probe magazine vol 13 issue 4 (1-15 dec 2014)

8/10/2019 Probe Magazine Vol 13 Issue 4 (1-15 Dec 2014)

1/41

Exclusive Excerpt

ystery ofrof. Shafiulsurder

Architects forheritage

The riseandfall of JSD

Probe Special

4 December 1-15,


2/41

Editorial

Issue: 4 I December 01 - 15, 2014 I Vol: 13 I Page: 1

Ed*&( % Ce

I+-"3a Na,"& A%"

Ed*&(A2e,!a Kab"+

E.ec+*,e Ed*&(A!&ed Ha,a'

S'eca# C&((e)'&%de%*A'0a+ Pa+/e3 Ha%"&

Se%&( C&((e)'&%de%*S!af"* Ra!&a'

S*a C&((e)'&%de%*)Md Be%a2e- H(,,a"'A+"-+a A'$a' M"-+a

C&%*(b+*&()Bad".% A%a& Ka&+.% Ha,a'

A%-af Pa+/e3 Ta"b A!&edHa+.'.+ Ra,!"d

O,e()ea) C&((e)'&%de%*)P+(f M(('",! A!&a+ Pa$",-a'

Pa+"-(,! Pa.% I'd"a

F+a'ce, B.%a-!a,"'!a%a S+" La'$aR S!+e,-a Ne)a%

Sa'd+a Kab"+ UKS!e!ab.dd"' K",,%. USA

Ce P&*&g(a'e(Bab%. C!(0d!.+2

C&,e( a%d G(a'c De)g%Ad/e'-.+e C(&&.'"ca-"(',

Ma%age(Deba,!",! Sa+$a+

Add(e))H(.,e 54B R(ad =

D!a'&('d" RA D!a$a 5649Ba'%ade,! Te%


3/41


4/41

W

"-! -!e 0(+%d ,-"%% ba--%"' -!eEb(%a (.-b+ea$ -!e e/"de'ce(f a c%ea+ %"'$ be-0ee' -!e

"'ab"%"-2 (f affec-ed c(.'-+"e, -( dea%0"-! -!e c+",", a'd -!e c(%%a),e (f).b%"c !ea%-! ,2,-e&, ", bec(&"',-+('e+ E1-+e&e )(/e+-2 "' -!eaffec-ed +e"(' e'e'de+ed b2 'e(%"be+a% )(%"c"e, f.+-!e+ c+ea-ed -!ec('d"-"(', f(+ -!e +a)"d ,)+ead (f -!ee)"de&"c T!", ", -!e c('-e1- -!a-"'f(+&, -!e c('-e'-, (f -!e 6458 G%(ba%Hea%-! Wa-c! GHW +e)(+- -!a- 0a,+e%ea,ed (' 56 N(/e&be+ 6458

GHW8 "'-e+a-e, +"(+(., a'a%2,",a%-e+'a-"/e )+()(,a%, a'd ,-(+"e, (f,-+.%e, a'd c!a'e -( )+e,e'- ac(&)e%%"' ca,e f(+ -!e "&)e+a-"/e -(0(+$ f(+ a +ad"ca% -+a',f(+&a-"(' (f -!e0a2 0e a))+(ac! ac-"(', a'd )(%"c"e,(' !ea%-! I- ", de,"'ed -( *.e,-"(')+e,e'- )(%"c"e, (' !ea%-! a'd -()+()(,e a%-e+'a-"/e, -!+(.! 'e0a'a%2,", ,a2, Sa'ee-a S!a,!"$a'-ad/",e+ -( -!e Pe'a'ba,ed -!"'$-a'$T!"+d W(+%d Ne-0(+$

W"-! c('-+"b.-"(', f+(& &(+e -!a' 0(&e',+e)+e,e'-a-"(' "' -!e"+ %eade+,!") b2

-!e 2ea+ 6464H(0e/e+ -!e )+()(+-"(' (f

0(&e', +e)+e,e'-a-"(' "'Ba'%ade,!, )(%"-"ca% )a+-"e, a-)+e,e'- ", fa+ f+(& ,a-",fac-(+2 O-!e+-!a' a !a'df.% (f )a+-"e, &(,- (f -!e+e",-e+ed )(%"-"ca% )a+-"e, a+e be+ef- (f0(&e', %eade+,!") 0!a-,(e/e+ S(&e)a+-"e, d('- e/e' !a/e &e'-"(' (f0(&e', %eade+,!") "' -!e"+c(',-"-.-"(', E1)e+-, fee% -!a- -!e)a+-"e, ,!(.%d -.+' -!e"+ a--e'-"('-(0a+d, e&)(0e+"' 0(&e' 0"-!"'

-!e )a+-"e,A0a&" Lea.e, )+e,"d".& a'd

ce'-+a% c(.'c"% (f ,ec+e-a+"e, !a/e a-(-a% (f 86 &e&be+, Of -!e& ,"1 a+e0(&e' -!a- ", 58> (f -!e %eade+,!")T!a- &ea', -!e2 0"%% !a/e -( a- %ea,-d(.b%e -!", 0"-!"' ,"1 2ea+,

BNP, ,-a'd"' c(&&"--ee !a, 5 (f -!e -(-a% T!e20"%% !a/e -( -+")%e -!", "' ,"1 2ea+,

Ja-"2a Pa+-2 !a, 85 )+e,"d".&

&e&be+, T!e2 !a/e ('%2 -!+ee0(&e' "' -!e )+e,"d".& -!a- ", ;> (f

-!e -(-a% I' -!e 'e1- ,"1 2ea+, -!e2 0"%%

!a/e -( .) -!", b2 89>Mea'0!"%e -!e %eade+,!") (f 57

+e",-e+ed I,%a&"c )(%"-"ca% )a+-"e, ",be+ef- (f 0(&e' %eade+, T!e"+c(',-"-.-"(', &a$e '( &e'-"(' (f0(&e' %eade+,!")

T!e ,-a-e (f 0(&e', %eade+,!") "'-!e (-!e+ )a+-"e, ", '(- ,a-",fac-(+2e"-!e+

I' -!", +ea+d De&(c+ac2I'-e+'a-"('a% !a, c(&e f(+0a+d 0"-!a' "'"-"a-"/e -( -a$e 0(&e' a!ead "'Ba'%ade,!, )(%"-"c, A &ed"a

ca&)a"' Na+"+ J(2 S!(ba+ J(2W(&e', /"c-(+2 ", e/e+2('e,/"c-(+2 0a, %a.'c!ed (' 5=N(/e&be+ a- a !(-e% "' -!e ca)"-a% c"-2US A&ba,,ad(+ -( Ba'%ade,! Da' WM(3e'a a--e'ded -!e )+(+a&&eA%,( )+e,e'- 0e+e Ad/(ca-e A). U$"%e'e+a% ,ec+e-a+2 (f Ba'%ade,! J.b(Ma!"%a Lea.e Se%"&a Ra!&a' /"cec!a"+)e+,(' (f BNP P+(fe,,(+ MMa,.da Ra,!"d C!(0d!.+2 Ja-"2aPa+-2 )+e,"d".& &e&be+ a'd ,(c"a%,c"e'-",- A2e,!a K!a'a& )+e,"de'-(f Ba'%ade,! Ma!"%a Pa+",!ad Ja'"'a

Ja+.3e%,$" USAID &",,"(' d"+ec-(+Ka-"e C+(a$e De&(c+ac2I'-e+'a-"('a%, De).-2 C!"ef (f Pa+-2

Da' M(3e'a ,a"d W(&e',)a+-"c")a-"(' "' )(%"-"c, ", "&)(+-a'- "',-+e'-!e'"' de&(c+ac2 He ,a"d-!a- 0(&e' !ad c(&e f(+0a+d "' US)(%"-"c,

Ja-"2a Pa+-2, )+e,"d".& &e&be+Ma,.da Ra,!"d C!(0d!.+2 ca%%ed.)(' M(3e'a -( (+a'",e a #("'-,e&"'a+ be-0ee' Ba'%ade,! a'd -!eUS a- -!e "'"-"a-"/e (f De&(c+ac2

I'-e+'a-"('a% S!e ,a"d -!", 0(.%dfac"%"-a-e -!e 0(&e' )(%"-"c"a', (f -!e-0( c(.'-+"e, -( ,!a+e -!e"+e1)e+"e'ce,

P+(fe,,(+ M Ma,.da C!(0d!.+2-e%%, PROBE I- ", ((d -!a-Ba'%ade,!, P+"&e M"'",-e+ Leade+(f -!e O))(,"-"(' a'd S)ea$e+ a+e a%%0(&e' B.- 0e ,!(.%d '(- bec(&)%ace'- ab(.- -!", beca.,e 94> (fBa'%ade,!, )().%a-"(' ", 0(&e'W(&e' a+e '(- e&)(0e+ed "' -!a-)+()(+-"(' W(&e' a+e ,-"%% 'e%ec-ed"' ,(c"e-2 T!e2 a+e ('%2 ca%%ed 0!e'

+e*."+ed -!e"+ 0(+$ ", '(- "/e' d.e+ec('"-"(' T!e+e ", 'eed f(+ 0(&e',-+a"'"' "' (+de+ -( &ee- -!e RPO+e*."+e&e'- (f !a/"' 77> 0(&e' "'%eade+,!") T!a- 0"%% e',.+e 0(&e'0"%% '(- &e+e%2 be "'f%.e'ced b2 &e'

b.- 0"%% e,-ab%",! -!e&,e%/e, "' -!e"+(0' +"!-

Ma,.da Ra,!"d C!(0d!.+2 ,a2,De&(c+ac2 I'-e+'a-"('a%, "'"-"a-"/e ",c(&&e'dab%e H(0e/e+ 0e ,!(.%d'-

#.,- %(($ -(0a+d, -!e& O.+ )(%"-"ca%)a+-"e, ,!(.%d a%% !a/e +e,ea+c! ce%%,T!", 0"%% &a$e "- ea,"e+ -( e/a%.a-e -!e0(&e' 0"-!"' -!e )a+-2

L3+ ;%< 3 +3 *36 ;3) 3A P(&be (e'&(*

G6 H;/ %;*/ 6;

"36( &%+ E&3%


5/41

-( !ea%-! ca+e -( "',.+a'ce c(/e+aeT!e ca,e ,-.d"e, )+e,e'-ed "' GHW8*.e,-"(' -!e ,.cce,, (f -!e UHC &(de%,!(0 -!e -!+ea- )(,ed b2 UHC%ed+ef(+&, -( e1",-"' !ea%-! ,2,-e&, a'd,!(0 -!e )(-e'-"a% (f &(de%, ba,ed ('-a1f.'ded ,2,-e& 0"-! .'"/e+,a%e'-"-%e&e'-, -( c(&)+e!e',"/e ,e+/"ce,a'd )a+-"c")a-(+2 &ec!a'",&,

GHW8 a'a%2,e, -!e c+",", "' -!eW(+%d Hea%-! O+a'"3a-"(' WHO ac+",", 0!"c! ca&e -( a !ead "' 644= a, "-0a, b(++(0"' aa"',- f.-.+e +e/e'.e,

-( &a"'-a"' "-, ()e+a-"(', T!ef.'da&e'-a% ca.,e (f WHO, c+",", ",-!e f+ee3e (' c(+e c('-+"b.-"(', a'd -!ec(',e*.e'- +e%"a'ce (' c('-+"b.-"(',-"ed ac-"/"-"e, 0!"c! f.'de+, 0a'- -()+"(+"-"3e H(0e/e+ -!e c+",", "' %(ba%!ea%-! -e+&, ", -!e ab,(%.-e "'ade*.ac2

(f WHO, b.de- e*."/a%e'- -( -!ec(,- (f +.''"' a b" !(,)"-a% "' E.+()e(+ -!e US C(&)a+ed -( -!e c(,- (f a'e)"de&"c %"$e SARS (+ -!e Eb(%a c+",", "-", -+"/"a% T!e c.++e'- +ef(+&, "' -!eWHO a+e "' a d"+ec-"(' -!a- -!+ea-e',-( ,-+e'-!e' d('(+, "'f%.e'ce a'dca' ('%2 a&)%"f2 -!e c(+)(+a-e"'f%.e'ce (' WHO, ae'da WHO ", a-+",$ (f %(,"' "-, +e%e/a'ce ,a2, Da/"dLee P+(fe,,(+ (f P.b%"c Hea%-! a- LaT+(be U'"/e+,"-2 A.,-+a%"a

A ,"'"f"ca'- fea-.+e (f -!", ed"-"(' (f

-!e GHW ", a ,)ec"a% f(c., (' La-"'A&e+"ca I- ca)-.+e, -!e "&)ac-, a'd"'-e+%"'$ae, be-0ee' -!e 0a/e (f)(%"-"ca% a'd ,(c"a% c!a'e !ea%-!ac-"/",& a'd a%-e+'a-"/e "'"-"a-"/e, "'-!e +e"(' N(- ('%2 a+e -!e2 "',)"+"',-(+"e, -!e2 a+e a +e,e+/("+ (f %ea+'"'f(+ -!e G%(ba% S(.-!

GHW8 0a, c((+d"'a-ed b2 -!ePe()%e, Hea%-! M(/e&e'- PHMA,(c"ac"(' La-"'(a&e+"ca'a deMed"c"'a S(c"a% ALAMES Hea%-!Ac-"(' I'-e+'a-"('a% Med"c(

I'-e+'a-"('a% T!"+d W(+%d Ne-0(+$TWN a'd Medac- n

Newsbeat


T!e +ea- -a,-e (fZ"'e+ B.+e+ (+ H(-W"', a- KFC #.,- (-

-a,-"e+ a'd 2(.+ ((d -"&e0"-! +ea- P"33a, #.,- (-

be--e+ 0"-! a V",a ca+dWe%% c+ed"- (e, -( V",af(+ e1-e'd"' ,.c!"'-e+e,-"' (ffe+, a'dd",c(.'-, -( ca+d !(%de+,N(0 2(. !a/e -!e )+"/"%ee

(f e'#(2"' 59> ,a/"', ('V",a (ffe+ c(&b( &ea%, a-P"33a H.- a'd KFC 0"-!2(.+ V",a Deb"- (+ C+ed"-ca+d A'(-!e+ +ea,(' -(d"'e a- P"33a H.- (+ KFCa'd a ((d 0a2 -( $ee)2(. 0a+& -!", 0"'-e+

VISA c+ed"- a'd deb"-ca+d .,e+, ca' a/a"% (f -!e,e+ea- (ffe+, (' -!e"+ ca+d,

a'd ca' e- "'-e+e,-"'d",c(.'-, (' c(&b( &ea% a-(.+ P"33a H.- @ KFC We-!a'$ VISA f(+ &a$"' -!",)(,,"b%e f(+ -!e 7+d -"&e,a"d A$$. C!(0d!.+2

Ma'a"' D"+ec-(+ a'dCEO (f T+a',c(& F((d,L"&"-ed -!e f+a'c!",ee (fP"33a H.- a'd KFC "'Ba'%ade,! T!e (ffe+ 0a,%a.'c!ed a- P"33a H.-G.%,!a' (' 69-! N(/e&be+6458 "' -!e )+e,e'ce (f+e'(0'ed ce%eb+"-"e, T().a'd M.'&.'

U'de+ -!", ,a/"', (ffe+P"33a H.- !a, b.'d%ed -!eV",a (ffe+ c(&b( &ea% 0"-!

R",(--( Pa,-a a'd P"33a&ea%, f(+ 6 a'd 8 )e+,(',a'd )+"ced a, %e,, a, BDT54=4 f(+ P"33a f(+ 6 A'2Med".& Pa' P"33a f+(&Fa/(+"-e, %"'e BBQ c!"c$e'0"', a'd Le&(' "ced -eaPe),";.)M de0M"+"'daO' -!e (-!e+ !a'd KFC

b.'d%ed V",a (ffe+ c(&b(&ea% f(+ 5 6 a'd 8 )e+,(',

a'd )+"ce ", a, %e,, a, BDT7;9 f(+ Mea% f(+ 5 5 PcF"e+2 G+"%% (+ HC S'ac$e+M"1ed R"ce Re.%a+C(%e,%a0 Re.%a+ Pe),"T!e V",a (ffe+ 0"%% be

a/a"%ab%e a- a%% 57 KFC a'd< P"33a H.- (.-%e-, "'Ba'%ade,! -"%% Ma+c! 686459

T+a',c(& F((d, L"&"-edTFL ,-a+-ed "-, #(.+'e2 "'6447 a, a f+a'c!",ee (fP"33a H.- -!e f"+,-I'-e+'a-"('a% C!a"'Re,-a.+a'- "' Ba'%ade,!a'd 0e'- -( ,"' -!ec('-+ac- -( bec(&e -!ef+a'c!",ee (f Ke'-.c$2

F+"ed C!"c$e' KFC "' -!e2ea+ 644: B(-! P"33a H.-a'd KFC a+e ,.b,"d"a+"e, (f-!e 0(+%d, %a+e,-+e,-a.+a'- c(&)a'2 Y.&Re,-a.+a'-, I'-e+'a-"('a%I' a ,)a' (f e%e/e' 2ea+,TFL !a, ()e'ed < P"33aH.- 57 KFC a'd 8 P"33aH.- De%"/e+2 (.-%e-, ,( fa+-!+(.!(.- -!e c(.'-+2 n

PI$$A HT AND KFC DEALFOR !ISA CARDS

%;/ *6;


6/41

I(% )%6 R 15,7506% 3 &9< 814 %6)6T!e +.%"' e,-ab%",!&e'- "' We,-Be'a% ,.,)ec-, -!a- -!e B.+d0a' b%a,-0a, fa%%(.- (f a c(',)"+ac2 -( d",%(de-!e T+"'a&((% C('+e,, (/e+'&e'-!eaded b2 -!e"+ f"+eb+a'd %eade+Ma&a-a Ba'e+#ee T!e TMC %eade+,-!"'$ -!a- -!e ,-ae&a'aed b%a,-,0e+e )a+- (f -!e BJP, de/"(., &a,-e+)%a' a c('ce+-ed ,-+a-e2 .,ed e/e'd.+"' Na+e'd+a M(d", )(%% ca&)a"'"' We,- Be'a% Acc.,"' -!e M(d"

(/e+'&e'- (f ,-ae&a'a"' -!eB.+d0a' b%a,- 0"-! -!e (b#ec-"/e (f

-+"e+"' +"(-, "' -!e ,-a-e Ma&a-aBa'e+#ee ,a"d -!e ce'-+e 0!"c! ", "'c!a+e (f b(+de+ ,ec.+"-2 !ad %e- "'"%%ea% "&&"+a'-, "'-( Be'a% 0"-!e1)%(,"/e, a'd !e%)ed -!e& f"'d a!(.,e a'd &a$e b(&b, 0"-! -!e(b#ec-"/e (f -+"e+"' +"(-, "' -!e ,-a-e

Ta+e-"' -!e P+"&e M"'",-e+Na+e'd+a M(d" 0"-!(.- 'a&"' !"&a'd -!e BJP Ma&a-a ,a"d -!e2 f"+,- ,a"d"%%ea% "&&"+a'-, ,!(.%d be -!+(0'(.- N(0 -!e B.+d0a' "'c"de'- ,ee&,a %"--%e +e%a-ed W!e' d"d -!e &a' +e'-

-!e !(.,e a- K!a+aa+! "' B.+d0a'I' J.%2 af-e+ -!e M(d" (/e+'&e'-ca&e -( )(0e+ ,!e ,a"d Ma&a-a a%,(a))+e!e'd -!a- -!e ce'-+a% (/e+'&e'-&a2 !a/e .,ed -!e RAW -( )%a'- -!e

b(&b "' B.+d0a'O' -!e (-!e+ !a'd T+"'a&((%

C('+e,, 'a-"('a% ,)($e,&a' a'dRa#2a Sab!a &e&be+ De+e$ OB+"e'c(.'-e+ed -!e a%%ea-"(' (f -!e -e++(+",-&(d.%e, &.,!+((&"' "' -!e ,-a-e&ade b2 -!e NSA a'd d.bbed D(/a% a,a $'(0' RSS ,2&)a-!",e+ He a%,(

a%%eed -!a- -!e de/"(., )%a', a+e a%%c('ce"/ed d+af-ed a'd a))+(/ed a-RSS HQ B.- -!e I'd"a' (/e+'&e'-,!a+)%2 +eac-ed -( -!e ,-a-e&e'- &ade

b2 Ma&a-a Se'"(+ BJP %eade+ a'dF"'a'ce M"'",-e+ A+.' Ja"-%2 ,a"d "'+e-a%"a-"(' -!a- -!e We,- Be'a% P(%"ce(+ -!e (-!e+ "'-e%%"e'ce ae'c"e, !a/e'( ,.b,-a'-"/e e/"de'ce -( e,-ab%",!-!a- -!e b%a,- 0a, ,-ae&a'aed If-!e+e ", '( ,.c! e/"de'ce 0!2 !a, didiMa&a-a c!(,e' -( a%%ee -!a- -!e b%a,-0a, ,-ae&a'aed S.c! a%%ea-"(',

c%ea+%2 !e%) -!e ac-.a% c.%)+"-, T!", ",'e"-!e+ +e,)(',"b%e '(+ 'a-"('a%",-"c n

Reports

Issue: 2 I November 01 - 15, 2014 I Vol: 13 I Page: 11

He'ce RAW ", '(- a',0e+ab%e -( -!e Pa+%"a&e'- (fI'd"a (' a'2 ",,.e 0!"c! $ee), "- (.- (f +eac! (f -!e R"!--( I'f(+&a-"(' Ac-

T!e Dee%ce i%*e##ge%ce Age%c/ DIA ", a'(+a'",a-"(' +e,)(',"b%e f(+ )+(/"d"' a'd c((+d"'a-"'"'-e%%"e'ce f(+ -!e I'd"a' a+&ed f(+ce, Af-e+ -!e"'-e%%"e'ce %a),e, -!a- (cc.++ed d.+"' -!e Ka+"% Wa+ -!e

Defe'ce I'-e%%"e'ce Ae'c2 0a, c+ea-ed a'd beca&e()e+a-"('a% "' Ma+c! 6446

I- ", -!e '(da% ae'c2 f(+ a%% defe'ce +e%a-ed "'-e%%"e'cea'd c((+d"'a-e, -!e D"+ec-(+a-e (f M"%"-a+2 I'-e%%"e'ceD"+ec-(+a-e (f A"+ I'-e%%"e'ce a'd -!e D"+ec-(+a-e (f Na/a%I'-e%%"e'ce M.c! (f -!e ae'c2, ()e+a-"(', a+e c%a,,"f"edDIA !a, c('-+(% (f I'd"a' A+&2, )+"3ed -ec!'"ca%"'-e%%"e'ce a,,e-, -!e D"+ec-(+a-e (f S"'a%, I'-e%%"e'cea'd -!e Defe'ce I&ae P+(ce,,"' a'd A'a%2,", Ce'-+eDIPAC W!"%e -!e S"'a%, D"+ec-(+a-e ", +e,)(',"b%e f(+ac*."+"' a'd dec+2)-"' e'e&2 c(&&.'"ca-"(', -!eDIPAC c('-+(%, I'd"a, ,a-e%%"-eba,ed "&ae ac*.","-"('

ca)ab"%"-"e, T!e DIA a%,( c('-+(%, -!e Defe'ce I'f(+&a-"('Wa+fa+e Ae'c2 DIWA 0!"c! !a'd%e, a%% e%e&e'-, (f -!e"'f(+&a-"(' 0a+fa+e +e)e+-("+e "'c%.d"' ),2c!(%("ca%()e+a-"(', c2be+0a+ e%ec-+('"c "'-e+ce)-, a'd -!e&('"-(+"' (f ,(.'d 0a/e,

T!e na*&%a# Sec+(*/ C&+%c# 0a, f(+&ed "' 5===

&e+"' -!e J("'- I'-e%%"e'ce C(&&"--ee JIC 0"-! "- I-

f.'c-"(', .'de+ -!e Cab"'e- Sec+e-a+"a- a'd ", +e,)(',"b%e

f(+ c((+d"'a-"' a'd a'a%2,"' "'-e%%"e'ce ac-"/"-"e,

be-0ee' RAW -!e I'-e%%"e'ce B.+ea.IB a'd -!e Defe'ce

I'-e%%"e'ce Ae'c2 DIA T!e na*&%a# Sec+(*/ Ad,)e(

NSA ", -!e c!"ef e1ec.-"/e (f -!e Na-"('a% Sec.+"-2 C(.'c"%

NSC T!e )(,- 0a, c+ea-ed "' 5==< b2 -!e A B Ba#)a2ee

(/e+'&e'- T!e NSA +ece"/e, a%% "'-e%%"e'ce +e)(+-, f+(&

RAW IB a'd DIA a'd c((+d"'a-e, -!e& -( )+e,e'- bef(+e

-!e P+"&e M"'",-e+ T!e NSA ", -!e )+"&a+2 ad/",e+ -( -!e

I'd"a' P+"&e &"'",-e+ (' 'a-"('a% a'd "'-e+'a-"('a% ,ec.+"-2 n

/


13/41

P+(fe,,(+ S!af".% I,%a& 0a,)().%a+%2 $'(0' b2 !",,-.de'-, a, L"%(' S"+ He

!ad c!(,e' -( %"/e ab(!e&"a' %"fe 0!"c! !ad

&ade !", &.+de+ a &2,-e+2 He !ad&a++"ed -!+ee -"&e, !", f"+,- 0"fe !adc(&&"--ed ,."c"de af-e+ !", &.+de+ a"+% 0a, f(.'d %(c$ed .) "' !", !(.,eRAB c('-e'd, a 0(&a' 0(+$"' "' -!e.'"/e+,"-2 0a, +e,)(',"b%e f(+ -!",&.+de+ a'd -!e )(%"ce ,a2 &"%"-a'-,0e+e "'/(%/ed W"-! RAB a'd -!e)(%"ce "/"' c('f%"c-"' /e+,"(', -!e&2,-e+2 dee)e', f.+-!e+ W!"c!/e+,"(' ", -!e -+.-! W!( $"%%ed S!af".%

a'd 0!2P+(fe,,(+ S!af".% 0a, !ac$ed -(dea-! b2 a,,a"%a'-, (' !", 0a2 !(&ef+(& Ra#,!a!" U'"/e+,"-2

A' ('-!e,)(- "'/e,-"a-"(' ca++"ed(.- b2 PROBE 2"e%d, a %(- (f .'$'(0'fac-, ab(.- P+(fe,,(+ S!af".% O.-,"de(f !", -eac!"' ca+ee+ -!e ,%a"')+(fe,,(+ 0(.%d %"/e a d",,(%.-e %"fe He0a, a ,(ca%%ed La%(' e'-!.,"a,- He0(.%d (f-e' !(,- &.,"c ,e,,"(', a-!(&e Teac!e+, ,-.de'-, a'd a %(- (f)e()%e f+(& a%% 0a%$, (f %"fe 0(.%d

c(&e -( -!e,e )+(+a&&e, He 0(.%da&b%e b(-! a- -!e .'"/e+,"-2 c%.b a'd

a- !(&e He 0(.%d (f-e' %.+e "',-.de'-, f+(& !", de)a+-&e'- 0"-! ",ca+ef+ee %"fe,-2%e He 0a, a%,( $'(0' -(

!a/e a +ea- 0ea$'e,, f(+ 0(&e'

WhO iS ThiS SOnAMOni>Af-e+ S!af".% 0a, &.+de+ed -!ede-ec-"/e )(%"ce +ec(/e+ed a "+% 'a&edS('a&('" f+(& !", !(.,e S!e 0a,%(c$ed .) 0"-!"' -!e !(.,e Af-e+ -!e

)(%"ce b+($e -!e %(c$ a'd e'-e+ed -!e2f(.'d -!e "+% a'd "&&ed"a-e%2 -(($!e+ a0a2 a'd $e)- !e+ "' !"d"'

Va+"(., ,(.+ce, ,a2 -!", ,-.de'-S('a&('" !ad c(&)%e-ed !e+ Ma,-e+,e1a&, "' S(c"(%(2 f+(& Ra#,!a!"U'"/e+,"-2 S!e !ad c(&e f+(& !e+/"%%ae "' G(b"'daa'# (' -!e e/e'"'(f 58 N(/e&be+ -( -!e )+(fe,,(+ -(

c(',.%- !"& ab(.- -!e /"/a e1a&, S!e,)e'- -!e '"!- -!e+e T!e 'e1- da2S!af".% %(c$ed -!e !(.,e f+(& -!e(.-,"de a'd 0e'- -( -!e ca&)., He0a, -!e' $"%%ed

S('a&('" !ad )!('ed !e+ &(-!e+a'd -(%d !e+ -!a- ,!e 0a, %(c$ed .) "'-!e -eac!e+, !(.,e He+ &(-!e+ -0(,",-e+, a'd .'c%e +.,!ed -( Ra#,!a!" -(f"'d (.- 0!a- !ad !a))e'ed B2 -!e'S('a&('" !ad bee' -a$e' "'-( )(%"cec.,-(d2

I' -!e &ea'-"&e -!e ca&)., !ea-ed

.) 0"-! de&a'd, f(+ -!e $"%%e+, -( bea++e,-ed T!e )(%"ce )(%"-"c"a', a'd(-!e+, c%a"&ed -!a- I,%a&"c &"%"-a'-,0e+e be!"'d -!e &.+de+ S(&e )("'-ed-(0a+d, S!"b"+ a'd Ja&aa- Ma'2

Ja&aa- a'd S!"b"+ ,.,)ec-, 0e+e e/e'a++e,-ed B.- &2,-e+"(.,%2 -!e )(%"cea'd e/e' -!e &ed"a -( a +ea- e1-e'-+e&a"'ed ,"%e'- ab(.- S('a&('"

S('a&('" ", )+e,e'-%2 a- -!e Ra#,!a!")(%"ce /"c-"& ,.))(+- ce'-+e He+&(-!e+ a'd -0( ,",-e+, 0!( ca&e "',ea+c! (f !e+ !a/e a%,( bee' $e)- -!e+e

Q.e,-"(', a+e '(0 be"' a,$ed a, -(0!2 -!e )(%"ce a+e $ee)"' S('a&('""' !"d"' Ha, ,!e bee' *.e,-"('edab(.- -!e &.+de+ I, ,!e "'/(%/ed "'-!e &.+de+ W!a- ,(+- (f +e%a-"(',!")d"d ,!e !a/e 0"-! -!e )+(fe,,(+ -!a- !e%(c$ed !e+ .) If ,!e ", "''(ce'- -!e'0!2 ",'- ,!e be"' +e%ea,ed T!e+e a+e'( c+"&"'a% c!a+e, aa"',- S('a&('",!e ", '(- a c!"%d a'd ,!e !a, .a+d"a',S( 0!2 ", ,!e be"' $e)- "' c.,-(d2

Ma,!+.&a M(,-a+" ,.)e+/",(+ (f -!e/"c-"& ,.))(+- ce'-+e a- S!a!

Ma$!d((& )(%"ce ,-a-"(' ca&)., "'Ra#,!a!" c"-2 -e%%, PROBE T!e "+% ",

Eclusive


T) 63*)36'


14/41

'(- a%('e He &(-!e+ a'd -0( ,",-e+,!a/e a%,( bee' $e)- a- -!e /"c-"&,.))(+- ce'-+e

T!e )(%"ce a+e '(- %e--"' -!e "+% (+!e+ fa&"%2 -a%$ -( a'2('e T!e,.)e+/",(+ c(.%d'- ,a2 0!2 -!e2 a+e

be"' $e)- !e+e (+ e/e' "f "- 0a,

)e+&",,"b%e f(+ a'2('e -( be de-a"'ed"' ,.c! a &a''e+

I' -!e &ea'-"&e S('a&('", f(+&e+%(/e+ Ja!a'"+ A%a& a f(+&e+ ,-.de'-(f -!e S(c"(%(2 De)a+-&e'- a- -!e.'"/e+,"-2 0a, a++e,-ed (' 5=N(/e&be+ f+(& S"+a#a'# b.- -!e )(%"ced"d '(- e- a'2 "'f(+&a-"(' ab(.- -!e&.+de+ f+(& !"&

T!e ).b%"c ", +(0"' ,.,)"c"(.,ab(.- -!e )(%"ce, &2,-e+"(., de-e'-"('(f S('a&('" D"d ,!e !a/e a'2"'f(+&a-"(' ab(.- -!e )+(fe,,(+ (+

ab(.- -!e &.+de+ ,(&e-!"' -!a-0(.%d be &ade ).b%"c "f ,!e 0a, f+eed

iMMOrAl ACTiviTiES Of ThEPhD ASPirAnTS AnD ThEirSuPErviSOrP+(fe,,(+ Na#&.% H.* (f -!e S(c"(%(2De)a+-&e'- 0a, a fa' (f S!af".%,&.,"c ,e,,"(', a'd a%,( !", 'e"!b(.+Na#&.% 0(.%d &a$e a%% a++a'e&e'-,f(+ -!e 0ee$%2 &.,"c ,e,,"(', a- -!eS!af"*.%, !(.,e T!e2 %"/ed "' ad#ace'-

b."%d"',

T!e &.+de+ed )+(fe,,(+ 0a, -!e P!D,.)e+/",(+ (f Na#&.%, 0"fe S.&('aA$!-e+ a'd (f -0( a,,",-a'- )+(fe,,(+,(f -!e ,a&e de)a+-&e'- Ab. R.,,e%R")(' a'd A&"'.% I,%a& A&"'.%,/"/a 0a, c(&)%e-ed "' Se)-e&be+S!af".% c('d.c-ed S.&('a a'd R")(',/"/a (' 56 N(/e&be+ I'/e,-"a-"(',+e/ea% -!a- Na#&.% !", 0"fe S.&('aR")(' a'd A&"'.% !ad a++a'ed a&.,"c )+(+a&&e (' 55 N(/e&be+ -!eda2 bef(+e -!e /"/a

P+(fe,,(+ Sa&"-a Ma''a a'd !e+

!.,ba'd !ad c(&e f+(& K(%$a-a,Ka%2a'" U'"/e+,"-2 a, e1-e+'a% -eac!e+,f(+ -!e /"/a a%(' 0"-! P+(fe,,(+Ka&a% A!&ed C!(0d!.+2 (f S!a!#a%a%U'"/e+,"-2, De)a+-&e'- (f S(c"(%(2Q.e,-"(', 0e+e +a",ed ab(.- !(0e-!"ca% "- 0a, f(+ -!e ,.)e+/",(+, a'd-!e PHD a,)"+a'-, -( #("' -!e &.,"c,e,,"(' #.,- a e/e'"' bef(+e -!e /"/aPHD a,)"+a'- S.&('a A$!-e+,!.,ba'd )+(fe,,(+ Na#&.% a++a'edf(+ a%% e'-e+-a"'&e'-, "'c%.d"' f((d

N(- ('%2 -!a- af-e+ S!af".% 0a,

&.+de+ed !", c%(,e,- f(%%(0e+ Na#&.%a'd 0"fe S.&('a %ef- -!e"+ !(.,e (' 5 -( 54> (f -!e )e()%e T!e a+c!"-ec-,!a/e '(-!"' -( (ffe+ %(0"'c(&e a'd&"d"'c(&e )e()%e T!", ", a' e%"-",& (f-!e )+(fe,,"('

Kab"+ !a, e&e+ed (.- f+(& -!",,)!e+e (f e%"-",& a'd ('e ,-+a"!- -('a-.+e a'd -!e !a+d0(+$"' c(&&('

)e()%e T!", /e'-.+e (f !", 0a, ,)a+$ed(ff b2 D+ If-e$!a+ )+(fe,,(+ (fa+c!"-ec-.+e a- -!e Ba'%ade,!U'"/e+,"-2 (f E'"'ee+"' a'dTec!'(%(2 BUET I' 6445 D+If-e$!a+ 0a, 0(+$"' (' a d.+ab%e!(.,"' c(',-+.c-"(' &(de% f(+ %(0"'c(&e )e()%e "' -!e f%((d)+('e a+ea,(f Ma'"$a'# Kab"+ #("'ed !"& Kab"+,a2, W!e' I 0e'- -!e+e I +ea%",ed -!a-0e +ea%%2 !ad '(-!"' -( "/e -!e +.+a%)e()%e a'2-!"' ab(.- c(',-+.c-"'!(.,e, We !a/e &.c! -( %ea+' f+(&-!e& (' -!e c('-+a+2

Kab"+ fe%- -!e+e 0e+e -0( a,)ec-, -!a-c(.%d be 0(+$ed (' O'e 0a, -("'c+ea,e -!e d.+ab"%"-2 -!+(.!-ec!'(%(2 -+a',fe+ (f &a-e+"a%, .,edf(+ !(.,e c(',-+.c-"(' -!e+e ,.c! a,

ba&b(( ca'e ,-+a0 e-c T!e,e&a-e+"a%, !a+d%2 %a,- &(+e -!a' a 2ea+

beca.,e (f +a"', f%((d, a'd :4> -( ;4>(f -!e a+ea, be"' "'.'da-ed "' 0a-e+f(+ %(' ,-+e-c!e, (f -"&e T!a- ", 0!2-!e f(.'da-"(', (f -!e !(.,e, a%,(e+(de e/e+2 2ea+

T!e (-!e+ a,)ec- -( dea% 0"-! ,a2,Kab"+ ", -!e .,e (f %"!- 0"'d )%a'-,a'd -+ee, -!e f+ee "f-, (f 'a-.+eS"&)%2 d.e -( )((+ )%a''"' 'a-.+a%%"!- a'd a"+ ca''(- e'-e+ -!e !(.,e,

I' -a%$"' ab(.- -!", a,)ec- (f %"!-a'd a"+ 0"-! -!e )e()%e (f -!e /"%%ae,Kab"+ d",c(/e+ed a 0!(%e 'e0 0(+%dT!e2 e1)%a"'ed -( Kab"+ -!a- -!e !(.,e0a, '(- a%% -!a- "&)(+-a'- f(+ da2-"&eac-"/"-"e, O.-e+ ,)ace, 0e+e &(,-%2.,ed f(+ ,(c"a% f.'c-"(', c!a--"'&ee-"', a'd e'-e+-a"'"' I -!e'

+ea%",ed -!a- I ,!(.%d %ea+' -!e ,c"e'ce(f .,"' (.-d((+ ,)ace, B.- '(

.'"/e+,"-2 "' Ba'%ade,! (ffe+, a'2c(.+,e (' -!", T!e .'"/e+,"-"e,

ba,"ca%%2 -eac! ab(.- "'d((+, a'd"'d((+ &a-e+"a%,

He -!e' 0e'- -( S!eff"e%d U'"/e+,"-2-( ,-.d2 %a'd,ca)e e'"'ee+"' T!e

-()"c (f !", -!e,", -!e+e 0a,Ide'-"f"ca-"(' (f +(ad,"de a'd!(&e,-ead )%a'- c(&&.'"-"e, "' -!ef%((d )%a"', (f Ba'%ade,! f(+ -!e"+)(-e'-"a% .,e, b(-! "' .+ba' a'd +.+a%%a'd,ca)e

He +e-.+'ed !(&e "' 6449 a'd #("'edBRAC U'"/e+,"-2 a, a %ec-.+e+ a'd '(0", a' a,,",-a'- )+(fe,,(+ -!e+e H",&",,"(' ", -( a))%2 a+c!"-ec-.+e f(+ -!ec(.'-+2, de/e%()&e'- He be%"e/e,-!", +e*."+ed )a+-"c")a-"(' (f -!e&a+"'a%",ed )e()%e (f -!e c(.'-+2 He

,a2, W!e-!e+ "- ", "' Ha"-" (+ "'Ba'%ade,! I ca''(- -a$e ,(%e c+ed"- f(+

-!e 0(+$ I 0(+$ed 0"-! -!e )e()%e (f-!e c(&&.'"-2 E/e+2('e de,e+/e,c+ed"-

Kab"+ )("'-, (.- -!e 0ea$'e,,e, "'-!e c(',-+.c-"(' )+(ce,,e, a'd&e-!(d, (f -!e c%.,-e+ /"%%ae "dea%

/"%%ae a'd ,"&"%a+ )+(#ec-, (f -!e(/e+'&e'- f(+ -!e %a'd%e,, a'd!(&e%e,, )((+ He ,a2, -!a- ,"&)%2&a$"' a fe0 !(.,e, a'd )%ac"')e()%e -!e+e ", c('ce)-.a%%2 0+('S.c! )+(#ec-, ca' 'e/e+ be ,.cce,,f.%%2,.,-a"'ab%e .'%e,, -!e c(&&.'"-2 ","'/(%/ed

T!e (/e+'&e'- "'c"de'-a%%2 !a,-a$e' .) a W(+%d Ba'$f.'ded )+(#ec--( c(',-+.c- ;944 %(0 c(,- !(.,e, 0"-!c(&&.'"-2 )a+-"c")a-"(' "' 69 ,%.&, (ff"/e d",-+"c- -(0', "' -!e c(.'-+2 See

+e)(+- (' L(0 C(,- H(.,"' f(+ %(0"'c(&e +(.), n

Probe Special


P%3% F H%%

T!e b."%d"', a+e +e)%e-e 0"-! "'-+"ca-e de,"', "' b+"c$ 0+(.!- "+(' 0((d ('-!e c(+'"ce, -!e 0a%%, a'd -!e /e+a'da!, T!e b."%d"', -!e&,e%/e, a+e "c(', (fa+c!"-ec-.+a% ae,-!e-"c, B.- d.e -( -!e 'e%ec- (f -!e c"-2 de/e%()&e'- a.-!(+"-2Ra#.$ -!e "++e,)(',"b"%"-2 (f -!e a+c!e(%("ca% de)a+-&e'- a'd -!e 0!"&, (f -!e

b."%d"' (0'e+, -!e,e ,-+.c-.+e, a+e ,%(0"' be"' de,-+(2ed T!e /(%.'-ee+,(f -!e U+ba' S-.d2 G+(.) USG 0(+$ -"+e%e,,%2 -( )+(-ec- -!e,e b."%d"',

T!e &(&e'- a !a&&e+ ", +a",ed -( de&(%",! a'2 (f -!e,e b."%d"', -!e USG/(%.'-ee+, +a,) eac! (-!e+, !a'd, -( f(+& a !.&a' c!a"' "' )+(-e,- T!e2 ,e--!e ,(c"a% 'e-0(+$, ab.33 0"-! -!e,e )+(-e,-, T!e2 +.,! f+(& )(%"ce ,-a-"(', -(Ra#.$ a'd (-!e+ (/e+'&e'- (ff"ce, T!e2 !a/e ('e ,%(a' (' -!e"+ %"), Sa/eO%d D!a$a T!e2 a%,( ac- a, ."de, (+ c(&)a'"(', (' -!e !e+"-ae 0a%$

Pa(%a F Ha''a 0"fe (f -!e f(+&e+ E.+()ea' C(&&",,"(' A&ba,,ad(+ "'Ba'%ade,! W"%%"a& Ha''a f"+,- #("'ed ('e (f -!e,e !e+"-ae 0a%$, (f USG "'6457 S!e e'#(2ed -!e 0a%$ ,( &.c! -!a- ,!e a++a'ed a -!+eeda2 0(+$,!() f(+-!e ."de, a'd /(%.'-ee+, 0!( c('d.c-ed -!e 0a%$ T!e )a+-"c")a'-, (f -!e0(+$,!() 0e+e Fa+3a'a K!a'a& f"'a% 2ea+ Ma,-e+, ,-.de'- (f E'%",! a- Kab"Na3+.% U'"/e+,"-2 !e+ c%a,,&a-e B"+a# B!a,!$a+ Na-! M(!a&&ed Ya,"' A%"

S.#"- Se' ,-.de'- (f acc(.'-"' a- Jaa''a-! U'"/e+,"-2 S(.+a/ Sa!a S!")%.Da, ,-.de'- (f &a'ae&e'- a- S!a!eed S.!+a0a+d2 C(%%ee a'd D")a'$a+H(0%ada+ (f -!e ,a&e c(%%ee T!e2 a+e '(0 &.c! ea,"e+ 0"-! c('d.c-"' -!e!e+"-ae 0a%$ T!e2 ,a2 -!a- (-!e+ -!a' #.,- de,c+"b"' -!e !",-(+2 (f -!e a+ea 0e!a/e %ea+'- -( b+"' !",-(+2 a%"/e "' (.+ de,c+")-"(', n


32/41

I- ", -!e &('-! (f Dece&be+ I &.,- +eca%% a'd I &.,-"'/"-e &2 +eade+, -( #("' &e "' &e'-a%%2 +e#("c"' -!e/"c-(+2 -!a- 0e ac!"e/ed (' 5: Dece&be+ 5=;5 T!e,-(+2 (f -!e f"!-e+, ca' !a+d%2 be -(%d "' ('%2 a c(%.&'(+ "' ('%2 a b(($ B.- a- %ea,- 0e &.,- )a2 (.+ !(&ae

-( -!(,e 0!( ,ac+"f"ced -!e"+ -(da2 f(+ (.+ -(&(++(0 I &2,e%fc(.%d !a/e bee' "' -!e -ea& (f -!e &a+-2+, (' -!e 0a2 -(!ea/e' A%&"!-2 A%%a! 0"%%"' I !a/e bee' %ef- be!"'d b2-!(,e )a-+"(-, -( 0a%$ (' '(-,()%ea,a'- +(.'d (f"'de)e'de'- Ba'%ade,! S(&e )a-+"(-, %ef- f(+ !ea/e' ,(&e+e&a"'ed Pa-+"(-",& ", %"$e a )%a'- 0!(,e +((-, ,-+e-c!

d(0' "'-( +ace a'd )%ace ,.bc(',c"(.,'e,, a )%a'- 0!(,ebe,- '.-+"e'-, a+e b%((d a'd -ea+, a )%a'- 0!"c! d"e, d(0' "')eace a'd f%(0e+, &(,- b+"!-%2 "' 0a+ Pa-+"(-",& d(e, '(-ca%c.%a-e d(e, '(- )+(f"-ee+ d(e, '(- ,-() -( +ea,(' "' a'a-&(,)!e+e (f da'e+ -!e ,a) be"', -( ,-"+ "- %"/e, "- -a$e,)(,,e,,"(' (f (.+ ,(.%-!", ", 0!a- Ge'e+a% S"+ Ia'Ha&"%-(' 0+(-e "' 5=65 W!a- )a-+"(-, d( ", '(- d"ff"c.%- -("&a"'e W"-!(.- b%"'$"' -!e e2e a )a-+"(- %a2, d(0' !", %"fef(+ -!e c(.'-+2 Le- ., +ead fe0 %"'e, f+(& a fa&(., )(e&

We a+e -a%$"' (f -!e Ba--%e (f Ba%ac%a/a 0!"c! -(($ )%ace(' 69 Oc-(be+ 5


33/41

0a, +ad.a%%2 d+a0' -( bec(&"' "'-e+e,-ed "' )(%"-"c, (fBa'%ade,! I- ", "' 644: a'd 644; -!a- Ib+a!"& 0a, dee)%2"',)"+ed -( #("' )(%"-"c, a, a' ac-"/e &e&be+ O' 8 Dece&be+

644; -!e+e 0a, a c('/e'-"(' (f 5644 )(%"-"ca% ac-"/",-, 0!( a--!e e'd (f -!e da2 dec%a+ed a 'e0 )(%"-"ca% )a+-2 T!e )a+-20a, ca%%ed Ba'%ade,! Ka%%2a' Pa+-2 T!e Ba'%a 0(+dKa%%2a' %"-e+a%%2 &ea', 0e%fa+e T!e &(--( (f -!e )a+-2dec%a+ed a'd ).b%"c"3ed ,"'ce da2 ('e ", ?$#i'ic& f#% cha"ge@T!e &(,- 'a-.+a% *.e,-"(' -aed -( -!", &(--( !a, bee'c!a'e (f 0!a- c!a'e f(+ 0!(& a'd c!a'e b2 0!(& I-c(.%d be +e)!+a,ed 0!a- -( c!a'e 0!e' -( c!a'e f(+0!(& -( c!a'e a'd 0!( 0"%% c!a'e Bef(+e -!e )a+-2 0a,dec%a+ed -!", /e+2 fa&(., &aa3"'e PROBE !ad -a$e' a'"'-e+/"e0 (f +e-"+ed Ma#(+ Ge'e+a% Ib+a!"& -!e )+(,)ec-"/ef(.'de+ (f -!e 'e0 )a+-2 T!e "'-e+/"e0 0a, ).b%",!ed a, -!ec(/e+ ,-(+2 f(+ PROBE, ",,.e (f 676= N(/e&be+ 644; I

+eca%% -!e fa&(., ,e'-e'ce (f &"'e *.(-ed "' -!e c(/e+ )aeI ,!a%% be &"dd%e(f-!e+(ad be-0ee' %ef- a'd +"!- )(%"-"c,,ec.%a+",& a'd +e%""(' I- !a, bee' d"ff"c.%- -( +e&a"' "' -!e&"dd%e f(+ a )a+- "- !a, bee' ea,2 f(+ -!e +e&a"'"' )a+- Le-&e e1)%a"'

Ba'%ade,! )(%"-"c, !a, -+a/e%ed a &ea'de+"' a'd-(+-.(., +(ad ,"'ce 5=;6 I- ", Ba'%ade,! A0a&" Lea.e0!"c! &a,-e+&"'ded a'd a/e %eade+,!") "' -!e Ba'%ade,!0a+ (f %"be+a-"(' "' 5=;5 B.- "' -!e /e+2 f"+,- 2ea+ (f"'de)e'de'- Ba'%ade,! Ba'%ade,! A0a&" Lea.e facedc!a%%e'e, O' 75 Oc-(be+ 5=;6 -!e JSD 0a, b(+' F(+ -!e 'e1-7 2ea+, JSD &ade )(%"-"c, d"ff"c.%- f(+ AL Be-0ee' Ja'.a+25=;6 a'd Ja'.a+2 5=;9 -!e ,.)+e&e )(%"-"ca% %eade+

Ba'aba'd!. S!e"$!M.#"b.+ Ra!&a' c!a'ed!a-, f+(& P+e,"de'- (fBa'%ade,! -( P+"&eM"'",-e+ (f Ba'%ade,!a'd aa"' -( P+e,"de'- (fBa'%ade,! I' Ja'.a+25=;9 a%% )(%"-"ca% )a+-"e,"'c%.d"' A0a&" Lea.e0e+e e"-!e+ e%"&"'a-ed (+ab,(+bed "'-( -!e 'e0%2c+ea-ed ('%2 )(%"-"ca% )a+-2ca%%ed Ba$,!a% T!e' 59

A..,- 5=;9 ,a0Ba'aba'd!. be"' $"%%ed

0!"%e 7 N(/e&be+ 5=;9 ,a0 -!e $"%%e+, be"' +e&(/ed A'd; N(/e&be+ 5=;9 0"-'e,,ed .')+ecede'-ed ,(%"da+"-2

be-0ee' -!e ,(%d"e+, a'd )e()%e (f D!a$a -( b+"'"' )+(

)e()%e %eade+, a- -!e !e%& (f ,-a-e affa"+,Ve-e+a' (f -!e %"be+a-"(' 0a+ Ma#(+ Ge'e+a% Z"a.+ Ra!&a'

B"+ U--(& beca&e -!e d+"/"' f(+ce (f -!e (/e+'&e'- a'd-!e c(.'-+2 W"-!"' 2ea+, &.%-")a+-2 de&(c+ac2 0a, bac$He f(.'ded a )(%"-"ca% )a+-2 'a&ed Ba'%ade,! Na-"('a%",-Pa+-2 BNP 0"-! &a,,"/e )().%a+ ,.))(+- Z"a.+ Ra!&a'0a, e%ec-ed P+e,"de'- (f Ba'%ade,! N('e-!e%e,, )(%"-"ca%d",a,-e+ ,-+.c$ Ba'%ade,! aa"' O' 74 Ma2 5= M6 G


34/41


35/41

S( &a'2 "'c"de'-, a'd e/e'-, (fBa'%ade,!, !",-(+2 +e&a"'.'+e/ea%ed a'd .').b%",!edA%% -(( (f-e' -!(,e 0!( )e'!",-(+2 a+e ())(+-.'",-, (+

,.b,e+/"e'- -( -!e )(0e+, -!a- be S(!",-(+2 ", +ed.ced -( d",-(+-"(' (f -!e

fac-, T!e 'e0 e'e+a-"(' ", c('f.,edH(0e/e+ M(!".dd"' A!&ad, b(($ ('-!e +",e a'd fa%% (f JSD Ja,!(de+ U--!a'P(-(' O,-!"+ S!(&(2e+ Ra#'"-" ", a'e1ce)-"(' P+(-!(&a P+($a,!(').b%",!ed -!", b(($ "' Oc-(be+ -!", 2ea+

JSD !ad c+ea-ed a f.+(+ "' )(%"-"c, bac$"' -!e da2 T!", b(($ "/e, a /"/"dde,c+")-"(' (f -!(,e e/e'-f.% da2, I-,)ea$, (f -!e )(%"-"ca% .'+e,- af-e+"'de)e'de'ce -!e 5=;9 $"%%"' c(.),a'd c(.'-e+c(.), -!e b"+-! (f JSDJSD, )+(+e,,"(' a'd d","%%.,"('&e'-

M(!".dd"' A!&ad !a, e1)(,ed -!",c!a)-e+ (f !",-(+2 0a+-, a'd a%%f#&-%g a(e e.ce('*) (&$ )g%ca%*'a(*) & *e b&&";

BACKGrOunDC('f%"c- 0a, a))a+e'- "' -!e 5=:7 c(.'c"%,e,,"(' (f C!!a-+a Lea.e I- 0a, &(+e(+ %e,, ce+-a"' -!a- KM Oba"d.+ Ra!&a'0(.%d be '(&"'a-ed a, P+e,"de'- S!a!M(a33e& 0a, "' fa/(.+ (f Se+a#.% A%a&K!a' "' -!e )(,- (f Ge'e+a% Sec+e-a+2B.- S!e"$! M('" 0a, ,.))(+-"'

Fe+d(., A!&ed Q.a+a",!" S!e"$! M('"0a, S!e"$! M.#"b, 'e)!e0 !", ,",-e+,,(' He 0a, a !a+d0(+$"' ,-.de'-%eade+ '( d(.b- b.- !e !ad -!a- e1-+a%e/e+ae a, be"' a &e&be+ (f -!e M.#"bfa&"%2 Q.+a",!" !ad &a'2 ,.))(+-e+, "'-!e ce'-+a% c(&&"--ee b.- Se+a#.% A%a&K!a' 0a, /e+2 )().%a+ a&(' -!ec(.'c"%%(+, F"'a%%2 "- 0a, Se+a#.% A%a&K!a' 0!( 0a, e%ec-ed Ge'e+a%Sec+e-a+2 T!e c('f%"c- be-0ee' S!e"$!M('" a'd Se+a#.% A%a& K!a' 0a, %a-e+&a'"fe,- "' a ,!a+) )(%a+",a-"(' 0"-!"'

C!!a-+a Lea.e a'd A0a&" Lea.e0!"c! 0(.%d !a/e fa++eac!"'c(''(-a-"(',


36/41

-!e&,e%/e, b2 -!e,e 'a&e, "' &a'2)%ace, M('" 0a, Ma'(# Se+a# 0a, Sa+(#Ra33a$ 0a, Ra#. a'd T(fa"% 0a, Ta)a'T!e f(.+ 3('a% c(&&a'de+, (f BLFM.#"b Ba!"'" 0e+e "/e' -!e +a'$ a'd)+(-(c(% (f L- Ge'e+a% T!e -+a"'ee,0e+e ba,"ca%%2 ,e%ec-ed f+(& a&('

C!!a-+a Lea.e &e&be+, I- ", '(-(ff"c"a%%2 $'(0' e1ac-%2 !(0 &a'2+ece"/ed -!e -+a"'"' Uba' e,-"&a-ed "-a- 54 -!(.,a'd T!e ac-.a% '.&be+ 0a,;444 Uba' 0a, "/e' a b.de- (f ;:&"%%"(' +.)ee, f(+ -!e f((d ,-a2 a'd(-!e+ e1)e',e, (f -!e -+a"'ee, a- -!e ba,eca&) T!e f.'d, 0e+e )a"d "'"',-a%%&e'-,


37/41

!a/e -!e *.a%"-"e, -( be 'a-"('a% %eade+,A'(-!e+ ,e'"(+ %eade+ (f -!e )a+-2K!a'd$a+ M.,!-a*.e 0a, /e+2 ca%&

a'd "'-e%%"e'- He 0a, (' c%(,e -e+&,0"-! M.#"b H(0e/e+ S!e"$! M.#"bd"d'- !a/e -!e c('f"de'ce -( "'/(%/e!"& "' &a'2 ac-"/"-"e, a'd -a,$, (f -!e)a+-2

T!(.! Ta#.dd"' 0a, "' c('f%"c- 0"-!M.#"b Ba!"'" 0!"%e +.''"' -!eM.#"b'aa+ (/e+'&e'- !", ac-.a%c('f%"c- 0a, 0"-! S!e"$! M('" S!e"$!M('" c(',"de+ed Ta#.dd"' -( be ac(&&.'",- ,)2 Af-e+ M.#"b +e-.+'ed -(-!e c(.'-+2 (' 54 Ja'.a+2 S!e"$! M('"bea' )(",('"' !", &"'d aa"',-

Ta#.dd"' Ta#.dd"' 0a, a+"e/ed b.-!e 'e/e+ ()e'%2 ,)($e aa"',- M.#"b

Acc(+d"' -( A0a&" Lea.e,c(',-"-.-"(' "f ('e ", "' a (/e+'&e'-)(,"-"(' ('e ca''(- be -!e !ead (f -!e)a+-2 T!a- ", 0!2 Ta#.dd"' 0a,d+())ed f+(& -!e )(,- (f )a+-2 Ge'e+a%Sec+e-a+2 S!e"$! M.#"b !(0e/e+ d"d'-+e%"'*.",! !", )(,"-"(' a, )a+-2P+e,"de'- De,)"-e Se+a#.% A%a& K!a',+e*.e,- !e d"d '(- &a$e Abd.+ Ra33a$Ge'e+a% Sec+e-a+2 M('" !"&,e%f 0a,eae+ -( -a$e !", )(,"-"(' H(0e/e+

&a'2 %eade+, a'd ac-"/",-, (f -!e )a+-2d",%"$ed !"&


38/41

b%a&e (f -!", -(( S!e"$! Ka&a% 0(.%dd( a'd ,a2 a %(- (f +a,! -!"', 0!"c!0e+e a' e&ba++a,,&e'- f(+ S!e"$!M.#"b O' 7 J.'e 5=;8 Sa+ba!a+a Pa+-2ca%%ed f(+ a ,-+"$e f(+ -0( c(',ec.-"/eda2, S!e"$! Ka&a% -(($ -!",)e+,('a%%2 O' -!e '"!- (f 6 J.'e !e

/e'-.+ed (.- 0"-! !", a,,(c"a-e, "' a&"c+(b., -( ca-c! Sa+ba!a+a ac-"/",-,T!e2 0e+e a+&ed T!e )(%"ce 0e+e,.,)"c"(., 0!e' -!e2 ,a0 -!e &"c+(b.,,)eed"' a%(' ,( %a-e a- '"!- T!e)(%"ce ()e'ed f"+e (' -!e &"c+(b.,Ka&a% 0a, ,e+"(.,%2 0(.'ded "' -!ef"+"'

A- 55 "' -!e &(+'"' -!e )(%"ce IGAbd.+ Ra!"& 0e'- -( S!e"$! M.#"b,+e,"de'ce acc(&)a'"ed 0"-! -!e NSIc!"ef Me,ba!.dd"' He a)(%(",ed ('be!a%f (f -!e )(%"ce a'd e1)+e,,ed !",

+e+e- S!e"$! M.#"b -(%d Ra!"& W!2a+e 2(. ,a2"' ,(++2 E/e' "f !e d"ed I0(.%d !a/e '( +e+e- W!( a,$ed !"& -(( (.- a- '"!- -( ca-c! &",c+ea'-, I!a/e'- e/e' ('e -( !(,)"-a% -( ,ee !"&


39/41

I,-"%% +e&e&be+ &2 %a,- &ee-"'0"-! %a-e Qa3" H.,,a"' A!&ad-!e &(,- e'e+e-"c A&"+ (f

Ja&aa-eI,%a&" &('-!, bef(+e!", dea-! "' 0!"c! !e e1)%a"'ed

0!2 Ja&aa- fa"%ed a, a -!"+d a%-e+'a-"/e-( PPP a'd PML N

Pa$",-a' Te!+ee$eI',aaf PTI.'de+ -!e c!a+",&a-"c %eade+,!") (fI&+a' K!a' !a, )e+!a), f"%%ed -!",/ac..& S( ", a'2 ,)ace a/a"%ab%e f(+ JI(+ 0"%% "- c('-"'.e -( ()e+a-e -!+(.!a%%"a'ce a'd c(a%"-"(' )(%"-"c,

Pe+!a), 0e 0e+e -(( d",c")%"'eda'd -(( +""d "' (.+ )(%"-"c, a'd c(.%d'(- ()e' (.+ d((+ f(+ (-!e+, -( #("' -!e)a+-2 %a-e Qa3" H.,,a"' A!&ad,a"dI- ", -"&e -( e1)a'd -!e )a+-2 a'd0e &.,- .'de+,-a'd -!a- -!(,e 0!( a+e'(- "' Ja&aa- a+e a%,( ((d M.,%"&,!e added

O' N(/e&be+ 65 a- M"'a+ePa$",-a' JI 0"%% be &a$"' a'(-!e+

a--e&)- -( "/e a' a%-e+'a-"/e )+(+a&-( -!e )e()%e "' a b"d -( a"' &(+ee%ec-(+a% ,.))(+- "' -!e 'e1- e'e+a%e%ec-"(', Ca' Ja&aa- %ed b2 "-,2(.'e,- A&"+ S"+a#.% Ha* d( "-

I' -!e )(,-5=;= I+a'"a' +e/(%.-"('f(%%(0ed b2 de/e%()&e'-, "'Af!a'",-a' -!e +ad"ca%",a-"(' a%,( !ad

"-, "&)ac- (' -!e )(%"-"c, "' Pa$",-a'Re%""(., e1-+e&",& !a, "'c+ea,ed 0"-!-!e f(+&a-"(' (f d(3e', (f b" a'd,&a%% +e%""(., +(.), be,"de a'.&be+ (f &"%"-a'- (+a'",a-"(',

T!., Ja&aa-, -a,$ !a, bec(&e &(+ed"ff"c.%- -( c!((,e be-0ee' )+(

de&(c+ac2 a'd a'-"de&(c+ac2+e%""(., fac-"(', Qa3" H.,,a"'A!&ad -!e %('e,- ,e+/"' A&"+ (f

Ja&aa- af-e+ "-, f(.'de+ Ma.%a'aM.!d((d" -(($ ,(&e "'"-"a-"/e, b.-faced ,-+(' +e,",-a'ce f+(& -!e )a+-2,(%d .a+d A, a +e,.%- !e ('ce +e,"'eda, )a+-2 !ead b.- -!e ce'-+a% ,!((+a+e#ec-ed "- a'd !e c('-"'.ed

P(,- =55 de/e%()&e'-, "'Af!a'",-a' )a+-"c.%a+%2 -!e US%edNATO a--ac$ f.+-!e+ e,ca%a-ede1-+e&",- )(%"-"c, "' -!e +e"(' Ja&aa-

a'd (-!e+ +e%""(., )a+-"e, e1)%("-ed-!e a'-"US ,e'-"&e'-, beca.,e (f -!e,"%e'ce (f -!e ,(ca%%ed %"be+a% a'd,ec.%a+ )a+-"e, PPP !ad aba'd('ed "-,a'-"US ,-a'ce "' 5=


40/41

0"%% "-, )+(+a&&e be d"ffe+e'- f+(&PTI -( a--+ac- -!e &"dd%e c%a,,

JI 0"%% be "/"' -!e c('ce)- (fI,%a&" Pa$",-a' W!a- ", 'e0 "' -!",,%(a' O'e !a, -( 0a"- a'd ,ee 0!a-)+(+a& "- 0"%% "/e -( -!e )e()%eT(da2 Pa$",-a', &a#(+ c!a%%e'e, a+ee1-+e&",& c(++.)-"(' )(/e+-2.'e&)%(2&e'- ed.ca-"(' !ea%-! a'd"'eff"c"e'- #.,-"ce ,2,-e&

JI c%a"&, -( be aa"',- -!e ,-a-.,*.( b.- ,(&e c+"-"c, "' (-!e+ +e%""(.,)a+-"e, a'd +(.), 0!( d('- be%"e/e"' de&(c+ac2 be%"e/e "- ", a ,-a-.,*.( )a+-2 JI a'd JUI F a+e -!e -0(&(,- )+(&"'e'- +e%""(., )a+-"e,0!"c! be%"e/e "' b+"'"' I,%a&"N"3a& -!+(.! Pa+%"a&e'-a+2,2,-e& b.- -!", "dea ", ())(,ed b2&a'2 (-!e+ ,-+(' +e%""(., +(.),"'c%.d"' Ja&aa- .d Da0a JUD

JUD 0!"c! e&e+ed a, a /e+2)(0e+f.% +(.) )(,-=55 a'd ", $'(0'

f(+ "-, ,(c"a% 0(+$ a'd f(+ "-, ,-a'ce ('Ka,!&"+ a'd ", a%,( !(%d"' "-,c('/e'-"(' a- -!e ,a&e /e'.e ('Dece&be+ 78 c(&)%e-e%2 +e#ec-, -!e"dea (f b+"'"' I,%a&"c +e/(%.-"('-!+(.! e%ec-"(', I- !ad e/e')+e/e'-ed "-, &e&be+, f+(& ca,-"'-!e"+ /(-e, "' -!e %a,- e'e+a% e%ec-"(',de,)"-e +e*.e,- f+(& )a+-"e, %"$e JI a'd

JUI FT!., ('e (f -!e b"e,- c!a%%e'e,

bef(+e JI 0(.%d be '(- f+(& -!e %"be+a%a'd ,ec.%a+ )a+-"e, %"$e PPP PML ANP(+ MQM b.- f+(& )a+-"e, %"$e JUDJI

JUI a'd JUP (f-e' c%a"& c+ed"- f(+

"'-+(d.c"' I,%a&"c )+(/","(', "' -!e5=;7 C(',-"-.-"(' b.- -!e fac- +e&a"',-!a- -!e2 !a+d%2 !ad a'2 &a#(++e)+e,e'-a-"(' "' Pa+%"a&e'- e1ce)- "'6446 F(+ "',-a'ce JUI "' -!e ;4,f(+&ed c(a%"-"(' (/e+'&e'- 0"-!,ec.%a+ Na-"('a% A0a&" Pa+-2 a'd JIc('-e,-ed e%ec-"(', f+(& -!e )%a-f(+&,(f PNA IJI a'd COP "' 5=;; 5=


41/41

T!e c%"&ac-"c &(&e'- "' B.'(Ha',! W"%d G((,eba,ed(' -!e b(($ b2 Sa&a+e,!Ma#.&da+", a )e+,('a%e1)e+"e'ce I- (cc.+, a- -!e

)+ec",e -"&e 0!e' 2(.+ "de'-"f"ca-"('0"-! -!e )+(-a('",- ", ,( c(&)%e-e -!a-2(. ca''(- de-ac! 2(.+,e%f f+(& !",,e',e (f .--e+ da&'a-"(' I- c(&e,0!e' 2(. fee% !", de,)e+a-"(' -( +e-+ea-f+(& -!e 0+(' -.+', !e !a, -a$e' "'%"fe b.- +ea%",e -!a- "-, -(( %a-e I-a++"/e, 0!e' !e a,$, "' be0"%de+&e'-H(0 d"d -!", !a))e' -( &e

A&a% De/ d(e,'- a,$ -!a- "' ,(&a'2 0(+d, T!e ,.cce,, (f A'"+.dd!aR(2 C!(0d!.+2, ,-(+2-e%%"' %"e, "'!", ab"%"-2 -( c('/e2 .',)($e'e&(-"(',

W!e' a' (%d f+"e'd b.&), "'-( !"&a'd &a$e, !"& a #(b (ffe+ a- a' e1)(+-

"&)(+- f"+& a' .'de+)a"d A&a% a,ec.+"-2 .a+d a- a ,0a'$2 &a%% "'Ca%c.--a f"'d, "- d"ff"c.%- -( dec%"'e a,!e, +e,)(',"b%e f(+ !", 0"d(0ed&(-!e+ .'e&)%(2ed b+(-!e+ a'd,",-e+"'%a0 He c.+,(+"%2 "f ,"'ce+e%2a,$, !", 'e0 e&)%(2e+, 0!(& !e,.,)ec-, -( be .'de+0(+%d ()e+a-(+,N( !a+& 0"%% c(&e -( &e f(+ d("'-!", 0(+$ 0"%% "-

T!a- *.e,-"(' f(+e,!ad(0, -!e!a+& -!a- .'f(%d, -!+(.! a +ac2 )%(-+e)%e-e 0"-! c!a,e, d",a))ea+a'ce,caba+e- da'ce, &af"a -!+ea-, ,!((-(.-,a'd -+2,-, 0"-! -e++(+",-, Se- "' -!e'a++(0 b2%a'e, c('e,-ed !e--(, a'd,-.ff2 %"*.(+ de', ac+(,, %(ca-"(', "'Ba'%ade,! T!a"%a'd a'd I'd"a -!ef"%& ca)-.+e, -!e .'+e%e'-"'())+e,,"/e'e,, (f A&a%, %"fe "' c+"&ea'd -!e "+('2 -!a- !", e,ca)e +(.-e ", !",

b"e,- -+a)T!(.! "- $"c$, (ff 0"-! a

,.,)e',ef.% ,!(- (f A&a% a'd !",c(&)a'"(' R"#.%a Ta'.,!+ee -+2"'

T!e ,a&e ca' be ,a"d ab(.- De/,ac-"' He 'eed, -"&e -( 0a+& .) Hede%"/e+, !", be,- )e+f(+&a'ce "' ,ce'e,0!"c! de)"c- A&a% !"--"' +(c$b(--(&%"$e 0!e' !e b+ea$, d(0' a- -!e 'e0,(f !", "+%f+"e'd S+ab('-", ("' "'-(c(&a (+ c(%%a),e, a- M.&ba",Ma-.'a +a"%0a2 ,-a-"(' af-e+ be"'c!a,ed b2 ((', B.- "'-e+&"--e'-%2 !e%ac$, e1)+e,,"(' a'd e&(-"(' "',"-.a-"(', de&a'd"' )a,,"(' a'dd+a&a M((' M((' ", de%"!-f.% a, -!e,0ee--a%$"' &af"a Mada& a'dA'"'d2( ", Be'a%" c"'e&a, &(,-de/"%",! /"%%a"' T!e )e+f(+&a'ce,0!"c! ,-a'd (.- &(,- a+e -!(,e (fS(!a Se' a, A&a%, 'a"'&.--e+"'.'de+-!eb+ea-! &(-!e+a'd S.d")-a C!a$+ab(+-2 !", e%de+

b+(-!e+, 0"fe 0!( c(($, c%ea', a'dc+"b, a%% da2T!e "'d"/"d.a% c('-+"b.-"(' (f -!e

f"%&, -ec!'"ca% -ea& &.,- be& e ' - " ( ' e d c " ' e & a - ( + a ) ! e +Ha+e'd+a S"'! c+ea-e, )(e-"cd+ea&%"$e "&ae, a'd A+!2a$a&a%M"-+a, ed"-"' "/e, "- a ,%"c$ fa,- )aceS!2a&a% Se'.)-a, ,c+ee')%a2 ",,e',"-"/e a'd S!a'-a'. M("-+a,'(,-a%"c &.,"c ", ,e- -( A'"'d2(

Film

s0!..(,&: D=, "

probe magazine vol 13 issue 4 (1-15 dec 2014)

Documents