7/25/2019 Pugh Analysis

1/4

Software Cost Speed

SolidWorks $12,000 0-0.005sec

PTC Creo $5,000 0.009sec

Inentor Professional $!,000 0.01sec

Qualitative Desiables Qualitative DesirablesCost "#in

Speed "#a% &ser 'riendliess"#a%

'eat(res"#a%

Scale 'actors

2 Speed

2 'eat(res

) Cost

* &ser 'riendliness

Baseline PTC Creo

7/25/2019 Pugh Analysis

2/4

'eat(res &ser 'riendliness

5 +i

/ow

#edi(

Cost )000-000 0 Weied i Scale000-11000 -1 Cost )

11000-1*000 -2 Speed 2

'eat(res 2

Speed 0-0.005 1 &ser 'rien *

0.005-0.009 0 Total

0.009-0.01) -1

'eat(res 2--5 1

5--! 0

!--12 -1ccordin to te P(

&ser 'riendliness +i 1

/ow 0

#edi( -1

7/25/2019 Pugh Analysis

3/4

SolidWork PTC Creo Inentor-2 0 -1

1 0 -1

1 0 0

1 0 -1

2 0 -9

nal3sis SolidWorks ies te 4est scale n(4er and as a res(lt is te 4est coice for

7/25/2019 Pugh Analysis

4/4

a C software