position paper of the gph peace panel submitted to the ... · 5/18/2015 · public hearings on...

1

POSITION PAPER OF THE GPH PEACE PANEL Submitted to the Senate Committee on Local Government

18 May 2015

Preliminary The Government Peace Negotiating Panel (GPH Peace Panel) for talks with the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) respectfully submits the following position paper to the Senate Committee on Local Government headed by the Honorable Senator Ferdinand R. Marcos, Jr. containing some clarifications on important issues that have been raised during the last two public hearings on Senate Bill no. 2408 or the draft Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL), especially as they relate with the subject of today's hearing with the representatives and supporters of the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF), as well as for the coming hearing with the Sultanates, the Indigenous Peoples (IPs), and the local government executives. At the outset, we wish to affirm and reiterate our unwavering commitment in supporting the legislative process for the enactment of the BBL. We are one with our honorable Senators in advocating for the passage of a Basic Law for the Bangsamoro that is just, comprehensive and truly responsive to the needs of the peace and development in Muslim Mindanao. Thus, we laud and sincerely appreciate the vigorous and dynamic efforts of the Senate in holding public hearings and consultations with the various stakeholders. On the Matter of Public Consultations Like the Senate, we in the GPH Panel also believe that wide-based and meaningful consultations with various stakeholders constitute a significant foundation to sound public policy. It is, as it has always been our practice, consistent with the memorandum of instructions to us of His Excellency President Benigno Simeon Aquino III, to listen to and take heed from the widest possible constituency of concerned groups and individuals when it comes to the Bangsamoro proposal, in particular, and the larger peace process, in general. As far back as the early stages of the peace negotiations with the MILF under the present administration up until the signing of the last document that culminated in the forging of the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro (CAB), and later, during the drafting of the BBL, the GPH Panel has consistently conducted and/or participated in extensive consultation activities with various individuals and groups from both within and without the prospective Bangsamoro territory. The records, which we are providing the honorable Senate Committee thru this position paper, will bear this fact out. While it is truly unfortunate that some groups and individuals feel that they have not been consulted, we would like to submit to the Honorable Senate Committee the fact that, from 2010 until 17 May 2015, the GPH Peace Panel has conducted and participated in a total of five hundred fifty three (553) consultation activities (e.g. meetings, workshops, fora, and briefings) in order to shed light on the developments in the peace process with the MILF as well as to share and gather information, positions, and insights from the various stakeholders. Significantly, out of these 553 consultation activities, the GPH Panel has met ten (10) times on different occasions with representatives and supporters of the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) (see Table I), six (6) times with the Sultanates in Mindanao (see Table II), thirty two (32)

2

times with the IPs (see Table III), and one hundred (100) times with leaders and officials of local government units (LGUs) (see Table IV). In all of these engagements and interactions with the different affected stakeholders, the GPH Peace Panel has taken into consideration their positions, insights and suggestions relative to our peace efforts with the MILF. Convergence of MNLF and MILF Peace Process With respect to the concerns of the MNLF, in particular, the above data on our consultation efforts with them also illustrates how, under the Aquino administration, it has been our policy to exert all possible efforts to ensure that the substance of the negotiations with the MILF is in harmony and convergence with the full implementation of the 1996 Final Peace Agreement with the MNLF. In view of this policy, several meetings and “convergence workshops” were held with MNLF cadres in 2011. These workshops aimed to inform representatives from the MNLF about substantial developments in the talks with the MILF and to solicit their inputs thereto as well. This convergence is also in line with the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation’s (OIC) efforts to unite the ranks of the MNLF and the MILF in their search for a political settlement with the Philippine Government. It will be recalled that during the 37th Session of the OIC Council of Foreign Ministers (CFM) in December 2010, the OIC adopted a resolution on Muslim Communities and Minorities in Non-OIC Member States urging the MNLF and MILF to unite their efforts for peace and development in the Bangsamoro. The Office of the Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process (OPAPP) is in full support of this call. Parenthetically, the inclusion of the OIC in the MILF peace process by way of being formally invited as observers in the GPH-MILF peace negotiations in March 2012 is in no small part due to their role in the MNLF peace process and in keeping with the desire for convergence between the two peace tracks. The OIC has since been consistently invited by the Malaysian Facilitator to attend the GPH-MILF talks in Kuala Lumpur. The OIC first attended the negotiations during the 28th GPH-MILF Formal Exploratory Talks in May 2012, where OIC–PSCP representative Ali Demirci, political officer of the office of OIC Sec. Gen. İhsanoğlu sat as observer. In the 39th and 40th Sessions of the OIC CFM, held in November 2012 and December 2013, respectively, the peace efforts between the GPH and the MILF were welcomed, expressing the hope that the Agreement between the two parties would be in line with the 1976 Tripoli Agreement. Unfortunately, the efforts towards convergence of the MNLF and MILF peace tracks has been admittedly strained by the Sabah standoff of February 2013 and the Zamboanga City crisis of September 2013. Be that as it may, the OPAPP has remained in close cooperation with the OIC, the MNLF and the MILF in furtherance of the desire for convergence. The same remains true up to the present. On 15 October 2014, the Bangsamoro Coordination Forum (BCF) was activated, as agreed upon during the meeting of the chairpersons of the MNLF and MILF and the OIC Secretary General. The BCF, as stated in its meeting report, shall serve as the mechanism for the MNLF and the MILF to “coordinate their movements toward achieving the aspiration of the Bangsamoro people towards just and lasting peace, and peaceful resolution of their problems.” In April 2015, OIC Secretary General Iyad Ameen Madani visited the Philippines and met leaders of the MNLF and the MILF to jointly discuss through the BCF on how to best move forward in harmonizing the Mindanao Peace Processes and the agreements they signed separately with the GPH.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ekmeleddin_İhsanoğlu

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ekmeleddin_İhsanoğlu

3

Substantive Provisions of the BBL affecting the MNLF, the Sultanates and the IPs The desire to make the Bangsamoro proposal as inclusive as possible for the various affected

stakeholders extends beyond the process of consulting with them and soliciting their inputs.

The results of the many engagements and interactions with them have since found their way

into the substance of the proposed BBL.

Relative to the concern on the access to seats of political power in the prospective Bangsamoro

regional government, for instance, the proposal contained in the draft BBL in Article VII, Section

5 thereof on party seats in the Bangsamoro Parliament to be filled by proportional

representation as well as the system of reserved seats are deemed significant entry points for

the MNLF, the Sultanates and the IPs, among others, to directly participate in the governance

and administration of the autonomous region. These special stakeholder groups may organize

themselves into regional political parties and vie for seats as Members of Parliament in the

Bangsamoro. Parenthetically, the non-Moro IPs within the territory of the Bangsamoro can also

field candidates for the parliamentary seats reserved for them under the proposed law. All of

these special mechanisms for winning seats in the Bangsamoro Parliament shall be without

prejudice still to the special stakeholders participating in the district seats contest in the same

Bangsamoro Parliament. Clearly, the BBL offers a wide range of opportunities and openings for

the special stakeholder groups such as the MNLF, Sultanates and the IPs to have a real and

meaningful access to political power in the autonomous regional government.

Thru the Council of Leaders – a body that shall serve as the advisors of the Chief Minister on

matters of governance – there is yet another opening for these special stakeholder groups to be

involved in the governance of the autonomous region since the bill mandates, in Article VI,

Section 5 thereof, that representatives of “other sectors” must be included in its composition. To

be sure, the important sectors of the MNLF, the Sultanates and the IPs have to be considered in

the membership of the Council when the Bangsamoro Parliament enacts the relevant

implementing legislation for the operationalization of the Council of Leaders.

For the Sultanates, additionally, the draft BBL in Article IX, Section 19 provides for the

establishment of a Bangsamoro commission for the preservation of the history, culture, arts,

tradition and rich cultural heritage of the Sultanates. This is in full recognition of the vast role,

influence and contributions of the various Sultanates in the Bangsamoro. Significantly,

moreover, the BBL in Article X, Section 26 on the Bangsamoro Justice System also puts primacy

on the institutionalization of traditional systems of dispute resolution in connection with the

mandate therein for the Bangsamoro to evolve a system of Alternate Disposition Resolution

(ADR). The traditional roles of the Sultanates in dispute resolution by way of conciliation or

mediation would surely figure prominently in the ADR system that the Bangsamoro Parliament

shall enact.

Further to the policy of convergence with the MNLF, on the other hand, the provisions of the

draft BBL have also incorporated the so-called “42 Consensus Points” of the GPH-MNLF-OIC

4

Tripartite Implementation Review of the 1996 Final Peace Agreement. These consensus points

are spread along five (5) themes, namely: (1) on Shari'ah and Judiciary; (2) on Special Regional

Security Force and Unified Command in the Autonomous Region; (3) on Education; (4) on

Natural Resources and Economic Development; and (5) on Political System and Right of

Representation. All of these have been considered in the parallel subjects of the draft BBL,

particularly in Articles VI, VII, IX, X, XI, XII and XIII thereof. In this manner, it is hoped the

proposed BBL can become an effective vehicle for the convergence of the MNLF and MILF peace

tracks. We wish only to underscore that the impetus for the inclusion of the product of the GPH-

MNLF-OIC Tripartite Implementation Review in the draft BBL was a product of the

consultations with the MNLF representatives and members as well as of other stakeholders.

As for the IPs, finally, we find that the various sections of the draft BBL amply provides for

recognition, protection and promotion of IP rights and interests in the Bangsamoro. Drawing

from the existing corpus of IP rights that are articulated in domestic and international legal

sources such as Republic Act no. 8371 or the Indigenous Peoples Rights Act of 1997 (IPRA),

International Labor Organization (ILO) Convention 169, and the United Nations Declaration on

the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UN-DRIP), the draft BBL provides for the base or minimum

substantive protections and guarantees of IP rights and interests from which the future

Bangsamoro Parliament, in crafting its own indigenous peoples rights law, cannot diminish or

subtract. Although the full application of the IPRA per se is not expressly provided in the draft

law, the “bundle of rights” that are set forth therein have since been disaggregated and

integrated into the proposed BBL as follows:

Right to Ancestral Domains and Ancestral Lands (e.g. Article V, Section 4 [d]; Article IX,

Section 5);

Right to Self-Governance and Empowerment (e.g. Article VII, Sections 5-6; Article IX,

Section 5; Article X, Sections 23-24; Article XII, Section 34; Article XIII, Section 12);

Right to Social Justice and Human Rights (e.g. Article IX, Sections 1, 2, 5, 6, & 8); and

Right to Cultural Integrity (e.g. Article IX, Sections 5 & 19-21), among others.

These provisions of the draft BBL illustrate the clear and manifest intent of the proposed law to

lean heavily in favor of recognizing, protecting and promoting the interests and rights of the IPs

in the prospective Bangsamoro territory. Importantly, there is nothing in the draft law that

professes to derogate from nor otherwise diminish the existing rights of the IPs. While a more

secure language in the text of the draft BBL could be introduced in order to carry this intent

through or to further enhance its import, it has never been the case that the proposed

Bangsamoro law endeavored to gloss over or weaken the existing rights of IPs, contrary to what

has been claimed by some during the public hearings.

Support to the BBL: SWS Survey Results Amidst claims that there is no support to the proposed Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL) in the island provinces, the results of the Special Mindanao Survey conducted by the Social Weather

5

Stations (SWS) in February 20151 demonstrate that there is indeed significant support for the approval of the proposed bill. Based on the survey, more than half in Basilan (59%) and Tawi-Tawi (52%) are in favor of the passage of the BBL with only 12% in Basilan and 22% in Tawi-Tawi opposing it (see Figure I). In Sulu, 31% said that they approve the bill while only 14% claimed that they do not support it. In Isabela City, 38% said they support the bill versus 20% who said they oppose it.

FIGURE I. While there is a significant margin of undecided constituents, the results demonstrate that claims of widespread or homogenous disapproval of the BBL may have little empirical basis. What the survey results show is a significant number of Filipinos in the core areas both in mainland areas and the island provinces who consider the passage of the bill as a necessary measure to bring in peace and development to conflict-affected Muslim Mindanao. The results highlight that majority in Sulu (59%), Basilan (70%) and Tawi-Tawi (80%) agree with the proposed replacement of the ARMM with an expanded autonomous area called the Bangsamoro (see Figure II). In these areas, only 15% in Sulu, 10% in Basilan and 7% in Tawi-Tawi do not approve of the proposed dissolution of the ARMM. Meanwhile, mainland areas of the core territory consistently show high public support to the establishment of the Bangsamoro. Based in the survey results, 8 out of 10 in these areas in Central Mindanao agree with the replacement of the ARMM by the proposed Bangsamoro (see Figure III).

1 The results of the survey, “Filipino Public Opinion on the Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL) and the Mamasapano

Incident,” were presented in Balay Kalinaw, University of the Philippines Diliman on 15 May 2015.

6

42Filipino Public Opinion on

Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL)

and the Mamasapano Incident

Nov2012

Sulu

Agree Undecided Disagree Net*

OPINION ON THE FAB PROPOSAL: The dissolution of ARMM which will

be replaced by an expanded autonomous area which will be called

Bangsamoro, BASULTA, NOV 2012 TO FEB 2015

*Net figures (% Agree minus % Disagree) correctly rounded.

94

49

59

65

57

70

60

40

49

72

75

80

6

47

27

28

41

21

33

29

43

25

18

14

0

3

15

7

2

10

7

30

7

3

6

7

Feb2014

Feb2015

Nov2012

Basilan Feb2014

Feb2015

Nov2012Isabela

City Feb2014

Feb2015

Nov2012Tawi-

Tawi Feb2014

Feb2015

+94

+46

+44

+58

+55

+60

+53

+10

+42

+69

+69

+72

FIGURE II.

43Filipino Public Opinion on

Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL)

and the Mamasapano Incident

Nov2012Lanao

Del sur

Agree Undecided Disagree Net*

OPINION ON THE FAB PROPOSAL: The dissolution of ARMM which will

be replaced by an expanded autonomous area which will be called

Bangsamoro, CENTRAL MINDANAO, NOV 2012 TO FEB 2015

*Net figures (% Agree minus % Disagree) correctly rounded.

Feb2014

Feb2015

Nov2012Maguin-

danaoFeb2014

Feb2015

Nov2012Cotabato

CityFeb2014

Feb2015

Nov2012

Feb2014

Feb2015

+82

+77

+83

+73

+82

+84

+73

+75

+82

+75

+71

+68

88

83

88

79

87

88

80

8186

83

81

80

91

77

85

6

11

7

13

8

8

12

13

11

9

7

8

411

15

6

6

5

6

6

4

7

6

4

8

11

12

5

7

1

Nov2012

Feb2014

Feb2015

Lanao

near

ARMM

Cotabato

near

ARMM

+87

+70

+84

FIGURE III.

7

Although hope that the proposed Bangsamoro will bring peace and development ranges from slightly to extremely positive in the core territories – with areas in Central Mindanao as the most hopeful and Sulu fairly hopeful (see figure IV) – it can be noted that only a slim margin claim that they are not hopeful at all that the creation of the Bangsamoro will lead to peace and development in the area. It is significant to highlight that there is indeed no overwhelmingly negative perception towards the ability of the proposed Bangsamoro to be an avenue for lasting peace and development in Muslim Mindanao.

FIGURE IV. These figures further accentuate with how majority of the constituents in the core areas in Central Mindanao and BASULTA perceive that pursuing the peace talks between the Government and the MILF despite the Mamasapano incident is indeed beneficial. In Central Mindanao and BASULTA, generally 9 out 10 say that there is benefit from continuing the peace talks with the MILF (see Figure V). Among these areas, mainland areas are extremely positive that the peace talks with the MILF will benefit the Filipinos while BASULTA areas feel that it would only be moderately beneficial.

8

FIGURE V. Indeed, it cannot be denied that the Mamasapano incident has greatly affected the general perception on the peace process with the MILF, leaving only a fifth of Filipinos still supportive of the BBL as of February 2015. However, this sentiment as observed in the survey results is clearly not equally shared in core areas in Central Mindanao and BASULTA, where support to the BBL still remain net positive. Residents in the core territories also remain highly optimistic that Congress can pass the proposed bill despite the Mamasapano incident. The passage of the proposed BBL and the eventual establishment of the Bangsamoro should be subject to the consent of the governed. The BBL as a legislative measure is seen as part of the whole democratic process, the sentiments of the constituents in the core areas should be equally accorded attention as part and parcel of the democratically governed body politic. The BBL gives life to the spirit in which social justice and autonomy are provided for in the Constitution. Thus, we sincerely hope that a BBL that is just and truly responsive to the needs of the peace and development in Muslim Mindanao will be passed by the Senate.

9

TABLE I. Meetings/Briefings/Fora/Workshops/Consultations with the MNLF

NO. DATE EVENT ORGANIZER VENUE REPRESENTATIVE

FROM GPNP-MILF/OPAPP

AUDIENCE

1 11 April

2011

Convergence

Workshop on the

Mindanao Peace

Process (Part I)

GPNP-MILF

(Government

Peace

Negotiating Panel

for Talks with the

MILF)

O-Bistro, 5F

Oracle Hotel,

Katipunan Ave.,

Quezon City

GPH Panel (Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Ramon Piang, Dr. Hamid Barra)

MNLF Women’s Committee: Bainon

Karon;

Former Local Government

Officials: Bai Nurmallah Lucman,

Tahira Ismael-Sansawi;

LGU: Barry Macaumbos Datu Jubair

L. Macaumbos;

CSO: Mr. Ismael G. Kuliat, Adzfar H.

Usman, Said Ali, Noraida C. Abu,

Edmund Gumbahali, Naque B.

Amad, Salem C. Demuna, Baileng

Mantawil, Rubina Macabnar

2 02 June

2011

Meeting with the

Junior Cadres of the

MNLF

GPNP-MILF Asian Center

Conference Hall,

UP Diliman,

Quezon City

GPH Panel (Dean Marvic

Leonen, Prof. Miriam

Coronel, Sec. Senen

Bacani, Dr. Hamid Barra)

MNLF Junior Cadres: Hji. Wati

Hussin, Hji. Nizam Alsad, Moh. John

Usman, Hji. Abbas Tangkian,

Nursad Wahi, Rajis Halipa, Jadjurie

Arasa, Saudi Zapanta, Nasser

Halipa, Ustadz Abdulkabir Musa,

Saber Sarail, Alimatar Alfad,

Sammy Arsad, Kernibi Jalali

10

3 16 June

2011

Convergence

Workshop on the

Mindanao Peace

Process (Part II)

GPNP-MILF,

MNLF, MILF

Oracle Hotel,

Katipunan

Avenue, Quezon

City

Sec. Ging Deles and GPH

Panel (Dean Marvic


Coronel Ferrer, Sec.

Senen C. Bacani, Dr.

Hamid Barra)

Ustadz Anwar Radiamoda, Ustadz

Ali Omar, Ustadz Musa Macapasir,

Ustadz Nasrodin Didaagun, Ustadz

Samsodin Mindalano, Ustadz

Camaludden Abdulhamid, Ustadz

Usman Casanguan, Ustadz Jaafar

Ali, Ustadz Abdulwahab Ayao,

Ustadz Bajunaid Ibrahim, Ustadz

Ahmad Mal

4 16

November

2011

Roundtable

Discussion on the

"Mindanao Peace

Processes: Issues and

Prospects" (MNLF-

MILF Convergence

Workshop Part III)

GPNP-MILF Richmonde Hotel,

Ortigas Center,

Pasig City

GPH Panel (Dean Marvic


Coronel Ferrer, Sec.

Senen Bacani)

MNLF, CSOs, Academe, Religious

5 02

December

2012

Provincial Forum on

the Framework

Agreement on the

Bangsamoro

Provincial Multi-

purpose Gym,

Patikul, Sulu

Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP)

Gov. Abdusakur Tan (Sulu), Usec. Nabil Tan (OP), Chairman Nur Misuari (MNLF), Hji Toks Ebrahim (MILF), Gov. Jum Akbar (Basilan), Gov. Sadikul Sahali (Tawi-Tawi), Gov. Esmael “Toto” Mangundadatu (Maguindanao), Comm. Edilwasif Baddiri (NCMF), Rep. Habib Tupay, CSOs, Academe

6 19

February

2013

Multi-stakeholders

forum on the FAB

Governor Miguel

Rene Dominguez,

Sarangani

Notre Dame Dadiangas University Auditorium, General Santos City

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer

Barangay officials, purok officials, elders, youth, women, farmers, fishermen, teachers, barangay health workers, religious leaders, traditional leaders, Moro National Liberation Front and ordinary

11

citizens from Region 12; SocSarGen Peace Network, Kalina

7 27 September 2013

Roundtable Discussion (RTD)on the Zamboanga Crisis

UP Institute of Islamic Studies and Initiatives for International Dialogue (IID)

UP Asian Center Auditorium

Usec. Jose Luis Gascon (Chair, GPH TWG on Power Sharing)

MNLF, CSOs, Academe

8 01

February

2014

Public Forum on the

Framework

Agreement on the

Bangsamoro (FAB)

Aksyon para sa

Kapayapaan at

Katarungan

(AKKAPKA)

Blue Mosque Cultural Center, Taguig

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman (Head, GPH Legal)

Jadjurie Arasa (Blue Mosque administrator and former MNLF senior leader), MNLF Former Commander Nikaburin Andah, MNLF Junior Official Benj Saudi, around 100 participants from CSOs, religious leaders, and local residents and community leaders

9 07 June

2014

Interreligious and

Intercultural

Conference “Peace is

Living together:

Religions and

Cultures in Dialogue

for Peace and

Reconciliation in

Mindanao”

The Archdiocese

of Cotabato

Notre Dame University, Cotabato


MNLF, ARMM,NGOs, Lumad, Political and Religious Leaders

10 20 January 2015

HOR Ad Hoc Committee on the BBL Hearing: Representatives from MNLF and its different factions, MILF, BIFF

House of Representatives

Nograles Hall, South Wing Annex, HOR, Batasan Complex, Quezon City

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman (Head, GPH Legal)

HOR, MNLF

12

TABLE II. Meetings/Briefings/Fora/Workshops/Consultations with Sultanates in Mindanao



AUDIENCE

1 14 March 2011

Briefing on Sulu Sultanate

GPNP-MILF UP College of Law, University of the Philippines Diliman, Quezon City

GPH Panel (Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani)

DFA Asec. Ed Malaya, Milet Mendoza, Vic Taylor, Abe Idjirani (Sultanate of Sulu)

2 09 June 2011

Meeting with Representatives from the Sultanate of Sulu

GPNP-MILF Richmonde Hotel, San Miguel Ave., Ortigas Center, Pasig City

Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer

Sultanate of Sulu: Sultan Jamalul Kiram III, Sultan Esmail Kiram, Rajah Muda Agbimuddin Kiram

3 09 February 2013

FAB Briefing with Hadja Bai Putri Marieta Nor-Aisha Mindalano, Maharadjah Tabunaway Descendants Council of the Philippines, Inc.

Maharadjah Tabunaway Descendants Council of the Philippines, Inc. (MTDCP)

El Manuel Convention Center, Parang Rd., Cotabato City


Maharadjah Tabunaway: Hadja Bai Putri Marieta Nor-Aisha Mindalano

4 18 March 2013

Sabah Forum UP Institute of Islamic Studies

UP College of Social Work and Development, University of the Philippines Diliman, Quezon City

GPH Panel (Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Mehol Sadain, Use. Yasmin Busran-Lao)

Royal Houses, Academe, CSOs, LGUs Sultanate of Sulu: Sec. Gen. Abraham Idjirani; Academe: Dean Julkipli Wadi (UP IIS), Prof. Carmen Abubakar (UP IIS), Dean Merlin Magallona (UP Law), Prof. Prospero De Vera

13

(NCPAG), Dean Carolyn Sobritchea (Asian Center), Prof. Amado Mendoza Jr. (CSSP); FSI: Kadatuan Usop; Former UN Amb. Lauro Baja Jr., Atty. Leonard de Vera, Public Officials: Rep. Tupay Loong, F/Vice Pres. Teofisto Guingona II, F/Gov. Tillah

5 28 December 2013

Sulu Forum OPAPP Provincial Capitol Ace Building, Patikul, Sulu

GPH Panel (Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Sec. Mehol Sadain), Sec. Ging Deles, Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP)

Gov. Abdusakur Tan, Rep. Tupay Loong, Hon. Miriam Arbison, BTC Comm. Asani Tammang, OES Usec. Nabil Tan, NCMF Comm. Edilwassif Baddiri, ARMM LGUs,Religious, Academe, Youth, AFP, Sultanate of Sulu, CSOs

6 17 May 2015

Meeting with Sultanate of Sulu Sec. Gen. Abraham Idjirani

GPNP-MILF Sentro, Serendra, Bonifacio Global City, Taguig City

Sec. Senen Bacani, Dir. Hadzer Birowa

Sultanate of Sulu: Sec. Gen. Abraham Idjirani

TABLE III. Meetings/Briefings/Fora/Workshops/Consultations with Indigenous Peoples (IPs)

NO. DATE EVENT ORGANIZER VENUE REPRESENTATIVE FROM

GPNP-MILF/OPAPP AUDIENCE

1 19 October 2010

Consultation with Non-Islamized IPs of ARMM and Sultan Kudarat

National Solidarity Conference on Mindanao

Marco Polo Hotel, Davao City

GPH Panel (Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Ramon Piang, Dr.

IPs

14

Hamid Barra) 2 28 May

2011

Consultation with IP Leaders at the Mindanao Human Rights Action Center (MinHRAC)

Mindanao Human Rights Action Center (MinHRAC)

Mindanao Human Rights Action Center (MinHRAC), Cotabato City

GPH Panel (Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Ramon Piang, Dr. Hamid Barra)

IPs, CSOs

3 02 September 2011

Focus Group Discussion with IP Leaders

Mayor Ramon Piang

Koresco Hotel, Cagayan de Oro City

Mayor Ramon Piang IPs

4 07 February 2012

Consultation with the LGU of Upi

LGU of Upi Upi Municipal Hall, Maguindanao

GPH Panel (Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec, Yasmin Busran-Lao, Mayor Ramon Piang)

LGUs, IPs

5 28 April 2012

Meeting with Davao CSOs

GPNP-MILF Coffee for Peace Café, Davao City

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer CSOs, IPs

6 03 March 2012

Meeting with Indigenous Peoples in Mindanao

NCIP and Mindanao Peoples’ Peace Movement (MPPM)

Aviary Restaurant, The Farm, Koronadal City, South Cotabato

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer IPs, Other government agencies, CSOs, Military

7 04 May 2012

Consultation with Teachers' Dignity Coalition-Mindanao

Punta Isla Resort, Lake Sebu, South Cotabato

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer Academe, IPs, Military

8 05 May 2012

Meeting with Kilos Kapayapaan and CSOs

Kilos Kapayapaan Manila Room, 15 Floor Regalia Tower Suites, P. Tuazon Avenue Cubao Quezon City, Philippines

Sec. Senen Bacani CSOs, IPs

9 18 May 2012

Caucus with Multi-stakeholders on the Mindanao Peace Process

Bishops-Ulama Conference, 4/F Karpentrade Bldg., McArthur

Dean Marvic Leonen CSOs, IPs

15

Highway, Matina, Davao City

10 24 November 2012

FAB presentation during the Peace Week forum

Interreligious Solidarity Movement for Peace

Marcian Business Hotel, Zamboanga City

Atty. Johaira Wahab (Head, GPH Legal Team)

CSOs, IPs

11 07 December 2012

Q&A on the FAB during the National Conference of Kilos Kapayapaan and Waging Peace Philippines

Kilos Kapayapaan and Waging Peace Philippines

ISO, Ateneo de Manila University

Sec. Ging Deles, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer

CSOs, IPs

12 09 January 2013

RTD with academe and CSOs on the Bangsamoro Basic Law

Alnor Suites, Cotabato City

Atty. Johaira Wahab (Head, GPH Legal Team)

Academe, IPs, Religious, CSOs, Media

13 12 January 2013

Regional Indigenous Peoples Consultative Assembly

LGU of Upi Upi, Maguindanao Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao

IPs, LGUs

14 13 March 2013

NCMF Partnership Forum

NCMF Visayas Cebu International Convention Center, Mandaue City

Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao IPs, CSOs

15 22 May 2013

Seminar on the FAB NCIP c/o Ms. Alzareth Barton

The Royal Mandaya Hotel, Palma Gil, Davao

Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman (Head, GPH Legal Team)

IPs

16 10/11/2013 Gathering with IP advocates to share developments of the GPH-MILF peace processes

Jimid Mansayagan, Chairperson, Lumad Mindanaw Peoples Federation

Eden Nature’s Park & Resort

Atty. Armi Beatriz Bayot (Member, GPH Legal Team)

IPs

17 20 December 2013

7th Mindanao Peoples’ Peace Summit Presentation on “Government

Mindanao Peoples' Peace Movement (MPPM)

Mindanao Civic Center (MCC), Tubod, Lanao del Norte

Atty. Armi Beatriz Bayot (Member, GPH Legal Team)

CSOs, IPs

16

Perspectives on the GPH-MILF Peace Process”

18 27 December 2013

“BARUG NA! Tribal Conference on Self Determination and the Peace Process”

Initiatives for International Dialogue (IID) and Mindanao Indigenous Peoples Forum (MIPF)

University of Southern Mindanao (USM) Hostel, Kabacan, Cotabato

Dir. Iona Gracia Jalijali (Head, GPH Panel Secretariat)

IPs

19 28 January 2014

Meeting with IP leaders Initiatives for International Dialogue (IID)

Cotabato City Dir. Iona Gracia Jalijali (Head, GPH Panel Secretariat)

IPs

20 06 February 2014

Meeting with IP groups Initiatives for International Dialogue (IID)

Alnor Suites, Cotabato City

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao

IPs

21 24 February 2014

RTD with NCIP NCIP NCIP Conference Room, 2F N. dela Merced Bldg., West cor. Quezon Ave., Quezon City

Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman (GPH Legal Team), Atty. Armi Bayot (GPH Legal)

IPs

22 07 June 2014

Interreligious and Intercultural Conference “Peace is Living together: Religions and Cultures in Dialogue for Peace and Reconciliation in Mindanao”

The Archdiocese of Cotabato


Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer MNLF, ARMM, NGOs, IPs, LGUs, Religious

23 25 July 2014 Meeting with Initiatives for International Dialogue (IID) and Key IP Leaders (Teduray,

Lyndee Prieto OPAPP Sec. Ging Deles, Wendell Orbeso (GPH Panel Secretariat)

IPs

17

Lambangian, Erumanen Menuvu)

24 19 September 2014

International Day of Peace – Discussion on some salient points of the BBL and status of GPH-MILF peace process

Dir. Rodel Ambangan, IPDS-SCC Chair, Mindanao Peoples Peace Movement (MPPC)

AVC Hall, Southern Christian College, Midsayap, Cotabato

Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin Julkipli (Member, GPH Legal Team)

CSOs, IPs


Lakbay Tribo para sa Karapatan sa Sariling Pagpapasya - Sept 25-26

Mindanao Peoples’ Peace Movement, Inc.

Pagadian City – ZamSurEco Gym Dinas, Zamboanga del Sur – Dinas Catholic Formation

Atty. Jesus Doque IV (Member, GPH Legal Team)

CSOs, IPs


Inter-tribal IP Peace Summit

Teduray Lambangian Women’s Organization, Inc. TLWOI

Municipal Gym, Upi, Nuro Upi, Maguindanao

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer IPs, CSOs

27 13 October 2014

Mindanao Peoples Peace Movement Inc. “Conversations with the IPs”

MPPCI Matet Norbe

Multi Media Room, College of Science


CSOs, IPs

28 17 October 2014

5th State of the Indigenous Peoples Address (SIPA) Dialogue with OPAPP

NCIP NCIP Central Office, 2F N. dela Merced Building, cor. West and Quezon Aves, Quezon City


IPs, CSOs

29 24 October 2014

HOR Ad Hoc Committee on the BBL public consultation


General Santos City, South Cotabato

Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP) CSOs, IPs

18

30 24 October 2014



Koronadal City, South Cotabato


CSOs, IPs

31 24 October 2014



Tacurong City, Sultan Kudarat


CSOs, IPs

32 11 May 2015

Orientation and Workshop on the CAB and BBL to Indigenous People Groups

OPAPP Woodland Resort and Restaurant, Zambowood Rd, Zamboanga,

CSOs and IPs

TABLE IV. Meetings/Briefings/Fora/Workshops/Consultations with LGUs



AUDIENCE

1 16/11/2010 Meeting with LGU officials of Lanao del Norte and Marawi City

GPNP-MILF Elena Tower Inn, Iligan City

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Mayor Ramon Piang

LGU of Lanao del Norte and Marawi City

2 08/03/2011 Planning Meeting for LGU Consultation

GPNP-MILF Kwago Function Room, Waterfront Insular Hotel, Lanang, Davao City

Mayor Ramon Piang LGUs: 3 Mayors; 1 Vice Mayor and representative of Mayor of Isulan

3 13/04/2011 Consultation with Local Government Officials of Maguindanao

GPNP-MILF Genalin Resort, Barangay Calean, Tacurong City, Sultan Kudarat

Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Mayor Ramon Piang, Dr. Hamid Barra

LGUs of Maguindanao: Gov. Toto Mangudadatu, 5 Provincial Board Members, 24 Mayors, 19 Vice-Mayors, 9 ABC Presidents and 2 SK Federation Presidents

4 14/04/2011 Consultation with Local Government

GPNP-MILF Provincial Capitol, Isulan, Sultan Kudarat

Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel

LGU of Sultan Kudarat: Rep. Arnulfo Go, Vice-Gov.

19

officials of Sultan Kudarat

Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Mayor Ramon Piang, Dr. Hamid Barra

Ernesto Fontanilla, 10 Mayors, 8 Vice-Mayors, 7 ABC Presidents

5 16/05/2011 Consultation with Local Government Officials of Basilan

GPNP-MILF Provincial Capitol, Isabela City


LGU of Basilan: Gov. Jum Akbar, Vice-Gov. Al-Rasheed Sakkalahul, 2 Provincial Board Members, 9 Mayors, 4 Vice-Mayors, 1 PCL President, 3 ABC Presidents and 2 SK Federation Presidents

6 17/05/2011 Consultation Meeting with Zamboanga City Mayor and the City Council

GPNP-MILF Sangguniang Panglungsod Session Hall, City Hall, Zamboanga City

Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Dr. Hamid Barra

LGU of Zamboanga: Mayor Celso Lobregat, Vice-Mayor Cesar Iturralde, 9 Councilors and ABC President Abdurahman Nuño

7 18/05/2011 Consultation with Local Government Officials of Sulu

GPNP-MILF Lantaka Hotel, Zamboanga City

Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Dr. Hamid Barra

LGU of Sulu: Vice-Governor Benjamin T. Loong, 3 Provincial Board Members, 9 Mayors, 5 Vice-Mayors

8 07/06/2011 Consultation with Local Government Officials of Tawi-Tawi

GPNP-MILF Sangguniang Panlalawigan Session Hall, Provincial Capitol, Bongao, Tawi-Tawi

Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Dr. Hamid Barra

LGU of Tawi-Tawi: Gov. Sadikul Sahali, Vice-Gov. Rubi Sahali-Tan, 3 Provincial Board Members, 8 Mayors, 4 Vice-Mayors, 7 ABC Presidents

9 29/08/2011 Consultation with Christian Leaders

Marco Polo Hotel, Davao City

Dean Marvic Leonen Religious, LGUs, Military: Former Gov. Manny Piñol, Former Gov. Grace Padaca, Gov. Miguel Dominguez,

20

Gen. Ariel Bernardo, Gen. Alan Luga, Gen. Roa, Maj. Carlos Sol

10 07/09/2011 Consultation with Governors and Chartered City Mayors

GPNP-MILF Marco Polo Hotel, Davao City

Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Sec. Ging Deles

LGUs: Sultan Kudarat Gov. Suharto T. Mangudadatu, N. Cotabato Gov. Emmylou J. Taliño-Mendoza, S. Cotabato Gov. Arthur Y. Pingoy, Jr., Sarangani Gov. Miguel Rene A. Dominguez, Zamboanga Sibugay Gov. Rommel A. Jalosjos, Zamboanga del Sur Gov. Antonio H. Cerilles

11 06/10/2011 Region-wide (Region 12) LGU Consultations

Region 12 LGU Provincial Capitol, Kidapawan City, North Cotabato


LGUs: Gov. Emmylou Taliño-Mendoza, 12 Mayors and 7 Vice Mayors Sultan Kudarat Vice Gov. Ernesto F. Matias, M.D., 2 Mayors, 1 Vice-Mayor and 1 Provincial Board Member

12 07/02/2012 Consultation with the LGU of Upi

LGU of Upi Upi Municipal Hall, Maguindanao

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Mayor Ramon Piang, Dr. Hamid Barra, Atty. Johaira Wahab (Head, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs, IPs: Upi Vice-Mayor, SB Members

13 02/05/2012 Meeting with Gov. Arthur Pingoy Jr.

GPNP-MILF South Cotabato Provincial Capitol


LGUs: Gov. Arthur Pingoy Jr., Vice-

21

and local executives in South Cotabato

Governor Elmo B. Toloso, Provincial Legal Officer Atty. Romeo Sucaldito Jr., LMT Jose Madunguit (Board Member), Former Cong. Piňol (Consultant in DAR), 10th ID BGen. Ariel Bernardo, GPH-CCCH Secretariat Head Major Carlos Sol,

14 11/05/2012 Peace and Order Council Meeting

Iligan City LGU SP Session Hall, Iligan City


LGUs

15 17/05/2012 Consultation with Zamboanga City executives

OPAPP Zamboanga City Hall Sec. Ging Deles, Dean Marvic Leonen

LGUs: Congresswoman Beng Climaco, Vice Mayor Cesar S. Iturralde, city councilors of two districts

16 07/06/2012 ARMM RLA Executive Session

ARMM RLA Executive Lounge, RLA Building, Cotabato

Dean Marvic Leonen, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Atty. Johaira Wahab (Head, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs, RLA

17 31/07/2012 Consultation with Gov. Lala Taliño and North Cotabato Mayors and Board Members

GPNP-MILF Governor's Office, Cotabato Provincial Capitol, Amas, Kidapawan City

Dean Marvic Leonen, Atty. Johaira Wahab (Head, GPH Legal Team)

Gov. Lala Taliño-Mendoza, Cotabato Mayors and Board Members, Officers of 6th ID, AHJAG, and CCCH, Senior Military Adviser

18 15/08/2012 Briefing with CG, 6th ID and ARMM OIC Governor

GPNP-MILF 6th ID, Cotabato City Dean Marvic Leonen, Atty. Johaira Wahab (Head, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs, Military: ARMM OIC Governor, Officers of AHJAG, CCCH and SMA

19 18/09/2012 Consultation with GPNP-MILF The Podium, ADB Ave., Sec. Ging Deles, Dean Gov. Lala Taliño-Mendoza

22

Cotabato Gov. Lala Taliño-Mendoza

Ortigas Center, Mandaluyong City

Marvic Leonen, Asec. Rosalie Romero

20 09/10/2012 Meeting with the ARMM Governors

OPAPP CYMA, MAkati Sec. Ging Deles LGUs: Gov. Esmael Mangudadatu, Gov. Jum Akbar, Gov Abdusakur Tan, Gov. Sadikul Sahali, Gov Mamintal Bombit Adiong

21 09/10/2012 Media consultation on the FAB

Office of the Regional Governor, ARMM

Office of the Regional Governor, ARMM Complex, Cotabato City

Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao LGUs: RG Mujiv Hataman, CSOs, ARMM local government officials

22 10/10/2012 Talk on FAB during a peace rally by the Consortium of Bangsamoro Civil Society

Consortium of Bangsamoro Civil Society

Cotabato City Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao LGUs, CSOs: RG Hataman, RVGov Bainon Karon, RLA Speaker Rasul Matmug, Jr., RLA Assemblyman Romeo Sema, other members of the RLA and Cabinet, members of Consortium of Bangsamoro Civil Society

23 17/10/2012 Consultation with ARMM RLA

ARMM RLA OPAPP Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Atty. Johaira Wahab (Head, GPH Legal Team)

Assy. Abdel Anni, Rahima Alba, Deonato Mokudef, Mohammad Sarapuddin, Sittie Norhanie Lao, Juni Kimin, Dayang Jumaide, Irene Tiillah, Rodolfo Bawasanta, Rasol Mitmug Jr., Samira Gutoc, Rajam Akbar, Mahendra Madjilon, Romeo Sema

24 02/12/2012 Provincial Forum on the Framework

Provincial Multi-purpose Gym, Patikul,


LGUs, CSOs, Community, Religious, MNLF, academe:

23

Agreement on the Bangsamoro

Sulu Gov. Abdusakur Tan (Sulu), Usec. Nabil Tan (OP), Chairman Nur Misuari (MNLF), Hji Toks Ebrahim (MILF), Gov. Jum Akbar (Basilan), Gov. Sadikul Sahali (Tawi-Tawi), Gov. Esmael Toto Mangundadatu (Maguindanao), Com. Edilwasif Baddiri (NCMF), Cong. Dr. Hamid Barraib Tupay

25 04/12/2012 Regional Forum on the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro

LGU of Sulu Provincial Multi-purpose Gym, Patikul, Sulu


LGUs, CSOs, Constituents: Gov. Abdusakur Tan (Sulu), Usec. Nabil Tan (OP), Chairman Nur Misuari (MNLF), Hji Toks Ebrahim (MILF), Gov. Jum Akbar (Basilan), Gov. Sadikul Sahali (Tawi-Tawi), Gov. Esmael Toto Mangundadatu (Maguindanao), Com. Edilwasif Baddiri (NCMF), Cong. Dr. Hamid Barraib Tupay

26 04/12/2012 Briefing for the Regional Peace and Order Council (RCPOC)

RPOC Davao City Usec. Jose Luis Martin Gascon (Chair, GPH TWG on Power Sharing)

LGUs members of RPOC

27 06/12/2012 FAB presentation during the Peace Conference 2012

Basilan State College Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer

LGUs, Academe, Religious

28 10/01/2013 Second Regional Province of Buluan Municipal Gym, Prof. Miriam Coronel LGU:

24

Forum on the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro

Maguindanao Buluan, Maguindanao Ferrer Gov. Esmael Mangudadatu

29 12/01/2013 Regional Indigenous Peoples Consultative Assembly

GPNP-MILF Upi, Maguindanao Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao

IPs, LGUs

30 13/01/2013 Wao Consultation on the FAB

LGU of LDS / LDS Provincial Government Office

Wao, Lanao del Sur Sec. Mehol Sadain LGUs, religious, youth: RG Mujiv Hataman, Gov. Bombit Adiong, Mayor of Wao, religious leaders, students, barangay officials and representatives, municipal council

31 29/01/2013 Provincial Peace and Order Council (PPOC) Meeting

PPOC Tubod, Lanao del Norte

Sec. Ging Deles, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer

LGUs, Other government agencies: Gov. Khalid Dimaporo, Atty. Rene Burdeos (Regional Director, DILG, Region X), PPOC Secretariat

32 04/02/2013 Presentation to the ARMM RLA on the FAB in relation to IPRA

ARMM RLA Cotabato City Atty. Johaira Wahab (Head, GPH Legal Team)

LGU: ARMM RLA Members

33 19/02/2013 Multi-stakeholders forum on the FAB

LGU of Sarangani / Governor Miguel Rene Dominguez, Sarangani

Notre Dame Dadiangas University Auditorium, General Santos City


LGUs, Youth, Community, CSOs, Religious, MNLF

34 12/03/2013 RLA 3rd Committee Hearing on Resolution No. 133

ARMM Regional Assembly

RLA Executive Lounge, ORG Compound, Cotabato

Atty. Armi Bayot (Member, GPH Legal Team)

LGU: ARMM RLA

25

35 30/04/2013 Inter-Faith Dialogue: Forum on Responsible Voting and Orientation on the Bangsamoro Framework Agreement

Province of Sarangani

Municipal Gym, Maasin, Sarangani

Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao LGUs, Community: LGUs and constituents from Sarangani

36 05/08/2013 Meeting with Iligan City Mayor Celso Regencia

Iligan City LGU Mayor's Office, Iligan City Hall

Prof. Miriam Coronel, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Yasmin Busran Lao

LGUs

37 13/12/2013 Orientation on the FAB and the MNLF Final Peace Agreement (FPA) participated by the Municipal, Provincial Officials and other peace partners in Sarangani Province

Sarangani Province, Office of the Governor (through IEC)

Sarangani Highlands, Sarangania Hall, Tambler, General Santos City

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Sec. Mehol Sadain

LGUs: Elected officials of Sarangani

38 18/12/2013 City Government Forum (updates on the peace process)

IEC-OPAPP Zamboanga City Hall Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Sec. Mehol Sadain

LGUs: Mayor Beng Climaco-Salazar, Vice Mayor Cesar Iturralde, city councilors

39 28/12/2013 Sulu Forum OPAPP Provincial Capitol Ace Building, Patikul, Sulu

Sec. Ging Deles, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Sec. Mehol Sadain, Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP)

LGUs, Religious, Academe, Youth, AFP, Royal Houses, CSOs, Community: Gov. Abdulsakur Tan, Hon. Tupay Loong, Hon. Miriam Arbison, BTC Comm. Asani Tammang, OES Usec Nabil Tan, NCMF Comm.

26

Edilwassif Baddiri, ARMM LCEs

40 05/02/2014 Briefing during the Joint Provincial Development Council (PDC) and Provincial Peace and Order Council (PPOC) meeting

North Cotabato PPOC

Capitol Rooftop, Amas, Kidapawan City


LGUs, Other government agencies: Gov. Lala Talino-Mendoza, VGov Gregorio Ipong, Rep. Jose Tejada, municipal and city mayors, board members, cooperatives, Hon. Kelie Antao (board member/chair)

41 11/02/2014 ARMM LGU Summit Waterfront Insular Hotel, Davao City

Sec. Mehol Sadain, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao

LGUs

42 18/02/2014 Public Hearing on Proposed Senate Resolution No. 471

Senate Senate, Pasay City Sec. Ging Deles, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao, Usec. Chito Gascon (Chair, GPH TWG on Power Sharing), Atty. Anna Basman (Head, GPH Legal Team)

Senate, LGUs

43 05/03/2014 House Committee on Mindanao Affairs briefing re FAB and Annexes

House of Representatives Committee on Mindanao Affaris

Nograles Hall, South Wing Annex, HOR

Sec. Ging Deles, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Mehol Sadain, Usec Chito Gascon (Chair GPH TWG on Power Sharing), Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman (Head, GPH Legal Team)

HOR, LGUs

44 11/03/2014 GPH Panel and BTC Lanao del Sur Provincial

LDS Provincial Gov Office and OPAPP

Provincial Capitol Gym, Marawi City

Sec. Ging Deles, Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Mehol Sadain, Usec.

LGUs, Religious, Academe, Youth, Traditional Leaders, CSOs, Community

27

Consultation Chito Gascon (Chair, GPH TWG on Power Sharing)

45 11/03/2014 Consultation with Lanao del Norte Mayors

GPH CCCH / GPNP-MILF

Hotel Alemania, Iligan City


LGUs: Mayor Fatima Tomawis (Tangkal, Lanao del Norte), Mayor Ibrahim Tuano (Tagaloan, Lanao del Norte),

46 12/03/2014 Consultation with Mayor Rommel Arnado

GPH CCCH / GPNP-MILF

Mayor's Office, Kauswagan, Lanao del Norte


LGUs

47 17/03/2014 WMSU Engagement with Conciliation Resources to discuss the Final Agreement on the Bangsamoro peace process

Western Mindanao State University (WMSU)

Grand Astoria Hotel, Zamboanga City

Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao LGUs, CSOs, community, Academe

48 19/03/2014 Briefing for the 3rd National Human Resource Development (HRD)

Cooperative Development Authority

Subic Bay, Travellers Hotel, Subic Bay

Usec. Yasmin Busran-Lao LGUs

49 21/03/2014 Briefing during the Provincial Peace and Order Council Meeting of Zamboanga del Norte

101st BDE, Philippine Army

Top Plaza Hotel, Dipolog City

Atty. Armi Bayot (Head, GPH Legal Team)

Military, LGUs

50 21/04/2014 Consultation at Wao, Lanao del Sur

GPNP-MILF with Lihok Wao and Lanao del Sur Provincial Government

Wao Public Plaza, Muncipality of Wao, Lanao del Sur

Sec. Senen Bacani LGUs, Community: Comm. Peter Eisma, Comm. Said Shiek, Gov. Mamintal Alonto Adiong III, Mayor Elvino Balicao, Jr.

51 05/06/2014 RDC Zamboanga NEDA Regional Audio Visual Room, Prof. Miriam Coronel LGUs, Other government

28

147th RDC IX meeting re CAtty. Armi Bayot (Member, GPH Legal Team)riefing

Office IX Claret College, Isabela City

Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani agencies

52 07/06/2014 Interreligious and Intercultural Conference “Peace is Living together: Religions and Cultures in Dialogue for Peace and Reconciliation in Mindanao”

The Archdiocese of Cotabato



MNLF, ARMM, NGOs, IPs, LGUs, Religious

53 25/06/2014 RDC XII 46th Regular Meeting Re CAB Briefing

RDC XII Provincial Capitol Rooftop, Amas, Kidapawan City, Cotabato

Atty. Armi Bayot (Member, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs

54 23/07/2014 Region XII LGA Orientation Workshop on CAB

Nasif Mangotara

General Santos City Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin (Member, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs

55 06/08/2014 Region IX LGA Orientation Workshop on CAB

Nasif Mangotara

Zamboanga City Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer

LGUs

56 07/08/2014 BASULTA LGA Orientation Workshop on CAB

Nasif Mangotara

Zamboanga City Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer

LGUs

57 09/08/2014 Discussion on the Bangsamoro political entity and it’s impact to peacebuilding in Mindanao

Municipal Gymnasium of Pangantucan, Bukidnon


LGUs, CSOs, Community

29

58 11/08/2014 Maguindanao, LDS LGA Orientation Workshop on CAB

Nasif Mangotara

Cotabato City Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer

LGUs

59 01/09/2014 BASULTA LGA Orientation Workshop

Nasif Mangotara

Zamboanga City Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin (Member, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs

60 10/09/2014 Region 10 LGA Orientation Workshop

Nasif Mangotara

Harbor Lights Hotel, CDO


LGUs

61 24/09/2014 Region 9 LGA Orientation Workshop

Nasif Mangotara

Zamboanga City Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin (Member, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs

62 25/09/2014 CARAGA LGA Orientation Workshop

Nasif Mangotara

Butuan City Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin (Member, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs

63 16/10/2014 HoR Public Consultation (Initial Public Consultation on the Bangsamoro Basic Law)

HOR (Office of Rep. Vicente Belmonte)

Celadon Pensionne House, Pala-o, Iligan

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani


64 22/10/2014 HOR Ad Hoc Committee on the BBL public consultation

HOR Upi, Maguindanao Asec. Howard Cafagauan (OPAPP)


65 22/10/2014 OMI Provincial Congress re BBL

Fr. Bert Binoligan Retreat Center, Kidapawan


LGUs

66 23/10/2014 Senate Public Hearing

Senate Marawi Provincial Capitol

Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin (Member, GPH Legal Team)


67 23/10/2014 HOR Ad Hoc Committee on the BBL public

HOR Polytechnic College Gym, Cotabato City



30

consultation 68 24/10/2014 LGA Orientation

Workshop on the CAB

Region XI Metropolitan Suites, Davao

Atty Jesus Doque Iv (Member, GPH Panel Legal Team)

LGUs


HOR General Santos City, South Cotabato


LGUs, CSOs, IPs


HOR Koronadal City, South Cotabato


LGUs, CSOs, IPs


HOR Tacurong City, Sultan Kudarat


LGUs, CSOs, IPs

72 11/11/2014 Senate Public Hearing on the BBL

Senate Sandbar Lepa Convention Center, Pasiagan, Bongao, Tawi-Tawi

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP), Atty. Al Julkipli

LGUs, CSOs, NGOs, Community


HOR Tawi-Tawi Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP), Atty. Al Julkipli



HOR Zamboanga City Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP), Atty. Al Julkipli


75 18/11/2014 CAB Orientation for DILG Reg XIII RPOC, PPOCs and CPOC

Region XIII Butuan City, Agusan Del Norte

LGUs, Other government agencies

76 19/11/2014 HOR Ad Hoc Committee on the

HOR Jolo, Sulu Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Usec. Jose Lorena

LGUs, CSOs, NGOS, Community

31

BBL public consultation

(OPAPP), Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman


HOR Isabela City, Basilan Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman



HOR Provincial Capitol Gym, Ipil Heights, Ipil, Zamboanga Sibugay

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP), Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman



HOR Marawi City Atty. Anan Tarhata Basman



HOR Tubod, Lanao del Norte

Sec. Senen Bacani LGUs, CSOs, Community


HOR Iligan City Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman



HOR Pagadian City Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer



HOR Cagayan de Oro City Sec. Senen Bacani, Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman


84 05/12/2014 HOR Ad Hoc Committee on the BBL public

HOR Northern Christian College, Laoag City, Ilocos Norte

Atty. Al Julkipli LGUs, CSOs, Community

32

consultation 85 05/12/2014 HOR Ad Hoc

Committee on the BBL public consultation

HOR Baguio City National High School, Baguio, Benguet,




HOR Municipal Gym, .Buluan, Magiundanao




HOR CAP Auditorium, Davao City

Usec. Jose Lorena, Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman



HOR Midsayap Municipal Gym, North Cotabato

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Jose Lorena



HOR CARAGA State University Gym, Butuan City

Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin Julkipli



HOR JSU-PSU Mariner's Court, Quezon Boulevard, Cebu City




HOR Session Hall, Provincial Capitol, Iloilo City

Usec. Jose Lorena, Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin Julkipli


92 21/01/2015 HOR BBL Committee Hearing: Mayors, Vice Mayors, Governors of certain

HOR House of Representatives - Batasan Complex, IBP Rd, Diliman, Quezon

Prof. Miriam Coronel Ferrer, Sec. Senen Bacani, Usec. Jose Lorena

HOR, LGUs

33

areas in Mindanao/ ARMM

City

93 28/01/2015 Lanao del Sur Provincial IEC Program

OPAPP Marawi City Provincial Capitol


LGUs, CSOs, Academe, Youth, and other government agencies

94 31/03/2015 Province of Sarangani's Interfaith Prayer Rally and Peace Forum

Province of Sarangani

Provincial Gymnasium, Capitol Compound, Alabel, Sarangani Province


LGUs, Religious, CSOs, Community

95 14/04/2015 2015 LMP General Assembly

League of Municipalities of the Philippines

Manila Hotel, Bonifacio Drive,One Rizal Park,Manila

Atty. Mohammad Al-Amin (Member, GPH Legal Team), Atty. Sittie Amirah Pendatun (Member, GPH Legal Team)

LGUs

96 18/04/2015 Symposium on BBL and FOI

HOR BBL Ad Hoc Committee & Committee on Public Information

Oroquieta City, Misamis Occidental,

Atty. Anna Tarhata Basman (Head, GPH Legal Team), Atty. Sittie Amirah Pendatun (Member, GPH Legal Team)

HOR, LGUs, CSOs, and Media

97 10/05/2015 Promoting Political Climate and Stability for Peace in the Bangsamoro and Forum on “Governance and Politics for Peace in the Evolving Bangsamoro”

IAG, LOGODEF, PCID, and ZABIDA

Marco Polo Davao, C. M. Recto Street, Poblacion District, Davao City


CSOs and LGUs

98 13/05/2015 Senate Public Hearing on the BBL

Senate Sulu Provincial Capitol, Patikul, Sulu

Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP), Atty. Al Julkipli (Member, GPH Legal Team)

Senate, CSOs, LGUs

34

99

14/05/2015 Senate Public Hearing on the BBL

Senate Royce Convention Hall, Grand Astoria Hotel, Zamboanga

Usec. Jose Lorena (OPAPP), Atty. Al Julkipli (Member, GPH Legal Team)

Senate, CSOs, LGUs

100 17/05/2015 Cotabato Provincial Peace Assembly

Cotabato Provincial Government

Pigcawayan Town Hall, Pigawayan, North Cotabato


Cotabato Provincial Government: Sangguniang Panlalawigan, local chapters of league of Board Members and Barangay Captains (Dulia Sultan, Kelly Antao, Eliseo Garcesa, Loreto Cabaya Jr.); Pigcawayan LGU: Mayor Herminio; Bangsamoro communities from Maguindanao and North Cotabato

position paper of the gph peace panel submitted to the ... · 5/18/2015 · public hearings on...

Documents