presentación de powerpointribamap.ormansu.gov.tr/shared/files/_en1497590571.pdf · 26 / 41...

Yorgos CHATZİNİKOLAOU

Monitoring Results

Technical Assistance for Conversion of River Basin Action Plans into River Basin Management Plans

9th Steering Committee Meeting 16th of June, 2017

2 / 41

Water Body Status Classification

• Characterisation Report (pressures, significant pressures, risk analysis and impact analysis)

• Water Body (WB) delineation according to the characterisation

• Monitoring network (distinguish between surveillance and operational) according to the WBs and the risk analysis (fail = operational, pass & uknown = surveillance)

• Monitoring and analysis according to the network definition

• Classification of WBs

3/ 41

WB delineation

Urban centers

4 / 41

WB delineation

WWTP

5 / 41

WB delineation

Untreated urban wastewaters

6 / 41

WB delineation

Treated & untreated industrial effluents, landfills

7 / 41

WB delineation

Water bodies

8 / 41

Monitoring Network: 368 Water Bodies

River Lake Transitional waters

Coastal waters

Konya WBs 58 34

Meriç Ergene WBs 79 37 3 1

Susurluk WBs 107 37 3 9

9 /

Monitoring network

9 / 41

10 / 41

Monitoring Network

River Lake Transitional waters

Coastal waters

Konya

Surveillance 27 16

Operational 18 5

Protected areas 0 10

Meriç Ergene

Surveillance 16 5 1 0

Operational 25 0 0 0

Protected areas 0 8 1 0

Susurluk

Surveillance 28 11 1 3

Operational 59 2 0 4

Protected areas 1 7 2 0

11 /

Monitoring network

11 / 41

12 / 41

Establishing the chemical status

Sampling in 250 points:12 months priority4 seasons rest substances

AnalysisConsortium & DSi for 336 parameters & substances (107 + 229)

Quality ControlMaximum & problematic values

Comparison to EQS AA & MAC

[ NBC ]

ClassificationO o A o

14 / 41

Quality Control of the Data

• ODK reports

• Double entry of data from DSi and automatic entry from NEN laboratory

• Checks for LoQ, LoD and result values

• Checks for extreme values

• Checks for combination of parameters and strange results

Information

from the

previous period

Data download

Data upload

2.Generates database

for demarcations

1. Opens period for

hydrological year

3.Data validation and

load

4.Biological (Metrics)

and physicochemical

calculations

5.Queries and reports

6.Calculation of state

Basin district

user

Information from

the previous

period

Validated data Validated data

[WEB]

[DESKTOP]

1.Opens

downloaded data

2.Division and

distribution of

data

4.Data validation

3.Data unionMinistry user

Chromium Total Chromium

Site HAVZA ADI Period mg/L Cr + 6 µg/L Cr

KKGİG004 Konya 7 0.379 246.2

KKGİG007 Konya 3 0.139 1.13

KKKAİG001 Konya 3 0.161 0.8

KKKAİG005 Konya 7 0.363 187.5

KKKAİG008 Konya 9 0.116 <0,60

KKOİG003 Konya 9 0.132 2.19

KKOİG004 Konya 3 0.075 7.72

KKOİG004 Konya 9 0.409 10.59

KKOİN012 Konya 3 0.091 6.78

KKOİN012 Konya 7 0.053 <0.6

KKOİN016 Konya 3 0.062 7.96

KKOİN020 Konya 3 0.197 1.62

KKOİN020 Konya 7 0.13 3.73

KKOİN021 Konya 3 0.063 <0.60

KKOİN021 Konya 7 0.05 <0.6

KKOİN022 Konya 3 0.442 47.94

MEGİG001 Meriç Ergene 9 0.011 4.12

MEGİG002 Meriç Ergene 9 0.024 5.3

error rule violated (all involved determinand records are flagged)

1 COD > BOD5 (1% toleration)

2 Total Phosphorus >= Orthophosphate (1% toleration)

3 Total Nitrogen >= Kjeldahl Nitrogen + Nitrate + Nitrite (5% toleration)

4 Kjeldahl Nitrogen >= Total Organic Nitrogen + Total Ammonium (5% toleration)

5 Total Oxidised Nitrogen >= Nitrate + Nitrite (5% toleration)

6 BOD5 < TotalOrganicCarbon (Indicada para WISE 2008-2009, no en 2010)

7 Total Chromium > = Chromium +6

15 / 41


16 / 41


17 / 41

Chemical assessment`

EQS = standard / limit

• MAC : Maximum Annual Concentration

• AAC : Average Annual Concentration

18 / 41

Chemical Status (87.390 results per month)

Analysis DSI DSI DSI DSI NEN DSI

No 13 14 15 18 20 19

Parameter Acetamiprid Aclonifen Alachlor Aluminum (µg/L Al) Anthracene Ammonium nitrogen

Unit µg/L µg/L µg/L µg/L Al µg/L mg NH4 +-N/L

Frequency 4 12 12 4 12 4

LoQ 0.01 0.025 0.2 0.33 0.002 0.05

MAC (freshwater) 42 0.12 0.3 27 0.100

AAC (freshwater) 42 0.12 0.3 2.2 0.100

HIGH/GOOD 0.2

GOOD/MODERATE 1

STATİON CODEPeriod NEN-DSI/StatusAcetamiprid Aclonifen Alachlor Aluminum Anthracene Ammonium nitrogen

1 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

2 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

3 No, Dry Dry Dry Dry Dry Dry Dry

4 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

5 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

6 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

7 No, Dry - Dry Dry - Dry Dry

8 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

9 Yes No Data No Data No Data No Data <0.002 <0.050

10 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

11 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

12 Yes <0.010 <0.025 <0.200 82.07 <0.002 <0.050

1 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

2 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

3 Yes <0.010 <0.025 <0.200 122.9 <0.002 0.0546

4 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

5 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

6 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

7 Yes <0.010 <0.025 <0.200 151.2 <0.002 <0.050

8 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

9 Yes No Data No Data No Data 102.2 <0.002 <0.050

10 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

11 Yes - <0.025 <0.200 - <0.002 -

12 Yes <0.010 <0.025 <0.200 54.28 <0.002 0.1833

KKGİG010

KKGİG011 MAX 0.005 0.0125 0.1 82.7 0.001

AVERAGE 0.005 0.0125 0.1 82.7 0.001

MAX 0.005 0.0125 0.1 151.2 0.001

AVERAGE 0.005 0.0125 0.1 107.6 0.001*75th percentile

KKGİG010

KKGİG011

0.025*

0.151*

19 / 41

Susurluk: Chemical StatusMAC EQSAAC EQS

20 / 41

Konya : Chemical StatusMAC EQSAAC EQS

21 / 41

Meriç Ergene: Chemical StatusMAC EQSAAC EQS

22 / 41

Büyük Menderes: Chemical StatusMAC EQSAAC EQS

23 / 41

Frequency, sampling campaigns and status`M

on

thly

Seas

on

al2

pe

rio

ds

An

nu

al

A M J J A S O N D J F M

Summer Autumn Winter Spring

Low flow period High flow period

Hydromorphological surveys

Priority substances

Physico-chemicals & non specific pollutants

Biological elements

Chem

ical

Status

Ecological

24 / 41

Biological assessment`

observedEQR = -----------------------------

expected (reference)EQS = standard / limit

Chemical assessment

25 / 41

Establishing the biological status: Step 1

26 / 41

Reference values = per river type, the median values of metrics from the reference, potential reference and the best attainable conditions.

Past projects data were also incorporated to the classification, given that they belong to the same river type and their values are higher than the original reference values.

In case of types that cannot establish proper reference values, the value of 11 was adopted, by expert judgement. IPS=11 was a value extracted from both the available data and the relevant reference values of Spain.

Establishing the biological status: Step 1Basin WB_Code NAME_StationPeriodWB_CategoryWB_Type WB_NatureMonit_TypeReferenceIPS Ref.val. IPS

KONYA KON_002_3 KKGİN009 1 RW A1R3E2Y2D1J1 NWB SU No 20.00

KONYA KON_002_3 KKGİN009 2 RW A1R3E2Y2D1J1 NWB SU No 20.00

AKARÇAY SMAKR21 1 RW A1R3E2Y2D1J1 BAEP 20 20.00

SUSURLUK SUN_008 SUOİN007 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP BAEP 10.2 16.10

SUSURLUK SUN_008 SUOİN007 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP BAEP 16.10

SUSURLUK SUN_033 SUOİN019 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 2 16.10

SUSURLUK SUN_033 SUOİN019 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 1.3 16.10

SUSURLUK SUN_036 SUOİN020 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 16.10






SUSURLUK SUN_039_3 SUOİN060 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 16.10

SUSURLUK SUN_039_3 SUOİN060 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 16.10

BUYUK MENDERES 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB BAEP 15.5 16.10

BUYUK MENDERES 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB BAEP 17.6 16.10

ANTALYA ANTGİN007 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 BAEP 16.1 16.10

ANTALYA ANTGİN007 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 BAEP 18.2 16.10

MERIC ERGENE MEN_023 MEGİN008 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU BAEP 8.1 13.10



MERIC ERGENE MEN_058 MEGİN016 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU BAEP 13.10

MERIC ERGENE MEN_006 MEOİN005 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB OP BAEP 8.9 13.10


MERIC ERGENE MEN_024 MEOİN025 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB OP BAEP 13.10






MERIC ERGENE MEN_022 MEGİN002 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 15.4 13.10



MERIC ERGENE MEN_002 MEGİN003 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 13.10


MERIC ERGENE MEN_001 MEGİN004 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 13.10



Basin WB_Code NAME_StationPeriodWB_CategoryWB_Type WB_NatureMonit_TypeReferenceIPS Ref.val. IPS EQR H/G G/M M/P P/B Sample Site

KONYA KON_002_3 KKGİN009 1 RW A1R3E2Y2D1J1 NWB SU No 20.00 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

KONYA KON_002_3 KKGİN009 2 RW A1R3E2Y2D1J1 NWB SU No 20.00 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

AKARÇAY SMAKR21 1 RW A1R3E2Y2D1J1 BAEP 20 20.00 1.000

SUSURLUK SUN_008 SUOİN007 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP BAEP 10.2 16.10 0.634 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 GOOD

SUSURLUK SUN_008 SUOİN007 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP BAEP 16.10 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

SUSURLUK SUN_033 SUOİN019 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 2 16.10 0.124 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 BAD

SUSURLUK SUN_033 SUOİN019 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 1.3 16.10 0.081 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 BAD

SUSURLUK SUN_036 SUOİN020 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 16.10 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

SUSURLUK SUN_036 SUOİN020 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 7.9 16.10 0.491 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 MODERATE


SUSURLUK SUN_036 SUOİN021 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 5.1 16.10 0.317 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 POOR


SUSURLUK SUN_052 SUOİN029 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 9.7 16.10 0.602 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 GOOD

SUSURLUK SUN_039_3 SUOİN060 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 16.10 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

SUSURLUK SUN_039_3 SUOİN060 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB OP No 16.10 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

BUYUK MENDERES 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB BAEP 15.5 16.10 0.963 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 HIGH

BUYUK MENDERES 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 NWB BAEP 17.6 16.10 1.093 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 HIGH

ANTALYA ANTGİN007 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 BAEP 16.1 16.10 1.000

ANTALYA ANTGİN007 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J1 BAEP 18.2 16.10 1.130

MERIC ERGENE MEN_023 MEGİN008 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU BAEP 8.1 13.10 0.618 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 GOOD



MERIC ERGENE MEN_058 MEGİN016 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU BAEP 13.10 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

MERIC ERGENE MEN_006 MEOİN005 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB OP BAEP 8.9 13.10 0.679 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 GOOD

MERIC ERGENE MEN_006 MEOİN005 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB OP BAEP 5.6 13.10 0.427 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 MODERATE

MERIC ERGENE MEN_024 MEOİN025 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB OP BAEP 13.10 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

MERIC ERGENE MEN_024 MEOİN025 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB OP BAEP 9.9 13.10 0.756 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 GOOD

SUSURLUK SUN_070 SUOİN044 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB OP BAEP 13.8 13.10 1.053 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 HIGH



SUSURLUK SUN_080 SUOİN052 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB OP BAEP 10.2 13.10 0.779 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 GOOD

MERIC ERGENE MEN_022 MEGİN002 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 15.4 13.10 1.176 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 HIGH

MERIC ERGENE MEN_022 MEGİN002 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 7.3 13.10 0.557 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 MODERATE

MERIC ERGENE MEN_002 MEGİN003 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 5.4 13.10 0.412 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 MODERATE

MERIC ERGENE MEN_002 MEGİN003 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 13.10 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

MERIC ERGENE MEN_001 MEGİN004 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 8.6 13.10 0.656 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 GOOD

MERIC ERGENE MEN_001 MEGİN004 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 13.10 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2

MERIC ERGENE MEN_007 MEGİN005 1 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 4.9 13.10 0.374 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 POOR

MERIC ERGENE MEN_007 MEGİN005 2 RW A2R1E1Y2D1J2 NWB SU No 3.6 13.10 0.275 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 POOR

GOOD

POOR

HIGH

HIGH

GOOD

GOOD

GOOD

MODERATE

GOOD

BAD

MODERATE

MODERATE

GOOD

HIGH

POOR

GOOD

27 / 41


Confidence level is assessed in all steps of classification of the individual BQEs.

At the sample level, the confidence level assessment usually arrives from the sampler

and/or the sample analyst. At the site level, the confidence level deals with the

justification of any inconsistency between the seasonal samples. Finally, at the water

body level, the confidence level reflects the robustness and the consistency of the

classification for a specific BQE.

Confidence level can take the values of:

_very confident (VM)

_moderately confident (M)

_not sure (UNC)

Classification results with an uncertain level of confidence are not taken into account.

28 / 41


WB name

Site name

BQE Period Sample SiteBQE

ME_01 M23 1st VCVC

ME_01 M23 2nd MC

ME_01 M23 1st VCMC

ME_01 M23 2nd VC

ME_01 M23 1st UNC

ME_01 M40 1st UNCMC

ME_01 M40 2nd MC

ME_01 M40 1st VCMC

ME_01 M40 2nd UNC

ME_01 M40 1st MC VC

29 / 41


30 / 41


WB name

Site name

BQE Period Sample SiteBQE

SiteAll (OoAo)

Overall(OoAo)

ME_01 M23 1st VCVC

VC

ME_01 M23 2nd MC

ME_01 M23 1st VCMC

ME_01 M23 2nd VC

ME_01 M23 1st UNC

ME_01 M40 1st UNCMC

MC

ME_01 M40 2nd MC

ME_01 M40 1st VCMC

ME_01 M40 2nd UNC

ME_01 M40 1st MC VC

31 / 41

Biological status in Susurluk

32 / 41

Ecological Status classification

33 / 41

Hydromorphological StatusSusurluk:

34 / 41

Physicochemical StatusSpecific Pollutants MAC EQSSpecific Pollutants AAC EQSSusurluk:

35 / 41

Susurluk: Ecological Status

36 / 41

Ecological StatusMerıç Ergene:

37 / 41

Ecological StatusKonya:

38 / 41

Ecological StatusBüyük Menderes:

39 / 41

40 / 41

1st Example of classification

Ergene Nehri 7

Ergene Nehri 6

Site M44 (OP) Site M55 (OP)

Pressures MEN_052 MEN_056

Oi1-Standard NI1 NI1

Oi2-Livestock / Nutrients NI2 NI2

Oi3-Urban Waste Water NI3 NI3

Oi6-Food Industry NI5

Oi18-Metal Industry NI7

Oi31-Mining NI8

Oi34-Agriculture NI9 NI9

ChemicalMEN_052 MEN_056

Dieldrin Cadmium

Fluorantene Dieldrin

Lead Fluorantene

Nickel Heptaklor

Nonilfenol Lead

Octyphenol Nickel

Nonilfenol

Octyphenol

Trichlorometane

EcologicalBiological

MEN_052 MEN_056

Phytobenthos Phytobenthos

Macroınvertebrates Macroınvertebrates

Physicochemical

General physicocjemical parameters

NH4 BOD

BOD COD

COD DO (mg/L)

DO (mg/L) Conductivity

Conductivity o-PO4

o-PO4 TKN

TKN TN

TN TP

TP

Specific pollutants

Aluminum (µg/L Al) Aluminum (µg/L Al)

Cobalt (µg/L Co) Cobalt (µg/L Co)

Copper (µg/L Cu) Copper (µg/L Cu)

Dieldrin Dieldrin

Iron (Fe) (µg/L Fe) Iron (Fe) (µg/L Fe)

Octyphenol Octyphenol

Vanadyum (µg/L V) Vanadyum (µg/L V)

Zinc (µg/L Zn) Zinc (µg/L Zn)

41/ 41

2nd Example of classification

Çorlu Çayı 2

Çorlu Çayı 3

Pressures MEN_002 MEN_054

Oi1-Standard NI1 NI1

Oi2-Livestock / Nutrients NI2 NI2

Oi3-Urban Waste Water NI3 NI3

Oi5-Textile Industry NI4 NI4

Oi9-Leather Industry NI6 NI6

Oi18-Metal Industry NI7 NI7

Oi34-Agriculture NI9 NI9

ChemicalMEN_002 MEN_053

Aldrin Anthracene

Cadmium Chloroalkanes C10-13

Chloroalkanes C10-13 Dieldrin

Fluorantene Endosulfan

Hexachlorocyclohexane (incluiding α-, β-, γ- and d-HCH)Fluorantene

Lead Heptaklor

Nickel Lead

Nonilfenol Nickel

Octyphenol Nonilfenol

Benzo(b)floranthene Octyphenol

Trichlorometane

EcologicalBiological

MEN_002 MEN_053

Phytobenthos Phytobenthos

Macroınvertebrates Macroınvertebrates

Physicochemical

General physicocjemical parameters

NH4 NH4

BOD BOD

COD COD

DO (mg/L) DO (mg/L)

Conductivity Conductivity

Manganese o-PO4

o-PO4 TKN

TKN TN

TN TP

TP

Specific pollutants

Aldrin Aluminum (µg/L Al)

Aluminum (µg/L Al) Antimony (µg/L Sb)

Antimony (µg/L Sb) Cobalt (µg/L Co)

Cobalt (µg/L Co) Copper (µg/L Cu)

Copper (µg/L Cu) Iron (Fe) (µg/L Fe)

Diflubenzuron Octyphenol

Iron (Fe) (µg/L Fe) Piren

Octyphenol Titanium( µg/L Ti)

Vanadyum (µg/L V) Vanadyum (µg/L V)

Zinc (µg/L Zn) Zinc (µg/L Zn)

Yorgos CHATZİNİKOLAOU

Monitoring Results

Technical Assistance for Conversion of River Basin Action Plans into River Basin Management Plans

9th Steering Committee Meeting 16th of June, 2017

presentación de powerpointribamap.ormansu.gov.tr/shared/files/_en1497590571.pdf · 26 / 41...

Documents