Developments of Tools Focused on Production Simulation to Improve

Productivity in Shipyards Workshops

!"#$

$%%&

"$'&

()

*+,&

*-+$

#*."

/0/1

Acknowledgments ! " " #$%

!&!'

("&)*+

,!)-.&

,&

!!'

(!'

& +/-*/.

+#0-1

2'

3

&4!25667

Abstract

!"

# $

$ %

& '

"&

"#()

"

"'

*()

+

%

"

%

Rsum ,'-..&

* .

*!/ !"

,.$#.#.$

/ .- ,

.$+

$ ( . .

. - / ,' . .0

0 1 & & -/ &

,.......&..

.&

( . .+ #() .. ..

,&

..+

*2.'

+. ( . . ..

. & #() ..

..&

- .

. - .

( .. &

, ..3/

& 4

.&

( .. ...

-.

Table of Contents

! "#

! "

#$%

$ %# &'(#) !!

&

& '!()* &

& &

&& ! +

&+ ,-*!!( +

!"# $

! $!

! *+#%%(,- $$

&&

!*! &+

++

& ! .

+ !//0, 1

%(! .

!! ./#+ 0

.1

%!!-*! 12

!$ !

$ %&''%%()

"# *+

$ %12#,& 3

& "+

& 3* # "

& #( "1

&& 4/5 ""

&+ 6 ""

$ 44

& 22

& !! 2

& !

2

$! #%%(,- 0

& ,#( .

& %/5

& '

+ %) *

3

3 5# !

+

+

+ (!! &

+& %!! +&

3! 30

, +*

6 5 3

6 2 3

6! 64

6$ % 6

-. ,

')(/ ,+

& 01

Chapter 1 Introduction

1.1 Context situation - - !# !

! ! !## ! % * ' 7!8

((9:*!*#

*#;8

((!(!8#(

#!!(!

5

$!*!!

! @!# *! !(

@ # !

?

!#

4#!

=(

! # !(

#

#((*!?

6

! !

4A*6 %

/ # 8

!(*!8

- !@((#

#@!!!(0!

!*!

( ( !( ## 8 *

A!

5

/5

! *!!!

!#(!#*!

'!+(!(!>!

!D!(

!(

! ! '=( ! !

!( *! B

( ! ! ( #

!(

# # ! % # !( # !D

E # !

! # #(

!(!!!!

*! # !(!#(

((!#(

4!#

!

Chapter 2 State-of-Art and Overview of the Industrial

Environment

2.1 Introduction

0( ! # >

B!(!B#

##'!!

!

7 5!

%#=4I:)J;(!#

(#!

E8 ! (

!@8((!@!

!8(

@ ! ( ! 8 #

!!@ # #

(

! !!

(,(#(#8

!*8#8#((8#(8

8

8 #(

8 ( ! 8 #8

8!@!#(

0@!8!((#(!

8*!((F8

!(

! =8 8 !(8 ! =!8

! !( 8 #

(!!!(

((!*#

#(K5 8"""L

( 0 @!8

#>

,#(?

/(>

E'?

,(?

35?

!(?

'(?

$5*8 4#

5(?

4!

##?

0

!

#?

'!(!?

## B@B

!!>

(+(

( 2,

7 53

(!#.)2#*7+8

($#,,)##)

(3+

65*8 4#

))

(8 ( ! (

(%(#!#

#!

!##%@!

! ( # 8 ! !8

*!(#(!#=(

%((#

#(#

(K$8".1L#(8(

(((!

!!(

( (8 @!8 #

( () !

E8!!(8

! (! !

(*#!((8*(8

(@!0(#

*8 # !( (

(*#(88#

(*#!(

! )

(

7 50

$ 5&

3 # !

(#

4 > 8 (

( # ?

8 (#(0

*#((8

(( # !8

8!

9:>(

8!!(

#=

>

% #

(

# @!> (

@(?!0

#8 %

( (

!@:;

,>*!8

!( # ! ! !

*GH

8 # %### 6 /

:%6/;8

: ;8 E# 6 % :E6%;

##%:3%;

3 ##)#

!!73"&2

#!!8##8

#(

*,'(#

! @(8

5*8 4#

(M3(

#

(@!!(

'! : ;!"+2

! ## ! $ ( 9

$

$/#:$/;(#!

$

'!5K5 8"""L

6 -#)9

-((((

( # (

# ( : ( =;

#>

;(!@(#!?

;(#!?

;?

&;!8 !

#B((B

@=#((#

G# *H

!!!

%!!=

! (-

!!8

(!!((%!

* ( # ( !! #

0 @!8## ( (

!

(!

(

8;7&

7 5

0

!!###>

- ( ( ! ( !

#>!8!8

-(8

#!K/#""+L>

3!8!#!

88 8#

45*8 4#

5

- # #

*#>

(@!(

! :# =8 !(

# (8 ; ( # @

!B(!8(

(( % =8 (

! ! (

:( ( !;8 (

(!?

, # = ! #

# @! 08 ( *

8 ((8 #(*( (

(

(!(

( !!5 ( @( !@

!

###

8

(

! ( !

K5 8"""L?

%((

= !

! #

7 5

(!B8B

?

( !8

! !( #

=#

8#8#>

,*(!#!*#

(!!##

GHG!H?

,( !! ! ! ( !

!*#!#(#(?

! ( ((8

!!#

(!*#0@!8

( ( #

#**8(8#?

' ( !@ (

!

:

! !(

E@!#>

#>

()@!?

(

#>

8?

(?

5*8 4#

(!

?

!@#!?

(#=!?

(#?

*?

E8(!E

*

! G- !! FH *

##(!(

# ! % ! !

*(

##*(!!(

( # !@(

(#(!=(

! @( =( #

(# #

(

( !(

# ! #( ! 0 #

(!(!!

!##*#

#((

!

! ( #

-(

* #

((

, #

7 5!

N(#=(!8

!8*8#

(#(

#!

2.2.2 Object oriented software :; K4

8 ""L = !(

(=##(0@!8

'OO P ! :/; ## # #

(###(

=*

%

$5*8 4#

(6;#.,

88

,

# 8 @!8 ( ! (! #

!!08(!(!##*

!8(#(8(!

#(8! (!#8(##

8@##(!#

A#

C ## #8 (

##!##(#(

7 53

- # ( ##

((!((

(-88(

8 ! 8

!#

!!

#(8

65*8 4#

# 8 ! (

#

(

(

,*#!

##

2/

!

!!>

/@#!

7 50

( ! @ !(

(-!8

@@!

!( !

!!

!

(051

0#.@,0%#

! @

* ! *!

@!#@

( ( ( ! !

$(!

!(

@!0#.8

@(0#1(!

B@!B8!

@!

5*8 4#

(:=

> (!:88'8;?

> @?

> ,###?

> 5###

-*@8

@:(;8

@ B 0# " !! (

#!

(:

>5

3!#

! ( !(

!!0#",

!#

2.3 Genetic algorithms

2.3.1 Description

'!!96BCB:8D96BBC:8

!45*8 4#

!(8!!

!( # #

!(!

( 8 ( #

! # %

#8 ! ( !

#(!

! +

(!>=

##08#=

##

(+&

%!@#(#

!*

(#,

! ##@#!(#

!(@##(#@#

>5!

!

.

'( !8 ! !!

@#((#

!#!@#

(!

,

N# ! #

!( #

# ! ! ##

-(!!

!(!

- ' :R; ! ! :# ;

/( , ' :/,R;

! 8(R8#!

*! #/,R! ! !

!! %

-!> 5

08!(

#

:;0#

!#@#4

!

0 8 %

*

!

!$ .

!(@#-

!

!5*8 4#

(

:;?

N!:&;?

N ! !(

!!!=(:/;?

* # #

:5;

!3 (

% # # 8

!#@#

!!(

>###

' > ! 8

#!?

(!>!

#5!!

%!!

!!!

! !

( % !( !!

#(-#

#( !! =

! # #

(

2.4 Presentation of the Aker Yards France shipyard

2.4.1 Introduction

# ! G, * &H * (

8#(G

!$5*8 4#

!

#5!3

%

*&+2#"2?

#

*&22#?

52222((

2.4.4 The production

%*C0!

/# ! :8 !@ !!@;

228%*C0'EB

G$ ! 4/'

!65*8 4#

(4

,)>

,*!!(#>

,#!:N0N;?

,#!:N/';?

,#!!:N/;?

0!:/5;?

-*!##?

-*!//0:##;?

/6:#;?

2-*!:#

#5!0

8#8# ! :*#; !

##

(+#

$3! +##7?%8

*!8 # * > # (#

!

*!> ! :*#; /

#:;

!5*8 4#

(+##

$3$ +#7?%8

*!8#*>

/####?

-###

(!+#

$33 (,7%28

*!8#*>#:;

# # # # #

!#(###

#5!

($(,

$36 -

*! # > 8

:222;8!#

(3-

$30 -%%(,

*!*!>GH//0

:#( ; GH//0*!

GH//0*!

*!

*

B'!,#!

$45*8 4#

(6-%%(,

$3 %:7%(,8

*!:;

#*>#!#

#####

> # !# # #

##

(0%:

$3 4-%+8

*! # *

* *!

1:;8#:;

*!'!+

!!

!

#5$

(4-

$34 4-%+8

*!2-*!

$5*8 4#

(4 %+

Chapter 3 Development of a Virtual Workshop

3.1 Introduction

* !

!!!@#(

(!!

- !!( !*! 3

//0*!!>

!(*!?

!?

!!(*#! @! (

*!/!!!@!A*D

! !

$$5*A 4;H

'! & !

8 !

; !

8 8+ !

*!0(((#!!

% !! * !

*!!%//0-*!

( '! !

/*!!

B0#03

$65*A 4;H

()

,

Very small assemblies

Formed assembly

Insert

(@,

,

;!((#

*#(>

N/> G=. . .+H # G! H

!#N/:V;N/?

N/':%4;>G=..H#GH

!#N/':VN/'%;

N/':N/'4;3N/':N/'%;

#!!?

/5>G#...H#G-

H

/#>#:$BG>KH

#G4#!H;!:/BG#&.H;3

(!*

% ! *! ((-

*! @ ! (

! ! ! ! = @

((>@

*(!(###B

! ! B ! *!

###4(

## ! % @ #

!D(!=!>*

!*!D

*!) > # : ;8*8 #

$5*A 4;H

(!*#%%(,-

*!*#:;

!B *! ! :

;#!=>*#B#B#%

*!#0#&

!! ! ! = !

(#=!

*!#!

# ! *# # !

((*

;

345*A 4;H

'##!#(!#!!

# ! +*#8 * (

; ##

! !*#!

#!

#!!

3**!#

! # *

!# * (# ## # B

(!

;-#5

(

*!

!(

8! *

( (

35*A 4;H

08=*!#!

G*!=H8G=H

*!=8##=*:

;!!*%

8@*

*

*/* (

:/,;

#=#(!=

##(#*!!/,!(

! ( ! *N(

! # #

! # ( !

-=(!(#

=8* :;

( !* # (

!( # ! ##

* ! ( 8 #(

!(@!*!(=!

( (! = # #8

!#

4(*:#*###8

##;(:9

; !! *# : !8W; ! #

!:(*;8(#((/,-

(!8##!#8!(

*

; /! :; B *# :; B-# :; B

0# :&;B'#( :+;-* *

:*#(#;#8

( # B !

@!#!>

(6

#,

= !! 4 !

* ! @(> * B # B *

#8(*##*@*D%

#(#!*#GH*

#((

##G@H**

3$5*A 4;H

# %* * G@HD

! > !

3 ! *!! * = !

(!*#*@(

* (#@*

GH*(G@H*!(*

##

!(:@;

!>

!!(:;?

!8!8

#?

!8!8

;

'% B'!% #>*

# #?

/ ,B / ,#> ! # 8

! / ! ( #

?

'%, B '! % ,#>

# B @! # 8# 8#

8?

5/ B ! 5 /#> ( # !#

#

# #( *

*=FE#

*=0*!D-*#

!!>*#8!

#8*8 !(

#'%,

( !# ( '%,

###!D

*! 8

#/##'%,

/E6BG#D,H0!##

( ( ! -

365*A 4;H

=( ! '%,

!= !

!+1

( ! *!

! = ! $ =D

N(!@(

!A(##0

* # ## *

#!D!!!#(

( *! %

E#((#!>*!

! 8 * # !

- #!

@!!

#5/

==!#!

>#

!- =( B * !

**

5/0*!8*

4 5.%/E6@(!=

! '=( ! !

+1

!@!*

((%

=

#%*C0!(

# # ,%5 , *!

(@#

*!0 //0*!

!D

,%5

L()#

;

35*A 4;H

(01A,

S#>

D!)N%4>!?

!ONM>*?

(, ( % (

( 6,X3 ( E35X 83/%38

3 8%8%& # (

?

D!)N%4>!?

!O#!>!(?

%!4> !!

(?

A> ( E

!#((-6,X3?

P>( *!(

( %& !

?

QN,O*,N,O*,>/(*#

#

(?

O=4> *# ( !#

!#(#

/E6

;)O=#(>@!?

!?)N)?> 0 * ! #

?

M%N**#

!ONM

%!##$5N/#

!=*!=#(

(#!*!

=E*!>!

!*!!*!

*(88!!(

*

!=*#!#!

@##!*#!

( = $5N/ *

#!

((!

3 !

**#B

!!(

!!! 11:+1%2,

>

!8#8#8$( /5

#6,!!B

3 8 %8 %& 3

( B @!@! #

->,NM%N?,(

! ,/

!*B9B#

645*A 4;H

4(U61=M4%

"!0

(#!

#(@!0#1

(#

!

- U6 M4%! !# ( #

!(!

!=!@!@

!!$ #':BAB;:5>

=C6X9X%46,NM%N*D%,4=

=!=#=>

1U(6##

"M4%!!

;

@6,6*

##>

65*A 4;H

(!4##':B11:+>

= @ # 6,

!!6 #':B1%2>

@/56*

##>

;

=#(*>

(!(#':BAB+1

'#!9BN

=###(#

!>

,X6#!:$8/%(;?

,X4!?

6$5*A 4;H

!*!!!#!

-#7CD3444D8

, )##

), ) - (

/ $ ?4%

;$%

,-

), *

/(# *

%A5 * 2.+

6** *& 22&

! *+ 2

#!; +2:A;E!*&*+

#0(*

!! #':BAB E:1

-9!

# !

!

! *#90

(#>

0!#(

!(?

0!!!

) (! ! =! = B

#!!8(8#8#8#8

' ! ( ! !

(?

0#(%#8#

!!@(()

*# !( (!

665*A 4;H

!8#*#(

#*#!?

0 ! !0 # !

#*#%

!!

9 ( ! %

! @# D

!@##('/N

*#

!! #

!=

8 = @ ! * @

B 0# = =8 !

*!

(!!2>

@ C6X9X%46!#

9 # ( %

#

B0#&

;

$!:#!;?

,##!##A

!#?

5#?

! 0#?

!%(!!?

4@!#?

!

65*A 4;H

,@ A',#:6808;?

%?

5#?

@!:#8,/$!

!;?

'!?

%?

!'% #?

E @ !*# > Z598 %#5*8

%(8%(6#8%8%,8%% 848'

#

:' ;8 '( 4 /8 ', "8 #( !

8 ! (8 @!08 @8 0@8 0 8 $8

$/AE8 # / ,# :/,;8 6,8 6,8

,%8 ,, !

;

,0?

5?

0?

N?

,N2?

@

!$ +(.,

045*A 4;H

(

,#

#

(

., 4#?

> 4,N?

> M#?

> 4A888?

> ,(

(*

(

;[V>[V>[V (8 8

:!A2222;#(@#(

#

1

.,88#8/8$848

0 ! **0 8 !

#

!8!(#-

!

(!

8!#*#8#8

*#:!(

;8

(

08 8

#

!!(#(#@(#

% :,N;@

! ##

05*A 4;H

(!B##!

!#

#

%

.,

##>##!

##

:,N; ! !! ##

#/

!

#-(

!8##!#,N

!(!!,N

,N!

8!

> #! !8

@!

( #!

,N - ( !

= 8

#=#!

4>4#!

,N,N

#//0*!

;

0$5*A 4;H

#

5

.,

;

*,N

#?8*@%

#

,N 8 @

#?

*

* ,N 8 *

#,N

!# !#,N @8 *@

%

#

- ( !

# #? 8

!

#=(#8

!

#2!

,N2

#

%E

.,

065*A 4;H

*

#

($#.,#?8

#8*

,N8/4!

#/

!

*,N

($!1)

%!(,N,N(

/4

;!#-#0

0 8 G/H ,N

!###B@

!#*!@!-(,N

%,N#!

(4,N#,N

(##?B0#&

05*A 4;H

($6##

%((!!

* ! ,N - (

# ( #? (

@ ,N 0

#0#&.#?

($0#)

! ! ! 8 #

B ,N B (#

# ( - #8 @!8

;

45*A 4;H

,/* ! (

!(#!(!(+H#

?

?*

!(+%#8

##884

? # =?

#(+88(=

%8 = % =

(

?=%8(!

#(+#?

#8(!

= ? *

*,/!=(+

?(=8(+#=

(8?

?!!!8

?#==!(+

(+8##@!

((+

(+

(+ @! *

! 4*

%#8##84

(+!%

%#?#(+#%%(+

!# 8 ## ?8

#%

=

H#

-*H#-*!0

/! 4*%

@!!

;

5*A 4;H

%*## *8

H#H##

*

*HH#H#!

!6##

,/ #

;

$5*A 4;H

end;

#*()

(!(>

self.execute(n-1)

@(#-

=@#

!8(3#

) % # ( %

( B *

(*)B

* ) '

!

;

; #

#

-#8@!8 @!

#8!8#8

!$$ ?

#((>* #

*

*#!(!(,/#

->

88@!

! 8 ((

4

- # # ,/

!4>

/ ! !@

*

;(8*

(

(#!!(

#!((+

65*A 4;H

%(E,6!

3.2.5 Development of the PrePreFabrication Model

!3

*!((?:G%H;

#:G4H;(*8

%##!4

GH(( *!G !!

(#

@ *'=( ( (

:G0H;#G!(H#

*! A (

#

%0*!#>

! 0 "

(

($#(#%%(,

;

4*D> # #

5*A 4;H

#)> # # ! ! 4(

#

*> # !

*!#

*>!*!&

D *> ( 0

> MBB0

#:0=*

( # ! *! 3 ( !8

(#8(*

-**#8

(B(

)>#!#

#B(

#>#! #

!!

%>'#@(,

/%!#(

)>-*(#

> % !

((

=*#

)> (

(!BB(

,>B!8!!8

B##

;(

! # #B 8 !8

3 > G#H

*##:(* ( @ /, : 'E ;8

!#*#!(!!!

##

45*A 4;H

0G%H@ 'E8GH8G,%H8

5%4G/H0#+

8

8

!G#H8

((#!!#

* ! #

B(

B1.D-(#

#!

1.B@!

0

##!

# D ! ( !##

1.8 !(

B((

!!@!

8

G%H8!

GH : ; ! G X%H :; ! G9XH :

;

:(;#B

0#+B ! !# (B!(

(3.

;

Contents of the Workshop Frame

%8#

#

Contents of the Machine Frame

-,!*!

#/

>

5*A 4;H

!

,N

#/

;

N/

#

( ! ,

/(>

G4N/H8

!N/

$5*A 4;H

G\H>

( ( !

:*8;

(!,/(>

?8 !

4

N/'>

N/'

*! *

!>

#!

!

(!,/(>

G4N/'H /

N/'% :

#;N/'4:;

G,/5H>

G,/5H ! :G#. . .+H 0 B ! #;

N/!,/(>

G!=]H>

0!#*!(*

! ! # ( /, G/=]H (

8 !(#3

;

65*A 4;H

#*

!!( #

*?*

*?,

!*#!#*

(!(*!!

! #

*

(

! !#? B @!?=#

N/ ! !#

#

3 * !A

!,N,/

@>

(3$+?#

!!= !

!#>

!!:!8;

;

5*A 4;H

@

!#-(@

!(* # *

! #&.N/'>EB

!(#&N/'

# :%=#8 %8 ;

!(

!3$ #+ (

%98,%*!

*!0!#/,*

/>

'/>

(33%

( # *

!>/5#N/

/( '/ *! ( 'E ( : 'EX

#/,;!*,%

'/

(!,/(>

(36%#

%&>

( //0*!:

;#(!

;

(30#+ (

( 9

3 9

*!'/#*

-!#B(*!B!(

@ !( '/!

(@!(!M

R#/5!8#

N/%*! #

(!/,*

!( (# @ /,%

!=(

445*A 4;H

00

*! :#6#8;8 #

/,('/X/58'/XN/%&

0(*?*

!!(*!!

*?

(>#(NM#

#*!*!#

!*

*&/!

*

*#

#'/

'/ ! * 5 * @!

G*?H#

! ! '/ : %& ; # (

*?4!#

'(9

( 0 !

#N/8/5%&

(#B##

! R : @!

Y'/XN/8 YX'/X/5; ! !#

0(!% 9 !!

: ;!##

(>

!

4!#,

%@!!(!!#=#;

;

!! @( ( M >

! 8 # # 8 ! !

!#!#!BR

45*A 4;H

!33 #5;

!#

;@#

4$5*A 4;H

8/,Y/,X#

3 #(* (

!( *! !

(!

4!#

((/,(

,%>!8#

;

465*A 4;H

@!B!*B((

!!@#!

( *

@!

! * (

# @

O#B 'E

%#(%

/##

!

O

(64#5;(

!36 #2 E(

#//,(

#(* ! ! (B

!!#*##

!%!#(/,

;

(6#2 E(

! (

!#%!!

!

! ( *

#(*'=((

(#!!!

!> @

45*A 4;H

!!!!>

-!5%4#

(!

-#!(G/5%4HB@

# ! ( ( 5%4 @

#)?B#68#88#A8#P8#I#J(

0#!(

@!E @!

!!!##)?

*!>

#N4>B=?

#NO>

!B=?

#NO>!?

#N>#NO

/,B#!

/,?

#N,>3#)?

*>#B%4

,(@!#

%

)

5

4!"

%@!!

(#

4

! ( ! #

! (

# #)? #)? !

!( HN !

;

(6#G%2 EG(

%

!

BGH

O

G)H*##

##*

)O

G)H*#

###**-*/

45*A 4;H

#N)

,!%#

#!-!*

*#

! @! (

#(#!#

!3 #FD(

#

!

>#

! !

#

#>

; (NM

# !**#4(*#

!

!

!+N(NM

! (N

( *+N(NM !# (NM B

#B@(NM*+N(NM

##

5*A 4;H

(6$#

(NMN6(NMNP@(,**

-*G(NMH(*

@(8((

#*!-*#

*#B

( 0# & (

N?(NM-*!

*#*#!D

#*

#@X9

*(*#-!*

##**#%!>

*#B#B#

*+N(NM

%# ( !( (NM 0 *#

*#* *

!*#0(*N(NM

!>(NM*

*N(NM

,((N#(*0

!NM(NM*

54NB@!!#

;

$5*A 4;H

(63#GB5G(

#9B9X9X

9X# @*# 9X

#*#

!34 #F1BAD(

-*#*##!

!(%*

B 8 ! (8 ! *8

!8

##>

;,#88#8

(!!#*>#

(!(*3!!!*#

#(#*#!>

*8

65*A 4;H

4Q

!

*#B

B ( #

; * ! !#

#(*?

!(#

#>

(60#G%

G(

)## ! *#!

5*A 4;H

/*4##4#

@)###@):

(

;

45*A 4;H

! *# ! : ! ! !;

##

0!#!*

!!,N!(

3X98RX6

8CX6

83/%38 3 898

X65/#%

! B(

*!8 @ 8 - ( !

5/ @

(

,N

@ ( @ ( !( 4# 4(

( ( #! *B

((

@!(,N*!*>

UN%3C#8

!!#-

!( ! * #

(>

4!O*!

%!*

(62

((NM

*B# (NM

G%#$/XH #! !B?>#

(#(G#$/XH!*

;#G#XH-#(G#XH

#

@ ( B

#-((>

%(B#

%(

(042

,)

((NM#

#((

!3 #F%D(

#*!-

#(*!

#!%#!!

E !(8 #8 ! #

(>

,(!(,%B

/,?

4#!#*#B!

*# ! ,%

!!(?

4#%&*#?

,(

N'/,%?

4#!#!

#

#*!(:8

##!(

#>

5*A 4;H

(0#G%G(

:;D;!*

!##?

+>!?

>

:R;

*#*#

?

.>

: C ;

*#*#

?

1>!(:;

##Q

# :R8 C; ! '

#

!%@(

O (

;#

*!(!##

,N # # ! <

##*

!(#

,N#D

;!,N

65*A 4;H

( #> # 8 # 8 ! :##

#;/, 'E

!>

- # ! # -

*

( !

##=!#

#BG(H08#

#%

;Q(#

4

5*A 4;H

*##!*#

B(?>#!#(!

* '=( * ! !

( O @

#!*#

0!>

*!(*,%

##*!/,*!

#*#

!>

* ! /,*%#*

!!!

%#

#@

;#(/,(!#B

!!B!/,

'(/,!#(

(!:@((;-

*

#%!((#:;/,

/,O

/,!

*/,

(/,/,

!(

/,!#!

#%(#(/,G

!H

#( ! #% #

!:(#;!!/,

! @ ( /,

G/H3(!/,

!(

* /,

(!

#B!(

* #

;!(

(/,#(

-/,#

,%/,D-!#O

#

# :!(; # * #

OB!#!(

!( # #

:!88;O

!( #!

!#(

-@!(# !

O ! !( #

!

!45*A 4;H

!3! #F%D(

%N4 # #

(0!#G%#G(

( >( * :D;

;

!5*A 4;H

(03#G2,G(

##

#

##(#

( (#0

(D

3

;

##!

(062#,

)7

%

),ND!

)

,N

>Q

#!

!

!>Q>Q!(

###

D

,N(!!D

(*

# # # #

(%

!33 #(

!-*!>

# !

# ! (!

!!B

!#*#(?

!$5*A 4;H

!

! ( 0

!!

0

!

!(#

! =*( # #

@ * ( '=(

(

*#

#>

(00#GG(

# !

(>

'(8*!

B0#..B!#@0#.1

; 4! %

?

> 4!?

> 4

!?

> 4*!?

> 4

O*!(

!-!B(*#B!#

*!

#!#*

*%

B@!

!(8

!

'*#

!65*A 4;H

(0#,,

> 6@!?

> 6@!?

> !4 5/E6?

> '*@/E6?

> =!4 5?

> %!?

> !#@*!#!?

> !

#@(!#!0

! G6 H# B

@B@B@4!

4 5 /E6( ! !

'*@&*

:;/E6

!(

#!

!*!#

!!!*!-*

:+;!((#B

#4 5B! @:; (2

@(

;

!5*A 4;H

(,

> 6*!?

> 6*

! !( ( * ( !

#( ! *

((

410#."!

!

#

! 4 !

#@0#1

(%,

> !!#?

> !!*#!?

> !!#!?

> !!#!?

; !!#!B#8 !!5B*?

> !!

*#?

> !!

4!##@>

(!5,/,

!/,!!

!#!:(;*

(

:G,#H; ( !

(!#

#:G#H;! (

# :( ( # 8 # ! *#

;

4:G%##H;0#1!#@!

*#!>

$45*A 4;H

($%#&

0 * ! :N/8N/'8 ; *#

!@(!**%&:(;

!##@!(

4! #@! ##@

! @! . 3 #

:%

;!

!!#@

#

4&!#@#!B0#1+

(3%##

#!!@*!

( # * (# >

* # * #

;

$5*A 4;H

*!#!!

#

0

(0-&%

4.!#@(*#B

0#11

(%

,H)&

!*#(#

(# !

;

8!!8*#8##0#1"

*#!%@!(

**(!

(3#

0#(!>!!8

0*>

/(88

!!!(-

!!!#

!#

!!

0 !! *# (

!!*#*

*#!B*!8!8

!8#

$$5*A 4;H

#B*!:##;8 !8

!8

;

'*@ B

?

> '*@!:;?

>

'*@!:;!*:.;

?

>

*## B(

*@?

> !*

* !*

*

*

* 4!#

- & 8 1 *# #

!(!(*!BB8*#8

>*(:(;!B#

*###

4&-*!#@B

0#"

(

*@ - !!

!(

*B8#

*!8

$65*A 4;H

(

**#

@##*

3 ( # @ B *# 8

#!(

#@B0#"

(

#

!

* ( ! ( -#

##

E,6 ! !

#!8 88 (

! # !8 8

! % B 0# .. B

( ! ! >

(*4 #8*@8

@8!

!!

* ( A 0

!*@#@0#."

!36 #&(

(!#**!

(

#>

3-*/

;

(!#G2G(

-H#

?

(#%68%88%A%P

**#!#

#>)N

)N?*##

3 ! > * B 0# "&

*(!

$5*A 4;H

($##.,#:5%4;

!(,/

-*8N!

8(Q)8!

8!#N!@

#=

!

!*

-S

*#2S

*

#8@!8 !S

*S

*!

S

*S

*##

- * 8 =

8!8

!!

#!

;

345*A 4;H

!30 #')(

'#

@%

BB

#

#>

(6#G,G(

,#!#>

%8)8(+?

,#>8*NN?

; *)

** *O *># *)# *,N

*)N*4O?

, #

#>,N(E=(!*(8*&

*)@

( !

!B#

@!

=!@!>

&> 4

*

*!#*M

%N4?

N:N?;>#(*

%:4;NN?&

4NN :4NN?;> -

N:N?;

NN :NN?;> -

! % : 4;

(

35*A 4;H

(0

< ! !#!

( B #(

(

>NB!@!

;

C6X9X%46>!((%

?

9X%46> ! C6X9X%46 *! (

3X98UN%3C8/%5385%3/5864%'3 ?

C6X9X,>@(%

(3X98

6,X38RX6'%68CX6'%68N ,?

9X/,>@ C6X9X,(!#

(/,*?

9X'/X/5> @ C6X9X, ( /5

!*?

3$5*A 4;H

9X'/XN/>@C6X9X,(#N/

!*?

9X%&>@C6X9X,(%&!

*?

/X%X# : /X4X#;> @ %

/X%:/X4;

!>!((%

?

/>(%

?

/(>(%

0(#!%8!%88

!4#!

%@!@(

M4% # $

#- *! ( !

(,/!$#

3 ( ( ! ( !! /5

# B '! & @ M4% $

#(!,/

$#@$@

!(,/!

!BB!##@>

(5,#"

66;?

68>

'

;

365*A 4;H

(

:*!#8!(8;

B # !

( # ( B @! G(H

G*NH%@!

GH#D

0@!

!(B

!B(

(+N#%

#%N#%N?!

B ? (

@*)

*NN

*,NM!!

# 4% 5 !

#*NN#

*! # '6X9 #

NNNNNN?

**

*!#!*

*)*

!>!!8*#88#8#

#

!#!%@!0#22

;

35*A 4;H

(4.

*>#

)>##

!#

(#-#>#

*#0#2

(4.,

*)#

)#

! #

;

645*A 4;H

(4$-

#*#

8 *8

*#

*,NM

,NM*

(4%-*)N

B*B#)NM@

)!*-@

:#,NM;)NM*

#N

*)N

%@!8@) *#,N

)NM**NM#

!*##!

*@*%@!0#2+

; (+N#%

** *O *># *)# *4O *,N

*NN

!#,/ 68T?P

@$@!4(

!(,/!#

@ ( M4%

$#*!

3 )

( *

65*A 4;H

(46.#,#

*N,N(E=(!*(

,N(E=(!*(:,NMNN%;

# = ,NMNN%

*!=-

!B#*8B

((

C6XUN3'

(

*&

& !# > >

>N>>#!

B*##!B%4

$!X9(#!*-

!=

(!=

&

*Q

;

6$5*A 4;H

(40#G2B:G(

%,

!4 54 5

!(*

@4 5B@@

!!'!

!G0H##!0

!(!!4 5

%

B#B

!!!%

@

! *! '=(8 (

( %

! 4 5

!D

(*!

( !4 5 !( ,

/

%N#D,

;

665*A 4;H

(#B

,NON4*DN68,NON4*DN

;

65*A 4;H

( ! *!

N( G( ! H

%G#(HG!#H#

!**!#(4!

# #

( # ( #

8

! *! *

!(!?*!

.22*N(6#D%

(((##*!

! !# ( #(

!!!*!#

(

%@!8=0

-* (! (

(#!(* ( #G#H

* ! ) #( #

#3#(*#

(5(

#!!

*! # #! (*

#>9B#,%

#

!

!#6,/5B@!

> 98 6, /5

@%

=!

B0#2"B#*8!

G9H46,/58*

G36,/5H

9 C6X9X%46 %

!

;

045*A 4;H

(4%#/

0!*!0#

(#

*#(

!(#>

*3(#

;

05*A 4;H

##

( @! ! 0# #

#!(

(*##

%@!(#>(

! 8 # ( *8 #

* # =!

!#

0*!#>

Side A Side B& + ." +

+1 + .1 +

++ + .1" +

++2 + .2& 2&

+2& 2 +2&

+2+ 2 12 +

++. 2 .2&

12 + 121 +

.2& + +2+

; ##

*#*#!(

@*#*!*(=

#

= #

! B !( ! B ! (

%@!

*

8 *! *!

! ( ! *%

!!*40#>

&(8&?

*

*(!!

* & (- * (

!= *

! 8

#*!*#-!!*#(

!0=*

1(+! = (

8"(.D'(!!

=#*

*)

%/5#(!*

*/5

!B'!

&

0$5*A 4;H

#=!##

=-(

!

!6! )

%! ( !

(#!!!(

!#=(!

!*

! 8 !#

#D%!

!

!#( !(0

#!-

#!!%

!!!

-!(##

#(!!

#FM(!@!

'=(8

!@(!-

! ! ! ) #

5 * * @

(#B

!! !

#B((4

!(!!*

! ( (

((D(

(*!!(

(##-

8# (

D

;

065*A 4;H

050000

100000150000200000250000300000350000400000450000500000

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5Multiplication Factor

Tota

l Pro

duc

tion

Ti

me

(3#(##%#

3 # ! (

####(

T!(#((TD

*!>

0!(

!!#!*(!

!?

(#!

!(!(*!

-!(#(

**(0!

*# ( 8 ( #

'=(!!

# ! 3 # ! # B

(

##-#*

( *#! # !

(!!

;

05*A 4;H

@! ! ( ##

( ! !

#*#(

4#(B@*(**#(

! B *# # * (

##

% 8 ( ( ! ! !#

8!

3.3 Optimization of the Model

3.3.1 Introduction

-@!!!

! % (!

*! * ! # ! !

*! 8 * ! !

3(('=(

( !

* ( !

!(D(#!(*

!

O" ! 8

8?

# > = @ B

*#

#!=*

#(

!*!!*

!(B(*!#

!

! # *

>*!

**( ( ! = #

E#*=!

!

45*A 4;H

G# /H #

# #

( (

@!#!!###(

!=!!

O"

5*A 4;H

E!!)B#BF

! ( !!( %

# #!#

# 8

#

#(!%

=#>!=*!

! ( = #

3 ## B

(#*!

! @( * ! @!

!#!B!=4

!

*!-#(#>

%(#*?

9 (# ! :

*!;?

*!!

O"#

# @( =8 # #

=@(D(8#8(!(

!!

'?

':;?

% @! # # $%8 (

#

! @! = - (

#

$5*A 4;H

#

* %!

'/N!=(

!

O"/,R

,

5,>2

! #! !

65*A 4;H

!

8#!8##!

B ( 8 !8 B

!

!

O"3?

!#>&?

0'!,:5;/:5;,8!

2$E

5*A 4;H

'>/,R?

,?

5,>2

(2/)>/

!!&H! (!

!!

=#>

0 ! !! @

#BO!?

0

!

#B#!?

! # B (

!?

=##

3 !! ( - !

!@!#

O"

45*A 4;H

!B!8!B(

(

(3(.)##

- ( (

0#0#

(6(

#

- ( !)

!! # ! 2 ! B

B 2 B 0# +%# &2

#%!O

! !( ! ! !

-(@!!

*>

(

:68;?

N!:6P;?

O"

5*A 4;H

(2#

!

*5!

=

$5*A 4;H

08!(#*!-

#!8!:!!;

*!8

! *8

*!4#*

**!8*#8

Chapter 4 Development of a Specific PERT Tool and

Application to the PrePreFabrication Workshop

4.1 PERT: Theoretical background

4.1.1 Introduction

#()&:/5;*

(!/5!"+2N

3(S/!8!

=!!!

!.((((/5#B

75555'5

#!

*!!#(#!B

@!##! ^U,(_

0(/5*#((

!*(!!

/5*

#

8 '/N! !(!

65*P 4#()##H

B!B/5#

B *!B ( ! #

!! *! % @! ! (

! !

(! **! B* B

*# B B *# =

8

F !

/5 # 4 /5

(>*

*D

((*(

B/5#B!(=

# M ( ## /58

/5(

4.1.2 The Network Diagram

!8 * ! ( : ;

*#!%(8

=:88!8(;8

!# 8 8 =

4(#8!#!

/ * ! ( /5

#((*8!

%! *!

* 8 * !

*8GH#

!

(#>

%(:*;

0%(

:*;

#()750

0 ! B

!*

/58>

> #

*#

#

)*!

/5(!!#(*##

(!@!/5#>

(1%12&

9: *8 #

##(!*

(8

9: *8 #

#@*(

(8

((

:#;-(*

!*(#(!*B

5*P 4#()##H

%(%4

4 ( % = (

!%((( !(

! ( ! =

!

4.1.3 Terminology

#

#(B

75555'5>

% > ( !

(#(=(

%> ( (

#(=(

O :.;> ! =

! *8

#(#!

(@!

# :%;> @ ! =

! *8

#(###:@#!;

=

! *8

#(#!

(+ :1;> =

! *8

#(#!

:!#@!

# * = * !

@!;

1I:.O$+O%; `6

,>(!

! ! /5

#!

, > ( ! /5

>&@

# % &7I8 ?

&?/&

#()75

>!#!

*>#

*!*(

# ( = * B :; / '! B

:;

4.1.4 Benefits of PERT

/5!#>

@!!!

/(!!

!(!!

*!

%(

4.1.5 Limitations

/5S*#K9%8221L>

( ! #

@! !#(8 (

(# 8 !#!!#(

(

( 8 /5

8(

!*8/5 *(

! ! !

4 ! !

(8/5(@!!!

! ! ! #

!!8,'

!*!@!

!!B

75555'5

445*P 4#()##H

4.2 Tool developed

4.2.1 Introduction

#!(@

!!(

//0*! !!

8

#88#!

( ! ! !)

( ( ! ! !

#!*!!

#

>

6:'

(( (*! !

=*( A 8 8 (

# ( !

:;#(

(

!((

08!!

D

# ( ! !)

*#!

8:O"'9":

0 (8 !( #

54

(!4#)

((*

! ( !! ! (

!

$( !!@( # # #

!!@ @! > ( B =

( B #

!B!!

#

#

@

45*P 4#()##H

6(!>!(

!D%

#!*

/(#!8

@!

6* 8 @ ! (

( !(!

B@!(#(

* !

54!

-((#(>

'I + ''' +M

!(:8';:0#2;

*

!

:; @8

>

(b

GH@

0!8 !@(@)I@B*!

# ( ( Q #! !8 *!

#

9 !

4$5*P 4#()##H

#!()!%!

(!8(@!@

!@ !! !( ( :# (

(;:D8@@6;( !@,

: ; @! 5 !@

,!

!#

#

!@(##!@

8 ( @ ! 8

# !

% (! !## !

((#>

,@

543

@OIW

@O

K 8LI,V2

(@84O

C@@!#:8!(=

=(;>

O

465*P 4#()##H

! :'/0 ; % :40;

# '/0 ( !

: 40 '/0 ; *

0 ( 8 !# !

!((#*

*( !@ (

40 (#$

8#=

K 8LI,

O

=

540

4 W 4

EI W W W

4 W 4

(# !#

K 8L:8,88E(!

!@@;

!@(E8E

(@8E,I,8!!(E

>

EE,IE

,

EEI8

,IE,

6, :#

45*P 4#()##H

,E2,E

,

4E,E

,

YI I

4!#!#

!8 @ ! # #

!!(#'=(8

,E4,E

,E

4E4 2E

E

8

I

@&

,E ,E

2E E

Y

I

,E,

E,

(!!

%">

40>*

%>

! > # 0 8

@! Y # :

(!;#

!> #0=

# (! :V2;8

# #

=#

!> 40> E,IE

,

O>

54

( * ! # 8 !

0 ! (8 !( !

(B@O(b

(B@O(B@)))I

@)))!@)))a2

N(8 !@ = *

(8(>

(B@O(B@)))O + I

+ + a2

I ( ) ''' +

45*P 4#()##H

()a2

3!:!;(!@

>

,@ ( ) ''' +

!

5

* ! 7 0

! @ !##!?

>

# A( :8 8

88;?

>

# : (; *

'*#!

>

/5*'! :8!8

%:;*(?

(?

5*P 4#()##H

:;?

!#:;?

:;

/&((!

5!

(!! ),

-#(!>

!>(G%(HO(#8

#BG-#H?

!N8!N8*N*N?

>!#B0#2?

>(:;?

*>(

%((#(

-:(;8#>

(!$@,

E#(!>

!> ( G3HO ( #8

#BG-#H?

$5*P 4#()##H

>(:;?

4>(0

!8#:!;4

!

:0#+;

*>'(?

NN+>?

NN N+N>

!(

(!3##

0 8 NN N+N # #

(!E#((

(#(

D#(!

53

(!6./&

% D #> (

8!

65*P 4#()##H

7

(!1K

7

(!)#

0 #! 8 ! :8 '; ( !

:XX!8 '; ! :X@X!8 ';

(!

4(#!#!B(#!0

@!8#.+8

(4.++8(#

!#4(+8(

#

)>

##H50

(

'

5*P 4#()##H

($4(,&%12&

8

*8

@*#4@*(

0*/5#>

($2

&

3.!1

(*0

/5 # * ( #

#*#!>

## # #

#0#&

##H5

($2

3/5##!!

*(:I(+;#

:I(;

!(-(!!(#(

!-#>

($!(

#/5#(

*

(

! *!D*! !( *

!(*#*>!*

(*!!!

G!H(( !*

(*(%!(

! !0

(

45*P 4#()##H

($$ 7$&8

0#&&!(

/5!=*B4(

#( ,!(

# * !#

!8*D

(##0#

&+#(GH*

%4B=%(+

($3####

-#(

!(#!%##

# #= /5#

- ## =(

! !( !

(R,6

##H5

4.3.2 Automatic creation of the PERT

# !

!*/5

((/5

-

R,6

R,6(!>

($6L+:)%12&

0#!:%;#

! :Q ; (

:4%;8!:@!;

* * R,6 /5 *

% * 8 *# :;8 ! :;8

-#:;80#:#;(:(;

/!!

!#

(#@!#

*!4 # /5 #

*!!

5*P 4#()##H

## * !4 (!GH?

H>GH?

>!GH

!

'(,?

'(

$! #+

% :; ( 8

!*#>

=*?

!

- !3 !

0 ( *

!#(!

=*!!@

(04(9

##H5!

*!8,/8R,6

#(/50#&.

($01%12>%%-

# ! ( ## GH

!-*!:;8#

8&!!!*!:%;

#:4;

% G-!%(H(

!(*! :2

)*;!(*

:2

* ;

!!*%=8

(*#(

((#

0!*#0#

&.#!(4848

%%&

(#

=(

!#

#!

!

$5*P 4#()##H

#( (

# !

!(D

0!!(B

0#&1

($##!

%!!//0*!(@

##H53

$! #,

%/50

##(*#

* ( !!@ * (

**#E#

*#/5

0 # ! (

> /E6: ; ( !

##

0 -

!!@*

(*

0 ! # :4 (; *

# *

!

#%:;

=

# ! ( #

=(-

!0**

# # ( # #

##

#D

= 8 (

B#8!(

(

=#,/R,6

( B ,

%

B *

=5 #!

:!###R,6;

!,/

% = ,/ R,6

!>

65*P 4#()##H

N#?

N#(

(

$!! ###

%!!#(/5

# # /5

(

8 # *#8

!8 # # ( # # *

*(3

!8 #8* B

B##>#8

!#*(

- @!0#&.&+*# #

>

5 5/5

/:; &"":; &&2:;

,,%12

&T%@!!#(

/5

#(

!:!!*; /5#3

(!(!

4.3.3 Conclusion

%#/5#*!#

(*(##

3!

##H50

%#'/N#!(

/5(

!!@!/5#

B # '/N

(*!

5*P 4#()##H

/5

* //0-*!# !!(

#

*#*

Chapter 5 Development of a tool to solve Space

Allocation Problem

5.1 Introduction

% ! B !( !# B

!

!4#!=!(#

#(!(#3#

!(##!*!8

# !

!45*I 4#

% #! ( :$N; # *!

#?

%!

45!

-!!(

*!32 B!(2

*!B12 B!( 12 *!

*!((!

!#!

5.2 Development of the tool

5.2.1 Introduction

-@(!F#-

*!*# !%(

>#

*B*!

!(**(=

#!*!

*

!##!>

(

*

!( # (

#3

* (

!!@((#

!!! #

!**#

*(8

!*@(@

*#

(!#8*#

!

!5*I 4#

>(

*A(

##

-(@(F!

!( # !#

'=(##

0( !*!

#B #(

(#

(# @!

*! !

8 !# !

*!!!

*D

#

*!D #!

!!#

*#

*8!(

#((*!

(!

45!!

! !( *! - !(

!4

* !( #N(

!-

# (

* # #

*!B0#+

(3;###

*!!

!#*!0#+

(3!#

'=(8

* !# (

(!(@B0#+&

!$5*I 4#

Overhead view of the Workshop Timeline view of the Workshop

(3$(&,&

#!*!)!(

( ! ! D

(*!D

4 # !

=

*

1

450B!

*A(B#!>

3

*=

*

!?

#?

6#?

=

*B?

$>#8#

( !#E

!#!*!0

12*!8#!((

*@>

*

( # ( @ ( * ! * !

(*!

*

(!

# 450

6C*;$$

45!3

3 = !

**! !

@(

- ( *!

!*!R,6"

#>

*!>

% @! (8 !

-?

- *# *!

!=!0!#

( ! '=( *# >

88!*!##

!!@

*

*

(-*#!*#

*!*##

*8!(!

! ( !(>

8!*!?

>@

!*!0@(

3 !(

!65*I 4#

-*#(*8@

*

#

*

3

*

*! !(

!8*!!(

*

-*

*!#@!B0#

++ ! #8 3 !(

##

*!(!

*@

0

*-@

@(8@*#@#D*

!

45!0

(33E&H

(

*(!#

!B0#+!*(0@

*#

*8(#*!(

!

(36+,&

-!

*(##B0#+1

3 ! !! ( ! !

!( (('=(

*

! !

#

!B0#+.

(30.

!5*I 4#

%#

*#*8!(

!#

*D

! !( #

*

! *# ( B !(

8 -

* !

* B ! B

#

*!B

0#+1

##( !

* (

*!

* !( @ 0 ( (

!(!

Normal Block

Fixed Block

Fictive Block Overlapping Blocks

(3:,&

!8

*

! ( ( *

#(!(

**!

*

-

*!#

- ! # - !

!#!

*!(

!

*

* (

#D

**

= ( D - !

*8 *

8 !8 # !8 * #

(!#

*)

!0#++B4.-!

(#

*%#

*

86

45!

!!

*B0#+"

*

*

( *!

* #

*

*!

(3

,&,&

#

*8* !

*(#8

*D4

!

*!(

B

*B

!(!(#!(

* ! #

# #

*-#

(>

*!D#

##(

!

!

*-*!

*!

*( ,

*

*

*

(BBD

%@!%#

*

*@

!#

# #

* (

*

$45*I 4#

(D!@

*-

!((!=*(%(

! %#

;88

* ! 0# ++-

*

*!(#

*%

# # *!> #

#) # #

* 8

*

*! @

* (

!(@

*

3 !(*!

* #B

(A@

**

450#

*>

*#

#D

B

450

*>

*#

*#?

'

!!

*)!*#?

*?

#

3@

*!0@!

#

* 0 #

@

*(0@-

* 450 - #

* +8 4?)( @ # #

(!!(

%!!%#(

*!

((D#

*

*(*#*!%

!(##-!(((

88(&Y(+Z

45$

(*#(((

! ( ( > *

(!#(*!!#(

= *!!# *# ( B ( (

E #(!

%

*#

#

0 0#++ B

(AA(B

)B

#>

5B(!

*?

,#

*B0#2?

5

B! !

!?

/(#!

*@

4

*(?

!

!#

*?

$5*I 4#

(64;#

3!(*!

0#

(6!5#

!##!

)*

45$!

5.2.3 Theory developments of the optimisation

N!!(

!!#8!#!(

#(((!#0

#

*

##

*B

*(@%!

!

!

$$5*I 4#

#

*!8#@

*>

!Ic28d#

*!?

Ic8W8%d

*!?

@(

8!#!!!

*

?

Ic28d:

*:@a2@OKO:;LbH;

*#:(a2(OKO:;Lb,;

*:aOb';

'

!

*

%!8(!

*

!!#

-@

*(#8

!Ic88d

@! #! !8

= #( ! (

= (! ( ! 4?

# # B 0# - ! !

(8#

*8

#

8AH

45$3

(6##,&,

/. 7%%

4 /*# / : 4//;8 #

#! 8

$65*I 4#

E0!8(!!#!

# ( #

8## !

*#(

0P !! 22 e!D A4 ?##e

##@(!

!((!!8

e

e

(/)

"#

!! (

(?8#(!

*8!*

!

45$0

%(!

!

!

(#R!

##R!Og:R!;!

( (! ( 08 (

18%#:%P9"1";

:$""2;8@*#

!

(8 #

(#(= # :

8 * @8 ( ! !!; 8

@!##

!((!#

8!!!>,:$6;

8

!(# #

,

:06;

"#

$6

E:$6;

33*

$38 ! (-# # :"";8 !!

! * * # $6 8

!(# 068 ( M :"".; M P #

:"".8""";8(!! 4//(0P:22;

4(8$6!!(

8 #8

$5*I 4#

!!8#!(

!

45$

#

g:R; #

(8 ( #

06

( #

@

R #

g:R; :R;[:R;8 R

R? !! #

!

#!#8-

#

8 06!

!!R8 8

$60!806

8#!(88

8(!@8

4(#8

!(!

!

345*I 4#

- 06 ! ( !

8 #

( 6

,O:R; ( ( $68 ! #

!#

%#

!

8

*8!#!

453

!# 8 ( ( ! !!# 8

#

*

4!! > ( *(

#

* 8!!!##

!

*88

*#(!!8(

!# 8

*

!8 ! ##!

*

8 # ! ! :# ( *

!

#!!;3!

08!#(

* ! # SS( #

kk R8

ROI>O:RS;( # :RRS;

#8!

!

*#

#

*

4(##8!

! * !!

! $6 !

!+-( ( E8 !

! ( #8

*( ( # 8 ( ( (

!(@!#(8!

35*I 4#

#"##

>!##!(

@%8(@(:#';

!(!!#!8

(#

8#((

*!

#%8#

*(8@!8

8

*

#!-

( ! 0 # Q8

:Q;

#@>

:Q;I:Q;O(+#:R;I< '

':Q;Oi' 8

!:Q;O(+#:Q;

(+#:Q;8

!#8!

#

453!

% 8 #(- !!#

*

*#(!

%# !!#

*

*-

!

!

*#

6(

**!

-

* F E #

!!(

*(!

0@!(##

!

9(

3$5*I 4#

= !(#!

* @

?

>

# " 9)((:>

!!(

*

!#8!!!#

((#!?

> ,>(!##)?

>

(+ 9#O!4()%O!NO)%(:> ## # @

!%@!8(!! ! @

*(!8(

#

*

F!#!

*

:;

3!(#*#

!

4533

(6$#4

*!GH!#@

! @

! B #8

# 8 !# B

(###%#*

8!

'!+(

#(

!!

#

(#

-(!!(#*!0

!(!#!

!! # D(@( *!

> ! # !

64A*J *

(!*!B//0*!B

88(!!

#((!

0 @! ! !# (

!#

'!&'!+@!!

6.3 Conclusion ##!#*!#

! *!(## '!(

!@(*-*#!@*!B

B#

#(#!@!#!

(*!!(B#(

!(

B

! !

#A6

!'=(!

//0*!# # (*

!((#!

'!&!!/5

!

!

('!+!

*!!0

#*!!

(D

M

!# *!

# # ! 5 !@ ,

!!(((

*(#

(#!!(

## !(

*! 4 *# # 8 !( (

'=( *!) # #

!! !( B

!B!(*

!

! B !,#

*!(#!

( B B !

6A*J *

((D%8!!!!

!(D

/5

!

!!!

#!

!!

!!

0 !

( !! !E #

((!!!

#!!%@#

6!

Glossary E!%@!

#(

A>!!(E(%%&

(?

P>!!(E(%&%+

%?

I> ! ! ( E( %+

?

?4)O>5/(%*C!(?

*>'!M!B

(B!(!(

?

4?)(> ' #

* !

!?

4*D> % //0 *! /,

?

()#> ! 5 /# 9 !#

#?

% //0 *!

*

!(!8##?

!> !

6$

#D,>0G#D,H/

!#

# (% !

)

*=#*?

#':(!;//0*!##!

?

#)>!##//0*!?

)?> % //0 *! #

!?

M> % //0 *!

!?

> # # ! % B

# //0 B #! !

(#?

*#>//0*!###?

=#*:N/'%N/'4;>#//0*!?

=#>#//0*!?

;7=(?

;?7M4%!!?

Q @,*! 6## # * # (

@(!?

63

Table of Figures 67

66

AB74O' LP

P@7O' LP

P67#?O' LI

P87%*O' LJ

PA7(+ LJ

PP7 LL

PI7$

60

LB7

6AJ

C@7, 6AL

C67 6AC

C87#+ 6AC

CA74+' 6AB

CP7# 6P@

CI7# 6P@

CJ7D 6P6

CL7H# 6P8

CC7# 6P8

CB7 6PA

B@7%"H 6PP

B67* 6PI

B87 6PJ

BA7 )` ` 6PL

BP7*O' 6PC

BI74' 6PB

BJ7 ` ` 6I@

BL7 6I8

BC74+>

+ 6IP

BB7>

##H 6II

6@@7> 6IL

6@67O 6IC

6@87O 6IC

6@A7O" 6IB

6@P7H 6J@

6@I74 6J6

6@J7O 6J8

6@L7 )`N, ` 6JP

6@C7 )` ` 6JL

6@B7 6JB

66@7#%" 6L@

6667% 6L@

6687; 6L8

66A7, 6LA

66P7%# 6LI

66I7%# 6LJ

66J7%

6

66B7D" 6CA

68@7! 6CP

6867)"7&" 6CC

6887) 6CB

68A7, 6CB

68P7(+ 6CB

68I7 6B@

68J7 6B@

68L7% 6B6

68C7) 6B8

68B7(+#() 6BL

6A@7* 8@6

6A67%#()! 866

6A87 868

6AA7

86A

6AP7!

86A

6AI7* 86P

6AJ7O" 86I

6AL7)# 86I

6AC7(5* 86J

6AB7% 86J

6P@7#() 86C

6P67)8 86C

6P87) 86B

6PA7 86B

6PP79P: 88@

6PI7 88@

6PJ7Q

6

6IB7 8AB

6J@7D 8P8

6J67A4 8P8

6J87 8PI

6JA7#O" 8IA

6JP768@ 8II

6JI76C@ 8II

6JJ7#

04

References Papers/Journal/Books:

%%5 %3 95 7? :"1";8 ?"

, '222

'00,%3$8$(,57 ?:"".;8+

7 8 E

8 + !# D

#8/-/#'!(4

'6C8 %?:""";8%>(8

-8#!

0%58/3$5 %3 Y%'E%5%3,?:22;8>,

4? ##8 305,7'!#8M+838!!

.1

$%5C,5%3 7E33 ? :".";8* %7 >

!# *8-E083C*

$6M50?:""2;788M283&8!!.&"&

$6 45$?:"1";>"

$5 38/?6 378:"12;8 8 7-( P 8

83C*

E665?645,%3?:22;%8

,%E58/3$5 %3 M$ ?:222;8%

!%!!,

/(8$

89(

9%558 $?4589/?3%8?5$8/?:22;8

7!!8!!&

0

9-%5%8 958 ,% ENN E%3% M58 M5%4E% 5% /8 N,3 5 ,58

5NMN5NM%%39%5E%5%E?:221;8O#()+

'87'37'!3*

(8M613

6%3$5C84%5084%C,?8'%/5%'78'5%,%C%3 5$/?:22+;8O"

8',/22+8E#

68?3$87?:"";8

7!!8!!"

666C8 ? $5%-8 9?-%6638 5? :22;8 4

7

!!8!!

,%3890?%3$89?9-3$?:""";8>8!#M#86

,%566 8 /3$5 %3 M$ ? :222;8

8305,!58M&1838!!+.

,N5%% E8 0N7CE 98 3%9%%9 %3 9%7%3 C? :"";8 ;,%

0

MN N5'%3 %3$?:"".;8

? 8 ! 5

628!!".

MN N5' %3 %3$? :"".;8>

8!7!5838!!&"

&""

-%3$'7%3 %3$:"";8

8 /

# ' % 3

3*8!!"+""

Websites:

755X

755X

75555'5X

75555#N(NN)N&X

755X

Other references

# DL@66