ NV¬ wdvdkwfi¬ how¬ |jkfnca¬ }oo¬ `tfi¬ d`|ikvnv¬ oc¬ }id¬ kf}owv¬ )kf}ow“fdc}wnf¬ k||wokfi.¬
kcm¬co}¬dcotai¬oc¬}id¬v~v}d`¬kv¬k¬qiojd¬kcm¬qik}¬kf}tkjj~¬fo`dv¬ot}¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`¬ nc¬}dw`v¬oh ¬
m~ck`nfv¬)Dm{tnv}¬;>>15¬Jnt¬kcm¬Qin}d¬7<<;.#¬¬
K¬
v~v}d`nf¬
htcf}nockj“v}wtf}twkj
¬k||wokfi
¬}o
¬nccoxk}noc
¬|ojnf~
¬kfecoqjdmadv
¬}id
¬hkf}
¬}ik}
¬k¬
`tj}n}tmd¬oh ¬kf}owv¬kwd¬ ncxojxdm¬ nc¬kf}nxn}ndv¬ }o¬|wo`o}d¬ nccoxk}noc#¬Jkfenca¬tcmdwv}kcmnca¬oh ¬ }id¬
tcmdwj~nca¬|wogjd`v¬kcm¬}id¬dcxnwoc`dc}¬nc¬qinfi¬}id¬v~v}d`¬nv¬vd}*¬`k~¬wdvtj}¬nc¬ncdhhdf}nxd¬|ojnf~¬
`dkvtwdv#¬ Foowmnck}noc¬ qn}inc¬ }id¬ indwkwfi~¬ oh ¬ |wogjd`v*¬ kf}nxn}ndv*¬ kcm¬ htcf}nocv¬ nv¬ d{tkjj~¬
n`|ow}kc}#¬Mdvnacnca¬|ojnf~¬kf}nxn}ndv¬`tv}¬}idwdhowd¬gd¬wdjk}dm¬}o¬}id¬NV¬htcf}nocv¬}ik}¬gdv}¬kmmwdvv¬
}id¬|wogjd`v¬nmdc}nhndm¬kcm¬ncfjtmd¬wdjdxkc}¬kf}owv¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`#¬¬
]idwd¬ nv¬ ogxnotvj~¬ co¬ adcdwnf¬ o|}n`kj¬ v}wtf}twd¬ oh ¬ kc¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`¬ kfwovv¬ kjj¬ ncmtv}wnkj¬ kcm¬
dfoco`nfkj¬ foc}dy}v¬ )@kjdwgk¬ 7<<75¬ @kwekwm¬ kcm¬ ]wthhdw¬ 7<<9.#¬ ]inv¬ |k|dw¬ ot}jncdm¬ k¬ wkcad¬ oh ¬
v|dfnhnf¬ |wogjd`v¬ hkfnca¬ mnhhdwdc}¬ ncmtv}wndv¬ nc¬ }id¬ wdanockj¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`¬ oh ¬ Veäcd*¬ kcm¬
kckj~vdm¬ioq¬mnhhdwdc}¬kf}owv¬hnjj¬mnhhdwdc}¬wojdv¬nc¬}id¬v~v}d`*¬~d}¬kfecoqjdmanca¬}ik}¬}id¬htcf}nocv¬
}id~¬|dwhow`
¬kcm
¬|wo`o}d
¬nc
¬`kc~
¬fkvdv
¬kwd
¬v}wocaj~
¬oxdwjk||nca#
¬]inv
¬wknvdv
¬k¬cddm
¬how
¬|ojnf~
¬
foowmnck}noc*¬co}¬ocj~¬oh ¬}id¬kf}owv¬kcm¬}idnw¬wdv|df}nxd¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬gt}¬kjvo¬oh ¬}id¬gwokmdw¬v~v}d`nf¬
htcf}nocv¬ }o¬ qinfi¬ }idvd¬ kf}nxn}ndv¬ fojjdf}nxdj~¬ foc}wngt}d#¬ ]id¬ }iwdd¬ vdf}ow¬ owndc}dm¬ wdanockj¬
ncmtv}w~¬vt||ow}¬fokjn}nocv¬kvvdvvdm¬nc¬}id¬|k|dw¬mdkj¬qn}i¬|ojnf~¬foowmnck}noc¬oc¬}id¬jdxdj¬oh ¬kf}owv¬
kcm¬kf}nxn}ndv*¬qinjd¬}id¬wdanockj¬kt}iown}~¬ )Wdanoc¬Veäcd.¬ftwwdc}j~¬`kedv¬k}}d`|}v¬}o¬foowmnck}d¬
}id¬ gwokmdw¬ v~v}d`nf¬ htcf}nocv¬ qinfi¬ }idvd¬ vt||ow}¬ fokjn}nocv¬ )kcm¬ o}idw¬ kf}owv¬ nc¬ }id¬ wdanoc.¬
|woxnmd¬kcm¬|wo`o}d#¬]idwd¬ nv¬v}njj*¬ioqdxdw*¬kc¬d`|nwnfkj¬{tdv}noc¬}o¬qik}¬dy}dc}¬}idvd¬dhhow}v¬oh ¬
v~v}d`nf¬foowmnck}noc¬qnjj¬`dd}¬}id¬aokj#¬
¬ ¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 22/35
7<¬
¬
Gngjnoawk|i~¬
Kw}itw*¬ Q#¬ Gwnkc¬ );>9>.*¬ 'Fo`|d}nca¬ ]dficojoandv*¬ Ncfwdkvnca¬ Wd}twcv*¬ kcm¬ Jofe“Nc¬ g~¬ Inv}ownfkj¬Dxdc}v*'¬]id¬Dfoco`nf¬Botwckj*¬>>¬)6>=.*¬;;8“6;#¬
Kw}itw*¬ Q#¬ Gwnkc¬ );>>=.*¬ Ncfwdkvnca¬ wd}twcv¬ kcm¬ |k}i¬ md|dcmdcfd¬ nc¬ }id¬ dfoco`~#¬ Kcc¬ Kwgow*2¬f;>>=#¬
Gdwade*¬
Kcck*¬
V}khhkc¬
Bkfogvvoc*¬
Go¬
Fkwjvvoc*¬
Vxdc¬
Jncm`kwe*¬
kcm¬
Kccnek¬
Wnfecd¬
)7<<9k.*¬
'Kckj~rnca¬
}id¬ htcf}nockj¬ m~ck`nfv¬ oh ¬ }dficojoanfkj¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v2¬ K¬ vfid`d¬ oh ¬ kckj~vnv*'¬
Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬61¬)6.*¬=<1“7>#¬Gdwade*¬Kcck*¬V}khhkc¬Bkfogvvoc*¬kcm¬Gbøwc¬K#¬Vkcmîc¬)7<<9g.*¬'!Jdan}n`k}noc!¬kcm¬!mdxdjo|`dc}¬oh ¬
|ovn}nxd¬dy}dwckjn}ndv!2¬}qo¬ed~¬|wofdvvdv¬nc¬}id¬how`k}noc¬|ikvd¬oh ¬}dficojoanfkj¬nccoxk}noc¬
v~v}d`v*'¬]dficojoa~¬Kckj~vnv¬(¬V}wk}danf¬@kckad`dc}*¬7<¬)4.*¬414“>7#¬Gowa*¬ Idcwne¬ )7<<4.*¬ 'Mdc¬ Veäcvek¬ Jnxv`dmdjvncmtv}wnc¬ “¬ \wobde}wk||ow}¬ nco`¬ Veäcdv¬ ncmtv}wndjjk¬
kwx#'¬Ewnv}nkcv}km2¬Wdanoc`tvdd}¬Ewnv}nkcv}km/¬Jkcmvkc}nexkwndc¬n¬Veäcd#¬Gowwëv*¬Vtvkck¬kcm¬M¬]vkamnv¬)7<<9.*¬Fjtv}dw¬\ojnfndv¬nc¬Dtwo|d2¬Hnw`v*¬Ncv}n}t}nocv*¬kcm¬Aoxdwckcfd#¬
Fidj}dcik`2¬Dmqkwm¬Djakw#¬Govfi`k*¬Woc¬)7<<>.*¬'Dxojt}nockw~¬dfoco`nf¬adoawk|i~¬kcm¬n}v¬n`|jnfk}nocv¬how¬wdanockj¬nccoxk}noc¬
|ojnf~#'¬T}wdfi}2¬ODFM#¬Govfi`k*¬Woc¬ )7<<4.*¬'\woyn`n}~¬kcm¬ Nccoxk}noc2¬K¬Fwn}nfkj¬Kvvdvv`dc}#*'¬Wdanockj¬V}tmndv*¬6>¬ );.*¬
8;“14#¬Gtnvvdwd}*¬]#*¬I#¬Fk`dwoc*¬kcm¬J#¬Adowainot¬);>>4.*¬'Qik}¬mnhhdwdcfd¬modv¬n}¬`ked?¬Kmmn}nockjn}~¬nc¬
}id¬|tgjnf¬vt||ow}¬oh ¬W(M¬nc¬jkwad¬hnw`v*'¬Nc}dwck}nockj¬Botwckj¬oh ¬]dficojoa~¬@kckad`dc}*¬;<¬)=“8.*¬491“8<<#¬
Fkwjvvoc*¬ Go*¬ V}khhkc¬ Bkfogvvoc*¬ @kactv¬ Ioj`dc*¬ kcm¬ Kccnek¬ Wnfecd¬ )7<<7.*¬ 'Nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v2¬Kckj~}nfkj¬kcm¬`d}iomojoanfkj¬nvvtdv*'¬Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬6;¬)7.*¬766“=4#¬
Fikw`nckmd*¬Fwnv}nck¬kcm¬Fikwjdv¬Dm{tnv}¬)7<<8.*¬'Hwo`¬}idow~¬}o¬|wkf}nfd2¬}id¬tvd¬oh ¬}id¬v~v}d`v¬oh ¬nccoxk}noc¬k||wokfi¬ nc¬ nccoxk}noc¬|ojnf~*'¬ nc¬Nccoxk}noc*¬Vfndcfd*¬kcm ¬Ncv}n}t}nockj ¬Fikcad*¬Bdwkjm¬Ikad¬kcm¬@kwntv¬@ddtv*¬dmv#¬Oyhowm2¬Oyhowm¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬\wdvv#¬
Fidvgwotai*¬Idcw~¬Q#¬)7<<6.*¬O|dc¬nccoxk}noc¬2¬}id¬cdq¬n`|dwk}nxd¬how¬fwdk}nca¬kcm¬|wohn}nca¬hwo`¬
}dficojoa~#¬Gov}oc*¬@kvv#2¬Ikwxkwm¬Gtvncdvv¬Vfiooj¬\wdvv#¬Fjkw~vvd*¬Gkw}*¬@ned¬Qwnai}*¬kcm¬\injn||d¬@tv}kw¬)7<<>.*¬'Gdikxnotwkj¬kmmn}nockjn}~¬oh ¬W(M¬vtgvnmndv2¬
K¬jdkwcnca
¬|dwv|df}nxd*'
¬Wdvdkwfi
¬\ojnf~*
¬69
¬);<.*
¬;4;1
“66#
¬
Foidc*¬ Qdvjd~¬ @#¬ ¬ kcm¬ Mkcndj¬ K#¬ Jdxnc}ikj¬ );>><.*¬ 'Kgvow|}nxd¬ Fk|kfn}~2¬ K¬ Cdq¬ \dwv|df}nxd¬ oc¬
Jdkwcnca¬kcm¬Nccoxk}noc*'¬Km`ncnv}wk}nxd¬Vfndcfd¬[tkw}dwj~*¬64¬);.*¬;79“47#¬Dm{tnv}*¬Fikwjdv¬ )7<;;.*¬ 'Mdvnac¬oh ¬ Nccoxk}noc¬\ojnf~¬ }iwotai¬ Mnkacov}nf¬ Kckj~vnv2¬ Nmdc}nhnfk}noc¬oh ¬
V~v}d`nf¬\wogjd`v¬)ow¬Hknjtwdv.*'¬Ncmtv}wnkj¬kcm¬Fow|owk}d¬Fikcad*¬How}ifo`nca#¬Dm{tnv}*¬ Fikwjdv¬ )7<<4.*¬ 'V~v}d`v¬ oh ¬ nccoxk}noc2¬ \dwv|df}nxdv¬ kcm¬ Fikjjdcadv*'¬ nc¬ ]id¬ Oyhowm ¬
ikcmgooe ¬ oh ¬ nccoxk}noc*¬ Bkc¬ Hkadwgdwa¬ kcm¬ Mkxnm¬ F#¬ @oqdw~¬ kcm¬ Wnfikwm¬ W#¬ Cdjvoc*¬ dmv#¬Oyhowm2¬Oyhowm¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬\wdvv#¬
Dm{tnv}*¬ Fikwjdv¬ Dm#¬ );>>1.*¬ V~v}d`v¬ oh ¬ nccoxk}noc2¬ }dficojoandv*¬ ncv}n}t}nocv*¬ kcm¬ owakcnrk}nocv#¬Jocmoc2¬\wnc}dw¬\tgjnvidwv/Fkv}djj¬Kfkmd`nf#¬
Hkje*¬Wkidj¬)7<<1.*¬'@dkvtwnca¬}id¬dhhdf}v¬oh ¬|tgjnf¬vt||ow}¬vfid`dv¬oc¬hnw`v!¬nccoxk}noc¬kf}nxn}ndv2¬Vtwxd~¬dxnmdcfd¬hwo`¬Ktv}wnk*'¬Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬68¬)4.*¬884“1>#¬
HOWK¬)7<<>.*
¬'Eow}jèacnca
¬kh
¬`njbù}decojoanved
¬xnwevo`idmdw
¬n¬Mkc`kwe
¬'#
¬
Hwdd`kc*¬ Fiwnv}o|idw¬ );>91.*¬ ]dficojoa~¬ |ojnf~¬ kcm¬ dfoco`nf¬ |dwhow`kcfd2¬ jdvvocv¬ hwo`¬ Bk|kc#¬Jocmoc2¬\nc}dw#¬
Adowainot*¬Jted¬kcm¬Mkxnm¬Wodvvcdw¬)7<<<.*¬'Dxkjtk}nca¬}dficojoa~¬|woawk`v2¬}oojv¬kcm¬`d}iomv*'¬
Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬7>¬)=“4.*¬841“19#¬Awkcoxd}}dw*¬@kwe¬);>94.*¬'Dfoco`nf¬Kf}noc¬kcm¬Vofnkj¬V}wtf}twd2¬]id¬\wogjd`¬oh ¬D`gdmmdmcdvv*'¬
]id¬K`dwnfkc¬Botwckj¬oh ¬Vofnojoa~*¬>;¬)6.*¬=9;“4;<#¬Ikcckc*¬ @nfikdj¬ ]#¬ kcm¬ Boic¬ Hwdd`kc¬ );>9=.*¬ 'V}wtf}twkj¬ Ncdw}nk¬ kcm¬ Owakcnrk}nockj¬ Fikcad*'¬
K`dwnfkc¬Vofnojoanfkj¬Wdxndq*¬=>¬)7.*¬;=>“8=#¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 23/35
7;¬
¬
Ideedw}*¬@kweo¬\#¬kcm¬Vn`ock¬O#¬Cdawo¬)7<<>.*¬'Htcf}nocv¬oh ¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬kv¬k¬hwk`dqowe¬}o¬
tcmdwv}kcm¬ vtv}knckgjd¬ }dficojoanfkj¬ fikcad2¬ D`|nwnfkj¬ dxnmdcfd¬ how¬ dkwjndw¬ fjkn`v*'¬
]dficojoanfkj¬Howdfkv}nca¬kcm¬Vofnkj¬Fikcad*¬18¬)=.*¬49=“>=#¬Ideedw}*¬ @kweo¬ \#*¬ W#K#K#¬ Vttwv*¬ Vn`ock¬ O#¬ Cdawo*¬ V#¬ Etij`kcc*¬ kcm¬ W#D#I#@¬ V`n}v¬ )7<<1.*¬
'Htcf}nocv¬ oh ¬ nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v2¬ k¬ cdq¬ k||wokfi¬ how¬ kckj~vnca¬ }dficojoanfkj¬ fikcad*'¬
]dficojoanfkj¬Howdfkv}nca¬kcm¬Vofnkj¬Fikcad*¬1=¬)=.*¬=;6“67#¬
Idccnca*¬
@kw}nc*¬
Bdwedw¬
@oom~vvoc*¬
kcm¬
@kactv¬
Cnjvvoc¬
)7<;<.*¬
Nccoxk}noc¬
kcm¬
Wdanockj¬]wkcvhow`k}noc2¬Hwo`¬Fjtv}dwv¬}o¬Cdq¬Fo`gnck}nocv#¬@kj`ø2¬Wdanoc¬Veäcd#¬
Nvkevdc*¬Kwcd¬)7<<;.*¬'Gtnjmnca¬Wdanockj¬Nccoxk}noc¬V~v}d`v2¬Nv¬Dcmoadcotv¬Ncmtv}wnkj¬Mdxdjo|`dc}¬\ovvngjd¬nc¬}id¬Ajogkj¬Dfoco`~?*'¬Fkckmnkc¬Botckj¬oh ¬Wdanockj¬Vfndcfd*¬;*¬;<;“7<#¬
Boicvoc*¬ Kcck¬ kcm¬ V}khhkc¬ Bkfogvvoc¬ )7<<<.*¬ 'Ncmtfd`dc}¬ kcm¬ gjofenca¬ `dfikcnv`v¬ nc¬ }id¬
mdxdjo|`dc}¬ oh ¬ k¬ cdq¬ ncmtv}w~2¬ }id¬ fkvd¬ oh ¬ wdcdqkgjd¬ dcdwa~¬ }dficojoa~¬ nc¬ Vqdmdc*'¬ nc¬
]dficojoa~ ¬kcm ¬}id¬`kwed}2¬md`kcm*¬tvdwv¬kcm ¬nccoxk}noc¬Wom¬Foo`gv¬kcm¬Edc¬Awddc¬kcm¬
Kjgdw}¬Wnfikwmv¬kcm¬Xnxndc¬Qkjvi*¬dmv#¬Fidj}dcik`2¬Dmqkwm¬Djakw#¬Ed`|ncve~*¬\d}dw*¬ Bkc¬ Vkcmwdm*¬ kcm¬Mkc¬ Vbøawdc¬ )7<;;.*¬'Itcmwk¬äw¬kx¬dwhkwdcid}2¬Jíwmo`kw¬ hwäc¬
Xnccxíy}¬7<<;“7<;;#'¬V}ofeioj`2¬XNCCOXK¬“¬Vqdmnvi¬Aoxdwc`dc}kj¬Kadcf~¬how¬Nccoxk}noc¬
V~v}d`v#¬Ejdnc¬ Qooj}itnv*¬ Wovkjncmd¬ *¬ @ktwddc¬ Jkceitnrdc*¬ kcm¬ Xnf}ow¬ Anjvnca¬ )7<<4.*¬ 'K¬ v~v}d`¬ hknjtwd¬
hwk`dqowe¬
how¬
nccoxk}noc¬
|ojnf~¬
mdvnac*'¬
]dficoxk}noc*¬
74¬
)8.*¬
8<>“
;>#¬
Jnt*¬Yndjnc¬kcm¬V}dxdc¬Qin}d¬)7<<;.*¬'Fo`|kwnca¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v2¬k¬hwk`dqowe¬kcm¬k||jnfk}noc¬}o¬
Finck!v¬}wkcvn}nockj¬foc}dy}*'¬Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬6<¬)1.*¬;<>;“;;=#¬Jtekv*¬Gw~kc¬K#*¬Btv}nc¬B#¬]kc*¬kcm¬]o`kv¬A#¬Itj}¬)7<<;.*¬'V}wk}danf¬hn}¬nc¬}wkcvn}nockj¬dfoco`ndv2¬]id¬
fkvd¬oh ¬Finck„v¬djdf}wocnfv¬ncmtv}w~*'¬Botwckj¬oh ¬@kckad`dc}*¬71¬)=.*¬=<>“7>#¬Jtcmxkjj*¬ Gdca}“Äed¬ )7<<1.*¬ 'Ck}nockj¬ Nccoxk}noc¬ V~v}d`v”Kckj~}nfkj¬ Focfd|}¬ kcm¬ Mdxdjo|`dc}¬
]ooj*'¬Ncmtv}w~¬kcm¬Nccoxk}noc*¬;=¬);.*¬>4“;;>#¬Jtcmxkjj*¬ Gdca}“Äed¬ );>>7.*¬ Ck}nockj¬ v~v}d`v¬ oh ¬ nccoxk}noc¬ 2¬ }oqkwmv¬ k¬ }idow~¬ oh ¬ nccoxk}noc¬ kcm¬
nc}dwkf}nxd¬jdkwcnca#¬Jocmoc2¬\nc}dw#¬Jtcmxkjj*¬Gdca}“Äed¬kcm¬Vtvkck¬Gowwëv¬)7<<4.*¬'Vfndcfd*¬]dficojoa~*¬kcm¬Nccoxk}noc¬\ojnf~*'¬nc¬]id¬
Oyhowm ¬Ikcmgooe ¬oh ¬Nccoxk}noc*¬Bkc¬Hkadwgdwa¬kcm¬Mkxnm¬F#¬@oqdw~¬kcm¬Wnfikwm¬W#¬Cdjvoc*¬dmv#¬Oyhowm2¬Oyhowm¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬\wdvv#¬
@kjdwgk*¬ Hwkcfo¬ )7<<7.*¬ 'Vdf}owkj¬ v~v}d`v¬ oh ¬ nccoxk}noc¬ kcm¬ |womtf}noc*'¬Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬ 6;¬ )7.*¬7=1“8=#¬
@kwekwm*¬Bofidc¬kcm¬Gdwcikwm¬]wthhdw¬)7<<9.*¬']dficojoanfkj¬nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬kcm¬}id¬`tj}n“jdxdj¬|dwv|df}nxd2¬]oqkwmv¬kc¬nc}dawk}dm¬hwk`dqowe*'¬Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬61¬)=.*¬4>8“8;4#¬
Ckwtjk*¬Wkbcddvi¬)7<<7.*¬'Nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`v¬kcm¬!ncdw}nk!¬nc¬W(M¬jofk}noc2¬Cowqdankc¬hnw`v¬kcm¬}id¬
wojd¬oh ¬v~v}d`nf¬jofe“nc*'¬Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬6;¬)4.*¬1>4“9;8#¬Cktqdjkdwv*¬ Fjknwd¬ kcm¬ Wdcî¬ Qnc}bdv¬ )7<<7.*¬ 'Nccoxk}nca¬ V@Dv¬ kcm¬ Wdanocv2¬ ]id¬ Cddm¬ how¬ \ojnf~¬
Nc}djjnadcfd¬kcm¬ Nc}dwkf}nxd¬\ojnfndv*'¬]dficojoa~¬Kckj~vnv¬(¬V}wk}danf¬@kckad`dc}*¬;=¬)7.*¬7<;“;4#¬
Cdawo*¬Vn`ock¬O#*¬@kweo¬\#¬Ideedw}*¬kcm¬Wttm¬D#¬V`n}v¬)7<<1.*¬'Dy|jkncnca¬}id¬hknjtwd¬oh ¬}id¬Mt}fi¬
nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`¬how¬gno`kvv¬mnadv}noc““K¬htcf}nockj¬kckj~vnv*'¬Dcdwa~¬\ojnf~*¬64¬)7.*¬>74“
69#¬Cow}i*¬Motajkvv¬F#¬);>><.*¬Ncv}n}t}nocv*¬Ncv}n}t}nockj¬Fikcad¬kcm¬Dfoco`nf¬\dwhow`kcfd#¬Fk`gwnmad2¬
Fk`gwnmad¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬\wdvv#¬Cow}i*¬ Motajkvv¬ F#¬ );>>7.*¬ ']wkcvkf}noc¬ fov}v*¬ ncv}n}t}nocv*¬ kcm¬ dfoco`nf¬ |dwhow`kcfd*'¬
Nc}dwck}nockj¬Fdc}dw¬how¬Dfoco`nf¬Awoq}i*¬Offkvnockj¬\k|dwv¬Co#¬6<#¬\kxn}}*¬Edn}i¬)7<<4.*¬'Nccoxk}noc¬\wofdvvdv¬'¬ nc¬]id¬Oyhowm¬Ikcmgooe¬oh ¬ Nccoxk}noc*¬Bkc¬Hkadwgdwa¬
kcm¬Mkxnm¬F#¬@oqdw~¬kcm¬Wnfikwm¬W#¬Cdjvoc¬)Dmv#.#¬Oyhowm2¬Oyhowm¬Tcnxdwvn}~¬\wdvv#¬V|dcfdw*¬ Bdccnhdw¬Q#¬ )7<<6.*¬'Hnw`v!¬ecoqjdmad“vikwnca¬v}wk}dandv¬ nc¬}id¬ajogkj¬ nccoxk}noc¬v~v}d`2¬
d`|nwnfkj¬dxnmdcfd¬hwo`¬}id¬hjk}¬|kcdj¬mnv|jk~¬ ncmtv}w~*'¬V}wk}danf¬@kckad`dc}¬Botwckj*¬7=¬
)6.*¬7;1“66#¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 24/35
77¬
¬
VQDC]DF¬)7<<1.*¬'Vxdcve¬`njbø}decne¬n¬vnhhwow#'¬V}ofeioj`#¬]øm}jnca*¬ H#¬ kcm¬ @#¬ ]wn||j¬ )7<<4.*¬ 'Ocd¬ vnrd¬ hn}v¬ kjj?¬ ]oqkwmv¬ k¬ mnhhdwdc}nk}dm¬ wdanockj¬ nccoxk}noc¬
|ojnf~¬k||wokfi*'¬Wdvdkwfi¬\ojnf~*¬6=¬)9.*¬;7<6“;>#¬]øm}jnca*¬ Hwkcr¬ kcm¬ Kjdykcmdw¬ Ekth`kcc¬ );>>>.*¬ 'Nccoxk}noc¬ v~v}d`v¬ nc¬ wdanocv¬ oh ¬ Dtwo|d”k¬
fo`|kwk}nxd¬|dwv|df}nxd*'¬Dtwo|dkc¬\jkccnca¬V}tmndv*¬1¬)8.*¬8>>“1;1#¬Xdcek}wk`kc*¬C#¬kcm¬Boic¬D#¬¬\wdvfo}}¬);>><.*¬'Dcxnwoc`dc}“v}wk}da~¬fokjnac`dc}2¬Kc¬d`|nwnfkj¬}dv}¬
oh ¬n}v
¬|dwhow`kcfd
¬n`|jnfk}nocv*'
¬V}wk}danf
¬@kckad`dc}
¬Botwckj*
¬;;
¬);.*
¬;“76#
¬Qnjjnk`voc*¬ Ojnxdw¬ D#¬ )7<<<.*¬ ']id¬ Cdq¬ Ncv}n}t}nockj¬ Dfoco`nfv2¬ ]kenca¬ V}ofe*¬ Jooenca¬ Kidkm*'¬
Botwckj¬oh ¬Dfoco`nf¬Jn}dwk}twd*¬69¬)6.*¬4>4“8;6#¬
¬
¬
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 25/35
FNWFJD DJDF]WOCNF QOWENCA \K\DWV VDWNDV )DQ\.
FNWFJD )Fdc}wd how Nccoxk}noc* Wdvdkwfi kcm Fo`|d}dcfd nc }id JdkwcncaDfoco`~. nv k `tj}nmnvfn|jnckw~ wdvdkwfi fdc}wd vd} ohh g~ vdxdwkj hkftj}ndv k} JtcmTcnxdwvn}~ kcm Gjdencad Ncv}n}t}d oh ]dficojoa~# FNWFJD ikv k `kcmk}d }o focmtf}`tj}nmnvfn|jnckw~ wdvdkwfi kcm dmtfk}noc oc }id hojjoqnca nvvtdv2 Joca-}dw`|dwv|df}nxdv oc nccoxk}noc* v}wtf}twkj fikcad kcm dfoco`nf awoq}i*Dc}wd|wdcdtwvin| kcm xdc}twd fk|n}kj how`k}noc qn}i k v|dfnkj hoftv oc cdq xdc}twdv*]id m~ck`nfv oh W(M v~v}d`v kcm }dficojoanfkj v~v}d`v* ncfjtmnca }idnw n`|kf} ocdc}wd|wdcdtwvin| kcm awoq}i* Wdanockj nccoxk}noc v~v}d`v nc mnhhdwdc} ck}nockj kcmnc}dwck}nockj foc}dy}v kcm Nc}dwck}nockj fo`|kwk}nxd kckj~vdv oh ck}nockj nccoxk}nocv~v}d`v# V|dfnkj d`|ikvnv nv mocd oc nccoxk}noc |ojnfndv kcm wdvdkwfi |ojnfndv# ;<ck}nockjn}ndv kcm ;= mnvfn|jncdv kwd wd|wdvdc}dm k`oca }id FNWFJD v}khh#
]id FNWFJD Djdf}wocnf Qowenca \k|dw Vdwndv kwd nc}dcmdm }o gd kc ncv}wt`dc} howdkwj~ mnvvd`nck}noc oh }id wdvdkwfi tcmdw}kedc g~ FNWFJD wdvdkwfidwv* kvvofnk}dvkcm xnvn}nca vfiojkwv kcm v}n`tjk}d mnvftvvnoc kcm fwn}nfkj fo``dc}#
]id qowenca |k|dwv |wdvdc} wdvdkwfi wdvtj}v }ik} nc qiojd ow nc |kw} kwd vtn}kgjd how
vtg`nvvnoc }o k wdhdwddm botwckj ow }o }id dmn}ow oh k gooe ow ikxd kjwdkm~ gddcvtg`n}}dm kcm/ow kffd|}dm how |tgjnfk}noc#
FNWFJD DQ\v kwd kxknjkgjd oc-jncd k}2 i}}|2//qqq#fnwfjd#jt#vd/|tgjnfk}nocv
Kxknjkgjd |k|dwv2
7<;;
Q\ 7<;;/<;V@Dv„ kgvow|}nxd fk|kfn}ndv kcm jkwad hnw`v„ ecoqjdmad v|njjoxdwv2 @nfwodxnmdcfd hwo` @dynfo
Fjktmnk md Htdc}dv kcm Akgwndjk Mt}wîcn}Q\ 7<;;/<7Fo`|kwnca ecoqjdmad gkvdv2 oc }id owakcnvk}noc kcm adoawk|i~ ohecoqjdmad hjoqv nc }id wdanockj nccoxk}noc v~v}d` oh Vfkcnk* vot}idwc VqdmdcWo`kc @kw}nc kcm Bdwedw @oom~vvoc
Q\ 7<;;/<6Owakcnrk}nockj |k}iv oh fo``dwfnkjnrnca |k}dc}dm ncxdc}nocv2 ]id dhhdf}v oh}wkcvkf}noc fov}v* hnw` fk|kgnjn}ndv* kcm fojjkgowk}nxd }ndv]kdi~tc Btca kcm Boic \# Qkjvi
Q\ 7<;;/<=
Ajogkj Nccoxk}noc Cd}qowev2 qik} kwd }id~ kcm qidwd fkc qd hncm }id`?)Focfd|}tkj kcm D`|nwnfkj nvvtdv.Idjdck Gkwckwm kcm Fwnv}nck Fik`nckmd
Q\ 7<;;/<4Vqdmnvi Gtvncdvv W(M kcm n}v Dy|ow} Md|dcmdcfdEkwnc Gdwa`kc kcm Ojoh Dbdw`o
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 26/35
Q\ 7<;;/<8Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~ Mdvnac2 Nmdc}nhnfk}noc oh V~v}d`nf \wogjd`v Fikwjdv Dm{tnv}
Q\ 7<;;/<1Wdanockj Ncv}n}t}nockj Dcxnwoc`dc} kcm N}v N`|kf} oc Nc}wk-hnw` kcm Nc}dw-owakcnvk}nockj Nccoxk}noc Cd}qowev2 K Fo`|kwk}nxd Fkvd V}tm~ nc Finck kcmVqn}rdwjkcmBt JNT
Q\ 7<;;/<9Dc}wd|wdcdtwvin|2 Dy|jownca }id Ecoqjdmad GkvdIkcv Jkcmv}wø`* Aot~k Ikwnwfin kcm Hwdmwne Äv}wø`
Q\ 7<;;/<>\ojnf~ foowmnck}noc nc v~v}d`v oh nccoxk}noc2 K v}wtf}twkj-htcf}nockj kckj~vnvoh wdanockj ncmtv}w~ vt||ow} nc Vqdmdc@kactv Cnjvvoc kcm Bdwedw @oom~vvoc
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 27/35
7<;<
Q\ 7<;</<;Nccoxk}noc |ojnfndv how mdxdjo|`dc}2 }oqkwmv k v~v}d`nf dy|dwn`dc}k}nocgkvdm k||wokfiFwnv}nck Fik`nckmd* Gdca}-Ked Jtcmxkjj* Bkc Xkca-Jktwnmvdc kcm EB Bovd|i
Q\ 7<;</<7Hwo` Gkvnf Wdvdkwfi }o Nccoxk}noc2 Dc}wd|wdcdtwnkj Nc}dw`dmnkwndv howWdvdkwfi Fo``dwfnkjnrk}noc k} Vqdmnvi ’V}woca Wdvdkwfi Dcxnwoc`dc}v„Ht`n En}kakqk kcm Fkwojncd Qnawdc
Q\ 7<;</<6 Mnhhdwdc} fo`|d}dcfdv* mnhhdwdc} `omdv nc }id ajogkjnrk}noc ohnccoxk}noc?K fo`|kwk}nxd v}tm~ oh }id \tcd kcm Gdnbnca wdanocv@ocnfk \jdfidwo kcm Fwnv}nck Fik`nckmd
Q\ 7<;</<= ]dficojoanfkj Fk|kgnjn}~ Gtnjmnca nc Nchow`kj Hnw`v nc }idKawnftj}twkj
Vtgvnv}dcfd Vdf}ow Nc ]kcrkcnk2 Kvvdvvnca }id Wojd oh Ak}vg~ FjtgvKv}wnm Vroav kcm Edjdhk @qkc}n`k
Q\ 7<;</<4]id Vqdmnvi \kwkmoy ‖ Tcdy|jon}dm O||ow}tcn}ndv+Fikwjdv Dm{tnv}
Q\ 7<;</<8K }iwdd-v}kad `omdj oh }id Kfkmd`~-Ncmtv}w~ jncenca |wofdvv2 }id |dwv|df}nxdoh go}i kadc}v Fjktmnk Md Htdc}dv kcm Akgwndjk Mt}wîcn}
Q\ 7<;</<1Nccoxk}noc nc v~`gojnf ncmtv}wndv2 }id adoawk|i~ kcm owakcnvk}noc ohecoqjdmad votwfncaWo`kc @kw}nc kcm Bdwedw @oom~vvoc
Q\ 7<;</<9]oqkwmv k v|k}nkj |dwv|df}nxd oc vtv}knckgnjn}~ }wkcvn}nocvJkwv Fodcdc* \ktj Gdccdqow}i kcm Gdwcikwm ]wthhdw
Q\ 7<;</<>]id Vqdmnvi ck}nockj nccoxk}noc v~v}d` kcm n}v wdjdxkcfd how }id d`dwadcfdoh ajogkj nccoxk}noc cd}qowevFwnv}nck Fik`nckmd* Boc @nedj Rkgkjk kcm Kmdjd ]wdffkcn
Q\ 7<;</;<Qio jdkmv Wdvdkwfi \womtf}nxn}~ Fikcad? Atnmdjncdv how W(M |ojnf~ `kedwvHdwckcmo Bn`îcdr-Vëdr* Boc @nedj Rkgkjk kcm Bovî J- Rohào
Q\ 7<;</;;Wdvdkwfi fotcfnjv hkfnca cdq vfndcfd kcm }dficojoa~Hwkce xkc mdw @ov} kcm Gkwdcm xkc mdw @dtjdc
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 28/35
Q\ 7<;</;7Hwo` cdq }o }id hnw` }o cdq }o }id qowjm# Dhhdf} oh adoawk|infkj |woyn`n}~ kcm}dficojoanfkj fk|kgnjn}ndv oc }id mdawdd oh coxdj}~ nc d`dwanca dfoco`ndv@ocnfk \jdfidwo kcm Fwnv}nck Fik`nckmd
Q\ 7<;</;6Kwd ecoqjdmad-gkvdv dcotai? K fo`|kwk}nxd v}tm~ oh }id adoawk|i~ ohecoqjdmad votwfdv nc Finck )Awdk} Gdnbnca. kcm Ncmnk )\tcd.Fwnv}nck Fik`nckmd
Q\ 7<;</;=Wdanockj Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~ gd~ocm ’Gdv} \wkf}nfd„2 Jdvvocv hwo` VqdmdcWo`kc @kw}nc* Bdwedw @oom~vvoc kcm Djdck Rtektvekn}d
Q\ 7<;</;4Nccoxk}noc nc ftj}twkj ncmtv}wndv2 ]id wojd oh tcnxdwvn}~ jncevDjdck Rtektvekn}d
Q\ 7<;</;8
Tvd kcm coc-tvd oh wdvdkwfi dxkjtk}noc# K jn}dwk}twd wdxndqHwkce xkc mdw @ov}
Q\ 7<;</;1T|vfkjnca d`dwanca cnfid }dficojoandv nc vtv}knckgjd dcdwa~2 kc nc}dwck}nockjfo`|kwnvoc oh |ojnf~ k||wokfidvJkwv Fodcdc* Wokjm Vttwv kcm D``k xkc Vkcmnfe
7<<>
Q\ 7<<>/<;Gtnjmnca v~v}d`v oh nccoxk}noc nc jdvv mdxdjo|dm fotc}wndv2 ]id wojd oh
nc}dw`dmnk}d owakcnrk}nocv#Vroav* Kv}wnm5 Ft``ncav* Kcmwdq kcm Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck
Q\ 7<<>/<7]id Qnmdcnca kcm Mdd|dcnca oh Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~2 Qik} Focmn}nocv \woxnmdhow Dhhdf}nxd Aoxdwckcfd?Gowwëv* Vtvkck
Q\ 7<<>/<6@kckadwnkj jdkwcnca kcm mdxdjo|`dc} nc v`kjj hnw`v2 n`|jnfk}nocv gkvdm ocogvdwxk}nocv oh `kckadwnkj qoweAkgwndjvvoc* Bockv kcm ]djj* Boken`
Q\ 7<<>/<=Tcnxdwvn}~ |wohdvvowv kcm wdvdkwfi fo``dwfnkjnrk}noc2 Kc d`|nwnfkj }dv} oh }id‚ecoqjdmad fowwnmow‐ }idvnvAkgwndjvvoc* Bockv* \ojn}nv* Mnk`kc}o kcm ]djj* Boken`
Q\ 7<<>/<4Oc }id focfd|} oh ajogkj nccoxk}noc cd}qowevFik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck
Q\ 7<<>/<8
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 29/35
]dficojoanfkj Qkxdv kcm Dfoco`nf Awoq}i - Vqdmdc nc kc Nc}dwck}nockj\dwv|df}nxd ;94<-7<<4Vfiøc* Jdcckw}
Q\ 7<<>/<1\tgjnf \woftwd`dc} oh Nccoxk}noc Mnhhtvnoc2 Dy|jownca }id Wojd oh Ncv}n}t}nocvkcm Ncv}n}t}nockj Foowmnck}nocWojhv}k`* @ky5 \injjn|v* Qdcm~ kcm Gkeedw* Dj`dw
Q\ 7<<>/<9Jofkj cnfid dy|dwn`dc}k}noc nc dcdwa~ }wkcvn}nocv2 k }idowd}nfkj kcm d`|nwnfkjdy|jowk}noc oh |woyn`n}~ kmxkc}kadv kcm mnvkmxkc}kadv Jkwv Fodcdc* Wog Wkxdc* Addw} Xdwgoca
Q\ 7<<>/>\womtf} Mdxdjo|`dc} Mdfnvnocv2 Kc d`|nwnfkj k||wokfi }o Ewnvickc kcm TjwnfiBoc @nedj Rkgkjk* ]nck Ikccd`kcc
Q\ 7<<>/;<
M~ck`nfv oh k ]dficojoanfkj Nccoxk}ow Cd}qowe kcm n}v n`|kf} oc}dficojoanfkj |dwhow`kcfd Bt Jnt* Fwnv}nck Fik`nckmd
Q\ 7<<>/;;]id Wojd oh Jofkj Tcnxdwvn}ndv nc N`|woxnca ]wkmn}nockj V@Dv Nccoxk}nxd\dwhow`kcfdv2 ]id Xdcd}o Wdanoc Fkvd@ocnfk \jdfidwo
Q\ 7<<>/;7Fo`|kwnca v~v}d`v k||wokfidv }o nccoxk}noc kcm }dficojoanfkj fikcad howvtv}knckgjd kcm fo`|d}n}nxd dfoco`ndv2 kc dy|jowk}nxd v}tm~ nc}o focfd|}tkjfo``ockjn}ndv* mnhhdwdcfdv kcm fo`|jd`dc}kwn}ndv
Fodcdc* Jkwv kcm Màkr Jö|dr* Hdwckcmo B#Q\ 7<<>/;6\tgjnf \woftwd`dc} how Nccoxk}noc )\\N. ‖ k \njo} V}tm~Fikwjdv Dm{tnv}
Q\ 7<<>/;=Ot}|t}v oh nccoxk}noc v~v}d`v2 k Dtwo|dkc |dwv|df}nxdFikwjdv Dm{tnv} kcm Boc @nedj Rkgkjk
7<<9
Q\ 7<<9/<;
W(M kcm hnckcfnkj v~v}d`v2 }id md}dw`nckc}v oh W(M dy|dcmn}twdv nc }idVqdmnvi |ikw`kfdt}nfkj ncmtv}w~@kj`gdwa* Fjkdv
Q\ 7<<9/<7]id Mdxdjo|`dc} oh k Cdq Vqdmnvi Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~# K Inv}ownfkj Ncv}n}t}nockjK||wokfi\dwvvoc* Go
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 30/35
Q\ 7<<9/<6]id Dhhdf}v oh W(M oc Wdanockj Ncxdc}noc kcm Nccoxk}nocOjoh Dbdw`o kcm Twgkc Awävbø
Q\ 7<<9/<=Fjtv}dwv nc ]n`d kcm V|kfd2 Tcmdwv}kcmnca }id Awoq}i kcm ]wkcvhow`k}noc ohJnhd Vfndcfd nc Vfkcnk@oom~vvoc* Bdwedw5 Cnjvvoc* @kactv5 Vxdcvvoc Idccnca* @kw}nc
Q\ 7<<9/<4Gtnjmnca kgvow|}nxd fk|kfn}~ nc jdvv mdxdjo|dm fotc}wndv]id fkvd oh ]kcrkcnkVroav* Kv}wnm5 Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck kcm Krk}~kc* Wtrkck
Q\ 7<<9/<8Mdvnac oh Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~ }iwotai Mnkacov}nf Kckj~vnv2Nmdc}nhnfk}noc oh V~v}d`nf \wogjd`v )ow Hknjtwdv.Dm{tnv}* Fikwjdv
Q\ 7<<9/<1]id Vqdmnvi \kwkmoy kwnvdv nc Hkv}-Awoqnca Vdf}owvDbdw`o* Ojoh5 Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm kcm Vxdcvvoc Idccnca* @kw}nc
Q\ 7<<9/<9\ojnf~ Wdhow`v* Cdq Tcnxdwvn}~-Ncmtv}w~ Jncev kcm N`|jnfk}nocv how WdanockjMdxdjo|`dc} nc Bk|kcEn}kakqk* Ht`n
Q\ 7<<9/<>]id Fikjjdcadv oh Ajogkjnvk}noc2 V}wk}danf Fionfdv how Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~Gowwëv* Vtvkck5 Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck kcm Dm{tnv}* Fikwjdv
Q\ 7<<9/;<Fo`|kwnca ck}nockj v~v}d`v oh nccoxk}noc nc Kvnk kcm Dtwo|d2 }idow~ kcmfo`|kwk}nxd hwk`dqoweDm{tnv}* Fikwjdv kcm Io``dc* Jdnh
Q\ 7<<9/;;\t}}nca Focv}wtf}dm Wdanockj Kmxkc}kad nc}o Vqdmnvi \wkf}nfd? ]id fkvd oh}id XNCCXÍY] ncn}nk}nxd !Hoom Nccoxk}noc k} Nc}dwhkfdv!Fodcdc* Jkwv5 @oom~vvoc* Bdwedw
Q\ 7<<9/;7Dcdwa~ }wkcvn}nocv nc Dtwo|d2 ;8<<-7<<<
Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm5 @kjkcn`k* \kojo kcm Qkwmd* \ktj
Q\ 7<<9/;6WNV kcm Mdxdjo|nca Fotc}wndv2 Jncenca hnw` }dficojoanfkj fk|kgnjn}ndv }owdanockj v~v}d`v oh nccoxk}noc \kmnjjk* Wk`oc5 Xkca* Bkc kcm Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 31/35
Q\ 7<<9/;=]id |kwkmoy oh inai W(M nc|t} kcm joq nccoxk}noc ot}|t}2 VqdmdcGn}kwwd* \ndwwd5 Dm{tnv}* Fikwjdv5 Io``dc* Jdnh kcm Wnfed* Kccnek
Q\ 7<<9/;4]qo Vnmdv oh }id Vk`d Fonc? Jofkj kcm Ajogkj Ecoqjdmad Hjoqv nc @dmnfocXkjjd~@oom~vvoc* Bdwedw5 Fodcdc* Jkwv kcm Kvidn`* Gbùwc
Q\ 7<<9/;8Djdf}wnhnfk}noc kcm dcdwa~ |womtf}nxn}~Dchjo* Edwv}nc5 Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm kcm Vfiøc* Jdcckw}
Q\ 7<<9/;1Focfjtmnca Fik|}dw2 Ajogkjnvk}noc kcm Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~Io``dc* Jdnh kcm Dm{tnv}* Fikwjdv
Q\ 7<<9/;9Wdanockj nccoxk}noc v~v}d`v kcm }id ajogkj jofk}noc oh nccoxk}noc kf}nxn}ndv2
Jdvvocv hwo` Finck^tc-Fitca* Fidc5 Xkca* Bkc kcm Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck
Q\ 7<<9/;>]id Wojd oh `dmnk}ow owakcnvk}nocv nc }id `kenca oh nccoxk}noc v~v}d`v ncjdkv} mdxdjo|dm fotc}wndv# Dxnmdcfd hwo` ]kcrkcnkVroav* Kv}wnm
Q\ 7<<9/7<Ajogkjnvk}noc oh Ecoqjdmad \womtf}noc kcm Wdanockj Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~2Vt||ow}nca V|dfnkjnrdm Itgv nc }id Gkcakjowd Voh}qkwd Ncmtv}w~Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck kcm Xkca* Bkc
Q\ 7<<9/7;T|awkmnca nc Kvnkc fjtv}dwv2 Wd}incenca }id n`|ow}kcfd oh nc}dwkf}nxd-jdkwcncaFik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck kcm Xkca* Bkc
7<<1
Q\ 7<<1/<;\k}i-hojjoqnca ow Jdk|hwoaanca nc Fk}finca-t|2 }id Fkvd oh Fincdvd]djdfo``tcnfk}noc D{tn|`dc} Ncmtv}w~Jnt* Yndjnc
Q\ 7<<1/<7]id dhhdf}v oh ncv}n}t}nockj fikcad oc nccoxk}noc kcm |womtf}nxn}~ awoq}i nc }id
Vqdmnvi |ikw`kfdt}nfkj ncmtv}w~@kj`gdwa* Fjkdv
Q\ 7<<1/<6Ajogkj-jofkj jncekadv* V|njjoxdwv kcm Ftj}twkj Fjtv}dwv2 ]idowd}nfkj kcmD`|nwnfkj ncvnai}v hwo` kc dy|jowk}ow~ v}tm~ oh ]owoc}o„v Hnj` Fjtv}dwXkca* Bkc5 Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 32/35
Q\ 7<<1/<=Jdkwcnca hwo` }id Gkcakjowd Dy|dwndcfd2 ]id Wojd oh Tcnxdwvn}ndv nc kcD`dwanca Wdanockj Nccoxk}noc V~v}d`Xkca* Bkc5 Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck#5 Fodcdc* Jkwv#
Q\ 7<<1/<4Ncmtv}wnkj m~ck`nfv kcm nccoxk}nxd |wdvvtwd oc dcdwa~ -Vqdmdc qn}iDtwo|dkc kcm Ajogkj ot}jooevVfiøc* Jdcckw}5 Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm#
Q\ 7<<1/<8Nc mdhdcfd oh djdf}wnfn}~ kv k adcdwkj |tw|ovd }dficojoa~Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm5 Dchjo* Edwv}nc5 Vfiøc* Jdcckw}
Q\ 7<<1/<1Vqdmnvi gtvncdvv wdvdkwfi |womtf}nxn}~ ‖ n`|woxd`dc}v kakncv} nc}dwck}nockj}wdcmvDbdw`o* Ojoh5 Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm
Q\ 7<<1/<9Wdanockj nccoxk}noc `dkvtwdm g~ |k}dc} mk}k ‖ modv {tkjn}~ `k}}dw?Dbdw`o* Ojoh
Q\ 7<<1/<> Nccoxk}noc V~v}d` \ojnfndv nc Jdvv Vtffdvvhtj Mdxdjo|nca fotc}wndv2 ]id fkvdoh ]iknjkcmNc}kwket`cdwm* \k}kwk|oca5 Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck
7<<8
Q\ 7<<8/<;
]id Vqdmnvi \kwkmoyDbdw`o* Ojoh5 Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm
Q\ 7<<8/<7Gtnjmnca WNV nc Mdxdjo|nca Fotc}wndv2 \ojnf~ Jdvvocv hwo` Gkcakjowd* NcmnkXkca* Bkc5 Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck
Q\ 7<<8/<6Nccoxk}noc \ojnf~ how Kvnkc V@Dv2 Dy|jownca fjtv}dw mnhhdwdcfdvFik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck5 Xkca* Bkc#
Q\ 7<<8/<=Wk}nockjdv how |tgjnf nc}dwxdc}noc hwo` k v~v}d` oh nccoxk}noc k||wokfi2 }id
fkvd oh XNCCOXK#Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck5 Dm{tnv}* Fikwjdv
Q\ 7<<8/<4]dficojoa~ kcm ]wkmd2 kc kckj~vnv oh }dficojoa~ v|dfnkjnrk}noc kcm dy|ow}hjoqvKcmdwvvoc* @kw}nc5 Dbdw`o* Ojoh
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 33/35
Q\ 7<<8/<8K Ecoqjdmad-gkvdm Fk}daownrk}noc oh Wdvdkwfi-gkvdm V|nc-ohh Fwdk}nocAkgwndjvvoc* Bockv5 Jkcmv}wø`* Ikcv5 Gwtcvcdv* D# ]io`kv
Q\ 7<<8/<1Gokwm foc}woj kcm fow|owk}d nccoxk}noc2 kc d`|nwnfkj v}tm~ oh v`kjj}dficojoa~-gkvdm hnw`vAkgwndjvvoc* Bockv5 \ojn}nv* Mnk`kc}o
Q\ 7<<8/<9Oc kcm Ohh }id Gdk}dc \k}i2]wkcvhdwwnca Ecoqjdmad }iwotai How`kj kcm Nchow`kj Cd}qowevWnfe Kkjgdwv5 O}}o Eo||ntv5 Qnjhwdm Mojhv`k
Q\ 7<<8/<>]wdcmv nc W(M* nccoxk}noc kcm |womtf}nxn}~ nc Vqdmdc ;>94-7<<7Dbdw`o* Ojoh5 Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm
Q\ 7<<8/;<
Mdxdjo|`dc} Gjofev kcm }id Vdfocm Ncmtv}wnkj Wdxojt}noc* Vqdmdc ;><<-;>1=Dchjo* Edwv}nc5 Ekcmdw* Kv}wnm5 Vfiøc* Jdcckw}
Q\ 7<<8/;;]id tcdxdc kcm vdjdf}nxd ck}twd oh fjtv}dw ecoqjdmad cd}qowev2 dxnmdcfd hwo`}id qncd ncmtv}w~Antjnkcn* Djnvk
Q\ 7<<8/;7Nchow`kj ncxdv}owv kcm xkjtd kmmdm2 ]id foc}wngt}noc oh ncxdv}owv„dy|dwndc}nkjj~ kf{tnwdm wdvotwfdv nc }id dc}wd|wdcdtwnkj |wofdvv\ojn}nv* Mnk`kc}o5 Akgwndjvvoc* Bockv
Q\ 7<<8/;6Nchow`kj ncxdv}owv kcm xkjtd kmmdm2 Qik} mo qd ecoq kcm qidwd mo qd ao?\ojn}nv* Mnk`kc}o5 Akgwndjvvoc* Bockv
Q\ 7<<8/;=Ncxdc}nxd kcm nccoxk}nxd kf}nxn}~ oxdw }n`d kcm adoawk|infkj v|kfd2 }id fkvd ohVqdmdcDbdw`o* Ojoh
7<<4
Q\ 7<<4/;Focv}wtf}nca Wdanockj Kmxkc}kad k} }id Cow}idwc Dmad
Fodcdc* Jkwv5 Kvidn`* Gbùwc
Q\ 7<<4/<7Hwo` ]idow~ }o \wkf}nfd2 ]id Tvd oh }id V~v}d`v oh Nccoxk}noc K||wokfi howNccoxk}noc \ojnf~Fik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck5 Dm{tnv}* Fikwjdv
Q\ 7<<4/<6]id Wojd oh Wdanockj Nccoxk}noc V~v}d`v nc k Ajogkjnvnca Dfoco`~2Fo`|kwnca Ecoqjdmad Gkvdv kcm Ncv}n}t}nockj Hwk`dqowev nc Cowmnf Fjtv}dwv
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 34/35
Kvidn`* Gbùwc5 Fodcdc* Jkwv
Q\ 7<<4/<=Ioq modv Kffdvvngnjn}~ }o Ecoqjdmad Votwfdv Khhdf} }id Nccoxk}nxdcdvv ohFow|owk}nocv? Dxnmdcfd hwo` VqdmdcKcmdwvvoc* @kw}nc5 Dbdw`o* Ojoh
Q\ 7<<4/<4Foc}dy}tkjnrnca Wdanockj Nccoxk}noc V~v}d`v nc k Ajogkjnrnca JdkwcncaDfoco`~2 Oc Ecoqjdmad Gkvdv kcm Ncv}n}t}nockj Hwk`dqowevKvidn`* Gbùwc5 Fodcdc* Jkwv
Q\ 7<<4/<8Nccoxk}noc \ojnfndv how Kvnkc V@Dv2 Kc Nccoxk}noc V~v}d`v \dwv|df}nxdFik`nckmd* Fwnv}nck5 Xkca* Bkc
Q\ 7<<4/<1Wd-cow`nca }id Vfndcfd-Vofnd}~ Wdjk}nocBkfog* @dwjd
Q\ 7<<4/<9Fow|owk}d nccoxk}noc kcm fo`|d}n}nxd dcxnwoc`dc}Itvd* @ow}dc5 Cdtgkt`* Mockjm O#5 Akgwndjvvoc* Bockv
Q\ 7<<4/<>Ecoqjdmad kcm kffotc}kgnjn}~2 Ot}vnmd mnwdf}owv! foc}wngt}noc nc }id fow|owk}dxkjtd fiknc Itvd* @ow}dc* Akgwndjvvoc* Bockv5 @ncnfinjjn* Kjdvvkcmwo
Q\ 7<<4/;<Wd}incenca }id V|k}nkj Owakcnrk}noc oh Fwdk}nxd Ncmtv}wndvXkca* Bkc
Q\ 7<<4/;;Nc}dwwdanockj Ncxdc}ow Cd}qowev kv V}tmndm g~ \k}dc} Fo-ncxdc}owvin|vDbdw`o* Ojoh5 Ekwjvvoc* Fikwjnd
Q\ 7<<4/;7Ecoqjdmad Gkvdv kcm V|k}nkj \k}}dwcv oh Fojjkgowk}noc2 Fo`|kwnca }id\ikw`k kcm Kawo-Hoom Gnowdanocv Vfkcnk kcm Vkvek}oocFodcdc* Jkwv5 @oom~vvoc* Bdwedw5 W~kc* Fk`njjd5 Kvidn`* Gbùwc5 \injjn|v* \d}dw
Q\ 7<<4/;6Wdanockj Nccoxk}noc V~v}d` \ojnf~2 k Ecoqjdmad-gkvdm K||wokfiKvidn`* Gbùwc5 Fodcdc* Jkwv5 @oom~vvoc* Bdwedw5 Xkca* Bkc
Q\ 7<<4/;=Hkfd-}o-Hkfd* Gtrr kcm Ecoqjdmad Gkvdv2 Vofno-v|k}nkj n`|jnfk}nocv howjdkwcnca kcm nccoxk}noc |ojnf~Kvidn`* Gbùwc5 Fodcdc* Jkwv* Xkca* Bkc
Q\ 7<<4/;4]id Fwdk}nxd Fjkvv kcm Wdanockj Awoq}i2 ]oqkwmv k Ecoqjdmad GkvdmK||wokfiEkjvù Ikcvdc* Iùacn5 Xkca* Bkc5 Gbùwc ]# Kvidn`
7/31/2019 Policy coordination in systems of innovation: A structural-functional analysis of regional industry support in Swede…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/policy-coordination-in-systems-of-innovation-a-structural-functional-analysis 35/35
Q\ 7<<4/;8D`dwadcfd kcm Awoq}i oh @bíwmdxn Vfndcfd \kwe nc Jnceø|nca* VqdmdcIo``dc* Jdnh5 Mojowdty* Mkxnm5 Jkwvvoc* D``k
Q\ 7<<4/;1]wkmd`kwe V}k}nv}nfv kv Nccoxk}noc Ncmnfk}owv? ‖ K @nfwo V}tm~@kj`gdwa* Fjkdv