presented by: steven moore and angelica ochoa denver, colorado may 16, 2012
DESCRIPTION
Strategies Every Company Needs to Know: How to Keep EEOC and ICE Investigations in Check. Presented by: Steven Moore and Angelica Ochoa Denver, Colorado May 16, 2012. 05.16.12. Denver, Colorado. 1 of 47. The EEOC’s Renewed Systemic Initiative. 2 of 47. EEOC’s Systemic Initiative. - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Presented by:
Steven Moore and Angelica Ochoa
Denver, ColoradoMay 16, 2012
Strategies Every Company Needs to Know:
How to Keep EEOC and ICE Investigations in Check
05.16.12Denver, Colorado 1 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
The EEOC’s Renewed Systemic Initiative
2 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
EEOC’s Systemic Initiative
Increased Funding EEOC attorneys being trained for systemic
litigation EEOC’s goal is to proactively identify class
cases
3 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Pattern or Practice Cases
Rule 23’s requirements of numerosity, commonality, typicality, and adequacy of representation do not apply
No class certification is required Proverbial “class action monster” Litigated in two phases
4 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
EEOC’s Systemic Initiatives
Systemic Discrimination– Pattern and Practice theory
E-RACE– Combating race and color discrimination– Intersects with systemic discrimination
5 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
ADA Enforcement Actions
Maximum Medical Leave Policies Example: a workers’ compensation policy
prohibiting leave for more than one year
6 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Avoid Being a Target
Watch for early indicators of exposure
Closely scrutinize individual charges and resolve early when possible
Be proactive with policies, procedures and training– This means more than just lip service
Look at your own stats
Be careful when providing information/ documents
7 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Defending Against A Systemic Charge
Has the EEOC followed its own administrative requirements?
Has the EEOC investigated on a class basis? Did the charge specify the company’s territories or
regions at issue? Did the EEOC identify class members in
conciliation? Did the EEOC conciliate in good faith?
8 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Courts Are Striking Back
EEOC criticized for failing to provide information during conciliation
“Sue First, Ask Questions Later”
9 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
If You Find Yourself A Target In Litigation
Hire the best statistical expert possible
Continue to be proactive with policies, procedures and training
Be prepared for massive electronic discovery requests
Alert Public Relations
Explore early settlement
10 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Settlement Strategies
Pre-Complaint– Conciliation and/or EEOC Mediation Program
– Confidential
Post-Complaint– Consent Decree and EEOC press release
– Extensive equitable relief
11 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Keeping ICE Investigations in Check
12 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Why are we here?
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
'09 '10 '11 '12
ICEAudits
ICE audits increasing and affecting all sizes of companies and all industries
Record number of fines against employers, even when no unlawful workers were found
Random, tip-based and government information sharing
13 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Why are we here?
14 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Strategy #1: Know the Basics
15 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado 16 of 47
I-9 Basics
Complete for every employee hired after November 6, 1986
Provide instructions and list of acceptable documents to employee
Employee must complete Section 1 no later than the end of his first day of work
Employer must complete Section 2 within three (3) business days of employee’s first day of work
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado 17 of 47
Current Interpretation of Timeframe for Completing Section 2
Employer must fully complete Section 2 within three (3)
business days of the first day of work Long standing interpretation – “Wednesday Rule” –
employee begins work on Monday, employer must complete Section 2 by Wednesday
New interpretation – “Thursday Rule” – employee begins work on Monday, employer must complete section 2 by Thursday
- M-274 appears to indicate employer has four (4) full business days to complete Section 2
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Form I-9
Versions currently valid for use: Rev. 8/7/09Y and Rev. 2/2/09N
18 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Completing Sections 1 & 2
Section 1:– ONLY employee may complete Section 1 BUT employer is
responsible for reviewing and ensuring that it is fully and properly completed
– ALL fields must be completed EXCEPT Social Security Number• Exception: E-Verify employers
Section 2:– Employer must permit employee to select the original documents
he/she will provide to show authorization to work in the US• One document from List A or one document from List B and one
from List C• Only unexpired documents permitted
19 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Strategy #2:
Avoid Common Errors
20 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado 21 of 47
Common Errors
Procedural/Technical vs. Substantive– Common Procedural/Technical Errors
• Completion errors but at least employee’s identity and employment authorization was vetted
– Common Substantive Errors• No Form I-9 - not completed or not retained• Failure to complete I-9 within 3 days of hire• No signature or employee attestation in Section 1• No employer signature or recordation of proper documents in
Section 2• Failure to re-verify in Section 3
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado 22 of 47
Complex Issues - Documents
Are Receipts for a List A, List B or List C document acceptable?– If receipt is for a replacement of a lost, stolen or damaged
document, but only for 90 days– Receipt for an initial Employment Authorization Document (EAD) or
an extension of an expiring EAD is NOT acceptable Lawful Permanent Resident Card
– LPRs NOT required to present I-551 Permanent Resident Card (green card) for Section 2
– I-551 cards with or without expiration are List A documents that should not be re-verified
Social Security Card– If contains restrictive language, it is NOT a valid List C document
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado 23 of 47
Complex Issues – Re-verification
Re-verification of employment authorization– Must be completed no later than the date employment
authorization expires
– Use Section 3, unless:• Not available because already used or• Version of I-9 is no longer valid
– If using a new I-9 to complete re-verification:• Ensure new form is current version• Write employee’s name in Section 1• Retain new I-9 with original
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Strategy #3:
Copy I-9 Documents
24 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
To Copy or Not to Copy?
Required under Colorado law For I-9 - transition in guidance –
– Attaching copies of I-9 documents can turn substantive violations into technical/procedural violations
Recommendations– Copy front and back and retain with I-9 and attestation
– Not expected to be document experts BUT need to practice due diligence in examining to ensure that documents do not appear fraudulent on their face
25 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Strategy #4: Properly Retain & Purge
Often
26 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Retention Rule
Must retain employee’s Form I-9 for as long as the individual works for the employer
Employer must retain I-9 for either
– Three (3) years from date of hire, or
– One (1) year after the date of termination, whichever is later
27 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Purging Practice
Once employment is terminated, move I-9 into separate binder for terminated employees and calculate the length of time for which the I-9 must be retained– I-9 Retention Calculation Worksheet (M-274, p. 23)
Once retention date lapses, purge old I-9 forms If want a blanket retention policy, it should be at least 3
years from the date of termination, or longer, to ensure that required period has lapsed– Caution: ICE could penalize for old I-9s if they contain
errors
28 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Strategy #5: Avoid Discrimination in the
I-9 Process
29 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Common Issues
Over-documentation – requiring more documents than necessary
Re-verification of documents where none is required Requiring employee to present a specific document,
either initially or at re-verification Handling I-9 process inconsistently Refusal to accept a document, or hire an individual,
because a document has a future expiration date
Limiting of jobs to U.S. citizens
30 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Strategy #6: Know the Audit
Process
31 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado 32 of 47
Step One – NOI Issued
ICE issues a Notice of Inspection (NOI)– ICE required to provide employer with at least three (3)
days written notice prior to a Form I-9 inspection
Contents of a NOI:– Name of business to be inspected, date/time of
proposed inspection/audit, waiver of 3-day notice, and time period covered by inspection
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
I-9 Inspection: Step One
Employer will be requested to provide the following:
– I-9s for all current and terminated employees
– List of all current and terminated employees with hire and termination dates
– Copies of quarterly wage and hour reports and/or payroll data for all employees (current and terminated) covering the inspection period
– Quarterly tax statements (IRS Form 941)
– FEIN, TIN or SSN of employer, address, telephone numbers, copies of Articles of Incorporation (if applicable), copies of business licenses, etc.
– Copies of any and all correspondence with Social Security Administration regarding mismatched or no matched Social Security Numbers
– Whether the company is a current or previous participant in the E-Verify or Social Security Number Verification System
33 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Step Two – Inspection of Forms
ICE not required to conduct inspection at location of business; employer may be required to produced the forms at the field office
– I-9s must be made available in original paper, electronic form, paper copy of the electronic form, or microfilm/microfiche
– ICE will document receipt of I-9s from employer on Customs and Border Protection Form 6051
– Interview of Human Resources Manager/Responsible Hiring Officer
34 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Step Three – Review of I-9s
ICE will review I-9s for violations
Report of Investigation (ROI) must document the process and results of the I-9 Inspection: # of forms inspected, # and types of violations present, and percentage of I-9s found in violation
ICE may issue a Notice of Technical or Procedural Failures, aka, “Ten-day Notice” – employer has 10 days to make appropriate changes to errors on I-9s or to provide explanations of the errors
35 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Step Four – Letters/Notices Issued
Letters/notices issued by ICE:– Notice of Inspection Results (Compliance Letter) – advises
employer is in compliance; no further investigation necessary
– Notice of Suspect Documents Letter – advises employer that that an employee is unauthorized to work; advises employer of possible civil and criminal penalties
– Notice of Discrepancies Letter – advises employer ICE has been unable to determine an employee’s work eligibility
– Notice of Intent to Fine (NIF) – Contains basis of the charges against employer, the statutory provisions alleged to have been violated, and the penalty that will be imposed
36 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Issuance of NIF
ICE will issue a Final Order within 45 days of the service of the NIF if a written request for a hearing is not received – NO appeal
Employer may enter into negotiations with ICE to reach a settlement
Employer may request a hearing if no settlement is reached
Final Order issued at conclusion of case
37 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Penalties of Non-Compliance:What’s the Cost?
Types of I-9 Violations
– Technical/procedural and/or substantive errors – “paperwork” violations
• $110 to $1,100 per violation
– “Knowing” violations – constructive and actual knowledge, knowing hire, and/or continuing to employ
• $375 to $16,000 per violation
– Discrimination violations
• $375 to $16,000 per violation
38 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Additional Penalties
Fines may be increased/decreased by up to 25% depending on mitigating/aggravating factors
Criminal prosecution possible
Attorneys fees for discrimination violations
Subsequent penalties enhanced
Barred from government contracts
39 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Strategy #7: Expect an Audit – Be
Prepared
40 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Be Proactive
Conduct I-9 self-audit to correct any procedural/technical and substantive errors, if possible
Maintain separate I-9 binders for current and termed employees – do NOT keep in personnel files
Have an audit plan in place
41 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Best Practices
42 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado 43 of 47
I-9 Best Practices
Establish a system to complete forms on time and term employees who cannot produce required documents
Provide training for all employees involved in the process and ONLY allow trained employees to complete form
Set up a system of checks and balances Pre-populate company name and address fields on I-9
in Section 2 Set up a tickler system for expiring documents that
must be re-verified
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado 44 of 47
I-9 Best Practices
Copy documents and attach to I-9 form Keep the I-9 process separate from other
processes which may require documents Review forms for purging eligibility Consider electronic I-9 systems and/or E-Verify Consider use of SSNVS, and having SSN No
Match and honesty policies Ask questions
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
ICE Audit Do’s
Develop a transparent process for interacting with employees Provide all workers with a reasonable amount of time to
correct discrepancies in their records identified by ICE and treat all workers in the same manner
Inform employees from whom you seek specific information that you are seeking this information in response to an ICE audit
Communicate in writing with employees from whom you seek information, and describe the specific basis for the discrepancy and/or what information you need from them
45 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
ICE Audit Don’ts
DON’T selectively verify employment eligibility of certain employees
DON’T terminate or suspend employees without providing notice and a reasonable opportunity to present valid I-9 documents
DON’T over document or limit the range of documents allowed for purposes of the I-9
DON’T treat employees differently at any point during the audit because they look or sound foreign, or based on assumptions about whether they are authorized to work in the US
46 of 47
May 16, 2012 ▪ Denver, Colorado
Questions? Need Articles/Updates?
If you have specific questions about the information presented today, please contact us at:
Steven W. Moore (303) [email protected]
Angelica M. Ochoa (303) [email protected]
47 of 47