priority substances inventory guidance a step towards international harmonization joost van den...
TRANSCRIPT
Priority Substances Inventory Guidance
a step towards international harmonization
Joost van den Roovaart
Outline presentation
• Why emission inventories, why a Guidance document?
• Usefull items from past and present
• Steps to harmonization
• Some questions for discussion
Why emission inventories?
• We have water quality problems
• Emissions are a key factor in that problem
• If we want to solve our problems, we have to know:
• what is the contribution of the sources to the WQ problem?
• what are possible measures?
• what is the effect of the measures (and the costs)
• Focus on the first point
WFD steps
define area/watersystem
define water quality problem
inventory of sources
selection of substance
selection of sources
selection of measures,based on (cost) effectiveness
inventory possible measures
implementation of measures
WFD: analyses of emission sources
surface water
Use of emission data
0
50
100
150
200
250
1990 2007
Ntotal (kton)
Use of emission data
0
50.000
100.000
150.000
200.000
250.000
300.000
1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
kilo copper
lead
Use of emission data
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
benzo(k)fluoranthene
nickel
copper
zinc
PCB's
nitrogen
phosforus
UWWT
industry
agriculture
nature
traffic
deposition
other diffuse
WFD River Basin Management Plan RhineRelative discharges of problem substance for main sources
International catchment: Rhine
Sw itzerlandFrance
Germany
the Netherlands
zinccopper
Ntotal
Why an Guidance Document?
• It seems to be a difficult job
• A lot of substances, sources, pathways, approaches, estimation methods, differences between countries
• A lot of information gathered, project results are available, actions carried out, but:
• Not always succesfull, just rather small steps forward
• Assist the Member States
Why an Guidance Document?
• We want to compare the data: EU-wide, within River Basin
• We need transparancy
• If is is possible: harmonization
• Second reason for this action
Some usefull experiences?
• 4th NSMC
• ICBR
• EU PS documents
• Dutch PRTR
4th NSMC
• 1998-2000, HARP project: Harmonised Quantification and Reporting Systems for nutriënts and hazardous substances:
HARP-NUT and HARP-HAZ
• Documents, reporting formats, digital reporting system
• Just a few countries made use of it: too complex, too early?
• Usefull: General Overview, Source- vs Load oriëntated approach
ICBR
• 1997-2000, Inventory of (some) Priority Substances
• River Basin wide harmonised inventory, methods for estimation of diffuse sources of heavy metals and lindane
• Took some years, nice methods, good match with WQ
• Not adopted by the Member States: each MS preferred own methods
• Usefull: Source schedule, methods
EU
• 2003, Emissions, discharges and losses for priority substances in the field of water policy – source identification and proposals for measures, Haskoning
• Inventory for all PS, Main Schedule, Factsheets per substance including entry routes
• Lots of information, info about measures difficult
• Is it used?
• Usefull: inventory, main routes per substance
Dutch PRTR
• since 1974
• national emissions to air, water and soil of 350 pollutants
• yearly update of dataset (t-2/t-1)
• cooperation about 70 experts of 10 institutes
• time series (>1990)
• national and regional data
• data accessible from internet (www.prtr.nl)
• methods documented in factsheets
• one system for (inter)national reports
Emission Register
Determination of pathways
Industry
Refineries
Energysector
Traffic andTransport
Consumers
Construction
Waste disposal
Trade, services and government
Agriculture
Nature
Surface w
aters
air
agricultural and natural soils
Sewers
UWWTP
discharge to air
discharge to soil
load to sewers
discharged load
Deposition on surface waters
Run-off and leaching
Untreated sewage
Rainwater drains
Stormwater overflows
Effluents
transboundary
Upstream loads
Estimation methods
different sources, different methods combination of models and measurements depending on data and knowledge availability
Basic method: emission factor * statistic variable = discharge load
Example:- Yearly loss of 2 kg copper per ship due to use of antifouling- 5000 ships
2 * 5000 = 10.000 kg copper
Reality is more complex
Spatial distribution
• each diffuse source has a spatial distribution
• the national totals are allocated• geographical coverage: water boards or
WFD river basins.
Example:Intensity of road use by passenger cars on national and regional roads in 2004.
Factsheets
For each source a factsheet documents:
• description of source;
• estimation methods;
• data used: emission factors and activity data;
• time series of emissions (yearly update);
• spatial distribution;
• reliability in five categories.
Available on the internet and in English!
www.prtr.nl
Dutch PRTR
• 35 year of work and money, expensive
• Based on a lot of information and statistical data
• Not to copy to other MS
• Usefull: main schedule, methods, factsheets, spatial distribution
Possible steps for international harmonization
1. Exchange of information (models and data used)
2. Harmonization of definitions (pathways, substances, time and spatial scales)
3. Exchange and comparison of methods and models