politics of the environment (ess 112) lecture 4: green ideology: ecologism

26
Politics of the Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism Green Ideology: Ecologism

Upload: sylvia-todd

Post on 24-Dec-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Politics of the Politics of the Environment (ESS 112)Environment (ESS 112)

Lecture 4: Lecture 4:

Green Ideology: EcologismGreen Ideology: Ecologism

Page 2: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

The ‘four pillars’ of green politicsThe ‘four pillars’ of green politics

In their 1983 political programme Die Grünen, the German In their 1983 political programme Die Grünen, the German green party, named four core principles of politics which green party, named four core principles of politics which have subsequently been adopted by most green parties in have subsequently been adopted by most green parties in the world:the world:

1. ecological responsibility1. ecological responsibility2. grassroots democracy2. grassroots democracy3. social justice3. social justice4. non-violence4. non-violence

The concept of ecological responsibility, or sustainability, is The concept of ecological responsibility, or sustainability, is informed by the two core ideas of ecologism: (1) the need to informed by the two core ideas of ecologism: (1) the need to recast human-nature relations; and (2) the limits to growth.recast human-nature relations; and (2) the limits to growth.

Page 3: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

The basics of environmental The basics of environmental

philosophyphilosophy A key concept in environmental philosophy is A key concept in environmental philosophy is valuevalueDefining value (according to Carter, p. 15):Defining value (according to Carter, p. 15):1.1. Instrumental valueInstrumental value is the value which something has for someone is the value which something has for someone

as a means to an end which they desire.as a means to an end which they desire. These are people who think that we ought to change our behaviour These are people who think that we ought to change our behaviour

towards the natural world otherwise we will hurt humans. Most people towards the natural world otherwise we will hurt humans. Most people who support environmental causes probably do so for these kinds of who support environmental causes probably do so for these kinds of reasons.reasons.

2.2. Inherent valueInherent value is the value something has for someone, but not as is the value something has for someone, but not as a means to a further end. A beautiful landscape has value for me, a means to a further end. A beautiful landscape has value for me, but not because it enables me to do something further. It is but not because it enables me to do something further. It is something which I find valuable in itself.something which I find valuable in itself.

3.3. Intrinsic valueIntrinsic value is simply the value which something has. No is simply the value which something has. No appeal need to be made to those for whom it has value. It simply appeal need to be made to those for whom it has value. It simply is valuable and is so independently of anyone finding it valuable.is valuable and is so independently of anyone finding it valuable. even if things had no aesthetic or spiritual value, or instrumental even if things had no aesthetic or spiritual value, or instrumental

value, they should be preserved for their own sake.value, they should be preserved for their own sake.

Page 4: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

History and definition of Ecologism History and definition of Ecologism (1)(1)

The origins of the term The origins of the term ecologyecology lie in biology and were lie in biology and were coined by the German zoologist Ernst Haeckel in 1866. coined by the German zoologist Ernst Haeckel in 1866.

It is derived from the Greek word It is derived from the Greek word oikosoikos which means which means household or habitat. household or habitat.

From the beginning of the 20th century it has been From the beginning of the 20th century it has been used to name a branch of biology that studied the used to name a branch of biology that studied the relationship amongst living organisms and their relationship amongst living organisms and their environment. environment.

Then it was more and more turned into a political term Then it was more and more turned into a political term because it was adopted and used by the growing green because it was adopted and used by the growing green movement, especially from the 1960s on. movement, especially from the 1960s on.

Nevertheless, there has been confusion about what Nevertheless, there has been confusion about what exactly the terms green, environmentalism and exactly the terms green, environmentalism and ecologism stand for.ecologism stand for.

Page 5: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

History and definition of Ecologism History and definition of Ecologism (2)(2)

From the 1950s the term From the 1950s the term greengreen had had been used to express sympathy for been used to express sympathy for environmental issues or projects. environmental issues or projects.

It has later been used in the naming It has later been used in the naming of environmental parties, with the of environmental parties, with the German Greens (German Greens (Die GrünenDie Grünen) being ) being the first in 1980. the first in 1980.

The term The term environmentalismenvironmentalism has also has also been used from the 1950s and been used from the 1950s and encompasses a wide field of beliefs – encompasses a wide field of beliefs – scientific, religious, economic and scientific, religious, economic and political – that are concerned with the political – that are concerned with the understanding of human life in context understanding of human life in context of the natural world. of the natural world.

Page 6: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

History and definition of Ecologism History and definition of Ecologism (3)(3)

Therefore it is essential to understand what the term ‘ecologism’ Therefore it is essential to understand what the term ‘ecologism’ stands for to avoid further confusion about the correct name of the stands for to avoid further confusion about the correct name of the ‘green’ ideology, whether it is ‘ecologism’ or ‘environmentalism’.‘green’ ideology, whether it is ‘ecologism’ or ‘environmentalism’.

Andrew Dobson’s book Andrew Dobson’s book Green Political ThoughtGreen Political Thought is sometimes is sometimes seen as the classical text on ecologism as an ideology. He seen as the classical text on ecologism as an ideology. He explains the difference of ecologism and environmentalism as explains the difference of ecologism and environmentalism as follows (p. 2):follows (p. 2):

““environmentalismenvironmentalism argues for a argues for a managerial approachmanagerial approach to to environmental problems, secure in the belief that they can environmental problems, secure in the belief that they can

be be solved without fundamental changes in present values or solved without fundamental changes in present values or patterns of production and consumption, andpatterns of production and consumption, andecologismecologism holds that a sustainable and fulfilling existence holds that a sustainable and fulfilling existence presupposes presupposes radical changesradical changes in our relationship with the in our relationship with the

non-non- human natural world, and in our mode of social and human natural world, and in our mode of social and political political life.”life.”

Page 7: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

History and definition of Ecologism History and definition of Ecologism (4)(4)

Only a theory that is radically different Only a theory that is radically different from any other has the ‘right’ to be from any other has the ‘right’ to be called an ideology on its own. called an ideology on its own.

Therefore Dobson argues that Therefore Dobson argues that environmentalism is just an adjusted environmentalism is just an adjusted view of the human–nature view of the human–nature relationship within the existing relationship within the existing (economic) system and hence lacks (economic) system and hence lacks the major characteristic of an the major characteristic of an ideology. ideology.

Consequently only ecologism, which Consequently only ecologism, which has a revolutionary approach and has a revolutionary approach and includes a radical new worldview and includes a radical new worldview and provides solutions for an alternative provides solutions for an alternative organisation, can be labelled as organisation, can be labelled as ideology.ideology.

Page 8: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

History and definition of Ecologism History and definition of Ecologism (5)(5)

Fundamental for the distinction between these two forms of the Fundamental for the distinction between these two forms of the environmental movement is the work of the Norwegian environmental movement is the work of the Norwegian philosopher Arne Næss who in 1973 coined the terms philosopher Arne Næss who in 1973 coined the terms shallow shallow ecologismecologism (environmentalism) and (environmentalism) and deep ecologismdeep ecologism (ecologism). (ecologism).

Simply put, environmentalists want to achieve their goals within an Simply put, environmentalists want to achieve their goals within an anthropocentric framework, whereas deep ecologists postulate a anthropocentric framework, whereas deep ecologists postulate a radical new – an ‘ecocentric’ – approach. radical new – an ‘ecocentric’ – approach.

Page 9: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

History and definition of Ecologism History and definition of Ecologism (6)(6)

There are diverse opinions about the origins There are diverse opinions about the origins of ecologism, but it was foremost a reaction of ecologism, but it was foremost a reaction to the process of industrialisation.to the process of industrialisation.

In the late 20th century industrialisation and In the late 20th century industrialisation and urbanisation were intensified which resulted urbanisation were intensified which resulted in the growth of ecologism. in the growth of ecologism.

It was driven by environmental concerns, in It was driven by environmental concerns, in particular the fear that economic growth particular the fear that economic growth threatens both the survival of the human race threatens both the survival of the human race and the planet it lives on. and the planet it lives on.

Milestones in expressing this fear have for Milestones in expressing this fear have for example been the (unofficial) UN report example been the (unofficial) UN report Only Only One EarthOne Earth (1972) and especially the Club of (1972) and especially the Club of Rome’s report Rome’s report The Limits to GrowthThe Limits to Growth in the in the same year. same year.

In this time also new activist pressure groups In this time also new activist pressure groups formed themselves, for example formed themselves, for example ‘Greenpeace’ and ‘Friends of the Earth’ ‘Greenpeace’ and ‘Friends of the Earth’ which drew the public’s attention to issues which drew the public’s attention to issues like the dangers of nuclear power or pollution. like the dangers of nuclear power or pollution.

Page 10: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

History and definition of Ecologism History and definition of Ecologism (7)(7)

Together with older groups like the WWF a more and Together with older groups like the WWF a more and more powerful environmental movement emerged.more powerful environmental movement emerged.

Although the environmental movement emerged out of Although the environmental movement emerged out of the concern about the natural world, ecologists do not the concern about the natural world, ecologists do not see themselves as a single issue lobby group. see themselves as a single issue lobby group.

They are concerned with a wide range of issues and They are concerned with a wide range of issues and have developed a completely new set of concepts and have developed a completely new set of concepts and values to understand and explain the world: values to understand and explain the world: ““Ecologism stands apart from traditional political Ecologism stands apart from traditional political

creeds because it starts from an examination of creeds because it starts from an examination of what they have tended to ignore: the what they have tended to ignore: the interrelationships that bind humans to all living interrelationships that bind humans to all living organisms and more broadly, to the ‘web of life’.”organisms and more broadly, to the ‘web of life’.”

Page 11: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Central themes and key conceptsCentral themes and key concepts

Ecologism is radically different from all other major Ecologism is radically different from all other major ideologies as it criticises the starting points of ideologies as it criticises the starting points of conventional political thought.conventional political thought.

Ecologists argue that the major flaw of traditional Ecologists argue that the major flaw of traditional doctrines and ideologies is their anthropocentric doctrines and ideologies is their anthropocentric (human-centred) view. (human-centred) view. They falsely see humans as the centrepiece of existence in They falsely see humans as the centrepiece of existence in

their what David Ehrenfeld called ‘arrogance of humanism’.their what David Ehrenfeld called ‘arrogance of humanism’. Ideologies like liberalism, socialism, feminism and Ideologies like liberalism, socialism, feminism and

nationalism conduct their analyses based on different nationalism conduct their analyses based on different notions of the human being and social groups, namely notions of the human being and social groups, namely individual, social class, gender or nation. individual, social class, gender or nation.

Page 12: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Central themes and key conceptsCentral themes and key concepts

Ecologists on the other side believe that this focus on human Ecologists on the other side believe that this focus on human beings has disturbed and damaged the relationship between beings has disturbed and damaged the relationship between the human species and its natural environment. the human species and its natural environment.

Therefore ecologists turned to a new style of politics which Therefore ecologists turned to a new style of politics which does not build on a theory about mankind and its needs, but does not build on a theory about mankind and its needs, but on a view of nature as a network of relationships between all on a view of nature as a network of relationships between all living species – including the human species – and their living species – including the human species – and their natural environment:natural environment: ““Humankind no longer occupies centre stage, but is Humankind no longer occupies centre stage, but is

regarded as an inseparable part of nature.”regarded as an inseparable part of nature.” Thus, humans must stop to view the earth just as a resource Thus, humans must stop to view the earth just as a resource

that they can exploit through science and technology to satisfy that they can exploit through science and technology to satisfy their needs.their needs.

Consequently, the central themes of ecologism are Consequently, the central themes of ecologism are ecologyecology, , holismholism, , sustainabilitysustainability, , environmental ethicsenvironmental ethics andand self-self-actualisationactualisation..

Page 13: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Ecologism (1)Ecologism (1)

At the heart of all forms of green thought lies At the heart of all forms of green thought lies ecologyecology, which means the study of organisms ‘in , which means the study of organisms ‘in their habitats’. their habitats’.

The characteristic of all ecosystems – consisting of The characteristic of all ecosystems – consisting of living and non-living elements – is that through a living and non-living elements – is that through a system of self-regulation they try to achieve a state system of self-regulation they try to achieve a state of harmony or balance. of harmony or balance.

The development of scientific ecology The development of scientific ecology fundamentally changed our understanding of the fundamentally changed our understanding of the natural world and the place of humans within it – natural world and the place of humans within it – that they are certainly not the ‘masters of nature’.that they are certainly not the ‘masters of nature’.

This view is important when looking at the rise of This view is important when looking at the rise of green thinking in the second half of the 20th green thinking in the second half of the 20th century. century.

Page 14: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Ecologism (2)Ecologism (2)

For ecologists there is no doubt that the prospect of For ecologists there is no doubt that the prospect of environmental disaster stems from mankind’s blind environmental disaster stems from mankind’s blind pursuit of material wealth, which disturbed the pursuit of material wealth, which disturbed the ‘balance of nature’. ‘balance of nature’.

Ecologism therefore gives a radically new view on Ecologism therefore gives a radically new view on nature and the place of human beings within it, nature and the place of human beings within it, which is which is ecocentric rather than anthropocentricecocentric rather than anthropocentric. .

Whereas green thinkers have this starting point in Whereas green thinkers have this starting point in common, their conclusions are quite different. common, their conclusions are quite different. central here is Arne Næss’ distinction between central here is Arne Næss’ distinction between

‘shallow ecology’ and ‘deep ecology’. ‘shallow ecology’ and ‘deep ecology’. Deep ecologists have been criticised for presenting Deep ecologists have been criticised for presenting

unrealistic and unappealing solutions to mankind.unrealistic and unappealing solutions to mankind.

Page 15: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Holism (1)Holism (1)

The second crucial feature of ecologism is the concept of The second crucial feature of ecologism is the concept of holismholism..

The term ‘holism’ does not have its origins in the green The term ‘holism’ does not have its origins in the green movement but was coined in 1926 by Jan Smuts, a Boer movement but was coined in 1926 by Jan Smuts, a Boer general and twice prime minister of South Africa. general and twice prime minister of South Africa. With this term he wanted to describe that the natural world could With this term he wanted to describe that the natural world could

only be understood as a whole and not through its individual parts. only be understood as a whole and not through its individual parts. For him, science had the problem of reductionism, i.e. trying to For him, science had the problem of reductionism, i.e. trying to

explain separated parts rather than the whole. Holism on the other explain separated parts rather than the whole. Holism on the other hand emphasises that ‘the whole’ is more important than its hand emphasises that ‘the whole’ is more important than its individual parts.individual parts.

Modern science and religion (esp. Hinduism, Taoism and Modern science and religion (esp. Hinduism, Taoism and Buddhism) have influenced the thinking about the relationship Buddhism) have influenced the thinking about the relationship between humans and their natural environment. between humans and their natural environment.

Page 16: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Holism (2)Holism (2) However, what influenced modern green However, what influenced modern green

thinking most was a referral to pre-Christian thinking most was a referral to pre-Christian spiritual ideas where all things including the spiritual ideas where all things including the Earth itself were regarded to be alive. Earth itself were regarded to be alive.

This ‘Mother Earth’ thinking has been This ‘Mother Earth’ thinking has been adopted and developed by James Lovelock adopted and developed by James Lovelock in in Gaia: A New Look at Life on EarthGaia: A New Look at Life on Earth (1979). (1979). ‘Gaia’ is the name of the Greek goddess of ‘Gaia’ is the name of the Greek goddess of the Earth and Lovelock claimed that Planet the Earth and Lovelock claimed that Planet Earth is a living organism (with all the Earth is a living organism (with all the implied consequences when an organism implied consequences when an organism gets seriously disturbed). gets seriously disturbed).

According to Lovelock, the species that According to Lovelock, the species that prospered were regulated by Gaia, “[…] prospered were regulated by Gaia, “[…] while any species that poses a threat to the while any species that poses a threat to the delicate balance of Gaia, as humans delicate balance of Gaia, as humans currently do, is likely to be extinguishedcurrently do, is likely to be extinguished.”.”

Page 17: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Sustainability (1)Sustainability (1)

A further key to ecologism is the concept of A further key to ecologism is the concept of sustainabilitysustainability. . The conventional political creeds which are more or less expressed The conventional political creeds which are more or less expressed

by all mainstream parties hold that human life has unlimited by all mainstream parties hold that human life has unlimited possibilities for material growth and prosperity.possibilities for material growth and prosperity.

Ecologists are opposing this ‘growth mania’ because they consider it Ecologists are opposing this ‘growth mania’ because they consider it to be the wrong way and the primary cause of environmental to be the wrong way and the primary cause of environmental disaster. disaster.

A result of this view is that green thinkers do not distinguish between A result of this view is that green thinkers do not distinguish between capitalism and communism since both represent industrialism with its capitalism and communism since both represent industrialism with its negative effects. negative effects.

Thus, there is a need in green economics to rethink the nature and Thus, there is a need in green economics to rethink the nature and purpose of economic activities, especially regarding the resources of purpose of economic activities, especially regarding the resources of the Earth. It builds on the notion that resources are limited and the Earth. It builds on the notion that resources are limited and therefore it is not possible to pursuit growth forever.therefore it is not possible to pursuit growth forever.

However, ecological economics do not only criticise but also provide However, ecological economics do not only criticise but also provide some solutions to these problems. some solutions to these problems.

Page 18: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Sustainability (2)Sustainability (2)

At the core of any solution is the belief that the human species can At the core of any solution is the belief that the human species can only survive and prosper if it acknowledges to be only one of many only survive and prosper if it acknowledges to be only one of many elements in the biosphere. elements in the biosphere.

Only an intact biosphere can sustain human life and therefore human Only an intact biosphere can sustain human life and therefore human policies and actions must be guided by the principle of ‘sustainability’ policies and actions must be guided by the principle of ‘sustainability’ to maintain the capacity of the system. to maintain the capacity of the system.

sustainability encompasses more than a ‘wiser’ use of natural sustainability encompasses more than a ‘wiser’ use of natural resources; it aims at a new thinking about economic activities.resources; it aims at a new thinking about economic activities.

The environmental movement here draws on E. F. Schumacher’s The environmental movement here draws on E. F. Schumacher’s idea of ‘Buddhist economics’ explained in his book idea of ‘Buddhist economics’ explained in his book Small is BeautifulSmall is Beautiful (1973). (1973). Ecologists adopted this idea in a way that economics in the future Ecologists adopted this idea in a way that economics in the future

should be there “[…] to serve humanity, rather than enslave it.”should be there “[…] to serve humanity, rather than enslave it.” The views of shallow and deep ecologists about economic growth are The views of shallow and deep ecologists about economic growth are

conflicting. conflicting. Whereas the former ones support the idea of ‘sustainable growth’, Whereas the former ones support the idea of ‘sustainable growth’,

the latter ones reject it and instead postulate ‘zero growth’ policies the latter ones reject it and instead postulate ‘zero growth’ policies and a post-industrial age with a ‘return to nature’.and a post-industrial age with a ‘return to nature’.

Page 19: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Environmental ethicsEnvironmental ethics A new way of thinking is also expressed in A new way of thinking is also expressed in environmental ethicsenvironmental ethics

since conventional ethical systems are anthropocentric as well. since conventional ethical systems are anthropocentric as well. In utilitarianism for example, the natural world has only In utilitarianism for example, the natural world has only

instrumental value for the human being as ‘utility maximisers’, instrumental value for the human being as ‘utility maximisers’, which can be found in a similar way in the labour theories of which can be found in a similar way in the labour theories of thinkers like Locke or Marx. thinkers like Locke or Marx.

This view conflicts with a central ethical issue, which is the This view conflicts with a central ethical issue, which is the question of our moral obligations towards future generations. question of our moral obligations towards future generations. For example, why should people today worry about the depletion of For example, why should people today worry about the depletion of

fossil fuels or the accumulation of nuclear waste since they will not fossil fuels or the accumulation of nuclear waste since they will not live any more when the problems become acute?live any more when the problems become acute?

Thus, what might be in the best interest of humans today to Thus, what might be in the best interest of humans today to ensure growth and prosperity can have very negative ensure growth and prosperity can have very negative consequences for the coming generations. consequences for the coming generations.

This forces ecologists to think of the human species as a whole, This forces ecologists to think of the human species as a whole, i.e. not to distinguish between the present and future generations.i.e. not to distinguish between the present and future generations.

This in turn implies a responsibility of the living not to endanger This in turn implies a responsibility of the living not to endanger the fundaments that have to sustain the yet to be born. the fundaments that have to sustain the yet to be born.

Page 20: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Self-actualisationSelf-actualisation

Self-actualisationSelf-actualisation is the other great theme in green philosophy. is the other great theme in green philosophy. The question that lies behind it is what do humans strive and live The question that lies behind it is what do humans strive and live

for? for? ecologists reject the human attitude of self-interestedness and ecologists reject the human attitude of self-interestedness and

material greed and therefore looked for an alternative philosophy material greed and therefore looked for an alternative philosophy which relates personal fulfilment to a balance with nature. which relates personal fulfilment to a balance with nature.

Self-actualisation has its roots in postmaterialism, which is loosely Self-actualisation has its roots in postmaterialism, which is loosely based on Abraham Maslow’s ‘hierarchy of needs’. based on Abraham Maslow’s ‘hierarchy of needs’. It basically values the need for esteem and self-actualisation higher It basically values the need for esteem and self-actualisation higher

than material or economic needs. than material or economic needs. If their livelihood is secured, people will act less egoistically and turn If their livelihood is secured, people will act less egoistically and turn

to ‘quality of life’ issues. to ‘quality of life’ issues. all ecologists agree that human development has become all ecologists agree that human development has become

dangerously unbalanced and that the ‘know-how’ acquired by dangerously unbalanced and that the ‘know-how’ acquired by humanity – for example to reach material wealth – is not humanity – for example to reach material wealth – is not accompanied at the same level by the ‘know-why’.accompanied at the same level by the ‘know-why’.

Page 21: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

The impact of ecologism (1)The impact of ecologism (1)

Green ideas have influenced politics in various Green ideas have influenced politics in various ways and inspired other political creeds. ways and inspired other political creeds. Ecologism, like nationalism and feminism, can Ecologism, like nationalism and feminism, can

therefore be viewed as a cross-cutting ideology. therefore be viewed as a cross-cutting ideology. Some of its ideas have for instance been adopted Some of its ideas have for instance been adopted by fascists, socialists, anarchists and feminists. by fascists, socialists, anarchists and feminists.

Out of this emerged some sub-traditions within Out of this emerged some sub-traditions within ecologism, for example right-wing ecologism, ecologism, for example right-wing ecologism, ecosocialism, eco-anarchism and ecofeminism.ecosocialism, eco-anarchism and ecofeminism.

Page 22: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

The impact of ecologism (2)The impact of ecologism (2)

The big impacts of ecologist ideas can The big impacts of ecologist ideas can be observed in the shifts in agriculture be observed in the shifts in agriculture and marketing. and marketing.

The organic food sector is growing, The organic food sector is growing, especially in Western Europe.especially in Western Europe.

Additionally there are more ‘fair trade’ Additionally there are more ‘fair trade’ products sold in so-called ‘One-World products sold in so-called ‘One-World Shops’ which pay adequate prices to Shops’ which pay adequate prices to the producers in the developing the producers in the developing countries. countries. It is about a responsible use of It is about a responsible use of

natural resources and against natural resources and against exploitation of the poor. exploitation of the poor.

People who buy these products People who buy these products want to have a good conscience want to have a good conscience towards nature and this refers to towards nature and this refers to environmental ethics. environmental ethics.

Page 23: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

The impact of ecologism (3)The impact of ecologism (3)

Moreover, many companies started Moreover, many companies started to advertise their products as being to advertise their products as being a ‘local product’ which is a ‘local product’ which is ‘environmentally friendly’, coming ‘environmentally friendly’, coming from ‘sustainable production’, using from ‘sustainable production’, using ‘recycled materials’ and being ‘recycled materials’ and being packed in ‘biodegradable packs’. packed in ‘biodegradable packs’.

The truth behind those claims might The truth behind those claims might be different, but it is an important be different, but it is an important first step in a changing mindset. first step in a changing mindset. It shows that people (at least those It shows that people (at least those

in relative material security) tend to in relative material security) tend to buy a more ‘ethical correct’ product buy a more ‘ethical correct’ product if quality and price are at the same if quality and price are at the same level as conventional products.level as conventional products.

Page 24: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Glossary of most important terms Glossary of most important terms (1)(1)

AnthropocentrismAnthropocentrism: A way of thinking that regards humans as : A way of thinking that regards humans as the source of all value and is predominantly concerned with the source of all value and is predominantly concerned with human interestshuman interests

BiodiversityBiodiversity: The number, variety and variability of living : The number, variety and variability of living organisms; sometimes refers to the total variety of life on Earthorganisms; sometimes refers to the total variety of life on Earth

Climate changeClimate change: Any change in climate over time, whether : Any change in climate over time, whether due to natural variability or to human activitydue to natural variability or to human activity

Deep ecologyDeep ecology: The pre-eminent radical economic moral : The pre-eminent radical economic moral theory which has the primary aim of preserving nature from theory which has the primary aim of preserving nature from human interferencehuman interference

EcocentrismEcocentrism: A mode of thought that regards humans as : A mode of thought that regards humans as subject to ecological and systems laws and whose ethical, subject to ecological and systems laws and whose ethical, political and social prescriptions are concerned with both political and social prescriptions are concerned with both humans and non-humanshumans and non-humans

Ecological footprintEcological footprint: A measure of the amount of nature it : A measure of the amount of nature it takes to sustain a given population over the course of a yeartakes to sustain a given population over the course of a year

EcologismEcologism: A distinctive green political ideology encompassing : A distinctive green political ideology encompassing those perspectives that hold that a sustainable society requires those perspectives that hold that a sustainable society requires radical changes in our relationship with the non-human natural radical changes in our relationship with the non-human natural world and our mode of economic, social and political lifeworld and our mode of economic, social and political life

Page 25: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Glossary of most important terms Glossary of most important terms (2)(2)

Genetically modified organismGenetically modified organism: New organisms created by : New organisms created by human manipulation of genetic information and materialhuman manipulation of genetic information and material

Green consumerismGreen consumerism: The use of environmental and ethical : The use of environmental and ethical criteria in choosing whether or not to purchase a product or criteria in choosing whether or not to purchase a product or serviceservice

HolismHolism: The view that wholes are more than just the sum of their : The view that wholes are more than just the sum of their parts, and that wholes cannot be defined merely as a collection of parts, and that wholes cannot be defined merely as a collection of their basic constituentstheir basic constituents

Intrinsic valueIntrinsic value: The value which something has, independently : The value which something has, independently of anyone finding it valuableof anyone finding it valuable

Limits to growthLimits to growth: The belief that the planet imposes natural : The belief that the planet imposes natural limits on economic and population growth.limits on economic and population growth.

Modern environmentalismModern environmentalism: The emergence, from the late : The emergence, from the late 1960s, of growing public concern about the state of the planet, 1960s, of growing public concern about the state of the planet, new political ideas about the environment and a mass political new political ideas about the environment and a mass political movement.movement.

Ozone depletionOzone depletion: Depletion of ozone in the Earth’s upper : Depletion of ozone in the Earth’s upper atmosphere which leaves the surface of the Earth vulnerable to atmosphere which leaves the surface of the Earth vulnerable to harmful ultraviolet radiation.harmful ultraviolet radiation.

Page 26: Politics of the Environment (ESS 112) Lecture 4: Green Ideology: Ecologism

Glossary of most important terms Glossary of most important terms (3)(3)

PostmaterialismPostmaterialism: The theory that, as material affluence spreads, : The theory that, as material affluence spreads, ‘quality of life’ issues and concerns tend to replace material ones, ‘quality of life’ issues and concerns tend to replace material ones, fundamentally changing the political culture and value of industrialised fundamentally changing the political culture and value of industrialised countries.countries.

Precautionary principlePrecautionary principle: The principle states that the lack of : The principle states that the lack of scientific certainty shall not be used as a reason for postponing scientific certainty shall not be used as a reason for postponing measures to prevent environmental degradation.measures to prevent environmental degradation.

RegimeRegime: The principles, norms, rules and decision-making procedures : The principles, norms, rules and decision-making procedures which form the basis of co-operation on a particular issue in which form the basis of co-operation on a particular issue in international relations.international relations.

RegulationRegulation: Any direct (‘command-and-control’) attempt by the : Any direct (‘command-and-control’) attempt by the government to influence the behaviour of businesses or citizens by government to influence the behaviour of businesses or citizens by setting environmental standards (e.g. for air quality) enforced via setting environmental standards (e.g. for air quality) enforced via legislation.legislation.

Renewable energyRenewable energy: Energy sources, such as wind, sun, geothermal : Energy sources, such as wind, sun, geothermal and hydroelectric, that never run out.and hydroelectric, that never run out.

Sustainable developmentSustainable development: The ability of the present generation to : The ability of the present generation to meet its needs without undermining the ability of future generations to meet its needs without undermining the ability of future generations to meet their needs.meet their needs.

TechnocentricTechnocentric: A mode of thought which optimistically believes that : A mode of thought which optimistically believes that society can solve all environmental problems, using technology and society can solve all environmental problems, using technology and science, and achieve unlimited material growth.science, and achieve unlimited material growth.