properties of metallic helimagnets
TRANSCRIPT
UMD 1
Properties of Metallic HelimagnetsKwan-yuet HoInstitute for Physical Science and Technology & Department of PhysicsUniversity of Maryland
Apr 3rd, 2012
UMD 2
OutlineHelimagnets (Introduction)Model and Energy ScalesPhase DiagramGoldstone ModesElectronic PropertiesColumnar Phase and SkyrmionsConclusion
UMD 3
HelimagnetsHelimagnets: materials
exhibiting helimagnetism in one of the phases.
In helimagnetism, there is ferromagnetic order on each plane.
The direction of the spin rotates as one goes along the helix.
Low-temperature systemq-1 >> aExamples: MnSi, FeGe,
FexCo1-xSi
For MnSi,Lattice constant: 4.56ÅHelical wavelength: 180ÅOrdering temperature: 29.5KResistivity ~ 0.33μΩ cm (T=0)
(kFl~6000)
(Ishikawa, Tajima, Bloch, Roth 1976)(Pfleiderer, Julian, Lonzarich 2001)
(Bauer et al 2010)
q
(Uchida, Onose, Matsui, Tokura 2006)
UMD 4
HelimagnetsHelimagnets
generally have richer phase diagrams than the other magnets.
Helimagnets are sensitive to a change of pressure. Helical order is destroyed at high pressures.
Universal quantum fluctuations lead to the tricritical point (TCP).
(Thessieu et al 1997)
(Pfleiderer, Julian, Lonzarich 2001)
(Kirkpatrick, Belitz, Vojta 1997)Experimental Phase Diagrams of MnSi
UMD 5
HelimagnetsAn exotic columnar
phase (A phase) at T≈Tc and intermediate H.
Six-fold symmetry was found in neutron scattering.
It is a 2D hexagonal columnar lattice, confirmed by Lorentz TEM images.
Believed to be a Skyrmion lattice.
(Mühlbauer et al 2009)
MnSi
(Yu et al 2010)Fe0.5Co0.5Si(For MnSi, see Mühlbauer et al 2009; for FeGe, see Yu et al 2010; for Fe0.5Co0.5Si, see Yu et al 2010)
UMD 6
HelimagnetsHelimagnets
generally have richer phase diagrams than the other magnets.
Helimagnets are sensitive to a change of pressure. Helical order is destroyed at higher pressures.
Universal quantum fluctuations lead to the tricritical point (TCP).
(Thessieu et al 1997)
(Pfleiderer, Julian, Lonzarich 2001)
(Kirkpatrick, Belitz, Vojta 1997)Experimental Phase Diagrams of MnSi
UMD 7
HelimagnetsThe disordered phase at p>pc has
a non-Fermi-liquid (NFL) transport properties that Δρ~T3/2.
(Pfleiderer, Julian, Lonzarich 2001)
UMD 8
HelimagnetsThese properties are due to the huge
fluctuations.Like cholesteric liquid crystals, a pure
helimagnet has a Goldstone mode (called helimagnon) with “transverse” susceptibility χ┴
-1~k||2+ck┴
4.◦True helimagnetic long-range order cannot
exist in d=3.Like columnar phases in liquid crystals,
columnar phase in helimagnets have a fluctuation spectrum k┴
2+ckz4.
(Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rosch 2006)
(Kirkpatrick & Belitz 2010)
UMD 9
OutlineHelimagnets (Introduction)Model and Energy ScalesPhase DiagramGoldstone ModesElectronic PropertiesColumnar Phase and SkyrmionsConclusion
UMD 10
Model and Energy ScalesFerromagnets can be described
by the LGW functional.
€
SFM M[ ] = d3xr2M2 +
a2∇M( )2 +
u4M2( )
2 ⎡ ⎣ ⎢
⎤ ⎦ ⎥∫
(Heisenberg 1930s)
UMD 11
Model and Energy ScalesTo stabilize a
helimagnet over a ferromagnet, Dzyaloshinski-Moriya (DM) interaction is needed.
Spin-orbit coupling constant: gso(dimensionless) c=akFgso
It exists in systems with no inversion symmetry.
€
S M[ ] = SFM M[ ] +c2
d3x M⋅ ∇ ×M( )∫
DM interaction(Dzyaloshinski 1958, Moriya 1960)
B20 cubic crystal, P213
gso ≈ 0.05 for MnSi
UMD 12
Model and Energy ScalesLGW functional
€
SFM M[ ] = d3xr2M2 +
a2∇M( )2 +
u4M2( )
2−H⋅M
⎡ ⎣ ⎢
⎤ ⎦ ⎥∫
€
SDM M[ ] =c2
d3x M⋅ ∇ ×M( )∫
€
Scf M[ ] = d3xb2∂iM i[ ]
2+b1
2∂iM i+1[ ]
2+v4M i
4 ⎡ ⎣ ⎢
⎤ ⎦ ⎥
i=1
3
∑∫€
S M[ ] = SFM M[ ] + SDM M[ ] + Scf M[ ]
c~gso b, b1 ~gso2 q=c/2a~gso
(Ho, Kirkpatrick, Sang, Belitz 2010)
gso <<1
Cubic anisotropyPinning
(Bak & Jenson 1980)Space group P213
(Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rosch 2006)v ~gso
4
O(gSO0)
O(gSO2)
O(gSO4)
UMD 13
OutlineHelimagnets (Introduction)Model and Energy ScalesPhase DiagramGoldstone ModesElectronic PropertiesColumnar Phase and SkyrmionsConclusion
UMD 14
Phase DiagramMean-field theoryH=0: pinned helical
phase, q in (1,1,1) for b<0, |b|~gso
2
M(x)=msp [cos(q.x)e1+sin(q.x)e2]
0<H<Hc1: q rotates from (1,1,1) to H
M acquires a homogeneous component along H
Elliptical conical phase near Hc1
(Ho, Kirkpatrick, Sang, Belitz 2010)
(Ishikawa, Tajima, Bloch, Roth 1976)
MnSi
UMD 15
Phase DiagramHc1 < H < Hc2: conical
phaseq aligns with HM(x)=msp
[cos(qz)x+sin(qz)y] + m//z
When H increases, msp decreases and m// increases.
msp vanishes at H=Hc2Columnar phase: 2D
hexagonal lattice of columns
UMD 16
Phase Diagram
(Thessieu et al 1997)
MnSi
(Ishimoto et al 1995)
Fe0.8Co0.2Si
UMD 17
OutlineHelimagnets (Introduction)Model and Energy ScalesPhase DiagramGoldstone ModesElectronic PropertiesColumnar Phase and SkyrmionsConclusion
UMD 18
Goldstone ModesA pure helimagnet breaks the continuous
translational symmetry Goldstone mode unusual electronic properties through electron-Goldstone-mode coupling
M(x)=msp (cos[qz+ϕ(x)], sin[qz+ϕ(x)],0)Energy fluctuations ~ ∫d3x [∇ϕ(x)]2 wrong,
because free energy is independent of the direction of q. Perpendicular fluctuations should not cost extra energy.
The next available order of perpendicular fluctuation ~ ∫d3x [∇⊥
2ϕ(x)]2 Fluctuation energy ~ ∫d3x {[∂zu(x)]2 + c[∇⊥
2u(x)]2}, leading to Goldstone mode kz
2+ck┴4
(Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rosch 2006)
UMD 19
Goldstone ModesMagnetic field and small crystal
field effects (~gSO4) make the
Goldstone mode less soft.For conical phase, χ┴
-
1~kz2+H2k┴
2+ck┴4
For pinned helical phase, χ┴-
1~kz2+|b| k┴
2+ck┴4
(Ho, Kirkpatrick, Sang, Belitz 2010)
UMD 20
Goldstone ModesThere are two
Goldstone modes in columnar phase, as the translational symmetry breaking is on a plane.
By similar argument, the Goldstone modes have the spectrum χ┴
-
1~k┴2+c’kz
4
Disordered columnar phase has one Goldstone mode of the same spectrum.
(Kirkpatrick & Belitz 2010)
UMD 21
OutlineHelimagnets (Introduction)Model and Energy ScalesPhase DiagramGoldstone ModesElectronic PropertiesColumnar Phase and SkyrmionsConclusion
UMD 22
Electronic PropertiesSpecific heat:
Helimagnon: C(T) ~ T2
Columnar phase: C(T) ~ T5/2(Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rosch 2006)
(Kirkpatrick & Belitz 2010)(Ho, Kirkpatrick, Sang,
Belitz 2010)
UMD 23
Electronic PropertiesSingle-particle relaxation rate:
Helimagnons (k||~T, k┴~T1/2): τ-1~ T3/2 (clean); τ-1~ T (ballistic disorder)
Columnar phase (k||~T1/2, k┴~T): τ-1~ T2 (clean); τ-1~ T3/2 (ballistic disorder)
(Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rosch 2006)
(Ho, Kirkpatrick, Sang, Belitz 2010)
(Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rosch 2006)
(Kirkpatrick & Belitz 2010)
UMD 24
Electronic PropertiesTransport relaxation rate:
Helimagnons (k||~T, k┴~T1/2): τ-1~ T5/2 (clean); τ-1~ T (ballistic disorder)
Columnar phase (k||~T1/2, k┴~T): τ-1~ T3 (clean); τ-1~ T3/2 (ballistic disorder)
(Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rosch 2006)
(Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rosch 2006)
(Ho, Kirkpatrick, Sang, Belitz 2010)
(Kirkpatrick & Belitz 2010)
UMD 25
Electronic PropertiesIn ballistic disorder, both
relaxation rates of the columnar phase show T3/2-dependence.
The NFL phase that has electrical resistivity T3/2 might be a liquid of columns.
UMD 26
OutlineHelimagnets (Introduction)Model and Energy ScalesPhase DiagramGoldstone ModesElectronic PropertiesColumnar Phase and SkyrmionsConclusion
UMD 27
Columnar Phase and SkyrmionsColumnar phase:
believed to be a Skyrmion lattice
Skyrmion: a topological object
Winding number: W=(1/4π)∫d2x (n.∂xn×∂yn), where n=M/|M|.
n = (-2yl, 2xl, (x2+y2-l2))/(x2+y2+l2), in σ model.
Algebraic decay at large distances
Size: believed to be q-1
W=-1(Pfleiderer & Rosch 2010)
(Abanov & Prokrovsky 1998; Belavin & Polyakov 1975)
(Skyrme 1961)
UMD 28
Columnar Phase and Skyrmionsn(x)=-sinθ(ρ)φ
+cosθ(ρ) zCore size R, defined
by core behavior θ(ρ) = π (1-ρ/R)
Tail length lT, defined by the long-range tail exponential decay length exp(-ρ/lT).
Matching length L as the size. (Ho, Kirkpatrick, Belitz 2011)
lT
(Röβler, Leonov, Bogdanov 2011) θ: polar angle between the spin direction and the ferromagnet
UMD 29
Columnar Phase and Skyrmions
The Skyrmion size is not always q-1, but it is the result of the competition of different length scales, e.g., correlation lengths, magnetic length, q-1
(Ho, Kirkpatrick, Belitz 2011)
UMD 30
Columnar Phase and SkyrmionsT~Tc, intermediate H:
columnar phase (A phase)
Believed to be 2D hexagonal columnar Skyrmion lattice
With some efforts, it can be derived from LGW functional
Core-to-core distance in a Skyrmion lattice ~ qξp
2 ~ (c/a) (a/r) ~ c/r
(Ho, Kirkpatrick, Belitz 2011)(Mühlbauer et al 2009)
(Han, Zang, Yang, Park, Nagaosa, 2010)
UMD 31
OutlineHelimagnets (Introduction)Model and Energy ScalesPhase DiagramGoldstone ModesElectronic PropertiesColumnar Phase and SkyrmionsConclusion
UMD 32
ConclusionHelimagnets are more favored than
ferromagnetism through DM interaction.Helimagnets have a richer phase diagram
than other magnets in general.Helimagnets have softer Goldstone
modes, resulting in huge fluctuations and special electronic properties.
The size of Skyrmions in helimagnets is the result of competition of various physical length scales.
UMD 33
AcknowledgmentsTheodore Kirkpatrick (UMD)Dietrich Belitz (UOregon)Yan Sang (UOregon)