project: v4 institute framework, assets, support model...

Driven by…

Approved for Public Release V4i.us

Project: V4 Institute Framework, Assets, Support

INTRODUCTION

Project Description Identify and illustrate (through the other five V4I Launch Projects) the principles,

processes, and methods for improving the cradle-to-grave life cycle management of

systems based on virtual models, using the assets of the V4I Framework.

System of Interest SOI Pattern System 2: Life Cycle Management System

Question being Answered What are the elements of the V4I Framework, and how are they applied to improve the

virtual model-based life cycle management of systems?

EXPECTED BENEFITS

• Provide uniform metadata “wrapper” description of diverse models, across technologies, domains, modeling methods, originators, tools.

• Improve compatibility of models for enhanced machine exchange and integration along with enhanced cross-team understanding.

• Increase ability to re-use trusted models in the form of configured patterns.

• Enable the use of model VVUQ techniques for diverse models at multiple component and system levels.

• Coordinate and integrate product application, production, and distribution models.

• Improve understanding to plan, integrate, manage COTS computational model toolchains, life cycle management tools, infosystems.

• Provide robust, credible means to manage provenance of trusted models carrying investment in credibility, enhance model supply chains.

• Means of planning models and model based methods, and justifying investment in same.

• Exploit evolving capabilities of new modeling tools and technologies while preserving investment in historical model IP.

PROJECT APPROACH SUMMARY: The V4 Institute Framework

Configurable Information-Process-Automation reference framework:

• S*Metamodel, mapped to COTS tools, artifacts, processes

• System of Innovation Pattern (S1-S2-S3)

• Embedded Intelligence (EI) Pattern

• V4I Repository Pattern

• V4I Enterprise Pattern

• Model VVUQ Pattern

• General Manufacturing Pattern

• S*MBSE/PBSE Methodology

Estimated Project Duration:

• Aligned to Projects 1-5 Schedules

FUTURE WORK

• Support additional

V4I Projects, Targeted

Domains, Members

PROJECT TEAM

• ICTT System Sciences

• V4I Project Teams 1-5

3. System of Innovation (SOI)

2. Target System (and Component) Life Cycle Domain System

1. Target System

(Bracket)

LC Manager of

Target System

Learning & Knowledge

Manager for LC Managers

of Target System Life Cycle Manager of

LC Managers

Learning & Knowledge

Manager for Target

Systems

(Substantially all the ISO15288 processes are included in all four Manager roles) Target Environment

S*Metamodel for

Model-Based Systems

Engineering (MBSE)

State

Input/

Output

Interface

Functional

Interaction

(Interaction)System

System of

Access

attribute

Technical

Requirement

Statement

Stakeholder Feature

attribute

Design

Component

attribute

(physical system)

(logical system)

Functional

Role

attribute

Stakeholder

World

Language

High Level

Requirements

Technical

World

Language

attribute

Design

Constraint

Statement

attribute

Stakeholder

Requirement

Statement

BB

WBDetail Level

Requirements

High Level

Design

“B”

Coupling

“A”

Coupling

“C”

Coupling

Embedded Intelligence (EI)

Pattern Roles

MTSC

SOUC

MDSC

SOAC

Mtmt

Interac

tion

Management

System (MTS)

System of

Users (SOU)

Managed

System (MDS)

System of

Access (SOA)

Manages

EI Hierarchy

Repository Release

Roadmap

Persistent Model Repository

Model Scope and Content

Repository Service

Compatibility

Info Systems Compatibility

Model Life Cycle Management

Configurable

Repository

Deployment

Model Credibility

Support

Model-Based

Pattern Support

Fit to User and UseCommunity of Interest and

Teaming Support

Model Application Transaction Support

Legend:

Configurable

Model Pattern

Library

Domain Library

Support

Model

Verification

Support

Model Validation

Support

Advanced

Decision-Making

Support

HPC Infrastructure

Access Facilitation

HPCI TYPE

DOMAINRisk Visualization

Behavior

Visualization

STAKEHOLDER

FEATURE

FEATURE PK ATTRIBUTE

Selectable Value Option



Other Feature Attribute


Model-Based Representations Non-Model Representations

Supply Chain

Reverse Auction

Model Application

Development

Model VVUQ

Pattern Support

Built In

Guidance and

Education

Example ModelsHybrid Public-

Private Layered

Model Security

Collaboration

Support

V4I Model Repository (Digital

Commons) Pattern Features

Version: 1.2.9 Date: 07 Aug 2018 Drawn By: ICTT System Sciences

Notes:

• This pattern is a specialization of the S*Repository Pattern.

• A specific repository configuration may have a populated subset of the features of this pattern

framework.

• This is a Feature pattern describing the trade space for such repositories, but the appearance

of a Feature in the above model is no guarantee that it can be supported in an implemented

system, unless it appears in the configured Features for that system.

Repository System

Sustainability

Enterprise

Information System

Compatibility

SYSTEM ID

Interface

Technology

Compatibility

INTERFACE TECHNOLOGY

User Interface

Capability

UI CAPABILITY

Decision-Making

Support

Capability

DECISION TYPE

User Education

Feature

My Customizable

Repository

External

Information System

Compatibility

SYSTEM ID

Annotation

Feature

Learning Sharing

Feature

Issues

Submission and

Tracking Feature

User Experience

Feature

EXPERIENCE TYPE

EDUCATIONAL

CAPABILITY

Repository

Release

Deliverability

REPOSITORY RELEASE

Availability Date

System

Performance and

Capacity

RESPONSE CLASS

Response Time

Sessions Capacity

System Reliability

and Availability

SERVICE TYPE

Availability

MTBF

MTTR

System Security

Management

CapabilitySM CAPABILITY

System Fault

Management

CapabilityFM CAPABILITY

System Configuration

Management

CapabilityCM CAPABILITY

System Accounting

Management

CapabilityAM CAPABILITY

System Performance

Management

CapabilityPM CAPABILITY

Team

Identification

Feature

Modeling Tools

Compatibility

PLM Systems

Compatibility

Learning Tools

Compatibility

Simulation Tools

Compatibility

Engineering Tools

Compatibility

Supported User

Population

TARGET GROUP

Model Versioning

and Configuration

ManagementCM CAPABILIY TYPE

MBSE Pattern

Management

Feature

Cross-Domain

Enterprise

Model Support

Partner

Ecosystem

Access Feature

Consortium Asset

Member Access

Domain

Manufacturing Domain

Distribution Domain

Sustainment Domain

Innovation Domain

Marketing Domain

Application Domain

Model-Based

Artifact Generation

Feature

Multi-Level System

Model Support

Component Model

Support

System Framework

Integration for

Computational

Models

Model Planning

and Lifecycle

Management

Framework

Model Scope and

Content Support

Model Life Cycle

Management

Modeled System

Life Cycle Support

Application

LC MANAGEMENT CAPABILITY

Data Driven

Model Support

Physics Based

Model Support

Trusted

Configurable Pattern

CONTENT AREA

External BehaviorExplanatory Decomposition

Failure Modes & Effects

Data-Driven Predictor

Parametric Couplings, Fitness

Parametric Couplings, DecompositionParametric Couplings, Characterization

Fitness & Value

Physical Architecture

External

References

Access

LIFE CYCLE PROCESS

SUPPORTED (ISO15288)

Stakeholder Needs, Requirements DefnSystem Requirements Definition

Requirements Validation

Architecture Definition

Design Definition

Verification by Analysis & Simulation

System Analysis

Business, Mission Analysis

Project Assessment & ControlDecision Management

Configuration Management

Risk Management

Quality Assurance Process

Information Management

Project Planning

Model

Representation

Transformation

DEVEL CAPABILITY

Regulated

Domain

Framework

IntegrationVerification by Test

Solution Validation

Acquisition

Supply

Implementation

Project Portfolio ManagementInfrastructure Management

Life Cycle Model Management

Human Resource Management

Quality Management

Knowledge Management Process

Measurement

Conceptual Model

Representation

Executable Model

Representation

Conceptual Model Representation Type

Conceptual Model Interoperability

Executable Model Representation Type

Executable Model Interoperability

Model UQ

Support

Pattern Archetype

Model Support

Model Dataset

Support

User Standards

Compliance

STANDARDS AREA

Development Cost

Development Risk

Pattern

Configuration

Generation

Accessibility

Persistent

Repository

Service

Entry Methods

Extraction

Methods

Collaboration

Merge vs. Git Hub

Cost of Use

Model

Representation

Linearization

Document

Computational

Model – System

Model Integration

Private Intranet

Configuration

Hybrid

Configuration

Shared

Community

Configuration

Cloud Service

Configuration

Model Semantic Compatibility

Adaptability to

Model Semantics

Metadata

Integration

Capability

Adaptability to

Information

Systems

SEMANTICS TYPE

Repository

Transactions

Support

External System

Transactions

Integration

TRANSACTION TYPE

TRANSACTION TYPE

Collaboration Tools

Compatibility

Database

DOCUMENT TYPE

Database Type

Capacity

Availability

Persistence

SERVICE INSTANCE

Repository

Organization

ORGANIZATION CAPABILITY

Model Portfolio

Management

PORTFOLIO CAPABILITY

Change Managed

Content

Model Life Cycle

Governance

Schema and

Ontology

Mapping

API Support

Interface Support

Assimilation AIds

Model Configuration

Item Identification

and Management

COTS Platform

Support

Model

Maintenance

Event Service

Technical

Compatibility

Standards

Compliance

External System

Relying

Stakeholder

STAKEHOLDER

Regulatory Entity

REGULATOR

API TYPE

INTERFACE TYPE

Satisfaction

User Experience

Feedback

Support

Model

Provenance

Management

STANDARD

Storefront

LicensingFeedback

Legend:

Target System Features

Target System

Production, Distribution,

& Support FeaturesNetworked Ecosystem Features

Management & Membership Advancement

Talent Development & Education Features

V&V State of the Art

Standards and Regulatory Compliance

Validation of Target System Requirements

Facilitation & Management Features

Risk Management Features

Modeling and Simulation Capability FeaturesVerification of Target System Design

Verification

Education Service

Requirements

Satisfaction

Verification

VERIFICATION CAPABILITY

Risk Management

of Virtual Model

Utilization

V4I Security

Management

Multi-Level System

Verification

Model

Compatibility /

Interoperabiity

Configurable

System Pattern

Library

Application

Environment

Familiarity

Technology

Familiarity

V&V Industry

Partner Capability

Regional Talent

Base Advancement

Professional

Society Partnership

ISO 15288

Life Cycle

Compatibility

MBSE

Compatibility

Configuration

Management

V4I Stakeholder

Feature Model

Version: 2.3.3Date:

10 May 2018

Drawn By:

ICTT System Sciences

V4I System 3 Features

Model Verification

Service

Model Validation

Service

Certifier Partnership

Capability

Model Support for

Target System

Risk Management

Collaboration &

Networking Forum

External Trends

Identification &

Learning

Sounding Board

Resource to

Regulator

Verification

References and

Best Practices

Model Support for

Standard and

Regulatory Compliance

HPC Infrastructure

Access FacilitationV4I Membership

Feature

EDUCATION CAPABILITY

Product System

Performance

Feature

Modeled

Production System

Feature

Modeled

Distribution System

Feature

Internal V4I Process

Identification &

Improvement

V4I Research and

Advancement

MEMBER TYPE

System 1 Features

MODELING STANDARDSTANDARD

MSRM CAPABILITY

CAPABILITY

TECHNOLOGY

TYPE

MRM CAPABILITY

APPLICATION DOMAIN

Product Component

Performance

Feature

Institute Performance

Improvement

Institute Model

Release

Behavior

Visualization

Requirements

Validation

Institute

PerformanceIMPROVEMENT CAPABILITY

Requirements

Readiness for

Design Verification

Supplier

Development &

Qualification

PROF SOCIETYPARTNER TYPESUPPLIER TYPE

V4I STAKEHOLDER

FEATURE

Supplier

Management

Fidelity

Cost

Time

Environmental

Model

Product Operational

Environment

Feature

Modeled Support

System Feature

Direct Automated Verification Test

Product Virtual Verification

Process Virtual Verification

Hardware in Loop Test

Software in Loop Test

Fault Tolerant Design Verification

Verification Results Analysis

Direct Manual Verification Test







Verification Readiness Assessment

Verification Trust Assurance

Design Space Exploration

Change Impact Analysis

Pattern-Based Verification

Prognostics

Verification Planning

Educational Reference

Conference Production

Educational Case Study

Educational Workshop

Internship-Apprenticeship

Educational Course

Tier 2 Membership

Tier 3 Membership

Tier 1 Membership

Configurable

System Pattern

Learning

NCSA

Big Red

Notre Dame

DMDII DMC

Purdue

OSC

TR Level

Client Model

Internalization

Service

Peer Review

Service

VV Workshop for Regulators

Model

Assumptions

Description Feature

RELEASE ID

In Service Date

STAKEHOLDER GROUP

Stakeholder Satisfaction

Client Enterprise

Regional Community

Local Government

State Government

State Government

V4I Sponsor-Investory

V4I Member

Certifying Authority

V4I Employee

V4I Contractor

V4I Service Provider

V4I Tooling Provider

Regulatory Agency

Model & Pattern

Portfolio

Management

Model and

Simulation Type

Capability

Data and Data

Sourcing Type

Capability

M&S TYPE DATA & SOURCE TYPE

Modeling and

Model VVUQ

Standards Support

ISO PROCESS AREA

System Transition

System Validation

System Operation

System Maintenance

System Disposal

System Acquisition Process

System Supply Process

System Verification

Infrastructure Management

Portfolio Management

Human Resource Management

Quality Management

Knowledge Management

Life Cycle Model Management

Stakeholder Needs & Reqs Definition

System Requirements Definition

System Architecture Definition

System Design Definition

System Analysis

System Implementation

System Integration

Business or Mission Analysis

Project Assessment and Control

Decision Management

Risk Management

Configuration Management

Information Management

Measurement

Project Planning

Quality Assurance

ASME VV20: Computational Fluid Dynamics and Heat Transfer

ASME VV30: Nuclear System Thermal Fluids

ASME VV40: Medical Devices

ASME VV50: Advanced Manufacturing

ASME VV60: Energy Systems, Non-nuclear

ASME VV10: Computational Solid Mechanics

VALIDATION CAPABILITY

Validation Readiness Assessment

Validation Planning

Validation Review

Validation Confirmation

Model Supported Risk Review

Model Supported Risk Control

Model Supported Risk Management Tools

Model Supported Risk Visualization

Model Supported Risk Assessment

Model Supported Decision Making

Review of Model Use Risk

Control of Model Use Risk

Tools for Model Use Risk Management

Communication of Model Use Risk

Assessment of Model Use Risk

Decision Making About Model Use

Model Data Security Management

Model VVUQ Capability Assessment

Legend:

Model Representation

Model Scope and ContentModel Credibility

Model Identity and Focus

Model Life Cycle Management

Model Utility

Modeled

Stakeholder

Value

Model Intended

Use

LIFE CYCLE PROCESS SUPPORTED

(ISO15288)

Perceived Model

Value and Use

Verified

Executable

Model Credibility

Modeled System

External (Black

Box) Behavior

Stakeholder Feature Model

for Computational Models

Version: 1.5.4 Date: 31 Aug 2017Drawn By:

B Schindel

Modeled System

of Interest

Modeled

Environmental

Domain

Conceptual Model

Representation

Executable

Model

Representation

Managed Model

Datasets

Executable Model

Environmental

Compatibility

Validated

Conceptual

Model CredibilityQuantitative Accuracy ReferenceQuantitative Accuracy Reference

STAKEHOLDER

FEATURE




Parametric

Couplings--

Fitness

Physical

Architecture

Explanatory

DecompositionModel Envelope

Trusted

Configurable

Pattern

Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) Reference

Function Structure Accuracy ReferenceFunction Structure Accuracy Reference

Model Validation Reference Speed

Quantization

Stability

Model Validation Reference

Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) Reference

Third Party

AcceptanceModel Ease of

Use

Model

Design Life Cycle

and Retirement

Model

Maintainability

Model

DeployabilityModel Cost

Model

Availability

Model Versioning

and Configuration

Management

System of Interest Domain Type

MODEL APPLICATION ENVELOPE

CONFIGURATION ID

Conceptual Model Representation Type

Conceptual Model Interoperability

Executable Model Representation Type

Executable Model Interoperability

USER GROUP SEGMENT

Level of Annual Use

Value Level

ACCEPTING AUTHORITY Perceived Model Complexity

CM CAPABILIY TYPE

DATASET TYPE

IT ENVIRONMENTAL COMPONENT Design Life

Maintenance Method Deployment Method Development Cost

Operational Cost

Maintenance Cost

Deployment Cost

Retirement Cost

Life Cycle Financial Risk

First Availability Date

First Availability Risk

Life Cycle Availability Risk

STAKEHOLDER TYPE

Parametric

Couplings--

Decomposition

Parametric

Couplings--

Characterization

Pattern Type

VVUQ Pattern

Learning

VVUQ PATTERN EXCEPTION

VVUQ Pattern Version

Project

Impacted VVUQ Feature

Person

Failure Modes

and Effects

Metamodel for

Model-Based Systems

Engineering (MBSE)

Pattern Hierarchy for

Pattern-Based Systems

Engineering (PBSE)

Pattern Class Hierarchy

Individual Product

or System Configurations

Product Lines or

System Families

General System Pattern

Pattern-Based Systems

Engineering (PBSE)

Processes

Pattern Management

Process

Pattern Configuration

Process

(Projects,

Applications)

Pa

ttern

s

Le

arn

ing

s

Configure,

Specialize

Pattern

Improve

Pattern

State

Input/

Output

Interface

Functional

Interaction

(Interaction)System

System of

Access

attribute

Technical

Requirement

Statement

Stakeholder Feature

attribute

Design

Component

attribute

(physical system)

(logical system)

Functional

Role

attribute

Stakeholder

World

Language

High Level

Requirements

Technical

World

Language

attribute

Design

Constraint

Statement

attribute

Stakeholder

Requirement

Statement

BB

WBDetail Level

Requirements

High Level

Design

“B”

Coupling

“A”

Coupling

“C”

Coupling

S*Metamodel SOI S*Pattern: S1-S2-S3 EI (Mgmt) S*Pattern V4 Institute S*Pattern V4 Repository S*Pattern

Model VVUQ S*Pattern (Metadata Wrapper) Manufacturing S*Pattern Pattern-Based Systems Engineering

project: v4 institute framework, assets, support model...

Documents