proceedings of the on marine mammal protected...
TRANSCRIPT
PROCEEDINGS OF THE SECOND INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON MARINE MAMMAL PROTECTED AREAS
ICMMPA 2: Endangered Spaces, Endangered SpeciesNovember 7–11, 2011 Fort-de-France, Martinique Editor: Erich Hoyt
EDITORErich Hoyt
CO-HOSTSAgence des aires marines protégées • French Marine Protected Areas Agency
National Marine Fisheries Service Office of International Affairs NOAA
PREMIERE SPONSORAustralian Government Department of Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities
SPONSORS AT THE BENEFACTOR LEVEL• AgoaSanctuary(SanctuaireAgoapourlesMammifèresMarinsauxAntilles)• CaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme(CEP)• ConseilGénéraldelaMartinique(France)• ConventiononBiologicalDiversity(CBD)• DEALMartinique(France)• GlobalOceanBiodiversityInitiative(GOBI)• InternationalFundforAnimalWelfare(IFAW)• InternationalUnionforConservationofNature(IUCN)• MarineMammalCommission(MMC)• MinisteriodeMedioAmbienteyMedioRuralyMarinodeEspaña• NationalMarineSanctuaries(NMS,NOAA)• TheOceanFoundation• RégionMartinique(France)• SpeciallyProtectedAreasandWildlife–RegionalActivityCenter(SPAW-RAC)(orCAR-SPAWCaraïbe)• UnitedNationsEnvironmentProgramme(UNEP)• WhaleandDolphinConservationSociety(WDCS)
ADDITIONAL SUPPORTwasprovidedbyAcadémiedelaMartinique;BachelorÉcolesdeGestionetdeCommerce(EGC);ComitéMartiniquaisduTourisme;EastCaribbeanCoalitionforEnvironmentalAwareness(ECCEA);FranceStationNautique/Fort-de-France;MartiniqueVidéoSub;OfficedeTourismedeFort-de-France;ParcnaturelregionaldelaMartinique;MartiniqueSocietyfortheStudy,ProtectionandDevelopmentofNature(Sepanmar);Seve;UniversitédesAntillesetdelaGuyane;VilledeFort-de-France;andFort-Saint-Louis(FrenchNavy).
ACKNOWLEDGMENTSTheICMMPA2ConferenceCo-hostsandtheSteeringCommitteewouldliketogivetheirdeepappreciationtotheconferencewelcomeandkeynotespeakers,thepanelandworkshopconveners,andallthesponsorslocalandinternationallistedabove.SpecialthanksfromtheSteeringCommitteeandtheproceedingseditorgotoJaclynTaylor,rapporteurfortheplenarysessions,theworkshoprapporteurs,andthePublicSystemteam(PCO),allofwhomeasedthetaskofeditingthesepagesandimprovedtheresult.InMartinique,PhilippeRobert,Marie-AudeSévinandthestaffoftheFrenchMPAAgency,ValérieMetral,NicolasMaslach,LaurentJuhelandLaurenceVigneron,werewarmandgraciousinwelcomingeveryonetoMartiniqueandmakingourstayverypleasant.Appreciationforsmoothandefficienttravelarrangementsandlogisticsforparticipants,beforeandduringtheconference,isduetoLee-AnnChoyofPacificRimConcepts.AfinalthankyougoestotheFrenchNavy,AEMAntilles,forallowingustohaveaclosingdinnerandcelebrationatthemagnificentmilitaryfortinFort-de-France.
©InternationalCommitteeforMarineMammalProtectedAreas(ICMMPA),Allrightsreserved.Copyrightofphotographsremainswithphotographersandindividualtextswiththeauthors.GratefulthanksaregiventoChristineBrammer,NaomiMcIntosh,GaryDukerandRebeccaWhiteforassistanceintheproductionofthereport.
ISBNforfullproceedings(thisedition):978-0-9853252-0-6
ISBNforsummaryproceedings(shortversion):978-0-9853252-1-3
Citation:Hoyt,E.(editor)2012.ProceedingsoftheSecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas(ICMMPA2),Fort-de-France,Martinique,7-11Nov.2011,ppi-vi,1-103
September2012
PROCEEDINGS OF THE SECOND INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON MARINE MAMMAL PROTECTED AREAS
ICMMPA 2: Endangered Spaces, Endangered Species
November 7–11, 2011 Fort-de-France, Martinique
Editor: Erich Hoyt
ii
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
Dall’s porpoise in Commander Islands Biosphere Reserve, Russia. Photo by Tatiana Ivkovich, Russian Cetacean Habitat Project, Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society
iii
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
ContentsExecutive Summary and Main Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
Conference Welcome and Opening Talks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Keynote 1: Australian Policy on Marine Mammal Conservation. Hon. Tony Burke, MP (Minister for Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities, Australia) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Panel 1: Special Management Considerations for Particularly Endangered Marine Mammals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
Panel 2: Refining Our Understanding of Marine Mammal Critical Habitat and Hotspots, Wading Through Large, Heterogeneous Masses of Data, to Inform MMPA Designation (including on the High Seas) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Keynote 2: Marine Mammals That Have Already Been Lost – Lessons Learned? Randall Reeves (Chair, IUCN SSC Cetacean Specialist Group, and Okapi Wildlife Associates, Canada) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
Panel 3 and 4 (combined): Using Marine Spatial Planning and Ecosystem-based Management to Address Broad Threats to Marine Mammals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
Panel 5: Managing Marine Mammal Protected Areas (MMPAs) for Localized Threats and Mitigation by Spatial Protection and Other Means . . . . . . 23
Panel 6: Regional Cooperation for MMPA Scientific and Technical Networking . . . . 27
Panel 7: Development of Marine Mammal Protected Areas (MMPAs) in the Wider Caribbean Region . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
Keynote 3: The Legal Regime Relating to Marine Protected Areas on the High Seas for Marine Mammal Protection. Christophe Lefèbvre (IUCN Global Ocean Councilor; French Marine Protected Areas Agency, France) . . . 35
Keynote 4: Thinking Big – But Not Forgetting Small. The ICMMPA 2 “Take Home” Vision. Erich Hoyt (Research Fellow and Global MPA Programme Head, Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society, UK) . . . . . . . . . . 37
iv
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
Workshop 1: Monk Seal Conservation Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39
Workshop 2: River Dolphin, Estuary, and Coastal Dolphin Conservation . . . . . . . 43
Workshop 3: Bycatch and Marine Mammal Protected Areas . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
Workshop 4A: Bilateral and Multilateral Agreements to Facilitate Partnerships between and among MMPAs: Making Them Work and Lessons Learned . . . . . . . . 51
Workshop 4B: Broad-scale Marine Spatial Planning of Mammal Corridors and Protected Areas in the Wider Caribbean and Southeast and Northeast Pacific, Including Identifying Ecologically or Biologically Significant Areas (EBSAs) . . . . . . . 55
Workshop 5: North East of South America, Regional Cooperation for a Marine Mammals Conservation Strategy Workshop – MAMA COCO SEA Project . . . . . 61
Workshop 6: GOBI-UNEP/LifeWeb Technical Session: Identifying EBSAs and Critical Habitats in the Wider Caribbean and East Pacific to Inform Marine Mammal Management Planning (cancelled as a separate workshop and included as part of Workshop 4B and Workshop 9) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65
Workshop 7: Immediate and Lingering Impacts of Oil Disasters on Marine Mammals: Review of Experiences and Policy Implications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67
Workshop 8: Conservation of Sirenians . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71
Workshop 9: Scientific Information to Support MSP: MSP for Marine Mammal Conservation, as well as Considerations of Marine Mammal Science in Broader MSP . . 75
Workshop 10: Management of Whale Watching in Marine Mammal Protected Areas (MMPAs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83
v
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
Side Event 1: Ship Strikes in the Caribbean and Mediterranean: Studies and Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 89
Side Event 2: International Whaling Commission (IWC) Five-Year Strategic Plan for Whale Watching . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91
Martinique Declaration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93
Directory of ICMMPA 2 Participants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95
Steering and Program Committee, International Committee on Marine Mammal Protected Areas – ICMMPA 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101
Organization and contacts (inside back cover)
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
vi
Bottlenose dolphins in proposed Hebrides Marine Reserve, Scotland Photo by Charlie Phillips, Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
1
Executive Summary and Main Conclusions
Some150marinemammalprotectedarea(MMPA)researchersandmanagersaswellasgovernmentandconservationgrouprep-resentativesfrom42countriesandoverseasterritoriesconvenedinMartiniqueintheFrenchCaribbeanfrom7-11November2011fortheSecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas(ICMMPA2).Thegoal:toseeksolutionstosharedproblemsrelatedtomarinemammalconservationandtoMMPAnetworkandsitedesign,creationandmanagement.AsecondarygoalwastoorientthoseworkinginMMPAstosetthoseprotectedareasinthebroadercontextofmarinemanage-ment,inordertoensurethatMMPAsarenotmarginalizedasmarinespatialplanningworkadvances.Unlikemostscientificmeetings,theICMMPAstressesworkshops,panels,andopenforumdiscussionstoemphasizecollaboration,communicationandnetworkingamongMMPApractitioners.
Theconferencewasco-hostedbytheFrenchMPAAgency(Agencedesairesmarinesprotégées)andtheUSNationalOceanicandAtmosphericAdministration(NOAA).Fifteenotherinternationalandregionalsponsors,aswellasadozensupport-ingorganizations,wereactivelyinvolved,mosteitherbasedinMartiniqueorwithrepresentationintheCaribbean.
Theconferencethemeof“EndangeredSpaces,EndangeredSpecies”wasexploredinkeynotetalks,panelsandworkshopsfocusingonmonkseals,sirenians,riverdolphinsandothersmallandlargecetaceans.Inseveralworkshopsandplenarytalks,specialattentionwasgiventothevaquita,themostendangered,space-restrictedmarinemammalintheworld.Delegatesagreedthatitwillrequireabroadpubliccampaigninordertogener-atethepoliticalwilltostopthegillnetfishingthatissqueezingthelastlifefromthe“shyporpoisewiththelittleblacksmile”.
Plenarysessionsweredividedintopanels,followedbydiscus-sions,focusingon
• SpecialconsiderationsforparticularlyendangeredmarinemammalsandwhetherMPAsaretherighttool.
• RefiningourunderstandingofmarinemammalcriticalhabitatandhotspotstoinformMMPAdesignation.
• Usingmarinespatialplanningandecosystem-basedmanagementtoaddressbroadthreatstomarinemammals.
• ManagingMMPAsforlocalizedthreatsandmitigationbyspatialprotectionandothermeans.
• DevelopmentofMMPAsinthewiderCaribbeanregion.
• RegionalcooperationforMMPAscientificandtechnicalnetworking.
Theworkshopsfocusedonmarinemammalsandoilspills,deci-sion-makingwithlimiteddata,bestpracticesforwhalewatchinginMMPAs,integratingmarinemammaldatainmarinespa-tialplanning,forgingagreementstoestablisheffectiveMMPA
networks,andthewidespreadmortalityattributedtofisheriesbycatch.
ICMMPA2washostedintheCaribbeantoaffordsynergiesandnetworkingopportunitiesfortheWiderCaribbean,includingsessionsontheeasterntropicalPacific,northeastSouthAmerica,aswellasonthenineriverdolphincountriesofSouthAmerica.Thesesessionsbuiltuponorinstitutednewregionalalliances,someofwhichwereformedatthefirstICMMPAinHawaii.
Key Recommendations and Conclusionsthatemergedfromtheconferenceworkshopswereasfollows(fromglobalandregionallevelstothetaxa-specificlevel).Pleasenotethatthefullsetofrecommendationsisavailableintheproceedings.
Of global relevance, the members of the “scientific information and marine spatial planning” workshop agreed, among other things:
• Toprovideinformationandadviceonhowtousemarinemammalsciencetoinformdecision-makingandtoensurethatrelevantinformationaboutmarinemammalimportantareasgetsincorporatedintotheConventiononBiologicalDiversity(CBD)processofecologicallyorbiologicallysignificantareas(EBSA)identification.
• Toformataskforcefordevelopingguidelinesforbestpracticalwaystoengagewiththeshippingindustry,InternationalMaritimeOrganization(IMO)andothersectors.
• Todevelopabestpracticesguideandstandardsformarinemammalspatialplanning.
• TodevelopanactionplantoidentifyandaddresscriticaldatagapsincludinguseofDelphicexpert-knowledgeapproachestocomplementdatacollection.
Additional global recommendations from various workshops were directed to the ICMMPA and associated MMPA researchers, managers and NGOs:
• TocoordinatethepreparationofadocumentprovidingguidancefortheMMPAcommunityintheformofessentialunderlyingprinciplesforeffectivedevelopmentofbilateralandmultilateralpartnershipandnetworkingagreementsandoutliningappropriatelegalmechanisms,bestpracticesfordevelopmentandimplementationofagreementsandillustrativecasestudies.
• TobringtogetherstakeholderstofocusonbycatchasanimportantpartofMMPAmanagementplansandlegislation.Thiscouldincludeinitiativesforthedevelopmentandtestingofmarinemammalsafefishinggear,aswellasservingasafocalpointforknowledgeaboutmarinemammalpopulations,fishingtypeandeffortwithinMPAboundaries,aswellasforcapacity-buildinginitiativesrelatedtodisentanglementandprevention.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
2
• ToencourageinternationalorganizationssuchastheInternationalMaritimeOrganization(IMO),InternationalTankerOwnersPollutionFederationLtd(ITOPF),amongothers,toworkwiththemarinemammalcommunityforoilspillresponsecontingencyplanning,drillsandpreparedness,aswellastoworkwithappropriatenationalauthoritiesorinternational/regionalbodies(suchastheregionalactivitycenters)toensurethatMMPAsandmarinemammalsareincludedinsuchplans.
• Toworkwithstakeholdersandlocalcommunitiestoexplore,establishorrefineappropriatemanagementframeworksformarinemammalwatchingactivities,includingvoluntaryand/orregulatorymeasures,coveringthevarioustraining,regulatoryandcomplianceaspects.
Regionally, it was recommended that countries, managers and scientific teams of the Wider Caribbean and Eastern Pacific collaborate:
• Todevelopaplantosynthesizeexistingdata,includingexpertopinioninmapsthatcanbeusedascommunicationtools,andtobeabletomakecomparisonsbetweenqualitativeandquantitativesummariestoincludesocio-economicinformation.
• Touseexistingdatainventoriestoidentifyandprioritizefillingdatagapsandtoconsidertheuseoflargescaleandstandardizedaswellasopportunisticandcost-effectivesurveystogatheradditionaldata.
The country and community representatives, MMPA managers and researchers of the North East South America MAMA COCO SEA Project (Regional cooperation for marine mammal conserva-tion) agreed tocompleteaworkshopbackgroundpaperoutliningtheaims,strategiesenvisionedandpossiblesynergiesleadingtotheorganizationofaworkshopfor2012inSurinametoestablishthecurrentstateofknowledgeonmarinemammalsandtheirhabitats,threatsandmanagementframeworkbycountryandtosetuparegionalactionplanwithcapacitybuildingformarinemammalconservation.
The monk seal workshop agreedthatagroupofmonksealsci-entists,managersandadvocatesbeformedtofindcommonvaluesandsolutionstomonksealproblems,aswellastoraiseawareness,understandingandmotivationbythepublictohelpencouragegovernmentstohonortheircommitmentstosavingmonkseals;andthatlocalcommunities,especiallyfishermenbeengagedinmonksealconservation.
Riverine and estuarine mammal researchers, managers and NGOs recommendedthatupstream-downstreamconnectivityandecologicallyviableflowbetakenintoaccountinthedesignandmanagementofprotectedareas,andthatthegoalsoftheSouthAmericanRiverDolphinProtectedAreaNetwork(SARDPAN)bestrengthenedandfulfilledto,amongotherthings,researchandconveyscience-basedinformationtoprotectedareastakeholders.
Sirenian researchers, managers and NGOs agreedtousearegionalapproachforcreating,managingandevaluatingtheeffectivenessofMPAsandMPAnetworksforsireniansincludingpromotionof
thegoalsofregionalmanagementplans.Theyalsorecommendedtheconsiderationofreintroductionprogramstoimprovesire-nianconservationbutwithcareful,transparentconsiderationofscience,localculturalvalues,potentialthreats,legalconstraintsandfullstakeholderinvolvement.
Two themes common to all levels – global, regional and species specific – emerged from the conference discussions and recommendations:
• Thatmarinemammalresearchers,managersandNGOsneedtoworkoutbetterwaystoengagestakeholdersandlocalcommunitiesaswellasthewiderpublictohelpwithlocalconservationeffortsaswellastoencouragegovernmentstowardeffectiveconservationmeasures.
• Sustainedfundingmustbefoundtohelptherecoveryofthreatenedandendangeredspecies.
Duringbackgrounddiscussionsattheconferenceandoverthepastyear,bothofthesethemeshavebeenconsideredasapos-siblepartofanenhancedmissionfortheICMMPAsteeringcom-mittee–i.e.,theInternationalCommitteeonMarineMammalProtectedAreas.
ThelocationoftheconferenceintheCaribbeancelebratedtheFrenchdeclarationoftheAgoaSanctuary,itselfoneofthecon-ferencesponsors.Agoahaslegalstatusalreadybuttherearemoredetailedplansforthe143,618km2area,whichcoverstheFrenchexclusiveeconomiczone(EEZ)intheCaribbean,tomakeitintoanMPAwithexpandedhighlyprotectedzonesandaman-agementplan.Duringtheconference,apresentationfromtheNetherlandsAntillesregardingDutchwatersoftheCaribbeanformallyopenedthepossibilitythatthesewaterscouldbeaddedtotheAgoaSanctuaryorjoinedaspartofanetworkthatcouldmeasurablyhelpmarinemammalconservationintheGreaterCaribbean.Ontheconference’sfinalday,amarinemammalpro-tectedareapartnership,the“MartiniqueDeclaration”,wasforgedbetweentheAgoaSanctuary,StellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary,theDutchCaribbeanproject,theMarineMammalSanctuaryoftheDominicanRepublicandtheRegionalActivityCenterfortheSPAWProtocol(SPAW-RAC).
TheICMMPAconferenceswillcontinuewithaproposedcon-ferenceforAustraliainlate2013or2014.BehindthescenestheInternationalCommitteeforMarineMammalProtectedAreasplanstohelpaddresstheneedsexpressedintherecommenda-tionsandtopromotebetternetworkingandproblemsolvingthroughthegrowingconstituencydevelopedfromthefirsttwoconferencesandintheplansforthenextconference.
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
3
Conference Welcome and Opening Talks
TheSecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas(ICMMPA2)openedwithawarmstatementofwelcometotheFrenchCaribbeanfromRaymond Saint-Louis-Augustin,MayorofFort-de-France.Hisremarkswerefollowedbytheintroductionofanotedfigureinthehistoryofpublicawarenessofmarinemammals,Albert Falco,CalypsoCaptainandcollaboratorofJacques-YvesCousteau,diverandhonoraryconferencechairman.Capt.Falcotalkedaboutthecontinuingneedtoprotecttheseasfromoverfishing,oilspillsandothercatastrophes,aswellastheneedtoempowerpeopletoprotecttheenvironment.
“Mygeneration–andIregretitdeeply,”saidCapt.Falco,“hasn’tdonemuchtopreservenature;however,itofferedmesomuchthatuntilmylastbreath,Iwilltryhardtomakepeoplereal-izetheextremeimportancetocreatepreservedareasaswellasmarinemammalsanctuariesinorderforthenextgenerationstoenjoythediscoveryofallthesemarinespeciesthatnaturehasenabledtothriveonourblueplanet.”
Theseopeningremarkswerefollowedbyofficialtalksfromnationalandinternationalbodieswithanimportantstakeinmarinemammalhabitatconservation:
Ferdy Louisy,PresidentoftheNationalParkofGuadeloupeandVice-PresidentoftheNationalParksofFrance,spokeaboutcon-servingmarinemammalsasanimportantaspectofprotectingtheentiremarineecosystem.HespokeaboutFrance’sambitiousprogramtodevelopmarineprotectedareasworldwideintheentireFrench11millionkm2EEZ,thefirstmajordeclarationofwhichcameinOctober2010withthenamingoftheAgoaSanctuarycoveringallFrenchCaribbeanwaters.However,henotedthatprotectionforFrenchwaterswasnotenough,thattheproblemsareclearlyonanoceanicscaleandthatweallneedtosupportinternationalcollaborationsandworldwidehabitatconservationformarinemammals.
Ryan Wulff,theUSDeputyCommissionertotheIWC,fromNOAA,notedthattheUShasbuiltonitssupportofthefirstICMMPAinMaui,Hawaii,throughitsvariousagenciescon-cernedwithmarinemammals,habitatprotectionandmarinespatialplanning.Inviewofthethemeoftheconferencebeing“EndangeredSpaces,EndangeredSpecies,”hesaidthattheUnited Statesagreesthatthisisarelevanttopicfordiscussion.NOAAhastakenanumberofdomesticmeasurestohelptherecoveryofendangeredspeciesandhascollaboratedwithinterna-tionalpartnersonresearch,trainingandmanagementactivitiesaimedatincreasingourknowledgeandcooperationonmarinemammalsandprotectedareas.NOAA’sinternationalmarinemammalinitiativesincludetheSpeciallyProtectedAreasandWildlife(SPAW)ProtocolintheCaribbeanandInternationalWhalingCommission(IWC)commitments,amongothers.
Jihyun Lee,EnvironmentalAffairsOfficerfromtheSecretariatoftheConventiononBiologicalDiversity(CBD),talkedabout
the10-yearStrategicPlan2011-2020forBiodiversityadoptedbytheConferenceofthePartiestotheCBDatits10thmeetingin2010inNagoya,Japan.Thisincludescommitmentsfromthe193Partiestoachieve20AichiBiodiversityTargets.Target11commitsParties,by2020,tohaveatleast17%ofterrestrialandinlandwaterareasand10%ofcoastalandmarineareas,espe-ciallyareasofparticularimportanceforbiodiversityandeco-systemservices,tobecoveredthrougheffectivelyandequitablymanaged,ecologically-representativeandwellconnectedsystemsofprotectedareas.
Thescience-drivenCBDhasadoptedscientificcriteriaforiden-tifyingecologicallyorbiologicallysignificantareas(EBSAs),forwhichStatesarerequestedtoapplyenhancedmanagementandconservationmeasures,includingmarineprotectedareas.TheCBDSecretariat,therefore,workscloselywithvariousinterna-tionalandregionalpartners,suchastheICMMPA,inscientifi-callydescribingtheareasmeetingthecriteriaforEBSAsthroughconveningaseriesofregionalworkshops.Amongconsiderableotherwork,CBDiscurrentlypreparingareportontheeffectsofunderwaternoiseonmarinebiodiversityincludingmarinemammals.
Leeremindedtheparticipantsthat,in2012,theworldwillrenewitscommitmenttosustainabledevelopmentbyconven-ingtheUnited Nations Conference onSustainableDevelopment(Rio+20)whichwillassesstheprogressmadeinmeetingglobal
Captain Albert Falco, honorary conference chairman and former Cousteau collaborator, talked to participants about the continu-ing need to protect the seas from overfishing, oil spills and other catastrophies, as well as the need to empower people to protect the environment.Photo by Agence Kréöl
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
4
commitmentsandaddressingnewandemergingchallenges.Tofacilitateeffortsatglobal,regionalandnationallevelsonachiev-ingbiodiversitytargetsandhighlightingtheroleofmarinebiodiversityinadvancingthecommongoalofsustainabledevelopment,theCBDhasgiventheInternationalBiodiversityDay 2012thethemeofmarineandcoastalbiodiversityforthefirsttime.TheCBDinviteseveryonetojoinhandswiththeConventionpartiesandpartnerstomakealltheseglobaloppor-tunitiesmeaningfulandsuccessfulinachievingthecommonvisionofmarinebiodiversityconservationandsustainableuse.
Fernando Félix,fromthePermanentCommissionfortheSouthPacific(CPPS),basedinEcuador,maderemarksonbehalfofOleVestergaardfromUnitedNationsEnvironmentProgramme(UNEP).FélixiscurrentlyhelpingtocoordinatetheLifeWebProjectincollaborationwithUNEPfocusingonthewatersoftheEasternPacificborderingCentralandSouthAmerica.HenotedtheparticularimportanceofPacificandCaribbeanwaterscov-eredbytheUNEPLifeWebprojectashabitatsforcalving,matingandfeedingmarinemammals.Still,thesewatersaresufferingtheimpactsfromhumanactivity.Managementoftransbound-arywatersisimportantinmarinespatialplanningandforthecreationofmarineprotectedareanetworks.TheLifeWebprojectisagoodexampleofhowUNEP’smarineandcoastalworkisgroundedinecosystem-basedmanagementprinciples.
Dan Laf foley, representing the Internat ionalUnion forConservationofNature(IUCN)GlobalMarineandPolarProgrammeandasMarineVice-ChairfortheWorldCommissiononProtectedAreas,talkedaboutthecriticalimportanceofthemeetingandurgedparticipantstobevisionaryintheirdiscus-sionsinmovingtheagendaforward.
LaffoleynotedhisoriginalinspirationfromCousteauandthatinthe40ensuingyearstheoceanhasbeenchangedandfewplacesremainnatural.HenotedthattheWorldSummitonSustainableDevelopment(WSSD)in2002gaveusthebasisforbuildingnetworksofmarineprotectedareasandtheConventionon BiologicalDiversityreaffirmedthetargetsforprotectingthemarineenvironment.
TherearenowenoughdataandcombinedglobaleffortstoknowthattheCBDtargetof10%willprobablybereachedby2040ratherthantheoriginalaimof2020unlessmoreconcertedactionistaken.Thereisasenseofpessimismaround,butthereisalsocauseforoptimismbecauseweknowthatweareactuallymak-ingprogressandopportunitiesexisttoscaleupefforts. In2010,therewerealmost6,000 marineprotectedareas,coveringabout1.17%ofthetotaloceanarea,andmorerecentfiguresbringthatpercentageupto1.42%.However,thereisofcoursestillsomewaytogotoachieveourtargetsandoneofthekeyissuesisthatmanymoreplacesintheopenoceanneedtobeprotected.We’reneglectingpelagicwatersofcountriesandthevasthighseas.
Laffoleyoutlinedsomeofthemainchallenges:
• ScalinguptoachievemuchlargerMPAgoalsonthehighseas.
• OrganizingmoreaccuratemappingofMPAs.
• Forgingbetterconnectionswithoceanusers.
• Fast-trackingofmarinepolicy.
• Addressingmaritimetrafficincludingnoise.
• Addressingmanagementofspecificfishinggears.
• Developingmorewaysofgettingpeopleinvolved,suchascreatingmobilephoneapplicationstomaketheoceanandmarineconservationmoreaccessibletothepolicymakersandthewiderpublic.
• Forgingnewpartnershipstospreadtheword,suchastheagreementwiththeAmerica’sCupsailingracewhichhaslauncheditsHealthyOceanProjectinpartnershipwithIUCN,SylviaEarleandMissionBlue.
LaffoleypresentedananimatedGoogleEarthTourspeciallymadefortheconferencewiththeassistanceofGoogle,IUCNandtheWhaleandDolphinConservationSociety.1ThetourusestheGoogleEarthoceansversionlaunchedin2009,whichtriestogivetheoceanarealistic3Dappearanceand,throughit,totellthestoryofmarineanimalsandecosystems.Importantly,thisprovidestheopportunitytousemultimediatechnologyaccessibleoncomputersandsmartphones,wherepeoplecandiscoverMPAsandcallupinformationonmarinemammals.Italsoallowstheidentificationofareasthatneedtobeprotected.Itisonethingtoinspirepeopleabouttheocean,butitisessentialtoprovidewaysofengaging.
ThefinalopeningandofficialtalkscamefromMartinique:
Jocelyn Régina, Presidentof theCulture andHeritageCommission,GeneralCouncil,Martinique,spokeabouttheimportanceoftheAgoaSanctuaryprojectcoveringtheFrenchCaribbeanwaterstoprotectthebreedinggroundsofhump-backwhales.Thegeneralcouncilhasmadeitapriorityforthedevelopmentofnatureprotectionofcoralreefsystemsandtostrengthenprotectedareas.ItisworkingtoraiseawarenessinthelocalcommunityoftheimportanceoftheoceaningeneralandtheAgoaSanctuaryinparticularfortourismandtherais-ingofawarenessofMMPAs.Byworkingtogethertoprotecttheocean,introducingsimplemeasures,wecanpassonourseastofuturegenerationsinamuchbetterstatethanwefindthemtoday.Protectingtheoceanisalsoaboutprovidingjobsinfishingandourchildrenarelearningthattheseaisnotjustanextentofwaterbutaplacethatishometoafragilepopulationandaplacethatproduces80%oftheplanet’soxygen.Itisvitalthatchildrenknowmoreabouttheseaandhowitcanbeprotected.
Daniel Chomet,President,NaturalPark,Martinique,stressedthefragilityoftheoceanwhichnowfacesmanyproblemsincludingglobalwarming,oceanacidification,habitatdegradation,andpollution.Manymarinespeciesareendangeredbecauseoftheseissues.Weallneedtotakeanactivepartinthesharedmanage-mentoftheAgoaSanctuary.Wewanttodevelopthetoolsthatwillhelpwiththeprotectionofcoastalareas.
1 TheGoogleEarthTourcanbeseenatwww.youtube.com/watch?v=2-ZW1U1eNIU
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
5
Laurent Prévost, PrefectofMartinique,presentedamessagefromNathalie Kosciusko-Morizet,FrenchMinisteroftheEnvironmentandSustainableDevelopment,assertingFrance’scommitmenttotheprotectionofmarinemammals.Shesaidthatwemustworktogethertofindsolutionsatlocal,regionalandinternationallevelsformarineconservationtoprotecttheenvironmentformarinemammalsandreducetheimpactofhumanactivities–pollution,bycatch,shipstrikesandcollisions.Francehasmadeitaprioritytodevelopmarineprotectedareas;10%oftheseasunderFrenchnationaljurisdictionuptothe200nauticalmilelimitwillbeprotected.France’scommitmentisbothregionalandinternational,andthisconferenceshowshowcommittedthelocalactorsare–akeypartofregionalcooperation.Sustainabledevel-opmentandhumanactivitiesbothhaveclaimsontheoceansandweneedtofindtoolsinfisheriesandtourismtomakebothsidesworktogether.AnimportantrecentdevelopmentcanbeseenintheformoftheCartagena Convention.Fourteencoun-triesintheCaribbeanhaveratifiedtheConvention’sprotocolandthisshouldhelpinstrengtheningcooperation.Foritspart,FranceissupportingtheimplementationoftheprotocolwithateambasedinGuadeloupe.
Kosciusko-Morizetcongratulatedeveryoneontheworkthathasgoneintoprotectedareas.SheaffirmedthatFrancewouldcon-tinuetoplayitspartthroughtheAgoaprojectandwithregionalandinternationalcooperationtoenabletheconstructionofanetworkofprotectedareasformarinemammals.
Dan Laffoley from IUCN presented an animated Google Earth Tour specially made for the conference that people can use to discover MPAs around the world that are important for marine mammals.Photo by Agence Kréöl
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
6
Dugong near Marsa Alam, Egypt Photo by Julien Willem, Wikimedia Commons
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
7
Keynote 1: Australian Policy on Marine Mammal Conservation Hon. Tony Burke, MP MinisterforSustainability,Environment,Water,PopulationandCommunities,AustraliaTheHon.TonyBurke,MPandMinisterforSustainability,Environment,Water,PopulationandCommunities,Australia,introducedAustralia’sstrongcommitmenttomarinemammalprotectionandhowAustralianpoliciesregardingmarinebioregionalplanningandmarineprotectedareasarecontributingtoenhancedmarinemammalconservation.Australiahasarangeofpoliciesinplacesthatdeliverprotectionofwhales,dolphins,sealionsanddugong.Italsoengagesinawiderangeofdomesticandinternationalmarinemammalresearchinitiatives.CurrentlyAustraliaiscollaboratingwiththeAmerica’sCuptopromoteoceanconservation.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
Conference delegates participated actively during the plenary sessions.Photo by Agence Kréöl
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
8
Steller sea lion bull, Alaska.Photo by Dave Withrow, National Marine Mammal Laboratory, AFSC, NOAA Fisheries
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
9
Panel 1: Special Management Considerations for Particularly Endangered Marine Mammals
Coordinator: Lorenzo Rojas Bracho(InstitutoNacionaldeEcología–INE,México)
Introduction and ObjectivesTheobjectiveofPanel1wastoexploreoneaspectofthemainconferencethemeof“EndangeredSpaces,EndangeredSpecies”,namelywhetherspecificconsiderationsneedtobemadeforhabitatprotectionformarinemammalspeciesandpopulationsthatareparticularlyendangered.Thepanelcommentedonthesituationfromtheperspectiveofanumberofspeciesgroupingsincludingsmallcetaceans(e.g.,vaquita),largecetaceans(espe-ciallyNorthPacificandNorthAtlanticrightwhales,bluewhalesandwesterngraywhales),pinnipeds(e.g.,monkseals,Stellersealions)andsirenians(allspecies).
Summaries of Presentations
Using MPAs to save endangered small cetaceans: Is this the right tool?Lorenzo Rojas Bracho(InstitutoNacionaldeEcología–INE,México)andRandall Reeves(Chair,IUCNSSCCetaceanSpecialistGroup,andOkapiWildlifeAssociates,Canada)
IUCNliststhreespecies,sixsubspeciesandtengeographicalsubpopulationsofsmallcetaceansaseithercriticallyendangeredorendangered.Invirtuallyallcasestheendangermentinvolvessomekindofaconflictwithhumanactivities,andalltoooftenonethatisnoteasilyaccepted,characterized,andresolved.
Foranyconservationtooltobeappliedsuccessfully,itisnecessarytoidentify,understand,andbeabletoclassifyriskfactorsaccord-ingtotheirimportanceasdriversofendangerment.Bycatchisacommondenominatorinalmostallcasesofendangeredsmallcetaceans,butusuallyotherfactorsarealsoinvolved,suchashabi-tatdeterioration,reducedpreyabundance,disturbancebyhumanactivities,orcompromisedhealthduetocontaminantexposure.Thesefactors,however,canbehardtoidentifywithcertainty,andevenmoredifficulttoaddressdecisively.
Inatleastsomeinstances,establishmentofoneormorepro-tectedareascanbepartofalegallycomprehensiveframeworkwithinwhichtopursueconservationactiononmultiplefronts;thevaquitaprovidesagoodexample.Designationinitselfmaysignifythatthespeciesorpopulationisintroubleandneedsspecialprotection.Itshouldalsobringanimpliedresponsibil-ity(includingtheprovisionofresources)formanagerstoact
immediatelytoreduceknownthreatsandatthesametimeinvestigateotherlikelyriskfactors.
Tragically,aftersome15yearsofthebiospherereserveintheUpperGulfofCaliforniathereareonlyanestimated245vaqui-tasremainingwhichis57%lowerthanestimatedin1997.Theonlyhopeforthepossiblerecoveryofthisspeciesistoeliminatebycatchcompletelyandtodothatrequiresremovalofallgillnets–easiersaidthandonedespitegreateffortsbycommittedpeople.
Twoothercasesare,first,theeasternTaiwanStraitIndo-Pacifichumpbackdolphinwhichsuffersfromhabitatloss,industrialpol-lutionandbycatch.VariousMPAscenarioshavebeenproposedbutthequestioniswhetherthedesignationofaprotectedareawouldreallyhelpsavethispopulationgiventheenormousprob-lemsofhabitatdegradationcausedbyintensehumanpressure.
InthecaseoftheHector’sdolphininNewZealand,therewasagreaterthan50%declinefrom1970to2009mainlyduetobycatchfromgillnets.Thisspeciesisonlyprojectedtorecoverifbycatchiseliminated,andthen,onlyslowly.
SotothequestionofwhetherMPAswillhelp,theanswerisyesandno,dependingonthescaleandnatureoftheproblemsandtheeffectivenessofthemeasuresputinplace.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NSBiologist John Reynolds talked about sirenian habitat conser-
vation during Panel 1: Special Management Considerations for Particularly Endangered Marine Mammals.Photo by Agence Kréöl
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
10
Optimizing the value of MPAs for conservation of sireniansBenjamin Morales Vela(ElColegiodelaFronteraSur,México)andJohn Reynolds, III(MoteMarineLaboratory,Florida,USA)
Conservationcrisesdidnotdevelopovernight,norwillsolu-tionstothosecrises.Effectivesolutionsareurgentlyneededforconservationofsirenians,allofwhicharethreatened,astheyoccupycoastalandriverinehabitatsinproximitytopeopleandtheiractivities.Awellintegratedsetofactions,includingthecreationoffunctionalmarine(oraquatic)protectedareasisvital.Todate,theenormouspotentialimportanceofprotectedareashasoftennotbeenrealizedforsirenianconservationbecausemanagersandgovernmentsfail(amongotherthings)toiden-tifygoals,provideadequateenforcement,developandsustainfunding,andconductassessmentsandmakeadaptivechanges.
Weoffercasestudiestoillustratewhereandhowprotectedareasforsirenianscanbeeffectiveforconservation,andwereinforcethefollowingattributesthatcanpromotesuccessineitherdevel-opedordevelopingcountries:communityinvolvement;planningtoreflectregionallegalframeworksandgoalsspecifictosireni-ans;encouragementoflegalframeworksandthepoliticalwilltomakethemwork;targetededucationandawarenessprograms;adequatespatialscale;long-termfunding;significantco-man-agement;anadaptivemanagementapproach;adequateenforce-mentpresence;capacitybuilding,includingsuccessionplanning,forallpartners;active,appliedresearchtoinformmanagement;andalternativelivelihoodsforaffectedcommunitymembers.
Sireniansarefoundwithintheterritorialwatersofapproximately90countries.OneMPAcasestudyistheChetumalBayManateeProtectedAreawhichstretchesoverpartsofBelizeandMéxico.MPAsareonlyfullyeffectiveiftheyaresupportedbyauthoritiesandthelocalpopulationshaveappropriatemeasuresincorpo-ratedintosufficientlywell-fundedmanagementplans.ThishotspotformanateesintheCaribbeanhasexperienceduncertainfundingstreamsandcommunicationandcoordinationissuesbetweenBelizeandMéxico.
AnexampleofageneralMPAthathasbenefitsformarinemam-malsistheGreatBarrierReefMarineParkandWorldHeritageAreaencompassing350,000km2.Thefocusherehasbeenmulti-speciesandprotectionofecosystemprocessesandthisinturnprovidesgreatprotectionfordugongs.
Design elements for pinniped protected areasDennis Heinemann (MarineMammalCommission,USA)
Fewmarineprotectedareashavebeendesignedprimarilyforpin-nipeds.Further,littleattentionhasbeengiventothegeneralMPAdesignprinciplesthatshouldbeappliedtopinnipedprotectedareas(PPAs),ortothelifehistoryandecologicalcharacteristics
ofpinnipedsthatwillbeimportanttodesigningeffectivearea-basedprotectionandmanagement.
Differenttypesofpinnipedprotectedareasservedifferentpurposes:
• CoastalPPAsprotectbreedingcoloniesorhaulouts.
• Pelagicareasprotectforagingareasandmigrationormovementcorridors.
• Fixedpelagicareasmayprotectpinnipedsandpreyassociatedwithbenthicorpredictablehydrographicfeatures.
• Ephemeralpelagicareasmayprotectpinnipedsassociatedwithtransitoryand/ormobileoceanographicfeatures.
Threefactorsareofparticularimportanceindesigningprotectedareasforpinnipeds:
Firstly,pinnipedsareassociatedwithlandoriceduringthebreedingseasonandwhilehauledout.Thismeansthattheyaremuchmoreavailabletoresearchers,whichcanleadtoagreaterunderstandingoftheirphysiology,reproductivebiology,andecologythancanbeachievedwithcomparableeffortforothermarinemammals.However,theirassociationwiththelandmeansthattheyaredirectlyexposedtoterrestrialthreatsandthattheirmanagementismorecomplex.
Secondly,thefactthatmanypinnipedsarecentralplaceforagersimposesspecialdesignconstraintsonpinnipedprotectedareas.
Thirdly,pinnipedsgenerallyhavesmallerranges,morerapidgrowthratesandacloserlinktolocalconditionsthanmanycetaceans.ThissuggeststhatPPAsgenerallywouldbesmallerthancetaceanprotectedareas,forexample,whichcouldincreasetheprobabilityofsuccess.
Aswithanyprotectedarea,designisinformedbygoals,whicharematchedtothreats.Typicalpinnipedprotectedareasareofthecoastaltypeandhaveacoreareathatexcludesallhumanactivitywithaseawardbufferareathatrestrictsactivitiessuchasfishingandboating–the“core-buffer”design.Whencompleteprotectioncannotbeprovided,considerationofthecharacter-isticsofthecolonyorhaulout,thepresenceorabsencenaturalbarriers,thearea’sisolation,whetherthecolonyisstableordeclining,andtheoceanographicconditionsforbreeders,arecriticaltooptimizingprotection.ThesizeofacoastalPPAwillbedeterminedbythedispersionofthecolonyorhaulout,andthetypes,intensityandspatialextentofanydisturbanceagents.Inaddition,tourism,educationandresearchaspectswillalsoplayapartinthedesignofcoastalPPAs.
Forpelagicprotectedareas,aswithcetaceanprotectedareas,theaimistoprotectcriticalhabitat,meetthelifestagerequirementsforthespecies,protectbiodiversityandthepreybase,andtoeliminateorreducefisheriesinteractions.Acost-benefitanalysiswilldetermine,toalargeextent,whethertheprotectedareaisfeasiblefromecological,economicandsocialperspectives,whileaconsiderationofitssize,locationandlevelofprotectionwillprovideanexpectationoftheenvironmentalandsocialbenefits
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
11
itcanachieve.Thedeterminationofthemosteffectivesizewill,forcapitalbreeders,bedeterminedlargelybytheprotectionpro-videdtotheecosystemandforagebase,and,forcentralplacefor-agers,bytheabilitytoprovidepredictableprotectionofanimalsonforaginggroundsandinmovementcorridors.
Pelagicprotectedareaswithfixedboundariesareassociatedwithbenthichabitatsorrelativelystaticoceanographicfeatures,while“ephemeral”protectedareasareassociatedwithtransitoryoceanographicfeatures.Ephemeralareas,becauseoftheelementofuncertainty,mayneedtobelargerthanfixedprotectedareas,whichcancreatepolitical,logisticandmanagementchallenges.Whilethecore-bufferdesigncouldservepelagicandbenthicfor-agersinstaticareasaswellasfortheephemeralareas,itselementswoulddiffer.Thecoreofacoastalareawouldbedesignedtopro-tectpinnipedsfromterrestrialthreats.Ontheotherhand,thecoreofastaticpelagicareawouldbedesignedtoprotectresourcesandcontrolhigh-riskthreatssuchasfishing,andthecoreofanephemeralareawouldbedesignedtoreducecompetitionandinteractionratesintransitoryhotspots.Acoastalbufferareawouldexisttocontroldistantdisturbanceagentssuchasnoiseorhumanactivity.Astaticpelagicbufferwouldexisttocontrolrelativelylow-riskthreatssuchassoundorboattraffic,whileatransitorybufferwouldbeusedtoprovideahedgeagainsttheinherentuncertaintyinpredictingthespatio-temporaldynam-icsoftransitoryhot-spots.
UnlikeaclassicMPA,successofapinnipedprotectedareacouldleadtotheneedformoreprotectedareas,especiallyforthreat-enedorendangeredspecies.Anincreasingpopulationcouldleadeventuallytoovercrowdingandthefoundingofnewcoloniesorhaulouts,aswellastheoccupationofnewforagingareasandanincreaseinfisheriesinteractions.Becausethereisthepoten-tialofcompetitionbetweenpinnipedsandfisheries,expandingpinnipedpopulationsmayrequirelargerfisheries“setasides”forthepinnipeds.
Endangeredpinnipeds,morethananyother,requireimmediateandcompleteprotection.Thesespeciesshouldhavestrongareaprotectionsofeverybreedingcolonyandhaul-outsite.Perhapsevenmoreimportantly,manyofthesespeciesrequirepelagicprotectiontoeliminateorsignificantlyreducemortalityandinjuryduetofisheriesinteractions,whichisaprimarythreattotheviabilityofthemajorityofendangeredandthreatenedpinnipeds.Otherimportantfactorsthatrequireattentionareecosystem-basedmanagement,communitycooperation,moni-toringandadaptivemanagement,andintegrationofoverlap-pinggovernmentauthorities.Finally,aswithanyprotectedarea,designcreatespotential,butrealizedsuccessisdependentonthemanagementsystemandcompliancebyoceanusers.
Strengths and weaknesses of the MPA approach for endangered large whales Greg Donovan (InternationalWhalingCommission,UK)
Effectiveconservation,includingestablishmentofMPAs,requiresinter alia(1)goodknowledgeofthebiologyoftheanimals,espe-ciallytheirtemporalandspatialdistribution,populationstruc-tureandabundance,(2)goodknowledgeofactualandpotentialthreatstothem,includingtheirspatialandtemporaldistribu-tion,(3)appropriatemitigationmeasurestoaddressthethreats.
Suchinformationisnevereasytoobtainandtheproblemsareevengreaterwhentheanimalsaremigratoryspecies,withlargerangesincludingbothnationalwatersandthehighseas.Insuchcases,obtainingthenecessarytemporalandspatialinformationisexacerbatedbyattendantlegalandpoliticaldifficultiesinget-tingagreementonmanagementmeasures.Moreover,ifaspe-ciesisendangeredinthetruesenseoftheword,i.e.,withverylowabsoluteabundance,determiningappropriatemanagementmeasuresforwhatcanbeindividuallyverylowlikelihoodoccur-rences(e.g.,bycatchinfishinggearonmigration)canbefraughtwithdifficultiesandmustinvolvesomelevelofagreementonanecologicalcurrency.
InthecourseofexploringtheseissuesinthecontextoftheuseofMPAsasamanagementtool,somekeypointsweremade:
Wecannotmanagecetaceans;wecanonlymanagehumanimpactsoncetaceans.Decidingtodonothingisamanagementdecision.Theterm‘MPA’isgenerallynotwelldefined–thiscanbebeneficialinthatitcanprovideaflexibleconcepttodealwiththegreatvarietyofproblemsfacingspeciesandenvironments.However,thereshouldbeminimumstandardsforMMPAsiftheyaretobeeffectiveandnotmerely‘paperparks’.Whethertheyarethebesttoolforendangeredmarinemammalsdependsonthespecificproblemstheyfaceandthemostappropriatemea-suresneededtoaddressthose.Theconceptofspecificconser-vationmanagementplans(e.g.,thatforthewesterngraywhale)addressingthreatsthroughouttherangeofapopulationisveryimportant.Whereappropriate,MPAscanformanimportantcomponentofsuchplans.
AsuggestedwaytomovefowardwithMMPAsisasfollows:
• Defineobjectiveswithrespecttostatusofthepopulation.
• Assesstheirstatus.
• Determinemeasurestoensureobjectivesaremet(canbedifficultwhenlittleisknownaboutthepopulation)–thisinvolvesidentifyingandprioritizingactualandpotentialthreats,identifyingandimplementingmitigationmeasures.
• Monitortomakesureyouhavegotthingsright.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
12
Summary of Discussion Itwasagreedthatwhilethereisaneedtofocusoncriticallyendangeredspecies,thisshouldnotbeatthecostofignoringotherproblemssuchthatweproducemoreendangeredspecies.AnMPAisonlyonetooltoaccomplishthis.MPAshavetobeactiveandeffective.EvenwhenpopulationshaverecoveredthereisavalueinkeepingtheprotectionaffordedbyMPAsrecogniz-ingotherpossiblegoalsofanMPAincludingenhancedscientificresearchandecotourismthatraisespublicawarenessofenvi-ronmentalproblems.Itisimportantnottolosesightofthebigpicture:weshouldstriveultimatelyto‘manage’thewholeoceanwisely,notonlyadesignatedsubset.
Evenwhereproblemsarewellknown,MPAsandotherconserva-tionmeasuresaredifficulttoeffectivelyimplement.Forexample,considerableefforthasbeenmadetotrytoreversethedeclineofthevaquita;whilethedeclinehasbeenslowedithasnotbeenreversedandtimeisrunningout.Inmanyinstances,especiallyindevelopingcountries,thehumansocio-economicissuesmustberecognizedandaddressedonarealistictimescaletoavoidcatastrophe.FishermenintheGulfofCaliforniawereofferedabuyouttoselltheirlicenseandboats,othersdecidedtorentouttheirboats.Therewasagroupthathelpedthefishermendecidewhattodowiththebuyoutmoneytheyreceived.Therewasalsotheoptionforthefishermentousealternativefishinggearthatislessharmfultothevaquita.Sometimesbuybackprogramsareineffective.ToemphasizeapointthatJohnReynoldsmade,ifwelookathumansuccessforprotectingoceans,wefailoften.Itisimportanttorealizethatacceptingthestateofplaymaynotgetusanywhere.Itisagreattimeforthinkingoutsidethebox.Weneedtothinkcreatively.
Therearemanyareasthathavemultipleobjectivesthatoffersomeprotectionforpinnipeds.Pinnipedshavespecialcharacteristics,whichmayrequiretheimplementationofparticularprotectionsbeyondtheclassicMPAprotections.Withoutthat,thepinnipedMPAmayfail.Wearestillatthebeginningstagesofdetermin-ingwhatpinnipedMPAsshouldbe.
Weshouldneverbecomplacent–establishmentofMPAs(orothermanagementmeasures)ismerelythestart.Theymusthavecarefullydesigned,well-fundedmanagementplansthatincludequantifiedobjectivesandintegratedmonitoringtoassesseffec-tiveness.Thisisparticularlydifficultbutnolessimportantforthemorecomplicatedcumulativeeffects–itisoftendifficulttogetpeopletomobilizebehindprotectionagainstthosethreatsasopposedtoeasilyidentifiedsingleissues.Itishardtohaveallofthethreatsundercontrol,especiallyforwide-rangingspeciesthatmovewithintheterritorialwatersofseveralcountriesaswellasthehighseas.
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
13
Panel 2: Refining Our Understanding of Marine Mammal Critical Habitat and Hotspots, Wading Through Large, Heterogeneous Masses of Data, to Inform MMPA Designation (including on the High Seas)
Coordinators: Kristin Kaschner(Albert-Ludwigs-UniversityofFreiburg,Germany)andRob Williams(UniversityofSt.Andrews,UK)
Introduction and Panel OverviewMarinemammalsandtheirhabitatsfacemultiple,urgentthreats,andMPAscanhelpmitigatethosethreats.Atitscore,thispro-cesscanbethoughtofasspatialconservationprioritization.Ultimately,theprocessofcreatingMMPAsinvolvesachoiceaboutwhichareasrequiremoreprotectionfromhumanactivitiesthanothers.Thisjobisimportantandurgent,butrequiresthatourdecisionsbebasedonsoundscienceinordertobetranspar-ent,repeatableandrobusttouncertainty.
Inpractice,oneofthebiggestproblemstocopewithwhenpri-oritizingmarinemammalhabitatstoprotectisthefactthatourdataontheirdistributionandabundanceisinherentlypatchy.Itisimportanttoensurethatwedonotinadvertentlycreate“DataProtectedAreas”,whereourpictureofanimaldistributionisheavilybiasedbythedistributionofresearcheffort.Afterall,therehasneverbeenoneglobalsurveytoprovideasnapshotofmarinemammaldistribution,sothecombinationofexistingsurveydataprovideanopportunisticcollectionofdisparatestudiesthatvaryspatiallyindataqualityandquantity.Thereareanumberofsoftwaretoolstosupportdecisionmaking,buttheyallhaveatendencytogravitatetowardsdata-richareas,andthistendencyneedstobeaddressedtogiveunbiasedresults.Takentoextremes,thiscouldcreateanissueofenvironmentaljustice,inwhichMMPAsaremostlikelytobeplacedinwatersunderjurisdictionofcountriesthatspendthemostmoneyonmarinemammalscience.
Thispanelintroducestheproblemofdecision-makinginthefaceofdatagaps,aswellasproposingsometoolsandsolutions.Weusedthesix-stageprocessofsystematicconservationplanning(Margules&Pressey2000)tostructurethefourpaneltalks.Thesestepsinclude:
• Compilingdataonthebiodiversityoftheplanningregion(discussedbyRobWilliamsandKristinKaschner).
• Identifyingconservationgoalsfortheplanningregion(discussedbyJessicaRedfern).
• Reviewingexistingconservationareas(discussedbySandraPompa).
• Selectingadditionalconservationareas(discussedbySandraPompa,withanemphasisondecision-supportsoftwaretools).
• Implementingconservationactions(discussedthroughouttheconference).
• Maintainingtherequiredvaluesofconservationareas(discussedthroughouttheconference).
Cetacean data: gaps and challenges for systematic marine conservation planningRob Williams (SeaMammalResearchUnit,UniversityofSt.Andrews,UK)
Thefocusofmytalk,compilingavailabledataonbiodiversity,isakintoaconservationassessmentinthemarinespatialplan-ningliterature.Aconservationassessmentisdesignedtoidentifydatagaps.InthecontextofMMPAs,akeyproblemtoovercomeisthedifficultyincombiningdatatypes.Spatialplanningalgo-rithmsrankareasonsimpledecisionrules,sodataneedtobeincommoncurrencylikedensity,countsorprobabilityofpres-ence.Thismakesitdifficulttoincorporateallofthedatawehaveonmarinemammaldistributionfromlinetransectandmark-recapturesurveys,acousticdata,opportunisticsightings,telemetrydataandwhalingrecords.Thereisanurgentneedforstatisticalmethodologicaldevelopmenttoproviderobustesti-matesofcetaceandistributionusingdatathatweredesignedtoestimatedifferentthings.
Mytalkoutlinestheproblemusingtworeal-worldcasestudiesfromtheWiderCaribbeanMarineRegion(WC)andtheNorthEastPacificMarineRegion(NEP).KristinKaschnerrecentlyledastudytodigitizedatafromvisualcetaceanlinetransectsurveyspublishedworldwide.Thisglobalgapanalysisidenti-fiedthatthevastmajorityofpublishedestimatesofcetaceandensityinWCcomefromwatersunderUSjurisdiction.Onepressingproblemthatthisanalysishighlightedistheneedfornewstatisticalmethodstoallowspatialplanninginputstomakebetteruseofinformationotherthandensityestimates,suchasfromthegraywhalebreedinglagoonsofMéxico,orthelong-termphoto-identificationstudiesofkillerwhalesandhumpbackwhales.Becausetheprocessofspatialconservationprioritization
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
14
inherentlyinvolvesrankingsomesitesoverothers,methodsareneededtointegratealltheinformationarisingfromthevariouswaysthatwestudycetaceans,toallowcross-studyandbetween-sitecomparisonsfromdifferentdatatypes.IntheNEP,thelarge-scalepictureofcetaceandensityisstronglyinfluencedbyoneplatform-of-opportunitysurveythatwasconductedinthe1980sforthreespecies.Beyondthis,thereisanenormousdisparityindataquantitywithintheregion.MoresurveyefforthasbeenconductedbyNOAA’sSouthwestFisheriesScienceCenterintheEasternTropicalPacificandtheCaliforniaCurrentthanintherestoftheNEPcombined.
Havingintroducedtheproblemofdatagaps,let’sconsiderana-lyticalsolutions.Insummary,thesesolutionsareclusteredinafewmainareas:
• Goingoutandfillinggapswithrealdata,inatleastafewrandomlysampledsites(thispresentation).
• Tryprioritizingareasbasedonthreats,ratherthananimals(thispresentation).
• Settingprecautionarytargets,honestaboutrealdatavs.predictionsanduncertainty(JessicaRedfern’spresentationbelow).
• Settingtargetsforonepriorityspeciesandhopingitservesanumbrellafunction(JessicaRedfern’spresentationbelow).
• Usingtoolsthatarerobusttogaps(SandraPompa’spresentationbelow).
• Usingstatisticalmodelstofillingapsandquantifyuncertainty(KristinKaschner’spresentationbelow).
• Improvingmethodstosynthesizetelemetrydata,photo-ID,whalingrecordsandopportunisticsightings(e.g.,Pirottaetal.20112).
Onepossiblewayto“leveltheplayingfield”andfillindatagapswouldbetoconducttwoparallelspatialconservationprioriti-zationexercises:oneonexisting,empiricaldensityestimates,andanotheronaderivedvaluesuchasthenumberofspeciespredictedtobeinaregion(seeKristinKaschnerpresentationbelow).Iftheresultsaresimilar,thedatagapsmaynotbeaprob-lem.Iftheydiffer,moreworkisneededtopayattentiontodatagaps.Theideaofusingthepredictednumberofspeciespresenthastheattractivequalityofprotectingmultiplespeciessimul-taneously,i.e.,meetingbiodiversitytargets,andanalyticallyhastheappealingpropertythatpredictionscanbemadeforeverypointintheworldocean,regardlessofwhetherasurveyhasevertakenplacethere.Thedownsideisthatprotectinghabitatusedbymultiplespeciesmayactuallyprotecthabitatthatisperiph-erallyusedbymanyspecies,butmayfailtoprotectcorehabitatforanyonespecies.Worse,biodiversitypatternsderivedfrommerepresence/absencerangemapsfailtorecognizethattherearepreferredhabitatswithinranges.
2 Pirotta,E.etal.2011.Modellingspermwhalehabitatpreference:anovelapproachcombiningtransectandfollowdata.Marine Ecology Progress Series436:257-272.
Atfirstglance,itmaybeeasytodismissthisconcernastheusualcomplaintofscientistswantingmoredata.Thepointofthispaneldiscussionisthatthisisanissuerelatingtothequal-ityandcoverageofdata,ratherthanthequantityofdata.Infact,having“moredata”mayworsentheproblemifitfailstoaddressthesystemicproblemofcoverage.Fortunately,marinemammalscientistshaveastrongtraditionofpartneringwithstatisticianstodevelopmethodsthatarerobusttonon-system-aticsampling.Asaresultofcopingwithlogisticalconstraintsofstudyingfree-rangingmarinemammals,themarinemammalsciencecommunityhashadtodevelopexpertisewithestimat-ingabundance,densityanddistributionfromsparsedataandcopingwithuncertainty.Ourresearchcommunityhasrefinedtheseskillsovertimeasabundanceestimatestakeonconten-tiousmeaninginthecontextofwhalingorbycatchmortalitylimits.Ournextchallengeasascientificcommunityistoinvestinbuildingstatisticallyrobustestimatesofmarinemammaldistributionthatarepeerreviewedandtakenasseriouslyaswetakeabundanceestimates.
Oneofthelessonstoemergefrommarinemammalscienceandmanagementoverthelastfewdecadesisthatpoliciesbenefitfromanimplicitrewardforscience.Anexampleofthisisthepoten-tialbiologicalremovalequationundertheUSMarineMammalProtectionAct,inwhichmoreprecisesurveyestimatesgener-allyallowhigherfisheries-relatedmortalitylimits,whichinturnwouldcarrylowersocio-economiccosts.Iseevalueinasimilar“rewardforscience”inmarinespatialplanning.Inmyopinion,thiscouldlivecomfortablywithinasystematicconservationplanningframeworkatthestageofsettingtargetsorobjectives(discussedbelowbyJessicaRedfern).Conceptually,thebettertheinformationavailable,thesmallertheMPAcouldbewhilestillmeetingobjectivesandbeingprecautionary.Inotherwords,onecouldadjustMPAtargetsupwardtocompensateforbiasedormissingdataoruntestedpredictions.
Nevertheless,therewillalwaysbegapsinourinformationonmarinemammaldistribution.AphilosophicallydifferentapproachwouldbetoguideMMPAplacementbythedistribu-tionofhumanthreats,ratherthandistributionofanimals.Afterall,MPAsaretoolstoseparatewildlifefromsomethreateningprocess,andifitisdifficulttogetunbiaseddataonwildlifedistribution,thengooddistributiondataonthreatscouldbeamoretractablealternative.Oneproxyforhuman-causedthreatsisavailableintheformofglobalmapsonshippingactivity.Shippingintensityisrelatedtoshipstrikerisk,andalsoprovidesanimportantinputforproducingaglobalmapofoceannoise.Ideally,thiscouldinformthedesignof“quietMPAs”inplacesthatareimportanttocetaceansbutnotusedmuchbyshipping.IseeimportantlinkagestobemadebetweentheMMPAandoceannoisecommunities,becausethedataweneedtomapoceannoisegloballywillalsohelpustofillingapsinmarinemammaldistribution.Onesuggestioncouldbeforourcommu-nitytojoinforceswiththeupcomingInternationalQuietOceanExperiment,whereourdatagapscouldbetargetedforpassiveacousticmonitoring.
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
15
Identifying critical habitat for baleen whales in the eastern tropical Pacific OceanJessica V. Redfern (SouthwestFisheriesScienceCenter,NOAAFisheries,USA)
Coauthors: Rob Williams(SeaMammalResearchUnit,UK),Daniel M. Palacios(SouthwestFisheriesScienceCenter,USA),Fernando Félix(MuseodeBallenas,Ecuador),Corey Sheredy(SouthwestFisheriesScienceCenter,NOAAFisheries,USA),Thomas J. Moore(SouthwestFisheriesScienceCenter,NOAAFisheries,USA),Kristin Rasmussen(Panacetacea,Panama),Ursula Gonzalez-Peral(UniversidadAutónomadeBajaCaliforniaSur,México),Jorge Urbán Ramirez(UniversidadAutónomadeBajaCaliforniaSur,México),Linda Nichol(FisheriesandOceans,Canada),andLisa T. Ballance(SouthwestFisheriesScienceCenter,NOAAFisheries,USA)
Manyspeciesofbaleenwhalesmigratelongdistancesbetweenbreedingandfeedingareas.Thesespeciesareexposedtoanthro-pogenicthreatsintheirfeedingandbreedingareasandalongtheirmigrationroutes;threatsincludeentanglementinfishinggear,shipstrikes,oceannoise,contaminants,andclimatechange.Mitigatingthesethreatsrequiresatransboundary,systematicplanningapproach.WeusethreespeciesofbaleenwhalesintheEasternTropicalPacific(ETP)toexploreseveralcomponentsoftheplanningprocess.
TheETPisa20millionkm2,open-oceansystemthatisseason-allyoccupiedbymigratoryblueandhumpbackwhalesfrombothnorthernandsouthernhemispheres;italsohostsimportantnumbersofresidentBryde’swhales.Weuse10yearsoflarge-scalesurveyeffortsinoffshorewaterstocomparethreemethodsforpredictingspeciesdensity:habitatmodels(usingseasurfacetemperature,salinity,andchlorophyll,mixed-layerdepth,andseafloordepthaspredictorvariables),staticmodels(usinglatitude,longitude,anddepthaspredictorvariables),andinversedistanceweightedinterpolationofdailydensityestimates.Generalizedadditivemodelswereusedtorelatehabitatandstaticpredictorvariablestoaneffort-correctedestimateofthenumberofwhales.Eachmethodwasusedtoderiveasynopticgridofdensityforblue,humpback,andBryde’swhales.Thesegridswereusedtoexplorethetrade-offbetweenmodelcomplexityandaccuratelycapturinghotspotsofspeciesdensity.Forhumpbackwhales,thegridswerealsocomparedtominimumconvexpolygonscreatedfrommother-calfsightingsincoastalsurveysofbreedingareasoffMéxico,CostaRica,Panama,andEcuador.Thiscomparisonguidedtheselectionofthebestmethodtoproducedensitygridsforallspecies.
Differentmetricshavebeensuggestedfordelineatingcriticalhabitat(e.g.,protectingapercentageofapopulation,protectingareasofknownoccurrence,orprotectingknownbreedingorfeedingareas).Wecomparedtheresultsofusingmultiplemet-ricstodelineatecriticalhabitatinthefinaldensitygridsforeachspecies.Thesecomparisonsprovidethebasisforfurtherman-agementactionsrelativetocriticalhabitat.First,theyidentify
areaswherefurtherdatacollectioneffortsareneeded.Second,theyallowstakeholdersfrommultiplecountriestounderstandhowspecificconservationmetricsproducecriticalhabitatareas.
Conservation planning tools available for MMPAs: Assumptions, strengths and weaknesses Sandra Pompa (InstitutodeEcología,UniversidadNacionalAutónomadeMéxico,México)
AvailabletoolsforconservationplanningincludeResNet,Marxan,C-Plan,ConsNet,MarxEnt,MarzoneandZonation.Thechoiceofsoftwaretooldependsonthedata,theobjectives,andtheexpectedresults.Threeofthesekeytoolsarecomparedbelow.
ResNet3isbasedonvariationsandextensionsofsoftwareorigi-nallyproposedbyMargulesetal.(1988).Ifaregionisdividedintoasetofplaces(onthebasisofgeographicalcoordinates,eco-logicalboundaries,etc.)ResNetalgorithmsorderthoseplacesbytheirbiodiversitycontent.Richness,rarityandcomplementarityareincorporatedintothesealgorithms.
Amongtheassumptionsarethatadefinitetargetissetintheformof(1)adequaterepresentationofeachsurrogate,thatis,thenumberofselectedplacesinwhichthatsurrogatemustbepres-ent;(2)maximumallowedarea;or(3)maximumallowedcostofaproposedsetofconservedplaces.Thegoalofthealgorithmsistoachievethesettargetefficientlybyselectingasfewplacesaspossiblethattogetherreachtheconservationgoal.Intermsofaccessibilityanduse,ResNetisofferedasafreedownload,takesupsmalldiskspace,andisfast-running;a1/0databaseisneeded.
Marxan isintendedtosolveaparticularclassofreserve-designproblemsinwhichthegoalistoachievesomeminimumrepre-sentationofbiodiversityfeaturesforthesmallestpossiblecost.Givenreasonablycomprehensivedataonspecies,habitats,and/orotherrelevantbiodiversityfeatures,Marxanaimstoidentifythereservesystem(acombinationofplanningunits)thatwillmeetuser-defined,cost-effectivebiodiversitytargets.OnefeaturefoundinMarxanisthatitemploysa“boundarylengthmodifier”,whichincreasesthecontinuityofreservesystems.SomeofthelimitationsandpitfallsofMarxanareits(1)inabilitytodealwithissuesofdemographicinter-connectedness;and(2)inmarinesystems,thepresenceofabiologicalfeaturedoesnotguaranteethepersistenceofthatfeatureintheabsenceofthesurround-ingecosystem–aconceptgenerallyknownas“connectivity”.
C-Plan mapstheoptionsandweighsthevariablesforachievinganexplicitconservationgoalinaregion,calculatinganddisplay-inginformationthatcanbeusedtoguideconservationplanningdecisions(e.g.,theextenttowhichtheconservationtargetforanyparticularfeaturehasbeenreachedbyconservationdecisionsmadeuptothatpoint).Oneofthekeypiecesofinformationthat
3 Margules,C.R.,Nicholls,A.O.andPressey,R.L.1988.Selectingnetworksofreservestomaximisebiologicaldiversity.Biol. Conserv.43,63-76.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
16
C-Plancalculatesanddisplaysistheirreplaceabilityofeachsiteintheplanningregion.Theirreplaceabilityofasitecanbeusedasaguidetotheimportanceofthatsiteforachievingaregionalconservationgoal.Theirreplaceabilitypredictorgeneratesan“average”siteassumingeachfeatureisspreadevenlyacrossallavailablesites.However,alimitationofthismeasureisthatitrevealsnothingabouthowmanyfeatureswillfailtomeettheirtargetifthesiteisnotselected.
Itisimportanttoacknowledgethatdataaresometimesscarce,andsamplingefforttendstobeveryheterogeneous,resultinginlargespatialandtemporaldatagaps.Thisbringstheneedtotryto“statisticallyflatten”theavailabledata.Alwaysbearinmindthateachalgorithmisnothingbutatoolthatwillkeepdevel-opingthroughtime.Basedonthedatayou’vechosen,pickthesoftwarethatbestfitsyourconservationneeds.Rememberyourspecificconservationobjectives:species,environment,migra-torycorridors,endemism,restrictedrange,andsoforth.Finally,makesureyourresults,includingallcaveats,arebroadcastedtopolicyanddecisionmakers,andthenparticipateinthedesignoftheMPAandthemanagementplanwiththelocalcommuni-tiesandcorrespondingnationalandinternationalauthoritiestoensurethatthescientificlimitationsanduncertaintiesaretakenintoaccount.
Where do we go from here: filling gaps and building models to predict densities in unsurveyed areas, and validating predictions with new dataKristin Kaschner (EvolutionaryBiologyandEcologyLab,Albert-Ludwigs-UniversityofFreiburg,Germany)
AsdiscussedinRobWilliams’presentation,therecentlycon-ductedanalysisofglobalvisualline-transectsurveysshowstheextremeheterogeneityofsurveyeffortdistributionandillustratestheprevailinglargegapsinsurveycoverage.Thesegapsamounttoalmostthreequartersoftheworld’soceans.Giventhevastnessofthemarineenvironmentandthehigheffortandexpenditurerequired,comprehensiveandfrequentmonitoringofmarinemammalspecies’occurrenceanddensitieswillremainpatchyfortheforeseeablefuture,evenunderthebestcircumstances.
Inadditiontothesolutionsdiscussedbypreviousspeakers,Ithereforeproposethedevelopmentofaglobaldatarepositoryforgeo-referencedmarinemammalabundanceestimates.ThiswouldcomplementtheexistingOBIS-SEAMAPportalwhichfocusesonmarinemammalpointoccurrencerecords.Ashigh-lightedearlier,itcouldideallybesupplementedbydevelopingmethodstostandardizeoutputsfromdifferentmonitoringoranalysistechniquesfromvariablesources,thusallowingthedirectcomparisonofallexistinginformationandknowledgeaboutmarinemammalabundanceandoccurrencewithinasinglecomprehensiveframework.Thiscouldthenserveasastartingpointforthedevelopmentofacost-effectiveglobalstrategyforoptimizingdatacollectioneffortswhenplanningfuturemarine
mammalmonitoringschemes,includingsurveydesignsthatspecificallyfocusonrandomizedsubsetsofunsurveyedareas.
Asaparalleltask,statisticalmodelsthatpredictspeciesoccur-renceordensitysurfacesfromlinetransectsurveydataandlocalenvironmentalconditionscouldbeexpandedtomakeinferencesaboutcetaceandensitiesbeyondsurveyedareas.Combinedwithenvironmentalnichemodels,thesetechniquescouldbeusedtopredictglobaldensitiesofmarinemammalsbyextrapolatingthestatisticalrelationshipbetweenobserveddensitiesandcor-respondingpredictedhabitatsuitabilitytounsurveyedareas.Thepreliminaryresultspresentedinthistalkareintendedtoillustratethegeneralprinciple,butexistingmodelswillneedtobedevelopedmuchfurtherinthefuture.Ienvisionanitera-tiveprocesseventuallyembeddingbothgap-fillingapproaches:modeloutputsofpredicteddensitiesthatwouldbevalidatedandimprovedwithnewlycollectedmonitoringdataasitbecomesavailable,andwhichtheninturnwouldinformmanagementdecisionsaboutthefocusoffuturemonitoringefforts.
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
17
Keynote 2: Marine Mammals That Have Already Been Lost – Lessons Learned? Randall ReevesChair,IUCNSSCCetaceanSpecialistGroup,andOkapiWildlifeAssociates,Canada
FromtheSocietyforMarineMammalogy’scurrentlyacceptedlistofmarinemammalsoftheworld,fivespecies–1otariid,1phocid,1cetacean,1sirenian,1mustelid–areconsideredextinct;thebaiji’sextinctionrepresentsthelossofanentirecetaceanfamily.Althoughthatnumberseemsrelativelysmall(5of133,or<4%),itdoesnotbegintorepresentthetruestateofloss.Itdisguisesthescaleoflossintermsofanimalabundanceanddistributionaswellasecosystemfunction.Also,ittakesnoaccountoftheinfra-speciesgeneticandmorphologicdiversityandadaptivebehaviorthatarelostwhengeographicallyseparatepopulationsdisappear.
Littlecanbelearnedfromtheextinctionoftheseamink,Steller’sseacow,oreventheCaribbeanmonksealandJapanesesealion,exceptperhapsthatunregulatedhuntingofvulnerableendem-icsisarecipeforextinction.
Somelessonsmightbelearnedthoughfromthebaiji’srecentdemise,e.g.,theimportanceofrigorousdiagnosisofcausation,theneedtoactswiftlyandaggressivelytoaddressriskfactors,andthedangerofallowingprotected-areadesignationswithoutrealmanagementteethtogiveafalsesenseofsecurity.ThebeliefthatareasalongtheYangtzeRiverthathadbeendesignatedandreportedlymanagedas“naturalreserves”gavethebaijisomekindofaddedprotectionfromfisheryimpactsprovedtobemerewishfulthinking.Assuch,itcontributedtocomplacencyandhelpedstrengthenresistancetoex situconservationalternatives,e.g.,thecaptureofdolphinstostocka“semi-naturalreserve”.
Endemismtorelativelysmallregionsincreasesvulnerability(forexample,withallfiveextinc-tionsmentionedabove)although,onthepositiveside,itmightalso,atleastinprinciple,sim-plifyprotectioneffortswhenthespeciesoccursinonlyonecountry.Still,thisdidnothelpthebaiji,nordoesitseemtobehelpingthevaquita.
Duringthequestionandanswersessionfollowingthepresentation,itwasnotedthatMediterraneanmonksealsareprobablygonefromtheBlackSea,thelastsightingtherehavingbeeninthelate1990s.Also,itwassuggestedthattheworld’scurrentlydominantpoliticalandeconomicregimesarenotdesignedtoprotectandpreservenaturalecosystemsorbiodiversity.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
Randall Reeves provided a keynote presentation on the opening day of the conference.
Photo by Agence Kréöl
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
18
Blue whale mother and calf in proposed Costa Rica Dome High Seas Transboundary MPA Lucy Molleson
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
19
Panel 3 and 4 (combined): Using Marine Spatial Planning and Ecosystem-based Management to Address Broad Threats to Marine Mammals
Coordinator and Chair: Tundi Agardy (SoundSeas,USA)
IntroductionThiscombinedsessionexploredthebroadscaleimpactstomarinemammalsandhowthesethreatanalysescaninformpol-icymakers.Thepanelbeganwithabroadoverviewofanthropo-genicimpactsonmarinemammalsandhowunderstandingofallthreatsactingcumulativelyovertimeandoftensimultaneouslyinthesamelocalecanbeaddressedwithinanecosystem-basedmanagement(EBM)framework,usingmarinespatialplanning(MSP).Paneliststhenreflectedontheirexperiencesofbringingscientificinformationtobearonpressuresorthreatstoderivestrategiesformarinemammalconservation,withpresentationsonscientificassessmentsmadeorinprocessintheCaribbeanandPacificFrenchOverseasTerritories,MSPperformedinBangladesh,andMarineBioregionalPlanningundertakeninAustralia.PanelistsalsoaddressedMSPforeffectivemanage-mentofmarinemammalsbasedondiverseexperiencesaroundtheworld.
Broad-scale impacts and the use of MPAs and MSP to advance EBM in the service of conservationTundi Agardy (SoundSeas,USA)
Marineecosystemandspeciesconservationisacomplicatedaffair:theeasiestmanagementtoolsarethosethatfocusonthebenthosandmorefixedspecies.Theconservationofmarinemammalsmustgowellbeyond,especiallyincasesofmigratoryspeciesthattravelgreatdistances.Recognizingtheconnectionsbetweenbiotawithinanecosystem,andbetweenecosystemsisanecessaryfirststep–butwhatcanbedonetomaintainthoseconnections?
Spatialmanagementcanallowustobemorecomprehensiveandeffective.Thespatialmanagementtools:marineprotectedareas(MPAs),MPAnetworks,marinespatialplanning(MSP)andtheoceanzoningthatmayresultfromitcanallunderpinecosystem-basedmanagement(EBM).EBMrecognizesthefullarrayofinteractionswithinanecosystem,allowingustoman-ageimpactsontheecosystem.Aquickreviewofthetoolssug-geststhatMPAsaregoodatprotectingbenthosandresidentspecies,whileMPAnetworkscancapturemoreoftheecologicalrequirementsofmigratoryorhighlymobilespecies.MSPismore
powerfulstill,sinceitcanconsidermultiplethreatstoecosys-temsoverwideareas,andfindwaystoaccommodatedifferentusesinawaythatkeepsresourceusesustainable.
EBM,whendonesuccessfully,allowsfullconsiderationofallcomponentsoftargetecosystems,andthehealthandproductivityofecosystemsthatareinterlinkedtothem.Marinemammalsfitintothishierarchyintwoways:marinemammals“need”EBMinthesensethateffectiveconservationrequiresmanaginghumanimpactsnotonlyonthespeciesthemselves,butalsoonthesys-temsthatsupportthem.However,thereverseisalsotrue:EBM“needs”marinemammals,foratleastthreereasons:
• IconicmarinemammalsactasflagshipsthatcangeneratepoliticalwilltodoEBM.
• Marinemammalspeciescanactas“umbrella”specieswhoseconservationforcestheconsiderationofwiderecosystemelements.
• Marinemammalsciencecaninformplannersonlocationofcriticallyimportantareastoprotectusingspatialmanagementtools.
The REMMOA surveys to establish baseline knowledge on pelagic megafauna for an ecosystem-based marine planning strategyVincent Ridoux (CentredeRecherchesurlesMammifèresMarins,ObservatoirePelagis,UniversitédeLaRochelle-CNRS,France)
Coauthors: Olivier Van Canneyt,Ghislain DorémusandSophie Laran(CentredeRecherchesurlesMammifèresMarins,ObservatoirePelagis,UniversitédeLaRochelle-CNRS,France)andPierre Watremez(Agencedesairesmarinesproté-gées,France)
TheREMMOA4projectaimstomapdiversityandrelativeabun-danceofmarinemammalsandotherpelagicmegafaunaacrossalltropicalregionsoftheFrenchEEZ,andtoidentifyareasofhigheranthropogenicpressure.Fourbroadregionsweredefined:NWAtlanticOcean,SWIndianOcean,SWPacificOceanandFrenchPolynesia.Themulti-targetsurveyprotocolfollowedastandardline-transectmethodologyformarinemammals,sea4 REcensement des Mammifères marins et autres Mégafaunes pélagiques par Observation Aérienne(Censusofmarinemammalsandotherpelagicmegafaunabyaerialsurvey)
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
20
turtles,largefishandhumanactivities,andastriptransectmeth-odologyforseabirdsandmacro-debris.Todate,NWAtlantic(16,000kmofeffort),SWIndian(90,000kmofeffort)andFrenchPolynesia(99,000kmofeffort)havebeensurveyed.TheSWPacific(90,000kmofeffort)surveysareplannedforNovember2012toFebruary2013;analysesareinprogress.
Thestrengthoftheprojectisitspotentialforcomparisonbetweenandwithinregions,aswellasbetweenyears.Encounterrateswereselectedasasimpleindicatorofdensity.Strongcontrastswerefoundincetaceanencounterrates,withhighestvaluesintheMozambiqueChannel,theSeychellesandoffFrenchGuiana;intermediatevaluesintheMarquesas;andlowestdensitiesintheCaribbean,theMascareignes(MascareneIslands)aswellasincentralandsouthernPolynesia.Variationincetaceandensitiesbetweenoligotrophicandproductiveareasoftheoceansvariedinaratioofc.1-30forsmalldelphinidsagainstonlyc.1-5inbeakedwhales,illustratingthelessersensitivityofthelattertoepipelagicbiologicalproduction.HotspotsofseabirddensitieswereintheCaribbean,theMozambiqueChannel,theSeychelles,theMarquesasIslandsandtheTuamotu.SeaturtlesweremostfrequentlyencounteredintheshelfwatersofFrenchGuiana,westernMadagascarandtheSeychelles,butturtledensitiesinPolynesiawereparticularlylow.Habitatandspatialmodelingwillallowtheproductionoftaxon-specificmodels.Theircom-binationintoasingletoppredatorhabitatmodelundervariousweightingwillbemadedependingontaxon-specificvulnerabilityaswellasonspatialmodelsofanthropogenicrisk.
Furtherstepsincludethecompletionofthesurveyseriesin2013andoftheanalysesin2015,theincorporationoftheresultsintomarinestrategicregionalanalysesalreadyconductedbytheAgencyforMPAsandthedevelopmentofamonitoringstrat-egy.Regionalcooperation,capacitybuildingandexchangesofinformationwithislandcommunitiesareanintegralpartofthesurveys.
Spatial planning, ecosystem-based management (EBM) and adaptation to climate change: A case study on freshwater cetaceans in waterways of the Sundarbans mangrove forest, Bangladesh Brian D. Smith(WildlifeConservationSociety/WCS,USA)
Coauthors: Rubaiyat Mowgli Mansur,Elisabeth Fahrni Mansur,andZahangir Alom(WCS,Bangladesh)
WaterwaysoftheSundarbansmangroveforestarecharacter-izedbyhighbiodiversity,includingendangeredGangesRiverandIrrawaddydolphins,andotherspeciesofkeyconservationinterest.Aquaticecologyintheforestissubjecttoextremepres-surefromalargeandgrowinghumanpopulationwhosesurvivallargelydependsontheexploitationofnaturalresources.Alteredfreshwaterandsedimenttransportregimescausedbyupstream
waterdevelopmentandclimatechange,includingsea-levelrise,arecausingmajorchangestotheecologyoftheSundarbans.Theseconsiderationspointtowardsspatialplanning(SP)andecosystem-basedmanagement(EBM)ascriticalforconservingfreshwatercetaceansinthisecologicallycomplexandhuman-impactedenvironment.
Surveysofdistributionandabundancewereavitalfirststep.Concurrentcountsinallnavigablewaterwaysresultedinabun-danceestimatesof225(CV=12.6%)GangesRiverdolphinsand451(CV=9.6%)Irrawaddydolphins.Duringlow-waterandhigh-waterseasonsurveys,wecollectedasuiteofenvironmentaldatatoinvestigatehabitatpreferences,predictseasonallocationsofhighdensityoccurrence,andestablishabaselineforlong-termmonitoring.GangesRiverdolphinsgenerallyoccupythenorth-eastlow-salinityportionoftheforestwhileIrrawaddydolphinsoccupythesouthwesthigh-salinityportionwithasmallzoneofoverlap.Duringthehigh-waterseason,withdecreasingsalinity,thedistributionofGangesRiverdolphinsexpandsandthedis-tributionofIrrawaddydolphinsshrinkstowardsthesouthwest.Habitatselectionmodelsindicatethatbothspeciesdependonlow-salinityandchannelconfluenceswhicharedeterminedbyfreshwaterflow(includingsediments)andsea-levelforcing.Thismakesthesedolphinsparticularlysensitivetohabitatlossduetoupstreamwaterdevelopmentandclimatechange.
Toidentifykeyareasofconservationimportanceweestablishedadolphinsightingnetworkamongcaptainsofnaturetourismvessels.Six5-kmchannelsegmentswereidentifiedascetaceanhotspotsduringmorethan26,000kmofsearcheffortconductedbythecaptains.Thehotspotssegmentsaccountedfor49%ofmorethan1,000GangesRiverdolphinsightingsand23%ofalmost300ofIrrawaddydolphinsightings.Thesehotspotseg-mentswereconsolidatedintothreeprotectedareas(PAs)withtheboundariesslightlyalteredtotakeintoaccounthumanuseandexistingmanagementinfrastructure.AlthoughthePAscoveronlyarelativelysmallarea,theyincludekeyhabitatwherebothspeciesaremostthreatenedbyhumanactivities.
Anadaptivelymanagedprotectedareanetworkforfreshwa-terdolphinscouldfunctionasa“livinglaboratory”fortestingadaptiveresponsestoclimate-changeandprovideacriticalsafetynetforensuringthelong-termpersistenceofthesethreat-ened,iconicspeciesandtheecologicalsystemuponwhichtheydepend.Freshwaterdolphinsintegrateclimaterelatedchangesfromthemountainstothesea.Thismeansthattheirfine-scaledistribution,movementpatterns,andforagingbehaviorcanbeinformativeforadaptiveresourcemanagement.Aslarge,mobilepredators,themannerbywhichthesefreshwaterdolphinssat-isfytheirlifehistoryneedsmaygivethemparticularvalueforidentifyingecologicallysignificantattributesforsite-basedpro-tection.Cetaceanscananchorecosystem-basedinitiativesforestablishingprotectedareasespeciallywhentheanimalsareviewedfavorablybylocalpeople,whichisthecaseamongmostculturesinAsiaincludingBangladesh.
EBMreferstoaspectrumofapproachesrangingfromthecon-siderationofmultipletaxatotheoptimizationofmanagementstrategiesforallelementsofanecosystem.ProbablynoPAs
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
21
thatincludecetaceansfullyachievethelatterbutEBMshouldbeseenasaworkinprogress.Aparticipatorystrategyhasbeenextremelyhelpfulforhelpingustomovefartheralongthespec-trumofaddressingallelementsoftheecosystem.
Takehomelessonsfromourexperienceare:
• SPandecosystem-basedapproachesareparticularlyrelevantforprotectingcetaceansinbiologicallydiverseandhighlyhuman-impactedecosystems.
• CetaceanscananchortheestablishmentofPAsandinformSPandEBMapproachesthroughunderstandingtheirpatternsofhabitatuse.
• ComprehensiveEBMisatallorder,butwemuststartsomeplace.
• Freshwatercetaceansmayprovideabiologicalshortcutforinvestigatingandmonitoringotherelementsoftheecosystem.
• Aparticipatoryapproachisessential,especiallyinadenselyhuman-populatedcountrysuchasBangladesh,tobuildinformedconstituenciesandmanagementcapacityforimplementingSPandEBMpractices.
Marine Bioregional Planning – an ecosystem-based management approachChris Schweizer (DepartmentofSustainability,Environment,Water,PopulationandCommunities,Australia)
Ecosystem-basedmanagementrecognizesthatallelementsofanecosystemareinterconnectedandrequiresthattheeffectsofactionsondifferentelementsofanecosystemaretakenintoconsiderationindecision-making.Thisavoidsthecumulativeimpactcreatedbymakingalargenumberofsmalldecisionswithoutconsideringthebiggerpicture. MarineBioregionalPlanning,Australia’sapproachtoimprovingthewayweman-ageourmarineenvironment,isonewaythatecosystem-basedmanagementisbeingprogressed.
MarineBioregionalPlanningisaprocesstodevelopmarinebio-regionalplansforfivelargemarineregionsintheCommonwealthwaters inAustralia,andtoidentifyregionalnetworksofmarinereservesthatwillbecomepartofAustralia’sNationalRepresentativeSystemofMarineProtectedAreas.
Thebioregionalplansthemselvesdescribethemarineenviron-mentandconservationvaluesofeachmarineregion,setoutbroadobjectivesforbiodiversityconservation,identifyregionalpriorities,andoutlinestrategiesandactionstoaddressthem.Thisincludesdescribingmarinespecies,keyecologicalfeatures,biologicallyimportantareasandregionalpriorities,pressureanalysisandadvice.Theseplanspresentaconsolidatedpictureofthebiophysicalcharacteristicsanddiversityofmarinelife,
assistingintakinganecosystem-basedmanagementapproachtodecisionmakingundernationalenvironmentallaw.
MarineBioregionalPlansaredevelopedthroughaprocessofexpertinputandpublicconsultationandareformallyadoptedbytheEnvironmentMinisterwhomustthenhaveregardtothemwhenmakingrelevantdecisions.
Summary of DiscussionTherewasonlyabriefdiscussionperiodaftereachspeakerfin-ished.Agardypointedoutthatitwasimportanttorecognizetheconnectionsamongthevariouscomponentsofthemarineenvi-ronment.MarineprotectedareanetworksarebetterthansingleMPAsforprotectingmigratoryspecies;itspreadsmanagementacrossawiderarea.Marinespatialplanning(MSP)allowsaccom-modationofmultipleusersandcanbeusedforawiderrangeofspecies.Itisimportanttounderstandusesandimpactsandthenderiveamanagementplanthataddressesthekeyimpacts.Ecosystem-basedmanagement(EBM)recognizesthefullarrayofinteractionswithinanecosystem.Wemanageourimpactsontheecosystem.MarinemammalconservationrequiresEBMandEBMalsorequiresmarinemammalscienceandresearch.AgardynotedthatUNEPhaspublishedausefulguideforstepstobetakentowardEBMandthatmorediscussiononthesetop-icswouldtakeplaceinWorkshop4BandWorkshop9,bothofwhichhaveafocusonMSPformarinemammalconservation.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
22
Martinique school teachers were thanked for the artwork their students contributed to celebrate the conference and the marine mammals living in the Caribbean.Photo by Agence Kréöl
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
23
Panel 5: Managing Marine Mammal Protected Areas (MMPAs) for Localized Threats and Mitigation by Spatial Protection and Other Means
Coordinator: David Mattila (InternationalWhalingCommission(IWC)andNOAA-ONMS,USA)
Special tribute to Alexandre de Lichtervelde
Beforethepanelbegan,aspecialtributewaspaidtoscientistAlexandredeLichtervelde(1958-2011),thefirstBelgiancom-missionertotheInternationalWhalingCommission,whodiedinSeptember.Aproactive,deeplyconscientiouschampionforhealthyoceansandtheenvironment,Alexandreimpressedallthosewhocameintocontactwithhimforhispassionandcom-mitmenttoconservation.Inrecentyears,heworkedtirelesslytoraiseawarenessforresearchers,governmentministries,andconservationgroupsofthethreattowhalesfromshipstrikes.HisworkwasglobalbuthehadaparticularloveforEuropeancetaceansandtheAntarctic.
IntroductionMMPAsarenumerousanddiverseyetsharemanyofthesameattributesandchallenges.Oilspills,shipstrikes,entanglementsandbycatchareallcommon,acutethreatsfacingmarinemam-malsinmanyMMPAs.Giventhesesimilarities,MMPAman-agers,administrators,andresearcherscanassisteachotheringeneratingideasandcommonsolutionsthroughimprovedcom-municationandnetworking.Indeed,recognitionoftheneedfornetworkingwasacatalystfororganizingthefirstICMMPAinHawaiiinMarch2009andhascontinuedasarecurringthemeinpanelandworkshopdiscussionsatICMMPA2.AspartofPanel5,fourspeakersandafollow-uppaneldiscussionfocusedonacuteandchronicthreats.
Addressing the effectiveness of management alternatives for reducing collisions between large ships and large whales in marine mammal protected areasScott M. Gende(NationalParkService,Alaska,USA)
Coauthors: A. Noble Hendrix(R2ResourceConsultants,USA)andKarin R. Harris-Webb(NationalParkService,USA)
Shipstrikes–inparticular,collisionsbetweenlargeshipsandlargewhales–areaglobalconservationissue.Generally,man-agementhasfocusedonre-routingshipsaroundwhalehotspotstoreducespatialoverlap.However,inmanycases,suchasspatial
bottlenecksorwhenarrivingintoport,shipscannotbere-routedandsothemanagementalternativeistoreduceshipspeed.Yet,relativelyfewstudieshaveattemptedtoquantifyempiricallytheimpactofreducingshipspeedowingtotheinherentrarityofcollisionsandlogisticdifficultiesincollectingdata.Indeed,simulationswithvaryingdetectionprobabilityandeffectsize–thetrueyetunknowneffectivenessofreducingshipspeedinreducingcollisionprobability–demonstratethatexistingdatastreamsareinsufficienttoevaluatemanagementeffectiveness.
Ourresearchoffersauniqueopportunitytoevaluatetheeffec-tivenessofreducingshipspeedtoreducetheprobabilityofcol-lisions,andmaybeapplicabletootherMMPAs.Since2006,wehaveplacedobserversaboardlargecruiseshipsinandnearGlacierBayNationalPark(Alaska,USA),alargemarinemam-malprotectedarea,torecordreal-timeencounterswithhump-backwhales.Weusednearly900uniqueship-whaleencounterstoparameterizeaBayesianchange-pointmodelwhichdem-onstratedthatshipstravelingfasterthan11.8knots(6.1m/s)encounteredwhales,onaverage,114mcloserthanthosetravel-ingslowerthan11.8knots.
Thisaddstotheevidencethatrequiringshipstotravelslowermaybeaneffectivemanagementtoolwhenre-routingisnotanoption.However,weemphasizethatwell-designedmonitoringplansfortestingmanagementeffectivenessunderdifferentcondi-tionsshouldbeputinplaceinMMPAs,andthatitisimportanttomaketransparent,informeddecisions.
Marine mammal bycatch: how big is the problem and how can MMPAs play a leading role in its solution?David Mattila (IWCandNOAA-ONMS,USA)
Thebycatch,orentanglement,ofmarinemammalsinpassive(stationery)fishinggear,whetherderelictoractivelyfished,isincreasinglyrecognizedasaserioussourceofhuman-causedmortalityformanypopulations.Indeed,thedevelopmentanduseofscarstudieshavebeguntogiveestimatesofscopeandimpactformanypopulations.Forinstance,anocean-widestudyofNorthPacifichumpbackwhalesshowedentanglementratesofapproximately20to60%,dependingonthesub-population’srange,andsomeannualmortalitiescouldbeashighas3to4%.Recognizingthis,the89membercountriesoftheInternationalWhalingCommission(IWC)recentlyagreedthatanycountry
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
24
withwhalepopulationsandpassivefishinggearintheirwaterslikelyhasaproblem,whethertheyknowitornot.Entanglementshavebeenreportedforalltypesofpassivefishinggear,andbycatchnumbersaregenerallyagreedtobeseverelyunderes-timated.TheIWCcountries,therefore,endorsedaninitiativetobuildcapacityinordertounderstandandmanagethisissue,recognizingthatpreventionshouldbetheultimategoal.
SomeMMPAsalreadyplayaleadingroleinprevention,usuallythroughtimeorareafisheryclosures,whichmayprotectcertainkeymarinemammalhabitats.Howeverthisrarelyreducestheoverallamountofdangerousgearinthewater,butinsteadsimplymovesitelsewhere.Theothergeneralapproachestopreventionaremodifyingorswitchingfishinggearandalertingmarinemammalstogearinthewater(e.g.,visuallyoracoustically).
ItissuggestedthatMMPAsmayplayagreaterroletowardsolv-ingtheoverallproblembyactivelypromotingandtestingtheuseofnew,lessdangerousfishinggearwithintheirboundaries.Forexample,acousticpingersappeartoworkforsomepopula-tionsofsmallcetaceansandswitchingfromgillnetstofishpotsorlonglineshasbeenshowntobeeffectiveinsomeinstances.Inaddition,theUSgovernmenthasmandatedtheuseofsink-inggroundlinesbetweenpotsandtheuseof“weaklinks”inthegearusedinsomeareas.Theuseofgearwithoutverticallinesasmarkersorpickupbuoysisalsobeinggivenseriousconsideration.However,wedonotyetknowtheeffectivenessorunintendedconsequencesofthesegearchanges,andsoMMPAswouldneedtoestablishcomprehensivemonitoringprogramsifalternatetechnologiesareused.
IthasalsobeensuggestedthatMMPAscanhelpwithimmediatemanagementofthisproblemthroughactingasacatalystorfocalpointforestablishingrescuenetworksuntilapreventativesolu-tioncanbefound.However,therearemanypublicmisconcep-tionsaboutentanglements;rescues,evenbytrainedindividuals,canbedangerous.Inresponsetothis,asecondIWCworkshopheldinOct.2011draftedprinciplesandguidelinesforsafeandeffectiveresponsetoentanglements.
Oil spills and marine mammals: findings from the recent spill in the Gulf of MexicoTeri Rowles (NOAAFisheries-OPR,MarineMammalHealthandStrandingResponseProgram,USA)
TheDeepwaterHorizonOilSpillwasthelargestoilspillinUShistoryrequiringasustainedresponseandanintenseinvestiga-tiontounderstandtheimpactsoftheoilspillontheecosystemincludingmarinemammals.TheGulfishometomanyspeciesofcetaceansaswellasWestIndianmanatees.
Duringtheoilspill,theSoutheastMarineMammalStrandingNetworkrespondedtoover100cetaceanstrandingsalongthenorthernGulfofMexico,collectingsamplestodetermineexpo-suretooilandcauseofdeath.Inaddition,photo-identification
andbiopsysurveysofcoastalbottlenosedolphins,aerialandboatsurveysofbothoceanicandcoastalareas,biopsyandtaggingofoceaniccetaceans,andhealthassessmentsoflivecapturedbottle-nosedolphinswereundertakentoassesstheinjuriestomarinemammalsduringandfollowingtheoilspill.Betterunderstand-ingofthepotentialimpactsofoilandofoilspillresponseactivi-tieswillassistMPAManagersinpreparednessandplanningforsuchemergencyeventsintheirmanagementareas.
Marine mammal protection in MéxicoDavid Gutierrez Carbonell(ComisiónNacionaldeÁreasNaturalesProtegidas,CONANP-SEMARNAT,México)
InMéxico,environmentallawsandspecificallythoserelatedtobiodiversityhaveonlybeeninplaceforonetotwodecades;how-everprotectionofsomemarinemammalspecieswasenforcedintheearly20thcentury.Sincethen,differentkindsofinstrumentshavebeendeveloped,fromtheestablishmentofprotectedareastotechnicalregulationssuchasthestandardforwhalewatchingactivitiesandmorerecentlytheestablishmentofrefugeareastoprotectaquaticspecies,asdefinedbytheGeneralLawonWildlife.In2007,theNationalCommissionofProtectedAreasstartedtheimplementationoftheSpeciesAtRiskConservationProgram(PROCER,inSpanish)with25actionplansinprocess,fourofthemrelatedtomarinemammals:humpbackandbluewhales,Caribbeanmanateeandvaquita.
ThispresentationmadeasynthesisofMexicanexperiencesintheuseofsomeoftheseinstruments,focusingonhowprotectedareas,withasolidmanagementplanthattakesintoconsiderationeconomicandsocialfactors,couldbecomearobustmechanismtomakewhalewatchingasustainableandwellorganizedactiv-itywithanimportanteconomicbenefitfortheinhabitantsofElVizcaínoBiosphereReserve.
Summary of DiscussionFollowingthepresentations,thepanelansweredquestionsfocusedonthreegeneraltopics:communicationofexistinginternationalefforts,databaseandenforcementdeficiencies,andtheoverallapplicabilityofresultandmethods.Forexample,thegrouphighlightedthatseveralinternationaleffortshavebeenini-tiatedtoaddresschronicthreatsformarinemammalsincludingaresolutionrecentlypassedattheInternationalConventionforParties(UNEP)dealingwithentanglementandmarinedebris.AnotherinternationaleffortisspearheadedattheIWCwhichhasanongoinginternationaldatabasetoreportshipstrikes(seewww.iwcoffice.org/sci_com/shipstrikes.htm).CountrieswithoutaformalnetworkforreportingshipstrikeswereencouragedtoreportthemthroughtheIWCdatabase.Finallythepanelwasencouragedtoworktoincreasecapacityfortraininggearedtowardstrandingresponseincludingforliveanimals.
Anothergeneraltopicduringthediscussionfocusedondeficien-ciesintermsofenforcementaswellasavailabilityofinformation.Forexample,anissuewasraisedthatmanyMMPAsexistonly
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
25
onpaper,includingbutnotlimitedtoMéxico.DavidGutierrezwasthankedforacknowledgingthatMéxico’s65MPAsandtworefugeareasarelargely“paperMPAs”butsaidthattheMexicangovernmentistryingtomakeprogresstoensureenforcement.Alongsidethetoolofprotectedareas,Méxicoparticipatesinregionalprotectionprogramsforhumpbackwhales.Progressisalsobeingmadetodeterminetheefficacyofbuyoutsoffishinglicensestoreducebycatchofvaquita;theinterestbyfishermeninbuyoutisdiminishingandthusotheroptionsarebeingexplored.
Anotherdeficiencyidentifiedisthelackofdataontheefficacyofhavingshipsusewarningdeviceswhentheynavigatethroughwhalehabitat.DavidMattilasaidthattheuseof“alarms”onlargeshipsisnotanactiveareaofresearchforshipsbecauseoflogisticsandhehighlightedthatoneofthefirststudiesonalarmswithrightwhalesdemonstratedthatwhalesweremorelikelytocometothesurfacewhenalarmswereused,whichmayhavetheoppositeeffectofreducingcollisions.
Thediscussionnextturnedtotheapplicabilityofresultsfromonetimetothenextandtheapplicabilityofmethodsfromonestudytoanother.Forexample,ifcruiseshipsencounterwhalesatnight,arethemodelresultsapplicableifdatawerecollectedbyobserversaboardtheshipsduringtheday?Thisisakeyissuebecausevirtuallyalllargeshipsundertakesomevoyagesatnight.Forthecruiseshipstudy,observationswereindeedonlymadeduringdaylighthoursalthoughthisspannedupto18hoursduetothelongsummerdaysinAlaska.Nevertheless,mostcruisinginAlaskaandinotherareasoftheglobeoccursinthelateandearlyhoursofthedaysothatportsofcallcanbevisiteddur-ingtheday.ThisisalsotrueinAlaskaexceptwhentheportofcallisanareaofinterest,suchasanationalparklikeGlacierBay.Nevertheless,thereisnoreasontoassumethatship-whaleencounterswouldbeanylessinfrequentatnight.Whethertheresultsderivedfromcollectingdataduringthedayareapplicableatnightthusdependsonthemechanism.Forexample,ifthemechanismbehindtherelationshipbetweenslowershipsandgreaterseparationdistanceisduetowhalesbeingbetterabletodetectandreacttotheships,thenwecouldassumethattheresultsareapplicabletoship-whaleencountersatnight.If,how-ever,therelationshipbetweenspeedandencounterdistanceisduetoacaptainorpilotdetectingwhalesandtakingavoidancemeasures,thentherelationshipbetweenspeedandencounterdistanceiscontingentuponthecaptaindetectingthewhalewhichwillbesignificantlyreducedorimpossibleatnight.IntheGlacierBaystudy,theobservergavenoindicationtothecap-tainwhenawhalewasdetectedandthetracksoftheshipwheninthepresenceofawhalegavenoindicationthatthecourseorspeedwasalteredinresponsetohavingawhaleinproximity.Thus,theassumptionisthattherelationshipisduetochangesinwhalebehaviorasaresultofreducedshipspeedandthusisapplicableatnight.
FurtherdiscussiononmanagementeffectivenessinGlacierBayaddressedwhethermanagementofshipsinoneareamayhaveaneffectonshipsinanotherarea.Forexample,thereareanumberofwhalehotspotsinAlaskaandifportschedulesfortheshipsaretight,slowingtheshipsdowninsomeareasmayresultin
shipsgoingfasterinotherareastomakeupforlosttime.Thus,itisimportanttothinkholisticallyaboutmanagementeffec-tivenessinanareaandtheimpactthatthiswillhaveonoverallconservationgoals.
Thequestionofapplicabilityalsofocusedonwhetherthetech-niquesemployedforthecruiseshipstudycouldbeusedtobetterunderstandentanglementandrightwhales.DavidMattilahigh-lightedthedifficultyinunderstandingentanglementrateswith-outhavingtaggedwhalesandknowledgeofwherefishinggearislocatedbutheacknowledgedthatsimulationssimilartothosehighlightedinthetalkoncruiseshipstrikescouldbeapplied.
Finally,adiscussionoccurredrelativetodetectionandquanti-ficationofcarcassesfollowingtheDeepwaterHorizonOilSpillandwhethertherewasanexplicitattemptinthedamageassess-menttocounthowmanycarcassesweremissed.TeriRowlesacknowledgedthatmodelingeffortsareattemptingtoaddressthis;itisnotlimitedtocetaceansbutalsoincludesothermarinemammals,turtlesandbirds.Thismodelingeffortisimportantbecauserelativelyfewmortalitiesweredetectedoffshore;only400mortalitieshavebeendocumentedfromthebeginningofthespilltillthepresentincludingcarcassesfarfromthewellheadandinareaswithbothhighandlowlevelsofoiling.5
5 FurtherdiscussiononoildisastersandmarinemammalsoccurredinWorkshop7,p67.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
26
Tiare Turang Holm talked about developments in Palau during Panel 6: Regional Cooperation for MMPA Scientific and Technical Networking.Photo by Philippe Robert
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
27
Panel 6: Regional Cooperation for MMPA Scientific and Technical Networking
Coordinators: Martine Bigan(Ministèredel’Ecologie,Directiondel’EauetBiodiversité,France)andDenis Girou(GuadeloupeNationalPark,Guadeloupe)
Chair: Denis Girou(GuadeloupeNationalPark,Guadeloupe)
IntroductionThispanelexaminedtheroleofregionalcooperationbetweenscientistsandMPApractitionersfromvariouscountrieswork-ingtogethertoestablishandmanageprotectedareanetworksthatincludemarinemammals.ThefirstthreepresentationsfocusedindetailontheMediterraneanandBlackseasandthelastexpansivelyonthePacificIslands.TheagreementsforgedintheseareasarehelpingtoimprovecollaborationandcapacityforeffectiveMMPAdesignandmanagement.
Protection of areas for cetaceans in the Mediterranean Sea – key issues, tools, possible solutionsAna Štrbenac (StateInstituteforNatureProtection,Croatia)
TheMediterraneanregionisabiodiversityhotspot,highlysus-ceptibletothreats.Itisamostlyenclosedsea,surroundedbydiversecountrieswith43millioncoastalresidentswhichdoublesbecauseoftourisminthesummer.Some22cetaceanspeciesandsubspeciesoccur,but60%ofthoseregularlyseenarethreatenedand40%aredatadeficient.
Atleast13EuropeanandMediterraneanagreementsarerelevantforcetaceans.TwomainregionalinstrumentsincludeanetworkofSpeciallyProtectedAreasofMediterraneanImportanceunderSPA/BDProtocoloftheBarcelonaConventionand18criti-calhabitatsidentifiedforprotectionbytheAgreementontheConservationofCetaceansoftheBlackSea,MediterraneanSeaandContiguousAtlanticArea(ACCOBAMS)undertheBonnConvention.TheEuropeanUnionestablishedtheNATURA2000ecologicalnetwork.InternationalandnationalNGOsareactiveincetaceanresearchandconservation.
AllmarineprotectedandmanagedareasintheMediterraneancoverapproximately4%ofthesurface.Thereare38MPAswithcetaceanhabitat,includingoneonthehighseas,andanumberofsmallerprotectedareas.Thebottlenosedolphinisthemostcommonconservationobjective.
MPAsforcetaceansintheMediterraneandisplaymanyweak-nesses:lackofrepresentativenessofcriticalhabitats,lackofstake-holders’involvement,inadequatemanagement,andlackofdataonstatusofspeciesandhabitats.Effortstoimprovethesituationshouldfocusontwoparalleltasks:strengtheningtheposition
forcetaceanconservationandimplementationofspecificmea-suresforimprovementofthemarineprotectedareasnetwork.
Towards a network of protected areas for Black Sea cetaceansAlexei Birkun, Jr.(BlackSeaCouncilforMarineMammals,BSCMM,Ukraine)
AllthreeBlackSeacetaceansubspeciesareendemicandassessedintheIUCNRedListasendangered(EN)orvulnerable(VU).TheBlackSeaharborporpoiseandbottlenosedolphinareEN,andtheBlackSeashort-beakedcommondolphinisVU.
Thesethreesubspeciesexperienceddramaticdeclinesinthe20thcenturyduetomasskillingthatfinallystoppedin1983.Currently,adverseimpactsfromfisheriesandhabitatdegrada-tioncontinuetoaffectthesepopulationsthroughouttheirrangeincludingintheBlackSeaandadjoiningAzovandMarmaraseasandconnectingstraits.
ThevariousBlackSeastateshavecommittedtoprotectingceta-ceansasPartiestoACCOBAMSandtheBucharestConvention.TheWorkshoponBlackSeaProtectedAreasEligiblefortheConservationandMonitoringofMarineMammals(Istanbul,2006)producedalistof19MPAswhichcouldconstitutethebackboneforaregionalnetwork.Thislistincludescoastalbio-sphereandnaturereservesandnationalparksestablishedinBulgaria(n=2),Georgia(1),Romania(2),Russia(1),Turkey(4),andUkraine(9).Thedevelopmentofthenetworkisstipu-latedasapriorityactionintheConservationPlanforBlackSeaCetaceans(2006)andtheStrategicActionPlanfortheRehabilitationandProtectionoftheBlackSea(2009).Thefor-merdocumentalsoenvisagescreatingnewMPAsspecializedincetaceanconservation.
ThedevelopmentofanetworkofMPAsfortheconservationofBlackSeacetaceansisstillinitsinitialphase.Moreover,thetotalsurfaceareaofthe19“eligible”MPAsislessthan1%oftheBlackSeatakenasawhole.Itisclearlynotenougheventoconserveknownsemi-residentcommunitiesofbottlenosedolphinsortoprotectwinteringareaswhereharbourporpoisesandcommondolphinsassembleinannualdenseaggregations.
ThesituationforBlackSeacetaceansmightbeeffectivelyimprovediftheentireBlackSeaalongwiththeAzovSea,MarmaraSeaandthestraitsweredeclaredbyBlackSeacoun-triesasabasin-widecetaceansanctuaryorsimilarregionaltransboundarybiospherereserve,withspecialemphasisonconservationofcetaceans.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
28
Using the MedPAN network to further marine mammal conservation …and using marine mammals to improve MPA managementChloë Webster (MedPAN,France)
MedPAN–thenetworkofmanagersofmarineprotectedareasintheMediterranean–isalegallyindependentNGOcreatedinresponsetoMPAmanagementdemands.Thenetworkiscom-prisedofmorethan60MPAmanagersandotherpartnersfrom20countriesworkinginnearly200MPAs,mostofthemsmallandlargelycoastal.MedPANundertakescommoninitiativestohelpMPAmanagerstoreinforcethemanagementoftheirareas.TheframeworkofMedPAN’sactionsisbasedonCBDobjectives,anditisalsoframedbytheBarcelonaConventionandotherAgreements(ACCOBAMS)andvariousEuropeanpoliciesandtools.
Thispresentationexplorestwoperspectivesasameanstoopendiscussionsforrecommendations.Theoverallaimofthepresen-tationistoprovideparticipantswiththechancetomakerecom-mendationstoMPAmanagersviaMedPANthusbroadeningthescopeofworkrelatingtomarinemammals.
VariouswaysofusingMedPANtofurthermarinemammalconservationareunderscored.WhileMedPANhasbeencon-structingitsdatabaseonMPAsandupdatinginformationonthestatusofMPAsintheMediterranean,opportunitieshavearisentoidentifythoseMPAsthatcoulddeveloptheirroleinfurtheringmarinemammalconservation.AstheMediterraneannetworkofMPAmanagers,MedPANprovidesbothaplatformtoexchangeinformationandexperience(technicalornot),andtoolstoimproveMPAmanagement.EventhoughtheyarenotMPAmanagers,marinemammalscientistsandconservationistsareencouragedtouseMedPAN.Itcanalsobeusefulfordecisionmakers,includingthosewhoarePartiestoACCOBAMS.MPAandcetaceannetworkstrategieshavemanycommonobjectivesandhighlightingtheseaimscanhelpcontributetoandenhancemarinemammalconservation.Ofcourse,tobeeffectivewithconservationinitiatives,italsoimportanttomoveoutsidetherealmsofscientistsandMPAmanagerstothelargerworldwheresocio-economicandpoliticalfactorsplaythemajorrole.
MarinemammalscanalsobeusedtoreinforceMPAmanage-mentthroughoutthenetwork.MedPAN’scurrentworkprovidesMPAmanagerswithopportunitiestoreinforcemanagementeffi-ciency.Thepowermarinemammalscanhaveinattractingpoliti-calandsocialattentioniseitherunderestimatedattheMPAlevelorgivenalesserpriorityinviewofMPAconservationobjectives.Managersmayalsobeunfamiliarwithcetologyforexample.However,usingtheseemblematicanimalstoattractattention,injustifyinganMPAextensionforexample,orelseinpublicawarenessmessages,oragaintodevelopresponsibletourism,hasprovenclout.Usingmarinemammalsinsuchwayswillbenefitthemarineenvironmentatlargeandinturnmarinemammals.
Strengthening collaboration and capacity for an effective regional marine mammals protected area (MMPA) network: The Pacific Islands experienceTiare Turang Holm(SustainableDecisions,Palau)
AcrossthevastPacificIslandsregion,wheremorethan2000languagesarespoken,therearediverseculturalvaluesregard-ingmarinemammals.Theyarealternatelyreveredasspiritualicons,orhuntedforceremonialpurposes,thoughinmostcaseshuntingisconsideredtaboo.SixcountriesparticipateintheInternationalWhalingCommission(IWC)meetings.Thereisadevelopinghistoryofregionalcollaborationformarinemam-malconservationandmanagement.
TheSecretariatforthePacificRegionalEnvironmentProgramme(SPREP)andtheSouthPacificWhaleResearchConsortium(SPWRC)togetherwithNGOpartnerssuchasIFAW,WhalesAlive,WWFandWDCShaveestablishedacriticalplatformforestablishingmarinemammalsanctuariesinPacificislandscountriesandterritories.Successesincludemorethantenyearsofresearchingmarinemammalsacross14countries,conserva-tionwithspeciesrecoveryandscienceactionplans,workinggroupsandConventiononMigratorySpecies(CMS)agreements,acomprehensiveassessmentofhumpbackwhalesinOceania,nationalwhalesanctuaries,andcapacitybuildingandlinkinginformationtokeydecisionmaking.Thehumpbackwhalepopu-lationhasformedthebasisformarinetourismandaneconomiclifelineformanyinislandsoftheSouthPacific,withnetworkimplicationsintheirtransboundarymigrations.
SPREPplaysanimportantleadershiproleintheregionformarinemammalconservation.Itassistedinsuccessfullydevel-opingamemorandumofunderstanding(MoU)onPacificCetaceansandtheirHabitatsundertheConventiononMigratorySpecies(CMS)whichopenedforsigningin2006(thusfarsignedby12SPREPmembersand6collaboratingNGOs).SPREP’smarinemammaleffortsdatebacktotheearly1990sandthecurrentPacificIslandsWhaleandDolphinActionPlan(WDAP-2012)servesasaguidetotheregiontoachievemarinemammalconservationgoals.
TheWDAPhasninethemes,includingnational,regionalandinternationalcollaboration,threatreduction,ecosystemandhabitatprotection(includingMMPAs),capacitybuilding,edu-cation,culturalsignificanceandvalue,legislationandpolicy,researchandmonitoring,andwhale-anddolphin-basedtourism.
SupportedbySPREP,SPWRCandarangeofNGOs,Pacificstateshaveestablishedanetworkof11marinemammalEEZsanctu-ariescoveringmorethan18millionkm2.TheinitialimpetusforcreationwasthefailureoftheSouthPacificSanctuarypro-posalintheIWC.Whencountries,mostlyoutsidetheregion,opposedthis,PacificIslandcountriesdecidedtodeclaretheirEEZsassanctuaries,beginningwiththeCookIslandsin2001.Sanctuarymanagementintheregionislargelybasedonlocal
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
29
needs,capacityandvaryingsituations.Theinvolvementofcom-munitiesanddifferentstakeholdersintheplanningandman-agementprocessiscritical.Niue,FijiandSamoaarestartingtoimplementthesanctuarieswithMPAmanagementplans.
Despitethesesuccesses,cetaceanconservation,includingscienceandmanagement,hasseenlittleinvestmentintheregionrela-tivetothescaleanddiversityoftheneeds.Moremustbedonetoresearchandunderstandcetaceanspecies,andtoaddressthehugedatagaps.WhenIattendedthelastICMMPAconferenceonMaui,Idiscoveredthatthegapsindatawerenottheresultoflackofcetaceansbutlackofresearchinvestment.
Palauisnoexceptiontothisobservationbutwearenowwork-ingtoenhancecetaceanconservationinPalau.Palaudeclaredallitswatersasmarinemammalsanctuariesin2010.Supportingnationallegislationwasthenintroduced,andfundingforatargetednationalresearchprojectwasapproved.TheNationalCouncilofMatriarchscalledonPalau’sleaderstosupporteffec-tiveimplementationofthesanctuaryinMarch2011.Thelegisla-tioniscurrentlyundergoingrevision,andin2012thecetaceanresearchprojectwillbegin.
Furtherresearchandmonitoringprotocolsarerequired,alongwiththeoptimizationofcommunicationtocommunitiesanddecisionmakers,developmentofasustainablemarinemam-malwatchingindustry,improvingIWCactivities,andbuildingcapacity.Thesearereflectiveoftheregion’schallenges,whichincludeaccesstofinancialandtechnicalresources,conductingfurtherresearch,fillingdatagaps,institutionalizingmonitoring,conductingeffectivesurveillanceandenforcement,linkinggoodinformationtocommunicationstrategiesanddecisionmaking,buildingemotionalandeconomiclinksbetweencetaceansandcommunities,andimprovingengagementandparticipationintheIWC.
Aregionalapproachtomanagementprovidesmanybenefits,thoughtherearechallengesinimplementingthematthenationallevel.Theroleofintergovernmentalandnon-governmentorga-nizationsiscrucialinimplementingnationalandregionalactionplans.Theinvolvementofcommunitiesandprimarystakehold-ersiscrucial,andeconomiclinksmustbeclarified.Partnershipsarecritical.
Summary of DiscussionThebriefdiscussionperiodfocusedonregionalcooperation,initiallywithMedPan’sexperienceintheMediterraneanandthenwithSPREPandtheCMSCetaceanMoUinthePacific,andregionalfinancing.
TiareTurangHolmfromPalaureportedthattheCMSPacificCetaceanMoUhadbeenausefultool,thoughtheyhavenotcomeclosetooptimizingitspotential.Morecountriesintheregionneedtobeonboard.Still,itcanserveasamodelforotherregions;itcommitsnationstoworkingtogether.
InPalau,legislationwaspassedwhichcreatesasustainablefinancemechanismforPalau’sprotectedareanetwork.Itcallsforallvisitorstopayintoafundsolelyforthemanagementofthese
protectedareas,whichcanincludesupportforcetaceanconser-vation.Alsoonaregionallevel,theMicronesiaChallenge–toprotectatleast30%ofmarineand20%ofterrestrialresourcesby2020–hasledtocollaborativeworkonfundraising.Thetar-getforthisisUSD$18million,ofwhichPalauhasbeenabletoraiseUSD$8million.
Palauisplanningtobringitsexperienceswithmarineconser-vationtoRio+20,inJune2012,althoughitwasnotedthat,sofar,marineissuesarenotyetofsignificantlyhighenoughprofileontheagendaofhostcountries.HolmansweredthatthiswasahugeopportunityandthattheywouldbeworkingthroughtheirnationaldelegationandthroughSPREPwhichhashelpedensuresuchissuesareproperlydealtwith.
HolmalsoreportedonPalau’smarinemammalanddugongsanctuaryandannouncedthatthefirstphaseofPalau’scetaceanresearchprojectwouldbegininJanuary2012–theresultofapartnershipformedwithWhalesAlivethroughPalau’spartici-pationintheICMMPA1inHawaiiin2009.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
30
A manatee floats just beneath the surface of a mangrove creek on the bayside in the Upper Keys. Florida Keys National Marine SanctuaryPhoto by Andy Collins, Papahanaumokuakea Marine National Monument, NMS/NOS/NOAA
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
31
Panel 7: Development of Marine Mammal Protected Areas (MMPAs) in the Wider Caribbean Region
CoordinatorandChair: Alessandra Vanzella-Khouri(UNEPCaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,Jamaica)
Introduction, Objectives and SummaryThemarinemammalfaunaoftheWiderCaribbeanRegionisdiverse,withatleast32speciesrecorded,andofferssignificantecological,aestheticandeconomicvaluetothecountriesandterritoriesoftheregion.However,dataarescarceconcerningmostcetaceanandmanateepopulationsintheregion.Itisoneofonlytworegionstohaveseentheextinctionofamarinespe-ciesin250years,theCaribbeanmonkseal.Huntingstilloccursinsomeareas,andthreatssuchaspollutionandnoisearelargelyuninvestigated.Itisoneofthebusiestshippingareasintheworld,alongwithbeingabiodiversityhotspotthatdependsheavilyontourism.Climatechangeimpactsheavilyonfoodwebs,ecosys-temproductivityandoceanographicconnectivity.Theregionisstartingtorecognisetheneedforconservationeffortsinclud-ingMMPAs.
AspecificMarineMammalActionPlan(MMAP)wasadoptedin2008undertheframeworkofUNEP’sCaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,afteralongconsultationprocessinvolvingscientists,NGOs,andgovernmentrepresentatives.AmongtheactivitiesbeingpursuedaspartoftheMMAParetrainingworkshopsonstrandingresponseandnetworking,whale-anddolphin-watchtraining,andimplementationofaregionalmanateeconserva-tionplan.
DespitethelargenumberofMPAsintheWiderCaribbeanregion(over300),lessthanahandfulhavebeenestablishedforthecon-servationofmarinemammals.Nonetheless,thefewthatexistareofmajorecologicalsignificance(e.g.,theMarineMammalSanctuaryoftheDominicanRepublic,themostimportantbreedingandnursinggroundsfortheNorthAtlanticpopula-tionofhumpbacks)orarepioneersinthedevelopmentof“sistersanctuaryarrangements”betweenprotectedareasthousandsofmilesapartprotectingendangeredmigratorymarinemammalspeciesonbothendsofitsrange.Regionalsuccessinmanagingandconservingmarinemammalsdependsultimatelyoneffec-tiveregionalcooperation;thecommitmentofthecountriesoftheregion;andtheimplementationofconservationpriorities,standards,andstrategiesformarinemammalconservationandeducation,someofwhicharediscussedinthispanel.
From a regional treaty to an action plan to conservation efforts at the national levelHélène Souan (SPAW–RegionalActivityCentre,Guadeloupe)
TheProtocolonSpeciallyProtectedAreasandWildlife(SPAW)oftheUNEPCartagenaConventionaimstoprotectandman-agesustainablymarineandcoastalbiodiversityintheWiderCaribbean.Amongspeciesofparticularconcern,marinemam-malsrepresentamajorchallenge,andtheContractingPartiestotheSPAWProtocolhaveadoptedin2008adedicatedActionPlanthatforeseesthedevelopmentofappropriateactionsfortheconservationofmarinemammals,fromthestrengtheningofstrandingnetworkstothecontrolofpollutants.
Oneofthekeygoalsistheimplementationofappropriatespa-tialprotection(e.g.,sanctuaries)withimportanteffortplacedoncooperationamongcountriestoensureecologicalcoherenceoftheactions.Crucialprogresshasbeenmaderecentlyunderthisframework,withseveralnationalinitiativestowardstheestab-lishmentofmarinemammalsanctuaries,orthereinforcementofmanagementinexistingsanctuaries.Bilateralpartnershipshavealsobeenconcluded,orareabouttobe,inordertopro-motecommonactionsandexchangesbetweenthesanctuaries’managementteams.
The Marine Mammal Sanctuary for the Dominican Republic: 25 years of learning by doing Oswaldo Vásquez (Advisor,MinisterofEnvironmentandNaturalResourcesoftheDominicanRepublic;AsesoríaAmbientalyTecnologíaMaritima–AtemarEirl,DominicanRepublic)
In1986SilverBankbecameoneofthefirstsanctuariesintheworldtobecreatedforconservationpurposes.TheIndianOceansanctuarywascreatedformanagementpurposesbeforeSilverBank,butSilverBankwascreatedforconservation.Whenitwascreated,theconceptsofasanctuaryandanexclusiveeconomiczone(EEZ)werenewconcepts,andthelegislationwaslatermodifiedtobringitintolinewiththem.SilverBankwasfirstdiscoveredin1973,andisuniquebecauseithasalongchainofcoralreefswhichmakesnavigationdifficult.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
32
Thesanctuaryishometorepresentativesofallthemarinespe-ciesintheDominicanRepublic,includinghumpbackwhalesandtwospeciesofdolphins.Pilotwhalesandspermwhalesarealsosighted.
Partofthefunctionofthesanctuaryhasbeentoconductsophis-ticatedresearch,includingenvironmentalandDNAstudiesandpopulationstudies.Twentyyearsago,researchersintheNorthAtlanticdidthelargeststudyonhumpbackwhaleswhichhadeverbeenconductedtothatpoint,involvingsevencountriesand42scientists.Thestudytaughtusalittleaboutdistribution,behaviorinthewinter,therelationshipbetweenthemotherandcalf,andmatingbehavior.Wedidafollow-upstudytenyearslatertotrytoestablishNorthAtlanticpopulationnumbers.
Atpresent,wehaveissued42whalewatchinglicenses.WehavealsocreatedanationalwhalecatalogbasedonphotoIDandDNAstudies.
ThehumpbackwhalepopulationfortheNorthAtlanticwasini-tiallyestablishedat1517,butnowitiscloseto14,000.Theyaredoingverywellatthemoment,withagrowthrateof2.3%peryear,buttheyarestillfarfromreachingtheoriginalpopula-tion.Thisdataissometimesusedtoattempttojustifyhunting.
Wehavebeencarryingouttaggingoperationsonthewhalestotracktheirmovements,andalsotoestablishthelevelofnoiseintheareaandhowthisaffectsthedistributionofthepopulation.
Wehaveanumberofissuestodealwith,suchasentanglement,shipstrikes,andclimatechange.However,wearecurrentlyrevis-ingthelegislationandwillsoonhaveamanagementplan.WearecreatingtheMarineMammalCommissionoftheDominicanRepublic.TheDominicanRepublicisalsoamemberoftheIWC,whereitwillcontinuefightingforwhaleconservation.BeforewejoinedtheIWC,weestablishedinlawthatwewerenotawhal-ingcountry.
The Agoa Sanctuary for the French AntillesNicolas Maslach (AgoaSanctuary,St-Barthélemy)
Agoa6isthefirstsanctuaryformarinemammalsintheFrenchWestIndies,i.e.,theterritorialwatersandexclusiveeco-nomiczone(EEZ)ofGuadeloupe,Martinique,St-MartinandSt-Barthélemy.Itwascreatedon5October2010.Withanareaof138,000km²,Agoawillmakeitpossibletoreinforcethepro-tectionofemblematicyetthreatenedspecies,suchassperm,humpbackandotherwhalesanddolphins,tosustainablyman-agetheirhabitatsandtoensurethattheyareconsideredinthedevelopmentofhumanactivities.
Withthedeclarationofthesanctuary,FranceandtheFrenchWestIndiescommunitieshavedemonstratedtheircommitmentbythefollowingactions:
6 AgoaisthenameofthegoddessoftheseainAmerindianmythology.
• AstronginvolvementofthelocalauthoritiesandtheFrenchStateinthegovernanceoftheAgoaSanctuary.ThisstructureiscompetenttoproposeprotectionandconservationmeasuresforspeciesandtheirhabitatsintheFrenchAntillesEEZ,particularlywithregardtothenewlegislationformarinemammalprotectioninAgoacreatedonJuly1st,2011.Thislegislationforbidsdestruction,removal,intentionalcaptureandharassmentofmarinemammals,aswellashabitatdegradation.In2012,regulationsonsafedistancesforwhalewatchingvesselswillbedeveloped.
• Theestablishmentofhuman,technicalandfinancialresourcesforthegovernanceofthesanctuary,toimprovescientificknowledgeandorganizationofawarenessamongseausersandthegeneralpublic.
• Theprovisionofmeanstomonitorthesanctuaryaspartofthe“ActionoftheStateatSea”.
Moreover,inviewofthecommunityissuesinconservationandmanagementofmarinemammalsintheCaribbean,Francehasundertakentoimplementacooperativestrategy(asrec-ommendedintheMarineMammalActionPlanadoptedattheConferenceofPartiestotheSPAWProtocolin2008)throughtheSPAW-RAC(SpeciallyProtectedAreasandWildlife–RegionalActivityCenter)onbehalfoftheUnitedNationsEnvironmentProgramme(UNEP)andtheFrenchMPAAgency(AAMP).Thiswillfacilitatethemanagementofmarinemammalmigrationcor-ridorsandprotectedareasformarinewildlifepopulationscom-montoseveralcountries.TheICMMPA2hasprovidedagreatopportunitytotakefurtherstepstowardtheseimportantgoals.
Tothisend,severalcountrieshavedemonstratedtheircom-mitmenttothisprocessatICMMPA2,namelytheDominicanRepublic,theNetherlandsfortheDutchAntilles,andtheUSAforStellwagenBank,whichareestablishing“twinning”partner-shipswiththeAgoaSanctuary.Anotherresultofthiscoopera-tiveapproachwillbetheestablishmentin2012ofascientificprotocolonobservationandidentificationofmarinemammalsintheEEZoftheFrenchAntilles,theNetherlandsAntillesandAnguillaintheLesserAntilles.
Inconclusion,thestudiesconductedsofarinthedraftingpro-cessofthemanagementplanoftheAgoaSanctuaryindicatethattheissuesare:
• Related to survival of the animals: collisions,illnessescausedbystressorcontaminants,entanglementandingestionofmacro-waste,noisepollutionandotherthreatsthathaveaneffectonmarinemammals;
• Related to animal growth:inadequatenutritionduetoadietarydeficiencyorexcessiveenergyexpenditurelinkedtorepetitivedisturbance(e.g.,highlevelsofvesseltrafficandwhalewatching),dependenceondepredation(e.g.,onfishinnetsoronlines),oravoidanceoffeedingareas;
• Related to reproduction and fertility:potentialfordisease,disturbance,contaminationbypollutantsandchemicalcompoundsthatcanaffectday-to-dayenergy
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
33
requirementsandultimatelyimpactageatmaturityorreducereproductivesuccess;and
• Related to habitat issues:threatsofcoastaldevelopmentandmarinepollution.
Maintainingsocio-economicinterestsisalsoanimportantissuefortheeconomyoftheFrenchAntillesandtherepresentativesofthesecommunities.ThiscomponentmustbeincludedinthechoiceofgovernancefortheAgoaSanctuary.Withsocio-economicconsiderationsincorporatedintotheframeworkofconsultativeandparticipatorygovernance,managementmea-suresonareaandspeciesconservationcanbeimplementedandacceptedbyall.
Towards a sanctuary for the Dutch Caribbean: A partnership effortPaul Hoetjes (DutchMinistryofEconomicAffairs,AgricultureandInnovation,Bonaire)
TheDutchislandsintheCaribbeanagreedin2009thatsincefishstocksandothermarinebiodiversityarenotboundbyborders,theEEZwatersshouldbemanagedjointlybyallislands,regard-lessoftheirseparatepoliticalstatuswithintheKingdomoftheNetherlands.TriggeredbythedeclarationofintentbyFrancetoestablishitsAgoamarinemammalsanctuaryandfollowingtheadoptionoftheMarineMammalActionPlan(MMAP)bythePartiestotheSPAWProtocol,theDutchislandsalsoagreedthatthemanagementoftheEEZshouldincludethedesignationoftheareainitsentiretyasamarinemammalsanctuary,con-nectingwiththeFrenchAgoainitiative.
AfterthedissolutionoftheNetherlandsAntillesin2010andtheaccessionofthesmallestislandstoTheNetherlands,TheDutchMinistryofEconomicAffairs,AgricultureandInnovationcommissionedtheDutchInstituteforMarineResourceandEcosystemStudies(IMARES)tostudyhowthismarinemam-malsanctuarydesignationcouldbestbeaccomplished.IMARESreviewedtheexistingrecordsofmarinemammalspeciespresentintheDutchwaters,resultinginacoupleofpublicationsinclud-ingapresentationattheIWCScientificCommitteemeetingin2011.MeanwhileaCommitteefortheMarineBiodiversityandFisheriesManagementfortheDutchEEZwasformedandmetforthefirsttimeinOctober.TheCommitteemeetingreaffirmedtheintenttoestablishaDutchCaribbeanmarinemammalsanctuary.
Amulti-partnerprogramtosurveythemarinemammalsinFrench,DutchandUKwaterswasrecentlyproposedtotheEUforfundingbyapartnershipoftheSPAW-RAC;theFrenchMPAAgency;theDutchMinistryofEconomicAffairs,AgricultureandInnovation;IMARES;Anguilla;andIFAW.EvenifEUfundingisnotobtained,bothFranceandtheNetherlandshavecommit-tedtoproceedwithjointmarinemammalsurveys.ItishopedthatthedesignationoftheDutchCaribbeanwatersasamarinemammalsanctuarymayberealizedin2012.
Intheleaduptotheformaldesignationofthesanctuary,theSouthernCaribbeanCetaceanNetwork(SCCN)hasbeensetup,andaDutchCaribbeanStrandingWorkshopwasheld.Allmarinemammalsarealreadylegallyprotected.Fishingpracticesarelimitedandcontrolled.Thesanctuarywillprovidefocustoinitiatedistributionandabundancestudies,andprovidegreaterhabitatprotection.
Building capacity and networking of marine protected areas: A platform for the conservation of marine mammals in the Wider Caribbean Alessandra Vanzella-Khouri (UNEP-CaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,Jamaica)
TheWiderCaribbeanRegionencompasses39differentpoliti-calentitiesborderingtheCaribbeanSea,GulfofMexico,andadjacentAtlanticOcean.Thisincludes13islandnations,12continentalnations,and14territoriesbelongingtoFrance,theUK,theUnitedStates,andtheNetherlands.Withsolittleinter-nationalwatersandsomanysharedboundaryareas,theneedisgreatforcoordinationbetweenandamongnations.Yettherearefourofficiallanguages(Spanish,French,English,andDutch),twolegalsystems(commonandcivil),wideeconomicdisparities,andnumeroussocio-economicandenvironmentalissuesheldincommon.Thisisoneofthebusiestshippingareasintheworld,withtrafficfromoiltankers,cruiseships,andcargovesselsinadditiontosmallerfishing,recreational,andtransportvessels.Itisalsoabiodiversityhotspotandthusthereisthepotentialfornumerousconflictsbetweenhumanactivitiesandthepreserva-tionofwildspeciesandnaturalecosystems.
Therearemorethan300marineprotectedareas(MPAs)estab-lishedintheWiderCaribbeanbutlessthan10%areconsideredeffectivelymanaged.Themainissuesincludeinadequatedesign,planning,andenforcement;insufficientfinancialresources;insufficientcapacityintheformoftrainedpersonnel;andlackofpoliticalwill.In1981,manygovernmentsintheregionadoptedanenvironmentalagreementundertheUNEPRegionalSeasProgrammeand,in1983,theCartagenaConventionprovidedanoverallframeworkforfurtherenvironmentalagreements.MostnotableinthepresentcontextistheSpeciallyProtectedAreasandWildlife(SPAW)Protocol(adopted1990,enteredintoforce2000)whichcallsonsignatorygovernmentstoestablish,man-age,andstrengthenMPAsandMPAnetworksandtoprotectlistedspecies(Annex2includes32speciesofmarinemammals).Inrecognitionofthevalueofbettercommunicationandcol-laborationamongMPAsandtheirstaffs,theCaribbeanMarineProtectedAreasManagementNetworkandForum(CaMPAM)partnershipwasbornin1997.Thisnetworkmaintainsalistserv(>300members)andaregionalMPAdatabase,providessmallgrantstosupportMPAstrengtheningandinitiatives,andfacili-tatescomprehensivetrainingandinformation-exchangeefforts.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
34
CaMPAMprovidesausefulplatformfortheimplementationofmarinemammalconservationactivitiesthroughbuildingcapac-ityinMPAs,strengtheningmanagementeffectiveness,andpro-motingpolicyformulationandgoodgovernance.Currently,inresponsetothecommitmentmadebymanycountriesaroundtheworldtoestablishnationalMPAsystemsandothermanagementmeasurestoensuretheprotectionoftheircoastalandmarineareas,CaMPAMofferstotheregionitsexperienceandfinancialresourcestoadvancetheimplementationofthesecommitments.
Summary of DiscussionFollowingthepanelpresentations,thelimitedtimeleftfordiscussionfocusedontheclarificationofanumberofpoints.ThecentralroleoftheSPAWProtocolwasstressedasitistheonlyregionallegally-bindingagreementonbiodiversityintheCaribbean.Intermsofmarinemammals,theRegionalActivityCenteroftheSPAWProtocol(SPAW-RAC)hasconvenedthreesub-regionalstrandingworkshops.InOct.2011,ithelpedorga-nizeaworkshopinPanamaonbestpracticesforwhalewatch-ingactivities;theresultingwhalewatchingguidelinesarebeingpresentedtotheParties.
ConcernwasexpressedaboutMéxiconothavingsignedtheSPAWProtocolandhowcollaborationscouldbeconducted.ItwasnotedthateffortsareunderwaytopromotetheMexicangovernmenttobecomeaContractingPartytotheProtocolwhichwillbeverybeneficialforthecountry’sCaribbeanmarineresourcesmanagement.TherewasalsoconfusionabouttheparticipationofNGOsintheProtocolifacountrywerenotamember.TheSPAWProtocoldoesnotpreventNGOsfromparticipatinginprojects,regardlessofthecountry.NGOsandexpertsalsoparticipateintheSPAWScientificandTechnicalAdvisoryCommittee(STAC);however,finaldecisionsareonlymadebytheParties.Forthemarinemammalwatchingwork-shoptherewereparticipantsfromallaroundtheCaribbean,includingnon-Parties.
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
35
Keynote 3: The Legal Regime Relating to Marine Protected Areas on the High Seas for Marine Mammal Protection Christophe Lefèbvre IUCNGlobalOceanCouncilor;FrenchMarineProtectedAreasAgency,France
TheUnitedNationsConventionontheLawoftheSea(UNCLOS)definesthelegalframe-workinwhichalloceanandsearelatedactivitiesmustbecarriedout.Anyactivityaffectingmarinebiologicaldiversitybeyondareasundernationaljurisdictionmustbecarriedoutinaccordancewiththeprinciplesofthisinternationallaw.Asaconsequence,exceptforageneralprincipletoprotectandpreservethemarineenvironment(article192andsubsequentarticles),theConventiononlygovernsthehighseasinafragmentedway:mineralresourcesinthesea-bedandbelowtheseabedaredesignatedthecommonheritageofmankindwhileelementsofthemarinebiodiversitykeepthestatusofres nulliusandcanthereforebefreelyappropriated.
ThecreationofmarineprotectedareastoprotectthebiodiversityofthehighseasrequiresaninternationallegalframeworktocomeunderUNCLOSratherthantheConventiononBiologicalDiversity(Article22oftheCBD).However,thesetwoconventionsdonotopposeeachotherbutarecomplementary.
Toidentifymarineareasworldwidethatmeetthecriteriaforecologicallyorbiologicallysignifi-cantareas(EBSAs),theIUCNinstigatedtheGlobalOceanBiodiversityInitiative(GOBI)in2010,notablyaimedatdevelopinginternationalscientificcooperationtopromoteareliable,shareddatabasefortheEBSAsandtoallowtheCBDtodrawupaworldlistofEBSAsasanecessarytoolformarinespatialplanningonthehighseas.ThisidentificationmeetstheCBDobjectiveofprovidingglobalprotectionfordeepseabiodiversity.Itcanthenbeusedtoproposerecog-nitionofthemarineprotectedareastoUNCLOS,aspartofitsinstitutionalresponsibilities.
Manycountriesconsiderthattoprotecttheoceans,itissufficienttoactwithintheRegionalFisheriesOrganizations(RFOs),andimprovethecooperationandcoordinationproceduresbetweenthevariousinternationalorganizationsconcerned(FAO,IMO,ISBA,UNESCO/IOC,UNEP).Whiletheprotectionofthemarineenvironmentwithrespecttotheexploitationofliv-ingmarineresourcesinareasofthehighseascomesundertheresponsibilityoftheRFOs,theirscientificcommitteesdonothaveasufficientcross-sectoralvisiontoberecognizedasad hocbodiesfortheMPAs.IntheNorthAtlantic,theroleofscientificvalidationpriortotheinterna-tionalpoliticalvalidationtocreateanMPAonthehighseascanbeassignedtotheInternationalCouncilfortheExplorationoftheSea(ICES),butotherregionsdonothavesuchatool.
ThecreationofhighseasMPAsisbasedonkeystepstobeimplementedwithintheinterna-tionalinstitutionalsystem:
• ScientificassessmentanditsacknowledgementbytheCBD,ofthebiodiversity,justifyingtheirone-offcreation.
• Commitmentfromthepartiesandusersconcerned,inacross-sectoralapproach.
• Settingupofdecision-makingprocessesandmechanismsbytheUnitedNationswithintheUNCLOSframework.
• ImplementationandmanagementcontrolofMPAswithinanappropriateinternationalsystem.
Wemustlookforcomplementaryaspectsandsynergiesbetweentheseandothertoolsandstrat-egiesinordertogainacceptanceforhighseasMPAsintheinternationallegalsystem.
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
36
Gray whale breaching in El Vizcaíno Biosphere Reserve in México.Photo by Steven Swartz, Office of Protected Resources, NMFS/NOAA
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
37
Keynote 4: Thinking Big–But Not Forgetting Small. The ICMMPA 2 “Take Home” Vision Erich HoytResearchFellowandGlobalMPAProgrammeHeadWhaleandDolphinConservationSociety,UK7
Thisisthestoryofthegraywhaleandthevaquita–twomarinemammals,onebreeding,andtheotherlivingyear-roundoffBajaCalifornia.The35-tonne,highprofile,wide-ranginggraywhalehaslittleincommonwiththesmall,lowprofile,geographically-restrictedvaquita.Thegraywhalewasthefirstwhaletobestudiedandwatchedcommerciallyinthewild,andthefirstevermarinemammaltohaveamarineprotectedareadesignatedforit,the1972OjodeLiebreRefugewhichlaterbecamepartofthenetworkoflagoonsdesignatedasElVizcaínoBiosphereReserve.Forthevaquita,the1993designationofanationalbiospherereserveaimedtoprotectthiscryptic,criticallyendangeredporpoise(n≥245in2008,decreasing~57%since1997).YetthespeciescontinuestodeclinebecauseofgillnetfishingforshrimpandfinfishwithinthereserveandevenoccasionallywithinthemorerestrictedhighlyprotectedVaquitaRefuge.Anestimated700artisanalgillnettersstilloperatethrough-outthevaquita’sdistributionrange.
ThegraywhaleembodiesthethemesofthefirsttwoICMMPAconferencesandisasuccessstory.Thegraywhalebecameanendangeredspeciesinthelate19thCenturyafterthediscoveryofitslagoonbreedinghabitatbywhalersmadeiteasypickings.Savingthegraywhalewasamatterofstoppingthewhalinginthelagoonsandalongthemigratoryroutesandkeepingthelagoonsasprotectedisolatedecosystems.ThegraywhaleinspirednetworkingoftheMexicanMPAsystemsandlatertheUSandCaliforniastatesanctuaries.Thegraywhaleisalsoapioneeringwhalewhenitcomestoclimatechange,withoneboldgraywhalehavingrecentlynavigatedtheice-freeNorthwestPassageenroutetoIsrael,settingadistancerecordofatleast21,000km.Marinemammalresearchersandclimatespecialistswonderifthisisasignofthingstocome.
Asscientists,managers,andconservationists,weneedtothinkbigandoutsidetheboxintermsofcreating,linkingandmanagingMPAsinthefaceofnotonlyclimatechange,butalsouncer-taintiesregardingspeciesdataacrosstheopenocean,emergingtechnologiesbothforandagainstconservation,andthestateoftheworldeconomy.Despitethenegatives,therearemanypositivesignsinthecollaborativeworkbytheGlobalOceanBiodiversityInitiative(GOBI)andHighSeasAlliance(HSA),thelatestdevelopmentsfacilitatingoffshoremonitoringandenforcement,aswellasthenetworksthathaveemergedintheCaribbean,northeastSouthAmericaandamongtheriverdolphinspecialistsfromeightcountriesinSouthAmericaplusAsia.
Nevertheless,wearefacedwithdifficultproblemstosolve,suchasthebattleforeffectivehabitatprotectionforthevaquita.Sincethebaijiwentextinctin2007,thevaquitaisthemarinemam-malspeciesvoted“mostlikelynottosucceed”.ThevaquitastorytouchesonthechallengesandconcernsofICMMPA2inMartinique–anendangeredspeciesinthiscaselivinginaprotectedproductiveecosystemintheUpperGulfbutendangeredbyoutsideforcesbeyondthecontrolofmarinemammalscientistsandmanagers.Intermsofacampaigntotrytosaveit,thevaquitawasrejectedasnotglamorousenoughbytheGrupo de los CienthatwaspartofthenationalandinternationalmovementthatstoppedMitsubishi’ssaltworksexpansionintheprotectedgraywhalehabitatofSanIgnacioLagoonin2000.Everyspeciesneedsitschampionbutitmaytakeaninspiredgrupo de los millónestorescuethevaquita.
7 Atranscriptofthistalkisavailable.Contact:[email protected]
Erich Hoyt provided a closing keynote presen-tation juxtaposing the great success of gray whale habitat conservation with the desper-ate efforts to save the currently most endan-gered marine mammal, the vaquita.Photo by Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara
KE
YN
OT
E S
PE
EC
HE
S &
PA
NE
L D
ISC
US
SIO
NS
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
38
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
Monk seals. Hawaii, Papahanaumokuakea Marine National Monument.Photo by Paulo Maurin, NOAA Coral Reef Conservation Program
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
39
Workshop 1: Monk Seal Conservation Issues
ConvenerandChair: Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara(TethysResearchInstitute,Italy)
Rapporteur: Charles Littnan(NOAAFisheries,USA)
Participants:PabloFernándezdeLarrinoa,Lenie‘tHart,CemOrkunKıraç,CharlesLittnan,HamadyOuldMohamed,GiuseppeNotarbartolodiSciara,VangelisParavas,RosaPires,EleniTryfon
Introduction and ObjectivesThepurposeofthisworkshopwastoseizetheopportunityforanupdateonthestatusofbothmonksealspecieswithintheirrespectiveranges,butinparticulartoexplorewaysinwhichmarineprotectedareas(MPAs)canbeusedtoprotectthesecriticallyendangeredspecies.TheconditionsunderwhichmonksealssurvivevarygreatlynotonlybetweenHawaiiandtheMediterranean/NorthAtlantic,butalsointhedifferentlocalitieswheretheanimalsremainwithineachspecies’range.Accordingly,thetoolstoaddressthedifferentpressuresaffectingmonksealstatusinclude,butarenotlimitedto,theestablish-mentofprotectedareasandtheapplicationofthesetoolsvariesgreatlybetweenthemanyprograms.
Presentations
Supporting the peaceful coexistence between human communities and monk seals in GreeceGiuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara(TethysResearchInstitute,Italy)
CoexistencebetweenhumansandmonksealsinGreeceisnowherepeaceful.Inthesecommunities–theeconomiesofwhichareinpartbasedonsmall-scaleartisanalfisheries–sealsthatoccasionallydamagecatchandfishinggearareperceivedasvermin.Althoughdamagesareeconomicallysmall,togetherwithmoreserioussourcesofhardshiptheymaybeperceivedasintolerable.
Astudywilltakeplacein2011-2012inGreece(thecountryhost-inghalfoftheremainingMediterraneanmonkseals),supportedbythePrinceAlbertIIofMonacoFoundation,inalocationwherehumancommunitiescoexistwithbreedingnucleiofmonkseals.Thestudywillassessthefeasibilityoftheimplementationofamulti-yearmodelprojecthavingthegoalofdemonstratinginpracticethatthepeacefulcoexistencebetweenlocalhumancommunitiesandMediterraneanmonksealsisnotonlypossible,but,underproperconditions,evenadvantageous.Thiswouldcreateaprecedentthatwouldhelptomaketheperspectiveofcoexistencewithmonksealsattractiveandpersuasivetoother
Mediterraneancommunitieshavingsimilarrelationshipswiththeseendangeredpinnipeds.
Monk seal protection on the Saharan coastPablo Fernández de Larrinoa(MediterraneanMonkSealConservationPrograminCapBlanc,Mauritania/MoroccoandCBD-HabitatFoundation,Spain)andHamady Ould Mohamed(CBD-HabitatFoundation,Spain)
OneofthemainchallengestoprotectingMediterraneanmonksealsmaybehowtodeterminewhicharetheappropriateareastobeprotected.Thisactionimpliestheprotectionofdiversemonksealcriticalhabitats,suchasbreedingplaces,foragingareas,andmatingareas.Thesecriticalhabitatsareveryoftencompletelyorpartiallyunknownandmaypreventaneffectivedesignorexecutionofprotectionmeasures.OntheSaharancoast,severalnon-invasivemethodologieshavebeendevelopedtoidentifythesecriticalhabitatsinordertoevaluateestablishedprotectionmeasuresandtodevelopnewones.Amongthesetools,satellitetrackingandphototrapcamerashaveanimportantrole.
AccordingtotheexperiencedevelopedontheSaharancoastofCapBlancpeninsula,regulationsneededforeffectiveprotectionofmonksealsshouldincludestricteliminationofhumandis-turbanceinbreedingplacesandthevicinity.Ontheotherhand,protectionmeasuresneedtobeaccompaniedbysocialcompensa-tionmeasurestopreventnegativeattitudesfromfishermenthatcanresultindirectpersecutionofmonkseals.
Marine protected areas as a tool for Hawaiian monk seal recoveryCharles Littnan (HawaiianMonkSealResearchProgram,NOAAFisheries,PacificIslandFisheriesScienceCenter,Hawaii,USA)
Withadecliningpopulationofapproximately1100seals,Hawaiianmonksealsareonthebrinkofextinction.Thepopu-lationcanbedividedregionallywithmostmonksealsresidingintheremoteNorthwesternHawaiianIslands(NWHI)wherethedeclineisapproximately4%/yr,whereasrelativelyfewersealscurrentlyoccupythemainHawaiianIslands(MHI).TheMHIpopulationisincreasingatanestimated6.5%peryear.
ThesetrendsunderscoretheNationalMarineFisheriesService’s(NMFS)urgencytomitigatetheNWHIdeclinewhiledevotingconservationeffortstofosterpopulationgrowthintheMHI,wheredocumentedthreatsincludingfisheryinteractions,directkilling,anddiseasecouldundothecurrentfragilepositivetrend.NMFShasproposedalarge-scaleplantoimprovechronicpoor
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
40
juvenilesurvivalintheNWHI,managethecurrentgrowthintheMHIandpreservethepopulation’sreproductivepotentialoverall.
Marineprotectedareasmayplay akey role in the suc-cessorfailureofrecoveryeffortsforthemonkseal.ThePapahānaumokuākeaMarineNationalMonument(PMNM)protectsthenaturalandculturalresourcesintheNWHI,includ-ingmonkseals;however,someoftheactionsthathavebeenpro-posedtoassistinmonksealrecoverymightbeviewedaseithersupportingorinconsistentwiththePMNM’secosystemman-agementgoals,dependingontheinterpretationorprioritizationofthosegoals.IntheMHI,habitatprotectionincludingcriti-calhabitatdesignationandMPAscouldplayimportantrolesinprotectingandaidingtherecoveryofmonksealsinthefuture.
MPAshavearoleintherecoveryofHawaiianmonksealsbuttherearedifficultecological,cultural,andotherfactorstocon-siderintheirapplication.
Mediterranean monk seal (Monachus monachus) and marine protected areas in GreeceEleni Tryfon (NatureManagementSection,MinistryfortheEnvironment,EnergyandClimateChange,Greece)
Monachus monachusiswidelydistributedinGreecewhichhostsatleastonethirdoftheworldpopulationofthespecies.
Fortheconservationofthespecies,theNationalMarineParkofAlonissos–NorthernSporadeswasestablishedin1992,covering2265km2.Itisestimatedthattheparkhostsapproximately30%oftheknownGreekpopulationofthemonkseal.Thedesignationoftwonewmarineparks,inhabitedbyanadditional40%oftheknownpopulationofthespecies,isatthefinalstagesofproce-dure.However,theprocessofMPAdesignationhasbeenslow.
TheNationalMarineParkofAlonissos–NorthernSporadeshasbeenmanagedsince2003byamanagementbody,supportedbyanadvisoryboardonwhichcentralandlocalcompetentauthori-ties,localstakeholdersandNGOsarerepresented.Themanage-mentbodyhastofaceanumberofchallenges.Mostprominentamongthemare:enactmentandapplicationofalocalmanage-mentplanforthespecies,conflictwithlocalinterests,andfinanc-ingandcreationofanetworkofMPAsinGreece.
Mediterranean monk seals: Are marine protected areas the panacea for the conservation of the species in Greek seas?Vangelis Paravas (MOm/HellenicSocietyfortheStudyandProtectionoftheMonkSeal,Greece)
GreekseascurrentlyhostthelargestMediterraneanmonksealpopulationthroughoutthespecies’range.Despitetheircritically
endangeredstatus,monksealsarestillwidelydistributedacrosstheinsularandmainlandcoastlineofthecountry.Howeverthespeciesisfacingsubstantialanthropogenicpressuresandthreats,suchashabitatdestructionandhuman-relatedmortality.
ConservationandresearchinitiativescarriedoutduringthepastthreedecadeshavebeencriticalforensuringtheviabilityofthespeciesintheeasternMediterraneanSea.Theseefforts,predomi-nantlybyNGOs,havebeenfocusingonecologicalresearchonthespecies,promotingrelevantlegislationtomitigatethealarm-ingdeclineofitspopulations,demandingthestrictmeasuresnecessarytofacedirectandindirectthreats,andimplementingessentialin situconservationactions.
ThecurrentstatusofMediterraneanmonksealconservationinGreeceisstemmingfromadouble-axisapproach,basedontheestablishmentandoperationofMPAs,aswellasontheimple-mentationof“horizontal”–onanationalscale–conservationmeasures.Bothapproacheshavetheirsuccessesandstrengths,butalsotheirdefectsandweaknesses.Inprincipletheirresultsactreciprocallytoeachother;neverthelesstheirsuccessfulimplementationishinderedbynumerousecological,butalsosocio-economicfactors.ThispresentationdescribedtheGreekexperience,aswellasthestrategyandtherationalebehindtheeffortsaimingatthepreservationofthemostendangeredmarinemammalintheEuropeanUnion.
Rehabilitation of Mediterranean monk seals (Monachus monachus) as part of an integrated approach to its survivalLenie ‘t Hart(SealRehabilitationandResearchCentre,TheNetherlands)
Thehabitatofmonksealscoversadiverserangeofcountrieswhichposesdifferentchallengesinordertobeabletomaketherehabilitationeffortasuccess.Therehabilitationprocessformonksealsisnotaneasyone,butexternalfactorscomplicatemattersevenfurther.Threatsexistsuchasdrowningthroughentanglement,disturbancesandevenintentionalkilling.Theestablishmentofprotectedareasisoneofthenecessaryrequire-mentsinadditiontotherehabilitationprocess.Afterthesealisreleasedfromtherehabilitationfacilityitneedsanareawhereitcansurvivewithasfewthreatsaspossible.Nexttoprotectedareas,supportfromthelocalcommunityneedstobeenhancedwithregardtothesurvivalneedsofthespecies.Especiallyindevelopingcountriesthiscanbeaccomplishedthrougheduca-tionandintegrationwithprogramsthatimprovethequalityoflifeforthelocalpeople.
ThecaseofMauritania,whererehabilitation,protectionandtheconstructionofahospitalforthefishingcommunitywasinte-grated,provedtobeessentialforthesuccessoftherehabilita-tionprogramandtheseals’survivalafterrelease.Atthesametimeitfulfilledamoralobligationtowardsthepeoplelivingclosetotheseals.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
41
Inthiswaytheindividualmonksealundergoingrehabilitationactsasanambassadortogeneratesupportfortheprotectionofthespeciesingeneral.
The case study of the Desertas Islands Nature Reserve – A home for the Mediterranean monk seal, Monachus monachusRosa Pires (ParqueNaturaldaMadeiraService,Madeira)
In1988,theMediterraneanmonksealwasnearextinctioninPortugal.Thelastcolonyof6-8individuals,residentontheDesertasIslands(MadeiraArchipelago),wasfacingunsustainablefishingpressure(usinggillnetsandexplosivesintensively)andfishermen’shostility.Itwasurgenttoprotectthemonksealanditshabitat.ButtherewasabigproblemtocreateanMPAontheDesertasIslands–thesocio-economicsituationofthefishermen.
Todealwiththissituation,anawarenesscampaignwasimple-menteddirectedtothefishermen,andtheMPA,createdin1990,designatedanintegratedareawherecontrolledfishingwasallowed.Asfishingnetswereforbidden,alternativefishinginstrumentswereofferedtothefishermen.Sincethen,themainstrategytoachieveeffectiveprotectionoftheMPAhasincludedenforcementandenvironmentaleducation.Asaresult,themonksealpopulationrecovered(todaythereare30-40individuals),asdidotherfaunaandfloraspecies.MoreoverthereishugesupportfromMadeira’scitizens.
Thispresentationfocusedonthestrategyfollowedintheestab-lishmentofthereservewhichintegratedsocialandeconomicconcerns.Suchanapproachwasthekeytothesuccessoftheproject.
Conservation of the Mediterranean monk seal Monachus monachus in Turkey and the role of coastal and marine protected areasCem Orkun Kıraç(SAD-AFAG,UnderwaterResearchSociety–MediterraneanSealResearchGroup,Turkey)
ThehistoricaldistributionrangeoftheMediterraneanmonkseal,Monachus monachus(Hermann,1779),coveredthewholeoftheTurkishcoastsofapproximately8500kmwiththeonlyuncertaintybeingalongtheeasternTurkishBlackSeacoast.Today,thepatchydistributionofthespeciesinthecountrymainlyextendsalongtheTurkishAegeanandMediterraneancoastswithatotalpopulationofaround100individuals.ThespeciesexistsverysparselyintheSeaofMarmaraandisbelievedextinctalongtheBlackSeacoastsofTurkeywiththelastreliablesightingrecordin1997.
Currently,themostimportantthreatagainstthespeciesishabi-tatdegradationduetocoastaldevelopmentprojectsincludingnewroadconstructionandhousing.Otherimportantthreatsincludepupandjuveniledeathsduetoentanglementinset-netsresultingindrowningandthedisturbanceofsealsincavesbyintrudingdiversandexcursionboatslocallyintourismzones.Thedeliberatekillingsofsealsbyartisanalfishermenhavebeenrarelyobservedinthelasttwodecades.Therefore,thehabitatlossofthewildcoasts,astheonlyirreversibleprocessamongallthethreats,isregardedasthemajorthreatinthecountry.
EstablishmentofMPAsisthepre-requisitefortheconservationoftheMediterraneanseal.However,withoutcompletemanage-mentplans,MPApracticeswillnoteffectivelyfunctionfortheconservationofthespeciesanditshabitat.IntegratedCoastalandMarineManagement(ICMM)planningplays,therefore,acrucialroleforeffectivehabitatprotection.Therearetenspecialenvi-ronmentalprotectionareas(SEPAs),eightnationalparks(NPs),ninenaturereservesandfiveRamsarsitesalongTurkishcoasts,whichconstitutes4%ofthemarineareaandaround18%ofwholecoastline.OnlyGöksuSEPAisknowntohaveanapprovedman-agementplan.SelectioncriteriafornewMPAsshouldbesetuptoexpandMPAs,andICMMplanningshouldbecompletedforallthecoastalprotectedareas.Therearesuccessfulimplementa-tionexamplesofcoastalandmarinemanagementpracticesinthecountry,andthenationalbackground,theknow-howandscientificdataareavailableforsettingupselectioncriteriaandICMMdesign,basedontheexperiencesgained.
Summary of DiscussionEachprogramshareditscollectiveexperienceonthedevelop-mentandimplementationofMPAsformonksealconservation.AllprogramsagreedontheimportanceofMPAsbuteachgrouphaddifferentvisionsoftheirapplication.GreekrepresentativesbelievedthatMPAswereimportantbutgreater“horizontal”measureswereessentialtomakerecoveryeffortsmoreeffective.ProgramsworkingontheAtlanticpopulationshadextremelypositiveresultswiththeimplementationandenforcementofregulationsofmarineandcoastalprotectedareas.Thesepro-gramshighlightedthesuccessfulinclusionoflocalcommuni-tiesandincreasesinlocalmonksealpopulations.InTurkeytheexperiencehasbeenthatMPAswillnotfunctioneffectivelywithoutintegratedcoastalandmarinemanagementplanning.Ingeneral,managementandprotectionofthesediversifiedPAsareinsufficient,althoughtherearesuccessfulexamplesofPAmanagementpracticesinthecountry.Finally,thebulkoftheHawaiianmonksealpopulationanditshabitatintheNorthwestHawaiianIslandshasbeenprotectedbytheestablishmentofthePapahānaumokuākeaMarineNationalMonument,butthereareconcernsthatthebureaucracycreatedtomanagethisareamayobstructcriticalenhancementactivitiesinthefuture.TherecentlyestablishedpopulationofsealsinthemainHawaiianIslandsbenefitfromMPAsthathavebeenestablishedforotherreasons;however,thereissomeconcernaboutpotentialnega-tiveconsequencesofestablishinganyprotectedareasspecifi-callyforthespecies.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
42
Despitegreatdifferencesinpopulationtrends,threats,andcon-servationstrategiesacrossthegenus,participantsidentifiedthreesharedissuesofconcernregardingtheireffortstorecovermonksealspecies.Firstisthatactivelyengaginglocalcommunitiesiscriticalforeachproject’ssuccessandisnecessarytoachievelong-termrecoverygoals.Onlybyunderstandingtheneedsofcommunities,findingsharedgoals,andidentifyingcreativesolutions,canwecreatethecultureofco-existencenecessarytoensurethepersistenceofthesespecies.
Thefinaltwoissuesarecloselylinkedand,attimes,difficulttoseparate.Increasedandsustainedfundingandgreateractionandsupportbygovernmentagenciesareessentialtocompletethenumerousongoingandplannedinitiativestoprotecthabitats,increasesealsurvival,andbuildpartnershipswithkeystakehold-ers.Anumberofideasweresharedonhowpotentiallytoinflu-encegovernmentactionandfunding.Whilethegroupdidnotreachconsensusonaparticularstrategy,itwasacknowledgedthatitwouldrequireeffortsonbothinternationalandlocalscalesandwouldvarybasedontheneedsoftheindividualprograms.
Recommendations from Workshop 1Workshop 1 recommends t hat the ICMMPASteer ingCommitteeworkstofacilitatethefollowingthreeactionsformonksealrecovery:
Monksealsarethreatenedbysomeactivitiesofparticularmarineandcoastaluserssuchasfishermenandcoastaldevelopers.TheConferencerecommendsthatagroupofmonksealscientists,managersandadvocatesbeestablishedtoachievetwogoals.First,toworkwiththeseuserstofindcommonvaluesandsolutionstotheproblemsfacedbytheseusersandmonkseals.Thiscanbeachievedbyadaptingrelevantsuccessfulcooperativeagreementsthathavebeendevelopedbetweentheseusersandconservation-istsaroundtheworldtosolvethesharedproblems.And,second,toraiseawareness,understandingandmotivationbythepublictoapplythesesolutionstosavingmonkseals,byencouraginggovernmentstofulfilltheircommitmentsandobligationstoactonbehalfofmonkseals,theseusersandhealthierenvironments.
ThisConferenceacknowledgesthenumerousongoingeffortstoengagelocalcommunities,inparticularfishingcommunities,inmonksealconservation.Wecommendandencouragethecontinuationandexpansionoftheseactivitiesandrecommendthattheappropriateattentionisgiventosocialandeconomiccomponentsofconservationsolutions.
TheConferenceacknowledgestheextensiveresearchandrecov-eryinitiativesbeingundertakenatcurrentfundinglevelsandrealizesthatfinancialsupportforprojectswilllikelydimin-ishduringtheseeconomictimes.However,thisConferencestronglyurgesthatappropriateandsustainedfundingbeprovidedtoaccomplishtherecoveryneedsforthesecriticallyendangeredspecies.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
43
Workshop 2: River Dolphin, Estuary, and Coastal Dolphin Conservation
Coordinators: Fernando Trujillo(FundaciónOmacha,Colombia),Erich Hoyt(WhaleandDolphinConservationSociety,UnitedKingdom),Miguel Iñíguez(FundaciónCethusandWhaleandDolphinConservationSociety,Argentina)
Chair: Fernando Trujillo(FundaciónOmacha,Colombia)
Rapporteur: Catalina Gomez-Salazar(DalhousieUniversity,CanadaandFundaciónOmacha,Colombia)
Participants:HeatherAnderson,PatriciaAramayoMariscal,MikeBossley,NancyDaves,MauricioFailla,CatalinaGómez-Salazar,ErichHoyt,ChantalLandburg,MiriamMarmontel,BenjamínMorales,OliviaPatterson,MarcelaPortocarrero-Aya,RandallReeves,ChrisSchweizer,RavindraK.Sinha,BrianD.Smith,FernandoTrujillo,RobWilliams,others
Introduction and ObjectivesThis workshop explored the special habitat protection needs of river dolphins. A broad view of river dolphins was taken, includ-ing the taxonomic classes of the various river dolphins.
InSouthAmerica,therearethreegenera:Inia,Sotalia andPontoporia.Recentstudieshavesuggestedthatthebaiji,orpinkriverdolphin,Iniahastwospecies:Inia geoffrensisintheAmazonandOrinocobasins(Brazil,Colombia,Ecuador,Peru,FrenchGuianaandVenezuela)andInia boliviensisintheAmazonandMadeiraupperbasins(Bolivia).Thetucuxi(Sotalia fluviatilis)inhabitstheAmazonbasin,whiletheGuianadolphin(Sotalia guianensis)inhabitstheCaribbeanandAtlanticcoastsofSouthAmerica,includingsomeestuarineandriverineareas.Todate,itisunknownwhatspeciesofSotalia inhabitstheOrinocobasin.Franciscana,Pontoporia blainvillei,isfoundincoastalAtlanticwatersofsoutheasternSouthAmerica.
InAsiatherearetwogenera:Platanista and Orcaella.TheGangesRiverdolphinPlatanista gangetica gangeticaisfoundintheGanges-Brahmaputra-MeghnaandKarnaphuli-SanguriversystemsofBangladeshandIndia.TheIndusRiverdolphinP. g. minorisprimarilyrestrictedtolessthan700kmofriver,inthemainstreambetweentheSukkurandGuddubarragesinSindProvince.TheIrrawaddydolphin,Orcaella brevirostris, occursnearcoastalareasandinestuariesoftheBayofBengalandSoutheastAsia,includingKalimantanandthecentralIndonesianarchipelago,extendingtothePhilippines.
RiverdolphinsinAsiaandSouthAmericahavemanythreatsincommon,someofwhicharelocalizedsuchasbycatchandinten-tionalhuntingforbaitorotherusesandsomelarge-scalesuchasdamconstructionandupstreampollutioneffects.Ingeneraltherearefewprotectedareasdedicatedtothedolphins.SomedolphinsareinfactfoundinprotectedareasinSouthAmericaandsomeincludeportionsoftherivers.Yetwithoutspecialattentionto
thedolphinsorspecialdolphinhabitatzones,anyrealprotectionisinquestion.Complicatingtheissueisthepoliticalgeographywithvariousriverdolphinpopulationsspreadoverninecoun-triesofnorthernSouthAmericaandatleastfourcountriesinSouthAsiafortheGangesRiverdolphinandtwelvecountriesfortheIrrawaddydolphin.
Theobjectivewastobringdiverseriverdolphinexpertstogethertoconsiderhowhabitatprotectioncouldbenefitriverdolphinconservation.ThespeakersandparticipantswereweightedtowardSouthAmericanriverdolphinresearchersandmanag-ers,mainlybecauseoftheproximityofMartiniquetonorth-ernSouthAmerica.TwokeyinitiativesinSouthAmerica,theActionPlanforSouthAmericanRiverDolphinsandtheSouthAmericanRiverDolphinProtectedAreaNetworkwereonthetablefordiscussiontoseehowthesemightbeadvancedinthecomingyears.
Presentations
River dolphins as indicators of ecosystem degradation in large tropical riversCatalina Gomez-Salazar (DalhousieUniversity,CanadaandFundaciónOmacha,Colombia)
HumanstressorsarecurrentlyimpactingboththeAmazonandOrinocoriverbasinsandthesearelikelytoincrease.However,thereisalackofstandardizedmonitoringprogramstotrackthesehumanstressorsinmostofthecountriesthatoverlapthesebasins,andnoclearecologicalindicatorshavebeenidentifiedtotrackthisdegradation.
Inthisstudyweinvestigatedthestatisticalrelationshipsbetweenestimatesofecosystemdegradationandpotentialecologicalindicators.Thepresenceofhumanstressorsandtheirdistancefromtheareassurveyedwereusedtoprovideanestimateofecosystemdegradation.Moreover,wetestedthreeecologicalindicatorsoffreshwaterecosystemdegradationusingriverdol-phinsasflagshipspecies:
• Densityofriverdolphins.
• Meandolphingroupsizeofdolphins.
• Dolphinsightingrates.
RiverdolphindensityestimatesinselectedlocationsoftheAmazonandOrinococanbegoodindicatorsoffreshwaterecosystemdegradation:ahighlysignificantnegativerelation-shipwasestablishedbetweendegradationanddolphindensities
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
44
andsightingrates.Moreover,sightingratesanddensitieswerehighlycorrelated.
Thisstudyhighlightsthatriverdolphinsaregoodcandidatesasecologicalindicators,flagshipandsentinelspeciesformoni-toringtheconservationstatusoflargetropicalriversinSouthAmerica.Wesuggestthateffortshouldbedirectedtowardcol-lectingreliabledataonhumanstressors,creatingcollaborativenetworksforcompilingexistingdata,andtodocumentingandmonitoringcurrenttrendsinfreshwaterecosystemdegrada-tionandindicatorspeciesintheAmazonandOrinocobasins.
The South American River Dolphin Protected Area Network SARDPAN Marcela Portocarrero-Aya (UniversityofHull,UKandFundaciónOmacha,Colombia)
Riverdolphinsarecurrentlyexposedtopressuresthatrangefromhabitatlossanddegradation,directkilling,conflictswithfisheries,tominingandinfrastructuredevelopment.Freshwatercetaceanshavebeenidentifiedassurrogatesofconservationcharacterizingecologicalprocessesthatsupportlocalbiodiver-sityandensuringprovisionofecosystemservicesandsocietalbenefitstotheregion.Potentially,thecurrentmethodofpro-tectingthespacewhereaspeciesexistsimprovesitschancesofconservationbyensuringtheprotectionofecosystemservicesandtheimprovementofthelivelihoodsoflocalcommunities.
Protectedareasalsoenablethreatstobecontrolledandareakeytoolforprovidingasoundbasisformanagementofecosys-tems,theirecosystemservicesandofendangeredspecies.Thishelpstomaintainecologicalprocesses,conservationofgeneticvariability,andtheproductivecapacitiesoftheseecosystems.
ThecreationoftheSouthAmericanRiverDolphinProtectedAreaNetwork(SARDPAN)constitutesaregionalcoopera-tioninitiativestretchingacrossSouthAmericatoevaluateandimprovethehabitatconservationofriverdolphinsbybring-ingtogetherresearchers,managers,policymakersandlocalcommunities.
The Action Plan for South American River Dolphins and major human stressors that impact river dolphins directly: Interactions with fisheries and killing of dolphins to be used as baitFernando Trujillo (FundaciónOmacha,Colombia)
Duringthelastfiveyears,negativeinteractionswithfisheriesanddeliberatekillinghavebecomethemainthreatsforriverdolphinsintheAmazonandOrinocobasins.Themotafisherystimulatesthehuntingofatleast900dolphinsperyearinBrazilalonefor
useasbait,andthemarketisbeingexpandedinColombia,BrazilandPeru.DespiteseveraleffortsfromNGOsandgovernmentstostopthekillingofdolphins,solutionsarenotinprocessduetotheeconomicsituationintheregion.Additionally,atleasttwocasesofdeliberatepoisoningofdolphinshavebeendocumentedinPerutoreduceinteractionswithlocalfisheries.
Asaresponsetothesestressors,aSouthAmericanActionPlanforriverdolphinshasbeenproduced,identifyingspecificactionstoimproveknowledge,implementconservationworkandreduceandmitigatehumanimpacts.Thisregionalactionplanhasmoti-vatedthecreationofnationalplansforriverdolphinsinBolivia,Peru,EcuadorandColombia.
Conservation of freshwater dolphins in protected areas: Mamiraua as a case studyMiriam Marmontel (InstitutodeDesenvolvimentoSustentavelMamiraua,Brazil)
TheMamirauaSustainableDevelopmentInstituteco-managestwolargestategovernment-ownedsustainabledevelopmentreservesinthewesternBrazilianAmazon:MamirauaandAmana.Together,theycompriseover3millionhectares,con-tainingbothfloodplainsandterrafirma,murkyandblackwaterenvironments.
TwospeciesofSouthAmericanfreshwaterdolphins(Inia geof-frensis andSotalia fluviatilis)occurthroughouttheseprotectedareas.Bothspeciesarepartofthedailylifeandfolkloreoftheregion.Localpeople’sancestralrelationshipwiththewater-worldinhabitantsinfluenceslocalconservation.Untilrecentlyonecouldstillfindbirthcertificateswherethefather snamewas“TheBoto”,andwomenstillavoidridingtheirdugoutcanoesduringtheirperiod,orcarrygarlicstringstoprotectthemselvesagainsttheevilcreature,orfrombeingtakentothe“encantados”(literallythe“enchantedones”,referringtothebotodolphinsthoughttobeabletoturnintohumans).
Bothdolphinspeciesarepronetobecomingentangledinfishingnets,butwhiletucuxiisusuallyreleased,botoisoftenmaimedorkilled.Morerecentlythiskillinghasbeenusedtogetbaitforpiracatingafishing.Botomaybeintentionallykilledforthisfish-ingpracticeaswell,aproblemthathasbeenescalatinginthepast10years.DealingwiththesedifferentsourcesofmortalityandmotivesarethechallengesofconservingfreshwaterdolphinsintheBrazilianAmazon.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
45
Establishing protected areas for freshwater cetaceans: Case studies from the Ayeyarwady River, Myanmar, and waterways of the eastern Sundarbans mangrove forest, BangladeshBrian D. Smith(WildlifeConservationSociety(WCS),USA)
Coauthors: Ishtiaq Ahmad(ForestDepartment,Bangladesh),Benazir Ahmed(UniversityofChittagong,Bangladesh),Zahangir Alom(WCS,Bangladesh),Aung Myo Chit(WCS,Myanmar),Tapan Kumar Dey(ForestDepartment,Bangladesh),Elisabeth Fahrni Mansur(WCS,Bangladesh),Rubaiyat Mowgli Mansur(WCS,Bangladesh),Mya Than Tun(DepartmentofFisheries,Myanmar)
Protectedareashavebeenusedextensivelyasamanagementtoolforconservingmarinecetaceans.Lessemphasishasbeengiventoestablishingprotectedareasforfreshwatercetaceans,andthelocationsandboundariesofthefewthathavebeenestablishedhavegenerallybeendeterminedopportunisticallywithoutrigor-ousconsiderationofhabitatuse,ecosystem-basedmanagement,orlocalhumanneeds.
Twocasestudiesarepresentedonestablishingprotectedareasforfreshwatercetaceans:oneforIrrawaddydolphinsintheAyeyarwadyRiver,Myanmar,andtheotherinthewaterwaysoftheeasternSundarbansmangroveforest,Bangladesh.Inbothcases,thefirststepwastoconductbroad-scalesystematicsur-veystoassessthedistributionandabundanceofthepopulations,followedbymorein-depthstudiesonhabitatselection,fisher-iesecology,andhumaninteractions.IntheAyeyarwadyRiver,anemphasiswasplacedonunderstandingthefisherydynam-icsandenlistingthesupportofcast-netfishermenwhocoop-eratewiththedolphinstocatchmorefish.IntheSundarbans,astrongemphasiswasplacedonidentifying“hotspots”ofdol-phinabundanceandcomparingtheecologicalandhuman-usecharacteristicsofthesechannelswith“non-hotspot”channels.
River dolphin conservation in IndiaRavindra K. Sinha(CentralUniversityofBihar,India)
TheGangesdolphin,isanexclusivelyfreshwaterdolphin,foundintheGangesBrahmaputra-MeghnariverbasinofIndia,NepalandBangladesh.Thecurrentestimatedpopulationisabout2,500-3,000animals.Theireyeslackacrystallinelenssotheyareblind.Theyhavemanyprimitivecharacters,namelypresenceofcaecum,amuchmoredorsaltestisposition,andsubcutaneousmusclesituatedbetweentwolayersofblubber,noneofwhicharefoundinothercetaceans.
Thethreatsthesedolphinsarefacingincludeexploitationaswellashabitatdegradationduetodeclinedflows,pollution,waterdevelopmentprojects,andfloodcontrolmeasures.IthasbeencategorizedasendangeredontheIUCNRedlist,listedinCITES
Appendix1,CMSAppendixII,andasa“Schedule–1”animalundertheIndianWildlife(Protection)Act1972.
TheGovernmentofIndia’sinitiativestosavetheecologicalinteg-rityandfunctionoftheGangesRiversystemwillhelpimprovedolphinhabitat.ThisspecieswasdeclaredaNationalAquaticAnimalin2010.
AConservationActionPlanpreparedforthisdolphinincludeshabitatrestoration,communityparticipation,capacitybuilding,monitoring,settingupprotectedareas,educationandaware-ness,minimizingincidentalcatches,rescueandrehabilitation,andresearchanddevelopmentprograms.
Franciscana dolphin conservation in Patagonia: Promoting a new protected area in the Río Negro EstuaryMauricio Failla(FundaciónCethus,Argentina)
Coauthors: Verónica Seijas(ProyectoPatagoniaNoreste,Argentina)andMiguel A. Iñíguez(FundaciónCethusandWhaleandDolphinConservationSociety,Argentina)
Thefranciscanadolphin(Pontoporia blainvillei)isthemostendangereddolphinofSouthAmerica:thousandsdieeachyearingillnets.ItisendemictotheSouthAmericancoastborder-ingthesouthwesternAtlanticOceanwherefourmanagementareashavebeenidentified,withasuggestedgeneticallyisolatedpopulationinArgentina.
Since2002,wehavestudiedfranciscanabioecologyintheRíoNegroEstuary(RNE),Patagonia,todesignstrategiesforitscon-servation.Groupsizevariedfromonetofivedolphins.Travelling,feeding,socializationandrestingbehaviorwererecorded.Calveswereobservedinspringandsummer.
ThemainthreatintheRNEisgillnetting.Fromatotaloftenstrandings,threehadsignsofbeingincidentallycaughtandanotherfourcaseswerereportedbylocalfishermen.Inordertomitigatetheimpactcausedbybycatch,aneducationalpro-gramfocusingonfranciscanaandothercetaceansiscarriedoutintheRNE.
Franciscanaisreportedyear-roundinthestudyareaandthisareaisconsideredthesouthernmostreportedfeedingandbreedingarea.Therefore,weareworkingwithotherinstitutionsinclud-ingtheRíoNegroprovincialgovernmenttocreateandimple-mentaprotectedareaintheRNEtoprotectthefranciscanaanditshabitat.
Summary of DiscussionFollowingthepresentations,theworkshopparticipantsdiscussedvariousthreatstoriverdolphinsincludingwaterdevelopmentprojects,climatechangeanddolphinsforuseasbaitinSouthAmerica.Participantsthentriedtoagreeonvariouspossiblerec-ommendationsrelatedtohabitatprotectionforriverdolphins.It
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
46
wasdecidedthatonerecommendationwouldbemoregeneral,onewouldfocusonSouthAmericaandoneonAsia.
Waterdevelopmentprojects:ThedrainageareasofseveralriversinAsiahavefacedextremechangesduetotheconstructionofdamsandwaterways.TheXinguRiverBasininAmazoniawillfacesimilarchangesinthenextfewyearswiththeconstructionoftheBeloMontedam.Damsarebuiltforfloodcontrol,irriga-tionandhydroelectricpower;however,severalassessmentshaveshownthatthefinaloutcomeoftendoesnotmeettheexpectedeconomicbenefitsandinsteadgeneratesmajorenvironmental,socialandhealthimpacts.Intermsofbiodiversityandecologi-calprocesses,theconstructionofdamscanfragmentpopula-tions,reduceriverflow,affectriverpulses,changethewaterquality,andultimatelycontributetotheextinctionofmanyspecies,includingperhapsriverdolphins.However,therearenobaselineassessmentsofriverdolphinpopulationsbeforeandaftertheconstructionofdams.Thesetypesofassessmentsareofhighprioritytoprovidequantitativedatathatshouldbeconsideredinrelationtothefurtherdamsthatareplanned.Inaddition,itwasnotedthatitisoftendifficultforriverdolphinresearchersandprotectedareamanagerstokeeptrackofdamsthatarebeingplannedoftenfarupstreamandsometimeslocatedindifferentcountries.
Climatechange:Thecascadingeffectsofclimatechangewilllikelyimpactriverdolphins,biodiversityandhumanpopula-tionsinAsia.Initially,increasedmeltingoftheHimalayaswillincreasewateravailability.Subsequently,therewillbeseverewatershortageswhenglacierscompletelydisappearorapproachnewequilibria.8TherewasnodiscussionaboutthepotentialimplicationsofclimatechangeforSouthAmericandolphins.
DolphinsforuseasbaitinSouthAmerica:ThecaptureofIniadolphinsforuseasbaitinthemota(Calophysus macropterus)fisheryisoneofthemostserioushumanstressorsthatmightincreaseinthenearfuture.However,thereislimitedinforma-tionregardingthenumberofdolphinsthatarebeingkilledperyearandmostoftheinformationcomesfromdataonfisheries.Thediscussionfocusedon(1)providingpotentialmitigationsactionstostopthisactivity,and(2)planningeffortstoconductabundanceestimatesofriverdolphinpopulationsinareaswherethisactivityoccurs(e.g.,MamirauaReserve,Brazil).
Recommendations from Workshop 2Workshop2preparedthreerecommendations:oneforriverdol-phinsinSouthAmericaandAsia,oneforSouthAmericanriverdolphins,andoneforAsianriverdolphins.
Workshop2recognizesthatthelargenumberofdamscurrentlybeingconstructed,orintheadvancedstagesofplanning,intheAmazon,Orinoco,Yangtze,Ayeyarwady,Mekong,GangesandBrahmaputrariversystemswilldramaticallyaffecttheenvi-ronmentsinhabitedbyfreshwaterdolphinsandotheraquatic
8 SeeJianchuXu,2009.TheMeltingHimalayas:CascadingEffectsofClimateChangeonWater,Biodiversity,andLivelihoods.Conservation Biology23,3:520-530.
mammalsandhavestrongimplicationsfortheestablishmentofprotectedareasaimingtoconservethesespecies.
(1)Theworkshoprecommends thatupstream-downstreamcon-nectivityandecologicallyviableflowbetakenintoaccountinthedesignandmanagementofprotectedareas.Inaddition,acomprehensiveinventoryshouldbeconductedofplannedandrecentdamsconstructedinriversystemsinhabitedbyfreshwaterdolphins,andtheconservationrequirementsoftheseanimalsbegivenstrongconsiderationinthedecision-makingprocessofwhetherornottoconstructnewdamsandintheoperatingproceduresofdamsthathavealreadybeenbuiltinriversystemsinhabitedbythesespecies.
Workshop2recognizesthattheSouthAmericanRiverDolphinProtectedAreaNetwork(SARDPAN)isacollaborative,low-cost,andrelativelysimpletooltocommunicateandlinkresearchers,organizationsandprotectedareas.ThisnetworkwasannouncedduringtheFirstInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas(2009),andsincethen,significanteffortshavetakenplacetowardsaccomplishingsomeofthemajorrecom-mendationsgiveninMaui.Theseaccomplishmentsincludebeginningtoprovideriverdolphinpopulationestimatesforsomeareas,identifyinghotpotsandcriticalareas,quantifyinghumanstressors,compilinginformationonexistingprotectedareaswheredolphinsoccur,andconnectingresearchersacrossdifferentcountries.
(2)Recognizingthemomentumofthisregionalnetwork,theworkshoprecommendsthatSARDPANbestrengthenedtocon-tinuetofillgapsininformation,todevelopproposalsforregionalconservationinitiativeswithemphasisonprotectedareas,andtoconveyscience-basedinformationtostakeholdersincludingdifferentlocalcommunitiesandmanagers.
Workshop2furtheracknowledgesthatthemostcriticalshort-termthreatfacingAsianfreshwatercetaceansisbycatchinfish-eries,particularlyentanglementingillnetsandlong-lineswithmultiplehooks,andinsomeareaselectrocutionfromillegalelectro-fishing.TheworkshopalsorecognizesthatprotectedareasforAsianfreshwatercetaceansmustbalancetheconser-vationneedsoftheseanimalswiththoseoflargeandgrowinghumanpopulations.
(3)Theworkshopthereforerecommendsthatexistingandplannedprotectedareasincludezoningsuchthatsomeportionsaredesignatedasno-fishingzoneswhileothersallowregulatedandmonitoredfishingactivitiesusing“dolphin-safe”techniques.Theselatterportionsshouldalsobeusedas“livinglaboratories”whereenvironmentallysustainablefishingpracticescouldbetestedforpotentialapplicationoutsideofprotectedareas.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
47
Workshop 3: Bycatch and Marine Mammal Protected Areas
Coordinator and Chair: Greg Donovan (HeadofScience,InternationalWhalingCommission,UK)9
Rapporteur:Jaclyn Taylor(NOAAFisheries,OPR,USA)
Participants: Yong-RockAn,AlexeiBirkun,GregDonovan,MauricioFailla,ScottGende,AlexandraGigou,Marie-ChristineGrillo-Compulsione,TiareT.Holm,ErichHoyt,ArtieJacobson,CecileLefeuvre,DavidMattila,SarahMesnick,JenniferMurphy,FrançoisPoisson,SandraPompa,OscarRamírez,RandallReeves,LionelReynal,CarolineRinaldi,LorenzoRojasBracho,TeriRowles,HassaniSami,BrianD.Smith,HawsunSohn,AurelieTasciotti,JaclynTaylor,StevenTucker,OlivierVanCanneyt,GaëlleVandersarren,NinaYoung
Introduction and ObjectivesWorkshopdiscussionswerefacilitatedbyfivepresentationsthatcoveredvariousaspectsofthebycatchissuerangingfromaglobaloverview,initiativestotrytoaddresstheproblemworldwideandlocalcasestudiesonthetestingofgearandonpreventionattemptsforacriticallyendangeredspecies,thevaquita.
Ithasbeenknownformanyyearsthatthebycatchofmarinemammalsinmanytypesoffishinggearisaworldwideproblem(e.g.,IWC,1994).Inadditiontoanimalwelfareconcerns,itisprobablythemajorpopulationlevelthreatfacingmostsmallcetaceanpopulationsaroundtheworldaswellassmallpopu-lationsofsomelargewhales.Ithascontributedtodeclinesinpopulationsofpinnipedsandsirenians.Inaddition,bycatch(anddepredation)causesproblemsforfishermenatavarietyoflevelsincludinglossanddamageofgearaswellasbadpublic-itythatmayleadtoreducedorclosedfisheries.Addressingthisproblemisthusimportantbothfromtheperspectiveofmarinemammalsandfishermenalike;solutionsaremostlikelytocomefromcooperationnotconfrontation.
Manypreviousworkshopsandpapershavedealtwiththedifficul-tiesofobtainingreliableestimatesofmarinemammalbycatchanddeterminingsustainablelevels(inmanycases,especiallyforsmallcetaceans,theinformationonbycatchlevels,popula-tionstructureandabundanceiseveninsufficienttoestimatewhatsustainablelevelsmightbe).Thosetopicswereconsideredbeyondthescopeofthisshortworkshop,althoughtheneedtoobtainabundanceestimatesforpopulations(notmerelyforabundancewithinjurisdictionalboundaries)toassessthreatswasemphasized.Theprimaryobjectiveofthepresentworkshopwastoexaminethecontributionthatmarineprotectedareascouldmaketolocalandglobaleffortstoreducelevelsofmarinemammalbycatch.
9 IntheabsenceofArneBjørgewhowasunfortunatelyunabletoattendduetoillness,GregDonovanchairedtheWorkshop.ThereportwasdraftedbyJaclynTaylorandGregDonovan.
Summaries of Presentations
Global review of marine mammal bycatch in gillnet and other entangling-net fisheries, 1990-2011Randall Reeves(Chair,IUCNSSCCetaceanSpecialistGroup,andOkapiWildlifeAssociates,Canada)
Coauthors: Kate McClellanandTim Werner
Sincethe1970s,theroleofbycatchasafactorlimitingorreduc-ingmarinemammalpopulationshasbeenincreasinglyrecog-nized.Theproceedingsofa1990IWCSymposiumandWorkshopontheMortalityofCetaceansinPassiveFishingNetsandTrapsinLaJolla,California,includedasummaryoffisheryandbycatchdatabyregion,byfishery,andbyspecies,aswellasanexperts’evaluationofthesignificanceofthe“impacts”ofbycatchinpas-sivegearonallcetaceanspeciesandonnumerousgeographi-callydefinedpopulations.Thatreporthighlightedsixspeciesorpopulationsasneedingurgentactiontoreduceunsustainablebycatch:thebaiji,thevaquita,coastalhumpbackdolphinsandbottlenosedolphinsinNatal(SouthAfrica),stripeddolphinsintheMediterraneanSea,andharborporpoisesinthewesternNorthAtlantic.
Muchhaschangedintheensuing20-plusyearsintermsofbothwhatisknownaboutbycatchandwhichspeciesandpopulationsareperceivedasbeingatgreatestrisk.Forexample,thebaijiisnowconsideredextinct,thevaquitahascontinuedtodeclineasadirectresultofunsustainablebycatch,andcoastaldolphinsinNatalcontinuetobekilledinanti-sharknetswiththesustain-abilityofthismortalitystillunclear.Ontheotherhand,stripeddolphinsintheMediterraneanandharborporpoisesinthewest-ernNorthAtlantichaveproventobelessseriouslythreatenedthanwasassumedin1990,althoughbothpopulationscontinuetoexperienceconsiderablebycatchmortality.
Intermsofbroaderchanges,large-scaledriftnetfishingonthehighseasisnowlegallyprohibitedbytheUnitedNationsandregionalbansondriftnettingareinplaceinsomeareas,althoughthesearenotalwayscompletelyeffective(e.g.,intheMediterranean).Itremainstruethatevenasothersignificantthreatstomarinemammalpopulationshavebecomebetterdocumentedandunderstood–underwaternoise,shipstrikes,reductionsinpreypopulations,toxicalgalblooms,epizooticdisease,andvariousenvironmentalchangesrelatedtoglobalwarming–bycatchremainsacriticalissuedemandingurgentattentionifthereistobeanyhopeofpreventingfurtherlossesofmarinemammaldiversityandabundanceandprotecting,orrestoring,ecologicalhealth.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
48
Theobjectivesofthisongoingstudyofmarinemammalbycatchareto:
• Updatesomeoftheinformationsummarizedinthe1990IWCreport.
• Reassesstheimpactofgillnetmortalityoncetaceanspeciesandpopulations,weighingitssignificanceinrelationtootherthreats.
• Assessbycatchdataonmarinemammalsotherthancetaceans(i.e.,pinnipeds,sirenians,andtwootterspecies).
• Determinewhereimportanttemporal,spatial,ortaxonomicdatagapsexist.
• Identifyspeciesandpopulationsknownorlikelytobeatgreatestriskfrombycatchingillnets.
Efforts to control marine mammal bycatch using the international provisions of the Marine Mammal Protection ActNina M. Young(NOAAFisheries,OfficeofInternationalAffairs,USA)
Bycatchisrecognizedasthemajorthreatfacingmarinemam-mals.Mostmarinemammalprotectedareamanagersfindbycatchassessmentandmitigationaparticularchallenge.
IntheUnitedStates,theMarineMammalProtectionAct(theAct)providesthetoolstoprotectmarinemammalsfromU.S.activitiesonthehighseasandtonegotiatewithnationstopro-tectandconservemarinemammalsininternationalandforeignwaters.InimplementingtheAct,theNationalMarineFisheriesServiceisalsorequiredtodemonstratethatdomesticeffortstoprotectmarinemammalsultimatelydonotplaceU.S.industriesatacompetitivedisadvantagetoforeignindustriesthatarenotconstrainedbysimilarconservationmeasures.
Additionally,intheUnitedStates,consumerstypicallydonotwanttopurchaseseafoodthatcontributestothekillingofmarinemammals.Therefore,theActrequiresthattheUnitedStatesbanimportsoffishandfishproductsfromnationswhosefisheriesexceedU.S.marinemammalbycatchreductionstandards.TheUnitedStateshasneverfullyimplementedthisportionoftheAct,butiscurrentlyconsideringdraftregulationsinresponsetoapetitiontobanswordfishimports.ImplementationofthisprovisionoftheActopensupnewavenuesforscientificcol-laborationandcapacitybuildingtoestimatemarinemammalpopulationsandbycatchaswellastodevelopasuiteofbycatchmitigationmeasures.ItalsoprovidesaprocessfortheUnitedStatestoengagewithitstradingpartnersandanincentiveforthesepartnerstorealizesignificantbycatchreductionandimprovedeffortstoconservemarinemammals.
A new capacity building and bycatch mitigation initiative from the International Whaling Commission (IWC)David Mattila (IWCandNOAA-ONMS,USA)
TheInternationalWhalingCommissionhasrecentlybeenwork-ingtoadvancetheunderstandingof,responsetoandpreventionoflargewhalebycatch.Thisincludedmoredetaileddiscussionsoftheresultsandrecommendationsofa2010workshoponthistopicinMaui,USA.Theworkshoprealizedthatfisheriesobserverprogramsarenotwellsuitedtounderstandingthescopeandimpactofthisissueforlargewhales,asthewhalesfrequentlydragthefishinggearawayfromitssetlocation,andtheentanglementisthereforenotfoundorcounted.
Currently,theprimarytoolsforgatheringthisinformationforlargewhalesare:
• Betterresponsetostrandedcarcasses.
• Theestablishmentofareportingandresponsenetworkforentangledliveanimals.
• Entanglementscarringstudies.
Abriefoverviewofeachwasgiven,includingadiscussionofthestrengthsandweaknessesofeachapproach.InordertoadvancetherecommendationsoftheMauiworkshop,theIWCsponsoredasecondworkshopinProvincetown,USA(2011).Althoughthereportoftheworkshopwasnotyetpublic,examplesofthekeyitemsontheagendawerediscussed,includingsomecurrentlyusedcomponentsofcapacitybuilding,andsomeuniversallyadheredtoprinciplesandguidelinesforsafe,professionalentan-glementresponse.Theseprinciples,andsomeofthebasicsofentanglementresponse,weresummarizedinashort“outreach”videoproducedbyNOAA,USA.
Bycatch initiatives in a newly created MPA in Brittany (Iroise Sea)Hassani Sami(Oceanopolis,France)
Coauthors: Yvon Morizur, Philippe Le Niliotand Eric Stephan
ApingerexperimentwascarriedoutontheFrenchtrammelnetfisheryinthemarineprotectedareaoffthewestcoastofBrittanyinordertocompareacousticmitigationmeasuresforharbourporpoises.Threetypesofpingerdevices(Aquamark 100,Marexi V2.2,DDD02)wereusedforporpoisemitigationintheareawherenobycatchestimationhadpreviouslybeenmade.ThepingersDDD02wereattachedateachendofthenetneartheanchor.ThepingersAquamark 100andMarexi V2.2wereattachedtotheheadlineofthenetsandwerespacedapart400mand200mrespectively.TheECregulation812/2004requiressuchapilotstudy.Duringthestudy,observersatseaweredeployedonboardtenfishingvesselsfromLeConquetandAudierneharbors.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
49
Duringoneyear,462kmofcontrolnets(non-equippednets)and150kmofequippednetssharedbetweenthethreesystemswereobservedinordertocomparebycatch,aswellasphysicalreliabilityandpracticabilityofpingers.
Threeharbourporpoises,Phocoena phocoena,werecaughtinthecontrolnetswhereastwoporpoisesandtwogreyseals,Halichoerus grypus,wererecordedinthenetsequippedwithAquamark 100.Thebycatchratewas0.006porpoiseperkilo-meteronthecontrolnetsandtwicemoreonthepingerednetsandsixtimesmoreforthoseequippedwiththeAquamark 100.Nostatisticaltestcanbeperformedduetothesmallnumbersofbycatchesobserved.Thepracticability,reliabilityandcostswerealsoanalyzedforeachpingertype.Theresultswerediscussedinrelationtomitigationmeasuresandregulations.
Coping with bycatch of a critically endangered species: The vaquita conservation action planOscar Ramírez-Flores (CONANP,México)
Thevaquita,discoveredjust53yearsago,isnowoneofthemostcriticallyendangeredmarinemammals.Inordertoprotectthespecies,alongwiththetotoaba(anendangeredfishspecies),theBiosphereReserveoftheUpperGulfofCaliforniaandColoradoRiverDeltawasestablishedin1993.Inthelate1990s,scientistsestimatedapopulationofabout567individuals.TheInternationalCommitteefortheRecoveryofVaquita(CIRVA),identifiedbycatchasthemainrisktothespecies.
InSeptember2005,aRefugeAreawasestablishedandapro-tectionprogramofgeneralguidelines,wasissuedinDecember.Unfortunately,thishighlightedaconflictwithartisanalfishing,whichisthemaineconomicactivityinSanFelipe,BajaCaliforniaandGolfodeSantaClara,Sonora.Trawlingisalsoimportant,andalthoughitdoesnotrepresentagreatdangertothevaquita,itdoesrepresentanimportantimpacttotheseafloor.
Asof2007,thelegalartisanalfishingeffortwasestimatedtobe1700boats(pangas)withatleasttwofishingpermits(finfishandshrimp)usingtrammelandgillnets,plus162trawlers–allconductingfishingactivitiesinthebufferzoneoftheBiosphereReserveandwithinthedistributionrangeofthevaquita.TheGulfofCaliforniaisconsideredahighlyproductiveecosystem,andassuch,intheUpperGulf,thereareimportantareaswherehighqualityblueshrimpareharvested,withincometoboththeartisanalandindustrialfleets.
Inthiscontext,withtheintenttoprotectthevaquita,environ-mentalauthoritiesformulatedandbegantheimplementationoftheVaquitaConservationActionPlanin2007,withthegoalofeliminatingbycatchbyreducingfishingeffortthroughvolun-tarybuy-outandsubstitutionofgillandtrammelnetsbymoreselectivefishingmethods.Technologicaldevelopmentofalterna-tivefishinggearandbiologicaldiversityconservationactionsintheRefugeAreawerealsopromoted.Todate,theSecretariatof
EnvironmentandNaturalResourceshasspentmorethan400millionpesos(morethan$30millionUSD)butthereisstillalongwaytogoandtimeisshortforthesurvivalofthevaquita.Theprotectedarea’smanagementbodyhasthewillbutnottheauthoritytoregulatefisheries,whichcomplicatesthechancetosucceedandtobeabletocontributetospeciesconservation.
ExperiencesintheimplementationoftheActionPlanhavetaughtusvariouslessons,whichnowcanbeturnedintorecommenda-tionsforscientists,politicians,decision-makersandcivilsocietyorganizationsconcernedaboutspeciesconservation:
• Threatstovaquitahavebeenreducedsignificantlybutnotsufficiently.
• Fishingefforthasbeenreducedandafisheriesmanagementprocessisbeingimplemented.
• Fishermenhaveinitiatedsuccessfulalternativeeconomicactivitieswhichprovidethemaproperlivelihood.
• Themechanismsofcontinuousdialogueandcoordinationofeffortsbetweenfishermenandgovernmenthavehelpedusreachinstitutionalagreements.
• ThebasisforsustainablefishingintheUpperGulfhasbeenestablished.
• ThereisanurgentneedforbetterfisheryregulationsenforcementandthedevelopmentofspecificregulationsandenforcementfortheupperGulfofCalifornia.
Summary of DiscussionAkeycomponentofthedevelopmentofmitigationandultimatelypreventionisanunderstandingoftheentanglementprocessfordifferentspeciesanddifferentgear;collectingrelevantdataandinformationfromentanglements,aswellasdisentanglements,isessential.
Ongoingandextensiveworkonthisproblemhasrevealedthatthereisnouniversalpanacea–localsolutionstolocalproblemswillneedtobefoundincooperationwithstakeholders.Thisisparticularlytruewhenexaminingthedifferentscalesandresourcesavailableforsuchcategoriesaslarge-scalecommercialversusartisanalfisheries,operationsindevelopedversusdevel-opingcountriesand/oroperationsinnationalwatersofoneormorecountriesversushighseas.
Itisimportanttorecognizethatwhileindividualbycatchesrep-resentanimportantanimalwelfareconsideration,bycatchesoftenrepresentathreattopopulationsor,inthecaseofthevaquita,aspecies.Inthatcontext,theeffectivenessorotherwiseofmitigationmeasureswithinboundariesoftheMMPAwillbedeterminedbytherelationshipoftheextentoftheMMPAtothetotalrangeofthepopulationandthebycatchthreat.Thus,pro-tectingmarinemammalsfrombycatcheswithinMMPAsalonewilloftenbeinsufficient.Reductionofbycatchshouldbeseenasasharedproblemofmanyincludingscientists,environmentalauthorities,fishermen,fishingauthorities,managersandNGOs.Withoutcooperationandtrustamongstallthesegroupsleadingtoactionsinatimelymanner,theremaybeseriousconsequences
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
50
formarinemammalpopulationsaswitnessedbythesadcaseofthevaquita.Itisespeciallyimportantthatenvironmentalandfisherymanagementauthoritiesworktogether,somethingthatunfortunatelyisuncommon.
Recommendations from Workshop 3Workshop3recommendsthattheSteeringCommitteeworkstofacilitatethefollowingactionswithinMMPAs(singly,inregionalgroupsand/oringroupsrepresentativeofparticularcircum-stancesrelatedtofishingtypes,speciesandresources)toassistwithaddressingthebycatchproblem,namelythat:
MMPAsactasanexamplebybringingtogetherthevariousstakeholderstoworkcollaborativelyonthisissueasanimpor-tantcomponentofMMPAmanagementplansandwhereappro-priate,legislation.
Whereappropriate(recognizingtheneedforpoweranalysesandproperlydesignedstudiesfortestingthattakeintoaccountlikelysamplesizes),MMPAsactivelyencourageinitiativesforthedevelopmentandtestingofmarinemammalsafefishinggear(note:thismayrequirezoning).
MMPAscontributetothenecessaryknowledgetoassessbycatchatthepopulationlevelbyatleastexaminingstockstructure,densityandfishingtypeandeffortwithintheirboundaries,recognizingthatthisinformationaloneisnotusuallysufficient.
MMPAsserveasfocalpointsforessentialcapacitybuildingini-tiativesrelatedtodisentanglementandprevention.
MMPAsincreasepublicawarenessofthisissueincludingtheprovisionofinformationonentanglementresponsenetworks.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
51
Workshop 4A: Bilateral and Multilateral Agreements to Facilitate Partnerships between and among MMPAs: Making Them Work and Lessons Learned
Chairs:Brad Barr(NOAA-ONMS,USA)andScott Gende(NationalParkService,Alaska,USA)
Rapporteur:Christina Geijer(UniversityCollegeLondon,UK/Sweden)
Participants:LeslieAbramson,BradBarr,JuliánBotero,CaroleCarlson,FernandoFélix,LionelGardes,ChristinaGeijer,ScottGende,PaulHoetjes,ArtieJacobson,JorgeJimenez,PascalMayol,CraigMcDonald,AnneNelson,SandraPompa,CarolineRinaldi,MarkJ.Spalding,OswaldoVásquez,NathalieWard
Introduction and objectivesWhenthefocusofthemanagementofamarinemammalpro-tectedarea(MMPA)isonahighlymigratorymarinemammalspeciesorgroupofspecies,networkingwithotherMMPAsthatprovideimportanthabitatsforsustainingthosespeciesisbothnecessaryandappropriate.Whilenotalwaysrequired,abilateral(orinthecaseofmorethantwoMMPAs,multilateral)agreementcanbeusedtoestablishaformal“sisterMMPA”relationship.ThiscanfostersupportforthepartnershipwiththemanagementagenciesresponsiblefortheMMPAswhichhelpsinsettingclearobjectives,clarifyingresponsibilities,andmanagingexpecta-tions.Whilepotentiallyuseful,suchagreementsrequirespecificlegalauthoritiestoempowerthem,canbechallengingtocraft,oftenrequirelongandsometimescomplexagencyreviews,andmanytimesarefoundultimatelytobeineffectiveinachievingtheaspirationsoftheMMPAsinvolved.
Thereareanumberofsuccessfulmodelsforsuchagreements.ThelessonslearnedcanbehelpfulinaddressingthemanychallengesinvolvedinnetworkingMMPAs.Theworkshopwasfocusedonpresentingtwoofthesepotentialmodelpartnerships,oneineffectforanumberofyearsandanotherinitsfirstyearofimplementation.Workshopparticipantsfromtencountriesandrepresentingseveralexistingpartnershipsdiscussedthedevel-opmentoftheagreements,thegoalsandaspirationsofthoseinvolvedinthedevelopmentofthepartnerships,andthelessonslearned,bothpositiveandnegative,intheirdevelopmentandimplementation.WhathasbeenlearnedcanguideandinformfutureeffortsatMMPApartnershipsandnetworking.
Presentations
Beyond borders – sister sanctuaries: An innovative management approach for transboundary marine mammal species in the Wider Caribbean RegionNathalie Ward (NOAA,USA)
Thesistersanctuaryrelationship,establishedin2006,betweenStellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary(SBNMS)andSantuariodeMamíferosMarinosdelaRepúblicaDominicana(SMMRD)markedanewchapterforthejoint managementoftheendangeredhumpbackwhale(Megaptera novaeangliae)intheNorthAtlantic.Thesistersanctuarywasthefirstinternationalaccordtoprotectanendangeredmarinemammalmigratoryspeciesonbothendsofitsrange–initsnorthernfeedingandnurserygroundsinSBNMSanditssouthernmatingandcalv-inggroundsinSMMRD.
In2011,SBNMSsignedasistersanctuaryagreementwiththeFrenchAntillesAgoaMarineMammalSanctuary,expandingthesistersanctuaryprogramme,which:
• Facilitatesanecosystem-basedapproachtocooperativesanctuarymanagementofhumpbackwhalesthroughcapacitybuilding,research,monitoringandeducation;
• Servesasatemplatetoelevatenationalandinternationalawarenessoftheimportanceoftheecologicalconnectionbetweenthesemarinemammalprotectedareas;and
• Emphasizesthecriticalneedtotakeabroadermanagementviewtowardtransboundaryconservationofmarinemammalspecies.
ThesistersanctuaryconceptispartofalargerinternationalandglobalvisionofMMPAs,suchasUNEP’sSpeciallyProtectedAreasandWildlife(SPAW)ProtocolfortheWiderCaribbeanRegion,thatprioritizesmanagementregimesthatmaintaineco-logicalconnectionsbetweenmarineprotectedareasinordertosatisfyspecies’requirements.Thesistersanctuarymodelpro-motesastrategythatdefinesemergingproblems(beyondEEZs),kindlescommitmenttocriticalhabitats,andmanifeststhetruespiritofregionalcooperation,whichisakeyelementtoensureeffectivemanagementforbiodiversityprotectionandthecon-servationofmigratory,marinemammalspecies.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
52
A bilateral agreement between similar MMPAs: Francisco Coloane Coastal and Marine Protected Area (Chile) and Glacier Bay National Park (USA)Scott Gende (NationalParkService,Alaska,USA)andSergio Cornejo(FranciscoColoaneMarineandCoastalProtectedArea–FCCMPA,Chile)
Bilateralagreementsareanintegraltoolforconnectingpersonnelanddevelopingmanagementstrategiesbetweenprotectedareasconnectedbymigratorymarinemammalspecies.However,arecentbilateralagreementestablishingasisterparkrelationshipbetweentheUSNationalParkServiceatGlacierBayNationalParkandtheChileanMinistryofEnvironmentatFranciscoColoaneMarineandCoastalProtectedAreawassignedbasednotonsharedresourcesbutonstrikingsimilaritiesinresourceandmanagementissues,includingmarinemammals.Bothparksarelargeglacialfjordsandrepresentoneofthelargestmarineprotectedareasintheirrespectivecountries.Bothparksrep-resenthotspotsforhumpbackwhalefeedingaggregations,andsupportalargenumberofsealions.
InGlacierBayNationalPark,concernsovertheimpactsoflargecruiseshipsviaacousticdisturbance,risksofoilspillsandcolli-sionswithwhales,areafocusofmanagement,monitoring,andresearch.InFranciscoColoaneMarineandCoastalProtectedArea,concernsovertheimpactsofcommercialshippingtohumpbackwhalesandpotentialexpansionofshippingduetorecentminingandexplorationareofprimaryconcern.Thedis-turbancetowhalesfromwhalewatchingvesselsisanissueinbothparks.
PersonnelexchangebetweenthetwoareashasbeensupportedbytheU.S.DepartmentofStateandwillcontinuewithlonger-termscientificexchangeNovember2011–May2012focusingonjointdevelopmentofmarinemammalmonitoringplans,applicationofresearchtechniquesdevelopedinGlacierBay,anddevelopmentofscience-basedmanagementplans.Thehistoryandmechanismsbywhichthisagreementwasestablishedwillbediscussedandhighlighthowotheragreementsmaybedeveloped.
Summary of DiscussionTheworkshopparticipantsengagedinageneraldiscussionofpartnershipsandtheagreementsthatempowerthem.Pointsraisedinclude:
• Itisimportanttoretainadegreeofflexibilitywithregardstoculturalandpoliticaldifferences,avoidingrigidityinterms.
• Acontinuumexistsfromgettingpeopletogetherandsharinginformationtotheactualsigningofbilateralagreements.Thiscomesdowntoidentifyingpotentialpartnersandusuallystartswithcooperationbetweenresearchers.Agoodwaycouldbetohaveworkshopsrelatedtoparticularspeciesorpopulations,bringingpeopletogetheranddiscussingthenextsteps.
• Itisimportanttodevelopacommondatabaseforinformationsharingtofacilitateconnectionstobeabletoidentifytherightpeople.
• Theneedtotrainpeopleandtohaveresearcherstoestablishtheresearchframeworkisfundamental.Wemustdevelopmethodologiestomakedatacollectionmoreunifiedanduseful.
• Itisrelativelyeasytodoconstituencybuildingingeneralandwiththepublicsopeopleunderstandandbegintothinkoutofthebox.
• Science,policyandthecommunityworkingtogethercanprovidesubstantialvalue.
• Weshoulduseuniversitiesasasourceofresearchintofurtheringbilateralagreements.WecouldmakelistsoftopicstoberesearchedonwebsitesandsendouttouniversitiesthathaveconservationscienceandmarinemammalMaster’sandPhDprograms.Wecouldalsotakeadvantageoflocalpeople,sothattheycanbestusethedataandkeeponworkinginthearea.
Basedonthediscussions,theworkshopparticipantsagreedthatthefollowingpointsformthebasisfor,andfurtherexpandandarticulate,therecommendationsattheendofthissectionwhichwereputforwardtotheconferenceandformallyadopted:
• Promoteinformationexchange,interpersonalrelationships,andeducationbetweenMMPAs.
• Promoteworkshops(e.g.,atbiggerconferences)–eitherthreatorspecies/stock-specific–tobringtherelevantpeopletogethertoaddressjointMMPAissues.
• StandardizedatacollectionmethodologyandacommondatabaseforinformationsharingbetweenMMPAs.
• Conceptuallyendorsetheideaof“sistersanctuary”programsanddevelopcasestudiestoshare“lessonslearned”andbestpractices/strategiesforimplementationofbi/multilateralagreements.
• PromotebilateralagreementsintomultilateralagreementswithMMPAs.
• SeekoutlegalframeworksandinternationalvehiclessuchasSPAWtocreatebilateralandmultilateralagreementsbetweenMMPAs.
• Bringtogetherscientists,managersandpolicymakerstoshareinformationandbemoreinclusiveandtransparent.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
53
Recommendations from Workshop 4AWorkshop4ArecommendsthattheICMMPA:
EndorseandsupporttheuseofmultilateralandbilateralagreementsforthepurposeofcreatingMMPAnetworksandpartnerships.
EndorseandsupportsistersanctuaryMMPApartnershipsestablishedthroughsuchagreements.
Coordinatethedevelopmentofadocumentprovidingguid-ancefortheMMPAcommunitythatoffersessentialunderlyingprinciplesforeffectivedevelopmentofbilateralandmultilateralagreements,outlinesappropriatelegalmechanisms,“bestprac-tices”fordevelopmentandimplementationofagreements,andillustrativecasestudies.
Humpback whales in the Commander Islands Biosphere Reserve, Russia Photo by Alexander Burdin, Russian Cetacean Habitat Project, Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
54
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
Northern fur seals on Bering Island in the Commander Islands Biosphere Reserve, Russia Photo by Erich Hoyt, Russian Cetacean Habitat Project, Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
55
Workshop 4B: Broad-scale Marine Spatial Planning of Mammal Corridors and Protected Areas in the Wider Caribbean and Southeast and Northeast Pacific, Including Identifying Ecologically or Biologically Significant Areas (EBSAs)10
10 Note:Workshop4BandWorkshop9eachincorporatedseparatepartsofWorkshop6originallyplannedasaseparateworkshoptentativelycalled“GOBI-UNEP/LifeWebTechnicalSession:IdentifyingEBSAsandCriticalHabitatsintheWiderCaribbeanandEastPacifictoInformMarineMammalManagementPlanning”
Coordinators:Alessandra Vanzella-Khouri (UNEP-CEP–CaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,Jamaica)andOle Vestergaard(UNEPDivisionofEnvironmentalPolicyImplementation,FreshwaterandMarineEcosystemsBranch,Kenya)
Chairs: Alessandra Vanzella-Khouri (UNEP-CEP–CaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,Jamaica)and Patricio Bernal (IUCNHighSeasInitiative,Switzerland)
Rapporteur: Monika Thiele (UNEP-CMS,RegionalOfficeforNorthAmerica,USA)
Participants: PatricioBernal,JuliánBotero,FernandoFélix,KristinKaschner,PatriciaLancho,FrançoisPoisson,JessicaRedfern,LionelReynal,HélèneSouan,MonikaThiele,AlessandraVanzella-Khouri,OswaldoVásquez,NathalieWard
Introduction and ObjectivesNetworksofwell-plannedandeffectivelymanagedmarineprotectedareas–rangingfrommultiple-usezonestono-takereserves–maybeausefulapproachtoprotectcriticalhabitatsformigratinglargemarinemammals.Protectedareasthatregu-latecertaintypesofhumanactivitycanbeeconomicallycostlyintheshortterm,butmayprovidesubstantialimmediateandlong-termeconomicbenefits,rangingfromfisheryenhancementtorecreationalandeducationalopportunitiesforthepublic,whileatthesametimesustainingmarinemammalpopulations.
AkeysteptoeffectiveMPAnetworkdesigniscomprehensivemarinespatialplanningandzoningofhumanactivitiesaddress-ingcumulativeenvironmentalpressures.Thisinvolvesenviron-mentalassessmentandmappingofkeymigrationroutesandstop-overpointsconnectinghabitatsatregionalscales,socio-economicassessmentandevaluationofmanagementtrade-offsinformingspatialplanningandzoning.Afurtherprerequisiteforeffectivemanagement,goodgovernanceandcomplianceisextensivenationalandregionalstakeholderconsultation.
Anongoingregionalproject,“Broad-scalemarinespatialplan-ningofmammalcorridorsandprotectedareasintheWiderCaribbeanandSoutheastandNortheastPacific”isassistingcountriesinbuildingcapacityformarinespatialplanningofMMPAsthroughsupportfromtheSpain-UNEPPartnership
fortheLifeWebInitiativerunningAugust2010-November2012.Theoverallobjectiveistobuildtechnicalcapacitiesfordesignoftransboundarymanagementandgovernancearrangementstoprotectlargemarinemammalcorridorsandcriticalhabitatsacrossthetworegions.Thisincludesregionaldatacollation,analysisandmappingofecologicalandsocio-economicdata,traininginspatialplanning,strategiccommunication,networkandpolicysupport,plustwoplanningdemonstrationprojects.[Projectwebsite:www.spain-unepforpas.org/-marine-mammal-corridors-a-critical-habitats-.html]
Theworkshopobjectivewastopresentanddiscussemerg-ingconceptsandpreliminaryprojectfindingsandtofurtherdevelopecologicalandsocio-economicmapsoflargemarinemammaldistribution,criticalhabitatsandhumanactivitiesintheSoutheastandNortheastPacificandWiderCaribbeanasabasisfortransboundarymarinespatialplanningscenariosandmanagementarrangements.
Summaries of Presentations
Broad-scale marine spatial planning for transboundary management of marine mammal corridors and critical habitatsAlessandra Vanzella-Khouri (UNEP-CEP–CaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,Jamaica)andOle Vestergaard(UNEPDivisionofEnvironmentalPolicyImplementation,FreshwaterandMarineEcosystemsBranch,Kenya)
UNEP’sDivisionofEnvironmentalPolicyImplementationincollaborationwithUNEP’sCaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme(UNEP-CEP),theRegionalActivityCentrefortheSPAWProtocol(SPAW-RAC),thePermanentCommissionfortheSouthPacific(CPPS)andUNEP’sRegionalOfficesforLatinAmerica-CaribbeanandNorthAmerica,havepartneredtoimplementtheinter-regionalLifeWebproject“Broad-scalemarinespatialplanningofmammalcorridorsandprotectedareasintheWiderCaribbeanandSoutheastandNortheastPacific”.Theproject,
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
56
fundedbytheGovernmentofSpainover2.5years,recognizesthestrategicimportanceofmultiple-useprotectedareasasatoolforresourcemanagementandbiodiversityconservationwithinbroadercross-sectoralmarinespatialplanningandmanagement.Theseareasareofparticularimportancefortransboundaryspe-ciessuchasmarinemammalsthatmayspendtimeincriticalhabitatareasthatcrossjurisdictionalboundaries.
Throughtheuseofstatisticalmodelingandmapping,thisbroad-scalespatialplanningprojecthasbeguntoidentifymarinemammaldistribution,criticalhabitatareas,andthreatstotheirprotection(e.g.,fisheriesimpacts,shippinglanes,pollution,coastalandoffshoredevelopment,andtourism-relatedactivi-ties)throughoutboththeWiderCaribbeanandthesoutheastandnortheastPacificregions.Inadditiontothiswork,dem-onstrationprojectsarecurrentlyunderwayintheDominicanRepublicthatwilldevelopamanagementplanfortheMarineMammalSanctuaryoftheDominicanRepublic,animportantmatingandcalvinggroundforthehumpbackwhale(Megaptera novaeangliae),aswellasineastPacificoutliningtransboundarymanagementscenariosfortheEasternTropicalPacificMarineCorridorregion.Inconjunctionwiththis,twolargeworkshopsarebeingplannedforspring2012.OnewillinviteregulatorsandofficialsfromEasternCaribbeancountriestovisitthesanctuaryduringthecalvingseasontounderstandthepotentialthatwhalewatchingandmarinemammalprotectionareascouldhaveontheircountries.Theotherwillconsistofatrainingcourseforgovernmentplannersandexpertsonmarinespatialplanning,managementandgovernanceoptionstosupportmarinemam-malmanagementforbothregions.
Inordertohighlighttheimportanceoftheprojectissuesandto“makethecase”forintegratedandtransboundarymanagementofmarinemammalmigrationroutesandcriticalhabitats,strate-giccommunicationproductswillbedevelopedanddistributedtogovernmentofficials,academicinstitutions,themediaandthewiderpublicinanefforttobringattentiontothemanagementofthesespeciesandthethreatsfacingthem.
AlloftheseactivitiessupporttheimplementationoftheActionPlansfortheConservationofMarineMammalsintheWiderCaribbeanandSoutheastPacificregionsandwillhelptoimprovetheinformationcurrentlyavailableonmarinemammaldistri-butionandthreatsaswellasthecapacity,governanceandsus-tainabilityofmarineprotectedareastohelpconservemarinemammalpopulationsintheseregions.
GOBI, the Global Ocean Biodiversity Initiative, and the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) process to establish MPA networks on the High Seas: Bridging international policy and SciencePatricio A. Bernal (IUCNHighSeasInitiative,Switzerland)
Thesector-by-sectormanagementofhumanactivitiesintheoceanhasproventobeinsufficient.Landdegradationisanacceptedtechnicalterminmanagement,andmanyactionsaretakenandresourcesspentannuallytomitigateitseffects,yetoceandegradation,untilnow,hasbeeninvisible.Themostrecentstudyonhumanactivitiesintheoceanconsidering17globalusesover20differenttypesofecosystemsshowsthat41%oftheoceanexperiencesmediumtohighanthropogenicimpact.
ThespatialmeasuresofMPAsandothermanagementtoolsarebeingeffectivelyappliedundernationalandotherjurisdictionssuchastheAntarcticTreaty.SinceMPAsarealsobeingproposedonthehighseasbeyondareasofnationaljurisdiction,theUnitedNationsGeneralAssemblyandtheUNFoodandAgricultureOrganizationhavesponsoredormandatedactionstoidentifyareasintheoceaninneedofprotection,tocorrectdestructivefishingpracticesonthehighseasandoverseamounts,andingeneraltopromoteanecosystemapproachtomanagement.TheConferenceofthePartiesoftheConventiononBiologicalDiversity(CBD)definedin2008asetofsevenscientificcriteriafortheidentificationofecologicallyorbiologicallysignificantareas(EBSAs)inneedofprotection,initiatingaprocessfortheidentificationoftheseareasandthecreationofarepositorywiththisinformation.
Fromascientificpointofview,andthankstonewtechniquesandtoolsavailabletoobservetheocean,thiscouldtranslateintoaprogramrevealingthetruecomplexityofmarinelifeintheocean.Thiswouldgobeyondthecurrentunderstandingofmarinelifedistribution,byattemptingtomeasuretheecologi-calandgeneticinterconnectionamongmarineecosystemsandbetweenthepelagicandbenthicdomainsindifferentgeomor-phologicalenvironments.
Toaccompanythepolicyprocesses,in2009IUCNwithsupportfromtheGermangovernmentcreatedGOBI,theGlobalOceanBiodiversityInitiative,withthespecificaimofbridgingthesepolicyprocesseswithscience.Duringthelasttwoyears,GOBI,nowapartnershipof21scienceorganizations,hasgeneratedguidancetousetheCBDcriteriafortheidentificationofEBSAs,havingidentified15examplesinwhichthesecriteriawereused.NowthattheCBDhasinitiatedaseriesofRegionalWorkshopswiththespecificaimtoidentifyEBSAs,GOBIattheinvitationoftheConferenceofthePartiesofCBDwillcontributetothisprocessbycompilingthedataandinformationnecessaryandsupportingthedevelopmentofcapabilitiesbytheStatepartiesoftheconvention.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
57
Challenges in implementing marine mammal spatial planning and management in the Eastern Pacific Fernando Félix (MarineMammalandMarineSpatialPlanningProject,UNEP/Spain/CPPS,Ecuador)
Thebroad–scalemarinespatialplanningformarinemammalcorridorsintheEasternPacific(Spain/UNEP)projecthasbeenintheprocessofbeingimplementedsinceearly2011,underthecoordinationofthePermanentCommissionfortheSouthPacific(CPPS).Theprojectaimstoprovideanoverviewofessentialhabitatsandregional-scalemigrationroutesformarinemam-malsinthisvastregionwhichcoversabout20millionkm2ofterritorialwaters,exclusiveeconomiczones,andislandterrito-riesof13countries,aswellasextensiveareasbeyondnationaljurisdictions.Approximately40speciesofcetaceansinhabittheeasternPacific,including9speciesoflargewhales.
Definingconservationprioritiesforthesespeciesoversuchalargeanddiverseareapresentsenormouschallenges,particularlyrelatedtospatialandtemporalscales,informationavailability,weakornonexistentlegalframeworks,weakcontrolandenforce-ment,andlackofpoliticalwill,amongothers.Inthiscontext,theSpain/UNEP/CPPSprojectisanopportunitytointroducecross-sectoralspatialplanningapproachesandtofacilitateregionaldialoguesandconsultationswithrelevantstakeholdersindesignmanagementoptionsformigratingmarinemammals.
Geo-referencedandsocio-economicdataarecurrentlyusedformodelingthehabitatoffivelargecetaceanspeciesintheEasternPacificfrombothhemispheres:blue,humpback,Bryde’s,spermandsouthernrightwhales.Someofthesespecieshavewell-definedmigrationpatternssuchashumpback,southernrightandtoalesserextentbluewhales,whilethepopulationstructureofBryde’sandspermwhalesremainspoorlyknown.SomeoverlapexistsinbreedingareasalongthecentralPacificbetweennorthandsouthpopulations(humpbackandbluewhales)creatingfavorableconditionsforgeneticexchangebetweenpopulationsofbothhemispheres.
SeveralofthemostimportantfisheriesintheworldoccurinEasternTropicalPacific(ETP)watersandtheseconstituteamajorthreattocetaceansinthisregion.Otherhumanactivitiesincludeshippingandpollutionfrombothsea-andland-basedorigins.
Formigratorycetaceans,theETPmustbeconsideredasanecologicalmanagementunitthatincludesthecentralaswellasthenortheastandsoutheastPacificwhalefeedingdestinations.BecausenoregionallegalframeworkonenvironmentalissuesinvolvingallthecountriesofETPexists,aMemorandumofCooperationorsimilarnon-legallybindinginstrumentwouldbehelpfulindefiningregionalpoliciesandpromotingconservationandmanagementofmarinemammalsintheregion.ThiscouldbeadvancedthroughanActionPlan,similartotheMemorandumofUnderstandingfortheConservationofCetaceansinthePacificIslandsundertheframeworkoftheConventiononMigratorySpecies(CMS).TheUnitedNationsConventionontheLawof
theSea(UNCLOS)inArticles64and65providesabroadframe-workregardingthemanagementofhighlymigratoryspeciesandmarinemammalsinareasbeyondnationaljurisdictions.
Habitat modeling of large whales in the Eastern Tropical PacificJessica V. Redfern(SouthwestFisheriesScienceCenter,NOAAFisheries,USA)
AnoverviewofprocessesforidentifyingcriticalhabitatforbaleenwhalesintheeasterntropicalPacificOcean,commonlyreferredtoastheEasternTropicalPacific(ETP),waspresentedinPanel2.Thispresentationprovidedamoredetailedandcriti-calexaminationofthemethodologiesandresultingdistributionmapsforthreespeciesofbaleenwhalesintheETP.
TheETPisa20millionkm2,open-oceansystemthatisseason-allyoccupiedbymigratoryblueandhumpbackwhalesfrombothnorthernandsouthernhemispheres;italsohostsimportantnumbersofresidentBryde’swhales.
Threemethodologicalissuesforidentifyingcriticalhabitatwereexplored:
• Datatypes.
• Methodsforcreatingdensitysurfaces.
• Conservationtargets.
Differencesinresultingmapsofcriticalhabitatwereexaminedforeachspecies;theneedforcautionwhenusingsuchmapstomakemanagementdecisionswashighlighted.
The Eastern Tropical Pacific Marine Corridor (CMAR) InitiativeJulián Botero (EasternTropicalPacificMarineCorridor–CMAR,Colombia)
TheEasternTropicalPacificMarineCorridor(CMAR)isaregionalinitiativefortheconservationandsustainableuseofbio-diversityandmarineandcoastalresourcesintheMPAsconsid-eredasa“coreareas”oftheislandsofCocos(CostaRica),Coiba(Panama),GorgonaandMalpelo(Colombia),andGalápagos(Ecuador).Theinitiativelooksforthesuitablemanagementofsuchresourcesthroughanecosystem-basedapproach,estab-lishingjointgovernmentstrategiessupportedbycivilsociety,governmentalagenciesofinternationalcooperation,andnon-governmentalorganizations(NGOs).
TheCMARinitiativehasitsrootsintheJointPresidentialDeclarationofDecember2001betweenthegovernmentsofCostaRicaandEcuadortostudytheproposalofcreatingacorridorofmarineconservationbetweenCocosandtheGalapagosislands.In2002,MalpeloandGorgonaislands(Colombia)andCoibaisland(Panama)askedtojointheinitiative,andinApril2004,
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
58
thesigningofthe«DeclarationofSanJosé»bytherepresenta-tivesoftheGovernmentsofCostaRica,Panama,ColombiaandEcuador,gavebirthtotheCMARinitiative.
Theoverallobjectiveistodefineandestablishbetweengovern-mentsajointmanagementsystemfortheconservationandsus-tainableuseofbiodiversityandcoastalandmarineresourcesintheMPAsoftheCMAR,theislandsofCocos,Coiba,Malpelo,Gorgona,andGalapagos,andtheirareasofinfluence.
Specificobjectivesinclude:
• Promotingthesustainablemanagementandconserva-tionofbiodiversityandcoastalresourcesoftheregion.
• EstablishingaregionalframeworkthatfacilitatesthedevelopmentandmanagementoftheCMAR.
• Promotingtheparticipationofgovernmentsandstake-holdersintheintegralmanagementoftheCMAR:tourism,fishingandconservation,amongotherthings.
• Improvingandconsolidatingtheprotectionandman-agementofthemarineprotectedareascomprisingthecoreareasoftheCMAR.
• IdentifyingandpromotingfinancingmechanismstosupportthemanagementoftheCMAR.
• DirectingtechnicalandfinancialcooperationfortheCMARatthenationalorinternationallevelbasedontheprioritiessetbycountries.
• BoostingresponsibletourismwhichcontributestothesustainabledevelopmentofthecommunitiesinvolvedintheCMAR.
• Providingasetofenvironmentalgoodsandservicestolocal,regionalandgloballevels.
• Promotingpropagationanddisseminationofinforma-tiononthescope,objectives,actionsandprogressmadeintheimplementationoftheCMAR.
TwoofthekeyongoingprojectsaretheEasternTropicalPacificSeascape(ETPS),byConservationInternational(CI),whichbeganin2003,andtheregionalmanagementsystemforthesustainableuseofthefisheryresourcesoftheCMAR,byIDB-FundaciónMalpelo,beginningin2009.
Futureplans(2011-2014)include:
• GivingsupportfortheimplementationoftheProgrammeofWorkoftheCBDonprotectedareasintheregion,throughtheconsolidationofcross-borderareas.
• EnlargementoftheCMARcorridorbyintegratingnewMPAs.
• Improvingcoordinationwithotherinternationalinstrumentsfortheconservationofthemarineenvi-ronment(CBD,CPPS,CBI,)amongstothers.
• Developmentoffutureprojectswithmajorcollabora-tivepartners(e.g.,WorldBankGEF).
Towards the identification of important marine mammal habitat and possible EBSAs in the greater Caribbean & tropical central AtlanticKristin Kaschner(Albert-Ludwigs-UniversityofFreiburg,Germany)
Coauthors: Rob Williams(UniversityofStAndrews,UK)andErin Ashe (UniversityofStAndrews,UK)
Theidentificationofecologicallyorbiologicallysignificantareas(EBSAs)isoneofthekeyfirststepstowardsreachingtheCBD2012MarineTargetsforSettingupMarineProtectedAreasintheHighSeas.CriteriausedtodefineEBSAsincludebiologicaldiversityandspecialimportancetolifehistorystagessuchasbreedingareasandmigrationcorridors.ThesecriterialargelyoverlapwiththemaingoalsoftheongoingUNEP-SpainLifeWebproject“Broad-scalemarinespatialplanningofmammalcorri-dorsandprotectedareasintheWiderCaribbeanandSoutheastandNortheastPacific”.
Herewepresentresultsfromananalysissummarizingtheextentofavailablemarinemammal(cetacean)dataandinfor-mationintheWiderCaribbeanRegion,initiatedandfundedbytheLifeWebprojectandtheWhaleandDolphinConservationSociety(WDCS).AsofNovember2011,thereweremorethan18,000occurrencerecordsofcetaceansintheWiderCaribbeanavailablethroughOBIS-SEAMAP,yetthevastmajorityoftheserecordsarespatiallyconcentratedinthenorthernGulfofMexico,whileoccurrencerecordsfromthemainCaribbeanSeaareverysparse.Inaddition,thereislargevariabilityintermsofthedataavailablefordifferentspecies,withcommonbottlenosedolphin(Tursiops truncatus)sightingsmakingupmorethan70%ofallrecords.
Theanalysisalsohighlightedtheimportanceofeffortconsider-ations,whichwouldotherwiselargelyimpacttheperceptionofoccurrenceanddistributionofcetaceansinthearea.Outputsfromlinetransectsurveysontheotherhandarecorrectedforeffortandcurrentlyprovidetheonlymeanstoproducethegeo-referenceddensityinformation,whichideallyshouldbethebasisofanyquantitativespatialplanningexercise.Ouranalysisshowed,however,thatsurveycoverageisverypatchy,concentratedinthenorthernGulfofMexico.IntheCaribbeanSeaitself,therewereonlytwosurveys,theFrenchREMMOA11surveys,producingabsoluteabundanceestimatesforFrenchoverseasterritorialwaterssurroundingtheFrenchAntillesandFrenchGuiana.Thevisualizationofaspeciesenvironmentalnicheenvelope,usingmappingapproachessuchastheRelativeEnvironmental(RES)modelorAquaMaps(www.aquamaps.org)mayrepresentausefulalternativetoassesspotentiallarge-11 RidouxV,CertainG,DorémusG,LaranS,VanCanneytO,WatremezP(2010)Mappingdiversityandrelativedensityofcetaceansandotherpelagicmegafaunaacrossthetropics:generaldesignandprogressoftheREMMOAaerialsurveysconductedintheFrenchEEZandadjacentwaters.ReportSC/62/E14submittedtotheScientificCommitteeoftheInternationalWhalingCommission(unpublished),Agadir,Morocco,13pp.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
59
scaleoccurrenceofcetaceansintheWiderCaribbeanRegion.Althoughthedirectlyavailableglobaldistributionsmatchedknownregionaloccurrencequitewellforsomespecies,acom-parisonofglobalRESpredictionswithregionalspeciesoccur-rencehighlightedtheimportanceofincorporatingregionalexpertknowledgeandseasonalaspectstoadequatelycaptureknownspeciesoccurrenceonsmallerscales.
Inconclusion,thecetaceandatacurrentlyavailablethroughonlinedatarepositorieshighlightthelargegapsandunrepre-sentativesurveycoverageofthisregion.Availabledatathusneedtobeusedwithcaution,keepingknowneffortbiasesinmind.Ultimately,thissituationcanbestberemediedthroughsomeconcentrated,large-scalesurveyeffortinthisarea.Modelingapproachesthatinfercetaceandensitiesinunsurveyedareasbasedonempiricaldataandpredicteddistribution,describedinKristinKaschner’spresentationinPanel2,mayalsobehelp-fulinthisrespect.Inthemeantimeanduntilbetterdataoroutputsfromthesetypesofmodelsbecomeavailable,mappingofknownandprobableoccurrenceofspecies,usingapproachessuchasAquaMapsthatallowforincorporationofregionalexpertknowledge,canbehelpfultodeterminepriorityareasforfutureresearchandconservationefforts.Thisiscurrentlybeingunder-takenaspartoftheUNEP-LifeWebproject(tobecompletedFebruary2012).OutputsintheformofmappedknownandprobabledistributionsofcetaceansintheCaribbeanmayalsorepresentausefulcontributiontotheregionalCBDworkshopfocusingontheidentificationofEBSAsintheTropicalCentralAtlantic(February2012,Recife,Brazil).
Mapping ecological and socio-economic factors for marine mammal management in the CaribbeanHélène Souan (SPAW–RegionalActivityCentre,Guadeloupe)
Theproductionofmapsdisplayingmarinemammaldistribu-tion,threats,andconservationmeasuresisthekeyexpectedoutputofcomponent1oftheSpain-fundedUNEPLifeWebproj-ect“Broad-scalemarinespatialplanningofmammalcorridorsandprotectedareasintheWiderCaribbeanandSoutheastandNortheastPacific”.Component1aimstoprogressdataintegra-tion,mappingandGISanalysisofmarinemammalmigrationroutes,criticalhabitatsandhumanthreatsattheregionalscaleforboththeCaribbeanandtheEasternPacific.
FortheCaribbeanregion,thedatafordocumentingsocio-eco-nomicfactorssuchasdirectfishingandbycatch,pollution,inten-sityofmarinetrafficandotheraspectshavebeencompiledandthecorrespondingmapshavebeenproduced.Thesamegoesforthemapsandfactsheetsonpoliciesformarinemammalconser-vation(describingsuitableMPAsformarinemammalsandout-lininglegalprotectionmeasures).Themapsandcomprehensivefactsheetsarenotallfinalizedyet,butsomeexamplesofpossibleoutputsweredisplayedduringthepresentation.
Describingandaccuratelymappingmarinemammaldistribu-tionsandmigrationroutes,however,remainsachallenge,asavailabledatasetsarescarce.Althoughmanypublicationshavebeenproducedovertheyears,fewspeciesarewelldocumented,andnotallthesectorsoftheWiderCaribbeanhavebeeninves-tigatedwiththesameintensityandwithconsistentprotocols.Inordertoovercome,totheextentpossible,thelackofhomoge-neoussurveysintherecordedefforts,othertoolsandapproacheshavehadtobeexplored.Thesefirstresultsobtainedsofarwillhopefullybeabletobecomplementedbyvariedinformationondistribution,speciesrichnessand/ormovementsforthewholeWiderCaribbeanRegion.
A Management Plan for the Dominican Republic Marine Mammal Sanctuary, a key to consolidate the Sanctuary, one of most important marine protected areas in the Caribbean and Western North AtlanticPatricia Lancho (FundaciónDominicanadeEstudiosMarinos–FUNDEMAR,DominicanRepublic)
TheMarineMammalSanctuaryoftheDominicanRepublicisthelargestprotectedareainthecountryandrecentlypassed25yearswithoutamanagementplan.Thisyear,FUNDEMAR,theDominicanRepublicMinistryofEnvironmentandNaturalResources,andUNEP-CEPmadeanagreementtodevelopthemanagementplanforthesanctuary.Someofthemaindifficultiesthatwehavefoundare:thelargesizeofthesanctuary,thelackofpermanentpersonnelthroughouttheyearandthedifferentlevelsofknowledgeaboutandusesofthearea.
TodeveloptheplanweareusingmethodologyfromtheMinistryofEnvironment,enrichedwithexperiencesfromthesistersanc-tuaryrelationshipwiththeStellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary,inordertoplaninadvanceforthenextfiveyears.Theprocesshasinvitedhighnumbersofstakeholders,individualandinstitutional,Dominicanandforeigners.ThemaininformationsourcesarefromtheMinistryofEnvironment,FUNDEMAR,Atemar,CIBIMAandCEBSE,andinNOAA spublicationsaboutresearchinthesanctuary,andthemainlackofinformationisregardingfuturefisheryuse.12
12 MMPAacronymscommonlyusedintheDominicanRepublicincludeFUNDEMAR,FundaciónDominicanadeEstudiosMarinos(DominicanFoundationforMarineResearch);CIBIMA,CentrodeInvestigacionesdeBiologíaMarinadelaUniversidadAutónomadeSantoDomingo(CenterforMarineBiologyResearchfromtheAutonomousUniversityofSantoDomingo);CEBSE,CentroparaelEcodesarrollodelaBahíadeSamanáysuentorno(CenterforEco-developmentoftheSamanáBayRegion).Atemar,AsesoríaAmbientalyTecnologíaMaritima,isaconsultingcompanyfocusingontheenvironmentandmarinetechnology.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
60
Summary of DiscussionThemaintopicsontheagendafordiscussioncenteredon:
• Effectivespatialinformationanddataforbroad-scalemarinespatialplanning(MSP)andmapping.
• Emergingplanningapproachesforlargemarinemammalmanagement.
• Transboundarymarinemammalmanagementstrategiesandarrangements.
• Synergiesthatmightbepossiblewithotherprocessesandefforts.
Theworkshopparticipantsrecognizedthatmarinemammalshavesignificantecological,aestheticandeconomicvaluetothecountriesandterritoriesoftheEastPacificandWiderCaribbeanregions,thatthewatersoftheseregionsserveasprimaryhabi-tatsforcriticalstagesoftheirlifecycles,whilealsoservingaskeysatellitesitesdirectlyconnectedtohabitatsindistantwatersvialong-rangingnorth-southmigrationroutesinbothAtlanticandPacificoceans.Theworkshopexpressedconcernthatmarinemammalsintheseregionsfacearangeofsevereimpactsfromhumanactivities,aswellasthosefromclimatechangeimpactingonfoodwebs,ecosystemproductivity,oceanographicprocessesandconnectivity.Thereisevergreaterneedtoaddressthesedif-ferentstressorsviacomprehensiveandintegratedecosystem-basedmanagementthatincludes, inter alia,marineprotectedareanetworksandspecialmarinemanagementareasastools.Marinespatialplanningisaveryusefultoolformarinemammalmanagementinterventionsthatrequiresquantitativeandqualita-tivedataandmappingofessentialhabitatsandmigrationroutes,includingecologicalandsocio-economicinformation(e.g.,spe-ciesdistributionandabundance,fisheries,shipping,pollution,tourismdevelopment,amongotherthings).However,therearedatalimitationsincludinglargedatagapsforregionssuchastheWiderCaribbeanandtheSoutheastPacificduetothevaryinglevelofeffortandthefinancialandtimeimplicationsforcom-prehensivequantitativedatagatheringandanalysis.
WorkshopparticipantsacknowledgedthattheLifewebProject“Broad-scalemarinespatialplanningofmammalcorridorsandprotectedareasintheWiderCaribbeanandSoutheastandNortheastPacific”supportedbytheGovernmentofSpainandcoordinatedthroughUNEP,constitutesanoutstandingopportu-nitytobringtogetheravarietyofstakeholderssuchasscientists,managers,andgovernmentalandnon-governmentalorganiza-tionstojoineffortsformarinemammalspatialplanningandnetworking.TherearealsoeffortsaspartoftheframeworkoftheConventiononBiologicalDiversity(CBD)toidentifylarge-scaleecologicallyorbiologicallysignificantareas(EBSAs);theupcomingregionalEBSAWorkshops(e.g.,fortheCaribbeanandTropicalAtlanticRegion,Bahia,Brazil,28February-2March2012)willprovideopportunitiesforbroad-scalemarinespatialplanningformarinemammalconservation.
Recommendations from Workshop 4BInlightoftheworkshopdiscussionsandconsideringtheActionPlansfortheConservationofMarineMammalsthathavebeenadoptedintheWiderCaribbeanandSoutheastPacificregionsundertheCartagenaandLimaConventionsoftheUNEPRegionalSeasProgrammes,theWorkshop4Bparticipantsencouragecountries,managersandscientificteamsoftheWiderCaribbeanandEasternPacificregionstoapplythefollowingrecommendations:
Immediatelydevelopafeasibleandrealisticplanforsynthesiz-ingexistingdata,includingexpertopinion,inmapsthatcanbeusedascommunicationtools.Thisplanshouldalsooutlinethewaysandmeanstomakereasonablecomparisonsbetweenthequalitativeandquantitativesummaries,whichshouldincludetherelevantsocio-economicinformation.
Compileandstandardizetheuseofhistoricaldata(e.g.,archaeo-logicaldata),aswellestablishminimumprotocolsforfuturedatacollectionefforts(e.g.,preparingstandardizedquestionnairesforwhalewatchingoperators;encouragingresearcherswhostudycetaceansthroughphoto-IDtoroutinelycollectgeo-referencedtracklineeffort,bearing,anddistancedatatoallowdensitytobemodeledfromeffortandsightingsdata).Thoseprotocolsshouldbemadewidelyavailabletostakeholderstofacilitatedatacom-parisonformarinespatialplanningpurposes.
Useexistingdatainventorytoidentifyandprioritizefillingthedatagaps,andconsider,forexample,conductingalarge-scalesurvey(onthescaleoftheSCANSII,TNASSorCODAsurveysconductedinotherareasoftheNorthAtlantic),aswellasotherstandardizedsurveyswhicharecost-effectiveandopportunis-tic,togatherrelevantoceanographic,ecologicalandsocio-economicdata.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
61
Workshop 5: North East of South America, Regional Cooperation for a Marine Mammals Conservation Strategy Workshop – MAMA COCO SEA Project
Coordinators: Marion Brichet (Agencedesairesmarinesproté-gées,France)
Co-Chairs: François Gauthiez (Agencedesairesmarinespro-tégées,France)andHélène Souan (SPAW–RegionalActivityCentre,Guadeloupe)
Participants: MarionBrichet,VirginieDosreis,Marc-HenriDuffaud,FrançoisGauthiez,CatalinaGomez-Salazar,ThierryHouard,GaëlHubert,SophieLaran,MiriamMarmontel,CaroleMartinez,NicolasMaslach,DenisOdy,LeninEnriqueOviedoCorrea,MoniquePool,MarcelaPortocarrero-Aya,RomainRenoux,JohnReynolds,VincentRidoux,Marie-CatherineSantoni,HélèneSouan,LesleySutty,FernandoTrujillo,OlivierVanCanneyt,GaëlleVandersarren,PierreWatremez
IntroductionInFrenchGuiana,aninventoryofmarinemammalpopulationsdrawnupbytheUniversityofLaRochelleMarineMammalsResearchCentre(Centrederecherchesurlesmammifèresmarins–CRMM),fortheFrenchMarineProtectedAreasAgency(Agencedesairesmarinesprotégées),revealedasignificant,previouslyunsuspected,abundance.ThedensityofcetaceansobservedinFrenchGuianaissubstantiallyhigherthanintheFrenchWestIndies.Thesestudies,andtheregionalstrategicanalysisofthemarineenvironmentperformedbytheFrenchMPAAgencyinFrenchGuiana(2009),highlightthepotentialimportanceofaregionalscientificcooperationprojectonmarinemammalstorespondtothechallengesidentified.
A regional approach vital for conservation
FrenchGuianasharesmanymarinemammalspecieswithneigh-boringcountries.Thediversityofthespecies,theircross-borderdistributionrangeandtheirstatus,forsomeofthemendangered,underlinetheneedforincreased,coordinatedactionbetweenthevariouscountries.Theinclusionofsomeorallofthespeciesinvariousinternationalconventionsandtreatiesmakescoop-erationbetweencountriesinnortheasternLatinAmerica,fromnorthernBraziltoVenezuela,includingTrinidadandTobagoandthe“ABCislands”oftheDutchCaribbean(Aruba,Bonaire,Curaçao),allthemorepertinent.Acooperationprojectcover-ingtheentireareafromBraziltoVenezuelawouldthusappeartobeausefulavenuetoexploreinresponsetothechallengesinFrenchGuianaandtheregion.
Presentations
REMMOA survey results for French Guiana and the French CaribbeanVincent Ridoux (CentredeRecherchesurlesMammifèresMarins,ObservatoirePelagis,UniversitédeLaRochelle-CNRS,France)
ThecontextfortheREMMOA13surveywastheFrenchpolicytodesignateMPAsin10%oftheFrenchworldwideexclusiveeco-nomiczone(EEZ)by2012and20%by2020.97%ofthe11mil-lionkm2marineEEZunderFrenchjurisdictionislocatedaroundoverseasterritories,whereoffshorebiodiversityispoorlyknown.Thereisanurgentneedtodevelopbaselineknowledgeofpelagicmegafaunaasanindexofoff-shorebiodiversityinthesevastareas.Themethodologymustbestandardizedtoallowregionalandyear-to-yearcomparisons.HabitatmodelingwillprovidethescientificbasisforidentifyingpriorityareasforfutureMPAs.
Theobjectivesweretoinformmanagementpolicywithobjec-tivedataonpelagicsystemsintheentireFrenchoverseasEEZ.In2008,twopilotstudieswereconductedintheAtlantic.Welookedforbasicmetricsfornatureconservationandmanagement(species,numbers,locations).Thesamplingprotocolconsistedofmultispecificaerialsurveysconstrainedformarinemammals,similartotheSCANSIIProtocolthatwasdevelopedforsmallcetaceansurveysinEurope.
Theresultsincludedasightingssummary,revealingmarinemammalspeciescomposition,tobefollowedbyspatialhabitatmodels,usingacovariateselectionprocesstorevealkeyhabitatsintheCaribbeanandinFrenchGuiana.SufficientsightingswererecordedtoestimateminimalabundanceforTursiops truncatusandSotalia guianensis.
Inconclusion,aerialsurveysprovide–quicklyandatcompara-tivelylowcost–standardizedinformationfortheidentificationofpriorityhabitatswithinthewholeEEZ.Themainhabitatshavebeenidentifiedforbothareas(FrenchCaribbeanandGuiana)andthesecanserveasanobjectivebasistodesignMPAsespe-ciallyifconfirmedbyadditionalsurveys.FurtherimprovementsareneededtoenhancethesamplesizeintheCaribbean-FrenchGuiana,toobtainseasonalandyear-to-yearvariability,inter-specificinteractions,andtoperformasensitivityanalysis.13 REcensement des Mammifères marins et autres Mégafaunes pélagiques par Observation Aérienne(Censusofmarinemammalsandotherpelagicmegafaunabyaerialsurvey)
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
62
New consideration for marine issues in French GuianaMarc-Henri Duffaud (EnvironmentalRegionalDirection,FrenchGuiana)
Fol low ing t he succes s f u l col laborat ion be tween t heEnvironmentalRegionalDirectioninFrenchGuianaandtheFrenchMPAAgency,strategicplanningformarinebiodiver-sityconservationwasestablished.Atthesametime,theMarineMammalsResearchCentrebegantomakeageneralinventoryoftheexclusiveeconomiczoneofFrenchGuiana.Theresultofthissurveywasnotableforthediversityandquantityofmarinemammalsfound.Thisnewknowledgehasledtoareviewoflocalassessmentsontheissueofmarinemammals.
TheEnvironmentalRegionalDirectioninFrenchGuianaisthereforeworkingnowwithBraziltoimplementaregionalcooperationprojectfortheconservationofmarinemammals.Thefirststepsofthisactionwillfocusondataexchangeandmonitoringcoordination.Moreover,basedonstrategicanaly-sis,studieswereconductedonseagrassbeds,submarinerockyareas,andinventoriesofpelagicbirds.Allofthesewillcontrib-utetotheimplementationofmarineZNIEFF(zonenaturelled’intérêtécologique,faunistiqueetf loristique,orNaturalAreasofEcological,FaunalandFloralInterest),alreadybegunwiththeadoptionofreferencelistsandthepreparationofcriticalspecieslists.
Dolphin monitoring and research programme in suriname Monique Pool (SurinameEnvironmentalAdvisoryServices,Suriname)
TheGreenHeritageFundSurinamehassetitselfthegoal,withintheframeworkofitsDolphinMonitoringandResearchProgramme,toengagepublicauthoritiesandthegeneralpublicinaprocesstoconsidertheestablishmentofMPAs.
Forthatpurpose,aworkshopwasheldinMarch2010–TheDolphinProgrammeCoastalZoneManagementandMarineProtectedAreasWorkshop–toprovideanintroductoryover-viewofMPAs.Duringthisworkshop,theprocess,aswellasaclarificationoftheroleoftheGreenHeritageFundinthedesig-nationandimplementationofMPAsintheterritorialsea(fromshoreto3miles),wereprovided.
ThisfirststepintheprocessinwhichtheGreenHeritageFundasanadvocacygroupwishedtoinformpublicauthoritiesandpublicopinionofthebenefitsofCoastalZoneManagementandMPAswasexpandedonataconference1½yearsaftertheinitialworkshop.Opinionsofpolicy-makerswerepresented,reportingonthecurrentstatusofthisinitiative.
Cetacean critical habitat assessment in the central-northeast coast of venezuelaLenin Enrique Oviedo Correa(TheSwireInstituteofMarineScience,TheUniversityofHongKong,China)
ThecoastalareaofVenezuelahasthelargestandmostconcen-tratedpopulationintheCaribbean(61%ofthecountry’spopula-tion),alongwithequallyconsiderableshippingtrafficandoneofthelargestfishingcatchesintheregion.Thisispartlyrelatedtoanimportantpelagicfishpopulation,whichsustainsthishighlevelofcoastaldevelopment.Venezuela’scoastalsosupportssomeoftherichestmarinebiodiversityintheregion.Currentstrategicpolicies,prioritizedbytheVenezuelangovernment,aimtopromoteandincreasenationalfoodproductiontoachieveself-sustainability,and,integratedwithinthesepolicies,istheimportantlocalsectorofartisanalfishing.
Coastalandneriticcriticalhabitatsofdolphinsareassociatedwithkeyecologicallydynamicprocesses,suchascoastalupwelling,andlocallyidentifiedbaysandcoveswithspecificvaluesintermofspeciesecologyandsurvival(e.g.,foragingareas).GrantingMPAstatustoidentifiedcriticalhabitatswouldpromotehealthypopulationgrowthandwiderecosystembenefits.Thus,thescopeofprotectionmightincludethebasiccomplexoftrophicrelation-shipswithupwellingsandsmallpelagicfishaggregations.
Manatees in French GuianaVirginie Dosreis (KwataNGO,FrenchGuiana)
OurmanateestudyinFrenchGuianahasusedvariousmethods.Twosurveysbasedoninterviewswereconductedin2000and2001andrevealedthewidedistributionofmanateesalongthecoastofFrenchGuiana.
Recently,moreinterviewswereundertakentoupdatetheinitialwork.Moreover,asurveymethodhasbeentestedforquantita-tiveestimationofpopulationsize,usinglateralsonartrackedinturbidwaterswithvisualconfirmation.
ThisprojectcouldbeexpandedincollaborationwithBrazilianteamsandbycomparisonwithothermonitoringmethods(e.g.,ARGOStags).Publicawarenessisneeded.
Conservation of freshwater dolphins in South America: A regional cooperation initiative among countries, stakeholders and policy makersMarcela Portocarrero-Aya (UniversityofHull,UK,andFundaciónOmacha,Colombia)
Theinitiative“AbundanceEstimationofRiverDolphinsinSouthAmerica”constitutesthefirstregionalschemefortheconser-vationoffreshwaterdolphins(Inia spp. andSotalia spp.) in
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
63
theAmazonandOrinocoriverbasins.Sofartheinitiativehasinvolved31researchersfromsixcountriesandhasbeensup-portedbyWWF,WCS,WDCS,IUCN,WhitleyFund,NationalGeographic,FundaciónOmachaandAsociaciónFaunagua.
TheformulationoftheActionPlanfortheConservationofSouthAmericanRiverdolphins(2010-2020)managedtogatherinthesamevenueforthefirsttimegovernmentrepresentatives,policymakers,expertsonriverdolphins,freshwaterecosystemsandfisheries,anddonorsfromColombia,Venezuela,Peru,Ecuador,Bolivia,Brazil,Argentina,UK,andSwitzerland.
TheestablishmentoftheSouthAmericanRiverDolphinProtectedAreaNetwork(SARDPAN)hasbecomethethirdregionalriverdolphinconservationinitiativeinrecentyearstobringtogetherstakeholdersinvolvedinriverdolphinandfresh-waterbiodiversityconservationandprotectedareasmanagement.
Aquatic mammals as ecological indicators to integrate monitoring programs and assessments with management practicesCatalina Gomez-Salazar (DalhousieUniversity,Canada,andFundaciónOmacha,Colombia)
Theimpactsofhumanactivitiesonaquaticecosystemsaredra-maticallyincreasingandareoftenunsustainableinthelongterm.Measuringhabitatdegradationinaquaticecosystemsisextremelychallengingbecausethemajorityofconsequencesofhumanstressorsoccurunderwaterandthusarehardertotrackandmeasuresincetheyarenotusuallydetectablebythetech-nologyusedinterrestrialsystems.
Therefore,includinginformationonindicatorspeciessuchasaquaticmammalstoassess,monitorandmitigatehumanstress-orsisworthinvestigating.Aquaticmammalscouldpotentiallybeusedasecologicalindicatorswiththeaimofintegratingthemonitoringandassessmentofecosystemdegradationwithman-agementpractices.
Summary of DiscussionFollowingtheaerialsurveyconductedinFrenchGuiana,therehasbeengreatinterestinmarinemammalpopulationsfromothercountriesintheregion.Detailsofthemethodswereexplainedincludingspeciesidentification,especiallyofSotaliaspecies.Somerecommendationstoorganizenetworksweresug-gested.Venezuela’srepresentativewelcomedthiscooperationprojectandthenetworkidea.First,itisnecessarytodefinecon-servationareasandstudythem;second,thedifferentmethodsofprotectionforlandandmarineneedtobeconsidered;third,everystakeholderhastobeinvolved.Theprojectshouldtakeintoaccountallthreatsincludingtheissuesofoilspillsandshippingaccidentsaswellaschronicland(run-off),marine-basedpollu-tionandfisheriesinteractions.
SeveralstudiesonSotaliaspeciesareprogressingandSurinamehasbeguntoworkwithBrazilianandCostaRicanteams.InVenezuela’snortheasterncoast,animportantworkisongoingonacoastalpopulationofSotalia sp.,whereevidencesuggeststhattheyhaveaverysmalllocalizedhomerange.InFrenchGuiana,aswell,localteamsareworkingwithBrazilianteamsespeciallyonmanatees.Thesestudiesaretestingacousticmethodsbecausetheturbidwaterspreventvisualobservations.Anotherproblemcomesfromhumancapacitybecausetherearenotenoughresearchers.
FrenchGuianaresearchintomarineissuesprovidesanindica-tionoftheoverallsituation.However,moremonitoringandsur-veysareneededwithdifferentprioritiestolearnaboutbycatch,fine-scalespeciesdistribution,andothermatters.Itwouldbevaluabletoexchangedatabetweencountriestounderstandthecurrentsituationanddatagaps.
Adebatehasbeenengagedonresearchpriorities.Someproposi-tionswereconsideredaswellasstandardizationofdatacollec-tionorsimilarapproachesfordifferentareas(forexample,aerialsurveys).Acommonprobleminseveralcountriesinthisproj-ectisalackofmarinebiologists.Concerningspecies,Sotaliaisthepriorityspeciesinthearea.Variousmarineprotectedareasexistbut,asreportedbyeachcountry,nonehavebeencreatedformarinemammalconservation.Forexample,inVenezuelaonlyrecentlyhavecetaceanshadcriticalhabitatsidentifiedwiththepurposeofexploringconservationstrategies,specificallyforthecommondolphinandotherdelphinidsinthecentralcoastofthecountry.
Allparticipantsagreeditwasessentialtoworkwithlocalstake-holderssuchasfishermen.Marinemammalshavebeensuggestedasecologicalindicatorsandcanbeusefultotransmitscientificinformationtostakeholders.Forexample,dolphindensitycanbecombinedwithahumanstress/anthropogenicthreatsindex.
Tobuildthisregionalproject,varioussuggestionshavebeenmadebyparticipants,whowereconsciousofthevariouscom-plexpoliticalandenvironmentalaspects.Muchinformationisneeded.Countrieshavemarineprotectedareas(thoughprinci-pallynotcreatedbasedonmarinewildlifedensities)buttherearegapsinmanagementandfunding.Itcouldbevaluabletodevelopanactionplanbutatriggerisneeded.
Recommendations from Workshop 5ToinitiatecooperationonmarinemammalsinthenortheasternLatinAmericanregion,Workshop5participantswillconcentratefirstonobtaininganddisseminatingknowledge.Allspeciesintheregionshouldbeconsidered,butspecialattentionshouldbeaffordedtoSotaliaspecies.
Intheshortterm,Workshop5participantsintendto:
(1)UpdateandcompletetheICMMPA2Workshop5back-groundpaper;
(2)OrganizeanewworkshoptobeheldinSeptemberorOctober2012,inParamaribo,Suriname,to:
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
64
a.establishthestateoftheartonknowledgeofmarinemammals(speciesandcriticalhabitats),threatsandcurrentlegalmanagementframework,countrybycountry.Insomecases,assistancefordataanalysiswillbeneeded,and
b.setupanactionplan(includinginter aliacapacitybuildingthroughtrainingcourses,regionalsurveys,astrandingnetwork).
Inthelongerterm,Workshop5participantsrecommendthatthey:
(3)Taketheopportunityfromexistingregionalprojectstofore-seethewaytodevelopsynergies(example:RíosdeAmericaproject);
(4) ConsiderjoiningtheAmazoncooperationtreatyorganiza-tionandGuianashieldfacility;
(5)Helpeachotherdevelopastrategyforfundraising;and
(6)InvolveSPAW-RACandthefollowingcountries–Brazil,FrenchGuiana,Suriname,Guyana,Venezuela,Trinidad&TobagoandABCDutchCaribbeanislands–intheirorganization.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
65
Workshop 6: GOBI-UNEP/LifeWeb Technical Session: Identifying EBSAs and Critical Habitats in the Wider Caribbean and East Pacific to Inform Marine Mammal Management Planning
(cancelled as a separate workshop and included as part of Workshop 4B and Workshop 9)
Blainville’s beaked whale in the Canary IslandsPhoto by David Sellwood (courtesy Erich Hoyt, WDCS)
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
66
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
Some populations of killer whales, or orcas, in the US, Canada and the Mediterranean are considered endangered by national or regional bodies. Photo by Harriet Huber, National Marine Mammal Laboratory, NOAA Fisheries
Killer whales off Kamchatka, Russia, where marine traffic, even in this remote corner of the North Pacific, is steadily increasingPhoto by Tatiana Ivkovich, Far East Russia Orca Project, Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
67
Workshop 7: Immediate and Lingering Impacts of Oil Disasters on Marine Mammals: Review of Experiences and Policy Implications
Coordinators:Teri Rowles(NOAAFisheries-OPR,MarineMammalHealthandStrandingResponseProgram,USA)andDavid Mattila(IWCandNOAA-ONMS,USA)
Rapporteur: Jaclyn Taylor (NOAA,USA)
Participants: PhilippeBaillot,PatricioBernal,NancyDaves,GregDonovan,CécileLefeuvre,DavidMattila,NaomiMcIntosh,VéroniqueMoriniere,JoséTrudaPalazzo,Jr,TeriRowles,RicSagarminagavanBuiten,AurelieTasciotti,JaclynTaylor,StevenTucker,ChloëWebster,RobWilliams,MikeZiccardi,others
IntroductionEveryoilspill,bothlargeandsmall,offersanopportunityforlearningexperiences.Inthewakeofthelarge-scaleDeepwaterHorizonOilSpillintheGulfofMexicoin2010,thelargestoilspillinUShistory,therehavebeenmorequestionsabouttheimpactsofoildisastersonmarinemammalsandwhatmightbedonetomitigatetheeffectsbothshort-andlong-termandtopre-parebetterforfuturespills.Thisworkshop,withexpertsinbothmarinemammalsandoilspillresponse,examinedtheeffectsonmarinemammalsandconsideredvariousscenariosandstrate-giesforoilspillpreparednessandresponse.Recommendationsfocusedonhowthesituationcanbeimproved.
Presentations
Oil spill contingency planning response strategies and toolsVéronique Moriniere (RAC/REMPEITC–Caribe,Curaçao,CaribbeanNetherlands)
TheREMPEITCistheRegionalMarinePollutionEmergencyInformationandTrainingCenterintheWiderCaribbeanRegion.ItisajointIMOandUNEPcenter,andisoneofthethreeRegionalActivityCenters(RAC)oftheCaribbeanEnvironmentProgram(CEP)ofUNEP,relatedtotheOilSpillProtocoloftheCartagenaConvention.Oneofitsmainmissionsistopromoteinternationalcooperationandpreparednessonoilspillresponse.ItworkswiththegovernmentsoftheWiderCaribbeanregionorganizingactivities,suchastraining,seminarsandexercises,atbothnationalandregionallevels.
Thekeyforanefficientoilspillresponseispre-planning.Themechanismsfortheestablishmentoftheresponseandman-agementtoolsmustbepre-definedinOilSpillContingency
Plans.Theseplansmustdefinethreelevelsofresponsecapabili-ties:local,nationalandinternational(tier1to3).ContingencyPlanningincludesthedefinitionofareasatrisktobeprotectedinorderofpriority,andthewildlifeprotectioncommunityhasanimportantroletoplayinthispre-definition.
Worldwide,thereexistsanumberofinternationalandregionalorganizationsinvolvedinoilspillpreparednessandresponse,includinggovernmentalorganizations,industries,andNGOs.Onechallengefortheoilspillresponsecommunityistocommu-nicate,worktogetherandsharetheresources,especiallyinlessdevelopedareaswheretheresourcesarescarce.AnexampleofacooperationagreementistheGlobalInitiative,ledbytheIMOandIPIECA(InternationalPetroleumIndustryEnvironmentalConservationAssociation),whichimplementprogramsinsev-eralregionsoftheworldtopromotecooperationbetweengov-ernmentsandindustry.
Promotingcooperationalsoincludesmakingsurethatallresponsepartiesknoweachotherandarewellconnected.REMPEITC’srepresentationatthis2ndICMMPAwasanoppor-tunitytodiscussthisimportanttopic:marinemammalsexperts,availabletoworkonoilspillresponseandrescueissues,havetobefamiliarwithoilspillresponsestrategiesandmanagement,andoilspillrespondershavetobefamiliarwithmarinemam-malsandotherwildlifespecificissuesandproblems.
Anexampleofcooperationbetweenthesetwoworldsisthecur-rentprojectoftheREMPEITCtodevelopaGIS-baseddatabaseonthemaritimeroutesintheWiderCaribbeanRegion(tobeavailableonlineattheendoftheyear).Thisprojectwillconsti-tuteanimportanttoolforoilspillriskassessmentintheregion,butitcanalsobeofgreatinterestforMMPAtopics.Thetworegionalactivitycenters(RACs)oftheCaribbeanEnvironmentPlan,theSPAW-RACandtheREMPEITC-RAC,havebeencom-municatingtosharedata.
The Effects of Oil on Marine MammalsTeri Rowles (NOAAFisheries-OPR,MarineMammalHealthandStrandingResponseProgram,USA)
Marinemammalprotectedarea(MMPA)managersandmarinemammalscientistsmayhavemanyrolesduringanoilspillincludingrolesinwildliferesponse,impactassessment,miti-gation,andlong-termassessments.OfcriticalimportancetoMMPAmanagersisthescientificinformationonoilspillimpacts
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
68
fromdirectorindirectexposuretooilandfromresponseactivi-tiessuchasdispersantapplicationsandin-situburnoperations.
Oilisacomplexmixtureofproductsandchangesovertimeastheoilisweathered.Thetoxicorphysicaleffectsofoilaredependentonthetypeofoil,thestatusoftheoil(weathering),exposure(inbothdoseandroute),thespeciesaffected,andtheoverallphysi-ological/biologicalstatusoftheindividualaffected.Somespe-cies,suchasottersandfurseals,havesignificantimpactsduetothephysicaleffectsoftheoilandmaybeobviousduringaspill;othersmaybesensitivetothetoxicologicaleffectsthatmaynotbeobviousineithertheshort-orlongterm.Intheplanningandresponsestage,theavailabilityofenvironmentalsensitivitymapsiscriticaltoprotectingareasorspeciesyetmostnationalorinter-nationalplansoftenincludeonlyshorelineorcoastalsensitivitymapsandnotoceanicsensitivitymaps.Therearepublisheddataonimpactsonpinnipedsandotterswhichincludebothexternalandinternaloilingeffects;forexample,impactsonreproduc-tion,survival,andorganpathology(neural,respiratory,blood,immune,liver,andkidney).Thereare,however,sparsedataonacuteeffectsoncetaceansandsomepublishedreportsdocument-inglossofindividuals(e.g.,inthecaseoftheorcasaftermissingfromtheirpodaftertheExxonValdezoilspill).
Aspartofamanager’sresponsibilities,documentationofexpo-sureandeffectsduringthespillandmediumtolong-termassess-mentsafterthespillareimportant.DuringDeepwaterHorizon,assessmentofcetaceansbothinshoreandoffshoredidoccuruti-lizingstrandinginformation,photo-ID,biopsy,tagging,passiveacousticmonitoring,andsurveys(boat-basedandaerial).MMPAmanagersshouldbefamiliarwiththepotentialimpactsofbothoilandresponseactivitiesandshoulduseappropriatetoolsandtechniquestodocumentacute,medium-andlong-termimpactsonpopulationsandtheir ecosystems.
Overview of oil spill response for marine mammals in the USMike Ziccardi (OiledWildlifeCareNetwork,USA)
IntheUnitedStates,thereisarequirementforAreaContingencyPlanstoprovideforaspecificfishandwildliferesponseplantominimizedisruptiontothemandtheirhabitat.Fundingtorespondtooiledwildlifeistheresponsibilityofthespilleror,ifthespillerisnotidentified,federalfundingmanagedbytheUSCoastGuardisavailable.Toassistwiththis(aswellastoorganizeresponseifandwhenneeded),NOAAhasdeveloped,andconductstrainingin,MarineMammalOilSpillResponseGuidelines(MMOSRG)–alivingdocumentthatchangesaftereverymajorevent,includingtheDeepwaterHorizonspill.
Thispresentationdetailedthekeyaspectsoftheseguidelinesasrelatedtomarinemammalcollection,care,andreadinessactivitiesasanexampleofhowanintegratedprogramcanbeimplementedtoprotectmarinemammalsduringsuchincidents.Ifwarranted,thismodelcouldbeeffectivelyusedformarineprotectedareasonaninternationallevelinorderto:
• Combinemammal-specificinformationintocontingencyplans.
• Developresourcesneededtorapidlyandeffectivelyrespondduringincidents.
• Integratelocalresourcesforimmediateandinter-mediatemonitoringprograms.
Summary of DiscussionParticipantsdiscussedtheinternationalcoordinationforoilspills.FortheWiderCaribbean,theRAC/REMPEITCdoestheplanning.Internationally,thereisadatabaseforalloftheexistingnationalcontingencyplans.ThereissomeinternationalcoordinationfromtheIMO,buteachcountrycoordinatesitsownresponse.IMO’sroleistoexchangeinformationwithothercountries,buttheinformationisfragmented.Thereisnosinglelocationforalloftheinformation.
Whataboutpost-responsemonitoring?Ifpost-responsemoni-toringisinthecontingencyplan,thenitmaybeincludedaspartoftheresponse.Eachcountryhasitsownpolicyonwhentostarteachphaseofanoilspillresponsefrominitialresponsetoinjuryassessmentandlong-termmonitoring.EvenintheUSOilPollutionActof1990(OPA90),itisstilldifficulttoobtainfund-ingforanythingbeyondtheactualresponsephaseandthereareregionaldifferencesbetweenwhatiscoveredinwildliferesponse.Whentheinitialresponseends,theCoastGuardandresponsiblepartymaydisappearinsomecountriesorsomesituations.Thenitisnotclearwhopaysfortheinjuryassessmentandthepost-responseandlong-termmonitoring.Internationally,thereisnoarequirementfordamageassessmentorforlong-termmonitoring.
Everycaseisdifferent.Isthereaplacewherepeoplecangotolearnfromotheroilspillresponseexperiences?TheIMOhasmeetingswithexpertsallovertheworld,butthemainfocusisontheoperationalportionoftheresponseandcleanup.Itincludesresponseandtheeffectsonnaturebutthewildlifeimpacts,particularlymarinemammals,maynotbeincludedasastrongcomponentofthepost-responsereviewandreporting.
Fortankerspills,theITOFalsoprovidessummaryplanningdocuments.FortheUS,themostcompletesourceofinforma-tionistheCoastGuard’sincident-specificpreparednessreviews,availableonline.
Itwasmentionedthatdispersantsdohelpwithbiodegrada-tionoftheoilbutPAHs(crudeoilcalledpolycyclicaromatichydrocarbons)areverypersistentintheenvironmentandmayremainlongerthanisevidentintheactualvisibleoil.Theuseofdispersantsdoesn’tmeantheoilisgone;itwillnotdegradethatquickly.Theoilisjustdisplacedintosmallerdropletsandintothewatercolumn,butitisstillthere.
WasthereanoverloadordysfunctionoftheIncidentCommandSystem(ICS)byhavinghandledbothresponseanddamageassessmentinaspillofthesizeofDeepwaterHorizon?UnderOPA90,damageassessmentisoutsideoftheunifiedcommand.Whenresponseandnaturalresourcedamageassessment(NRDA)overlapwithalimitedorthesamestaff,itistaxingtostaff.At
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
69
heightoftheresponse,therewereover47,000peopleactivelyworkingontheresponseincludingprivategroupsworkingontheirown.Wenowknownewcomplexitiesofworkingonaspillofnationalsignificance.
Regardingpublicpressureputonresponsedecisions(e.g.,tosavetouristbeachesvs.savingthewhales),throughoutaspillresponsetherearecompetingneedsandenvironmentaltradeoffdecisionsthathavetobemade.Humanandenvironmentalimpactshavetobeconsidered.WithintheICSduringanactualresponse,onehopesthereisenoughknowledgetoknowwhatthecriticalresourcesarethathavetobedealtwith.Attimesitisdifficulttoemphasizetheimportanceofthemarshandseagrass.Thepublicwantsthebirdsandwhalessavedovertheseagrass.Peopleoftendon’tunderstandtheinterconnectionofthese.Pre-planningiscriticalinordertohavethosediscussionsofsensitivitybeforeaspillratherthanhavingthosediscussionsduringaspill.
DuringDeepwaterHorizon,theUSCoastGuardgotagoodles-soninhandlingpublicaffairsandwasinitiallybehindonthecommunicationstothepublic.TheCoastGuardbeganholdingpublicmeetingstocommunicatethereasonsbehindtheresponsedecisions.Thehopeisthatyouhavetheresourcetosavetheani-malsandthehabitatandamechanismforinputfromthepublic.Beforethespillresponsestarts,theenvironmentaltrade-offsshouldbediscussedbetweentheresponsecommunityandthewildlifeorenvironmentalcommunityandpossiblythepublic.Itisbesttoevaluatetheoptionsanddevelopcommunicationstrat-egiesinacalmsituation,notduringtheheightoftheresponse.
Wearealsomissingoutonhugeopportunitiestolearnfromsmalleroilspills.Thelessonsarethatweshouldstronglyencour-agedebriefingsandlessonslearnedfromsmallerspillswhichoccurmoreoften.Ofcourse,itisalsoimportanttohaveadequatesciencetosupportdecisions.
Discussion Toward Recommendations Marinemammalsarelong-livedanimals,anditisdangerousforshort-termstudiestomakepronouncements.Weneedtobelook-ingatlong-termmonitoringstudies.InthecontextofMPAs,weneedtoknowmuchbetterwhatwemeanbybaselines.WeneedabetterideaofwhatthevariabilityisandwhattypesofwildlifepopulationswehaveinMPAs.Thelikelyeffectsfromaspillcanbedifficultormeaninglesstodetectintheshortterm.Itisalsodifficulttomaintainfundingforlong-termstudies.Duringaspill,thereneedtobeinvestigationsonanimalsthathavebeenimpactedaswellason“unimpacted”animalsforcomparisons.Thereneedtobeshort-termandintermediatetermassessments.Thereneedstobepost-releasemonitoringofreleasedanimals(bothbeachreleaseandrehabilitationrelease)aswellthosethatwereassessedduringthespill.
IntermsoftabletopexercisesthatcouldbedevelopedfromtheDeepwaterHorizonexperiencesandsharedwithmanagers,thepartnershipbetweentheOiledWildlifeCareNetwork(OWCN),NOAAandtheUSCoastGuardwillincorporatewildlifeinthetabletopexercisesthatalreadyexist.Theresponseandwildlifecommunitiesneedtounderstandeachother.Themostrecent
drillinCaliforniahadalargecontingentfromtheChannelIslandsNationalMarineSanctuary.Thingsarechanging.Iftherearedrillsandexercisesthatareplanned,itisimportanttojoinearlytobeincludedintheexercise.TheREMPEITCexercises,however,donotincludemarinemammalsandonlybrieflymen-tionwildliferecovery.
Marinemammalsarenotincludedinbroaderdisasterresponses–hurricanes,typhoons,etc.Marinemammalsneedtobeincludedindrillsforbroadernaturaldisasters.
Findingqualifiedpersonnelcanbedifficult.NewZealandhasagoodnationalplan.Intheirplan,theyidentifyinternationalgroupsaheadoftimeandatatier3responsetheywillcallininternationalexpertstohelp.Thebestthingtodoistogetinvolvedwithsomeoftheinternationalprograms–some10organizations.OWCNisfundedtorespondtoandprepareforeventsinCalifornia.Theyarealwaysinterestedinpromotingtrainingandoutreach.
IntheRussianFederation,typicalofotherplaces,theoilcom-panyisinchargeoftheresponseandhastheplan.Oilcompa-nieshavecontingencyplansandareofteninchargethroughprofessionalgrouporganizations.IfOSRisrespondingtoaspillandthereisnowildlifeplaninplace,theycandosomeoftheresponsethroughexistingagreements.
IntheUSArctic,theUSCleanSeaswouldbetheleadforcleanup–includingfortheAlyeskapipelines.
Thereisnoprofessionalbodythatisgearedtoreviewingcompa-nies’responseplans.Bestthingistoidentifysomeoneyoutrusttoreviewwouldbeagoodthing.
Humanerrorandequipmentfailurearetheleadingcausesofoilspills.Oilcompanypracticesandsafetycanvarybycounty.Notallcountrieshavecontingencyfundingifthepolluterdoesn’tpayforthecleanup.ThatseemstoonlyhappenintheUS.Spillersinsuranceiswhatpaysfortheresponseinmanyinstancesandthatusuallyhasaceilingwhichlimitsthefundsavailable.Thereisabigdifferenceifaspilltakesplaceinacountry’sEEZorifitoccursoffshoreoutsideofnationaljurisdiction.
Someofthepossibleneeds,recommendationsandotherdesiredoutcomesthatwereidentifiedandputonthetable,andleduptothefinalrecommendations,include:
• Contingencyfundsareneededinternationallywithadvanceplanning.WaysshouldbefoundtogainthefundsthoughMPAs.
• Astrongpartofthelawoftheseaisfreetransitforships.WehaveusedthetermMPAtoshowthatanareaisnotano-takezone.ItmightbenecessarytonarrowthetermMPAtomeanno-takezonesforareaswherewewantahighlevelofmarinemammalprotection.ThechallengeforprotectionismostlywiththehighseaswheresomefeeltherearenoagreementstoestablishlargeMPAs.Theideaofprotectingareasinthehighseasresonateswithpeople,buttheideaofenforcementandsurveillancewouldbedifficult.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
70
• Weneedtomovetowardsamoreconsistentprocessfortheresponsiblepartywhenanspilleventhappens–somethingthatcaneasilyfitintotheirbusinessplan.
• InternationalorganizationssuchasIMOITOPF/Industries,IPIECA,ARPEL,APIshouldbeencouragedtoworkincooperationwithmarinemammalspecialistsforoilspillresponsecontingencyplanning.
• Marinemammalspecialistsshouldbeencouragedtopresentimpactsofoilsspillsonanimalsatkeyindustrymeetings.
• Allmarinemammalprotectedareamanagersshouldbeurgedtoworkwiththegovernmentornationalauthoritiestobeincludedintheregionaloilspillresponsecontingencyplanningandtraining.
• TheICMMPAshouldpresentanddistributetheseproceedingsatInternationalOilIndustryConferences.
Recommendations from Workshop 7Recognizingthatmanyinternationaloilspillcontingencyplansdonotincludemarinemammalsormarinemammalprotectedareas,Workshop7recommendsthattheICMMPAsteeringcommitteeandMMPAmanagersshould:
• WorktogethertoencourageinternationalorganizationssuchastheIMO,ITOPF,IPIECA,ARPEL,andAPI14toworkincooperationwithmarinemammalspecialistsforoilspillresponsecontingencyplanning,drills,andpreparednesstoensureamoreconsistentprocessandexpectationforoilspill(orotherhazard/disaster)responses,and
• Workwiththeappropriategovernment(s),nationalauthorities,orinternational/regionalbodies(suchastheRegionalActivityCenters)toensurethatMMPAsandmarinemammalsareincludedinnational/regionaloilspillresponsecontingencyplans,trainingactivities,andresponses.
Thereremainstoolittleinformationonindividualandpopula-tioneffectsofoilonmarinemammals,particularlycetaceansandsirenians.Recognizingthedifficultyinunderstandingtheimpactsespeciallyinlong-livedanimals,theWorkshop:
Stronglyencouragesdebriefings,lessonslearned,andpubli-cationofsuchevaluationsfromallspills,includingbothlargeandsmallspills,andincidentsthatresultintheoilingofmarinemammalswithoutadeclaredspill;
RecommendsthatMMPAmanagersandthemarinemammalscientificcommunitydevelopbaselineinformationonthevari-abilityandtypesofpopulationsinMMPAs(includingtempo-ral,spatial,andotherbiologicalaspects)andthatshort-and
14 Acronyms used are as follows: IMO – International Maritime Organization; ITOPF – International Tanker Owners Pollution Federation; IPIECA – Global Oil and Gas Industry Association for Environmental and Social Issues; ARPEL – Regional Association of Oil, Gas and Biofuels Sector Companies in Latin America and the Caribbean; API – American Petroleum Institute .
long-termstudiesbeundertakenusingappropriateassessmenttoolssuchasstrandings,photo-ID,biopsy,andsurveys,usingsolidsciencetosupportdecisions;and
Recommendshavingjointinternationalstrandingnetworksandoilspillworkinggroups.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
71
Workshop 8: Conservation of Sirenians
Chair: John Reynolds (MoteMarineLaboratory,USA)
Rapporteurs: Anaïs Gainette(NationalParkofGuadeloupe,Guadeloupe)and Gaël Hubert (SPAW–RegionalActivityCentre,Guadeloupe)
Participants: AnaïsGainette,GaëlHubert,BorisLerebours,HervéMagnin,BenjaminMoralesVela,OscarRamírez,JohnReynolds,VincentRidoux,LorenzoRojasBracho,HélèneSouan,FernandoTrujillo,AlessandraVanzella-Khouri
Introduction and GoalsThesessionwasdevelopedaroundseveralpresentations,sum-marizedbelow.Followingthepresentations,alivelydiscussionfocusedprimarilyaroundthere-introductionofmanateesinnearbyGuadeloupe.Nonetheless,asetofover-archingrecom-mendationswasmade.ManythanksgotoAnaïsGainetteandGaëlHubertforvolunteeringtoserveasrapporteursandfordoingaterrificjob.
Fortworeasons,thepresentationsfocusedtoalargeextentonongoingmanateespatialmanagementintheWiderCaribbean.Themainreasonwasthat,givenconstraintsontravelandcom-petitionwithotherconferences,attendancebyCaribbean-basedprofessionalswasmoreassuredthanwasattendancebypeoplefromotherlocations.Inaddition,though,excitingongoingeffortsinthewiderCaribbeanprovideamodelforsomecreative,effectiveandinstructivemodelsthatcouldbetransferredandappliedtosireniansinotherpartsoftheworld.
Thus,thegoalsoftheworkshopwereto:
• DiscussconservationofsireniansandtheroleMPAscouldandshouldplayinconservationofthisorder.
• Examinespecificcausesofsuccessandfailureofexist-ingprograms.
• ProvideavisionofmanateeconservationintheWiderCaribbeanandexploretherolethatnationalandinter-national(e.g.,LifeWeb)programscouldplay.
• Describecreativeandnoveloptions(e.g.,reintroduc-tions)ofmanateesintoexistingandeffectiveMPAs,asapowerfultoolforregionalconservation.
• SolicitrecommendationsregardingoptimizationofMPAsforsirenianconservation.
Presentations15
Conservation of sireniansJohn Reynolds (MoteMarineLaboratory,Florida,USA)
Reynoldsbeganbydefiningtheterm“conservation”inaman-nerthataddressedbothcurrentandfuturethreats,highlightingconsiderationsofbothspeciesandtheirenvironments,andthatclearlyincludedhumansandtheirneedsandactivities.Reynoldsindicatedthatkeystosuccessinthedevelopingcountriesarenotrelatedtosciencesomuchastoalleviationofpovertyandfoodinsecuritiesandcreationofalternativelivelihoods.HeillustratedthiswithanexamplefromMozambique’sBazarutoArchipelagoNationalPark.Indeed,insuchcountries,thevalueofadeadanimalismoreimportantthanthatofalivinganimal.Untilthatsituationchanges,conservationofsireniansisgoingtobeextremelydifficult,ifnotimpossible.
Conservationcanoccurwithoutscienceifthepoliticalwillexiststoconserve;conversely,evenwithgreatscientificinfor-mation,conservationmayfailwithoutappropriatepoliticalwill.Reynoldsindicatedthatconservationistsneedtoestablishcleargoals;confrontthefactthatconservationisvalues-based,morethanitisbasedonscience,andestablishacentralroleinconservationofvalues;adoptageocentricconservationethic;clarifyissuesoftemporalandgeographicscale;andestablishfundamentalprinciplesforthe21stcentury.Optimally,conser-vationeffortsshouldinclude:long-termfunding;aproactive,notreactiveapproach;appropriatebutnotexcessiveinfrastructure;acoherentideology;leadership;creativity(i.e.,notbeweddedtotraditional,oftenunsuccessfulapproaches);interdisciplinaryteams(ecologists,economists,sociologists,amongotherdisci-plines);andtransparencyincommunication.
Toolsforconservationincluderegulatorytoolsthatoftenfailtoworkwell(e.g.,legalprotection,enforcement,andaquaticpro-tectedareas)aswellasenablingtools.Thelatter,whicharewelldescribedintherecentlypublishedEcology and Conservation of Sirenia: Dugongs and Manatees,16includebutarenotlimitedto:education/awareness;communitypartnerships(assireniansoftenlivenearhumans);spatialmanagementofrisks;andeco-nomicincentivesandothereconomicstoolssuchaseconomicmortgages,cashpaymentincentives,andconditionalcashtrans-fersforpoorcountries.
15 TherewastohavebeenoneadditionalpresentationbyEllenHinesentitled“EvolvingMPAmonitoringintomarinespatialplanning:Aligningscienceandpolicytoconservedugongsandtheirhabitat.”Thespeakerwasunabletoattendduetoanunforeseen,last-minuteconflict.16 Marsh,H.,T.J.O’Shea,andJ.E.Reynolds,III.2011.Ecology and Conservation of Sirenia: Dugongs and Manatees.CambridgeUniversityPress.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
72
Reynoldsconcludedthatconservationeffortsmustrecognizethemultiplevaluesofecosystems,placeahighvalueonconser-vation,andbetransparentandproactive.Individualsengagedinsucheffortsmusthavecourage;becreative,imaginative,andopportunistic;andfocusonwinningwars,noteverybattle.MPAsneedtobeacomponentofconservationstrategies,buttheymustbecomemorethan“paperparks”.
Conservation of manatees in the wider Caribbean: Vision, initiatives, momentum, and transferabilityAlessandra Vanzella-Khouri (UNEPCaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,Jamaica)
Coauthors: Hélène Souan(SPAW–RegionalActivityCentre,Guadeloupe)andJohn Reynolds (MoteMarineLaboratory,Florida,USA)
Vanzella-Khouribeganbydescribingthegeographic,political,environmentalandeconomicattributesoftheWiderCaribbeanRegion.Shenotedthatthereismostlyinsufficient,anecdotalinformationonthestatusofthemanateeshere.TheAntilleansub-speciesisendangered,withperhaps4,000-5,000widelyscat-teredindividuals(comparedtonearly5,000FloridamanateesinFlorida).Majorregionalissuesforsustainabilityofwildlifeandecosystemsincludeclimatechange,invasivespecies,andexpan-sionofcoastaldevelopment.
IntheCartagenaConventionanditsProtocolforSpeciallyProtectedAreasandWildlife(SPAW),themanateewas,fromtheoutset,apriorityspeciesforactionbythegovernments.ThefirstregionalmanagementplanforthemanateewasadoptedbythePartiestotheCartagenaConventionin1995.ArevisedManateeRegionalManagementPlan17fortheWestIndianmanateewaspublishedin2010aroundthesametimethataregionalMarineMammalActionPlan(MMAP)wasdevelopedandapprovedbythePartiestoSPAW.
Vanzella-KhourireviewedtheprovisionsoftheregionalMMAP.ShenotedthelackofinformationonthestatusandabundanceofmarinemammalsintheWiderCaribbean;thecontinuedexploitationoftheresource;habitatdeterioration;limitedpro-tectionmeasures;insufficientnationalcapacityforresearch,enforcementorconservation;andfragmentedornon-existingpolicy.Thefive-yearprioritiesoftheMMAPinclude:improvingknowledge;enhancingcapacitytoaddressandmanagethreats;developinganexpertgrouptoguideimplementationoftheplan;andimprovingresearchandconservationcapacity.ManateeresearchandconservationareanimportantcomponentoftheregionalMMAP,inadditiontothemanatee-specificmanage-mentplan.Thelatterprovidesbothanoverallregionalreview(coveringtaxonomy,ecologicalimportance,generalstatusin
17 UNEP2010.RegionalManagementPlanfortheWestIndianManatee(Trichechus manatus)compiledbyEsterQuintana-RizzoandJohnReynoldsIII.CEPTechnicalReportNo.48.UNEPCaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,Kingston,Jamaica.
theregion)andnationalstatusaccount(focusingoncountry-by-countryanalysis,statusanddistribution,majorthreatsandconservation,legislationandconservation,socio-economicsig-nificancetolocalcommunities).
TheCaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme(CEP)andtheSPAWRegionalActivityCenter(SPAW-RAC)worktogethertoimple-mentrelevantprovisionsofboththeCartagenaConventionandtheSPAWProtocol.Theirjointeffortsinvolvefocusedconser-vationactionsformanatees,aswellasactiontoprotecthabitatandtobuildlocalandregionalcapacitytoidentifyandmitigatethreats.
Someofthelessonslearnedhavebeenthat(a)transboundarycooperation(regional,multilateral,bilateral)andintegratedapproachesaremoreusefulthanmorefocusedefforts;(b)regionalinitiativestaketimeandcommitmenttoachieve;(c)aregional,integrated,legalframeworkforcooperationisessentialtopursuecommongoalsandpriorities;(d)meaningfulactionsrequireandarebestdeliveredwithpartners,withcommonvisionandobjectives;and(e)ultimately,politicalwilliscriticaltotheachievementofobjectives.
The LifeWeb program as a potential tool for sirenian conservation in MesoamericaHélèneSouan(SPAW–RegionalActivityCentre,Guadeloupe)
Coauthor: Alessandra Vanzella-Khouri (UNEPCaribbeanEnvironmentProgramme,Jamaica)
ManateesarethreatenedthroughoutMesoamerica.Thereisadramaticneedtodevelop(a)protectedareasformanatees,(b)transboundarycooperation,and(c)spatialmanagementeffortsinvolvingallthecontiguouscountriesofthissub-region.
TheUNEPLifeWebproject“Broad-scalemarinespatialplan-ningofmammalcorridorsandprotectedareasintheWiderCaribbeanandSoutheastandNortheastPacific”wasinstitutedbythegovernmentofSpaintopromotebroad-scalemarinespa-tialplanningtoprotectmarinemammalhabitats.Thegoaloftheprojectistoimproveprotectionofmarinemammalsthroughthedevelopmentandenforcementofappropriatetoolsinclud-ingMPAsandtravelcorridors.Itseekstointroduceintegratedplanningapproaches,technicalguidance,regionaltrainingandlearningexchange.Thesuccessoftheprojectdependstoagreatextentonpoliticalwillineachcountry.
TheLifeWebprojectonmarinemammalshasmultiple,inter-linkedcomponents.Forexample,component1requiresregionalintegration,mappingandGISanalysisofmarinemammalmigra-tionroutes,corridorsandhabitats.Therelevantdatasetsconsid-eredforintegrationincludenotonlybiological/ecologicaldataonspecies,butalsodataoneffectsthathumanactivitiescanhaveonmarinemammals(e.g., directandindirecteffectsoffisheries).Themaintasksassociatedwithachievingthegoalsofcompo-nent1includeaninventoryandcollationofexistingecological
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
73
andsocio-economicdatainacoherentformat,followedbyGISanalysisandmappingofecologicalandsocio-economicinfor-mationtoregionallyvisualizecriticalhabitatsandkeyareasformarinemammals–locationswheremarinemammalconser-vationisaffectedbyspecifichumanactivitiesandwhereactivemitigationorconservationareurgentlyneeded.
Component2involvesregionaltrainingandlearningexchangestodevelopsharedbestpracticesandgovernanceprinciplesforsuccessfulmanagementactivities.
Theabovetwocomponentsdonotdirectlytargetmanatees,butmanateeconservationcanbenefitfromtheirimplementa-tion.DataonmanateesandsuitableMPAsarealreadybeingincorporatedintheanalysescarriedoutundercomponent1,asdescribedabove;component2canprovideimportantopportu-nitiestostrengthencapacityforandawarenessoftheneedforimprovedspatialprotectionformanatees.
Multi-nationaleffortstocreatetransboundaryMPAsthatsafe-guardhabitatessentialforfeeding,breeding,andmigrationcanbeanespeciallyusefulingredientinmanateeconservationeffortsintheCaribbeanandelsewhere.AnexpertworkinggrouponmanateeshasbeenestablishedundertheSPAWprotocoltoguideimplementationoftherecommendedactionsintheregionalmanateemanagementplan.
The establishment and challenges of the Chetumal Bay Manatee Protected AreaBenjamin Morales Vela(ECOSUR,Chetumal,México)
AlongtheYucatanPeninsulaofMéxico,manateesaremostabundantinChetumalBaywhichMéxicodesignatedasapro-tectedareaformanateesinOctober1996.AsChetumalBaylieswithintheterritorialwatersofbothMéxicoandBelize,Belizesubsequentlycreatedaprotectedareathere,too.Since1992,therehasgenerallybeenstrongbilateralcooperationtoprotectmana-tees.NewinformationwithGPStagsshowsthatmanateesmovefrequentlybetweenMéxicoandBelize.TheGPSdataalsoshowaregionalconnectionforfemalemanateesthatuseChetumalBayandalagoonsystemlocatedsomedistancesouthinBelize.Thus,cooperationbetweenthetwocountriesisindispensableformanateeconservation.
Inrecentyears,therehasbeenonlymodestenvironmentalinterestintheChetumalBayManateeProtectedAreafromtheMexicanstate(i.e.,QuintanaRoo),andlimitedmanagementauthorityexercisedbythedirectoroftheMexicanreserve.Whereasinfrastructure,federalandstatefunding,stakeholderparticipationandcommunitysupportfortheChetumalBayManateeProtectedAreawereonceverystrong,thoseparametershaveweakenedovertime.
TwokeythreatstomanateesandtheirhabitatinChetumalBayandsurroundingwatersare:highlevelsofPCBsthatexceedthecurrentthresholdfortoxicityindolphins(thresholdsforsireniansareunknown),andtheuseofnylonfishinglinesbyfishermen.
MoralesstronglyrecommendedthefollowingstepstostrengthentheMexicanmanateereserve:
• Establishanewprotectedareaunderfederaljurisdiction.
• Continuetoadvocateregionalstrategies(e.g.,theMesoamericanbarrierreefsystemproject,aLifeWebprogramformanatees).
• EncourageMéxicotosignupandbecomeaPartytotheSPAWProtocol.
The reintroduction of manatees to the waters of GuadeloupeBoris Lerebours (NationalParkofGuadeloupe,Guadeloupe)
Coauthors: Hervé Magnin (NationalParkofGuadeloupe,Guadeloupe)andJohn Reynolds (MoteMarineLaboratory,Florida,USA)
LereboursdescribedtheknownhistoryofmanateesinthenearbywatersofGuadeloupeandcitedreasonswhytheFrenchgov-ernmentandtheNationalParkofGuadeloupewishtoconsiderreintroducingthespecies.Thereasonsinclude:
• ThecurrentenhancedknowledgeofAntilleanmanateeshasaffordedtheopportunitytoexplorethereintroductionoption;
• Thehistoricalthreatsintheareawherethepopulationwouldbeestablishedarerelativelyminorandgenerallywellcontrolled;and
• Thisprojectcouldhelptherestorationofthenatural/historicalbiodiversityofGuadeloupe.TheprojecthasalsoreceivedsupportfromPartiestotheSPAWProtocolasameansbywhichtopromoteregionalconservationofmanateesintheWiderCaribbean.
TheproposedsiteofthereintroductionistheGrandCul-de-SacMarin,amarineprotectedareathatalreadycontainsno-entryzonesandexcellentinfrastructureformanagement,enforcement,andresearch.AreviewbyscientistsatMoteMarineLaboratoryindicatedthatthereintroductioncouldhaveimportantregionalimplicationsformanateesustainabilityandconservation,butthatcertainquestionsmustbeaddressed(e.g.,pollutionlevels)andcertainobstaclesovercome(e.g.,threatsoffishinggearandboats;endorsementoftheprojectbylocalstakeholders).
Lereboursdescribedtheproposedtimelinesfordifferentphasesoftheproject.Thepreparationphaseisintendedtotakeapproxi-matelyfouryears(between2009and2013),followedbyafive-yearimplementationandmonitoringphase.Theaccomplishmentstodateincludedevelopingimprovedcommunicationswithlocalfishinggroups,assessmentoforganiccontaminants(whichareatlowlevels),andestablishinganinternationalexpertwork-inggrouptoadviseontheprocess.Thechallengesthatremainincludedevelopingrelationshipswithforeigngovernmentstoprovideanimalsforthereintroduction.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
74
Summary of DiscussionDiscussionofthevariouspresentationsandtheirimplications,coordinatedbyReynolds,centeredontheGuadeloupereintro-ductionprojectinpartbecauseitisaregionalproject,butalsobecauseitisanovel,experimentalapproachtomanagementofsireniansandpossiblyothermarinemammals.
ThecriticalissuesofconcernregardingtheGuadeloupeprojectextendacrossarangeofeconomic,sociological,biologicalandecologicalparameters.Lerebours,Magnin,andReynoldsdealtwiththemajorityofthequestions.Attheendofthediscussion,itwasapparentthatworkshopparticipantsfeltmorecomfortableaboutthereintroductionprogramasapotential,responsibletoolformanateeconservationintheWiderCaribbean.Theissuesweremoreamatterofincompletecommunicationofinforma-tionthanoffundamentaldisagreements.Asnotedbelow,theworkshopparticipantsultimatelyendorsed,withcaution,theconceptofreintroductionofmanateesintoappropriateprotectedareas(suchastheNationalParkofGuadeloupe)asaveryusefulconservationmeasure.Attheconclusionofthediscussion,Dr.Moralesstated:“Don’tgiveupevenifitisalongroadtosuc-cess.Evenifthelegislationforthecondordidn’tauthorizetheirreintroduction,todaywehavecondors!It’sabeautifulproject.”
Reynoldsthenaskedworkshopparticipantstoconsiderbiggerpic-tureissuesregardingsirenianconservationandtherolethatMPAscouldplay.Workshopparticipantswereaskedtodevelopalistofthreekeyrecommendations,recognizingthatthelistcouldandshouldbeconsiderablylongertotrulypromotetheoptimaluseofMPAsforsirenianconservation.Inthatregard,participantsnotedthatcomprehensiveoverviewsofthetopicappearinapublicationbyMarshandMorales-Velacalled“GuidelinesforDevelopingProtectedAreasforSirenians”andinReynoldsandMorales-Vela’spresentationondayoneoftheMartiniqueconference.18
Recommendations from Workshop 8Workshop8agreestothefollowingkeyrecommendations:
AregionalapproachtoMPAsforsireniansisrecommended(e.g.,GreatBarrierReefMarineParkAuthority;northernSouthAmerica;Amazonbasin)topromotegoalsofinternationallyendorsedregionalmanagementplans(e.g.,Caribbean-wideMMPA),butaparallelprogramtoreviewandrecommendimprovementstoexisting,focused,sirenian-basedMPAsisalsoneededtoassesswhethertheyarelocatedinoptimallocations(hotspots),involveusefulprocessesandscope(bufferzones),andproduceresultsintheformofconservationbenefits.
Giventhecloseproximityofsirenianstohumancommunitiesandtheirattendantactivities,itisespeciallyimportanttodevelopachievablegoalsandactivitiesbasedinthecommunities,with
18 Marsh,H.andB.Morales-Vela.Inpress,2012.“GuidelinesforDevelopingProtectedAreasforSirenians”In:Hines,E.,J.E.Reynolds,III,A.A.Mignucci-Giannoni,L.V.Aragones,andM.Marmontel(eds.).Sirenian Conservation: Issues and Strategies in Developing Countries.UniversityPressofFlorida,Gainesville;andReynolds,J.E.andB.Morales-Vela.2011.OptimizingthevalueofMPAsforconservationofsirenians.SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas,7-10November,Martinique,seep10ofthisreport.
goodcommunicationandtransparencyamongstakeholders(e.g.,Chetumal BayandtheColombianAmazon).
Reintroductionprograms,suchasthatbeingdevelopedinGuadeloupe,representacreativeoptionwiththepotentialtoimprovesirenianconservation,butthoseprogramsrequirecarefulandtransparentconsiderationofscience,localculturalvalues,potentialthreats,legalconstraints,andfullstakeholderinvolvementatallstages.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
75
Workshop 9: Scientific Information to Support MSP: MSP for Marine Mammal Conservation, as well as Considerations of Marine Mammal Science in Broader MSP19
19 Note:Workshop9andWorkshop4BeachincorporatedpartsofWorkshop6originallyplannedasaseparateworkshoptentativelycalled“GOBI-UNEP/LifeWebTechnicalSession:IdentifyingEBSAsandCriticalHabitatsintheWiderCaribbeanandEastPacifictoInformMarineMammalManagementPlanning”.
Coordinators: Tundi Agardy(SoundSeas,USA)andPatricio Bernal(GlobalOceanBiodiversityInitiative–GOBI,IUCN,Switzerland)
Participants:TundiAgardy,PatricioBernal,AlexeiBirkun,NancyDaves,JacquesDenis,LionelGarder,FrançoisGauthiez,ChristinaGeijer,HassaniSami,TiareT.Holm,ErichHoyt,JorgeJimenez,KristinKaschner,DanLaffoley,VéroniqueMoriniere,AnneNelson,GiuseppeNotarbartolodiSciara,DenisOdy,JessicaRedfern,RicSagarminagavanBuiten,BrianD.Smith,StevenTucker,ChloëWebster,others
Introduction and OverviewThepresentationsforthiscombinedworkshopfocusedongloballevelplanningprocesses,regionalplanningprocesses,andmorelocalizedinitiativeswithinMPAs,aswellasareasinwhichMPAsdidnotyetexist.Ineffect,practitionersprovidedexperiencesandnotjustopinionsonwhatkindsofinformationaboutmarinemammalsweremostusefulforspatialmanage-mentthatspecificallytargetedmarinemammalsunderthreat–butalsowhatkindsofinformationaboutmarinemammalscouldinformbroadermarinespatialplanning(MSP),inordertoensurethatconservationofmarinemammalswasembeddedintheplanningprocessestakingplace.Thekindsofsciencediscussedincludedinformationaboutdistribution,abundance,populationtrends,behaviorandecology(especiallyintermsofcriticalareas),pressures,andimpacts.Wediscussedinforma-tionimportanttoplanning(whetherfornewMPAsiteselectionanddesign,orMSPinitiatives)aswellasinformationimportanttomanagement,suchasmonitoringtodeterminemanagementefficacyandtoallowforadaptivemanagement.
Capsulesummariesofthepresentationsforthiscafé-stylework-shopwereasfollows:
• KristinKaschnerpresentedonthemethodologysheusedintheGOBIprocess,comparinguseofdistribution/occurrencedatawithenhancedrangemaps.
• PatricioBernalpresentedontheConventiononBiologicalDiversity(CBD)processandGOBI,aswellasthespecialcaseofidentifyingecologicallyorbiologicallysignificantareas(EBSAs)intheArctic.
• GiuseppeNotarbartolodiSciarapresentedfindingsoftheEBSAandCHOMP(CriticalhabitatofMediterraneanpredators)initiativesintheMediterranean.
• ChristinaGeijeraddressedtheutilityoffinwhaledatainsupportingMSPintheMediterranean,highlightingtwotypesofuncertaintyandtheirimplications.
• RicSagarminagavanBuitenspoketotheuseofmarinemammalresearchfindingsininfluencingthelocationofshippinglanesintheAlboránSea,Mediterranean.
• DenisOdyaddressedmarinemammalresearchinthePelagosSanctuary(alsoMediterranean)includinginvestigationofpopulationsizeanddistribution,aswellashormonalconditionoffinwhalesasanindicationofreproductivestatus.
• BrianD.SmithpresentedworkintheSwatch-of-NoGround,Bangladesh,wheremark/recaptureandgeneticresearchhasinformedtheselectionofaprospectiveprotectedareanetwork.
Fullsummariesfollowbelow.
Presentations
Species distributions and critical areasKristin Kaschner (Univ.Freiburg,Germany)
Muchprogresshasbeenmadeoverthepast10yearstocom-pileavailableinformationonmarinemammaloccurrenceanddistributioninonlinedatarepositoriessuchasOBIS-SEAMAP(seamap.env.duke.edu/),whichintotalnowcontainmorethan700,000pointrecords.However,therearelargetaxonomicandgeographicbiasesaffectingthisdataset:Taxonomically,thedifficultieslieinthefactthatmorethanhalfoftheserecordsrepresentsightingsorstrandingsthathaveonlybeenidentifiedtothegenusorfamilylevel.Forrecordsidentifiedtothespecieslevel,thereismuchvariationindataavailabilityfordifferentspe-cies;whiletherearefewerthan10ornooccurrencerecordsformorethanathirdofallrecognizedspecies,combinedrecordsofthetop10speciesrepresent75%ofallavailabledataformarine
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
76
mammalsavailablethroughOBIS-SEAMAP(November2011).Geographically,monitoringeffortishighlyconcentratedinnorthernhemispherecontinentalslopeandshelfwaters;eveninthemostintensivelysurveyedareas,marinemammalspeciesinventoriesremainincompleteafterdecadesofsurveyeffortsduetotherelativerarityandlowdetectabilityofmanyspecies(Kaschneretal,2011).Arecentanalysisofglobalcetaceanlinetransectcoverageestimatesthatonaverageonlyabout10%oftheknownrangeofcetaceanspecieshasbeencoveredbydedi-catedsurveysandamuchsmallerpercentagehasbeencoveredfrequentlyenoughtoallowthedetectionofrelevantpopulationchanges(Kaschneretal,submitted).
Theskeweddistributionofmonitoringeffortinthemarineenvi-ronmenthaslargeimplicationsintermsofourabilitytodirectlydeducespecieshabitatuseorbiodiversitypatternsfromavailabledata.Inaddition,italsohamperstheuseofsuchdatatogen-eratepredictionsofspeciesoccurrenceusingstandardspeciesdistributionmodelingtools.Whilesystematic,spatially-explicitgapanalysescanhelpustodevelopbetterfuturedatacollectionstrategies,thesizeofthemarineenvironmentandthehighcostsofmonitoringeffortswilllikelyprecludeanoticeableimprove-mentofthecurrentsituationintheforeseeablefuture.Inlightofurgentconservationissues,Iarguethatinthemeantimeanduntilbetterdatabecomeavailable,alternativetypesofinforma-tionneedtobeconsideredthatcaninformmarinespatialplan-ningprocessesatlargerscales.
Onepossiblealternativeistherefinementofexpert-drawnbinaryrangemapsthroughtheapplicationofmethodsthatenablethevisualizationofaspeciesenvironmentalnicheenvelope.Inessence,thesetechniquesproducedistributionmapsinaGIS/spatialmodelingframeworkthatallowsfortheincorporationofexpertknowledgeinenvironmentalratherthangeographicalspace.ExamplesincludetheRelativeEnvironmentalSuitability(RES)model(Kaschneretal.2006)ortheAquaMapsapproach(www.aquamaps.org)(Kaschneretal.2008,Readyetal.2010),bothofwhichsupplementsuboptimalpointoccurrencedatawithotheravailableinformationandexpertinputtodescribespecieshabitatusageandenvironmentalpreferencesintheformofso-callednicheenvelopes.Ideally,envelopesettingsshouldbedefinedbasedonconsensusofagroupofspeciesexpertsinaworkshopsettingorthroughaniterativeprocessinawiki-typeenvironment.Byrelatingagreedenvelopestolocalenvironmen-talconditionsingeographicspace,rangemapscanbeproducedthatbalanceerrorsofomissionsandcommissionthusnarrowingdownpotentialspeciesoccurrenceasmuchaspossible.
Theresultingdistributionshaveseveraladvantagesincomparisontostandardpresence/absencerangemaps.Firstly,mapsrepresentreproducibleandtestablehypothesesaboutspeciesdistributions,basedonclearlydescribedunderlyingassumptions,whichcaneasilybereviewedandmodifiedasnewinformationbecomesavailable.Secondly,outputscanbedisplayedintheformofgradientsofrelativehabitatsuitability,showntobecorrelatedwithrelativeoccurrenceforanumberofspecies(Kaschneretal,2006).Duringmarinespatialplanningprocesses,suchinforma-tionaboutrelativeoccurrence,especiallyforspecieswithnear
cosmopolitanranges,canbehelpfulinprioritizingimportanthabitatorareasinneedofprotectionanditcanalsoallowthevisualizationofbiodiversityhotspotswhereoptimalconditionsfordifferentspeciesmightcoincide(Kaschneretal.2011).Finally,byinvestigatingtherelationshipbetweenpredictedrelativespe-ciesoccurrenceandobserveddensities,inferencesmaybemadeaboutspeciesdensitiesinunsurveyedareas(seealsoPanel2,KristinKaschner’spresentation).20
Making visible the ultimate global commons. Identifying ecologically or biologically significant areas (EBSAs) in the ocean: the CBD processPatricio A. Bernal(IUCNHighSeasInitiative,Switzerland)
Theneedtoinformpolicyprocessesbasedonthebestscientificdataandinformationavailableisahugechallengeintheocean,duetoitsscale,fluidnatureand3-Dcharacter.Theoceanisamediumessentiallyopaquetoelectromagneticradiation,wheredirectobservationsthroughremotesensingtechniquesareseverelylimitedtothemonitoringofthesurfacelayersoftheoceanandtheinferencebyextrapolationandmodellingoftheassociated3-Ddynamics.Thisrelative“invisibility”ofthemarinerealmisatrueobstaclelimitingcomprehensionbythegeneralpublicandpolicymakersofthisfascinatingdomainofnature,thehealthyfunctioningofwhichunderpinsmuchofourlife-supportsystemonEarth.
Withthepurposeofactinginaprecautionarymannerandtocon-tributetothemanagementofmarineresourcesandtothedevelop-mentofnetworksofrepresentativeMPAs,in2008theConventiononBiologicalDiversity(CBD)establishedsevencriteriatoidentifyecologicallyorbiologicallysignificantareas(EBSAs):
• Uniquenessorrarity.
• Specialimportanceforlifehistoryofspecies.
• Importanceforthreatened,endangeredordecliningspeciesand/orhabitats.
• Vulnerability,fragility,sensitivity,slowrecovery.
• Biologicalproductivity.
• Biologicaldiversity.
• Naturalness.20 Referencesinthispresentationare:KaschnerK,WatsonR,TritesAW,PaulyD(2006)MappingworldwidedistributionsofmarinemammalsusingaRelativeEnvironmentalSuitability(RES)model.Marine Ecology Progress Series316:285-310;KaschnerK,ReadyJS,AgbayaniE,RiusJ,Kesner-ReyesK,EastwoodPD,SouthAB,KullanderSO,ReesT,CloseCH,WatsonR,PaulyD,FroeseR(2008)AquaMaps:Predictedrangemapsforaquaticspecies.Worldwidewebelectronicpublication,www.aquamaps.org,Version08/2010;KaschnerK,TittensorDP,ReadyJ,GerrodetteT,WormB(2011)Currentandfuturepatternsofglobalmarinemammalbiodiversity.Plos One6:e19653;ReadyJ,KaschnerK,SouthAB,EastwoodPD,ReesT,RiusJ,AgbayaniE,KullanderS,FroeseR(2010)Predictingthedistributionsofmarineorganismsattheglobalscale.Ecological Modelling221:467-478
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
77
TheprocessofidentifyingEBSAsusingthebestscientificdataandinformationavailable,discountingtheirfurtheruseinman-agement,isequivalenttoestablishinganopen-endedscientificprogramwiththegoalofrevealingthetrueecologicalcomplexityofthis“oceaniclife-web”,updatingitasnewdataandinforma-tionbecomesavailable.
TheGlobalOceanBiodiversityInitiative(GOBI)wascreatedwiththeinitialsupportoftheGermanFederalAgencyforNatureConservation(BfN)andfundedbytheGermanFederalMinistryforEnvironment,NatureConservation,andNuclearSafety(BMU)toassistStatesandrelevantregionalandglobalorganisationstoidentifyEBSAsusingthebestavailablescien-tificdata,tools,andmethodstoprovideguidanceonhowtheCBD’sscientificcriteriacanbeinterpretedandappliedtowardsmanagement,includingrepresentativenetworksofMPAsandtoassistindevelopingregionalanalyseswithrelevantorganisa-tionsandstakeholders.
Todaywehaveafullycompetentobservationsystemforthephys-icsoftheocean.Ithasenabledtherefineddepictionatmultiplescalesofthedistributionofheatandmomentumuptosixdaysinadvance,informationcriticalforweatherandclimateforecasting.Lifeontheglobaloceanisfarfrombeinguniformlyobservedorsampled.Mostscientificobservationsofoceanlifearemadenearrichcountries,nearshoreandnearsurface.Despiteahugeincreaseincoverageandaccesstoglobaloceanbiodiversitydatainthepasttenyears,therearesignificantgapsincoveragemainlyintheSouthernHemisphere.TheNorthAtlanticiswellcovered,whileinthePacific,albeitwithrepresentativesampling,coverageismuchsparser.Coastal,surface,bottomandwatersimmediatelyoverlayingthebottomarebetterstudiedthanthevastoceaninterior.In2005therewere5millionrecordsinOBIS,whiletodaytherearemorethan31millionrecordsof112,000speciesfrom744databases.
Newwaysofobservingthelivingoceanhaveemergedandaretransformingourvision.TrackingtoppredatorsinthePacificOceanprovidesnewinsightsonthebehaviorandecologyofkeyspeciesinthemarinefoodweb:marinemammals,turtles,largemigratoryfishesandbirds.Applyingthenewtechniquesofgenomicsintheoceanwehavefoundthatitsabundanceandgeneticdiversityexceedsanythingimaginedbefore:Itisthoughtthatinoneliterofseawaterthereareabillionindividualmicrobesof24,000geneticallydistincttypes(OTUs).Researchersestimatethatmarinemicrobesmakeup50to90%oftheocean’sentirebiomass.Upward-lookingsonarplacedatthebottomgiveusdetaileddescriptionsofotherwisecrypticecologicalinteractionsbetweenverticallymigratingmeso-andmacro-zooplankton,myctophidfish,squids,marinemammalsandlargerfishes.
Finally,asanexampleofcurrentworkintheArctic,theresultsofaworkshopheldatScrippsInstitutionofOceanographyinNovember2010werepresented.Theworkshopconvened34scientistsandindigenouspeoples’representativeswithexper-tiseinvariousaspectsofArcticmarineecosystemsandspeciesandproducedasetofmapsdepicting77ArcticmarineEBSAsbasedontheCBDcriteria.Inaddition,13areaswereidentifiedwheremostorallsevenoftheCBDEBSAcriteriaweremet,and
insomecaseswithoneormoreofthecriteriaachievingagloballevelofsignificance.
How knowledge of top predators’ critical habitat can support placing Mediterranean MPAs in areas beyond national jurisdiction on the mapGiuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara(TethysResearchInstitute,Italy)
AlargeportionoftheMediterraneanSeaisstillbeyondnationaljurisdictionduetothereluctanceofmanystatesintheregiontodeclaretheirEEZs.Thus,mostMPAshavebeendesignatedinterritorialseasandthereforeonlyincoastalhabitats.Tworecent,separateeffortsaredescribedheretoidentifyopenseaareasintheregionthatwarrantprotectionduetotheirecologicalvalue.Bothwerelargelybasedonknowledgeofthedistributionandabundanceoftopmarinepredators.
Thefirsteffort,promotedbyUNEP’sMediterraneanActionPlanin2009incooperationwiththeEuropeanCommission,concernstheidentificationofsitesinMediterraneanAreasBeyondNationalJurisdictionwherethedesignationofSPAMIs(SpeciallyProtectedAreasofMediterraneanImportance)couldbeenvisagedbythePartiestotheBarcelonaConvention.ThestateoftheartonMediterraneanecologyisinsufficientasabaselinetodevelopeffectiverepresentativenetworksofMPAsintheHighSeas.InordertodelineateEBSAs(ecologicallyorbio-logicallysignificantareas)coincidingwithhighpriorityareas,andconsideringthatlargeportionsoftheMediterraneanSeaareverydata-poor,thepublishedknowledgewassupplementedwithexpertopinion.Locallyderivedindicatorswereemployedasproxiesofmarinebiodiversityhotspots.TheMediterraneanwassubdividedintoeightsub-regionsandineachoftheseatotaloftenEBSAswereidentifiedbyaskingapoolofexpertsinMediterraneanmarineecology,biodiversity,oceanography,andgeomorphology,whorecommended90polygonsthattheythoughtwererelevantfortheeffortonthebasisofsevencriteriadevelopedbytheConventiononBiologicalDiversity.
Theimpetusforthesecondeffort,presentedattheCIESMCongressofVenice(2010)derivedfromtheopportunitytodes-ignateMPAsforselectedapexmarinespecieshavingumbrellaand/orflagshipproperties,whichcouldsupporttheprotectionofawidernumberofspecies,ormarinebiodiversityingeneral,ultimatelyenhancingtheconservationstatusofthewholeregion.ThereisastrongneedintheMediterraneantointegrateplace-basedprotectionforavarietyofdifferenttaxaofapexspeciessharingthesameecosystem,sothatjustificationforMPAdes-ignationbecomesmorecompellingandthechanceofsuccessfulresultsincreases.Forexample,threatsthatmarinemammalssharewithotherspecies(e.g.,bycatch)canbeaddressedbythesamemanagementmeasures.Justasimportantly,mitigatingonemarinemammalthreat(e.g.,bycatchindriftnets)byinducingshiftsingearuse(e.g.,fromdriftnetstolonglines)mayendup
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
78
increasingamarineturtlethreat.Sothereisaneedforinte-gratedmanagementpolicies.Acollaborativeeffortwasunder-takentomaphabitatofseveralgroupsofmarinetoppredatorandcharismaticspecies(i.e.,marinemammals,seabirds,marineturtles,sharks,andbluefintuna),inaprocessinwhichexpert-anddata-derivedknowledgeismadetooverlap.ThiseffortwasalsointendedtosupporttheidentificationofEBSAsintheMediterranean,aninitialstepintheplanningofrepresentativeregionalMPAnetworks.
Similarresultsforthetwoseparateeffortsprovidedafirstindi-cationofareasofspecialrelevancetomarinebiodiversitycon-servationintheMediterranean.Aroadmapforimplementationwassuggested,including:
• Thecreationofanad hoc multi‐disciplinarygroup(comprisedof aminimumofoneexpertforeachoftherelevantdisciplinesandmethods)chargedtoperformathoroughinventoryoftheavailableknowledgeandexpertise,includingtheidentification,enrollmentandinvolvementintheprocessofthevariousscientificinstitutionsandexpertsthatareknowntoactivelyoperateinthesub‐region.
• TheconductoftargetedresearchtodeterminewithgreaterspecificitytheecologicalcharacteristicsofeachEBSA,itsboundaries,anddirectthreatstothearea’sbiodiversity.
• AnalysestodeterminetheoptimalspatialmanagementschemeforeachoftheMPAs,includingwhetherprotectedareasshouldbezoned,whatsortofregulationsshouldbeinstituted,howareasshouldbemonitoredandregulationsenforced,andtheirappropriategovernanceregime.
• ThedevelopmentofastrategicplantoelaboratetheprioritieswithintheMPAnetwork,includingconsiderationsofthechronologyforplanningandimplementingaregion-wideMPAnetwork.
Through the lens of uncertainty: Protecting migratory habitats. Insights from fin whale conservation in the Mediterranean Sea Christina Geijer (UniversityCollege,London)
Migrationroutesrepresentcriticalhabitatsforseasonallymigrat-ingwhales.Nevertheless,veryfewmigratoryhabitatscurrentlyfallundersomesortofprotection.Onereasonforthisisthechal-lengeofuncertaintyandobtainingreliablescientificinformationtoinformconservation.Inexaminingtheperspectiveofmigra-torywhaleprotectionasseenthroughalensofuncertainty,itisusefultolookatinsightsfromfinwhale(Balaenoptera physalus)migrationandconservationintheMediterraneanSea.Asaresultofadaptationstoaspecific,semi-enclosedmarineenvironment,residentMediterraneanfinwhalesexhibituncharacteristicallydynamicmigratorybehavior.Thisinherentvariabilitycoupled
withextensiveresearchgapshasleftMediterraneanfinwhalemigrationpatternsinastateofuncertainty.
Inordertodesignmoreappropriateandeffectiveconservationstrategiestoprotectfinwhalesthroughouttheirrange,itcanbehelpfultoexaminetheconceptofscientificuncertaintyitself.Uncertaintycanbedissectedandsystematizedinto“epistemic”uncertainty–knowledgegapswhichcanbereducedbygather-ingmoredata–and“ontological”uncertainty–theinherentcomplexityandvariabilityofasystem,forwhichtheuncertaintycannotbereducedbyadditionalinformation.Themainchallengetomigratoryhabitatprotectionthroughmarineprotectedarea(MPA)networksand/ormarinespatialplanning(MSP)isahighlevelofontologicaluncertainty,sincemigrationpathwayswillbetoounpredictableforzonation.Ifhighontologicaluncertaintyprevails,itmaybemoreappropriatetofocusconservationeffortsonwider-scalerestrictionspertainingtothesector(s)present-ingthemajorthreat(s)inordertoprotectwide-rangingspeciesduringtheirmigrations.Bycontrast,ifontologicaluncertaintyislow,protectingmigratoryroutesascriticalhabitatsorzoneswithinanarea-basedconservationframeworkismorerealistic.
However,evenincircumstancesoflowontologicaluncertainty,animportantquestiontoconsideriswhetherMPAnetworksorMSPshouldbeconsideredtheobviouschoiceformigratoryhabitatconservation?Thegeopoliticalclimatewithinwhichthescienceisbeingapplied–thatis,thescience–policyinterface–influencesthechoiceofconservationtools.AstheMediterraneancasestudydemonstrates,inareasofconsiderablegeopoliticalcomplexityandlowpoliticalwill,theestablishmentoftrans-boundaryMPAnetworksandMSPrepresentsaconsiderable–andpossiblyinsurmountable–challenge.
Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) in the Alborán Sea (SW Mediterranean) Ric Sagarminaga van Buiten(Alnitak,Spain)
VisualandacousticsurveysconductedintheSWMediterraneanSeabyAlnitakhaverecordeddataoncetacean,seabirdandseaturtleobservations,humanactivities,andin situnotationsforthecalibrationofoceanographictelemetrydataonphysiogra-phy,seasurfacetemperature,chlorophyll,amongotherthings.Theanalysisandmodelingofthisdatahasbeenusedtoobtainmappingdataformanagementshowingabundanceofkeypro-tectedspecies,priorityhabitat,riskzonesandestablishmentofconservationactionsundertheframeworkoftheEuropeanUnion’sMaritimeStrategyFrameworkDirectiveandtherelevantUnitedNationsorganizations(FAO,IMO,UNEP).
Since2005,inthecontextoftheEULIFENatureProjectINDEMARES,AlnitakhasincorporateddatafromelectronicmonitoringsystemssuchasPAMGUARD,Cpods,Dmons,sat-ellitetags,AISandCCTV.
Alnitak’spresentationhighlightedspecificcasestudiesshowingtheutilityandcostefficiencyofthedatacollectedanditsanalysistoputinplaceconcretemanagementmeasuresincludingdesign
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
79
ofMPAs,spatialmanagementofhighriskfisheryoperations,andreconfigurationofmaritimetrafficseparationschemes.
Inadditiontokey,urgentissuesaddressedbyAlnitakwithregardstoriskstobiodiversityinthesectorsoffishing,defense,tourism,transportandenergy,thedatacollectediscurrentlyanimportantcontributiontoSpanishauthoritiesinchargeofMSPaspartoftheimplementationoftheMaritimeStrategyDirective.
Identification of physiological status in reproductive hormonal analysis of fin whales in the Pelagos SanctuaryDenis Ody(WWFFrance,France)
Coauthors: Brigitte SiliartandCaroline Berder(ONIRIS,France),Thierry Legavre, Ronan Rivallan and Ange Marie Risterucci(UMRAGAP,CIRAD,INRA,UniversitéMontpellier,France)andAurélie Tasciotti(WWFFrance,France)
Knowingthepopulationbirthrateanditsdynamicinagivenareacanprovideimportantinformationaboutthestateofthispopulationtomanagers.Theaimofthepresentworkistodeter-minethereproductivestatusoffinwhalesinthenorthwesternbasinoftheMediterraneanSea,andtoprovideanswersonthestatusofreproductionofindividuals(breedingmalesandpreg-nantfemales)andthebirthrateandseasonalityofreproductioninthisspecies.
BiopsyresearchatseafromMaytoOctoberwasorganizedbyWWFFrancein2010andbiopsiesof67individualswerecol-lected.Sexdeterminationandgeneticidentityusingelevenmicrosatellitelociwerecarriedoutforeachindividual.Thegeneticidentitydatawerecomparedwithin2010samplesandwith2009samples.
Therateofprogesterone,testosterone,estradiolandandro-stenedionewasmeasuredforeachsample.Allthesteroidsweremeasuredbyradioimmunoassay:RIAKitIM1188BeckmanCoulterforprogesterone,RIAKitSpectriaOD68628IDSfortes-tosterone,RIAKitSpectriaOD68633IDS(ImmunodiagnosticSystems)forestradiol,andRIAKitIM1322BeckmanCoulterforandrostenedione.
Thesexhormoneprofilesfromfatcandistinguishpregnantfemalesfrombreedingmales.Theotheranimals,femalesandnon-breedingmalescannotbedifferentiatedonlybythesexhormoneprofile.
Whentheprogesteronerateisabove100ng/gfat,thefemaleisunambiguouslypregnant.From67individualsbiopsiedin2010,14werepregnantfemales.Theresultsofthe2011campaignwillenableustocheckthepresenceofyoungandthehormonalchanges(iftherearerecaptures).
Forsexuallyactivemales,therateofandrostenedionewasgreaterthan6ng/gwithoutprogesteroneincreasing.Of67individu-alsbiopsiedin2010,30werebreedingmales.Thesetestsprovide
indirectinformationontheageofindividuals.Otherindividu-alsbiopsiedwerefemaleswithlowprogesteronelevels,orlessactivemales.
Theseasonalandannualrecapturesfinallyallowustoanalyzethehormonalchangesofindividuals.Apregnantfemalebiop-siedinJulyandinSeptember2010hadstrongprogesteronelevelsintherangeof>375ng/gfatinJulyand298ng/gfatinSeptember2010.
ThisdemographicinformationemphasizestheimportanceofthePelagosSanctuaryforfinwhaleconservation.
Scientific information for MSP: Experiences from the Swatch-of-No Ground, BangladeshBrian D. Smith (WildlifeConservationSociety(WCS),USA)
Coauthors: Rubaiyat Mowgli Mansur, Elisabeth Fahrni Mansur and Zahangir Alom (WCS,Bangladesh)
About25kmfromtherimoftheSundarbansmangroveforestlaystheSwatch-of-NoGround(SoNG),a900+meterdeepriver-erodedsubmarinecanyonthatsustainstheworldlargestsedi-mentfan.SpatialplanningforapotentialPAforcetaceansintheSoNGhasbeeninhibitedbynotbeingabletosurveyacrosstheborderwithIndiawhichiscurrentlyindispute.
TheIndianOceanisan‘ecologicalcul-de-sac’forcetaceans.CoolupwelledwatersintheSoNGmaybeavitalecologicalrefugeformobilemarinespeciesthatcannotadapttoincreasingoceantemperaturesorpotentialdeclinesinbiologicalproductivity.Indo-PacificbottlenosedolphinsarethemostabundantspeciesoccurringintheheadoftheSoNG.Knowledgeoftheirrangingpatternsisvitalfordevelopingplanstoprotectcetaceansinthesubmarinecanyon.
Vessel-basedsurveyswereconductedtophoto-identifyIndo-PacificbottlenosedolphinsintheSoNGduringthewintersea-sonsof2005-2009.Fromatotalof376dolphingroupsdetectedalongalmost8,000kmoftracklineandabout40,000dorsalfinphotographs,atotalof1,144individualdolphinswereidentifiedusingdistinctivemarksontheirdorsalfins.
Toestimatepopulationparameters,weusedaPollock’srobustmark-resightdesign.Thesetypesofmodelsusephoto-identifica-tionandsightingsdatafromopenandclosedsamplingperiods.Unliketraditionalopenmark-recapturemodels,thesemodelscanestimatetemporarymovementinandoutofthestudyarea,i.e.,whetherweweresamplingtheentirepopulationoronlyasubsetofalargersuperpopulation.
Resultsofthestudyindicateapopulationofabout2,000dol-phins.Thismakesitamongthelargestassessedofthespecies.Overallapparentsurvivalwasestimatedas0.96(95%CI=0.80-0.99).Inter-seasonalprobabilitiesoftransitioningtoanunob-servablestatewereestimatedas0.05-0.36indicatingsubstantialmovementinandoutofthestudyarea.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
80
Whiletheoverallnumbersofdolphinsareencouragingandsur-vivorshipappearsfairlyhigh,31.6%ofthe1,126photo-identi-fiedindividualsexhibitedmarksorwoundsthatwereprobablyrelatedentanglementswithfishinggear.IfthetruesurvivalrateforbottlenosedolphinsintheSoNGisatthelowerendofthe95%confidenceinterval,thiscouldindicateadecliningpopula-tionpossiblyduetomortalitycausedbyfisheriesinteractions.
Geneticscanbeusedtoinvestigatethepopulationidentityanddispersalofcetaceans–vitalinformationforMSP.Analysisofthemitochondrialcontrolregionof38samplesofBryde’swhalefromtheSoNGindicatedthattheyweremorecloselyalignedwiththesmallnearshoreformB. edeni intheIndo-Pacific.ComparisonswithothersamplesofB. edeni inthenorthernIndianOceanshowedremarkablylowgeneticdiversityprobablyindicatingsubstantialdemographicconnectivity.Futuremicro-satelliteanalysesofgeneticsamplesshouldprovideinformationondispersalpatterns.
TakehomelessonsforMSPfromourexperienceintheSoNGare:
• Innovativetechniquesforestimatingpopulationparameterscanprovideinformationaboutmovementsinandoutofastudyarea,whichmaybeboundedbyinternationalborders,fieldlogistics,orlackoffundingtoexpandthestudytoalargerarea.
• ThisinformationisvitalforknowingifaPAorPAnetworkistoosmalltoencompasscriticalhabitatforanentirecetaceanpopulation.However,ifthePAorPAnetworkisfoundtobetoosmall,littleinformationisprovidedonhowlargeitshouldbeorhowthearea(s)shouldbeconfigured.
• Geneticsareanotherpowerfultoolforansweringsomeofthesamequestionsbutgenerallyoveralargerareaandlongertime-scale.
• Informationprovidedbyrobustpopulationestimationtechniquesandgeneticsisagoodstart,butinsufficientforMSP.InsituationsliketheSoNG,transboundaryresearchinitiativesareanessentialnextstep.
Conclusions from Workshop 9• Onthebasisofpresentationsandthefollow-up
discussion,Workshop9generatedthreeclassesofconclusionsandrecommendations:
• HighlightsofthekindsofscienceprovingmostusefulforMSP.
• ConsiderationsfortheuseofmarinemammalscienceinMSP(includingconstraintstotheabove).
• Actionitemsneedingtobetakenupbythemarinemammalcommunitywritlarge,theICMMPAsteeringcommittee,andthenewlyformedMarineMammalScienceinMSPNetwork.
Themainfindingsaresummarizedasfollows:
Kinds of data and information most useful
Marinemammalscienceisneededtoinformplanningandmanagement–i.e.,monitoringthatallowsforadaptiveman-agement.Priorityscientificinformationincludesdistributionofkeymarinemammals(beyondjustoccurrence),abundance,populationdynamics,populationtrends,populationgenetics,pressures(humanusesofconcurrentspace),andimpactsonmarinemammals.Theuseofsciencetoprovideinformationonthresholds,andidentificationofchangeindicators,isparticularlyimportantformanagers.TheidentificationandquantificationoftheextentofexistingandpotentialconflictsbetweenmarinemammalsandvarioussectorsusingthemarineenvironmentisalsoinformativeforMSP.Recognizingthatthestartingpointwasthequestion“MSPforwhat?”,theworkshopparticipantssuggestedbetterrecognitionoftheimportanceofmarinemam-malsasindicatorsforecosystemhealth.
Effort considerations and reliability of data
Forlarge-scaleassessmentandMSPefforts(e.g.,GOBI,CBD),thereisaneedtoimprovedatabeingusedandtorecognizetheimportanceofeffortconsiderations.Werecommendjudicioususeofmodels,andhighlighttheimportanceofusingexpertknowledgeatthesescales.Recognizinguncertainty,beinghon-estaboutuncertainty,anddealingwithuncertaintyiscrucial,especiallyunderstandingthenatureandlevelsofuncertainty.Informationaboutdatagapsisusefulforallocatingresourcesforresearchandininfluencingspatialplanningprocesses.
BothregionalMSPinitiativesandthosewithinregionsandwithinMPAscanallowustogroundtruthglobalscience-basedassessments.TheworkshopthusrecognizesandencouragestheuseofMPAsastrialareasorexperimentaltoolsfortestinganddevelopingMSPapproaches(MPAshavedemonstrationvaluebeyondconservationandmanagementin situ!).However,thegroupacknowledgedthelimitationsofbothMPAsasatoolforMSP,andthefactthatMSPitself(inallforms)maynotbethemostappropriatesolutiontoallmarinemammalchallenges.
Itisimperativethatwepromotedata-sharingamongourselves(marinemammalscientistsandconservationists).Theworkshopalsoacknowledgedtheimportanceoftransboundaryeffortsin
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
81
providingrobustscientificinformationforspatialplanning,managementandconservation.
Sharinganalyticalresultsisasimportantasdata-sharing.SharinginformationaboutpotentialEBSAsandongoingMSPprocessesintheopenoceanswiththegeneralpublicprovidesadeeperunderstandingoftheimportanceofmarinemammalinforma-tiontopromotebetteruseofMSPandMPAs.
Thegroupagreedabouttheimportanceofcollecting,compiling,andconsideringinformationonnoiseinthemarineenviron-mentinallspatialplanning,regardlessofscale.Asapriority,thegrouprecommendedexploitingeveryopportunitytodeploynoise-monitoringtechnologyinexistingobservationplatforms.
Action itemsActionitemswillbeconsideredasWorkshop9recommenda-tionsbelow.
Recommendations from Workshop 9Recognizingtheneedtoimproveunderstandingoftheimpor-tanceandutilityofmarinemammalscienceinMSP,workshopparticipantsagreetoworkonanoutreachstrategytoassistcolleagueswithmarinemammalMSP,especiallyindata-poor,species-richareasoftheworld.
Thiswillinclude:
DevelopingabestpracticesguideandstandardsforusingmarinemammalscienceinMSP.Abestpracticesguidewouldcap-turestate-of-artknowledgeandpracticalexperienceinusingmarinemammalscienceforeffectiveMSP.Aspartofthis,orcomplementarytoit,werecommenddevelopingastandardizedapproachformakingspatiallyexplicitriskassessments,includ-ingconsiderationsoftheimpactsofshipping,offshoreenergy,andlanduse,especiallyinrelationtoreleaseofcontaminants.ThereisastandardizedapproachforvulnerabilityassessmentsforIUCN,andthiseffortisnotmeanttocompetewithorsub-stituteforthat,butrathertopushthevulnerabilityassessmentsintotheMSPdomain,foruptakebyplanners.
Relatedtorecommendation1butlistedasaseparatetargetedinitiative:weproposetoinvestigateoptionstoincorporatethenicheenvelopeandothermodelingapproachesintotheIUCNRedListmapping.
Developinganactionplantoidentifyandaddresscriticaldatagaps.Thisactionplanwouldaddresshowtouseexpert-knowl-edge-based(Delphic)approachestocompileinformationthatcomplementsdatacollectedonmarinemammalstoidentifyareasofknowledgeaswellasareasof“ignorance”.Itwouldalsoaddresshowtopredictspeciesdistributioninunsurveyedareas,andhowtoprioritizenewdatacollectiontoallowvalidationacrossawiderangeofpredictedvalues.
Establishingashippingsectortaskforce.Recognizingtheneedtoworkdirectlywithsectorsandgovernancebodiesregulatingthosesectors,theworkshoprecommends formationofataskforcefordevelopingguidelinesforhowtoengagewithsectors
(focusingoneducationandawareness).Engagingwiththeship-pingindustryandIMOisthetoppriorityandcanbeaccom-plishedattheglobalscale.Cross-regionalexchangeoflessonslearnedaboutworkingwithothersectorsacrossnetworksofMPAsisencouraged,buildingontherecommendationsandinitiativescomingoutofICMMPA1.
PlanningforICMMPA3andbeyond.Thegrouprecommendsafullortwo-dayworkshopforthenextconference,toadvanceknowledgeandalsototakestockofhowwellthisworkshophadfulfilleditscommitmentsintheseactionitems.Togobeyond,andtotakeadvantageofotherforacomingsooner,thegroupplanstouseupcomingconferences(WorldParksCongressandIMPAC3meetingsin2013)assteppingstonestodisseminatesomeofoutcomes,productsandrecommendationsfromthisconferencetothegreaterMPA/MSPcommunity.ThegroupplansalsotocollaboratewithpartydelegationstoUNprocessestoprovideinformationandadviceonhowtousemarinemammalsciencetoinformCOPdecision-making.ThiscanhelpensurethatrelevantinformationaboutmarinemammalimportantareasgetsincorporatedintotheCBDprocessofEBSAidentification.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
82
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
Endangered North Atlantic right whale spouts in the classic v-pattern which helps distinguish this species.Photo by NOAA
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
83
Workshop 10: Management of Whale Watching in Marine Mammal Protected Areas (MMPAs)
Convener:Chris Schweizer(DepartmentofSustainability,Environment,Water,PopulationandCommunities,Australia)
Co-Chairs:José Truda Palazzo, Jr.(CCC–CetaceanConservationCenter,Chile/Brazil)andMiguel Iñíguez(FundaciónCethusandWhaleandDolphinConservationSociety,Argentina;apologiesforabsence)
Rapporteur:Ryan Wulff
Participants:MikeBossley,CaroleCarlson,MauricioFailla,Marie-ChristineGrillo-Compulsione,GaëlHubert,ArtieJacobson,StéphaneJeremie,JoséMartinsdaSilva,Jr.,PascalMayol,CraigMcDonald,JoséTrudaPalazzo,Jr.,RomainRenoux,CarolineRinaldi,PhilippeRobert,ChrisSchweizer,AlbertSturlese,LesleySutty,GaëlleVandersarren,OswaldoVásquez,ChloëWebster,RyanWulff,others
IntroductionMPAmanagers,marinemammalresearchers,andNGOrepre-sentativesattendedWorkshop10,onwhalewatching,to:
• Shareinformationanddiscussthemanagementofwhalewatchinginmarinemammalprotectedareas(MMPAs).
• Identifythreekeyrecommendationstoadvancethemanagementofwhale(anddolphin)watchingglobally.
Thediscussionswereaffordedasenseof immediacyduetothecurrentattentiondevotedtowhalewatchingguide-linesintheWiderCaribbeanandinAustralia,andtotheInternationalWhalingCommission’s“FiveYearStrategicPlanforWhalewatching”.TherecentregionalworkshoponMarineMammalWatchingintheWiderCaribbean,heldinPanamainOctober,producedproposedoverarchingprinciplesandgeneralguidelinesandstimulatedfurtherdiscussionsandactionsonwhalewatchingintheregion.InAustralia,thereiscurrentlyaCommonwealthreviewofwhalewatchingpolicyandguide-lines,aswellasareviewatthestatelevelinQueensland,witheffortsbeingmadenationallytotrytoharmonizetheregula-tionsacrossjurisdictions.Inaddition,theInternationalWhalingCommission’s“FiveYearStrategicPlanforWhalewatching”waseffectivelylaunchedintheMMPAcommunitywithaseparatesideeventattheconference.
Presentations
Whale and dolphin watching – an Australian perspective 2011Artie Jacobson (DepartmentofSustainability,Environment,Water,PopulationandCommunities,Australia)
In1980theAustralianGovernmentbannedwhalinginallAustralianwaters.Australiangovernmentshavesinceestab-lishednumerousmarineprotectedareasarounditsvastcoast.AdditionallyAustraliahasdeclaredtheAustralianWhaleSanctuary,whichcoverstheentireEEZandtheAustraliancon-tinentalshelf,andhasinstitutedmanagementmeasuressuchastheNationalGuidelinesforWhaleandDolphinWatching.ItisAustralia’sintentiontoprovideaconsistentapproachtoimple-mentinglawstoprotectcetaceansfromadverseinteractions.
Overrecentdecades,adiverseandsuccessfulwhaleanddolphinwatchingindustryhasdevelopedontheeastandwestcoastsinbothtemperateandtropicalzones.Theseprogramsprovideopportunityforlargenumbersofpeopletohaveacloseencounterwithawhaleordolphinbutunderprofessionallyadministeredarrangements.
Australiaacknowledgesthesocial,economicandenvironmentalbenefitsofasustainablewhaleanddolphinwatchingindustryandiseagertopromotetheuseoftheseanimalsininternationalwatersasanalternativetowhaling.Australiaalsoacceptsthechallengesofadvancingaresponsibleandsustainablewhalewatchingindustrytoconformtobestpracticewhaleanddol-phinwatchingprinciples.
Whale watching in the Mediterranean Sea: Toward a labelMarie-Christine Grillo-Compulsione (ACCOBAMS–AgreementontheConservationofCetaceansintheBlackSea,MediterraneanSeaand ContiguousAtlanticArea,Monaco)andPascal Mayol(Souffleursd’Ecume,France)
WhalewatchingintheMediterraneanSeaseemstobegrowingrapidly.AnareaofparticularinteresttowhalewatchingisthePelagosSanctuaryforMediterraneanMarineMammalslocatedwithintheCorsico-Provençal-LigurianBasin,westofcentralItalyandsouthofFranceandMonaco.
Therationalebehindtheestablishmentofthesanctuaryis“toprotectthewhalesanddolphinsinprimecetaceanhabitatinthe
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
84
MediterraneanwatersofFrance,MonacoandItaly”.Thehabitat,locatedfromnearshoretodeeppelagicwaters,includescetaceanfeedinggroundsaswellasareasusedbymigratingandbreedingcetaceans.Thesanctuaryconsistsof47%nationalwatersand53%internationalorhighseaswaters.
Thereisconcernhowever,thatthewhalewatchingindustryisdevelopinginanunplannedmanner,i.e.,nocontrolsonthenumberofoperations,commercialobservationeffortbeingconcentratedincertainareas,intrusiveapproachesbyvesselsandinadequateeducationofoperatorsandthegeneralpublic.
Inordertoimprovewhalewatchingstandardstobetterprotectcetaceansfromadverseinteractions,bothACCOBAMSpartiesandthePelagosSanctuaryaredevelopinganaccreditationpro-gram,i.e.,eco-labeling,topromotesustainablewhalewatchingwithinahighprofilemarineenvironment,firstlyinPelagosandtheninalltheACCOBAMSarea.Theaccreditationprogramwillincludetrainingoftheoperatorsinthedeliveryofaqualitywhalewatchingexperienceandthecommitmentfromallmembersoftheprogramtorespectthecodeofgoodconduct.Thiswillalsorequireoperatorstoconformtoagreedapproachdistances.Thefirsttrainingsessionwilltakeplaceinspring2012inFrance.
Inordertobeabletoapplythelabelininternationalwatersastudyofthelegalaspectsassociatedwiththiswasconducted.Adedicatedcommunicationplanisbeingdevelopedtopromotethelabelwithinindustryandtothewiderpublic.Alogoisalsobeingdeveloped.
Marine mammal watching in Brazilian marine protected areasJosé Martins da Silva, Jr. (AquaticMammalsCenter,NationalBiodiversityInstitute–ICMBio,Brazil)
Aquaticmammalwatchingcanbeeitherasolutiontomarinemammalconservationoraproblem,dependingonthewayitisplannedandmanaged.
Itbecomesasolutionwhenthetouristactivityismatchedwithvisitororientationandassociatedexpectations,providesenvi-ronmentalawarenesstowardsmarineconservationandenhancesthevalueofthenon-lethaluseofaquaticmammals.
Ifnotproperlymanaged,however,itcanbecomeaproblemfortheanimals,causingmortalityandwoundsfromboatstrikesorbehavioralchangesduetocontinualharassment.Whereaquaticmammalwatchingactivitiestakeplaceinsideprotectedareas,solutionsaremaximizedandproblemsminimizedduetoanimprovedcapabilitytoimplementandenforceadequateman-agementmeasures.
TheBrazilianmarineareaconsistsof3,555,796km2.Ofthisonly1.57%ismanagedasmarineprotectedareas,totaling102units(55,716km2)ofwhich38arefullyprotected(4,977km2)and64areofmultipleuse(50,739km2).
AquaticmammalwatchingisagrowingactivityinBrazil,par-ticularlyinprotectedareasandencompassingseveralspeciessuchasEubalaena australis, Megaptera novaeangliae, Sotalia guianensis, Stenella longirostris, Trichechus manatusandOtaria flavescens.
In2010,275,000peopleparticipatedintheseecotourismactivi-tiesinBrazil.
Presentation on the Regional Workshop on Marine Mammal Watching in the Wider Caribbean Region, Panama City, Panama, 19-22 Oct 2011Carole Carlson (DolphinFleetandProvincetownCenterforCoastalStudies,USA)
Agrowing,yetnotfullyrealizedcomponentoftourismintheWiderCaribbeanRegion(WCR)ismarinemammalwatching.Withapotentialforgrowthinexistingoperationsandthepos-sibilityofnewonesemerging,itisanopportunetimetodeveloparegionalplanforthedevelopmentofahigh-quality,responsiblemarinemammaltourismindustrythatconformswithbestprac-tices,includingenhancedcoordinationandpartneringamongstakeholdersandinformationsharing.
Tothisend,afour-dayworkshop,developedundertheframe-workoftheCartagenaConventionanditsSPAWProtocol,includingtheMarineMammalActionPlan,washeldinPanamaCityinOctober2011.Theworkshopbroughttogether38par-ticipants,bothtouroperatorsandofficials,from22countriesandterritories.
Thegoalsoftheworkshopwereto:
• Assesstheextentofproblemsandneedsandidentifyopportunitiesinexistingmarinemammalwatchingoperations.
• Identifyareaswithpotentialformarinemammalwatchingactivities.
• Discusstheformulationofregionalcodesofconductforobservingmarinemammals.
• Standardizedatacollectionformsandorganizebaselineresearchoncetaceans.
• Documentexistingmarinemammaleducationalmaterials.
• Discussnextsteps.
ThedraftreportoftheworkshopwillbepresentedbyUNEP-CEPtotheSPAWPartiesatCOPin2012forconsiderationanddecisiononfurtheraction.
Oncefinalized,thereportwithguidelinesandrecommenda-tionswillbeavailableinSpanish,FrenchandEnglishon:www.cep.unep.org/meetings-events/regional-workshop-on-marine-mammal-watching-in-the-wider-caribbean-region.
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
85
The evolution of marine mammal policies and whale watching in the East Caribbean, Martinique and GuadeloupeLesley Sutty (EastCaribbeanCoalitionforEnvironmentalAwareness–ECCEA)
TheOrganisationofEastCaribbeanStates(OECS)isachainofsixindependentsmallislanddevelopingnationsthatencom-passthesouthernCaribbeanSea.FromnorthtosouththeyrunfromAntiguaandBarbudadowntotheislandofGrenada.CentraltothiszonearetheFrenchWestIndies,MartiniqueandGuadeloupe,OverseasDepartmentsofFrance.
Marinemammalsremainofgreatconservationandculturalsig-nificancetomanypeoplethatlivewithinthisarea.Historically,marinemammalswereseenastreasuredancestralcreaturesbyTupiArawakantribesthatinhabitedtheseterritoriesformorethan3,000years.DiscoveryoftheAmericasbroughtwithitdrasticchangeinthissubregionthroughcommercialwhalingandafinalintensivehuntofNorthAtlantichumpbackwhalesbyNorwayin1925whichdramaticallyimpactedpopulations.
WhalewatchingwithintheEastCaribbeanareaisconsideredacriticalgrowthindustryforconservation,cultural,socialandeconomicreasons.Itisunlikelythatwhalewatchingwouldhavebecometheindustryitistodaywithintheareahadtheislandsnotbeenexposedtoaseriesofunexpectedpoliticalscenariosandexternalpressuresfrom1992onwards.Theseinfluenceswereresponsibleforestablishingblockadhesiontopoliciesthatthreat-enedtheInternationalWhalingCommission’s(IWC)whalingmoratorium,theregion’smarinemammalconservationagendaandtheOECSjointobjectiontothecreationoftheAntarcticWhaleSanctuary,ultimatelyadoptedbythePartiestotheIWCin1994(seewww.eccea.org:Socio-EconomicandPoliticalAspectsofAidProvidedbyJapantotheFishingIndustryintheSmallIndependentIslandsintheEastCaribbean).
TheEastCaribbeanCoalitionforEnvironmentalAwareness(ECCEA)1991TrinidadresolutionforaCaribbeanSeawhalesanctuarytookplaceatthesametimeastheFrenchgovern-mentproposaltodeclareasanctuaryintheSouthernOceansurroundingAntarctica,whichwasoverwhelminglyacceptedin1994.Againcoincidingwiththiswasanothercomplexinitia-tivetodevelopastrategicplanforaCaribbeanwhalesanctuaryreinforcedin1995byaregionalconsultationprocess.Theaimoftheplanwastoinitiatechangeinhumanbehaviourandbuildpublicsupportformarinemammalpreservationandoceanbio-diversityatbothgovernmentandcommunitylevel.
TheprocessresultedintheECCEAregionalinitiativeforCommunityBasedNatureandHeritageTourism,EnvironmentalEducationandtheConservationofIslandEcosystemsintheEastCaribbean.ThisinitiativeidentifiedanumberofprojectswhichincludedawhalewatchingandnatureobservationsegmentaswellasthecreationofparksandMPAs.Associatedspinofftradeswerealsodesignedtocreatealternativeeconomiesandalleviate
poverty.Whiletheprojectsweredevelopedandundertakenincollaborationwithgovernmentdepartments,theyweredirectedbycommunityleaderswithvaluabletraditionalknowledge.Aspartoftheprocess,domesticlegislationwaseitherchartedorendorsedbygovernments.
Technicalassistancewasalsoconsideredcriticaltothesuccessofprojects,including:
• Whalewatchingtrainingworkshops,
• Capacitybuildingexercises,and
• Marinemammaleducationandawarenessprograms.
Theresultofthislong-terminitiativewouldbe:
• Thecreationofaseriesofnowhalingzoneslinkedforbothpoliticalandconservationreasons.
• TheestablishmentoftheAgoamarinemammalsanctuaryintheFrenchWestIndies.
• ThecooperativeexpansionofmarinemammalprotectedareasintheregionthatincludestheCommonwealthofDominica’sMorneTroisPitonsWorldHeritageSite.
Greatconcernremainsthatwhilesomeislandshavemovedawayfrompro-whalingprinciples,othershavehungontena-ciously,practicingbothwhalewatchingandthelethalhuntingofsmallcetaceansandhumpbackmothercalfpairs.Theprac-ticeoflethalhuntingsignificantlyconflictswithwhalewatchingwhichisnowamajorgrowthindustryintheCaribbeanBasin(currentlygeneratingapproximatelyUSD$55millionannuallyintourismexpenditures).
Insomeareas,however,marinemammalshavesufferedcollisionsonoccasionandhaveexhibitedchangedbehaviourasaresultofintensivecommercialwhalewatchingactivity.
TheECCEAandtheMartiniqueSocietyfortheStudy,ProtectionandDevelopmentofNature(Sepanmar)havesubmittedamodus operandiforcommercialandnon-commercialapproachestocetaceansforlocal,regionalandnationalapplication.ThesearecompatiblewithcurrentFrenchlegislationforMarineMammalsthatdefinesharassmentasillegal.Itisanticipatedthatthroughtheapplicationoftheseguidelinesadverseimpactswillbereduced.
TheECCEAalsosuggeststheimplementationofanumberofinitiativessuchastheclosureofkeycetaceanhabitatthroughMPAdeclaration,accreditationschemessuchaslabelingandcertification,monitoringandreportingprogramsandregularperformanceassessmentsbasedonresilienceprinciples.ThesechangestocetaceanconservationmanagementshouldensuretransparentandsustainableoperationsbasedontheAustralianandKaikouraexperience.
Summary of DiscussionWithpresentationscoveringarangeofsituationsinvariouscoun-tries,participantsweregivenagoodoverviewofdifferentwhaleanddolphinwatchinglandscapesandstandards.Theseincluded
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
86
WO
RK
SH
OP
S
thehistorical,social,economicandenvironmentalconditionsinkeywhalewatchingareasofAustralia,Brazil,theMediterranean,theCaribbeanandmorelocallytheeasternCaribbean.
Followingeachpresentation,workshopattendeeswereencour-agedtoraisequestionswithpresentersanddiscussissuesasagrouponthelocaloperationalenvironmentsthatwerepresentedandonwhalewatchinggenerally.
Significantdiscussiontookplaceonthequestionofhowtoachievesustainableandresponsiblewhale(ormarinemam-mal)watchingwithinMMPAs,anditwassuggestedthatthekeyapproachestotakeinclude:
• Startingwiththecommunityinordertocreateastrongsenseofownershipovertheprogramandparticularlypromotingtheeconomicbenefitstodevelopingcountries.
• Workingcloselywithkeystakeholderstodevelop,maintainandimplementnational(orinternational)guidelinesthatwillsustainhighstandards–preferablypriortotheestablishmentoftheindustryortheMMPA.
• Workingcooperativelyacrossjurisdictions/statesformigratingspecies.
• Utilizingagradualorincrementalapproachinwhalewatchingareastoallowformanagementandindustrygrowthtodevelopresponsiblyandwithcaution.
• Implementingacomprehensiveeducationalprogramthatdeliversaccurateinformation.
• Adoptinganon-adversarialapproachwithoperatorsbyprovidingservicestoimprovethedeliveryoftheprogram,i.e.,interpretivematerial,opendialoguetoimproveconditionsofoperationandincentivessuchaslabeling.
• Havingenforceableregulationsandthecapacityandauthoritytoenforcetheseduringtheseasontoserveaslessonslearned.
• Throughthisaction,demonstratingtoboththeindustryandthegeneralboatingpublicthatmanagementtakescetaceanconservationandassociatednon-complianceseriously.
Educationwasalsoconsideredimportantinensuringthatthevisitorexperiencewasnotonlyenhancedduringtheactualencounterbutwasusedtopromotewhaleconservationgenerally.Itwasalsodiscussedthateducationandresearchshouldworkhandinhandtoimproverelationshipsbetweenresearchersandoperatorsandpotentiallyfacilitatescooperativearrangementsthatwouldbenefitparties,thevisitorandthewhales.Thiswouldpotentiallyincluderesearchfindingstobecommunicatedtotheindustrytothenbeusedtoimproveeducationalprogramsandconverselyforoperatorstoinformresearchersoftheirday-to-dayobservationstoassistresearcherstoundertaketheirresearch.
Therecurringissueof“uninformed”recreationalvesseloperatorsimpactingonbothwhalewelfareandtheactivitiesofarespon-siblewhalewatchingindustrywasraised.Itwassuggestedthat
managersgivedueconsiderationtotheissueofwhaleandves-selinteractionsregardlessofwhetherthevesselwascommercialorrecreationalandthattheseissuesshouldbeconsideredwhendevelopingmanagementframeworks.
Itwasalsonotedthatwhiledifferentapproachlimitswereappliedwithindifferentareasandfordifferentspecies–forexample,humpbackwhalesvs.graywhalesvs.rightwhales–themostconsistentapproachlimitappliedwas100meters.Theissuesoftheuseofaircraftforadvancedspotterservicesandasawhalewatchplatformwerealsodiscussedasmattersofconcern.
Therewasalsosomediscussiononformalwhalewatchingprogramsbeingasolutionthatcouldleadtoenhancedpublicawarenessandthecapacitytoapplycontrolsonthetypesofinteractions.Buttheycouldalsopresentproblems,i.e.,requireadministrativeandmanagementresources,causevesselconges-tioninthevicinityofawhaleandincreasetheriskofcollision,influencewhalebehavioralchanges,andcauseconflictbetweenusers.Itwassuggestedthat,throughthedeclarationofMMPAs,solutionswerepotentiallymaximizedandproblemsmorethanlikelyminimized.
Followingonfromthis,itwasgenerallyagreedthatMMPAs,comparedwith“unprotected”marineareas,providedadditionalbenefitsfortheprotectionofwhales.Thesebenefitsmanifestmainlyintheformofmitigatingadverseimpactsassociatedwithwhalewatchingwhereoperatorswerebettermanagedthroughguidelines,approvals(andassociatedconditions),regulationsoramixofthese.
Inmostinstanceswherecontrolswereappliedtheyincludedtheapplicationof:
• Specifiedapproachlimits.
• Limitingthenumberofvesselswitha“cautionzone”.
• Speedrestrictionswheninproximitytowhalesanddolphins.
• Industrycontrolsbylimitingthenumberpermitsissued.
• Educationalstandardsthroughconditionsofpermissions.
• Improvedstakeholderengagement.
Variousotherinitiativesthatwerebeingimplementedindiffer-entregionswereoutlined.Theseincludedanaccreditationpro-gram,amarinemammalmonitoringsystem,nationalguidelines(enactedthroughlaw),adatacollectionsystemthatinvolvedthewhalewatchingindustry,andanationalcomplianceprogrampromptedbythewhalewatchingindustry.Alsodiscussedwastheconceptofsistersanctuaries–ausefulmanagementtoolforaconsistentapproachtomanagingmigratoryspeciesacrossmigratorypathsandterritorialseas.
Concernwasexpressedoftheriskofestablishing“paperparks”–i.e.,declaringanareaasaprotectedareabutwithoutapply-inganymanagementregimes.ThisledtoasharedviewamongparticipantsthatanecessarycomponentofsuccessfulMMPAdeliverywastheestablishmentandongoingimplementationofappropriatelyresourcedmanagementprograms.
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
87
Land-basedwhalewatchingwhichoccurredinmostcountrieswaspromotedandencouragedas“minimalimpactandminimalenergy”alternativetovessel-basedwhalewatching.
Itwasalsosuggestedthatwherewhalewatchingandwhalingtookplaceconcurrentlythatthiswastobediscouragedorpref-erablyopposed.
Therewasalsoausefuldiscussionontheadvantagesandchal-lengesofestablishinguniversalstandardstoguidewhaleandothermarinemammalwatchingactivities–suchasuniformminimumapproachdistances,anddiscouragementofswim-withprograms,amongotherthings.
WorkshopdiscussionsplacedsignificantemphasisonthebenefitsofMMPAmanagementagenciesandthecommunity,includingNGOs,workingtogethertosharelessonslearntinordertobuildefficienciesintodevelopingandmaintainingsoundmarinemam-malwatchingpracticesandmanagement.Theultimategoalwasthatthiswouldcontributetomarinemammalconservationatalocalleveland,moreimportantly,globally.
Issues Identified for Further Consideration• ICMMPA3shouldengageadiversityofstakeholders,
especiallymanagers,tomoreeffectivelygetacrosstherangeofmanagementissues/messagesthroughmorebroadandinformedinput.TheSteeringCommitteeshouldnotnecessarilybeallscientists–particularlyifICMMPAismeanttobeoperationallyoriented.
• Thereisaneedtobetterutilizenationalsynergiesandnetworksthataremorefocusedonmigratingpopulationsastheytravelacrossjurisdictionalboundaries.Thechallengeistointegratedifferentstates’policyandmanagementinitiativesandnothavethemrunseparatelyorinisolation,andattheexpenseofsoundpopulationconservation.
• Furtherdiscussionshouldbearrangedonaerialwhalewatching(maybeasanitemforICMMPA3).
• Thereisaneedtoexploreissuesassociatedwiththeuseofspotterplanestofindmarinemammalsasatooltoimprovethechancesofencounteringwhalesandsubsequentlyassistindustrytobettermeetcustomerexpectations.
• Land-basedwhalewatchingshouldbepromotedandencouragedasa“minimalimpactandnoenergy”alternativetovessel-basedwhalewatching.
• ThereisaneedtoimprovetheknowledgeofthewhalewatchingindustryandMMPAmanagersthroughjointeducationalventures.
• Thereisaneedtoencouragetheimplementationofaccred-itation(labeling)programsforwhalewatchingoperators.
• Thereisaneedtopromoteresponsiblewhaleanddolphinwatchingbyimprovingcustomerawarenessoftherulesofengagementwithcetaceans.Informedcustomerswillkeepoperatorshonest.
• Thereisaneedtoestablishwhalewatchingperformancemeasurestoassessthesuccessofmanagementincludingaccreditationinitiatives.
• Operatorsshouldbediscouragedfrompromotingguaranteesofseeingananimalasthisplacespressureontheoperatortopotentiallyinterfere(breachanapproachlimit)withawhaleordolphin–anditmayencouragecorruption,i.e.,ifamasterofvesselwerepaidtogetcloser.
• Thereisaneedtodevelopaprocesstoaddressthechallengeswithswim-withoperationsandtheeconomicincentivesprovidedbycustomerstotheoperator.
Recommendations from Workshop 10Workshop10agreestothefollowing:
Whereopportunitiesexistformarinemammalwatchingactivi-tiesinMMPAs,managersshouldthinkearlyonabouthowbesttoaddressboththecommercialandrecreationalactivitiesfromatraining,regulatoryandcomplianceaspect.Theyshouldworkcloselywithstakeholdersandthelocalcommunityinmovingforwardtoexplore,establishorrefineappropriatemanagementframeworks,includingvoluntaryand/orregulatorymeasures.
TheintegrationofscientificresearchandcollaborationshouldbeexploredwithlocalscientistsorinstitutionsinMMPAswithmarinemammalwatchingactivities.Whenpursuingopportunitiesfordatacollection,trainingandstandardizationareimportant.
MarinemammalwatchingoperationsinMMPAsprovideagoodvehicletoincreasegeneralunderstandingandpublicawarenessaboutmarineecosystemsandthevalueofMMPAs.Assuch,marinemammalwatchingoperationsshouldbeencouragedtoensureactivitiesarepresentedinabroadercontextthanwithasinglespeciesfocus.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
88
SID
E E
VE
NT
S
Endangered short-beaked common dolphins travel in the proposed Alborán Sea MPA in the Mediterranean.Photo by Lucy Molleson
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
89
Side Event 1: Ship Strikes in the Caribbean and Mediterranean: Studies and Solutions
Presented by Pascal Mayol (Souff leursd’Ecume,France),Marie-Christine Grillo-Compulsione (ACCOBAMSSecretariat–AgreementontheConservationofCetaceansoftheBlackSea,MediterraneanSeaandContiguousAtlanticArea,Monaco),andGaëlle Vandersarren (SPAW–RegionalActivityCentre,Guadeloupe)
Thescientificcommunityandshippingcompaniesareseriouslyconcernedaboutcollisionsbetweenvesselsandlargecetaceansindifferentregionsoftheworld,suchasintheMediterraneanandCaribbeanseas.
In the Caribbean Sea, a research program on collisions has started.TheCaribbean’smarinebiodiversity,includingcetaceans,isprotectedbytheCartagenaConvention.Inthisframework,theMarineMammalActionPlan,adoptedin2008,istheinstrumentthatdealswithshipstrikesundertheagreedprotocolforSpeciallyProtectedAreasandWildlife,theso-calledSPAWProtocol.
Lastyear,theSPAWRegionalActivityCenter(SPAW-RAC)startedtocollateinformationonvesselactivityandcollisions.Thefirstdatacollectedshowedthatvesselstrikesareanissue,andthatbigandsmallspeciescanbeaffectedindifferentpartsoftheregion.Followingthatconclusion,agroupofregionalexperts21lookingatregionalshippingroutesoverlaidtrafficmapsonadistributionmapofmarinemammalsinordertotargetpotentialareasofconflict.
ThefirstresultsofthisresearchrevealthatcollisionshappenintheCaribbeanmoreoftenthanwethought.Thestudieswillbecontinuedandcompletedbycollectingmoredataonvesselactivitiesandstrikes.Itwillalsobeessentialtoimprovecom-municationwithpeoplefromthemaritimesectorandmarineenvironment.Inparallel,itwouldberelevanttothinkaboutmeasuresthatcouldbeimplementedintheregioninordertolimittheriskofcollisions.
21 IncludingtheFrenchNavy,CROSSAG,theFrenchMarineProtectedAreasAgency(AAMP),theEastCaribbeanCoalitionforEnvironmentalAwareness(ECCEA),theNGOSepenmarandtheSPAW-RAC/UNEPoffice.
In the Mediterranean Sea, the REPCET system is now operative.IntheMediterraneanSea,coveredbytheACCOBAMStreatyandincludingthePelagosSanctuaryforMediterraneanMarineMammals,researchers,engineersandrepresentativesofmaritimetransportcompanieshavejoinedforcestodevelopREPCET,theREal-timePlottingofCETaceans,acollaborativecomputersys-tembasedonthedensityofthenavigationnetwork.
Onboardeachequippedvessel,crewmemberscaninstantlytransmitpositionsofdetectedwhalestoothershipsusinganinputinterface.Amappinginterfacedisplaysthealertssentbyothercontributors.Foreachalert,thesystemcalculatesandbroadcastsadynamicriskarea.Insidetheseareascrewmem-berscanenhancetheirwatchfulness,addsomeobserversandreducethespeed.Thisallowsthemtodetectwhalesoveralon-gerdistance,togiveenoughtimetoevaluatethesituationandoperatethebestavoidanceprocedure.Thesystemisdesignedtointegratedistributionpredictionmodels,andtoenableanytypeofsensor,infuture,toautomaticallydetecttheanimals.ThankstotheobservationsprovidedbyREPCET-equippedvessels,wewilllearnmuchaboutcetaceanpresenceanddistribution.AsimulationoftheREPCETsystemisavailableatwww.repcet.com/simulateur_en.
AcollaborationbetweenthePelagosSanctuaryforMediterraneanMarineMammalsintheACCOBAMSareaandtheSPAW-RACandAgoaSanctuaryintheCaribbeanishopedforinthenearfuture,inordertobenefitfrommutualexperiencesregardingknowledgeoftheshipstrikeissueandthemeasurestolimitit.
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
90
SID
E E
VE
NT
S
A humpback whale dives deep off California, a spectacle for whale watchers in the Gulf of the Farallones National Marine Sanctuary.Photo by Tom Kieckhefer.
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
91
Side Event 2: International Whaling Commission (IWC) Five-Year Strategic Plan for Whale Watching
Presented by Lorenzo Rojas Bracho (MexicanCommissionertotheIWC), Chris Schweizer (AustralianAlternateCommissionertotheIWC),and Ryan Wulff (UnitedStatesAlternateCommissionertotheIWCandChairoftheIWC’sStandingWorkingGrouponWhaleWatching)
TheInternationalWhalingCommission’sFive Year Strategic Plan for Whalewatchingaimstosettheagendaforthedevelopmentofaprosperousandresponsiblewhalewatchingsector,consistentwithinternationalbestpractice.
Asinterestinwhalewatchinggrows,itisvitallyimportantthatbestpracticemanagementisadoptedandpromotedacrosstheworld.Aresponsiblewhalewatchingindustryofferstheopportunityforcoun-triestoshowcasetheirnation’smarinebiodiversityandecosystems,andhenceaidintheconservationofcetaceans.
Recognizingtherecentandpotentialgrowthinwhalewatching,theIWChasdevelopedandendorsedthisFive-Year Strategic Plan for Whalewatching.Whenundertakeninasustainableway,whalewatchingisabletodeliversignificantbenefitstocoastalcommuni-tiesacrosstheglobe.
Thestrategicplansetsoutfiveobjectives–research;assessmentandmonitoring;capacitybuilding;development;andmanagement.Theactionsassociatedwitheachobjectivewillassistcountriesinterestedinbuildingsustainablewhalewatchingindustriesandensuringtheongoingdeliveryofeconomic,environmentalandsocialbenefits.
Asoneofthekeyproponentsofthestrategicplan,Australiahascom-mitteditselftohelpingothercountriesbuildtheirwhalewatchingsectorandconstantlylookstoimproveitsownwhalewatchingpro-grams.Tothisend,areviewiscurrentlyunderwayofitsNational Guidelines for Whale and Dolphin Watching to ensureAustralia’sapproachref lectsthebestscience;incorporatescommunityandindustryneeds;andpromotesinternationalbestpracticewhiledeliveringeconomicsocialandenvironmentalbenefitstonumerousAustraliancommunities.
FormoreinformationabouttheStrategicPlanortoobtainacopy,pleasevisitiwcoffice.org/_documents/sci_com/IWCStratPlanWW.pdf
92
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
The Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary has resident populations of several marine mammal species, including the endangered West Indian manatee. Photo by Laurel Canty-Ehrlich, Office of National Marine Sanctuaries, NOAA
Hawaiian monk seal, Laysan Island, Hawaii. Photo by James P. McVey, NOAA Sea Grant Program.
93
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
Martinique Declaration DeclarationofIntentbytheFollowingPartnersonCooperationbetweenExistingandProjectedMarineMammalSanctuariesintheCaribbeanRegion:TheAgoaSanctuary,StellwagenBankNationalMarineSanctuary,theDutchCaribbeanproject,theMarineMammalSanctuaryoftheDominicanRepublicandtheRegionalActivityCenterfortheSPAWProtocol(thepres-entpartners)
Notingthatmarinemammalconservationissuesarefunda-mentaltomarineissueswithinandbeyondrespectivenationaljurisdictions,
TakingadvantageofthefruitfulexchangesofICMMPA2andthankingtheorganizersforthesuccessofthisnewsteptowardsmarineconservation,
Considering theregionalframeworkprovidedbytheActionPlanfortheConservationofMarineMammalsintheWiderCaribbeanRegionundertheSPAWProtocol,andtheopportu-nitiesitoffers,
CongratulatingthecurrentnationaleffortsintheCaribbeanregionintermsofmarinemammalconservationandmarinemammalsanctuarycreation,aswellas
NotingandencouragingthemobilizationofdifferentCaribbeancountriesandterritories,
AwareofthespecialimportanceoftheCaribbeanregionwhichrepresentsauniquesituationbringingtogetherfourlanguagespeakingcountriesandterritoriesandemphasizingtheneedforcross-cuttingandtransboundaryapproachesinarichmulti-culturalandpoliticallydiversecontext,
HighlightingthatCaribbeancountriesandterritoriessharenotonlythesameissuesbutalsothesameresponsibilityofhostingsharedmarinemammalpopulationsintheirrespectivewaters,
Takingintoaccounttheneedtosupportnationalinitiativesandstrengtheningregionalcooperationfortheconservationofglob-allydistributedspecies,
Underlining theinterestofcapitalizingexistingpartnershipsbetweensanctuaries,
Willingtodevelopsynergies,
ThepresentGovernment representatives,AgenciesandInstitutionsexpresstheirstrongwillingnesstobuildadeeperCaribbeancooperationonmarinemammalissuesanddeclaretheirdeterminationto:
• PromotetheestablishmentofmarinemammalprotectedareasandotherappropriatetoolsintheWiderCaribbeanRegion.
• Developcommoninitiativesandprogramsrelatedtothedevelopmentandmanagementofmarinemammalsanctuaries,includingbutnotrestrictedtomonitoring,awarenessraising,capacitybuildingandcommunicationandon-the-groundmanagement.
• Seekappropriatesourcesoffundingfortheirimplementation.
• Supportstandardizationofregionaldatacollectionefforts.• Shareinformationonmarinemammalpopulations,
managementexperiencesandpractices,
• SharetechnicalexperiencesthroughSanctuarystaffexchanges.
• Helpeachotherstrengthentheeffectivenessoftheirmanagementframeworksandtheirimplementation.
• Pursueregulardiscussionswithoneanother,includingifpossibleorganizationofmeetingsintheirrespectiveterritoriesorcountries.
• PromotethespecialimportanceoftheCaribbeanSeaatinternationalmeetings.
94
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
Participants of the ICMMPA2 Conference included 150 people from 42 countries.Photo by Agence Kréöl
95
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
Directory of ICMMPA 2 ParticipantsArgentina Failla, Mauricio Fundación Cethus Argentina mauricio .failla@cethus .org; mauriciofailla@gmail .com
Australia Bossley, Mike Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society
mike .bossley@wdcs .org
Jacobson, Artie Dept of Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population & Communities
artie .jacobson@environment .gov .au
Schweizer, Chris Dept of Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population & Communities
christine .schweizer@environment .gov .au
Bahamas Patterson, Olivia Friends of the Environment olivia@friendsoftheenvironment .org
Bangladesh Smith, Brian See United States listing
Bolivia Aramayo Mariscal, Patricia Rosario
AKAPACHA xnocallar@gmail .com
Bonaire (Caribbean Netherlands)
Hoetjes, Paul Ministry of EL&I, National Office Caribbean Netherlands
paul .hoetjes@rijkdsdienstcn .com
Brazil Gerling de Oliveira, Cynthia Rua de São Miguel 318 mt-morumbi@uol .com .br
Marmontel, Miriam Instituto de Desenvolvimento Sustentável Mamirauá
marmontel@mamiraua .org .br
Martins da Silva, Jr., José Instituto Chico Mendes de Conservação da Biodiversidade, Centro Mamíferos Aquáticos
josemartinscma@gmail .com
Truda Palazzo, Jr., José Truda Palazzo & Associates palazzo@terra .com .br
Canada Gomez-Salazar, Catalina Dalhousie University (Canada) and Fundación Omacha (Colombia)
gomezcatalina@gmail .com
Lee, Jihyun Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity, UNEP
jihyun .lee@cbd .int
Reeves, Randall Okapi Wildlife Associates rrreeves@okapis .ca
Turgeon, Samuel Université de Montréal sturgeon09@gmail .com
China Oviedo Correa, Lenin E. The Swire Institute of Marine Science, Cetacean Ecology Lab
lavinovia@gmail .com
Colombia Botero, Julián Eastern Pacific Marine Corridor jubotero@gmail .com
Gomez-Salazar, Catalina See Canada listing
Portocarrero Aya, Marcela See United Kingdom listing
Trujillo, Fernando Fundación Omacha fernando@omacha .org
Costa Rica Jimenez, Jorge MarViva jorge .jimenez@marviva .net
Oviedo Correa, Lenin E. See China Listing
Croatia Strbenac, Ana ACCOBAMS ana .strbenac@gmail .com
Curaçao (Caribbean Netherlands)
Moriniere, Véronique RAC / REMPEITC - Caribe vmoriniere@cep .unep .org
Dominican Republic
Lancho, Patricia FUNDEMAR patlancho@yahoo .com
Vásquez, Oswaldo ATEMAR atemar@gmail .com
Ecuador Felix, Fernando Permanent Commission for the South Pacific (CPPS), Southeast Pacific Action Plan
ffelix@cpps-int .org
96
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
France Bré, Hervé EnezGreen hb@enezgreen .com
Brichet, Marion French Marine Protected Areas Agency marion .brichet@aires-marines .fr
Culioli, Jean-Michel Office de l’Environnement de la Corse culioli@oec .fr
Denis, Jacques IFREMER Unité de Recherche Antilles jacques .denis@ifremer .fr
Falco, Albert falconaute@cegetel .net
Gauthiez, François French Marine Protected Areas Agency
francois .gauthiez@aires-marines .fr
Hassani, Sami OCEANOPOLIS - Marine Mammals sami .hassani@oceanopolis .com
Houard, Thierry Parc Nationale de Port-Cros, Le Castel Ste Claire
rose-abele .viviani@portcros-parcnational .fr
Labach, Hélène E-mail not available
Laran, Sophie University of La Rochelle, Centre de Recherche sur les Mammifères Marins
sophie .laran@univ-lr .fr
Lefèbvre, Christophe French Marine Protected Areas Agency
christophe .lefebvre@aires-marines .fr
Lefeuvre, Cécile French Marine Protected Areas Agency, Iroise Marine Nature Park
cecile .lefeuvre@aires-marines .fr
Mayol, Pascal Souffleurs d’Ecume pmayol@souffleursdecume .com
Mourand, Laetitia laetitia .mourand@gmail .com
Ody, Denis WWF France dody@wwf .fr
Poisson, François IFREMER, French Research Institute for Exploration of the Sea
francois .poisson@ifremer .fr
Ridoux, Vincent University of La Rochelle, Centre de Recherche sur les Mammifères Marins
vincent .ridoux@univ-lr .fr
Robert, Philippe French Marine Protected Areas Agency
philippe .robert@aires-marines .fr
Santoni, Marie-Catherine Office de l’Environnement de la Corse santoni@oec .fr
Scuiller, Laëtitia EnezGreen laetitiascuiller@enezgreen .com
Sevin, Marie-Aude French Marine Protected Areas Agency
marie-aude .sevin@aires-marines .fr
Sterckeman, Aurore French Marine Protected Areas Agency
aurore .sterckeman@aires-marines .fr
Tasciotti, Aurelie WWF France atasciotti@wwf .fr
Van Canneyt, Olivier University of La Rochelle, Centre de Recherche sur les Mammifères Marins
olivier .van-canneyt@univ-lr .fr
Watremez, Pierre French Marine Protected Areas Agency
pierre .watremez@aires-marines .fr
Webster, Chloë MedPAN Science chloe .webster@medpan .org
French Guiana (France)
Dos Reis , Virginie Association KWATA, Guyane Francaise virginie@kwata .net
Duffaud, Marc-Henri DEAL Guyane marc-henri .duffaud@developpement-durable .gouv .fr
Martinez, Carole French Marine Protected Areas Agency
carole .martinez@aires-marines .fr
Louis, Max Université des Antilles et de la Guyane, Sciences Exactes et Naturelles
max .louis@univ-ag .fr
Germany Kaschner, Kristin Albert-Ludwigs-University of Freiburg kristin .kaschner@biologie .uni-freiburg .de
Greece Paravas, Vangelis MOm/Hellenic Society for the Study and Protection of the Monk Seal
v .paravas@mom .gr
Tryfon, Eleni Ministry for the Environment, Energy & Climate Change — Nature Management Section
eltryfon@otenet .gr
97
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
Guadeloupe (France)
Gainette, Anaïs Parc National de la Guadeloupe anais .gainette@guadeloupe-parcnational .fr
Gandilhon, Nadege University of Guadeloupe, Marine Biology
nadege .gandilhon@univ-ag .fr
Girou, Denis Guadeloupe National Park denis .girou@aires-marines .fr
Hubert, Gaël CAR-SPAW gael .hubert .carspaw@guadeloupe-parcnational .fr
Lerebours, Boris Parc National de la Guadeloupe boris .lerebours@guadeloupe-parcnational .fr
Magnin, Hervé Parc National de la Guadeloupe herve .magnin@guadeloupe-parcnational .fr
Rinaldi, Caroline CARIBWHALE Inc . caribwhale@gmail .com
Souan, Hélène CAR-SPAW Parc National de la Guadeloupe
helene .souan .carspaw@guadeloupe-parcnational .fr
Vandersarren, Gaëlle CAR-SPAW Parc National de la Guadeloupe
gaelle .vandersarren .carspaw@guadeloupe-parcna-tional .fr
India Sinha, Ravindra Central University of Bihar rksinha .pu@gmail .com; rksinha@cub .ac .in
Italy Notarbartolo di Sciara, Giuseppe
Tethys Research Institute giuseppe@disciara .net
Sturlese, Albert San Remo Cetacei Whale Watch sturlesealbert@yahoo .it
Jamaica Vanzella-Khouri, Alessandra
United Nations Environment Programme, Caribbean Environment Programme
avk@cep .unep .org
Korea, Republic of
An, Yong-Rock National Fisheries Research & Development Institute, Cetacean Research Institute
rock@nfrdi .go .kr
Sohn, Hawsun National Fisheries Research & Development Institute, Cetacean Research Institute
sealover@nfrdi .go .kr
Madeira (Portugal) Cordeiro Pires, Rosa Maria Servico do Parque Natural da Madeira rosapires .sra@gov-madeira .pt
Martinique (France)
Ademar, René Comité Régional des Pêches E-mail not available
Augier, Dominique Association Geoceanide, Mansarde Catalogne Bois Neuf
doaugier@gmail .com
Bertome, Marie-France DEAL Martinique Marie-France .bertome@developpement-durable .gouv .fr
Boulard, Nicolas Conservatoire du littoral – Antenne de Martinique
n .boulard@conservatoire-du-littoral .fr
Brador, Aude SEPANMAR E-mail not available
Britmmer, Ronald Parc Naturel Régional de la Martinique, Maison du Parc
jcnicolas972@yahoo .fr
Debise, David Planète Dauphins david .debise1975@hotmail .fr
Delarancie, Dominique Dauphins Martinique domc@orange .fr
Jeremie, Stéphane SEPANMAR st_jeremie@hotmail .com
Lehmann, Laurent Planète Dauphins nkd .lehmann@wanadoo .fr
Metery, Michel Martinique Vidéo Sub michel .metery@wanadoo .fr
Neree, Nathalie DEAL Martinique nathalie .neree@developpement-durable .gouv .fr
Nicolas, Jean-Claude Parc Naturel Régional de la Martinique, Maison du Parc
jcnicolas972@yahoo .fr
Renaux, Jean-François Société O Fil de l’O o .fildelo@wanadoo .fr
Reynal, Lionel IFREMER lionel .reynal@ifremer .fr
Sutty, Lesley East Caribbean Coalition for Environmental Awareness — ECCEA
l .sutty@orange .fr
Vernier, Jean-Louis DEAL Martinique E-mail not available
98
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
Mayotte (France) Gigou, Alexandra French Marine Protected Areas Agency, Mayotte Marine Nature Park
alexandra .gigou@aires-marines .fr
México Gutierrez Carbonell, David CONANP/SEMARNAT daguti@conanp .gob .mx
Morales-Vela, José El Colegio de la Frontera Sur bmorales@ecosur .mx
Pompa, Sandra Universidad Nacional Autonoma de México - Instituto de Ecología
sandra_pompa@ecologia .unam .mx
Ramírez, Oscar Comisión Nacional de Áreas Naturales Protegidas
oramirez@conanp .gob .mx
Rojas-Bracho, Lorenzo Instituto Nacional de Ecología lrojas@gmail .com; lrojas@cicese .mx
Urbán Ramirez, Jorge Universidad Autónoma de Baja California Sur, Programa de Investigación de Mamíferos Marinos
jurban@uabcs .mx
Monaco Grillo-Compulsione, Marie-Christine
ACCOBAMS mcgrillo@accobams .net
Netherlands Hart, Lenie ‘t SRRC leniethart@planet .nl
New Caledonia (France)
Gardes, Lionel French Marine Protected Areas Agency, New Caledonia Office
lionel .gardes@aires-marines .fr
Palau Holm, Tiare Sustainable Decisions tiareholm@yahoo .com
Saint-Martin (France)
Renoux, Romain Réserve Naturelle de Saint-Martin reservenaturelle@domaccess .com
Spain Fernandez de Larrinoa, Pablo
Fundación CBD-Habitat pablo .fernandezdelarrinoa@cbd-habitat .com
Mohamed, Hamady Ould Fundación CBD-Habitat hamadymoh@yahoo .es
Sagarminaga, Ricardo ALNITAK ricardo@alnitak .info
St-Barthélèmy (France)
Maslach, Nicolas French Marine Protected Areas Agency, West Indies Office
nicolas .maslach@aires-marines .fr
Suriname Landburg, Chantal Green Heritage Fund Suriname landburgc@seasnv .biz
Pool, Monique Green Heritage Fund Suriname poolms@seasnv .biz
Sweden Geijer, Christina See United Kingdom listing
Switzerland Bernal, Patricio GOBI - IUCN Global Marine and Polar Programme
patricio .bernal@iucn .org
Turkey Kıraç, Cem Orkun SAD-AFAG, Underwater Research Society – Mediterranean Seal Research Group
sad@sad .org .tr
Ukraine Birkun, Alexei ACCOBAMS alexeibirkun@gmail .com
United Kingdom Anderson, Heather Mary Sea Mammal Research Unit, St . Andrews University
ha237@st-andrews .ac .uk
Donovan, Greg International Whaling Commission greg .donovan@iwcoffice .org
Geijer, Christina University College London, Geography c .geijer@ucl .ac .uk
Hoyt, Erich Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society
erich .hoyt@me .com
Laffoley, Dan IUCN World Commission on Protected Areas
danlaffoley@btinternet .com
Portocarrero Aya, Marcela Hull University (UK) and Fundación Omacha (Colombia)
marzop@gmail .com
Williams, Rob University of St . Andrews rmcw@st-andrews .ac .uk
99
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedingsICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
United States Abramson, Leslie NOAA ONMS Gulf of the Farallones NMS
leslie .abramson@noaa .gov
Agardy, Tundi Sound Seas tundiagardy@earthlink .net
Alexander, Louise North Carolina State University louise_alexander@ncsu .edu
Barr, Brad NOAA Office of National Marine Sanctuaries
brad .barr@noaa .gov
Carlson, Carole Dolphin Fleet/Provincetown Center for Coastal Studies
carolecarlson123@gmail .com
Choy, Lee-Ann Pacific Rim Concepts LLC prc@hawaiibiz .rr .com
Daves, Nancy NOAA National Marine Fisheries Service
nancy .daves@noaa .gov
Gende, Scott National Park Service scott_gende@nps .gov
Heinemann, Dennis US Marine Mammal Commission dheinemann@mmc .gov
Littnan Jr., Charles NOAA NMFS Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center
charles .littnan@noaa .gov
Mattila, David NOAA ONMS Hawaiian Islands Humpback Whale NMS
david .mattila@noaa .gov
MacDonald, Craig NOAA ONMS Stellwagen Bank NMS craig .macdonald@noaa .gov
McIntosh, Naomi NOAA ONMS Pacific Islands Region naomi .mcIntosh@noaa .gov
Mesnick, Sarah NOAA ONMS Hawaiian Islands Humpback Whale NMS
sarah .mesnick@noaa .gov
Nelson, Anne Collaborative Ocean Solutions collaborativeoceansolutions@gmail .com
Redfern, Jessica NOAA NMFS Southwest Fisheries Science Center
jessica .redfern@noaa .gov
Reynolds, John Mote Marine Laboratory reynolds@mote .org
Rowles, Teresa NOAA NMFS Office of Protected Resources
teri .rowles@noaa .gov
Smith, Brian Wildlife Conservation Society bsmith@wcs .org
Spalding, Mark Joseph The Ocean Foundation mspalding@oceanfdn .org
Taylor, Jaclyn NOAA NMFS Office of Protected Resources
jaclyn .taylor@noaa .gov
Thiele, Monika United Nations Environmental Program – Convention on Migratory Species
monika .thiele@unep .org
Tucker, Steven United States Coast Guard, Living Marine Resources Enforcement
steven .m .tucker@uscg .mil
Ward, Nathalie NOAA ONMS Stellwagen Bank NMS nathalie .ward@noaa .gov
Wulff, Ryan NOAA NMFS Office of International Affairs
ryan .wulff@noaa .gov
Young, Nina NOAA NMFS Office of International Affairs
nina .young@noaa .gov
Ziccardi, Mike Oiled Wildlife Care Network, Wildlife Health Center
mhziccardi@ucdavis .edu
100
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
Southern sea otter, at South Harbor, Moss Landing, California. World Ocean Day Photo Contest Submission by Steve Lonhart
Killer whale in Kamchatka, Russia Tatiana Ivkovich, Far East Russia Orca Project, WDCS
101
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
Steering and Program Committee, International Committee on Marine Mammal Protected Areas – ICMMPA 2Tundi Agardy(USA),ExecutiveDirector,SoundSeas;ScienceandPolicyDirectorforWorldOceanObservatory;authorOcean Zoning: Making Marine Management More Effective
Brad Barr(USA),SeniorPolicyAdvisor,NOAA-ONMS
Arne Bjørge(Norway),SeniorScientist,InstituteofMarineResearch,UniversityofOslo;IWCScientificCommittee
Douglas DeMaster(USA),DirectorofNOAA/AFSC,USDeputyCommissionertotheIWC
Mike Donoghue(Samoa/NewZealand),ExecutiveDirector,PacificIslandsProgram,Asia-PacificFieldDivision,ConservationInternational
Scott Gende(USA),CoastalEcologist,NationalParkService,GlacierBayNationalPark,Alaska
Erich Hoyt(Scotland,UK),Head,GlobalMPAProgramme,WhaleandDolphinConservationSociety;Author,Marine Protected Areas for Whales, Dolphins and Porpoises;IUCNWCPAandSSCCetaceanSpecialistGroup
Miguel Iñíguez(Argentina),FundaciónCethus;WhaleandDolphinConservationSociety;HeadofDelegationtoIWCScientificCommittee;AlternateCommissionertoIWCfromArgentina
Michiko Martin(USA),NationalEducationCoordinator,NOAA-NMSP
David Mattila(USA),NOAA-ONMS-HawaiianIslandsHumpbackWhaleNationalMarineSanctuary,TechnicalAdvisor–entangle-mentandshipstrikes–totheSecretariatoftheIWC
Naomi McIntosh(USA),NOAA-ONMS,PacificRegion;chair,ICMMPA
Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara (Italy),President,TethysResearchInstitute;DeputyChair,IUCN/SSCCetaceanSpecialistGroup;IUCNWCPA-MarineRegionalCoordinatorfortheMediterraneanandBlackSeas
José Truda Palazzo, Jr.(Brazil),CCC–CetaceanConservationCenter,Chile
Oscar Ramírez Flores(México),ComisiónNacionaldeÁreasNaturalesProtegidas(CONANP)
Vincent Ridoux(France),CentredeRecherchesurlesMammifèresMarins,UniversitédeLaRochelle-CNRS;HeadofDelegationtoIWCScientificCommittee
Philippe Robert(France),Agencedesairesmarinesprotégées(FrenchMPAAgency),InternationalRelations
Lorenzo Rojas Bracho(México),InstitutoNacionaldeEcología;HeadofDelegationtoIWCScientificCommittee
102
SecondInternationalConferenceonMarineMammalProtectedAreas
Minke whales in proposed Ross Sea Region Marine Reserve Photo by David Ainley
103
ICMMPA ConferenceProceedings
Organization and contacts
Agence des aires marines protégées 16 Quai de la Douane BP 42932 29229 BREST Cedex 2 France www.aires-marines.fr
NOAA Office of National Marine Sanctuaries Pacific Islands RegionNaomi McIntosh6600 Kalanianaole Highway, Suite 302Honolulu, Hawaii 96825 USAsanctuaries.noaa.gov
icmmpa.org
ISBN:978-0-9853252-0-6
PROCEEDINGS OF THESECOND INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON MARINE MAMMAL PROTECTED AREASICMMPA 2Endangered Spaces, Endangered Species
November 8 – 11, 2011Fort-de-France, Martiniqueicmmpa.org