production costs: evidence from colombia

19
PRODUCTION COSTS: EVIDENCE FROM COLOMBIA Mark Lundy

Upload: ciat

Post on 14-Aug-2015

194 views

Category:

Science


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

PRODUCTION COSTS: EVIDENCE FROM COLOMBIA

Mark Lundy

Page 2: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

Cost of Production is a function of:

Adapted icons from the Noun Project

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Of these factors, farmers have different levels of control G = decision made irregularly / once every 10-15 years E = Not manageable by farmers (mostly), specifically small farmers M = Direct farmer decision-making and control However crop Management is influenced by two other factors that need to be taken into account, namely: Importance of coffee in farmer livelihood strategies Market channels Basically producers 'place a bet' on coffee which combines the above factors and directly influences the cost of production, yields, quality, etc. 
Page 3: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

Cost of Production is a function of:

Adapted icons from the Noun Project

Presenter
Presentation Notes
However crop Management is influenced by two other factors that need to be taken into account, namely: Importance of coffee in farmer livelihood strategies Market channels Basically producers 'place a bet' on coffee which combines the above factors and directly influences the cost of production, yields, quality, etc. 
Page 4: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

NARIÑO, COLOMBIA AN ILLUSTRATIVE CASE

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Context: 35,000 small producers, average of less than 2 Ha farm size Low levels of traditional Producer Organizations (outside of FNC structures) Strong market concentration (Nespresso and Starbucks by 94% of all coffee in Nariño) Highest coffee prices in Colombia Methods / data 1,200 Household surveys (2012) Focus group discussions with different typologies Sales prices from official FNC prices and microlots 
Page 5: Production costs: evidence from Colombia
Page 6: Production costs: evidence from Colombia
Page 7: Production costs: evidence from Colombia
Page 8: Production costs: evidence from Colombia
Page 9: Production costs: evidence from Colombia
Page 10: Production costs: evidence from Colombia
Page 12: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

Adapted icons from the Noun Project

Page 13: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

Adapted icons from the Noun Project

Page 14: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

Adapted icons from the Noun Project

Page 15: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

Adapted icons from the Noun Project

Page 16: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

Adapted icons from the Noun Project

Adapted icons from the Noun Project

Page 17: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

We aren't talking about "producer cost" but rather "producers costs" • 3 types of farmers = 3 production costs

• Production costs vary spatially especially over diverse landscapes such as those found in the coffeelands

• Be wary of "average costs" which hide variation.

Page 18: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

Profitability depends on farmer typology AND market access

• Farmers who specialize and invest in coffee can be profitable in more market channels

• Lower income or less specialized farmers tend to invest less, achieve lower yields and have higher unit costs

• In many case non-specialization in coffee makes sense under market, climatic and price uncertainty

Page 19: Production costs: evidence from Colombia

1. Farmers are diverse and production costs vary. There is no ONE production cost. You need to understand who your producers are.

2. Production costs (and yields) are sticky. One off price increases might not lead to increased on-farm investment; rather market linkages that provide consistent incentives (price and support) are needed to achieve significant gains.

3. If you want famers to receive more income, you need to have a

clear idea of how your supply chain works and where additional payments will arrive if they are made. The ability of the chain to deliver coffee is NOT a good proxy for how information and cash flow.