presented by : len john acting provincial head icd / kzn 09/11/2007

Independent Complaints Directorate Independent Complaints Directorate KwaZulu NatalKwaZulu Natal

Review 04/2007 – 09/2007Review 04/2007 – 09/2007

Portfolio Committee on Safety and Portfolio Committee on Safety and SecuritySecurity

Presented by : Len JohnPresented by : Len JohnActing Provincial HeadActing Provincial Head

ICD / KZNICD / KZN09/11/200709/11/2007

Provincial Head(Vacant)

Deputy Provincial HeadMr. L.B. John (M)

Secretary to Provincial HeadMs. P. S. Gamede (F)

Assistant Manager: HRM Mr S.G. Moodley (M)

Assistant Manager: InvestigationMr. MJ. Ngcobo (M)

Monitor Ms. N. Gibson (f) 1/08/2007

Admin ClerkMrs. C. Lupke (F)

Principal InvestigatorMr SJA. Nene (M)

Senior Investigator Ms. S,. Williams (F) 6/08/2007

Principal InvestigatorMr. SC. Mseleje (M) (suspended)

Senior Investigator Vacant (30/09/2007)

Principal Investigator Mr CS. Vorster (M)

Senior Investigator Mr. RY. Haffajee (M)

Senior InvestigatorMs WA. Mpanza (F)

Complaints ReceptionistMs. Z. Nxumalo (F)

Case Analyst Ms. L. Harripersadh (F)

Case AnalystMrs. N. Ndlovu (F)

Legal Intern (Vacant)

Legal Intern (Vacant)

Senior InvestigatorMs. P. Dlamini (F)

Senior InvestigatorMr. J. Singh (M)

Senior Investigator (Vacant – 30/09/2007))

Data CapturerMs. Ndlovu

Satellite Office – Richards BaySatellite Office – Richards Bay

Principal Investigator

Vacant

Senior Investigator

Mr. B. Ncanana (M)

Case Analyst

Mrs. C. Iyer (F)

AdministrativeClerk

Mr. Sibani (M)

Satellite Office : Richards BaySatellite Office : Richards Bay

Reasons for delay in establishment :Reasons for delay in establishment :

Sourcing of accommodation by Department Sourcing of accommodation by Department of Public Worksof Public Works

ProgressProgress Meeting held with DPW on 22/10/2007, Meeting held with DPW on 22/10/2007,

re : accommodationre : accommodation

Only post of Principal Investigator to be filledOnly post of Principal Investigator to be filled

Budget 2006/07 vs 2007/08Budget 2006/07 vs 2007/08

Programme 1Programme 1 Programme 2Programme 2 Programme 3Programme 3 TotalTotal

06/706/7 07/0807/08 06/0706/07 07/0807/08 06/0706/07 07/0807/08 06/0706/07 07/0807/08CompensaCompensation of tion of employeeemployeess

344344 417417 24742474 32613261 394394 465465 32123212 41434143

Goods and Goods and servicesservices 3939 163163 11241124 11771177 340340 348348 15031503 16881688TransfersTransfers 22 22Machinery Machinery and Equip.and Equip. 1212 5555 135135 3030 2020 8585 167167SoftwareSoftware 11 11 55 99 33 33 99 1313

TotalTotal 384384 593593 36603660 45824582 767767 836836 48114811 60116011

Budget / Richards BayBudget / Richards Bay

Programme Programme 11



TotalTotal

Compensation of Compensation of EmployeesEmployees 9393 511511 104104 708708

Goods and Goods and ServicesServices 7272 254254 143143 469469

TransfersTransfers

BuildingBuilding 8080 8080

Machinery and Machinery and EquipmentEquipment 112112 464464 224224 800800

SoftwareSoftware 11 22 11 44

TotalTotal 358358 12311231 472472 20612061

Portfolio Committee Recommendation Portfolio Committee Recommendation Regarding StaffingRegarding Staffing

Increased investigation capacityIncreased investigation capacity

Reduced requirement for entry level position - Reduced requirement for entry level position - investigatorsinvestigatorsIncreased Increased investigation investigation capacity in the capacity in the provinceprovince

To establish To establish satellite office in satellite office in Richards BayRichards Bay

Established Established

P/I post to be filled P/I post to be filled in November 2007in November 2007

Reduced Reduced requirement for requirement for entry level position - entry level position - investigationinvestigation

Requirement for Requirement for a degree or a degree or diploma reduceddiploma reduced

Three year legal Three year legal qualification and qualification and extensive extensive experience due to experience due to the upgrade of the upgrade of investigators’ levelinvestigators’ level

Geographical AreaGeographical Area

NorthNorthEmangusi (Mozambique Border)Emangusi (Mozambique Border)Pongola (Swaziland Border)Pongola (Swaziland Border)

SouthSouthPort Edward, Kokstad, Port Edward, Kokstad, GowanleaGowanlea, , IbisiIbisi,,IntsekeniIntsekeni

WestWestSani Pass Border, OliviershoekSani Pass Border, Oliviershoek ,,Van Reenen’s PassVan Reenen’s Pass

Files Received Files Received 4/2006 – 10/20064/2006 – 10/20064/2007 – 10/20074/2007 – 10/2007

Class 1Class 1 Class 2Class 2 Class 3Class 3 Class 4Class 4

PREPRE CURRCURR PREPRE CURRCURR PREPRE CURRCURR PREPRE CURRCURR

APRILAPRIL 1212 99 00 00 99 2222 99 2121

MAYMAY 1414 1818 11 44 3232 2828 3434 2626

JUNEJUNE 1616 1515 11 33 1212 2626 1515 3434

JULYJULY 1212 2020 11 44 1919 2323 1818 2727

AUGAUG 1313 1515 00 11 88 2727 2626 4646

SEPTSEPT 77 88 00 11 99 2525 99 2929

TOTTOT 7474 8585 33 1313 8989 151151 111111 183183

Case IntakeCase Intake2006/07 vs 2007/082006/07 vs 2007/08

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

Class 1 Class 2 Class 3 Class 4 Total

2006/72007/8

2006/2007 - Closed Files2006/2007 - Closed FilesMONTHMONTH CLASS 1CLASS 1 CLASS 2CLASS 2 CLASS 3CLASS 3 CLASS 4CLASS 4 TOTALTOTAL

APRIL 06APRIL 06

MAY 06MAY 06 11 11 88 88 1818

JUNE 06JUNE 06 88 00 77 99 2424

JULY 06JULY 06 99 00 22 00 1111

AUG 06AUG 06 22 00 11 33 66

SEPT 06SEPT 06 6060 00 88 55 7373

OCT 06OCT 06 2323 00 22 33 2828

NOV 06NOV 06 11 00 44 66 1111

DEC 06DEC 06 22 00 11 11 44

JAN 07JAN 07 2323 00 22 1414 3939

FEB 07FEB 07 1818 1010 99 3737

MAR 07MAR 07 4242 2929 4646 117117

TOTALTOTAL 189189 11 7474 104104 368368

2007/2008 Closed Files2007/2008 Closed Files

11 22 33 44BacklogBacklog CurrentCurrent BacklogBacklog CurrentCurrent BacklogBacklog CurrentCurrent BacklogBacklog CurrentCurrent

AprilApril 1515 11 55 3030 5151

MayMay 1313 33 4242 7070 128128

JuneJune 66 11 2020 3939 6666

JulyJuly 1414 22 11 1717 33 6161 55 103103

AugAug 88 55 11 99 1111 22 1414 5050SeptSept 33 33 66 33 00 88 2323

OctOct 2929 22 22 2020 11 3030 33 8787

8888 1212 77 22 119119 1818 232232 3030 508508

Closed files 2006/07 vs 2007/08Closed files 2006/07 vs 2007/08

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

class 1 class 2 class 3 class 4 total

2006/7

2007/8

Convictions 2006/2007Convictions 2006/2007

StationStation CAS no.CAS no. MemberMember ChargesCharges ConvictionConviction I/OI/OAlexander Alexander RdRd

46/04/0346/04/03 Supt. O’ Supt. O’ ConnellConnell

Culpable Culpable HomicideHomicide

Departmental Departmental Contravening Contravening reg. 18 (26)reg. 18 (26)

Mr. SJA Mr. SJA NeneNene

TongaatTongaat 113/04/02113/04/02 Insp. SP Insp. SP MduliMduli

MurderMurder Sentenced : 15 Sentenced : 15 years impr.years impr.


VryheidVryheid 284/01/06284/01/06 Ms. Ms. MthembuMthembu

PerjuryPerjury Sentenced : 3 Sentenced : 3 years susp. For years susp. For 5 years5 years


Kwa Kwa MashuMashu

817/04/03817/04/03 Sgt. TG Sgt. TG MchunuMchunu

MurderMurder Departmental Departmental contravening of contravening of Reg. 18 (26) – Reg. 18 (26) – Dismissal Dismissal Criminal case Criminal case pendingpending

Mr. MJ Mr. MJ NgcoboNgcobo

MarianhillMarianhill 211/08/99211/08/99 Capt. CM Capt. CM DumaDuma

Attempted Attempted ExtortionExtortion

3 years impr. 3 years impr. Susp. For 5 Susp. For 5 years – years – Departmental : Departmental : dischargeddischarged


UmbiloUmbilo 632/03/06632/03/06 Insp. Insp. GumedeGumede

Insp. NdimaInsp. Ndima

CorruptionCorruption Departmental Departmental discharged – discharged – criminal case criminal case pendingpending

Mr. CS Mr. CS VorsterVorster

Convictions – 2006/2007Convictions – 2006/2007Durban Durban CentralCentral

927/01/04927/01/04 Insp. TD Insp. TD Sindolwane Sindolwane

Murder, Murder, Assault Assault GBHGBH

Sentenced to Sentenced to 15 years for 15 years for Murder and 2 Murder and 2 years for years for Assault GBH Assault GBH

Mr. CS Mr. CS VorsterVorster

TongaatTongaat 220/04/03220/04/03 C. NaidooC. Naidoo

(Metro Police)(Metro Police)Culpable Culpable HomicideHomicide

Sentenced to Sentenced to R20000-00 fine R20000-00 fine or 5 years or 5 years imprisonment, imprisonment, 16 hours 16 hours community community service for two service for two years and to years and to attend rehab.attend rehab.

Mr. SC Mr. SC MselejeMseleje

ChatsworthChatsworth 68/11/0468/11/04 Cst. P. PillayCst. P. Pillay CorruptionCorruption Departmental Departmental discharged : discharged : Criminal case Criminal case pendingpending

Mr. LB JohnMr. LB John

Inchanga Inchanga 19/05/0319/05/03 Insp. DL Insp. DL MkwanaziMkwanazi

MurderMurder

Assault Assault GBHGBH

Attempted Attempted MurderMurder

20 years imp.20 years imp.

3 years impr.3 years impr.

10 years impr.10 years impr.


UmbiloUmbilo 757/09/02757/09/02 Insp. TS Insp. TS ShangaseShangase

MurderMurder Found Guilty Found Guilty of murder, of murder, sentencing on sentencing on 4/04/20074/04/2007

Mr. WS Mr. WS MdlaloseMdlalose

Mt. SC Mt. SC MselejeMseleje

Convictions 2006/2007Convictions 2006/2007

HighflatsHighflats 3/12/033/12/03 Insp. CZ Insp. CZ KhumaloKhumalo

3 counts of 3 counts of Murder and Murder and count 4 count 4 Attempted Attempted MurderMurder

Count 1 : 15 Count 1 : 15 yearsyears




Count 3 & 4 : Count 3 & 4 : to run to run concurrently concurrently with count 1 with count 1 & 2. & 2. Effective Effective imprisonment imprisonment term is thirty term is thirty yearsyears


UmbiloUmbilo 757/09/02757/09/02 Insp. Insp. NtshangaseNtshangase

MurderMurder 12 years 12 years imprisonmentimprisonment

Mr. WS Mr. WS Mdlalose / Mdlalose / Mr. CS Mr. CS VorsterVorster

Domestic Related Shootings (April 2006 – March 2007)Domestic Related Shootings (April 2006 – March 2007)

StationStation Cas No.Cas No. DescriptionDescription Status of CaseStatus of Case

Newlands Newlands EastEast

115/03/06115/03/06 Member fatally Member fatally shot his wifeshot his wife

Court matterCourt matter

Mt. RiseMt. Rise 800/04/06800/04/06 Member assault on Member assault on wife and daughterwife and daughter

Court MatterCourt Matter

UmlaziUmlazi 274/02/06274/02/06 Member shot and Member shot and wounded his sonwounded his son


MayvilleMayville 76/02/0776/02/07 Member fatally Member fatally shot his wifeshot his wife


UmlaziUmlazi 11/12/0611/12/06 Member fatally Member fatally shot his wife and shot his wife and fatally shot himselffatally shot himself

InquestInquest

UmlaziUmlazi 661/01/07661/01/07 Member shot and Member shot and wounded his wifewounded his wife

Court matterCourt matter

Arrest 04/2007 to 31/08/2007Arrest 04/2007 to 31/08/2007

STATIONSTATION CAS NO.CAS NO. MEMBERMEMBER CHARGESCHARGES ICD I/OICD I/O

BellairBellair 72/04/0772/04/07 Sgt. Sgt. HlatshwayoHlatshwayo

Extortion and Extortion and CorruptionCorruption

Ms. MpanzaMs. Mpanza

BellairBellair 107/05/07107/05/07 Insp. EbrahimInsp. Ebrahim RapeRape Ms. MpanzaMs. Mpanza

KwaDabekaKwaDabeka 138/10/05138/10/05 Bhekisisa Bhekisisa Micheal Micheal Mzimela / CeleMzimela / Cele

MurderMurder

(Summons (Summons issued)issued)

Mr. NeneMr. Nene

WentworthWentworth 167/03/07167/03/07 Derrick Derrick WaymaneWaymane

MurderMurder Mr. NeneMr. Nene

Durban Durban CentralCentral

254/07/07254/07/07 Dees Dees GovenderGovender

CorruptionCorruption Mr. VorsterMr. Vorster

Durban Durban CentralCentral

710/04/07710/04/07 Steve Steve GovenderGovender

CorruptionCorruption Mr. VorsterMr. Vorster

Arrest 04/2007 to 31/08/2007Arrest 04/2007 to 31/08/2007

StationStation CAS noCAS no MemberMember ChargesCharges ICD I/OICD I/O

PointPoint 656/10/06656/10/06 Gonasen Gonasen PadayacheePadayachee

AssaultAssault Mr. VorsterMr. Vorster

SydenhamSydenham 421/05/07421/05/07 Kelvin Kelvin ShumugamShumugam

ExtortionExtortion Mr. VorsterMr. Vorster

Sydenham Sydenham 421/05/07421/05/07 Sgt. NgcoboSgt. Ngcobo ExtortionExtortion Mr. VorsterMr. Vorster

PhoenixPhoenix 61/06/200661/06/2006 Roven PillayRoven Pillay Indecent AssaultIndecent Assault Mr. SinghMr. Singh

MelmothMelmoth 97/01/0497/01/04 TA SibisiTA Sibisi Assault GBH, Assault GBH, RobberyRobbery

Mr. NcananaMr. Ncanana

InandaInanda 395/01/06395/01/06 Cst. N. SheziCst. N. Shezi Culpable Culpable HomicideHomicide

Mr. VorsterMr. Vorster

Total Backlog Total Backlog end 09/2007end 09/2007

DOCKETSDOCKETS FILESFILES

PRIOR PRIOR 20072007

20072007 PRIOR PRIOR 20072007

20072007

338338 6868 174174 432432

Total : 406Total : 406 Total :606Total :606

Current dockets at CourtCurrent dockets at CourtNoNo CCNCCN StationStation ChargeCharge MemberMember StatusStatus

1.1. 20070103152007010315 UmlaziUmlazi Att. MurderAtt. Murder Insp. MduboInsp. Mdubo Awaiting TDAwaiting TD

2.2. 20061100092006110009 Kwa MashuKwa Mashu Murder Murder Insp. MabasoInsp. Mabaso 12/12/200712/12/2007

3.3. 20070400092007040009 DonnybrookDonnybrook MurderMurder Cst. GumedeCst. Gumede SPP DecisionSPP Decision

4.4. 20070900102007090010 IbisiIbisi Att. MurderAtt. Murder Insp. FihlaInsp. Fihla InvInv

5.5. 20070303952007030395 KwaDengeziKwaDengezi MurderMurder Cst. MakhathiniCst. Makhathini InvInv

6.6. 20060700952006070095 Durban CentralDurban Central CorruptionCorruption Insp. PapaInsp. Papa 13/03/200813/03/2008

7.7. 20070403442007040344 PhoenixPhoenix Assault GBHAssault GBH Insp. MoonsamyInsp. Moonsamy Awaiting TDAwaiting TD

8.8. 20020700222002070022 GreytownGreytown MurderMurder Insp. MhlongoInsp. Mhlongo 08/11/200708/11/2007

9.9. 20070600282007060028 PhoenixPhoenix Ind. AssaultInd. Assault Cst. R. PillayCst. R. Pillay 03/09/200803/09/2008

10.10. 20060602892006060289 Port ShepstonePort Shepstone MurderMurder Cst MkhizeCst Mkhize SummonsSummons

11.11. 20070504882007050488 PhoenixPhoenix Assault GBHAssault GBH Insp. NairInsp. Nair SPP DecisionSPP Decision

12.12. 20040902402004090240 HimevilleHimeville MurderMurder Insp. ZiqubuInsp. Ziqubu 12/12/200712/12/2007

13.13. 20070904332007090433 B/BeachB/Beach RapeRape Sgt. PT MtoloSgt. PT Mtolo 31/10/200731/10/2007

14.14. 20031200962003120096 MarianhillMarianhill MurderMurder S KhwelaS Khwela 16/11/200716/11/2007

NoNo CCNCCN StationStation ChargeCharge MemberMember StatusStatus

15.15. 20060102592006010259 InandaInanda C/HomicideC/Homicide N SheziN Shezi 06/11/200706/11/2007

16.16. 20070201642007020164 TongaatTongaat P/of FirearmP/of Firearm T. NaidooT. Naidoo 07/11/200707/11/2007

17.17. 20060504602006050460 Durban CentralDurban Central FraudFraud S/Supt SitholeS/Supt Sithole 13/05/200813/05/2008

18.18. 20070701142007070114 Durban CentralDurban Central CorruptionCorruption M GovenderM Govender 20/11/200720/11/2007

19.19. 20070304832007030483 Durban CentralDurban Central CorruptionCorruption P GovenderP Govender 29/11/200729/11/2007

20.20. 20040500332004050033 PM BurgPM Burg Armed RobbArmed Robb (4 Accused)(4 Accused) 14/12/200714/12/2007

21.21. 20060602432006060243 HluhluweHluhluwe MurderMurder C EngelbretchC Engelbretch 20/11/200720/11/2007

22.22. 20070900682007090068 LadysmithLadysmith MurderMurder A SithebeA Sithebe 25/11/200725/11/2007

23.23. 20030502952003050295 PhoenixPhoenix MurderMurder S SinghS Singh 31/10/200731/10/2007

24.24. 20051004042005100404 KwaDabekaKwaDabeka MurderMurder Insp. MzimelaInsp. Mzimela 25/10/200725/10/2007

25.25. 20020903322002090332 WentworthWentworth MurderMurder Insp. JamesInsp. James 18/12/200718/12/2007

26.26. 20030600052003060005 HibberdeneHibberdene MurderMurder Sgt. MajoziSgt. Majozi 08/11/200708/11/2007

27.27. 20040500272004050027 MelmothMelmoth Assault GBHAssault GBH SANDF (5 accd)SANDF (5 accd) 12/12/200712/12/2007

28.28. 20031001592003100159 NewcastleNewcastle RapeRape RameshpersadhRameshpersadh 23/11/200723/11/2007

COURT DOCKETS (CONTINUED)


29.29. 20041003172004100317 OsizweniOsizweni MurderMurder Insp. NkosiInsp. Nkosi 28/04/200828/04/2008

30.30. 20070303932007030393 WentworthWentworth MurderMurder Insp. WymaneInsp. Wymane SPP SummonSPP Summon

31.31. 20040102512004010251 PhoenixPhoenix MurderMurder S MoodleyS Moodley 4/12/20074/12/2007

32.32. 20030502772003050277 IxopoIxopo MurderMurder Insp. MkhizeInsp. Mkhize 2/11/20072/11/2007

33.33. 20060401812006040181 PM BurgPM Burg MurderMurder Sgt. SitholeSgt. Sithole 30/10/200730/10/2007

34.34. 20030903432003090343 Durban Central Durban Central MurderMurder Leon StevenLeon Steven A / Trial DateA / Trial Date

35.35. 20040502342004050234 Durban CentralDurban Central CorruptionCorruption Insp. ReyneckerInsp. Reynecker 19/11/200719/11/2007

36.36. 20061102122006110212 Durban CentralDurban Central F/A ControlF/A Control (Metro Police)(Metro Police) DPP DecisionDPP Decision

37.37. 20040203212004020321 MelmothMelmoth Ass. GBHAss. GBH TA SibisiTA Sibisi 20/11/200720/11/2007

38.38. 99kn00025399kn000253 VerulamVerulam InquestInquest DPP decisionDPP decision

39.39. 20060503092006050309 ChatsworthChatsworth Crimen Inj.Crimen Inj. IE KhanIE Khan SPP declinedSPP declined

40.40. 20030902282003090228 MpungamhlophMpungamhlophee

Culp. H.Culp. H. E. MbathaE. Mbatha 08/11/200708/11/2007

41.41. 20060104662006010466 UmhlaliUmhlali InquestInquest Formal Inq.Formal Inq.

42.42. 20070100462007010046 MpumalangaMpumalanga MurderMurder OB MthetwaOB Mthetwa 1/11/20071/11/2007

43.43. 20070101112007010111 MtunziniMtunzini Culp. H.Culp. H. SPP DecisionSPP Decision




44.44. 20061103372006110337 BhekithembaBhekithemba MurderMurder Insp. NgcoboInsp. Ngcobo A/ Trial DateA/ Trial Date

45.45. 20070203642007020364 NongomaNongoma Culp. H.Culp. H. Cst. CeleCst. Cele A/ Trial DateA/ Trial Date

46.46. 20070505452007050545 BellairBellair RapeRape Insp. EbrahimInsp. Ebrahim A/ Trial DateA/ Trial Date

47.47. 20070201902007020190 MayvilleMayville Att. MurderAtt. Murder Cst. MvuyaniCst. Mvuyani A/ Trial DateA/ Trial Date

48.48. 20070401562007040156 BellairBellair ExtortionExtortion Sgt. HlatswayoSgt. Hlatswayo A/ Trial DateA/ Trial Date

49.49. 20070104392007010439 UmlaziUmlazi MurderMurder Insp. MduboInsp. Mdubo 21/01/200821/01/2008

50.50. 20030201442003020144 PhoenixPhoenix MurderMurder Sgt. NS AhmedSgt. NS Ahmed 22/02/200822/02/2008

DVA / Cell VisitsDVA / Cell Visits

DATEDATE STATIONSTATION19/09/200719/09/2007 NtambamhlopheNtambamhlophe

WembeziWembezi

Nottingham RoadNottingham Road

22/08/200722/08/2007 Gowan LeaGowan Lea

22/08/200722/08/2007 IbisiIbisi

22/08/200722/08/2007 IntsekeniIntsekeni

MapumaloMapumalo

24/10/200724/10/2007 NongomaNongoma

Outreach ProgrammesOutreach ProgrammesDateDate VenueVenue

3/04/20073/04/2007 Howard College – UmbiloHoward College – Umbilo

10/04/200710/04/2007 Phoenix Community Policing ForumPhoenix Community Policing Forum

11/04/200711/04/2007 Sundumbili Community Hall – ImbisoSundumbili Community Hall – Imbiso

12/04/200712/04/2007 Richards Bay Community Hall – ImbisoRichards Bay Community Hall – Imbiso

14/04/200714/04/2007 Sundumbili SAPS – Policing ForumSundumbili SAPS – Policing Forum

18/04/200718/04/2007 Sundumbili Community Hall – ImbisoSundumbili Community Hall – Imbiso

18/04/200718/04/2007 Phoenix Westham School Hall – ImbisoPhoenix Westham School Hall – Imbiso

08/05/200708/05/2007 Phoenix Community Policing ForumPhoenix Community Policing Forum

10/05/200710/05/2007 ICD Board Room – Visit by Portfolio CommitteeICD Board Room – Visit by Portfolio Committee

10/05/200710/05/2007 SAPS Durban Central – Portfolio CommitteeSAPS Durban Central – Portfolio Committee

10/05/200710/05/2007 SAPS Kwa Mashu – Portfolio CommitteeSAPS Kwa Mashu – Portfolio Committee

10/05/200710/05/2007 SAPS Pinetown – Portfolio CommitteeSAPS Pinetown – Portfolio Committee

11/05/200711/05/2007 SAPS KwaDukuza – Portfolio CommitteeSAPS KwaDukuza – Portfolio Committee

11/05/200711/05/2007 SAPS Inanda – Portfolio CommitteeSAPS Inanda – Portfolio Committee

Outreach Programmes (Continued)Outreach Programmes (Continued)

DateDate VenueVenue

29/05/200729/05/2007 Blue Waters Hotel – CSL Workshop on Child Porn InvBlue Waters Hotel – CSL Workshop on Child Porn Inv

07/06/200707/06/2007 Richards Bay Community Policing ForumRichards Bay Community Policing Forum

24/08/200724/08/2007 Adams Mission Sports Ground – Anti Crime CampaignAdams Mission Sports Ground – Anti Crime Campaign

07/09/200707/09/2007 Fraud and Corruption Forum – Premier’s OfficeFraud and Corruption Forum – Premier’s Office

22/10/200722/10/2007 Mpopohemi Community Hall – Imbiso (HRC)Mpopohemi Community Hall – Imbiso (HRC)

27/10/200727/10/2007 Glendale Community Hall – Imbiso (CPF)Glendale Community Hall – Imbiso (CPF)

Training at Metro Police / SAPS CollegesTraining at Metro Police / SAPS Colleges

DateDate InstitutionInstitution TopicTopic24/04/200724/04/2007 Durban Metro PoliceDurban Metro Police Mandate of ICD Mandate of ICD

Sect. 49 / DVASect. 49 / DVA

06/06/200706/06/2007 Durban Metro PoliceDurban Metro Police Mandate of ICD Mandate of ICD


26/06/200726/06/2007 Durban Metro PoliceDurban Metro Police Mandate of ICDMandate of ICD


06/09/200706/09/2007 National SAPS Training National SAPS Training CollegeCollege

Mandate of ICD to all Mandate of ICD to all commanders of commanders of SAPS CollegesSAPS Colleges

22/09/200722/09/2007 Chatsworth Training CollegeChatsworth Training College

(SAPS)(SAPS)Mandate of ICD Mandate of ICD


09/10/200709/10/2007 Ulundi Training CollegeUlundi Training College

(SAPS)(SAPS)Mandate of ICD Mandate of ICD


STRENGTHSSTRENGTHSExperienceExperienceIndependenceIndependenceOn going TrainingOn going TrainingTeam WorkTeam WorkStakeholder ManagementStakeholder ManagementAttend all Provincial Joints MeetingsAttend all Provincial Joints MeetingsAttend all PIJF MeetingsAttend all PIJF MeetingsAttend all Provincial Fraud and Corruption Attend all Provincial Fraud and Corruption Committee meetings – Premier’s OfficeCommittee meetings – Premier’s OfficeAttend all JCPS Cluster meetingsAttend all JCPS Cluster meetingsPartnership with Community Safety and Liaison in Partnership with Community Safety and Liaison in relationship to Service Delivery Complaintsrelationship to Service Delivery ComplaintsPartnership with Department of Justice (DPPs)Partnership with Department of Justice (DPPs)Relationship with SAPS and MPSRelationship with SAPS and MPS

ChallengesChallenges

Shortage of Manpower – Increase of Mandate (MPS, DVA and DSO)Shortage of Manpower – Increase of Mandate (MPS, DVA and DSO)

Large Province – Inheritance of Eastern Cape Towns without any Large Province – Inheritance of Eastern Cape Towns without any additional staffadditional staff

Too many accounting stations – lack of support from Station Too many accounting stations – lack of support from Station CommissionersCommissioners

Lack of support from SAPS Duty Officers on Call (Non-reporting of Lack of support from SAPS Duty Officers on Call (Non-reporting of crime scenes and criminal activities involving members)crime scenes and criminal activities involving members)

Lack of Disciplinary Processes of SAPS and MPS– Disciplinary steps Lack of Disciplinary Processes of SAPS and MPS– Disciplinary steps takes too long to be finalised - (Unlawful use of Police Vehicles is a takes too long to be finalised - (Unlawful use of Police Vehicles is a problem to be managed by SAPS) problem to be managed by SAPS)

Stations are not diligent when it comes to attending to prisoners / Stations are not diligent when it comes to attending to prisoners / Prisoners are in custody for long period which is a riskPrisoners are in custody for long period which is a risk

Non reporting of SAPS non-compliance with provisions of Domestic Non reporting of SAPS non-compliance with provisions of Domestic Violence ActViolence Act

No applications for exemptions (DVA) received from SAPSNo applications for exemptions (DVA) received from SAPS

SAPS accused frustrate process of criminal proceeding by changing SAPS accused frustrate process of criminal proceeding by changing legal repslegal reps

ChallengesChallenges Many court cases attended by members of ICD to protect Many court cases attended by members of ICD to protect

witnesseswitnesses

Long delays of Post Mortems, DNA reports and Blood analysisLong delays of Post Mortems, DNA reports and Blood analysis

Shortage of Funds – Special Programmes (Government Shortage of Funds – Special Programmes (Government Calender)Calender)

Reservist and members not fully trained on the Domestic Reservist and members not fully trained on the Domestic Violence Act and the Amended Section 49 Act.Violence Act and the Amended Section 49 Act.

Public Works – No new accommodation even though the Public Works – No new accommodation even though the application was made in August 2006.application was made in August 2006.

Cases of Attempted Murder / Assault GBH not opened for Cases of Attempted Murder / Assault GBH not opened for victims of Domestic Violencevictims of Domestic Violence

There is a culture in SAPS and MPS of a code of silence and There is a culture in SAPS and MPS of a code of silence and closing of ranksclosing of ranks

Investigate to arrest rather than arrest to intimidate.Investigate to arrest rather than arrest to intimidate.

Additional Manpower required to Additional Manpower required to perform optimallyperform optimally

3 Principal Investigators3 Principal Investigators 24 Senior Investigators24 Senior Investigators 3 Case Analyst3 Case Analyst 2 Administrative Support2 Administrative Support

WAY FORWARDWAY FORWARD Establishment of the satellite office in Establishment of the satellite office in

financial year 2007/2008financial year 2007/2008 Results driven projects – Criminal activities – Results driven projects – Criminal activities –

Corruption cases – Pro-active investigationCorruption cases – Pro-active investigation Continuous stakeholders interactionContinuous stakeholders interaction Continuous involvement with Community Continuous involvement with Community

Policing ForumsPolicing Forums

Continuous Audits in respect of the DVAContinuous Audits in respect of the DVA

Way Forward - BacklogsWay Forward - Backlogs

PROJECTSPROJECTS

Two investigators only concentrating on the backlogs Two investigators only concentrating on the backlogs files in the investigation component (Principal files in the investigation component (Principal Investigator will monitor the progress)Investigator will monitor the progress)

• Two case analysts to deal with only the backlog in the Two case analysts to deal with only the backlog in the Monitoring and Complaints Component (Monitor and DPH Monitoring and Complaints Component (Monitor and DPH will monitor the progress)will monitor the progress)

• Progress will be monitored on a monthly basisProgress will be monitored on a monthly basis

• Work weekends to update and close files on databaseWork weekends to update and close files on database

• Deputy Provincial Head will be addressing the Deputy Provincial Head will be addressing the problematic stations in the Provinceproblematic stations in the Province

OCTOBER 2007OCTOBER 2007

CLOSED FILESCLOSED FILES

BACKLOGBACKLOG CURRENTCURRENT TOTALTOTAL

CLASS 1CLASS 1 3131 33 3434

CLASS 2CLASS 2 22 11 33

CLASS 3CLASS 3 2121 33 2424

CLASS 4CLASS 4 3131 99 4040

TOTALTOTAL 8585 1616 101101

Recommendations by Portfolio Committee on Safety Recommendations by Portfolio Committee on Safety and Securityand Security

• Number of Post have been filled, however Number of Post have been filled, however there is still a shortage of staff to function there is still a shortage of staff to function effectivelyeffectively

• There is still no budget for Special There is still no budget for Special ProgrammesProgrammes

• Retention of existing senior employeesRetention of existing senior employees• Requirements for Case Analyst not reviewedRequirements for Case Analyst not reviewed• Lengthy vetting process – still existLengthy vetting process – still exist• Approval of use of private transport – still Approval of use of private transport – still

existexist• Amendment of policies – not rectifiedAmendment of policies – not rectified

Recommendations by Portfolio Committee on Safety Recommendations by Portfolio Committee on Safety and Securityand Security

• Policing powers – still a major problemPolicing powers – still a major problem• Training – New investigators have not been Training – New investigators have not been

trainedtrained• Anti-Corruption Command – problem still existAnti-Corruption Command – problem still exist• Domestic Violence Act – ongoing problemDomestic Violence Act – ongoing problem• Scene Notifications – minor problem in KZNScene Notifications – minor problem in KZN• Budget allocation – problem still existBudget allocation – problem still exist• Sharing of Monitoring with Secretariat – Sharing of Monitoring with Secretariat –

Problem still existProblem still exist• CAS system – still no accessCAS system – still no access

presented by : len john acting provincial head icd / kzn 09/11/2007

Documents