project monitoring: a vicious cycle of donor accountability or a necessary stepping stone to better...
TRANSCRIPT
Project Monitoring: A vicious cycle of donor accountability or a necessary stepping stone to better national WASH sector monitoring?Harold LockwoodAguaconsult
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
“You can’t manage what you don’t measure”
Monitoring really does matter ….
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Country-led systems progressing• Aid effectiveness principles
and commitment (Paris +)• Country ownership and
leadership• Emergence of SWAps – 11
countries in Africa (AfDB, 2010)
• DP alignment with country systems (moderate progress)
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Comprehensive country-led systems are the goal
Common monitoring to improve performance• Historic trending• Benchmarking• Well informed decisions• Basis for sector learning• Consumer
empowerment
But many challenges remain
GLAAS 2011; 74 responding countries
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Is there a national monitoring system used to inform decision making?
No system in place
Under development
System in place and used
42%
16%
42%
Country-led monitoring remains weak
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
• Under-funded – low resource environment
• Challenges with decentralisation of responsibility for data collection and management
• Incompatibility between data systems at local government level
• Often low political priority
Development aid project monitoring
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
• Defined life-span (< 5 years) - not beyond ‘end of the project’
• Limited to ‘own projects’• Not aligned with national
monitoring frameworks or indicators (outside SWAp)
• Data flows ‘upwards and outwards’ to external DPs
Project monitoring
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Opportunities Challenges
• Innovative• Flexible• (often) well resourced• Quick cycles• Piloting
• Short-term• Temporary structures• Costly• Fragmented or duplicative initiatives
71% of European funding channelled through projects and programmesEU Water Initiative, Africa Working Group, 2008
The reality of project monitoring
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
• 1 region• 7 different funding
streams and monitoring requirements
• 1 national monitoring system
• Local government – marginalised
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Lending banks, bi-lateral donors and large multi-laterals:• Operate at scale
• Influence over policy and sector processes
• Can fund via SWAps or Direct Budgetary Support – but not all do so
Not all project monitoring is created equal
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Not all project monitoring is created equal
NGOs, foundations, charities and faith organisations:• Operate at varying scale - decentralised level
• Direct implementation and field research
• Advocacy and influence
• Direct (localised) funding
Accountability: the key driverWhy do we monitor? • To improve operational performance • To measure impact• To inform sector policy• To show progress and results• To see how funds are utilised
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Accountability: the key driver
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
For whom do we monitor? • Consumers and operators• Government technocrats• Policy makers and politicians• Civil society groups• Project staff• Funders of aid projects
Development partner dilemma: the vicious cycle of accountability
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
The virtuous cycle of country-led monitoring and accountability
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Development aid supports monitoring via
SWAps or other common mechanisms
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Project monitoring: a force for good • Triple-S service delivery indicators, Ghana• Piloted in 3 districts in 2010 - 12 • Integrated with DiMES of CWSA• Now being scaled up to 64 districts
!(
!(
!(!(!(
!(!(
!(!(!(!(!(!(!( !(
!(!(!(!(
!(!(!(!(
!(!(!(!( !(
!(!(
!(!(!(!(!(!(
!(
!(!(
!(!(!(
!(!(
!(
!(!(!(!(!(
!(
!(!(!(!(
!(
!(!(!(!(!(!(
!(!(
!(!(
!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(
!(!(
!( !(
!(
!(!(!(
!(
!(!(
!(!(!(!(
!(!(
!(
!(
!(!(
!(!( !(!( !(
!(!( !(!(!(!(
!(!(
!(
!(!(!( !(!(!(!(!(!(!(
!(!(!(
#*
#*
#*
#*
#*
#*
#*
#*
!!
!
Legend
! Salaga (District capital)
Piped system functionality
#* Functional
#* Non functional
#* Partially functional
Point source functionality
!( Functional
!( Non functional
!( Partially functional
!( broken down
Water
TripleSdistricts
East Gonja District
0 7 14 21 283.5Kilometers
No easy answers, but some critical questions
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
How can we align accountability of donor-driven project monitoring with support for country-led monitoring?
But, project monitoring is not going to go away (soon)
• How to incentivize donors to think (and fund) beyond the end of the project?
• How to better scale up and integrate innovation and learning into national frameworks?
• And, where there is no credible country-led monitoring framework, what do we do?
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Sessions in the ‘project monitoring stream’
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Tuesday 9th AprilSession 1: ‘Setting the scene’ (14:00 – 15:30)
• Government of Indonesia; experiences from WSP/World Bank supported monitoring
•AfDB strategy for M&E in Africa
Session 2: ‘Bi-lateral donors’ (16:00 – 17:30)• DGIS/Government of Netherlands; Sustainbility Check – experience from Mozambique
• USAID/USA; Sustainbility Index Tool – pilot experiences
Sessions in the ‘project monitoring stream’
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Wednesday 10th AprilSession 3: ‘NGO innovation’ (11:00 - 12:30)
•UTS/AusAID - multi-country/partner experiences
•MWA – multi-partner experiences, Ethiopia
•Water for People – local government perspective
•WASH Advocates – schools perspective
Session 4: ‘Joining hands with countries’ (14:00 - 15:30)Panel debate
Some warm up discussions
Monitoring Sustainable WASH Service Delivery Symposium
Turn to your immediate neighbour(s):
1. Do you recognize this tension between project monitoring and country-led monitoring?
2. How do you feel this can be best reconciled from a policy or practical perspective?
Discuss for 10 minutes or so