power u protective relay series bus protection 10-22-18 · 2018. 11. 2. · high impedance bus...

15
By Matt Horvath, P.E. November 6, 2018 Introduction to Bus Protection Presentation Outline 1. Physical Bus Types 2. Typical Bus Configurations 3. Bus Protection Methods & Schemes 4. High Z Bus Differential Protection After this presentation you will be able to: Identify common bus arrangements Identify and understand the operation of common bus protection schemes Understand high impedance bus differential operating principles (SEL-587Z) Purpose & Learning Objectives Electrical Buses Physical and Electrical Junction “A bus is a critical element of a power system, as it is the point of convergence of many circuits.” From IEEE Std. C37.97 A Guide for Protective Relay Applications to Power System Buses Main Components Copper or aluminum conductor Supporting structures Post Insulators Solid and/or flexible connectors Advantages Relatively Economical – Simple Easy to trouble shoot Short repair time Longer Free Spans Open Air Rigid Bus Disadvantages Exposure Larger footprint required

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jan-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • By

    Mat

    t Hor

    vath

    , P.E

    .

    Nov

    embe

    r 6, 2

    018

    Intr

    oduc

    tion

    to B

    us P

    rote

    ctio

    n

    Pre

    sent

    atio

    n O

    utlin

    e1.

    Phy

    sica

    l Bus

    Typ

    es2.

    Typi

    cal B

    us C

    onfig

    urat

    ions

    3.B

    us P

    rote

    ctio

    n M

    etho

    ds &

    Sch

    emes

    4.H

    igh

    Z B

    us D

    iffer

    entia

    l Pro

    tect

    ion

    Afte

    r thi

    s pr

    esen

    tatio

    n yo

    u w

    ill b

    e ab

    le to

    :•

    Iden

    tify

    com

    mon

    bus

    arr

    ange

    men

    ts•

    Iden

    tify

    and

    unde

    rsta

    nd th

    e op

    erat

    ion

    of c

    omm

    on b

    us

    prot

    ectio

    n sc

    hem

    es•

    Und

    erst

    and

    high

    impe

    danc

    e bu

    s di

    ffere

    ntia

    l ope

    ratin

    g pr

    inci

    ples

    (SE

    L-58

    7Z)P

    urpo

    se &

    Lea

    rnin

    g O

    bjec

    tives

    Ele

    ctric

    al B

    uses

    PhysicalandElectricalJunctio

    n

    “Abu

    sisa

    criticalelemen

    tofa

    power

    system

    ,asitisthe

    pointo

    fconvergenceof

    manycircuits.”

    From

    IEEE

    Std.C3

    7.97

    AGu

    idefor

    ProtectiveRelayAp

    plica

    tions

    toPower

    System

    Buses

    •M

    ain

    Com

    pone

    nts

    –C

    oppe

    r or a

    lum

    inum

    con

    duct

    or–

    Sup

    porti

    ng s

    truct

    ures

    –P

    ost I

    nsul

    ator

    s–

    Sol

    id a

    nd/o

    r fle

    xibl

    e co

    nnec

    tors

    •A

    dvan

    tage

    s–

    Rel

    ativ

    ely

    Eco

    nom

    ical

    –S

    impl

    e–

    Eas

    y to

    trou

    ble

    shoo

    t–

    Sho

    rt re

    pair

    time

    –Lo

    nger

    Fre

    e S

    pans

    Ope

    n A

    ir R

    igid

    Bus

    •D

    isad

    vant

    ages

    •E

    xpos

    ure

    •La

    rger

    foot

    prin

    t req

    uire

    d

  • •M

    ain

    Com

    pone

    nts

    –Fl

    exib

    le C

    ondu

    ctor

    s–

    Sup

    porti

    ng S

    truct

    ures

    –S

    train

    insu

    lato

    rs

    •A

    dvan

    tage

    s–

    Sm

    all f

    ootp

    rint

    –S

    impl

    icity

    –Ve

    ry E

    cono

    mic

    al–

    Sho

    rt re

    pair

    time

    Stra

    in B

    us

    •D

    isad

    vant

    ages

    •Lo

    wer

    relia

    bilit

    y•

    Exp

    osur

    e•

    Con

    duct

    or s

    paci

    ng a

    nd c

    apac

    ity

    •M

    ain

    com

    pone

    nts:

    –R

    idge

    d ce

    nter

    con

    duct

    or–

    Sup

    porti

    ng in

    sula

    tors

    –A

    ir di

    elec

    tric

    –B

    ushi

    ngs

    at te

    rmin

    atio

    n po

    ints

    –E

    xter

    nal s

    uppo

    rting

    stru

    ctur

    es

    •A

    dvan

    tage

    s–

    Hig

    her r

    elia

    bilit

    y–

    Pro

    tect

    ed–

    Sm

    alle

    r con

    duct

    or s

    paci

    ng–

    Forc

    ed a

    ir co

    olin

    g po

    ssib

    le

    Isol

    ated

    -Pha

    se B

    us

    •D

    isad

    vant

    ages

    •H

    igh

    cost

    •Lo

    ngre

    pair

    time

    •E

    xpen

    sive

    •M

    ain

    com

    pone

    nts:

    –R

    idge

    d ce

    nter

    con

    duct

    or–

    Sup

    porti

    ng in

    sula

    tors

    –In

    sula

    ting

    gas

    –B

    ushi

    ngs

    at te

    rmin

    atio

    n po

    ints

    –E

    xter

    nal s

    uppo

    rting

    stru

    ctur

    es

    •A

    dvan

    tage

    s–

    Hig

    her r

    elia

    bilit

    y–

    Pro

    tect

    ed–

    Very

    sm

    all c

    orrid

    or

    Gas

    Insu

    late

    d B

    us

    •D

    isad

    vant

    ages

    •H

    igh

    cost

    •D

    iffic

    ult t

    roub

    lesh

    ootin

    g•

    Long

    repa

    ir tim

    e

    •M

    ain

    Com

    pone

    nts

    –A

    lum

    inum

    or c

    oppe

    r con

    duct

    or–

    Sol

    id C

    onne

    ctor

    s–

    Sup

    porti

    ng In

    sula

    tors

    •A

    dvan

    tage

    s–

    Vers

    atile

    –S

    mal

    l foo

    tprin

    t–

    Pro

    tect

    ed•

    Dis

    adva

    ntag

    es–

    Con

    fined

    spa

    ce

    Indo

    or S

    witc

    hgea

    r Bus

  • Bus

    Fau

    lt C

    hara

    cter

    istic

    s

    •N

    ot v

    ery

    com

    mon

    Whe

    n th

    ey d

    o oc

    cur:

    •U

    sual

    ly b

    olte

    d fa

    ults

    •H

    ighe

    r fau

    lt m

    agni

    tude

    s

    Bus

    Fau

    lt Im

    pact

    :•

    All

    bus

    circ

    uits

    mus

    t be

    inte

    rrup

    ted

    •C

    an re

    sult

    in s

    ever

    e sy

    stem

    di

    stur

    banc

    es

    Impo

    rtanc

    e of

    Bus

    P

    rote

    ctio

    n•

    Ded

    icat

    ed p

    rote

    ctio

    n•

    Hig

    h sp

    eed

    oper

    atio

    n fo

    r in

    tern

    al fa

    ults

    •Tw

    o-ou

    t-of-t

    wo

    trip

    crite

    ria•

    Opt

    iona

    l red

    unda

    nt p

    rote

    ctio

    n sc

    hem

    e•

    Rem

    ote

    back

    up p

    rote

    ctio

    n•

    Tim

    e ov

    ercu

    rrent

    pro

    tect

    ion

    Sec

    urity

    for o

    ut-o

    f-zon

    e fa

    ults

    •S

    ensi

    tivity

    for m

    inim

    um in

    tern

    al

    faul

    ts

    Bus

    Pro

    tect

    ion

    Phi

    loso

    phy

    Prin

    cipl

    e an

    d O

    pera

    tion

    •Tr

    ips

    and

    lock

    outs

    the

    bus

    brea

    kers

    •M

    any

    outp

    ut c

    onta

    cts

    •O

    pera

    tion

    isol

    ates

    its

    trip

    coil

    •Ve

    ry fa

    st o

    pera

    tion

    •H

    ardw

    ired

    to b

    reak

    er tr

    ip

    circ

    uits

    •C

    an b

    e us

    ed to

    pro

    tect

    re

    lay

    cont

    acts

    Bus

    Loc

    kout

    Rel

    ays

    •Im

    prov

    es s

    yste

    m re

    liabi

    lity

    •M

    inim

    izes

    Impa

    ct o

    f Out

    ages

    •U

    tiliz

    es V

    ario

    us A

    rrang

    emen

    ts–

    Com

    bine

    d A

    rrang

    emen

    ts–

    Ope

    ratin

    g Fl

    exib

    ility

    –S

    elec

    tivity

    –B

    us p

    rote

    ctio

    n m

    ust a

    dapt

    Bus

    Sec

    tiona

    lizin

    g

    Diagram

    1

    Diagram

    2

  • One

    of t

    he m

    ost b

    asic

    and

    ec

    onom

    ical

    des

    igns

    No

    oper

    atin

    g fle

    xibi

    lity

    No

    sele

    ctiv

    ity

    Zone

    of P

    rote

    ctio

    n•

    Enc

    ompa

    sses

    the

    who

    le b

    us

    Bus

    faul

    t will

    inte

    rrupt

    all

    asso

    ciat

    ed s

    ervi

    ces

    Sin

    gle

    Bus

    –S

    ingl

    e B

    reak

    er•

    Zone

    of P

    rote

    ctio

    n:

    –B

    us a

    nd T

    rans

    form

    er p

    rote

    ctio

    n is

    co

    mbi

    ned

    •U

    sual

    ly u

    sed

    in d

    istri

    butio

    n su

    bsta

    tions

    •N

    o se

    lect

    ivity

    •N

    o fle

    xibi

    lity

    •Fa

    ult l

    ocat

    ion

    diffi

    culty

    •Ve

    ry e

    cono

    mic

    al

    Bus

    & T

    rans

    form

    er –

    Sin

    gle

    Bre

    aker

    Dou

    ble

    Bus

    w/B

    us T

    ie

    –S

    ingl

    e B

    reak

    er

    •Zo

    ne o

    f Pro

    tect

    ion:

    Bus

    A a

    nd B

    us B

    ha

    ve in

    depe

    nden

    t an

    d de

    dica

    ted

    prot

    ectio

    n

    •Li

    ttle

    Flex

    ibili

    ty

    •S

    ome

    Sel

    ectiv

    ity

    Mai

    n &

    Tra

    nsfe

    r Bus

    Sin

    gle

    Bre

    aker

    Breakersub

    stitu

    tion

    Zone

    ofProtectio

    nEncompasses

    mainbu

    son

    ly

    Transfer

    busp

    rotection

    provided

    bytransfer

    breaker

    Noselectivity

    Flexibilityincreases

    Ofte

    nCo

    mbine

    d

  • Dou

    ble

    Bus

    –S

    ingl

    e B

    reak

    er•

    Zone

    of P

    rote

    ctio

    n:

    •B

    us 1

    and

    Bus

    2 h

    ave

    inde

    pend

    ent

    prot

    ectio

    n as

    sign

    ed b

    ased

    on

    switc

    hing

    co

    nditi

    on

    •Lo

    ts o

    f ope

    ratin

    g fle

    xibi

    lity

    •S

    ome

    sele

    ctiv

    ity

    •C

    ompl

    ex s

    witc

    hing

    •C

    T w

    indi

    ng a

    ssig

    nmen

    ts c

    hang

    e

    •N

    ot c

    omm

    only

    use

    d in

    the

    U.S

    .

    Dou

    ble

    Bus

    –D

    oubl

    e B

    reak

    er•

    Zone

    of P

    rote

    ctio

    n:•

    Bus

    1 a

    nd B

    us 2

    hav

    e in

    depe

    nden

    t pro

    tect

    ion

    •Fu

    ll op

    erat

    ing

    flexi

    bilit

    y

    •Im

    prov

    ed S

    elec

    tivity

    •In

    crea

    sed

    cost

    •Ve

    ry c

    omm

    on

    Rin

    g B

    us

    •N

    o de

    dica

    ted

    bus

    prot

    ectio

    n

    •Fu

    ll op

    erat

    ing

    flexi

    bilit

    y

    •G

    ood

    sele

    ctiv

    ity

    •S

    hare

    d br

    eake

    rs

    •E

    cono

    mic

    al

    Bre

    aker

    -And

    -A-H

    alf

    Bus

    •Fu

    llop

    erat

    ing

    flexi

    bilit

    y

    •E

    xcel

    lent

    sel

    ectiv

    ity

    •W

    idel

    y us

    ed

    •Zo

    ne o

    f Pro

    tect

    ion:

    Bus

    A a

    nd B

    us B

    hav

    e in

    depe

    nden

    t an

    d de

    dica

    ted

    prot

    ectio

    n zo

    nes.

    •Li

    ne p

    ositi

    on p

    rote

    ctio

    n pr

    ovid

    ed b

    y br

    anch

    circ

    uits

    •E

    cono

    mic

    al

  • Diff

    eren

    tial O

    verc

    urre

    nt

    •C

    T se

    cond

    ary

    lead

    s su

    mm

    ed o

    ut s

    ide

    the

    rela

    y

    •Id

    entic

    al T

    ap ra

    tios

    •C

    T m

    atch

    ing

    •D

    iffer

    ence

    Cur

    rent

    usi

    ng

    51/5

    0 el

    emen

    ts

    •Ti

    me

    dela

    yed

    •Av

    oid

    mis

    oper

    atio

    ndu

    e to

    tra

    nsie

    nt s

    atur

    atio

    n

    Adv

    anta

    ges

    •E

    cono

    mic

    al

    Dis

    adva

    ntag

    es•

    Sec

    urity

    •S

    trong

    sou

    rces

    •Ti

    me-

    dela

    yed

    clea

    ring

    •D

    iffic

    ult t

    o se

    t pro

    perly

    •N

    ot s

    uita

    ble

    in a

    reas

    of s

    yste

    m

    with

    hig

    h X

    /R ra

    tio

    Diff

    eren

    tial O

    verc

    urre

    nt

    (con

    tinue

    d)

    Par

    tial B

    us D

    iffer

    entia

    l

    Ope

    ratin

    g P

    rinci

    ples

    :

    •S

    ourc

    e C

    T le

    ads

    sum

    med

    ou

    tsid

    e re

    lay

    •Ti

    e br

    eake

    r CTs

    incl

    uded

    •O

    verc

    urre

    nt e

    lem

    ent

    •P

    icku

    p se

    t abo

    ve lo

    ad

    •S

    elec

    tivity

    requ

    ired

    •O

    ptio

    nal:

    Dis

    tanc

    e el

    emen

    ts

    Par

    tial B

    us D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    Par

    tial B

    us D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    Adv

    anta

    ges:

    Very

    eco

    nom

    ical

    Dis

    adva

    ntag

    es:

    •Fa

    ult C

    urre

    nt/F

    LA•

    Req

    uire

    d se

    lect

    ivity

    •R

    educ

    ed s

    ensi

    tivity

    •U

    sed

    with

    radi

    al

    circ

    uits

  • Zone

    Inte

    rlock

    Sch

    eme

    (Fas

    t Bus

    Trip

    ping

    )O

    pera

    ting

    Prin

    cipl

    e: (A

    nim

    atio

    n)•

    Sou

    rce

    circ

    uit(s

    ) •

    Tim

    e de

    laye

    d •

    Rec

    eive

    s/S

    ends

    Blo

    ck

    Sig

    nal

    •D

    irect

    iona

    lity

    •R

    adia

    l circ

    uit(s

    )•

    Inst

    anta

    neou

    s el

    emen

    t se

    nds

    bloc

    k si

    gnal

    •C

    omm

    unic

    atio

    n

    Zone

    Inte

    rlock

    Sch

    eme

    (Con

    tinue

    d)

    Adv

    anta

    ges:

    •Fa

    st c

    ompa

    red

    to in

    vers

    e-tim

    e O

    C e

    lem

    ents

    •R

    elat

    ivel

    y ec

    onom

    ical

    Dis

    adva

    ntag

    es:

    •R

    equi

    res

    Com

    mun

    icat

    ion

    Sch

    eme

    •S

    ecur

    ity a

    gain

    st C

    T S

    atur

    atio

    n•

    Slo

    wer

    than

    hig

    h-Z

    or p

    erce

    ntag

    e-re

    stra

    int

    sche

    mes

    Dire

    ctio

    nal C

    ompa

    rison

    Ope

    ratin

    g P

    rinci

    ple:

    •D

    ista

    nce

    Ele

    men

    ts

    Adv

    anta

    ges

    •R

    elat

    ivel

    y E

    cono

    mic

    al•

    Few

    CT

    cons

    train

    ts

    Dis

    adva

    ntag

    es•

    Volta

    ge R

    efer

    ence

    •M

    ultip

    le F

    ailu

    re P

    oint

    s

    Hig

    h C

    urre

    nt

    Inte

    rrup

    tion

    & L

    imiti

    ngFu

    ses

    & S

    hort

    Circ

    uit L

    imite

    rs•

    Hig

    h In

    terr

    upt r

    atin

    g•

    IS li

    mite

    r ope

    rate

    s in

    less

    th

    an 1

    ms

    Adv

    anta

    ges

    •E

    xtre

    mel

    y H

    igh

    Spe

    ed

    Dis

    adva

    ntag

    es•

    Rep

    lace

    men

    ts n

    eede

    d w

    ith fu

    sibl

    e in

    terr

    upte

    rs

  • Arc

    Fla

    sh P

    rote

    ctio

    n

    Opt

    ical

    Sen

    sors

    •Fi

    ber o

    ptic

    sen

    sors

    or l

    oops

    •In

    door

    Sw

    itchg

    ear

    Adv

    anta

    ges

    •R

    elat

    ivel

    y E

    cono

    mic

    al•

    Ext

    rem

    ely

    Hig

    h S

    peed

    Dis

    adva

    ntag

    es•

    Sup

    ervi

    sion

    with

    opt

    ical

    Per

    cent

    age

    Res

    train

    ed

    Diff

    eren

    tial

    Ope

    ratin

    g P

    rinci

    ple:

    (Ani

    mat

    ion)

    •R

    elay

    mea

    sure

    s di

    ffere

    nce

    and

    rest

    rain

    t qua

    ntiti

    es•

    Trip

    if d

    iffer

    ence

    cur

    rent

    exc

    eeds

    a s

    et p

    erce

    ntag

    e of

    the

    rest

    rain

    ing

    quan

    tity

    TieBK

    RN.O.

    I01C

    FI02C

    FI01

    I02

    BKR2

    N.C.

    BKR1

    N.C.

    Per

    cent

    age

    Res

    train

    ed

    Diff

    eren

    tial (

    Con

    tinue

    d)

    •O

    pera

    te v

    s. R

    estra

    int R

    elat

    ions

    hip

    •S

    lope

    Set

    ting

    •C

    ontro

    lling

    Fac

    tors

    •C

    T P

    erfo

    rman

    ce•

    X/R

    Rat

    io•

    Faul

    t Mag

    nitu

    de

    •D

    uel S

    lop

    Cha

    ract

    eris

    tic

    Per

    cent

    age

    Res

    train

    ed

    Diff

    eren

    tial (

    Con

    tinue

    d)

  • Per

    cent

    age

    Res

    train

    ed

    Diff

    eren

    tial (

    Con

    tinue

    d)P

    erce

    ntag

    e R

    estra

    ined

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    CT4Cu

    rren

    ts:

    Per

    cent

    age

    Res

    train

    ed

    Diff

    eren

    tial (

    Con

    tinue

    d)

    •Re

    layconstantlymon

    itors

    changesinop

    erateand

    restraintcurrents

    •Increase

    inrestraint

    with

    outa

    nincrease

    inop

    eratecurren

    tind

    icates

    externalfault

    •Re

    layentershigh

    securitymod

    e

    •Onlyrequ

    iress

    hortpe

    riod

    (~24m

    s)of

    unsaturated

    operation

    Per

    cent

    age

    Res

    train

    ed

    Diff

    eren

    tial (

    Con

    tinue

    d)

    Settings

    Considerations

    •Minim

    umpickup

    mustb

    egreaterthanerrord

    ifferen

    cecurrent,

    butlessthanminim

    umavailablefaultcurrent

    •Typically

    setto1p

    uof

    busc

    ontin

    uous

    ratin

    gon

    solid

    grou

    nded

    system

    s•

    Lower

    pickup

    susedon

    impe

    dancegrou

    nded

    system

    s

    •Slop

    esettings

    •With

    standmeasuremen

    terrorsa

    tlow

    curren

    ts•

    With

    standsaturatio

    nindu

    cederrorsat

    high

    curren

    ts

    •Mod

    ernrelays

    with

    adaptivean

    slope

    characteristic

    provide

    enhanced

    securityandsensitivity

  • Per

    cent

    age

    Res

    train

    ed

    Diff

    eren

    tial (

    Con

    tinue

    d)

    Adv

    anta

    ges:

    •Fa

    st O

    pera

    tion

    •G

    ood

    secu

    rity

    Dis

    adva

    ntag

    es:

    •C

    T cr

    iteria

    and

    pe

    rform

    ance

    crit

    ical

    •M

    ay re

    quire

    man

    y re

    lay

    curr

    ent i

    nput

    s

    •S

    ensi

    tivity

    —H

    igh

    Z G

    roun

    ded

    Sys

    tem

    s

    IOP=|I1+I2|

    IRST

    =|I1|

    +|I2|

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    (V

    olta

    ge) D

    iffer

    entia

    l In

    trodu

    ctio

    n an

    d B

    asic

    Con

    cept

    (Ani

    mat

    ion)

    •P

    opul

    ar B

    us P

    rote

    ctio

    n S

    chem

    e•

    Arc

    Fla

    sh M

    itiga

    tion

    Vsmall

    Vbig

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    •CTsc

    onne

    cted

    inparallelw

    ithhigh

    impe

    dancerelayinpu

    t

    •Re

    layop

    erates

    onvolta

    geacross

    high

    impe

    danceinpu

    ts

    •Ca

    naccommod

    atealarge

    numbe

    rofterminals

    •Excellent

    sensitivity

    and

    speed

    •Simpleelem

    enttoconfigure

    Characteristicsa

    ndTypicalA

    pplicationLayout

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    ExternalFault(or

    typicalloa

    ding)C

    ase:

    •Cu

    rren

    tcirculates

    betw

    eenCTs

    •Negligiblecurren

    tflowthroughhigh

    impe

    dancerelayinpu

    t(high

    resistance/bu

    rden

    path)

  • Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    Worst

    Case

    ExternalFault:

    •CT

    2completelysaturates(do

    esno

    tsup

    plyanyrepresentativesecond

    arycurren

    twaveform)

    •High

    impe

    danceinpu

    tseesv

    oltage

    develope

    dby

    second

    arycurren

    tflowingthrough

    CTwinding

    resistanceandlead

    resistance

    •Elem

    entp

    ickupmustb

    esetg

    reater

    than

    thisvolta

    ge(typicallyby

    afactor

    of1.5to

    2)forsecurity

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    InternalFaultC

    ase:

    •Cu

    rren

    tflowsthrou

    ghstabilizin

    gresistora

    ndprod

    uces

    high

    second

    aryvolta

    ges

    •Vo

    ltage

    magnitude

    limite

    dby

    MOV

    •LO

    R‘a’con

    tactsreq

    uiredacrosshigh

    impe

    danceinpu

    t

    •CTsp

    rodu

    cecurren

    tand

    second

    aryvolta

    geun

    tilthey

    saturate

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    •S

    tabi

    lizin

    g re

    sist

    or

    •M

    OV

    pro

    tect

    s el

    emen

    t

    •B

    us L

    OR

    requ

    ired

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    •S

    EL

    587Z

    Rel

    ay•

    Use

    s a

    2000

    resi

    stor

    •M

    OV

    siz

    e op

    tions

    •S

    EL

    Rec

    omm

    ende

    d S

    ettin

    gs (P

    er A

    N20

    08-0

    1)•

    Vs

    setti

    ng o

    f 200

    V•

    Opt

    iona

    l Tim

    e D

    elay

    ed S

    ettin

    g

  • Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    Man

    ufac

    ture

    r Int

    erna

    l Fau

    lt Te

    stin

    g•

    Test

    cur

    rent

    s of

    20

    kA, 4

    0 kA

    and

    60

    kA a

    pplie

    d.•

    Hea

    vy C

    T sa

    tura

    tion

    obse

    rved

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    Wav

    efor

    ms

    obta

    ined

    from

    man

    ufac

    ture

    r tes

    ting

    •D

    iffer

    entia

    l cur

    rent

    and

    vol

    tage

    wav

    efor

    ms

    •N

    ote

    the

    volta

    ge is

    lim

    ited

    to 1

    500V

    by

    the

    inte

    rnal

    MO

    V•

    C20

    0 12

    00:5

    CTs

    , 60

    kA in

    tern

    al fa

    ult

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    60 k

    A In

    tern

    al F

    ault

    Test

    1. C

    T Vo

    ltage

    (Gre

    en)

    2. T

    otal

    Cur

    rent

    (Blu

    e)3.

    Exc

    itatio

    n C

    urre

    nt (R

    ed)

    •R

    esis

    tor v

    s. M

    agne

    tizin

    g C

    urre

    nt

    •Th

    e vo

    lt-tim

    e ar

    ea

    C40

    0

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    C10

    0

    Volttim

    earea

    prop

    ortio

    naltoCratin

    g

    Dictated

    bylowestratedCT

    indiffe

    rentialcircuit

    SELrecommen

    dsat

    leasta

    C200

    CT

  • Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    Vo

    lttim

    earea

    issim

    ilarfor

    CTsw

    itheq

    uivalent

    Cratin

    g,even

    ifratio

    sare

    diffe

    rent

    Maxim

    umvolta

    gelim

    itedby

    MOV

    Man

    ufac

    ture

    r Ext

    erna

    l Fau

    lt Te

    stin

    g R

    esul

    ts

    •Fa

    ult c

    urre

    nts

    of 2

    0 kA

    , 40

    kA a

    nd 6

    0 kA

    .

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    MO

    V S

    izin

    g fo

    r SE

    L-58

    7Z•

    MO

    V re

    quire

    men

    ts b

    ased

    on

    ene

    rgy

    diss

    ipat

    ion

    limits

    for

    4-cy

    cle

    dura

    tion

    •Re

    quire

    s86“a”

    contactswire

    dacross

    relayinpu

    ts!

    •E

    nerg

    y ra

    ting

    is a

    func

    tion

    of k

    nee-

    poin

    t vol

    tage

    and

    m

    axim

    um s

    econ

    dary

    cu

    rren

    t

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    H

    igh

    Impe

    danc

    e B

    us

    Diff

    eren

    tial (

    Con

    tinue

    d)

    Man

    ufac

    ture

    r Tes

    ting

    Res

    ults

    for S

    EL-

    587Z

    Rec

    omm

    ende

    d H

    igh-

    Valu

    e S

    ettin

    g:•

    200V

    with

    no

    time

    dela

    y•

    Sen

    sitiv

    e an

    d S

    ecur

    e

    Opt

    iona

    l Rec

    omm

    enda

    tions

    For

    Low

    -Val

    ue S

    ettin

    g:•

    Onl

    y ne

    eded

    in s

    ome

    appl

    icat

    ions

    (e.g

    . HR

    G/L

    RG

    )•

    Min

    imum

    sen

    sitiv

    ity c

    alcu

    latio

    ns•

    Impl

    emen

    t a ti

    me

    dela

    y (m

    in 1

    cyc

    le).

  • Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    Sec

    ure

    Volta

    ge S

    ettin

    g C

    alcu

    latio

    n

    •S

    ensi

    tivity

    impa

    cted

    by

    wiri

    ng d

    esig

    n

    •W

    orst

    -cas

    e ou

    t-of-z

    one

    faul

    t con

    ditio

    n

    •R

    elay

    pic

    kup

    set t

    o a

    mul

    tiple

    of V

    r

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    ontin

    ued)

    Min

    imum

    Sen

    sitiv

    ity C

    alcu

    latio

    n•

    Verif

    y fo

    r Int

    erna

    l Fau

    lt•

    Igno

    re M

    OV

    leak

    age

    curr

    ent

    •U

    se C

    T E

    xcita

    tion

    Cha

    ract

    eris

    tic•

    Whe

    n V

    s <

    knee

    poi

    nt v

    olta

    ge:

    •W

    hen

    Vs

    > kn

    ee p

    oint

    vol

    tage

    :

    Hig

    h Im

    peda

    nce

    Bus

    D

    iffer

    entia

    l (C

    oncl

    usio

    n)

    Advantages:

    •Very

    fastop

    eration

    •High

    security

    •Incorporates

    largenu

    mbe

    rof

    term

    inals

    Disadvantages:

    •Sensitivity

    decreasesa

    snum

    bero

    fCTsa

    nd/orleadlengthsincreases

    •Mustu

    seCTsw

    ithC2

    00ratin

    gor

    greater

    •Co

    mplexities

    associated

    with

    mixed

    ratio

    CTs

    •B

    us p

    rote

    ctio

    n is

    crit

    ical

    •B

    us S

    ectio

    naliz

    ing

    –O

    pera

    ting

    flexi

    bilit

    y–

    Sel

    ectiv

    ity

    •B

    us P

    rote

    ctio

    n S

    chem

    es–

    Wid

    e va

    riety

    of s

    chem

    es

    avai

    labl

    e ba

    sed

    on a

    pplic

    atio

    n•

    Crit

    ical

    ity•

    Avai

    labl

    e fa

    ult c

    urre

    nt &

    X/R

    ratio

    •S

    ensi

    tivity

    /Spe

    ed R

    equi

    rem

    ents

    •C

    T av

    aila

    bilit

    y

    Sum

    mar

    y

  • •IE

    EE

    Std

    . C37

    .97,

    Gui

    de fo

    r Pro

    tect

    ive

    Rel

    ay A

    pplic

    atio

    ns to

    Pow

    er B

    uses

    •B

    lack

    burn

    , J. L

    ewis

    , Pro

    tect

    ive

    Rel

    ayin

    g, P

    rinci

    ples

    and

    App

    licat

    ions

    , Thi

    rd

    Edi

    tion,

    New

    Yor

    k: M

    arce

    l Dek

    ker,

    1998

    •B

    asle

    r Ele

    ctric

    Com

    pany

    , Bus

    Pro

    tect

    ive

    Rel

    ayin

    g, M

    etho

    ds a

    nd

    App

    licat

    ion,

    Rev

    isio

    n D

    ate:

    6-8

    -200

    5

    •G

    ener

    al E

    lect

    ric C

    ompa

    ny, B

    us D

    iffer

    entia

    l Pro

    tect

    ion,

    WP

    RC

    199

    5, G

    ER

    -39

    61

    •Zo

    chol

    l, E

    . Sta

    nley

    and

    Cos

    tello

    , Dav

    id, S

    chw

    eitz

    er E

    ngin

    eerin

    g La

    bora

    torie

    s, In

    c., A

    pplic

    atio

    n G

    uide

    lines

    for M

    icro

    proc

    esso

    r-Bas

    ed, H

    igh-

    Impe

    danc

    e B

    us D

    iffer

    entia

    l Rel

    ays

    •C

    oste

    llo, D

    avid

    and

    Moo

    ney,

    Joe

    , App

    lyin

    g th

    e S

    EL-

    587Z

    in S

    witc

    hgea

    r, S

    EL

    App

    licat

    ion

    Not

    e A

    N20

    08-0

    1

    Ref

    eren

    ces

    Than

    k yo

    u fo

    r you

    r tim

    e!Th

    is c

    oncl

    udes

    the

    educ

    atio

    nal c

    onte

    nt o

    f thi

    s ac

    tivity

    .

    Mat

    t Hor

    vath

    , P.E

    .

    Elec

    tric

    al E

    ngin

    eer

    (509

    ) 780

    -004

    2

    mat

    t.Hor

    vath

    @po

    wer

    ing.

    com