promoting low impact development - utct.org page/promoting low... · why low impact development? -...

79
Promoting Low Impact Development Sustainable Stormwater Management Anthony Kendrick, ENV SP Director, Green Infrastructure Design I Protect I Sustain

Upload: others

Post on 23-Jun-2020

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Promoting Low Impact DevelopmentSustainable Stormwater Management

Anthony Kendrick, ENV SP

Director, Green Infrastructure

Design I Protect I Sustain

Page 2: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

I

Stormwater

Page 3: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 4: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Low Impact Development

• Exceeds Local Water Quality Requirements

• Eases Burden on Support Entities

• Prevents Downstream Erosion

• Mitigates Flash Flooding

• Aesthetically Appealing

• Mimics Nature

• Absorbs Greenhouse Gasses

• Solves Tough Engineering Challenges

Page 5: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

But Do Developers Care?

Why Should Developers Care?

Page 6: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

The Golden Circle

Page 7: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

WHY

HOW

WHAT Deliverables

Beliefs

Vision

Page 8: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 9: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 10: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

HOW

WHAT

Page 11: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

“We Sell Great Computers at a Competitive Price"

Page 12: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 13: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

HOW

WHAT

Page 14: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

"In everything we do, we believe in challenging the status quo"

Page 15: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

We Must Start With WHY

Page 16: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

But Do Developers Care?

Developers Don’t Care About What The Deliverables Are…

Page 17: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

But Do Developers Care?

…Not At First

Page 18: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

But Do Developers Care?

But Yet That’s All We Talk About

Page 19: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 20: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

But Do Developers Care?

Developers Don’t Care About How You Do It…

Page 21: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

But Do Developers Care?

Developers Primarily Care About WHY They Should Do It…

Page 22: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

WHY Low Impact Development

• Increased Lot Yield

• Lower Overall Cost of Development

• Increased Revenue

• No Design Delays / No Construction

Delays

Page 23: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

LID WHY

“To Provide Developers With an Ecologically SustainableWater Management Solution That Positively Impacts Their Bottom Line; Through Creativity, Innovation &

Collaboration, Together We Can Build a Future”

Page 24: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Story Telling WHY

Page 25: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Birnamwood Drive – Harris County

WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT?

- Reduced Construction Costs- Reduced Maintenance Costs- Safety- Practice What We Preach- Proof of Concept

Page 26: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Birnamwood Drive – Economics

1-Mile Long 4 lane Concrete Boulevard with Median

Traditional (estimated) LID (actual)

Site Prep & Earthwork $391,634.00 $449,060.00

Drainage $400,000.00 $288,432.00

SWPPP $69,600.00 $87,000.00

Landscape Planting $30,000.00 $66,140.00

Landscpe warranty/Maint $0.00 $34,630.00

Bridge $208,517.00 $208,517.00

Subgrade & Paving $1,139,791.00 $1,139,791.00

Traffic $9,000.00 $9,000.00

Signing & Striping $25,461.00 $25,461.00

Traffic Signal $128,010.00 $128,010.00

Utilities $16,140.00 $16,140.00

Extra Work Items $15,650.00 $36,650.00

Biofiltration System $0.00 $132,931.00

SWQ System $30,000.00 $0.00

Detention Basin $350,000.00 $0.00

Total $2,813,803.00 $2,621,762.00

estimated cost benefit: $192,041.00 7% Cost Reduction Per Mile

Page 27: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Easton Commons – New Quest Property

WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT?

- Economics- Economics- Economics- Economics- Economics- Economics- Economics

Page 28: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Easton Commons – Economics

WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT?

- Economics- Economics- Economics- Economics- Economics- Economics- Economics

Underground Detention:Required Storage – 27,950 CFCost Per CF - $9.50 to $12.00 CF

Cost of System - $280,000

Page 29: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Easton Commons – Economics

Page 30: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Easton Commons – Economics

Page 31: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Queenston Manor Apartments –

Academy Development Corp.

WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT?

- Economics- Aesthetics- Maintenance

Page 32: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Queenston Manor Apartments - Economics

Page 33: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

• Biofiltration

• Underground storage

•Pervious pavement (parking)

• Bioswales

Queenston Manor Apartments - Economics

Page 34: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Queenston Manor Apartments - Economics

Hard Costs

• 7 Acres @ .35 ACFT/AC = 106,000 CF

Integrated Design Approach

• 43,560 SF Porous Pavers @ $12 SF = $522,720 (-$217,800) = $304,920

• 21,000CF UG Detention / Drainage @ $6 = $126,000 (-$50,000)= $76,000

• 600 SF Biofiltration System @ $100 SF = $60.000

• 50,000 CF @ $.50 CF (Bioswale Excavation & Hauloff) = $25,000

• 2,500 SY Sod @ $1.30SY = $3,250

Total Cost = $469,170

Opportunity Seized – ROI = 10 Months

Page 35: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Queenston Manor Apartments - Economics

Page 36: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Maple Court – Palt, Inc

WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT?

- Economics- Aesthetics

Page 37: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Maple Court – Palt, Inc

Page 38: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Maple Court – Palt, Inc

Page 39: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

HOW - Beliefs

“We must be disciplined in our core values”

Page 40: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Having a Clear Message in HOW

“Low Impact Development”

“Green Infrastructure”

“Multifunctional Design”

Page 41: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

The Future is Multifunctional

• Pavements

• Landscapes

• Drainage

• Rooftops

Page 42: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 43: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

What’s The Cost Per Square Foot?

Page 44: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 45: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

What’s The REAL Cost Per Square Foot?

Page 46: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 47: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 48: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics
Page 49: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Mimic Predevelopment Hydrology

Page 50: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Would Multifunctional Design…

Page 51: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Time of Flow to Outlet = 3 Minutes Time of Flow to Outlet = 15 Minutes

Slow It Down, Spread It Out, Soak It In

Page 52: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Convey It

Page 53: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Filter It, (Harvest It?) & Let It Go

Page 54: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Resilient Design

Site

Overflow

High Performance

Engineered Filter

LID Elements

Bio-swales: 3 Units

Volume=125,000 CuFt

HPMBS Area = 330 SF

Wetland Pond Storage

Page 55: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Resilient Design

Page 56: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Resilient Design – Tax Day > 16”

Page 57: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Resilient Design– Harvey > 29”

Page 58: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Resilient Design– Harvey > 29”

Page 59: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Resilient Design– Harvey > 29”

Page 60: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

HOW - Beliefs

“We must be disciplined in our core values”

Page 61: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

WHY LID

HOW

WHAT

Page 62: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

What - Deliverables

“We must be consistent in our deliverables”

Page 63: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Delivering on a Promise

• Verify Performance

• Understand Maintenance Requirements

• Be Clear About Maintenance Budget

• Discuss Life-Cycle Costs

• Keep It As Simple As Possible

• Have a Post Construction Plan / Budget

Page 64: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Silt Happens

Page 65: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Silt Happens

Page 66: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Performance Verification

Page 67: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Performance Verification

Page 68: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Performance Verification

Page 69: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Maintenance Requirements

Page 70: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Maintenance Requirements

Page 71: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Maintenance Requirements

Page 72: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Maintenance Requirements

Page 73: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Performance Dictates Maintenance

Page 74: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Planting Dictates Maintenance

Page 75: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Planting Dictates Maintenance

Page 76: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Post Construction Plan

Page 77: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

WHY

HOW

WHAT

Page 78: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Delivering on a Promise

• Verify Performance

• Understand Maintenance Requirements

• Be Clear About Maintenance Budget

• Discuss Life-Cycle Costs

• Keep It As Simple As Possible

• Have a Post Construction Plan / Budget

Page 79: Promoting Low Impact Development - utct.org Page/Promoting Low... · WHY LOW IMPACT DEVELOPMENT? - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics - Economics

Questions?

Anthony Kendrick, ENV SPDirector, Green Infrastructurewww.ecosvs.com214.701.2117

THANK YOU!