public defender services annual reportpds.wv.gov/documents/fy15 - annual report.pdf · public...

214
Public Defender Services FISCAL YEAR 2015 PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES ANNUAL REPORT One Players Club Drive, Suite 301 Charleston, WV 25311 Phone:304-558-3905 Fax: 304-558-1098 Website: www.pds.wv.gov DANA F. EDDY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

Upload: nguyentu

Post on 07-Feb-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Public Defender Services

F I S C A L Y E A R 2 0 1 5

P U B L I C D E F E N D E R S E R V I C E S

A N N U A L R E P O R T

One Players Club Drive, Suite 301

Charleston, WV 25311

Phone:304-558-3905

Fax: 304-558-1098

Website: www.pds.wv.gov DANA F. EDDY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

Table of ContentsExecutive Director's PageExecutive Summary--Indigent Defense in West Virginia Infographic (FY15) --Appointed Counsel Summary--PDC SummaryAgency Information--Staff, History, and OrganizationFinancial Data--Summary of Appropriations, Expenditures, and Fund --Balances Statement of Revenues, Expenditures, and Changes Division Reports--Auditing and Accounting Division----Voucher Processing----Public Defender Corporations--Criminal Law Research Center--Appellate Advocacy Division--Indigent Defense CommissionAppendix A - Appointed Counsel StatisticsAppendix B - PDC StatisticsAppendix C - Appointed Counsel/PDC Comparisons Appendix D - AC Payee Totals--Top 100 Highest Compensated--Total Billed Travel TimeAppendix E - Historical Overview of Key Statistical Indicators

1345678

202123242525262730313289

126148190197212

The Executive Director’s Page

Public Defender Services’ administrative responsibilities include, by statute, processing for payment the vouchers setting forth the court-appointed counsel’s claims for fees and reimbursement of expenses; providing and administering grants to public defender corporations

operating in eighteen (18) judicial circuits; operating an appellate advocacy division; and providing support to criminal defense lawyers through a criminal law research center. In all these areas, the agency strives for excellence. However, each day in the world of indigent defense brings new challenges or exposes existing flaws.

The agency’s most daunting problem is overcoming the perception that panel attorneys are overbilling. This perception is the hurdle most often encountered in the effort to increase the rates of compensation. A common refrain from lawmakers or administrators is that, “attorneys have given themselves a raise”. One statistic is sufficient

to attest to an endemic problem in the billing: Since January 1, 2013, attorneys have billed over twenty-four hours in a day 183 times. This number will increase as additional vouchers with services in FY2015 are received.

The agency is auditing the vouchers of attorneys who are identified as billing in excess of twenty-four hours and have conferred with eleven counsel directly. The effort will continue. The hope is that by the end of FY2016, the level of billing will not be so obviously open to criticism, and a raise in the rates of compensation, assuming funding is available, will be more readily discussed.

In FY2015, Public Defender Services achieved a goal of processing vouchers for payment within thirty days of receipt. Unfortunately, the funding for the vouchers has not kept pace and attorneys may not be beneficiaries, yet, of this increased efficiency. In FY2015, the agency processed 36,266 vouchers.

In FY2015, Public Defender Services structured the funding for a public defender corporation in the Fourth Judicial Circuit of West Virginia and assisted in the formulation of a board of directors for the corporation. The anticipation is that the public defender corporation will take appointments, commencing in January 2016.

In FY2015, Public Defender Services provided continuing legal education credits to 264 attorneys throughout the state; provided newsletters summarizing all opinions of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia; and provided summaries of legislation affecting criminal laws.

In closing, a delicate balance has to be reached by the agency. Public Defender Services is charged with “administer[ing], coordinat[ing,] and evaluat[ing] programs by which the state provides legal representation to indigent persons”. This means supporting attorneys in the effort, but it also means addressing issues with attorneys and challenging attorneys on questionable practices. So, at times, the agency will be perceived as an antagonist rather than a protagonist.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 1 of 212

While unfortunate, this is also unavoidable. In FY2016, the agency will continue to strive to achieve this balance and to enhance the experience of defending individuals whose liberty interests are at stake and who do not have the means to hire legal counsel.

Respectfully,

Dana F. Eddy Executive Director Public Defender Services

Front Row: Dana Eddy, Sarah Saul, Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin, Sheila Coughlin, Crystal Walden Second Row: Teresa Asbury, Brenda Thompson, Marjorie K. Wilson, Rachel Flynn, Don Stennett Third Row: Kimberly Bennett, Jonathan Friley, Lee Carper Back Row: Rhonda Ashworth, Heather Atkins, Lori Waller, Pam Clark, Jason Parmer,

Jackie Linthicome, Matt Brummond Not Picture: Betsy Chapman, Rosa McFarland

FY2015 Annual Report Page 2 of 212

Executive Summary

• Indigent Defense In West Virginia – FY2015 Infographic

• Appointed Counsel Summary

• Public Defender Corporation Summary

FY2015 Annual Report Page 3 of 212

Indigent Defense in West Virginia FY2015

Appointed Counsel

Public Defender Corporations

Claims Paid Cases Closed

Total Amount Total Paid in Claims Disbursements

Average Cost

Per Hour

Average Cost Per Case

* Average cost per hour for Public Defender Corpora ons is calculated by removing Administra ve Time (i.e., all

non‐client related work, such as office administra on and paid leave). This provides a be er indicator of the

amount it costs for direct legal services to compare to Appointed Counsel. If you include Administra ve Time, the

average cost per hour for Public Defender Corpora ons is $69.91.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 4 of 212

Total Amount Paid In Claims $25,954,897.24

Total Fees Paid to Counsel $23,399,286.67

Total Expenses Paid $2,555,610.57

Total Hours In‐Court 74,773.5

Total Hours Out‐Of‐Court 411,952.9

Total Number of Hours Paid 486,726.4

Percent of Total Hours In‐Court 15.36%

Percent of Total Hours Out‐Of‐Court 84.64%

Percent of Total Funds Paid Attributable To Fees 90.15%

Percent of Total Funds Paid Attributable To Expenses 9.85%

Average Total Cost Per Hour $53.33

Total Claims Paid 36,205

Less: Supplemental Claims Paid (1,669)

Less: Direct Claims Paid (777)

Total Claims Paid without Supplemental & Direct 33,759

All Claims W/O Supp & Dir.

Average Total Cost Per Claim $716.89 $768.83

Average Counsel Fee Per Claim $646.30 $693.13

Average Expenses Per Claim $70.59 $75.70

Comparative Analysis between All Claims and Claims With Out Supplemental and Direct

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL FISCAL YEAR 2015

STATISTICAL SUMMARY

FY2015 Annual Report Page 5 of 212

Total Number of Cases Closed

Total Amount Disbursed to Corporations*1

Average Total Cost Per Cases Closed

SUMMARY OF HOURS**

Total In Court Hours Worked

Total Out of Court Hours Worked

Total Drug Court Hours Worked

Total Administrative Hours Worked

Total Number of Hours Worked during FY 2014

Average Total Cost Per Hour

Percent of Total In Court Hours

Percent of Total Out of Court Hours

Percent of Drug Court Hours Worked

Percent of Total Administrative Hours

**Note: The Summary of Hours illustrates the difference in considering the total 

administration time reported by Public Defenders. These Administrative Hours include 

Holiday, Sick and Annual Leave hours paid to Corporation Attorneys. Moreover, it includes 

performance reviews as well as management of the facilities and personnel. It also includes 

time that cannot readily be allocated to a single case such as representing numerous clients 

on the same day in municipal court and peer reviewing files to ensure adequate legal 

representation by counsel. 

0.51% 0.68%

25.25% Not Considered

*Note: Total amount disbursed includes payments made on behalf of Corporations to audit 

providers; Office of Technology; State Auditor’s Office; and Legal Research Services.

1  Excludes $400,000 grant to 4TH Judicial Circuit PDC for startup expenses. This figure will be 

included in the FY16 cost‐per‐case calculation.

69.91 93.53

21.32% 28.52%

52.92% 70.79%

1,297.70 1,297.70

64,124.00 Not Considered

253,930.20 189,806.20

With Admin Without Admin

54,135.50 54,135.50

134,373.00 134,373.00

$535.22

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES

STATISTICAL SUMMARY

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS FISCAL YEAR  2015

33,170.00

$17,753,257.00

FY2015 Annual Report Page 6 of 212

Agency Information

FY2015 Annual Report Page 7 of 212

Agency Contact Information

Dana F. Eddy Executive Director Betsy Chapman Executive Assistant Donald L. Stennett Deputy Director Marjorie K. Wilson Chief Financial Officer Brenda K. Thompson General Counsel

One Players Club Drive, Suite 301

Charleston, WV 25311

Phone: (304) 558-3905 Fax: (304) 558-1098

Criminal Law Research Center Pam Clark Coordinator

Appellate Division Crystal Walden Director Matthew Brummond Appellate Counsel Jason Parmer Appellate Counsel Lori Waller Appellate Counsel Sarah Saul Paralegal Rhonda Ashworth Secretary

Accounting and Auditing Division Marjorie K. Wilson Director Jonathan Friley PDC Administrator Teresa Asbury Supervisor Heather Atkins Accounting Technician Rosa McFarland Accounting Technician Rachel Flynn Accounting Technician Kimberly Bennett Accounting Technician

Operations Donald L. Stennett Director Jackie Linthicome Receptionist Lee Carper Office Manager

Special Projects Sheila Coughlin Coordinator

FY2015 Annual Report Page 8 of 212

Employee Recognition & Activities

We host monthly luncheons to recognize the accomplishments of various members of our team. One of our more notable achievement luncheons was a tailgate theme, complete with grilled lunch and cornhole.

Pictured: Pam Clark, CLRC Coordinator, is all laughs

Pictured: Teresa Asbury, Kimberly Bennett, Heather Atkins, Rachel

Flynn, and Rosa McFarland after Teresa left Dana a surprise (see below)

Pictured: Teresa Asbury shows Dana Eddy what happened to the last person who beat her in cornhole

FY2015 Annual Report Page 9 of 212

We also hosted an agency-wide CPR certification class and held a staff retreat one afternoon at Coonskin Park.

Pictured: Matt Brummond, Brenda Thompson, Sheila Coughlin, Teresa Asbury, Lori Waller, and Rhonda Ashworth at the staff retreat

Pictured: Don Stennett observes Lori Waller, Lee Carper, and Rhonda Ashworth’s CPR skills

FY2015 Annual Report Page 10 of 212

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES Historical Overview

1. The State of West Virginia’s Constitutional Obligation.

Over fifty years ago, the Supreme Court of the United States recognized that:

[R]eason and reflection require us to recognize that in our adversary system of criminal justice, any person haled into court, who is too poor to hire a lawyer, cannot be assured a fair trial unless counsel is provided for him. This seems to us to be an obvious truth. Governments, both state and federal, quite properly spend vast sums of money to establish machinery to try defendants accused of crime. Lawyers to prosecute are everywhere deemed essential to protect the public’s interest in an orderly society. … The right of one charged with crime to counsel may not be deemed fundamental and essential to fair trials in some countries, but it is in ours. From the very beginning, our state and national constitutions and laws have laid great emphasis on procedural and substantive safeguards designed to assure fair trials before impartial tribunals in which every defendant stands equal before the law. This noble idea cannot be realized if the poor man charged with crime has to face his accusers without a lawyer to assist him.

Gideon v. Wainwright, 372 U.S. 335, 344, 83 S.Ct. 792 (1963). With this decision, the Supreme Court of the United States extended the Sixth Amendment guarantee of the assistance of counsel in criminal prosecutions to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment. Essentially, states had to provide counsel for persons who were too poor to pay for legal services when these persons were confronted with criminal charges or the loss of other important rights by reason of state action.

The Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia reaffirmed this constitutional mandate as follows:

“There can be no equal justice where the kind of trial a man gets depends on the amount of money he has. ...” Griffin v. Illinois, 351 U.S. 12, 76 S.Ct. 585, 100 L.Ed. 891 (1956). … The state must, as a matter of equal protection, provide indigents with the basic tools for an adequate defense or appeal, when those tools are available for a price to others.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 11 of 212

State v. England, 363 S.E.2d 725, 727 (W. Va. 1987). Accordingly, a defense must be provided to indigent defendants and the defense must include not only the services of the attorney, but the provision of other services and material, including the transcripts of proceedings. Id. 2. The Legislative Findings. In 1981, the following was codified at W. Va. Code §29-21-1:

The Legislature finds and declares that in certain proceedings the state is required to provide high quality legal assistance to indigent persons who would be otherwise unable to afford adequate legal counsel; that providing legal representation to those who face an economic barrier to adequate legal counsel will serve the ends of justice in accordance with rights and privileges guaranteed to all citizens by the Constitution of the United States of America and the constitution of the state of West Virginia; that the availability of quality legal assistance reaffirms the faith of our citizens in our government of laws; that the present system which utilizes appointed counsel is not operating satisfactorily in some areas of this state and the Legislature is presently unable to determine what system or systems will provide the most efficient means for providing legal representation; that there is a need to explore alternative methods of delivering legal assistance, including the use of salaried public defenders complemented by private panel attorneys; that innovative programs and pilot projects as well as a continuation of the present appointed counsel system are necessary in separate areas of the state to provide information and experience upon which to base future legislative action.

The West Virginia Public Legal Services Council was then created “for the purpose of facilitating required legal representation of indigent persons”. W. Va. Code §29-21-3 (1981; superseded in 1989). In 1989, the agency was renamed as Public Defender Services and was charged as follows:

The agency shall have as its principal purpose the development and improvement of programs by which the state provides legal representation to indigent persons.

W. Va. Code §29-21-4. This remains the agency’s charge.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 12 of 212

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES An Organizational Overview

VISION: “There can be no equal justice where the kind of trial a man gets depends on the amount of money he has.” Griffin v. Illinois, 351 U.S. 12 (1956)

MISSION STATEMENT: To fulfill the State of West Virginia’s constitutional obligation to provide quality legal assistance to persons who otherwise could not afford legal counsel in proceedings in which the person’s liberty interests are at stake. ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE: Public Defender Services is within the Department of Administration for the State of West Virginia. The chief administrative officer is the Executive Director, who is appointed by the governor.

The agency has three divisions. The Accounting and Auditing Division is charged with the following responsibilities:

The agency shall establish and the executive director or his or her designee shall operate an accounting and auditing division to require and monitor the compliance with this article by public defender corporations and other persons or entities receiving funding or compensation from the agency. The accounting and auditing division shall review all plans and proposals for grants and contracts and shall make a recommendation of approval or disapproval to the executive director. The accounting and auditing division shall prepare, or cause to be prepared, reports concerning the evaluation, inspection or monitoring of public defender corporations and other grantees, contractors, persons or entities receiving financial assistance under this article and shall further carry out the agency's responsibilities for records and reports as set forth in section eighteen of this article. The accounting and auditing division shall require each public defender corporation to submit financial statements monthly and to report monthly on the billable and nonbillable time of its professional employees, including time used in administration of the respective offices, so as to compare the time to similar time expended in nonpublic law offices for similar activities. The accounting and auditing division shall provide to the executive director assistance in the fiscal administration of all of the agency's divisions. This assistance shall include, but not be limited to, budget preparation and statistical analysis.

W. Va. Code §29-21-6(d).

FY2015 Annual Report Page 13 of 212

The Accounting and Auditing Division also contains the voucher processing staff that processes for payment the vouchers which are submitted by private attorneys who accept appointments in eligible proceedings, which are defined as follows:

Criminal charges which may result in incarceration; juvenile proceedings; proceedings to revoke parole or probation if the revocation may result in incarceration; contempt of court; child abuse and neglect proceedings which may result in a termination of parental rights; mental hygiene commitment proceedings; extradition proceedings; proceedings which are ancillary to an eligible proceeding, including, but not limited to, proceedings to enhance sentences brought pursuant to sections eighteen and nineteen, article eleven, chapter sixty-one of this code, forfeiture proceedings brought pursuant to article seven, chapter sixty-a of this code, and proceedings brought to obtain extraordinary remedies; and appeals from or post-conviction challenges to the final judgment in an eligible proceeding. Legal representation provided pursuant to the provisions of this article is limited to the court system of the state of West Virginia, but does not include representation in municipal courts unless the accused is at risk of incarceration ….

W. Va. Code §29-21-2(2). The Criminal Law Research Center is another division of the agency and has the following statutory charge:

(1) Undertake research, studies and analyses and act as a central repository, clearinghouse and disseminator of research materials; (2) Prepare and distribute a criminal law manual and other materials and establish and implement standard and specialized training programs for attorneys practicing criminal law; (3) Provide and coordinate continuing legal education programs and services for attorneys practicing criminal law; and (4) Prepare, supplement and disseminate indices and digests of decisions of the West Virginia supreme court of appeals and other courts, statutes and other legal authorities relating to criminal law.

W. Va. Code §29-21-7. Finally, the agency’s third division, the Appellate Advocacy Division is established as follows:

The agency shall establish and the executive director or his or her designee shall operate an appellate advocacy division for the purpose of prosecuting litigation on behalf of eligible clients in the Supreme Court of Appeals. The executive director or his or her

FY2015 Annual Report Page 14 of 212

designee shall be the director of the appellate advocacy division. The appellate advocacy division shall represent eligible clients upon appointment by the circuit courts or by the Supreme Court of Appeals. The division may, however, refuse the appointments due to a conflict of interest or if the executive director has determined the existing caseload cannot be increased without jeopardizing the appellate division's ability to provide effective representation. In order to effectively and efficiently use the resources of the appellate division, the executive director may restrict the provision of appellate representation to certain types of cases. The executive director may select and employ staff attorneys to perform the duties prescribed by this subsection. The appellate division shall maintain records of representation of eligible clients for record purposes only.

W. Va. Code §29-21-6(e). In addition to the agency’s divisions, the statutory framework for the agency includes two additional entities. Indigent Defense Commission.

The first is the Indigent Defense Commission. Specifically,

(a) There is hereby established the Indigent Defense Commission to provide assistance to Public Defender Services with regard to the general policies and procedures of the agency, including, but not limited to, the opening, closing or merging of public defender offices throughout the state and the establishment of performance measures for the qualitative review of indigent defense.

(b) In order to demonstrate a collaborative approach to solving criminal justice problems, the commission shall consist of the Executive Director of Public Defender Services, who shall serve as chair, and the following members appointed by the Governor:

(1) One former or retired circuit judge;

(2) Three lawyers, one from each congressional district,

who have significant experience in the defense of criminal cases or have demonstrated a strong commitment to quality representation of indigent defendants;

FY2015 Annual Report Page 15 of 212

(3) One current chief public defender; […],

(4) One nonlawyer with a demonstrated commitment to providing legal services to the indigent;

(5) One person who is a member of an organization that

advocates on behalf of people with mental illness and developmental disabilities; and

(6) One attorney with significant experience in the defense of juvenile delinquency and abuse and neglect cases.

(c) The commission shall meet at the times and places specified by

the call of the chair: Provided, That the commission shall meet no less than four times each year. Members shall serve without compensation but may receive reimbursement of actual and necessary expenses for each day or portion thereof engaged in this discharge of official duties in a manner consistent with the guidelines of the Travel Management Office of the Department of Administration. …

(f) The commission has the following powers and duties:

(1) To develop standards regarding the qualifications and training for public defenders, assistant public defenders and staff;

(2) To explore opportunities related to the training of appointed panel attorneys;

(3) To evaluate, on an annual basis, the compensation and caseloads of public defenders and appointed panel attorneys;

(4) To develop standards for providing and compensating expert witnesses, investigators and other persons who provide services related to legal representation under this article;

(5) To study, monitor and evaluate existing standards for determining eligibility for legal representation under section sixteen of this article;

(6) To study the feasibility and need of creating additional public defender corporations, the activation of public defender corporations and the formation of multicircuit

FY2015 Annual Report Page 16 of 212

or regional public defender corporations in accordance with the provisions of section eight of this article;

(7) To study the potential for the dissolution of public defender corporations;

(8) To study, monitor, evaluate and make recommendations regarding the training, experience and background necessary for a public defender or panel attorney to competently represent indigent defendants in capital cases; and

(9) To monitor and make recommendations regarding the following activities of the board of directors of each public defender corporation receiving funding pursuant to this article:

(A) The appointment of the public defender and any

assistant public defenders pursuant to subdivision (1), subsection (c), section fifteen of this article;

(B) The fixing of professional and clerical salaries pursuant to subdivision (2), subsection (c), section fifteen of this article; and

(C) The removal of any public defender, assistant public defender or other employee for misfeasance, malfeasance or nonfeasance pursuant to subdivision (3), subsection (c), section fifteen of this article.

W. Va. Code §29-21-3b. Public Defender Corporations. The second entity is the public defender corporation, which, if active within a judicial circuit, is “to provide legal representation … in accordance with the provisions” of the governing statute. W. Va. Code §29-21-8(a)(2).

For each public defender corporation, a board of directors is appointed. The chairperson of the board is appointed by the governor. One to two members for each county in the judicial circuit are appointed by the county commission. One to two additional members are appointed by each county bar association within the judicial circuit. The board selects a “chief” public defender who is then responsible for the delivery of legal services by the corporation. Unless

FY2015 Annual Report Page 17 of 212

inconsistent with the governing statute, the provisions of the state’s nonprofit corporate laws govern the public defender corporations.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 18 of 212

Financial Data

• Summary of Appropriations, Expenditures, and Fund Balances

• Statement of Revenues, Expenditures, and Changes in Fund Balances

FY2015 Annual Report Page 19 of 212

0010

009

900

4350

035

200

7880

091

300

TOTA

LTO

TAL

APPR

OPR

IATI

ON

S20

15 A

PP

RO

PR

IAT

ION

S1,

022,

620.

00$

317,

137.

00$

-

19,8

04,4

66.0

0$

10,7

23,1

15.0

0$

2,89

3.00

$ 31

,870

,231

.00

$ S

ecre

tary

Tra

nsfe

r 15

*5(4

5,00

0.00

)$

-

-

-

-

-

(45,

000.

00)

$

T

rans

fer

from

352

00 t

o 78

800

-

-

-

(400

,000

.00)

$

40

0,00

0.00

$

-

-

S

UP

P A

PP

RO

P r

ec

3/18

/201

5-

-

12

,700

,000

.00

$ -

-

-

12,7

00,0

00.0

0$

RE

AP

PR

OP

RIA

TIO

NS

-

-

-

-

2,12

3,38

4.28

$

-

2,

123,

384.

28$

TO

TAL

FUN

D A

PPR

OPR

IATI

ON

S97

7,62

0.00

$

317,

137.

00$

12,7

00,0

00.0

0$

19,4

04,4

66.0

0$

13,2

46,4

99.2

8$

2,89

3.00

$ 46

,648

,615

.28

$

TOAL

EXP

END

ITU

RES

PER

SON

AL S

ERVI

CES

& B

ENEF

ITS

120

0 P

erso

nal S

ervi

ces

549,

070.

33$

-

-

29

8,66

1.66

$

-

-

84

7,73

1.99

$

1

206

Ann

ual I

ncre

men

t10

,020

.00

$

-

-

-

-

-

10,0

20.0

0$

2

200

PE

IA F

ees

700.

00$

-

-

-

-

-

70

0.00

$

2

201

Per

sonn

el F

ees

2,21

0.00

$

-

-

810.

00$

-

-

3,

020.

00$

2

202

FIC

A40

,910

.30

$

-

-

20

,799

.15

$

-

-

61,7

09.4

5$

2

203

Pub

lic E

mpl

Insu

ranc

e66

,564

.00

$

-

-

27

,696

.00

$

-

-

94,2

60.0

0$

2

205

Wor

kers

Com

p1,

483.

06$

-

-

67

0.72

$

-

-

2,15

3.78

$

2206

U

nem

ploy

men

t C

ompe

nsat

ion

8,19

0.00

$

-

-

-

-

-

8,

190.

00$

22

07

Pen

sion

& R

etire

men

t76

,416

.44

$

-

-

41

,690

.37

$

-

-

118,

106.

81$

2208

PE

IA-O

PE

B C

ontr

ibut

ion

26,7

32.0

0$

-

-

7,38

0.00

$

-

-

34

,112

.00

$

TOTA

L PE

RSO

NAL

SER

V &

BEN

EFIT

S78

2,29

6.13

$

-

-

397,

707.

90$

-

-

321,

552.

04$

PUB

LIC

DEF

END

ER S

ERVI

CES

SUM

MA

RY

OF

APP

RO

PRIA

TIO

NS,

EXP

END

ITU

RES

, AN

D F

UN

D B

ALA

NC

ES B

Y A

CTI

VITY

FO

R T

HE

FUN

D 0

226-

2015

-022

1

FOR

TH

E PE

RIO

D J

ULY

1, 2

014

- JU

NE

30, 2

015

as o

f Jul

y 31

, 201

5

FY2015 Annual Report Page 20 of 212

UN

CLA

SSIF

IED

EXP

ENSE

S:

3200

O

ffic

e E

xpen

se-

17,0

06.3

6$

-

2,

245.

28$

-

-

19,2

51.6

4$

3201

P

rintin

g &

Bin

ding

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

3202

R

enta

l Exp

ense

-

58

,691

.04

$

-

19,8

43.1

6$

-

-

78

,534

.20

$

32

04 T

elec

omm

unic

atio

ns-

1,72

1.29

$

-

-

-

-

1,72

1.29

$

32

06

Con

trac

tual

& P

rofe

ssio

nal

-

1,

065.

50$

346,

395.

31$

18

,036

,093

.69

$ 35

5,24

2.78

$

-

18

,738

,797

.28

$

3207

P

rofe

ssio

nal S

ervi

ces

-

13

,343

.10

$

-

58,0

00.0

0$

-

-

71

,343

.10

$

32

11

Tra

vel E

mpl

oyee

-

3,

235.

47$

-

3,51

1.10

$

-

-

6,

746.

57$

3213

C

ompu

ter

Ser

vice

s-In

tern

al-

67,9

24.7

1$

-

55

,387

.50

$

-

-

123,

312.

21$

32

14

Com

pute

r S

ervi

ces-

Ext

erna

l-

500.

00$

-

-

-

-

50

0.00

$

3216

V

ehic

le R

enta

l-

599.

75$

-

1,41

8.00

$

-

-

2,

017.

75$

3217

Ren

tal(M

achi

ne &

Mis

c)-

28.3

5$

-

-

-

-

28.3

5$

3218

A

ssoc

Due

s &

Pro

f M

embe

rshi

ps-

2,45

0.00

$

-

2,

780.

00$

-

-

5,23

0.00

$

32

19

Fire

, A

uto,

Bon

d &

Oth

er In

sura

nce

-

82

7.25

$

-

-

-

2,

893.

00$

3,72

0.25

$

32

22

Sup

plie

s H

ouse

hold

-

13

.65

$

-

-

-

-

13

.65

$

32

24

Adv

ertis

ing

& P

rom

otio

n-

-

-

-

-

-

-

32

29

Rou

tine

Mtc

e C

ontr

acts

/War

rant

ies

-

4,

784.

38$

-

-

-

-

4,

784.

38$

3232

C

ellu

lar

Cha

rges

-

12

9.07

$

-

-

-

-

129.

07$

32

33

Hos

pita

lity

-

64

3.29

$

-

1,

222.

81$

-

-

1,86

6.10

$

32

35

Ene

rgy

Exp

ense

- V

ehic

le/A

ircra

ft-

-

-

-

-

-

-

32

41

Mis

cella

neou

s -

176.

76$

-

-

-

-

17

6.76

$

3242

T

rain

ing

& D

evel

opm

ent-

In-

762.

00$

-

955.

00$

-

-

1,

717.

00$

3243

Tra

inin

g &

Dev

elop

men

t-O

ut-

-

-

1,

750.

00$

-

-

1,75

0.00

$

32

44

Pos

tal

-

12

,038

.02

$

-

92.5

2$

-

-

12,1

30.5

4$

3245

F

reig

ht

-

56

6.27

$

-

11

.94

$

-

-

57

8.21

$

3246

S

uppl

ies-

Com

pute

r-

(495

.10)

$

-

-

-

-

(4

95.1

0)$

32

47

Sof

twar

e Li

cens

es

-

65

9.73

$

-

-

-

-

659.

73$

32

48

Com

pute

r E

quip

men

t -

4,48

3.60

$

-

-

-

-

4,48

3.60

$

32

49

Off

ice

Equ

ipm

entC

urre

nt E

xp

-

3,

186.

96$

-

-

-

-

3,

186.

96$

3250

A

ttor

ney

Lega

l Ser

vice

Pay

men

ts-

-

11

,504

,953

.85

$ -

11

,884

,592

.23

$ -

23,3

89,5

46.0

8$

32

51

Att

orne

y R

eim

burs

able

Exp

ense

-

-

704,

683.

95$

-

79

6,46

5.46

$

-

1,

501,

149.

41$

3252

M

isce

llane

ous

Equ

ipm

ent

Pur

chas

es-

950.

90$

-

-

-

-

95

0.90

$

3267

O

ther

Inte

rest

& P

enal

ties

-

-

1,09

5.92

$

-

239.

90$

-

1,

335.

82$

3272

P

EIA

Res

erve

Tra

nsfe

r-

5,59

4.00

$

-

3,

128.

00$

-

-

8,72

2.00

$

32

93

Med

ical

Ser

vice

Pay

men

ts-

-

14

2,86

9.09

$

-

209,

680.

06$

-

352,

549.

15$

33

24

Sta

te T

reas

urer

's O

ffic

e F

ees

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

5208

B

ooks

& P

erio

dica

ls-

2,81

0.64

$

-

23

1.42

$

-

-

3,04

2.06

$

82

03 C

ompu

ter

Sof

twar

e-

-

-

29

9.97

$

-

-

299.

97$

TOTA

L U

NC

LASS

IFIE

D E

XPEN

SES

-

20

3,69

6.99

$

12

,699

,998

.12

$ 18

,186

,970

.39

$ 13

,246

,220

.43

$ 2,

893.

00$

44,3

39,7

78.9

3$

TOTA

L FU

ND

EXP

END

ITU

RES

782,

296.

13$

20

3,69

6.99

$

12

,699

,998

.12

$ 18

,584

,678

.29

$ 13

,246

,220

.43

$ 2,

893.

00$

44,6

61,3

30.9

7$

FUN

D B

ALAN

CE

195,

323.

87$

11

3,44

0.01

$

1.

88$

819,

787.

71$

278.

85$

-

1,

987,

284.

31$

FY2015 Annual Report Page 21 of 212

2420-2015-0221

REVENUES Sales of Publications - Continuing Legal Education 23,920.00$ DVD/VIDEO Sales (with CLE) 530.00$ TOTAL REVENUES $24,450.00

EXPENDITURES 3200 Office Expense 3,197.58$

3202 Rental Expense 515.00$

3204 Telecommunications 45.00$

3211 Travel Employee 2,145.00$

3216 Vehicle Rental 218.00$

3217 Rental(Machine & Misc) 125.00$

3218 Assoc Dues & Prof Memberships 500.00$

3233 Hospitality 2,859.15$

3245 Freight 29.98$

3248 Computer Equipment 902.35$

3252 Miscellaneous Equipment Purchases 716.94$ $11,254.00

Revenues Over (Under) Expenditures $13,196.00

Fund Balance Beginning of Period July 1, 2014 $30,978.26

Fund Balance, June 30, 2015 $44,174.262421-2015-0221

Fund Balance Beginning of Period $6.00 Add: Consumer Sales Tax Collections - Less: Remittance of Taxes $6.00Fund Balance, June 30, 2015 -

Public Defender ServicesStatement of Revenues, Expenditures,

and Changes in Fund BalancesFor the Period July 1, 2014 to June 30, 2015

FY2015 Annual Report Page 22 of 212

Division Reports

• Voucher Processing

• Public Defender Corporations

• Criminal Law Research Center

• Appellate Advocacy Division

• Indigent Defense Commission

FY2015 Annual Report Page 23 of 212

DIVISION REPORTS

AUDITING AND ACCOUNTING DIVISION: VOUCHER PROCESSING

In FY2015, the staff of the voucher processing succeeded in its mission to process vouchers within thirty (30) days of the received date.

FY 2015: Public Defender Services Vouchers Paid July 1, 2014 through June 30, 2015

Dollar Amount Paid  Number of Vouchers 

July 2014  $1,201,738.49   1,774 

August 2014  $1,891,803.92   2,579 

September 2014  $2,697,217.03   3,404 

October 2014  $1,446,151.67   2,186 

November 2014  $1,969,203.34   2,800 

December 2014  $2,245,734.16   3,122 

January 2015  $1,319,258.83   1,828 

February 2015  $411,827.74   489 

March 2015  $6,353,213.40   9,100 

April 2015  $2,506,103.62   2,799 

May 2015  $2,476,974.69   4,122 

June 2015  $1,460,798.66   2,023 

TOTAL  $25,980,025.55   36,226 

Pictured: Marjorie K. Wilson accepts her 30 years-of-service certificate from Governor Earl Ray Tomblin

FY2015 Annual ReportPage 24 of 212

AUDITING AND ACCOUNTING DIVISION: PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS

For FY2015, there were seventeen public defender corporations serving eighteen judicial

circuits (see subsequent table below). Although Public Defender Services establishes strategic objectives for the delivery of legal services to indigents in eligible proceedings, public defender corporations are not subordinate divisions of this agency, but are autonomous quasi-governmental entities. The Internal Revenue Code classifies these organizations as non-profit (see 26USC501) and as a public charity (see 26USC509). In essence, employees of the public defender corporations are neither employees of Public Defender Services nor employees of the State of West Virginia, but are employees of a specific non-profit organization governed by a board of directors appointed by the Governor, local bar associations, and county commissions.

Summary of Activated Public Defender Corporations

See W.Va. Code § 29-21-8 Circuit Fiscal Year Office Locations

1st 1990 Wheeling & Weirton 2nd Before 1991 Moundsville 4th 2015 Parkersburg 5th 1996 Ripley & Spencer

6th & 24th 1995 Huntington & Wayne 7th 1991 Logan 8th 1990 Welch 9th 1991 Princeton 10th Before 1991 Beckley 11th 2000 Lewisburg & Marlinton 12th 1990 Fayetteville 13th 1990 Charleston 15th 1994 Clarksburg 18th 2001 Kingwood 23rd Before 1991 Martinsburg & Charles Town 25th 2000 Madison & Hamlin 28th Before 1991 Summersville 30th 1990 Williamson

For FY2015, Public Defender Services made grants in the amount of $17,753,2601 to and

on behalf of the Public Defender Corporations. In return for these grants, the Public Defender Corporations reported 253,930.2 attorney hours and 33,170 closed cases. This represents approximately $69.91 per hour and $535.22 per closed case. However, reducing the attorney time by the 64,124 hours reported as administrative time (189,806.20), the cost per hour increases to $93.53 with no effect to the overall cost per case. 1 Excludes $400,000 grant to 4th Circuit for startup expenses. This figure will be included in the FY16 cost-per-case calculation.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 25 of 212

CRIMINAL LAW RESEARCH CENTER

In the FY2015, the Criminal Law Research Center provided the following legal seminars to public defenders and to private attorneys at a substantially lower cost than commercial providers: Up Your Game: Tools to Improve Your Practice

Flatwoods, WV February 27, 2015 Matt Brummond,

Brandon Cook, Dana Eddy, Jonathan Friley, Jason Nicholas, Jason Parmer, Don Stennett, Stephanne Thorton, Crystal Walden, Lori Waller

Fifty-seven (57) attorneys attended this conference. Attendees earned 7.3 hours of continuing education legal credits, including 3.5 hours of office management/ethics. Trial I – Pretrial Planning Marshall University, April 1, 2015 Matthew Brummond,

South Charleston Campus Jason Parmer, Don Stennett, Crystal Walden, Lori Waller

Northern Comm. College, April 10, 2015 Matthew Brummond,

Wheeling, WV Jason Parmer, Don Stennett, Crystal Walden, Lori Waller

Potomac State College, May 14, 2015 Matthew Brummond,

Keyser, WV Jason Parmer, Don Stennett, Crystal Walden, Lori Waller

Fifty-seven (57) attorneys attended these conferences. 6.0 credits of continuing legal education in ethics were earned by the attorneys in attendance.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 26 of 212

Public Defender Services—2015 Annual Conference Stonewall Resort June 18 & 19, 2015 Variety of Speakers

The Criminal Law Research Center organized the agency’s annual conference, to which public defenders and private counsel engaged in criminal defense were invited. The topics included:

Opening Remarks, Dana Eddy, Executive Director, Public Defender Services

Legislative Reform, Joseph D. Garcia, Esq., Governor's Office, Director of Legislative Affairs

Challenging Drug Evidence, Drew Northrup, Esq., Assistant Public Defender, Baltimore, MD

The 411 on 404: A Summary of Opinions of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia on Rule 404(b) of the Rules of Evidence, Dana F. Eddy, Executive Director, Public Defender Services and Jason Parmer, Esq., Appellate Advocacy Division, Public Defender Services

Juvenile Welfare Reform (Improving the Effectiveness of Juvenile Justice Programs), Jason Nicholas, Esq., Assistant Public Defender, 13th Judicial Circuit PDC and Lori Waller, Esq., Appellate Advocacy Division, Public Defender Services

Domestic Violence, Allen E. Barry, Esq., Assistant Public Defender, 13th Judicial Circuit PDC

Resources for Clients Who Have Been Judged Incompetent, Georgette A. Bradstreet, Statewide Forensic Coordinator and Charity N. Sayre, JRI Coordinator, Office of the Cabinet Secretary, WV Dept. of Military Affairs and Public Safety

Perspectives on Representing the Youthful Offender, Alicia MacIntire, WVDHHR Youth Services Policy Specialist; Teresa Lyons, Panel Attorney, Hedges & Lyons, PLLC; Rob McKinney, Division of Probation Services, WV Supreme Court; Cindy Largent-Hill, Director, Juvenile Justice Commission, WV Supreme Court; and John Lehman, Esq., Assistant Public Defender, 23rd Judicial Circuit PDC

Panel Discussion - Magistrate Court - "Life in the Fast Lane", 15th Judicial Circuit PDC Attorneys: Perry B. Jones, Esq., Chief Defender; Jack E. Clark, Esq., Assistant Public Defender; Eric D. Householder, Esq. , Assistant Public Defender; and Elizabeth B. Gross, Esq., Assistant Public Defender

FY2015 Annual Report Page 27 of 212

Preventing Burnout in the Practice of Law: Psychoneuroimmunology, The Healing Power of Laughter, Music & Joyful Living, George Daugherty, Executive Director, WV Lawyer Assistance Program

ABC's of DUI, David Pence, Esq., Member, Zerbe & Pence, PLLC

Case Studies in Mitigation, Stephanne Thornton, LICSW,MAC, Sentencing Advocate Director, 13th Judicial Circuit PDC

How to Talk to Your Expert - Court Ordered Psychological Evaluations & Strategies, Timothy S. Saar, PhD

4th Circuit & U.S. Supreme Court Update, Jonathan Byrne, Esq., Federal Public Defender Office, Southern District of WV

Ethics, “The Presentation That Will Change Your Life -- Forever!!!”, Terri Tarr, Esq., Chief Counsel, Judicial Investigation Commission

Award Recipients

George Casetlle, Former Chief Public Defender, Public Defender Corporation for the 13th Judicial Circuit, Second Annual John A. “Jack” Rogers Award for Outstanding Leadership in Public Service

Greg Ayers, Former Supervisor of Appellate Attorneys, Public Defender Corporation for the 13th Judicial Circuit, Second Annual Award for Outstanding Scholarship in Criminal Law

One Hundred Fifty (150) attorneys attended these conferences. Attendees earned 11.5 credits of continuing legal education, including 1 hour of ethics and 1 hour of office management. Additional credits were available by ordering DVDs of concurrent seminars not attended.

The Criminal Law Research Center continued its publication of the Legislative Watch, and reported on legislative activity and laws affecting criminal laws or criminal defense. The Criminal Law Research Center also published six (6) newsletters that addressed general issues affecting the criminal defense practice, discussed specific issues affecting the operations of Public Defender Services, and provided summaries of relevant decisions of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia and the Supreme Court of the United States. The Criminal Law Research Center continues to maintain a library of material that is available to practitioners throughout the state. The material is listed on the agency’s website at www.pds.wv.org.

Pictured: Jason Nicholas (13th PDC) and Lori

Waller (Appellate Division, PDS), presenting at the

2015 Annual Conference.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 28 of 212

APPELLATE ADVOCACY DIVISION

“The right of an accused in a criminal trial to due process is in essence, the right to a fair opportunity to defend against the State’s accusations.” Chambers v. Mississippi, 410 U.S. 284, 294, 93 S. Ct. 1038, 1045 (1973). The Appellate Advocacy Division strives to protect this right and to ensure that West Virginia conducts its criminal trials in accordance with the rule of law rather than compromising justice in light of the citizen-defendants’ perceived opprobrium.

The Appellate Advocacy Division’s primary task is to pursue appeals on behalf of

indigent criminal defendants throughout the state who stand convicted of serious crimes resulting in lengthy prison sentences. The four lawyers and two staff comprising the division zealously advocate for their clients in the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, and in appropriate cases, three of the division’s lawyers can file petitions for certiorari to the Supreme Court of the United States. The Appellate Division prefers complex cases or cases presenting issues of first impression so that in addition to protecting each individual client’s rights, the law in general can advance in a positive direction.

The Appellate Advocacy Division believes that trial and appellate lawyers can develop a

united front in the defense of the indigent citizens of our state. In an effort to implement this team approach, the division assists attorneys throughout the State by answering attorney assistance calls and participating in continuing legal education programs offered by the Criminal Law Research Center. The Appellate lawyers participated in every CLE program the Criminal Law Research Center held this year, including the Annual Conference.

Attorney assistance calls are a new service the division offers to fulltime public defenders

and panel attorneys appointed to represent indigent defendants. Trial attorneys can call with a legal question and speak to one of the appellate attorneys who will research the issue and provide feedback, discuss strategy, provide sample motions or any other resource that could be helpful to the trial attorney. The division can also brainstorm and host moot court for attorneys either in person or via phone conference. In the first full year of the assistance call program, the division assisted more than 40 panel attorneys and fulltime public defenders calling with legal questions.

The Appellate Advocacy Division is dedicated to vigorous representation of every client

during both the trial and appellate phase. The division’s ultimate goal is to help to ensure that every indigent citizen charged with a crime enjoys all the constitutional rights and protections guaranteed under the constitutions of both the United States and West Virginia.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 29 of 212

INDIGENT DEFENSE COMMISSION

The Indigent Defense Commission was reconstituted in 2014. The members are the Honorable John L. Cummings, Senior Status Judge from Milton; Valena E. Beatty, WVU College of Law Professor and Chair of the WV Innocence Project, from Morgantown; Lonnie C. Simmons, a criminal defense attorney and the Chair of the Public Defender Corporation for the 13th Judicial Circuit, from Charleston; George Castelle, former Chief Public Defender for the 13th Judicial Circuit, from Charleston; Lawrence P. Shao, Ph.D., former Professor of Finance at Marshall University, from Huntington; Karen B. Yost, President and Chief Executive Officer of Prestera Center for Mental Health Services, Inc., from Huntington; and Vanessa Ann Welch, an attorney with significant experience in the defense of Juvenile delinquency and abuse and neglect cases, from Morgantown. The Executive Director of Public Defender Services serves as Chair of the Commission. The Commission met three times this year before the drafting of this Annual Report. On January 29, it held its organizational meeting at the PDS offices in Charleston. The members discussed the online voucher system; the statutory directives to develop standards for providing and compensating expert witnesses, investigators and others, and to study the feasibility of creating multi-circuit or regional public defender corporations; and the findings; and recommendations of two performance reviews issued by the Legislative Auditor’s office in January 1999 and June 2004. Also discussed was the concept of gathering information on the qualitative aspects of public defense and the reasons cases are assigned to panel attorneys rather than to public defender corporations. Members then discussed the possibilities of developing a continuing legal education seminar on how to navigate the mental health system, and preparing a video to be made available through the state bar, which panel attorneys could review before accepting appointments of mental health cases. The Commission met again on April 24. At that meeting, the Chair reported that he and members of the PDS staff had met with Barbara Core and Matt Arrowood, Division of Circuit Clerk Services of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, on April 2 in Marion County, to discuss the Supreme Court’s E-Filing Pilot Project. This project will allow PDS to have electronic access to Circuit Court documents, which will facilitate further analysis of vouchers submitted for payment. The Commission also discussed the hourly rates paid to panel attorneys, and the consideration of proposing a decrease of hourly rates for travel to effectuate an increase for legal services.

FY2015 Annual Report Page 30 of 212

Appendix A

Appointed Counsel Statistics

• Summary of Claims Paid • Claims Paid

o Total o Without Supplemental or Direct Expenses o Supplemental and Direct Expenses Only

• Hours Paid by Case Type • Fees Paid by Case Type • Expenses Paid by Case Type • Expenses Paid by Category • Hours Paid In Court / Out of Court • Average Costs by Case Type

o Total o Without Supplemental or Direct Expenses

• Average Per Charge

FY2015 Annual Report Page 31 of 212

Attorney Fees $23,399,286.67 Attorney Expenses $1,479,912.09 Direct Expenses $1,075,698.48 Total Claims Paid $25,954,897.24 

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY OF APPOINTED COUNSEL CLAIMS PAID

Attorney Fees90.15%

Attorney Expenses5.70%Direct Expenses

4.14%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 32 of 212

Attorney Attorney Direct Total Total FeesCircuit Attorney Fees Expenses Expenses Expenses & ExpensesCounty Hours ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)

01 Circuit

BROOKE 6,361.47               302,787.94           20,369.09             16,997.50             37,366.59             340,154.53          

HANCOCK 8,552.43               411,064.16           25,558.83             6,963.00               32,521.83             443,585.99          

OHIO 14,095.82             659,022.02           33,292.46             31,083.21             64,375.67             723,397.69          

Total 29,009.72             1,372,874.12       79,220.38             55,043.71             134,264.09           1,507,138.21      

02 Circuit

MARSHALL 3,173.21               152,999.06           5,546.57               1,735.00               7,281.57               160,280.63          

TYLER 1,783.04               85,893.84             7,038.79               7,723.05               14,761.84             100,655.68          

WETZEL 2,952.10               142,291.22           7,858.57               139.02                   7,997.59               150,288.81          

Total 7,908.35               381,184.12           20,443.93             9,597.07               30,041.00             411,225.12          

03 Circuit

DODDRIDGE 4,532.00               212,676.04           22,907.80             7,866.31               30,774.11             243,450.15          

PLEASANTS 3,262.90               154,603.91           13,153.40             6,454.68               19,608.08             174,211.99          

RITCHIE 5,087.00               241,933.84           21,375.01             13,377.92             34,752.93             276,686.77          

Total 12,881.90             609,213.79           57,436.21             27,698.91             85,135.12             694,348.91          

04 Circuit

WIRT 1,616.90               75,712.97             9,072.69               7,405.46               16,478.15             92,191.12            

WOOD 25,879.74             1,227,967.43       80,328.26             60,975.20             141,303.46           1,369,270.89      

Total 27,496.64             1,303,680.40       89,400.95             68,380.66             157,781.61           1,461,462.01      

05 Circuit

CALHOUN 4,556.30               221,131.30           23,135.81             620.50                   23,756.31             244,887.61          

JACKSON 8,208.60               399,946.29           44,569.22             3,116.56               47,685.78             447,632.07          

MASON 8,693.20               420,406.07           17,795.77             1,500.00               19,295.77             439,701.84          

ROANE 4,224.70               205,120.65           23,477.86             ‐                         23,477.86             228,598.51          

Total 25,682.80             1,246,604.31       108,978.66           5,237.06               114,215.72           1,360,820.03      

06 Circuit

CABELL 18,848.72             943,129.44           32,680.58             47,840.47             80,521.05             1,023,650.49      

Total 18,848.72             943,129.44           32,680.58             47,840.47             80,521.05             1,023,650.49      

07 Circuit

LOGAN 11,732.20             567,309.74           29,362.04             2,552.70               31,914.74             599,224.48          

Total 11,732.20             567,309.74           29,362.04             2,552.70               31,914.74             599,224.48          

08 Circuit

MCDOWELL 9,840.30               476,368.30           17,104.99             30,781.32             47,886.31             524,254.61          

Total 9,840.30               476,368.30           17,104.99             30,781.32             47,886.31             524,254.61          

09 Circuit

MERCER 30,296.27             1,462,332.11       129,507.25           92,969.01             222,476.26           1,684,808.37      

Total 30,296.27             1,462,332.11       129,507.25           92,969.01             222,476.26           1,684,808.37      

10 Circuit

RALEIGH 18,587.48             901,838.32           63,042.23             15,798.96             78,841.19             980,679.51          

Total 18,587.48             901,838.32           63,042.23             15,798.96             78,841.19             980,679.51          

11 Circuit

GREENBRIER 7,605.30               360,106.03           5,292.57               3,833.32               9,125.89               369,231.92          

POCAHONTAS 2,821.10               132,309.76           6,524.78               341.60                   6,866.38               139,176.14          

Total 10,426.40             492,415.79           11,817.35             4,174.92               15,992.27             508,408.06          

12 Circuit

FAYETTE 7,976.20               385,865.47           1,600.00               18,516.02             404,381.49          

Total 7,976.20               385,865.47           16,916.02             1,600.00               18,516.02             404,381.49          

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY REPORT FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL

ATTORNEY HOURS, FEES, AND EXPENSES

FY2015 Annual Report Page 33 of 212

Attorney Attorney Direct Total Total FeesCircuit Attorney Fees Expenses Expenses Expenses & ExpensesCounty Hours ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY REPORT FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL

ATTORNEY HOURS, FEES, AND EXPENSES

13 Circuit

KANAWHA 35,498.85             1,711,050.92       80,665.35             46,502.72             127,168.07           1,838,218.99      

Total 35,498.85             1,711,050.92       80,665.35             46,502.72             127,168.07           1,838,218.99      

14 Circuit

BRAXTON 5,824.07               282,915.68           26,168.16             700.35                   26,868.51             309,784.19          

CLAY 7,359.39               351,134.75           24,225.89             207.90                   24,433.79             375,568.54          

GILMER 3,640.75               175,380.11           18,704.66             546.10                   19,250.76             194,630.87          

WEBSTER 10,712.20             513,526.82           62,622.63             28,700.00             91,322.63             604,849.45          

Total 27,536.42             1,322,957.36       131,721.34           30,154.35             161,875.69           1,484,833.05      

15 Circuit

HARRISON 10,733.90             508,117.91           89,198.52             79,031.93             168,230.45           676,348.36          

Total 10,733.90             508,117.91           89,198.52             79,031.93             168,230.45           676,348.36          

16 Circuit

MARION 17,834.20             830,121.03           22,139.87             84,829.20             106,969.07           937,090.10          

Total 17,834.20             830,121.03           22,139.87             84,829.20             106,969.07           937,090.10          

17 Circuit

MONONGALIA 23,827.99             1,129,932.23       49,353.63             40,717.03             90,070.66             1,220,002.89      

Total 23,827.99             1,129,932.23       49,353.63             40,717.03             90,070.66             1,220,002.89      

18 Circuit

PRESTON 7,604.30               358,126.10           26,687.23             12,358.02             39,045.25             397,171.35          

Total 7,604.30               358,126.10           26,687.23             12,358.02             39,045.25             397,171.35          

19 Circuit

BARBOUR 6,466.60               304,220.86           18,273.71             1,302.50               19,576.21             323,797.07          

TAYLOR 7,210.20               337,919.80           18,845.91             ‐                         18,845.91             356,765.71          

Total 13,676.80             642,140.66           37,119.62             1,302.50               38,422.12             680,562.78          

20 Circuit

RANDOLPH 10,126.80             493,737.00           26,036.91             47,354.05             73,390.96             567,127.96          

Total 10,126.80             493,737.00           26,036.91             47,354.05             73,390.96             567,127.96          

21 Circuit

GRANT 2,734.80               132,746.47           8,320.52               5,219.25               13,539.77             146,286.24          

MINERAL 5,925.10               278,560.28           11,658.47             31,977.61             43,636.08             322,196.36          

TUCKER 786.40                   37,274.00             3,365.78               4,490.44               7,856.22               45,130.22            

Total 9,446.30               448,580.75           23,344.77             41,687.30             65,032.07             513,612.82          

22 Circuit

HAMPSHIRE 6,504.90               316,700.94           17,588.08             22,175.94             39,764.02             356,464.96          

HARDY 5,437.60               263,260.01           15,287.07             11,047.54             26,334.61             289,594.62          

PENDLETON 1,324.40               62,908.88             6,820.72               4,950.00               11,770.72             74,679.60            

Total 13,266.90             642,869.83           39,695.87             38,173.48             77,869.35             720,739.18          

23 Circuit

BERKELEY 18,197.45             870,562.96           54,176.02             93,501.65             147,677.67           1,018,240.63      

JEFFERSON 7,368.30               355,270.91           25,700.32             42,318.55             68,018.87             423,289.78          

MORGAN 4,839.10               232,698.49           20,120.17             12,958.99             33,079.16             265,777.65          

Total 30,404.85             1,458,532.36       99,996.51             148,779.19           248,775.70           1,707,308.06      

24 Circuit

WAYNE 4,929.80               257,221.30           14,019.70             10,420.20             24,439.90             281,661.20          

Total 4,929.80               257,221.30           14,019.70             10,420.20             24,439.90             281,661.20          

FY2015 Annual Report Page 34 of 212

Attorney Attorney Direct Total Total FeesCircuit Attorney Fees Expenses Expenses Expenses & ExpensesCounty Hours ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY REPORT FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL

ATTORNEY HOURS, FEES, AND EXPENSES

25 Circuit

BOONE 4,707.82               241,420.17           8,639.88               3,308.69               11,948.57             253,368.74          

LINCOLN 7,692.60               376,922.01           14,960.49             1,486.00               16,446.49             393,368.50          

Total 12,400.42             618,342.18           23,600.37             4,794.69               28,395.06             646,737.24          

26 Circuit

LEWIS 7,722.94               371,118.12           22,332.10             15,522.15             37,854.25             408,972.37          

UPSHUR 5,926.40               286,261.19           10,860.39             14,782.91             25,643.30             311,904.49          

Total 13,649.34             657,379.31           33,192.49             30,305.06             63,497.55             720,876.86          

27 Circuit

WYOMING 10,476.20             501,375.03           30,751.56             36,943.18             67,694.74             569,069.77          

Total 10,476.20             501,375.03           30,751.56             36,943.18             67,694.74             569,069.77          

28 Circuit

NICHOLAS 4,963.24               238,949.86           22,132.14             6,761.52               28,893.66             267,843.52          

Total 4,963.24               238,949.86           22,132.14             6,761.52               28,893.66             267,843.52          

29 Circuit

PUTNAM 15,493.70             739,879.86           44,543.44             25,375.03             69,918.47             809,798.33          

Total 15,493.70             739,879.86           44,543.44             25,375.03             69,918.47             809,798.33          

30 Circuit

MINGO 8,814.78               434,975.70           6,498.24               25,561.23             32,059.47             467,035.17          

Total 8,814.78               434,975.70           6,498.24               25,561.23             32,059.47             467,035.17          

31 Circuit

MONROE 2,416.20               117,700.57           10,269.68             2,973.01               13,242.69             130,943.26          

SUMMERS 2,938.40               144,480.80           13,034.26             ‐                         13,034.26             157,515.06          

Total 5,354.60               262,181.37           23,303.94             2,973.01               26,276.95             288,458.32          

State Total 486,726.36           23,399,286.67     1,479,912.09       1,075,698.48       2,555,610.57       25,954,897.24    

FY2015 Annual Report Page 35 of 212

Felony 8,937Misdemeanor 9,312Mental Hygiene 2,531Juvenile 3,248Parole/Prob. Rev. 1,430Term/Abuse & Neglect 8,949Habeas, Supreme Court 392Municipal Court Charges 604Other 802   (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

Total Claims Paid 36,205

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL CLAIMS PAID

Felony24.68%

Misdemeanor25.72%

Mental Hygiene6.99%

Juvenile8.97%

Parole/Prob. Rev.3.95%Term/Abuse & 

Neglect24.72%

Habeas, Supreme Court

1.08%

Municipal Court Charges1.67%

Other2.22%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 36 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

85

                     

63

                     

50

                     

17

                     

5                       

82

                     

1                       

‐                    

3                       

30

6                   

HA

NC

OC

K1

25

                   

79

                     

17

                     

27

                     

27

                     

15

9                   

5                       

4                       

5                       

44

8                   

OH

IO9

7                     

81

                     

25

5                   

10

                     

3                       

18

1                   

18

                     

‐                    

2                       

64

7                   

Total

307

                   

223

                   

322

                   

54

                     

35

                     

422

                   

24

                     

4                       

10

                     

1,401

               

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

63

                     

49

                     

60

                     

11

                     

10

                     

58

                     

2                       

‐                    

2                       

25

5                   

TYLE

R1

8                     

10

                     

6                       

12

                     

5                       

36

                     

1                       

‐                    

2                       

90

                     

WET

ZEL

59

                     

17

                     

52

                     

8                       

9                       

57

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

20

2                   

Total

140

                   

76

                     

118

                   

31

                     

24

                     

151

                   

3                       

‐                    

4                       

547

                   

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

79

                     

80

                     

12

                     

28

                     

33

                     

98

                     

‐                    

‐                    

19

                     

34

9                   

PLE

ASA

NTS

57

                     

74

                     

6                       

30

                     

9                       

54

                     

1                       

‐                    

8                       

23

9                   

RIT

CH

IE5

2                     

10

5                   

7                        

16

                     

7                       

98

                     

1                       

‐                    

4                       

29

0                   

Total

188

                   

259

                   

25

                     

74

                     

49

                     

250

                   

2                       

‐                    

31

                     

878

                   

04 Circuit

WIR

T4

2                     

56

                     

1                       

33

                     

8                       

22

                     

2                       

‐                    

6                       

17

0                   

WO

OD

55

6                   

1,2

07

               

29

2                   

21

3                   

70

                     

53

8                   

26

                     

‐                    

65

                     

2,9

67

               

Total

598

                   

1,263

               

293

                   

246

                   

78

                     

560

                   

28

                     

‐                    

71

                     

3,137

               

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

42

                     

8                       

3                       

5                       

2                       

14

8                   

9                       

‐                    

2                       

21

9                   

JAC

KSO

N1

14

                   

46

                     

2                       

18

                     

32

                     

25

2                   

16

                     

‐                    

23

                     

50

3                   

MA

SON

19

9                   

29

9                   

49

                     

11

9                   

50

                     

84

                     

6                       

‐                    

14

                     

82

0                   

RO

AN

E6

6                     

22

                     

13

                     

34

                     

7                       

15

5                   

5                       

‐                    

11

                     

31

3                   

Total

421

                   

375

                   

67

                     

176

                   

91

                     

639

                   

36

                     

‐                    

50

                     

1,855

               

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L4

85

                   

91

                     

60

7                   

12

4                   

74

                     

42

0                   

22

                     

‐                    

28

                     

1,8

51

               

Total

485

                   

91

                     

607

                   

124

                   

74

                     

420

                   

22

                     

‐                    

28

                     

1,851

               

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

14

2                   

46

0                   

1                       

14

5                   

16

                     

17

1                   

7                       

‐                    

5                       

94

7                   

Total

142

                   

460

                   

1                       

145

                   

16

                     

171

                   

7                       

‐                    

5                       

947

                   

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L1

94

                   

15

2                   

24

                     

21

                     

3                       

17

0                   

5                       

‐                    

6                       

57

5                   

Total

194

                   

152

                   

24

                     

21

                     

3                       

170

                   

5                       

‐                    

6                       

575

                   

09 Circuit

MER

CER

52

7                   

40

4                   

16

7                   

46

0                   

69

                     

71

4                   

16

                     

29

                     

42

                     

2,4

28

               

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA

IMS PAID

FY2015 Annual Report Page 37 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA

IMS PAID

Total

527

                   

404

                   

167

                   

460

                   

69

                     

714

                   

16

                     

29

                     

42

                     

2,428

               

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H2

89

                   

22

3                   

8                       

41

                     

35

                     

81

4                   

14

                     

‐                    

8                       

1,4

32

               

Total

289

                   

223

                   

8                       

41

                     

35

                     

814

                   

14

                     

‐                    

8                       

1,432

               

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

96

                     

48

                     

6                       

9                       

12

                     

11

0                   

7                       

3                       

5                       

29

6                   

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S4

1                     

15

                     

19

                     

7                       

‐                    

33

                     

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

11

6                   

Total

137

                   

63

                     

25

                     

16

                     

12

                     

143

                   

7                       

3                       

6                       

412

                   

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

15

9                   

15

2                   

‐                    

16

                     

15

                     

20

0                   

8                       

5                       

1                       

55

6                   

Total

159

                   

152

                   

16

                     

15

                     

200

                   

8                       

5                       

1                       

556

                   

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A8

47

                   

64

8                   

‐                    

13

0                   

74

                     

67

6                   

51

                     

42

2                   

39

                     

2,8

87

               

Total

847

                   

648

                   

‐                    

130

                   

74

                     

676

                   

51

                     

422

                   

39

                     

2,887

               

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

93

                     

15

3                   

10

                     

29

                     

11

                     

14

5                   

1                       

‐                    

11

                     

45

3                   

CLA

Y6

9                     

63

                     

1                       

10

                     

4                       

18

0                   

1                       

1                       

1                       

33

0                   

GIL

MER

62

                     

91

                     

1                       

19

                     

5                       

52

                     

2                       

5                       

28

                     

26

5                   

WEB

STER

15

5                   

11

1                   

2                       

21

                     

9                       

19

6                   

4                       

‐                    

13

                     

51

1                   

Total

379

                   

418

                   

14

                     

79

                     

29

                     

573

                   

8                       

6                       

53

                     

1,559

               

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N1

46

                   

10

6                   

43

                      

40

                     

23

                     

16

3                   

17

                     

‐                    

14

                     

55

2                   

Total

146

                   

106

                   

43

                     

40

                     

23

                     

163

                   

17

                     

‐                    

14

                     

552

                   

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N3

77

                   

45

9                   

13

2                   

21

2                   

10

9                   

19

1                   

15

                     

38

                     

50

                     

1,5

83

               

Total

377

                   

459

                   

132

                   

212

                   

109

                   

191

                   

15

                     

38

                     

50

                     

1,583

               

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A4

93

                   

59

4                   

16

3                   

10

4                   

10

8                   

18

7                   

20

                     

69

                     

38

                     

1,7

76

               

Total

493

                   

594

                   

163

                   

104

                   

108

                   

187

                   

20

                     

69

                     

38

                     

1,776

               

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N6

4                     

82

                     

8                       

3                       

9                       

18

7                   

5                       

‐                    

19

                     

37

7                   

Total

64

                     

82

                     

8                       

3                       

9                       

187

                   

5                       

‐                    

19

                     

377

                   

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R9

7                     

10

9                   

7                       

72

                     

5                       

14

2                   

3                       

‐                    

1                       

43

6                   

TAYL

OR

12

0                   

92

                     

9                       

17

4                   

18

                     

15

4                   

2                       

‐                    

32

                     

60

1                   

Total

217

                   

201

                   

16

                     

246

                   

23

                     

296

                   

5                       

‐                    

33

                     

1,037

               

FY2015 Annual Report Page 38 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA

IMS PAID

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H1

99

                   

29

0                   

18

                     

10

3                   

46

                     

67

                     

14

                     

9                       

33

                     

77

9                   

Total

199

                   

290

                   

18

                     

103

                   

46

                     

67

                     

14

                     

9                       

33

                     

779

                   

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T7

4                     

63

                     

7                       

34

                     

22

                     

33

                     

‐                    

‐                    

12

                     

24

5                   

MIN

ERA

L1

83

                   

33

1                   

9                       

60

                     

55

                     

44

                     

3                       

‐                    

11

                     

69

6                   

TUC

KER

14

                     

33

                     

‐                    

29

                     

3                       

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

3                       

84

                     

Total

271

                   

427

                   

16

                     

123

                   

80

                     

79

                     

3                       

‐                    

26

                     

1,025

               

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E1

53

                   

21

7                   

6                       

52

                     

35

                     

44

                     

6                       

‐                    

34

                     

54

7                   

HA

RD

Y1

08

                   

16

8                   

5                       

60

                     

20

                     

44

                     

1                       

‐                    

13

                     

41

9                   

PEN

DLE

TON

21

                     

27

                     

4                       

20

                     

12

                     

4                       

1                       

‐                    

5                       

94

                     

Total

282

                   

412

                   

15

                     

132

                   

67

                     

92

                     

8                       

‐                    

52

                     

1,060

               

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY3

05

                   

10

1                   

‐                    

38

                     

34

                     

29

2                   

25

                     

5                       

1                       

80

1                   

JEFF

ERSO

N1

12

                   

13

0                   

‐                    

23

                     

26

                     

10

5                   

7                       

‐                    

3                       

40

6                   

MO

RG

AN

47

                     

38

                     

‐                    

13

                     

17

                     

85

                     

5                       

‐                    

5                       

21

0                   

Total

464

                   

269

                   

‐                    

74

                     

77

                     

482

                   

37

                     

5                       

9                       

1,417

               

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

78

                     

25

                     

54

                     

22

                     

36

                     

21

3                   

1                       

7                       

5                       

44

1                   

Total

78

                     

25

                     

54

                     

22

                     

36

                     

213

                   

1                        

7                       

5                       

441

                   

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E7

5                     

34

                     

‐                    

18

5                   

17

                     

93

                     

4                       

‐                    

5                       

41

3                   

LIN

CO

LN1

21

                   

64

                     

31

                     

24

                     

62

                     

11

7                   

2                       

‐                    

89

                     

51

0                   

Total

196

                   

98

                     

31

                     

209

                   

79

                     

210

                   

6                       

‐                    

94

                     

923

                   

26 Circuit

LEW

IS2

06

                   

17

3                   

25

1                   

11

                     

47

                     

39

                     

2                       

‐                    

14

                     

74

3                   

UP

SHU

R1

15

                   

18

4                   

11

                     

77

                     

33

                     

76

                     

1                       

‐                    

10

                     

50

7                   

Total

321

                   

357

                   

262

                   

88

                     

80

                     

115

                   

3                       

‐                    

24

                     

1,250

               

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G2

85

                   

36

1                   

14

                     

44

                     

11

                     

23

0                   

4                       

‐                    

6                       

95

5                   

Total

285

                   

361

                   

14

                     

44

                     

11

                     

230

                   

4                       

‐                    

6                       

955

                   

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

82

                     

27

                     

‐                    

12

                     

2                       

14

2                   

8                       

‐                    

‐                    

27

3                   

Total

82

                     

27

                     

‐                    

12

                     

2                       

142

                   

8                       

‐                    

‐                    

273

                   

FY2015 Annual Report Page 39 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA

IMS PAID

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M3

31

                   

44

2                   

80

                     

16

3                   

51

                     

11

5                   

4                       

5                       

33

                     

1,2

24

               

Total

331

                   

442

                   

80

                     

163

                   

51

                     

115

                   

4                       

5                       

33

                     

1,224

               

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

15

8                   

16

5                   

5                       

22

                     

7                       

18

3                   

10

                     

1                       

9                       

56

0                   

Total

158

                   

165

                   

5                       

22

                     

7                       

183

                   

10

                     

1                       

9                       

560

                   

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

70

                     

10

7                   

‐                    

16

                     

10

                     

33

                     

‐                    

1                       

1                       

23

8                   

SUM

MER

S9

0                     

83

                     

3                       

22

                     

8                       

61

                     

1                       

‐                    

2                       

27

0                   

Total

160

                   

190

                   

3                       

38

                     

18

                     

94

                     

1                       

1                       

3                       

508

                   

WV TOTA

L8,937

               

9,312

               

2,531

               

3,248

               

1,430

               

8,949

               

392

                   

604

                   

802

                   

36,205

             

FY2015 Annual Report Page 40 of 212

Felony 7,657Misdemeanor 8,851Mental Hygiene 2,530Juvenile 2,926Parole/Prob. Rev. 1,380Term/Abuse & Neglect 8,718Habeas, Supreme Court 356Municipal Court Charges 576Other 765   (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

Total Claims Paid 33,759

 PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL CLAIMS PAID

Without Direct Expenses and Supplementals

Felony22.68%

Misdemeanor26.22% Mental Hygiene

7.49%

Juvenile8.67%

Parole/Prob. Rev.4.09%

Term/Abuse & Neglect25.82%

Habeas, Supreme Court

1.05%

Municipal Court Charges1.71%

Other2.27%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 41 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

65

                     

58

                     

49

                     

15

                     

5                       

78

                     

1                       

‐                    

3                       

27

4                   

HA

NC

OC

K1

06

                   

72

                     

17

                     

24

                     

26

                     

14

9                   

5                       

4                       

3                       

40

6                   

OH

IO8

5                     

79

                     

25

5                   

10

                     

3                       

17

8                   

16

                     

‐                    

1                       

62

7                   

Total

256

                   

209

                   

321

                   

49

                     

34

                     

405

                   

22

                     

4                       

7                       

1,307

               

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

59

                     

47

                     

60

                     

10

                     

10

                     

57

                     

2                       

‐                    

2                       

24

7                   

TYLE

R1

2                     

10

                     

6                       

11

                     

5                       

36

                     

1                       

‐                    

2                       

83

                     

WET

ZEL

50

                     

17

                     

52

                     

8                       

8                       

57

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

19

2                   

Total

121

                   

74

                     

118

                   

29

                     

23

                     

150

                   

3                       

‐                    

4                       

522

                   

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

57

                     

68

                     

12

                     

24

                     

32

                     

94

                     

‐                    

‐                    

19

                     

30

6                   

PLE

ASA

NTS

46

                     

62

                     

6                       

27

                     

9                       

54

                     

1                       

‐                    

8                       

21

3                   

RIT

CH

IE3

7                     

96

                     

7                        

16

                     

6                       

97

                     

1                       

‐                    

4                       

26

4                   

Total

140

                   

226

                   

25

                     

67

                     

47

                     

245

                   

2                       

‐                    

31

                     

783

                   

04 Circuit

WIR

T2

5                     

55

                     

1                       

28

                     

8                       

22

                     

2                       

‐                    

6                       

14

7                   

WO

OD

40

4                   

1,1

17

               

29

2                   

17

6                   

67

                     

51

3                   

23

                     

‐                    

64

                     

2,6

56

               

Total

429

                   

1,172

               

293

                   

204

                   

75

                     

535

                   

25

                     

‐                    

70

                     

2,803

               

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

38

                     

8                       

3                       

5                       

2                       

13

9                   

9                       

‐                    

2                       

20

6                   

JAC

KSO

N1

04

                   

46

                     

2                       

16

                     

31

                     

22

9                   

15

                     

‐                    

23

                     

46

6                   

MA

SON

17

8                   

29

1                   

49

                     

11

3                   

49

                     

84

                     

6                       

‐                    

13

                     

78

3                   

RO

AN

E5

9                     

22

                     

13

                     

30

                     

6                       

14

9                   

4                       

‐                    

11

                     

29

4                   

Total

379

                   

367

                   

67

                     

164

                   

88

                     

601

                   

34

                     

‐                    

49

                     

1,749

               

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L4

21

                   

88

                     

60

7                   

12

0                   

74

                     

41

2                   

21

                     

‐                    

27

                     

1,7

70

               

Total

421

                   

88

                     

607

                   

120

                   

74

                     

412

                   

21

                     

‐                    

27

                     

1,770

               

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

12

8                   

45

0                   

1                       

14

3                   

16

                     

17

1                   

6                       

‐                    

5                       

92

0                   

Total

128

                   

450

                   

1                       

143

                   

16

                     

171

                   

6                       

‐                    

5                       

920

                   

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L1

44

                   

14

8                   

24

                     

18

                     

3                       

16

8                   

5                       

‐                    

6                       

51

6                   

Total

144

                   

148

                   

24

                     

18

                     

3                       

168

                   

5                       

‐                    

6                       

516

                   

09 Circuit

MER

CER

44

3                   

38

3                   

16

7                   

40

3                   

65

                     

69

1                   

9                       

28

                     

38

                     

2,2

27

               

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA

IMS PAID W

ITHOUT DIREC

T EX

PEN

SES OR SUPPLEMEN

TALS

FY2015 Annual Report Page 42 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA

IMS PAID W

ITHOUT DIREC

T EX

PEN

SES OR SUPPLEMEN

TALS

Total

443

                   

383

                   

167

                   

403

                   

65

                     

691

                   

9                       

28

                     

38

                     

2,227

               

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H2

33

                   

21

4                   

8                       

33

                     

31

                     

79

4                   

13

                     

‐                    

6                       

1,3

32

               

Total

233

                   

214

                   

8                       

33

                     

31

                     

794

                   

13

                     

‐                    

6                       

1,332

               

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

77

                     

44

                     

6                       

8                       

10

                     

11

0                   

5                       

3                       

5                       

26

8                   

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S3

3                     

15

                     

19

                     

7                       

‐                    

33

                     

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

10

8                   

Total

110

                   

59

                     

25

                     

15

                     

10

                     

143

                   

5                       

3                       

6                       

376

                   

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

15

6                   

14

8                   

15

                     

15

                     

19

6                   

8                       

5                       

1                       

54

4                   

Total

156

                   

148

                   

‐                    

15

                     

15

                     

196

                   

8                       

5                       

1                       

544

                   

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A7

20

                   

58

9                   

‐                    

12

1                   

71

                     

66

1                   

45

                     

40

1                   

37

                     

2,6

45

               

Total

720

                   

589

                   

‐                    

121

                   

71

                     

661

                   

45

                     

401

                   

37

                     

2,645

               

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

89

                     

15

0                   

10

                     

29

                     

10

                     

14

2                   

1                       

‐                    

11

                     

44

2                   

CLA

Y6

0                     

59

                     

1                       

10

                     

4                       

17

7                   

1                       

1                       

1                       

31

4                   

GIL

MER

59

                     

90

                     

1                       

18

                     

5                       

51

                     

2                       

5                       

28

                     

25

9                   

WEB

STER

13

3                   

10

9                   

2                       

18

                     

9                       

19

3                   

4                       

‐                    

13

                     

48

1                   

Total

341

                   

408

                   

14

                     

75

                     

28

                     

563

                   

8                       

6                       

53

                     

1,496

               

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N1

11

                   

10

1                   

43

                      

37

                     

21

                     

16

2                   

17

                     

‐                    

14

                     

50

6                   

Total

111

                   

101

                   

43

                     

37

                     

21

                     

162

                   

17

                     

‐                    

14

                     

506

                   

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N3

49

                   

44

1                   

13

2                   

18

4                   

10

4                   

18

9                   

14

                     

37

                     

45

                     

1,4

95

               

Total

349

                   

441

                   

132

                   

184

                   

104

                   

189

                   

14

                     

37

                     

45

                     

1,495

               

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A4

38

                   

55

6                   

16

3                   

87

                     

10

4                   

18

4                   

20

                     

65

                     

37

                     

1,6

54

               

Total

438

                   

556

                   

163

                   

87

                     

104

                   

184

                   

20

                     

65

                     

37

                     

1,654

               

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N5

7                     

76

                     

8                       

3                       

8                       

18

2                   

4                       

‐                    

15

                     

35

3                   

Total

57

                     

76

                     

8                       

3                       

8                       

182

                   

4                       

‐                    

15

                     

353

                   

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R9

0                     

10

6                   

7                       

59

                     

5                       

14

0                   

3                       

‐                    

1                       

41

1                   

TAYL

OR

10

5                   

81

                     

9                       

13

9                   

17

                     

15

2                   

2                       

‐                    

29

                     

53

4                   

Total

195

                   

187

                   

16

                     

198

                   

22

                     

292

                   

5                       

‐                    

30

                     

945

                   

FY2015 Annual Report Page 43 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA

IMS PAID W

ITHOUT DIREC

T EX

PEN

SES OR SUPPLEMEN

TALS

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H1

71

                   

27

8                   

18

                     

96

                     

45

                     

65

                     

13

                     

8                       

32

                     

72

6                   

Total

171

                   

278

                   

18

                     

96

                     

45

                     

65

                     

13

                     

8                       

32

                     

726

                   

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T7

0                     

63

                     

7                       

32

                     

22

                     

33

                     

‐                    

‐                    

12

                     

23

9                   

MIN

ERA

L1

69

                   

32

4                   

9                       

59

                     

55

                     

44

                     

2                       

‐                    

11

                     

67

3                   

TUC

KER

12

                     

32

                     

‐                    

29

                     

3                       

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

3                       

81

                     

Total

251

                   

419

                   

16

                     

120

                   

80

                     

79

                     

2                       

‐                    

26

                     

993

                   

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E1

35

                   

21

0                   

6                       

46

                     

35

                     

43

                     

6                       

‐                    

33

                     

51

4                   

HA

RD

Y9

8                     

16

3                   

5                       

56

                     

18

                     

42

                     

1                       

‐                    

13

                     

39

6                   

PEN

DLE

TON

17

                     

26

                     

4                       

20

                     

11

                     

4                       

1                       

‐                    

5                       

88

                     

Total

250

                   

399

                   

15

                     

122

                   

64

                     

89

                     

8                       

‐                    

51

                     

998

                   

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY2

58

                   

99

                     

‐                    

36

                     

34

                     

27

7                   

23

                     

5                       

1                       

73

3                   

JEFF

ERSO

N9

1                     

12

6                   

‐                    

20

                     

26

                     

98

                     

7                       

‐                    

3                       

37

1                   

MO

RG

AN

44

                     

35

                     

‐                    

10

                     

17

                     

82

                     

5                       

‐                    

5                       

19

8                   

Total

393

                   

260

                   

‐                    

66

                     

77

                     

457

                   

35

                     

5                       

9                       

1,302

               

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

69

                     

25

                     

54

                     

22

                     

35

                     

21

0                   

1                       

7                       

5                       

42

8                   

Total

69

                     

25

                     

54

                     

22

                     

35

                     

210

                   

1                        

7                       

5                       

428

                   

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E6

6                     

34

                     

‐                    

16

5                   

17

                     

91

                     

3                       

‐                    

5                       

38

1                   

LIN

CO

LN1

13

                   

64

                     

31

                     

23

                     

57

                     

11

6                   

1                       

‐                    

83

                     

48

8                   

Total

179

                   

98

                     

31

                     

188

                   

74

                     

207

                   

4                       

‐                    

88

                     

869

                   

26 Circuit

LEW

IS1

86

                   

16

7                   

25

1                   

11

                     

46

                     

39

                     

1                       

‐                    

14

                     

71

5                   

UP

SHU

R1

06

                   

17

9                   

11

                     

73

                     

32

                     

75

                     

1                       

‐                    

10

                     

48

7                   

Total

292

                   

346

                   

262

                   

84

                     

78

                     

114

                   

2                       

‐                    

24

                     

1,202

               

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G2

20

                   

32

8                   

14

                     

42

                     

11

                     

22

5                   

3                       

‐                    

6                       

84

9                   

Total

220

                   

328

                   

14

                     

42

                     

11

                     

225

                   

3                       

‐                    

6                       

849

                   

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

78

                     

27

                     

‐                    

12

                     

2                       

14

1                   

7                       

‐                    

‐                    

26

7                   

Total

78

                     

27

                     

‐                    

12

                     

2                       

141

                   

7                       

‐                    

‐                    

267

                   

FY2015 Annual Report Page 44 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL CLA

IMS PAID W

ITHOUT DIREC

T EX

PEN

SES OR SUPPLEMEN

TALS

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M2

88

                   

42

1                   

80

                     

14

9                   

51

                     

11

3                   

4                       

5                       

32

                     

1,1

43

               

Total

288

                   

421

                   

80

                     

149

                   

51

                     

113

                   

4                       

5                       

32

                     

1,143

               

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

13

9                   

16

5                   

5                       

22

                     

7                       

18

0                   

10

                     

1                       

8                       

53

7                   

Total

139

                   

165

                   

5                       

22

                     

7                       

180

                   

10

                     

1                       

8                       

537

                   

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

66

                     

10

7                   

‐                    

16

                     

10

                     

33

                     

‐                    

1                       

1                       

23

4                   

SUM

MER

S9

0                     

82

                     

3                       

22

                     

7                       

61

                     

1                       

‐                    

2                       

26

8                   

Total

156

                   

189

                   

3                       

38

                     

17

                     

94

                     

1                       

1                       

3                       

502

                   

WV TOTA

L7,657

               

8,851

               

2,530

               

2,926

               

1,380

               

8,718

               

356

                   

576

                   

765

                   

33,759

             

FY2015 Annual Report Page 45 of 212

Felony 575Misdemeanor 75Mental Hygiene 0Juvenile 11Parole/Prob. Rev. 5Term/Abuse & Neglect 87Habeas, Supreme Court 17Municipal Court Charges 1Other 6   (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

Total Claims Paid 777

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL DIRECT EXPENSE PAID

Felony74.00%

Misdemeanor9.65%

Mental Hygiene0.00%

Juvenile1.42%Parole/Prob. 

Rev.0.64%

Term/Abuse & Neglect11.20%

Habeas, Supreme Court

2.19%

Municipal Court Charges0.13%

Other0.77%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 46 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

6                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

6                       

HA

NC

OC

K3

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

4                       

OH

IO8

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

10

                     

Total

17

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

20

                     

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

TYLE

R3

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

3                       

WET

ZEL

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

Total

4                       

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

5                       

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

13

                     

5                       

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

19

                     

PLE

ASA

NTS

5                       

6                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

11

                     

RIT

CH

IE1

2                     

3                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

15

                     

Total

30

                     

14

                     

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

45

                     

04 Circuit

WIR

T1

1                     

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

12

                     

WO

OD

98

                     

9                       

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

24

                     

3                       

‐                    

1                       

13

6                   

Total

109

                   

9                       

‐                    

1                       

1                       

24

                     

3                       

‐                    

1                       

148

                   

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

JAC

KSO

N2

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

4                       

MA

SON

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

RO

AN

E‐

                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

Total

4                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

6                       

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L2

9                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

31

                     

Total

29

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

31

                     

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

3                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

3                       

Total

3                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

3                       

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L1

4                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

15

                     

Total

14

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

15

                     

09 Circuit

MER

CER

31

                     

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

3                       

6                       

‐                    

‐                    

42

                     

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

TOTA

L DIREC

T EX

PEN

SE CLA

IMS PAID

FY2015 Annual Report Page 47 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

TOTA

L DIREC

T EX

PEN

SE CLA

IMS PAID

Total

31

                     

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

3                       

6                       

‐                    

‐                    

42

                     

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H2

0                     

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

3                       

10

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

34

                     

Total

20

                     

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

3                       

10

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

34

                     

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

4                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

5                       

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S2

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

Total

6                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

7                       

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

Total

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A6

1                     

2                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

3                       

4                       

‐                    

1                       

72

                     

Total

61

                     

2                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

3                       

4                       

‐                    

1                       

72

                     

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

CLA

Y1

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

GIL

MER

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

WEB

STER

6                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

6                       

Total

8                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

9                       

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N3

1                     

2                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

34

                     

Total

31

                     

2                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

34

                     

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N1

2                     

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

14

                     

Total

12

                     

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

14

                     

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A1

6                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

18

                     

Total

16

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

18

                     

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N2

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

1                       

‐                    

2                       

7                       

Total

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

1                       

‐                    

2                       

7                       

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R2

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

TAYL

OR

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

Total

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

FY2015 Annual Report Page 48 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

TOTA

L DIREC

T EX

PEN

SE CLA

IMS PAID

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H2

2                     

10

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

35

                     

Total

22

                     

10

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

35

                     

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T3

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

3                       

MIN

ERA

L7

                       

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

9                       

TUC

KER

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

Total

12

                     

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

14

                     

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E8

                       

2                       

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

13

                     

HA

RD

Y3

                       

1                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

6                       

PEN

DLE

TON

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

Total

13

                     

3                       

‐                    

3                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

21

                     

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY3

9                     

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

13

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

53

                     

JEFF

ERSO

N1

7                     

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

4                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

23

                     

MO

RG

AN

2                       

1                       

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

3                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

7                       

Total

58

                     

3                       

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

20

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

83

                     

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

4                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

5                       

Total

4                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

5                       

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E3

                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

5                       

LIN

CO

LN‐

                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

Total

3                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

6                       

26 Circuit

LEW

IS2

                       

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

3                       

UP

SHU

R1

                       

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

3                       

Total

3                       

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

6                       

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G3

5                     

25

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

62

                     

Total

35

                     

25

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

62

                     

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

Total

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

FY2015 Annual Report Page 49 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Municipal

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Claim

s

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

TOTA

L DIREC

T EX

PEN

SE CLA

IMS PAID

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M8

                       

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

12

                     

Total

8                       

1                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

1                       

12

                     

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

14

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

16

                     

Total

14

                     

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

16

                     

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

SUM

MER

S‐

                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

Total

2                       

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2                       

WV TOTA

L575

                   

75

                     

‐                    

11

                     

5                       

87

                     

17

                     

1                       

6                       

777

                   

FY2015 Annual Report Page 50 of 212

Felony 155,882.57                        

Misdemeanor 67,328.15                          

Mental Hygiene 8,258.42                            

Juvenile 34,200.31                          

Parole/Prob. Rev. 11,717.42                          

Term/Abuse & Neglect 183,270.05                        

Habeas, Supreme Court 16,966.07                          

Municipal Court Charges 3,977.16                            

Other 5,126.21                               (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition,  Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

Total Hours Paid 486,726.36                        

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS

Felony32.03%

Misdemeanor13.83%

Mental Hygiene1.70%

Juvenile7.03%

Parole/Prob. Rev.2.41% Term/Abuse & 

Neglect37.65%

Habeas, Supreme Court

3.49%Municipal Court 

Charges0.82%

Other1.05%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 51 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Hours

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

1,8

23

.70

          

77

6.1

7             

29

2.4

0             

23

5.2

0             

81

.30

               

2,9

30

.40

          

17

2.7

0             

‐                    

49

.60

               

6,3

61

.47

          

HA

NC

OC

K2

,55

8.0

0          

75

2.9

0             

10

3.7

0             

40

4.2

0             

24

9.9

0             

4,1

96

.13

          

23

1.6

0             

30

.20

               

25

.80

               

8,5

52

.43

          

OH

IO3

,07

2.8

0          

1,0

44

.50

          

1,7

45

.50

          

16

3.7

0             

37

.60

               

6,7

31

.12

          

1,2

78

.10

          

‐                    

22

.50

               

14

,09

5.8

2        

Total

7,454.50

          

2,573.57

          

2,141.60

          

803.10

             

368.80

             

13,857.65

       

1,682.40

          

30.20

               

97.90

               

29,009.72

       

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

1,1

26

.20

          

37

1.6

0             

15

5.9

0             

10

2.7

0             

80

.50

               

1,2

36

.61

          

87

.40

                

‐                    

12

.30

               

3,1

73

.21

          

TYLE

R3

99

.10

             

11

9.1

0             

15

.60

               

10

1.4

0             

35

.50

               

1,0

27

.34

          

36

.70

               

‐                    

48

.30

               

1,7

83

.04

          

WET

ZEL

1,1

25

.30

          

11

1.4

0             

12

5.5

0             

12

2.1

0             

79

.90

               

1,3

87

.90

          

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

2,9

52

.10

          

Total

2,650.60

          

602.10

             

297.00

             

326.20

             

195.90

             

3,651.85

          

124.10

             

‐                   

60.60

               

7,908.35

          

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

1,3

90

.20

          

77

6.2

0             

40

.80

               

31

6.5

0             

28

7.9

0             

1,6

21

.90

          

‐                    

‐                    

98

.50

               

4,5

32

.00

          

PLE

ASA

NTS

1,2

23

.40

          

55

3.6

0             

22

.60

               

29

7.5

0             

55

.10

               

1,0

50

.70

          

20

.20

               

‐                    

39

.80

               

3,2

62

.90

          

RIT

CH

IE1

,09

9.8

0          

90

0.5

0             

25

.80

               

28

6.9

0             

47

.40

               

2,5

40

.00

          

15

9.8

0             

‐                    

26

.80

               

5,0

87

.00

          

Total

3,713.40

          

2,230.30

          

89.20

               

900.90

             

390.40

             

5,212.60

          

180.00

             

‐                   

165.10

             

12,881.90

       

04 Circuit

WIR

T5

52

.80

             

37

5.2

0             

1.2

0                  

28

0.1

0             

60

.40

               

21

7.9

0             

70

.80

               

‐                    

58

.50

               

1,6

16

.90

          

WO

OD

6,5

13

.40

          

7,8

45

.50

          

60

5.3

0             

1,5

23

.30

          

48

6.9

0             

7,4

34

.44

          

1,1

84

.40

          

‐                    

28

6.5

0             

25

,87

9.7

4        

Total

7,066.20

          

8,220.70

          

606.50

             

1,803.40

          

547.30

             

7,652.34

          

1,255.20

          

‐                   

345.00

             

27,496.64

       

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

1,5

89

.50

          

10

6.5

0             

12

.90

               

16

.00

               

18

.30

               

2,5

44

.00

          

24

8.7

0             

‐                    

20

.40

               

4,5

56

.30

          

JAC

KSO

N2

,05

8.6

0          

37

2.9

0             

4.9

0                  

28

8.0

0             

24

4.8

0             

4,4

01

.40

          

65

6.1

0             

‐                    

18

1.9

0             

8,2

08

.60

          

MA

SON

2,7

24

.40

          

2,1

40

.30

          

18

1.5

0             

1,0

70

.40

          

42

2.1

0             

1,8

02

.10

          

22

0.2

0             

‐                    

13

2.2

0             

8,6

93

.20

          

RO

AN

E1

,99

8.9

0          

16

9.1

0             

59

.90

               

25

5.0

0             

88

.00

               

1,4

54

.20

          

11

5.1

0             

‐                    

84

.50

               

4,2

24

.70

          

Total

8,371.40

          

2,788.80

          

259.20

             

1,629.40

          

773.20

             

10,201.70

       

1,240.10

          

‐                   

419.00

             

25,682.80

       

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L8

,23

0.2

0          

55

9.7

0             

1,2

27

.82

          

66

9.2

0             

59

1.2

0             

6,5

09

.00

          

83

8.7

0             

‐                    

22

2.9

0             

18

,84

8.7

2        

Total

8,230.20

          

559.70

             

1,227.82

          

669.20

             

591.20

             

6,509.00

          

838.70

             

‐                   

222.90

             

18,848.72

       

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

2,5

32

.40

          

2,7

30

.70

          

3.0

0                  

1,8

09

.70

          

20

5.0

0             

4,0

73

.10

          

35

1.5

0             

‐                    

26

.80

               

11

,73

2.2

0        

Total

2,532.40

          

2,730.70

          

3.00

                 

1,809.70

          

205.00

             

4,073.10

          

351.50

             

‐                   

26.80

               

11,732.20

       

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L4

,23

8.5

0          

1,6

54

.70

          

11

8.0

0             

14

6.9

0             

17

.80

               

3,1

80

.90

          

40

1.1

0             

‐                    

82

.40

               

9,8

40

.30

          

Total

4,238.50

          

1,654.70

          

118.00

             

146.90

             

17.80

               

3,180.90

          

401.10

             

‐                   

82.40

               

9,840.30

          

09 Circuit

MER

CER

10

,97

4.6

3        

2,4

85

.44

          

58

6.5

0             

4,5

88

.26

          

50

3.9

0             

10

,15

3.8

4        

50

1.7

0             

18

0.1

0             

32

1.9

0             

30

,29

6.2

7        

Total

10,974.63

       

2,485.44

          

586.50

             

4,588.26

          

503.90

             

10,153.84

       

501.70

             

180.10

             

321.90

             

30,296.27

       

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS PAID BY CIRCUIT & CASE TYPE

FY2015 Annual Report Page 52 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Hours

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS PAID BY CIRCUIT & CASE TYPE

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H4

,17

3.6

1          

1,4

05

.31

          

22

.10

               

49

4.3

0             

33

6.9

9             

11

,57

3.1

7        

53

9.4

0             

‐                    

42

.60

               

18

,58

7.4

8        

Total

4,173.61

          

1,405.31

          

22.10

               

494.30

             

336.99

             

11,573.17

       

539.40

             

‐                   

42.60

               

18,587.48

       

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

2,7

26

.90

          

50

2.5

0             

12

.40

               

11

7.6

0             

87

.20

               

3,8

25

.80

          

22

5.0

0             

34

.40

               

73

.50

               

7,6

05

.30

          

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S1

,09

6.8

0          

20

4.1

0             

33

.20

               

73

.90

               

‐                    

1,3

99

.80

          

‐                    

‐                    

13

.30

               

2,8

21

.10

          

Total

3,823.70

          

706.60

             

45.60

               

191.50

             

87.20

               

5,225.60

          

225.00

             

34.40

               

86.80

               

10,426.40

       

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

2,9

79

.20

          

69

8.9

0             

‐                    

23

5.8

0             

10

2.7

0             

3,5

98

.50

          

33

4.3

0             

23

.40

               

3.4

0                  

7,9

76

.20

          

Total

2,979.20

          

698.90

             

235.80

             

102.70

             

3,598.50

          

334.30

             

23.40

               

3.40

                 

7,976.20

          

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A1

1,0

82

.40

        

5,1

96

.54

          

‐                    

1,7

01

.00

          

69

7.8

0             

11

,32

4.9

0        

2,4

42

.65

          

2,6

74

.45

          

37

9.1

0             

35

,49

8.8

5        

Total

11,082.40

       

5,196.54

          

‐                   

1,701.00

          

697.80

             

11,324.90

       

2,442.65

          

2,674.45

          

379.10

             

35,498.85

       

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

1,4

96

.14

          

86

1.2

9             

13

.10

               

30

3.9

3             

10

8.4

0             

2,9

74

.31

          

20

.90

               

‐                    

46

.00

               

5,8

24

.07

          

CLA

Y1

,82

1.5

6          

40

2.2

0             

5.2

0                  

28

8.3

7             

27

.90

               

4,7

66

.26

          

37

.20

               

5.9

0                  

4.8

0                  

7,3

59

.39

          

GIL

MER

1,1

56

.90

          

65

1.9

7             

3.7

0                  

32

5.2

0             

57

.40

               

1,2

95

.80

          

49

.32

               

43

.30

               

57

.16

               

3,6

40

.75

          

WEB

STER

3,5

06

.53

          

65

5.1

4             

7.1

0                  

54

7.8

5             

97

.63

               

5,5

39

.80

          

31

0.1

0             

‐                    

48

.05

               

10

,71

2.2

0        

Total

7,981.13

          

2,570.59

          

29.10

               

1,465.35

          

291.33

             

14,576.18

       

417.52

             

49.20

               

156.01

             

27,536.42

       

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N4

,18

3.5

0          

94

1.7

0             

93

.50

               

37

0.7

0             

22

3.9

0             

4,1

93

.70

          

59

2.2

0             

‐                    

13

4.7

0             

10

,73

3.9

0         

Total

4,183.50

          

941.70

             

93.50

               

370.70

             

223.90

             

4,193.70

          

592.20

             

‐                   

134.70

             

10,733.90

       

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N6

,79

3.6

9          

3,3

94

.80

          

34

5.0

0             

1,8

99

.70

          

80

3.2

0             

3,3

44

.81

          

59

3.3

0             

33

1.6

0             

32

8.1

0             

17

,83

4.2

0        

Total

6,793.69

          

3,394.80

          

345.00

             

1,899.70

          

803.20

             

3,344.81

          

593.30

             

331.60

             

328.10

             

17,834.20

       

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A9

,85

8.5

9          

5,1

43

.40

          

46

5.4

0             

1,4

05

.50

          

1,0

27

.30

          

4,4

49

.00

          

75

6.1

0             

47

9.2

0             

24

3.5

0             

23

,82

7.9

9        

Total

9,858.59

          

5,143.40

          

465.40

             

1,405.50

          

1,027.30

          

4,449.00

          

756.10

             

479.20

             

243.50

             

23,827.99

       

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N1

,70

8.4

0          

83

6.1

0             

28

.10

               

76

.20

               

99

.50

               

4,5

05

.10

          

12

0.7

0             

‐                    

23

0.2

0             

7,6

04

.30

          

Total

1,708.40

          

836.10

             

28.10

               

76.20

               

99.50

               

4,505.10

          

120.70

             

‐                   

230.20

             

7,604.30

          

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R1

,36

6.4

0          

79

7.5

0             

18

.60

               

1,0

56

.00

          

37

.80

               

3,0

72

.10

          

91

.70

               

‐                    

26

.50

               

6,4

66

.60

          

TAYL

OR

1,7

44

.00

          

79

1.2

0             

54

.80

               

1,4

41

.40

          

11

6.0

0             

2,7

89

.70

          

44

.30

               

‐                    

22

8.8

0             

7,2

10

.20

          

Total

3,110.40

          

1,588.70

          

73.40

               

2,497.40

          

153.80

             

5,861.80

          

136.00

             

‐                   

255.30

             

13,676.80

       

FY2015 Annual Report Page 53 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Hours

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS PAID BY CIRCUIT & CASE TYPE

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H3

,55

5.6

0          

2,1

26

.30

          

71

.20

               

1,5

27

.80

          

26

2.1

0             

1,8

03

.70

          

43

0.4

0             

62

.40

               

26

8.9

0             

10

,10

8.4

0        

Total

3,555.60

          

2,126.30

          

71.20

               

1,527.80

          

262.10

             

1,803.70

          

430.40

             

62.40

               

268.90

             

10,108.40

       

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T1

,08

0.3

0          

50

6.1

0             

14

.00

               

28

5.4

0             

17

3.0

0             

62

3.7

0             

‐                    

‐                    

70

.70

               

2,7

53

.20

          

MIN

ERA

L2

,13

7.5

0          

1,9

63

.20

          

31

.00

               

33

9.9

0             

24

2.8

0             

1,0

63

.80

          

62

.60

               

‐                    

84

.30

               

5,9

25

.10

          

TUC

KER

22

9.3

0             

22

3.3

0             

‐                    

22

2.0

0             

23

.50

               

83

.80

               

‐                    

‐                    

4.5

0                  

78

6.4

0             

Total

3,447.10

          

2,692.60

          

45.00

               

847.30

             

439.30

             

1,771.30

          

62.60

               

‐                   

159.50

             

9,464.70

          

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E2

,44

4.6

0          

1,3

58

.50

          

16

.20

               

63

7.3

0             

27

7.1

0             

1,4

67

.40

          

23

4.7

0             

‐                    

69

.10

               

6,5

04

.90

          

HA

RD

Y1

,56

1.4

0          

1,3

00

.00

          

27

.50

               

63

0.4

0             

14

1.2

0             

1,6

74

.40

          

52

.70

               

‐                    

50

.00

               

5,4

37

.60

          

PEN

DLE

TON

50

3.7

0             

20

9.8

0             

11

.40

               

14

0.2

0             

25

2.7

0             

14

9.4

0             

38

.70

               

‐                    

18

.50

               

1,3

24

.40

          

Total

4,509.70

          

2,868.30

          

55.10

               

1,407.90

          

671.00

             

3,291.20

          

326.10

             

‐                   

137.60

             

13,266.90

       

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY4

,39

9.3

0          

44

4.2

0             

‐                    

52

9.3

0             

32

8.4

0             

10

,78

0.4

5        

1,6

88

.60

          

22

.20

               

5.0

0                  

18

,19

7.4

5        

JEFF

ERSO

N1

,49

8.8

0          

69

2.1

0             

‐                    

34

9.2

0             

26

1.4

0             

4,2

32

.80

          

31

4.2

0             

‐                    

19

.80

               

7,3

68

.30

          

MO

RG

AN

1,0

90

.90

          

41

3.6

0             

‐                    

20

9.1

0             

11

5.1

0             

2,8

90

.30

          

10

1.9

0             

‐                    

18

.20

               

4,8

39

.10

          

Total

6,989.00

          

1,549.90

          

‐                   

1,087.60

          

704.90

             

17,903.55

       

2,104.70

          

22.20

               

43.00

               

30,404.85

       

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

1,0

73

.20

          

13

5.6

0             

13

4.2

0             

10

7.8

0             

23

7.7

0             

3,0

86

.60

          

10

2.1

0             

15

.30

               

37

.30

               

4,9

29

.80

          

Total

1,073.20

          

135.60

             

134.20

             

107.80

             

237.70

             

3,086.60

          

102.10

             

15.30

               

37.30

               

4,929.80

          

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E9

62

.10

             

10

2.6

0             

‐                    

1,3

56

.70

          

13

9.3

0             

1,8

48

.82

          

23

4.1

0             

‐                    

64

.20

               

4,7

07

.82

          

LIN

CO

LN2

,33

1.8

0          

65

8.4

0             

17

2.7

0             

41

2.4

0             

65

2.9

0             

3,1

42

.90

          

43

.70

               

‐                    

27

7.8

0             

7,6

92

.60

          

Total

3,293.90

          

761.00

             

172.70

             

1,769.10

          

792.20

             

4,991.72

          

277.80

             

‐                   

342.00

             

12,400.42

       

26 Circuit

LEW

IS4

,00

3.6

4          

1,3

60

.60

          

72

7.7

0             

11

1.7

0             

35

8.2

0             

97

8.0

0             

89

.90

               

‐                    

93

.20

               

7,7

22

.94

          

UP

SHU

R1

,90

4.8

0          

1,1

00

.80

          

40

.40

               

81

9.5

0             

19

9.5

0             

1,8

03

.00

          

6.0

0                  

‐                    

52

.40

               

5,9

26

.40

          

Total

5,908.44

          

2,461.40

          

768.10

             

931.20

             

557.70

             

2,781.00

          

95.90

               

‐                   

145.60

             

13,649.34

       

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G3

,75

2.7

0          

2,5

83

.40

          

52

.90

               

55

2.3

0             

71

.90

               

3,2

45

.50

          

16

0.5

0             

‐                    

57

.00

               

10

,47

6.2

0        

Total

3,752.70

          

2,583.40

          

52.90

               

552.30

             

71.90

               

3,245.50

          

160.50

             

‐                   

57.00

               

10,476.20

       

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

1,4

41

.60

          

13

4.7

0             

‐                    

55

.00

               

10

.30

               

2,9

95

.04

          

32

6.6

0             

‐                    

‐                    

4,9

63

.24

          

Total

1,441.60

          

134.70

             

‐                   

55.00

               

10.30

                

2,995.04

          

326.60

             

‐                   

‐                   

4,963.24

          

FY2015 Annual Report Page 54 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juvenile

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Hours

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS PAID BY CIRCUIT & CASE TYPE

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M5

,45

9.6

0          

3,8

76

.90

          

49

6.6

0             

2,1

27

.50

          

38

5.0

0             

2,7

55

.60

          

91

.30

               

55

.70

               

24

5.5

0             

15

,49

3.7

0        

Total

5,459.60

          

3,876.90

          

496.60

             

2,127.50

          

385.00

             

2,755.60

          

91.30

               

55.70

               

245.50

             

15,493.70

       

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

2,9

23

.08

          

97

5.2

0             

13

.90

               

42

8.8

0             

55

.60

               

4,0

92

.20

          

24

0.6

0             

13

.40

               

72

.00

               

8,8

14

.78

          

Total

2,923.08

          

975.20

             

13.90

               

428.80

             

55.60

               

4,092.20

          

240.60

             

13.40

               

72.00

               

8,814.78

          

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

1,2

48

.20

          

46

6.3

0             

‐                    

11

3.8

0             

50

.90

               

53

0.3

0             

‐                    

5.6

0                  

1.1

0                  

2,4

16

.20

          

SUM

MER

S1

,35

4.0

0          

36

7.9

0             

17

.70

               

22

9.7

0             

61

.60

               

87

6.6

0             

15

.50

               

‐                    

15

.40

               

2,9

38

.40

          

Total

2,602.20

          

834.20

             

17.70

               

343.50

             

112.50

             

1,406.90

          

15.50

               

5.60

                 

16.50

               

5,354.60

          

WV TOTA

L155,882.57

     

67,328.15

       

8,258.42

          

34,200.31

       

11,717.42

       

183,270.05

     

16,966.07

       

3,977.16

          

5,126.21

          

486,726.36

     

FY2015 Annual Report Page 55 of 212

Felony 7,458,273.81Misdemeanor 3,224,269.68Mental Hygiene 409,780.28Juvenile 1,659,347.82Parole/Prob. Rev. 563,854.00Term/Abuse & Neglect 8,871,695.83Habeas, Supreme Court 772,071.25Municipal Court Charges 195,874.20Other 244,119.80  (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

Total Fees Paid 23,399,286.67

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL FEES PAID

Felony31.87%

Misdemeanor13.78%

Mental Hygiene1.75%

Juvenile7.09%

Parole/Prob. Rev.2.41%

Term/Abuse & Neglect37.91%

Habeas, Supreme Court

3.30%Municipal Court 

Charges0.84%

Other1.04%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 56 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Fee

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

86

,95

8.1

33

7,3

86

.72

13

,93

8.2

41

1,4

29

.47

3,8

66

.50

13

9,0

67

.38

7,8

27

.50

0.0

02

,31

4.0

03

02

,78

7.9

4

HA

NC

OC

K1

23

,59

1.8

33

7,9

02

.06

4,9

16

.27

19

,44

7.0

01

2,3

58

.32

19

9,5

12

.12

10

,55

4.5

61

,43

7.0

01

,34

5.0

04

11

,06

4.1

6

OH

IO1

42

,94

5.7

54

8,7

72

.50

82

,89

2.4

37

,61

4.5

01

,75

2.0

03

15

,87

7.7

25

8,1

48

.62

0.0

01

,01

8.5

06

59

,02

2.0

2

Total

353,495.71

124,061.28

101,746.94

38,490.97

17,976.82

654,457.22

76,530.68

1,437.00

4,677.50

1,372,874.12

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

54

,23

5.4

41

7,8

82

.52

7,6

56

.36

5,0

81

.50

3,9

65

.05

59

,55

7.6

94

,00

7.0

00

.00

61

3.5

01

52

,99

9.0

6

TYLE

R1

9,1

61

.91

5,6

16

.13

71

8.4

24

,97

3.2

21

,70

7.5

04

9,6

40

.48

1,6

51

.50

0.0

02

,42

4.6

88

5,8

93

.84

WET

ZEL

53

,19

3.7

35

,27

9.0

06

,04

9.6

65

,87

0.3

64

,00

5.5

06

7,8

92

.97

0.0

00

.00

0.0

01

42

,29

1.2

2

Total

126,591.08

28,777.65

14,424.44

15,925.08

9,678.05

177,091.14

5,658.50

0.00

3,038.18

381,184.12

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

64

,49

6.1

53

6,1

72

.97

2,0

28

.31

14

,95

9.3

41

3,5

55

.56

76

,75

2.1

80

.00

0.0

04

,71

1.5

32

12

,67

6.0

4

PLE

ASA

NTS

57

,42

7.9

92

5,7

56

.40

1,1

77

.00

14

,22

3.4

52

,60

3.5

05

0,6

05

.57

92

5.0

00

.00

1,8

85

.00

15

4,6

03

.91

RIT

CH

IE5

1,4

90

.20

42

,43

5.4

21

,34

7.0

01

3,6

73

.31

2,2

61

.00

12

2,0

83

.42

7,3

79

.00

0.0

01

,26

4.4

92

41

,93

3.8

4

Total

173,414.34

104,364.79

4,552.31

42,856.10

18,420.06

249,441.17

8,304.00

0.00

7,861.02

609,213.79

04 Circuit

WIR

T2

5,7

91

.59

17

,66

6.0

05

8.0

01

3,2

47

.30

2,8

34

.00

10

,22

9.5

83

,18

6.0

00

.00

2,7

00

.50

75

,71

2.9

7

WO

OD

30

8,2

93

.29

37

2,9

60

.99

29

,16

4.5

57

2,0

99

.90

23

,12

9.6

63

54

,59

7.6

75

4,1

30

.00

0.0

01

3,5

91

.37

1,2

27

,96

7.4

3

Total

334,084.88

390,626.99

29,222.55

85,347.20

25,963.66

364,827.25

57,316.00

0.00

16,291.87

1,303,680.40

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

75

,93

7.5

05

,09

3.6

06

74

.50

79

2.0

08

43

.50

12

5,6

53

.20

11

,19

1.5

00

.00

94

5.5

02

21

,13

1.3

0

JAC

KSO

N9

9,0

61

.45

18

,04

2.5

02

46

.76

14

,05

4.0

01

1,9

34

.68

21

7,7

39

.05

30

,07

4.5

00

.00

8,7

93

.35

39

9,9

46

.29

MA

SON

13

1,4

20

.25

10

1,6

76

.88

9,0

74

.18

52

,55

1.1

02

0,2

29

.16

88

,96

4.5

01

0,1

23

.00

0.0

06

,36

7.0

04

20

,40

6.0

7

RO

AN

E9

6,2

29

.49

8,0

94

.69

2,8

68

.38

12

,83

8.7

34

,27

0.0

07

1,5

54

.32

5,1

85

.74

0.0

04

,07

9.3

02

05

,12

0.6

5

Total

402,648.69

132,907.67

12,863.82

80,235.83

37,277.34

503,911.07

56,574.74

0.00

20,185.15

1,246,604.31

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L4

05

,42

1.8

12

8,9

65

.58

64

,74

0.5

83

4,6

62

.43

28

,59

4.3

53

31

,97

6.1

83

7,9

57

.50

0.0

01

0,8

11

.01

94

3,1

29

.44

Total

405,421.81

28,965.58

64,740.58

34,662.43

28,594.35

331,976.18

37,957.50

0.00

10,811.01

943,129.44

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

12

0,6

74

.31

13

0,3

80

.90

14

9.0

08

7,9

69

.56

9,8

05

.00

20

0,9

77

.47

16

,07

3.5

00

.00

1,2

80

.00

56

7,3

09

.74

Total

120,674.31

130,380.90

149.00

87,969.56

9,805.00

200,977.47

16,073.50

0.00

1,280.00

567,309.74

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L2

04

,37

2.4

87

9,0

23

.81

6,0

52

.44

7,0

69

.30

85

3.5

01

56

,02

1.2

71

9,0

69

.50

0.0

03

,90

6.0

04

76

,36

8.3

0

Total

204,372.48

79,023.81

6,052.44

7,069.30

853.50

156,021.27

19,069.50

0.00

3,906.00

476,368.30

09 Circuit

MER

CER

52

3,3

49

.86

12

1,6

08

.61

28

,50

4.9

12

27

,35

7.1

62

4,7

64

.91

48

9,6

80

.53

22

,73

8.5

08

,97

7.7

71

5,3

49

.86

1,4

62

,33

2.1

1

Total

523,349.86

121,608.61

28,504.91

227,357.16

24,764.91

489,680.53

22,738.50

8,977.77

15,349.86

1,462,332.11

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES BY CASE TYPE

FY2015 Annual Report Page 57 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Fee

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES BY CASE TYPE

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H2

00

,67

2.2

26

8,0

34

.48

1,1

36

.50

24

,01

1.0

11

6,1

78

.95

56

5,2

28

.66

24

,48

1.2

00

.00

2,0

95

.30

90

1,8

38

.32

Total

200,672.22

68,034.48

1,136.50

24,011.01

16,178.95

565,228.66

24,481.20

0.00

2,095.30

901,838.32

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

12

8,3

10

.47

23

,72

5.5

57

16

.00

5,6

54

.58

4,1

68

.00

18

2,4

64

.31

10

,04

7.6

21

,61

6.0

03

,40

3.5

03

60

,10

6.0

3

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S5

1,5

01

.52

9,6

17

.15

1,5

58

.09

3,6

07

.50

0.0

06

5,4

17

.00

0.0

00

.00

60

8.5

01

32

,30

9.7

6

Total

179,811.99

33,342.70

2,274.09

9,262.08

4,168.00

247,881.31

10,047.62

1,616.00

4,012.00

492,415.79

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

14

3,8

26

.47

34

,21

7.9

60

.00

11

,13

5.0

05

,05

7.6

21

75

,10

8.9

21

5,2

41

.50

1,1

15

.00

16

3.0

03

85

,86

5.4

7

Total

143,826.47

34,217.96

11,135.00

5,057.62

175,108.92

15,241.50

1,115.00

163.00

385,865.47

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A5

28

,76

4.9

12

53

,21

7.8

80

.00

82

,12

5.0

33

3,5

24

.72

55

1,0

08

.56

11

0,6

61

.25

13

3,7

40

.06

18

,00

8.5

11

,71

1,0

50

.92

Total

528,764.91

253,217.88

0.00

82,125.03

33,524.72

551,008.56

110,661.25

133,740.06

18,008.51

1,711,050.92

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

71

,92

4.3

04

1,4

92

.61

74

1.5

01

5,5

23

.41

5,2

25

.07

14

4,6

95

.65

1,0

28

.50

0.0

02

,28

4.6

42

82

,91

5.6

8

CLA

Y8

5,4

14

.68

18

,99

2.1

53

12

.00

13

,95

4.5

51

,30

9.5

02

28

,96

2.3

71

,67

4.0

02

91

.50

22

4.0

03

51

,13

4.7

5

GIL

MER

55

,54

0.3

33

1,0

78

.75

21

0.5

01

5,6

72

.00

2,7

37

.00

62

,92

5.2

42

,30

5.4

22

,04

8.6

92

,86

2.1

81

75

,38

0.1

1

WEB

STER

16

7,2

63

.12

31

,58

1.7

63

53

.50

27

,17

1.4

34

,66

5.1

42

66

,01

0.8

11

4,1

64

.74

0.0

02

,31

6.3

25

13

,52

6.8

2

Total

380,142.43

123,145.27

1,617.50

72,321.39

13,936.71

702,594.07

19,172.66

2,340.19

7,687.14

1,322,957.36

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N1

97

,21

3.8

14

4,4

24

.47

4,4

39

.50

17

,73

9.7

51

0,7

22

.05

20

0,3

62

.02

26

,98

8.1

80

.00

6,2

28

.13

50

8,1

17

.91

Total

197,213.81

44,424.47

4,439.50

17,739.75

10,722.05

200,362.02

26,988.18

0.00

6,228.13

508,117.91

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N3

13

,62

6.4

61

58

,57

0.6

51

7,2

38

.31

88

,77

1.6

23

7,5

89

.09

15

6,8

97

.65

26

,89

0.5

01

5,4

26

.00

15

,11

0.7

58

30

,12

1.0

3

Total

313,626.46

158,570.65

17,238.31

88,771.62

37,589.09

156,897.65

26,890.50

15,426.00

15,110.75

830,121.03

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A4

66

,15

1.2

32

42

,88

2.9

62

4,4

18

.68

68

,08

2.2

94

8,7

94

.50

21

1,0

82

.94

34

,18

0.7

92

2,7

51

.18

11

,58

7.6

61

,12

9,9

32

.23

Total

466,151.23

242,882.96

24,418.68

68,082.29

48,794.50

211,082.94

34,180.79

22,751.18

11,587.66

1,129,932.23

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N8

0,3

12

.17

39

,28

2.3

11

,41

0.5

03

,61

1.0

04

,66

5.5

02

12

,80

0.3

95

,45

5.5

00

.00

10

,58

8.7

33

58

,12

6.1

0

Total

80,312.17

39,282.31

1,410.50

3,611.00

4,665.50

212,800.39

5,455.50

0.00

10,588.73

358,126.10

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R6

4,8

71

.37

37

,23

8.4

19

03

.00

49

,34

4.2

21

,77

5.0

01

44

,72

7.8

64

,13

2.5

00

.00

1,2

28

.50

30

4,2

20

.86

TAYL

OR

82

,62

8.3

23

7,6

32

.20

2,9

50

.47

66

,29

8.2

55

,57

6.0

01

30

,23

8.7

11

,99

3.5

00

.00

10

,60

2.3

53

37

,91

9.8

0

Total

147,499.69

74,870.61

3,853.47

115,642.47

7,351.00

274,966.57

6,126.00

0.00

11,830.85

642,140.66

FY2015 Annual Report Page 58 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Fee

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES BY CASE TYPE

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H1

73

,08

2.8

31

02

,55

7.9

63

,87

4.0

07

6,0

50

.32

12

,70

4.6

48

9,6

50

.30

19

,99

8.0

02

,93

8.0

01

2,8

80

.95

49

3,7

37

.00

Total

173,082.83

102,557.96

3,874.00

76,050.32

12,704.64

89,650.30

19,998.00

2,938.00

12,880.95

493,737.00

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T5

2,0

74

.70

24

,60

2.9

07

22

.00

13

,84

9.0

08

,31

9.5

22

9,7

00

.85

0.0

00

.00

3,4

77

.50

13

2,7

46

.47

MIN

ERA

L1

00

,17

9.8

79

2,1

08

.75

1,6

09

.61

16

,14

3.2

21

1,4

55

.10

50

,31

9.2

32

,81

7.0

00

.00

3,9

27

.50

27

8,5

60

.28

TUC

KER

10

,73

6.5

01

0,4

78

.50

0.0

01

0,6

08

.00

1,1

17

.50

4,1

21

.00

0.0

00

.00

21

2.5

03

7,2

74

.00

TOTA

L162,991.07

127,190.15

2,331.61

40,600.22

20,892.12

84,141.08

2,817.00

0.00

7,617.50

448,580.75

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E1

19

,27

9.0

46

5,7

09

.10

96

7.0

03

1,6

44

.41

13

,41

4.3

17

1,3

00

.68

10

,84

2.8

70

.00

3,5

43

.53

31

6,7

00

.94

HA

RD

Y7

5,3

47

.33

61

,96

3.4

61

,53

3.5

03

1,4

52

.85

6,7

99

.37

81

,37

0.0

02

,37

1.5

00

.00

2,4

22

.00

26

3,2

60

.01

PEN

DLE

TON

23

,81

9.0

09

,92

7.1

75

69

.21

6,7

11

.00

11

,97

9.5

07

,21

1.0

01

,79

3.5

00

.00

89

8.5

06

2,9

08

.88

Total

218,445.37

137,599.73

3,069.71

69,808.26

32,193.18

159,881.68

15,007.87

0.00

6,864.03

642,869.83

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY2

14

,33

9.4

22

1,5

97

.63

0.0

02

5,5

85

.06

15

,83

8.7

05

15

,50

7.9

47

6,3

54

.21

1,0

63

.00

27

7.0

08

70

,56

2.9

6

JEFF

ERSO

N7

3,6

70

.29

33

,74

0.6

30

.00

16

,67

8.0

01

3,1

32

.35

20

2,8

17

.64

14

,28

9.0

00

.00

94

3.0

03

55

,27

0.9

1

MO

RG

AN

52

,80

0.3

21

9,6

08

.15

0.0

09

,92

7.8

95

,56

5.9

11

39

,30

5.7

24

,61

9.5

00

.00

87

1.0

02

32

,69

8.4

9

Total

340,810.03

74,946.41

0.00

52,190.95

34,536.96

857,631.30

95,262.71

1,063.00

2,091.00

1,458,532.36

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

54

,39

2.0

07

,54

8.8

78

,47

1.9

55

,43

3.2

11

1,7

94

.50

16

2,1

36

.69

4,6

80

.50

79

4.5

01

,96

9.0

82

57

,22

1.3

0

Total

54,392.00

7,548.87

8,471.95

5,433.21

11,794.50

162,136.69

4,680.50

794.50

1,969.08

257,221.30

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E5

0,9

65

.06

5,6

25

.40

0.0

06

7,1

15

.57

6,9

26

.63

97

,08

6.0

11

0,5

74

.50

0.0

03

,12

7.0

02

41

,42

0.1

7

LIN

CO

LN1

13

,16

9.9

73

1,8

74

.14

8,1

47

.50

20

,56

6.0

03

1,5

02

.50

15

6,2

11

.93

2,0

16

.50

0.0

01

3,4

33

.47

37

6,9

22

.01

Total

164,135.03

37,499.54

8,147.50

87,681.57

38,429.13

253,297.94

12,591.00

0.00

16,560.47

618,342.18

26 Circuit

LEW

IS1

92

,79

2.5

16

4,8

00

.43

35

,47

4.5

05

,32

0.5

01

7,5

59

.47

46

,63

2.1

24

,11

6.5

90

.00

4,4

22

.00

37

1,1

18

.12

UP

SHU

R9

1,9

81

.16

53

,19

3.2

92

,13

0.0

03

9,3

39

.73

9,8

49

.71

86

,94

9.3

02

70

.00

0.0

02

,54

8.0

02

86

,26

1.1

9

Total

284,773.67

117,993.72

37,604.50

44,660.23

27,409.18

133,581.42

4,386.59

0.00

6,970.00

657,379.31

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G1

78

,46

7.3

31

23

,32

4.1

22

,84

6.5

02

6,8

73

.68

3,5

43

.74

15

6,2

10

.06

7,3

32

.50

0.0

02

,77

7.1

05

01

,37

5.0

3

Total

178,467.33

123,324.12

2,846.50

26,873.68

3,543.74

156,210.06

7,332.50

0.00

2,777.10

501,375.03

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

69

,56

8.1

76

,66

0.2

40

.00

2,8

17

.00

52

0.1

31

44

,65

3.3

01

4,7

31

.02

0.0

00

.00

23

8,9

49

.86

Total

69,568.17

6,660.24

0.00

2,817.00

520.13

144,653.30

14,731.02

0.00

0.00

238,949.86

FY2015 Annual Report Page 59 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Fee

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES BY CASE TYPE

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M2

57

,84

6.3

61

86

,05

3.7

42

3,1

22

.97

10

2,3

06

.83

18

,37

7.7

11

33

,84

4.7

44

,13

6.5

02

,70

6.5

01

1,4

84

.51

73

9,8

79

.86

Total

257,846.36

186,053.74

23,122.97

102,306.83

18,377.71

133,844.74

4,136.50

2,706.50

11,484.51

739,879.86

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

14

4,3

02

.50

50

,03

8.4

37

49

.50

20

,97

0.0

82

,59

0.0

02

01

,22

6.2

51

0,9

61

.94

70

5.0

03

,43

2.0

04

34

,97

5.7

0

Total

144,302.50

50,038.43

749.50

20,970.08

2,590.00

201,226.25

10,961.94

705.00

3,432.00

434,975.70

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

60

,37

8.6

92

2,5

01

.70

0.0

05

,87

4.1

62

,51

2.8

82

6,1

19

.64

0.0

02

64

.00

49

.50

11

7,7

00

.57

SUM

MER

S6

7,0

06

.22

17

,64

8.5

09

16

.50

11

,46

6.0

43

,02

8.0

04

3,0

07

.04

69

7.5

00

.00

71

1.0

01

44

,48

0.8

0

Total

127,384.91

40,150.20

916.50

17,340.20

5,540.88

69,126.68

697.50

264.00

760.50

262,181.37

WV TOTA

L7,458,273.81

3,224,269.68

409,780.28

1,659,347.82

563,854.00

8,871,695.83

772,071.25

195,874.20

244,119.80

23,399,286.67

FY2015 Annual Report Page 60 of 212

Felony 1,466,581.02Misdemeanor 200,694.53Mental Hygiene 13,452.13Juvenile 90,290.58Parole/Prob. Rev. 34,234.51Term/Abuse & Neglect 600,113.83Habeas, Supreme Court 121,781.33Municipal Court Charges 6,111.78Other 22,350.86

Total Expenses Paid 2,555,610.57

APPOINTED COUNSEL EXPENSES PAIDINCLUDING DIRECT EXPENSES

   (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition,  Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

Felony57.39%

Misdemeanor7.85%

Mental Hygiene0.53%

Juvenile3.53%

Parole/Prob. Rev.1.34%

Term/Abuse & Neglect23.48%

Habeas, Supreme Court4.77%

Municipal Court Charges0.24%

Other0.87%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 61 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Expenses

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

22

,32

2.5

33

,18

1.8

84

99

.33

71

3.5

23

08

.68

7,6

70

.73

1,6

40

.06

0.0

01

,02

9.8

63

7,3

66

.59

HA

NC

OC

K1

6,3

43

.14

2,2

29

.00

15

9.8

01

,34

9.3

11

,07

2.9

89

,87

2.8

61

,26

4.4

49

9.6

11

30

.69

32

,52

1.8

3

OH

IO4

3,0

93

.22

2,8

20

.23

21

.24

29

5.2

71

20

.64

11

,71

2.9

36

,28

3.6

10

.00

28

.53

64

,37

5.6

7

Total

81,758.89

8,231.11

680.37

2,358.10

1,502.30

29,256.52

9,188.11

99.61

1,189.08

134,264.09

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

2,0

51

.98

2,3

04

.23

49

1.0

01

84

.00

11

0.8

81

,72

3.2

53

95

.87

0.0

02

0.3

67

,28

1.5

7

TYLE

R9

,84

9.5

65

14

.90

72

.32

32

8.1

11

80

.78

3,4

03

.65

19

0.1

00

.00

22

2.4

21

4,7

61

.84

WET

ZEL

2,8

36

.48

32

8.3

25

50

.28

17

8.2

63

20

.49

3,7

83

.76

0.0

00

.00

0.0

07

,99

7.5

9

Total

14,738.02

3,147.45

1,113.60

690.37

612.15

8,910.66

585.97

0.00

242.78

30,041.00

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

12

,48

2.6

05

,50

4.5

43

34

.28

1,5

30

.66

1,9

09

.00

8,4

52

.28

0.0

00

.00

56

0.7

53

0,7

74

.11

PLE

ASA

NTS

10

,17

0.8

33

,86

5.5

91

20

.14

81

3.8

52

88

.06

4,1

83

.12

91

.66

0.0

07

4.8

31

9,6

08

.08

RIT

CH

IE1

6,4

12

.55

4,4

26

.44

16

3.9

42

88

.33

14

3.2

71

2,6

59

.06

56

5.2

70

.00

94

.07

34

,75

2.9

3

Total

39,065.98

13,796.57

618.36

2,632.84

2,340.33

25,294.46

656.93

0.00

729.65

85,135.12

04 Circuit

WIR

T1

1,0

79

.60

1,9

98

.47

0.9

41

,50

4.5

72

72

.08

90

9.1

04

52

.73

0.0

02

60

.66

16

,47

8.1

5

WO

OD

66

,25

2.4

61

7,3

57

.15

1,0

82

.97

2,9

80

.60

2,5

01

.48

29

,49

7.0

92

0,8

19

.28

0.0

08

12

.43

14

1,3

03

.46

Total

77,332.06

19,355.62

1,083.91

4,485.17

2,773.56

30,406.19

21,272.01

0.00

1,073.09

157,781.61

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

10

,21

2.3

48

61

.41

49

.35

0.0

01

41

.35

10

,13

7.3

42

,18

7.4

20

.00

16

7.1

02

3,7

56

.31

JAC

KSO

N1

7,3

51

.05

2,7

23

.46

14

.06

1,4

16

.07

1,2

36

.96

19

,37

2.5

44

,60

4.8

10

.00

96

6.8

34

7,6

85

.78

MA

SON

8,6

65

.74

4,5

52

.14

0.0

01

,72

4.0

83

24

.32

2,6

16

.03

1,2

57

.66

0.0

01

55

.80

19

,29

5.7

7

RO

AN

E1

3,2

79

.30

1,0

18

.81

52

2.9

01

,00

4.7

88

12

.18

5,1

34

.64

92

3.4

50

.00

78

1.8

02

3,4

77

.86

Total

49,508.43

9,155.82

586.31

4,144.93

2,514.81

37,260.55

8,973.34

0.00

2,071.53

114,215.72

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L7

0,3

40

.84

31

8.9

94

21

.74

33

1.6

39

50

.65

5,8

95

.73

2,0

16

.37

0.0

02

45

.10

80

,52

1.0

5

Total

70,340.84

318.99

421.74

331.63

950.65

5,895.73

2,016.37

0.00

245.10

80,521.05

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

11

,34

4.4

88

,71

1.0

30

.30

2,6

06

.07

1,1

71

.19

6,5

05

.35

1,5

49

.88

0.0

02

6.4

43

1,9

14

.74

Total

11,344.48

8,711.03

0.30

2,606.07

1,171.19

6,505.35

1,549.88

0.00

26.44

31,914.74

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L3

5,3

86

.60

1,4

49

.47

21

6.5

84

13

.00

88

.44

8,0

39

.65

2,0

23

.05

0.0

02

69

.52

47

,88

6.3

1

Total

35,386.60

1,449.47

216.58

413.00

88.44

8,039.65

2,023.05

0.00

269.52

47,886.31

09 Circuit

MER

CER

11

9,2

90

.93

10

,78

7.6

72

,19

3.6

32

1,4

05

.33

1,6

98

.60

51

,25

5.8

61

4,0

38

.01

1,0

18

.51

78

7.7

22

22

,47

6.2

6

Total

119,290.93

10,787.67

2,193.63

21,405.33

1,698.60

51,255.86

14,038.01

1,018.51

787.72

222,476.26

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL EX

PEN

SES BY CASE TYPE

FY2015 Annual Report Page 62 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Expenses

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL EX

PEN

SES BY CASE TYPE

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H2

2,9

74

.23

3,9

65

.67

23

.25

72

7.1

12

,51

6.2

24

4,8

43

.72

3,6

77

.53

0.0

01

13

.46

78

,84

1.1

9

Total

22,974.23

3,965.67

23.25

727.11

2,516.22

44,843.72

3,677.53

0.00

113.46

78,841.19

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

5,4

36

.32

88

.79

10

.67

2.4

07

2.3

92

,74

6.6

76

31

.21

35

.64

10

1.8

09

,12

5.8

9

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S3

,58

7.4

74

74

.47

6.5

89

5.2

00

.00

2,6

91

.85

0.0

00

.00

10

.81

6,8

66

.38

Total

9,023.79

563.26

17.25

97.60

72.39

5,438.52

631.21

35.64

112.61

15,992.27

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

7,1

53

.50

41

8.2

30

.00

79

7.4

73

11

.08

8,4

70

.97

1,3

16

.73

36

.20

11

.84

18

,51

6.0

2

Total

7,153.50

418.23

797.47

311.08

8,470.97

1,316.73

36.20

11.84

18,516.02

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A8

0,6

72

.69

7,2

00

.52

0.0

03

,48

5.3

35

93

.54

22

,13

8.4

28

,54

0.9

63

,03

3.6

01

,50

3.0

11

27

,16

8.0

7

Total

80,672.69

7,200.52

0.00

3,485.33

593.54

22,138.42

8,540.96

3,033.60

1,503.01

127,168.07

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

9,0

76

.41

4,2

04

.92

0.0

09

94

.76

69

9.7

21

1,6

60

.60

86

.49

0.0

01

45

.61

26

,86

8.5

1

CLA

Y4

,64

2.1

12

,42

9.1

30

.00

1,8

06

.58

28

6.4

51

4,8

12

.29

36

0.6

14

6.0

65

0.5

62

4,4

33

.79

GIL

MER

7,0

27

.41

3,3

77

.06

0.0

01

,35

5.1

04

31

.17

6,5

59

.00

20

8.1

01

47

.02

14

5.9

01

9,2

50

.76

WEB

STER

47

,68

9.4

83

,38

7.0

83

2.8

74

,02

1.3

36

19

.58

33

,38

8.8

91

,88

5.4

70

.00

29

7.9

39

1,3

22

.63

Total

68,435.41

13,398.19

32.87

8,177.77

2,036.92

66,420.78

2,540.67

193.08

640.00

161,875.69

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N1

52

,27

7.5

31

,74

2.1

34

19

.18

2,2

88

.18

61

6.0

56

,54

7.4

34

,18

6.1

80

.00

15

3.7

71

68

,23

0.4

5

Total

152,277.53

1,742.13

419.18

2,288.18

616.05

6,547.43

4,186.18

0.00

153.77

168,230.45

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N9

3,5

11

.60

4,0

50

.96

86

8.3

81

,96

6.7

08

38

.83

3,1

97

.09

1,9

34

.31

20

9.9

73

91

.23

10

6,9

69

.07

Total

93,511.60

4,050.96

868.38

1,966.70

838.83

3,197.09

1,934.31

209.97

391.23

106,969.07

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A6

0,2

17

.52

9,3

60

.84

1,0

75

.15

2,1

70

.49

1,5

02

.68

10

,63

1.6

13

,51

5.0

68

21

.29

77

6.0

29

0,0

70

.66

Total

60,217.52

9,360.84

1,075.15

2,170.49

1,502.68

10,631.61

3,515.06

821.29

776.02

90,070.66

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N7

,94

3.3

22

,24

7.5

11

50

.94

35

2.4

74

31

.61

18

,78

6.7

32

,86

8.1

20

.00

6,2

64

.55

39

,04

5.2

5

Total

7,943.32

2,247.51

150.94

352.47

431.61

18,786.73

2,868.12

0.00

6,264.55

39,045.25

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R5

,16

1.7

22

,77

7.2

94

9.1

12

,74

5.4

73

58

.79

7,7

37

.82

71

4.2

70

.00

31

.74

19

,57

6.2

1

TAYL

OR

6,0

00

.11

2,2

00

.34

54

.51

2,5

16

.47

25

7.9

36

,69

8.0

06

30

.72

0.0

04

87

.83

18

,84

5.9

1

Total

11,161.83

4,977.63

103.62

5,261.94

616.72

14,435.82

1,344.99

0.00

519.57

38,422.12

FY2015 Annual Report Page 63 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Expenses

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL EX

PEN

SES BY CASE TYPE

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H5

4,6

82

.51

8,1

12

.49

12

4.2

72

,11

8.4

57

18

.39

3,9

59

.77

2,5

60

.94

40

9.7

87

04

.36

73

,39

0.9

6

Total

54,682.51

8,112.49

124.27

2,118.45

718.39

3,959.77

2,560.94

409.78

704.36

73,390.96

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T7

,39

8.5

87

09

.50

1.8

89

41

.84

36

0.0

73

,94

5.5

40

.00

0.0

01

82

.36

13

,53

9.7

7

MIN

ERA

L3

4,0

20

.50

6,6

81

.54

9.2

02

52

.10

51

2.8

01

,48

2.9

46

29

.70

0.0

04

7.3

04

3,6

36

.08

TUC

KER

5,1

42

.02

1,4

43

.44

0.0

08

42

.02

11

8.9

42

94

.29

0.0

00

.00

15

.51

7,8

56

.22

Total

46,561.10

8,834.48

11.08

2,035.96

991.81

5,722.77

629.70

0.00

245.17

65,032.07

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E2

3,5

45

.33

4,6

92

.57

0.0

02

,51

6.4

54

81

.03

2,7

34

.16

4,7

96

.63

0.0

09

97

.85

39

,76

4.0

2

HA

RD

Y1

3,1

67

.57

5,2

83

.22

1.8

81

,07

0.2

84

86

.44

6,0

85

.12

14

8.3

20

.00

91

.78

26

,33

4.6

1

PEN

DLE

TON

9,0

39

.86

38

5.1

33

3.8

47

83

.70

1,0

43

.09

13

8.8

63

10

.28

0.0

03

5.9

61

1,7

70

.72

Total

45,752.76

10,360.92

35.72

4,370.43

2,010.56

8,958.14

5,255.23

0.00

1,125.59

77,869.35

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY7

9,1

88

.43

1,0

18

.67

0.0

01

,66

9.1

77

91

.15

56

,41

9.8

78

,54

4.1

14

6.2

70

.00

14

7,6

77

.67

JEFF

ERSO

N4

0,2

13

.22

5,3

05

.75

0.0

01

,58

7.1

64

23

.45

15

,91

4.2

94

,51

7.4

30

.00

57

.57

68

,01

8.8

7

MO

RG

AN

10

,14

6.7

03

,31

4.2

20

.00

1,0

88

.88

60

7.2

01

6,7

90

.61

89

2.8

50

.00

23

8.7

03

3,0

79

.16

Total

12

9,5

48

.35

9,6

38

.64

0.0

04

,34

5.2

11

,82

1.8

08

9,1

24

.77

13

,95

4.3

94

6.2

72

96

.27

24

8,7

75

.70

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

14

,22

2.0

62

90

.50

46

.07

11

6.2

81

65

.95

9,3

21

.78

25

2.3

33

.45

21

.48

24

,43

9.9

0

Total

14,222.06

290.50

46.07

116.28

165.95

9,321.78

252.33

3.45

21.48

24,439.90

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E2

,90

0.3

13

2.7

40

.00

2,0

39

.83

48

3.1

54

,91

8.6

81

,52

6.1

20

.00

47

.74

11

,94

8.5

7

LIN

CO

LN3

,60

4.9

11

,37

5.1

52

46

.78

1,5

79

.85

93

1.2

26

,65

8.7

11

,48

6.0

00

.00

56

3.8

71

6,4

46

.49

Total

6,505.22

1,407.89

246.78

3,619.68

1,414.37

11,577.39

3,012.12

0.00

611.61

28,395.06

26 Circuit

LEW

IS2

6,8

98

.34

3,8

17

.64

2,2

43

.53

35

2.8

01

,26

4.4

31

,79

8.1

61

,06

4.4

50

.00

41

4.9

03

7,8

54

.25

UP

SHU

R7

,38

6.4

32

,52

5.6

31

28

.68

1,1

23

.25

46

8.8

91

3,8

58

.13

0.7

00

.00

15

1.5

92

5,6

43

.30

Total

34,284.77

6,343.27

2,372.21

1,476.05

1,733.32

15,656.29

1,065.15

0.00

566.49

63,497.55

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G3

7,3

85

.77

15

,74

6.3

81

56

.04

1,6

20

.85

26

5.7

31

1,7

87

.06

50

2.6

10

.00

23

0.3

06

7,6

94

.74

Total

37,385.77

15,746.38

156.04

1,620.85

265.73

11,787.06

502.61

0.00

230.30

67,694.74

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

13

,10

3.2

25

76

.56

0.0

09

7.0

90

.00

13

,17

8.3

01

,93

8.4

90

.00

0.0

02

8,8

93

.66

Total

13,103.22

576.56

0.00

97.09

0.00

13,178.30

1,938.49

0.00

0.00

28,893.66

FY2015 Annual Report Page 64 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Total

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Expenses

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL EX

PEN

SES BY CASE TYPE

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M3

1,4

56

.39

12

,26

2.4

87

29

.24

4,6

14

.61

1,2

52

.99

17

,47

3.9

25

92

.21

18

3.9

91

,35

2.6

46

9,9

18

.47

Total

31,456.39

12,262.48

729.24

4,614.61

1,252.99

17,473.92

592.21

183.99

1,352.64

69,918.47

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

26

,84

7.2

46

98

.72

0.0

08

.10

1.4

93

,49

4.8

11

,00

2.3

10

.00

6.8

03

2,0

59

.47

Total

26,847.24

698.72

0.00

8.10

1.49

3,494.81

1,002.31

0.00

6.80

32,059.47

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

8,0

62

.80

1,9

33

.92

0.0

05

84

.02

27

3.3

52

,36

4.3

70

.00

20

.39

3.8

41

3,2

42

.69

SUM

MER

S6

,03

1.1

81

,60

9.6

11

25

.28

89

1.3

53

96

.68

3,7

58

.40

15

6.4

20

.00

65

.34

13

,03

4.2

6

Total

14,093.98

3,543.53

125.28

1,475.37

670.03

6,122.77

156.42

20.39

69.18

26,276.95

WV TOTA

L1,466,581.02

200,694.53

13,452.13

90,290.58

34,234.51

600,113.83

121,781.33

6,111.78

22,350.86

2,555,610.57

FY2015 Annual Report Page 65 of 212

Expert Witness $410,010.98Court Reporter $82,000.02Investigator $471,101.18Travel $870,422.48Miscellaneous Office $287,900.03Paralegal $85,539.97Other $348,635.91Total Expenses $2,555,610.57

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL EXPENSES BY CATEGORY

Expert Witness16.04%

Court Reporter3.21%

Investigator18.43%

Travel34.06%

Miscellaneous Office11.27%

Paralegal3.35%

Other13.64%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 66 of 212

Circuit

County

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

45

0.0

01

,14

2.3

50

.00

15

,90

6.8

42

,46

6.9

05

36

.00

16

,86

4.5

03

7,3

66

.59

HA

NC

OC

K6

,90

0.0

05

36

.30

0.0

01

8,5

67

.79

4,8

96

.84

1,0

80

.00

54

0.9

03

2,5

21

.83

OH

IO1

8,5

75

.00

5,1

20

.35

4,4

98

.08

15

,52

7.2

79

,28

9.9

22

,09

1.3

09

,27

3.7

56

4,3

75

.67

Total

25,925.00

6,799.00

4,498.08

50,001.90

16,653.66

3,707.30

26,679.15

134,264.09

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

1,7

35

.00

0.0

00

.00

4,1

05

.71

1,4

40

.86

0.0

00

.00

7,2

81

.57

TYLE

R0

.00

0.0

01

,20

3.0

56

,20

0.8

07

35

.50

0.0

06

,62

2.4

91

4,7

61

.84

WET

ZEL

0.0

08

4.7

11

39

.02

6,8

44

.47

79

2.1

20

.00

13

7.2

77

,99

7.5

9

Total

1,735.00

84.71

1,342.07

17,150.98

2,968.48

0.00

6,759.76

30,041.00

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

0.0

00

.00

8,4

27

.87

19

,42

0.7

32

,22

5.5

16

34

.70

65

.30

30

,77

4.1

1

PLE

ASA

NTS

1,2

00

.00

11

4.0

06

,93

5.2

48

,27

9.7

51

,12

7.7

11

,95

1.3

80

.00

19

,60

8.0

8

RIT

CH

IE5

,83

0.4

41

,22

9.7

58

,36

2.1

81

3,8

92

.51

3,9

97

.43

1,3

05

.70

13

4.9

23

4,7

52

.93

Total

7,030.44

1,343.75

23,725.29

41,592.99

7,350.65

3,891.78

200.22

85,135.12

04 Circuit

WIR

T0

.00

0.0

07

,40

5.4

66

,00

5.9

41

,31

9.2

52

47

.50

1,5

00

.00

16

,47

8.1

5

WO

OD

3,4

20

.88

7,2

18

.10

53

,31

6.3

53

0,5

55

.61

19

,98

0.3

01

4,0

58

.41

12

,75

3.8

11

41

,30

3.4

6

Total

3,420.88

7,218.10

60,721.81

36,561.55

21,299.55

14,305.91

14,253.81

157,781.61

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

0.0

01

,60

7.9

00

.00

19

,06

1.6

83

,08

6.7

30

.00

0.0

02

3,7

56

.31

JAC

KSO

N0

.00

1,2

05

.80

6,2

08

.16

32

,66

1.1

95

,93

9.7

17

21

.00

94

9.9

24

7,6

85

.78

MA

SON

1,5

00

.00

30

.80

47

6.3

81

4,4

44

.33

2,2

09

.76

0.0

06

34

.50

19

,29

5.7

7

RO

AN

E0

.00

90

0.9

50

.00

20

,59

0.7

41

,98

6.1

70

.00

0.0

02

3,4

77

.86

Total

1,500.00

3,745.45

6,684.54

86,757.94

13,222.37

721.00

1,584.42

114,215.72

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L1

3,7

12

.80

6,9

66

.50

34

,19

3.7

31

0,0

74

.24

5,1

10

.03

8,0

36

.00

2,4

27

.75

80

,52

1.0

5

Total

13,712.80

6,966.50

34,193.73

10,074.24

5,110.03

8,036.00

2,427.75

80,521.05

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

2,1

00

.00

6,6

54

.55

29

1.0

01

7,0

59

.86

4,1

57

.63

1,6

42

.55

9.1

53

1,9

14

.74

Total

2,100.00

6,654.55

291.00

17,059.86

4,157.63

1,642.55

9.15

31,914.74

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L5

,40

0.0

09

83

.95

16

,52

8.1

01

2,3

84

.40

4,0

75

.11

0.0

08

,51

4.7

54

7,8

86

.31

Total

5,400.00

983.95

16,528.10

12,384.40

4,075.11

0.00

8,514.75

47,886.31

09 Circuit

MER

CER

30

,69

3.0

01

,65

1.7

04

9,8

74

.60

73

,95

5.7

61

7,6

23

.21

7,4

60

.34

41

,21

7.6

52

22

,47

6.2

6

Paralegal

Other

Total Expenses

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL TO

TAL EX

PEN

SES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY

Expert 

Witness

Court 

Reporter

Investigator

Travel

Misc. Office

FY2015 Annual Report Page 67 of 212

Circuit

County

Paralegal

Other

Total Expenses

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL TO

TAL EX

PEN

SES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY

Expert 

Witness

Court 

Reporter

Investigator

Travel

Misc. Office

Total

30,693.00

1,651.70

49,874.60

73,955.76

17,623.21

7,460.34

41,217.65

222,476.26

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H3

00

.00

90

6.2

01

5,7

91

.32

38

,94

7.4

51

0,7

55

.89

9.0

31

2,1

31

.30

78

,84

1.1

9

Total

300.00

906.20

15,791.32

38,947.45

10,755.89

9.03

12,131.30

78,841.19

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

3,3

60

.00

57

.75

12

0.0

02

,99

4.6

78

80

.29

1,3

59

.86

35

3.3

29

,12

5.8

9

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S0

.00

16

5.5

53

06

.95

6,0

78

.50

13

2.6

81

82

.70

0.0

06

,86

6.3

8

Total

3,360.00

223.30

426.95

9,073.17

1,012.97

1,542.56

353.32

15,992.27

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

1,6

00

.00

1,0

54

.90

18

0.0

01

1,2

35

.22

3,4

80

.98

69

9.1

02

65

.82

18

,51

6.0

2

Total

1,600.00

1,054.90

180.00

11,235.22

3,480.98

699.10

265.82

18,516.02

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A1

0,8

58

.00

6,3

49

.78

58

,67

1.1

52

7,7

39

.32

19

,38

2.2

01

,11

8.0

53

,04

9.5

71

27

,16

8.0

7

Total

10,858.00

6,349.78

58,671.15

27,739.32

19,382.20

1,118.05

3,049.57

127,168.07

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

0.0

07

0.3

50

.00

22

,40

7.6

33

,60

6.3

82

8.8

07

55

.35

26

,86

8.5

1

CLA

Y0

.00

30

0.3

02

07

.90

19

,70

5.4

63

,79

1.1

34

24

.00

5.0

02

4,4

33

.79

GIL

MER

0.0

00

.00

54

6.1

01

6,8

71

.33

1,7

36

.53

28

.80

68

.00

19

,25

0.7

6

WEB

STER

17

,05

0.0

00

.00

1,5

00

.00

53

,41

5.4

38

,93

1.6

01

24

.60

10

,30

1.0

09

1,3

22

.63

Total

17,050.00

370.65

2,254.00

112,399.85

18,065.64

606.20

11,129.35

161,875.69

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N3

9,9

50

.96

3,4

46

.65

41

,48

9.0

21

0,3

09

.07

13

,29

3.8

01

3,0

58

.00

46

,68

2.9

51

68

,23

0.4

5

Total

39,950.96

3,446.65

41,489.02

10,309.07

13,293.80

13,058.00

46,682.95

168,230.45

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N6

,17

5.0

02

,83

8.9

51

2,6

00

.15

7,6

10

.97

9,2

93

.01

3,6

93

.24

64

,75

7.7

51

06

,96

9.0

7

Total

6,175.00

2,838.95

12,600.15

7,610.97

9,293.01

3,693.24

64,757.75

106,969.07

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A1

2,4

87

.64

2,3

23

.95

20

,14

1.4

12

0,4

54

.94

13

,95

2.8

34

,92

0.2

71

5,7

89

.62

90

,07

0.6

6

Total

12,487.64

2,323.95

20,141.41

20,454.94

13,952.83

4,920.27

15,789.62

90,070.66

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N5

,48

3.5

01

,63

4.7

25

,04

1.2

02

0,1

17

.33

5,0

99

.41

1,1

61

.09

50

8.0

03

9,0

45

.25

Total

5,483.50

1,634.72

5,041.20

20,117.33

5,099.41

1,161.09

508.00

39,045.25

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R0

.00

33

2.5

00

.00

9,1

10

.19

8,4

18

.05

15

.60

1,6

99

.87

19

,57

6.2

1

TAYL

OR

0.0

03

19

.45

0.0

09

,78

1.1

78

,14

7.3

00

.00

59

7.9

91

8,8

45

.91

Total

0.00

651.95

0.00

18,891.36

16,565.35

15.60

2,297.86

38,422.12

FY2015 Annual Report Page 68 of 212

Circuit

County

Paralegal

Other

Total Expenses

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL TO

TAL EX

PEN

SES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY

Expert 

Witness

Court 

Reporter

Investigator

Travel

Misc. Office

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H1

3,0

85

.00

7,7

18

.96

26

,02

6.2

01

5,7

94

.77

4,5

50

.08

0.0

06

,21

5.9

57

3,3

90

.96

Total

13,085.00

7,718.96

26,026.20

15,794.77

4,550.08

0.00

6,215.95

73,390.96

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T4

,75

0.0

04

69

.25

0.0

06

,64

9.5

21

,65

5.0

01

6.0

00

.00

13

,53

9.7

7

MIN

ERA

L1

2,6

50

.39

71

6.8

01

4,2

67

.22

4,6

09

.05

6,1

21

.72

0.0

05

,27

0.9

04

3,6

36

.08

TUC

KER

0.0

00

.00

4,4

90

.44

3,0

22

.75

25

1.5

30

.00

91

.50

7,8

56

.22

Total

17,400.39

1,186.05

18,757.66

14,281.32

8,028.25

16.00

5,362.40

65,032.07

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E1

8,9

40

.78

0.0

04

,10

8.7

86

,53

4.8

96

,16

6.4

22

,96

1.2

41

,05

1.9

13

9,7

64

.02

HA

RD

Y1

1,0

47

.54

2.0

08

13

.00

10

,68

8.3

83

,10

1.1

56

4.0

06

18

.54

26

,33

4.6

1

PEN

DLE

TON

4,9

50

.00

0.0

00

.00

3,7

86

.80

69

3.0

41

0.0

02

,33

0.8

81

1,7

70

.72

Total

34,938.32

2.00

4,921.78

21,010.07

9,960.61

3,035.24

4,001.33

77,869.35

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY5

9,4

22

.67

10

,57

3.0

09

,29

4.8

41

6,5

69

.74

20

,36

2.6

75

,08

7.9

02

6,3

66

.85

14

7,6

77

.67

JEFF

ERSO

N2

7,8

51

.26

1,7

39

.50

3,9

58

.34

12

,99

5.3

68

,00

4.2

32

,71

4.6

01

0,7

55

.58

68

,01

8.8

7

MO

RG

AN

11

,58

7.5

09

59

.20

1,1

59

.74

14

,24

5.6

71

,81

9.0

03

,23

5.3

07

2.7

53

3,0

79

.16

Total

98,861.43

13,271.70

14,412.92

43,810.77

30,185.90

11,037.80

37,195.18

248,775.70

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

3,7

35

.00

14

7.0

01

,53

8.2

08

,88

9.6

21

,26

2.0

81

,65

8.0

07

,21

0.0

02

4,4

39

.90

Total

3,735.00

147.00

1,538.20

8,889.62

1,262.08

1,658.00

7,210.00

24,439.90

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E8

08

.13

41

9.6

52

91

.60

6,1

31

.11

1,6

17

.17

2,6

80

.91

0.0

01

1,9

48

.57

LIN

CO

LN0

.00

1,4

86

.00

0.0

01

3,6

17

.50

1,0

60

.75

34

.00

24

8.2

41

6,4

46

.49

Total

808.13

1,905.65

291.60

19,748.61

2,677.92

2,714.91

248.24

28,395.06

26 Circuit

LEW

IS1

4,9

82

.00

25

.00

54

0.1

51

9,3

76

.90

2,9

09

.00

0.0

02

1.2

03

7,8

54

.25

UP

SHU

R1

1,4

89

.98

0.0

03

,51

7.9

38

,49

3.2

02

,06

3.6

70

.00

78

.52

25

,64

3.3

0

Total

26,471.98

25.00

4,058.08

27,870.10

4,972.67

0.00

99.72

63,497.55

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G3

00

.00

18

2.0

03

8,0

50

.10

20

,66

1.2

37

,31

3.7

60

.00

1,1

87

.65

67

,69

4.7

4

Total

300.00

182.00

38,050.10

20,661.23

7,313.76

0.00

1,187.65

67,694.74

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

1,8

50

.00

45

6.0

00

.00

17

,89

1.8

53

,11

0.7

92

20

.00

5,3

65

.02

28

,89

3.6

6

Total

1,850.00

456.00

0.00

17,891.85

3,110.79

220.00

5,365.02

28,893.66

FY2015 Annual Report Page 69 of 212

Circuit

County

Paralegal

Other

Total Expenses

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL TO

TAL EX

PEN

SES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY

Expert 

Witness

Court 

Reporter

Investigator

Travel

Misc. Office

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M1

5,9

75

.00

1,1

63

.90

4,0

50

.01

33

,35

7.1

38

,51

2.3

30

.00

6,8

60

.10

69

,91

8.4

7

Total

15,975.00

1,163.90

4,050.01

33,357.13

8,512.33

0.00

6,860.10

69,918.47

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

5,1

00

.00

31

1.8

54

,54

0.2

13

,43

7.6

12

,12

1.6

82

70

.00

16

,27

8.1

23

2,0

59

.47

Total

5,100.00

311.85

4,540.21

3,437.61

2,121.68

270.00

16,278.12

32,059.47

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

2,7

03

.51

38

1.1

50

.00

9,1

75

.34

98

2.6

90

.00

0.0

01

3,2

42

.69

SUM

MER

S0

.00

0.0

00

.00

12

,17

5.7

68

58

.50

0.0

00

.00

13

,03

4.2

6

Total

2,703.51

381.15

0.00

21,351.10

1,841.19

0.00

0.00

26,276.95

WV TOTA

L410,010.98

82,000.02

471,101.18

870,422.48

287,900.03

85,539.97

348,635.91

2,555,610.57

FY2015 Annual Report Page 70 of 212

In‐Court at $65 per hour 74,773.45Out‐Of‐Court at $45 per hour 411,952.91

Total Hours Paid 486,726.36

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL TIME PAID IN/OUT‐OF‐COURT

In‐Court at $65 per hour

15.36%

Out‐Of‐Court at $45 per 

hour84.64%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 71 of 212

Circuit/County In‐Court Out‐Of‐Court Total Hours

01 Circuit

BROOKE 824.10 5,537.37 6,361.47

HANCOCK 1,310.10 7,191.73 8,501.83

OHIO 1,234.60 12,861.22 14,095.82

Total 3,368.80 25,590.32 28,959.12

02 Circuit

MARSHALL 509.80 2,663.41 3,173.21

TYLER 281.70 1,501.34 1,783.04

WETZEL 472.20 2,479.90 2,952.10

Total 1,263.70 6,644.65 7,908.35

03 Circuit

DODDRIDGE 435.80 4,096.20 4,532.00

PLEASANTS 388.30 2,874.60 3,262.90

RITCHIE 649.90 4,437.10 5,087.00

Total 1,474.00 11,407.90 12,881.90

04 Circuit

WIRT 147.40 1,469.50 1,616.90

WOOD 3,165.10 22,714.64 25,879.74

Total 3,312.50 24,184.14 27,496.64

05 Circuit

CALHOUN 804.80 3,751.50 4,556.30

JACKSON 1,527.70 6,680.90 8,208.60

MASON 1,459.80 7,233.40 8,693.20

ROANE 749.50 3,475.20 4,224.70

Total 4,541.80 21,141.00 25,682.80

06 Circuit

CABELL 4,744.12 14,104.60 18,848.72

Total 4,744.12 14,104.60 18,848.72

07 Circuit

LOGAN 1,967.50 9,764.70 11,732.20

Total 1,967.50 9,764.70 11,732.20

08 Circuit

MCDOWELL 1,676.50 8,163.80 9,840.30

Total 1,676.50 8,163.80 9,840.30

09 Circuit

MERCER 4,947.73 25,348.53 30,296.27

Total 4,947.73 25,348.53 30,296.27

10 Circuit

RALEIGH 3,267.19 15,320.29 18,587.48

Total 3,267.19 15,320.29 18,587.48

11 Circuit

GREENBRIER 896.90 6,708.40 7,605.30

POCAHONTAS 267.90 2,553.20 2,821.10

Total 1,164.80 9,261.60 10,426.40

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL IN/OUT OF COURT HOURS

FY2015 Annual Report Page 72 of 212

Circuit/County In‐Court Out‐Of‐Court Total Hours

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL IN/OUT OF COURT HOURS

12 Circuit

FAYETTE 1,345.10 6,631.10 7,976.20

Total 1,345.10 6,631.10 7,976.20

13 Circuit

KANAWHA 5,677.80 29,821.05 35,498.85

Total 5,677.80 29,821.05 35,498.85

14 Circuit

BRAXTON 1,040.80 4,783.27 5,824.07

CLAY 997.00 6,362.39 7,359.39

GILMER 577.10 3,063.65 3,640.75

WEBSTER 1,573.20 9,139.00 10,712.20

Total 4,188.10 23,348.32 27,536.42

15 Circuit

HARRISON 1,253.50 9,480.40 10,733.90

Total 1,253.50 9,480.40 10,733.90

16 Circuit

MARION 1,377.90 16,456.30 17,834.20

Total 1,377.90 16,456.30 17,834.20

17 Circuit

MONONGALIA 2,883.80 20,944.19 23,827.99

Total 2,883.80 20,944.19 23,827.99

18 Circuit

PRESTON 794.40 6,809.90 7,604.30

Total 794.40 6,809.90 7,604.30

19 Circuit

BARBOUR 660.80 5,805.80 6,466.60

TAYLOR 672.40 6,537.80 7,210.20

Total 1,333.20 12,343.60 13,676.80

20 Circuit

RANDOLPH 1,941.90 8,166.50 10,108.40

Total 1,941.90 8,166.50 10,108.40

21 Circuit

GRANT 442.50 2,310.70 2,753.20

MINERAL 595.60 5,329.50 5,925.10

TUCKER 94.30 692.10 786.40

Total 1,132.40 8,332.30 9,464.70

22 Circuit

HAMPSHIRE 1,198.10 5,306.80 6,504.90

HARDY 927.90 4,509.70 5,437.60

PENDLETON 165.50 1,158.90 1,324.40

Total 2,291.50 10,975.40 13,266.90

23 Circuit

BERKELEY 2,582.70 15,665.35 18,248.05

JEFFERSON 1,184.20 6,184.10 7,368.30

MORGAN 746.30 4,092.80 4,839.10

Total 4,513.20 25,942.25 30,455.45

FY2015 Annual Report Page 73 of 212

Circuit/County In‐Court Out‐Of‐Court Total Hours

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL IN/OUT OF COURT HOURS

24 Circuit

WAYNE 1,768.80 3,161.00 4,929.80

Total 1,768.80 3,161.00 4,929.80

25 Circuit

BOONE 1,477.70 3,230.12 4,707.82

LINCOLN 1,525.50 6,167.10 7,692.60

Total 3,003.20 9,397.22 12,400.42

26 Circuit

LEWIS 1,178.80 6,544.14 7,722.94

UPSHUR 978.40 4,948.00 5,926.40

Total 2,157.20 11,492.14 13,649.34

27 Circuit

WYOMING 1,496.90 8,979.30 10,476.20

Total 1,496.90 8,979.30 10,476.20

28 Circuit

NICHOLAS 779.30 4,183.94 4,963.24

Total 779.30 4,183.94 4,963.24

29 Circuit

PUTNAM 2,131.20 13,362.50 15,493.70

Total 2,131.20 13,362.50 15,493.70

30 Circuit

MINGO 1,915.20 6,899.58 8,814.78

Total 1,915.20 6,899.58 8,814.78

31 Circuit

MONROE 447.90 1,968.30 2,416.20

SUMMERS 612.30 2,326.10 2,938.40

Total 1,060.20 4,294.40 5,354.60

WV TOTAL 74,773.45 411,952.91 486,726.36

FY2015 Annual Report Page 74 of 212

Felony 998.64Misdemeanor 367.80Mental Hygiene 167.22Juvenile 538.68Parole/Prob. Rev. 418.24Term/ Abuse & Neglect 1,058.42Habeas/Sup. Ct. 2,280.24Municipal Court Charges 334.41Other 332.26   (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition,  Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL STATEWIDE AVERAGE COSTS BY CASE TYPE

$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500

Felony

Misdemeanor

Mental Hygiene

Juvenile

Parole/Prob. Rev.

Term/ Abuse & Neglect

Habeas/Sup. Ct.

Municipal Court Charges

Other

$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500

Felony

Misdemeanor

Mental Hygiene

Juvenile

Parole/Prob. Rev.

Term/ Abuse & Neglect

Habeas/Sup. Ct.

Municipal Court Charges

Other

FY2015 Annual Report Page 75 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Circuit

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Average

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

1,2

85

.65

          

64

3.9

5             

28

8.7

5             

71

4.2

9             

83

5.0

4             

1,7

89

.49

          

9,4

67

.56

          

‐                    

1,1

14

.62

          

1,1

11

.62

          

HA

NC

OC

K1

,11

9.4

8          

50

7.9

9             

29

8.5

9             

77

0.2

3             

49

7.4

6             

1,3

16

.89

          

2,3

63

.80

          

38

4.1

5             

29

5.1

4             

99

0.1

5             

OH

IO1

,91

7.9

3          

63

6.9

5             

32

5.1

5             

79

0.9

8             

62

4.2

1             

1,8

09

.89

          

3,5

79

.57

          

‐                    

52

3.5

2             

1,1

18

.08

          

Average

1,417.77

         

593.24

             

318.10

             

756.46

             

556.55

             

1,620.17

         

3,571.62

         

384.15

             

586.66

             

1,075.76

         

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

89

3.4

5             

41

1.9

7             

13

5.7

9             

47

8.6

8             

40

7.5

9             

1,0

56

.57

          

2,2

01

.44

          

‐                    

31

6.9

3             

62

8.5

5             

TYLE

R1

,61

1.7

5          

61

3.1

0             

13

1.7

9             

44

1.7

8             

37

7.6

6             

1,4

73

.45

          

1,8

41

.60

          

‐                    

1,3

23

.55

          

1,1

18

.40

          

WET

ZEL

94

9.6

6             

32

9.8

4             

12

6.9

2             

75

6.0

8             

48

0.6

7             

1,2

57

.49

          

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

74

4.0

0             

Average

1,009.49

         

420.07

             

131.68

             

535.98

             

428.76

             

1,231.80

         

2,081.49

         

‐                    

820.24

             

751.78

             

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

97

4.4

1             

52

0.9

7             

19

6.8

8             

58

8.9

3             

46

8.6

2             

86

9.4

3             

‐                    

‐                    

27

7.4

9             

69

7.5

6             

PLE

ASA

NTS

1,1

85

.94

          

40

0.3

0             

21

6.1

9             

50

1.2

4             

32

1.2

8             

1,0

14

.61

          

1,0

16

.66

          

‐                    

24

4.9

8             

72

8.9

2             

RIT

CH

IE1

,30

5.8

2          

44

6.3

0             

21

5.8

5             

87

2.6

0             

34

3.4

7             

1,3

74

.92

          

7,9

44

.27

          

‐                    

33

9.6

4             

95

4.0

9             

Average

1,130.21

         

456.22

             

206.83

             

614.72

             

423.68

             

1,098.94

         

4,480.47

         

‐                    

277.12

             

790.83

             

04 Circuit

WIR

T8

77

.89

             

35

1.1

5             

58

.94

               

44

7.0

3             

38

8.2

6             

50

6.3

0             

1,8

19

.37

          

‐                    

49

3.5

3             

54

2.3

0             

WO

OD

67

3.6

4             

32

3.3

8             

10

3.5

9             

35

2.4

9             

36

6.1

6             

71

3.9

3             

2,8

82

.66

          

‐                    

22

1.6

0             

46

0.7

2             

Average

687.99

             

324.61

             

103.44

             

365.17

             

368.43

             

705.77

             

2,806.71

         

‐                    

244.58

             

465.14

             

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

2,0

51

.19

          

74

4.3

8             

24

1.2

8             

15

8.4

0             

49

2.4

3             

91

7.5

0             

1,4

86

.55

          

‐                    

55

6.3

0             

1,1

18

.21

          

JAC

KSO

N1

,02

1.1

6          

45

1.4

3             

13

0.4

1             

85

9.4

5             

41

1.6

1             

94

0.9

2             

2,1

67

.46

          

‐                    

42

4.3

6             

88

8.1

6             

MA

SON

70

3.9

5             

35

5.2

8             

18

5.1

9             

45

6.0

9             

41

1.0

7             

1,0

90

.24

          

1,8

96

.78

          

‐                    

46

5.9

1             

53

6.2

2             

RO

AN

E1

,65

9.2

2          

41

4.2

5             

26

0.8

7             

40

7.1

6             

72

6.0

3             

49

4.7

7             

1,2

21

.84

          

‐                    

44

1.9

2             

73

0.3

5             

Average

1,074.01

         

378.84

             

200.75

             

479.44

             

437.28

             

846.90

             

1,820.78

         

‐                    

445.13

             

733.20

             

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L9

80

.95

             

32

1.8

1             

10

7.3

5             

28

2.2

1             

39

9.2

6             

80

4.4

6             

1,8

16

.99

          

‐                    

39

4.8

6             

55

3.0

3             

Average

980.95

             

321.81

             

107.35

             

282.21

             

399.26

             

804.46

             

1,816.99

         

‐                    

394.86

             

553.03

             

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

92

9.7

1             

30

2.3

7             

14

9.3

0             

62

4.6

6             

68

6.0

1             

1,2

13

.35

          

2,5

17

.63

          

‐                    

26

1.2

9             

63

2.7

6             

Average

929.71

             

302.37

             

149.30

             

624.66

             

686.01

             

1,213.35

         

2,517.63

         

‐                    

261.29

             

632.76

             

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L1

,23

5.8

7          

52

9.4

3             

26

1.2

1             

35

6.3

0             

31

3.9

8             

96

5.0

6             

4,2

18

.51

          

‐                    

69

5.9

2             

91

1.7

5             

Average

1,235.87

         

529.43

             

261.21

             

356.30

             

313.98

             

965.06

             

4,218.51

         

‐                    

695.92

             

911.75

             

09 Circuit

MER

CER

1,2

19

.43

          

32

7.7

1             

18

3.8

2             

54

0.7

9             

38

3.5

3             

75

7.6

1             

2,2

98

.53

          

34

4.7

0             

38

4.2

3             

69

3.9

1             

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER

AGE COST BY CASE TYPE

FY2015 Annual Report Page 76 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Circuit

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Average

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER

AGE COST BY CASE TYPE

Average

1,219.43

         

327.71

             

183.82

             

540.79

             

383.53

             

757.61

             

2,298.53

         

344.70

             

384.23

             

693.91

             

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H7

73

.86

             

32

2.8

7             

14

4.9

7             

60

3.3

7             

53

4.1

5             

74

9.4

7             

2,0

11

.34

          

‐                    

27

6.1

0             

68

4.8

3             

Average

773.86

             

322.87

             

144.97

             

603.37

             

534.15

             

749.47

             

2,011.34

         

‐                    

276.10

             

684.83

             

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

1,3

93

.20

          

49

6.1

3             

12

1.1

1             

62

8.5

5             

35

3.3

7             

1,6

83

.74

          

1,5

25

.55

          

55

0.5

5             

70

1.0

6             

1,2

47

.41

          

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S1

,34

3.6

3          

67

2.7

7             

82

.35

               

52

8.9

6             

‐                    

2,0

63

.90

          

‐                    

‐                    

61

9.3

1             

1,1

99

.79

          

Average

1,378.36

         

538.19

             

91.65

               

584.98

             

353.37

             

1,771.47

         

1,525.55

         

550.55

             

687.44

             

1,234.00

         

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

94

9.5

6             

22

7.8

7             

‐                    

74

5.7

8             

35

7.9

1             

91

7.9

0             

2,0

69

.78

          

23

0.2

4             

17

4.8

4             

72

7.3

0             

Average

949.56

             

227.87

             

745.78

             

357.91

             

917.90

             

2,069.78

         

230.24

             

174.84

             

727.30

             

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A7

19

.52

             

40

1.8

8             

‐                    

65

8.5

4             

46

1.0

6             

84

7.8

5             

2,3

37

.30

          

32

4.1

1             

50

0.3

0             

63

6.7

2             

Average

719.52

             

401.88

             

‐                    

658.54

             

461.06

             

847.85

             

2,337.30

         

324.11

             

500.30

             

636.72

             

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

87

0.9

8             

29

8.6

8             

74

.15

               

56

9.5

9             

53

8.6

2             

1,0

78

.32

          

1,1

14

.99

          

‐                    

22

0.9

3             

68

3.8

5             

CLA

Y1

,30

5.1

7          

34

0.0

2             

31

2.0

0             

1,5

76

.11

          

39

8.9

9             

1,3

54

.30

          

2,0

34

.61

          

33

7.5

6             

27

4.5

6             

1,1

38

.09

          

GIL

MER

1,0

09

.16

          

37

8.6

4             

21

0.5

0             

89

6.1

6             

63

3.6

3             

1,3

36

.24

          

1,2

56

.76

          

43

9.1

4             

10

7.4

3             

73

4.4

6             

WEB

STER

1,3

86

.79

          

31

5.0

3             

19

3.1

9             

1,4

85

.37

          

58

7.1

9             

1,5

27

.55

          

4,0

12

.55

          

‐                    

20

1.1

0             

1,1

83

.66

          

Average

1,183.58

         

326.66

             

117.88

             

1,018.98

         

550.81

             

1,342.09

         

2,714.17

         

422.21

             

157.12

             

952.43

             

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N2

,39

3.7

8          

43

5.5

3             

11

2.9

9             

50

0.7

0             

49

2.9

6             

1,2

69

.38

          

1,8

33

.79

          

‐                    

45

5.8

5             

1,2

25

.27

          

Average

2,393.78

         

435.53

             

112.99

             

500.70

             

492.96

             

1,269.38

         

1,833.79

         

‐                    

455.85

             

1,225.27

         

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N1

,07

9.9

4          

35

4.3

0             

13

7.1

7             

42

8.0

1             

35

2.5

5             

83

8.1

9             

1,9

21

.65

          

41

1.4

7             

31

0.0

4             

59

1.9

7             

Average

1,079.94

         

354.30

             

137.17

             

428.01

             

352.55

             

838.19

             

1,921.65

         

411.47

             

310.04

             

591.97

             

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A1

,06

7.6

9          

42

4.6

5             

15

6.4

0             

67

5.5

1             

46

5.7

1             

1,1

85

.64

          

1,8

84

.79

          

34

1.6

3             

32

5.3

6             

68

6.9

4             

Average

1,067.69

         

424.65

             

156.40

             

675.51

             

465.71

             

1,185.64

         

1,884.79

         

341.63

             

325.36

             

686.94

             

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N1

,37

8.9

9          

50

6.4

6             

19

5.1

8             

1,3

21

.16

          

56

6.3

5             

1,2

38

.43

          

1,6

64

.72

          

‐                    

88

7.0

1             

1,0

53

.50

          

Average

1,378.99

         

506.46

             

195.18

             

1,321.16

         

566.35

             

1,238.43

         

1,664.72

         

‐                    

887.01

             

1,053.50

         

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R7

21

.99

             

36

7.1

2             

13

6.0

2             

72

3.4

7             

42

6.7

6             

1,0

73

.70

          

1,6

15

.59

          

‐                    

1,2

60

.24

          

74

2.6

5             

TAYL

OR

73

8.5

7             

43

2.9

6             

33

3.8

9             

39

5.4

9             

32

4.1

1             

88

9.2

0             

1,3

12

.11

          

‐                    

34

6.5

7             

59

3.6

2             

Average

731.16

             

397.25

             

247.32

             

491.48

             

346.42

             

977.71

             

1,494.20

         

‐                    

374.26

             

656.28

             

FY2015 Annual Report Page 77 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Circuit

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Average

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER

AGE COST BY CASE TYPE

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H1

,14

4.5

5          

38

1.6

2             

22

2.1

3             

75

8.9

2             

29

1.8

1             

1,3

97

.17

          

1,6

11

.35

          

37

1.9

8             

41

1.6

8             

72

0.6

2             

Average

1,144.55

         

381.62

             

222.13

             

758.92

             

291.81

             

1,397.17

         

1,611.35

         

371.98

             

411.68

             

720.62

             

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T8

03

.69

             

40

1.7

8             

10

3.4

1             

43

5.0

2             

39

4.5

3             

1,0

19

.59

          

‐                    

‐                    

30

4.9

9             

58

7.4

9             

MIN

ERA

L7

33

.34

             

29

8.4

6             

17

9.8

7             

27

3.2

6             

21

7.6

0             

1,1

77

.32

          

1,1

48

.90

          

‐                    

36

1.3

5             

46

2.9

3             

TUC

KER

1,1

34

.18

          

36

1.2

7             

‐                    

39

4.8

3             

41

2.1

5             

2,2

07

.65

          

‐                    

‐                    

76

.00

               

53

7.2

6             

Average

773.26

             

318.56

             

146.42

             

346.64

             

273.55

             

1,137.52

         

1,148.90

         

‐                    

302.41

             

499.14

             

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E9

33

.49

             

32

4.4

3             

16

1.1

7             

65

6.9

4             

39

7.0

1             

1,6

82

.61

          

2,6

06

.58

          

‐                    

13

3.5

7             

65

1.6

7             

HA

RD

Y8

19

.58

             

40

0.2

8             

30

7.0

8             

54

2.0

5             

36

4.2

9             

1,9

87

.62

          

2,5

19

.82

          

‐                    

19

3.3

7             

69

1.1

6             

PEN

DLE

TON

1,5

64

.71

          

38

1.9

4             

15

0.7

6             

37

4.7

4             

1,0

85

.22

          

1,8

37

.47

          

2,1

03

.78

          

‐                    

18

6.8

9             

79

4.4

6             

Average

936.87

             

359.13

             

207.03

             

561.96

             

510.50

             

1,835.22

         

2,532.89

         

‐                    

153.65

             

679.94

             

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY9

62

.39

             

22

3.9

2             

‐                    

71

7.2

2             

48

9.1

1             

1,9

58

.66

          

3,3

95

.93

          

22

1.8

5             

27

7.0

0             

1,2

66

.47

          

JEFF

ERSO

N1

,01

6.8

2          

30

0.3

6             

‐                    

79

4.1

4             

52

1.3

8             

2,0

83

.16

          

2,6

86

.63

          

‐                    

33

3.5

2             

1,0

42

.59

          

MO

RG

AN

1,3

39

.30

          

60

3.2

2             

‐                    

84

7.4

4             

36

3.1

2             

1,8

36

.43

          

1,1

02

.47

          

‐                    

22

1.9

4             

1,2

65

.61

          

Average

1,013.70

         

314.44

             

‐                    

764.00

             

472.19

             

1,964.22

         

2,951.81

         

221.85

             

265.25

             

1,202.33

         

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

87

9.6

7             

31

3.5

7             

15

7.7

4             

25

2.2

5             

33

2.2

3             

80

4.9

7             

4,9

32

.83

          

11

3.9

9             

39

8.1

1             

63

8.6

9             

Average

879.67

             

313.57

             

157.74

             

252.25

             

332.23

             

804.97

             

4,932.83

          

113.99

             

398.11

             

638.69

             

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E7

18

.20

             

16

6.4

2             

‐                    

37

3.8

1             

43

5.8

7             

1,0

96

.82

          

3,0

25

.16

          

‐                    

63

4.9

5             

61

3.4

8             

LIN

CO

LN9

65

.08

             

51

9.5

2             

27

0.7

8             

92

2.7

4             

52

3.1

2             

1,3

92

.06

          

1,7

51

.25

          

‐                    

15

7.2

7             

77

1.3

1             

Average

870.61

             

397.01

             

270.78

             

436.85

             

504.35

             

1,261.31

         

2,600.52

         

‐                    

182.68

             

700.69

             

26 Circuit

LEW

IS1

,06

6.4

6          

39

6.6

4             

15

0.2

7             

51

5.7

5             

40

0.5

1             

1,2

41

.80

          

2,5

90

.52

          

‐                    

34

5.4

9             

55

0.4

3             

UP

SHU

R8

64

.07

             

30

2.8

2             

20

5.3

3             

52

5.4

9             

31

2.6

8             

1,3

26

.41

          

27

0.7

0             

‐                    

26

9.9

6             

61

5.2

0             

Average

993.95

             

348.28

             

152.58

             

524.28

             

364.28

             

1,297.72

         

1,817.25

         

‐                    

314.02

             

576.70

             

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G7

57

.38

             

38

5.2

4             

21

4.4

7             

64

7.6

0             

34

6.3

2             

73

0.4

2             

1,9

58

.78

          

‐                    

50

1.2

3             

59

5.8

8             

Average

757.38

             

385.24

             

214.47

             

647.60

             

346.32

             

730.42

             

1,958.78

         

‐                    

501.23

             

595.88

             

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

1,0

08

.19

          

26

8.0

3             

‐                    

24

2.8

4             

26

0.0

7             

1,1

11

.49

          

2,0

83

.69

          

‐                    

‐                    

98

1.1

1             

Average

1,008.19

         

268.03

             

‐                    

242.84

             

260.07

             

1,111.49

         

2,083.69

         

‐                    

‐                    

981.11

             

FY2015 Annual Report Page 78 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Circuit

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Average

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER

AGE COST BY CASE TYPE

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M8

74

.03

             

44

8.6

8             

29

8.1

5             

65

5.9

6             

38

4.9

2             

1,3

15

.81

          

1,1

82

.18

          

57

8.1

0             

38

9.0

0             

66

1.6

0             

Average

874.03

             

448.68

             

298.15

             

655.96

             

384.92

             

1,315.81

         

1,182.18

         

578.10

             

389.00

             

661.60

             

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

1,0

83

.23

          

30

7.5

0             

14

9.9

0             

95

3.5

5             

37

0.2

1             

1,1

18

.69

          

1,1

96

.43

          

70

5.0

0             

38

2.0

9             

83

3.9

9             

Average

1,083.23

         

307.50

             

149.90

             

953.55

             

370.21

             

1,118.69

         

1,196.43

         

705.00

             

382.09

             

833.99

             

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

97

7.7

4             

22

8.3

7             

‐                    

40

3.6

4             

27

8.6

2             

86

3.1

5             

‐                    

28

4.3

9             

53

.34

               

55

0.1

8             

SUM

MER

S8

11

.53

             

23

2.0

3             

34

7.2

6             

56

1.7

0             

42

8.0

9             

76

6.6

5             

85

3.9

2             

‐                    

38

8.1

7             

58

3.3

9             

Average

884.24

             

229.97

             

347.26

             

495.15

             

345.05

             

800.53

             

853.92

             

284.39

             

276.56

             

567.83

             

State Average

998.64

             

367.80

             

167.22

             

538.68

             

418.24

             

1,058.42

         

2,280.24

         

334.41

             

332.26

             

716.89

             

FY2015 Annual Report Page 79 of 212

Felony 1,165.58Misdemeanor 386.96Mental Hygiene 167.29Juvenile 597.96Parole/Prob. Rev. 433.40Term/ Abuse & Neglect 1,086.47Habeas/Sup. Ct. 2,510.82Municipal Court Charges 350.67Other 348.33   (Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition,  Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL STATEWIDE AVERAGE COSTS BY CASE TYPE

Without Direct Expenses and Supplementals

$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000

Felony

Misdemeanor

Mental Hygiene

Juvenile

Parole/Prob. Rev.

Term/ Abuse & Neglect

Habeas/Sup. Ct.

Municipal Court Charges

Other

$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000

Felony

Misdemeanor

Mental Hygiene

Juvenile

Parole/Prob. Rev.

Term/ Abuse & Neglect

Habeas/Sup. Ct.

Municipal Court Charges

Other

FY2015 Annual Report Page 80 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Circuit

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Average

01 Circuit

BR

OO

KE

1,6

81

.24

          

69

9.4

6             

29

4.6

4             

80

9.5

3             

83

5.0

4             

1,8

81

.26

          

9,4

67

.56

          

‐                    

1,1

14

.62

          

1,2

41

.44

          

HA

NC

OC

K1

,32

0.1

4          

55

7.3

8             

29

8.5

9             

86

6.5

1             

51

6.5

9             

1,4

05

.27

          

2,3

63

.80

          

38

4.1

5             

49

1.9

0             

1,0

92

.58

          

OH

IO2

,18

8.6

9          

65

3.0

7             

32

5.1

5             

79

0.9

8             

62

4.2

1             

1,8

40

.40

          

4,0

27

.01

          

‐                    

1,0

47

.03

          

1,1

53

.74

          

Average

1,700.21

         

632.98

             

319.09

             

833.65

             

572.92

             

1,688.18

         

3,896.31

         

384.15

             

838.08

             

1,153.13

         

02 Circuit

MA

RSH

ALL

95

4.0

2             

42

9.5

1             

13

5.7

9             

52

6.5

5             

40

7.5

9             

1,0

75

.10

          

2,2

01

.44

          

‐                    

31

6.9

3             

64

8.9

1             

TYLE

R2

,41

7.6

2          

61

3.1

0             

13

1.7

9             

48

1.9

4             

37

7.6

6             

1,4

73

.45

          

1,8

41

.60

          

‐                    

1,3

23

.55

          

1,2

12

.72

          

WET

ZEL

1,1

20

.60

          

32

9.8

4             

12

6.9

2             

75

6.0

8             

54

0.7

5             

1,2

57

.49

          

‐                    

‐                    

‐                    

78

2.7

5             

Average

1,168.01

         

431.42

             

131.68

             

572.95

             

447.40

             

1,240.01

         

2,081.49

         

‐                    

820.24

             

787.79

             

03 Circuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

1,3

50

.50

          

61

2.9

0             

19

6.8

8             

68

7.0

8             

48

3.2

7             

90

6.4

3             

‐                    

‐                    

27

7.4

9             

79

5.5

9             

PLE

ASA

NTS

1,4

69

.54

          

47

7.7

7             

21

6.1

9             

55

6.9

4             

32

1.2

8             

1,0

14

.61

          

1,0

16

.66

          

‐                    

24

4.9

8             

81

7.9

0             

RIT

CH

IE1

,83

5.2

1          

48

8.1

4             

21

5.8

5             

87

2.6

0             

40

0.7

1             

1,3

89

.10

          

7,9

44

.27

          

‐                    

33

9.6

4             

1,0

48

.06

          

Average

1,517.72

         

522.84

             

206.83

             

678.94

             

441.71

             

1,121.37

         

4,480.47

         

‐                    

277.12

             

886.78

             

04 Circuit

WIR

T1

,47

4.8

5          

35

7.5

4             

58

.94

               

52

6.8

5             

38

8.2

6             

50

6.3

0             

1,8

19

.37

          

‐                    

49

3.5

3             

62

7.1

5             

WO

OD

92

7.0

9             

34

9.4

3             

10

3.5

9             

42

6.5

9             

38

2.5

5             

74

8.7

2             

3,2

58

.66

          

‐                    

22

5.0

6             

51

5.5

4             

Average

959.01

             

349.81

             

103.44

             

440.35

             

383.16

             

738.75

             

3,143.52

         

‐                    

248.07

             

521.39

             

05 Circuit

CA

LHO

UN

2,2

67

.10

          

74

4.3

8             

24

1.2

8             

15

8.4

0             

49

2.4

3             

97

6.9

1             

1,4

86

.55

          

‐                    

55

6.3

0             

1,1

88

.77

          

JAC

KSO

N1

,11

9.3

5          

45

1.4

3             

13

0.4

1             

96

6.8

8             

42

4.8

9             

1,0

35

.42

          

2,3

11

.95

          

‐                    

42

4.3

6             

96

0.5

8             

MA

SON

78

7.0

0             

36

5.0

5             

18

5.1

9             

48

0.3

1             

41

9.4

6             

1,0

90

.24

          

1,8

96

.78

          

‐                    

50

1.7

5             

56

1.5

6             

RO

AN

E1

,85

6.0

8          

41

4.2

5             

26

0.8

7             

46

1.4

5             

84

7.0

3             

51

4.6

9             

1,5

27

.30

          

‐                    

44

1.9

2             

77

7.5

5             

Average

1,193.03

         

387.09

             

200.75

             

514.52

             

452.18

             

900.45

             

1,927.88

         

‐                    

454.22

             

778.06

             

06 Circuit

CA

BEL

L1

,13

0.0

8          

33

2.7

8             

10

7.3

5             

29

1.6

2             

39

9.2

6             

82

0.0

8             

1,9

03

.52

          

‐                    

40

9.4

9             

57

8.3

3             

Average

1,130.08

         

332.78

             

107.35

             

291.62

             

399.26

             

820.08

             

1,903.52

         

‐                    

409.49

             

578.33

             

07 Circuit

LOG

AN

1,0

31

.40

          

30

9.0

9             

14

9.3

0             

63

3.4

0             

68

6.0

1             

1,2

13

.35

          

2,9

37

.23

          

‐                    

26

1.2

9             

65

1.3

3             

Average

1,031.40

         

309.09

             

149.30

             

633.40

             

686.01

             

1,213.35

         

2,937.23

         

‐                    

261.29

             

651.33

             

08 Circuit

MC

DO

WEL

L1

,66

4.9

9          

54

3.7

4             

26

1.2

1             

41

5.6

8             

31

3.9

8             

97

6.5

5             

4,2

18

.51

          

‐                    

69

5.9

2             

1,0

16

.00

          

Average

1,664.99

         

543.74

             

261.21

             

415.68

             

313.98

             

976.55

             

4,218.51

         

‐                    

695.92

             

1,016.00

         

09 Circuit

MER

CER

1,4

50

.66

          

34

5.6

8             

18

3.8

2             

61

7.2

8             

40

7.1

3             

78

2.8

3             

4,0

86

.28

          

35

7.0

1             

42

4.6

7             

75

6.5

4             

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER

AGE COST BY CASE TYPE WITHOUT DIREC

T EX

PEN

SES AND SUPPLEMEN

TALS

FY2015 Annual Report Page 81 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Circuit

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Average

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER

AGE COST BY CASE TYPE WITHOUT DIREC

T EX

PEN

SES AND SUPPLEMEN

TALS

Average

1,450.66

         

345.68

             

183.82

             

617.28

             

407.13

             

782.83

             

4,086.28

         

357.01

             

424.67

             

756.54

             

10 Circuit

RA

LEIG

H9

59

.86

             

33

6.4

5             

14

4.9

7             

74

9.6

4             

60

3.0

7             

76

8.3

5             

2,1

66

.06

          

‐                    

36

8.1

3             

73

6.2

5             

Average

959.86

             

336.45

             

144.97

             

749.64

             

603.07

             

768.35

             

2,166.06

         

‐                    

368.13

             

736.25

             

11 Circuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

1,7

36

.97

          

54

1.2

4             

12

1.1

1             

70

7.1

2             

42

4.0

4             

1,6

83

.74

          

2,1

35

.77

          

55

0.5

5             

70

1.0

6             

1,3

77

.73

          

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S1

,66

9.3

6          

67

2.7

7             

82

.35

               

52

8.9

6             

‐                    

2,0

63

.90

          

‐                    

‐                    

61

9.3

1             

1,2

88

.67

          

Average

1,716.69

         

574.68

             

91.65

               

623.98

             

424.04

             

1,771.47

         

2,135.77

         

550.55

             

687.44

             

1,352.15

         

12 Circuit

FAYE

TTE

96

7.8

2             

23

4.0

3             

79

5.5

0             

35

7.9

1             

93

6.6

3             

2,0

69

.78

          

23

0.2

4             

17

4.8

4             

74

3.3

5             

Average

967.82

             

234.03

             

‐                    

795.50

             

357.91

             

936.63

             

2,069.78

         

230.24

             

174.84

             

743.35

             

13 Circuit

KA

NA

WH

A8

46

.44

             

44

2.1

4             

‐                    

70

7.5

2             

48

0.5

4             

86

7.0

9             

2,6

48

.94

          

34

1.0

8             

52

7.3

4             

69

4.9

8             

Average

846.44

             

442.14

             

‐                    

707.52

             

480.54

             

867.09

             

2,648.94

         

341.08

             

527.34

             

694.98

             

14 Circuit

BR

AX

TON

91

0.1

2             

30

4.6

5             

74

.15

               

56

9.5

9             

59

2.4

8             

1,1

01

.10

          

1,1

14

.99

          

‐                    

22

0.9

3             

70

0.8

7             

CLA

Y1

,50

0.9

5          

36

3.0

7             

31

2.0

0             

1,5

76

.11

          

39

8.9

9             

1,3

77

.26

          

2,0

34

.61

          

33

7.5

6             

27

4.5

6             

1,1

96

.08

          

GIL

MER

1,0

60

.47

          

38

2.8

4             

21

0.5

0             

94

5.9

5             

63

3.6

3             

1,3

62

.44

          

1,2

56

.76

          

43

9.1

4             

10

7.4

3             

75

1.4

7             

WEB

STER

1,6

16

.18

          

32

0.8

2             

19

3.1

9             

1,7

32

.93

          

58

7.1

9             

1,5

51

.29

          

4,0

12

.55

          

‐                    

20

1.1

0             

1,2

57

.48

          

Average

1,315.48

         

334.67

             

117.88

             

1,073.32

         

570.49

             

1,365.92

         

2,714.17

         

422.21

             

157.12

             

992.54

             

15 Circuit

HA

RR

ISO

N3

,14

8.5

7          

45

7.1

0             

11

2.9

9             

54

1.3

0             

53

9.9

1             

1,2

77

.22

          

1,8

33

.79

          

‐                    

45

5.8

5             

1,3

36

.66

          

Average

3,148.57

         

457.10

             

112.99

             

541.30

             

539.91

             

1,277.22

         

1,833.79

         

‐                    

455.85

             

1,336.66

         

16 Circuit

MA

RIO

N1

,16

6.5

8          

36

8.7

6             

13

7.1

7             

49

3.1

4             

36

9.5

0             

84

7.0

6             

2,0

58

.92

          

42

2.5

9             

34

4.4

9             

62

6.8

2             

Average

1,166.58

         

368.76

             

137.17

             

493.14

             

369.50

             

847.06

             

2,058.92

         

422.59

             

344.49

             

626.82

             

17 Circuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A1

,20

1.7

6          

45

3.6

8             

15

6.4

0             

80

7.5

0             

48

3.6

3             

1,2

04

.97

          

1,8

84

.79

          

36

2.6

5             

33

4.1

5             

73

7.6

1             

Average

1,201.76

         

453.68

             

156.40

             

807.50

             

483.63

             

1,204.97

         

1,884.79

         

362.65

             

334.15

             

737.61

             

18 Circuit

PR

ESTO

N1

,54

8.3

4          

54

6.4

5             

19

5.1

8             

1,3

21

.16

          

63

7.1

4             

1,2

72

.46

          

2,0

80

.91

          

‐                    

1,1

23

.55

          

1,1

25

.13

          

Average

1,548.34

         

546.45

             

195.18

             

1,321.16

         

637.14

             

1,272.46

         

2,080.91

         

‐                    

1,123.55

         

1,125.13

         

19 Circuit

BA

RB

OU

R7

78

.15

             

37

7.5

1             

13

6.0

2             

88

2.8

8             

42

6.7

6             

1,0

89

.04

          

1,6

15

.59

          

‐                    

1,2

60

.24

          

78

7.8

3             

TAYL

OR

84

4.0

8             

49

1.7

6             

33

3.8

9             

49

5.0

7             

34

3.1

7             

90

0.9

0             

1,3

12

.11

          

‐                    

38

2.4

2             

66

8.1

0             

Average

813.65

             

427.00

             

247.32

             

610.63

             

362.17

             

991.10

             

1,494.20

         

‐                    

411.68

             

720.17

             

FY2015 Annual Report Page 82 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Circuit

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Average

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER

AGE COST BY CASE TYPE WITHOUT DIREC

T EX

PEN

SES AND SUPPLEMEN

TALS

20 Circuit

RA

ND

OLP

H1

,33

1.9

6          

39

8.1

0             

22

2.1

3             

81

4.2

6             

29

8.2

9             

1,4

40

.15

          

1,7

35

.30

          

41

8.4

7             

42

4.5

4             

78

1.1

7             

Average

1,331.96

         

398.10

             

222.13

             

814.26

             

298.29

             

1,440.15

         

1,735.30

         

418.47

             

424.54

             

781.17

             

21 Circuit

GR

AN

T8

49

.62

             

40

1.7

8             

10

3.4

1             

46

2.2

1             

39

4.5

3             

1,0

19

.59

          

‐                    

‐                    

30

4.9

9             

61

2.0

8             

MIN

ERA

L7

94

.09

             

30

4.9

1             

17

9.8

7             

27

7.8

9             

21

7.6

0             

1,1

77

.32

          

1,7

23

.35

          

‐                    

36

1.3

5             

47

8.7

5             

TUC

KER

1,3

23

.21

          

37

2.5

6             

‐                    

39

4.8

3             

41

2.1

5             

2,2

07

.65

          

‐                    

‐                    

76

.00

               

55

7.1

6             

Average

834.87

             

324.64

             

146.42

             

355.30

             

273.55

             

1,137.52

         

1,723.35

         

‐                    

302.41

             

517.23

             

22 Circuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E1

,05

7.9

6          

33

5.2

5             

16

1.1

7             

74

2.6

3             

39

7.0

1             

1,7

21

.74

          

2,6

06

.58

          

‐                    

13

7.6

2             

69

3.5

1             

HA

RD

Y9

03

.21

             

41

2.5

6             

30

7.0

8             

58

0.7

7             

40

4.7

7             

2,0

82

.26

          

2,5

19

.82

          

‐                    

19

3.3

7             

73

1.3

0             

PEN

DLE

TON

1,9

32

.87

          

39

6.6

3             

15

0.7

6             

37

4.7

4             

1,1

83

.87

          

1,8

37

.47

          

2,1

03

.78

          

‐                    

18

6.8

9             

84

8.6

3             

Average

1,056.79

         

370.83

             

207.03

             

608.02

             

534.43

             

1,897.08

         

2,532.89

         

‐                    

156.66

             

722.18

             

23 Circuit

BER

KEL

EY1

,13

7.7

0          

22

8.4

5             

‐                    

75

7.0

6             

48

9.1

1             

2,0

64

.72

          

3,6

91

.23

          

22

1.8

5             

27

7.0

0             

1,3

89

.14

          

JEFF

ERSO

N1

,25

1.4

7          

30

9.8

9             

‐                    

91

3.2

6             

52

1.3

8             

2,2

31

.96

          

2,6

86

.63

          

‐                    

33

3.5

2             

1,1

40

.94

          

MO

RG

AN

1,4

30

.61

          

65

4.9

2             

‐                    

1,1

01

.68

          

36

3.1

2             

1,9

03

.61

          

1,1

02

.47

          

‐                    

22

1.9

4             

1,3

42

.31

          

Average

1,196.84

         

325.33

             

‐                    

856.61

             

472.19

             

2,071.68

         

3,120.49

         

221.85

             

265.25

             

1,311.30

         

24 Circuit

WA

YNE

99

4.4

1             

31

3.5

7             

15

7.7

4             

25

2.2

5             

34

1.7

3             

81

6.4

7             

4,9

32

.83

          

11

3.9

9             

39

8.1

1             

65

8.0

9             

Average

994.41

             

313.57

             

157.74

             

252.25

             

341.73

             

816.47

             

4,932.83

          

113.99

             

398.11

             

658.09

             

25 Circuit

BO

ON

E8

16

.14

             

16

6.4

2             

‐                    

41

9.1

2             

43

5.8

7             

1,1

20

.93

          

4,0

33

.54

          

‐                    

63

4.9

5             

66

5.0

1             

LIN

CO

LN1

,03

3.4

1          

51

9.5

2             

27

0.7

8             

96

2.8

6             

56

9.0

1             

1,4

04

.06

          

3,5

02

.50

          

‐                    

16

8.6

4             

80

6.0

8             

Average

953.30

             

397.01

             

270.78

             

485.64

             

538.43

             

1,279.59

         

3,900.78

         

‐                    

195.14

             

744.23

             

26 Circuit

LEW

IS1

,18

1.1

3          

41

0.8

9             

15

0.2

7             

51

5.7

5             

40

9.2

2             

1,2

41

.80

          

5,1

81

.04

          

‐                    

34

5.4

9             

57

1.9

9             

UP

SHU

R9

37

.43

             

31

1.2

8             

20

5.3

3             

55

4.2

9             

32

2.4

6             

1,3

44

.10

          

27

0.7

0             

‐                    

26

9.9

6             

64

0.4

6             

Average

1,092.67

         

359.36

             

152.58

             

549.24

             

373.62

             

1,309.10

         

2,725.87

         

‐                    

314.02

             

599.73

             

27 Circuit

WYO

MIN

G9

81

.15

             

42

4.0

0             

21

4.4

7             

67

8.4

4             

34

6.3

2             

74

6.6

5             

2,6

11

.70

          

‐                    

50

1.2

3             

67

0.2

8             

Average

981.15

             

424.00

             

214.47

             

678.44

             

346.32

             

746.65

             

2,611.70

         

‐                    

501.23

             

670.28

             

28 Circuit

NIC

HO

LAS

1,0

59

.89

          

26

8.0

3             

‐                    

24

2.8

4             

26

0.0

7             

1,1

19

.37

          

2,3

81

.36

          

‐                    

‐                    

1,0

03

.16

          

Average

1,059.89

         

268.03

             

‐                    

242.84

             

260.07

             

1,119.37

         

2,381.36

         

‐                    

‐                    

1,003.16

         

FY2015 Annual Report Page 83 of 212

Parole

Circuit

Mental

Prob.

Term

.Hab

eas

Muni.

Circuit

County

Felony

Misd.

Hygiene

Juv.

Rev.

Abuse

Sup. C

t.Court

Other

Average

PUBLIC DEFEN

DER

 SER

VICES

APPOINTED COUNSEL AVER

AGE COST BY CASE TYPE WITHOUT DIREC

T EX

PEN

SES AND SUPPLEMEN

TALS

29 Circuit

PU

TNA

M1

,00

4.5

2          

47

1.0

6             

29

8.1

5             

71

7.5

9             

38

4.9

2             

1,3

39

.10

          

1,1

82

.18

          

57

8.1

0             

40

1.1

6             

70

8.4

8             

Average

1,004.52

         

471.06

             

298.15

             

717.59

             

384.92

             

1,339.10

         

1,182.18

         

578.10

             

401.16

             

708.48

             

30 Circuit

MIN

GO

1,2

31

.29

          

30

7.5

0             

14

9.9

0             

95

3.5

5             

37

0.2

1             

1,1

37

.34

          

1,1

96

.43

          

70

5.0

0             

42

9.8

5             

86

9.7

1             

Average

1,231.29

         

307.50

             

149.90

             

953.55

             

370.21

             

1,137.34

         

1,196.43

         

705.00

             

429.85

             

869.71

             

31 Circuit

MO

NR

OE

1,0

36

.99

          

22

8.3

7             

‐                    

40

3.6

4             

27

8.6

2             

86

3.1

5             

‐                    

28

4.3

9             

53

.34

               

55

9.5

9             

SUM

MER

S8

11

.53

             

23

4.8

6             

34

7.2

6             

56

1.7

0             

48

9.2

4             

76

6.6

5             

85

3.9

2             

‐                    

38

8.1

7             

58

7.7

4             

Average

906.92

             

231.18

             

347.26

             

495.15

             

365.35

             

800.53

             

853.92

             

284.39

             

276.56

             

574.62

             

WV Average

1,165.58

         

386.96

             

167.29

             

597.96

             

433.40

             

1,086.47

         

2,510.82

         

350.67

             

348.33

             

768.83

             

FY2015 Annual Report Page 84 of 212

CHARGE AVERAGE TOTAL $ # CLAIMS

ABUSE & NEGLECT 1,055.99 9,424,344.13 8,926

CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES 682.52 1,792,156.22 2,626

JUVENILE 538.76 1,749,638.40 3,248

MURDER 4,202.15 1,046,334.63 249

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE 399.13 817,740.33 2,048

BURGLARY 819.71 675,431.37 824

PAROLE/PROBATION 418.29 598,577.07 1,431

SEXUAL ASSAULT 2,037.08 529,277.89 260

CONSPIRACY 775.06 516,967.73 667

ASSAULT & BATTERY 417.07 489,369.39 1,174

GRAND LARCENY 767.17 474,877.88 619

HABEAS CORPUS 2,164.96 471,960.93 218

MENTAL HYGIENE 167.22 423,232.41 2,531

CHILD ABUSE 996.70 392,699.35 394

MFG/POSS OR DIST OF METH 923.13 366,482.95 397

DUI 1ST OFFENSE 364.40 360,870.56 990

SUSPEND/REV LICENSE 376.80 351,173.56 932

BREAKING & ENTERING 772.95 346,282.48 448

AGGRAVATED ROBBERY 1,194.94 311,880.44 261

MAL WOUNDING/ASSAULT 908.63 288,036.17 317

SEXUAL ABUSE 1,837.85 272,001.40 148

PETIT LARCENY 350.11 246,601.68 704

SUPREME COURT APPEAL 2,672.86 221,847.72 83

FORGERY & UTTERING 703.98 212,600.48 302

OBSTRUCTION JUSTICE 358.62 207,284.47 578

FRAUD 628.08 206,008.85 328

ATTEMPT 1,200.17 202,346.63 175

ABUSE & NEGLECT APPEAL 2,198.28 200,043.93 91

REC/TRANS STOLEN PRO 525.11 199,016.51 379

DESTRUCTION OF PROPERTY 418.95 159,335.31 380

SHOPLIFTING 445.40 153,395.76 345

DUI 3RD OFFENSE 777.50 115,070.07 148

DUI 2ND OFFENSE 428.93 107,660.22 251

FAIL TO REG SEX OFFENDER 658.38 103,365.61 157

WANTON ENDANGERMENT 742.95 93,612.01 126

FALSE PRETENSES 517.42 93,136.02 180

DEADLY WEAPON 610.58 92,197.00 151

ARSON 1,244.39 85,862.98 69

ROBBERY 1,006.73 78,524.67 78

KIDNAPPING 1,611.84 75,124.24 46

SENTENCE REDUCTION 438.28 70,449.96 162

EMBEZZLEMENT 740.43 62,936.80 85

FAIL PAY CHILD SUPPORT 309.17 52,867.79 171

DISORDERLY CONDUCT 361.89 52,753.45 145

TERM PARENTAL RIGHTS 2,063.72 47,465.53 23

PORNOGRAPHY 1,333.80 46,683.13 35

INCEST 3,036.90 45,553.55 15

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAVERAGE PER CHARGE IN TOTAL $ ORDER

FY2015 Annual Report Page 85 of 212

CHARGE AVERAGE TOTAL $ # CLAIMS

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAVERAGE PER CHARGE IN TOTAL $ ORDER

FLEEING VEHICLE W/DUI 631.70 44,850.60 71

TRUANCY 390.50 41,783.14 107

TERRORIST ACTS 1,112.44 36,710.50 33

HOME CONFINEMENT 322.22 36,410.68 113

JAIL ESCAPE 773.78 35,593.86 46

CRUELTY TO ANIMALS 661.62 35,065.90 53

BRANDISHING WEAPON 390.79 32,826.13 84

FALSE SWEARING 389.17 32,690.19 84

CONTRIBUTE DEL MINOR 442.67 30,986.58 70

MOTOR VEHICLE SAFETY 400.43 29,631.99 74

UNLAWFUL WOUNDING 757.87 29,556.98 39

COMPUTER RELATED FRAUD 746.15 29,099.89 39

EXTRADITION 210.83 27,618.19 131

FAILURE TO APPEAR 517.67 26,918.59 52

HARASSMENT 337.96 26,360.82 78

FUGITIVE/JUSTICE 203.98 25,089.90 123

BOND REDUCTION 535.19 22,477.98 42

ACCESSORY 506.63 21,785.15 43

TRESPASSING 273.35 21,594.70 79

AIDING & ABETTING 629.65 21,408.09 34

LEAVE SCENE ACCIDENT 327.41 20,954.50 64

SOLICIT/PROSTITUTION 818.56 20,463.88 25

PUBLIC INTOXICATION 316.35 20,358.67 64

RECKLESS DRIVING 349.29 19,909.31 57

DUI W/ INJURY 649.02 17,523.67 27

WELFARE FRAUD 620.78 17,381.95 28

INTIMIDATE WITNESS 589.77 14,744.26 25

UNDER AGE DRINKING 359.07 14,721.96 41

JOYRIDING 374.72 14,614.10 39

MISCELLANEOUS 498.83 13,967.18 28

MAGISTRATE APPEAL 734.77 13,960.58 19

NEGLIGENT HOMICIDE 3,486.04 13,944.14 4

DNR CHARGE 414.61 13,682.28 33

CONCEAL A MINOR 755.63 12,090.10 16

DEL CONTRABAND INMATE 816.34 11,428.72 14

NO OPERATORS 316.62 11,398.26 36

PERMITTING DUI 329.64 10,878.11 33

NO PROOF OF INS 274.78 10,441.46 38

JUVENILE STATUS MISC 599.99 10,199.80 17

ANIMAL CONTROL 423.42 9,738.56 23

RESISTING ARREST 384.60 9,615.05 25

COUNTERFEITING 553.23 8,298.41 15

ADULT ABUSE 780.26 7,022.31 9

SHOOT W/N 500 FEET 462.36 6,935.39 15

AUTO TAMPERING 420.31 6,724.98 16

STALKING 310.32 6,206.34 20

EXTORTION 946.35 5,678.11 6

FY2015 Annual Report Page 86 of 212

CHARGE AVERAGE TOTAL $ # CLAIMS

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAVERAGE PER CHARGE IN TOTAL $ ORDER

VOL MANSLAUGHTER 1,394.46 5,577.85 4

PERMIT UNAUTH/DRIVE 348.88 5,233.23 15

SPEEDING 312.78 4,691.72 15

FAIL MAINTAIN CONTROL 456.02 4,560.19 10

DISTURB THE PEACE 317.88 4,450.28 14

CONTEMPT 314.93 4,094.05 13

OPEN CONTAINER 235.15 3,997.51 17

OBSTRUCT CITY PERSONNEL 1,963.32 3,926.64 2

INDECENT EXPOSURE 323.23 3,878.72 12

RETALIATE PUBLIC OFFICIAL 894.26 3,577.02 4

CONCEAL DEAD BODY 1,700.06 3,400.12 2

UNLAWFUL RESTRAINT 487.63 2,925.75 6

RESTITUTION 324.81 2,923.28 9

BRIBERY 712.35 2,849.41 4

PROHIBITION 890.82 2,672.47 3

DUI/W DEATH 2,564.00 2,564.00 1

EXPUNGEMENT 331.04 1,986.26 6

LITTERING 230.47 1,843.74 8

PEACE WARRANT 361.47 1,807.34 5

MANDAMUS 885.96 1,771.91 2

CIVIL RIGHTS VIOLATION 1,462.80 1,462.80 1

FORFEITURE 1,316.10 1,316.10 1

PRE GRAND JURY 518.79 518.79 1

OBS EMERGENCY PERSONNEL 168.23 336.46 2

OFFENSES BY INMATES 110.00 110.00 1

STATE AVERAGE & TOTALS 716.89 25,954,897.24 36,205

FY2015 Annual Report Page 87 of 212

Appendix B

Public Defender Corporation Statistics

• Map

• Chairpersons of PDC Boards of Directors

• Grants and Total Disbursements

• Attorney Time

• Total Cases Closed

• PDC Office Narratives

FY2015 Annual Report Page 88 of 212

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATION CIRCUITS

FY2015 Annual Report Page 89 of 212

PD CORPORATIONS’ BOARD OF DIRECTORS’ CHAIRPERSONS CIRCUIT         COUNTIES    CHAIRS  1ST           BROOKE    KAREN E. KAHLE, ESQ. CHAIR           HANCOCK    WHEELING, WV           OHIO  2ND           MARSHALL    VICKI VOORHIS, CHAIR           TYLER      NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV           WETZEL  4TH           WOOD      BLAINE MYERS,           WIRT      PARKERSBURG, WV  5TH           CALHOUN    JEANETTE ATKINSON, CHAIR           JACKSON    SPENCER, WV           ROANE  6TH/24TH        CABELL     JOHN F. CYRUS, ESQ., CHAIR           WAYNE     HUNTINGTON, WV  7TH          LOGAN      MARK HOBBS, ESQ., CHAIR                 CHAPMANVILLE, WV  8TH          MCDOWELL    JOHN “MIKE” CALLAWAY, CHAIR                 WELCH, WV  9TH          MERCER    WILLIAM O. HUFFMAN, ESQ., CHAIR                 PRINCETON, WV  10TH           RALEIGH    JANE CALVERT, CHAIR                 CRAB ORCHARD, WV  11TH          GREENBRIER    A. DAVID SMITH, CHAIR           POCAHONTAS    RONCEVERTE, WV  12TH          FAYETTE    CHRIS MOOREHEAD, ESQ., CHAIR                 FAYETTEVILLE, WV  13TH          KANAWHA    LONNIE SIMMONS, ESQ., CHAIR                 CHARLESTON, WV  15TH           HARRISON    GEORGE F. FORDHAM, ESQ., CHAIR                 CLARKSBURG, WV  18TH          PRESTON    DEBORAH DELAUDER, CHAIR                 TERRA ALTA, WV 

FY2015 Annual Report Page 90 of 212

  PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS BOARD CHAIRS CONTINUED  CIRCUIT        COUNTIES    CHAIRS  23RD          BERKELEY    JAMES CRAWFORD III, ESQ., CHAIR           JEFFERSON    CHARLES TOWN, WV           MORGAN  25TH          BOONE     JAMES HENSLEY, CHAIR           LINCOLN    DANVILLE, WV  28TH           NICHOLAS    MALCOLM F. VAUGHAN, ESQ., CHAIR                 SUMMERSVILLE, WV  30TH          MINGO     JANE MORAN, ESQ., CHAIR                 WILLIAMSON, WV  

Pictured: Dana Eddy presenting to Chief Public Defenders and Office Managers. Flatwoods, WV. December 2014

FY2015 Annual Report Page 91 of 212

Circuit

Distributed Contractual

Amounts

Total Funds Allocated toEach Circuit

Total PDC

Funding1ST 1,100,391 10,363 1,110,754 2ND 494,148 5,471 499,619 5TH 837,791 8,339 846,130

6TH/24TH 1,799,418 16,503 1,815,921 7TH 654,966 9,152 664,118 8TH 453,241 5,132 458,373 9TH 979,136 6,402 985,538

10TH 1,006,343 11,496 1,017,839 11TH 609,105 8,204 617,309 12TH 574,567 6,419 580,986 13TH 3,247,523 30,657 3,278,180 15TH 1,048,740 11,602 1,060,342 18TH 431,762 5,252 437,014 23RD 2,683,906 16,401 2,700,307 25TH 756,947 7,020 763,967 28TH 329,810 4,435 334,245 30TH 575,568 7,047 582,615

TOTALS 17,583,362 169,895 17,753,257

1Excludes $400,000 grant to 4TH Judicial Circuit PDC for startup expenses. This figure will be included in the FY16 cost-per-case calculation.

GRANTS TO PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS1PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES

July 1, 2014 to June 30, 2015

Corporations for Legal Research, Auditing Services, InformationTechnology Services, and Auditor Transaction Fees.

NOTES: Total funds Allocated to Each Circuit represents fundsdisbursed by the WVPDS on behalf of the Public Defender

FY2015 Annual Report Page 92 of 212

1,297.7                           

253,930.2                       

In‐Court

Out‐of‐Court

Administrative

Drug Court

TOTAL TIME

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATION ATTORNEY TIMEBY IN‐COURT/OUT‐OF‐COURT/ADMINISTRATIVE/DRUG COURT

54,135.5                         

134,373.0                       

64,124.0                         

In‐Court21.32%

Out‐of‐Court52.92%

Administrative25.25%

Drug Court0.51%

FY2015 Annual Report Page 93 of 212

IN OUT OF DRUG

COURT COURT COURT

1st Circuit 2,415.2             11,891.2           3,965.6             ‐                     18,272.0          

2nd Circuit 987.1                 4,978.9             2,038.0             ‐                     8,004.0            

5th Circuit 2,520.8             5,785.8             2,616.0             ‐                     10,922.6          

6th & 24th Circuits 7,921.4             15,496.4           6,205.1             391.9                 30,014.8          

7th Circuit 1,174.9             3,577.9             1,524.3             1.8                     6,278.9            

8th Circuit 1,457.0             3,512.9             938.0                 ‐                     5,907.9            

9th Circuit 3,007.7             7,231.6             2,845.8             130.4                 13,215.5          

10th Circuit 4,922.8             7,031.4             4,261.3             2.0                     16,217.5          

11th Circuit 1,865.6             5,381.5             1,620.4             63.8                   8,931.3            

12th Circuit 1,708.0             4,833.2             1,849.5             ‐                     8,390.7            

13th Circuit 9,779.5             20,462.4           12,251.1           345.5                 42,838.5          

15th Circuit 3,224.4             9,741.3             5,131.3             148.1                 18,245.1          

18th Circuit 687.4                 3,525.3             1,651.5             98.7                   5,962.9            

23rd Circuit 7,720.8             18,902.8           10,323.1           ‐                     36,946.7          

25th Circuit 2,490.0             6,067.7             3,553.8             115.0                 12,226.5          

28th Circuit 1,446.0             1,685.6             889.3                 0.5                     4,021.4            

30th Circuit 806.9                 4,267.1           2,459.9           ‐                    7,533.9            

PD TOTAL 54,135.5           134,373.0         64,124.0           1,297.7             253,930.2        

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS ATTORNEY TIMEBY IN‐COURT/OUT‐OF‐COURT/ADMINISTRATION/DRUG COURT

ADMIN. TOTALPDC

FY2015 Annual Report Page 94 of 212

Felony 8,209            

Misdemeanor 17,560          

Mental Hygiene 1,511            

Juvenile 2,757            

Parole / Probation Revocation 1,139            

Term/Abuse & Neglect 722                

Habeas / Sup. Ct. 47                  

Drug Court ‐                 

Other 1,225            

Total Cases 33,170          

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATION

TOTAL CASES CLOSED

Felony24.75%

Misdemeanor52.94%

Mental Hygiene4.56%

Juvenile8.31%

Parole / Probation Revocation</