proving driver fatigue in trucking and commercial vehicle...
TRANSCRIPT
Proving Driver Fatigue in Trucking and
Commercial Vehicle Accidents: Federal and
State Laws, Evidentiary Concerns
Today’s faculty features:
1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific
The audio portion of the conference may be accessed via the telephone or by using your computer's
speakers. Please refer to the instructions emailed to registrants for additional information. If you
have any questions, please contact Customer Service at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 1.
TUESDAY, MARCH 5, 2019
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A
Lawrence M. (Larry) Simon, Of Counsel, Javerbaum Wurgaft Hicks Kahn Wikstrom & Sinins, New York
Matthew Wright, Founder, Wright Law, Franklin, Tenn.
Tips for Optimal Quality
Sound Quality
If you are listening via your computer speakers, please note that the quality
of your sound will vary depending on the speed and quality of your internet
connection.
If the sound quality is not satisfactory, you may listen via the phone: dial
1-866-869-6667 and enter your PIN when prompted. Otherwise, please
send us a chat or e-mail [email protected] immediately so we can address
the problem.
If you dialed in and have any difficulties during the call, press *0 for assistance.
Viewing Quality
To maximize your screen, press the F11 key on your keyboard. To exit full screen,
press the F11 key again.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Continuing Education Credits
In order for us to process your continuing education credit, you must confirm your
participation in this webinar by completing and submitting the Attendance
Affirmation/Evaluation after the webinar.
A link to the Attendance Affirmation/Evaluation will be in the thank you email
that you will receive immediately following the program.
For additional information about continuing education, call us at 1-800-926-7926
ext. 2.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Program Materials
If you have not printed the conference materials for this program, please
complete the following steps:
• Click on the ^ symbol next to “Conference Materials” in the middle of the left-
hand column on your screen.
• Click on the tab labeled “Handouts” that appears, and there you will see a
PDF of the slides for today's program.
• Double click on the PDF and a separate page will open.
• Print the slides by clicking on the printer icon.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
L A R R Y S I M O N
J A V E R B A U M W U R G A F T H I C K S K A H N W I K S T R O M & S I N I N S
N E W Y O R K A N D N E W J E R S E Y8 0 0 - 7 8 4 - 5 1 4 0
L S I M O N @ L A W J W . C O M
T R U C K I N G L A W Y E R @ G M A I L . C O M
Arguing Driver Fatigue in Trucking and Auto Accidents
5
Bio
Lawrence Simon is a partner in the New York area firm of Javerbaum Wurgaft. He is past Chair of the American Association for Justice (“AAJ”) Trucking Litigation Group.
He is also Past Chair of the AAJ Bus Litigation Group and Motor Vehicle and Premises Liability Section.
Larry is current co-chair of the AAJ Rideshare Litigation Group.
6
Drowsy Driving Statistics
According to the American Sleep Foundation, about half of U.S. adult drivers admit to consistently getting behind the wheel while feeling drowsy.
7
More Stats
About 20% admit to falling asleep behind the wheel at some point in the past year – with more than 40% admitting this has happened at least once in their driving careers.
8
Effect of Drowsy Driving
Driving after going more than 20 hours without sleep is the equivalent of driving with a blood-alcohol concentration of 0.08% – the U.S. legal limit
You are three times more likely to be in a car crash if you are fatigued
Micro-sleep of just 4 or 5 seconds can result in a vehicle traveling the length of a football field if the driver is driving at highway speed
9
Common Instances of Drowsy Drivers
Interstate Truck Drivers
Delivery Drivers
Motor Coach Bus Drivers
Taxi/Rideshare Drivers
Lack of Sleep unrelated to driving
10
More Statistics
According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, every year about 100,000 police-reported crashes involve drowsy driving.
A study by the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety estimated that 328,000 drowsy driving crashes occur annually. That's more than three times NHTSA’s number.
11
Cost of Drowsy Driving
NHTSA stats: Crashes due to drowsy driving result in more than 1,550 fatalities and 71,000 injuries per year
AAA-Their study found that 109,000 of annual drowsy driving crashes resulted in an injury and about 6,400 were fatal.
NHTSA estimates fatigue-related crashes resulting in injury or death cost society $109 billion annually, not including property damage
12
Commercial Vehicle Crashes
Trucks and Buses travelling in interstate commerce are regulated by the Federal Government
Trucks and Buses not travelling in interstate commerce are subject to many of the same rules as interstate vehicles, as the states have adopted the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations as state law, in most instances
13
Non-Commercial Drivers
Limited laws-It is a crime in New Jersey and Arkansas to drive when 24 hours have passed without sleep.
47 State Driver’s Manuals (and Washington DC) include drowsy driving topics
17 states include drowsy driving in their driver’s education curriculum
14
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration
The Motor Carrier Safety Improvement Act of 1999 created the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) as a separate administration within the U.S. Department of Transportation on January 1, 2000.
The primary mission of FMCSA is to reduce crashes, injuries, and fatalities involving large trucks and buses.
15
What has the FMCSA done?
Hours of Service regulations/rulemaking for truck drivers
Hours of Service regulations /rulemaking for bus drivers
Fatigue Rulemaking/Model CDL
manual requirements
16
Recent Reaffirmation by FMCSA
“The goal of [the HOS] rulemaking is to reduce excessively long work hours that increase both the risk of fatigue-related crashes and long-term health problems for drivers.”
The objective of the HOS rules “is to reduce both acute and chronic fatigue by limiting the maximum number of hours per day and week that the drivers can work.”
17
FMCSA Studies
“[S]tudies have demonstrated that long work hours, both daily and weekly, lead to reduced sleep and, in the absence of sufficient recovery time, chronic fatigue.”
“Fatigued drivers have slowed reaction times and a reduced ability to assess situations quickly.”
18
Purpose of Hours of Service Rules
1) To make our roadways safer by reducing crashes caused by driver fatigue;
2) The link between driver fatigue and attentiveness is well-recognized and has been known for many decades;
3) A fatigued driver, whether that fatigue results from excessive hours of work or other causes, may become an inattentive, careless, or otherwise unsafe driver
19
The Truth20
We Need More of These21
And Less of This!
22
23
What Does this Mean?
Driving too
long is bad! Resting before driving is good!
Mkay?
24
Log Reporting
Who Must Complete Logs:
Driver of CMV in Interstate commerce where CMV is:
1) Over 10,001 pounds2) Gross vehicle weight/gross combination weight of 10,001 pounds or more+3) Transporting 9 passengers or more for compensation (including driver).4) Transporting 16 passenger or more, regardless of $$ (including driver)5) HazMat-Placardable
* Review exceptions—i.e. 100 miles radius, non CDL vehicle (short haul/short distance)
25
Foot on the pedal never ever false metalEngine running hotter than a boiling kettleMy job's ain't a job it's a damn good time
"No Sleep 'Til Brooklyn"
26
Record keeping
The FMCSRs require a daily log: Complete record of all activity in a 24-hour period for compliance with the maximum driving time set out in §395.3 for trucks (property carrying vehicles) and 393.5 for buses and other commercial passenger carrying vehicles.
The daily log is to be sent to the carrier employing the driver within 13 days of completion.
Carrier only required to keep these logs for six (6) months
27
I'll squeeze into heaven and ValentineMy bed is pulling me, gravity
Daysleeper
"Daysleeper"
28
Important Terms
Driving Time
On Duty Time
Off Duty Time
29
Max Times
§395.3 of the FMCSRs sets forth the maximum working times.
These rules set limits on driving based on both “on-duty time” and “driving time”
There is an 11-hour driving limit and a 14-hour on-duty limit per day, and a 60 or 70 hour on-duty limit per 7- or 8-day “week.”
30
Exit lightEnter nightTake my handOff to never never land
"Enter Sandman"
31
Bus rules
For a bus driver, the requirements under 395.5 are similar, with the exception that the driving time is limited to 10 hours, rather than 11.
The 11-hour driving limit essentially provides that a trucker may not drive for more than 11 hours at a time following 10 consecutive hours of off-duty time.
For a bus driver, the reset/restart time is only 8 consecutive hours off duty.
32
Truck vs Bus
The 14-hour on-duty limit allows a truck driver a 14-hour window within which to drive. As with the 11-hour driving limit, the 14-hour limit is allowed after 10 consecutive hours of off-duty time.
For a bus driver, the time period for being able to drive after coming onto duty is 15 hours under Part 395.5, an hour more than the 14 hour truck driver time period under Part 395.3.
33
Weekly rules
Although sometimes referred to as a “weekly” limit, the 60 or 70 hour rules set driving limits for 7- and 8-day periods, and prohibit driving after either 60 or 70 hours of on-duty time.
If the trucking company does not operate vehicles every day of the week, a trucker may not drive after being on-duty for 60 hours during any 7 consecutive days.
If the trucking company does operate vehicles every day of the week, it may assign drivers to the 70-hour/8-day schedule
34
Rut-ro
Once a driver reaches the 60- or 70-hour limit, he or she cannot drive again until their on-duty time drops below 60 or 70 hours for the 7- or 8-consecutive-day time period.
The 7- or 8-day time period for calculating the 60- or 70-hour limits can be “reset” by taking 34 consecutive hours of off-duty time.
35
Driving Time
“Driving time.” All time spent at the driving controls of a commercial motor vehicle in operation.
36
I had to escapeThe city was sticky and cruelMaybe I should have called you firstBut I was dying to get to youI was dreaming while I droveThe long straight road ahead, uh, huh
I drove all night to get to you
37
On Duty Time
“On-duty time.” All time from the time a driver begins to work or is required to be ready until the time the driver is relieved from work and all responsibility for performing work. The definitions has a list of activities that are included within this definition, such as time spent waiting at a plant or terminal facility waiting to be dispatched and inspection time. Essentially, any time spent performing any work for the trucking company is considered “on-duty time.”
38
Off Duty Time
“Off-Duty time.” Curiously, “off-duty” is not included anywhere in the §395.2 definitions section for the HOS regulations. It is discussed in FMCSA publications as anytime a trucker is not “on-duty.” Additionally, since on-duty time is covered in nine subsections of part
395-.2, an argument can be made by motor carriers that anything not covered in the on-duty section would fall under off-duty.
39
Sleep tight, we'll drive all nightTurnpikes across state lines...
Hand claps are fading fast, but you still can believe it's passingThese night are fading fast, so you made ?? Until midnight, Six hundred miles will be soon
Sleep Tight 40
Sleeper Berth
“Sleeper berth.” As with “off-duty,” the definitions section of the HOS regulations does not specifically define sleeper berth time. However, §395.8, when describing how to record sleeper berth time, describes it as “time off-duty resting in a sleeper berth, as defined in §395.2.” Additionally 395.3 and 395.5 discuss sleeper berth time requirements for trucks and buses.
41
All the lights they try to pull me inOh and I should be sleepingOh but I can't close my eyes anymoreSo wide awake again
And everybody says that I should just forgetThe hardest part is over with
But it’s so dark and I can't see the light
"Overnight"
42
• Using the FMCSRs, the Logbook Guide, and
look for HOS violations
Analyzing Logbooks in your Case
43
• Look at “driving miles” and the “driving time”
on the Driver’s Daily Log:
Analyzing Logbooks in your Case
44
• Cross-reference the driver’s log
– Miles match the destination points?
– Destination Points match fuel receipts? Tolls?
Analyzing Logbooks in your Case
45
I'm so sleepy yeahI'm so sleepy yeahI could lay my head on a piece of leadand imagine it was a springy bed'cause i'm sleepy, sleepy
"I'm So Sleepy"
46
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
47
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
48
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
49
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manuals
50
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
51
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manuals
52
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
53
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
54
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
55
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
56
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
57
HOS/Fatigue Rules: CDL Manual
58
And Aloha Means Goodbye
Lawrence M. Simon, Esq.Javerbaum Wurgaft Hicks Kahn Wikstrom & Sinins
New York & New Jersey
59
“PROVING DRIVER FATIGUE IN TRUCKING AND COMMERCIAL ACCIDENTS: FEDERAL AND STATE LAWS, EVIDENTIARY CONCERNS”
STRAFFORD WEBINAR
MARCH 5TH, 2019
WRIGHT I LAW I PLCMatthew E. Wright
60
61
62
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
63
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
64
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
PHINEAS GAGE BEFORE:
• 25 year-old responsible, employed railroad foreman
65
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
PHINEAS GAGE AFTER:
• Crude, vulgar, impatient
• Traveled with the circus
• Developed epilepsy
• Health spiraled downward
• Died age 37
66
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
+ =TIME
UNTREATEDLACK OF SLEEP
67
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Chronic sleep debt can be caused by both lack of:
1. Quantity of sleep; and
2. Quality of sleep (Obstructive sleep apnea, insomnia, restless leg syndrome, illnesses and medications interfere)
68
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
SLEEP DEBT
The accumulated loss of sleep and any sleep less than an individual’s daily requirement.
69
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
FATIGUE
The sleepy or drowsy state is when one requires effort to stay attentive or struggle against closing eyes. This is a red flag that means the driver is impaired and has created a hazard.
70
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
FATIGUE
A ten-hour break before driving does not mean a driver is alert.
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
71
”If sleep does not serve an absolutely vital function, then it is the biggest mistake the evolutionary process has ever made.”
-Dr. Richard Rechtschaffen
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
72
Every species ever studied sleeps even though they can’t hunt, gather, socialize, reproduce or even protect themselves during sleep.
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
73
Every major organ in the body is optimally enhanced during sleep.
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
74
Many physical effects are linked to over-activation of the sympathetic nervous system (fight or flight). Sleep provides decreases in cortisol levels, lowers blood pressure and causes growth hormones to to replenish the linings of blood vessels.
SLEEP-WAKE CYCLES:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
75
CIRCADIAN RHYTHM:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
76
CIRCADIAN RHYTHM:
INTERRUPTION CAN RESULT IN DECREASED PERFORMANCE AND
IMPAIRED JUDGMENT –
DRIVING IN THE DANGER ZONE
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
77
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
78
The brain sends calming signals during NREM sleep to the sympathetic nervous system which decreases blood pressure and heart rates.
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
79
Sleep allows cells to retain the ability to absorb blood glucose.
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
80
Sleep regulates balance of hormones that control appetite.
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
81
Sleep releases cells that fight foreign and diseased cells, like cancer:
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
82
Sleep protects fragile genes. Damaged genes increase the effects of aging:
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
WHY WE SLEEP:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
83
Sleep removes toxic protein (beta-amyloid) in the brain that in poisonous to neurons and is linked to Alzheimer’s:
THE BIOLOGICAL MYSTERY -
EFFECTS OF CHRONIC SLEEP LOSS:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
84
85
KNOWN RISKS:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
NEW RESEARCH:
COGNITIVE RISK OF HARM:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
➢ SHORTFALLS IN PERFORMANCE
➢ IMPAIRED JUDGMENT
➢ ATTENTION FAILURES
➢ INABILITY TO LEARN AND RETAIN INFORMATION
➢ INABILITY TO RECOGNIZE SYMPTOMS
86
NEW RESEARCH:
DISEASE-RELATED RISK OF HARM:
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
87
➢ Cancer
➢ Stroke
➢ Destroys immunity
➢ Increases risk of diabetes
➢ Increases risk of heart attack
88
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Sedative-Hypnotics:
89
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
≠ SLEEP
90
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Sedative-Hypnotic:
Sedates (knocks out) the higher regions in the
brain’s cortex and prevents cells from firing.
91
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Sedative-Hypnotic:
The induced sedation prevents the deep
brainwaves normally achieved in sleep and
deprives the person of the benefits associated
with deep sleep.
-Knurowska and Dijk, Journal of Pharmacology 29, no. 7 (2015); 764-76.
92
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Sedative-Hypnotic:
Can also produce rebound insomnia and depedency.
93
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Risk factors for obstructive sleep apnea:
1. Obesity;
2. Family history of snoring or apnea;
3. Being male
94
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Evidence:
• Not uncommon for a driver not to recall that he dozed off in the moments before crash.
• How do we prove it?
95
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Consider:
• Scientific studies on effects of chronic sleep deprivation;
Basis of expert opinions:
96
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Consider:
• Work hour history of driver (e.g., erratic schedules, factors that make it more likely to impair sleep quality).
Basis of expert opinions:
97
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Darling v. J.B. Expedited Servs., 2006 LEXIS 5400 (M.D. Tenn. 2006):
• Plaintiff claims truck driver dozed off and side-swiped plaintiff while he was on side of road and killed him.
• Defendant claimed he “fell” into the path of truck.
98
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Darling v. J.B. Expedited Servs., 2006 LEXIS 5400 (M.D. Tenn. 2006):
• Plaintiff’s accident reconstructionist opined defendant driver could not have completed the trip from Texas to Tennessee in less than the maximum 11 hours drive time.
99
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Darling v. J.B. Expedited Servs., 2006 LEXIS 5400 (M.D. Tenn. 2006):
Plaintiff’s sleep physiology expert opined:
• Trucker was fatigued and sleep-deprived at the time of the crash;
• Trucker was impaired by fatigue;
• His fatigue was a contributing to crash.
100
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Darling v. J.B. Expedited Servs., 2006 LEXIS 5400 (M.D. Tenn. 2006):
Plaintiff’s sleep physiology expert based his opinion on:
• Police reports, accident recon. report, published studies including articles he authored.
101
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Darling v. J.B. Expedited Servs., 2006 LEXIS 54000 (M.D. Tenn. 2006):
Expert ruling (Judge William Haynes):
• Plaintiffs’ expert satisfies Fed. R. Evid. 702, 703, 403, Daubert and Kumho Tire Co.
102
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Ryans v. Kock Foods, LLC., 2015 LEXIS 179979 (E.D. Tenn. 2015):
Plaintiff’s expert was to testify:
• The driver violated the standard of care of a commercial driver in a way that was consistent with a driver who was on the verge of falling asleep; and
• He failed to respond to a long period of warning that reasonably alert driver woud respond to.
103
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Ryans v. Kock Foods, LLC., 2015 LEXIS 179979 (E.D. Tenn. 2015):
Expert ruling (Judge Susan Lee):
• “The question of what ‘any reasonably alert driver’ would do, however, does not require any scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge…[t]he effects of fatigue on a driver are matters of common knowledge.”
104
CAN TECHNOLOGY ERADICATE DROWSY DRIVING?
WRIGHT I LAW I PLC
Thank You!
Matthew E. Wright
“PROVING DRIVER FATIGUE IN TRUCKING AND COMMERCIAL VEHICLE ACCIDENTS: FEDERAL AND STATE LAWS, EVIDENTIARY CONCERNS ”
STRAFFORD WEBINAR
MARCH 5TH, 2019
105