presented by: timothy w. reed, p.e., cpesc · mega-ditch batter chute, southbridge, ma. corrugated...

49
Building Trust. Engineering Success. Batter Chute Design Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC Project Director / CAD Services Manager Sanborn, Head & Associates, Inc. October 2, 2018

Upload: others

Post on 03-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Building Trust. Engineering Success.

Batter Chute DesignPresented by:

Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESCProject Director / CAD Services Manager

Sanborn, Head & Associates, Inc.October 2, 2018

Page 2: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Experience P.E. – NH, MA, ME CPESC - 2011 Solid waste designer for 20+ years Industrial facility drainage and landfill cell

and closure construction projects

2

Page 3: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

What is a Batter Chute?A batter chute or “drainage chute” is a steep drainage channel that passes down the face of a slope.

3

Page 4: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Natural ConditionIn nature, water finds the path of least resistance.

4

Page 5: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

EngineeredEngineered batter chutes are typically more uniform and range from concrete-lined dam spillways…

5

Page 6: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Engineered… to riprap-lined channels.

6

Page 7: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

The Power of Water

7Oroville, California dam spillway failure – March 2017

Page 8: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Landfill Final Cover System Steep slopes (3H:1V) Tall slopes (> 100 feet) Limited area Perimeter roads Detention basins Highly regulated

8

Page 9: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

9

Page 10: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Landfill Cap System

10

Page 11: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Gabion-Lined Downchute

11

Page 12: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Landfill Cap System

12

Page 13: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Landfill Cap System

13

Page 14: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Anatomy of a Batter Chute

14

CHANNEL

INLET(S)

OUTLET1X

Page 15: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Anatomy of a Batter Chute

15

1X

SUBCRITICAL FLOW

SUBCRITICAL FLOW

SUPERCRITICAL FLOW

Page 16: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

16

Froude Number and Critical Depth

Fr = v/(g hm)1/2

The Froude Number is “the inertia force on an element of fluid to the weight of the fluid element”

v = velocity

g = acceleration of gravity

hm = hydraulic mean depth

hm = A / TT = width of channel open surface

A = cross-sectional area

Page 17: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

17

Page 18: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Inlet Erosion Protection

18

1X

y1

y2TRASITION ZONE IS

POTENTIAL AREA FOR EROSION

SUBCRITICAL FLOW

SUPERCRITICAL FLOW

Page 19: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

19

Page 20: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

20

SUMP

VAULT

BASIN

DRAINAGE CHUTE

Page 21: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Channel Erosion Protection

21

1X

SUPERCRITICAL FLOW

y2

Page 22: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Manning’s Equation

22

Q = VA = ( )AR2/3S1/2

1.49nV = ( )R2/3S1/2

1.49n

Page 23: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Channel Geometry

23

TRAPEZOIDAL TRIANGULAR

RECTANGULAR PARABOLIC

Page 24: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Channel Erosion Protection Rock needs to be large and angular to stay

on slope Rock can be secured (gabion or grouted in

place) Alternative armoring system can be used

24

Page 25: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Rock-Filled Gabion Baskets

25

Page 26: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale

26MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA

Page 27: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale

27MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA

Page 28: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale

28MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA

Page 29: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Geomembrane-Lined Swale

29

Page 30: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Centralized Sediment Mgmt.

30

Page 31: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Geoweb/Geocell

31

Page 32: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Geoweb/Geocell

32

Page 33: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Articulated Concrete Block

33

ARMORFLEX BY CONTECH

Page 34: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Grout-Filled Geotextiles

34ARTICULATING BLOCK MATS BY SYNTHETEX

Page 35: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Outlet Erosion Protection

35

1X

SUBCRITICAL FLOW

SUPERCRITICAL FLOW

Page 36: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Stable Outlet Options

36

DROP-INLET HEADWALL

PLUNGE POOLENERGY

DISSIPATER

Page 37: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Outlet Erosion Protection

37

Page 38: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Basin Inlet

38

Page 39: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Location of the Hydraulic Jump

39

CASE A CASE B

CASE C

VELOCITY HIGH AND DEPTH LOW = JUMP

AWAY FROM TOE

VELOCITY AND DEPTH MATCHES =

JUMP CLOSE TO TOE (OPTIMAL)

VELOCITY HIGH AND DEPTH HIGH = JUMP

OCCURS OVER SLOPE (POTENTIAL

FOR PROBLEMS)

Page 40: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Hydraulic Above the Channel

40

ACTS LIKE A HYDROFOIL (AIRPLANE WING)

Page 41: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Case C – Resulting in Damage

41

Page 42: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Consider Below-Grade Flow

42

Page 43: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Size Recess Based on Flow

43

SIZE A RECESS TO ENSURE THAT JUMP OCCURS CLOSE TO THE TOE OF SLOPE

Z

Page 44: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Sizing Guidance

44

Page 45: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Additional Design Information

45

Catchments & Creeks

https://www.catchmentsandcreeks.com.au/index.html

Page 46: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Additional Design Information

46

Design and Construction of Urban Stormwater Management Systems, ASCE, 1992 Older document >700 pages

Page 47: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Additional Design Information

47

Page 48: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Questions?

48

Thank You!

Page 49: Presented by: Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESC · MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Corrugated HDPE-Lined Swale 28 MEGA-DITCH BATTER CHUTE, SOUTHBRIDGE, MA. Geomembrane-Lined

Building Trust. Engineering Success.

Timothy W. Reed, P.E., CPESCProject Director / CAD Services Manager

Sanborn, Head & Associates, [email protected]

www.sanbornhead.com