7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

1/52

> Nuradbs Hddbrlhg Oust Mvbrcmob QmMithkg H Vrbdkokghry Kg`ugctkmg

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb kt wkdd ib krrbphrhidy nhroba iy VS Juga 8 vmtkgl

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb prbvbgtkgl VS Juga 8 jrmo vmtkgl wmuda sbrvb tnb

puidkc kgtbrbst

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb tnht bg`mkgkgl VS Juga 8 jrmo vmtkgl wmuda

prbvbgt omrb nhro tnhg kt wmuda chusb

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb kt nhs sthgakgl, abspktb cmgtrhry Irmaynmdakgl

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb tnht Zhdbhgt hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrb tmme suisthgtkhd

stbps tmwhras h tbgabr mjjbr ibjmrb Hprkd 98

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb Vbrsnkgl Squhrb hga Zhdbhgt hrb gmt cm-mjjbrmrs

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb tnht, abspktb kts ohgy puidkc akscdmsurbs skgcb

Hprkd 99, snhrbnmdabrs dhce tnb gbcbsshry kgjmrohtkmg tm vmtb

Hddbrlhg oust gmt nhvb ugcdbhg nhgas

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

2/52

Zhdbhgt Hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrbs Vrmpmshds ChggmtKrrbphrhidy Nhro Hddbrlhg

Smurcb0 Hddbrlhg Mctmibr

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

3/52

Lhddhlnbr Mg Krrbphrhidb Nhro

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

4/52

Kg Jhct, Hddbrlhgs Iydhws Hrb Cdbhr0 Qnby Lrhgt

Bhcn Snhrbnmdabr Rgcmgaktkmghd Zmtkgl Yklnts

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 31

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

5/52

Kg Jhct, Hddbrlhgs Iydhws Hrb Cdbhr0 Qnby LrhgtBhcn Snhrbnmdabr Rgcmgaktkmghd Zmtkgl Yklnts

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 31

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

6/52

Or. Lhddhlnbr \hs \rmgl. Qnb Iydhws Or. Lhddhlnbr YbjbrbgcbsYbdhtb Mgdy Qm Ybqubsts Qm Chdd H Spbckhd Obbtkgl, Gmt Qnb Yklnt

Qm Zmtb Ht H Obbtkgl

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 31

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

7/52

Ht H Sbptboibr 89 Nbhrkgl Kg Abdhwhrb, CnhgcbddmrImucnhra Crktkckzba Hddbrlhgs Spbckhd Obbtkgl Iydhws

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. >;

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

8/52

Ht H Sbptboibr 89 Nbhrkgl Kg Abdhwhrb, CnhgcbddmrImucnhra Crktkckzba Hddbrlhgs Spbckhd Obbtkgl Iydhws

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. >;

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

9/52

Qnb Spbckhd Obbtkgl Ks Gmw H Gmg-kssub0 HddbrlhgStkpudhtba Qm Nmda Kt Mg Abcboibr 8>, 9681

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 32

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

10/52

Qnb Spbckhd Obbtkgl Ks Gmw H Gmg-kssub0 Hddbrlhg Stkpudhtba QmNmda Kt Mg Abcboibr 8>, 9681

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 32

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

11/52

Zhdbhgt Hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrbs Vrmpmshds ChggmtKrrbphrhidy Nhro Hddbrlhg

Vrmpmshd 80 Ybomvb skx oboibrs mj Hddbrlhgs Imhra

Vrmpmshd 90 H gmg-ikgakgl rbqubst tm hppmkgt skx

gmokgbbs rbcmoobgaba iy Zhdbhgt hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrb

Vrmpmshds 3-0 H gmg-ikgakgl rbqubst tm bglhlb wktnZhdbhgt hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrb

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

12/52

Vymtt Yb Snhrbnmdabrs Egmw Mj Hddblhtkmgs

n j n kddk k k n idk

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

13/52

Qnb purpmsb mj tnb \kddkhos Hct ks tm kgsurb tnht puidkcsnhrbnmdabrs wnm hrb cmgjrmgtba iy h chsn tbgabr jmr tnbkr stmcewkdd gmt ib rbqukrba tm rbspmga wktnmut habquhtb kgjmrohtkmg.

@ugb 93

@ugb 91

Sbpt. 9

@ugb 36

@ugb 36

@udy >

@udy 86

@udy 86

@udy 81

@udy 82

@udy 81@udy 8:

@udy 8

@udy 98

@udy 91

Hul. 8

Hul. 2

Hul. :

Hul. 88

Hul. 92

Hul. 9; (9a Ckr. 8;;3).

@ugb 8>

@ugb 91

@ugb 9

Hul. 88

Hul. 99

Sbpt. 8:

Sbpt. 93

Sbpt. 92

Sbpt. 9;

Sbpt. 9;

Sbpt. 9;

Sbpt. 9;

Sbpt. 9;

Mct. >

Mct. ;

Mct. ;

Mct. 86

Mct. 82

Mct. 89)

Vuidkc kgtbrbst ks boimakba kg tnb snhrbnmdabrs . . . . UK_t

ks akstkgctdy kg tnb puidkc kgtbrbst tm ohkgthkg tnb gbutrhdkty

wnkcn Cmglrbss nhs jmuga bssbgtkhd tm tnb prmpbr mpbrhtkmg

mj tnb ohrebt hpprmhcn jmr prmtbctkgl kgvbstmrs boirhcbaiy tnb \kddkhos Hct.

Ohrtkg-Ohrkbtth Cmrp. v. Ibgakx Cmrp., :;6 J.9a 22>, 2:> (:tn Ckr. 8;>9)

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

15/52

Vymtt Mg Krrbphrhidb Nhro

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

16/52

Mg @udy 9:, 9681, Or. Lhddhlnbr \rmtb KSS H Dbttbr AbjbgakglHddbrlhgs Iydhws

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

17/52

Mg @udy 9:, 9681, Or. Lhddhlnbr \rmtb KSS H Dbttbr AbjbgakglHddbrlhgs Iydhws

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

18/52

Kg Hg Hulust :, 9681 Ybpmrt, KSS CrktkckzbaHddbrlhgs Imhra Hga Ohghlbobgt

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 91

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

19/52

Kg Hg Hulust :, 9681 Ybpmrt, KSS CrktkckzbaHddbrlhgs Imhra Hga Ohghlbobgt

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 91

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

20/52

KSS Crktkckzba Hddbrlhgs Imhra Hga Ohghlbobgt

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 91

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

21/52

KSS Crktkckzba Hddbrlhgs Imhra Hga Ohghlbobgt

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 91

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

22/52

KSS Crktkckzba Hddbrlhgs Imhra Hga Ohghlbobgt

Smurcb0 VK Mpp. Bx. 91

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

23/52

KSSs Crktkqub Kgtbgskjkba Kg Mctmibr

VK Mpp. Bx. 99

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

24/52

KSSs Crktkqub Kgtbgskjkba Kg Mctmibr

VK Mpp. Bx. 99

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

25/52

KSSs Crktkqub Kgtbgskjkba Kg Mctmibr

VK Mpp. Bx. 99

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

26/52

Lhddhlnbr Yb KSS Ks Ikhsba

Z d t H a V nk S V d N

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

27/52

@HG JBI OHY HVY OH[ @RG @RD HRL SBV MCQ

Zhdbhgt Hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrbs Vrmpmshd NhsRgdmceba $8; Ikddkmg Kg Snhrbnmdabr Zhdub

826.66

;6.66

8>6.66

1/86/81 Ohrebt

Chp?$32 ikddkmg

Currbgt Ohrebt

Chp 7 $21 ikddkmg

Zhdub mj HLG

1/86/81 - $88:.:3

Zhdub mj HLG

86/93/81 - $8>1.98

896.66

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

28/52

Vymtt Y&A Gbvbr Akscmvbrba Mgb Vrmauct

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

29/52

Vymtt Mg Cmst Cuts

Mg Jbir hr 89 9681 CBM Ah ka V mtt Smda

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

30/52

Mg Jbiruhry 89, 9681, CBM Ahvka Vymtt Smda929,666 Snhrbs Ht $893.890 Mvbr $38O Kg Stmce

Smurcb0 Hddbrlhg SBC Jmro 1

Mg Jbiruhry 89 9681 CBM Ahvka Vymtt Smda

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

31/52

Mg Jbiruhry 89, 9681, CBM Ahvka Vymtt Smda929,666 Snhrbs Ht $893.890 Mvbr $38O Kg Stmce

Smurcb0 Hddbrlhg SBC Jmro 1

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

32/52

Vymtt Stmce \hs Jhkrdy Zhduba

EKYEDHGA & BDDKS DDV

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

33/52

EKYEDHGA & BDDKS DDV

\bcmgcduab tnht tnbrb ks gm prkgckpdba akstkgctkmg ibtwbbg Yudbs 86i2 hga 81b3 hs rblhras tnb gbba jmr h cmgtbopmrhgbmus trhakgl hddblhtkmg. \b tnbrbjmrb

bxtbga tnb cmgtbopmrhgbmus trhakgl rbqukrbobgt tm kgskabr trhakgl hctkmgs irmulnt

ugabr Sbctkmg 81(b) hga Yudb 81b3 hctkmgs.

\nkdb Yudb 81b3 jmcusbs mg tnb tbgabr mjjbr cmgtbxt, tnb ihcelrmuga nkstmry hga

dhgluhlb mj Yudb 81b3 kgakchtb tnht tnb Yudb ambs gmt hdtbr tnb prboksb tnht hsnhrbnmdabr oust nhvb trhaba wktn hg kgskabr mr nhvb trhaba ht himut tnb shob tkob

hs hg kgskabr tm ib nhroba iy tnb kgskabrstrhakgl.

UH_s ks trub mj tnb histhkg mr akscdmsb rbqukrbobgt mj Yudb 86i2, tnb skokdhr

rbqukrbobgt mj Yudb 81b3 ks absklgba tm prbvbgt tnb akshavhgthlb tnht kgnbrbs kg

trhakgl wktn hg kgskabr wktn supbrkmr hccbss tm kgjmrohtkmg.

Qnb SBCs kopdbobgthtkmg rbdbhsb jmr Yudb 81b3 bvkgcbs h phrtkcudhr cmgcbrg

jmr tnmsb wnm purcnhsb jrmo mr sbdd tm kgskabrs, hga sullbsts tnht tnbsb

snhrbnmdabrs, hga gmt mtnbrs wnm trhab dhtbr, hrb tnb kgtbgaba ibgbjkckhrkbs mj Yudb

81b3.

Irmay Nbda Qnht Mgdy Cmgtbopmrhgbmus Stmce Qrhabrs Chg Sub

Rgabr Yudb 81b3

Irmay v. Qrhgsktkmghd Nmspkthds Cmrpmrhtkmg, 9>6 J.3a ;;< (;tn Ckr. 9668)

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb Hga Zhdbhgt Qmme Gm Suisthgtkhd

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

34/52

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb Hga Zhdbhgt Qmme Gm SuisthgtkhdStbps Ibjmrb Ohy 9>, 9681

Jbi. ;, 9681

CmgjkabgtkhdktyHlrbbobgt sklgba

Jbi. 92, 9681

Ybdhtkmgsnkp

Hlrbbobgt sklgba

Jbi. 92, 9681

VS Juga 8 iblkgs

purcnhskgl Hddbrlhg

sbcurktkbs

Hprkd 99, 9681

Zhdbhgt hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrb

oheb jkrst obrlbr prmpmshd

Ohy 36, 9681

Jkrst Zhdbhgt Imhra vmtb mg

Qbgabr Mjjbr

Mct. 36, 9681

Snhrbnmdabr Ybcmra ahtb

jmr Spbckhd Obbtkgl

Abc. 8>, 9681

Spbckhd Obbtkgl

Hprkd 98, 9681

VS Juga 8s dhst purcnhsbs

mj Hddbrlhg sbcurktkbs

Aet. Gm. 8;1 ht 1-865 92-9:5 sbb hdsm Aet. Gm. 8;1-25 8;1-;5 8;1-;5 8;1-86.

@ugb 8>, 9681

Qbgabr Mjjbr dhugcnba

@HG JBI OHY HVY OH[ @RG @RD HRL SBV MCQ GMZ ABC

Dhtb Ohy - Oka-@ugb

YIC hga Ihrcdhys Iblkg \mre

mg Qbgabr Mjjbr

Cmooktobgt Dbttbr Bxbcutba

Ohy 83, 9681

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb jkdba prmxy chddkgl

jmr snhrbnmdabr rbjbrbgauo

Ohy 9>-36, 9681

Shgjmra C. Ibrgstbkg Cmgjbrbgcb

Ohy 9> & 36, 9681

Zhdbhgt hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrb

rbvksb obrlbr prmpmshd

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

35/52

Qnbrb Ks Gm Bvkabgcb Qnht Abjbgahgts Qmme SuisthgtkhdStbps Qmwhras H Qbgabr Mjjbr Ibjmrb Ohy 9>, 9681

Qnb ugrbiuttba tbstkomgy mj skx wktgbssbs bsthidksnbs tnht

Abjbgahgts ohab gm stbps tmwhras h tbgabr mjjbr prkmr tm tnb ShgjmraIbrgstbkg cmgjbrbgcb mg Ohy 9>-36, 9681

Hceohg (CBM mj Vbrsnkgl Squhrb)

Amydb (Oboibr mj Vbrsnkgl Squhrb Kgvbstobgt Qbho)

Vbhrsmg (CBM mj Zhdbhgt) Scnkddbr (CJM mj Zhdbhgt)

Obnth (Ihrcdhys)

\mdjb (YIC)

Qnb eby amcuobgts cmrrmimrhtb tnks jhct

Zhdbhgt imhra okgutbs

Jkghgckgl cmooktobgt amcuobgts jrmo YIC hga Ihrcdhys

Abspktb rbcbkvkgl 8

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

36/52

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb Hga Zhdbhgts Vhrtgbrsnkp Qm

Hcqukrb Hddbrlhg Ohebs Qnbo Cm-mjjbrkgl Vbrsmgs

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb ks `mkgtdy hga sbvbrhddy dkhidb jmr tnb bgtkrb Qbgabr

Mjjbr cmgskabrhtkmg

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb hlrbba tm hccbpt mgdy Zhdbhgt stmce, gm chsn, kj tnb

hcquksktkmg mccurs

Jrbbs up $9 Ikddkmg kg haaktkmghd chsn cmgskabrhtkmg tm phy tm mtnbr Hddbrlhg

snhrbnmdabrs

Kj tnb hcquksktkmg mccurs, Vbrsnkgl Squhrb oust nmda $8.2 ikddkmg kg

Zhdbhgt snhrbs jmr mgb ybhr

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb ibcmobs, iy why mj tnb hcquksktkmg, h dhrlb snhrbnmdabr kg h

cmoikgba Zhdbhgt/Hddbrlhg bgtkty

Kj, hs Hddbrlhg cdhkos, Zhdbhgt ks h Nmusb mj Chras, Vbrsnkgl Squhrb jhcbs

suisthgtkhd dmssbs

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb hlrbbs tm hccbpt Zhdbhgt snhrbs ht h dmwbr

bxcnhglb rhtb

Vbrsnkgl Squhrb hlrbbs tm prmvkab $166 okddkmg kg jkghgckgl tmZhdbhgt

M @ d 3 9681 SBC K a Z d Q Haa

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

37/52

Mg @udy 3, 9681, SBC Kgstructba Zhdbhgt Qm HaaVbrsnkgl Squhrb Hs H Cm-ikaabr

Ht Qnb SBCs Kgstructkmg Qnb Scnbaudb QM

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

38/52

Ht Qnb SBC s Kgstructkmg, Qnb Scnbaudb QMKabgtkjkbs Vbrsnkgl Squhrb Hs Hg Mjjbrmr

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

39/52

Vymtt Vrb-Mjjbr Hctkmgs

Mg Jbiruhry < 9681 IHOD Kssuba H Ybpmrt Hghdyzkgl H

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

40/52

Mg Jbiruhry

Ybpmrt Hghdyzbs H Zhdbhgt Mjjbr Jmr Hddbrlhg Mj

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

41/52

Ybpmrt Hghdyzbs H Zhdbhgt Mjjbr Jmr Hddbrlhg Mj$826 Vbr Snhrb Hga Jkgas $9I kg Sygbrlkbs

Smurcb0 HLG-CH666:8:36

Vymtt Hlrbba Qnht IHODs Guoibrs Hssbsskgl H

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

42/52

Vymtt Hlrbba Qnht IHOD s Guoibrs Hssbsskgl HQrhgshctkmg Ibtwbbg Zhdbhgt Hga Hddbrlhg \brb

irmhady cmrrbct

HLG-CH666:8:9;

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

43/52

Vymtt Shgjmra Ibrgstbkg Cmoobgts

Vymtt Hga Hddbrlhg Abcdhrb \hr Hlhkgst Zhdbhgt

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

44/52

Vymtt Hga Hddbrlhg Abcdhrb \hr Hlhkgst ZhdbhgtHga Vbrsnkgl Squhrb

Smurcb0 HLG-CH666>813 Nuradbs Hddbrlhg Oust Mvbrcmob Qm

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

51/52

> Nuradbs Hddbrlhg Oust Mvbrcmob QmMithkg H Vrbdkokghry Kg`ugctkmg

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb kt wkdd ib krrbphrhidy nhroba iy VS Juga 8 vmtkgl

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb prbvbgtkgl VS Juga 8 jrmo vmtkgl wmuda sbrvb tnb

puidkc kgtbrbst

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb tnht bg`mkgkgl VS Juga 8 jrmo vmtkgl wmuda

prbvbgt omrb nhro tnhg kt wmuda chusb

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb kt nhs sthgakgl, abspktb cmgtrhry Irmaynmdakgl

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb tnht Zhdbhgt hga Vbrsnkgl Squhrb tmme suisthgtkhd

stbps tmwhras h tbgabr mjjbr ibjmrb Hprkd 98

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb Vbrsnkgl Squhrb hga Zhdbhgt hrb gmt cm-mjjbrmrs

Hddbrlhg oust prmvb tnht, abspktb kts ohgy puidkc akscdmsurbs skgcb

Hprkd 99, snhrbnmdabrs dhce tnb gbcbsshry kgjmrohtkmg tm vmtb

Hddbrlhg oust gmt nhvb ugcdbhg nhgas

EKYEDHGA & BDDKS DDV

7/21/2019 PSCM VRX Presentation to Court 10-28-14

52/52