possibilities for transformation or more of the same...

9
Possibilities for transformation or more of the same? Ethnic health system development in Shan State, Myanmar Sharon Bell [email protected] @SharonBell_NZ

Upload: others

Post on 06-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

Possibilities for transformation or more of

the same? Ethnic health system

development in Shan State, Myanmar

Sharon Bell

[email protected]

@SharonBell_NZ

Page 2: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

Outline

•Context

• INGO approaches

•Partnership with non-state armed group

•Ethnic capacity

•Possibilities for transformation?

Page 3: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

Ethnic health system development

Page 4: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

Context: Shan State, Myanmar

Page 5: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

1. Current INGO approaches

•Too technocratic

•Volunteerism should be based on

ability not availability

Page 6: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

2. Partnership

•Legitimate partnership with non-state armed group

•But complex working within

military structures

Page 7: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

3. Ethnic civil society capacity

•Negative = Global shift in funding away from ethnic CSOs to the Myanmar state

•Positive = This INGO still working

with ethnic CSO

Page 8: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

Possibilities for transformation?

1. Context-specific approaches

2. Transformative partnership with NSAG

3. Support ethnic CSOs

Page 9: Possibilities for transformation or more of the same ...devpolicy.org/2017-Australasian-Aid-Conference/Presentations/Panel… · Possibilities for transformation or more of the same?

Funded by Claude McCarthy Fellowship &

Sharon Bell

[email protected]

@SharonBell_NZ