preparation of alumina supported gold catalysts: influence of washing procedures, mechanism of...
TRANSCRIPT
www.elsevier.com/locate/apcata
Applied Catalysis A: General 298 (2006) 57–64
Preparation of alumina supported gold catalysts: Influence of washing
procedures, mechanism of particles size growth
Svetlana Ivanova, Veronique Pitchon, Yvan Zimmermann, Corinne Petit *
Laboratoire des Materiaux, Surfaces et Procedes pour la Catalyse (UMR 7515 du CNRS),
ECPM-ULP, 25 rue Becquerel, F-67087 Strasbourg Cedex 2, France
Received 14 June 2005; received in revised form 16 September 2005; accepted 22 September 2005
Available online 18 November 2005
Abstract
This publication deals with the influence upon catalytic gold particle size distribution of the washing procedures preceding calcination.
The proposed preparation method and washing procedures lead to perfectly reproducible gold catalysts with a gold particle size of less than
2 nm. An explanation for the mechanism of gold particle growth is proposed. A controlled use of ammonia as a washing agent strongly
improves the dispersion of gold metal on alumina. The possibility of gold complexes being stabilised by the presence of ammonia is also
discussed.
# 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Gold catalysis; Supported gold; Alumina; Washing procedures; Ammonia
1. Introduction
Gold has long been believed to be inactive as a catalyst.
However, Haruta and co-workers [1,2] reported that gold
exhibits extraordinarily high catalytic activity for low
temperature CO oxidation when it is deposited on a selected
group of metal oxides as small particles. The catalyst synthesis
procedure and subsequent pre-treatment plays a crucial role in
determining the particle size and the metal–support interac-
tion. There is general agreement in the literature that the
utilisation of preparation methods such as deposition–
precipitation, coprecipitation and CVD produces catalysts
of a broad dispersion with gold particle size of less than 5 nm.
The method of ionic exchange is essentially applied to zeolites
[3], while the gold complex [Au (en)2]3+ is used for cationic
exchange [4]. The synthesis procedure employed is a direct
anionic exchange method (DAE) [5]. Control of both catalyst
preparation and reproducibility requires a profound knowl-
edge of the precursors and the nature of metal/support
interaction.
* Corresponding author. Fax: +33 3 90 24 27 68.
E-mail address: [email protected] (C. Petit).
0926-860X/$ – see front matter # 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.apcata.2005.09.020
The low melting temperature of gold metal could provoke
gold particle sintering during the calcination and catalytic tests.
So the choice of calcination temperature is also very important.
The optimal calcination temperature reported in the literature is
300 8C and beyond this temperature certain authors have
observed an increase in the gold particle size and a parellel
diminution of catalytic activity [6,7]. However, Maciejewski
et al. [8] did not report gold particle sintering for catalysts
supported on titania and zinc oxide calcined at temperatures as
high as 600 8C. Another important parameter is the atmosphere
inwhich calcination is performed.Lee et al. [9] suggested that the
treatment of manganese supported gold catalysts in air is
preferable than the use of hydrogen or vacuum conditions.
Alternately, the presence of chloride was reported by Costello
et al. [10] and by Oh et al. [11] to be responsible for gold particle
growth during the calcination. This is why chloride removal is a
very important step in the preparationof a gold catalyst. To assure
chloride removal awashing procedure is necessary. The presence
of a basic agent will permit the substitution of chloride ions by
hydroxyl groups. Here, we have chosen ammonia as a washing
agent. This kind of treatment is similar to that proposed by Xu
et al. [12] even if the precise details are not given in this article.
The aim of this paper is to study the influence of washing
procedure on gold particle size and to explain the mechanism of
particle formation and growth.
S. Ivanova et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 298 (2006) 57–6458
Table 1
Elemental analysis of gold and chlorine as a function of washing agent and time
Samples supported
on g-Al2O3
Washing
agent
Elemental
analysis (wt%)
Au Cl
AuW H2O, 60 min 2 0.33
Au25N 25 mol L�1 NH3 1.37 �150 ppm
Au4N5 4 mol L�1 NH3, 5 min 1.36 �150 ppm
Au4N20 4 mol L�1 NH3, 20 min 1.32 �150 ppm
Au4N60 4 mol L�1 NH3, 60 min 1.36 �150 ppm
Au4N24H 4 mol L�1 NH3, 24 h 1.57 �150 ppm
AuS NaOH, 60 min 0.53 �150 ppm
AuU Urea, 60 min 0.99 �150 ppm
2. Experimental
2.1. Catalysts preparation
We have developed a novel method of preparation based
upon the direct anionic exchange of the gold species for the
hydroxyl groups of the support [5]. Aqueous solutions of
HAuCl4 of concentration 10�4 mol L�1 (pH 3.5) were made in
order to obtain a final Au loading of 2 wt%. The support g-
Al2O3, with a BET surface of 190 m2 g�1 was sieved with the
fraction 125–250 mm being retained. The gold solution was
heated to 70 8C and the support was introduced. Then the slurry
was filtered, washed, dried in an oven at 120 8C overnight and
calcined in air at 300 8C for 4 h.
2.2. Washing procedures
The washing procedures are applied in order to remove the
chloride ligands from the gold chlorohydroxy complexes or the
chloride simply attached to the support. The washing agents
were aqueous solution of ammonia (NH3�H2O) of different
concentrations (4 and 25 mol L�1), water, urea or NaOH. Two
different washing procedures were employed in the case of the
ammonia solution, short washing: 20 min with 25 mol L�1
NH3(aq) and slow washing: 1 h with 4 mol L�1 NH3(aq). No
additional washing by water has been made after ammonia
washing procedures.
Caution/safety note: The contact of ammonia with a gold
solution could provoke the formation of gold ammonia
complexes which are explosive [13]. The use of this procedure
is not dangerous if the gold complexes are strongly attached to
the support. The assurance that there remains no gold in the
solution prior to the introduction of ammonia is a pre-requisite.
2.3. Characterisation
Chemical analysis of Au and Cl in the samples was
performed by inductively coupled plasma atom emission
spectroscopy at the CNRS Center of Chemical Analysis
(Vernaison, France). The detection limit is 150 ppm for Cl.
Chemical analysis was performed following sample calcina-
tion. The Au weight loading of the samples is expressed in
grams of Au per gram of calcined sample: wt% Au = [mAu/
(mAu + mAl2O3)] � 100.
XRD analyses were performed on a Siemens D5000 powder
X-ray diffractometer. Diffraction patterns were recorded with a
detector side Ni filtered Cu Ka radiation (1.5406 A) over a 2u
range of 15–858 and a position sensitive detector using a step
size of 0.028 and a step time of 2 s.
The catalysts were characterised by transmission electron
microscopy (TEM) Topcon EM002B for determining the
morphology of the solid and gold particle size distribution. The
dispersion was calculated using the model proposed by Polisset
[14].
Mass spectrometry measurements were carried out on a
Quattro II (Micromass) triple quadrupole mass spectrometer
fitted with an electrospray source and operated in negative
mode. The principal parameters were fixed at 80 8C for the
source temperature, sample injection flow rate 5 mL min�1, the
m/z range from 200 to 2000 was obtained in 18 s, five scans
were summed to obtain the final spectrum.
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Influence of washing agent and washing time
Elemental analysis of the samples of gold and chloride
loadings as a function of washing agent and washing time is
presented in Table 1. The theoretical gold loading per catalyst
was calculated to be 2 wt%.
As indicated, the desired quantity of gold is obtained in the
case of the water washed sample (AuW). However, the quantity
of chloride is comparatively high which means that the water
treatment is not able to remove the chloride from the catalysts.
For all the other samples the chloride level was found to be
below 150 ppm which suggests that all basic treatments prior to
calcination are able to remove the chloride from the catalysts.
The aim of this basic treatment is to replace the chloride ligands
of the gold complexes over alumina with OH� groups and to
remove, the free chloride attached to the surface of the catalyst
before the calcination. From this point of view the washing
procedures are successful as the chloride level is beneath the
detection limit of the techniques employed. For ammonia
treated samples, a constant loss of around 30% of the gold
introduced is observed. This loss was attributed to non-attached
gold complexes removal. The ammonia concentration seems
not to affect the gold loadings. We have observed the same
values for the two concentrations tested. Changing the washing
time between 5 and 60 min did not affect the gold loadings
either. In all cases, loss of Au was found to be around 30%. It
seems that in the case of ammonia washing, the replacement of
chloride by OH groups provides the greatest interest as the
concentration and the time of contact between solid and
ammonia solution do not affect the percentage of gold
deposited. However, increasing the contact time between the
solid and ammonia solution to 24 h provided an increase in gold
loading. A subsequent deposition of gold as Au(OH)3 could
perhaps be supposed. While the quantity of gold deposited is
higher the possibility of a quick precipitation of Au(OH)3remains which could produce larger undesirable gold particles.
S. Ivanova et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 298 (2006) 57–64 59
Fig. 1. Gold loadings as a function of the number of preparation.
This increase of gold loading is thought to be a coexistence of
DAE complexes with a precipitate of gold hydroxide.
For samples washed with NaOH (AuS) and urea (AuU) in
NH3 (4 mol L�1) an equal concentration in hydroxides was
calculated. Washing with urea at 80 8C permits the decom-
position of urea and formation of OH groups. The duration of
washing is fixed at 1 h. The elemental analysis results revealed
that the use of urea and NaOH cause large losses of gold,
particularly the NaOH. It could be supposed that the effects
over the gold complexes are different from those caused by
ammonia. If the role of the ammonia solution is only to
substitute the OH groups for the chloride ligands in the
complexes, then the NaOH and urea could possibly modify the
metal/support interaction and provoke a reappearance of gold
complexes in the solution and subsequently their elimination
through washing. Alternately, it is possible in the case of urea
that increasing the duration of washing brings a larger quantity
of deposited gold. A further explanation for the higher gold
loadings, in the case were ammonia is the washing agent, is a
possible stabilisation enhanced by the substitution of chloride
by an amino-type species, as suggested by Siller et al. [15] and
Duval [16].
Fig. 2. TEM photographs of Au/Al2O3: (a) water w
3.2. Reproducibility
Repeating the synthesis seven times during 6 months
indicates the reproducibility of both the preparation method and
the washing procedures. The results are presented in Fig. 1.
Preparation of alumina supported gold catalysts by DAE is
reproducible, with an average value of 1.34 wt% actual gold
loading.
As we have already noted, washing with ammonia
completely removes the chloride from the catalyst. However,
the presence of Cl� increases the possibility of gold particle
sintering [11,12]. Gold particle size on ammonia washed
samples was smaller compared to water washed one (Fig. 2).
Ammonia washing provokes a decrease in the average gold
particule diameter, e.g. from 16 nm for non-treated sample
(AuW) to 2.4 nm for Au4N60. Particle size distribution is
narrow and depends on the concentration of the washing agent.
For Au25N, gold particles size decreases to an average of
1.9 nm though particles smaller than 1 nm could be observed.
Particle size distribution for the samples is presented in Fig. 3.
The number of measured particles is 483 for Au4N60 and 567
for Au25N. 90% of the particles for these two samples are in the
fraction between 1 and 3 nm. For the Au4N60 sample, a few
particles larger than 5 nm are observed.
The average diameters are calculated by using the equation:
d ¼P
nidiPni
where ni is the number of particles with diameter di.
Sample characterisation by TEM was also undertaken as a
function of the duration of washing with ammonia (Fig. 4). The
following average gold particles diameters were obtained:
2.6 nm for Au4N5 (for a total of 216 particles), 2.4 nm for
Au4N20 (for a total of 586 particles), 2.4 nm for Au4N60 (for a
total of 483 particles) and 3.1 nm for Au4N24H (for a total of
460 particles). The results reveal that there is an optimal time
period for washing of between 20 and 60 min. Similar particle
size and distribution are observed for the two samples, Au4N20
and Au4N60. This underlines the conclusion from elemental
ashed sample and (b) ammonia washed sample.
S. Ivanova et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 298 (2006) 57–6460
Fig. 3. Particle size distribution for Au/Al2O3 as a function of washing agent
concentration.
Fig. 4. Particle size distribution for Au/Al2O3 as a function of washing time
(washing agent concentration 4 mol L�1).
Fig. 5. TEM photographs of Au/Al2O3: (a) water
Table 2
Elemental analysis of gold catalysts
Washing agent Elemental analysis
(wt% Au)
Elemental analysis
(wt% Cl)
Theoritical Experimental
H2O 0.5 0.5 0.21
NH3 (4 mol L�1) 0.5 0.31 �150 ppm
H2O 1 1 0.31
NH3 (4 mol L�1) 1 0.7 �150 ppm
H2O 2 1.93 0.48
NH3 (4 mol L�1) 2 1.36 �150 ppm
H2O 5 3.7 0.81
NH3 (4 mol L�1) 5 3.1 �150 ppm
analysis that an increase in the length of time for washing up to
1 h did not affect the catalyst.
For a sample washed continuously over 24 h (Au4N24H), an
increase in the average diameter was observed. Our conclusion,
considering the elemental analysis and the higher gold loading,
is that subsequent deposition of Au(OH)3 from solution onto
the surface of the catalyst occurred. The observation of the
coexistence of a small particle size fraction with another,
greater fraction of large particles confirms the hypothesis of a
subsequent precipitation of Au(OH)3.
3.3. Influence of gold loadings
In addition to the catalysts made by anionic exchange and
having an amount of gold close to 2 wt%, a series of catalysts
with different gold loadings was prepared. The elemental
analysis for these samples compared with the theoretical one is
presented in Table 2.
The desired gold loadings were obtained in the case of all
water washed catalysts, except the most loaded one. So a
limiting value of the capacity for adsorption was observed. Our
results confirm those reported by Brunelle [17] who found the
limiting value of adsorption of 3 wt% for platinum over gamma
alumina with a specific surface of 200 m2 g�1. The quantity of
washed and (b) ammonia washed 4 mol L�1.
S. Ivanova et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 298 (2006) 57–64 61
Fig. 6. Particle size distribution for the sample 3.1% Au/Al2O3 washed
4 mol L�1 NH3.
Fig. 8. Variation in theoretical dispersion as a function of gold particle size in
cuboctahedral model.
chloride increases in parallel with the gold loadings. This is due
to the different quantity of gold precursor used. Washing with
NH3 causes loss of around 30% of the desired gold loading in
all the cases except for the most loaded catalyst. This was not
surprising, since all of the non-attached species are lost prior to
the washing procedure.
The twomost loaded catalysts were studied by TEM (Fig. 5).
The increase in gold loading should provoke an increase in
particles size because of greater amount of gold deposited and
also in the increase in the quantity of chloride.
Large gold crystallites are obtained in the case of a water
washed catalyst. This was expected because of incapability of
this type of washing procedure to eliminate the chloride prior to
the calcination. For this sample, particles larger than 100 nm
were observed. The high degree of dispersion for the catalyst
washed with NH3 is somewhat surprising. The stabilisation of
gold nanoparticles by ammonia washing could be supposed
here. The mobility of gold nanoparticles is limited by this
treatment and species strongly anchored across the support are
obtained. Size distribution for the sample washed with
ammonia is presented in Fig. 6. The average particle size
measured over 541 particles is 1.9 nm.
High-resolution TEM photographs were taken of this sample
in order to study the morphology of the particles (Fig. 7).
Fig. 7. HR TEM of the sample 3.1% Au/Al2O3 washed with 4 mol L�1 NH3.
We observed, in accord with the literature, a non-spherical
symmetry suggesting hemispherical morphology for particles
smaller than 3 nm [18]. The inter-reticular distance was
calculated to 2.72 A. In using this data and the model for
cuboctahedral particles proposed by Polisset [14], the disper-
sion of the gold particles was calculated.
A modeling of the dispersion is presented in Fig. 8.
From the average values obtained by TEM for gold particle
diameters the corresponding dispersion could be calculated
from a theoretical curve. All of the results for gold catalysts
supported over alumina and fully characterised by TEM are
presented in Table 3.
For water washed samples, the dispersion improves with the
dilution of the initial gold solution [5]. In fact, for these samples
the model is not fully appropriate owing to the change in the
morphologyofgoldparticleswhen theaveragesize isgreater than
5 nm, above which threshold they are considered as spherical.
Washing with ammonia prior to the calcination causes a
significant decrease in gold particle size, from 16 to 2.4 nm, and
an improvement in the degree of dispersion from 9 to 54%.
Using a more concentrated washing agent (25 mol L�1 rather
than 4 mol L�1) reduces the gold particle size while augment-
ing the dispersion up to as high as 70%. The same result is
obtained for 3Au4N60 samples.
It is possible to obtain, though difficult to provide evidence
for, gold particles smaller than 1 nm. A different catalytic
Table 3
Dispersion values of gold for the series of Au/Al2O3 catalysts
Sample Average particle size (nm) Dispersion (%)
AuW 16 9
Au25N 1.9 70
Au4N5 2.6 52
Au4N20 2.4 54
Au4N60 2.4 54
Au4N24H 3.1 41
3Au4N60a 1.9 70
a 3.1 wt% Au/Al2O3 washed with ammonia 4 mol L�1.
S. Ivanova et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 298 (2006) 57–6462
Fig. 9. Condensation products in gold in ethyl acetate solution.
Fig. 10. Polymers identified in aqueous gold solution by MS.
performance is anticipated for these samples and studies of the
surface of the catalyst are required [19].
3.4. Mechanisms of particles growth
A number of MS experiments were undertaken in order to
study the state of the gold precursor HAuCl4, in solution [20].
Recently, the results presented by Moreau et al. [21] confirm
mainly our results presented previously for pH effect on this
salt. HAuCl4 exists in solution together with simple gold
complexes of type [Au(OH)xCl4�x]�, where x is between 0 and
4, these polymers have m/z ratios greater than 700 (Fig. 9).
These experiments show some surprising results, namely the
links in polymer chain include metallic–oxygen bond and not
the expected metallic–chloride bond.
Three species are identified at this m/z ratio:Awith principal
m/z ratio 779. The loss of two chloride atoms results in a
structural isomer B and the loss of four OH groups in isomer Cwith m/z principal ratio at 713 and 707. All of the species
identified are in ratio 1:2:1 (Fig. 10).
These observations suggest the conclusion that the same
type of complex agglomeration could be possible not only in
the solution but also at the surface. Alternately, we have
observed a change in the colour of the catalyst precursor from
pale yellow to mauve during the process of sample drying at
100 8C. This again suggests a possible reduction of the metal
during drying, always a delicate step of the preparation.
If we consider that the majority of the DAE gold complexes
are bidentate, then a model of the growth of particle size for the
catalyst of type AuW could be proposed. If four neighbouring
Fig. 11. Model of the growth gold particle si
adsorption sites on alumina are occupied by bidentate gold
complexes particle size growth is possible through formation of
Au–Cl–Au bridges. The chloride ligand adopts the role of
electron acceptor and one of the gold species being deficient in
electrons will break the Au–O–Au bond leading to a lower
oxidation state (Fig. 11).
The distance between gold atoms decreases and results in an
increase of gold particle size during the calcination. The
presence of chloride (free or as a ligand) facilitates the mobility
of DAE species on the surface which is easier for monodentate
than for bidentate species and could provoke large gold particle
formation as seen with water washed samples (Fig. 5). The
ze through Au–Cl–Au bridges formation.
S. Ivanova et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 298 (2006) 57–64 63
Fig. 12. Stabilisation of gold particles in an ammonia washed catalyst.
lower oxidation state Au(I) is unstable and decomposes easily
with gold metal deposition [22]. This phenomenon –
autoreduction – could explain the change of catalyst colour
observed during the drying process at 100 8C.Ammonia washing replaces Cl� ligands with OH groups
in the DAE complexes. The gold complexes such as
[AuCl4]�, which are adsorbed simply, are removed from
the surface by washing procedures. The chloride is
completely removed as revealed by elemental analysis and
cannot provoke an increase in particle size during thermal
treatments. The model mentioned above could not be applied
to these catalyst precursors. However, the formation of Au–
O–Au bridges could be envisaged, though oxygen is not able
to attract and break the Al–O–Au bond. For this sample, no
colour change was observed, which is an indication that the
gold complex migration and agglomeration is not very likely.
Alternately, stabilisation of gold complexes by NHx type
ligands, which are electron donors, could occur. The model
presented in Fig. 12 describes one of the possibilities of
stabilisation and do not claim for sure the real state on the
surface.
In theory, the increasing of gold loading in percentage terms
provokes an increase of gold particle size as well as the chloride
loading on the surface. For the samples heavily charged with
gold, the saturation of alumina adsorption sites supposes that
the grafting of the species is more likely in monodentate mode.
The agglomeration of gold particles in this case is favoured for
water washed samples and particles greater than 100 nm are
observed. This is somewhat predictable because this type of
washing cannot remove the chloride and the existence of
monodentate species only facilitates the migration and for-
mation of large gold particles during the thermal treatment. The
higher degree of dispersion for the most loaded catalyst washed
with ammonia, 3Au4N60, is surprising. However, this is proof
that the agglomeration of gold particles does not occur through
Au–O–Au bridges, either as a result of of geometrical
limitations or because of dispersion stabilisation through
hydrogen bonding and as mentioned above, ammonia
stabilisation could also occur.
3.5. Catalytic activity
The catalysts were tested in the reaction of CO [5] and
hydrocarbons (C1 to C3) total oxidation [23]. The catalysts
showed high activities over a range of concentrations and
temperatures. The very positive effect of the washing
procedure is observed and consists in a gain of 95 8C in
terms of T50 (temperature defined as the temperature at which
50% conversion was obtained), i.e. decrease from 163 8Cfor the water washed catalyst to 68 8C for the ammonia
washed sample. Furthermore, a remarkable resistance
to thermal ageing at 600 8C in the absence or presence
of water was observed due to the presence of strongly
anchored nanosized gold particles during the preparation
step.
4. Conclusions
In this paper, we have shown that the desired quantity of gold
is obtained in the case of water washed catalysts supported on
alumina. The washing with ammonia of the catalyst precursor
before the calcination causes loss of up to around 30% of gold,
by weight, which is an indication of the non-attached gold
species being removed from the surface. The quantity of gold
deposited is constant and depends upon the specific surface and
number of adsorption sites on alumina. The catalysts obtained
are perfectly reproducible.
The use of other washing agents is not appropriate because
of the positive role of ammonia in the stabilisation of DAE gold
complexes.
Washing with ammonia encourages gold nanoparticle
formation with an average diameter of less than 2 nm and a
high degree of dispersion, 70%.
A model of gold particle growth is proposed through the
formation of Au–Cl–Au bridges during the thermal treatment
of the catalysts washed only with water. However, this model
could not be applied to the catalysts washed with ammonia
for which a stabilisation by the groups of amine type is more
likely.
S. Ivanova et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 298 (2006) 57–6464
Acknowledgements
The authors are indebted to Dr. Brooks for proof-reading of
the manuscript. We gratefully acknowledge the partial financial
support of this research within the AuTEK project by
Anglogold and Mintek (Johannesburg, South Africa). The
authors thank to H. Herschbach and E. Leize for mass
spectroscopy experiments and fruitful discussion.
References
[1] M. Haruta, Catal. Today 36 (1997) 153.
[2] S. Tsubota, D.A. Cunningham, Y. Bando, M. Haruta, in: G. Poncelet, et al.
(Eds.), Preparation of the Catalysts, vol. VI, Elsevier Science B.V., 1995,
p. 227.
[3] V. Ponec, G.C. Bond, Catalysis by Metals and Alloys, Elsevier Science
B.V., Amsterdam, 1996.
[4] G. Riahi, D. Guillemot, M. Polisset-Thfoin, A.A. Khodadadi, J. Fraissard,
Catal. Today 72 (2002) 115.
[5] S. Ivanova, C. Petit, V. Pitchon, Appl. Catal. A 267 (2004) 191.
[6] E.D. Park, J.S. Lee, J. Catal. 186 (1999) 1.
[7] F. Boccuzzi, A. Chiorino, M. Manzoli, P. Lu, T. Akita, S. Ichikawa, M.
Haruta, J. Catal. 202 (2001) 256.
[8] M. Maciejewski, P. Fabrizioli, J.-D. Grunwaldt, O.S. Becker, A. Baiker,
Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 3 (2001) 384.
[9] S. Lee, A. Gavriilidis, Q.A. Pankhurst, A. Kyek, F.E. Wagner, P.C.L.
Wong, K. Yeung, J. Catal. 200 (2001) 298.
[10] C.K. Costello, M.C. Kung, H.-S. Oh, Y. Wang, H.H. Kung, Appl. Catal. A
232 (2002) 159.
[11] H.-S. Oh, J.H. Yang, C.K. Costello, Y.M. Wang, S.R. Bare, H.H. Kung,
M.C. Kung, J. Catal. 210 (2002) 375.
[12] Q. Xu, K.C.C. Kharas, A.K. Datye, Catal. Lett. 85 (2003) 229.
[13] J. Fisher, Gold Bull. 36 (2003) 155.
[14] M. Polisset, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Paris VI, 1990.
[15] L. Siller, M.R.C. Hunt, J.W. Brown, J.-C. Coquel, P. Rudolf, Surf. Sci. 513
(2002) 78.
[16] C. Duval, Traite de Microanalyse Minerale Qualitative et Quantitative
(1956) 372.
[17] J.-P. Brunelle, Pure Appl. Chem. 50 (1978) 1211.
[18] M. Haruta, CATTECH 6 (2002) 102.
[19] S. Ivanova, C. Petit, V. Pitchon, Appl. Catal. A, in press.
[20] S. Ivanova, C. Petit, V. Pitchon, Catal. Today, in press.
[21] F. Moreau, G.C. Bond, A.O. Taylor, J. Catal. 231 (2005) 105.
[22] P. Braunstein, R.J.H. Clark, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans. 2 (1973) 1845.
[23] S. Ivanova, C. Petit, V. Pitchon, Gold Bull., in press.