public cemetery district services - calaveras lafco · public cemetery district services adopted...

40
Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts 2005 Municipal Service Review (MSR) And Sphere of Influence (SOI) Plan Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission of Calaveras County

Upload: others

Post on 19-Oct-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts 2005

Municipal Service Review (MSR) And

Sphere of Influence (SOI) Plan

Public Cemetery District Services

Adopted

August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12

Local Agency Formation Commission of Calaveras County

Page 2: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts 2005

CALAVERAS COUNTY LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION (LAFCO) Government Center 891 Mountain Ranch Road San Andreas, CA 95249 John Benoit, Executive Officer (209) 754-6303

I:a.1. Commissioners Tom Tryon, Member Victoria Erickson, Member Norman Price, Member Lee Seaton, Member John Lavaroni, Independent Special District Member Tony Tyrrell, Independent Special District Member Mike Hathaway, Public Member

I:a.2. Alternate Commissioners Merita Callaway, County Member Bill Hutchinson, City Member Al Ohlau, Independent Special District Member Gene Weatherby, Public Member

a) Consultant Dennis Dickman, Principal

II. Dennis Dickman and Associates P.O. Box 1418 San Andreas, CA 95249 (209) 293-7211

a) Mapping Calaveras County Technology Services Department Government Center San Andreas, CA 95249 Howard Stohlman, Director David Pastizzo, GIS Coordinator Doug Polzoni, GIS Technician (209) 754-6366

Page 3: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts 2005

TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page I. Executive Summary ................................................................................. III-1 II. Introduction .............................................................................................. IV-1

II:a. Local Agency Formation Commission ............................................... IV-1 II:b. Local Government Reorganization Act .............................................. IV-1 II:c. Service Review Guidelines ................................................................ IV-2

III. Public Cemetery Districts ........................................................................ V-1 III:a. Altaville Cemetery District .................................................................. V-2 III:b. Copperopolis Cemetery District ......................................................... V-3 III:c. Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District ...................................................... V-3 III:d. Murphys Cemetery District ................................................................. V-4 III:e. Rail Road Flat Cemetery District ........................................................ V-4 III:f. San Andreas Cemetery District ........................................................... V-5 III:g. Vallecito Cemetery District ................................................................. V-5 III:h. West Point Cemetery District ............................................................. V-6

IV. Determinations ......................................................................................... VI-1 IV:a. Infrastructure Needs and Deficiencies .............................................. VI-1 IV:b. Growth and Population Projections .................................................. VI-1 IV:c. Financing Constraints and Opportunities .......................................... VI-2 IV:d. Cost Avoidance Opportunities .......................................................... VI-2 IV:e. Rate Restructuring Opportunities ..................................................... VI-2 IV:f. Opportunities for Shared Facilities .................................................... VI-3 IV:g. Governmental Structure Options ...................................................... VI-3 IV:h. Management Efficiencies ................................................................. VI-3 IV:i. Local Accountability and Governance ............................................... VI-3

V. Considerations for Reorganization ....................................................... VII-1 V:a. Consolidation .................................................................................... VII-1 V:b. Formation ......................................................................................... VII-1 V:c. Dissolution ........................................................................................ VII-1 V:d. Annexation and Detachment ............................................................ VII-1

VI. Conclusions and Recommendations ................................................... VIII-1 VI:a. Conclusions .................................................................................... VIII-1 VI:b. Recommendations .......................................................................... VIII-1

VII. References ............................................................................................... IX-1 VIII. Appendices ................................................................................................ X-1

VIII:a. Financial Overview .......................................................................... X-1

Page 4: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page III-1

III. Executive Summary Local Agency Formation Commissions (LAFCO) were created in 1963 to

assist the State of California in encouraging the orderly development and formation of local public agencies. There is a LAFCO in each California County. LAFCO has the power to conduct studies, approve or disapprove proposals, modify boundaries of cities and special districts, and impose reasonable terms and conditions on approval of proposals.

The Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Local Reorganization Act of 2000 (CKH Act)

established procedures for local government changes of organization. The CKH Act also requires LAFCO to update the Spheres of Influence (SOI) of all local agencies within the county by January 1, 2006. A Sphere of Influence is defined as a plan for the probable physical boundary and service area of a local agency or municipality. A service review must be conducted for each local agency to update the SOIs.

This Municipal Service Review addresses public cemetery district services

within Calaveras County and updates the SOI for the eight public cemetery districts as follows. Altaville Cemetery District Copperopolis Cemetery District Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District Murphys Cemetery District Rail Road Flat Cemetery District San Andreas Cemetery District Vallecito Cemetery District West Point Cemetery District

There are private cemeteries within Calaveras County but they are not part of this service review.

It is recommended that the SOIs remain coterminous with the district

boundaries for the Altaville, Mokelumne Hill, Murphys and West Point Cemetery Districts. It is also recommended that the SOIs be amended for the Copperopolis, Vallecito, Rail Road Flat, and San Andreas Cemetery Districts to include additional territory beyond their current district boundaries. Refer to the map in Section V of this report for a description and depiction of the proposed SOIs.

Page 5: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page III-2

It is recommended that LAFCO adopt the Resolutions contained in

Section VI of this report. The Resolutions contain written determinations as required by the CKH Act plus various recommendations. These recommendations are summarized as follows:

The County Board of Supervisors should consider appointing itself to serve as the Board of Trustees of the cemetery districts and appoint the current Trustees as Advisory Committees.

The County Board of Supervisors should consider the creation of a “Special

Districts Coordinator” position within County government to manage the cemetery districts plus perform other special district functions. The Special District Coordinator would be responsible for working with the Advisory Committees in preparing capital improvement plans for each cemetery, proposing adequate funding sources and fees to undertake needed capital improvements, preparing long-range budgets taking into account acceptable reserve amounts, and applying for available grant funding. The Special District Coordinator could also likely serve this function for the County’s Lighting Districts as well as for other special districts within the County. Funding for the Special Districts Coordinator position could come from a combination of special district funds and grant administration funding.

If the County Board of Supervisors decides not to appoint itself as Trustees and

not create a Special District Coordinator position, the current Board of Trustees of the cemetery districts should at least prepare long-range Capital Improvements Plans with accompanying financial plans for adequate fees and reserve amounts.

Prior to the next Municipal Service Review update, LAFCO should investigate

the consolidation of the cemetery districts into one countywide cemetery district.

Page 6: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page IV-1

IV. Introduction

IV:a. Local Agency Formation Commission Local Agency Formation Commissions (LAFCOs) are quasi-legislative

local agencies created in 1963 to assist the State in encouraging the orderly development and formation of local agencies. There is a LAFCO in each California County. LAFCOs are independent agencies that are not part of county government, special district, or cities.

LAFCO in Calaveras County is comprised of seven Commissioners

appointed by the County, City of Angels, special districts, and a public member appointed by the other six Commissioners.

The fundamental mission of a LAFCO is to implement the provisions of the

Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Local Government Reorganization Act of 2000 (CKH Act). LAFCO has the power to conduct studies, approve or disapprove proposals, modify boundaries of cities and special districts, and impose reasonable terms and conditions on approval of proposals.

IV:b. Local Government Reorganization Act The Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Local Government Reorganization Act of

2000 (CKH Act) establishes procedures for local government changes of organization. The CKH Act contains three previous laws that governed changes in the boundaries and organization of cities and special districts. The Knox-Nisbet Act, the Municipal Reorganization Act and the District Reorganization Act were consolidated into the CKH Act.

The CKH Act contains the following major policies: • To encourage orderly growth and development which are essential to

the social, fiscal, and economic well being of the State; • To promote orderly development by encouraging the local formation

and determination of boundaries and working to provide housing for families of all incomes;

• To discourage urban sprawl; • To preserve open space and prime agricultural lands by guiding

development in a manner that minimizes resource loss; • To exercise its authority to ensure that affected populations receive

efficient governmental services, to promote logical formation and boundary modifications that direct the burdens and benefits of

Page 7: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page IV-2

additional growth to those local agencies that are best suited to provide the necessary services and housing;

• To make studies and obtain and furnish information which will contribute to the logical and reasonable development of local agencies and to shape their development so as to advantageously provide for the present and future needs of each county and its communities;

• To establish priorities by assessing and balancing total community services needs with financial resources available to secure and provide community services and to encourage government structures that reflect local circumstances, conditions, and financial resources;

• To determine whether new or existing agencies can feasibly provide needed services in a more efficient or accountable manner and, where deemed necessary, consider reorganization with other single purpose agencies that provide related services;

• To update the Spheres of Influence (SOIs) of all local agencies within the county by January 1, 2006; and

• Conduct a review of all municipal services by county, region, sub-region or other geographic area prior to, or in conjunction with, SOI updates or the creation of new SOIs.

Sphere of Influence (SOI) is defined as a plan for the probable physical

boundary and service area of a local agency or municipality as determined by LAFCO. The SOI is an important tool for planning and shaping the logical and orderly development and coordination of local governmental agencies so as to advantageously provide for the present and future needs of the county and its communities.

In determining the SOI of each local agency, the Commission shall

consider and prepare a written statement of its determinations with respect to four factors: (1) the present and planned land uses in the area, including agricultural and open space lands, (2) the present and probable need for public facilities and services in the are, (3) the present capacity of public facilities and adequacy of public services which the agency provides or is authorized to provide, and (4) the existence of any social or economic communities of interest in the area if the Commission determines that they are relevant to the agency.

IV:c. Service Review Guidelines

The Governors Office of Planning and Research (OPR) has prepared guidelines for LAFCO to conduct reviews of California municipal services. OPR published in August of 2003 the Final Guidelines.

The CKH Act, together with OPR’s guidelines, requires LAFCO to conduct a comprehensive review of all agencies that provide services within the county.

Page 8: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page IV-3

The service reviews must prepare a written statement of LAFCO’s determination with respect to each of the following:

• Infrastructure needs or deficiencies; • Growth and population projections; • Financing constraints and opportunities; • Cost avoidance opportunities; • Opportunities for rate restructuring; • Opportunities for shared facilities; • Government structure options, including advantages and

disadvantages of consolidation or reorganization of service providers; • Evaluation of management efficiencies; and • Local accountability and governance.

Page 9: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page V-1

V. Public Cemetery Districts

Calaveras County is located on the eastern side of the Central Valley east of Stockton, California. It is part of the historic Mother Lode region of the Sierra Nevada Mountains. The County encompasses 1,028 square miles and had a population of 40,554 according to the 2000 Census. There is one city in the County, the City of Angels (also known as Angels Camp), with a population of 3,004 based upon the 2000 Census.

There are eight public cemetery districts within Calaveras County. Refer to the accompanying map. The cemetery districts are identified below: Altaville Cemetery District Copperopolis Cemetery District Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District Murphys Cemetery District Rail Road Flat Cemetery District San Andreas Cemetery District Vallecito Cemetery District West Point Cemetery District

Cemetery districts were formed under various California legislative acts

beginning in 1854. The State in 1909 enacted legislation that provided for the formation of public cemetery districts as they exist today with specific boundaries to maintain, operate, and acquire cemeteries for the burial needs of their communities. The public cemetery districts act and operate under the California statutory law known as the Health and Safety Code, Division, Part 4, Public Cemetery Districts. Pursuant to Sections 9020-9031, the County Board of Supervisors may appoint three or five persons to serve as the Board of Trustees of each cemetery district. The Board of Supervisors may instead appoint itself as the Board of Trustees.

In addition to the public cemetery districts, there are a number of private

cemeteries in the County. This Municipal Service Review report addresses the public cemetery

districts within the County and does not address private cemeteries that may exist upon private property.

A brief description of each public cemetery district follows.

Page 10: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page V-2

V:a. Altaville Cemetery District

The Altaville Cemetery District was established in August of 1926 by a resident petition of those living within the Angels Camp and Altaville areas. The governing board of the District is known as the Trustees and is comprised of 5 members, who are residents of the district, and who are appointed by the County Board of Supervisors. The Board of Trustees meets at least once a month. The Board meets at a Board member’s home since the District does not have an office. The meetings are publicly noticed.

The District has four cemeteries all that were in operation prior to 1926.

The cemeteries are within the city limits of the city of Angels but the district’s boundary and service territory extend beyond the city limits. The four cemeteries have a total acreage of 15.76 acres. The Catholic Cemetery has 5.68 acres, the Protestant Cemetery 7.08 acres, the Lode Cemetery (IOOF) has 1.15 acres and the Serbian Cemetery has 1.85 acres. The District is currently working on establishing the number of existing burial sites using a GPS system.

The District’s cemeteries provide a history of the community with the in

migration to the area of people from various places in the world such as Herzegovina, Bosnia, Italy, France, Portugal and Germany.

The Altaville Cemetery District does not provide any services other than

the sale of burial and cremation plots. The District has a fee schedule for the plots that vary in price for residents of the district, eligible non-residents and out of district.

The District is a member of the California Association of Public

Cemeteries and the California Special Districts Association from which the District purchases its insurance coverage.

The District has adopted a Capital Improvements Plan (CIP) outlining

needed improvements at each of the cemeteries. The CIP outlines improvements to waterlines, drainage systems, tree trimming and removal, fencing, and access roads.

The District has one-part time employee for maintenance. Volunteers

from the Old Rose Committee help categorize and maintain the old antique roses found within the Catholic and Protestant Cemeteries. The District occasionally contracts for maintenance and improvement services.

The Altaville Cemetery District boundary and current SOI are coterminous.

Page 11: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page V-3

V:b. Copperopolis Cemetery District

The Copperopolis Cemetery has been in use for over a hundred years. However, the Copperopolis Cemetery District was established in 1950 for the purpose of maintaining a public cemetery. The Copperopolis Cemetery District is governed by a three-member Board of Directors that are appointed by the County Board of Supervisors. The Board meets upon a quarterly basis.

The Copperopolis Cemetery was established as a community cemetery in

the 1880’s. It is located off Reed’s Turnpike on Jackson and Cemetery Lanes not far form the historical part of the Copperopolis Main Street. The cemetery currently occupies 5.8 acres with 413 existing burial sites. The cemetery can accommodate over 2,000 burial plots.

The cemetery provides a vital historical picture of the town of

Copperopolis since its beginning in 1853 through the present. The cemetery reflects the growth of the town in its height of mining and ranching and is a local attraction.

The Copperopolis Cemetery District does not currently provide any

services other than burial plots. Plots were provided free of charge until recently when the district established a fee per plot to assist in off setting maintenance costs. The Board is considering the establishment of annual maintenance dues and the possibility of development impact fees.

The Cemetery District has no employees. Bids are solicited in the late

spring of each year for grounds maintenance. The Copperopolis Cemetery District boundary and Sphere of Influence

(SOI) are coterminous.

V:c. Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District

The Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District was established in 1941 for the purpose of maintaining a public cemetery. A three-member Board governs the District.

The District maintains and operates three cemeteries, two of which are

located in town and one outside of town. The Protestant Cemetery is located at the corner of West Center Street and Miwok Trail. It contains approximately 7 acres and has 1,850 burial plots plus a Jewish Cemetery of .36 acres with 300 plots. The Catholic Cemetery is located on East Center Street and has 2,700 burial plots on 6.72 acres. The Jesus Maria Cemetery is a rural cemetery

Page 12: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page V-4

located along Jesus Maria Road approximately 10 miles from the intersection with State Highway 26.

As other cemeteries in the County, the cemeteries in Mokelumne Hill date

back to the Gold Rush era. A portion of the Protestant Cemetery was set aside for burial of the Chinese in urns until the remains could be shipped to China for burial.

The District offers burial and cremation plots at various rates for residents

and non-residents. The District has one part-time Secretary. All other staffing is on a

volunteer basis. The District has no offices or other facilities or equipment. The District does not have a Capital Improvements Plan but makes improvements on an as needed basis. The District undertook road improvements to the cemeteries last year.

The Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District boundary and SOI are

coterminous.

V:d. Murphys Cemetery District

The Murphys Cemetery District was established in 1930 for the purpose of maintaining the Protestant and Catholic cemeteries in the Murphys Area. A three-member Board governs the District. The Catholic Church assumes all responsibility for the operations of the Catholic Cemetery other than maintenance.

The District’s boundaries and current SOI are coterminous. The District

did not respond to LAFCO’s request for data. Therefore, no additional information is available for the Murphys Cemetery District.

V:e. Rail Road Flat Cemetery District

The Rail Road Flat Cemetery District was established in 1956 for the purpose of maintaining and operating an existing cemetery. The District is governed by a three member Board of Trustees that are appointed by the County Board of Supervisors. The Board meets once every one to two months.

The District operates and maintains the Rail Road Flat Cemetery which is

located on Cemetery Road off Independence Road near the community of Rail Road Flat. The cemetery is located on 7.5 acres, has approximately 500 existing burial sites and 200 available burial sites.

Page 13: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page V-5

The cemetery, as others in the County, was established during the gold rush era.

The District has one part-time maintenance employee and volunteer

assistance. The District does not have a capital improvements plan but undertakes maintenance of the cemetery as needed.

The Rail Road Flat Cemetery District boundary and current SOI are

coterminous.

V:f. San Andreas Cemetery District

The San Andreas Cemetery District was formed in 1943 for the purpose of assuming the maintenance and operation of a public cemetery in San Andreas. A three-member Board of Trustees governs the District.

The District operates and maintains the Peoples Cemetery that is located

on Cemetery Lane in the town of San Andreas. The cemetery contains 11.55 acres and has approximately 700 burial sites with one-half currently utilized. A portion of the cemetery contains the Masonic Cemetery and Odd Fellows Cemetery. The District is in discussions with the St. Andrews Catholic Church regarding the ownership and maintenance of the Catholic Cemetery located in San Andreas. The District has two part-time maintenance persons and one secretary. The District has a small tool shed but no office. The District primarily relies upon its own staff rather than private contractors for maintenance services.

The San Andreas Cemetery District boundary and current SOI are coterminous.

V:g. Vallecito Cemetery District

The Vallecito Cemetery District was formed in 1949 for the purpose of acquiring land for use as cemeteries and the maintenance of such cemeteries. A three-member Board of Trustees governs the District.

The District operates and maintains two cemeteries. Cemetery Number 1

is located on Cemetery Lane in the town of Vallecito and is approximately 1 acre in size. Cemetery Number 2 (also known as the Odd Fellows Cemetery) is located off of the intersection of State Highway 4 and Vallecito Bypass Road and is approximately one-half acre in size. The number of existing burial sites at each cemetery is unknown. The District has indicated there is sufficient acreage at the cemeteries for future burial sites.

Page 14: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page V-6

The District does not have any employees. Volunteers, inmates, or persons performing community service primarily perform maintenance. The District does not own any facilities or equipment.

The Vallecito Cemetery District boundary and current SOI are

coterminous.

V:h. West Point Cemetery District

There is no record of when the West Point Cemetery was established but the oldest headstone is dated 1865. The West Point Cemetery District was established by the County but the date of establishment is unknown. The Board of Trustees of the District is appointed by the County Board of Supervisors. The Board is comprised on three members and meets monthly.

The District’s main cemetery is located on Cemetery Lane in West Point

off of Spink Road. The cemetery occupies approximately 8 acres. An exact number of existing burials in the cemetery are unknown. There are approximately 2,500 burial plots available. The District is also responsible for a 1-acre cemetery located at Sandy Gulch. This cemetery is an old pioneer cemetery and generally is not used for new burials unless other family members are currently buried there.

The district has one part-time grounds keeper. Occasionally contract

services are retained by bids. The West Point Cemetery District boundary and current SOI are

coterminous.

Page 15: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VI-1

VI. Determinations LAFCO must prepare a written statement of its determination with respect

to nine factors as required by the CKH Act and OPR’s Guidelines. This section of the Service Review Report addresses each of those nine factors as they may relate and be of pertinence to public cemetery district services within Calaveras County.

VI:a. Infrastructure Needs and Deficiencies The term infrastructure needs and deficiencies refers to the status of

existing and planned public facilities and services and its relationship to the quality and levels of service that are, can, and need to be provided. The Altaville Cemetery District is the only cemetery district that has prepared a Capital Improvement Plan (CIP). The other cemetery districts undertake maintenance as needed without a long-range plan of future improvements and their associated cost. Maintenance and improvements at cemeteries primarily involve access roads, water systems, fencing, and grounds maintenance including tree trimming.

VI:b. Growth and Population Projections

LAFCO needs to consider whether service provisions are facilitating the implementation of adopted land use plans, or alternatively inducing growth in areas not intended to be urbanized.

The County is experiencing growth in resident population and the development of second homes. The County’s population in 1990 was 31,998 and in 2000 a total of 40,554. This represents a 27 percent increase or 2.7 percent per year. From 2000 to 2004 the County’s population grew by another 1,930 persons. The County’s population is expected to continue to increase especially if current trends continue with people retiring to the County from more urban centers in the State. The state of the overall economy, interest rates, and the retirement of the baby-boomer population will in part influence the rate in which this growth occurs. The City of Angels 2004 population estimate of 3,441 is expected to increase to 4,603 by the year 2020 based upon the City’s Housing Element.

The cemetery districts have sufficient land to accommodate additional burial sites in the future. Many of the cemeteries were developed during the Gold Rush era when many of the County’s towns had abundant populations of

Page 16: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VI-2

miners. Today the County’s population is less than what it was during the Gold Rush.

VI:c. Financing Constraints and Opportunities An examination of financing constraints and opportunities includes an

evaluation of issues that affect the cost and implementation of financing mechanisms or practices used to fund needed improvements and enhance revenue streams.

The financing of costs associated with the cemetery districts in the County

are obtained from either property taxes or fees for burial plots. All the cemetery districts for the reporting period had annual revenues exceeding annual expenses except the Murphys and Rail Road Flat Cemetery Districts. These two districts had small operating deficits for the fiscal year reported. All of the districts have fund equity exceeding annual expenses between a ratio of 3.8 to 21.5. On average fund equity was 11.5 times larger than annual expenditures. A Little Hoover Commission report in 2000 raised questions why some special districts were accumulating large reserves. Policy-makers and the public were asking why districts were setting aside so much money and how were they planning to spend it. Special districts should improve the way they report their fiscal activities and explain the purpose of the reserves.

VI:d. Cost Avoidance Opportunities Cost avoidance opportunities include those that eliminate unnecessary

costs. The cemetery districts have limited administrative costs with either part-

time assistance or volunteer assistance. Maintenance of and improvements to the cemeteries represent their major costs.

If the cemetery districts were managed under on jurisdiction,

administration and maintenance costs could potentially be reduced.

VI:e. Rate Restructuring Opportunities

Rate restructuring opportunities deal with positive rate impacts that will not adversely affect service quality or other factors.

The cemetery districts obtain the majority of their revenue from property

taxes. The cemetery districts have the authority to raise fees for burial plots and other services.

Page 17: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VI-3

VI:f. Opportunities for Shared Facilities Public service costs may be reduced if service providers develop strategies for sharing facilities and resources. Sharing facilities and utilizing excess capacity in another agency’s service system works to avoid service duplications, reduces costs, and minimizes unnecessary resource consumption. Many miles physically separate the cemetery districts and as a result the opportunity for sharing facilities is limited.

VI:g. Governmental Structure Options

LAFCO should consider the advantages and disadvantages of changes to government structure when conducting service reviews.

The current governmental structure of the cemetery districts is that the

County Board of Supervisors appoints three to five Trustees to administer and manager each cemetery district. Pursuant to Sections 9020-9031 of the Health and Safety Code, Division, Part 4, Public Cemetery Districts, the County Board of Supervisors may instead appoint itself as the Board of Trustees.

VI:h. Management Efficiencies

Management efficiencies refers to the organized provision of the highest quality public service with the lowest necessary expenditure of public funds. The cemetery districts are managed by each of the Board of Trustees with some support services provided by the County Auditor-Controller and County Treasurer. If the Board of Supervisors were to appoint itself as the Board of Trustees of the cemetery districts, County staff would need to assume manage responsibilities for the cemetery districts.

VI:i. Local Accountability and Governance

Local accountability and governance refers to public agency decision making and operational and management processes.

All of the public cemetery districts within Calaveras County were formed under the laws of the State of California and are subject to and comply with state disclosure laws and the Brown Act. The Boards of Trustees are appointed, hold periodic meetings that are open to the public, adopt annual budgets, and have regular financial audits.

Page 18: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VII-1

VII. Considerations for Reorganization

Considerations for reorganization of the cemetery districts in the County would include the consolidation, formation or dissolution of any or all of the agencies and the annexation or detachment of territory. Each of these considerations is briefly discussed below.

VII:a. Consolidation

There does not appear to be an immediate need for the consolidation of the cemetery districts into one countywide cemetery district. The individual cemetery districts have respective funding sources, either property taxes or assessments, in place that are adequate to provide cemetery services. Also, the cemetery districts are physically separated by many miles. Eventually consolidation of the cemetery districts into one countywide district may prove to be beneficial especially if the need arises to develop new public cemeteries in other parts of the County.

VII:b. Formation

There are areas of the County that do not have local public cemeteries and are not within a public cemetery district. The largest two areas are the Mountain Ranch area and greater Valley Springs area. The Valley Springs area includes the Wallace, Burson and Valley Springs Highway 12 corridor.

The ability of forming new cemetery districts in areas without local

cemeteries would require voter approval and provisions for adequate funding sources to acquire land and operate and maintain the cemeteries. Private cemeteries possibly could serve this need instead.

VII:c. Dissolution

Each of the districts is adequately providing cemetery services and is financially sound. There is not a need to consider dissolution of any of the cemetery districts.

VII:d. Annexation and Detachment

There are no reasons to consider the detachment of territory from any of the cemetery districts.

Page 19: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VII-2

A review of each of the cemetery districts was made in relationship to the County’s General Plan and accompanying community plans. This review concluded that the two areas that are outside public cemetery districts are proposed for future residential development and a need for local public cemeteries could develop in the future in these areas. Consideration should be given to expanding the SOI of the San Andreas Cemetery District to include the Mountain Ranch area and expanding the Copperopolis Cemetery District SOI to include the broader Valley Springs area. Consideration should be given to adding an island of land to the SOI territory for the Vallecito Cemetery District. Also, consideration should be given to assigning two islands of land in the vicinity of the Rail Road Flat Cemetery District to this District’s SOI. One area covers the community of Glencoe. Refer to the enclosed map showing the proposed SOI modifications.

Page 20: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-1

VIII. Conclusions and Recommendations

VIII:a. Conclusions

The public agencies providing cemetery services within the County provide adequate services to their respective geographic areas. The Boards of Trustees of the cemetery districts are appointed and should be commended for their volunteer contributions and efforts. The cemetery districts largely rely upon volunteer assistance plus some paid assistance for administration, maintenance and improvements.

Only one of the districts has a Capital Improvement Plans (CIPs) for their

cemetery. The other districts perform maintenance and improvements on an as needed basis. The preparation and periodic updating of CIPs are important in order to budget for and set necessary revenue targets to adequately maintain and improve the cemeteries within the County. Some of the Board of Trustees may need technical assistance to prepare adequate CIPs.

The cemetery districts have substantially large reserves in relationship to

their annual expenditures without documentation of how these funds will ultimately be used.

The Spheres of Influences of the cemetery districts cover large areas of

the County and in most cases adjoin each other. The Mountain Ranch area and greater Valley Springs area are not within any public cemetery districts. Also, there are a few islands of land adjacent to the Rail Road Flat Cemetery District and Vallecito Cemetery District that are not within a public cemetery district.

VIII:b. Recommendations It is recommended LAFCO adopt the following Resolutions approving the updated SOIs based upon the following written determinations and recommendations. A summary of these recommendations follows. It is recommended the County Board of Supervisors consider appointing themselves as the Board of Trustees of the cemetery districts. The current appointed Board of Trustees could continue their volunteer role of community liaison as advisory committees. The County should also consider the creation of a “Special Districts Coordinator” position within County government to manage the

Page 21: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-2

cemetery districts plus perform other special district functions. The Special District Coordinator would be responsible for working with the advisory committees in preparing capital improvement plans for each cemetery, proposing adequate funding sources and fees to undertake needed capital improvements, preparing long-range budgets taking into account acceptable reserve amounts, and applying for grant funding. The Special District Coordinator could also likely serve this function for the County’s Lighting Districts and County Service Areas, and provide technical assistance to the veteran’s memorial districts and park district, and fire districts. Funding for the Special Districts Coordinator position could come from a combination of special district funds and grant administration funding. Consideration should be given at the next Municipal Service Review update to consolidate the cemetery districts into one countywide district. This consideration would be especially pertinent if the County assumes the responsibility for the management of the cemetery districts. If the County Board of Supervisors decides not to appoint itself as Trustees and not create a Special District Coordinator position, the current Board of Trustees of the cemetery districts should at least prepare long-range Capital Improvements Plans with accompanying financial plans for adequate fees and reserve amounts. It is also recommended that the Sphere of Influences of the cemetery districts be amended as depicted upon the preceding map. It is recommended that the SOIs for the San Andreas, Copperopolis, Rail Road Flat and Vallecito Cemetery Districts be amended to include additional territory.

Page 22: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-3

Resolution 2005-__ of the

Local Agency Formation Commission of

Calaveras County, California

Approving a Municipal Service Review of Cemetery District Services Provided by the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District,

San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District and adopting Written Determinations Thereon

WHEREAS, California Government Code Section 56425 requires that a Local Agency Formation Commission (“LAFCO”) adopt and periodically review Sphere of Influence Plans for all agencies in its jurisdiction; and, WHEREAS, California Government Code Section 56430 requires that a LAFCO conduct a review of the municipal services provided by and within an agency prior to updating or adopting its Sphere of Influence Plan; and, WHEREAS, the Sphere of Influence Plan is the primary planning tool for LAFCO and defines the probable physical boundaries and service area of a local agency as determined by LAFCO; and, WHEREAS, the Commission adopted its Work Plan and included a schedule for completion of Municipal Service Reviews (MSRs) and Spheres of Influence; and WHEREAS, the State of California has established guidelines for conducting MSRs, which applies to this MSR for cemetery district services provided by the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District; and, WHEREAS, at the time and in the manner provided by law, the Executive Officer gave notice of the date, time, and place of a public hearing by the Commission for the services provided including approval of the report and adoption of the written determinations contained therein; and, WHEREAS, the Commission hereby determines that the final draft of the Municipal Service Review for public cemetery district services provided by and within Calaveras County and written determinations contained therein will provide information for updating the spheres of influence for cemetery districts managed by the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery

Page 23: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-4

District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District, and is otherwise consistent with the purposes and responsibility of the Commission for planning the logical and orderly development and coordination of local governmental agencies so as to advantageously provide for the present and future needs of the county and its communities; and, WHEREAS, in making this determination, the Commission has considered the documentation on file in this matter; and, WHEREAS, the Commission has heard all interested parties desiring to be heard and has considered the proposal and report by the Executive Officer and all other relevant evidence and information presented at said hearing; NOW, THEREFORE, the Local Agency Formation Commission of Calaveras County hereby resolves, orders and determines the following: The Municipal Service Review of public cemetery district services provided by the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District are attached hereto as Exhibit A, is approved and the written determinations presented in the Municipal Service Review report are hereby adopted. LAFCO staff is further ordered to proceed as appropriate with an update to the Sphere of Influence Plan for the public cemetery districts in and around the area served by the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District. LAFCO staff is further ordered to forward copies of this resolution containing the adopted Municipal Service Review to the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District. The foregoing resolution was duly passed by the Local Agency Formation Commission of Calaveras County at a regular meeting held on _______________________, by the following roll call vote:

Ayes: Noes: Abstentions: Absent:

Page 24: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-5

Signed and approved by me after its passage this day of , 2005. ______________________ Chair, Calaveras LAFCO Attest: _________________ John Benoit, Executive Officer LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION, Calaveras County

Page 25: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-6

Exhibit A 1. Regarding infrastructure needs and deficiencies, the Commission determines

that the public agencies have sufficient resources and the ability to ultimately serve the proposed SOIs. It is recommended Capital Improvement Plans be prepared for each public cemetery within the County.

2. Regarding growth and population projections for the affected area, the

Commission determines the proposed SOIs for the public agencies providing public cemetery services will facilitate the implementation of the County’s and City’s adopted land use plans.

3. Regarding financing constraints and opportunities, the Commission determines

the public agencies have sufficient financing opportunities to provide public cemetery services to the proposed SOIs and/or have the capability of raising funds for these purposes.

4. Regarding cost avoidance opportunities, the Commission determines the public

agencies to be the logical provider of public cemetery services in the proposed SOIs, that there will not be an overlapping of service boundaries with other agencies, and the agencies have undertaken cost avoidance opportunities.

5. Regarding opportunities for rate restructuring, the Commission determines the

rates of the public agencies to be fair and equitable. The Commission further determines the cemetery districts should prepare long-range plans and provide a basis for its reserve amounts prior to any future change in organization.

6. Regarding opportunities for shared facilities, the Commission determines that

the public agencies have reduced public service costs by sharing facilities, resources and programs with other entities.

7. Regarding governmental structure options, including the advantages and disadvantages of consolidation or reorganization of service providers, the Commission determines the current governmental structure of the public agencies are sufficient to carry out its mission without the need for consolidation or reorganization at this time. However, it is recommended the County Board of Supervisors should consider appointing itself as the Board of Trustees of the cemetery districts, establishing community advisory committees, and creating a position of Special District Coordinator to manage the cemetery districts plus perform other special district functions.

8. Regarding evaluation of management efficiencies, the Commission determines

the public agencies provide the highest quality of service with the lowest necessary expenditure of public funds.

Page 26: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-7

9. Regarding local accountability and governance, the Commission determines the

public agencies conduct their public agency decision making and operational and management processes in such a way that its customers and the general public have the opportunity to participate.

Page 27: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-8

Resolution No. 2005-__ LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION

OF CALAVERAS COUNTY

A Resolution Making Determinations and Approving a Sphere

of Influence Update for the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road

Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District

WHEREAS, Government Code Section 56425 requires each Local Agency Formation Commission to adopt and periodically review and update a sphere of influence for each local governmental agency within its jurisdiction; and

WHEREAS, the Local Agency Formation Commission of the County of Calaveras, in compliance with the aforementioned requirement, is providing a “plan for the probable physical boundaries and service area” for the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District; and

WHEREAS, the Commission has set the hearing date of _______________, for the update of the sphere of influence for the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District and has noticed this hearing at the times and as otherwise prescribed by Government Code Section 56150, et seq.; and WHEREAS, the Commission has heard and adopted a Municipal Services Review of services provided by the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District in accordance with Gov. Code section 56430; and

WHEREAS, the Commission has reviewed and considered the proposed Sphere of Influence update report and the proposed Sphere of Influence Update Maps which are attached hereto and incorporated herein; and

WHEREAS, Calaveras LAFCO considered project related environmental factors and determined that the subject project is not subject to the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act pursuant to Section 15060 (c)2; and

Page 28: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-9

WHEREAS, the Commission has considered those factors determined by it to be relevant to the proposed sphere of influence update, including, but not limited to, those factors specified in Government Code Section 56425, et seq., and has heard from interested parties and considered requests for amendment and/or revision of the proposed updated sphere boundary, if any; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Local Agency Formation Commission of the County of Calaveras does hereby find and determine as follows:

1. That the proposed sphere of influence update with respect to the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District comply with the provisions of Government Code Section 56000, et seq.

2. That no significant protests have been received regarding the

establishment of this Sphere of Influence update. 3. That, pursuant to Government Code Section 56425, the Commission

makes and adopts those determinations set forth below: a. The present and planned land uses in the area, including agricultural and

open space lands. Planned land uses in each respective sphere of influence lands planned for urban development including residential and commercial uses. Calaveras County has approved area plans delineating boundaries of ultimate growth limits in various community areas in the territory proposed for inclusion into the Sphere of Influence. The existing land uses surrounding the subject lands consist of a variety of residential and commercial uses.

b. The present and probable need for public facilities and services in the

area. The current and planned development of properties within the proposed Spheres of Influence will require cemetery services as development occurs. Other services are to be provided either by other service providers or the same service provider.

c. The present capacity of public facilities and adequacy of services that the agency is authorized to provide. The present capacity of the cemetery districts are adequate to provide cemetery services within the Sphere of Influence territory as described in Attachment “A” (the Municipal Service Review and Sphere of Influence Plan report).

Page 29: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-10

c. The existence of any social or economic communities of interest. The Commission determines the community and district areas described in Attachment “A” are each a unique social and economic community of interest and are distinct from one another.

4. The Commission makes a specific finding that there is no substantial

evidence in light of the whole record before Calaveras Local Agency Formation Commission that this Sphere Update for the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District may have a significant adverse effect on the environment and is not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act.

5. That the Sphere of Influence Update and Municipal Service Review

Report and Maps and the Executive Officer’s Report, for the Altaville Cemetery District, Copperopolis Cemetery District, Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District, Murphys Cemetery District, Rail Road Flat Cemetery District, San Andreas Cemetery District, Vallecito Cemetery District and West Point Cemetery District updated Spheres of Influence are hereby adopted and approved as set forth in Attachment “A”.

PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Local Agency Formation Commission of the County of Calaveras, State of California, on the ____________ 2005, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN:

_________________________ Chairman, Local Agency Formation Commission

of Calaveras County Attest: _____________________________ John Benoit, LAFCO Executive Officer Calaveras LAFCO

Page 30: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page VIII-11

Page 31: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page IX-1

IX. References Altaville Cemetery District Financial Statements, June 30, 2004, E. Clay Maddox, CPA. Copperopolis Cemetery District, Audit Report, June 30, 2004, Robert G. Martin, CPA. Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District Financial Statements, June 30, 2001, Robert G. Martin, CPA. Murphys Cemetery District Audit Report, June 30, 2001, Daniel J. Ayala, CPA. Rail Road Flat Cemetery District Financial Statements, June 30, 2002, Moss, Levy & Hartzheim, CPAs. San Andreas Cemetery District Financial Statements, June 30, 2001, Bain & Comings, LLP. Vallecito Cemetery District Financial Statements, June 30, 2004, E. Clay Maddox, CPA. West Point Financial Statements, June 30, 2004, Moss, Levy & Hartzheim, CPAs. Special Districts: Relics of the Past or Resources for the Future, Little Hoover Commission, May 2000.

Page 32: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-1

X. Appendices

X:a. Financial Overview

The following provides a financial overview of the cemetery districts. Some of the districts financial statements are prepared on an annual basis while others prepare the statements upon either a biennial or quinquennial period. All the cemetery districts for the reporting period had annual revenues exceeding annual expenses except the Murphys and Rail Road Flat Cemetery Districts. All of the districts have fund equity exceeding annual expenses between a ratio of 3.8 to 21.5. On average fund equity was 11.5 times larger than annual expenditures.

Financial Overview Cemetery District and Fiscal Year Ending Data

Total Revenue

($)

Total Expenses

($)

Revenues Over

(Under) Expenses

($)

Fund Equity End of Period

($)

Ratio between

Fund Equity

and Annual

Expenses Altaville 6/04 68,475 38,517 29,958 342,399 8.9 Copperopolis 6/04 6,399 2,970 3,429 41,201 13.9 Moke Hill 6/01 16,563 5,958 10,605 80,721 13.5 Murphys 6/01 49,019 50,904 (1,885) 191,217 3.8 Rail Rd Flat 6/02 5,579 7,130 (1,551) 30,859 4.3 San Andreas 6/01 24,379 21,806 3,293 108,895 5.2 Vallecito 6/04 7,787 1,924 5,863 41,383 21.5 West Point 6/04 27,315 11,856 15,459 250,129 21.1

Page 33: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-2

HWY 2 6

HWY 12

HWY

49

HWY 49

HWY 4

HWY 4

HWY 26

HWY 4

HWY 12

HWY

26

HWY 4

HWY 26

HWY 4

HWY 49

HWY 49

HWY 1 2

HWY 26

J ESUS MARIA RD

MOUNTAIN

RANCH RD MORAN

RD

RIDGE RD

SHEEP RANCH RD

RAI

LRO

AD

FLAT

RD

O'BYRNES FERRY RD

ValleySprings

WestPoint

Wallace

Tamarack

San Andreas

Rail Road Flat

Murphys

Mountain Ranch

Mokelumne Hill

Jenny Lind

Glencoe

Dorrington

Copperopolis

Burson

Angels Camp

Calaveras CountyCemetery Districts

Map Design and CartographyBy Calaveras County GISSan Andreas, CA 95249

May, 2005

4 0 4 82

Miles

All district boundaries are generalized and

are not to be used ona parcel by parcel basis.

LegendCemetery Districts

ALTAVILLE

COPPEROPOLIS

MOKELUMNE HILL

MURPHY'S

RAIL ROAD FLAT

SAN ANDREAS

VALLECITO

WEST POINT

Highways

Main Roads

Main Rivers

Lakes

County Boundary

Page 34: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-3

Tele graph Creek

Cop

per

Cre

ek

B

i g S

p

ri

n

gs

Cre

e

k

French Creek

G re e nh orn Gulch

Litt l ej

ohns C

reek

Indian C

re

e

k

W

aterm

an Cre

e

k

Aque

duct

Li ttle

jo

hn s

Cre e

k

Ro

c

k

y

Creek

S

ixmil e

C

reek

Hoo

ds

C

reek

Shirle

y

Creek

Sou

th D

itc h

Mar te

lls Cr

e

ek

Sta

nislaus Rive r

Stanislaus

River

Wa

term

an Cre

ek

MAIN ST

Blac

k

Creek

Bro wer C reek

Stani s la u

s R

ive

r

Lit

tle

j oh

n

s C

re

ek

Sla

te C

ree

k

Stanis

laus River

HWY 49Che

rokee Cre

e k

Clo

ve

r C

reek

B

ean G

ulch

U

nd erwood Cree

k

Ca

r s

on

Cre

ek

G

r

e

en

horn

C

re

ek

C

oyote

Cre

e

k

Dry

Cre

e

k

Bear

Creek

Thom

pso

n C

re

e k

Bear C ree k

HWY 4

OBYR

NES F

ER

RY

RD

South

D

itc

h

Rock Cre

ek

South G ulch

Littlejoh

n s

Creek

Stan islaus R

iver

A ngels Creek

Nassau

Cree

k

HWY 4

L

it

tle joh n

s

Cr

e

ek

Bla

ck Cree

k

Whis

ky C

reek

Ange

ls C

ree

k

Mc Ca

rt y Creek

S

tani slaus R

i ver

A

ngels

Cre

ek

HWY4

Copperopolis

Angels Camp

CopperopolisCemetery District

Map Design and CartographyBy Calaveras County GISSan Andreas, CA 95249

May, 2005

1 0 1 2 3 40.5

Miles

LegendCopperopolis Cemetery District

Lakes

Parcels

Roads

Highways

Main Creeks

All district boundaries are generalized and

are not to be used ona parcel by parcel basis.

Page 35: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-4

J ESUS MARIA

HWY26

North Fo rk Calaveras River

No

rth

Fork

Cal av

eras River

North Fork M urray Cre ek

Nor

th For k C a lave ras Ri ver

J esus Maria C reek

J esus Maria Creek

Salamander Creek

Esp eranz a Cree k

H WY

26

Mokel umne River

MA

IN S

T

RIDGE

RD

HWY 49 HWY 26

Mokelumne

Hill

Mokelumne Hill

Cemetery District

Map Design and Cartography

By Calaveras County GIS

San Andreas, CA 95249

May, 2005

0.6 0 0.6 1.20.3

Miles

Legend

Mokelumne Hill Cemetery District

Parcels

Roads

Highways

Main Creeks

Lakes

All district boundaries

are generalized and

are not to be used on

a parcel by parcel basis.

Page 36: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-5

JESU S MARIA

H unter Cre ek

R IDGE RD

U ti ca Di tc h

Uti ca Di tch

A i rola Cre ek

S out h Fork

W i ll

ow

Cr

ee

k

Mil l C

r ee

k

Ut

ica

Ditch

Bellf

our C

anyo

n

Pepp er

mint Cr ee

k

Little Mokelumne Ri v er

W illow Cr eek

Love Cr ee k

Willow Creek

Sixm

i le Cr eek

Je

lmini

C reek

J

upit er Di tch

Ind

ian

Cre

ek

Coyote C ree

k

Mo

ran C reek

M ur

ray Cr eek

Aque

duct

Mid dle Fo rk Mo kel umne Rive r

Midd le For k Mo ke lumne River

Bea r T

ra p Ba s in

O 'Neil Cree k

Ind ian Creek

Bear Creek

S alam

ander Creek

Ch er o kee

Creek

Sa

n A nto

nio Cr eek

Sa

n Ant o ni o Cree k

San An to n io

Cr

e ek

San Anto ni o Cr eek

S outh F ork Moke lumn e River

MO

RA

N RD

Lion C reek

Nor

t h Fo

rk Mu

rr ay Cr eek

Jesus M ari a Creek

Jes us Ma ria C ree k

MOU NTAIN RA NCH RD

Hayw ar d Cr ee k

Esp eran za Cre ek

M oore Cr eek

Bloo

ds Cr

eek

Fo res t C re ek

F ores t Creek

Sa

n Do mi ngo

Cree k

San D omingo Creek

Stanislaus

River

Sw

amp Cr e ek

Dry Cre ek

L ightn ing Cr eek

McK

inney

Cre ek

Nor th F ork

St ani s lau

s R ive r

Murra y Creek

Co op

ers Creek

M urra y Creek

RAIL R

OA D FL

AT RD

Sou th Fo

rk

Mo kelumne River

Eldo rado Creek

Coy ote C r e

ek

Lit tle Mokelumne River

San D o ming o C

re ek

Blue CreekBlue C ree k

HWY 49

N orth F ork Stanis l au

s R

iver

M oke

l um

n e

Rive r

North

Fork Mo kelum ne Ri ver

Nass

au

C

ree k

Cal averi tas Cr eek

Mi dd le F

o r k M

okelumn e Riv er

An

gels Cr ee

k

Dut

ch Cr

e ek

San Anto nio Cr ee

k

Coy

o

te

C reek

Mill Cre

ek

HWY 26

An gel s Creek

Fr e nc h G

u lch

No

rt h

Fo rk Sta

ni sl aus

Ri ver

Nort h For k Mok e lu

mne

Ri

ver

North For k Mokelumn

e Ri ver

S

out h Fo

rk Mo

kelu mne

Ri ver

Sout h

D

itch

North Fo rk Mokelumn e Ri ver

HWY4

Big

Me adow

Cre

ek

Mat tle y Creek

Bass

ella

Cr

eek

Lick in g ForkLic k ing Fo rk

MAIN ST

Nort h

Fork

Stan

is lau

s R iver

Nort h For k C

a lave r as R i v er

Je s u

s Mar ia C

reek B ig Trees Creek

Ch

er o

k ee Creek

HWY4

SHEEP RANC

H R

D

HWY 4

O 'Neil C re e k

Forest Cre

ek

RAILROA

D F LAT R

D

RAILROAD

FLAT RDUt

ic a

Dit ch

MAIN ST

North Fork Ca laveras River

West Point

Tamarack

SheepRanch

RailRoadFlat

Murphys

Mountain Ranch

Glencoe

Dorrington

Arnold

AngelsCamp

Murphy'sCemetery District

Map Design and CartographyBy Calaveras County GISSan Andreas, CA 95249

May, 2005

2.5 0 2.5 51.25

Miles

LegendMurphy's Cemetery District

Lakes

Parcels

Roads

Highways

Main Creeks

All district boundaries are generalized and

are not to be used ona parcel by parcel basis.

Page 37: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-6

HWY4

HWY 26

JESUS MA RIA

Hunt er Creek

Murra y Creek

RIDGE RD

MOR AN RD

Little Mok elumne River

Eldorado Cre e k

Ai rola Creek

Mo ran

Creek

Love

Creek

Middle Fork Mo kelum

n e RiverMi ddl e

Fork Mokelu mne Riv er

O'Neil Creek

Bear Creek

S

alamander Cre ek

San Ant o nio Cr ee

k

Sa n

An ton io Cr e ek

South Fork Mok elumne River

Lion Creek

Salamande r Cr eek

Esperanza Creek

Jesus Maria Creek

Jesu s Maria Creek

MOUNTAIN R ANCH

RD

Sou th Fork Mok e lum

ne River

Hayward Creek

Esperanz a Cr eekEsper anza Creek

MAI

N ST

S wamp Creek

Lightning Creek

SHEEP RAN

CH R

D

Forest Creek

F orest Cr e ek

R AILROAD F

LAT

RD

Li ttl e Mokelumne River

McK inney Creek

B lue Cree k

S outh Fork M okelumne R iver

Mi dd le For k Mok e

lum ne R iver

Dut c

h Cr eek

Nort h Fork Mokel umn e RiverNorth Fork Mokelumne River

South Fork Mok elum

ne

Rive r

So uth Fo rk M

okel um ne R iver

Li cking Fork

L icking Fo rk

Bass

el l

a C reek

Big Trees Creek

Mi ddl e Fo

r k M okelumne

Ri v er

S out h

Fork Mokel umn e Ri

ver

South Fo

rk Moke

lumn e River

North Fork Mokelumne Rive

r

Nor t h Fork Mok elumn e River

Fo re st CreekH

W

Y 26

North

For k Stanis

laus Ri

ver

R AILR O AD FLAT

RD

RAILROAD

FLAT RD

MAIN ST

North Fork Calave ras River

West Point

Rail Road Flat

Glencoe

Dorrington

Arnold

Rail Road FlatCemetery District

Map Design and CartographyBy Calaveras County GISSan Andreas, CA 95249

May, 2005

1 0 1 20.5

Miles

LegendRail Road Flat Cemetery District

Lakes

Parcels

Roads

Highways

Main Creeks

All district boundaries are generalized and

are not to be used ona parcel by parcel basis.

Page 38: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-7

JESUS MARIA

HWY26

South

F

o rk

Willo

w C

re

ek

Wil low Creek

Will o

w Cre

ek

U tic

a Dit c h

Murr

a

y Cre

ek

Sa

n Andreas C

ree k

RAIL

RO

AD F L

AT

RD

O'Neil C

reek

Mu r r ay

Creek

Sa

lam

a

nder

Cre

ek

Mu r ray C reek

B

ear C

reek

Coo

pers C

reek

Nort h Fork

Murray Cr

eek

San Do

mingo

Cre

ek

MOUNTAIN RANCH RD

Nort

h F

o

rk

C

ala

veras Riv

er

Cosg ro ve Creek

S

an

D

o

mingo C

r eek

HWY 12

M

c

K

in

n

ey C

re

ek

Bea

r C

reek

Je

s

u s Ma

ria Cree

k

Mu r ray Cre

ek

Murray Cr eek

Calaveras River

Y

oun

g

s

Cr e

ek

E

ldora

do

Cre

e

k

Sa

n Domingo Creek

S prin

g

Valle

y

Cre

ek

Moke lum

ne River

Calaveri t a s Cr eek

S a

n Anto nio C ree k

F rench

Gu l c

h

India n Cr ee k

C alaverita

s C reek

Bla

c

k

S

prin g Cr

ee

k

San A

nto

nio Cr

e

ek

Esperan za

Cre ek

S

ou

th

Fork

C

alav

era

s R

iv

er

HWY 49

HWY12

S tee le Creek

HWY12

MA

IN S

T

Sou

th

Fo

r k C

a lave

ra

s Riv

er

HW

Y 49

Je

sus Ma

r i a C ree k

San Andreas

MountainRanch

San AndreasCemetery District

Map Design and CartographyBy Calaveras County GISSan Andreas, CA 95249

May, 2005

0.75 0 0.75 1.5 2.25 30.375

Miles

LegendSan Andreas Cemetery District

Lakes

Parcels

Roads

Highways

Main Creeks

All district boundaries are generalized and

are not to be used ona parcel by parcel basis.

Page 39: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-8

S outh Ditch

Utica Di tc h

S ixmile Cre ek

Littl

e Dr

y Cr

eek

In dian Cr

eek

Utica Di tch

RU

NN

ING

SP

RING

S RD

VA

LLE CIT

O BLUFFS RD

HWY 4Dry

Creek

CAR SON S T

HWY 4 ACCESS RD

South

Ditch

RANCH RD

Dry Creek

Coyote

Creek

PYSHON R

D

MAIN ST

PAR

RO

TTS

FERR

Y R

D

BOR BE

RANC

H RD

C oyot

e Cr

eek

RED

HILL R

D

Stan

islau

s RiverRE D HI LL

RD

CA MP NI NE RD

French G ulch

FREN

CH GUL CH

RD

J

UNI PER

DR

MA

IN S

T

MO

ANIN

G C

AVE

R D

RE

D H

ILL A

CC

ESS

RD

Angels Creek

RED HIL L RD

SIX

MILE RD

MAI

N ST

POAG RDOL

D MU

RP HYS RD

OLD

MUR

PHY

S R

D

BAT

TEN

RD

SIX

MIL

E R D

MURPHYS

GRADE

RD

SI X MILE R DCAN

YON

DR

VallecitoCemetery District

Map Design and CartographyBy Calaveras County GISSan Andreas, CA 95249

May, 2005

0.4 0 0.4 0.80.2

Miles

LegendVallecito Cemetery District

Parcels

Roads

Highways

Main Creeks

Lakes

All district boundaries are generalized and

are not to be used ona parcel by parcel basis.

Page 40: Public Cemetery District Services - Calaveras LAFCo · Public Cemetery District Services Adopted August 15 2005 Lafco Resolutions 2005-11 and 2005-12 Local Agency Formation Commission

Municipal Service Review Study Calaveras County LAFCO Cemetery Districts Page X-9

Hunter Creek

Little Mokelu

m ne River

Airola

Creek

Moore

Cre ek

Bear Creek

STA NL

EY RD

Sa

n An tonio

Cre

ek

Sout h Fork M

o

kelu m

n

e Riv

er

Lion Creek

AIRSTRIP

Esp

e ranza Creek

J esus Maria C reek

Sou th Fo

rk

Moke

lu mn e

Riv

er

Hayward Creek

Es peranz a C re

ek

LYNN

BV

Blue Cr ee k

PO

NDEROS

A W Y

HW Y 26

Sw

amp Cree k

L ightnin g Cr eek

MAS

ON

RD

Little M oke

lum

ne R

iver

HWY 26

Fore

s t C

reek

Mo

ke

lumne R

ive

r

Sou

th Fork M okelumne Riv

er

S PINK RD

Mid

dle F

or

k Mokelum n

e Ri

ver

Dutch C

r eek

SPI NK RD

North F ork

M

o ke

lumne Ri

ve

r

T R EE LN

North Fork Moke lu

mne R iv er

D OE R

D

S

outh

F

ork

Moke

lum ne Ri

v

er

WINTON RD

Sou

th F o

rk Mok

elumn e

River

BALD MO UNTA IN

RD

HWY 4

OUT

BAC

K W

Y

Lic king Fork

Licking Fork

HIGD ON RD

N

o

rth F o

r k Ca la

ve

r as River

SILVER MO

U NTA IN RD

Forest C reek

JESU

S MARIA

RD

Mi

d dl

e F

o r k M

o k elum

n e Riv e

r

M idd le Fo r

k Mo kelumn e

R iv er

TOP DOLLA

R RD

South

Fo rk

Mo ke

lu

m

n

e R

iver

F

ore

st C

r e

ek

BL U E MOU NTAIN RD

BAILEY RI DGE R D

RIDGE RD

S KUN

K H

OLL

OW

L N

N

BALD MOUNTAIN R

D

MITC H ELL

M

ILL R

D

PRU

SSIAN HI L L RD

BA NNE R

RD

JUR

S RD

S

CHA D D

RD

SCH

ADD

RD

SUM

MI T LEV

EL RD

North F ork Ca

laveras River

SU MMIT L EVEL RD

WI NTON RD

SK

ULL FL AT RD LILY GAP RD

SU MMIT L EVEL R DWestPoint

RailRoad Flat

Glencoe

Dorrington

West PointCemetery District

Map Design and CartographyBy Calaveras County GISSan Andreas, CA 95249

May, 2005

0.8 0 0.8 1.6 2.4 3.2 40.4

Miles

Legend

Parcels

Roads

Highways

Main Creeks

West Point Cemetery District

Lakes

All district boundaries are generalized and

are not to be used ona parcel by parcel basis.