professional standards...this performance report is provided by police scotland for the information...

19
OFFICIAL PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS SPA – Performance Report Reporting Period: 1 April 2018 to 30 November 2018 Meeting Date: 13 December 2018

Upload: others

Post on 20-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS SPA – Performance Report

Reporting Period: 1 April 2018 to 30 November 2018

Meeting Date: 13 December 2018

Page 2: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

CONTENTS AND EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity up to and beyond the second quarter (1 April 2018 to 30 November2018).

The report provides a summary of complaint allegations and conduct matters for the East, North and West areas. Information is provided regarding the activity of the Conduct Unit, the National Gateway Assessment Unit, the Anti-Corruption Unit, information regarding Police Investigations & Review Commissioner (PIRC) Complaint Handling Reviews (CHR), Investigations and finally aspects of organisational learning.

Complaints about the Police

Overall, there has been a 13% decrease in allegations (7103 LYTD to 6178YTD). 'On Duty' allegations have decreased by 15% (5499 LYTD to 4675YTD). Every ‘On Duty’ allegation category has decreased with the exception of 'Excessive Force' allegations which

recorded a 7.7% increase (379 LYTD to 408 YTD). This is a reduction in comparison to Q1 2018/19 whichrecorded a 13% increase and is taken in the context of a 10.9% decrease in ‘Assault’ allegations (101 LYTD to90 YTD). Considerable scrutiny is being placed on the categorisation of Assault and Excessive Force. COPFS areto dip sample allegations to ensure accurate recording.

The most common On Duty allegation categories remain Irregularity in Procedure, Incivility and Excessive Force. Within Irregularity in Procedure, the most common sub categories remain Insufficient Enquiry, Insufficient

Updates and allegations relating to the care and custody of prisoners (See Appendix B) The East and West have recorded reductions (15.6% and 17,5% respectively) in the number of allegations while

the North remained relatively unchanged with a 0.4% increase 67 Early Interventions have been conducted YTD. Of note is that having been subject to the process no officer

has been subject to a further intervention.

Page 3: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY (continued)

Conduct Unit

The Conduct Unit has undertaken 258 preliminary assessment since April this year, resulting in 45 cases beingassessed as Gross Misconduct or meriting a misconduct investigation. These have resulted in 17 Misconducthearings and 10 misconduct meetings

National Gateway Assessment Unit

The National Gateway Unit has received more referrals since April this year than obtained in total for 2017/18.This is predominantly due to the introduction of the Business Interest and Secondary Employment SOP.

Anti-Corruption Unit

The Anti-Corruption Unit has instigated 24.8% more enquiries than LYTD (149LYTD to 186YTD). Disclosure of Information and Controlled Drug Use and Supply remains the most common referrals considered

by the Anti-Corruption Unit.

PIRC Complaint Handling Review

YTD PIRC have conducted 92 Complaint Handling reviews, considering 378 allegations, during which they found167 (44.2%) had been handled to a reasonable standard.

15 Complaint Handling Reviews, including 36 separate allegations, resulted in PIRC issuing a ReconsiderationDirections. One of these was subject to the Commissioners supervision.

PIRC Referral

There has been a 91.6% increase in the number of referrals to PIRC (83 LYTD to 159YTD) demonstratingincreased awareness of the referral process and transparency.

Page 4: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

180

5499

37

1567

157

4675

22

1481

0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000

Of which Criminal

On Duty

Off Duty

Quality of Service

Allegations received - Police Scotland

YTD PYTD

Overall allegations have reduced by 13% from 7103 LYTD to 6178 YTD.

Quality of Service allegations have decreasedby 5.5%.

Allegations which occurred ‘On Duty’ decreasedby 15%.

Criminal allegations have decreased by 12.8%.

These allegations arose from 4051 complaints received YTD and have been assessed by the National Complaint Assessment and Resolution Units (NCARU), resulting in 38.4% of the complaints being Frontline Resolved (FLR) by PSD through explanation. Work is ongoing to audit FLR allegations to ensure it is only attempted where appropriate to do so.

The most common On Duty allegation categories remain Irregularity in Procedure (2504), Incivility (1031) and Excessive Force (408).

A breakdown of the sub-categories within Irregularity in Procedure shows that of the 2504 allegations, the three most common categories remain, Insufficient Enquiry (591), Insufficient Updates (266) and allegations relating to the Custody/Care of prisoners (214) (See Appendix B).

Page 5: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

2

1

4

0

11

7

20

107

315

926

19

45

9

68

34

20

197

86

24

1

53

76

86

132

0

0

0

1

13

3

14

102

250

748

15

53

17

46

19

15

250

88

15

0

37

50

54

103

0 200 400 600 800 1000

Off Duty ‐ Incivility

Off Duty ‐ Miscellaneous Offences

Off Duty ‐ Other

Off Duty ‐ Other Crimes

On Duty ‐ Assault

On Duty ‐ Corrupt Practice

On Duty ‐ Discriminatory Behaviour

On Duty ‐ Excessive Force

On Duty ‐ Incivility

On Duty ‐ Irregularity in Procedure

On Duty ‐ Neglect of Duty

On Duty ‐ Oppressive Conduct / Harassment

On Duty ‐ Other ‐ Criminal

On Duty ‐ Other ‐ Non Criminal

On Duty ‐ Traffic Irregularity / Offence

On Duty ‐ Unlawful / Unnecessary Arrest of Detention

Q of S ‐ Lack of satisfaction with action taken

Q of S ‐ Police failure to take action

Q of S ‐ Policing policy

Q of S ‐ Policing Practice

Q of S ‐ Policing presence

Q of S ‐ Policing procedure

Q of S ‐ Time of response

Q of S ‐ Type of response

Allegations received - East

YTD PYTD

Overall allegations in the East have reduced by 15.6% from 2243 LYTD to 1893 YTD.

Quality of Service allegations have decreased by 8.9% from 655 LYTD to 597 YTD.

Allegations which occurred ‘On Duty’ decreased by 18.1% from 1581 LYTD to 1295 YTD.

Oppressive conduct allegations have increased by 17.8% (8 allegations). Q1 2018/19 recorded an increase of 109% in comparison to Q1 2017/18, so the YTD increase demonstrates a levelling of the number of these allegations. A review has not identified a reason for this increase, beyond the subjective nature of the allegation type, recorded dependant on the terminology used by a complainer.

Q of S lack of satisfaction has increased by 26.9%. There is no obvious cause for this and the matter will be monitored.

Page 6: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

3

3

2

13

8

7

66

222

754

25

31

10

59

29

24

72

42

16

6

48

35

60

3

2

4

11

1

14

78

234

753

27

31

9

63

21

20

83

26

11

2

52

27

69

0 200 400 600 800

Off Duty ‐ Incivility

Off Duty ‐ Miscellaneous Offences

Off Duty ‐ Other

On Duty ‐ Assault

On Duty ‐ Corrupt Practice

On Duty ‐ Discriminatory Behaviour

On Duty ‐ Excessive Force

On Duty ‐ Incivility

On Duty ‐ Irregularity in Procedure

On Duty ‐ Neglect of Duty

On Duty ‐ Oppressive Conduct / Harassment

On Duty ‐ Other ‐ Criminal

On Duty ‐ Other ‐ Non Criminal

On Duty ‐ Traffic Irregularity / Offence

On Duty ‐ Unlawful / Unnecessary Arrest of Detention

Q of S ‐ Lack of satisfaction with action taken

Q of S ‐ Police failure to take action

Q of S ‐ Policing policy

Q of S ‐ Policing presence

Q of S ‐ Policing procedure

Q of S ‐ Time of response

Q of S ‐ Type of response

Allegations received - North

YTD PYTD

Overall allegations in the North have increased by 0.4% from 1535 LYTD to 1541 YTD. This is a stabling on previous increases (5% at Q1), and is attributable to several individual complaints which contained large numbers of allegations. It is significant that LYTD represented a low figure, with the comparable figure for 2016/17 being higher at 1738.

Quality of Service allegations havedecreased by 3.2% from 279 LYTDto 270 YTD.

Allegations which occurred ‘OnDuty’ increased by 1.1% from1248 LYTD to 1262 YTD.

On Duty – Excessive Force allegations have increased by 18.2% (12 allegations). The allegations are evenly spread across North Divisions with no specific pattern and will be monitored.

Q of S lack of satisfaction allegations have increased by 15.3% (72 LYTD to 83YTD). There is no obvious cause for this and the matter will be monitored.

Page 7: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

1

4

6

1

10

0

77

8

21

206

642

1353

43

109

43

79

35

54

200

76

37

29

96

71

124

0

1

1

1

8

1

66

2

13

228

543

1003

25

87

26

52

37

36

182

105

23

26

89

30

159

0 500 1000 1500

Off Duty ‐ Crimes of Indecency

Off Duty ‐ Incivility

Off Duty ‐ Miscellaneous Offences

Off Duty ‐ Offences Involving Motor Vehicles

Off Duty ‐ Other

Off Duty ‐ Other Crimes

On Duty ‐ Assault

On Duty ‐ Corrupt Practice

On Duty ‐ Discriminatory Behaviour

On Duty ‐ Excessive Force

On Duty ‐ Incivility

On Duty ‐ Irregularity in Procedure

On Duty ‐ Neglect of Duty

On Duty ‐ Oppressive Conduct / Harassment

On Duty ‐ Other ‐ Criminal

On Duty ‐ Other ‐ Non Criminal

On Duty ‐ Traffic Irregularity / Offence

On Duty ‐ Unlawful / Unnecessary Arrest of Detention

Q of S ‐ Lack of satisfaction with action taken

Q of S ‐ Police failure to take action

Q of S ‐ Policing policy

Q of S ‐ Policing presence

Q of S ‐ Policing procedure

Q of S ‐ Time of response

Q of S ‐ Type of response

Allegations received - West

YTD PYTD

Overall allegations have decreased by 17.5% from 3325 LYTD to 2744 YTD.

Quality of Service allegations have decreased by 3% from 633 LYTD to 614 YTD.

‘On Duty’ allegations decreased by 20.7% from 2670 LYTD to 2118 YTD. This is primarily due to a decrease in Irregularity in Procedure allegations. Anecdotally this can be attributed to greater divisional awareness of causal factors of complaints.

On Duty Excessive Force allegations have increased by 10.7%, coupled with a decrease in Assault allegations. As described considerable scrutiny is being placed on the classification of these allegations.

On Duty – Irregularity in Procedure allegations have decreased by 25.9%.

Q of S, Lack of satisfaction with Action taken allegations have increased by 15.3%. There is no obvious cause for this and the matter will be monitored.

Page 8: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

7

13

16

8

6

17

3

2

15

30

30

7

5

23

16

4

11

8

22

1

1

6

7

0

Gross Misconduct

Misconduct ‐ Improvement Action

Misconduct ‐ No Action

Referred to Performance Regulations

Misconduct Investigation

Not Misconduct ‐ No Action

Not Misconduct ‐ ImprovementAction

Other Regs / Disposals

0 10 20 30 40

Misconduct Assessment YTD

NORTH WEST

EAST

2

1

7

1

1

3

1

1

1

4

2

3

Misconduct Meeting ‐ Not misconduct NFA

Misconduct Meeting ‐ Verbal Warning

Misconduct Meeting ‐ Written Warning

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Not Proven (2013 reg)

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Caution (2013 reg)

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Written Warning

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Final Written Warning

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Demotion in rank (2013 reg)

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Reduction in pay

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Officer resigned prior

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Officer required to resign

Misconduct Hearing ‐ Dismissal

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Misconduct Outcomes YTD

The PSD Conduct Unit have undertaken 258 preliminary assessments this year. These have resulted in 45 being assessed as either Gross Misconduct or meriting a misconduct investigation. To date 17 misconduct hearings and 10 misconduct meetings have taken place. This demonstrates that the majority of assessments result in less formal disposals, with a focus on individual and organisational learning.

The Conduct Unit are continuing to develop their processes through improved administration and auditing, all aimed at maximising consistency in the approach to preliminary assessment, ensuring that organisational learning is captured, leading to more effective outcomes.

There are currently 103 Police officers and 5 members of Police staff subject to Duty restrictions. 11 Police officers and 5 members of Police Staff are currently suspended from duty.

Page 9: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

26

3

24

7

24

0

44

239

8

27

62

24

48

26

40

860

39

55

Vulnerability

Theft and Fraud

Sexual Misconduct

Perverting the Course of Justice

Misuse of Force Systems

Infiltration

Inappropriate Association

Notifiable Association

Grievance

Organisational Risk

Performance

Inappropriate use social media

Disclosure of Information

Controlled Drug Use and Supply

Commit, Incite, Aid and Abet, assist…

Business Interest

Abuse of Authority

Other (Audit Requests, NCA Finance…

0 200 400 600 800 1000

Referrals Considered by National Gateway Assessment Unit

70

115

9

158

31

13

26

45

849

2

4

8

2

210

14

ACU Referral

Noted for Information Only

Advice & Guidance Briefing

Memo to Division for Progression

Other*

PSD Complaints

PSD Conduct

PSD Specialist Investigations

Business Interest

Alleagation Disproved

Allegation Malicious

Allegation Not Substantiated

Performance (Memo to Division)

Notifiable Associations

Ongoing Assessment

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900

National Gateway Assessment Unit - Outcomes

The Gateway Unit (GWU) has received more referrals since April 2018 than obtained in total for financial year 2017/18. For period: 01 April 2017 – 31 March 2018, the GWU received 1,165 referrals. To date for period: 01 April 2018 – 30 November 2018, the GWU has received 1,556 referrals.

This is predominately due to the introduction of the new Business Interest and Secondary Employment SOP, introduced in June 2018, which is currently sitting at 55.3% of the unit’s referrals. The referrals for this category are unlikely to increase by much over remainder of financial year with the majority of this work now concluded.

Page 10: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

10 

54

1

12

16

1

1

1

16

5

1

39

36

12

13

36

0

1

0

6

5

2

58

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

Disclosure of Information

Perverting the Course of Justice

Sexual Misconduct

Controlled Drug use and Supply

Theft

Misuse of Force Systems

Abuse of Authority

Inappropriate Association

Vulnerability

Commit, Incite, Aid and Abet, assist an offender in…

Other (*in 2018 as a result of the BISE SOP)

Referrals Received by ACU Intelligence

YTD PYTD

18

1

4

53

1

1

11

1

59

25

0

2

65

7

3

6

0

78

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

For info only

Notifiable Association ‐ Memo to Division

Referred to Division

Allegation not substantiated

Allegation Disproved

Miscellaneous

Referred to PSD

Management meeting ‐ Preventative Brief

Passed to ACU Operations

ACU Closure Categories

YTD PYTD

The Anti-Corruption Unit has instigated 24.8% more enquiries than LYTD (149LYTD to 186YTD). This is indicative of the referral and National Gateway Assessment Unit process becoming well established, following HMICS recommendations. The decline in Disclosure of Information and increase in Perverting the Course of Justice enquiries correlate to more detailed referrals being received which infer the Common Law Offence. The increase in Controlled Drugs Use and Supply and Perverting the Course of Justice, can be attributed to a more front facing and proactive engagement role being undertaken by the ACU. 

A total of 13 SOCGs are identified as having an involvement, or markers, in relation to corruption. These are rigorously reviewed and allocated to both Intelligence and Operations ACU staff to monitor and progress as appropriate. The threat of infiltration/ corruption is heightened by staff use of Social Media and use of open source resources. The Social Media SOP and Force memorandum have been issued reminding staff to protect themselves online. In addition, inputs to staff regarding the appropriate and safe use of social media platforms are ongoing.

Page 11: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

11 

126

14

1

460

176

24

238

92

14

1

378

166

36

167

Number of CHRs

Reconsideration Directions

Supervised Reconsideration Direction

Number of Allegations reviewed

Number of Recomendations

Number of learning Points

Number of Allegations handled to areasonable standard

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500

Complaint Handling Reviews (CHR)

YTD PYTD

0

6

29

29

2

25

75

64

0 20 40 60 80

Other

Record and / or respondto complaint

Further Enquiry

Fuller / further responserequired

PIRC Recommendations

YTD Q1

YTD PIRC have conducted 92 Complaint Handling Reviews, considering 378 separate allegations. Of these, PIRC found 167 to have been handled to a reasonable standard, issuing 166 recommendations and 36 learning points. The % of allegations found handled to a reasonable standard is 44.2% which is reduced from the same period last year of 51.7%. PSD are working with PIRC to improve this. Where PIRC have conducted a CHR, they can make recommendations to the Police which are broadly categorised in the adjacent table. Following a CHR, if the Commissioner is of the opinion that a complaint should be reconsidered, the Commissioner can issue a Reconsideration Direction and can instruct that this is under the Commissioners supervision.

During YTD, 15 CHRs resulted in Reconsideration Directions being issued by PIRC following a CHR, one of which was subject to the Commissioners supervision. These related to 36 separate allegations and the key themes relate to insufficient enquiry being conducted into the allegation (often statements not specifically addressing allegations) and the response not being well reasoned, sufficiently explaining policy procedure and determinations not being made using the balance of probabilities test.

Page 12: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

12 

83

17

66

0

159

35

119

5

Total Number ofReferrals

Investigations by PIRC

No Investigations byPIRC

Awaiting Decision byPIRC

0 50 100 150 200

PIRC Referrals

YTD PYTD

0

4

6

3

3

3

25

24

15

0

7

11

2

2

20

40

33

44

Complaints made against Constables (ACC…

Crown Directed

Death Following Police Contact

Death in Police Custody

Discharge of Police Firearm

Discharge of Police Firearm (Taser)

Presentation of Police Firearm

Serious Injury Following Police Contact

Serious Injury in Police Custody

0 10 20 30 40 50

PIRC Referral and Category

YTD PYTD

8

74

1

0

35

119

1

4

Live

Closed

At COPFS

Awating Decision by PIRC

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140

Investigative Status

YTD PYTD

The tables adjacent show the number, category of referrals and the current overall investigative status.

* Discharge of a Police Firearm relates to an incident where a baton round and Taser were deployed and a separate incident where a pyrotechnic device was used.

The increase in discharge of Tasers follows the introduction of Specially Trained Officers (STOs) who carry Taser. These figures to do not include PAVA discharge.

PIRC Operation Canisp (see Organisational Learning) has led to learning being shared regarding the referrals of all aspects of a firearms operation and that ‘off-aim’ firearm presentations will also be referred to PIRC.

The increases in Serious Injury following Police Contact and while in Police Custody relate generally to people jumping from height to evade Police, falling over when running from Police, Police Dog bites, Police vehicle RTCs, self-inflicted injuries and injuries through the use of force.

PSD are continuing to develop their processes and have improved consistency in the approach to PIRC referral.

Page 13: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

13 

ORGANISATIONAL LEARNING

Nature of learning

PIRC conducted an investigation regarding a Firearms Operation (Op Canisp), following which they made a number of recommendations, which included: ensuring that all officers in charge of, or who form part of any firearms operation apply the National Decision Models principles; Ensures that all ‘firearms incidents’ are referred to PIRC and adopts a system to ensure that ITFCs/TFCs are timeously sighted on all available information which may impact on decisions made.

Action

Ongoing good practice regarding the emphasis on the NDM has been supplemented by input regarding the NDM during the ongoing National Command refresher training program and a Tactical and Strategic Firearms Commander Forum has been established to share experience and learning.

The circumstances of Operation Canisp have been shared with the PSD On call cadre to ensure awareness and Armed Policing command are ensuring that all firearm presentations, including ‘Off Aim’ are referred to PIRC.

Further support has been afforded to ITFCs/TFCs in the form of loggist training to communications officers and an additional Constables Post on each shift (15 in total) who will aim to ensure that all available information is provided to ITFC/TFCs.

Page 14: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

14 

Nature of learning

PIRC have identified common themes of shortcomings in the complaint handling process which have recently included

The heads of complaint form should be completed to ensure a clear understanding of the allegations made

The final letter should state clearly whether an allegation is Upheld/ Not Upheld Any determination should be based on the balance of probabilities. Front Line resolution should not be attempted for complaints which cannot be assessed as ‘non-serious’.

Action

A learning bulletin around common complaint handling errors has been prepared for those involved in the complaint handling process. In a further effort to improve the proportion of complaints found handled to a reasonable standard, Police Scotland is working with PIRC who are assisting with presentations / workshops to complaint handlers. Furthermore, a bespoke one-day training course is being developed in-house for supervisors involved in complaint handling.

Page 15: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

15 

APPENDIX A – ALLEGATIONS RECEIVED BY DIVISION

309

537

573

492

89

87

77

19

60

280

490

493

385

70

44

59

23

49

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700

Forth valley

Edinburgh

Lothian and Scottish Borders

Fife

Contact, Command and Control

Custody

Operational Support Division

Corporate Functions

Specialist Crime

EAST - Allegations Received by Division

YTD PYTD

As previously detailed there has been an overall reduction in the number of allegations within the East in comparison to LYTD. The most significant reductions are within Custody and Fife Division, where allegations decreased by 49.4% and 21.7% respectively.

Page 16: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

16 

518

504

318

48

54

68

19

6

569

527

268

47

41

55

13

21

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

North East

Tayside

Highlands & islands

Contact, Command & Control

Custody

Operational Support Division

Corporate Functions

Specialist Crime

NORTH - Allegations Received by Division

YTD PYTD

As previously detailed the overall number of allegations within the North remains relatively unchanged in comparison to LYTD. This is an improvement on the previous quarter which recorded an increase in allegations of 5%. Specialist Crime, North East Divisions and Tayside have recorded an increase, respectively increasing by 250% (6 to 21), 9.8% and 4.6%.

Highlands & islands Division has recorded a 15.7% decrease in allegations which is a continuation of the 13% decrease recorded at Q1.

A review of allegation categories and complaints within those Divisions recording an increase could not find any clear explanation, however an organisational learning document, detailing common complaint themes has been circulated on the Police Scotland intranet page to address.

Page 17: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

17 

1125

280

241

651

299

271

92

167

123

38

38

956

185

236

596

280

176

65

89

56

32

73

0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200

Greater Glasgow

Renfrewshire and Inverclyde

Argyll and West Dunbartonshire

Lanarkshire

Ayrshire

Dumfries

Contact, Command & Control

Custody

Operational Support Division

Corporate Functions

Specialist Crime

WEST - Allegations Received by Division

YTD PYTD

As detailed there has been an overall significant decrease (17.5%) in the number of allegations within the West in comparison to LYTD. In particular Dumfries and Galloway (35%), Renfrewshire and Inverclyde (33.9%) and Greater Glasgow (15%) Divisions have recorded large reductions. Anecdotally this can be at least partly attributed to a greater awareness in local divisions of the primary causal factors which generate complaints.

Specialist Crime Division have recorded a 133% increase. A review of allegations within West SCD, could find no obvious pattern, trend or explanation with the breakdown of allegation types being similar to the national position. This will be monitored going forward.

Page 18: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

18 

APPENDIX B – ALLEGATIONS OF IRREGULARITY IN PROCEDURE - SUB CATEGORIES

1

13

350

79

61

96

625

54

131

28

39

615

129

196

293

89

120

15

39

60

0

13

214

86

61

74

591

34

101

20

40

523

118

128

266

68

98

14

36

19

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700

ASBO/Conditional Offer etc Issues

ABSO/Fixed Penalty procedures

Custody procedures / Care of prisoners

Disclosure of information (non criminal)

Forced entry to Premises

Inaccurate information placed on police systems

Insufficient enquiry carried out

Interview procedures

length of time taken to investigate / carry out enquiries

Method of Arrest / Detention

Officer did not provide name or shoulder number

Other

Productions / Lost & Found property

Provide insufficient explanation regarding police…

Provide insufficient updates to the complainer

Road Traffic procedures

Search procedures ‐ persons or property

Search procedures ‐ Stop and search

Statement taking

Vehicle recovery Scheme

Irregularity in Procedure - Sub Categories

YTD PYTD

The three most common sub-categories within Irregularity in procedure are Insufficient Enquiry (591), Insufficient Updates (266) and Custody/ Care of Prisoners (214). 523 allegations were recorded as Irregularity in Procedure – Other. A limited dip sample of these revealed that a number of these subjective allegations could have been recorded under other allegation sub-categories of Irregularity in Procedure.

The PSD training package delivered to PCSOs has been amended to include guidance addressing common complaints regarding the care and welfare of prisoners.

Page 19: PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS...This Performance Report is provided by Police Scotland for the information of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA) and details Professional Standards activity

OFFICIAL

19 

APPENDIX C – ALLEGATIONS OF DISCRIMINATORY BEHAVIOUR SUB CATEGORIES

1

8

2

3

29

5

0

10

2

3

23

3

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

Age

Disability

Faith

Gender

Race

Sexual Orientation

Discriminatory Behaviour - Sub Categories

YTD PYTD